key: cord-0708255-s8gwowur
authors: Tang, Kuo-Tung; Hsu, Bo-Chueh; Chen, Der-Yuan
title: Immunogenicity, Effectiveness, and Safety of COVID-19 Vaccines in Rheumatic Patients: An Updated Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis
date: 2022-04-01
journal: Biomedicines
DOI: 10.3390/biomedicines10040834
sha: 8c74827c66ce498ab587d0f37083c656910662ae
doc_id: 708255
cord_uid: s8gwowur

Background: Vaccination is one of the most important measures worldwide to halt the spread of the corona virus disease 2019 (COVID-19). However, the efficacy and safety of these vaccines in rheumatic patients are not well explored. Therefore, we conducted a systematic review and meta-analysis. Methods: We performed a literature search of the PubMed and EMBASE databases on 17 November 2021. Forty-seven studies relevant to the immunogenicity, efficacy/effectiveness, and safety of COVID-19 vaccines were selected. Results: Our results demonstrated that COVID-19 vaccination is effective in protecting rheumatic patients from severe illness caused by the virus. Both the humoral and cellular immunogenicity of vaccines were impaired in rheumatic patients, which were greatly enhanced after the second vaccine dose. Receiving anti-CD20 therapy was associated with impaired humoral immunogenicity. Adverse events due to COVID-19 vaccines in rheumatic patients were similar to those in healthy controls, except for an increased incidence of arthralgia. The incidence of disease flares after COVID-19 vaccination was low. Conclusion: Our systematic review indicated the importance of full vaccination in rheumatic patients. Withholding anti-CD20 therapy was found to be potentially beneficial for the immunogenicity. Furthermore, the vaccines were found to be safe in general. Despite significant heterogeneity between studies, we recommend that rheumatic patients receive these vaccines amidst the global pandemic.

Since the initial outbreak in December 2019, the coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19) pandemic has placed a tremendous burden on healthcare systems and is still a huge threat to all human beings. As of 31 December 2021, nearly 285 million cases have been diagnosed, and 5.1 million fatalities reported globally. The severity of the disease may be alleviated by the global application of effective and safe vaccinations [1] . The mRNA and recombinant adenovirus formats are novel vaccine technologies; however, only healthy or immunocompetent adults were systemically assessed for immunogenicity and the safety of COVID-19 vaccines in phase I, II, and III clinical trials [2] [3] [4] [5] [6] [7] [8] [9] [10] . To date, very few phase IV clinical trials have been conducted to evaluate the immunogenicity and safety of vaccines for patients with rheumatic diseases [11] [12] [13] [14] .

Increasing evidence indicates that COVID-19 poses a higher risk for rheumatic patients of more severe disease and mortality, which include systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE), rheumatoid arthritis (RA), systemic sclerosis, and idiopathic inflammatory myositis, compared with healthy individuals [15] [16] [17] . However, the safety profile of COVID-19 vaccines has been relatively unexplored in rheumatic patients, and multiple studies have demonstrated that the immunogenicity of vaccines may be attenuated by the use of certain immunosuppressants or biologics [13, [18] [19] [20] [21] [22] . While making efforts in terms of widespread vaccination, physicians also need to understand the immunogenicity and adverse effects of vaccines in such patients, including the possibility of vaccine-induced exacerbation of preexisting rheumatic diseases. Therefore, we aim to update the evidence of immunogenicity, efficacy/effectiveness, and safety of COVID-19 vaccines in rheumatic patients. Hopefully, our results will have beneficial clinical implications for these vulnerable populations.

The present review focuses on existing evidence of the immunogenicity and safety profile of COVID-19 vaccines in rheumatic patients. The algorithm of the systematic review followed the Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses (PRISMA) checklist. We searched the EMBASE and MEDLINE databases. We reviewed English literature from 1 January 2020 to 17 Supplementary Table S1 . Eventually, we identified a total of 47 studies according to the Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses (PRISMA) guidelines ( Figure 1 ). The present study has been registered in PROSPERO (CRD42022307795). 

Three authors (KT Tang, BC Hsu, and DY Chen) independently assessed the titles and abstracts identified by the search mentioned above and retrieved the relevant fulltext articles. Two authors (KT Tang and DY Chen) independently evaluated the fulltext articles for eligibility. We selected potentially relevant articles on immunogenicity, efficacy/effectiveness, and/or safety of COVID-19 vaccines in rheumatic patients, including trials, cohorts, cross-sectional and case-control studies involving equal to or more than 10 patients.

Information regarding humoral and/or cellular immunogenicity, efficacy/effectiveness, local/systemic adverse effects, and disease flares after COVID-19 vaccination were recorded for each study in a standardized Excel file. The influence of relevant drugs, including corticosteroids, conventional synthetic disease-modifying anti-rheumatic drugs (csDMARDs), biologic DMARDs (bDMARDs), targeted synthetic DMARDs (tsDMARDs) such as Janus kinase inhibitors (JAKi), and other immunosuppresants, were also documented.

A statistical analysis was performed using Stata, version 14.0 (StataCorp, College Station, TX, USA). A summary estimate of proportions was derived using the command "metaprop" in a random-effects model. The confidence interval was based on the binomial distribution. The summary estimates of rate ratios (RRs) between rheumatic patients and healthy controls, and between drug users and non-users, were derived using the "metan" command. A random-effects model was used following the procedure of DerSimonian and Laird [23] . The heterogeneity was quantified using Tau 2 , Chi 2 , and I 2 measures, based on the Mantel-Haenszel model. Begg's and Egger's tests were used to assess publication bias, while funnel plots were constructed to visualize asymmetry with respect to immunogenicity and disease flares after COVID-19 vaccination.

The characteristics of the selected studies are demonstrated in Table 1 . Most studies were conducted in Western countries and involved Caucasians. In most studies, female adults were predominant, and only one study focused on adolescents [24] . Most study participants received the BNT162b2 vaccine and only a few studies reported on viral vectorbased or inactivated vaccines. In terms of rheumatic diseases, inflammatory arthritis and RA in particular constituted the majority of participants in most studies. Twenty-five studies investigated humoral immunogenicity, whereas cellular immunogenicity was less studied, with only seven relevant studies available. Twenty-seven studies documented adverse events based on either clinical records or questionnaires. 

Humoral response (seroconversion) and T cell response rates after mRNA-based vaccination in rheumatic patients are summarized in Figure 2a [12, 31] . The seroconversion rate after Ad26.COV2.S was 80 (95% CI: 65, 90)% [36] . Notably, Schmiedeberg et al. found that a third dose of mRNA vaccine led to a seroconversion rate of 88% (15/17) in RA patients who had no or minimal serological response after two doses [59] . The RRs between rheumatic patients and healthy controls in terms of immunogenicity after COVID-19 vaccination are illustrated in Figure 2b . The RRs for the seroconversion after the first and second dose were 0.42 (95%CI: 0.34, 0.52) and 0.86 (95%CI: 0.84, 0.87), respectively. The RRs for the T cell response after the first and second dose were 0.69 (95%CI: 0.68, 0.69) and 0.86 (95%CI: 0.55, 1.36), respectively. It is worth noting that seroconversion was absent in a few patients receiving anti-CD20 therapy, whereas T cell response could still be elicited in these patients [28, 52] . 

The seroconversion rates after the second dose of mRNA vaccines in certain medication users are illustrated in Figure 3a . The use of mycophenolic acid or anti-CD20 therapy was associated with a lower seroconversion rate, i.e., 66 (95%CI: 57, 73)% and 41 (95%CI: 35, 48)%, respectively. The seroconversion rate ratios between medication users and nonusers among rheumatic patients after the second dose of mRNA vaccines are illustrated in Figure 3b . The use of corticosteroids, mycophenolic acid, or anti-CD20 therapy was associated with a lower seroconversion rate when compared with non-users. In particular, anti-CD20 therapy was associated with a seroconversion rate that was 55% lower than that of non-users. Additionally, some other factors were found to be associated with a lower seroconversion rate, as summarized in Table 2 . To be noted, Bugatti et al. found that withholding methotrexate or b/tsDMARD for a short time did not significantly influence the seroconversion rate [34] . Table 2 . Factors other than medication use that were associated with a lower seroconversion rate after COVID-19 vaccination in rheumatic patients.

Lower serum IgG Shorter interval between vaccination and last infusion of anti-CD20 therapy Not achieving B cell reconstitution after anti-CD20 therapy 

Only two retrospective studies demonstrated the effectiveness of COVID-19 vaccines in rheumatic patients. Papagoras et al. showed that the hospitalization and mortality rates were higher in unvaccinated (29% and 4%) than the fully vaccinated rheumatic patients (10% and 0%) [53] . In another study, the effectiveness of two doses of mRNA vaccines against COVID-19 hospitalization was 81%, which was slightly lower than that (90%) of immunocompetent controls [41] .

The incidence rates of adverse events after COVID-19 vaccination are illustrated in Figure 4a , b. Local pain (30-55%) was the most common, followed by fatigue (19-28%) after the first dose of viral vector-based vaccine or both doses of the BNT162b2 vaccine. A total of two (0.04%) serious adverse events developed in 4433 rheumatic patients after COVID-19 vaccination. The incidence rate ratios of adverse events after the first dose of COVID-19 vaccines between rheumatic patients and healthy controls are illustrated in Figure 4c . Compared with healthy controls, local pain was less common, whereas arthralgia was more common after receiving the BNT162b2 vaccine, and fever and myalgia were less frequent after viral vector-based vaccination in rheumatic patients. 

As illustrated in Figure 5 , around 2-3% of rheumatic patients developed a flare after COVID-19 vaccination. The disease activity measures, such as disease activity score (DAS)28 and Systemic Lupus Disease Activity Index (SLEDAI), etc., were not different before and after the vaccination [13, 33, 51] . 

Visual inspection of funnel plots demonstrated the existence of potential publication biases with regards to seroconversion rate and rate ratios after mRNA vaccines and the proportion of disease flares after vaccination, although the Begg's and Egger's test results did not reach statistical significance ( Supplementary Figures S1 and S2 ).

Efficacious COVID-19 vaccination is needed to contain the ongoing pandemic. However, a comprehensive evidence analysis or consensus regarding the efficacy and safety of COVID-19 vaccines in rheumatic patients is lacking to date. According to our review, despite the impaired immunogenicity of vaccines in these patients, the vaccines were still very effective in reducing hospitalization and mortality. There were no new safety signals for these vaccines in rheumatic patients except for arthralgia. In addition, the risk of a disease flare after vaccination was minimal.

Being immunocompromised due to inherent immune dysregulation and the concomitant use of immunosuppressants, rheumatic patients are more vulnerable to severe or opportunistic infections. During the COVID-19 pandemic, rheumatic patients were more likely to be hospitalized or succumb [15, 66] , and were strongly advised to receive COVID-19 vaccination [67] . We found that rheumatic patients had impaired humoral and cellular immune responses after COVID-19 vaccination, which was consistent with previous observations of poorer responses to different kinds of vaccines [68] . However, the second or even third dose seemed to significantly enhance the immunogenicity of COVID-19 vaccines. Furthermore, retrospective studies revealed that vaccination was still highly effective against severe illness when contracting COVID-19 for rheumatic patients, supporting the importance of full vaccination.

Immunosuppressants and bDMARDs, including methotrexate, abatacept, and anti-CD20 therapy (rituximab), have been shown to impair vaccine response in rheumatic patients [68, 69] . In the present meta-analysis, we found impaired humoral response in patients receiving anti-CD20 therapy. In addition, several studies demonstrated that other B lymphocyte-associated factors were also implicated in poor humoral response after COVID-19 vaccination. Therefore, it is better to postpone anti-CD20 therapy until B lymphocytes reconstitution before COVID-19 vaccination. On the other hand, the use of mycophenolic acid was also associated with impaired humoral response after COVID-19 vaccination, which was similarly found in transplantation patients [70, 71] . Although withholding most of these immunosuppressants before vaccination was generally recommended [67] , we did not find sufficient evidence to support the beneficial effect of such measures, probably due to very few related study results. The only exception was anti-CD20 therapy, in which the interval between the last infusion and COVID-19 vaccination was positively associated with increased humoral response. More studies are required to provide evidence in terms of deciding which medications to withhold and the optimal time frame.

Vaccine hesitancy has led some rheumatic patients to abstain from vaccination, putting them at an unnecessary risk for COVID-19. The two main reasons for hesitation were adverse events and worries about flares of underlying diseases [72] . Our review seeks to reassure such individuals that no new safety signal has been found in rheumatic patients receiving vaccination except for arthralgia after receiving the BNT162b2 vaccine, and most of these joint symptoms were transient and lasted for a few days. The rate of serious adverse events was extremely low after COVID-19 vaccination, i.e., comparable to that in the general population [73] . Additionally, the incidence rate of disease flare after vaccination was also low, and there was, on average, no increase in disease activity in most rheumatic patients.

Our review has some limitations. First, the study population, comorbidities, concomitant medication use, interval between vaccination and outcomes, and outcome measurements differed considerably among studies. Such heterogeneity limited the strength of the interpretation of the results. Furthermore, the combination of several medications precluded the precise determination of the effect of a single drug in terms of immunogenicity. Second, underrepresentation of ethnic groups such as Asians and Hispanics, age groups such as adolescents and children, receivers of non-mRNA vaccines, and patients with rheumatic diseases other than inflammatory arthritis should cause some concern when extrapolating our findings. Third, we found that the humoral immune response was more impaired than the cellular response in rheumatic patients after COVID-19 vaccination. Could such preserved cellular response protect these patients from COVID-19 infection? A relatively small number of effectiveness studies suggested an urgent need to conduct more such studies to elucidate this question and find other influencing factors (such as medications). Fourth, the duration of medication use was not specified in these studies. For instance, the duration of corticosteroid use may affect vaccine efficacy. Despite these limitations, our review still provides an updated and valuable overview of effectiveness and safety issues while rheumatic patients worldwide are receiving vaccinations due to the COVID-19 pandemic. Moreover, our results were similar to those of studies on patients with multiple sclerosis, an autoimmune neurological disorder which is treated with similar drugs [74, 75] .

Our comprehensive review demonstrated the efficacy, albeit lower when compared with healthy individuals, and safety of COVID-19 vaccines in rheumatic patients. The results support the recommendations of full vaccination in these patients. However, significant study heterogeneity may undermine our conclusions.

Supplementary Materials: The following are available online at https://www.mdpi.com/article/ 10.3390/biomedicines10040834/s1, Figure S1 : The funnel plots, as well as Begg's and Egger's tests results, of the seroconversion rate and cellular response rate after (a, b) 1st and (c, d) 2nd dose of mRNA vaccines, and (e) the proportion of disease flares after COVID-19 vaccination, Figure S2 : Begg's and Egger's tests results, of the seroconversion rate ratios after (a) 1st and (b) 2nd dose of mRNA vaccines when compared with healthy controls, Table S1 : Search strategies. Informed Consent Statement: Informed consent was not needed because this is a systemic review.

The datasets used and/or analyzed during the current review are available from the corresponding author on reasonable request.

Immunological mechanisms of vaccine-induced protection against COVID-19 in humans

Safety and immunogenicity of the ChAdOx1 nCoV-19 vaccine against SARS-CoV-2: A preliminary report of a phase 1/2, single-blind, randomised controlled trial

An mRNA Vaccine against SARS-CoV-2-Preliminary Report

Immunogenicity and safety of a recombinant adenovirus type-5-vectored COVID-19 vaccine in healthy adults aged 18 years or older: A randomised, double-blind, placebo-controlled, phase 2 trial

Phase I/II study of COVID-19 RNA vaccine BNT162b1 in adults

Ad26 vector-based COVID-19 vaccine encoding a prefusion-stabilized SARS-CoV-2 Spike immunogen induces potent humoral and cellular immune responses

Interim Results of a Phase 1-2a Trial of Ad26.COV2.S Covid-19 Vaccine

Safety and Immunogenicity of SARS-CoV-2 mRNA-1273 Vaccine in Older Adults

Safety and Immunogenicity of Two RNA-Based COVID-19 Vaccine Candidates

Safety and immunogenicity of concomitant administration of COVID-19 vaccines (ChAdOx1 or BNT162b2) with seasonal influenza vaccines in adults in the UK (ComFluCOV): A multicentre, randomised, controlled, phase 4 trial

Immunogenicity and safety of the CoronaVac inactivated vaccine in patients with autoimmune rheumatic diseases: A phase 4 trial

Immunogenicity and safety of the BNT162b2 mRNA COVID-19 vaccine in adult patients with autoimmune inflammatory rheumatic diseases and in the general population: A multicentre study

Systemic autoimmune myopathies: A prospective phase 4 controlled trial of an inactivated virus vaccine against SARS-CoV-2

Factors associated with COVID-19-related death using OpenSAFELY

Risk Factors for Severe Outcomes in Patients with Systemic Vasculitis and COVID-19: A Binational, Registry-Based Cohort Study

Comorbidities in rheumatic diseases need special consideration during the COVID-19 pandemic

COVID-19 vaccination and antirheumatic therapy

Humoral and T-cell responses to SARS-CoV-2 vaccination in patients receiving immunosuppression

Assessment of humoral and cellular immunity induced by the BNT162b2 SARS-CoV-2 vaccine in healthcare workers, elderly people, and immunosuppressed patients with autoimmune disease

Vaccine response following anti-CD20 therapy: A systematic review and meta-analysis of 905 patients

Immunogenicity and safety of anti-SARS-CoV-2 mRNA vaccines in patients with chronic inflammatory conditions and immunosuppressive therapy in a monocentric cohort

Meta-analysis in clinical trials

Safety and tolerability of the COVID -19 messenger RNA vaccine in adolescents with juvenile idiopathic arthritis treated with tumor necrosis factor inhibitors

Impaired Antibody Response to the BNT162b2 Messenger RNA Coronavirus Disease 2019 Vaccine in Patients with Systemic Lupus Erythematosus and Rheumatoid Arthritis

Immunogenicity of the COVID-19 mRNA vaccine in adolescents with juvenile idiopathic arthritis on treatment with TNF inhibitors

Local and systemic reactogenicity of COVID-19 vaccine BNT162b2 in patients with systemic lupus erythematosus and rheumatoid arthritis

Presence of specific T cell response after SARS-CoV-2 vaccination in rheumatoid arthritis patients receiving rituximab

Incidence of Disease Flare After BNT162b2 Coronavirus Disease 2019 Vaccination in Patients with Rheumatoid Arthritis in Remission

Adverse events after first COVID-19 vaccination in patients with autoimmune diseases

Antibody development after COVID-19 vaccination in patients with autoimmune diseases in the Netherlands: A substudy of data from two prospective cohort studies

Antibody response to a single dose of SARS-CoV-2 mRNA vaccine in patients with rheumatic and musculoskeletal diseases

Disease activity and humoral response in patients with inflammatory rheumatic diseases after two doses of the Pfizer mRNA vaccine against SARS-CoV-2

Methotrexate and glucocorticoids, but not anticytokine therapy, impair the immunogenicity of a single dose of the BNT162b2 mRNA COVID-19 vaccine in patients with chronic inflammatory arthritis

Safety of the ChAdOx1 nCoV-19 and the BBV152 vaccines in 724 patients with rheumatic diseases: A post-vaccination cross-sectional survey

CoV-2 vaccine in patients with rheumatic and musculoskeletal diseases

Disease Flare and Reactogenicity in Patients with Rheumatic and Musculoskeletal Diseases Following Two-Dose SARS & CoV -2 Messenger RNA Vaccination

Safety profile of pfizer-biontech covid-19 vaccine in patients with rheumatic diseases: Preliminary assessment

Effect of Immunosuppression on the Immunogenicity of mRNA Vaccines to SARS-CoV-2: A Prospective Cohort Study

Safety of BNT162b2 mRNA COVID-19 vaccine in a cohort of elderly, immunocompromised patients with systemic vasculitis

Effectiveness of 2-Dose Vaccination with mRNA COVID-19 Vaccines Against COVID-19-Associated Hospitalizations Among Immunocompromised Adults-Nine States

Adverse events of six COVID-19 vaccines in patients with autoimmune rheumatic diseases: A cross-sectional study

Impaired immunogenicity to COVID-19 vaccines in autoimmune systemic diseases. High prevalence of non-response in different patients’ subgroups

Evaluation of antibody response to BNT162b2 mRNA COVID-19 vaccine in patients affected by immune-mediated inflammatory diseases up to 5 months after vaccination

COVID-19 vaccine safety and nocebo-prone associated hesitancy in patients with systemic rheumatic diseases: A cross-sectional study

Methotrexate hampers immunogenicity to BNT162b2 mRNA COVID-19 vaccine in immune-mediated inflammatory disease

Evaluation of Immune Response and Disease Status in Systemic Lupus Erythematosus Patients Following SARS -CoV -2 Vaccination

The SARS-CoV-2 Vaccine Response in ANCA-Associated Vasculitis

Two-dose COVID-19 vaccination and possible arthritis flare among patients with rheumatoid arthritis in Hong Kong

Mariette COVID-19 vaccine safety in patients with rheumatic and musculoskeletal disease

BNT162b2 vaccine-induced humoral and cellular responses against SARS-CoV-2 variants in systemic lupus erythematosus

SARS-CoV-2 vaccination in rituximab-treated patients: B cells promote humoral immune responses in the presence of T-cell-mediated immunity

Better outcomes of COVID-19 in vaccinated compared to unvaccinated patients with systemic rheumatic diseases

ImmunosuppressiveTherapies Differently Modulate Humoral-and T-Cell-Specific Responses to COVID-19 mRNA Vaccine in Rheumatoid Arthritis Patients

Preliminary Data on Post Market Safety Profiles of COVID 19 Vaccines in Rheumatic Diseases: Assessments on Various Vaccines in Use, Different Rheumatic Disease Subtypes, and Immunosuppressive Therapies: A Two-Centers Study. Vaccines 2021

Anti-SARS-CoV-2 mRNA vaccine in patients with rheumatoid arthritis

High antibody response to two-dose SARS-CoV-2 messenger RNA vaccination in patients with rheumatic and musculoskeletal diseases

Global Rheumatology Alliance Vaccine Survey

Efficacy and tolerability of a third dose of an mRNA anti-SARS-CoV-2 vaccine in patients with rheumatoid arthritis with absent or minimal serological response to two previous doses

Safety and tolerability of mRNA COVID-19 vaccines in people with antiphospholipid antibodies

Antibody response to inactivated COVID-19 vaccine (CoronaVac) in immune-mediated diseases: A controlled study among hospital workers and elderly

Patients with immune-mediated inflammatory diseases receiving cytokine inhibitors have low prevalence of SARS-CoV-2 seroconversion

A prospective multicenter study assessing humoral immunogenicity and safety of the mRNA SARS-CoV-2 vaccines in Greek patients with systemic autoimmune and autoinflammatory rheumatic diseases

Gensler Reactogenicity of SARS-COV-2 vaccines in patients with autoimmune and inflammatory disease

Side effects and flares risk after SARS-CoV-2 vaccination in patients with systemic lupus erythematosus

Coronavirus disease 2019, immune-mediated inflammatory diseases and immunosuppressive therapies -A Danish population-based cohort study

American College of Rheumatology Guidance for COVID-19 Vaccination in Patients with Rheumatic and Musculoskeletal Diseases: Version 3. Arthritis Rheumatol

update of EULAR recommendations for vaccination in adult patients with autoimmune inflammatory rheumatic diseases

Effect of Methotrexate, Anti-Tumor Necrosis Factor α, and Rituximab on the Immune Response to Influenza and Pneumococcal Vaccines in Patients with Rheumatoid Arthritis: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis

Reduced humoral response to mRNA SARS-CoV-2 BNT162b2 vaccine in kidney transplant recipients without prior exposure to the virus

BNT162b2 vaccination in heart transplant recipients: Clinical experience and antibody response

Vaccination against COVID-19: Expectations and concerns of patients with autoimmune and rheumatic diseases

Evaluation of the safety profile of COVID-19 vaccines: A rapid review

Immunogenicity and safety of mRNA COVID-19 vaccines in people with multiple sclerosis treated with different disease-modifying therapies

SARS-CoV-2 serology after COVID-19 in multiple sclerosis: An international cohort study

The authors thank Shiow-Jiuan Wey, of the Chung Shan Medical University Hospital, Taiwan, for the help in manuscript preparation.

The authors have no competing interest to declare.