key: cord-0948127-ewv125jl
authors: Navandar, Archit; Frías López, Daniel; Alejo, Lidia B.
title: The Use of Instagram in the Sports Biomechanics Classroom
date: 2021-08-12
journal: Front Psychol
DOI: 10.3389/fpsyg.2021.711779
sha: fb35d919fbb469b74a8841ad66d892bc5efbe923
doc_id: 948127
cord_uid: ewv125jl

Students in higher education habitually use mobile devices such as smartphones and tablets, specifically using social networks on them for staying updated on current affairs, communication between one another, and entertainment. However, its use as a potential medium for learning especially in times of distance learning has not been studied in depth. Instagram is the fastest growing social network in the world and its graphical interface makes it a useful learning tool for a theoretical-practical subject such as biomechanics, where movement is analyzed. The main objective was to evaluate the change in perception of students in the use of Instagram as a learning medium for qualitative biomechanical analysis as a part of their undergraduate sports science program. 171 students filled out a questionnaire on the use of smartphones, social networks, and specifically Instagram, before and after doing an assignment of qualitative analysis that was carried. The results indicated a positive change in the perspective of the students when asked if class assignments can be done on mobile devices (p = 0.002) and social media (p < 0.001). The students also indicated a greater interest in doing assignments via social networks (p < 0.001), especially in the subject of biomechanics (p < 0.001). They also cited that Instagram is a useful source for information on sports biomechanics (p = 0.015) and could be used to make observations of sporting movements (p = 0.043). The results indicated that an introduction of familiar devices in undergraduate teaching could produce a positive change in perception of using such methodologies and facilitate learning. The students, who use smartphones very frequently in their daily lives, and specifically, many use them for browsing social networks, find the platform to be very useful in finding and sharing information related to sports and specifically in sports biomechanics. The visual aspect of social networks like Instagram can help engage them with learning strategies in a subject like biomechanics.

Information and Communication Technologies (ICTs) are increasing their influence in the world and have been responsible for bringing about social changes in the last decade (Vilhelmson et al., 2017) . Similarly, they are making inroads into the educational field as well, providing an effective environment to facilitate student learning and improving teaching efficiency (Fu, 2013) . One of the ubiquitous uses of ICTs has been the use of mobile devices such as smartphones and tablets, and the growing presence of mobile devices in the education environment has greatly shown its potential in promoting its use as an effective learning tool (Khalitova and Gimaletdinova, 2016) .

Over the last few years, one of the most important trends in education has been learning through mobile devices (Luguetti et al., 2017) and has been used to perform academic activities ranging from simple activities, such as readings, to more complex activities as oral exhibitions or problem-based learning (Tang and Hew, 2017) . This use has been further enhanced presently with the lockdown caused by the COVID-19 pandemic causing face-to-face teaching to move online overnight (Knudson, 2020) . All around the world, owing to economic and social constraints, students have not had access to traditional PCs and have had to follow lessons on mobile devices (Biswas et al., 2020; Rodriguez Martinez, 2020; The Hindu, 2020) , resulting in the increase in the downloads of education-centric apps and greater time spent on these devices (Ohme et al., 2020) .

Students in higher education habitually use mobile devices such as smartphones and tablets (Gikas and Grant, 2013) , specifically using social networks on them for staying updated on current affairs, communication between one another, and entertainment (Chaffey, 2018) . Mobile devices, through social networks, provide immediacy and openness, enabling them to be used both as an information source and as a collaborative tool (Junco et al., 2013) , and hence its use in the educational environment must be considered (Piñón et al., 2016) as their use is also on the rise (Wiley, 2019) .

A survey conducted just before the COVID-19 pandemic showed that 49% of the global population uses social networks (Kemp, 2020) , with this percentage being higher in developed countries where there was greater access to mobile devices (The Social Media Family, 2018; Kemp, 2020) . Specifically, social networks were popular in people aged between 18 and 39 years (The Social Media Family, 2018) with those belonging to this age group being known as "digital natives" (Boyd, 2007) .

Social networks are gradually being used as a novel tool for teaching and learning (Lescano and Quiroga, 2017) , facilitating the development of student-professor and studentstudent interactions (Evans, 2014) , and increasing the scope of the learning environment by permitting easy interaction between people from all over the world in different and innovative ways (Bista, 2015) . Studies using social networks as an educational tool have shown a positive impact on learning research, demonstrating that social networks could improve student learning, affective learning, creativity (Dawson et al., 2011) , and classroom climate, both inside and outside the class (Brady et al., 2010) . In the context of higher education, many studies have analyzed the relationship between the use of social networks, such as Twitter (Tang and Hew, 2017) , Facebook (Hew, 2011; Cuesta et al., 2015) , and YouTube (Roodt and Peier, 2013 ) as a didactic tool and its possible benefits in learning, however, there are only a few studies which have used Instagram (Manca, 2020) .

Instagram is the fastest growing social network in the world (The Social Media Family, 2018) with over one billion active users (Kemp, 2020) and is the most popular social network amongst millennials (Kemp, 2020) . Instagram is a mobile-centric photo and video capturing and sharing platform that allows one to tag, and search for images and videos using hashtags (Sheldon and Bryant, 2016) . Given that it is a more visual platform, it has the potential to be a great learning medium considering that there is previous research which states that students retain information better when it is presented visually (Levie and Lentz, 1982; Fisk et al., 1994; Kizilcec et al., 2014) . Moreover, this graphical interface of Instagram could be useful in facilitating learning in biomechanics, a subject that is essentially based on the analysis of movement.

Undergraduate biomechanics courses teach human movement through principles of classical mechanics, motor control, neural control, and anatomy (Knudson et al., 2009) and their relation to physical function and mobility in activities of daily living, sports, and pathological conditions (Riskowski, 2015) . Biomechanics instructors surveyed in North America highlighted the importance of kinematic analysis as a fundamental part of the curriculum; but also showed that the biggest challenges they face in classes of introductory biomechanics are the difficulties associated with learning math (60% of the respondents) and physics (27% of the respondents) (Garceau et al., 2012) , both of which form the crux of kinematic analysis. Although they suggest a preparatory course or easier access to biomechanical equipment, the limited economic and time resources for the faculty and the heterogeneity of students' backgrounds make implementing such strategies difficult (Garceau et al., 2012) .

Different approaches using blended (Riskowski, 2015) and active learning (Knudson, 2020) have been suggested to engage undergraduate biomechanics students, but a study has shown that these approaches might face difficulty when students are not sufficiently autonomous to undertake independent study (Keogh et al., 2017) . With remote learning enforced by the COVID-19 pandemic, approaches such as blended and active learning might be difficult to implement remotely, but an audio-visual platform such as Instagram has the potential to overcome such hurdles. Since qualitative analysis forms, the basis of any biomechanical analysis in sport (Knudson, 2007a) , the use of technology (that they are familiar with) could be a possible approach to help students into learning biomechanical concepts and alleviating the fears of math and physics temporarily. Therefore, the present study has the main objective of evaluating the change in perception of students in the use of Instagram as a learning medium for qualitative biomechanical analysis as a part of their undergraduate sports science program. The hypothesis was that the use of Instagram would change their perceptions positively after performing the designated assignment.

An experimental study design was applied where students filled out questionnaires before and after undertaking an assignment on sports biomechanics. Approval for the research design was obtained from the ethics committee of the Universidad Europea de Madrid.

An a priori power analysis was performed with a 95% confidence interval and Cohen's d = 0.3, power of 0.95, giving the required sample to be composed of at least 154 participants (Faul et al., 2009) . 243 students enrolled in the sports biomechanics course (2nd year of the undergraduate sports science program) were invited to participate in this study, of which 171 undergraduate students in sport sciences (males: n = 141; females: n = 30) aged 21.98 ± 3.39 years (range: 19-48 years) finally volunteered to participate in this study. This was the only biomechanics course they had over the four-year study program, and the course consisted of 72 h of face-to-face learning, with each session lasting no more than 100 min. The students that participated gave their consent to their participation in the research study.

As a part of the assignment, the students had to carry out a qualitative biomechanical analysis of a sports movement of their choice, basing their analysis on the guidelines indicated by Knudson (2007a) and previously taught in class. The explanation of qualitative analysis was done over two theoretical-practical classes, where they were taught about how to develop a structured framework of analysis (Bartlett, 1997) . This required them to follow the four stages of biomechanical analysis (Knudson and Morrison, 2002; Knudson, 2007b) : preparation, observation, evaluation and diagnosis, and intervention. Emphasis was given to the phases of preparation and observation, and the students submitted an initial needs analysis, establishing critical features of the movement, through the Blackboard R virtual learning environment (Blackboard Inc., Washington D.C., United States).

The students had three weeks to submit the entire assignment as a single post on Instagram which involved the four stages of qualitative analysis. For this part of the assignment, the students were required to create a private account on Instagram (Kassens, 2014) . They were free to use relevant emojis, hashtags, other tools offered by Instagram present at that time (like Super Zoom, Rewind, etc.), and could use other applications and software to prepare their post as long as it did not exceed the restrictions of a single post on Instagram (a maximum of ten photos and/or videos per post, with a video not lasting over 59 s, Instagram TV was not an available feature at the time of implementing the research). During these three weeks, the students could clarify their doubts about qualitative biomechanical analysis or the use of Instagram with the professor.

First, an initial questionnaire was designed with forty questions and sent to fifteen experts for their validation. The experts were professionals in the educational sector and taught sports biomechanics, research methods, and pedagogy-related subjects. The initial questionnaire was sent to them via Google Forms and their responses were recorded online anonymously, and the experimental design was explained to them via telephone and/or email. They had to rate the questions on relevance on a five-point Likert scale, with 1 representing "not relevant" and 5 representing "very relevant." The experts also had an option of open-ended comments that they could leave to give their overall feedback on the questionnaire. Finally, twelve experts (females = 6, males = 6; age: 39.11 ± 8.14 years; 9 with PhDs and 3 with Master's degrees; Teaching experience = 12.33 ± 8.01 years; all used some social networks and ten had Instagram accounts). Once the results were obtained from the experts, the coefficient of content validation validity of the questionnaire was calculated using Aiken's V, and its 95% confidence intervals were also determined (Penfield and Giacobbi, 2004) . Only those questions were selected that had a content validity score of 0.75 or more (Penfield and Giacobbi, 2004) . The calculations were carried out using Microsoft Excel 2016 software (Microsoft R , Redmond, United States). Finally, a questionnaire of the twenty-seven validated questions (reliability of 93.3%, Table 1 ) was used for the study ( Table 1) .

Students filled out online questionnaires ( Table 1) before and after the assignment through a link sent to them by the professor. The pre-assignment questionnaire included questions divided into four different categories: (1) the use of smartphones and using a smartphone as a learning medium; (2) the use of social networks and using social networks as learning mediums; and (3) the use of Instagram and using it as a learning platform (only the students who had Instagram accounts answered these questions). The questions consisted of open questions, closed multiple responses, and a five-point Likert-type scale, where 1 represented "complete disagreement with the statement, " and 5 represented "complete agreement with the statement."

The responses from all participants were downloaded as a spreadsheet and responses from the open-ended questions were grouped. Since the responses were anonymous, they were grouped as pre-and post-assignment responses and input into Tableau (version 2020.3, Salesforce, Washington, Seattle) for analysis and visualization. The data from the first section of the questionnaire (the use of smartphones and social networks) with open responses were represented as packed bubble charts, and pie charts were used to represent yes/no questions. The responses from sections two, three, and four (using smartphones/social networks/Instagram as learning mediums) were represented in a Gantt chart, with each response being given a specific color, and the mean was represented as a black dot. The size of the bubble/Gantt bar represented the number of people that responded with the corresponding answer.

The responses to the nineteen Likert-scale type questions were compared pre-and post-assignment using non-parametric tests. Significance set at α = 0.05, and effect sizes of the differences were determined using Cohen's d, with the following thresholds being used to interpret the findings: 0.2 ≤ d < 0.5 small differences; 0.5 ≤ d < 0.8 medium differences; and d ≥ 0.8 large differences. All statistical analysis was carried out on Jamovi (version 1.8.1 1 ). 

The main results from the pre-and post-assignment questionnaires are shown in Figures 1-5 , and the number of respondents per answer is indicated by the size of the bars.

Instagram was the most popular social network with 93.57% of the participants using it, compared to 41.52% for Facebook, 35.67% for Twitter, and 5.85% for Snapchat. The daily usage of smartphones ( Figure 1A) showed that 38.60% used their phones for over 3 h, 26.32% between 2 and 3 h, 25.15% between 1 and 2 h, and 9.94% under 1 h. When comparing this to the use of social networks (Figure 1B) , 12.87% of the participants admitted to spending over 3 h on them, 14.04% between 2 and 3 h, 29.24% between 1 and 2 h, while 43.86% used them for under an hour. Instagram (37.43%) and WhatsApp (36.84%) were the most used applications ( Figure 1C) . Specifically, in the case of Instagram, 32.75% checked the application every 1-2 h, 27.49% every 15 min-1 h, and 19.30% between 2 and 6 h ( Figure 1D) .

Instant messaging (43.86%) and "making/receiving calls" (39.77%) were cited by the participants as the most important reason for using their smartphones (Figure 2A) . Sharing photos/videos were cited by most of the participants (67.84%) as the reason for using social networks (Figure 2B) , followed by sharing information (11.70%) and posting status updates (5.85%).

Comparing pre-and post-data on the questionnaire (Figure 3 ), significant differences were obtained for the question "Can classroom assignments be done exclusively on mobile devices?" (PRE: 2.28 ± 1.29 vs POST: 2.60 ± 1.12; p = 0.002, d = 0.33). Small differences were observed for the question "Can you study through your mobile device?, " but this result was statistically 

Significant differences were observed for the questions "Can you do classroom assignments through social networks?" (PRE: 2.65 ± 1.25 vs POST: 3.20 ± 1.03; p < 0.001, d = 0.49) and "Would you like to do classroom assignments on social networks?" (PRE: 2.92 ± 1.41 vs POST: 3.66 ± 1.08; p < 0.001, d = 0.58). The other questions related to the use of social networks showed no significant differences when comparing data pre-to postassignment (Figure 4) .

Three questions asked on the Instagram section of the questionnaire showed small to medium significant differences when comparing pre-and post-assignment data ( Figure 5) 

This study aimed to look at the changes in perception of using Instagram in the teaching of the undergraduate introductory course of biomechanics. 171 students filled out a questionnaire on the use of smartphones, for social networks and specifically on Instagram before and after doing an assignment of qualitative analysis that they presented via Instagram. The results confirmed the hypothesis and indicated a positive change in perception in using Instagram to submit the qualitative analysis assignment, and that an introduction of familiar devices and tools from dayto-day life in teaching could facilitate learning in conjunction with traditional teaching methods.

There was a large change in perspective in the participants about the use of social networks to do assignments both in general and specifically in the subject of biomechanics (Figures 3-5) .

Instagram helped them carry out the task easily as indicated by the results in which they preferred using Instagram to a traditional virtual learning environment (Figure 5) . These results were similar to those seen in students of radiology (Shafer et al., 2018) , where the students learned more by tasks on Instagram as compared to traditional learning environments. The study of Sugimoto et al. (2015) further corroborates the finding that the use of social networks in the classroom could enhance learning experiences in undergraduate students. Given the limited time on hand per subject in the undergraduate degrees, biomechanics teachers tend to lay lesser importance on the qualitative analysis of movement (Garceau et al., 2012) . Moreover, they often cite the fear of math and physics as the biggest hurdles in teaching (Garceau et al., 2012) . The introduction of qualitative movement analysis in a familiar environment for the students such as Instagram could address this issue and further helped students before delving into math and physics-centric kinematic and kinetic analysis.

As of today, Instagram is by far the most popular social network in the age group of students, the results of this study reconfirm the statistics seen worldwide (Kemp, 2020) . Instagram, a social network that uses audio-visual information, can serve as an excellent support learning tool, without completely replacing traditional teaching methods. Learning through Instagram moves away from compiling information and contents of the subjects in written form by setting up communication channels, which often occur in a non-hierarchical and informal context, and encourage bidirectional communication (Burns et al., 2016) . This is especially crucial when access to laboratories and/or equipment may be restricted, such as in the case of distance learning. Instagram can bridge the gap by not only helping to make useful observations of sporting movements as indicated by the results of the study (Figure 5) , but also open communication channels between students and teachers, and with other practitioners (biomechanists, researchers, sports scientists, coaches, athletes, etc.) beyond the walls of the traditional classroom.

The results of the study reinforce this point as after doing the assignment, the students found Instagram to be a useful source of information for sports biomechanics (Figure 5) . In the long term, such sources can help students contribute more to online communities of their interest when they feel comfortable with the environment and learn from the contribution of others (Akhiar et al., 2017) . Given that the students use the application very frequently (Figure 1) , Instagram can facilitate the active participation of students and can mediate the process of self-learning (Khalitova and Gimaletdinova, 2016) . This can potentially address the situation of students from heterogeneous backgrounds, with each student being able to find information that is specific to the student's field of interest. Moreover, this can also benefit the students who are shy to participate in faceto-face classes by allowing them to participate in communication without relying on social trust (Burns et al., 2016) , as they can "like, " "comment, " and "share" content that is not their own (Mikum et al., 2018) .

The overall results of this study indicated that the students participated more using Instagram for their assignments, a finding similar to that previously reported in the literature (Hortigüela-Alcalá et al., 2019) . The use of Instagram could increase student participation (Hortigüela-Alcalá et al., 2019) . Both these stem from the familiarity and simplicity of the tools used, along with Instagram's quick access through mobile devices and the application's attractive interface (Khalitova and Gimaletdinova, 2016) . Social networks increase the ease of transmitting information through very small devices, and the simpler the application, the more profitable its use will be and probably more students will use it to participate (Mikum et al., 2018) , making this aspect tangible in the case of Instagram.

It is important to remark that the use of Instagram as a learning tool has its inconveniences as well. Students seem to be averse to learning through mobile devices and are not convinced that a smartphone, as of today, can completely replace a PC or the knowledge of traditional books (Figure 3) . However, this study was carried out before the onset of the COVID-19 pandemic, and it would certainly be interesting to replicate this study now in order to gage the impact of the pandemic in changing these perceptions. Although the students might be well-versed with the use of digital tools, they are still not used to using social networks educationally (Akhiar et al., 2017) . The use of social networks in teaching is still in its nascent stage and as a learning tool, it must not detract students from conventional teaching (Burns et al., 2016) , rather complement it.

The primary purpose of teaching within the field of biomechanics is to develop the cognitive and practical knowledge required to function as competent practitioners within the chosen field (Riskowski, 2015) , and Instagram could perhaps provide that platform. This platform can be used as a steppingstone to introduce basic concepts of movement analysis, involve students based on their varied interests, before delving into the introduction of more complex kinematic and kinetic analysis concepts. Thus, students are exposed to real-world applications of biomechanics while simultaneously addressing the issues of limited space and/or equipment (Garceau et al., 2012) . Nevertheless, it is important to highlight the lessons taught with them must be well-planned (Grosseck, 2009 ) using the right methodologies (Hamid et al., 2009) keeping in mind the diversity of the students. Considering that the task required a simple video analysis, the fact that the theoretical base was previously taught over the course of two lessons (200 min), making the use of Instagram easier for the task assigned.

Given the situation that the world is passing through, as professors, we have had to move to remote learning overnight. In this regard, social networks can be very useful for engaging the biomechanics community, as evidenced by the popularity of the Sports Biomechanics Lecture Series (McErlain-Naylor, 2020), but to encourage future students into biomechanics, one must speak their language. Although the results of the study are promising, one must consider the limitations of this study. This study focused solely on the qualitative aspect of sports biomechanics lectures. Future studies can look at incorporating quantitative analysis, which also forms an important part of biomechanics studies. Secondly, this study looked at only the sports biomechanics subject, and professors can look at using social networks in other subjects of sports science to gage its feasibility in the overall sports science course. Thirdly, the study only analyzed the Likert scale scores of qualitative responses and incorporating studies that contextualize actual student feedback will help improve the application of social networks in the higher education setting. Finally, based on the recommendations of the ethics committee, the students created private accounts for this study -the results of using public accounts, where social networks provide analytics describing the reach of the account and each publication can help the students understand user engagement in a particular social network and benefit from it when they work in a professional environment.

More studies are needed which use on the use of social networks in teaching, and it is important to get both qualitative feedback from the students in terms of their experiences and simultaneously gage the learning that has occurred. These studies ought to be robust statistically analyzed using big samples, but practically this might be difficult to carry out in a single university. Although there is resistance to the use of social networks in education, they have the potential of being used to facilitate learning with an excellent effect. In the next few years, Instagram will likely be replaced by another social network, or maybe Instagram is not the most popular social network in the country of the reader, nevertheless, it is expected that the aspects extracted from this study can be considered for future applications.

The results show that the perception of undergraduate students in using Instagram to learn qualitative biomechanical analysis is quite positive. The students, who use smartphones very frequently in their daily lives, and specifically, many use them for browsing social networks, find the platform to be very useful in finding and sharing information related to sports and specifically in sports biomechanics. The students, after performing the assignment, did not only believe that they could use smartphones, and social networks in particular, to perform classroom assignments, but also were more willing to use it in their studies. They also believed that Instagram in particular could be a useful source of information on sports biomechanics, and could also be a platform to present their work. This could be attributed to the visual aspect of social networks like Instagram which can help engage them with learning strategies in a subject like biomechanics. Given the large sample of students that participated in the study, the results show a possible positive application of social networks in education and specifically in sports education.

The original contributions presented in the study are included in the article/supplementary material, further inquiries can be directed to the corresponding author.

The studies involving human participants were reviewed and approved by Comité de Investigación, Universidad Europea de Madrid. The participants provided their written informed consent to participate in this study.

Students' perceptions and attitudes towards the use of Instagram in English language writing

Introduction to sports biomechanics

Is Twitter a pedagogical tool in higher education? Perspectives of education graduate students

Students perception of Mobile Learning during COVID-19 in Bangladesh: university student perspective

Social network sites: public, private, or what

The use of alternative social networking sites in higher educational settings: a case study of the e-learning benefits of Ning in education

Everybody phones out: teaching experiments with Instagram

Global social media research summary

Using Facebook as a co-learning community in higher education

Measuring creative potential: using social network analysis to monitor a learners' creative capacity

Twitter for teaching: can social media be used to enhance the process of learning

Statistical power analyses using G * Power 3.1: tests for correlation and regression analyses

Long-term retention of skilled visual search: do young adults retain more than old adults?

Complexity of ICT in education: a critical literature review and its implications

Teaching practices of the undergraduate introductory biomechanics faculty: a North American survey

Mobile computing devices in higher education: student perspectives on learning with cellphones, smartphones & social media

To use or not to use web 2.0 in higher education?

Identifying the use of online social networking in higher education. Same places, different spaces

Students' and teachers' use of Facebook

Social networks to promote motivation and learning in higher education from the students' perspective

Putting twitter to the test: assessing outcomes for student collaboration, engagement and success: twitter collaboration & engagement

Tweeting your way to improved #writing, #reflection, and #community

Essential insights into how people around the world use the internet, mobile devices, social media, and ecommerce

Perceptions of sport science students on the potential applications and limitations of blended learning in their education: a qualitative study

Mobile technologies in teaching English as a foreign language in higher education: a case study of using mobile application Instagram

Showing face in video instruction: effects on information retention, visual attention, and affect

Fundamentals of biomechanics

Qualitative biomechanical principles for application in coaching

A tale of two instructional experiences: student engagement in active learning and emergency remote learning of biomechanics

Qualitative Diagnosis of Human Movement

Correlates of learning in introductory biomechanics

#ProblemasParaPensar: inspirar, motivar y sugerir aprendizajes

Effects of text illustrations: a review of research

That is like a 24 hoursday tournament!': using social media to further an authentic sport experience within sport education

Snapping, pinning, liking or texting: investigating social media in higher education beyond Facebook

Students' participation in peer-to-peer communication supported by social media

Staying Informed and Bridging "Social Distance": Smartphone News Use and Mobile Messaging Behaviors of Flemish Adults during the First Weeks of the COVID-19 Pandemic

Applying a score confidence interval to Aiken's item content-relevance index

Social Networks in University Students: Academic Use and Learning Scenarios

Teaching Biomechanics with Just-in-Time Teaching (JiTT)

El móvil salva la brecha escolar en tiempos de cuarentena por el coronavirus

Using YouTube© in the classroom for the net generation of students

Instagram as a vehicle for education: what radiology educators need to know

Instagram: motives for its use and relationship to narcissism and contextual age

Friend or faculty: social networking sites, dual relationships, and context collapse in higher education

Using Twitter for education: beneficial or simply a waste of time?

Coronavirus Lockdown | Over 80% of Students Depend on Mobiles for Learning: NCERT. New Delhi: The Hindu

IV Estudio sobre los usuarios de Facebook

Where does time spent on the Internet come from? Tracing the influence of information and communications technology use on daily activities

The Use of Mobile Devices in Online Classrooms

AN organized the database and performed the statistical analysis. All authors wrote the first draft of the manuscript and contributed to the conception, design of the study, manuscript revision, read, and approved the submitted version.

The authors declare that the research was conducted in the absence of any commercial or financial relationships that could be construed as a potential conflict of interest.