key: cord-1029776-8v9fu9a1
authors: Tirelli, Umberto; Franzini, Marianno; Valdenassi, Luigi; Pandolfi, Sergio; Berretta, Massimiliano; Ricevuti, Giovanni; Chirumbolo, Salvatore
title: Patients with Myalgic Encephalomyelitis/Chronic Fatigue Syndrome (ME/CFS) Greatly Improved Fatigue Symptoms When Treated with Oxygen-Ozone Autohemotherapy
date: 2021-12-22
journal: J Clin Med
DOI: 10.3390/jcm11010029
sha: 453d8f6c31a457130c4071164f4898485ead540c
doc_id: 1029776
cord_uid: 8v9fu9a1

(1) Background: Myalgic Encephalomyelitis/Chronic Fatigue Syndrome (ME/CFS) is a chronic syndrome characterized by fatigue as its major and most outstanding symptom. Previous evidence has supported the ability of ozone to relief ME/CFS related fatigue in affected patients (2) Methods: A number of 200 ME/CFS previously diagnosed patients, (mean age 33 ± 13 SD years) were consecutively treated with oxygen-ozone autohemotherapy (O(2)-O(3)-AHT). Fatigue was evaluated via an FSS 7-scoring questionnaire before and following 30 days after treatment. (3) Results: Almost half (43.5%) of the treated patients evolved their FSS scale from the worst (7) to the best (1) score, assessing the highest improvement from being treated with O(2)-O(3)-AHT. Furthermore 77.5% of patients experienced significant ameliorations of fatigue, of 4–6 delta score. No patient showed side effects, yet experienced long lasting fatigue disappearance, by three months follow up (4) Conclusions: Treatment with O(2)-O(3)-AHT greatly improves ME/CFS related fatigue, aside from sex and age distribution.

Myalgic encephalomyelitis/chronic fatigue syndrome (ME/CFS), which has been thoroughly reviewed very recently [1] , is a complex terminology used to identify a multisystemic, serious and long-term illness characterized by fatigue and debilitating muscularskeletal pain, which usually compels patients to abruptly shutting down many active aspects of their social lives [2] [3] [4] . Fatigue is a symptom of the utmost importance in ME/CFS and is usually employed to test the general development of ME/CFS symptomatology upon a defined therapy [5] [6] [7] [8] [9] [10] [11] . The epidemiology of ME/CFS has been widely investigated [12] [13] [14] [15] . Previous studies conducted in Italy as forerunner approaches in treating fatigue date back to nineties [5, 6, 11, 16] . In Italy, a recent study performed on 82 CFS patients living in the Northern areas of the country, reported that the mean age was 32 years, quite half of these patients showed early symptoms between 24 and 40 years and ME/CFS was prevalently (3:1) observed in female subjects [15] . Yet, evaluating a correct prevalence of ME/CFS is a burdensome task, as ME/CFS diagnosis is particularly difficult and often patients with fatigue and other clinical signs are misunderstood with other chronic illnesses [17, 18] . The recent diagnostic criteria for ME/CFS from the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, the so-called IOM 2015 Diagnostic Criteria, which updated the CDC-1994 guidelines [19] , encompassed symptoms and signs such as a severe and chronic fatigue usually lasting longer than six months, as well as the presence of at least four of the following physical symptoms: unrefreshing sleep, impaired concentration, attention or memory, post-exertional malaise, headaches, muscular-skeletal pain and polyarthralgia, tender lymph nodes and sore throat [20] [21] [22] [23] . ME/CFS diagnosis is therefore quite completely based on the clinical evidence, where long-lasting, debilitating fatigue represents the major and most outstanding symptom [24, 25] The difficulty in reaching a sound and proper diagnostic evaluation of ME/CFS, hampers somehow the possibility to find an effective therapy for ME/CFS [26] . Commendable attempts were addressed in the past, even by our group [5, 7, 11] , yet ME/CFS remains so far a very complex task for clinics. Individuals with ME/CFS should be investigated for concurrent depression, pain, and even sleep disturbances. To date, the only available treatment options include a kind of cognitive behavior therapy, including graded motor exercise rehabilitation, approaches that have been demonstrated to only slightly improve fatigue and ameliorating also social adjustment, anxiety, and post-exertional malaise. However, no pharmacologic medicine therapies have been proven thoroughly effective, to date.

Encouraging attempts in treating ME/CFS fatigue with oxygen-ozone autohemotherapy (O 2 -O 3 -AHT) were successfully accomplished by our groups and others [27] [28] [29] . Oxygen-ozone therapy is able to modulate many complex aspects of immunity, the majority of which underlie the pathogenetic mechanisms causing ME/CFS [30, 31] . Interestingly, as occurring in COVID-19, where O 2 -O 3 -AHT resulted particularly effective in treating the oxidative stress associated with the sickness, ME/CFS too might have an oxidative stress causative pathogenesis [32, 33] . This evidence, associated with the increasing awareness that ozone is able to modulate inflammation by targeting the oxidative stress signaling [32] and by previous encouraging outcomes on ME/CFS [27] , suggested us to treat fatigue in patients with O 2 -O 3 -AHT.

In this paper we treated fatigue symptomatology in a large cohort of patients diagnosed as ME/CFS by adopting O 2 -O 3 -AHT. Results are herein described and discussed.

A number of 224 outpatients coming as a whole to the different clinical centers of Pordenone and Gorle (Bergamo) were recruited on the basis of the eligibility criteria assessed for the present research study, 200 entered the study, 19 did not follow up the study design and were excluded from the investigation. 5 formally accepted the research study but never started for different individual reasons. Age distribution reported a mean of 33.08 ± 13.50 SD years [CI 95 = 31.20-34.97] and a median of 33.14 years, the cohort was composed of 69 males (34.5%), so the majority of patients was represented by female subjects. All patients were thoroughly informed of the therapy protocol and about the use of data for research purposes, according the recommendations of the Helsinki Declaration.

Inclusion criteria were represented by outpatients referring to our clinical healthcare previously diagnosed for ME/CFS [23, 34] , suffering from fatigue, having accepted and signed the informed consent for therapy and moreover enabled and agreed in sharing data for research. Exclusion criteria were represented by patients with chronic active inflammatory pathologies or neurodegenerative and psychiatric disorders, SARS-CoV2 positivity, having experienced COVID-19 within the previous 6 months, included in the suspicion of a post-COVID symptomatology, intaking pharmaceutical drugs within the previous 72 h, having been diagnosed for autoimmune disorders aside from ME/CFS, having cancer, if pregnant women.

Sample size was calculated to achieve an error range of about 10%. Referring to a population proportion of 51%, forecast data resulted in a 13.86% error with 50 patients, whereas 9.80% (<10%) with 103 patients, therefore 200 patients were within the minimal sample size with p < 0.001. The Cohen d test for the two separate groups, i.e., before O 2 -O 3 -AHT and following O 2 -O 3 -AHT was successful, (p = 0.004323 or Hedges' g value). Moreover, Glass' delta p = 0.012444 (p < 0.02).

An anamnestic interview and complete visitation of about 40-60 min was performed. Fatigue was the major symptom evaluated in the study as able to highlight the patient's overall clinical status in the most sound and reliable approach, due to its optimal performance features, stability over time and scant possibility to be shadowed by other minor symptoms. Each patient was asked to respond to a 7-scoring system Fatigue Severity Scale (FSS) before undergoing therapy and one month following therapy [35, 36] . Results were collected as scores and statistically evaluated.

Patients underwent not less than two weekly sessions of major oxygen-ozone autohemotherapy, according to the protocol previously assessed by the Italian Society of Oxygen-Ozone Therapy (SIOOT) [27] . For each O 2 -O 3 -AHT session a treatment time of 30 min was held. Improvements are not immediate but can be observed in the posttreatment period, from 1 week to 1 month following at least one oxygen-ozone therapy session. Therefore, one cannot calculate if more sessions are made, much higher is the improvement. Ozone does not act in a cumulative way but elicits subtle and complex mechanisms in the patient's physiology. A volume of 200 mL of blood was withdrawn from any patient and collected in a CE certified SANO3 bag, then immediately treated with 45 µg/mL of ozone in a O 2 -O 3 mixture, continuously regulated and tuned by the instrumental device Multioxygen Medical 95 CPS (Gorle, BG, Italy). The Multioxygen ® Medical 95 is disposed as an outpatient unit for O 2 -O 3 therapy, allowing operators to customize the gas mixture according to the clinical request. Actually, the O 2 -O 3 mixture generator is managed by a microprocessor that ensures the precision of the ozone delivery, once the O 3 -O 2 mixture amount is selected by the operator. Therefore, it is possible to customize the treatment by selecting the ozone concentration in a continuous range from 1 to 100 µg of O 3 . Then the 200 mL of ozonized blood was reintroduced into the circulatory blood directly, from the sterile bag. Therefore, the therapy required an ozone generator, medical grade oxygen, a sterile syringe and a certified bag endowed with an intravenous cannula, for the O 2 -O 3 -AHT. If following one week from the O 2 -O 3 -AHT treatment, the FSS delta score was 0, a second session of O 2 -O 3 -AHT will be performed with 150 mL treated blood at 45 µg/mL of ozone in a O 2 -O 3 mixture. A median of 155 mL, CI 95 = 135-245 mL of blood was ozonized and reintroduced for each treated patient [27, 37] . Patients were followed up at 30 days subsequently to the second O 2 -O 3 -AHT session and asked to complete the FSS questionnaire, as previously agreed.

Data were collected and expressed as mean ± standard deviation, for quantitative values. Sample size was evaluated by assessing data and forecasting evaluations with Cohen d test and a Glass' delta. Statistical inference, if any, was evaluated following nonparametric tests. Scores were evaluated by a Kruskall-Wallis test with p < 0.05. Data were elaborated with a SPSS v 24 software and Stata software for graphs. Table 1 summarizes the results obtained in the present study. When treated with O 2 -O 3 -AHT fatigue symptoms within the first one-two weeks ameliorated from a score value of 7 (meaning the worst) to 1 (meaning the best, i.e., completely absent symptoms) in almost half of the oxygen-ozone treated patients (43.5%), whose only 24.64% were males and more than 75% females.

The percentage of patients experiencing a delta scoring of 4-6 points were higher than 75%. Anyway, only 5% reported very small, quite negligible improvements in fatigue symptoms. Age distribution did not show any difference in the whole randomized patients' population (p = 0.38765), therefore age did not affect significantly the results of this investigation. About 6.5% of patients diagnosed with ME/CFS, with fatigue symptoms and treated with O 2 -O 3 -AHT were teen agers. The Kruskall-Wallis (KW test) for this cohort of subjects was 18.7778 (p = 0.00001). Neither age nor sex distribution affected the correct evaluation of the FSS questionnaire, as KW tests were significant at p < 0.05 (Table 1) ), and when this ratio was referred to the number of subjects recruited on the total, the rate of males responding to the therapy for about 60% (59.48%) was 1.5 higher than females, responding for about 75% (74.58%) to the therapy.

This might indicate that male patients are particularly sensitive to O 2 -O 3 -AHT despite their age range and that female are much more responsive but with higher variability. Quite 80% of patients responded optimally to O 2 -O 3 -AHT (77.5%) and more than half (51%) responded with the maximal FSS delta score. Figure 1 shows the impressive difference in fatigue score before and after the O 2 -O 3 -AHT.

No patient reported adverse manifestation upon O 2 -O 3 -AHT and following the next 3 months from the treatment. No patient reported adverse manifestation upon O2-O3-AHT and following the ne 3 months from the treatment.

The results here described assess that O2-O3-AHT is able to relief fatigue in almo half of the whole cohort of ME/CFS patients. The study of ME/CFS was pioneered in Ita by Tirelli and coworkers [11] , when several theories about the concurrent viral origin ME/CFS and the immune impairment in T cell activation and NK cell function depression were addressed [11] . Immune modulation, even via the tuning of cell surviv with the oxidative stress response, might be a solution to address ME/C symptomatology, mainly represented by fatigue, and ozone may be a possible approa [5, 6, 27] . So far, no reliable explanation has been forwarded to elucidate how ozone is ab to restore wellness in patients suffering from ME/CFS-related fatigue [27] . The rece evidence associating COVID-19 with ME/CFS pathogenesis as a manifestation of impaired stress response is particularly intriguing [33] . The ability of ozone to modula the Nrf2/Keap1/ARE system and the NO/eNOS signaling pathways may provi insightful suggestions to highlight possible mechanisms underlying the effect of O2-O AHT in ME/CFS-caused fatigue symptomatology [27] . During ME/CFS mitochondr functionality may be greatly disturbed, so generating an impairment in man mitochondria-related activities, including ROS signaling [38] and in inflammati disorders [39, 40] . ME/CFS is characterized by an increase in CD4 + CD25 + Foxp3 + regulatory (Treg) cells [41] , which may be modulated and lowered by ozone [42] . Anoth impairment in ME/CFS regards Th17 cells. The CCR6 + Th17 cells in ME/CFS were report to secrete less IL-17 respect to healthy subjects, circulating cell frequency is significant lower, whereas ozone can restore their amount, even with IL-17A [43, 44] . The immu micro-environment in ME/CFS is of the utmost importance to elucidate how ME/CF associated fatigue develops and how treating the same [9] [10] [11] . To date, the mechanism with which O2-O3-AHT may restore physical activity and relief fatigue-related discomfo and myalgia or arthralgia, is far to be fully elucidated. A dysregulated Treg immu response and an impaired Th2 and Th17 cytokine pattern, may be modulated and tun by ozone and its oxidized metabolites. This activity is closely linked with the cell an oxidant endowment and the machinery deputed to the optimal stress respons Noticeably, the major ozone-induced blood byproduct, the 4-hydroxynonenal (4-HN 

The results here described assess that O 2 -O 3 -AHT is able to relief fatigue in almost half of the whole cohort of ME/CFS patients. The study of ME/CFS was pioneered in Italy by Tirelli and coworkers [11] , when several theories about the concurrent viral origin of ME/CFS and the immune impairment in T cell activation and NK cell functional depression were addressed [11] . Immune modulation, even via the tuning of cell survival with the oxidative stress response, might be a solution to address ME/CFS symptomatology, mainly represented by fatigue, and ozone may be a possible approach [5, 6, 27] . So far, no reliable explanation has been forwarded to elucidate how ozone is able to restore wellness in patients suffering from ME/CFS-related fatigue [27] . The recent evidence associating COVID-19 with ME/CFS pathogenesis as a manifestation of an impaired stress response is particularly intriguing [33] . The ability of ozone to modulate the Nrf2/Keap1/ARE system and the NO/eNOS signaling pathways may provide insightful suggestions to highlight possible mechanisms underlying the effect of O 2 -O 3 -AHT in ME/CFS-caused fatigue symptomatology [27] . During ME/CFS mitochondria functionality may be greatly disturbed, so generating an impairment in many mitochondria-related activities, including ROS signaling [38] and in inflammation disorders [39, 40] . ME/CFS is characterized by an increase in CD4 + CD25 + Foxp3 + T regulatory (Treg) cells [41] , which may be modulated and lowered by ozone [42] . Another impairment in ME/CFS regards Th17 cells. The CCR6 + Th17 cells in ME/CFS were reported to secrete less IL-17 respect to healthy subjects, circulating cell frequency is significantly lower, whereas ozone can restore their amount, even with IL-17A [43, 44] . The immune micro-environment in ME/CFS is of the utmost importance to elucidate how ME/CFS-associated fatigue develops and how treating the same [9] [10] [11] . To date, the mechanisms with which O 2 -O 3 -AHT may restore physical activity and relief fatigue-related discomfort and myalgia or arthralgia, is far to be fully elucidated. A dysregulated Treg immune response and an impaired Th2 and Th17 cytokine pattern, may be modulated and tuned by ozone and its oxidized metabolites. This activity is closely linked with the cell anti-oxidant endowment and the machinery deputed to the optimal stress response. Noticeably, the major ozone-induced blood byproduct, the 4hydroxynonenal (4-HNE) induces the thioredoxin reductase 1, via the Nrf2 pathway, then increasing the level of Tregs [45, 46] .

Although the scant evidence able to tailoring a speculative hypothesis on how O 2 -O 3 -AHT can relief fatigue in ME/CFS patients may regard cells and functional models either than ME/CFS, the ability of ozone to modulate immunity and inflammation via the Nrf2 system is particularly documented [32] . Furthermore, ozone may regulate nitric oxide (NO) and the activity of the endothelial nitric oxide synthase (eNOS) [32] . Yet, ME/CFS patients seem to have normal NO alongside with normal IL-6 levels, before and after a physical exercise upon fatigue symptoms but exhibit high levels of F2-isoprostanes, which are oxidative stress biomarkers, probably quenched by the activity of ozone on the Nrf2/Keap1/ARE system [47] [48] [49] .

The ability of ozone to modulate the complex interplay between oxidative stress and chronic inflammation may be the key to comprehend how ME/CFS patients felt a rapid relief in their fatigue symptoms following O 2 -O 3 -AHT.

Patients suffering from ME/CFS fatigue and treated with O 2 -O 3 -AHT experienced rapid relief of their symptoms. Further insights are needed to elucidate the mechanism by which about 95% of treated patients recovered their ability to move without pain and discomfort. 

Myalgic Encephalomyelitis/Chronic Fatigue Syndrome (ME/CFS): An Overview

Pain-related post-exertional malaise in Myalgic Encephalomyelitis/Chronic Fatigue Syndrome (ME/CFS) and Fibromyalgia: A systematic review and three-level meta-analysis

A Comprehensive Update of the Current Understanding of Chronic Fatigue Syndrome. Anesthesiol

Prevalence of Chronic Fatigue Syndrome (CFS) in Korea and Japan: A Meta-Analysis

Treatment of 741 Italian patients with chronic fatigue syndrome

Oxygen-ozone therapy as support and palliative therapy in 50 cancer patients with fatigue-A short report

Idiopathic chronic fatigue and chronic fatigue syndrome: A comparison of two case-definitions

Brain positron emission tomography (PET) in chronic fatigue syndrome: Preliminary data

Cytokine signature associated with disease severity in chronic fatigue syndrome patients

Immunological abnormalities in patients with chronic fatigue syndrome

Clinical and immunologic study of 205 patients with chronic fatigue syndrome: A case series from Italy

Systematic Review of the Epidemiological Burden of Myalgic Encephalomyelitis/Chronic Fatigue Syndrome Across Europe: Current Evidence and EUROMENE Research Recommendations for Epidemiology

Prevalence, incidence, and classification of chronic fatigue syndrome in Olmsted County, Minnesota, as estimated using the Rochester Epidemiology Project

Systematic review and meta-analysis of the prevalence of chronic fatigue syndrome/myalgic encephalomyelitis (CFS/ME)

Chronic fatigue syndrome: Features of a population of patients from northern Italy

Fatigue in cancer patients receiving chemotherapy

Factors influencing the diagnosis of chronic fatigue syndrome

Comparative Survey of People with ME/CFS in Italy, Latvia, and the UK: A Report on Behalf of the Socioeconomics Working Group of the European ME/CFS Research Network (EUROMENE)

The specificity of the CDC-1994 criteria for chronic fatigue syndrome: Comparison of health status in three groups of patients who fulfill the criteria

Diagnosis and Treatment of Myalgic Encephalomyelitis/Chronic Fatigue Syndrome

Myalgic encephalomyelitis: International Consensus Criteria

Diagnosis and Treatment of Chronic Fatigue Syndrome/Myalgic Encephalopathy (CFS/ME)

Knowledge Centre for the Health Services at The Norwegian Institute of Public Health (NIPH)

Making the diagnosis of Chronic Fatigue Syndrome/Myalgic Encephalitis in primary care: A qualitative study

Differential diagnosis between "chronic fatigue" and "chronic fatigue syndrome

Differential diagnosis for chronic fatigue syndrome

Chronic fatigue syndrome: Evaluation and treatment

Ozone therapy is an effective therapy in chronic fatigue syndrome: Result of an Italian study in 65 patients

Oxygen-ozone therapy in meningoencephalitis and chronic fatigue syndrome

A novel therapeutic option for Chronic Fatigue Syndrome and Fibromyalgia

Ozone in Medicine. The Low-Dose Ozone Concept and Its Basic Biochemical Mechanisms of Action in Chronic Inflammatory Diseases

Neuro-immune, and Neuro-oxidative Stress Interactions in Chronic Fatigue Syndrome

Insights on the mechanisms of action of ozone in the medical therapy against COVID-19

Redox imbalance links COVID-19 and myalgic encephalomyelitis/chronic fatigue syndrome

Diagnosis and management of chronic fatigue syndrome or myalgic encephalomyelitis (or encephalopathy): Summary of NICE guidance

Measures of fatigue Arthritis and Rheumatisms

Fatigue in post-acute sequelae of SARS-CoV2 (PASC) treated with oxygen-ozone autohemotherapy-preliminary results on 100 patients

Ozone therapy: A clinical review

Mitochondria and immunity in chronic fatigue syndrome

Evidence for inflammation and activation of cell-mediated immunity in Myalgic Encephalomyelitis/Chronic Fatigue Syndrome (ME/CFS): Increased interleukin-1, tumor necrosis factor-α, PMN-elastase, lysozyme and neopterin

Inflammatory and cell-mediated immune biomarkers in myalgic encephalomyelitis/chronic fatigue syndrome and depression: Inflammatory markers are higher in myalgic encephalomyelitis/chronic fatigue syndrome than in depression

Role of adaptive and innate immune cells in chronic fatigue syndrome/myalgic encephalomyelitis

Effects of ozone exposure on percentage of CD4(+)CD25(high)Foxp(3+) regulatory T cells and mRNA expression of Foxp3 in asthmatic rats

A formal analysis of cytokine networks in chronic fatigue syndrome

Ozone-induced IL-17A and neutrophilic airway inflammation is orchestrated by the caspase-1-IL-1 cascade

4-Hydroxynonenal induces adaptive response and enhances PC12 cell tolerance primarily through induction of thioredoxin reductase 1 via activation of Nrf2

Thioredoxin induces Tregs to generate an immunotolerant tumor microenvironment in metastatic melanoma

Nitric oxide concentrations are normal and unrelated to activity level in chronic fatigue syndrome: A case-control study

Plasma IL-6, its soluble receptors and F2-isoprostanes at rest and during exercise in chronic fatigue syndrome. Scand

F2-isoprostanes as markers of oxidative stress in vivo: An overview

A special thank to all the caregivers and health personnel involved in the management of the study.

The authors declare no conflict of interest.