key: cord-0698333-tdzi068i authors: nan title: A Bibliometric Analysis of Corona Pandemic in Social Sciences: A Review of Influential Aspects and Conceptual Structure date: 2020-07-13 journal: IEEE Access DOI: 10.1109/access.2020.3008733 sha: 181ec17633d0043ca5d86f7fb65871a6a84f7e49 doc_id: 698333 cord_uid: tdzi068i Corona pandemic has affected the whole world, and it is a highly researched area in biological sciences. As the current pandemic has affected countries socially and economically, the purpose of this bibliometric analysis is to provide a holistic review of the corona pandemic in the field of social sciences. This study aims to highlight significant, influential aspects, research streams, and themes. We have reviewed 395 journal articles related to coronavirus in the field of social sciences from 2003 to 2020. We have deployed ‘biblioshiny’ a web-interface of the ‘bibliometrix 3.0’ package of R-studio to conduct bibliometric analysis and visualization. In the field of social sciences, we have reported influential aspects of coronavirus literature. We have found that the ‘Morbidity and Mortality Weekly Report’ is the top journal. The core article of coronavirus literature is ‘Guidelines for preventing health-care-associated pneumonia’. The most commonly used word, in titles, abstracts, author’s keywords, and keywords plus, is ‘SARS’. Top affiliation is ‘The University of Hong Kong’. Hong Kong is a leading country based on citations, and the USA is on top based on total publications. We have used a conceptual framework to identify potential research streams and themes in coronavirus literature. Four research streams are found by deploying a co-occurrence network. These research streams are ‘Social and economic effects of epidemic disease’, ‘Infectious disease calamities and control‘, ‘Outbreak of COVID 19,’ and ‘Infectious diseases and the role of international organizations’. Finally, a thematic map is used to provide a holistic understanding by dividing significant themes into basic or transversal, emerging or declining, motor, highly developed, but isolated themes. These themes and subthemes have proposed future directions and critical areas of research. Coronavirus infects humans most commonly leads to Upper Respiratory Infection (URI). It is single-stranded RNA viruses that cause various kinds of illnesses in birds and mammals, including humans. Family of coronaviruses is used to be epidemic, but SARS-CoV-2 is declared as the pandemic by WHO. Figure 1 is a clear representation of the spread of COVID-19. The disease spread from a person with the virus to a person through droplets from the mouth The associate editor coordinating the review of this manuscript and approving it for publication was Derek Abbott . and nose [1] . The impact of SARS-CoV-2 causes social and economic damages throughout the world. Figure 1 shows the daily confirm cases in the world by WHO. As of June 23, 2020, there are approximately 8.86 million confirmed cases across the globe and 0.46 million loss of lives. It has a severe social impact. Moreover, coronavirus has affected the social, business, and economic dynamics of the world. As with COVID-19 outbreak throughout the globe, different governmental pandemic mitigation restrictions (PMR) has been imposed. Under these arrangements, maximum social activities are ban in various countries. Non-essential trade within and outside the states has been restricted. Both the VOLUME 8, 2020 This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 License. For more information, see https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ infectious disease outbreak and PMR have a significant effect on the development and growth of society economically [2] . It is essential to propose the solution for socio-economic hindrances created from the outbreak of infectious diseases such as Severe Acute Respiratory Syndrome (SARS), Middle East Respiratory Syndrome (MERS), and SARS-CoV 2. It is imperative to see that there are various epidemic infectious diseases in the past. These viral diseases have put pressure on societies and economies. This study undertakes the past literature of viral infections related to coronavirus in the field of social sciences, economics, and business and performs a bibliometric analysis. The objective of this research is to analyze the literature and identify top countries, authors, affiliations, sources related to infectious viral diseases. Furthermore, this study aims to find research streams and themes by using the literature of coronavirus in the field of social sciences for the period 2003-2020. The themes and research streams may lead the policymakers, scholars, and researchers to the direction for future research and find answers to current problems. Moreover, it is the quantitative approach to provide a systematic study of written publications. The bibliometric analysis significantly improves the quality of the literature review by introducing a transparent, systematic, and reproducible review process. It provides means for mapping the research fields and influential work without subjective bias that is imperative for holistic aid to the literature process [3] . For bibliometric analysis, this study uses 'biblioshiny' the web-based interface of R-package ('bibliometrix 3.0'). This article proceeds with five steps, known as a bibliometric workflow that is suggested by Zupic and T. Čater [4] . The current situation in the world raises many questions that need to be answered. For this research, we consider the following questions to be answered that will help to identify the dynamics of coronavirus literature and provide holistic means for future research in the field where biological sciences links with social sciences. This study addresses the following questions. 1. What are the influential aspects of coronavirus literature in the field of social sciences? 2 . Exploring coronavirus literature of social sciences, what are the main trends and key themes? 3. To prepare for the future, what comprehensive lessons can we take from the past literature, and what future agendas can be set? We answer question 1 with descriptive analysis and find core sources, authors, countries, publications, and affiliation in the coronavirus publications in the field of social sciences. For core sources and core authors, we have used source impact, total citations (TC), and net publications (NP) per year. Moreover, we identify the core sources by using Bradford's Law. According to Bradford's Law, sources are divided into three zones. Zone 1 is highly productive and considered as the nuclear zone. Zone 2 is moderately productive, and sources related to zone 3 has low production [5] . We suggest top countries and affiliations based on publication frequency and total citations. Core areas of study and key themes are imperative for linking various research streams and generating future direction of study. For this purpose, we have adopted some technical tools such as co-occurrence map, thematic map, and thematic evolution. We use keywords plus for analysis because it describes the knowledge structure of the study and helps to identify and link different research areas [6] . The author's keywords indicate the main issues of the study. Keywords plus are provided by the database that expresses the article contents succinctly. Keywords plus offer more descriptive trends than the author's assigned keywords [7] . We are deploying 'biblioshiny', which is the bibliometric analysis tool provided by the R-program, to identify research streams and themes using keywords of infectious disease literature. The objective of this study is to provide the bibliometric review of the literature of coronavirus in social sciences, which can be used to curb the minus created by the infectious disease in the global social network. Moreover, we aim to provide means to improve our economic and social set up under a globalized network from these pathogens. We have subdivided our objective for better understanding. The first objective of the study is to find core publications, authors, countries, and institutions. To fulfil this objective, we use 'biblioshiny', a web-specific R package ('bibliometrix 3.0') for descriptive analysis of documents. Tools from the 'biblioshiny' interface for analysis are; Bradford's Law, global citation, h, g, and m-index. The second objective is the find the key research streams and themes. For this objective, we are using science mapping techniques of conceptual structure and using keywords plus as the input data. After completion of objections 1 and 2, we can provide a comprehensive interpretation and define future research agendas. The composition of our bibliometric data has two segments. In the first segment, we select the source from where we can take and analyze articles. For that purpose, we have selected various databases such as Scopus, Web of Science (WOS), Emerald, and google scholar. In the second segment, we have formed the search query for holistic data collection. We have selected the field of social sciences for collection for that purpose, we have applied various filters to our search query and make it match to our objective and optimal results. The reason for using COVID 19 is to check whether any research hinted towards this keyword in the past. The final search query has able to find 328 articles from social sciences, 27 articles are from economics, econometrics, and finance, and 40 articles are from the field of business, management, and accounting. Business and economics have a significant effect on social wellbeing, which is why we are considering these articles under social sciences. The conceptual framework uses keywords for theme generation, and for efficient analysis, we limit our search query to only journal articles and articles with the English language. The reason for using one comprehensive language to provide efficient bibliometric analysis is that it gives us various tools that compare keywords, articles sources, and affiliations. There are ten articles in other languages, and keyword analysis will perform better in one language. Moreover, we manually analyze the articles, and twelve articles were dropped because they were not according to the objective of this study, our final sample is comprising of 395 articles. Bibliometric analysis is the application of statistical and mathematical tools to books and media communication [8] . 'Biblioshiny' is the tool under the package which is designed for non-coders to provide means for complete scientometric and bibliometric analysis offering numerous options divided into categories of sources, documents, authors, conceptual structure, social structure, and intellectual structure. It allows obtaining multiple results in the shape of tables and graphs, which are not common in other software [9] . Table 1 provides the descriptive characteristics of corona literature that is imperative to understand before moving forward with the analysis. We finalized 395 documents that only journal articles. All these journals use 1699 keywords VOLUME 8, 2020 A total of 1492 authors wrote these documents; among them, only 104 articles are with a single author. There is a high collaboration in corona publications that is shown by the collaboration index. Document per author ratio is 0.264, which means, on average, almost four authors have written one document. Figure 3 shows the annual production, and figure 4 shows the citation per year for coronavirus publications. There is limited production at the start, but literature production increases with time, especially after the identification of Severe Acute Respiratory Syndrome (SARS) coronavirus in the Guandong province of China. SARS was also an epidemic disease affecting 26 countries and resulted in more than 8000 cases. At that time, implementations of feasible practices for infection control brought the end to this infection [10] . After the control, there was a decrease in both production and citation of coronavirus studies. However, then again, after 2010, there was an increasing trend in the publications and citations of coronavirus studies. There was a significant increase in the annual citation of coronavirus publications from 2013 to 2015. This increase in citation and total production after 2015 is due to the outbreak of MERS. In addition to the annual production and article citations per year, it is imperative to see the main topics, places, and affiliations of coronavirus publications. Figure 5 presents the three-fold analysis of coronavirus publication with a keyword plus on the left side of the figure, affiliations on the right, and countries of interest in the middle. The figure shows that the USA is working with most of the top affiliations concerning topics related to the outbreak of infectious disease. Furthermore, China, Hong Kong, Canada, and the United Kingdom have significant contributions based on various social science topics of infectious disease. Issues related to SARS are most studied in most of the countries. To find the core journals, involved in publishing coronavirus literature in the field of social sciences, we use source impact and Bradford Law. Table 2 ranks the articles based on h, m, g-index, total citation (TC), and net production (NP) and publication starting year (PY_start). Table 3 represents Bradford law, which divides the journal into three zones. Zones 1 represents core sources for publishing coronavirus articles. This is the nuclear zone representing journals having significant publications. Table 3 reports the journal rankings according to Bradford law. We have found that out of 395 journals, 23 journals comes under core zone 1, the rest of the journals are in zone 2 and zone 3. Top 23 journals are the core publishing sources for corona literature in social sciences. Morbidity and mortality weekly report (MMWR) is a significant platform for publishing coronavirus literature in the field of social sciences. From its recent publications by Ng et al. in [11] stating that during COVID-19 pandemic, test the multipronged surveillance system, in which they 133380 VOLUME 8, 2020 provide means to detect coronavirus patients in Singapore. Furthermore, the reporting provided by Burke et al. in [12] and Jernigan in [13] , indicated the effect of COVID-19 in the United States and suggested monetary measure to the center of disease control, states, local and public health care to reduce the spread of COVID-19. 70% of symptomatic persons have a travel-related risk of getting coronavirus, 20% having contact with laboratory diagnosed patients. 9% had both risk factors [14] . Published in MMWR, As reported by Foote et al. in [15] , the urgency of Isolation and rapid recognition during the infectious disease outbreaks. The study used unannounced mystery patient drills in 49 New York City hospital emergency departments to test protocols and the ability of staff members to manage and identify the infectious patients. The results of the drills indicated that infectious patients were masked and isolated 78% of drills. Moreover, 88% of the time, patients were masked and isolated when travel history was obtained, and 21% when it was not. Median time taken by staff for masking was 1.5 minutes and 8.5 minutes for isolation. The study suggested tool kits for similar drills to enhance the health care system in the United States. The nosocomial outbreak of SARS infectious disease in the health care hospital in Riyadh is also covered by MMWR [16] . It has also published reports regarding found cases and has suggested public guidelines about the Middle-East respiratory syndrome coronavirus (MERS-COV) infection [17] - [19] . Figure 6 shows the growth in the publication by top journals. We use the loess smoothing technique that is the locally weighted smoothing use regression analysis to demonstrate the smooth line with the help of a time plot or scatter plot. Loess smoothing helps to understand treads through time [20] . There has been significant growth in publications by MMWR since 2010. it represents the primary source of coronavirus literature in social sciences. Economic and political weekly have a decreasing trend from 2014 to 2016, then there is a Sharpe increase in the publications from 2016 onwards. Health security has a significant growth for the past three years. Scholars and policymakers should go through these publications during pandemic times because these journals can provide useful information for infectious diseases their socio-economic impact. The rest of the journals has no significant loess smoothing when regress through time. This section highlights the leading articles in coronavirus publications in the field of social sciences. We have listed down the top 10 globally cited articles in table 4. On top of the list, Tablan et al. [21] conducted the study in 2004 regarding guidelines for reducing the incidence of severe acute respiratory infections in health care settings and acute care hospitals. The study from Ng [22] is second on the list of most globally cited articles and can be used for future remedial research regarding coronavirus impacts on the globalized world. They investigated the spread of SARS in 2003 in Hong Kong. Ng in [22] discussed the implementation and scientific process of air ventilation assessment (AVA) system in urban areas of Hong Kong. Qureshi in [23] reported the surge capacity needs in the situation of catastrophic disasters. He has surveyed surge capacity from health workers and found that 83% were willing to report in the circumstances of mass casualty incidents, but 64% were willing to report in the situation of the SARS outbreak. He also identified that barriers to willingness were fear and concern for family and oneself and tentative health problems. Smith [24] highlighted the main concerns for the future from the outbreak of SARS in 2006 that we are facing in the 2019 pandemic. He indicated that the epidemic of SARS might assist in dealing with the pandemic situation in the future. He suggested that perception of risk, management, and communication played an essential role in the economic impact of infectious disease. Furthermore, the role of official organizations and media and the establishment of risk priorities for a better system might prevent a future global pandemic. We do not agree with his conclusion that there is low potential for the spread of infectious disease after SARS. Rittichainuwat and Chakraborty [25] investigated the impact of infectious diseases such as SARS into the hospitality industry of Thailand. Their article comes on fifth highly cited article among 395 articles. They suggested that travelers continue traveling in the time of crises, but they choose less dangerous destinations. Table 5 provides the most frequent words used in coronavirus literature in the field of social sciences. The table is divided into four parts of keywords plus, Authors Keywords, Abstract, and Title. In all parts, SARS is the most common word. Social sciences are related to society, economy, and people, which has been shown in the keywords as well. These keywords are related to infectious diseases, public health, humans. In coronavirus literature, minimal author keywords are used. Keyword plus covers the broad topics, where there are common infectious diseases used as keywords. Additionally, keywords related to Human, male, female, and middle-aged indicate the relationship between coronavirus and society. There are topics related to disease outbreak and epidemic. Not many researchers used author keywords. Health is the most used word in the abstract, and SARS is the highly used word in the title. Terms used in abstract and title are more generic that are less likely to produce any theme or research stream. Figure 7 shows the word cloud made from keyword plus. Words with high frequency in the literature are more in size. Humans and SARS have the highest frequency in the literature of social sciences. So, these are the biggest of all the words used. Then there is an epidemic, which has a strong history in China and Canada. The literature is about social sciences. That is why much research is done on the social aspects of society. Like many researchers link the infectious disease with humans, gender, age groups animals, etc. There are studies on communicable diseases, disease outbreaks, and viral infections. Some studies link the infectious diseases with travel history, so travel is used as a keyword. Isolation and purification are used in coronavirus literature as a keyword, and it is crucial as well because it helps to strengthen the isolation strategies further and secure the society. Risk assessment and infection control are also used as the keyword in literature, and these studies can be used to elaborate on the solutions for epidemic control further. All these keywords are linked and address many problems that the world is facing today. Use this literature and find a solution that can save the globalized economies from a possible future pandemic. VOLUME 8, 2020 In addition to the word cloud, figure 8 gives us a picture of word growth in literature through time. As shown in the figure, the coronavirus keyword started to grow after 2010. The body of knowledge began to identify the need for this problem to get solved. Beta coronavirus represents coronaviruses one of four genera that infect bets mainly, but the infection can be found in other species like camels, rabbits and humans [31] . Figure 8 uses a loess smoothing technique to analysis the growth of keywords usage overtime. The use of COVID 19 keyword decreases after 2014, but after 2017, there has been a Sharpe increase in the topics related to COVID 19. Throughout the years from 2000 to 2013, SARS dominated the rest of the keywords, but after 2013 there is a decrease in SARS keyword and increase in coronavirus related topics. The growth has been observed in keywords such as coronavirus, pandemic and china. This section provides information regarding core authors, affiliations, institutions and countries of coronavirus literation in the field of social sciences. There are ten authors having a more significant impact in coronavirus literature, and these authors are listed in table 7. Ranking is on the basis of h-index. Chau is at number one on the list of authors with the highest impact. Chau, with collaboration with Ho (ranked second), published profoundly impact journal articles. Wong et al. [32] discussed environmental quality and human health. They indicated that despite the absence of the central ventilation system, the nasal discomfort was the primary source of sick building syndrome (SBS). Moreover, they surveyed about indoor environmental quality (IEQ) and concluded that noise rather ventilation was the major IEQ problem. They, in [33] , analyzed the impact of crises shock on housing prices using the hedonic price model. They reported a negative impact of SARS on housing prices. Just before this article, they in [34] observed a similar impact on the town planning board (TBT) and housing developers. They concluded that TBT was effected by the shocks created from the outbreak of infectious disease, but developers were not affected by any shocks. They, in [35] , investigated the stigmatization created from SARS. They indicated that many residents were affected by stigma in various sorts of being insulted, shunned, and rejected in the domain of work, schooling, services, and interpersonal relationships. According to their respondents, stigmatization decreased but never disappeared after the outbreak. Ali (Third rank) in [36] discussed the disease outbreak in a political and social context. He suggested that infectious disease outbreaks should be addressed from a global perspective. Ali et al. [37] and Ali and Keil [38] discussed the risk of SARS and its mitigation. He described the political, economic, and social risk factors created from the pandemic and implications of these risk factors in a globalized world. Furthermore, Sanford and Ali [39] discussed various challenges for public health in Toronto after the SARS outbreak. Huang (ranked four) in his single-authored manuscript [40] described the deteriorated seafood market of china because of the drug residue incidents. He stated the food safety policies and state control over the animal epidemic after the SARS outbreak. He further disclosed through his findings that the state faced hindrance local formers for transforming public rural vets into technology savvy and market-sensitive professionals that can discipline the fish market. His second article discussed the model for individual vulnerability and challenges from the outbreak of an infectious disease such as SARS and H1N1 [41] . Gerber is number fifth on the list of authors, but he has contributed significantly to the field of SARS, MERS, and social sciences. He has started publishing from 2014 with three net publications. He has 97 total citations. Gerber's first two articles were published in MMWR that studied the first cases of MERS-COV identified in the United States and highlighted the guidelines for health authorities, clinicians, and the public [17] , [18] . Li (rank sixth) studies the transmission of viruses and bacteria in [42] . The result of the study suggested that droplets and particles of virus transport short distance during breathing, but it traveled to longer distances during cough. Rha (ranked sixth) in [19] reported SARS as a novel coronavirus in the United States. Further, Rha reported the growth of MERS-CoV infection in the United States and provided guidelines for public health authorities, clinicians, and the general public [17] . Smith is on number eight concerning h and g-index, but he possesses the highest number of citations. Smith, in [24] , discussed the risk of a more lethal outbreak than SARS in 2003. He suggested how people perceive the risk of disease outbreak was effected by the role of official organizational policies, research priorities, and the role of media. Smith, in [43] , analyzed the economic impact due to the outbreak of infectious diseases. The study suggested that due to pandemic situations, specific steps were taken by states such as school closure and absenteeism from work. The authors suggested that pandemic became the reason for 0.5% to 2.0% GCP loss. In the case of school closure and absenteeism from work, this impact became triple in size. Table 7 shows two sets of data; the left side represents the countries and regions with many scientific productions over time. On the right side, there are countries with several citations. As the USA is on top with several publications, Canada ranked second, and china ranked 3 rd , but in citations, Hong Kong's total citations are better than the USA. VOLUME 8, 2020 Most relevant affiliations are reported in figure 9 . The University of Hong Kong (HKU) comes in the first place. The university has provided a strong basis for research on infectious diseases. It has started the HKU forum on the COVID 19 pandemic and HKU research in COVID 19 for quality publications [44] . University of Toronto (UT) comes on the second list of most relevant affiliations. UT founded in 1827 and became the leading institution of Canada for knowledge creation, discovery, and learning. UT is Canada's leading research institution [45] . The national center for immunization and respiratory diseases (NCIRD) at third the list of affiliations. NCIRD is responsible for coordinating, planning, and conducting immunization operations in the United States. It is the part of centers of disease control and prevention. NCIRD provides training, consultation, educational, epidemiological, statistical, and promotional services to state and local health departments in the US [46] . [49] . 'Another day and another breakthrough' is the slogan of the research center of Mount Sanai Hospital (ranked seventh). It like a technological and scientific revolution with the mission to create advanced treatments for patients through research laboratories and multi-disciplinary centers [50] . The national center for emerging and zoonotic infectious diseases (NCEZID) is eight on the list of most relevant affiliations. There are seven divisions of NCEZID that work with partners in the United States and all around to world for prevention of illness and deaths from various infectious diseases. Their objective is to protect people from health threats such as foodborne and waterborne illness, and infections spread in hospitals, antibiotic-resistant infections, a deadly disease like Ebola and anthrax, an illness that affects travelers, the disease caused by contact with animals such as SARS, MERS and corona and diseases spread by fleas and mosquitoes [51] . Center of global health (CGH) provides its unique scientific knowledge, technical skills, and research to take global public health actions. Its mission is to improve the safety, security, and health of Americans while restricting mortality and mor-bidity worldwide [51] . It is the 10 th most relevant affiliation for coronavirus publications. Table 8 presents the data regarding the top 10 corresponding author countries, and the USA is at number one. Corresponding authors from the USA have published 64 articles from which 48 are single country publications (SCP), and 16 are multiple country publications (MCP). The issue of coronavirus is related to global social networks, and for the safety of diverse societies, major collaborations are required on coronavirus literature in the field of social sciences. Table 9 has addressed this issue, but unfortunately, very little collaboration has been observed with countries around the globe. China collaborated with the USA in 3 articles, and the USA collaborated with Korea in 5 publications. The rest of the countries in the table collaborated in 4, 3, and 2 articles only. This section helps us to understand various themes using the relationship among words (keyword plus). At first, the study proposes a co-occurrence network that allows us to evaluate multiple topics of coronavirus pandemic in social sciences over time. Then we will put these networks of words on a bi-dimensional matrix called 'Thematic Map' to analyze to centrality and density of the network. Figure 10 shows the co-occurrence network of keyword plus. The figure is extracted from the 'biblioshiny' of R-package ('bibliometrix'). The co-occurrence network of keywords is showing that coronavirus literature in social sciences can be divided into four streams. Red cluster is the central cluster with high centrality, blue and green clusters are linked together in terms of themes. SARS coronavirus has the highest centrality. Each group divides the coronavirus literature in various research streams. The red cluster represents the main coronavirus and discusses multiple characteristics of the viral disease. Its epidemic effect on humans and how it outbreaks and communicate from person to person. This research stream is named as 'social and economic effects of epidemic disease'. The blue cluster represents the research stream of 'Infectious disease calamities and control'. In this research streams, studies are related to the identification of risk factors from disease outbreaks, health care policy and knowledge about the disease, precautions among people and controlling authorities, preparations to tackle infectious disease, practices, and attitudes of people and government towards contagious disease. The green cluster represents the research stream of the medical solution to contemporary viral disease, i.e., COVID 19. It describes various tests, methodologies, and cures to curb the effect of epidemic disease. It also covers the topics related to the role of social media in communicating and educating the society about novel coronavirus. Purple cluster is the isolated cluster, yet it the important one. It relates to the crucial role of international health organizations in controlling VOLUME 8, 2020 and managing the spread of infectious disease. The purple research stream is titled 'Infectious disease and the role of international organizations'. We have detected some research themes now for the superior interpretation of the results. We can categories the identified themes into a strategic diagram to analyze the importance and development of the research theme [52] . Figure 11 represents the thematic map based on density (y-axis) and centrality (x-axis). The centrality measures the importance of the selected theme, and density measures the development of the chosen theme. The graph is divided into four parts. Themes that appear on the lower left part are emerging or declining themes. These are new themes that can emerge to be better or drop from the research area. Themes that come under the lower right part of the thematic map are the basic or transversal themes. These themes represent low density but high centrality. Much research has been done on these themes. The Upper left part represents high density but lower centrality, these themes are highly developed but isolated. The upper right part represents high density and high centrality. The themes in this part are a motor theme, which is developed and essential [53] . The size of the thematic map is to the factors that come under the theme. Thematic map of figure 11 is constructed based on a full-time span from 2003 to 2020. We have used the top 400 keywords, but items shown in the clusters are set to the minimum frequency of 4 in 'biblioshiny' web software. The number of representative labels in each theme is set to 3. This has no link with the literature but represents the subjective judgment of the authors keeping in view the dynamics and best representation of coronavirus literature. Table 9 is constructed from the clusters shown in figure 11 . First cluster is represented by SARS and topics under this cluster are related to risk management and assessment, public health, infectious disease spread and outbreak such as [54] - [60] , [24] and [61] . According to the thematic map, these themes come under the basic or transversal themes with high centrality and low density. There is much work in these themes, but it is difficult to find future direction from them because most of the topics are covered. The topics covered in these clusters are related to the Second research theme has some part in emerging themes and many parts in transversal theme. The cluster of the stated theme is represented by humans. Topics related to different characteristics of the virus-host are discussed here. Significant research has been done, and more is required, that is why this theme is converting from emerging to transversal. Research topics under this themes are related to the effect of infectious disease on descriptive of humans such as male, female, adults, old age, middle age, residents, foreigners and travelers such as discussed in [62] - [64] , [16] , [65] , and [66] . This research theme cluster is represented by a communicable disease. It is an emerging theme in coronavirus literature. This theme is indicating the management and organization of communicable diseases with various methodologies [67] - [71] and [72] . Researchers can look this emerging theme from the dimension of communicable disease and public surveillance and role of public health administration [73] - [76] , [17] and [18] . Moto themes are highly contributory themes because of high centrality and high density. In coronavirus literature theme with infection control as the representative qualified to be in that part of thematic map. Main dimensions of this theme are public health service, education about infectious disease. Education covers both professional and general public education. Psychological impact of infectious diseases and attitude towards pandemic outbreak. Researchers can understand this theme by going through [77] - [84] and [85] . Themes related to avian influenza is considered as highly developed yet isolated. The density is high, but centrality is low. There is a lot of potential in these themes and researcher can do much impactful work in these themes. Avian influenza is linked with topics related to health care personal, attitude towards pandemic outbreak and acquired immune deficiency syndrome. Theme directions are widely discussed in [86] - [91] , [25] , [92] - [94] and [95] The themes represented by coronavirus is also highly developed and isolated. How are these respiratory and viral diseases affecting humans? This theme sees the link between coronavirus, disease outbreak, epidemic, gender and age [96] - [99] and [100] . Finally this theme covers latest computer simulated methods to identify various dynamics of infectious diseases [101] - [103] , [42] , [104] and [105] . This research stream can be linked with basic themes which are represented by coronavirus and researchers can develop a drug that can be helpful to curb the disease spread. The risk assessment identifies various risk factor involved in the spread of viral diseases. It can be controlled by public feedback. A significant amount of research can be done with public surveys. It can be linked with basic themes and check the risk tolerance, public reactions and preventions with respect to gender, age, and ethnicity. It adds to the body of knowledge and helps in infection control. Infection control is also part of the motor theme. Coronavirus is generated from animals so these themes should be linked with motor and basic themes as well. If research is conducted on emerging themes, then these themes can move to basic or motor themes in future. In addition to the thematic map there is thematic evolution (figure 12), that is showing the historical development of coronavirus literature. Using the keywords plus the thematic evolution depicts the history of themes and how these themes evolved. The thematic evolution is made using 'biblioshiny' and with four segments of time. This time segmentation is based on the subjective judgement of the authors keeping in view the better representation of thematic evolution. The first segment is from 1999 to 2010, the second segment is from 2009 to 2015, third is from 2015 to 2019 and last segment is from 2019 to 2020. Themes have evolved with time. As analyzed from 1999 to 2010 the coronavirus literature was about a disease outbreak, epidemic, SARS. From 2011 to 2015 research in SARS got increased and topics related to disease outbreaks evolved into SARS literature. Furthermore, part of epidemic literature evolved into SARS and other parts into effects on humans. Pathogenicity was introduced during the period 2011 to 2015 but evolved into controlled study literature from 2016 to 2019. 3c like protease, was a drug had some success for SARS patients. Studies on the topic were available from 1999 till 2009 but after that it got evolved with other methodologies for protection and disease control. From 2016 till date topic related to risk assessment are under observation. Part of SARS literature has been used in coronavirus literature and humans' effect is also studied in coronavirus pandemic literature. This study has found significant influential aspects of coronavirus literature. These influential aspects provide implication for core future research. The study finds that 'Morbidity and Mortality Weekly Report', 'Social Science and Medicine' and 'Health Security' are top three journals with highest impact in coronavirus literature. There are 23 core journals according to Bradford law. Tablan et al. [21] is the core jounral article with most global citations, who reported the guidelines that are formed to decrease the incidence of pneumonia and other SARS related infections. 'SARS' is the word that is most frequently used in titles, author keywords and keywords plus and 'Health' in abstract. Conceptual structure from 'biblioshiny' R-package has provided key research streams and themes. We have identified four core research streams in coronavirus literature by using co-occurrence network. These research streams are; 'Social and economic effects of epidemic disease', 'Infectious disease calamities and control', 'Outbreak of COVID 19' and 'Infectious diseases and the role of international organizations'. Combining these research streams will address many issues in the times of pandemic attack. Furthermore, in conceptual structure, the study has deployed thematic map to put the themes and subthemes on graph and divides them into four parts (dropping or emerging themes, basic themes, highly developed and isolated themes, motor themes). Basic or transversal themes are represented by SARS, risk assessment and management, public health, infectious disease transmission and control and role of world health organization. Moreover, impact of infectious disease on humans and various demographics of humans are also basic themes. Methodologies related to communicable disease and public surveillance; health administrations are emerging themes. Public health services and education for infection control and psychological impact on behaviors and attitudes created by infectious diseases are motor themes. Highly developed but isolated themes of corona literature are topics related to Avian influenza. As we have reviewed the coronavirus literature thoroughly by looking at various influential aspects and conceptual framework. We can set forth some directions for researchers, doctors, policy makers to investigate the right aspects for answers of alarming issues. 1) Overall limited studies are there on coronavirus outbreak in social sciences. More research is required. 2) Availability of funds for core journals such as the sources found under zone 1 by using Bradford law can create quality future research. 3) Collaboration with core authors, affiliations, and understanding the globally cited articles will create quality future research. 4) According to the influential structure USA and Hong Kong are the coronavirus research hub in social sciences. These two research hubs should collaborate with health and research departments of underdeveloped countries where COVID-19 effects are limited. They should study these countries social habits and vaccine routines. ' 5) Very limited collaboration among countries has been observed. More collaboration for infectious disease policy and control is required in social sciences fields. The conceptual framework has cleared some themes for research directions. These directions can be explored by using the following points 6) In the co-occurrence network there are various themes identified with various colors red cluster is the basic cluster relating to public health, uncertainty, epidemic and economy. On the other hand, publications of purple cluster are related to infectious disease and role of international organizations. The link between a red cluster and purple cluster can create strategies for international health organizations to curb the spread of infectious disease and suggest economic development plan under pandemic situations. Similarly, red cluster publications can be linked with blue to identify and study risk factors that are responsible for disease spread. Blue cluster with green can generate studies to identify resilience strategies and crisis management from SARS and MERS related studies and apply them to outbreak of COVID 19. 7) Methodologies and management of Communicable diseases are the emerging theme. Future research is required in this research field. 8) SARS is the old virus in the family of coronaviruses, but the findings related to SARS can be used to identify remedies for novel coronavirus. 9) For theme identification we have used keyword plus. There should be a software that can take essential terms from all sources such as author's keywords, keywords plus, abstract and title and produce the final form of keywords for the conceptual framework. Studies for such software methodology are required The main limitation of the study is that there is very limited literature available on coronavirus in social science, economics and business field. More research is required to tackle the needs of the economy in a pandemic situation. Furthermore, Due to the limited number of author's keywords, this study only used keywords plus for development of various themes. COVID-19) Coronavirus-infected international business transactions: A preliminary diagnosis The bibliometric analysis of scholarly production: How great is the impact? Bibliometric methods in management and organization Application of Bradford's law of scattering to the literature of library & information science: A study of Doctoral theses citations submitted to the universities of Maharashtra Evolutionary features of academic articles co-keyword network and keywords co-occurrence network: Based on two-mode affiliation network Occurrence of author keywords and keywords plus in social sciences and humanities research: A preliminary study Measuring Academic Research: How to Undertake a Bibliometric Study Software tools for conducting bibliometric analysis in science: An up-to-date review Severe Acute Respiratory Syndrome) Evaluation of the effectiveness of surveillance and containment measures for the first 100 patients with COVID-19 in Singapore Active monitoring of persons exposed to patients with confirmed COVID-19-United States Update: Public health response to the coronavirus disease 2019 outbreak-United States Persons evaluated for 2019 novel coronavirus-United States Assessment of hospital emergency department response to potentially infectious diseases using unannounced mystery patient drills Notes from the field: Nosocomial outbreak of Middle East respiratory syndrome in a large tertiary care hospital-Riyadh, Saudi Arabia Update on the epidemiology of Middle East respiratory syndrome coronavirus (MERS-CoV) infection, and guidance for the public, clinicians, and public health authorities First confirmed cases of Middle East respiratory syndrome coronavirus (MERS-CoV) infection in the United States, updated information on the epidemiology of MERS-CoV infection, and guidance for the public, clinicians, and public health authorities Update: Severe respiratory illness associated with a novel coronavirus-Worldwide Lowess smoothing Guidelines for preventing health-care-associated pneumonia, 2003 recommendations of the CDC and the healthcare infection control practices advisory committee Policies and technical guidelines for urban planning of high-density cities-air ventilation assessment (AVA) of Hong Kong Health care Workers' ability and willingness to report to duty during catastrophic disasters Responding to global infectious disease outbreaks: Lessons from SARS on the role of risk perception, communication and management Perceived travel risks regarding terrorism and disease: The case of thailand Distinguishing knowledge-sharing, knowledgeconstruction, and knowledge-creation discourses Disease metaphors in new epidemics: The UK media framing of the 2003 SARS epidemic The impact of crisis events and macroeconomic activity on Taiwan's international inbound tourism demand Representations of SARS in the british newspapers The airborne transmission of infection between flats in high-rise residential buildings: Particle simulation Isolation and characterization of a novel betacoronavirus subgroup a coronavirus, rabbit coronavirus HKU14, from domestic rabbits Sick building syndrome and perceived indoor environmental quality: A survey of apartment buildings in Hong Kong Impact of political incidents, financial crises, and severe acute respiratory syndrome on Hong Kong property buyers Impact of political incidents, financial crises, and severe acute respiratory syndrome on Hong Kong regulators and developers The experience of SARS-related stigma at amoy gardens The social and political context of disease outbreaks: The case of SARS in toronto Pandemics, place, and planning: Learning from SARS Global cities and the spread of infectious disease: The case of severe acute respiratory syndrome (SARS) in Toronto, Canada The new public health hegemony: Response to severe acute respiratory syndrome (SARS) in Toronto,'' Social Theory Health Neoliberalizing food safety control: Training licensed fish veterinarians to combat aquaculture drug residues in Guangdong Modeling individual vulnerability to communicable diseases: A framework and design Numerical study of the transport of droplets or particles generated by respiratory system indoors The macroeconomic impact of pandemic influenza: Estimates from models of the United Kingdom, France, Belgium and The Netherlands Immunization and Respiratory Diseases (NCIRD) Home | CDC About the Center for Global Health (CGH)-Centers for Disease Control (CDC) Science mapping software tools: Review, analysis, and cooperative study among tools The effects of repetitive information communication through multiple channels on prevention behavior during the 2015 MERS outbreak in South Korea Exploratory spatiotemporal analysis in risk communication during the MERS outbreak in South Korea Exploring Canadians' and Europeans' health care professionals' perception of biological risks, patient safety, and professionals' safety practices Transnational quarantine rhetorics: Public mobilization in SARS and in H1N1 flu Spatio-temporal and stochastic modelling of severe acute respiratory syndrome Work-related critical incidents in hospitalbased health care providers and the risk of post-traumatic stress symptoms, anxiety, and depression: A meta-analysis The politics of risk and blame during an epidemic of fear Keeping SARS out: An education program for SARS screeners in one ontario hospital Developing a simulation-based training program for the prehospital professionals and students on the management of middle east respiratory syndrome The role of social work for foreign residents in an epidemic: The MERS crisis in the republic of Korea Modeling online health information-seeking behavior in China: The roles of source characteristics, reward assessment, and Internet self-efficacy Identification of information types and sources by the public for promoting awareness of Middle East respiratory syndrome coronavirus in Saudi Arabia Predicting support for non-pharmaceutical interventions during infectious outbreaks: A four region analysis Improving detection and response to respiratory events-Kenya Challenges to the system of reserve medical supplies for public health emergencies: Reflections on the outbreak of the severe acute respiratory syndrome coronavirus 2 (SARS-CoV-2) epidemic in China Bridging complexity theory and resilience to develop surge capacity in health systems A lesson learned from middle east respiratory syndrome (MERS) in saudi arabia HHS), ''Possession, use, and transfer of select agents and toxins; biennial review. Final rule How to reduce the impact of 'low-risk patients' following a bioterrorist incident: Lessons from SARS, anthrax, and pneumonic plague Selective adaptation and human rights to health in China SARS: A quality management test of our public health safety net SARS Surveillance Project-Internet-enabled multiregion surveillance for rapidly emerging disease Field investigations of emergency department syndromic surveillance signals To Rid oneself of the uninvited guest': Robert Koch, Sergei Winogradsky and competing styles of practice in medical microbiology Mobile migrants, mobile germs: Migration, contagion, and boundary-building in Shenzhen, China after SARS Resilience training for hospital workers in anticipation of an influenza pandemic Forced to shut down Institutional trust as a determinant of anxiety during the SARS crisis in Hong Kong Does social capital matter when medical professionals encounter the SARS crisis in a hospital setting Psychosocial factors influencing the practice of preventive behaviors against the severe acute respiratory syndrome among older Chinese in Hong Kong Factors influencing compliance with quarantine in Toronto during the 2003 SARS outbreak Evaluation of state plans and the livestock emergency response plan (LERP) What we are watching-top global infectious disease threats, 2013-2016: An update from CDC's global disease detection operations center Global health from the outside: The promise of place-based research The international politics of disease reporting: Towards post-Westphalianism? Predictions and measurements of the stack effect on indoor airborne virus transmission in a high-rise hospital building The reaction of elderly asian tourists to avian influenza and SARS The Canadian geospatial data infrastructure and health mapping Assessing impacts of SARS and avian flu on international tourism demand to Asia Government public health policy: Three cautionary tales from Malaysia, South Africa and the United States Globalization of health insecurity: The World Health Organization and the new International Health Regulations COVID-19 virus outbreak lockdown: What impacts on household food wastage?'' Environ Rapid surveillance of COVID-19 in the united states using a prospective space-time scan statistic: Detecting and evaluating emerging clusters Abortion at the edges: Politics, practices, performances Sicken thy neighbour: The initial trade policy response to COVID-19 Investigating a serious challenge in the sustainable development process: Analysis of confirmed cases of COVID-19 (New type of Coronavirus) through a binary classification using artificial intelligence and regression analysis Spatial approximations of network-based individual level infectious disease models Post-SARS tourist arrival recovery patterns: An analysis based on a catastrophe theory Transient CFD simulation of the respiration process and inter-person exposure assessment Virtual screening of novel noncovalent inhibitors for SARS-CoV 3C-like proteinase Predicting the impacts of epidemic outbreaks on global supply chains: A simulation-based analysis on the coronavirus outbreak (COVID-19/SARS-CoV-2) case Interview with marcelle C. Layton, MD assistant commissioner, bureau of communicable disease new york city department of health and mental hygiene Editorial: Studying the effects of the coronavirus pandemic on intercultural relations Empowerment by hotline: Experiences during the SARS outbreak Managing a health-related crisis: SARS in singapore China's response to pandemics: From inaction to overreaction Biases in the perceived prevalence and motives of severe acute respiratory syndrome prevention behaviors among Chinese high school students in Hong Kong Are tourist arrivals stationary? Evidence from Singapore A study in hospital Noise-A case from taiwan Did public risk perspectives of mad cow disease reflect media representations and actual outcomes? Circulating health rumors in the 'Arab World': A 12-month content analysis of news stories and reader commentary about Middle East Respiratory Syndrome from two Middle Eastern news outlets Managing tourism crises: An interview with lily shum, former director, the americas, hong kong tourism board Hospital admissions syndromic surveillance-connecticut Asian stock markets and the Severe Acute Respiratory Syndrome (SARS) epidemic: Implications for health risk management The practice of biosecurity in canada: Public health legal preparedness and Toronto's SARS crisis The impact of the Severe Acute Respiratory Syndrome on hotels: A case study of Hong Kong Research note: The SARS epidemic and international visitor arrivals to cambodia: Is the impact permanent or transitory? Will regional economic integration influence carbon dioxide marginal abatement costs? Evidence from Chinese panel data Framing a mega-disaster: Political rhetoric and the Wenchuan earthquake Pandemic cities: Biopolitical effects of changing infection control in post-SARS Hong Kong Addiction, risk, and resources Causes of effective policy implementation: China's public health response to SARS From concerned citizens to activists: A case study of 2015 south korean MERS outbreak and the role of dialogic government communication and citizens' emotions on public activism Enhancing quality of data through automated SARS contact tracing method using RFID technology SARS update Japanese tourism and the SARS epidemic of 2003 Flexible coping responses to severe acute respiratory syndrome-related and daily life stressful events Bricolage or entrepreneurship? Lessons from the creation of the European centre for disease prevention and control Preparing for future uncertainty: Creating a crisis management team Paediatric pandemic planning: Children's perspectives and recommendations Emerging victorious against an outbreak: Integrated communication management of SARS in singapore media coverage and impact of the SARS campaign in moving a nation to be socially responsible Forecasting japanese tourism demand in taiwan using an intervention analysis Evolution of health provision in pre-SARS China: The changing nature of disease prevention WHO decides on the exception? Securitization and emergency governance in global health Framing SARS: A case study in toronto of a mainstream newspaper and a chinese ethnic newspaper The response of hotel performance to international tourism development and crisis events Impact of the spread of infectious disease on economic development: A study in risk management A comparison study of realtime fatality rates: Severe acute respiratory syndrome in Hong Kong Evaluation of UR-UVGI system for sterilization effect on microorganism contamination in negative pressure isolation ward Constant vigilance: Heritage values and defensive pessimism in coping with severe acute respiratory syndrome in Singapore SARS in Asia: Crisis, vulnerabilities, and regional responses Nursing students as epidemiologists: A simulation approach Has SARS infected the property market? Evidence from Hong Kong Correlation of 'Google Flu Trends' with Sentinel Surveillance Data for Influenza in 2009 in Japan Contagious insecurity: War, SARS and global air mobility Evaluation on indoor environment quality of dense urban residential buildings Post-occupancy evaluation of negative-pressure isolation rooms: Using the balanced scorecard framework Information control in time of crisis: The framing of SARS in China-based newspapers and Internet sources Can new infectious diseases be stopped? Lessons from SARS and avian influenza: Infectious diseases can emerge and spread with deadly and debilitating effects A global health elective for US medical students: The 35 year experience of the State University of New York, downstate medical center, school of public health Comparative stigma of HIV/AIDS, SARS, and tuberculosis in Hong Kong SARS: A non-event for affected countries' stock markets? How do Mainland Chinese travelers choose restaurants in Hong Kong?: An exploratory study of individual visit scheme travelers and packaged travelers Control of communicable diseases. Interim final rule with comment period Metaphors and biorisks: The war on infectious diseases and invasive species Within the boundaries of politics: News framing of sars in China and the united states By the numbers. The bird flu that's sweeping across Asia Exploring the roles and nature of science: A case study of severe acute respiratory syndrome Road to recovery The China syndrome: The impact of the SARS epidemic in southeast Asia Placing pandemics: Geographical dimensions of vulnerability and spread SingaporePharmakon Nursing Students' anxiety and clinical performance Literature-related discovery: Potential treatments and preventatives for SARS Effect of small-world networks on epidemic propagation and intervention Did the S.A.R.S. epidemic weaken the integration of asian stock markets? Evidence from smooth time-varying cointegration analysis The HKSAR Government's PR sense and sensibility: Analysis of its SARS crisis management Pandemic disease: A past and future challenge to governance in the united states Accelerated contagion and response: Understanding the relationships among globalization, time, and disease The determinants of inbound tourism to Malaysia: A panel data analysis Epidemic modelling using SARS as a case study Community under stress: Trust, reciprocity, and community collective efficacy during SARS outbreak Optimism across cultures: In response to the severe acute respiratory syndrome outbreak VITLE experience: HKBU library supporting e-learning in a SARS environment Developing the duty to treat: HIV, SARS, and the next epidemic The impact of the SARS outbreak on taiwanese hotel stock performance: An event-study approach Globalization, plague and the local community: Healthcare capacity, politics, and the microbe war The over-reaction to SARS and the collapse of asian tourism Singapore's prescription for successful control of transnational emerging infectious diseases From 'Cinderella' to 'Beloved Princess': The evolution of early childhood education policy in China Preferring negative or positive news? A closer examination of journalistic negativity in a health crisis The effects of SARS on the hong kong tourism industry: An empirical evaluation Infectious disease outbreak response: Mind the rights gap Medical evacuation of patients with infectious diseases Political succession and elite politics in twenty-first century China: Toward a perspective of 'Power balancing Quality management case studies in health service emergencies: SARS and wildland-urban interface fires Globalizing risks-the cosmo-politics of SARS and its impact on globalizing sociology Severe acute respiratory syndrome epidemic and change of people's health behavior in China Impact of SARS visiting restrictions on relatives of long-term care residents The coming coronavirus crisis: What can we learn? Incentives for reporting infectious disease outbreaks Spatial distribution of infection risk of SARS transmission in a hospital ward The duty to care in an influenza pandemic: A qualitative study of canadian public perspectives Catching the flu: Syndromic surveillance, algorithmic governmentality and global health security A study on the impact of SARS on the forecast of visitor arrivals to China A qualitative study of the duty to care in communicable disease outbreaks Flying scared. Seven ways to make air travel safer Interview with David L. Heymann, MD, representative for polio eradication and former executive director, communicable diseases, World Health Organization. interview by madeline drexler Crisis management in the Australian tourism industry: Preparedness, personnel and postscript An innovative regime switching model to forecast taiwan tourism demand Testing the structural break of Taiwan inbound tourism markets Inferior vena cava thrombosis as a cause of haemolysis in a patient on ECMO Flight crew stress and fatigue in low-cost commercial air operations-an appraisal China IN 2003: From SARS to spaceships Epidemics, labour markets and unemployment: The impact of SARS on human resource management in the Hong Kong service sector Value of buildings with design features for healthy living: A contingent valuation approach The relational activation of resilience model: How leadership activates resilience in an organizational crisis Health and human security challenges in Asia: New agendas for strengthening regional health governance The resilience development for the entrepreneurs tourism sector (RDETS) from the 2019 coronavirus crisis in Thailand Coping with the threat of severe acute respiratory syndrome: Role of threat appraisals and coping responses in health behaviors The influence of the middle east respiratory syndrome outbreak on online and offline markets for retail sales Human resources, labour markets and unemployment: The impact of the SARS epidemic on the service sector in singapore Nationality matters: SARS and foreign domestic Workers' rights in taiwan province of China The impact of city epidemics on rural labor market: The Korean middle east respiratory syndrome case Duty to care Global information flows and Chinese responses to tragic news events Learning during a crisis: The SARS epidemic in taiwan International organisations and crisis management: Do crises enable or constrain IO autonomy? Emerging infectious disease content in newspaper editorials: Public health concern or leadership issue? Capitalism is making us sick: Behind the SARS crisis in Toronto Assessment of awareness and knowledge towards novel coronavirus (nCoV) amongst University Students in India Defining health risk by media template: Hong Kong's news discourse of the Swine Flu pandemic The effects of SARS on the Korean hotel industry and measures to overcome the crisis: A case study of six Korean five-star hotels SARS and migrant workers in China: An institutional analysis Malaysia's tourism demand from selected countries: The ARDL approach to cointegration The macroeconomic determinants of international casino travel: Evidence from South Korea's top four inbound markets Group debriefing for people with chronic diseases during the SARS pandemic: Strength-focused and meaningoriented approach for resilience and transformation (SMART),'' Community Woodd, Jensen, and Archer examine the concept of'duty to respond'in the Australian SARS context Duty in the time of epidemics: What China and zimbabwe teach us Planning for pandemics: Lessons from the past decade Crisis management-dealing with asymmetric information problems Social extremity, communities of fate, and the sociology of SARS Turning crisis into opportunity: Nature of science and scientific inquiry as illustrated in the scientific research on severe acute respiratory syndrome Crisis management and recovery: How restaurants in Hong Kong responded to SARS Global health surveillance After SARS: Fear and its uses Mapping population and pathogen movements A perspective on SARS and education in hospitality and tourism The impacts of SARS on the consumer behaviour of Chinese domestic tourists Human security and public health in southeast asia: The SARS outbreak Homelessness and the response to emerging infectious disease outbreaks: Lessons from SARS Are employees more committed and willing to accept critical assignments during a crisis? A study of organizational commitment, professional commitment and willingness to care during the SARS outbreak in taiwan Public health monitoring tools for multiple data streams A nonhomogeneous agent-based simulation approach to modeling the spread of disease in a pandemic outbreak Forecasting tourism demand by fuzzy time series models Emerging infectious disease: Trends in the literature on SARS and H7N9 influenza Salience of public leaders' 'meaning making' in news coverage of a health crisis Maintaining the sanitary border: Air transport liberalisation and health security practices at UK regional airports Affect work and infected bodies: Biosecurity in an age of emerging infectious disease The duty to report disease outbreaks: Of interest or value? Lessons from H5N1 Changes in participation in leisure and outdoor recreation activities among Hong Kong people during the SARS outbreak Economic implications of the corona crisis and economic policy measures [Wirtschaftliche Implikationen der Corona-Krise und wirtschaftspolitische Maßnahmen Effects of government dialogic competency: The MERS outbreak and implications for public health crises and political legitimacy The impact of SARS on China's human resources: Implications for the labour market and level of unemployment in the service sector in Beijing, Guangzhou and Shanghai Daily emergency department surveillance system Tourism demand in Hong Kong: Income, prices, and visa restrictions Governing the Sick City: Urban governance in the age of emerging infectious disease New York City's communication trials by fire, from West Nile to SARS Attitudes of chinese medical students toward the global minimum essential requirements established by the institute for international medical education Environmental effects of intensification of agriculture: Livestock production and regulation Managing emerging infectious diseases with information systems: Reconceptualizing outbreak management through the lens of loose coupling It's a small world after all: Ethics and the response to SARS A textual analysis of the coverage of SARS and the image of China-a comparative analysis Internet Web logs as cultural resistance: A study of the SARS arts project Ethical study on the reform and development of medical and health services in China The FIFA World Cup 2002: The effects of terrorism on sport tourists Planetary health research digest Making sense of risk Experiences and implications of social workers practicing in a pediatric hospital environment affected by SARS Severe acute respiratory syndrome outbreak promotes a strong sense of professional identity among nursing students Examination of characteristics of news media under censorship: A content analysis of selected Chinese newspapers' SARS coverage When information from public health officials is untrustworthy: The use of online news, interpersonal networks, and social media during the MERS outbreak in South Korea The SARS crisis: Was anybody responsible? Dynamic efficiency assessment of the chinese hotel industry Salmonellosis outbreak among factory workers-Huizhou Impact of unexpected events on inbound tourism demand modeling: Evidence of middle east respiratory syndrome outbreak in South Korea Turning crisis into opportunity: Enhancing student' teachers' understanding of nature of science and scientific inquiry through a case study of the scientific research in severe acute respiratory syndrome The rumouring of SARS during the 2003 epidemic in China Psychological responses to the SARS outbreak in healthcare students in hong kong Public library responses to a consumer health inquiry in a public health crisis: The SARS experience in Ontario More or less? Welfare provision amidst economic downturn-the Hong Kong experience When the illiberal and the neoliberal meet around infectious diseases: An examination of the MERS response in South Korea Civet cats, fried grasshoppers, and david Beckham's pajamas: Unruly bodies after SARS Balancing individual rights versus collective good in public health enforcement A 12-year followup study of combined treatment of post-severe acute respiratory syndrome patients with femoral head necrosis The politics of cyber participation in the PRC: The implications of contingency for the awareness of citizens Bibliometric analysis of severe acute respiratory syndrome-related research in the beginning stage The determinants of inbound tourism demand in Malaysia: Another visit with non-stationary panel data approach The making and remaking of a Chinese hospital in Hong Kong Contextual thermal face detection for fever mass screening SARS attacks, China shudders A disaster diplomacy perspective of acute public health events Oil flow analysis in the maritime silk road region using AIS data Looming cognition for global competition: The approaching avian influenza pandemic How partisan newspapers represented a pandemic: The case of the middle east respiratory syndrome in South Korea Assessing the health and hygiene performance of apartment buildings Using common sense in a mathematical modelling task The impact of SARS on Hong Kong's tourism industry Between global and local: The glocalization of online news coverage on the trans-regional crisis of SARS Swine flu, doctors and pandemics: Is there a duty to treat during a pandemic? Susan sontag, battle language and the Hong Kong SARS outbreak of The polls-trends: Public reactions to global health threats and infectious diseases Severe acute respiratory syndrome and the delivery of continuing medical education: Case study from Toronto The airborne transmission of infection between flats in high-rise residential buildings: Tracer gas simulation Intervention analysis of SARS on japanese tourism demand for taiwan Skewed Urbanisation and the Contagion Characteristics of health care personnel with COVID-19-United States Investigation of a cluster of severe respiratory disease referred from Uganda to Kenya Severe outcomes among patients with coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19)-United States COVID-19 and the public health system in Bihar Geographic differences in COVID-19 cases, deaths, and incidence-United States Algae: A potential source to prevent and cure the novel coronavirus-A review Capacity in the time of coronavirus COVID-19: Fear appeal favoring purchase behavior towards personal protective equipment Estimating the COVID-19 cash crunch: Global evidence and policy Public health education in saudi arabia: Needs and challenges Impact of pandemic COVID-19 on the teaching-learning process: A study of higher education teachers Italy in a time of emergency and scarce resources: The need for embedding ethical reflection in social and clinical settings COVID-19 among workers in meat and poultry processing facilities-19 States Computational models that matter during a global pandemic outbreak: A call to action COVID-19: Real-time dissemination of scientific information to fight a public health emergency of international concern Policy response, social media and science journalism for the sustainability of the public health system amid the COVID-19 outbreak: The Vietnam lessons The effect of COVID-19 and subsequent social distancing on travel behavior Characterizing the propagation of situational information in social media during COVID-19 epidemic: A case study on Weibo What's really 'Happning'? A forensic analysis of Android and iOS Happn dating apps Startups in times of crisis-A rapid response to the COVID-19 pandemic Economic and monetary union at twenty: A stocktaking of a tumultuous second decade: Introduction COVID-19: Top 60 drug treatments in development COVID-19 should make us re-imagine the world order Emergency mental health legislation in response to the COVID-19 (Coronavirus) pandemic in Ireland: Urgency, necessity and proportionality Strategies to inform allocation of stockpiled ventilators to healthcare facilities during a pandemic Death and contagious infectious diseases: Impact of the COVID-19 virus on stock market returns Community transmission of SARS-CoV-2 at two family gatherings Serving up food studies online: Teaching about 'food from somewhere' from nowhere Presymptomatic transmission of SARS-CoV-2-Singapore The planning, execution, and evaluation of a mass prophylaxis full-scale exercise in Cook County, IL Responding to covid-19: How to navigate a public health emergency legally and ethically How can we evaluate an interrelation of symptoms? Atrial Arrhythmias in a Patient Presenting With Coronavirus Disease-2019 (COVID-19) Infection,'' J. Investigative Med COVID-19 outbreak among three affiliated homeless service sites-King County, Washington Characteristics of health care personnel with COVID-19-United States Cleaning and disinfectant chemical exposures and temporal associations with COVID-19-National poison data system State aid versus COVID-19: The commission adopts a temporary framework COVID-19 and US-China Tussle Media in the time of COVID-19 Timing of cmmunity mitigation and changes in reported COVID-19 and community mobility-Four US metropolitan areas Assessment of SARS-CoV-2 infection prevalence in homeless shelters-Four US cities Professional autonomy and liability of the resident doctor: Between the hammer and the anvil Tackling COVID-19 is a crucible for privacy Initial impacts of global risk mitigation measures taken during the combatting of the COVID-19 pandemic Epidemics and Pandemics: Covid-19 and the 'The Drop of Honey Effect A socialist cry for civilisational change: COVID-19 and the failure of neo-liberalism Detection of SARS-CoV-2 among residents and staff members of an independent and assisted living community for older adults The 'Heart Kuznets Curve'? Understanding the relations between economic development and cardiac conditions Public health responses to COVID-19 outbreaks on cruise ships-Worldwide Informational flow on Twitter-Corona virus outbreak-topic modelling approach Estimating and projecting air passenger traffic during the COVID-19 coronavirus outbreak and its socio-economic impact Standard expected years of life lost as a neglected index for calculating the burden of premature mortality due to middle east respiratory syndrome Will COVID-19 mark the end of an egalitarian national health service? Hotel cleanliness: Will guests pay for enhanced disinfection? Geographical tracking and mapping of coronavirus disease COVID-19/severe acute respiratory syndrome coronavirus 2 (SARS-CoV-2) epidemic and associated events around the world: how 21st century GIS technologies are supporting the global fight against outbreaks and epidemics Identification of critical airports for controlling global infectious disease outbreaks: stress-tests focusing in europe Estimates of the potential impact of the COVID-19 pandemic on sexual and reproductive health in low-and middle-income countries Coronavirus disease 2019 in children-United States Academic leadership in a time of crisis: The coronavirus and COVID-19 The corona virus can infect banks too: The applicability of the EU banking and state aid regimes Flattening the infection curve-understanding the role of telehealth in managing COVID-19 Malaysia's political crisis Cohesion in distancing Public health response to the initiation and spread of pandemic COVID-19 in the United States Clinical characteristics of older patients infected with COVID-19: A descriptive study NetNCSP: Nonoverlapping closed sequential pattern mining Hope as a generative force: Lifting our gaze to the future Ethiopia's factional politics Rapid sentinel surveillance for COVID-19 COVID-19 and airline employment: Insights from historical uncertainty shocks to the industry Masks can't stop this virus The singaporean response to the SARS outbreak: Knowledge sufficiency versus public trust Anti-SARS coronavirus 3C-like protease effects of Rheum palmatum L. extracts The chairman and the coronavirus: Globalization and China's healthcare system Spatio-temporal exploration of SARS epidemic SARS and it's implications Mentoring an undergraduate research student in the structural and nonstructural properties of drugs A comprehensive collection of systems biology data characterizing the host response to viral infection A qualitative study of zoonotic risk factors among rural communities in southern China Characterization of the interaction between recombinant porcine aminopeptidase n and spike glycoprotein of porcine epidemic diarrhea virus Investigating the effects of mass media exposure on the uptake of preventive measures by Hong Kong residents during the 2015 MERS outbreak: The mediating role of interpersonal communication and the perception of concern Exploring knowledge and attitude toward middle east respiratory syndrome-coronavirus (MERS-coV) among university health colleges' students, Saudi Arabia: A cross-sectional study Getting ready for the next pandemic COVID-19: Why we need to be more prepared and less scared Enzootic patterns of Middle East respiratory syndrome coronavirus in imported African and local Arabian dromedary camels: A prospective genomic study A database of geopositioned middle east respiratory syndrome coronavirus occurrences Clinical characteristics and therapeutic procedure for four cases with 2019 novel coronavirus pneumonia receiving combined chinese and western medicine treatment Drug treatment options for the 2019-new coronavirus (2019-nCoV) Comparison of trends in the quantity and variety of science citation index (SCI) literature on human pathogens between China and the united states Severe acute respiratory syndrome (SARS) and the rhetorical construction of 'bad' scientific work Inhibitors of SARS-3CLpro: Virtual screening, biological evaluation, and molecular dynamics simulation studies Economic impact of the 2015 MERS outbreak on the republic of Korea's tourism-related industries LocaPep: Localization of epitopes on protein surfaces using peptides from phage display libraries Tabletop exercise to prepare institutions of higher education for an outbreak of COVID-19 Middle east respiratory syndrome on health information websites: How much credible they are? The monad and the nomad: Medical microbiology and the politics and possibilities of the mobile microbe Severe respiratory illness associated with a novel coronavirus-Saudi Arabia and Qatar Structure and infrastructure of infectious agent research literature: SARS Dis-ease surveillance: How might surveillance studies address COVID-19? Surveillance for emerging diseases with multiplexed Point-of-Care diagnostics Factors influencing preventive behavior against middle east respiratory syndrome-coronavirus among nursing students in South Korea Update: severe respiratory illness associated with Middle East respiratory syndrome coronavirus (MERS-CoV)-Worldwide Social big data analysis of information spread and perceived infection risk during the 2015 middle east respiratory syndrome outbreak in South Korea Severe air pollution events not avoided by reduced anthropogenic activities during COVID-19 outbreak Resilience in risk communication networks: Following the 2015 MERS response in South Korea Global health security: Building capacities for early event detection, epidemiologic workforce, and laboratory response Severe acute respiratory syndrome (SARS) in asia: A medical geographic perspective WHO COVID-19 Dashboard ADEEL NASIR received the M.Phil. degree in commerce from the University of Central Punjab, and the Ph.D. degree in management sciences from COMSATS University Islamabad, Lahore Campus. He is currently working as an Assistant Professor in tenor track system with the Lahore College for Women University. He has eight years of teaching and research experience. His research interest includes integration of financial practices with computer programing languages, financial markets, management sciences, and bibliometric analysis. He has published 13 research articles that are published in reputable local and international journals. He has presented his research at four international conferences.KAMRAN SHAUKAT received the M.Sc. degree in computer science from Mohammad Ali Jinnah University, Pakistan. He is currently pursuing the Ph.D. degree with The University of Newcastle, Callaghan, NSW, Australia. He is author of many articles in the area of machine learning, databases, and cyber security. He has served the University of the Punjab, Pakistan, for seven years, as a Lecturer. He has served as a Reviewer to many journals, including IEEE ACCESS. He has attended several international conferences, including USA, U.K., Thailand, Turkey, and Pakistan. He received the Gold Medal for his M.Sc. degree. SUHUAI LUO received the bachelor's and master's degrees from the Nanjing University of Posts and Telecommunications and the Ph.D. degree from the University of Sydney, all in electrical engineering. His main research interests include image processing, computer vision, machine learning, cyber security, and media data mining. He has lectured and developed curricula for courses in computer science, electrical engineering, and information engineering.TALHA MAHBOOB ALAM received the bachelor's degree in software engineering from the University of Management and Technology (UMT), Lahore, in 2017, and the master's degree in computer science from the University of Engineering and Technology (UET), Lahore. He is currently a Researcher. He has several publications in international journals and conferences, including IEEE ACCESS and The Computer Journal. His research interests include data science, data mining, knowledge discovery in databases, bioinformatics, big data, information retrieval, and AI.FARHAT IQBAL received the B.Sc. degree (Hons.) in computer science from the University of the Punjab, Lahore, Pakistan. She has attended many national and international research conferences, including ECTI-CON 2020, Thailand. She has won Full Merit Scholarship, while she was completing her college studies. She has also received merit scholarships during her study at the University of the Punjab. She is currently an Active Researcher. She had published papers in leading conferences and journals. Her current area of research is big data, artificial intelligence, data mining, and cyber security.