key: cord-0775437-0emxcdgc authors: Cai, Siyu; Guo, Qiaohong; Wang, Xianjing; Wang, Ruixin; Yang, Peiyi; Zhou, Yuchen; Luo, Yanhui; Zhou, Xuan; Peng, Xiaoxia title: Development levels of pediatric palliative care teams and the extent of palliative care understanding and implementation among pediatric oncologists in China date: 2021-09-27 journal: Pediatr Investig DOI: 10.1002/ped4.12291 sha: 3f2913b171baac6e489f9ad8cc943d67954aeb43 doc_id: 775437 cord_uid: 0emxcdgc IMPORTANCE: Pediatric palliative care (PPC) is an interdisciplinary collaboration that focuses on the prevention and relief of patient suffering. PPC has emerged as a critical field of medical expertise and practice. However, no information is available regarding the progress of PPC in the Chinese mainland. OBJECTIVE: This study investigated the geographic distribution, team structure, and services of PPC teams in the Chinese mainland. It also investigated the level of understanding and implementation among pediatric oncologists regarding PPC. METHODS: The PPC subspecialty group of the Pediatrics Society of the Chinese Medical Association included 45 PPC teams. The team structure and services were investigated using questionnaires mailed to the team leader of each PPC team. In addition, we sent questionnaires regarding the level of PPC understanding and implementation of PPC practices to 170 pediatric oncologists in 11 hospitals. RESULTS: The geographical distribution of PPC teams is uneven in China. Most PPC teams are concentrated in the eastern provincial capital of China. Most PPC teams had limited staff and services. The level of PPC understanding was considerably limited across all demographics; most pediatric oncologists reported “some understanding” (n = 71, 41.8%) or “poor understanding” (n = 50, 29.4%). Only 62.9% of pediatric oncologists had experience providing advice to family members regarding PPC matters. INTERPRETATION: China is currently experiencing a critical shortage of PPC resources. Most pediatric oncologists had a limited understanding of PPC and reported limited practical implementation of PPC, which leads to underutilization of PPC resources. Pediatric palliative care (PPC) is an interdisciplinary collaboration that focuses on the prevention and relief of patient suffering, as well as holistic management of the physical, psychosocial, and spiritual needs of both children and families. 1, 2 Over the past two decades, PPC has emerged as a critical field of medical expertise and practice in western nations. 3 Although PPC has experienced exponential growth in the past decade, overall development of this field is limited and demonstrates a lack of balance among countries. 4 In 2011, Knapp et al 5 found that approximately two-thirds of countries worldwide had no known PPC activities, and only 5.7% had a provision that was reaching mainstream providers. According to the International Observatory on End of Life Care, the PPC status in China is Level 2 (i.e., capacity building activities). 5 According to mortality surveillance data-related estimates, 90 600 children in China could potentially benefit from end-of-life PPC in 2017. 6 However, no information is available in China regarding PPC progress and the gaps that still exist in provision. Therefore, this study investigated the geographic distribution, team structure, and services of PPC teams in the Chinese mainland. Currently, PPC services are mainly provided to patients with cancer. The WHO recommends integration of PPC into standard pediatric oncology care. 7 The level of understanding among pediatric oncologists regarding PPC influences their application of PPC in clinical practice; this application influences PPC service utilization and quality of life among affected patients. Therefore, this study also investigated the level of PPC understanding among pediatric oncologists in China and the degree to which they implement this knowledge in clinical practice. This study was approved by the Ethics Committee of Beijing Children's Hospital (2018-165). All participants voluntarily completed this anonymous survey and were thus exempt from requirements for written informed consent. The PPC subspecialty group of the Pediatrics Society of the Chinese Medical Association was established in 2017. It has included 45 member units until June 2019 and is the only PPC-related professional organization in the Chinese mainland. The establishment of this organization constituted the beginning of PPC development in the Chinese mainland. We investigated the geographic distribution, team structure, and services of these 45 PPC teams. Geographic distribution information was obtained from the leader of the PPC subspecialty group. Team structure and services data were collected using questionnaires (Supplementary file S1). Questionnaires were mailed to the team leader of each PPC team. Each organization received only one survey questionnaire. The questionnaire collected information regarding team establishment time, staff composition, and scope of services offered by the PPC teams. The questionnaire was developed by researchers (Siyu Cai, Xuan Zhou and Xiaoxia Peng) on the basis of literature reviews. 8, 9 Pilot tests involving three teams were performed to identify items that were ambiguous or poorly worded. This survey was conducted from August 2019 to October 2019; the response rate was 100%. Adult hospice units in some general hospitals may accept adolescent patients. Because these teams cannot provide services applicable to children, they were excluded from this study. This study surveyed pediatric oncologists affiliated with hospitals in which the 45 PPC teams were located. Only pediatric oncologists in hospitals with mature PPC teams were eligible to participate because they had the greatest likelihood of possessing knowledge regarding PPC. Therefore, we excluded 12 hospitals with immature PPC teams (i.e., teams comprising doctors alone or teams with only one year of working experience). We sent emails to the remaining 33 hospitals, 11 of which agreed to participate in this study. The questionnaire survey platform "Wenjuanxing" (www. wjx.cn) was used for data collection. A research summary and questionnaire website link was sent to pediatric oncologists by the director of the pediatric oncology department of each hospital via WeChat. The questionnaire could not be submitted to the platform if a participant only provided some answers or did not complete the required items. The duration of the questionnaire was approximately 5-10 min. Oncologists who responded to this survey were not the members of PPC teams. The survey items concerned basic information, PPC understanding level, PPC practices, and barriers toward PPC (Supplementary file S2). Before general release of the survey, the questionnaire was reviewed, piloted, revised, and repiloted by an expert panel of pediatric oncologists. This survey was conducted from April 2019 to June 2019. Duplicate questionnaires were deleted based on review of IP addresses. The number of total surveys distributed was not recorded because of the method by which questionnaires were distributed. Thus, the questionnaire response rate could not be accurately calculated. Data were analyzed using SAS version 9.4. Descriptive statistics were used to summarize the data. Frequencies and counts were reported for categorical variables. Means and standard deviations were reported for normally distributed numerical variables. Medians and interquartile ranges were reported for non-normally distributed numerical variables. Normality was determined by Shapiro-Wilk test. Bivariate and multivariate logistic regression analyses were performed to assess the associations between demographic characteristics and level of PPC understanding. The PPC subspecialty group of the Pediatrics Society of the Chinese Medical Association included 45 PPC teams. These teams covered 22 provinces or municipalities in the Chinese mainland, and their geographical distributions were uneven (Table S1 ). PPC teams were concentrated in economically developed regions in the eastern part of China. Reports of PPC activities in western China were limited. Forty-four teams belonged to tertiary hospitals and one team belonged to a secondary hospital. The first PPC team was established in 2009 in Shanghai, and most teams (23/45, 51.1%) were established in 2017. The 45 PPC teams included 300 staff members. Staffing situations reported by PPC teams indicated wide variations regarding the types of professionals and the numbers of people providing PPC services. The mean number of team members was 6.7 (range, [1] [2] [3] [4] [5] [6] [7] [8] [9] [10] [11] [12] [13] [14] . PPC team members included physicians (100.0% of teams), nurses (88.9% of teams), social workers (37.8% of teams), nutritionists (31.1% of teams), pharmacists (28.9% of teams), psychologists (28.9% of teams), and anesthesiologists (11.1% of teams). Importantly, no teams included spiritual support workers, bereavement specialists, child life specialists, or case managers. Furthermore, approximately one-third of the teams comprised physicians and nurses alone (n = 13, 28.9%), and some teams comprised physicians alone (n = 4, 8.9%). Twenty teams (44.4%) included long-term volunteers (individuals who had received training and performed services more than 3 months), with a median of three volunteers per team. As shown in Table 1 , the services provided by existing PPC teams are limited. These services include pain and symptom management (100.0% of teams), psychological and spiritual support for patients (80.0% of teams), psychological and spiritual support for families (73.3% of teams), bereavement support (33.3% of teams), and advance care planning (31.1% of teams). Consultation care in a home setting was the main pattern of service. Palliative care beds or suites were rarely available. Only 11.1% of teams reported access to a dedicated inpatient unit; the median number of beds was 1 (interquartile range, 1-1.5). Few teams (n = 15, 33.3%) had experience in providing PPC to patients with non-cancer diseases. Thirty PPC teams (66.7%) cared for cancer patients only. In total, 170 pediatric oncologists from 11 hospitals completed the questionnaire; their demographic characteristics are shown in reported "some understanding" (n = 71, 41.8%) or "poor understanding" (n = 50, 29.4%). Only 35 (20.6%) reported "fair understanding" and 7 (4.1%) reported "good understanding" of PPC. Seven (4.1%) reported "no understanding". We performed logistic regression analyses to assess the associations between demographic characteristics (i.e., age, sex, specialty, title, and academic degree) and level of understanding. For the purpose of analysis, level of understanding was dichotomized as good understanding (fair or good) or poor understanding (no, poor, or some). Multivariate analysis revealed that specialty (chemotherapy) and high title (professor and assistant professor) were associated with good understanding level ( 10, 11 The number of facilities is insufficient to meet the growing demand for PPC services in China. Our findings provide strong evidence that PPC development in China is urgently needed to improve service accessibility. Formal PPC services should be incorporated in the mainstream healthcare system. Policy-level support is essential for establishing PPC services and making those services available to all individuals and communities in China. Remaining gaps include the preparation of PPC standards (e.g., structure, human resources, and environment), promotion of Considering that most pediatric care occurs outside the hospital, diverse programs and round-the-clock care should be developed. 7, 14 The PPC workforce shortage problem is worsened because palliative care needs frequently occur outside of traditional working hours; hence, the palliative care workforce may benefit from flexible work hours and different forms of service (e.g., "online wards"). [15] [16] [17] During the COVID-19 pandemic, some PPC teams have admitted and remotely managed patients using "online wards" to maintain a safe working environment and ensure service quality. 18 This survey showed that most pediatric oncologists have limited PPC understanding and conduct limited implementation of PPC, although they work in hospitals with PPC teams. These findings are presumably related to a lack of palliative care education for healthcare providers. 19 Few medical schools in China provide formal training regarding palliative care. 19 National standards are needed with respect to clinical training in palliative care. Among the pediatric oncologists who desired additional information regarding PPC, the most strongly preferred learning method was case discussion. Previous studies have shown that a compelling story could be a strong source of motivation for change. Sharing stories and experiences can help pediatric oncologists to better understand palliative care and implement important aspects in clinical practice. 20 It is crucial for healthcare providers, hospitals, governments, and policy makers to understand the barriers to PPC. At the national level, there is a need to develop policies, legislation, national standards, clinical guidelines, and referral criteria regarding PPC. At the hospital level, PPC programs should effectively integrate their services into hospital practice. At the PPC team level, multidisciplinary teams should be built to ensure that the physical, emotional, spiritual, and social needs of both children and their families are identified and addressed. From a research perspective, localized PPC service models should be constructed in accordance with Chinese national conditions and needs. This study had two limitations. First, because of the general lack of data management among 45 PPC teams, the number and characteristics of Chinese patients receiving PPC are unknown. Second, the non-response bias limited the representativeness of the findings. In conclusion, most PPC teams across the Chinese mainland had limited staff and services, which indicates that China is experiencing a critical shortage of PPC resources. Furthermore, most pediatric oncologists had a limited understanding of PPC and reported limited implementation of PPC, which leads to underutilization of PPC resources. World Health Organization. WHO definition of palliative care Pediatric palliative care and hospice care commitments, guidelines, and recommendations Specialist palliative care service for wileyonlinelibrary children with life-threatening conditions: A nationwide survey of availability and utilization Pediatric palliative care provision around the world: a systematic review Estimation of pediatric end-of-life palliative care needs in China: a secondary analysis of mortality data from the 2017 National Mortality Surveillance System Cancer pain relief and palliative care in children with cancer A summary of pediatric palliative care team structure and services as reported by centers caring for children with cancer Pediatric palliative care programs in children's hospitals: a cross-sectional national survey National Coalition for Hospice and Palliative Care, National Consensus Project. Clinical Practice Guidelines for Quality Palliative Care Global Atlas of Palliative Care at the End of Life End of life care for infants, children and young people with life-limiting conditions: planning and management: the NICE guideline 2016 Advanced certification for palliative care programs. www.jointcommission.org/certification/ palliative_care.aspx Increased access to palliative care and hospice services: Opportunities to improve value in health care Palliative care afterhours: A review of a phone support service Use of telehealth in pediatric palliative care Responses of pediatric palliative care to the COVID-19 pandemic in China Palliative care medical student education: a cross-sectional medical school survey in mainland China Development and implementation of a pediatric palliative care program in a developing country No financial or non-financial benefits have been received or will be received from any party related directly or indirectly to the subject of this article. Additional Supporting Information may be found online in the supporting information tab for this article.