key: cord-0979104-aogjosfh
authors: Goodman, Sara; Zahn, Matthew; Bruckner, Tim; Boden-Albala, Bernadette; Lakon, Cynthia M.
title: Measuring Hazards of Undetectable Viral Load among Hepatitis C Antibody Positive Residents of a Large Southern California County
date: 2021-12-13
journal: Health Serv Res Manag Epidemiol
DOI: 10.1177/23333928211066181
sha: 762377bd601542830a4b6c9614736fe7ddc9df9c
doc_id: 979104
cord_uid: aogjosfh

Abstract Background Hepatitis C virus (HCV) infection is the most common bloodborne infection in the U.S. However, only a small proportion of persons are treated and cured. Previous research has not characterized sociodemographic characteristics of who receives treatment. We examined predictors of undetectable for HCV in Orange County, the sixth largest county in the United States, where HCV is the most commonly reported infection. Methods: From 2014 to 2020, we acquired public health surveillance data from 91,165 HCV antibody-positive care encounters from the California Reportable Disease Information Exchange (CalREDIE). We used a time-to-event proportional hazards framework to estimate individual and area-level correlates of time-to-HCV undetectable viral load among HCV + individuals. Results: Older adults (>65 years) showed an increased hazard of undetectable viral load relative to younger adults (HR = 2.00). In addition, residents of census tracts with greater enrollment in health insurance showed a greater likelihood of undetectable viral load (HR = 1.36). The moderating effect of higher tract median household income and higher tract levels of health insurance were more likely to have undetectable viral load and was statistically significant. Conclusion: In a large urban county, HCV antibody-positive older adults appear much more likely to show undetectable viral load compared to younger adults. Residents in areas with higher quartiles of health insurance enrollment have an increased likelihood of undetectable viral load. The extent to which constraints impede HCV care requires further investigation, including follow-up studies on health insurance type to test the relationship of health insurance type to undetectable viral load.

initiation, and treatment completion. [8] [9] [10] [11] [12] [13] With successful treatment leading to a sustained virologic response (SVR) with the virus remaining undetectable 12 weeks post-treatment completion. [8] [9] [10] [11] [12] [13] Although generally accepted as the standard of care, the care cascade may vary by treatment facility and clinician. This cascade is crucial because it identifies where patients can drop out of HCV care and assists public health practitioners in defining denominators for analysis using the number of patients in that part of the care cascade.

Diagnosis of HCV is imperative for patients to receive care. To diagnose HCV infection, patients must complete antibody testing and a subsequent viral load test to confirm viremia or chronic infection. Active infection of HCV is only confirmed using a viral load test. 14 The recommended diagnosis procedure begins with an HCV antibody enzyme-linked immune absorbed assay (ELISA) test with a follow-up RNA viral load test with viremic patients referred to treatment. 15, 16 A viable cure for HCV is available. In 2014, the Food and Drug Administration (FDA) approved the first wave of Direct Acting Antivirals (DAAs), curing the disease in as few as eight weeks with a likelihood of reinfection post-SVR. 13, [17] [18] [19] [20] [21] [22] [23] [24] Numerous studies have shown that these DAAs are over 95% % effective. 8, 17, 21, [23] [24] [25] [26] Although DAA medications are effective, their cost (ranging from $24,000 to $100,000) is a barrier to utilization, preventing infected individuals from seeking treatment. [27] [28] [29] [30] Insurance coverage of these medications should be examined to understand their independent and multiplicative effect on attaining an undetectable viral load.

Orange County, California, is the sixth most populous county in the U.S. with a population of 3.3 million. 31 The morbidity and mortality from hepatitis C infection in Orange County is substantially greater than any other infectious disease in the last decade (excluding the recent COVID-19 pandemic.) 12, 32 Despite the availability of effective treatment, it remains unclear what fraction of Orange County, California (O.C.) with an antibody-positive test, the sociodemographic determinants of who ultimately receives treatment are not wellcharacterized due to gaps in surveillance data. Other studies have not examined undetectable viral load using public health surveillance data in the U.S. and have only examined effectiveness of point of care testing on viral load. [33] [34] [35] [36] [37] To better understand the infection rates in O.C. and how it relates to HCV testing, we examine the relationship between the individual (age, gender, out of state status) and area-level factors (census-tract level median income and insurance coverage) and the likelihood of an undetectable viral load for HCV.

Participants in this dataset included 23,950 HCV antibody positive patients (and 91,165 patient encounters) in the (California Reportable Disease Information Exchange) CalREDIE infectious disease report database.

This dataset was a convenience sample compiled from all HCV antibody positive case reports assigned to O.C., California from January first, 2014, to March first, 2020. 12 Each person was counted individually and each test result categorized a as a different encounter. Out of the 159 to 140 total encounters, 91,365 were able to be joined to census tracts and 91,165 had no missing variables. that could be joined using census tract information to American Community Survey 2017 data. A sample diagram can be found in appendix A.

This dataset was compiled from all hepatitis C antibody positive results from CalREDIE from 2014 to March first, 2020. All HCV viral load tests, regardless of the result, are reported to CalREDIE. Power calculations were conducted and there was an appropriate sample size to perform this analysis with 0.80 power according to the statistical software. 38 

The dependent, or time-to-event variable is an undetectable viral load. An undetectable viral load was classified as having less than 20 copies/ml on a PCR RNA viral load test. 40 A sensitivity analysis was conducted with different viral load cut-offs to determine an undetectable viral load that could lead to sustained virologic response or natural clearing of HCV infection 40 We measured history of HCV infection by extracting data from the CalREDIE database for patients assigned to the OCHCA who tested positive using a HCV antibody test; cases with addresses outside of California were designated out of state.

We specified a Cox proportional hazard model, and the time period for evidence of undetectable viral load was by year. This regression uses time over multiple individual encounters per person to control for it in analysis and helps to see what the hazard of an event (in this case, whether an undetectable viral load) will happen. 41 The hazard function, in this case, is the "risk" of having an undetectable viral load at time t. 40, 41 In this dataset, there were 23,950 people with 91,165 total encounters as panel data. The unit of analysis is by person. The proportional hazards assumption using Schoenfeld residuals was not met so we cannot assume that the hazards are the same for every individual in this regression, 38 however these results are still insightful and can be used to better target public health interventions. Independent variables at the individual level included age, gender, and in/out of state status. The coding for gender was categorical as collected (male, female, or unknown) and recoded into binary, male, or female. Age was divided into 10-year age groups after the age of 19 also as binary (65 and younger and over 65 years of age). 19 Due to 80% of missing race/ethnicity data in this dataset, we did not examine this covariate in these analyses.

Observations with census tract information were joined with data from the 2017 American Community Survey (ACS) (n = 23,950 or 73%). The 2017 ACS was used as it was the most recent ACS 5-year estimate conducted at the time of analysis. This matching allowed us to examine the role of median household income and % of residents with health insurance with an undetectable HCV viral load. Health insurance was further divided into % with private health insurance, % with no health insurance, and government health insurance (state or federal, Medicaid or Medicare.) 42 These data were aggregated into quartiles to be consistent with the literature and to better understand the wealth as distributed. 43 Data were analyzed using Stata version 13 (StataCorp, College Station, TX).

The mean age was 52.47 years (± 15.20, min: 0, maximum of 119) ( Table 1 ). Participants were mostly male (58.66%), and 20.47% of participants were over 65 years. California residents Figure 1 ). In addition, in/out of state residence does affect an undetectable viral load making the hazard lower (HR = 0.65 95% Confidence Interval [0.45-0.95].

Residents of census tracts with the highest percentage of any health insurance coverage were more likely to have an undetectable viral load (HR = 1.36, 95% CI [1.09-1.70]). Patients in tracts with higher quartiles of government health insurance were less likely to have an undetectable viral load. The fourth quartile of % health insurance (over 92% coverage compared to quartile 1) HR = 1.36 (1.19-1.57) and all quartiles of % on government health insurance compared to quartile 1 were less likely to have an undetectable viral load. In general, persons residing in census tracts with a higher percentage of public health insurance showed reduced HRs of receiving treatment.

An interaction term between median income and health insurance was significant (Table 3) When holding quartile of income constant, increasing the quartile of insurance increased the HR of an undetectable viral load. Quartile 4 compared to quartile 1 had the highest HR of 9.75.

Given the discovered difference in treatment rates by those over 65 compared to younger patients and the strong relationship between retirement age and health insurance type, we conducted a stratified post hoc analysis for those aged 65 and younger (n = 74,136) and those over 65 (n = 17,029 in Table 4 , hazard curves in Figure 2 ). Among older adults, a greater proportion of public health insurance at the census tract corresponds with an increased probability of that patient having an undetectable viral load.

This study examined over a seven-year period with 91,165 care encounters of 23,950 patients in the sixth largest county in the U.S., approximately 97% of patients who have HCV virus antibodies do not indicate undetectable viral load indicating a lack of HCV treatment or spontaneous clearance. Those who lived in census tracts with higher quartiles of private health insurance, and those over the age of 65, had higher odds of an undetectable viral load with 34% patients not being tested at all for viral load. Taken together, findings indicate an alarming level of potential under-diagnosis and linkage to care for detected HCV antibodypositive cases. These results indicate financial and health insurance barriers to diagnosis that impede patients' ability to be linked to care.

These findings imply inadequate screening for those 65 and younger compared to their older counterparts. 44 This confirmed results from a study that found that universal screening identified that those younger than the 1945 to 1965 birth cohort comprised nearly 48% of all HCV cases in four large metropolitan emergency departments. 45 Those in census tracts with lower insurance coverage are less likely to have undetectable viral load. In a study of 38,025 persons in sites across the United States, Ditah and colleagues found that those who did not continue HCV follow-up care were less likely to have health care insurance. 46 Our work builds upon that of Ditah and colleagues and covers a period after DAA approval. If others replicate our work using individual-level data on health insurance type, this financial barrier to treatment requires significant policy attention and amelioration. 47 Our study with a large sample size, in a large geographical area allows health practitioners to identify gaps in the care cascade and where some patients may still have infections.

The current study has policy implications, including bridging the gaps for poor insurance coverage negatively impacting care. Persons living with HCV need appropriate health insurance for those uninsured to help initiate treatment. Connections to care with more expansive insurance plans could be implemented using peer navigators and specialty pharmacies to target those ages 65 and younger and lower income. 48 Scientists must conduct further research to identify patients who fall out of the care cascade and better target interventions to link patients to care.

Some of the limitations related to using surveillance data for secondary analysis. The missing covariates in surveillance data do not capture or indicate information relevant to HCV infection such as risk factors (eg, race, employment), occupation, individual insurance providers, persons in incarceration settings or risk behaviors such as injection drug use or those without homes. We are also unable to determine comorbidities such as HIV, hepatitis B infection, or other disease using these data. We cannot examine in this dataset if these groups with increased vulnerability have an increased risk of contracting HCV. 2, 46 Those with less access to health care and lower incomes are less likely to have an undetectable viral load, widening the gap of those who are unable to pay for expensive DAA medications. The inability to categorize and analyze these populations may lead to an underestimation of socioeconomic characteristics on likelihood of undetectable viral load.

Another limitation is the incomplete nature of public health surveillance data with missing values on individual covariates. We do not have accurate race/ethnicity data for these HCV cases, as 80% are missing. Regarding lab tests, we only know if individuals are viremic if they have tested for viral load, and we cannot verify if undetectable viral load was due to spontaneous clearance or treatment. We could not use these cases in the analysis because they had a missing address or failed to geocode. In addition, census tract-level information does not necessarily reflect the status of individuals living in that tract. Also, viremic, out-of-state patients may have returned to their home state for treatment, which we cannot capture in this dataset.

Finally, O.C. is a popular tourism destination for substance abuse rehabilitation in the U.S. This dataset may not reflect the burden of HCV in other settings such as homeless encampments and incarceration facilities. 49 Our results only reflect an undetectable HCV viral load from one county in California. They may not be generalizable to other locations in the state or the United States as a whole. Despite this limitation, the size of O.C.'s population (> 3 million) indicates that these results have public health implications for this community and counties of similar size and demographics.

In an era of effective treatment, the overwhelming HCV antibody positive patients OC do not have a detectable HCV viral load and are potentially infectious. Only 1% of all persons with HCV positive antibody tests had an undetectable viral load from 2014 to the beginning of 2020, which indicates a lack of HCV diagnosis and treatment initiation. Disparities in insurance coverage illustrate the potential for severe inequity in treatment. The USPSTF updated their guidelines in 2020, recommending universal HCV screening for all people ages 18 to 79. 50 Universal HCV screening and viral load testing will help increase care and treatment initiation. Ensuring that health insurance will cover treatment costs and connecting persons living with HCV to appropriate treatment and treatment completion are top priorities. Subsequent work in this area would benefit from understanding the structural, socioeconomic, and cost barriers to achieving this successful care cascade.

This research was approved by the Institutional Review Boards of the University of California, Irvine protocol H.S. # 2019-548 and the Orange County Health Care Agency (Research Project 2020-03). No consent was obtained as this is routinely collected public health data.

The author(s) disclosed receipt of the following financial support for the research, authorship, and/or publication of this article: This work was supported by the University of California, Irvine Program in Public Health Dissertation Writing Fellowship.

Sara Goodman https://orcid.org/0000-0003-0425-9688

Supplemental material for this article is available online

Compressed mortality file 1999-2018 multiple cause of death 1999-2018 on CDC WONDER online database

Viral hepatitis surveillance-United States

Estimating prevalence of hepatitis C virus infection in the United States

Trends in mortality after diagnosis of hepatitis C virus infection: an international comparison and implications for monitoring the population impact of treatment

What is killing people with hepatitis C virus infection? Paper presented at: seminars in liver disease

Mortality among persons in care with hepatitis C virus infection: the chronic hepatitis cohort study (CHeCS)

Impact of sustained virologic response on risk of type 2 diabetes among hepatitis C patients in the United States

Infectious Diseases Society of America. HCV Guidance: recommendations for testing, managing, and treating hepatitis C. Overview of cost, reimbursement, and cost-effectiveness considerations for hepatitis C treatment regimens

Overview of hepatitis C in orange county

World Health Organization

Hepatitis C virus diagnosis and the holy grail

Evaluation of a prison outreach clinic for the diagnosis and prevention of hepatitis C: implications for the national strategy

Diagnosis of hepatitis C virus infection by enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay and reverse transcriptase-nested polymerase chain reaction: a comparative evaluation

Prioritization of HCV treatment in the direct-acting antiviral era: an economic evaluation

Risk of late relapse or reinfection with hepatitis C virus after achieving a sustained virological response: a systematic review and metaanalysis

Viral hepatitis surveillance-United States

Cost effectiveness of universal screening for hepatitis C virus infection in the era of direct-acting, pangenotypic treatment regimens

Direct-acting antiviral agents for patients with hepatitis C virus genotype 1 infection are cost-saving

American Association for the Study of Liver Diseases and the Infectious Diseases Society of America. HCV Guidance" recommendations for testing, managing, and treating hepatitis C

Impact of direct acting antiviral therapy in patients with chronic hepatitis C and decompensated cirrhosis

Cost and access to direct-acting antiviral agents

Infectious Diseases Society of America. HCV Guidance" recommendations for testing, managing, and treating hepatitis C

The HCV epidemics in key populations (including PWID, prisoners, and MSM): the use of DAAs as treatment for prevention

Food and Drug Administration. Hepatitis B and C treatments

High-Cost HCV Drugs in Medicaid: Final Report: Report for Medicaid and CHIP Payment and Access Commission (MACPAC), Contract # MACP16406T2

Hepatitis C drug's lower cost paves way for medicaid, prisons to expand treatment

Population health in an era of rising income inequality: USA, 1980-2015. The Lancet

Orange County Health Care Agency Epidemiology and Assessment Branch. Hepatitis C chronic cases In: California reportable disease information exchange

Multicenter evaluation of the cepheid Xpert hepatitis C virus viral load assay

The new Xpert HCV viral load real-time PCR assay accurately quantifies hepatitis C virus RNA in serum and whole-blood specimens

Food insecurity may lead to incomplete HIV viral suppression and less immune reconstitution among HIV/hepatitis C virus-coinfected people

Rapid point-of-care HCV RNA quantification in capillary whole blood for diagnosing chronic HCV infection, monitoring treatment and detecting reinfection

Utility of the new cobas HCV test for viral load monitoring during direct-acting antiviral therapy

Stata 13 base reference manual

Sexually Transmitted Diseases (STD) Control Branch: Office of Viral Hepatitis Prevention. Orange county -chronic hepatitis C cases and rates of newly reported cases

Association of Public Health Laboratories. Interpretation of hepatitis C virus test results: guidance for laboratories

Regression models and life-tables

Glossary: american community survey (ACS) health insurance definitions

Association of census tract-level socioeconomic status with disparities in prostate cancer-specific survival

United States Preventive Services Task Force. Hepatitis C: screening

High prevalence of hepatitis C infection Among adult patients at four urban emergency departments

Lack of health insurance limits the benefits of hepatitis C virus screening: insights from the national health and nutrition examination hepatitis C follow-up study

Using the Electronic Health Record to Characterize the Hepatitis C Virus Care Cascade

Increasing access to hepatitis C virus medications: a program model using patient navigators and specialty pharmacy to obtain prior authorization approval

How some Southern California drug rehab centers exploit addiction

Preventive Services Task Force. Final recommendation statement: hepatitis C virus infection in adolescents and adults: screening

Author Biographies

Candidate in the Department of Health, Society, and Behavior in the Program in Public Health at the University of California, Irvine. Her dissertation research uses public health surveillance data to determine facilitators and barriers to hepatitis C testing and diagnosis

Matthew Zahn currently serves as the Medical Director of the Communicable Disease Control Branch in Epidemiology and Assessment for the Orange County Health Care Agency. He is also a clinical faculty affiliate of the Children's Hospital of Orange County

Tim Bruckner is a Professor in Health Society and Behavior and Population Health and Disease Prevention at the University of California, Irvine. He is also co-Director of the Center for Population

Bernadette Boden-Albala currently serves as the Director and Founding Dean of the Program in Public Health

Lakon currently serves as the interim chair and Associate professor in the Department of Health, Society, and Behavior at the University of California

The authors would like to thank the entire Orange County Health Care Agency Communicable Disease Control Team, including Stephen Klish, Patrick Pham, and Joshua Jacobs, for their assistance in helping access and extract these data.

SG was responsible for extracting and coding the data, performing the analysis, drafting, and writing the manuscript, MZ provided technical expertise, TB was responsible for reviewing and editing the manuscript and helping to create the analysis plan. BBA and CL also provided technical and writing advice for this manuscript.

The author(s) declared no potential conflicts of interest with respect to the research, authorship, and/or publication of this article.

The data that support the findings of this study are available from the California Department of Public Health CalREDIE data warehouse, but restrictions apply to the availability of these data, which were used under data sharing agreements for the current study, and so are not publicly available. Data are however available from the authors upon reasonable request and with permission of the California Department of Public Health (CDPH). CDPH can be reached by phone or email: Point of contact: +1 866-866-1428 or CalREDIEHelp@cdph.ca.gov

As part of routine infectious disease surveillance under California State Health Code Title 17 a §2500, §2593, §2641.5 to 2643.20, and §2800 to 2812 Reportable Diseases and Conditions this data is collected regularly and may be used for enhanced surveillance. Ms. Goodman's role as a intern epidemiologist at the Orange County Health Care Agency, the director of the communicable disease control branch, Dr. Matthew Zahn (a co-author on this paper), through the California Department of Public Health granted permission for Ms. Goodman to use this anonymized data for analysis as part of her doctoral dissertation. See attached documentation from the Orange County Health Care Agency IRB application and approval letter.