key: cord-0824662-ohojsal7 authors: Jiang, Shirley Xue; Hussaini, Trana; Yoshida, Eric M. title: N-acetylcysteine for non-acetaminophen induced acute liver failure: A review date: 2022-02-07 journal: Saudi J Gastroenterol DOI: 10.4103/sjg.sjg_406_21 sha: 4302f5c46fc7f38e250a9f1ff57cdddf71b67004 doc_id: 824662 cord_uid: ohojsal7 The use of N-acetylcysteine (NAC) for non-acetaminophen-induced acute liver failure (NAI-ALF) has been increasing despite controversy in its efficacy. National guidelines are in disagreement for NAC use as standard of care; however, many healthcare centers continue to adopt the use of NAC outside of acetaminophen poisoning. While NAC may have multiple mechanisms of action in treatment of ALF, this has not translated to clinical benefit. Murine models have reported antioxidant and anti-inflammatory properties, as well as improvement in liver-specific microcirculation. Multiple case studies and series have reported positive outcomes of NAC treatment for ALF of various etiologies. While prospective studies suggested the benefit of NAC treatment, these studies have methodological and statistical shortcomings that affect the validity of the results. In this review, we aimed to summarize the existing literature on the efficacy of NAC for NAI-ALF including mechanism of action, case studies and series demonstrating outcomes, and prospective studies that have led to its current widespread use, along with the reported rate of adverse events. guidelines state that NAC treatment for NAI-ALF should be limited to clinical trials only. [6] Multiple reviews investigating the efficacy of NAC treatment for NAI-ALF have concluded that there is insufficient evidence to recommend its routine use. Two reviews, which included two prospective cohort studies in adults with NAI-ALF, made no recommendation for NAC due to multiple areas of bias in existing studies. [7, 8] In a meta-analysis of two adult and two pediatric studies, there was no significant improvement in overall survival with NAC treatment though there was suggestion of better transplant-free survival and post-transplant survival. [8] Another review specifically studied NAC treatment for NAI-DILI leading to ALF, but was too underpowered to draw conclusions. [9] The most recent systematic reviews appear to provide conflicting conclusions. In 2020, Siu et al. conducted a Cochrane systematic review on NAC in NAI-ALF including only one adult trial, [10] and deemed the evidence to be inconclusive due to the risk of bias and imprecision. [11] Contrastingly, Shrestha et al. [12] conducted a meta-analysis of NAC in acute liver injury in pediatric and adult populations and found mortality benefit in NAC use; however, on closer examination, this finding did not reach significance when including only randomized trials. While these reviews provide a summary of evidence, their findings require contextualization and critical appraisal before they can be clinically applied. Animal models have studied possible mechanisms of NAC in ALF, whereby oxidative injury leads to hepatocyte apoptosis and mitochondrial failure [13] [ Figure 1 ]. NAC has been shown to have antioxidant properties beyond acting as a precursor to glutathione. [14] In a mouse model of ALF, NAC treatment attenuated hepatocyte apoptosis resulting from oxidative stress. [15] Further, NAC has been shown to improve mitochondrial dysfunction in mouse models of liver injury. [16, 17] NAC also exhibits an anti-inflammatory effect by inhibiting activation of toll-like receptors and lowering systemic cytokine levels. [18] This anti-inflammatory effect was shown to normalize mice cerebral edema and decrease neutrophil infiltration of the liver, [19] which mitigates hepatocyte death. [20] ALF is also associated with tissue hypoxia, [13] which has been shown to improve with NAC treatment in early physiologic studies. After NAC administration to ALF patients, Harrison et al. [21] observed improved oxygen delivery and consumption, though this effect was diminished in patients with NAI-ALF. While cyclic guanosine monophosphate (cGMP) is elevated during ALF, [22] a further increase in cGMP was observed after NAC treatment, leading to the proposal that improved oxygenation was secondary to cGMP-induced vasodilation. [23] This result was criticized as studies by Harrison et al. utilized the Fick method to calculate oxygen consumption, which is prone to false elevations. [24, 25] Other studies that directly measured systemic oxygen delivery and consumption found no improvement of oxygenation with NAC treatment. [26] Nonetheless, there may be a specific effect in hepatosplanchnic circulation as subsequent studies measured improved blood flow index and associated increased hepatic clearance after NAC treatment. [27] As such, NAC treatment likely improves liver-specific circulation, but none of these effects have translated to clinical outcomes. [28] Some case studies and series suggest that NAC treatment in NAI-ALF is effective in the early stages of hepatic encephalopathy (HE). In a case series of eight adults in Sri Lanka with dengue-associated ALF treated with NAC infusions, recovery was seen in patients with grade I-II HE. [29] Similarly, another case series in Israel including seven adults with NAI-ALF treated with intravenous or oral NAC, showed clinical recovery and reversal of coagulopathy in three patients with grade 0-II HE (a fourth patient recovered but died from unrelated causes), though it is unclear whether recovered patients had acute liver injury that was spontaneously reversible or had liver failure that would have been irreversible if NAC had not been provided. [30] Further, the reversal of coagulopathy is of unclear significance as NAC treatment has been shown to increase clotting factors in healthy participants with no liver injury. [31] Multiple case studies have demonstrated outcomes of NAC treatment in NAI-ALF, ranging from DILI, shock liver, and infectious causes [ Table 1 ]. Outcomes are generally positive with complete clinical and biochemical resolution; however, there are also reports of death due to ALF or mortality from other causes. There are also several studies of NAC treatment for ALF in the pediatric population of various etiologies, which have led to conflicting results that may not be directly comparable to the adult population [ Table 2 ]. [32] [33] [34] [35] Although these case reports and series are clinically interesting, hypothesis-generating, and suggest the potential for benefit, without a comparator control group of patients on non-NAC standard care alone, it is impossible to determine whether NAC treatment was definitely beneficial. Prospective cohort studies suggesting the benefit of NAC in NAI-ALF are limited in size and heterogeneity [ Table 2 ]. Mumtaz et al. [49] preformed a prospective cohort study in Pakistan of oral NAC treatment for NAI-ALF, where ALF was mainly secondary to viral hepatitis (HEV, HBV) and DILI. Compared to a historical control group, NAC treatment was associated with a higher survival rate (47% vs. 27%, P = 0.05). The authors acknowledge that there were advances in critical care during the study period, rendering the historical control incomparable, especially as the control group had more deaths attributed to "sepsis/ multiorgan failure." A similar prospective cohort study was conducted in Kuwait by Darweesh et al. [51] However, the majority of their participants did not have encephalopathy at enrolment, which represents a major departure from other studies adhering to the strict definition of ALF. Hassen 2018 [36] Middle-aged female presenting with cocaine and alcohol use leading to ALF. Zhang 2019 [37] Young male with sickle cell disease and frequent pain crisis, presenting with ALF. Resolution of clinical and biochemical derangements. Dengue hemorrhagic fever (DHF) Abeysekera 2013 [38] Middle-aged female with DHF, symptom onset 5 days ago, presenting with ALF. Resolution of clinical and biochemical derangements. Manoj 2014 [39] Middle-aged male with DHF, symptom onset 4 days ago, presenting with ALF. Resolution of clinical and biochemical derangements. Dalugama 2017 [40] Middle-aged male with DHF, symptom onset 4 days ago, presenting with ALF. Resolution of clinical and biochemical derangements. Dissanayake 2021 [41] Thirty adults with severe dengue fever leading to ALF. Resolution of clinical and biochemical derangements. Parvataneni 2020 [42] Elderly male presenting with sepsis and atrial fibrillation with rapid ventricular response, leading to multi-organ failure, including ALF. Improvement in clinical status and biochemical derangements, with eventual discharge. Tyrosine kinase inhibitor -Crizotinib Brown 2017 [43] Middle-aged female with metastatic non-small cell lung cancer on crizotinib, presenting with acute liver injury, which progressed to ALF. Worsening bilirubinemia, coagulopathy, and hepatic encephalopathy. The patient ultimately developed subarachnoid hemorrhage and supportive care was withdrawn. Tyrosine kinase inhibitor -Crizotinib Adhikari 2018 [44] Middle-aged male with ALK + metastatic non-small cell carcinoma on crizotinib, presenting with ALF and multiorgan dysfunction. Worsening bilirubinemia, coagulopathy, and hepatic encephalopathy despite improvement in transaminitis. The patient ultimately died from multi-organ dysfunction. Ifosfamide Cheung 2011 [45] Middle-aged female with synovial sarcoma of the neck, treated with ifosfamide and doxorubicin leading to ALF. Resolution of clinical and biochemical derangements. No further liver toxicity in subsequent chemotherapy cycles with doxorubicin alone. Norfloxacin Elliot 2016 [46] Older female on treatment with norfloxacin treatment for 3 days presented with ALF. Resolution of clinical and biochemical derangements. Rifampin, isoniazid, pyrazinamide, ethambutol (RIPE) Fox 2020 [47] Young female with tuberculosis presenting with ALF after 4 days of RIPE treatment. Resolution of clinical and biochemical derangements. Discharged on alternative tuberculosis medications. Remdesivir (in context of COVID-19 infection) Carothers 2020 [48] Two patients developed ALF after 3-10 days of remdesivir treatment for COVID-19 pneumonia. One patient fully recovered while the other died of presumed septic shock. treatment (96.4% vs. 23.3%, P < 0.01), and no further analysis was conducted given their substantial result. The transplant-free survival with NAC dramatically exceeds the results of other studies and the authors attributed this to using significantly higher doses of NAC treatment. The most rigorous and commonly referenced study reporting benefit of NAC in NAI-ALF is by Lee et al. in 2009 . [10] This prospective, double-blind, randomized study, included 24 centers across the US from 1998 to 2006, and enrolled 173 patients with NAI-ALF. Eighty-one patients were treated with NAC. The etiologies of ALF were predominantly DILI, unknown, HBV, and autoimmune hepatitis. The primary endpoint of overall survival at 3 weeks was not significantly improved with NAC treatment (70%, 95% CI: 60-81) compared to the control group (66%, 95% CI: 56-77, one-sided P = 0.2). The secondary endpoint of transplant-free survival was significantly higher in NAC group (40%, 95% CI: 28-51) compared to the control group (27%, 95% CI: 18-37, one-sided P = 0.043). This effect was emphasized in grade I-II HE with an odds ratio of 2.46 (95% CI: 1.14-5.30) compared to HE grade III-IV (OR: 0.33, 95% CI: 0.06-1.74). Further analysis performed on the same dataset found that transplantation or death is associated with higher ALT and advanced HE. [52] Higher IL-17 concentration was inversely associated with transplant-free survival in both NAC and placebo patients. [53] The trial by Lee et al. [10] has been criticized in subsequent literature. The foremost issue is use of one-sided P values for overall survival and transplant-free survival instead of the standard two-sided test, that has become accepted as the conventional level of significance (i.e., P = 0.05 for a one-sided test becomes 0.10 when one uses the conventional two-sided test). When Siu et al. [11] re-analyzed data using two-sided P values, they could not replicate the original findings, including the subgroup analysis of transplant-free survival by coma grade. Further, there was no adjustment for multiple comparisons, leading to increased risk of false positive results. Another consideration is that nine participants were excluded despite the intention-to-treat analysis. However, Siu et al. [11] performed a "best-worst/ worst-best case scenario" analysis and found no change in the effect, suggesting low risk of attrition bias. Lastly, Siu et al. [11] found reporting bias due to omission of one-year outcomes. International RCTs studying the effect of NAC on NAI-ALF have also suggested a survival benefit but require a critical appraisal. Nabi et al. [54] conducted a randomized controlled trial in India on the efficacy of NAC infusion in NAI-ALF. The etiology was primarily unknown, DILI, and HEV. On univariate analysis, the NAC group had an improved survival (72.5% vs. 47.5% in the placebo group, P = 0.025), though when stratified by etiology, only the DILI group retained slightly superior outcomes with NAC (P = 0.049). It is unreported if adjustments were made for multiple comparisons for this marginal P value. On logistic regression analysis, predictors of mortality included NAC treatment (adjusted OR: 4.6, P = 0.01), grade I-II HE (adjusted OR: 5.254, P = 0.007), and presence of ascites (adjusted OR: 7.077, P = 0.034). Unfortunately, the lack of reporting in methodology limits validity of the results. There was unclear allocation concealment and blinding, which can lead to selection bias especially as there were significant differences in baseline clinicodemographic factors between treatment arms. There was also no reporting of loss-to-follow-up, Kortsalioudaki 2008 [50] Randomized controlled trial of pediatric patients with ALF of various etiologies. Superior survival in patients treated with NAC (75% vs 50% untreated, P<0.01) and transplant-free survival (48% vs 22% untreated, P<0.01). Not stated Rashid 2011 [34] Sixty patients aged 1 to 14 years with ALF of unstated cause were treated with NAC. Eighty percent of patients treated with NAC survived, compared to 63.3% of patients surviving without NAC treatment. Dengue viral infection Senanayake 2013 [35] Seven patients aged 6 months to 12 years with severe dengue infection leading to ALF. Resolution of clinical and biochemical derangements. intention-to-treat design, or stated predefined outcomes to assess for reporting bias. Nabi et al. [55] further studied NAC treatment in viral-specific ALF, predominantly HEV, HBV, and HAV, in a similar population to their 2017 study. The primary analysis showed no significant survival benefit with NAC (61.1% vs. 31.6% in the control group, P = 0.079). On subgroup analysis of HEV patients, the NAC group had improved survival (90% vs. 37.5% in the control group, P = 0.022). This study faced similar limitations in reporting and methodology. The above-mentioned clinical studies of NAC treatment report different adverse events, which may be due to differences in dose and formulation [56] [ Table 3 ]. Lee et al. [10] reported higher incidence of nausea and vomiting in the NAC treated group (14% vs. 4% in the control group, P = 0.03), with other adverse events being similar between both treatment. Using the same intravenous NAC protocol, Nabi et al. [54] reported no adverse events. Mumtaz et al. [36] used oral NAC and found the most common adverse event was vomiting (8%), followed by rash (4%) and transient bronchospasm (2%). Darweesh et al. [51] used considerably higher doses of NAC compared to other studies and found 96.4% of patients with NAC treatment had prolonged cholestasis with elevated bilirubin for 2-3 months. The authors noted that prolonged cholestasis was not seen in the placebo group, concluding that this was not due to natural sequelae of ALF. Other adverse events included allergic reaction (10%) and dyspepsia (13%). Compared to existing literature, the adverse events noted in the above-mentioned prospective studies are similar except for prolonged cholestasis, which has not been previously reported. The most commonly reported adverse events in NAC treatment are mild anaphylactoid reactions such as nausea, vomiting, and rash, though more severe reactions can include angioedema, bronchospasm, and hypotension. [57] CONCLUSION While there is a suggested benefit of NAC treatment in NAI-ALF given the demonstrated effects in early [10] however, the transplant-free survival benefit in early HE could not be re-demonstrated using more conventional analysis. [11] The efficacy of NAC for NAI-ALF remains unclear and requires more rigorous investigation. While there is no clear and unequivocal benefit, there also appear to be few adverse effects at studied doses, as well as the drug being relatively inexpensive, readily available, and simple to administer. It is important to clarify the role of NAC in NAI-ALF, especially in the treatment of patients who do not qualify for liver transplant or in low-resource settings where transplantation is not accessible. Ultimately, we conclude that there is insufficient evidence to suggest routine clinical use of NAC for NAI-ALF given the lack of demonstrated clinical benefit. Importantly, omission of NAC in NAI-ALF cannot be regarded as a breach of reasonable care, and clinicians should not be criticized for electing not to administer it. On the other hand, with few adverse drug effects and reasonable costs, clinicians may choose to administer NAC on the grounds that often the exact etiology of acute liver failure is not known and occult acetaminophen use may still have been a factor in the patient's clinical situation; that is to say, there is no harm in giving it and it is better to "cover all bases." Clinical use of NAC in NAI-ALF, however, should follow individualized discussion with patients and families for informed consent to use this medication off-label for this indication. Further study is needed, especially randomized clinical trials to provide an unequivocal answer regarding clinical benefit. Nil. There are no conflicts of interest. Intravenous acetylcysteine in paracetamol induced fulminant hepatic failure: A prospective controlled trial Outcomes in adults with acute liver failure between 1998 and 2013: An observational cohort study European Association for the Study of the Liver. Clinical practice guidelines panel, Wendon J, Panel members Use of Acetylcysteine as the Life-saving Antidote in Amanita phalloides (Death Cap) Poisoning Introduction to the revised American Association for the study of liver diseases position paper on acute liver failure AGA Institute Clinical Guidelines Committee. American Gastroenterological Association Institute Guidelines for the diagnosis and management of acute liver failure Use of acetylcysteine for non-acetaminophen-induced acute liver failure Efficacy and safety of acetylcysteine in "non-acetaminophen" acute liver failure: A meta-analysis of prospective clinical trials N-acetylcysteine for non-paracetamol drug-induced liver injury: A systematic review: N-acetylcysteine for non-paracetamol drug-induced liver injury Intravenous N-acetylcysteine improves transplant-free survival in early stage non-acetaminophen acute liver failure N-acetylcysteine for non-paracetamol (acetaminophen)-related acute liver failure N-acetyl cysteine versus standard of care for non-acetaminophen induced acute liver injury: A systematic review and meta-analysis Mechanisms of hepatocyte injury, multiorgan failure, and prognostic criteria in acute liver failure Prevention of radiocontrast nephropathy with N-acetylcysteine in patients with chronic kidney disease: A meta-analysis of randomized, controlled trials N-acetyl-cysteine protects liver from apoptotic death in an animal model of fulminant hepatic failure Metabolic insights into the hepatoprotective role of N-acetylcysteine in mouse liver Oral N-acetylcysteine rescues lethality of hepatocyte-specific Gclc-knockout mice, providing a model for hepatic cirrhosis N-acetylcysteine inhibits activation of toll-like receptor 2 and 4 gene expression in the liver and lung after partial hepatic ischemia-reperfusion injury in mice N-Acetylcysteine attenuates cerebral complications of non-acetaminophen-induced acute liver failure in mice: Antioxidant and anti-inflammatory mechanisms Chemokines and mitochondrial products activate neutrophils to amplify organ injury during mouse acute liver failure Improvement by acetylcysteine of hemodynamics and oxygen transport in fulminant hepatic failure In vivo evidence of enhanced guanylyl cyclase activation during the hyperdynamic circulation of acute liver failure Evidence of increased guanylate cyclase activation by acetylcysteine in fulminant hepatic failure Hazards with both determining and utilizing oxygen consumption measurements in the management of critically ill patients Significance of pathologic oxygen supply dependency in critically ill patients: Comparison between measured and calculated methods The effect ofN-acetylcysteine on oxygen transport and uptake in patients with fulminant hepatic failure N-acetylcysteine increases liver blood flow and improves liver function in septic shock patients: Results of a prospective, randomized, double-blind study Acetylcysteine treatment for nonacetaminophen-induced acute liver failure Intravenous N-acetylcysteine in dengue-associated acute liver failure N-acetylcysteine in acute hepatic failure (non-paracetamol-induced) Effect of intravenous N-acetylcysteine infusion on haemostatic parameters in healthy subjects Intravenous N-acetylcysteine in pediatric patients with non-acetaminophen acute liver failure: A placebo-controlled clinical trial Safety and efficacy of N-acetylcysteine in children with nonacetaminophen-induced acute liver failure Role of N-acetylcysteine in fulminant hepetic failure N-acetylcysteine in children with acute liver failure complicating dengue viral infection The role of acetyl cysteine in cocaethylene (non-acetaminophen) acute liver failure N-acetylcysteine in the management of acute liver failure from sickle cell hepatic crisis Successful use of intravenous N-acetylcysteine in dengue haemorrhagic fever with acute liver failure Successful use of N-acetyl cysteine and activated recombinant factor VII in fulminant hepatic failure and massive bleeding secondary to dengue hemorrhagic fever Dengue hemorrhagic fever complicated with acute liver failure: A case report Use of intravenous N-acetylcysteine in acute severe hepatitis due to severe dengue infection: A case series N-acetyl cysteine use in the treatment of shock liver Crizotinib-induced fulminant liver failure Crizotinib-induced fulminant hepatic failure: A rare adverse event Acute liver toxicity with ifosfamide in the treatment of sarcoma: A case report Resolution of norfloxacin-induced acute liver failure after N-acetylcysteine therapy: Further support for the use of NAC in drug-induced ALF? Possible role for acetylcysteine as a treatment for acute liver failure secondary to antitubercular medication use Acetylcysteine for the treatment of suspected remdesivir-associated acute liver failure in COVID-19: A case series Role of N-acetylcysteine in adults with non-acetaminophen-induced acute liver failure in a center without the facility of liver transplantation Safety and efficacy of N-acetylcysteine in children with non-acetaminophen-induced acute liver failure Effect of N-Acetylcysteine on mortality and liver transplantation rate in non-acetaminophen-induced acute liver failure: A multicenter study Improvements in hepatic serological biomarkers are associated with clinical benefit of intravenous N-acetylcysteine in early stage Non-acetaminophen acute liver failure Effects of N -acetylcysteine on cytokines in non-acetaminophen acute liver failure: Potential mechanism of improvement in transplant-free survival Role of N-acetylcysteine treatment in non-acetaminophen-induced acute liver failure: A prospective study N-acetylcysteine treatment in viral-induced acute liver failure A multicenter comparison of the safety of oral versus intravenous acetylcysteine for treatment of acetaminophen overdose Adverse reactions associated with acetylcysteine