key: cord-0881544-ga5d33df
authors: Shiferaw, Kirubel Biruk; Tilahun, Binyam Chakilu; Endehabtu, Berhanu Fikadie; Gullslett, Monika Knudsen; Mengiste, Shegaw Anagaw
title: E-health literacy and associated factors among chronic patients in a low-income country: a cross-sectional survey
date: 2020-08-06
journal: BMC Med Inform Decis Mak
DOI: 10.1186/s12911-020-01202-1
sha: df609c8fcfc22cc93f882adbb8c3f4f9a41ee9b1
doc_id: 881544
cord_uid: ga5d33df

BACKGROUND: Chronic patients persistently seek for health information on the internet for medication information seeking, nutrition, disease management, information regarding disease preventive actions and so on. Consumers ability to search, find, appraise and use health information from the internet is known as eHealth literacy skill. eHealth literacy is a congregate set of six basic skills (traditional literacy, health literacy, information literacy, scientific literacy, media literacy and computer literacy). The aim of this study was to assess eHealth literacy level and associated factors among internet user chronic patients in North-west Ethiopia. METHODS: Institutional based cross-sectional study design was conducted. Stratified sampling technique was used to select 423 study participants among chronic patients. The eHealth literacy scale (eHEALS) was used for data collection. The eHEALS is a validated eight-item Likert scaled questionnaire used to asses self-reported capability of eHealth consumers to find, appraise, and use health related information from the internet to solve health problems. Statistical Package for Social science version 20 was used for data entry and further analysis. Multivariable logistic regression was used to examine the association between the eHealth literacy skill and associated factors. Significance was obtained at 95% CI and p < 0.05. RESULT: In total, 423 study subjects were approached and included in the study from February to May, 2019. The response rate to the survey was 95.3%. The majority of respondents 268 (66.3%) were males and mean age was 35.58 ± 14.8 years. The multivariable logistic regression model indicated that participants with higher education (at least having the diploma) are more likely to possess high eHealth literacy skill with Adjusted Odds Ratio (AOR): 3.48, 95% CI (1.54, 7.87). similarly, being government employee AOR: 1.71, 95% CI (1.11, 2.68), being urban resident AOR: 1.37, 95% CI (0.54, 3.49), perceived good health status AOR: 3.97, 95% CI (1.38, 11.38), having higher income AOR: 4.44, 95% CI (1.32, 14.86), Daily internet use AOR: 2.96, 95% CI (1.08, 6.76), having good knowledge about the availability and importance of online resources AOR: 3.12, 95% CI (1.61, 5.3), having positive attitude toward online resources AOR: 2.94, 95% CI (1.07, 3.52) and higher level of computer literacy AOR: 3.81, 95% CI (2.19, 6.61) were the predictors positively associated with higher eHealth literacy level. CONCLUSION: Besides the mounting indication of efficacy, the present data confirm that internet use and eHealth literacy level of chronic patients in this setting is relatively low which clearly implicate that there is a need to fill the skill gap in eHealth literacy among chronic patients which might help them in finding and evaluating relevant online sources for their health-related decisions.

Conclusion: Besides the mounting indication of efficacy, the present data confirm that internet use and eHealth literacy level of chronic patients in this setting is relatively low which clearly implicate that there is a need to fill the skill gap in eHealth literacy among chronic patients which might help them in finding and evaluating relevant online sources for their health-related decisions.

Keywords: eHealth literacy, Chronic patients, eHealth, Low income country, Electronic health Background Noncommunicable diseases (NCDs) are "also known as chronic diseases, which tend to be of extended period resulted from a combination of genetic, physiological, environmental and behavioral factors" [1] . According to the world health organization's (WHO) report in 2018, non-communicable diseases (NCDs) are accounted for the deaths of 41 million people each year, equivalent to 71% of all deaths globally [1] . In Ethiopia, 39% of all deaths are estimated to be due to Non-communicable diseases [2] . Worldwide, Numerous activities and initiatives are undertaking to alleviate this huge number of incidence and death by one third as indicated in United Nations sustainable development goals (SDG) by 2030 [3] . Literatures depicted that patient empowerment and education focused on self-management and health promotion is very important [4, 5] . Enabling patients to ask about their condition, to follow medication instructions, to improve their adherence and to enhance their engagement in the healthcare process is not an easy task. But, helping patients to help themselves is a key step in improving the overall health status and even in reducing the patient load in hospitals specially in low-income countries [6] [7] [8] .

The development in internet access and the improvements in performance due to the new technologies makes the internet to be the focus of many new healthcare improvements [9, 10] . Systematic reviews conducted in different chronic disease cases have steadily stated that eHealth interventions for people with chronic diseases have considerable impact on enhancing selfmanagement and patient engagement for their healthcare [11] [12] [13] [14] . Despite of the limited number of studies from the perspective of chronic patients in middle and low-income countries, eHealth literacy is pointed in several literatures as one of the major skill required to be acquired by patients with chronic diseases if eHealth interventions are tailored to improve patient's selfmanagement and facilitating patient's engagement in the care service [11, 15, 16] . In addition to the low internet penetration in Ethiopia (15%), the gap in skill to find and evaluate online resources is another challenge. E-Health literacy is defined as "one's ability to seek, find, understand, and appraise health information from electronic sources and apply the knowledge gained for addressing or solving a health problem." [17] . As the concept of eHealth literacy is a function of different set of skills, it is highly affected by multidimensional factors including sociocultural, economical and behavioral factors [18] . According to the Lily model, eHealth literacy is a congregate set of six basic skills (traditional literacy, health literacy, information literacy, scientific literacy, media literacy and computer literacy) [19] . The details of each components are available in the attached table as Additional file.

Although it is not mandatory to have a mastery in all the six literacy skills, the gap in any of these could be a constraint to benefit from eHealth merits. As a result, one has to have at least a moderate level of skills in all the literacies to make an effective use of the outrageous eHealth resources. To explore the eHealth literacy level and its associated factors in a population with chronic disease is more urgent and important now than ever. The lesson from COVID-19 thought the world that eHealth is not optional and luxurious approach to healthcare rather it is necessary, safer and effective way of providing healthcare service for both patients with underlying conditions and others during such times. The escalating number of internet users, information needs and smartphone penetration in African countries are the most important driving reasons ringing the relevance of assessing eHealth literacy & factors thereof among patients to harness eHealth merits. Given the gap in literatures regarding chronic patients' eHealth literacy skill in Africa, conducting this study will contribute to the scientific knowledge in addressing the research question in this region. Hence, the aim of this study was to assess eHealth literacy level and associated factors among internet user chronic patients in University of Gondar comprehensive specialized hospital, North West Ethiopia.

An institutional based cross-sectional study was conducted to assess eHealth literacy skill and associated factor among internet user chronic patients in University of Gondar comprehensive specialized hospital (UOGCSH). Gondar is placed 725-km driving distance North-west from the capital Addis Ababa. The UOGCS hospital is the largest specialized teaching hospital in the Amhara region serving more than five million peoples annually. It provides a specialized care and follow up service for different chronic cases in different days of a week. According to the hospital's statistics, cardiovascular diseases like hypertension, chronic respiratory diseases like asthma, epilepsy and type2 diabetes are the most common chronic disease morbidities in the hospital at the time when this study was conducted (2019).

The sample size for this study was calculated using single population proportion formula [20] with 95% confidence level, proportion of eHealth literacy 50% [21] since there were no previous study done in this study population in Ethiopia and relative precision to be 5%. With 10% none-response rate, the total sample size calculated was 423. The participants for this study was selected using a stratified random sampling method with proportional allocation technique. Stratified sampling is a method of sampling applied for a population with subsets of known size where the sub-sets make up different proportions of the whole [22] . Thus, it is appropriate to use stratified random sampling to have a representative sample of the population under study. Participants were approached randomly and the stratification was based on the most prevalent chronic diseases in University of Gondar Comprehensive Specialized Hospital (cardio vascular disease, chronic respiratory disease, diabetics, epilepsy and other chronic diseases were categorized as "other chronic diseases") hoping for an eHealth literacy difference among patients with different chronic cases [2] .

Data was collected by using interviewer administered questionnaire from February to May 2019. The questionnaire requires 10-15 min to complete and had three parts. The first section contained questions about participant's socio demographic characteristics (10 items), the second part contained items related with internet use (6 items), knowledge about the availability and importance of online resources (5 items), attitude of participant to use online health resources (4), computer literacy (5 items) and the third section contained items related to eHealth literacy skill (8 items). Except for the first part (sociodemographic related items), all items were measured in 5-point Likert scale ranging from strongly agree (5) to strongly disagree (1). A validated tool was used to determine eHealth literacy skill which was developed by Norman and Skinner [23, 24] . The eHEALS (eHealth literacy scale) is an eight-item scale used to asses selfreported capability of eHealth consumers to find, appraise, and use health related information from the internet to solve health problems [23] . According to Norman and Skinner, the eHealth Literacy Scale (eHEALS) is a promising tool to evaluate users' ease and skills to use the internet in order to obtain health related information [19, 23] . Apart from the measurement tool coined by Norman and Skinner, researchers have also suggested and used a modified versions of the original eHEALS tailored to their context and variable of interest [25, 26] . Moreover, researchers have also developed a novel measurement tools to assess eHealth Literacy [27] [28] [29] . Yet the widely used and constantly validated measurement scale for consumers eHealth Literacy is the original eHEALS proposed by Norman and Skinner. The scale had been used in various studies in different populations exhibiting considerable reliability and validity of items [26, [30] [31] [32] [33] [34] [35] [36] . As the eHEALS aims to asses a wide-ranging summary of literacy skills, it is a potential instrument to evaluate the comprehensive literacy skill of eHealth consumers.

The items were translated to Amharic to avoid language barriers and the reliability of the translated items were assessed for its internal consistency by calculating Cronbach alpha coefficient among 30 chronic patients in other hospital (Bahirdar Felegehiwot Referral Hospital) [37] . Data collectors with minimum of diploma in Health Information Technician (HIT) were recruited and trained for data handling and related issues. Participants were approached for consent and data collection while they are on the queue waiting for their turn to see their doctors.

A one-day training was delivered to data collectors by the investigator in regard with data handling and participants approach. Continuous and active supervision was done during the data collection and after data collection was completed, it was checked for completeness and accuracy. Finally, the data was entered using statistical package for social science (SPSS) software version 20 for further analysis.

Descriptive analysis was performed to summarize participant's socio-demographic characteristics. The extent of internet use, knowledge and attitude were described using frequency and percentages. Before running the logistic regression model, assumptions were checked for outliers, multicollinearity and independent error terms. Multicollinearity was tested by running a false linier regression iterating the independent variables as a dependent variable and the result showed all the variance inflation factor (VIF) value less than three and tolerance greater than 0.7 which demonstrated the absence of multicollinearity [38] . The data was also checked for outliers by box plot and no outshining outlier effect was observed. The models' goodness of fit was also checked using omnibus tests of model coefficients for overall (global) fitness of the model and Hosmer and Lemeshow test for fitness of the data to the model. Consequently, the omnibus test result was significant with p-value < 0.05 and the Hosmer and Lemeshow test shows a good model fit with p-value = 0.608, which signifies the goodness of the model [39] . A bivariate logistic regression was performed for each independent variable and a p-value < 0.2 [40] was included in the final model. A multivariable logistic regression was fitted to identify significant factors (P-value< 0.05) associated with eHealth literacy skill. The strength of association was explained in terms of odds ratio (OR) and a 95% confidence interval (CI).

In total, 423 study subjects were approached and included in the study from March 02 to May 17, 2019. The response rate was 95.3%. The majority of respondents 268 (66.3%) were males and the mean age participants was 35.58 ± 14.8 years. A large number of respondents were diploma holders and above 208 (51.5%). Most of the study participants were urban resi-dents352 (87.1%). About 150 (37.1%) of the respondents were governmental employees. See (Table 1) for detail descriptive statistics.

The result indicated a 47.0% daily internet use of chronic patients with 81.2% usage for browsing social media. About 95.8% of the participants reported that their major means of internet use was smartphone. Concurrently, 83.4% of those internet user chronic patients confirmed that their major sources of health information were health professionals followed by television broadcasts which was 30.0%.

The mean eHealth literacy score was 24.6 with a standard deviation of 6.4. Scores less than the median value was labeled as low eHealth literacy and scores greater than & equal to the median value was labeled as high eHealth literacy level. Associated factors with p-value less than 0.25 from the bivariate analysis were included in the final multivariable logistic regression model to control the effect of confounding. Accordingly, the statistically insignificant results were Gender, marital status, type of chronic disease and number of medications. From the socio-demographic variables, age, educational status and residence were significantly associated with frequency of internet use where younger, educated and peoples from urban residence were more frequent users of internet. On the other hand, only educational status and residence were significantly associated with knowledge of participants about the availability and importance of online health information. Attitude of chronic patients towards using online sources were primarily associated with their educational status, residence and their monthly income. Whereas computer literacy was associated with Gender, marital status, frequency of internet use and knowledge about the availability and importance of online sources.

The multivariable logistic regression model indicated that participants holding diploma and above are more likely to possess high eHealth literacy skill with AOR: 3.48, 95% CI (1. 54, 7.87 Table 2 for detail.

The purpose of this study was to determine the level of eHealth literacy skill and associated factors among internet user chronic patients in University of Gondar Comprehensive Specialized Hospital. The result showed that eHealth literacy skill was relatively low with 188 (46.5%) of the participants reporting high eHealth literacy skill. The result also shows 353 (87.3%) use of daily and several days a week internet use of participants with more than three fourth of them using it for browsing social medias like Facebook. Younger, educated and peoples from urban residence were more frequent users of internet. Educational status, occupation type, residence, selfreported health status, monthly salary, frequency of internet use, knowledge about the availability and importance of online resources, attitude toward using online resources and computer literacy level were statistically significant factors associated with eHealth literacy skill among internet user chronic patients in this study. This study also found that, the majority of respondents 268 (66.3%) were males and there was no significant chi square difference among the groups which is different from a study which revealed that males are superior internet users [41] . This could be due to the fact that the participants in this study are all internet users. The mean age was 35.58 ± 14.8 years and when compared to elders, youngsters were more frequent internet users. This could be due to the internet penetration rate among youngsters which is related with internet using habit [42] .

when compared to studies conducted in other countries, the mean eHealth literacy score of chronic patients in this study was relatively lower and this could be due to the less internet penetration and economic berries in low-income countries like Ethiopia [43] [44] [45] . The univariate analysis indicated that patient's educational status, occupation type, permanent residence, self-reported health status, monthly salary, frequency of internet use, knowledge about the availability and importance of online health information resources, attitude towards using online sources and computer literacy level of participants were significantly associated with eHealth literacy skill with 95% confidence interval, (p-value< 0.05). After adjustment for the covariates, except for two variables (residence and frequency of internet use) all the other predictor variables were significantly associated with eHealth literacy skill with p-value< 0.05. See Table 2 for detail. Patients with diploma and above education level were 3.48 (CI: 1.54, 7.87) times more likely to have high eHealth literacy skill compared with those with primary and below education level (p-value< 0.05). This finding is similar with other studies in different populations which underlined the need for capacity building and continuous educational support for chronic patients with lower educational status [15, 46, 47] . Participants who works in governmental organizations were more likely to possess high eHealth literacy when compared to unemployed chronic patients with AOR: 1.73, 95%CI: (1.11, 2.68). This study also indicated that chronic patients living in urban setting are COR: 3.77 (95%CI: (1.88, 7.57) times more likely to possess high eHealth literacy skill compared to patients residing on rural setting. The finding seems obvious in most cases [48, 49] but it is different in developed countries in which majority of rural patients have computer and internet connection in their home preferring internet for health information [50] [51] [52] . Income was the other significant factor associated with eHealth literacy skill among chronic patients in which patients those who have a monthly income > 5500 ETB are more likely to have higher eHealth literacy skill compared with those who earn monthly income < 800 ETB with AOR:4.44, (95%CI, 1.32, 14.86), P-value< 0.05. Higher income is highly associated with higher eHealth literacy skill in different studies [53, 54] . In this study, patients who perceived their health status as good were 3.97 times more likely to have higher eHealth literacy skill with 95% CI: (1.38, 11.38) and p-value< 0.05 compared to those who perceive their health status as bad. This finding is similar with other studies done elsewhere which argues the more likely possession of eHealth [30, 55, 56] . This could be due to the fact that peoples with perceived good health condition are more likely to be looking for possible medical treatment and preventive actions before their health get worse. Frequency of internet use was also the predictive variable with p-value< 0.05 where chronic patients those who use internet on a daily basis are almost 3 (AOR: 2.96) times more likely to have high eHealth literacy skill when compared to those who use internet 1 day and less than 1 day a week with 95%CI: (1.08, 6.76). This finding is similar with different studies confirming that frequent internet users possess higher eHealth literacy skill [15, 30, 57, 58] . In addition, higher computer literacy was also highly associated with higher eHealth literacy skill which is similar with studies done elsewhere [59] [60] [61] .

Knowledge regarding the availability and importance of health information and attitude toward using online resources were significant factors associated with eHealth literacy skill where patients with good knowledge and favorable attitude toward online resources are more likely to possess high eHealth literacy skill with AOR: 3.12, 95% CI: (1.61, 5.3) and AOR: 2.94, 95%CI: (1.07, 3.52) respectively. This finding was also in line with other studies [62] [63] [64] [65] .

This study found that educational status, perceived health status, income and frequency of internet use have significant impact on consumers eHealth literacy skill confirming with several studies. It also suggested other factors like knowledge about availability and importance of online sources, attitude and computer literacy are important variables associated with eHealth literacy level in this population. Internet use and eHealth literacy level of chronic patients in this setting is relatively low. This clearly implicate the need to fill the skill gap in eHealth literacy among chronic patients which may help them in building their capacity to find and evaluate relevant online sources for their health-related decisions.

As this is the first study to investigate eHealth literacy and associated factors among chronic patients in resource limited settings, there were limitations identified for further investigators. This limitation of this study is that more than half of the study participants were from urban resident setting and all participants were selected after confirming their previous internet exposure. Those with previous internet exposure were interviewed further and those who doesn't know about the internet were excluded. This could have caused a selection bias where urban residing and internet user participants are more likely to possess high eHealth literacy. The other limitation of this study was the small sample size & it was conducted in a single institution in Northern Ethiopia. Therefore, the results may not be generalizable to all chronic patients and future researchers should consider more broader samples from different clusters of populations in the country to ensure generalizability.

Considering the importance of chronic patients' ability to find and evaluate health information for their health management decisions, it is highly important for the Ethiopian Federal ministry of health and other responsible bodies to consider methodical approach to improve the eHealth literacy skill of internet user chronic patients through short trainings and education. Hospitals should also consider facilitating health care providers advisory of online sources for their patients. It is also important for future researchers to consider exploring other relevant factors associated with eHealth literacy skill of chronic patients.

Supplementary information accompanies this paper at https://doi.org/10. 1186/s12911-020-01202-1.

Additional file 1. 

This study was financed by University of Gondar research and community service Directorate & CBMP project eHealth lab Ethiopia. The funding offices had no direct or indirect involvement in the study writeup and analysis, it was only involved in budgeting and budget evaluation.

All data generated or analyzed during this study are included in this published article.

Ethics approval and consent to participate Ethical clearance for this study was secured from University of Gondar, College of medicine and health science ethical review board. Necessary permission was obtained from the hospital director and written informed consent was obtained from study participants.

Noncommunicable diseases

Noncommunicable diseases

Patient empowerment, patient participation and patient-centeredness in hospital care: a concept analysis based on a literature review

The empowerment of elderly patients with chronic obstructive pulmonary disease: managing life with the disease

The effectiveness of the teach-back method on adherence and self-management in health education for people with chronic disease: a systematic review

Diabetes self-management education and support in type 2 diabetes:a joint position statement of the American Diabetes Association, the American Association of Diabetes Educators, and the academy of nutrition and dietetics

Self-management support from the perspective of patients with a chronic condition: a thematic synthesis of qualitative studies

Internet developments and their significance for healthcare

Making the future of healthcare

Behavior Change Techniques in Physical Activity eHealth Interventions for People With Cardiovascular Disease: Systematic Review

Information and Communication Technology-Enabled Person-Centered Care for the "Big Five" Chronic Conditions: Scoping Review

Engaging Patients in Online Self-Care Technologies for Chronic Disease Management

Online health communities and chronic disease selfmanagement

eHealth literacy: predictors in a population with moderate-to-high cardiovascular risk

Cardiac patients' experiences with a telerehabilitation web portal: implications for eHealth literacy

EHealth Literacy: Essential Skills for Consumer Health in a Networked World

eHealth literacy: essential skills for consumer health in a networked world

Practical Issues in Calculating the Sample Size for Prevalence Studies

Sample size calculation in medical studies

Design, data analysis and sampling techniques for clinical research

eHEALS: the eHealth literacy scale

Examination of an eHealth literacy scale and a health literacy scale in a population with moderate to high cardiovascular risk: Rasch analyses

A cross-sectional study assessing determinants of the attitude to the introduction of eHealth services among patients suffering from chronic conditions

eHealth literacy: extending the digital divide to the realm of health information

Proposing a transactional model of eHealth literacy: concept analysis

Development of the PRE-HIT instrument: patient readiness to engage in health information technology

Development of the Digital Health Literacy Instrument: Measuring a Broad Spectrum of Health 1.0 and Health 2.0 Skills

Assessing eHealth skills across Europeans

eHealth literacy among undergraduate nursing students

Self-reported eHealth literacy among undergraduate nursing students in selected districts of Sri Lanka. Stud Health Technol Inform

eHealth Literacy 2.0: Problems and Opportunities With an Evolving Concept

Association of Electronic Health Literacy with Health-Promoting Behaviors in patients with type 2 diabetes: a crosssectional study

eHealth literacy, online help-seeking behavior, and willingness to participate in mHealth chronic disease research among African Americans, Florida

Internet and eHealth service usage: a survey among cancer patients and their relatives

Sample size for pre-tests of questionnaires

A caution regarding rules of thumb for variance inflation factors

Applied logistic regression

The impact of confounder selection criteria on effect estimation

The global digital divide-within and between countries

Exploring the digital divide: internet connectedness and age

eHealth literacy in chronic disease patients: an item response theory analysis of the eHealth literacy scale (eHEALS)

Predictors of high eHealth literacy in primary lung Cancer survivors

Predictors in a Population With Moderate-to-High Cardiovascular Risk

Internet access and use by COPD patients in the National Emphysema/COPD association survey

Examining the relationship between online social capital and eHealth literacy: implications for Instagram use for chronic disease prevention among college students

Medical Service Information Seeking Behaviors in Rural and Urban Patients in Sichuan Province, Sichuan Da Xue Xue Bao Yi Xue Ban

Personalized health monitoring system for managing well-being in rural areas

Interest in internet lung cancer support among rural cardiothoracic patients

The consumer-driven development and acceptability testing of a website designed to connect rural cancer patients and their families, carers and health professionals with appropriate information and psychosocial support

Technology use among patients in a nonurban southern U.S. HIV clinic in 2015

Older adult internet use and eHealth literacy

Navigating the digital divide: a systematic review of eHealth literacy in underserved populations in the United States

Predictors in a Population With Moderate-to-High Cardiovascular Risk

Disparities in health-related Internet use by US veterans: Results from a national survey

Internet-Based Cognitive Behavioral Therapy for Patients With Chronic Somatic Conditions: A Meta-Analytic Review

Promoting emotional well-being in older breast Cancer patients: results from an eHealth intervention

Relationship between parental and adolescent eHealth literacy and online health information seeking in Taiwan

Relationships between eHealth literacy and health behaviors in Korean adults

Evidence-based heuristics for evaluating demands on eHealth literacy and usability in a Mobile consumer health application

Trusted online sources of health information: differences in demographics, health beliefs, and health-information orientation

An e-health intervention to support the transition of young people with long-term illnesses to adult healthcare services: design and early use

Web-based health information seeking and eHealth literacy among patients living with chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD)

From chronic disease management to person-centered eHealth; a review on the necessity for blended care

Publisher's Note

Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations

The authors would like to thank University of Gondar, University of Gondar comprehensive specialized hospital administrative staffs and e-health lab Ethiopia for their support and collaboration.

Consent for publication Not applicable.

The authors declare that they have no competing interests.