key: cord-1004488-wexnkuqk authors: ALOJAIMY, RUEDA SALEH; NAKAMURA, KEIKO; AL-SOBAIHI, SABER; TASHIRO, YURI; WATANABE, NOZOMI; SEINO, KAORUKO title: Infection prevention and control standards and associated factors: Case study of the level of knowledge and practices among nurses in a Saudi Arabian hospital date: 2021-07-30 journal: J Prev Med Hyg DOI: 10.15167/2421-4248/jpmh2021.62.2.1957 sha: 32e986af6b3e58c4c699ceaf4774872f6ce201b9 doc_id: 1004488 cord_uid: wexnkuqk INTRODUCTION: Healthcare-associated infection is a significant public health issue in both developed and developing countries. This study was performed to assess the knowledge and practices of infection prevention and control (IPC) of nurses working in a Saudi hospital, and to examine their associations with the nurses’ sociodemographic characteristics and work/training experience. METHODS: A self-administered questionnaire survey was conducted with participation of male and female nurses of all nationalities who had direct contact with patients while providing healthcare services at King Abdulaziz Medical City-Riyadh (KAMC-R). Sociodemographic characteristics, and work/training experience were reported; IPC knowledge and practices were assessed by questionnaire. Data of 308 valid responses were analyzed. Percentage of correct responses to nine IPC knowledge questions and frequent adherence to 11 IPC practices were calculated. IPC knowledge and practice scores were developed by using principal component analyses; individual scores were classified into high/low level of knowledge or practices by the median of the scores. Logistic regression analysis was performed to evaluate associations between IPC knowledge or practice scores and sociodemographic or work/training variables. RESULTS: Majority of the participants were females (89.3%). Significant associations between high education level and high level of IPC knowledge (AOR = 2.72, 95% CI = 1.45-5.10) and practices (AOR = 3.66, 95% CI = 1.90-7.05) were observed, after controlling the influence of sociodemographic and work/training variables. CONCLUSION: High scores for IPC knowledge and IPC practices were independently associated with nurses’ high level of education, regardless of their nationality or previous working experience. Further studies to develop effective programs for IPC regardless of the nurses’ educational attainment are recommended. Healthcare-associated infection (HAI) is a significant public health issue around the world [1] . It affects both developed and developing countries [2] . About 5% to 10% of hospitalized patients in developed countries, and about 20% of patients in developing countries are affected by HAI [3] . Treatment of HAIs draws a lot from countries' budgets for healthcare; in the U.S., it costs 5 to 10 billion dollars annually to manage HAIs [4] . The World Health Organization (WHO) has created the term Infection Prevention and Control (IPC), for encouraging a scientific approach and practical solutions to prevent the harm accruing from HAI to patients and healthcare workers (HCWs) [5] . The Centers for Disease Control (CDC) established the concept of universal precautions (UPs) in 1987, and then, changed to standard precautions (SPs) in 1996 [6] . SPs are used when dealing with any patient, regardless of the diagnosis [7] . Studies have discussed IPC from different points of view. According to one reported study, assessment of the current levels of knowledge and practices of HCWs is the first step towards establishment of a successful IPC program [2] . Another study suggested that in order to increase the compliance level of HCWs towards IPC standards, the barriers need to be known and removed [8] . Another study has recommended periodic assessment of the knowledge levels for filling any gaps [9] . As a background to this study, Saudi Arabia has a total population of 34,218,169 persons, and is a high-income country [10] . The Saudi healthcare system has been ranked by the WHO as 26th from the top, out of 191 countries [11] . The nursing workforce in Saudi Arabia depends mainly on expatriate workers, who account for 62.6% of the entire workforce, and there are workers of over 44 nationalities in the Saudi health sector [10] . Saudi IPC is a young and rapidly growing speciality [12] . The most common types of HAIs in Saudi Arabia are pneumonia, urinary tract infection (UTI), and bloodstream infection. Approximately, 19 .2% of HAIs in Saudi Arabia are reported to be device-associated [13] . WHO [14] . The Saudi Ministry of Health (MOH), at the current time, follows the healthcare 2020 vision, aimed at achieving the best possible health condition or health status for Saudi inhabitants [15] . This vision involves the establishment of an effective system by following appropriate and effective methods to estimate the risks and benefits of the methods employed [15] . This study was performed to assess the IPC knowledge and practices of nurses working in a Saudi hospital, and to examine their associations with the nurses' sociodemographic characteristics and work/training experience. A cross-sectional self-reported questionnaire survey was conducted at King Abdulaziz Medical City-Riyadh (KAMC-R) between August 2 to September 5, 2019. The hospital follows the Joint Commission International (JCI) standards as the unifying standard for healthcare and practice [16] . According to the assumption of proportion of high level of IPC knowledge as 50%, degree of precision as 0.05, sample size for the study was calculated as 384. Nurses working at the following units of the hospital were invited to participate in the study, regardless of their gender and nationalities: medical unit, surgical unit, cardiac unit, emergency unit, labor and delivery unit, hemodialysis unit, intensive care unit, and ambulatory care center. Nurses who provided healthcare services and had direct contact with patients were included in the study sample. During the study period, 820 nurses participated in the survey; data of 803 valid responses were analyzed. The questionnaire was developed in English based on the WHO guidelines [17] and CDC guidelines [18] . Nurses in Saudi Arabia use English as a working language. By using multiple choice questions and a Likert scale for responses, sociodemographic characteristics, work/ training experiences, knowledge about IPC, and IPC practices of participated nurses were evaluated. To develop a questionnaire, a pilot questionnaire form was sent to two nurses and their views on the questionnaires were reflected to formulate words in the questionnaire. The sociodemographic information included the gender, age, education, and nationality. Questions on work/training experiences included years of service, previous work experiences, experience in KAMC-R, and experience outside KAMC-R. Nine questions were used to evaluate the subjects' knowledge on IPC, and 11 questions were used to evaluate the adherence to IPC practices by referencing WHO guidelines [17] , CDC guidelines [18] and surveys conducted in other countries. The survey instrument was pre-tested in a preliminary survey with 30 nurses from the same hospital prior to the start of the actual data collection process. Those nurses were excluded in the actual main data collection. The Statistical Package for the Social Sciences (SPSS) version 22 software was used for the statistical analyses. The responses to nine individual questions about IPC knowledge were divided into correct or in-correct responses. The percentages of correct responses to individual questions were calculated. Adherence to IPC practices were evaluated based on self-reported responses on a Likert scale for frequencies (Always = 3; Sometimes = 2; Seldom = 1; Never = 0) to perform 11 practices. The percentages of the response of "always" for IPC practices and the means of the score for 11 practices were calculated. To develop composite scores for IPC knowledge and IPC practices, individually, principal component analyses (PCA) were performed by using correct or incorrect answers to nine questions on IPC knowledge and self-reported frequencies of adherence to 11 IPC practices. The factor scores of the first component of IPC knowledge questions and the first component of IPC practices questions were used as the composite IPC knowledge score and the composite IPC practice score. For further analysis to evaluate the associations between IPC knowledge or practices and the sociodemographic or work/training variables, the composite scores for IPC knowledge and practices were classified into high/ low level of knowledge or practice by the median of individual composite scores. The associations between IPC knowledge or practice scores and sociodemographic characteristics or work/ training variables were evaluated by logistic regression analysis. Composite IPC knowledge score, high/low, was used as a dependent variable and its association with independent variables (sociodemographic characteristics and work/training experiences) were analyzed. Similar analysis using composite IPC practice score, high/low, as a dependent variable was also performed. The study was conducted with the approval of the Tokyo Medical and Dental University Ethics Committee (M2018-310), and King Abdullah International Medical Research Center (SP19/406/R). The survey followed the principle of voluntary participation and informed consent for participation was obtained before answering to questions. They were informed that they were free to withdraw from the study at any time without any disadvantages accruing to them. Nurses who refused to participate in the survey were not included in the study. Those who were not directly involved in providing healthcare services to patients, such as nurse managers, were excluded from the study. The high percentage of female nurses among the study participants was consistent with the reported percentage of female workers in the Saudi nursing workforce (80.7%) [10] . The percentage of expatriate workers in the current study of 78.2% was higher than reported percentage of foreign workers in the Saudi nursing workforce (62.6%) [10] . More than half of the participants were Filipinos (55.5%). This reflects a report in 2011 by Kanchanachitra et al., which reported large number of international migration of Filipino nurses to Saudi Arabia, UAE, UK and USA, and referred the Philippines as one of the major countries for export of nurses [18] . The current study showed that nurses participated in the study had a high level of knowledge on hand hygiene, respiratory hygiene, contact infection, and rubbing of hands procedure, handling of personal protective equipment and handling of sharp objects; an intermediate level of knowledge on SP; knowledge below the average on the 5 moments of hand hygiene and immunization schedule or healthcare providers. HAI is central to the provision of safe and high-quality healthcare, therefore, the related IPC policies and procedures should be adhered when dealing with patients as well as equipment. The IPC methods should ideally be applied to ensure that a sterile environment is provided. With regards to the scores for IPC knowledge and practices developed by PCA, the score for IPC practices explained 29.1% of variance for the 11 variables and showed reasonable representation and consistencies; on the other hand, the IPC knowledge score only explained 15.5% of the variance for the 9 variables. Further studies are needed to develop a good indicator to reflect level of knowledge among HCWs in the context of Saudi Arabia. The results identified education level of the nurses as a significant independent factor related to high scores for both IPC knowledge and IPC practices. No significant associations of the scores were observed with previous work experience or experience of receiving training on IPC. These findings suggest that for nurses below a bachelor degree education, effective interventions to improve their knowledge of IPC and IPC practices are critically important. The hospital had experienced an outbreak of MERS-CoV in 2015, and a special IPC program called "right care, right now" was implemented [16] , however, the current results did not show any association of the scores for IPC knowledge or practices with experience of IPC training inside KAMC-R. Therefore, the impacts of in-hospital training programs need further investigation. Saudi Arabia has announced the Saudi Vision 2030 for improving the delivery of services in all fields and sectors, including the health sector. The vision is aimed at improving the efficiency and effectiveness of the healthcare sector through the use of information technology and digital transformation [19] . Thus, for provision of training on IPC or IPC education sessions, use of modern information technology and digital sources is highly recommended. The study was designed as a cross-sectional study, which is not adequate to address causation. There could be potential reporting bias due to self-reporting of practices by the HCWs rather than observational or objective evaluation. Furthermore, there could have been potential sampling bias, as this survey was conducted at a single hospital run under unique system by the Ministry of National Guard Health Affairs, while Saudi Arabia is a big country with 13 administrative regions. The study reported IPC knowledge and IPC practices of nurses working in a Saudi hospital. High scores for IPC knowledge and IPC practices were independently associated with a high level of education completed by the nurses, regardless of their nationality or previous working experiences. It is important to develop effective programs to improve IPC knowledge and compliance to recommended IPC practices, regardless of the level of education of nurses in the current workforce. Periodic conduct of an IPC awareness program for HCWs is also recommended. The study protocol was approved by the Tokyo Medical and Dental University Ethics Committee (M2018-310), and King Abdullah International Medical Research Center (SP19/406/R). Table IV . Distribution of high infection prevention and control (IPC) practices score and its association with sociodemographic characteristics and working/training experiences of nurses working in a Saudi hospital (n = 308). High Health care-associated infections -an overview Assessment of knowledge and practices of healthcare workers towards infection prevention and associated factors in healthcare facilities of West Arsi District, Southeast Ethiopia: a facility-based crosssectional study Knowledge and Practice on Infection Prevention among Nurses of Bir Hospital Hospital-acquired infections due to gram-negative bacteria History of Guidelines for Isolation Precautions in Hospi Precautions for All Patient Care Clinical Experiences as Related to Standard Precautions Compliance among Nursing Students: A Focus Group Interview Based on the Theory of Planned Behavior Knowledge and behaviour of nursing students on the prevention of healthcare associated infections General Authority for Statistics-Kingdom of Saudi Arabia Healthcare human resource development in Saudi Arabia: emerging challenges and opportunities-a critical review Infection control in Saudi Arabia: meeting the challenge Burden of healthcare-associated infections at six tertiary-care hospitals in Saudi Arabia: A point prevalence survey Middle East respiratory syndrome coronavirus (MERS-CoV) -The Kingdom of Saudi Arabia Kingdom of Saudi Arabia Ministry of Health. MOH Vision 2020 Kingdom of Saudi Arabia Ministry of National Guard Health Affairs. King Abdulaziz Medical City in Riyadh Human resources for health in southeast Asia: shortages, distributional challenges, and international trade in health services Vision 2030 and the Opportunities it Represents in Healthcare in Saudi Arabia The authors appreciate Dr. Hanem F. Mohamed and Ms. Arwa Alhamed, King Saud bin Abdulaziz University for Healthy Sciences for their support to coordinate the implementation of the study, and King Abdulaziz Medical City-Riyadh for their support and cooperation to conduct this study.The authors declare no conflicts of interest. RSA and KN conceptualized and designed the study, RSA coordinated and managed the implementation of the survey and obtained data, RSA, KN, and SA analyzed and interpreted the results, and KS reviewed the analysis. RSA developed initial manuscript, and KN, SA, YT, NW and KS reviewed and revised the manuscript.