The Book of comfort called in latin Boetius de Consolation philosophy Translated in to englesse tongue. Prefatio Translatoris. un suffysance of cunning & of whit Defaute of language & experience This labour viche you have upon me put Must fully excuse unto your reverence if it be not with craft of eloquence Depaynted so as other books be yet must I needs do my diligence with all my power to please yo●ur sovereignty ¶ This subtel matter of Boetius In his book of consolation So high it is so hard and curious Full far a bow my estimation That it be not by my translation Defouled ne corrupt to god I pray So help me with thy inspiration That art of wisdom both lock and key ¶ As fro the text that I vary nougth But keep the sentence in his true intent And words eke as nigh as may be brougth where law of metre will thereto consent This matter wiche that is so excellent And passeth both my cunning & my migth So have it lord in thy government That canst reform all thing to rygth I have herd speak & somewhat have I seyn Of divers men that wonder craftily In metre some & some in prose pleyn Haveth this book translated diversly In to englesse tongue word for word well nigh But I must use the wits that I have Though I may not do so well/ yet truly with the help of god the sentence will I save To chaucer that was flower of retoryke In englesse tongue & excellent poet I woteful well I am no thing like Though I his making do conterfete And Gover that so craftily doth trete As in his books of moralyte Thougth I to him in making an unmeet yet will I she worteh that is in me it liketh not me to labour nor muse upon these old poises dark For cristen faith such things most refuse As witnesseth jerom the noble clerk it should be no cristen man's work though false god's names to renew For he that hath received cristes merke if he do so to Christ he is untrue Fro them that criste in heaven bless shall Such manner works must be put a side For certainly it nedet not at all To uhette now the darts of cupyde Ne for to bid that venus be our guide So that we may our foul lusts win lest hereafter the same to us betide As did to the said venus for her sin ¶ And certain I have tasted wonder light As of the wells of calyope No wonder though I sympelly indite yet will I nofte unto Tessiphone Ne to her sisters that in hell be Beseking after craft of eloquence But may to god of his benignity My spirit to inspire with his influence ¶ Calliope as poetes feigneth is one of the sons daughters & is one & chief of the ix muses & they call her goddas of eloquence. She hath. three wells Gramatica/ Dialetica/ & Retorica. of whom is drived all craft of eloquence Also they feyneth to be in hell three fusters called furyas or vengeresses/ that punish men for their mesdedes. the one is called Allecco/ another Megner/ & the three Tessiphone. These also be called muses of morning that tecyth & informeth men to mahe souroful complaints: ¶ So that fro blame and confusion Of all this foul worldly wrechednesse He help me in this occupation To the honour of his blysfulnesse And in reverence of your worthiness Madame this work at your instance I have begun after my symplenesse In will to do you service and plesance Incipit Prologus. THe while that room was regning in her flores And of the world held all the monarchy She was governed then by emperors Andrea was renowned wonder nobly Till pride had set there hearts up on high Then began they to use crudelyte And reigned by rygurnesse and tyranny And oppressed sore the comynalte ¶ For like as poverty causeth soberness And feebleness enforceth continence Rygth so prosperity and sykernesse is the mother of vice and negligence And power also causeth insoleuce And after honour changes good manners There is none so perilous pestilence As is high astate given to srewes ¶ Of the which was Nero one and principal That such manner tyranny began Though he bore the diadem ymperial. yet was he a very cursed man. So cruelly he 'gan to regne than Heslew his master & his mother both. And moche he did that tell I ne can. Ho so hath it read he knoweth well the sooth. ¶ The chief of holy church he slew also. Scent Peter & Paul both upon one day. And after them full many other more. And of the same it is I dare well say. That Paul writeth thus it is no nay. And saith now is the foune of wickedness. And figure rygth of anticristes lay. In whom shall be all manner of cursedness. Misterium iam operatur iniquitatis/ ut qui tenet iam teneat donec de medio fiat. ¶ Now saith sent Paul worchet the mystery & form of anticristes wickedness. which anticriste shall be like to him/ using none other lave but wylfulnesse/ leading his life in lusts/ finding occasions for to destroy all the good & virtuous/ cruel and full of unkyndly affections draing to him all the that be like to him in foul conditions. ¶ For they that truly teacheth Christ's lore. To make men forlete their vice. Antecriste will punish them therefore. And all their preaching set at no price. So was he given to lusts & delyce. That what desire came unto his thougth. He would it do without more advise. For no thing than would he spare it nougth. ¶ And he that would again his vices speak. And counsel him his lusts co refrayn. withouten more anon he would bewreke. He would him put in torment and in pain. And he that would his Instes oft withsayn. He ne was but dead if that he would appear. For such a cause Boecius was slain. Of whom this process after treteth here ¶ And rygth these days men may see this same Of some that have the astate of governance. Ho so will their vices or lusts blame. They take it in despite and displesance. They will him do some mischief or mischance And though th' sat hold amend e& correct. vice/ in them it hath her sustenance. And good folk they holdeth as suspect ¶ The year of criste. u hundred &. xv. when Anastasius was emperor Boetius this same of whom I mean. In Rome he was a noble cenatour. But in manner as a conqueror. Theodoricus reigned in Italy And Rome he held as king and governor He had it won by conquest in batayle ¶ For Anastasius was not like Ne not so strong of many at jest He consented that Theodoryke Should regne in Rome & hold it at his hest And he would hold himself in the este He said it was according to his heel And for his ease in sooth he thougth it best For Romayns be full perilous with to deal ¶ This king of Rome then Theodoryke Was full of malice and of cursedness And eke for cause he was an heretic The cristen people 'gan he sore oppress Boetius with all his business withstood 'em alway sparing none offence And him present often time express Reversed his unlawful judgements ¶ He ne spared nought the height of his astate But ever he spoke agenste his tyranny wherefore the king hem had sore in hate And him exiled in to lombary To prison in the cyte of papy where as for a recreation Between himself and philosophy He wrote this book of consolation ¶ In prose & metre interchangingly with words set in colour wonder well Of retoryke indited craftily And schewing that these wealths temporel Are not to be desired never a deal Ne worldly mischeffe nothing to be dread Enforseng us by reason natural So virtue fully for to taken heed ¶ Then Anastasins had made his fine As time of age unto his death hem drawn Then aster hem was emperor justine A noble knygth a faithful & a true For cristes laves wonder well he known And kept them as a very cristen man And heretics fast he 'gan pursue That arrianes were called than ¶ His letters then in to Rome he sent For to destroy all that heresy And fully gave them in commandment That they should put them out of company Theodorincus took this wonder high For he himself was holly one oh though This message he repelled utterly And made a vow it should not be so ¶ And sworn but if the arrianes must Have their peses granted to them again He would not leave one in all that cost Of cristen faith but he should be slain And thus he bed the messengers sayn That if he would with arrianes strive saith the emperor with words plain Of cristen will I leave none a live ¶ To constantinople he sent a none Of senators which that him lest And a mouges other pope john And bid them labour for their own best And ruthfully they made their request That justyne should this mandement relese For the cristen migth not been in rest But if he granted the arrianes piece ¶ The emperor his malice understood Benyngly he granted them their bone And well he thougth that it was as good That matter to cease till eft soon And better mygth it afterward be done By good advise of wiser ordinance The arrianes so he let alone To usen forth there old governance ¶ These messengers to the kings pay turned not so hastily again As he desired at a certain day wherefore in heart he had great dysdeyne And Boyce that lay in prison & in pain In exile in the cyte of Papey In Melayn he made him to be slain In Papey been his bones sickerly ¶ And when these messengers at the last Returned were/ in heart he 'gan to brenne Pope john in prison than he cast Fer out in the cyte of Ravenne And made him closed in a narrow den where he ne mygth torn himself ne wend And soothe to say he went never thenne Till of his life he had made an end ¶ Also the worthy noble Symmacus That was a man grounded all in grace The which in virtue was heroicus Theridamas left not such another as he was Vir heroicus is a man given all to contemplation & to virtue/ in whom all flesly passyous been quenched & repressed. without cause surfyt or trespass At Ravenne eke he slew him cruelly And after wards in that same place The next year he died suddenly ¶ And as sent gregory doth himself write As yet his books maketh mentyon There was that time a holy heremyte As he was in his contemplation He did see Theodoryke in visyon Between Symacus and pope john Right as a theffe to his damnation How he was led/ & after that anon ¶ In the isle of vulcane was he cast then That full is of a fire flame of hell Theryn alway in pains sore to brenne And with the foul fendes for to dwell For tyrants that so fierce been and fell Been arrayed such rewards for their meed I say you but as old books do tell Now to my purpose time is that I speed ¶ And every lord or lady what you be Or clerk that liketh for to readen this Beseking louly with humility Supporteth where I have oft said a miss Correcteth only there that nedful is if word or sentence be not as it should Myself I am unsufficyant I iwis For if I could have better done I would Explicit prologus. ¶ Reason and intelligens purely considered in kind of their worching haveth themself every again other/ as practic & theoric/ or as actyf & contemplatyf. And all though the worching of reason like to practyf in order & ꝓcesse in us that useth process go before intelligence as practycke goeth before theorich/ & actyf before contemplatyfe/ yet in worthiness & also in perfection of blestulhed/ intelligens sormounteth & is sovereign to reason. For the same treuthes that reason seeketh & findeth by discourse/ these pure blissful spirits (which been called iutelligences) saith & knoweth perfectly in the mirror of eternal lygth/ that is god's son with outen any discurse of reason. And moche more viche ne may not be perceved here of us in this pilgrimage. But rygth as a good practiser by exercise of labur & experiens of his craft/ may deserve to be made privy of soteltes of his craft & to be made a master/ rygth so a soul coniuned to bodily matter/ may by his good labour of discourse/ deserve to atteyu to be made privy by intelligence of all the same trouthes on high in bliss that these blesful spirits haveth of their first creation. ¶ By nature of the resonabelte of man's soul/ viche resonabelte is the form substantial of the self soul/ there should not be denied hem that he would desire. And that may be scheved by this skyle. ¶ The soul uhos form substaniial is reason or resonabilte/ he may of proper kind nought desire but reasonable. for if he other desired/ he were unreasonable. And if he desire but that is proper to hem of kind/ it may not of reason be denied him. But how is it that a soul coniuned desireth oft other than reasonable/ Theridamas be ii causes. One is for some souls for the intemperance & bosteynesse of their material body faileth in discourse In other that haveth clear discourse yet sensualite vych us the flesly part of the soul replieth ever a gen this discourse of reason/ asking his lusts as proper to his kynder And togth he be never ●o oft ausuered & concluded/ yet ever he resorteth to his first asking havyur ●o regard to all the reasons that may be made agenste him. Right as a man that faileth discourse who men calleth a mad man/ tough a man make to him never so great reasons/ yet is he not ansuered/ he feeleth them not/ but ever he resorteth to that he first began. ¶ This importunate pressenge of sensualite of such unreasonable replications encumbereth so the reason that he leaveth the true end that he had traveled for by discourse & entendethe to the lust of sensualite desiring things that be unreasonable/ which desire if it were grounded in sensualite vych is changeable/ it should a none bring the soul in to endless mischef. for there may no thing stand kindly that contrarieth his aune kind. Ne a reasonable spirit though he be movable in working & in affections yet of proper kind he may not will contradiction/ that is to say nove this & now the contrary for then he erred again reason So then a soul desiring that thyug that is unreasonable/ & consequently to his destruction/ by the high governed it is oftentyme denied him. wherefore he falls in to a peynful heaviness be cause he lacketh that he desireth/ or hath that him loatheth. And were not that the sensualite beareth this peyn the mischef were endless. wherefore the sensualite that is changeable & loatheth this peyn vylling to be delivered thereof/ sometime reforteth to reason forsaking such unskyleful desires & suffereth reason to have his kindly operations. And if this peynful heaviness be mored in the soul & reason fully overcome/ then falls a man in despair. & so some destroeth themselves by wilful death & so continued in perpetual peyn vythout end. Thus fell it of the first angel that desired undiseretly to be leken to god & for he migthe not have his desire/ he fell in peynful heaviness. but in heaven may be no pain/ And he mighth not will the contraty to that he one's villed/ he was so pure & simple of nature. wherefore without remedy he was cast in to mischef in the peyn of hell ¶ So it be fell of this noble clerk Boyce/ because he had that he would not/ that was prison & other tribulation. And also he wanted that he would have/ that was his astate in the cyte of Rome/ his house/ books/ & his other goods/ presens of his wife & children & his other friends uherof he was wron gfully spoiled & but out of his cyte/ exiled as a traitor/ he fell in to a peynful heaviness and made his complaint sayug. Alas I wretch. &c. But for asmuch as this heaviness was but the meving of sensualite/ viche of his nature is chaungable. And lest he fell in to full forgetting of himself & in the uttermost myschef. Reason comforteth the flesly kind/ reducing it to knoulege of it self/ & so to forget the heaviness that he was so grevosly peyned with for losing of his dignity/ wyffe/ children/ & goods afore rehearsed. Incipit liber Boetij de consolatone philosophy. Metrum primum. Carmina qui quondam. ALas that I wretch uhiles I was in wealth And used lusty dytes for to write Now am I set in sorrow & unhelthe with tmorning my mirth I must respite Lamentable muses teacheth me to indite Of woe. with weeping they weteth my face Thus hath dysese destroyed all my delight And brougth my bliss & jolyte full base ¶ And though that I with myschef now be met That false fortune loureth thus on me No dread fro me mygth these muses let Me to ensue in mine adversity My joy they were in all my jolyte Of you the that was so glad am & so green Now they solaceth my dreary destyne And in my age my comforteno we they been ¶ Vnwarely age cometh on me hastily Heyngh on me for harm that I have had And soro we his hests hath hoten to be ny Whore heres on my head to rathe been spread All to me of blood my bodey waxeth bad My empty skin beginneth to tremel & quake I have no cause whereof I may be glad Thus morning for mysese my moan I make ¶ A death of men a blesful thing it were if he would spare them in their lustiness And come to them that be of heavy cheer When they him call to lake their distress But oh alas how dull & deaf he is wrynging away fro wrecches when they cleped And worneth thenne with wonder cruelness The yes for to close that we'll & weep ¶ But while fortune unfaithful & untrue Of lusty life was to me favourable Full suddenly my head to ground he dreu The careful hour of death unmerciable But now that she so changing & unstable Hath turned unto me her cloudy face This wrecched life that is uncomfortable Draeth along and tarrieth now alas ¶ whereto you friends maden your a vaunt So often times of my felycite This worldly wealth is not perseveraunte Ne never abiding in no stabilyte For he that falls out of his degree Full sooth it is that stable was he nougth Ne he stood never in full prosperity That in to mischef was so low I brought ¶ Fortune was depaynted after fantasy of poetes a lady sitting in mids of a while viche herself continuelly turned a bout/ she had two. visages/ one brygth & another dark. & in both she was blind ¶ The commentor trinet assgneth three causes why that philosophy was described appearing unto Boyce in lekenesse of a woman The first cause is for this name philosophia as well in latin as in greke is put in the feminyne gender. The second cause is for rygth as a woman norysseth her child with her milk/ rygth so philosophy no ressched her disciples with the subtilyte of her science. The third cause is/ for a woman is of kind more tender and compacient for to comfort a man in mischef. And sith this clerk was fall than in to mischef as himself seemed/ he iuduced philosophy in lekenesse of a woman to comfort him in a s●akynge of his heaviness She was also descrived reverent/ for she maketh the people reverent in vyche she is impressed. The yees of philosophy been reason and understanding/ uherby philosophy is kendly perceived. ¶ They bren by desire of cunning ¶ They shine clear by possibilite of understanding. ¶ Her myghtes been the virtue of her principles that never may be empted ne fully comprehended. ¶ The chyre of her visage is perfection of doctrine. the colour is fullness of truth. for the whole intent is for to perceive and conprehende truth. She passedde man's age/ for her truths been perpetual. not subget to time that mesureth man his age. Prosa prima. Capitulum secundum Hec dum mecum Boecius loquitur. In murning thus I made my complaint And for to writ my fingers 'gan I fold For drerinesse I wax all feeble & faint That of my life almost no thing I told But upward at the last I 'gan behold In sooth I see so fair a creature I couth her not descriven though I would So femly was her shape and her feyture ¶ She was so wonder reverent of her chyre Her colonr eke so lovely & so brygth Her yene bren semenge as for clear Passing far a boven man's sygth Albina thoe she were full fresh & clean of mygth As she had been full yongly of courage yet seemed she to every worldly wigth That she was over passed man his age ¶ Her stature was of doubtful judgement sometime thus of comen men's meet And sometime was her stature so extent That with her head she seemed heavens bete And other while so high her head she gete She pierced heaven & migth no more be seen So that we moste the sygth of her forlete And all our looking after was in veyn Her clotheses were wrogthof thredessmale By subtel cratf of matter perdurable And with her hands by her own tale She had them wrogth I trow for no fable The beutey of them was full commendable But dusky they wereforleten as for eld As images that in smoke had stonden stable That be oot weshe ne wiped but seld ¶ And in the him beneath made she had So as I could it know a greeks P. O. And in the bordure all a bow I rad And there also she had made a And so between these letters migth I see like to a ladder what that ever it mend whereon men migth alway fro 'gree to gre from there beneath upward ever ascend ¶ Nevertheless some men by violence Had cut this clot & pieces born a weigh Such as they migth without reverence And did there with as was unto there pay This creature of whom I 'gan you say In her rygth hand small books were A septre also of full rich array For certain in her other hand she bore ¶ And when this lady saw these muses there un to my beds side approaching neigh Enditing words to my weeping cheer She 'gan to look upon them fervently Ho she said let in this company Thus with their song this seek man to please That no thing heleth him of his malady But rather doth him grievance & dysese ¶ Lo these it been she said that fowls feeden with the sweet venem of corruption And tender hearts maketh for to bleden with thorns of their foul affection They sleyn the worthy fruits of reason And only bringeth sickness in usage This is the kind of their condition And naught at all the sickness to assuage ¶ if you she said with your dalyance Had driven fro me some foul unprofitable Less it should have done me displesance I might have boren it then as sufferable For why in such a foul that is unable May naught been harmed of my business But these that ever in studies hath been stable Should not be founden with your folesnesse ¶ But goeth you fylthes out of my presence your sweetness would him bring at an end I shall him save with the self of my science That shall be more comfort unto his kende And thus this company a way 'gan wend And bitterly abashed them of their blame Showing well the habit of their mind Hanging down to ground their heads for shame ¶ I than that nigh for tears saw right naught 'Gan wonder moche what might this woman be marveling also greatly in my thought That so imperial of authority She made that many smartly fro me i'll I was abashed & hinge my head to ground what she would after done or say to me Than I abode & held me still a stound ¶ But to my bed then 'gan she nyen near And on the corner down herself she set And sadly 'gan behold upon my cheer That so was then with tears all be wet And right thus she began wythouten let Complaining on my perturbation Because of myschef wherewith I was met Of me she made this lamentation Metrum secundum. Capitulum tercium. Heu quam precipiti. Philosophta loquitur ¶ Alas she said how this man's mind Is casten down in to full deep dullness Forlete the clearness of his proper kind And menting for to go to strange derknesse As often time as noyos business wythouten measure gynneth to encrece when worldly wind with myschef & distress Him hath byrafte all out of rest & piece ¶ This is that man that sometime was so free To whom by craft was even for to con Up in to heavens to behold and see And to measure the move of the son By craft also the cunning had he won How that the moan changes for to prymen And what recourse the stars have run In their spears how diversly they moven ¶ As victor hath he sotelly conquered The craft by number all he comprehendeth from uhens also these winds been a rered The smooth see that torneth so & wendeth why esperus at even so ascendeth Este/ in the west a down again to lout And what spirit so busily intendeth The round world to wend all a bout ¶ And what a tempereth so the lusty hours Of the fair first summer seson Araing it with read rose flowers Of the vyche in winter been very feweor none And all this could he show by very reason In full years ho is that our feedeth with great grapes that the people pleson And other fruits that them all needeth ¶ I wont he was also to seek & to know Prime causes for to tell of kind Alas witless now lieth this man full low Under full heavy bonds that him bind And now can he none other comfort find But heavily his face he hath down fold So is he all dysmayed in his mind That needs wrecched earth he mote behold Prosa secunda. Capitulum quartum. Sebastian medicine. Philosophia loquitur. ¶ But now of medicine ꝙ she have we need For in complaints lieth no remedy un to that purpose let our works speed She set her ye on me ententyfly Art thou not he she said which that I Have fed with milk while thou were young of age And sith with strenger metes tenderly Till thou were wexen a man of strong courage ¶ And sith I gave the armour good & strong Wych but if thou had cast away fro the Thou mightest have be dysesed with no wrong But have been sure fro all adversity why art thou still she said knovest thou not me Is it for shame or thou art stoned sore The ne shameth nought I trow by cause of me Thou art a stoned of that me dreadeth more ¶ And when she see me sytten doom & still She set her hand full saved upon my breast As here she saed no perel is of ill This man is with a letargy a rest A comen sickness that many hath oppressed That out of mind themselves have forlete Full esely this evil shall be redreste A little whate he hath hemself forget ¶ He shall remember well & esely if I may first me make him for to know I shall his yeen wypen tenderly Of clouds dark that have them over grow And then he shall amend as I trow A pleyt she lapped of her garnement My yeen then that tears had beflowe She wiped till the darkness was all spent Metrum tercium. Capitulum quintum. Tunc me discussa. Boecius loquitur. And when this cloud was cleansed fro mine you I was anon restored to my sight Right as when clouds clippeth in the sky The son is let to leme a down his light And rain clouds maketh in manner night But when a north wind chaseth them a way The son will show then his beams bright And as it were bringeth again the day Prosa tercia. Capitulum sextum. Haud aliter trsticie. Boecius loquitur ¶ But even so & in/ none other wise This drerynesse out of mine heart 'gan reach I looked up & 'gan me better advise if I might know the visage of my leche Than known I well by visage & by speech Mine own gentle nourish philosophy That me was wont to viset & to teach And fro yought had me in company ¶ Do ꝙ I my worshypful masteres Of all virtues and of honest what do you in this wretched wilderness Comen thus a down out of the sovereign see In to this exile whether be cause of me As guilty made also of my trespass it ne beseemeth not your sovereynte For to be seyn in this unworthy place Phia.) O nory ꝙ she should I the forsake Sigh thou for me art falsely put in blame And not the charge also upon me take The which thou bearest for envy of my name To philosophy it were reprove & shame To leave an Innocent so thus a rayed And now at last redoute me of that game That is not new to me ne un a said ¶ trowest thou that I have been not erst assayied Of wicked folk with perel & damage How have I been tormented & travailed with fulhardinesse & foul outrage Be foren Plato in time of elder age And while that Plato lived presently Socrates was slain & had to wage In my presence a crown of victory ¶ The Epicures & The Stoicenes The heritage of there opynyou They caughten to them as for very means Of wealth fullness everych a portion And more of wiche I make no mention Haveth enforced them with sotelte Dravenge his words to their entention Of their opynatyve felicity ¶ This same folk in partey of their a pray Caught this cloth that myself had weven And though that I rebelled & said nay To rent this clot/ ne would they not believed And with though clouts that they had me bereven They went there weigh & though all had been well And folysly they did themselves deceven And went I had gone with them every deal ¶ And so for cause that they these pieces ber● Loo some men troved as fowls utterly That they had been with me familiar And in my household been abydyngly And so thorough error of this company Full many a fool is foul out of the way And by them been perverted perylosly And ween that all be wisdom that they say ¶ Haste thou not herd of Anaxagoras That was exiled for be cause of me Of Socrates that eke enpoysoned was How zeno was tormented by cruelty And though that this be a strange thing to the yet Canio & Seneke as I trow And Sorane also in thy mind be For this is a late thing & well y knowe ¶ Naught else these brought in to distress But for they were learned in my lore And all unlike as in their business To wicked folk that hated them therefore it is no thing that thou should wonder fore Though we be stirred with storms of desese Sigh that our purpose hath been ever more These wicked folks for to dysplese ¶ And though thereof be hugy habundance yet nevertheless yet is to be reproved Foruhy they been withouten governance And naught but flod of error hath them moved And if they by this error this contrived Arese an host with strength & us assetteth Our governor by this is naught a grieved His treasure all in to his tour he fetteth These fowls laboureth than ententyfly On veyn things that may them naught avail And we that sitteth in this tour on high Full sure enough fro them that us assail In such a palace strong of apparyle whereto these fowls may not up attain we scorneth them of all their waste travail There business is everydeal in vain Metrum quartum. Capitulum seven. Quisquis composito. Philosophia loquitur. ¶ He that standeth clear & ordynate And proud haps suffereth under slide In all fortunes standing streght algate In wealth & woe can evenlych a bide The wood see that floveth to every side Him dredeh unto thing of his cruelty But what desese that may to him betide Him grieveth naught but standeth in one degree ¶ The foul fire that out of hell reketh In the monteyn that cleped is vesene Ne thunder light that high towers breaketh Ne dreadeth not me/ what is it that you mean Why dredeye than you wrecches that you been Tyrants fierce that been withouten migth Put false hope out of our hearts clean And flesly dread putteth fro your sight ¶ For if thou no thing of a man desire Ne what he may the don thou haste no dread Thou shalt deserve the wrecched man's Ire And in no wise he may the naught mysbede Ho so hopeth aught or dreadeth out of need He casts a weigh his shield & is unstable And knetteh a cheyn/ hemselfen with to lede where that them lust to him unprofitable ¶ The covetous king Mida was made juge betvene Apollo & Pan by their both assignment for to demen whether the harp of Apollo were more delicyous/ other the shalmuse of Pan. And so when he had heard them both/ he judged that the shalmuse was swetter than the harp uherfor Apollo having indignation of his lewd judgement/ punysshede him in that party that was seeming the cause of his error/ and gave him long ass ears. ¶ Motally Mida is every worldly man that more appryseth the lust & like of the world them he doth any whit or ghostly wisdom. wherefore such men been dull & insensible to reason/ like to rude asses. Prosa iiij. Caplm viij. Sentis ne inquit ¶ feelest thou not whether my word be soft or sharp ꝙ she withyn thy heart ententyfly Or art thou like an ass to the harp That is not moved with no melody If thou covetest help or remedy Thou must unhele the wondes that the greven Be then a know & show me openly And hide it not for I the shall releven Boecius) ¶ I droe to me the might of my courage you been ꝙ I that brought me in astate Needeth it now to tellen my damage That haveth me had in your presence algate you knoweth in what degree I was but late Ne meveth you naught the manner of this place Is this the library where you with me sat when you were all my joy & my solace divine things dysputing there with the And other sciences that full lusty were when that I stood with you in this degree was than this mine habit & my cheer when I with you was wont to seek & lere Full privy points langing to nature How that the stars moved far or nyre Descryving it in numbers and figures ¶ Forming in me the manner of my live I like unto the heavenly governance And teaching me to be contemplative I yield you thank with louly obecyance This was a sentence of your ordinance That Plato written if I well understand Full blesful were thestate of governance if only wise might it have on hand ¶ Or if that they which have government would upon wisdom spend their business And Plato also to the same intent teacheth us thus/ thine own lore it is To wise men a skyleful cause is this For to desire astate of sovereynte lest wicked folk that will govern a miss receive astate & harm a comynalte ¶ For if that wise men & virtuous Should thestate of sovereignty forsake Then other wicked folk and vicious would be full feyn the same astate to take And such as they been soveraynes would they make And wise people should be set at naught Thus should vice & wickedness a wake And treuth & virtue be to ground y brought ¶ As showing therefore your authority I had desire to this entention That I had lered of your benygnyte To put it forth in execution witness upon your own dyscretion And god that hath you set in man's mend I coveted never administration But comen profit was both cause & end The hate that I have had & heaviness Of wicked folk is open evidence In maintenance of treuth & ryghtuesnesse By very freedom of my consciens Of wicked folk I spared none offence when Conigast the porayl would oppress I met him ever with mighty resistens And oft I let him of his cruelness ¶ And Tranguyle provoste of the kings house How oft I cast him down of his malice And many a poor man & anguissous That weren asset by cursed covetise Of men that full of venem were & vice I halpe them oft in their adnersyte For to defend them out of such foleys Lo mine astate I put in jupardy ¶ There was no man that me fro right withdrow To wrong by favour/ frenshyp/ or by wage But when I see the contres now & now Be put in thraldom & in foul servage what by tribute & what by carriage And what by raven & extortion As sore me grieved the harm of their damage As them that suffered tribulation ¶ And when the province hoten Campaye was sore oppressed in a dear year So that no man must sell ne buy Till that the king had sold up his garner At snch a price so grenous & so dear That poor folk were harmed & a noyed Than I withstood the kings office Witting the king that statute I destroyed ¶ And Paulyn eke a consuler of Rome Whom palace hounds had oppressed so That wrongfully his goods him benumb I received him whether they would or no Albyne that was a conseyler also That was a judged to a grievous pain Myself alone to saven him there fro Of Cypryane I suffered great dysdeyne ¶ That had accused him (how seemeth you In palace have I hate & enmyte For love of right & were not thus enough For to be favoured of the comynalte Sigh I no frendshype have as toward me In kings court I have no love reserved Me seemeth than I should the surer be withouten fail where I have love deserved ¶ But now by whom was I accused thus Forsooth of none that honest was of fame But one there was that height Basileus wych that be forehand founden was with blame And out of offyce was he put with shame And sith he fell at myschef & at need He was accept accuser of my name Alas thereto by geftes & by meed yet other ij. that haven me thus defiled were Gaudencius and Opilion The which the kings judges had exiled For certain surfeit that they had done In to the sanctuary than 'gan they gone Them to defend again the kings law But knowing thus the king commanded soon That out of sanctuary they should be draw ¶ But if they voided the cyte of Ravenne By time assigned at a certain day And in their frounte an Iren should them brenne And be compelled for to go their way un to these false attaynte what shall I say Or to the kings cursed cruelty Upon that same day it is no nay They were admitted to accusen me ¶ whether that mine art & occupation Deserved had thus falsely to be blamed Other else thus that my damnation Had made them true that false were proclaimed And was not fortune hereof foul a shamed That she rewarded not mine Innocency Unworthiness of them that were defamed Should none appeal have made in her presence ¶ But peradventure you would wite the ground In to this exile why I am removed I would the senate had been hole & sound And in no manner hindered ne reproved This is the cause that I am sore aggrieved But you would wite the manner & the wise By cause of letters viche I had beryved Fro him that would the senators accuse ¶ you masteres what will you demen now Shall I this blame forsake or call again lest that it should be shameful unto you Nay sekerly I shall it never with seyn I have it willed & ever shall certain That the senate were in rest & piece But the accuser hereafter to refrayn Or let him oft of his intent I cese ¶ But vether to willen their prosperity Should been deputed for sin or felony And certainly they self in their decree Have put on me that point of treachery But unwise be they that to themself doth lie They may not change the meret of my deed Though that the fowls themselves will destroy My good will is worthy thank & meed ¶ But unto me by doom of socrates' How so ever it stand in their intent I trow it be not laful nevertheless To deny a sooth or to a false assent But nevertheless all this verament Excuseth not me in no manner wise I put it holly in the judgement Of your selfen and of other wise ¶ The process of this matter every deal I have it write & put in remembrance That men hereafter may perceive & feel How wrongfully I suffer this grievance But the ylke letters of their ordinance That in my name so falsely were contrived if I had had that liberty perchance There false fraud should plainly have been proved ¶ Or had I at the examination Myself been present when I was accused Right by their own apart confession I 'trow' that they should have me clean excused This liberty were goodly to been used But now what liberty shall I a bide Of an answer I am fully advised if ever I should that liberty abide ¶ As Canio unto the king answered That was accused of conspyracy Had I ꝙ he thereof known or heard Thou shuldeste have known it not sickerly And sooth to seyn the same wise would I Mine own letters better can I bestow And also procured them so privily That no thing thereof should the king know ¶ yet hath not morning dulled so my mind That this should be the cause that I complain That wicked folk been alway so unkende A genste virtue such malice for to leyn But this is it where I have dysdeyne Not only for the purpose of their will But that they may there purpose so menteyn I meruyl moche how they it may fu●●lle ¶ For as to wyllen 〈…〉 That may be of thee 〈…〉 But that they have that power 〈…〉 To execute that so purposed is As Innocency & virtue to destres Only of that I meruele in my mind As in his sight that all thing seethe express it seemeth me a monster out of kind ¶ wherefore there was with you familiar One that complained thus & skylefully sith god is present here & every where Fro uhens cometh all evil this marvel I And if that god ne were not verily Fro uhens should all good things be But he that causeth things perfectly May know all and none in sooth but he ¶ All were it leeful to though surfetours That all good men noyeth & dysesen Purposing for to sle the senators No wonder were though they would me losen For ever my purpose was them to dysplesen And let them of their foul entention To senators yet gave I none encheson For to conspyren my damnation ¶ And masteres you remembreth well That uhatsoever I thought to done or say Both word & work you ruled every deal And all by you I governed me alway And eke the senators it is no nay For their defence they knoweth every one In what perel I put me at one day A gen the the king myselfen at verone ¶ you knoweth well that I ne say but so the Though I myself had kept it in silence For certainly alway I have been loath To be commended of my excellence For he that will be fain of reverence And so receveth reward of renown The privy secret of his conscience appeareth moche by that condition ¶ But here you may yourself take heed For innocency now what worchyp have I For virtue loo receive I to my meed pains that proper be for felony And ho had ever for any treachery His judges so concord in cruelty For guilt that was confessed openly That some of them ner moved with petty ¶ All had it be so that I had desired The priests death or holy church y brente Or cruel death to good men conspired Or what malice so that I had ment yet should I have been deemed me present So convycre of my surfeit or confessed And after this have had my judgement Thus justly might my doom have been dressed ¶ But then I being for that same while with all my labour & my diligence Fro my judgement five hundred mile Having in court no advocate ne defence To death I was a judged in absence Me being in the senators needs And they consenting given was the sentence Loo how I am rewarded to my medes ¶ O worthy men of worchyppe & of meed For none of them came never at that degree To be convyct of such a manner deed As to withstand a kings cruelty As I have done for their comodyte And therefore were they of my guilt a shamed For thy in foyling of the dignity with sorcery now they have me defamed ¶ They sayen for covetes of high astate That I had used craft of sorcery But you that were my governor algate you knoweth well how falsely that they lie For fro my heart you hadden utterly A voided clean all worldly covetise And in your presence might not skylefully Such sacrilege be used in no wise ¶ For every day you putten in my thought These sothfast sentence of Pictagoras That many gods should we serve not But one alone that maketh corn & grass it needed not/ ne none accord it was To me/ but full unsembly in your sight The help of foul ghosts to purchas Sigh you have made me like to god almight ¶ Also my wise that is full Innocent And other friends of my compaygne My wives father also reverent Fro such defaults may defend me But o malice & cursed crudelyte This blame they beareth on you by evidence By cause that my governor you be They say that I use such enchauntementes ¶ And this to them it seemeth not enough That reverence of you me naught profiteth But eke my guilt they putteth upon you And mine offence fully you they wyteth another thing my sours yet excyteth That men saith not the meret of your deed But saith alway when that fortune us smiteth Of our meret it was deserved need ¶ And saeth that wealths & prosperity Cometh unto us for our rightuesnesse And also when there cometh adversity it falls only for our wickedness with fortune goeth our fame & worthiness Owe noble thing so light it is to lose And certainly the first thing it is That fleeth a way fro wrecches in mysese ¶ what rumours now this folk will of me find How divers sentence & how varyente it loatheth me to think it in my mind For every man of me saeth his intent And this it is that most my heart shent There is no fortune grieveth me so sore As when that myschef is to wrecches sent Men saith it was deserved there before ¶ I am a way fro all my good y put Also despoiled of my dignity And to my heart it noyeth more yet My name defoyled in the comynalte And for the benfet of mine own bounte Lo now I suffer torment & distress And in my heart me seemeth that I see How felons folk beth on their lustynesse ¶ And every lorel ready is & boon Some new coniected frauds to devise And good folk hangs the head a down Jest they be served in he same wise And every surfetour now dare accuse By cause of favour & unpunishment The good men to defoulen & despise And proudly to performen their intent ¶ stirred thereto by geftes & by meed And rightuesnesse may have no reverence So Innocentes leaveth now in dread Not only that/ but lacketh their defence A genst malice is made no resistance But sothfastnesse is had in all dysdeyn That god will suffer this in his presence A cause I have to cry & me complain Metrum iiij. Capitulum seven. O stelliferi conditor or Phia loquitur. ¶ O maker of the sterred heaven on high Eternally that sittest in thy throne Thou torneste heaven with a wonder swy constraining stars to thy law alone So that now in fullness of the moan Beshened with her brother's beams bright The small stars hedeth them full soon In her presence to shine they have no might ¶ And when she to the son nyeth near Full soon she must her bright horns hide And hesperus that shineth bright & clear And showeth him in the cold even tide another year he is the sons guide A rising up full pale in the morn Loo needs in that course he must a bide For so thou hast commanded him before ¶ In winter when that leves gone a way Thou shortest then the fair days light In hot summer lengthest thou the day And makest short the derknesse of the night And thou attemperest times by thy might That bore branches waxeth fair & green which that were defouled & unhyght By stiff storms of the winter keen ¶ The sedes in winter that been sow Thou makest them to wexen fair & high And when that they been full to corns grow Thou makest them to rypen & to dry Thine old law there may no thing unplye Ne by no way there kindly course forlete Owe god that governest all certainly Now only man's work thou hast forget ¶ why shall fortune tornen up so down This thing that is in thy government These wicked folk to set in high renown And driven down the good & innocent with pains that by righteous judgement Ben dew to catyffes for their cursedness Loo faithful men been shamed & y shent And wicked folk been set in worthiness ¶ Thus false folk the faithful have oppressed And virtue that so worthy is of name Is put in darkness till it be redressed The righteous beareth the wicked men's blame Forshoren men that been withouten shame They colour their deceits as them lust And usen they as for a comen game Deceyving them that most upon them trust ¶ And after them they draeth to consent Kings great that many a man must dread And maketh them to perform their intent And them encumbereth with their cursedhed And as they lust rygth so they will them lede But now behold this wrecched earthly place Thou that knettest all in length & breed Now sometime send us succour of thy grace ¶ For of thy work we been a portion Not foul/ but fair after the form of the we men that fortune driveth up & down A 'mong the wawes of this worldly see Repress this flod lord what ever thou be That knetteste all in certain ordinance Thou reuleste heavens in tranquillyte Now set us somuhat in that governance ¶ it belongeth not a wise man to be moved with a fools word but rather to inform & teach & comfort him/ reducing him in to the bonds of reason. So was this clerk by excess of heaviness/ in manner fallen in to foley/ forleting the bonds of reason/ which philosophy calleth his kende country. for by resonablete man is made like to angeles & a very citizen of heaven. wherefore lest this painful heaviness should put him in despair/ bailly comforted him & saeth that he is not exile by the foresaid violence out of his kende country/ but by error of his own false deduction. For why as long as a man keepeth the knoving of his kendly principles/ he may not be compelled to leave the bonds of reason. but erren he may by his false deduction/ by vyche he weeneth that he be necessed & constrained to that false conclusion. But standing the knoulege of these forsaed principles/ he may return & examen his deduction by labour or by techenge/ & find out his error & consequently return again to the truth ¶ Multitude of astates in a land or cyte is cause of great confusion/ for be cause that everych of them coveteth to be gretteste/ so that after his will may stand all the rule & governance. ¶ it betydeth oft that lords sotellen in destruction of other/ that be cause of favour of the cominalte/ by wisdom of governance/ or by excellence of cunning or of wit/ been preferred or like been to be preferred in to high astates so that they may the more freely & seketly werken as they would as for to win the astates that they de●yren/ or else the astates that they haven the more freely for to hold/ o'th' for to be prefered in excellens more singnlerly than other ¶ But in this realm of resonabelte that specially belongeth to the court of heaven/ there is but one lord & sovereign. the vyche is god/ principle and ruler of reason/ wherefore in so moche as any man leaveth after reason/ in how moche he is subgect to the rule of god's law. And in how moche he leaveth after reason/ & so moche he a bideth in his country & in his proper cyte. In which god alone is prince & governor Then ensueth thus/ that if a man be obesyant & subgect unto god's law. he may not be exile not put out of his country. Boetius complained him of no ghostly desese but only of harms bodily/ weling of his prison & wanting of kiss books To vyche complaint philosophy answereth & saith/ that him ought more to complain the perturbation of his spiret that so erred weling the lost of his temporal goods which must needs at last utterly be berafte him. Also she saeth he erreth foul weling for his books/ for why she had put in his mind though same things that maketh books dear and precious/ subtle sentences of reason & of kende ¶ Sienim cuius oriundus sis patrie. The realm & the very country of resonablete is the bliss of heaven. And all the while we work after reason we been in our country as holy & hevenlych by manner of werkenge ¶ The realm of Athenes first was governed by kings/ vyche reigned the term of lives. And after that were ordained princes/ vyche reigned commonly ten ye0res'/ After these were made princes annual that reigned but one year/ & of them should be ix. at once. and of these here speaketh Boetius ¶ Romulus when he had founded the cyte of Rome/ that he might make the cyte copyous of people/ ordained this law that ho so would build in that cyte/ he should never been exiled after for no manner trespass. Prosa quarta Hec ubi continuato dolore. Boetius loquitur. ¶ when I with morning thus had made my moan She was no thing of my complaint a moved with pleasant cheer she held her still as stone soothly she said while oer thus I conceived That thou were exile & thy good beryved Right by thy weeping cheer I known it well But yet how far ne yet had I not perceived But thou thyself had told me every deal ¶ Nevertheless understand now well this Thou art not exile out of thy cyte But thou thyself haste taken thy way a miss A strayed out in to a strange country And if thou ween that thou exiled be Than haste that put thyself out sekerly For that power hath none over the But thou thyself will do it willingly ¶ For if thou knew or could have in thy mind As of what land or what cyte thou were Of which thou took thy nature & thy kende The laws of that land I could the lere For all the world ne may it not conquer Not like Athenes that many lords had But one lord one law & none other there That of his multitude is blithe & glad ¶ He is full fain that folk will to him draw And willingly he will no wight forlete For to obey under his lusty law Is liberty the greatest that may be gete Ne knoveste thou not or else thou haste forget The law that alway there is had & used Ho so that lust theryn to build his sete The lord he will not that he be refused ¶ And ho so will in that place a byden still He may deserve none adversity But also soon as he forleteth that will He may no longer in that pales be For he forfeteh then his liberty And fleeth his country of his own assent when that he sueth sensualyte Forleting reason in his judgement Thou askest where the manner of this place Me with the for to morn moveth aught Me moveth more the manner of thy face For this prison moveth me right naught Thy lybrary with glass & juery wrought neither thy books set I at no price But I seek the habit of thy thought Where I have made a sete at my devise ¶ For in thy heart I have no books put But things that maketh books precious Sotel sentence of cunning & of wit wiche un to me was more delicyous Of thy meret thou haste remembered us The wiche thou haste on comen wealth bestow Full sooth it is & not suspecious Some haste thou said & yet well more I know ¶ Thou haste also rehearsed furthermore The manner of thine accusation And the guilt that thou art grieved fore Full honest in thine estimation None harm deserved ne damnation But rather reward for thy business And now for thy remuneration Thou haste no thing but harm & heaviness ¶ And shortly haste rehearsed every deal The false frauds of thine accusers wiche the comen people knoweth weal The wrongful doom eke of the senators That rather should have been thy defensours Thou soroest also greatly for my blame The which I bear for the of surfetours Thou welest eke the losing of thy fame ¶ But at last with fortune 'gan thou chide That meed with meret was even weigh why surfetours been suffered in their pride And good men a grieved thus I herd the say And in thy song to god thus 'gan thou pray That the ylke piece that is in heaven on hay This wrecched world should keep under his key That now is ruled thus uncertainly ¶ I understand all thine entention But yet soon in that other side I see That moche desire of thine affection Hath now distracted & dystrobled thee And put thy mind out of tranquillyte As sorrow/ morning/ heaviness/ & Ire And while that thou art in this degree Thou mayst no mighty medicine endure ¶ wherefore we shall attempten & assay Now with a little lighter remedy That doleful sorrow for to put away That in thy heart is wexen hard & dry with esy self a chafe it and defy A medicine than that more mighty is Amenden shall that malice esely That soroful swelling lightly shall we lose Metrun quintum. Capitulum. xi. Cum phebi radiis. Philosophia loquitur. ¶ Ho so that will in hot summer seson when that the son in cancer is y set Sown his corn he worcheth out of reason And of his trust no doubt he shall be let By that he hath with winter days met Of other purueyance he shall have need And but he can govern himself the bet with akernes his hunger must he feed ¶ And when the north wind bloveth kine & cold In winter time a very foul he were In wild wood that gether flowers would Or ripe grapes in the time of ver it falls not that ceson of the year The flowers fresh ne ripe fruit to find For god hath set all thing in earth here To kepen ever one certain course of kind ¶ He ne suffereth not the stounds for to melle That he hath set in certain governance As in there offyce every thing to dwell They may not faylen with no variance what thing that leaveth certain ordinance A biding not withyn the course of kende He prospereth not but falls in mischance He may not faylen of a feeble end ¶ Here before hath philosophy enquered the quality & condition of the grievance that this clerk was in. Now here she beginneth to enquere the rote & the original cause/ viche standeth specially in three things one because he soroed unskylfully that is to say of measure the lost of his temporel goods. The second stood in error of false opinion troving that wicked mighty men to the world were by might of wickedness welful. The third that he troved the enterchaunging of fortune by vyche often times the good been depressed and the wicked resed/ was without rule of god's purueance. So the very ground of all his heaviness/ was ignorance or else more verily to say forgetting of divyn governance/ as touching the kende of man/ vich error he was fallen in/ by false deduction fro his first principles. for he granted well that god was maker & governor of al. but be cause that he sufferedde wicked folk to execute their malice upon the good/ vyche execution is very open wrong/ to vyche wrong god that is perfit righteous by no way may consent▪ wherefore he supposed that god had forllete the governance of man/ committing their rule to fortune's unstabilyte from known principles by very true deduction/ a man is brought to exclusion of error by conclusions deduced of this principle. So of this principle that god governeth all as precedent to his proper work/ which Boyes confessed/ it ensueth well that god forleteth not the governance of man/ but dresseth his works rightuously. To vyche conclusion this clerk feled the contrary. The fallace of this consequent of this foul error than is founden in three things. One in false deduction. another in defaute of knovenge of the manner of governance. And the third of knoving verily the kind of man. In this his deduction failed that. for cause god wetyngly suffereth wrongs/ he said other god consenteth to wrong (viche is inconvenient) other he forleteth the governance/ & suffereth in that wise. but this foloeth not/ for he snffereth wrongs knovyngly both by righteous & by mercy & yet he consenteth not ne farleteh not his governance By ryghtuesnes he may compel no creature again the principal property of his kende. But the property of man's will is for to be free to good or to yvel/ than shall not god bereave him that liberty. but rightuosly suffereth him choose so that for his good chose he may deserve meed/ & for his bad chose he deserveth pain. ¶ if god should bereave him this liberty then failed mercy/ for them must he needs utterly destroy him/ or put him in to endless punesment. for bereving the principal property of a creature/ that creature is utterly destroed. as bereave hete fro fire/ then is it no fire Right so bereave liberty fro free will/ then is it no will. But sy●h a spiret may not be destroyed. if he should lose this liberty of will/ 〈◊〉 must then anon be put in to endless punishment/ & this must a void mercy. This may be proved thus. if god left this evil unponeshed finally/ then might he seem to consent to evil/ but that may he not no more ne may he leave it finally unponeshed. if he berafte him his liberty/ then might he never after deserve meed in releving of his puneshment/ & then must he needs be endless in pain/ wherefore of mercy & of rightuesnesse he suffereth wickedness. But here might be saed that god of his goodness might let the execution of such malicious purpose/ Not doubt so he doth for the more partey. For though malice be executed/ yet faileth it the full intent of his execution. Prosa sexta. Capitulum xij. Primum igitur pateris. But first she said will't thou suffer me Now with a few demands for to feel The very kende of thy infirmyte And all the ground to gropen every deal that I may weet how thou might have thy hele Boecius) Now saith on ꝙ I what you lust That you enserche my sore I will it well And I shall answer as me thinketh best Phia) Say meshe said how is this world demened As whether by fortune his variance Or else thou trowest that it is sustened By reason of some certain ordinance Boetius) That god knoweth that hath all in governance This doubt I not/ but truly I believe Come never that day that me befall that chance Out of my heart that sentence for to meve Phia) Right as thou sayest ꝙ she so it is And in thy song while oer right so thou meant But neverthelater thy complaint was this That god on man set no government Ne to their works taketh he none intent That thing it was that thou 'gan weep & we'll All other thing thou wouldest well consent That god had set it at certain governele ¶ O that I wonder now full hugely sith thou in such a sentence art y set That thou art seek of any malady Some thing there is whereby thy hele is let wherefore the ground I shall enserchen bet sith god himself all things ruleth Thus sayest thou while ere/ but say me yet By what governments as the seemeth Boecius) your sentence ꝙ I have I not conceived I can not answer to your question Phia) In sooth ꝙ she now am I not deceived The causes of thy perturbation I know them well by estimation But say me yet if thou have this in thy mind To what purpose by inclination Draeth finally the comen course of kind Boecius) I have ꝙ I herd tell it here be forn But drerynesse hath marred all my thought Phia) yet hast thou not ꝙ she thy wit forlorens That thou ne wost ho hath this world wrought Boecius) O god ꝙ I hath all thing forth y broft Phia) I wonder than she said how may this be Of the beginning sith thou doutest nofte The end may not been unknoven pard ¶ This is the kind of such desturbelance That they may move a man out of his place But nevertheless such manner of grievance Ne may him not all utterly arace Ne put him fully fro the state of grace Might thou remember that thou art a man Boecius) In sooth ꝙ I this were a wonder case if I should not myself in mind han Phia) yet canst thou ꝙ she tellen furthermore The kindly ꝓperte of man what it is Boecius (you ꝙ I as I have herd be fore A reasonable best with dedlynesse That I am such I know & will confess Phia) Naught else ꝙ, she knovest thou of thy kende Boecius) In sooth ꝙ I noft else as I gece Ne nought but this can I have in my mind Phia) another cause now know I well ꝙ she Of thy desese & that I wonder great wiche is the ground of thine infirmyte For what thou art thou hast thyself forget wherefore the reason fully have we gete Of thy desese/ & furthermore a mean How that thou shalt it utterly forlete And thou to health be restored clean ¶ For cause thou art confounded in thy wit with the forgetting of thyself/ for thy That fro thy good in exile art thou put Thou weenest/ & complainest pyteosly And furthermore also as suppose I For thou ne knovest what the end of things is Thou trowest that wrecches full of felony That they have very might & welthynesse Thou hast forget by wiche governements This world is led this makest thou thy colour That these fortunes enterchaungementes Ben fleting thus withouten governor Lo these been causes of right great vygour Not only to sickness & desese But unto death if that thou fail succour That may the with these bitter pains lose ¶ yet nature hath not all forsaken the worth thanks be the auctor of thy hele we have yet one comfort that I see That shall thy sorrow slaken every deal This sothfast sentence have we saved well That god this world hath in his governance Thus thou believest as I conceive and feel And naught subject to haps variance ¶ Ne dread the naught for of this little schyn A lyfly hete shall springen in thy breast But for asmuch as mighty medycyn To give the yet the time is not best And for as moche as minds thus oppressed Haveth this nature & condition That when they have true conceits jest They cloth themselves in false opinion ¶ whereof derknesse & perturbation May wexen up that fully will destroy The syghth of true consideration where for I shall a say sotelly To a void with some esey remedy This dark cloud if it may voided be Of false affection/ and esely The very lyȝth than migth thou know & see Metrum. seven. Capitulum xiij. Nubibus atris condita nullum. The stars covered with the clouds black Ne may not clearly casten down their lyȝth And when the wood south wind doth a wake He waleweth up the see with hugy might The wawes then that were clear & bright like as the glass or as the summer's day with filth that is resolved been on hyghth And fro these wawes letteth our sight always The river running out of high montens Is often time withstanden hugely As by some stone encontering there a gens The which is fallen fro some rock on high if thou therefore will't seyn ententyfly with true beholding truths for to dame Loo/ take this path & hold it certainly Gladness & dread out of thy heart thou fleyn ¶ Ne joy thou naught of worldly welthynes Ne dread the nothing of this worldly dine Ne hope thou not that transitory is Ne sorrow thou naught but if it be for sin For every thofte that these regneth in trouble & dark it is & may not see He is so wrest a way he may nofte win And bridled so that he may not be fire Incipit Liber secundus. Prosa prima. Capitulum secuudum. Post hec paulisper THen after this a stound she held her still And when she by a temporet stylnesse See well that mine attention & my will was set to hearen her with soberness Thus she began if it be as I gese Quod she/ that I the ground & cause know Of all the habit of thy heaviness I can the tellen fully as I trow ¶ In thy desire thou soroest & complainest Upon fortune that with the was a while which that hath perverted as thou feynest Thastate of thy courage in this exile I understand her wrenches & her wile Of the ylke fortune wonderly dysgesed The wiche to them that so her lust beguile Not first in the/ but ever she hath them used ¶ She will be pleasant & familiar Full blandesshing/ full soft & deboner Till that her like for to change her cheer And atlast forlete them in despere Albina out of hope that ever she will repair if that thou known her kende & her desert That thou by her ne hadst no thing fair Ne naught lost thou shouldest know apart ¶ But as I trow withouten great travail we shall revoken this to thy science For thou were wont to dispute & assail with manly words drawn of my science when that she blandeshing in thy presence So pleased the/ but certain sooth is this There falls never such sudden chaungementes That your courage somewhat ne changed is ¶ So is it now befall it is no nay That thou art put out of tranquillyte But time it is to tasten & assay Some soft things that sweet & lusty be That when it hath his deveyr done in the I hope it shall the amend & dispose That stronger drinks may have there entre That shall the heal up as I suppose ¶ Come forth now sweetness retoryens with sotelty of thy suasyon Wiche only then thy ways canst demene When thou ne levest our institution Mysyke also with sweetness of thy sound That art a damsel of our own house Attempre well thy tunes up & down That to this man may be delycyous ¶ what is that man/ whereof canst thou complain what is the cause of all thy heaviness Some new or uncouth things hast thou seyn Fortune again the only turned is Now trowest thou so/ then errest thou y wys For always such her manners hath be But she hath kept in the her stabelnesse That kendly standeth in mutabilyte ¶ Right such she was with all her blandyshing when she such flattering plesance 'gan the make To lere the lusten in these worldly things That passeth right as doth the clouds black Take heed/ that blind goddas hast thou take with double face of doubtful adventure For she it is that hath the now forsake Of whose frendshep there may no man be sure ¶ if thou approve in thine opinion Her goodness when she is to thy plesance Take thou a worth than her condition And use it must thou with her varyance complain the naught make no contraryance And if the greseth of her treachery Than cast her of/ despise her with mischance That to pley is wont so harmfully ¶ The cause that hath the now with sorrow schent Should move the now with joy & lustiness She hath the left/ the which oer she be went There is no wight that may have sekernesse And holdest thou this as for a welthynesse Of preciosty/ that thus a way shall slide And now so dear to the the presence is Of this fortune unfaithful to a bide ¶ And when she goeth/ to morn she you maketh Sigh halden at your will she may not be She leaveth wrecches the that she forsaketh She is nofte else than/ as seemeth me That so uncertainly will fro you i'll But sign of mischef that shall after fall Loo than/ is this all your felicity Naught but a fair that you foloeth all ¶ For it sufficeth not I the ensure Only to say one thing that is present The end of things prudens doth measure For why this divers interchaungement For weal to woe that fortune hath the sent it should the teach her menace noft to dread Ne to her blandyce take right none intent To her behests take no manner hide ¶ For at last the behoveth need Sigh thou hast once in her yoke draw To suffer all that fortune will the bede with esey heart & stand thy lady awe And if thou to thy lady write a law To go or come at thine ordinance Thy labour loo/ availeth not an haw Thou wrongest her with thine unsufferance ¶ Now suffer then & take it not to strange Jest thou her feerser in her wreath find And sharp the swords wiche thou mayst not change Thou mayst her not compellen out of kende For if thou have thy sail up in the wind Thou mayst not choose where thou shalt arrive For what so be the purpose of thy mind Thou must there/ as the weder will the drive ¶ if thou thy corn wilt in the fields sow it may not wexen as thy wits fain For in thy thought thou must conceve & know Some years been plenteous & some bareyn Ne for to grow thou mayst it not constrayn And if it fail/ thereto what mayst thou done How ever it be/ to whom shalt thou complain Lete nature all herself therewith alone ¶ Thou hast the put under the governance Of fortune/ loo she must thy lady be un to her manners owest thou obecyance And if thou purpose to enforcen the To stint her uhele of mutabilyte Of all fowls yet art thou the meste For when fortune standeth in stabilyte The name of fortune may no longer lest Metrum primum. Capitulum ij. Hec cum superba Philosophia loquitur. ¶ When that thus fortune with her hands proute Hath thus her stounds changed to & fro As Erinus Erinus is a river that sometime runneth one way/ sometime another so that she useth no ready course/ ne certain in to neither partey. So fareth fortune byche indifferently and uncertainly giveth both mischeffe and prosperity. that runneth in and out So wonderly her uhele begenneth to go Full ryal kings casts she dove in woe The which some time many a man 'gan dread And some that lieth dyscomfet & undo Loo these untrusty/ lifteth up your head ¶ She thus of wrecches hath no pity Though that they weyle & weep day & night She scorneth eke so wonder hard is she The wailing that herself hath them dight Loo thus she playeth thus proveth she her might To her servants showing many a wonder For he that high in wealths was now right withyn an hour he lieth casten under Prosa ij. Capitulum iij. Vellem autem tecum. Philosophia loquitur. MENANDER lnst to plede a little now with the with such words as fortune may Loo saith she/ right now look thyself & see Me seemeth well such words might she say what is the man/ complaining every day what have I guilt/ what wrong have I the wrought what good of thine have I berafta way That was thine own or with thyselfen brought ¶ Assign thou & I shall soon appear Be fore a juge that can this case redress And if thou canst thy purpose proven clear Of high astate/ riches/ or worthiness To any man that leaveth in dedlynesse That these things should appropryat be And certainly I shall the grant express That thine it was that thou now askest me When that nature in to this world the brought Out fro thy mother where that thou began I took the needy/ naked/ & with naught And I the nourished with my goods than And all with favour noreshed the to man wherefore impatient I find the now Have I the wronged/ tell me if thou can As in what points/ where with/ & as how ¶ with all goods longing to my right I had the fully fret with habundance why should it not be fully in my might As fro the same/ wiche that I avaunce Mine hand withdraven after my plesance The joys thou hadst that was of my grace it was not thine/ take it for no grievance with wrong thou the complainest in this case ¶ Why plainest thou I do the no duresse Ne violence as every man may trowen well liketh me such honour & riches Right as me liketh fully to be stawen The main need must there lady known with me they come & with me must they wend This dare I say if they had been thine own Thou mightest never have lost them in this kende ¶ where I be she that only am forhyght To execute the custom of my law The heaven may the days make bright And eke at night she may her light withdraw The year also the earth may bestrawe with flowers & them eft with winter shined The see may now be calm withouten wawe And now with stiff storms torn & wend ¶ But the said unfulsome man's covetise Me would now to stabelnesse bind A genst mine own manner & my wise But this my might is/ this play is my kind My swift while thus up & down I wind The high & low to enterchaungen oft That now be forn is/ eft mote be behind That now is law/ me lust to set a loft ¶ Now worth upon my uhele if that the lust But on this covenant that I shall the say Thou must descend again thereto thou trust when that the reason asketh of my play Ne known thou not my manners ere this day How Croesus that was called king of Lyde That Cyrus oft a feared with great a fray yet Cyrus took him in his most pride ¶ And in the fire he cast him for to brenne Loo how the effect was turned to reverse A little rain defended him fro than what befell him after books doth rehearse And when that Paul had take the king of pierce This Paul 'gan on him weep for pure pity what crieth all tragedyens verse But plaineth all on mine unstabylyte ¶ Tragedies hen dytes made of certain people/ vyche begynnethe in wealth and prosperity/ and endeth in myscheffe & adversity They weepeth that sodenlyche I smite And welful realms oft I overthrow Thou learned this when thou were young & light Thou hast not yet forgeten as I trow That jupiter ij. tons had bestow Withyn the thresfold of his celer laid That one was good wine every man to know That other nofte/ now hast thou both assayed ¶ And what if thou more plenty hast y take Lo of the better part of lustynesse what if I yet have the not all forsake what if so be that mine unstabelnesse May give the hope of better after this For why dysmay the no thing in thy thought Ne withyn the realm that comen is Thy proper law to use/ covet the naught Metrum ij. Capitulum iiij. Si quantas rapidus. Phia loquitur. Though plenty wiche that cleped is goods Of worldly good/ would cast un you at one's As many habundances of richesse Loo as the see hath small gravel stones Other as stars when full many one is Full clearly shining in a lusty even yet this mankend of their ruthful moans Ne their complaints can they not leaven ¶ And though that god of his benygnyte There prayer here & gladly would them please And of he's goods grant them great plente Of riches & honour fully to their ease Theridamas covetise yet/ may there no thing peses There cruel raven gapeth after more And always been complaining of desese And set at nofte all that they had before ¶ what manner brydel might a man devise This wrecched lust to rulen & restrayn To this unthryfty men's covetise That ever the more they have the more they pleyn The thirst of having brenneth them with peyn For he that nedeles so fereful is And weyleth so/ forsooth I dare well sayen He is not rich though all the world were his Prosa iij. Capitulum u. Hijs igitur verbis. Phia loquitur. ¶ if that fortune might for herself sayen Right in these wise as I have said to the Thou hast not what one word to speak again And if thou have now say it unto me Defend thy quarrel (if thou canst) let see Thou shalt be herd till that thou have rehearsed And if thou canst not let thy plaints be Vnlaful quarrel aught to been amerced Boecius) Certain ꝙ I full fair is this to hire Of retoryke all full/ & honey sweet wiche only while they souneth in mine ere They lusteth well/ but soon it is forget For my desese so light is not to let For all so smartly as your song is cessed The grugging of my grievance is so great That all my mind with morning is oppressed Phia) Right so it is she saed/ but yet for that This is no remedy for thy sickness But again thy sorwes obstynat Again thine health it is a manar less But when I see that better seson is Of such as shall the percen to the rote I shall the serve/ & all that is a miss it shall redress & hoelly be thy boat ¶ But jest that thou thyself a wrecche hold Now would I weet where thou remember not The manner of thy wealths many a fold Boecius) I hold my peace ꝙ I saeth on your thought Phia) when thou she saed were so low brought As orphelyn in manner desolate Fortune for the so goodly had wrought Thou were in cure of men of high astate ¶ And drawn scythe in to affynyte Of princes & of men of governance Full lief to lords/ ere thou mightest be Aught worth thyself in worldly suffysance And set in high degree of alliance Honorio saed not then that thou were fully blessed Thy father in law whom virtue doth avaunce Thy wyf also so goodly & honest ¶ Thy sons both sitting by thy side your worship went on every man's mouth And for to let these comen things slide what dygnytes thou hadst in thy youth That to full old men been werned in sooth But I delight to tellen more express Of soleyn things stranger & uncouth How thou were wrapped all in welthynesse ¶ if any thing that mortal is in kende with any fruit of bliss be founden here There may no myschef put out of thy mind That day that when thy sons both in fere Hadden take thestate of consuyler And with assemble fro thy hons y lad Of senators & lords that there were with hugy press of people blithe & glad ¶ And than in court when that thou saw them sit In setes belonging to their dignity There won thou joy of eloquence & wit As pronouncer of kings nobylyte Of all that folk behalding upon the And with thy preysing as victoryous So well thou feddest all that comynalte with geftes of thy words glorious ¶ Thou feoffedest fortune then with words gay while she the norshed in her own delyce And such guerdon fro her thou bore a way The wiche in sooth was so high a price That never before that day at my device She granted not unto no comyner wilt thou a count with fortune/ art thou wise Of a rereage thou shalt not passen clear ¶ For now at arst she hath on the behold And prynched on the with a bitter you But now considering clearly if thou would The manner of thy wealths by & by Of all thy joys leaving lustily And in that other side thy heaviness A counted all/ yet mayst thou not deny That thou ne haste yet a part of welthynesse ¶ And if thou hold thyself infortunate Now for asmuch as these that wealths semen Ben passed thus/ no cause haste thou for that That thou in mischef should thyselfen demen For these sorrows that trobeleth thus thine heart And haldest them as for a grievous pain Ne doubt the naught but fro the will they start Than art thou set in welthynesse again ¶ And wilt thou trow that thou the first be That to this life came as a sudden gyst Or wilt thou trow that any stabylyte In man's life be where upon to trust This knovest thou well it is nothing unwist That in an hour a man is at an end Loo all your life with death so is bet wist Now here you been/ & here a way you wend ¶ And if so be as it betydeth seld That in fortune is any faithfulness Abiding with man till he the ghost up eld The last day yet of your life y wys A manner death eke unto fortune is what for'rs is than where she the forsaketh Fleing fro the of her untrustynesse Or thou fro her/ when death a way the taketh Metrum iij. Capitulum uj. Cum polo phoebus'. Philosophia loquitur VHen that phoebus' beginneth for to spread Her bright beams out on every side As by the morning/ the stars for dread They waxeth pale beginning them to hide Forestes eke that large been and wide Full fresly in the first summer ceson The zephirus right as it were for pride with flowers hath depaynted/ you to plesen ¶ And when that austere putteth out his horns And bitter blasts gynneth for to blow A bateth than the beutey of the thorns Thus all your lusts passeth in a throw The see also as every man may know Now may be calm withouten movone And suddenly oer any man will trow with tempest is it turned up so down ¶ And sith the form of all this worldly things So selden is it that it standeth stable But changeth by so many varyenges And man's fortune is so transmutable Than wilt thou trust to goods deceivable This is a law withouten chaungementes There may no thing be kendly perdurable That is engendered of these elements Prosa iiij. Capitulum seven. Tum ego/ vera inquam Boecius loquitur. ¶ Than said I thus/ O worshypful nourish all virtue to feeden and sustain In all my wit/ but if I were unwise I can not weet but sooth is that you sayen And of my fortune sooth it is certain That wonder smartly hath she me enhanced But here upon it is that I complain That she undoth wiche that she had avaunced ¶ For of myshappes to rehersen all it is the worst/ for to be well And in to myschef aster to be fall For this must shend a very heart of steel Phia) Though thou ꝙ she thus in thy wits feel By false conceit of thine opinion The truth ne aggrieveth the never a deal To wite it her/ yet hast thou no reason ¶ And if this Idel name of welthynesse That so uncertain is/ yet moveth the with me now come & thine a counts guess Of thynghes wiche as yet) thou hast plenty The wiche thou hadst ever in most deynte when all in richesse fortune had the fret How might thou plain of thy felicity Sigh that thou hast thy best goods yet ¶ yet whole & sound the father of thy wyf He leaveth loo/ honour & reverence Of all man kende/ which thou with thy life wouldest gladly obey standing in his defence Symmachus made of all sapience All full of virtue & of honest Though he be sure of any violence As to himself/ yet weyleth he for the Thy witty wyf so full of soberness So chaste/ so honest/ & so debonaer In short to conclude all her worthiness like to her father as his kendly heyer Full loath her life she leadeth in despaer Only to the she keepeth her careful ghost This one thing is that may thy wealth apayre This grant I well & do moon it most ¶ And of thy sons wiche been consulers what shall I sayen/ but shortly that they be In manner print & as exemplares Both of their elder father & of the And every mortal thing as thou mayst see Upon this hath his princypal business This live to keep fro all infirmyte And unto man the dearest thing it is ¶ And these to the been dearer than thy life I dare it well affermen certainly Lo Symmachus/ thy sons/ & thy wife Thou hast them yet now let thy tears dry For yet fortune is not thine enemy In all/ so ferforthe as thyself fainest Ne yet is not on the so fervently The tempest fallen as thou the complainest ¶ For why good holding hath thine anchor hent They been full strong & cleaveth wonder fast The wiche/ thy comfort of this time present Ne hope of better/ suffereth not to be passed Boecius) Owe god ꝙ I thou grant it that they last For while they haldeth how that ever it stand Or how that ever these wicked winds wrest Yet in some manner shall we fleet a land ¶ But how great beauty of mine apparel Is fro me gone/ yowselfen saith it best Phia) I have ꝙ she if it may aught a veil Promoted somewhat that thou were in rest But if so be thou thyselfen tempest Dysplesed with the sort of all thy life How should than thy myschef be redressed if thou wilt always set thyself in stryf But I ne may not suffer thy delyce Complaining with so grievous heaviness Always coniecting so in thy devise That somewhat wanteth of thy welthynesse For hoys that that leaveth in dedlynesse That in his wealths standeth so ordynat That he ne striveth always more or lass with the quality of his astate ¶ Full anguesous they been as for the nonce The kende of worldly wealth I say/ for why For other they cometh not all at one's Or they ne standeth never stabelly For these hath riches loo habundantly Him shameth that his lineage is so low And these loo is renowned nobelly Yet had he liefer for poverty been unknown ¶ Another hath both renown & riches He hath no wyf wherefore he is dysplesed These hath a wyf that to him lusty is Defaute of issue maketh him be desesed He note ho with his goods shall be sesed And these hath issue to his lust perchance yet haply of their vice he is unesed And weyleth of their wicked governance ¶ wherefore in sooth there is no wight that can with proper fortune hold hemself a paed For why some thing is feled of every man That none knoweth but he that hath assaed And he that knoweth he is thereof afraid Set this thereto the every welful wight Full tender is to suffer & mysapayed If all thing fall not to his will a right ¶ And he that worldly is most fortunate And set most hyely in prosperity Full little thing his bliss may abate That is not used in adversity How many trowest thou in this world there be if that they had the jest bliss of. seven. That I can tell of thy felicyte They would supposen that they were in heaven ¶ This place of exile as thou hast it named Good country is to them that in it been And never the worse though it of the be blamed Thou art no wrecche but thou thyself it ween Though fantasy have brought the thus in tene And every fortune there again is good Ho so can in patience himself demene And suffer softly with an esy mode ¶ Now tell me thus what wilful man is that That standeth in bliss as he can devise That sometime nold changen his astate when patience is put out of service what trobel with your wealths many a wise Is menged/ if you could it have in mind Though they be sweet to such as them use They will not be with hold when they wend ¶ Than may you seyn by open evidence The myschef of these mortal things thus They standeth not though thou have patience Ne lusteth not in all thy anguysous O folly/ unwyt/ so erroneus Of mortal folk seeking themself without your welthynesse & it so plenteous Is set withyn yourself withouten doubt ¶ I shall the show of thy felicity A sovereign point/ intend what I shall say Is any thing so dear worth unto the As is thyself thou wilt answer me nay if thou be hole thine own conclude I may Thou haste that thou ne wouldest forlete The wiche fortune may not bereven a way Till thou thyself it wilfully forfete ¶ And that thou know that things temporel May not be such wherein thou shouldest find Thy blysfulnesse/ now understand me well And take these words hoelly to thy mind Sigh blysfulnesse is sovereign good of kind Hose life is reason & intelligence And sovereign good is thing that hath no end Ne may beraft the by no violence ¶ Than upon this I may conclude & seyn That these fortune's mutabilyte To blesfulnesse may no thing attain Ne is not had by such unstabylyte And when so that this false felicyte Thus carrieth forth/ he wot or wot it not How false she is & always hath y be This division is immedyat ¶ if he ne wot it not he is deceived what bliss may be than in this ignorance And if so be he hath well a perceived The manner of her kindly varyance He dreadeth than with full great grievance To lose that thing that lightly may be gone So that this dread with long continuance withdraweth his bliss wiche that he trust upon ¶ Other if it be so that he lose his bliss He weeneth to stand in repreffe & in scorn And no doubt full little good it is whose lost with esey heart may be born And thou art he to who that here be forn it hath be showed by demonstration That man's soul ne may not be forlorn As thing that turneth to corruption ¶ And clear it is that all this worldly weal As fro you men with death a way shall wende● Than may it not be doubted never a deal But sooth it is by reason & by kende if worldly bliss should be your final end And very form of all your welthynesse Than every creature of mortal kende with death must tornen in to wrecchednesse ¶ But we have wist of many one here be fore To seek the fruit of bliss in their intent That haveth it bought full bitterly & sore By death/ by dolour/ by pains & torment How might it be then that this life present with any lusts/ might you welful make sith it is so that when this life is went They be no wrecches wiche it hath forsake Metrum iiij. Capitulum viij. Quisquis volet Phia loquitur. HO so that lust to byld hemself a sete That should be mighty/ sure/ & perdurable That bitter Eurus brese it naught ne bete Ne fers floddes make it not movable The high hills be not profitable And moystey sands must he needs exchew For on the mounteyn may no thing be stable neither in sand no thing be true ¶ For uhy/ the south wind bloweth sore a loft That on the monteyn may no thing be sure And sands that so loose been & soft An heavy borden may they not endnre To i'll therefore this perilous adventure A syker sete to set thyself a upon Take this in mind & do thereto thy cure To byld a law house on a syker stone ¶ That is to sayen that thou shalt set all thy mind Upon that bliss that ever shall a bide And though so fall that the wood wind Torn up & down the see on every side In very rest/ thou mayst thyselfen hide As in thy castle full of blesfulnesse In lusty age than shall the well betide And set at naught this worldly wrecchednesse Prosa u. Capitulum ix Sed quoniam rationum. Phia loquitur. But for asmuch as I have done this By my reason descending in to the To usen now (I trow that time is) Some medicine that more mighty be Now understand/ all were it so pard That goods wiche that fortune hath bestowen Should standen ever in perdurabelte How might thou ever account them for thy own ¶ And these same that you acompte them best if that they were consydred as they aught Full foul they sholden seem & dyshoneste And been a counted for a thing of naught Now of riches how seemeth in thy thought why been they good/ whether of their proper kind Or for they been in to your ward y brought And should been good till that they fro you wend ¶ What is it./ gold wiche that you call riches Or money gathered in your tresory But these showeth more their worthiness In putting out/ then keeping privily For avarous men been hated commonly And every wight will have them in dysdeyn And though that will dyspenden largely They shall have love & worship there again ¶ And this good that thou dyspendest thus when it is spent a bideth not with the Than is thy money only precious when thou it hast pnt a way fro the Than in dyspending lieth the precyouste Of your treasure & not in hepes great it stint you never at no comodyte Ne availeth no thing till it be forlete ¶ And what if all the gold that all men han As it is now in dystribution were assembled in an heap/ and than One man it had in his possession This gold then by this supposition All other men must needy make & bore And one man rich this is no question believing after all the world in care ¶ A voice universal (I may conclude) At one's may without apeyrement fulfil the years of a multitude your riches is not so suffycyant For till they be departed & y spent To many men ne may they not be taken And these men fro whom they been y went They leave them pour when they have them forsaken ¶ O strait & pour that riches may I call which all men ne may not have at one's Ne one have all/ but if that other all For poverty & for need make their moans And eke I marvel that these precious stonies That you be haldeth them so lustily And feigneth beauty in things where none is And their it is you can it not a spy ¶ And what thing is it? brightness of colour why that this perry seemeth you so fair This weet you well the brightness is not your Ne naught of you/ but only it is there As by a light rebounding in the air And moche I marvel why you wonder so On things that may be a mend ne pair Your kendly good by nought that they may do ¶ what thing is that that lacketh life & light what may be lekened to a creature That beareth life/ & reason hath there with That should be deemed fair as by nature And though they draw a beauty in figure Of him that made it/ yet in your presence They may not worthy been in no measure To be merueled of your excellence ¶ And where these fields that been fair & green So full of flowers delighteth aught your sight Boecius) why should they not said I sigh that they been A fair part of the work of god all might For so some times when the see is bright we wonder moche/ & when the heaven is clear Upon the moan & stars in the night And on the son that shineth a 'mong us here Phia) ¶ But apperteyneh ꝙ she aught to the Mayst thou that beauty in thyselfen find darest thou reioycen that they in the be As thing subjecteth in thy proper kind Art thou depaynted seemeth in thy mind with flowers of the first summer seson Or art thou as a tree with rote & rind Mayst thou nourish fruits? trowest thou this by reason ¶ And wherefore art thou ravished so in vain As though these goods should be thine own The which fro the been utterly foreyn And wonder fer as every man may known For why fortune (thou mayst it fully trowen Ne may not make them thine for to be The wych nature hath else where bestowen And utterly made fro the alien ¶ For why the fruit that doth on earth encrecen Deserveth unto bests sustynance And little thing your need may a cessen So that nature have her suffysance why shouldest thou then desire abundance And ask of fortune superfluity sith that nature may have her plesance with little thing in prise & quantity ¶ And if thou wilt her suffysance oppress with superfluity surfetously Other it will the bring in heaviness Other else the a noyen grievously But of this one thing certain meruyl I That thou wouldest semen fair & glorious As for to be clothed ryally In divers shape & colour precious ¶ For if in clotheses any beauty be where by the sight is fair & agreeable That appertaineth no thing unto the But that matter hauled I meruylable Other the wit of him is commendable That made this thing this may be cause of word But that thou shouldest therefore be honourable As in your kenned/ you been full far a sounder ¶ Or for to walken with a hugy rout And of main to be copyous May make the blysful/ nay wythouten doubt For I suppose that they been vicious They been a grievous charge unto thy house And may be cause of thy destruction And what if they be good & virtuous And very honest of condytion ¶ why should their virtue other honest Be accounted as part of thy riches Or wherefore shouldest thou commended be Or have a thank of foreyn worthiness Loo in all these rehearsed here express The which as thou acomptest in thy thought As for thy goods clearly as I guess I have the showed that thine be they naught ¶ In wych things as I have said beforn if thou no lusty beauty canst find why soroest thou that thou them hast forloren Or of the having enjoyest in thy mind if they be fair as of their own kind what may that apperteyn unto the For had they been fro the wythouten end Also fair & lusty had they be ¶ For no doubt they be not precious For thou them hast & keepest busily But for they seemed the delycyous Thou them accompest in thy tresory what crave you then with so great a cry That you on fortune calleth thus alway with abundance in sooth/ as suppose I you seeketh for to dryven need a way ¶ But yet the contrary to your intent doth fall For you needeth help (not little) to maintain And for to keep your precious things all Jest so be fall that you it lose again So moche the more your labour is in vain That you must live in heaviness & dread And this is sooth also that I shall sayen Ho so much hath/ of moche thing hath need ¶ And little thing him needeth certainly That can his plenty measure on this wise Right even as nature needeth kendly And not unto the lust of covetise Ne can you not yourself better advise To see what good is set yourself wythyn But needs will you seken & devise In strange things your goods for to win ¶ And thus of things that should be worthiest The order is perverted up so down The which is called a divine best By kendly might & meret of reason Ne can not known his own condytion Nor see the meret of his excellence But by the desire of vain possession Trusteth worldly riches to be his defence ¶ All other bests haldeth themself a paid Of beauty that wythyn themself is But you men the which as I have said your god hath set you in such a worthiness That in your souls you beareth his lekenesse And be in kende so noble a creature you seeketh here by filth & wrecchednesse To enblemesshe your excellent nature you understand not ne will not see what wrong you do unto your creator sith he man kind hath set in this degree All earthly things to exceed in vaylour you do your dignity great dishonour To thrust it under most unworthy things Right as it were a lord & governor would make him subject to his underlynges ¶ For if you should have this entention That all thing which is had of every wight Should more be set of reputation Than he that hath or aweth it by right you do yourself shame & great unhyght So foul things/ sith you dame them yours Submytting you as in your own sight To things where of you been the possessors ¶ At your desert this falls verament The kind of man loo standeth in this degree That only than he is most excellent when that he knoweth his own dignity And there again eftsoons when that he Ne can not know his own worthiness He is be nethen bestyalyte And undercast to all wrecchednesse ¶ A rude best his nature useth thus To may not know hemselfen kindly In man it is full foul & vicious His nature to forleten folely And thus your error showeth openly There you supposeth that such accydentes your kende that is so worthy & so high Should make fair by foreyn ornaments ¶ it may not be that reason hath forfended For if such accydentes be fair & gay These accydentes aught to be commended But that covered thing it is no nay In his filth a bideth still all way And I deny & utterly dyspreve That any thing is good/ that harmen may Or aught the haver noyen or a grieve ¶ Now is this sooth in certain as I guess Thou wilt it say/ I gabbe not of this For oft it falls that treasure & riches Maketh her lords for to far a miss sith every wrecched foul that cursed is Such gold & treasure uhoes that ever it be He will covet & will that it were his And therefore put his life in jeparde ¶ And only them he holdeth worthiest That of such gold & treasure haveth enough For why he besyeth him with outen rest To have that good ne recketh he not how But thou that levest in such a dread now As though thou shouldest with sword or spear be stonge Hadst thou been pour it had been for thy prow Be fore the theffe thou mayst have gone & song ¶ O/ wonder clear is this felicity Of mortal thing & worthy to be soft That reaveth a man of his tranquillity And maketh him destrobled in his thought I note how dear that bliss may be boght A man to win such a welfulnesse Thou art in peace the while thou hast it nought when thou it hast thou lesest thy sykernesse Metrum. u Capitulum x. Felix nimium prior etas. Phia loquitur. ¶ Full wonder blysful was that rather age what time that men couth halde themself a paid To feed themself with out such outrage With meet that true fields had a raid With akernes their hunger was a laid And so they couth cessen their talon They had as yet no quenty craft assayed As clarrey for to make/ ne pyment ¶ To die purper couth they not bethynke The white flees with venem tyryens The running river gave them lusty drink And wholesome sleep they took upon the green The Pynus that so full of branches been That was their house to keep them under shade The see to kerue no ships were there seyn Theridamas was no man that merchandise made ¶ Them leked not to saylen up & down But kept themself there they were bread though was full husche the cruel claryoune with eyger hate there was no blood y shed Ne therewith was none armour yet be bled For in that time ho dared have been so would Such bitter wondes that he would not dread wythouten meed for to lose his blood ¶ I would our time might tornen certainly And these manners always with us dwell But love of having brenneth fervently Moore ferser than the very fire of hell Alas ho was that man that would him mell This gold & gems that were covered thus That first began to mine I can not tell But that he found a perel precious Prosa. uj. Capitulum xj Quid autem de dignitatibus Phia loquitur. ¶ But furthermore what shall I tell or sayen Of high power or else of dignity The which you magnyfyeth so in vain As though they should as high as heavens be Rygh as a thing of high felicity And folely you faileth all a miss Ne can you not wythyn your wits see where that very dignity & power is ¶ And if it so be that a wrecched wight As often hath it fallen hire before In high astate or dignity be dight How fierce a flod may harmen you so sore The fire of Ethna may not harmen more That blasteth out & brenneth every side Such a wretch had better been vnbore Than such astates should to him betide ¶ And certes thou remembreste as I guess Of the consulers' dignity That was the hyeste astate of worthiness In the beginning of your liberty They were so full of pride & cruelty wherefore your elders would it have removed And for the same cause fro your cyte The name of king was voided & repryved ¶ And if so be that good men be raised To high astate as selden is that chance Ho is therefore of reason to be praised Not that astate/ but there good governance So than in virtue lieth the suffysance where by that honour cometh to dignity And dignity not by contraryance Maketh not virtue worshypful to be ¶ This power which that is so sore y soft So dear worth & so clear in your intent what thing is it/ & why behold you nofte To wiche things you been presydent And uher upon your power is extent what if thou saw a wrecched mouse alone To cleymen power or government Of other mice/ thou wouldest laughed soon ¶ And if thou wouldest behalden in thy mind what is the mortal body of a wight A freyler thing ne shalt thou none find That less hath of power or of might How soon it may beflayed or a fright Or dead by biting of a little fly Or by some worm that crepen may in right withyn a man's body privily ¶ And ho is he that may do strength or forhis Or usen might or power/ say me this But only on a corruptible cors Right of the same kende/ that is his Other on thing/ that more unworthy is As on fortune/ or uhose might may attain By high astate/ pour ●or worthiness A free courage to arteyn or constrayn ¶ Steadfast that hath hemself in rest And knetteh himself in reason every deal Mayst thou his piece bereave out of his breast un to thy will his purpose to compelle Of such a man (zeno) as some time it be fell A tyrant would have arted him by pains A certain counsel to be wrey and tell The wiche that was conspired him a geynes But then this man boat of his tongues end And in his face it spete/ so that he This torment wiche this same tyrant wend To have been matter of his cruelty This wise mau to show his liberty Of free courage that may not be constrained He made it cause of virtue for to be And set at naught how sore that he were peyned ¶ And what is that of auger or of grame wherewith a man another may oppress That he ne may sustain of him the same if afterward such adventure encresse As we have learned that Busirides His own gests often had slain And afterward hemself of Hercules That was his geste: was done to death again ¶ And Regulus full many one in batel Of men of affryke/ as thou hast it rad Had taken when he had governayle And cast them in to bonds sore & sad And afterward in manner was he glad For fere of pain to put forth his hands To though that first of him were sore a dread Than was he fettered in the same bonds ¶ And wouldest thou setten by a man's might That may not let the same thing be wrought unto himselfen of the same wight The wiche he hath in to desese y brought And if so were as seemeth in thy thought if high astate might kendly contain Any proper good/ I ne doubt it naught To wicked folk ne should it never atteyn ¶ Contrarious things that manner hath not used As for to be coniuned & y met For ever yet nature it hath refused And sith that often wicked men been set In high astate as it will not be let Than seweth this that no good kendly Hath that astate that suffereth to be knet To such that leadeth their lives wickedly ¶ And loo the same I may well dame of all Fortune's goods be they more or less That most abundantly be wont to fall To wicked people full of cursedness For of all these I may suppose & guess That ho so hath strength a mighty man he is And in when may be founden great swyftnesse That man is swift/ so most it needs be ¶ Thus music maketh a musytion And phisyke a physician to be Thus rethoryke maketh a retoryens The kende of every thing (we may well see Most needs induce his kendly property Ne suffereth not to be coniuned to None effects of contraryouste But all adverse things putteth him fro But loo your worldly riches hath not that For to restrain your cursed avarice Neither the power of none high astate May make him strong that is bond in vice That leadeth his life in lusts & delyce Ne dignity in shreved folk bestaved Maketh not them the worthier of price But rather maketh them unthryfty to be knowed ¶ And uhy is this? in soothe for you delyten And reioycen in your fantasy False names on things to conterfeten All other/ than becometh them kendly For uhy/ the effects proveth openly That dignity/ that power/ that richesse Theridamas names beareth all unto As I have showed/ it sueth even express ¶ And too this same I may concluden well Of all fortune's things (as seemeth me) In which there is no bounte naturel Ne cause why they should desired be For seld it is as every man may see They joineth them to good & virtuous As may thestate of good plente Of foreyn thing to needen nought at all But in it self to have all suffysance Of all good to speak in general ¶ And furthermore what sayest thou/ erren they That such a thing a counten honourable The which is sovereign good/ for soothe nay For such a thing may not be repreveable That to all mortal folk is desyreable where to is set all their entention And also power/ is it commendable it is full good it is no question ¶ How should might fro such a thing be ryved The which of all thing is worthiest And noble renown should it be reproved That is a thing so worthy & honest sith thing that is most excellent & best Must need be worchypful & reverent For every wight to win it is full priest And there to traveleth with their hole intent ¶ But for to speak of anger or distress Or sorrow/ murning/ anguesse/ other pain Such things may not be in blysfulnesse Therefore of ●uche it needeth nought to sayen For in full little things men be fain To have & use that may them do solace And only this to haven in certain All worldly men enforcen to purchase ¶ And for this cause desireth they abundance As lordship/ fame/ delyce/ & dignity There by to win & have suffysance Of honour/ revoune/ might/ & glad to be Than is it good as every man may see That men so fast seeketh in this wise And so traveleth everych in his degree To win it as they can best devise ¶ In which desire appeareth openly How great & mighty is the strength of kende sith also be it that full diversly Dyscordeth loo the sentence of their mind yet all these consenteth at one end As for to love a thing that seemeth best For here to nature doth there hearts tend Till this be had they may not be in rest Metrum ij. Capitulum iiij. Quamtas rerum flectat. Phia loquitur. it lust to shown by subtle songs And by the so●ne of delectable strenges How that nature that mighty is & strong Attempreth the government of things This great world with all his varynges So by her laws keepeth & sustaineth And by bonds that haveth no losynges Full sickerly she bindeth & restraineth ¶ For though the lion of that strange land That height Pene/ the fair chains bear And taketh meet by gefte of man's hand And of their sturdy masters haveth fere Of who they often stiff strokes bear And softly they suffereth to be bete yet be they once loosed of that gere There old courage will they not forget ¶ For if the hot blood of any best There foul mowthes have made read There high courage that long hath been a rest it will repair in to there cruelhed He casts then his chains over head And roareth fast remembering as it were His master first of whom he was a dread with bloody tethe than will he all to tear ¶ The bird that singeth on the branch on high if he be closed in a cage of tree And lusty men him serveth busily with metes that full sweet & lusty be if he may once skyp out & be free His Insty meet he casts under foot And to the wood full fast seeketh he And beginneth to trute with a lusty note ¶ A yerde that is grown up in length with man's hand bowed down to ground if that the hand remitteh of his strength The crop full soon will up again rebound And when the son is passed days stound As undergon the wawes of the west Full soon he hath a privy path y found And in the morning a riseth in the este ¶ And so again the day beginneth spring Thus every thing rejoiceth in his kende There recourse againward for to bring And busily to tornen & to wend Loo this we should conceiven in our mind That all things must there order sew And the beginning joinen with the end And to themselfen make a circle true Prosa iij. Capitulum u. Vos quoque terrena. Phia loquitur. But you earthly bests/ as it seemeth with a full thin Imagination your beginning as it were you dremeth I led by natural inclination And haveth in manner blind inspection As of the end of very blysfulnesse But error of your false affection Wythdraeth you to very wrecchednesse ¶ Behalde & see now if it may be so where men atteyn mown in this wise un to that end that nature draeth them to Of blysfulnesse so as themself devise if so be that there nice covetise Of money/ honour/ or such other thing May make them fully to themself suffice That no good lack as unto their like ¶ And than by these will I grant & seyn That a man may leaven blysfully But than eft in that other side again if they may not performen verily All that they have behyght them utterly But many goods lacketh that they miss will it not than apperen plenerly As a full false colour of blysfulnesse ¶ But first of the I ask this demand As thou that were not yet full long a go In worldly wealths fully habundante whether thou a 'mong though wealths everichone As in thy courage/ never feldest thou none distress or grievance no time in thy mind Boecius) Certain ꝙ I that I can think upon In that astate couth I me never find ¶ That I ne was always somewhat in distress Phia) And was not this ꝙ she the cause why That some thing lacked the as dyst thou guess The which thou wouldest have had presently And some thing eke thou hadst sickerly The which thou wouldest gladly have foregone Boecius) Right as you sayen right so it is ꝙ I Phia) Thou wyllest ꝙ she the presence of that one ¶ And the absence of that other than Boecius) ꝙ I I grant I can not go there fro Phia) Now than ꝙ s; he needeth every man The same thing that he desireth to Boecius) Full sooth it is ꝙ I him needeth so Phia) Now than ꝙ she he that needeth aught He is not suffysant (Boecius) I said no As to himselfen he sufficeth not Phia) when thou she said were full in thy riches Thou suffered then this same unsuffysance Boecius) How else ꝙ I so it is express Phia) Than is it so ꝙ she that abundance Of worldly good may never a man a vaunce As to himselfen that he may suffice And need naught of foreyn purueyance And this is that they height to a complyse ¶ And this is to be consydred I trow That money hath no kendly resystens For to defend the lords that them own That they ne may be rafte by violence Boecins) I grant well ꝙ I to your sentence Phia) And what ꝙ she though that thou sedyst nay sith every day men doth their diligence The strengest for to gete it if he may ¶ For uhereof else be quarrels moved That men all day in courts them complain But for their good is falsely them bereaved By forhis or fraud & asketh it again Boecius) In sooth ꝙ I it is right as you seyn Phia) Loo then ꝙ she needeth every man Of succour & of foreyn help certain As for to keep the money that they han ¶ Boecius) Honorio is that may denyen this ꝙ I PHia) And then ꝙ she should him need none Of such defence ne ward certainly Ne had he that money that he may foregone Boecius) There is ꝙ I no doubt there upon Phia) Loo then ꝙ she all your affyance Is turned you unto reverse a none For it bereveth you your suffysance ¶ where by you ween in ease for to be And bringeth you in anguysse & distress Of foreyn help to have necessity yet would I know the manner wise express How need may been voided by riches where rich men ne hungereth never a deal Or where they may not thursten wilt thou guess where they ne may no cold in winter feel ¶ But unto this thou wilt answer me soon That rich men have uherwyth every day There cold/ there thirst/ their hunger to for done As unto this in all I say not nay In sooth this will I graunten that they may By there good be comforted at their need But utterly to putten need a way That power have they not wythowten dread ¶ For sith this need that always gapeth so To be fulfilled/ & after more it gredeth Is such a thing that never may be do Of kende ne speak I naught that jytel needeth But avarice that no thing fully feedeth Ne may not be fulfilled with habundance But in to more necessity you leadeth why trow you there by to have suffysance Metrum iij. Capitulum uj. Quamuis fluente dives Phia loquitur. ALL were it that the rich covetous Had all of gold full running a river And also feel of stones precious As in his neck he might hem selfen bear And o●en on field his lands for to eyre His business yet till that he shall they He will not leave/ ne when he lieth on bear All his riches ne shall him not convey Prosa iiij. Capitulum. seven. Sed dignitates. Phia loquitur. VHether dygnytes to such as them win May make them fully worshypful to be Other impressen virtue them wythyn And make vice out of their hearts i'll Not so for sooth thou mayst thyselfen see it is not wont to a voyden wickedness But vice that was all close in prevyte it maketh fully to be known express ¶ where of it is I have right great dysdeyn That such wicked men & surfetours Should any time in dignity be seen There fore it was that one Catullius when he see one that height Nomius Set in a sete of worship in the town He called him a postem venomous All full of atter & corruption ¶ Ne sayst thou not what shame & velony To such shrewd wicked folk it is For to be set in such honour on high For were not that/ yet their unworthiness Of other folk should known be the less And what perilous wouldest thou standen at ere thou wouldest bear an offyce/ shall I guess with a such cursed man dedecorate ¶ Ne I ne may not demen in my wit That such wrecches should been honourable And worth that worship though they have hy● That been there to unworthy & unable But if thou see a wise man & an able And hoelly all fulfilled with sapience wouldest thou dame that man as repreveable And as unworthy to that excellence Boecius) I said no (Phia) now certes thē● she These dygnytes belongeth properly Only to virtue & to honest And virtue shall transport them verily To which she is conjoined sewyngly And for as mychel as such reverence received of the people commonly Accords not always with conscience ¶ Ne to that honour wych that they receiven Ne may not make them worthy for to be Than may we clearly known & conceiven That honour hath in proper no bewte As even worthy to that dignity And most to this you awth to taken heed The more folk that despiseth them perdie The more abject they been it is no dread ¶ So than as dignity may not suffice To maken srewes worth no reverence But rather maketh that men them will despise Though they honour them in their presence yet they despise them in their conscience Theridamas dygnytes so maketh them to be know And clearly showeth to folks their offence Of whom they been despised as they own ¶ And this is not unponysshed sickerly For they revenge them on their dignity The which they have defouled wrecchedly As with their vice & their unhoneste But that thou might thyselfen know & see That very honour falls in no wise By such astates that transitory be Now understand what I the shall devise ¶ I suppose that a man of high renown That oft hath had the astate of consuler Should come a 'mong a strange nation That they ne known what astate he bore Trowest thou they would him honouren there For his astate thou wilt answer me nay But if honour in such astates were In kenned a proper thing/ than would I say ¶ There kendly office should they not forlete Though that he went unto the worlds end As fire ne may not cessen of his hete Vhyle that it fire is where that ever it wend But honour is no proper thing of kind To dignity/ but false opinion As nice men devyseth in their mind where fore a 'mong a strange nation ¶ That naught ne knoweth of that dignity He is honoured as another man In strange land thou sayst this may well be But look that land uher that astate be 'gan where that it should always his honour han Stands it always in his honour there But of the provostry what sayest thou than That uhylom was astate of high power ¶ Now is it no thing but an Idel name And loo the charge of senators rend Now at this day it standeth in the same Though that some time it was full reverent A man some time was held excellent That had the charge of vytayl in the town Thus up so down is the world ywent Now is it of no reputation ¶ As we have said a little here beforn A thing that hath no beauty properly Now hath it honour & now it hath forlorn After the use of men's fantasy sith dignity ne may not kendly Inducen very cause of reverence But oft it is defouled sickerly By them that useth it with insolence ¶ And if they now be fair & now not so As times have their transmutation And if their beauty thus them passeth fro After man's estymatyon what is there/ after your opinion Of beauty in them worthy to be sought sith that they been of such condytion How should they give that they ne haveth nought Metrum iiij. Capitulum viij. Quamuis se tirio. Phia loquitur. Though proud Nero with his lechery Clothed him with purpur tyryens And with full rich perry ryally Of life he was unthryfty & unclean That he was loathly every wight to seyn yet gave he seytes to the senators How shouldest thou trow them blysful for to be though that of wrecches taketh such honours Prosa u. Capitulum ix. An vero regna. Phia loquitur. But what trowest thou for to be a king Other with kings to been familiar wouldest thou hold it for a noble thing That may the make strong & mighty here Boecius) what else ꝙ I should I trow it were Phia) you ꝙ she when that their felicity Shall always stonden in his wealths clear And ever a bide in perdurabylyte ¶ But elder age of time that is y went Ensamples hath of great unstabelnesse And also of this time now present we see it proved every day express That kings falls fro their welfulnesse And unto very myschef been brought Owe/ clear & noble thing that renown is To save it seluen that sufficeth not ¶ For if that realms of such regalte And governance of lands long & wide May make a man to have felicity what if him lacketh aught in any side Than must his wealth some what slake & slide And myschef enter for unsnffysance And though it be so as it may betide That kings haveth in their governance ¶ Moche folk at their commandment yet shall we find many a nation That been to kings not obedient Ne haldeth them at no reputation Than here of ensueth this conclusion where faileth might that causeth blysfulnesse There is no mean in this division Vnmyght is there that causeth wrecchednesse ¶ There is none earthly king this dare I say That is so mighty in his governance But more there been that will him not obey Than be constrained at his ordinance In these his power lacketh suffysance And if that both/ his power & unmyght Should been counterpeysed in balance His unpower would be the more of wight ¶ sith wrecchednesse cometh of unpower As may not be withsaid by no reason And loo there is no king that leaveth here But his unmyght hath in proportion As for to make a just comparison well moche more than his power is Than will there ensuen this conclusion Loo that his more part is wrecchednesse ¶ A king there was that had experience Of great perel & often was in dread He made a man be set in his presence And made a sword to hang a 'bove his head Fastened by a little subtle thread That every man might wnderstand & see Loo break this thread than is this man but dead So stint a king always in juparde ¶ what is this power that nought may remewe The bitter biting of this business Ne the pricks may he not exchwe Of all this dread & all this heaviness These kings loo would leave in sykernesse But certainly they can not come there to And ever more they seek it as they guess And ever the far they been a way there fro ¶ But they reioycen mighty to be hold And wilt thou trow him mighty for to be That may not worken that he fainest would Or for to walken with a company Of mighty men that lusty been to see And at his bidding all a realm a rereth And yet himselfen standeth in this degree He dreadeth the same that he feareth ¶ And for he would mighty seem & strong He must put himselfen in danger As of the main which he is among And of his life he standeth in a where Or with a king to be familiar To what it shall a veil I can not sayen sith often is it showed a 'mong us here That kings of their main have be slain ¶ And often times is this shown express Of some that with kings haveth be nigh That these kings of their cruelness Haveth them put at myschef suddenly Some time stirred by malice & envy Of wicked folk that worse been than fendes And kings often standeth slyperly And if they fallen falls eke their friends ¶ For loo Nero that cursed emperor Made Seneca his own death devise That was his master & his governor And Antoninus in the same wise Papynyan that had him done service And a full mighty man had long been He made his knights full of cowardyse That with their swords all they should him slain ¶ And both ij. yet would they have been glad To have forlete their power utterly And Seneca loo all the good he had He would have given it Nero willingly And been exiled ever perpetuelly Forsaking all his occupation And so have lived solytaryly And led his life in contemplation ¶ But he that menteth downward for to go His own wight will draw him down in haste And therefore neither of them both to Ne might his purpose haven at last This power than that every man so fast Desireth thus/ what is it would I see sith he that hath it is there of aghast Honorio so will forlete it may not syker be ¶ And when thou wouldest it willingly forsake Loo at thy will thou mayst it not foregone And friends which that fortune doth the make And virtue not/ what profit may they done when lusty fortune forth is fro the gone Than all her friends with her goeth in fere A more perilous myschef is there none Than is thy foo wyththe familiar Metrum u Capitulum x. Qui se volet. Phia loquitur. ¶ Ho so desireth mighty for to be And of his foes to have the victory first his courage that is so fierce & keen He must repressen well & mightily So that the foul lust of lechery May have no manner mastery in his mind For though thou be so haught & so high That men the dreadeth in the land of Ind ¶ And eke the isle that ferrest is of all Out in the west that tile cleped is Be to the suget as thy bond thrall yet if thy foul dark business with sore complaints of thy wrecchednesse Thus in their bounds haldeth the so fast That thou ne might them voyden ne repress I say it is no power that thou hast Prosa uj. Capitulum xj. Gloria vero quam fallax. Phia loquitur. But high renown how full of vanity How foul it is & often deceivable As a tragedyens in his dyte Not causeless thus crieth in a fable Owe/ renown saith he false & variable To many a thousand of thine homagers In no thing else art thou commendable But as a wind that swelleth in their years ¶ For many one by false opinion Of nice folk have had a hugy name But certainly a foul confusion it is/ so falsely for to have a fame For needs return to them most shame when that they been commended wrongfully And though they have deserved yet that same what shall a wise man furdred be there by ¶ That meeteth not the measure of his meed By veyn rumour of folks audience But putteth all the meret of her deed In very virtue of their conscience And if thou hauled it for an excellence Thy noble renown for to be extended Than will it enswe even of consequence That thou were foul but if thou were commended ¶ But as I said a little here beforn That needs must be many a nation To which one man's name may not be born The which as in thine estymatyon A man of worship is & of renown Loo than as for the most quantity Of all this little worldly region He must needs unrenowned be ¶ I hauled it not full moche expedient Of comen people to be commendable That haveth no reason in their judgement For it is fleting & not perdurable They dyscord in dryth & moisture/ for fire is dry & air is mostey this dyscord letteth them for to meddle/ that everich keepeth his kendly place ¶ Also the air & the water accordeth in moisture/ & they dyscordeth in hete & cold. for air is hot & water cold. which discord lettethe them to meddle. water & earth accordeth in cold & dyscordeth in moisture & drythe/ for the earth is dry & the water moystey Fire & earth accordeth in drouthe so that the earth may not disjoin fro his place/ ne the fire fro his & they dyscord in cold & hete/ wherefore they may not meddle but everych keepeth his kendly place. Also the elements that of qualyteys been contrary/ he bindeth together by intermene elements according in qualyteys with both/ as fire & water that been very contrary in qualyteys/ been bound to gedres with air that is intermene according with fire in hete & with water in moisture. Earth and air been knet to gedres by water that is entermene according with earth in cold & with air in moisture. ¶ For clear understanding of this chapiter/ it is for to know that he that shall help another/ it needeth that he be mighty/ wise/ and well willed. For if a thing be asked of a man the which he may not do ne can not/ ne his will skylefully may not consent/ of very right he may deny it/ for no such thing aught to be asked. ¶ Therefore first he showeth the suffysance of god in might/ in asmuch as he governeth all the world/ not by great labour as creatures governeth/ but by perdurable reason. For sith he first set the world in governance the natural progression never varied/ but haldeth himself always in the first ordinance. Also in producing of creatures he showeth his benevolence & good will to all that is consonant to reason. In that he showeth that is to say In that he maketh the elements as seed & matter whereof been engendered all earthly things. And thus doth he not compelled of no foreyn cause as men been compelled/ but only of the habundance of his goodness▪ which is & ever was perfe●ly in himself/ the which goodness was so entensyfly habundant that it must needs of reason be extended by communion: ¶ Also he showeth the suffysance of his wisdom & cunning/ in as moche as all that ever was/ is/ or shall be her after/ it is open to him/ in his eternal exsampler or mitrour of his mind that all things comprehendeth presently at once. And sith so wisely produceth it in to his being/ not only in general/ but all parts in special absolutely without default or need of any exterior cause. And in this is showed the wisdom of god in as much as he is the formal cause of all thing as in exsampler. After that he hath showed the suffysance of god in might/ goodness/ & wisdom/ in governance of these things in special/ he commendeth the same suffysance in general in creation & governance of some other things of more deeper conceit of inward speculation/ in that he showeth & rehearseth the sotel knytting of the iiii. elements/ as is before said ¶ Furthermore also in creation of the mean spiret of triple kenned/ which some phylosophres as plato & his folders called anima mundi/ the soul of the world For cause that Plato saw his master Socrates empoysened & put to death for his sooth saying/ he would not dyscover his sotel conceits ne the preuy●es of nature to the rude people/ but put them under manner of parables & privy words which might enstore his wysedom unto the time that men would be better willed for to hire truth. The greeks at that time wor shypped the son & called him Apollo/ god of wysedom/ fantasing that he caused all other things to be. from which error socrates' dyssented & said that the son was a form creature/ wherefore he was slain as is be fore said. And before him Anaxagoras was exiled for the same cause. wherefore Plato left the cyte of Athenes & chose his habytation in a cyte or place named Acadencia. In which place was often times earth quakes. This place he chose be cause his disciples should ever leave in dread of their lives/ which dread should refrayn foul passions of flesly lusts/ & so for to a void the foul error of Epicurenes that did put the fulfelycyte of man in fleshly delight. ¶ Plato then speaking of the governance of the world in his book named Thimeus/ saith thus. ¶ God of the same & ever a hiding matter. & also of divers matter and variable/ meddled & made the third kende. Of the which he took first one part. sith two. sith three & after iiii. after viii. after ix. & after xxvii Of vyche he made the kende of this spyret or of this soul. And then he fulfilled the intervals of these numbers with mean proportions/ as here after doth appear. I dupla two. sesqueal●a three sesque●cia. three. dupla viii sesqueotaua ix. tripla xxvi● ¶ Then this renge thus draen a long he divided in two. parts of the which one should contain even numbers & proportions/ and the other odd/ so that the beginning of either should be I Then either of these numbers he brought in to compace/ & put the lass Circle wythyn the more. And the circle of the same nature that is to say of odd proportions he turned fro the right hand to the left hand. And the other of divers nature that is to say of even ꝓportions/ he turned fro the life hand to the right hand/ this may be perceived by this figure foloing diagram of the celestial sphere Primum mobile movetur motu uniformi ab oriente in occidentem. ¶ Sphere planetarum movea difformiter ab occidente in orientem. ¶ Inter numeros exterioris sphere est proportio equalis. ¶ Inter numeros interioris sphere est proportio inequalis. ¶ Fordermore Philosophia showeth her petitonn reasonable as to three things asked first he asked the knowledge of sovereign God. He asked also in this knowledge perseverance. And last he asked to be comforted by his sovereign light. ¶ first she assigneth a reason for this last petition/ where she saith thou art clernesse/ by which all things been beshened & cleared. For perseverance she assygneth the second reason & saith/ thou art peseable rest to the meek. Than assyneth she the third reason & saith the to behold it is the end to which man was made. For thou art beginner of all thou betest & conteynest all/ thou ledest us by natural inclination. thou art the path of the way of love by which we shall return to the. thou art all the bliss or heaven/ thou art the term & end of all our worldly labour/ we seeketh none other. ¶ The understanding of this sotel conceit is thus. where he saith this soul is meddled of the same matter & diverse/ he understandeth that the soul of the world was made of nature changeable & of nature unchangeable. Nature unchangeable he calleth the same/ And changeable he calleth diverse. The even numbers for asmuch as they may be divided in to even/ he calleth nature changeable: And the odd numbers that may not eveuly be divided/ he calleth nature unchangeable. ¶ Furthermore for to show that this soul is princyple of doblenesse/ that is to say of unyformyte that is in the first movable which is the sterred fitmament that clerks callen Primunr mobile/ And also of difformyte/ that is in the planets. he saith that god cut these numbers in two. parts. of the which one part contained odd numbers that longeth to uniformyte. And the other contained even numbers that pertaineth to difformyte/ by cause of his divisibilyte. And either of these parts he turned in to compass in sign of circular moving But the part of odd numbers he turned for the rygth hand to the left hand in sign of uniformyte in moving. And the other of even numbers/ he turned fro the lift hand to the right/ in sign of difformyte. The right hand of the world is the este/ the life hand the west/ the head is the south/ & the feet is the north. The moving of uniformyte he put to move fro este to west for so meveth the sterred sphere. The moving of difformyte/ he calleth the spears of the seven. planets/ which is moved fro west to the este. ¶ Also it is to considre that both these numbers of odd & even meeteth at one/ that is called unyte/ in sign of the onehed & the simplicite of god. at whom beginneth & endeth all creatures. upon hoos stableness is grounded every move/ upon hoos uniformyte/ all difforme & variable things been ryghted & reduced. ¶ Now then to the process & conceit of Boecius where he saith thus. Thou god knettest the mean soul that is the soul of the world of triple kenned that mevythe all thing. He calleth the soul of the world/ the spyret that next under god intendeth to the move & governance of the world/ which is mean be tuene the stabilyte of godhead & meveablenesse of creatures. Of triple kind. For first he is partner of the kende of angeles vithe been of uniform kende/ that is to say of simple nature/ pure/ & unmedled: which Plato calleth the same & ever a by●ynge matter/ that is to seyn of perdurable kende. The second part of his kende/ may be called the alliance to these earthly things. which been variable & corruptible & divers in there being. The third part of his kende/ is medlede of these both/ that is his alliance to the spheres of stars & of planets. which been in part movable & in part unmeveable. they be movable in their kendly course/ & unmeveable in continuance of their course & ●e●yng of the place & order which they were set in at their first creation. How he meveth all thing the letter showeth furthermore where he saeth. Resolving it in membres consonant/ that is to say/ departing his labour in to the move of all the viii. spheres of stars & of planets. Hoos moving though they be discordant in their course/ contrarious & divers in effects/ yet be they so consonant to gedres/ that none letteth but rather righteth & dresseth everych other. For the viii. sphere moving west ward ravesheth all the neither spheres & maketh them to move the same way/ where there natural move is estewarde. Also though the effects of the planets been divers yet there kendly course of moving is such that everych tempereth other so that there fall no confusion in this worldly governance ¶ Also this move he dyvydeth in to two. spheres or two. cercles as is afore said. by moving of which/ been governed the clements with all their transmutations & all other things under the moan. And he retorneth unto himself/ that is to say to there where he began for there is no perfect moving but in compace that always retornethe in to himself/ by which circular move or worching he atteyneth by similitude of natural perfection to the deep mind of divine intelligence which is the last end of nature simpliciter. withouten other And after this circular moving by form of like convenience he tornethe heaven & bout/ dressing the effects of all this moving after the sovereign exempler of the high purueance of god. Furthermore Boecius commendeth the might/ the goodness/ & the wisdom of god/ in making & governing of earthly things/ & specially in the disposing of man's soul uhee ●e saith in the text thus Thou avauncest or reysest souls & less lives of creatures & by evenly or like causes makest them able to lift carts. ¶ Vhen he hath sotelly treted of the soul of the world than goeth he to the soul of man & saith that in manner like as god hath made the soul of the world of three natures/ so hath he made the soul of man. For first he taketh a matter perdurable that is to say a nature immortal of the kende of angeles & joineth it to a nature changeable & corruptible/ that is the sensualyte driven of this corruptible f●eshe. And of these it▪ resulteth the third/ wiche is in part deadly be cause of he body & also be cause of his unstableness/ And in part undedly/ be cause of the perdurable nature of intelligence/ uhereof he is partner This soul is druyded in to two. compaces of the which one is of perdurable nature that is reason/ & meveth kendly fro the right hand to the left hand that is to say▪ he groundeth all his works upon virtue/ & so putteth them in perfect execution▪ But the other circle of sensualyte meveth in contrary for he groundeth all his works upon the flesh/ & so proceedeth in to vicious lusts. But the reason must ravyshe the sensualyte with him in to the way of virtue. or else must they both torn in to mischief And so though reason be stirred & distracted by error & rehellyon of sensualyte/ yet must he return in to himself/ beholding the excellence of his nature/ not resting there proudly with Lucifer/ but enserching & seeking by thought & devote prayer the de●e intelligence that is god. And there behold in the mirror of eternal wisdom what he aught to do. repressing with the fire of love all vicious mevynges. For why thou god haste made the soul able to high carts (that is to say) to be re●ed in heaven. ¶ Thou sowest in heaven and in earth. first he maketh the soul & puttethe it in to this earthly body/ there for to increase in meret and virtues. And sith when they been ripe/ he taketh 'em in to heaven: And how? For sooth the virtues that himself hath planted in the soul/ he himself no●ysheth them with ●yry beams of love/ And maketh them rypen in to full ●rute/ and so return up to him fro whennes they took there being. Prosa x. Capitulum nineteeen. Quoniam igitur. Phia loquitur. FOr as moche as thou hast seyn in this which is imperfet good & to eschwe The form of good also that perfect is The which that is to seken & to sue from heavens forth our process to pursue it is to shown as it seemeth me The very good that perfect is & true what thing it is & where it might be ¶ But first I hold it needful to enquere if such thing may been in any kende As we be forn dyffyned have while ere Jest so be that in vain our wits wend And jest we be deceived at the end As by a false Imagination Of thing that naught is form in our mind And so to lose our occupation ¶ But that we save our purpose hole & sound That perfect good is/ no wight may wythsayn The which is in manner the well & ground Of all good that is/ thou be certain There may no wight replyen there again if any thing have imperfection That is be cause it is not full ne pleyn with perfect thing as in comparison ¶ For why in any general of kende where any thing imparfet is/ say I A perfect thing also there mayst thou find For if there were no perfect utterly sith lack of perfect is the cause why That any thing imperfet may be proved A perfect thing there must be sickerly from which imperfet things be dyscryned ¶ For why of things scars & dymynute Nature took not her first production But all hole complete & absolute Fro all defaute & all corruption And so fro thence made progressyon un to these lower things that we seyn That less havethe of perfection And as it were all void & empty been ¶ And if so be/ as I have showed ere this Theridamas is an imperfet felicity Of frayel & feeble good/ full sooth it is Another good & perfect must there be Boecius) Full sooth is this ꝙ I as seemeth me Concluded also full & fermly Phia) But now she said thou must behold & see where that this good is founden finally ¶ The comen conceit loo of man's mind By reason is unto this point y brought That god/ that prince & auctor is of kende Himself is good/ in this they faileth nought sith that there may no better thing be thought Than god himself/ this wot well every wight That god is good & worthy to be sought This doutethe none that reason saith a right ¶ yet reason will inducen furthermore By very forhis that in god perfetly Is very good/ in no wight may be more He were not else called ryghteusly The prince of things/ I shall the tellen why For else one were worthier than he That perfect good possessed principally That rather must & also elder be ¶ For every thing that fully is perfect Than any thing imperfet rather is Now jest our process pass in infynyt we be compelled for to graunten this That sovereign god of perfect good y wys Loo is fulfilled/ than suethe here upon sith perfect good is very blysfulnesse In god is perfect blysfulnesse alone Boecius) Full well ꝙ I this I perceive & feel There may no wight replyen here again Phia) I pray the ꝙ she understand me weal How fermly is proved that we sayen Loo/ that of perfect good & sovereign God is fulfilled by my conclusion Boecius) In sooth ꝙ I this would I hearen fain How you it prove by demonstration Phia) That self ꝙ she that is the prince of all And full of sovereign good how seemeth the That fro wythouten this good is fall Or is it in 'em by kendly property And thinkest that two. things must they be God/ the haver/ & his blysfulnesse And in their substance have diversity This wilt thou not supposen as I guess ¶ And if he have received of without This blysfulnesse/ then suethe sickerly The giver of that thing/ is no doubt Precelleth the receiver certainly But this we must confessen utterly A bow all things god is excellent And if this good in god be kendly In substance & in reason dyfferent ¶ The prince of things which that we rehearse Let se devise or fain it ho so may Honorio hath conjoined these ij. diverse He may no further by no manner way But at last this dare I soothly say A thing that divers fro another is it may not be the same it is no nay Fro which it is dyversed so ywis ¶ wherefore that thing that hath diversity Fro sovereign good/ in reason of nature The same sovereign good it may not be And god forbid that any creature As in his wit should passen so measure Of god our sovereign for to dame so That keepeth all & hath us in his cure So perfect & so good there beth no more ¶ Loo this I trow perceiveth every man That the kenned of no thing utterly May better been than he that it be 'gan Than may I thus concluden finally That he that is beginner verily Of all thing that is/ I say that he In substance & in kende properly This sovereign good he must needs be Boecius) This is ꝙ I concluded well & clear Phia) And sovereign good ꝙ she is blysfulnesse Boecius) Right so ꝙ I this granted I while ere Phia) Lo than ꝙ she it suethe here express That god himself is sovereign blysfulnesse Loo where it is that thou so long hast sought Boecius) This must I ꝙ I grant & confess your reasons have me to that point brought ¶ Phia) That this ꝙ she be proved fermly Behold & here what I shall further sayen ij. things that been divers properly They may not be ij. goods sovereign For if there be dyscord between them twain They may not been the self & the same Euerych that other is/ thou be certain though that they both be called on by name ¶ if they be sovereign goods both ij. devise it in his conceit ho so may if that this one good be that other fro Imperfet been they both it is no nay sith neither been wythouten other may But thing that lacketh of perfection That it be sovereign good thou wilt not say it would includen contradiction ¶ Then may they not be ij. thus ne diverse This sovereign good as sueth here express But blysfulnesse & god that we rehearse This sovereign good in all wise it is That same thing that than is blysfulnesse That same thing is sovereign deyte Boecius) No thing ꝙ I may truer be I guess Ne worthier of god concluded be Phia) Than right ꝙ she as geometres all when they have showed their propositions They bringeth in Porismus/ that they call That been conceits or conclusyons And as in manner declarations Of foresaid thing/ right so shall I the fede As suing on my demonstrations This correlary I give the to thy meed ¶ sith that by getting of this blysfulnesse Men been blysful made/ & wilt thou see Blysfulnesse the sovereign godhead is And eke the getting of that deyte Maketh blysful/ as it is showed to the But right as wisdom maketh men be wise And ryghtuosnesse righteous for to be I may conclude & suyngly devise ¶ That by winning of divinity Men been maked gods sickerly Loo than is every blysful man pard A god/ this suethe also formally Though that there be but one god kendly In sooth yet by participation Right well there may be many/ not for thy As in the astate of full perfectyon ¶ Boecius) This is ꝙ I full fair & precious whether it porysme or corrolary is Phia) it is ꝙ she more fair & glorious That reason will annecten unto this Boeus) I asked what Phia) ꝙ she sith blysfulnesse So moche thing doth in it self contain As honour/ power/ lust/ fame/ & richesse whether all they been as membres will thou sayen ¶ which as of parts divers in manner This blysfulnesse compoundeth in this wise In to a perfect body as it were Other thou trowest that some one thing of these The same blysfulnesse doth a complesse In to one perfect thing substantial To whom these other as I do devise Referred been as to their pryncypal ¶ Boecius) I would have this ꝙ I declared fain Phia) Have we not said ꝙ she that blysfulnesse Is good (Boeus) yes said I/ high & sovereign Phia) Add we ꝙ she the remanent un to this That sovereign good before rehearsed is Loo sovereign might & sovereign suffysance Lust/ fame/ honour/ one thing they been ywis with blysfulnesse wythouten varyance ¶ This is that I would asken ere of the This suffysance/ honour/ delight/ renown whether they be membres of felicity As divers parts doth one thing compoune Or thou hast this consideration That all these which that we rehearsed han To sovereign good should have relation As to their head/ this say me if thou can Boecius) In sooth ꝙ I now understand I weal what you pnrposeth to enserchen here But I desire to here of you & feel This question that you would make it clear Phia) I shall ꝙ she said in this manner if all these things which that we rehearse Of blysfulnesse in manner membres were Than must these membres needs be divers ¶ For loo of parts this the nature is That they divers one body certainly Shall make/ but it is showed ere this That all these been one thing Boecius) you ꝙ I Phia) They been ꝙ she no membres sickerly sith they been one/ or else would it sue That blysfulnesse were made full wonderly Of a member that nature would exchwe Boeus) This is ꝙ I full sooth I doubt it nought But now full fain the remanent would I see Phia) Than all these things ꝙ she must be brought And to this good as chief referred be And for this good full sooth it is pard Men desiren after suffysance To have power or stand in high degree For it is good they maketh purueyance ¶ The same I may devysen suyngly Of reverence/ renown/ & lustynesse They dame it good that is the cause why That they require it with their business Than is this good the very cause y wysse And some of all that aught to be required For thing that no good hath in lekelynesse Ne none in sooth/ it may not be desired ¶ And there again loo in contrary wise A thing that is not good in no manner yet if it seemeth good as they devise Right as they very right goods were Men willeth them/ than will it suen here That bounte is the ground & cause of all why things aught to be leave & dear That any man of right desiren shall ¶ And over this it seemeth furthermore That every thing that is the cause why Loo that another is desired fore That cause is eke desired principally Right as be cause of he'll finally A man desireth for to ride & play His hele he doth desiren sekerly As well as for to ride it is no nay ¶ sith all this thing that thus desired is The cause of all is pryncypal/ bounte This bounte is desired than y wys As moche as that thing in his degree But we have granted that felicity is 'cause these things everichone Desired been/ then sueth it pard That blysfulnesse desired is alone ¶ Of this it seemeth & it suethe loo That then this good & very blysfulnesse In substance been one thing & no more And verily the same thing express Boecius) I can not say ꝙ I in sothfastnesse How any wight your words may blame Phia) But god ꝙ she & very blysfulnesse As we have showed been one thing & the same Boecius) Right as you sayen ꝙ I it is full clear Phia) Than may I ꝙ she well & sickerly The sentence & the some of this matter Loo thus concluden full & finally That the substance loo of god on high Is set & founded in none other place But in the same good eternally To find it there god sand the grace Metrum x. Capitulum xx. Huc oens pariter venite. Phia loquitur. How cometh all you that been y brought In bounds full of bitter business Of earthly lust a biding in your thought Here is the rest of all your business Here is the port of peace & restfulnesse To them that standeth in storms of desese Only refuge to wrecches in distress And all comfort of myschef & mysese ¶ For all that ever Tagus ¶ Tagus is a river of Spayn/ full of golden greynes. doth you bede with his golden gravel stones bright Other Erinus ¶ Erinus is a river in Asya the less/ all full of greynes of gold. with his stronds rede May given you for to please your sight Other the river which that Indus Indus is a river of India/ that rennethe in to the read see/ full of perry and moche precyousty. height That is full nigh the hot region which the green stones with his might with white perelles torneth up so down ¶ They shineth wonder clear unto your you But your insyght in sooth they maketh blind And with their dark clouds perylously with vanity your hearts doth they bind For how that ever they plesith to your mind As praised worth full many a thousand pound yet been they full unworthy in there kenned As noreshed in the caves of the ground ¶ But the shining of that sovereign light By which the high heaven governed is Chaseth a way the foul dark night That hath your souls drawn all a miss This sovereign light if thou may say ywis Behold it well & keep it if thou con And thou shalt see that in regard of this There be no bright beams in the son Prosa xj. Eapitulum xxj. Assencior inquam. Boecius loquitu TO this ꝙ I/ I must needs assen● your words haveth me knet so fermly By reason of your subtel argument Phia) what if thou known ꝙ she verily This good/ what wouldest thou than set there by if thou might known clearly what it were Boecius) I would it prese at infinite ꝙ I If I might known god in that manner Phia/ I shall ꝙ she as very reasonable Show the that apertly oer thou go So that these things stand farm & stable That we be fore this have consented to Boecius) They must ꝙ I we may not go there fro Phia) Have I not showed the plenerly ꝙ she That all these things that been desired so Of fell folk been full of vanity ¶ And sith they been divers it is no nay They be no very goods perfetly For when that one fro other is a way No full ne very goods utterly To no wight may they bring certainly But when they been assembled in to one In working & in form verily Than is it good & else is it none ¶ So that this power & this suffysance Gladsomeness/ honour/ & nobelte Be right the same & one thing in substance And if they lacketh of this unity There is not why they should desired be Ne loved/ if you do look well a bout Boecius) while ere ꝙ I thus have you showed ꝑde Full true it is it may not been in doubt ¶ sith so it is that good be they naught when diversity is founden them between Andrea when that they to onehed been y brought Than be they good as every man may seyne what is that maketh them good for to been But the getting of this unity Boecius Right so it is ꝙ I right as you mean Phia) But every thing that good is then ꝙ she ¶ why is it good/ wilt thou not graunten this That for it hath partycypatyon Loo of this foresaid good (Boecius) I said eyes Phia) Than must thou ꝙ she by the same reason Grant also this conclusion That good & one been one thing verily For things lekely of condytyon Not divers in effects kendly ¶ In substance been they one thing & no more Boecius) Fro this ꝙ I y may not go a side Phia) And knowest thou not that every thing also That is ꝙ she/ so long shall a bide while it is one/ & if it so betide That this thing forleteth to be one Is it not then dyssolued & destroyed Boecius) And how ꝙ I Phia) I shall the tell anon ¶ Thou sayst thyself that in a best ꝙ she while soul & body been together knet And so abideth in their unity This knowest thou well a best men calleth it But when this onehed is divided As by their bothes separation That no best it is/ it is perceived But careyn torning to corruption ¶ And eke also the body of a wight while that the membres standeth kendly On/ in that form that nature hath them dight He is a man this knowest thou verily But if they been departed sickerly So that this unity be done a way That same thing it is not utterly Ne no man's body the sooth to say ¶ And in the same wise it stint y wys Of every thing to thynken in thy thought The while it standeth one/ that while it is And when it faileth one than is it nought For it is to corruption brought Boecius) In sooth ꝙ I I can not other find Of every creature that may be sought This must be sooth by very course of kende Phia) But wilt thou trow that any thing ꝙ she Hath this of natural intention As to forleten utterly to be And lust to torn in to corruption Boecius) To have ꝙ I consideration To bests which that haveth of nature Both will & nel by fire election I will not trow it of no creature ¶ That but they be constrained of without There kendly being will they not foregone Ne willingly be dead it is no doubt Therefore it is that bests everichone Loo all their labour setteth here upon Them selfen for to save & keep in hele And willingly to death there willeth none I note ho is/ with death that lust to deal ¶ But nevertheless as yet I am in doubt Of trees & eke of herbs & of grass And stone that utterly is live without Phia) There is naught why to douten in this case sith thou mayst see ꝙ she be fore thy face And every day thou hast experience That trees & herbs wexyth in that place As to there kenned is most convenience ¶ So that asmuch as their nature sufficeth They suffereth not to schorchen ne to die For some of them in fair fields riseth And some wexyth in the hills high And some doth in marreys' multyply And some to the hard roches clyngeth And some there be that in the sands dry That bareyn been full plenteously springeth ¶ And if a wight that nought there kendes knoweth would elleswhere them plant they die as fast For nature giveth to everych that him oweth And laboureth that as long as they may lest That they be not destroyed ne down cast Now & what sayest thou of their chevysance As though their mouths were in earth y thraste So by the rote they draw their sustenance ¶ And so the kendly moisture after this In to the stock & rind it sendeth wide And yet this moisture that most tender is wythynforth always it doth a bide again the wedres hard/ it self to hide wythouten hath it sadness of the tree wythouten that the bark on every side That may defence a geynst the wedres be ¶ Here mayst thou well behold & taken hide Loo how nature intendeth busily Every thing to nory hen by his seed That year by year doth cress & multyply Not only for a time sickerly But they been subtle gins as it were That it may stonden perdurabelly By generation in that manner ¶ And things that without souls been also Doth they not everych busily intend To that his nature aperteyneth to why else doth a flame of fire ascend Or why doth heavy earth so descend But for that everych hath convenience To certain place to which as to their end They meveth/ so they have no resistance ¶ For every thing intendeth sickerly As ferforthe as it may have suffysance though things to conseruen busily with which it hath in kenned his accordance Right even as thing that of contraryance Albina that they may corrupteth & destroyeth Right so have they there kendly governance For to exchwe all thing that them noyeth ¶ And stones that so hard & strong been How they wythstandeth their partytion And clyngeth fast as every man may say To save the parts fro corruption And things that so floeth up & down air & water parteth esely By violence/ fro which division To onehed they retorneth kendly ¶ But fire all such division refuseth Of wilful moving of the soul I let To speak as now/ in that he reason useth But of the natural intent I trete That when you do receiven so your meet you swoloeth & haveth thereon no thought And in your sleep when all thing is forget you draweth breath & yet you know it nought ¶ Not only of the soul's wylfulnesse These bests loveth to leave & endure But principally dependeth it express Of the high pryncyples of nature For oft it falls that a creature His own death will taken willingly where needful causes been peradventure The which that nature aborreth kendly ¶ you seethe also that in contrary wise The will of man wythstandeth & refraineth The lust of very kendly covetise By which all only nature hath ordained That deadly kenned to keep & be sustained The which is flesly generation so that this love is not only contained principally in your bestly motion ¶ But also of intention natural For why the sovereign god's purueance Hath given this as 'cause effectual To things that been of his ordinance That by a very kendly governance They shall desyren always for to be As long as nature hath that sufffysance To keep she parts in their unity ¶ There is nought why thou shouldest doubt in this But that all thing coveteth kendly To keep it self in firm stableness And to be corrupt they lothen utterly Boeus) Loo now must I confess this ꝙ I For things that in doubt were before Now I behold them well & certainly Phia) And thing that so desireth evermore ¶ For to stand in firm stableness That self thing desireth for to be And if this one be voided sooth it is Then is it not/ thou mayst thyselfen see Boecius) Full sooth ꝙ Phia) then all thing ꝙ she Desireth one Boecius) ꝙ I I grant it well Phia) But one & good as thou hast granted me Loo be the same & divers near a deal Boeus) Right so ꝙ Phia) them all thing requireth This one ꝙ she that thus may be described Good is that thing that all thing desireth Boecius) No thing ꝙ I may sother be contrived All thing to nought must else be derived As flowing ever wythouten governor As destitute & of their head deprived Than were our end but myschef & dolour ¶ And if there may be founden there again One thing to whom all other been intended Of all good this must be sovereign As he that all hath in him comprehended Phia) This conceit ꝙ she may not been amended My nory dear now am I glad y wys The point now of thy thought thou hast extended Right in the mids of very sothfastnesse ¶ And loo in this is showed the plenerly The thing which whyler thou toldest me Thou known it not Boecius) & what is that ꝙ I Phia) what is the end of things said she This same thing loo must it needs be That every thing of kenned desiren shall And sith that this is good it seemeth me That sovereign good must be the end of all Metrun xj. Capitulum xxij. Quisquis profunda. Phia loquitur. NOT so will ensearch sothfastnesse a right And will not be deceived never a deal The pure clearness of his inward sight wythyn hem self he must revoluen weal And all his thoughts trenden as a wheel And leave this earthly occupation And teach his soul to understand & feel By doom of good delyberation ¶ That all that ever he seeketh here without Travelling these truths for to know Hid it was all close it is no doubt Right as treasure wythyn hemself bestow though things than that erst were overblow with the clouds of error & ignorance it shall to the be clearer as I trow Than is the son & more to thy plesance ¶ For why the body that hath that soul oppressed As with the wight of his corruption Hath not all despoiled ne dystressed The light of understanding & of reason Theridamas cleaveth yet a noble portion wythyn thy soul right as an abylyte The seed of truth in full possession The which by teaching must enforced be ¶ How might you else jugen formally Other answer to demands that you hire But if your heart contained verily A lyfly nourishing as it were And thing that Plato said in this manner if it be sooth as do his books trete no thing else do you when you lere But as record a thing that was forget ¶ Not thing else do you when you lere & ●. ¶ An harp well & lustily ●uned by true accords of music/ all be it in that no wight toche it ne set hand there to/ yet containeth that harp wythyn hem all songs ● all twes possible to be song or toched upon the same harp. Or else might not the harper find there on that was not there be fore Right so in man's soul is contained all conny●ge/ that of an earthly creature possible is be known. But it is slylled & in manner forget/ other more properly for to speaken/ forlete/ which cunning by labour of reason & exercise of learning is found out by little & little. right as a man that learneth to harp seeketh out his tunes. Prosa twelve. Capitulum twenty-three. Tum ego platoni. Boecius loquitur. TO Plato said I/ must I need consent For twice now you have remembered me Of thing that first was fro my mind y went As by my bodily contagyouste And sith I stood eftesone in this degree Of heaviness/ I had it eke forlorn Phia) if thou she said wilt behold & see To things of the granted here be forn ¶ Thou shalt record also to thy science Things which thou said whyler thou knwe it nought Boeus) & what ꝙ I Phia) by wych governments This world ꝙ she is in this rule brought Boecius) I am ꝙ I remembered in my thought Of mine uncunning that I was beknowe And though I have as now perceived aught Moore plenerly yet would I lern of you ¶ Phia) while ere ꝙ she thou dowted noft at all Loo that this world by god governed is Boecius) Ne now ꝙ I ne never hereafter shall As in that matter been in doubt ywis And what reason induceth me to this Briefly I shall you show/ as seemeth me Now look yourself if I perceive a miss This world ꝙ I stonding in this degree ¶ Of parts divers & contraryous As every wight may understand & feel In such a form might never accorden this Butt if that one conjoined every deal That so divers been/ this wot I well Ne so conjoined might they not endure But if one keeper were perpetuel The same diversity of their nature ¶ So dyscordant should apeyr & shende And all disjoin as seemeth in my thought But if there were one governor of kende To keep all this that is to gedres brought Ne such a certain order might not Of nature/ so proceed in ordinance To meven so/ but he that all hath wrought Should have it holly in his governance ¶ There moving is so fair & ordynat In times/ steeds/ space/ & quality And such effects causeth eke algate That wondered it is/ every wight to see Than is there one that this diversity Him selfen stable that so dysposeth all And ho so doth all this/ I say that he Is god/ this used name I will 'em call Phia) sith thou ꝙ she mayst this behold & feel I trow I shall with little business Full hole & sound the make to see full weal Thine own country full of blysfulnesse But that we have purposed her ere this Let us behold/ have we not long a go said that suffysance is in blysfulnesse And that god is blysfulnesse also Boeus) Right so ꝙ I phia) & that him needeth nought ꝙ she unto this worldly governance For if he of without needed aught He had not then plenary suffysance Boecius) Fro this ꝙ I there is no varyance Phia) Himself alone all thing dysposeth than Boecius) I may ꝙ I now make none avoydaunce Phia) And god is good as we deduced han ¶ Boeus) And this also remember I well ꝙ I Phia) By good than he governeth all ꝙ she For sith as thou hast granted/ suyngly He that is good dysposeth all pard Himself alone than must he needs be Right as it were a ruler of a stern Hym selfen stable ever in one degree That all this world incorrupt doth govern Boecius) Full well ꝙ I accord I unto this And loo whyler as by suspection I trowed the same you would have said y wys And proved this in your conclusion Phia) I trow it well/ for thine inspection Is more ententyf then it was before As to behold a truth & good reason But that I shall the shown furthermore ¶ it is as clear & open to thy sight Boeus) And what ꝙ I that known fain I would Phia) sith god ꝙ she if we believed right with his stern of bounte as I told Governeth all & rewleth as he should These things all by natural intent Ben willingly subject & underfolde Obeing always unto his government ¶ Boecius) This is ꝙ I full true & necessary For else were no blysful governance if no yoke were to things contrary That will not obey to his ordinance Phia) Then is there nought that doth their observance To keep themself in order of nature That may enforcen with contraryance again there god Boecius) ꝙ I no creature ¶ Phia) what if so that again this governayle They might enforcen them with frowardness Might they aught again their god avail wych that by right of very blysfulnesse As we be forn have said almighty is Boeus) In sooth they might nought avail ꝙ I Phia) ꝙ she then is there no thing as I guess That may or will wythstanden kendly ¶ This sovereign good what wilt thyself suppose Boeus) I said no Phia) this sovereign good ꝙ she All things than full sweetly doth dispose And mightily all thing governeth he Boecius) ꝙ I not only I delight me As in the sum of your conclusion But the words wych that you use to me well more they doth me delectation ¶ In so far forth that in myself I shame And of my folly foul I am confused So high a thing to reprehend or blame And that I have so masedlych y mused That man of god was utterly refused And that he had him not in his governance Phia) Such fables ꝙ she have poetes used As thou hast heard/ that some time giants ¶ would have made their way up in to heaven And high hills 'gan they to bylden fast But god sent down a thunder certain And all their work upon them over cast And so they were wythstonden at last By the might of sovereign god benign which for them all disposed so in haste As their dysert was worthy & condign ¶ But wilt thou now that we to gedres drive Thesresons all & in to one them bring And peradventure of that stroke as belive Theridamas may of truth a little sparkle spring Boecius) Now saith ꝙ I as is to your leking Phia) we say ꝙ she that god almighty is Boecius) sith he of all ꝙ I is lord & king There is no wight that is in doubt of this ¶ Phia) And he she said that is so full of might Is their any thing that he ne may Boeus) Nay ꝙ I Phia) ꝙ she now say me right May god do any evil Boecius) I said nay Phia) Loo than is evil no thing I dare well say sith he that is almighty may it not Boecius) ꝙ I whether do you scorn or else play And have to this labour it brought ¶ your reasons weaveth you so wonderly In manner like the house of Didalus Full hard for to resoluen or unplye your reasons been so high & curious that to my wit they been full marvelous Where you go out you entereth eft a none And even there as you been entered thus The same way you passeth out eft soon ¶ A wonder compace have yo knet & fold Of the high divine ymplycyte For thus while oer when you began you told Of blysfulnesse that is felicity That sovereign good was it you said to me And that also in sovereign good it is That god was sovereign good than said you Also that he is perfect blysfulnesse ¶ And for a gift you took me this there to That no wight might have very blysfulnesse But if he were in manner god also By lekelynesse of possessing of his bliss And furthermore also you said this That the form of very perfect good it is the substance of this welfulnesse And eke of god/ loo this I understand ¶ you said also as unto my conceit That good & one all one thing should they be That every kende of things must covet That god eke with the stern of his bounte Governeth all this hole university And all must to his governance a lout That evil is no thing/ also proved you Not seeking hereto reasons fro without ¶ But you have this enplyed & preved By skyles that been known openly And everych maketh other to be believed They knetteth so in compace sotelly Phia) She said than I play not sickerly But that we have whyler of god besoght Now have I showed the here that is so high And greteste that in heart may be thought ¶ For of substance divine the form is this That he may not augment ne decresse By no foreyn thing the so the it is And all yet he containeth never the less But right as said Perymenydes The round wheel of things all a bout He meveth/ yet himself is in piece And meveth nought at all it is no doubt ¶ if I have showed the skyles good & meet Not fro wythouten sought/ but verily wythyn the things whereof that we trete To wonder now thou hast no cause why For thou hast herd & read as suppose I This sothfaste sentence/ Plato said it loo That words must be cousins kendly To things which they been referred to Full blysful is that man that may behold The bright well of very blysfulnesse And well is him that may himself unfold from bounds of this worldly wrecchednesse The poet Orpheus with great heaviness His wyffes death had weyled wepyngly And with his songs full of carefulness Made woods for to run full wonderly ¶ And made the streams standen & bide The hind also feared of no perel But suffered the lion to lie by her side neither the hare dreaded near a deal To see the hound/ it leked them so weal To here these songs that so lusty were And boldly they durst together dwell That near a best then had of other fere ¶ And when the love 'gan kendle in his breast Of his wyffe most hot & fervently His song that had so many a wild best Made so meek to leaven commonly They might him not conforten utterly On high gods 'gan he then complain And said they deled with him cruelly That they did sand him not his wyffe again ¶ He went then to houses infernal And fast his strenges there dressed he And souned out the sweet songs all That he had tasted of the wells three Of his mother dear Calliope That is goddess & chief of eloquenc● With words that most pyteoust myghe be As sorrow had given him full experience ¶ And love also that dobeleth heaviness To hell began he his complaint to make asking mercy there/ with lowliness At the lords of these shadous black And Cerberus that woned was to wake with heads three & hell gates keep So hadden him these new songs take That the sweetness made him fall on sleep ¶ The furies that been vengeresse of sin And surfetours smiteth so with fere For heaviness that this man was in They 'gan to morn & wept many a tere And though the swift while had no power To torn a bout the head of Ixyon Ne Tantalus for thirst all though he were I peyned long/ yet water would he none ¶ The gripe that eat the maw of Ticius And tired on it long there be fore This song to him was so delycyous He cast it of & tired it no more And when that Orpheus had mourned sore though said the juge of hell/ pains strong Pyte me hath convict/ I will restore This man his wyffe/ this wone he with his song ¶ But with a law this geft I will restrayn That unto he this bounds have forsake if he behold upon his wyffe again His wyffe fro him eftsoons shall be take But ho to lovers may a law make For love is rather to hemself a law when he was nigh out of the bounds black He turned him & Erudis he saw ¶ Alas he lost & lest his wyffe behind This fable loo to you pertaineth right For you that would lift up your mind In to the high blysful sovereign light if you eftsoons torn dove your sight In to this foul wrecched earthly delle Loo all that ever your labour hath you dight you loose when you looketh in to hell ¶ As Duyde in his book of Metamorphoseos maketh mention/ and feigning in manet a fable saying that Orpheus was a curious harper dwelling in Trace/ that was sometime a province in the north side of Grece. which Orpheus was the son of Callyope. He harped so lustily/ that not only men were drawn by his melody/ but also wild bests for very delight forget there kendly courage of fersnesse. And not only this/ but he made rivers for to stand & forestes for to move & ten ¶ This Orpheus had a wife named Erudis/ which a shepherd named Aristeus wooed & desired. But Erudis refusing his love fled thorgh a meed/ & treding upon a serpent she was enuenemed & dead. & went to hell. Orpheus' soroing for his wife & willing for to draw her out of hell/ purposed for to please the high gods with his melody that they should restore him his wife/ but it availed not. Than went he to hell/ & as this process showeth in the letter/ so moche he pleased the gods of hell with his melody/ that at last upon a condition his wife was granted him/ so that he looked not upon her/ till that he were passed the bounds of hell. But when he was nigh the bounds/ so moche he desired for to see his his wife/ that he turned him & looked upon her/ & a none she was gone again to hell where she was before▪ This fable Fulgencius exponeth morally on this uhyse. ¶ By Orpheus is understand the higher part of the soul/ that is resonabelte/ informed with wisdom & eloquence. wherefore he is called the son of phoebus' & of Laliope Phoebus of the greeks was called god of wysedom. The same is Apollo. Calliope is asmuch to say/ as god's son. & it betokeneth eloquence. so every wise man & eloquent in this manner of speaking may be called the sorne of phoebus' & Calliope. ¶ This Orpheus bythe sweetness of his harp/ that Explicit Liber tercius. Liber Quartus. But though that haveth might to worken ill They may not worken all that is their will ¶ Then is it plain & clear enough to seyn These wicked men that wyckedlych may Full less of power & of might they been Set this there to that I shall after say sith might is such a thing the which always Aught to be coveted & desired And every thing that is to be required ¶ To good it must be referred need As to the sovereign head & pryncypal But power for to worken wrecchedhed To good may not referred been at all it is nought then/ that be desired shall But power shall desired be by right Than power of the wicked is no might ¶ Loo of all this it will apperens well That mighty been the good folk alone And wicked folk be mighty never a deal But week & myghtles been they everichone The sentence than may be perceved soon where that Plato writeth in this wise Do that them liketh only may the wise ¶ For wicked men do works that them lust But their desire they may not yet fulfil what them delighteth that them seemeth best For why they do it be it never so ill To their desire yet may they not a till The which they seek in lusts & delights For blysfulnesse may not be had by vice Metrum ij. Capitulum iiij. Quos vides sedere celsos. Phia loquitur. These great kings full of cruelty Shining in their purpur ryally sitting in the heythes of there see with wild words threating cruelly with blasting woodness of their hearts high with moche wrecched weeping by their side Ho so would fro these princes full of pride ¶ Spoil them of their wrecched vain a ray Behold & see well what they be wythyn Though they be lords wonder stout & gay In streyt chains been they bond of sin Fro which they may not themselfen win These loo leadeth his life in lechery That all the world him speaketh velony ¶ So is he troubled by this passion with wretch his mind is beaten & oppressed Or heaviness draeth him a down Or slyper hope him else hath distressed Loo such an head I trow is evil y blessed That is encumbered with so moche vice His might is to be set at little price Prosa iij. Capitulum u. Vides ne igitur. Phia loquitur. ANd sayst thou not the foul vicious what filth them hath defiled & unhyght And the good folk & virtuous How worthily they shine fair & bright Of this it may apperens to thy sight That the wicked folk faileth never of peyn Ne the good folk their meed there again ¶ That same thing that meveth any wight For to done or worken any deed That same thing I may it seyn by right Loo of that work it is the very meed This shall I prove if thou wilt taken hide For running lieth a garland for the game And he that runneth best shall have the same ¶ But sovereign good is very blysfulnesse And is the very ground & cause why That any manner work purposed is As for to speak of purpose kendly Than is this good purposed commonly For man's work a meed for his travail Fro good men this meed may not fail ¶ Ho so lacketh good as seemeth in my thought Be called good of right yet may not he The good then of meed faileth nought sith their meed is verily bounty Though wicked folk be wood in cruelty And useth all the malice that they mown yet the wise man loseth not his crowen ¶ For why there is no foreyn wickedness Of men that been so perilous & proute That may bereave the kendly worthiness That longeth to the good/ it is no doubt But if they had it wonnen of without another then might it take a way Or he that gave that good/ it is no nay ¶ But sith the goodness of a worthy wight Of good manners must be caused need when he forleteth them/ then is it right That he should be despoiled of his meed But finally in this matter to proceed sith all medes that desired been it is for they been good/ or as they ween ¶ Of him that hath this good ho will it seyn That he this meed lacketh utterly None that reason hath I am certain But what thing is this meed verily The best thing & fairest sekerly That may be had or heart may devise This is it that is disposed for the wise ¶ A Corrolary high & precious That I the gave whyler remember the which all in sum thou shalt assemble thus Loo sith that god is this felicity which that maketh blysful for to be All though that good works usen And wrecched vice will utterly refusen ¶ And though that blysful been thou understand In a manner gods that they were Than is this gift the meed of all good That no day may consume in no manner Ne dymynuce it may no power Ne dymmen it no other man's vice Though wicked folk it would of their malice ¶ sith it is so it is wythouten dread The wicked may not be wythouten peyn For sith that evil & good/ loo pain & meed Contraryous been/ then is it clear & pleyn sith good is sure of meed in full certain The bad is sure of pains & of woe if one be sooth the other must also ¶ Then is the goodness of the good wight The reward & the meed of his goodness And to the wicked by the same right Theridamas peyn is eke there proper wickedness what ever he be/ than sueth it express That with such pains is he desesed oft with evil he is infect it faileth nought ¶ For if the wicked would themselfen seyn Might they trowen as it seemeth the That they wythouten bitter pains been whom loo the uttermost extremyte Of all wickedness & cruelty Not only hath infected grievously But eke him hath infected hugely ¶ But now behold that other part upon if any pains have the good a grieved Hast thou not learned/ that all that ever is one Is good also/ as I have it described Loo consequently than it may be proved As seemeth well that every thing that is it must also be good it is no miss ¶ I may concluden than that all though That faileth fro this good rehearsed here He faileth then for to be also The wicked than they be not that they were For thoh thou see that man's body there Full sooth it is a man he was beforn By wickedness his kende he hath forlorn ¶ But sith that only virtue & goodness A boven manhood may a man a raise Needs than ho so useth wickedness Benethen manhood down it doth him peyse And though so be that many one them praise whom that thou sayst transformed in to vice Thou holdest him not a man if thou be wise ¶ whose lusts brenneth all in covetise And riveth men there good by violence I like a wolf thou might him well devise He that is fers & spareth none offence And what he saith he hath no consciens To make stryffes & dissension He is an hound as by comparison ¶ And he that will a wayten privily Foreyn goods how he may beryven A fox thou might him callen skylefully And whom that cursed Ire doth a moven A lion as in that thou might him preven He that is feared & fleeth wythouten need An heart thou might him call it is no dread ¶ And he that useth sloth & I delnesse And will not do no works profitable Thou might him call a very ass express And he that is inconstant & unstable To fowls might thou hauled him comparable And he that leadeth his life in lechory Aswyne thou might him callen skylefully ¶ it seemeth than that he that hath forlete The life of virtue & of honest To been a man in that he hath forfete And skylefully forlorn that dignity And there he might a god in manner be Or like to god in leaving at jest Now is he changed to a rude best Metrum iij. Capitulum uj: Vela Naricii ducis. Phia loquitur. ¶ The south-west wind that bloweth boustesly The sails of the Duke Naricius But of that we have granted here before As necessary must it suen need Boeus) I asked what phia) ꝙ she now take good heed Moore welful been the wicked in their peyn Than if they sholden none at all susteyn ¶ But this is not my conceit principally That commonly men have in their devise That wicked folk so peyned ryghtuously There by they been corrected of their vice And dread of peyn a peseth their malice And that example unto other more whythdraeth them fro that they wolden do ¶ But in another manner wise I mean That bad folk without punytion Moore unwelful sickerly they been Than if they suffered none affliction Not having regard to correction Ne to example/ ne to dread of peyn That moche myschef often doth refrayn ¶ Boectus) ꝙ I what manner wise may this be Other than you tolden here before Phia) Loo have not we confessed here ꝙ she That good men been welful evermore And wicked folk been wrecches & forlore Boeus) right so ꝙ I phia) ꝙ she now say me thyg What if that unto such a wrecchednesse ¶ If any part of good were added to were not he then more welful wilt thou say Than he that standeth all in myschef so Fro whom all manner good is raft a way Boecius) ꝙ I it seemeth so it is no nay Phia) And what ꝙ she if to this wrecched man Fro whom all manner goods lacketh than ¶ Another harm were joined & y knet Above the myscheffe which hath him oppressed wouldest thou not dame him more unwelful yet Than of his myschef somewhat were relesed And so by perceiving of good repressed Boecius) ꝙ I How should it other wise be Phia) Than have the wicked certainly ꝙ she ¶ Somewhat of good when that they been in pain Annexed then unto his wrecchednesse when they been punished so/ that is to seyn The same peyn that for their wickedness They suffer/ which be cause of ryghtuosnesse where by that peyn is give it is no nay That self peyn is good I dare well say ¶ And when that they been spared of torment Of this yvel than have they somewhat more That is the favour of unpunysment Of righteous pains that they been forbore The which as thou hast granted here before sith peyn is dwe reward of felony Vnpunysment is evil sickerly Boecius) I may not this denyen though I would Phia) The wicked them unpunished so with wrong So more unsely been they many a fold Then when by righteous doom they underfong Vengeance for their sin & soroes strong sith ryghtuousnesse tormenteth trespasours Than is it wrong to sparen surfetours ¶ Boeus) Denyen this ꝙ I there may no wight Phia) May any man ꝙ she denyen this That all is good that ever is done by right And all that ever is wrong is wickedness Boecins) And this ꝙ I is consequent iwis To that you hove concluded loo while ere But now I pray you one thing say me hire ¶ When that the body resolved is by death Shall the soul suffern any pain Phia) when that the soul out of the body geth Full hugy ꝙ she/ take it in certain For some full bitter pains shall susteyn And some shall be purged all with grace To treten here of this/ we have no place ¶ But I have unto this that is in me Full done my dever that thou shouldest known The might of shrews/ which as seemeth the In them is full unworthily bestowen it is no power verily to trowen And there as thou complainest in thy thought That wicked folks been y punysshed nought ¶ There might thou sayn the wicked for their sin To faylen never of pains sickerly But that they may there wicked purpose win with licence for to worken wickedly Thou dyst pray to been ended hastily And I have made the clearly for to know That it ne lesteth but a little throw ¶ And that the longer that endureth though The more wrecches been they I the told And if they shulden ever endure so Than were they wrecches more a thousand fold And more wrecches eke thou might them hold when they with wrong of pains been relesed Then when they be with righteous peyn oppressed ¶ And over this yet shall I further sayen Loo of this sentence sueth consequent Than are the bad in most despytous pain When that they seem they have no punysment Boeus) I said than/ when I with hole intent Behold your reasons how you doth them prove No thing is sother said as I believe ¶ But to the judgement of man's wit That is not moved by such evidence Ho is that man that will beleven it Or dame it worthy any audience They troweth no thing but experience Phia) As thou hast said ꝙ she right so it is For yees that been used to derknesse ¶ The light of treuthe may they not behold As fowls that been wont to i'll by night For to be seen a day they be not bold For why the day is blynding to their sight But nights derknesse maketh there yees bright So men infect with lusts & lekynges Have no regard to the ordinance of things ¶ For they supposeth that such sufferance Or unpunyshment of cursedhede Should a man to welfulnesse avaunce But in the law eternal mayst thou rede if thou do well thou hast no manner need To ask a juge for thy recompense For thou hast set thyself in excellence ¶ And if thou have thyselfen willingly Inclined unto sin & wrecchednesse To seek no vengeour of thy felony without thyself it needeth not iwis For thou hast set thyself in wickedness And made the like unto a rude best And put the in pains that ever shall jest Right as thou wouldest cast thy sight a bout Now to ground & now to heaven light All other causes ceasing of without Be cause of thine unstableness of sight Now wouldest thou seem with the stars bright And now right in this moddy ground to be But comen people this can they not see ¶ Boeus) I asked than what this should mean Phia) Should we ꝙ she consenten unto these which we have showed that like to bests been if one of them which that the lust devise Loo had forlorn his sight in any wise All utterly/ & also furthermore Had all forget that ever he see before ¶ And weeneth him want no thing utterly Of man's natural perfection Now we that this beholdeth verily Should we accord to their entention And not believe our own inspection Should we not trove that such men been blind And well the blynder for their mased mind ¶ And things that as like may be proved By reasons of as mighty foundement Of such folk they may not be believed That such wicked men & violent when they desese a simple Innocent lWel more unsely been they in the deed Than though that suffereth all there wrangfulhede Boeus) though reasons said I would I hearen fain Phia) Every wicked shrewd man ꝙ she wilt thou deny him worth care & pain Boecius) Nay ꝙ I that have you not of me Phia) Than more unsely must they needs be Such that leadeth their lyffes cursedly Boecius) Right as you sayen right so it is ꝙ I ¶ Phia) And though ꝙ she that worthy been torment wilt thou not dame them wrecches in that case Boecius) yes ꝙ I it is full convenient Phia) ꝙ she if thou shouldest. jugen in this place And mightest do vengeance or else grace whom wouldest thou demen worthy to be hung whether him that doth or him that suffereth wrong ¶ Boeus) To him ꝙ I that had the wrongs done I would a jugen suffysance of peyn The patient so should be a venged soon That he should have no matter to complain Phia) Moore wrecched is the worcher wilt thou sayen ꝙ she than he that soffereth every deal Boeus) In sooth ꝙ I right so it sueth well ¶ Phia) Of these causes & of other more That of the self rote suyngly Enforced been/ it will apperen loo That the filth of sins kendly Right of the self sins properly though men they maketh wrecches for to be That useth vices & dyshoneste ¶ The wrong also is not the wrecchednesse Of him that suffereth harms & grievance But in sooth the wrecchednesse is his That wrongusly hath done him a noyance But pledours done in this contraryance That so the judges unto mercy moven A genst them that wrongs doth agreven ¶ For sickerly the pity longeth more To 'em that hath unthryftyfully wrought And as the seek a leche is led before So should he be before the judge brought Of piteous accusours and wroth nought That with the pain as with a sotel gin Cowde cut a weigh the malady of sin ¶ And thus the business of advocates Schuld be forleten & men schuld it refusen Or if they would approven men algates All other wise they schuld there offyce usen And though that so mysdone alway accusen And if these wrecches also furthermore Mygth seen the virtue that they have forlore ¶ Sigh that bounty with pains may be had And filth of vice been utterly fordone To suffer pains schuld he be full glad Ne pains soothly schuld he hold them none His advocates forsaken should he soon And to the juge he should hem self be take That might hem hole of all his sins make ¶ Than is it so that as a genst the wise Is left no place of hate it is full sooth Hoo will the good haten or despite But a fool that wot not what he doth And though the bad be to the full loath To haten 'em yet have you no reason But rather have of them compassion ¶ for as sickness the body doth grievance Rygth so is vice a manner malady The which the soul oppresseth with noyance And as we should not demen skylefully Him worthy hate that seek is bodily But rwen rather on his pains sore Then ghostly languor should us meven more ¶ it is not convenient to haten ne pursue The souls that oppressed been with vice But rather on their bitter pains rwe And ho that could (not moved with malice) That man a menden with full good advise Though that he put him to full bitter peyn Of cruelty there may no wight complain Metrum iiij. Capitulum viij. Quid tantos juuat. Phia loquitur. WHat helpeth it to meven or excite with ꝓper hands your haps busily For if you seek death it needeth light For he will come hymselfen willingly He tarrieth not he spedeth him hastily Loo serpent/ Leon/ Tiger/ Bore/ & Bear They seeketh you to a racen & to tere ¶ And you with sword each other doth assail For cause that your manners been divers Vnryghtuously so meveth you battle with enterchaunging darts for to pierce your cruelty/ your reason doth reverse wilt thou that every man his meret had Loo love the good/ & rwe upon the bad Prosa u. Capitulum ix. Hinc video inquam. Boecius loquitur. ¶ In this ꝙ I I perceive every deal Both the myschef & the welfulnesse As for the meed of them that worcheth well And eke of them also that done a miss But nevertheless alday I see well this That of fortune to which the people hedeth Both good & evil full often time proceedeth ¶ Ne there is no wise man as I guess That rather would be power & nameless And in exile/ than flouresh in riches In power & in honour to encresse And in his cyte for to dwell in piece This is the best way as I devise To profit by the offyce of the wise ¶ So may their blyssfulnesse/ it is no doubt As by the virtue of their governance Be well transfunded in to folk a bout That been committed to their ordinance But than/ this mine heart doth grievance sith it is so that lawful prysonment divers Ingynnes/ pains & torment ¶ For wicked folk were first ordained And unto them it longeth skylefully why is it then that good men beth peyned And in their stead oppressed grievously And meed that to virtue properly Of very right is pertynent & dwe These medes have the wicked & untrwe ¶ What is the skyle of this confusion That so unrighteous seemeth for to be Of you I would have Information For less merueyl should it be to me if all things stood in this degree Meddled all with fortune & with chance And had at all none other governance ¶ But god that is the governor of all Lo maketh me a stoned as in this Sigh joy & wealths often doth befall To good folk. & often time iwis The wicked be in care and heaviness And often time the bad there again Been in there lusts & the good in peyn ¶ But if there be some skyle or evidence why god rewardeth folk in this manner. As thinketh me there is no difference But hap and fortune rewleth all yfere Phia) Of this ꝙ sche I misorder naught as here Sigh thou ne couldst the skyle of ordinance Though thou meruele upon the governance ¶ And hauled it folly & confusion But though to the the causes beth unknow As of so high a dysposytion when so him lust to setten high or low sith he is good as thou must needs trow That all governeth/ take this for a sooth That all is righteous what that ever he doth Metrum u Capitulum x. Si quis arcturi sidera Phia loquitur. HE that knoweth not the causes why Ne how it is/ in sooth he can not sayen That the star arcturus goeth so nigh moving a bout the pole sovereign And why Bootes' rests not his weyn And he his flames plongeth down so late And why so soon he riseth este algate ¶ it is no doubt he shall be stoned soon As of the law of high heaven bright why that the horns of the full moan So infected with the dark night Becometh pale/ & the stars light which that she hid with her beams clear Dyscovering them/ she maketh to us appear ¶ And open error maketh fowls blind That beteth brass the moan to reskewen Men wondereth nought upon the stormy wind That maketh the see so fersly for to flown That doth the brenkes bete & overthrown Ne that the cold forsen clottes great So been resolved by the sons hete ¶ The cause of this is esy to be feled These other are hid/ therefore you wonder so For all that falls suddenly & seld Thus wondereth these movable folks loo And if this cloudy error pass them fro So that they might the very causes see They should not semen wondered to be Prosa uj. Capitulum xi. Ita est inquam. Boecius loquitur. RIght so ꝙ I this will I not reverse But loo this gift is yours sickerly These prime causes which that you rehearse And reasons hid in clouds mystycally To maken clear/ this one thing coveyt I it is a thing that trobleth most my mind And with merueyl marred/ I me find Phia) She 'gan to smile a little & said than Thou askest now of me a question Loo of the highest thing that any man May asken at mine estymation Or may perceive by clear entention To which unnethes may there aught suffice Of any word that I can the devise ¶ Such is the matter that we been a bout The which to known thou desirest so That when we been delivered of a doubt wythouten number soon riseth more That been well nigh as hard to a voyden fro As heads that one dragon encresse The serpent that was slain of Hercules ¶ Ne in this matter is none other end Ne how these great doubts to redressen But that a lyfly fire of man's mind Must myghtly restrayn them & repressen For otherwise thou shalt them not expressen For loo in this men useth to enquere Thus fell as I shall the rehercen here ¶ first of the wondered symplycyte Of the high divine purueyance Of fatum that men calleth desteney Of fortune that is called sudden chance Of knowing & of god's ordinance That is called predestination And eke of freedom of election ¶ How hugyous is this matter with to deal Thou knowest it well thyself it is no nay But sith it is a parcel of thine hele To known this/ I shall do what I may Thou that the time be short I shall a say sith I have said the somewhat here before I shall myself enforcen furthermore ¶ And though so be that music the delight And metre is full lusty to thine ere As for a time that lust must thou respite The while that I in order knette in fere My reasons which I shall the shown here Boecius) Right as you lust ꝙ I/ & she began As it were all another process than ¶ Phia) Loo every kendly generation Of all things be they more or less And every natural progress you That in his being hath chaungeablenesse And what that ever hyt be that moved is Theridamas order/ form & causes forth been brought Fro the stable high divine thought ¶ This sovereign thought that all doth so devise Set in the tour of high symplycyte Hath ordained many divers manner wise To things that been done/ loo wilt thou see And if this manner of desposytion referred be un to the pure divine intelligence Than is it purueyance or prescience ¶ But when this same manner referred is To things that been moved & governed As old men have called it ere this Than is it destiny as I have learned Full soon is this diversity dyscerned Of him that seethe the myghtes of them both And esely he shall well see the sooth ¶ For purueyance loo is that reason high Of good our aller prince sovereign By which/ all he desposeth mightily But destiny the very sooth to sayen Loo is that dysposytion certain which these things been annexed to That of their kendes been movable so ¶ By which the high divine prescience All things in their ordinance enlaceth This purueyance loo hath this excellence That all thing at one's he embraceth Fro his presence is no thing that passeth Though they be infinite & endless Yet all he comprehendeth nevertheless ¶ But destiny in certain time & space singularly dyvydeth every deal Disposing it in meving time & place And when that this disposing temporel Is comprehended & referred well un to the onehed of god's governance Than is it soothly called purueyance ¶ But for to have consideration How they divided in divers times be That self order of this desposytion Than is it hothly called destiny And though they have such diversity yet nevertheless there may no thing be sother Then that one of them dependeth of the other ¶ For of the symplycyte of purveyance This order fatal certain doth proceed There is the form of all that ordinance Right as a crafty man that will him speed A work to maken/ first he taketh heed And all the shape desposeth in his mind And sith the effect he bringeth to the end ¶ As he hath first devised every deal And in his thought enprented symplely He bringeth forth by order temporel Right so god all purueyeth singularly And to be done desposeth stablely And when it fully is disposed so By destiny he maketh it to be do ¶ And whether this exercise destynal By any spirits of the heaven on high That to this purueyance intendeth all Or if the soul doth it verily Or else nature doth it kendly Or the moving of the stars bright Or else angeles of the heaven light ¶ Other else by the fendes business By some of these other by all in fere This order destynal performed is yet loo this is full open & full clear And needs it must be so in all manner That the stable & simple ordinance Of thing to don is called purueyance ¶ But loo/ the process of succession In which they been performed suyngly By the simple dysposytion Before seyn of god be forn eternally Loo destiny men call it sickerly So all that ever is under destiny So must it under purueyance be ¶ As is the self destiny also And to that self purueyance both Some things been subject that been ydone As after this I shall declaren to the That again standeth destiny for sooth And some to god approacheth so by love That order destynal they pass a 'bove ¶ As divers compace on one point y pyght Upon the centre turning all a bout The Innermest compace to thy sight The which next to the centre is without A centre will it seem/ it is no doubt And seemeth as it meveth never a deal A bout which so meveth all the while ¶ But this uttermost circumference That to thy sight is largest in compace And ferrest fro this point in difference So must he moven in a larger space And he that negheth to that myddel place Compressed next to that symplycyte He cesseth for to moven as seemeth the ¶ By lekely reason he that ferrest fleteth Fro the sovereign thought of god on high To destiny the faster he him knetteth And he that can & will approach nigh This sovereign centre-god ententyfly The more he standeth in freedom & in ease That destiny shall little him desese ¶ Right as dyscours of reason may not be meet un to the Intellect of man's mind Ne thing that is/ to thing that is not yet Ne a little stound to time wythouten end May not be like in worthiness of kende But as the point to the circumference Between them is an hugey difference ¶ Right so this fatayl mutabylyte That always is so full of varyance Referred to the high symplycyte Of the stable & sovereign purueyance which that heavens hath in governance He meveth stars/ he tempereth elements Transforming them by enterchaungementes ¶ And all that nature doth on earth breed And so bideth/ shall fallen down eft soon Renewing them by fruits & by seed He seethe also the works that you done And fortunes he governeth everych one Constreyning with an Insoluble bond Of causes which that may not be wythstonde ¶ And sith these causes passen fro so high A ground/ as purueyance unuaryable Than may I say full well & sothfastly That needs must it been untransmutable That governance/ & most profitable when this symplycyte of divine thought ordaineth causes which that faileth nought ¶ Thus in a certain order sooth to sayen That steadfast is & it may faylen never And but this order govern & refrayn This worldly things which that changeth ever Full soon they shall dyssoluen & dessever Fleting/ right as thing of no valour And whavering so wythouten governor ¶ And though so be that we may not behold The causes of this desposytion Ne see the skyleful order as we should There fore be we in perturbation it seemeth us error & confusion Yet is it dressed if we understood And well disposed every deal to good ¶ For cause of evil is no thing verily Performed of the worst man that is For as I have declared plenerly They seeketh good/ but they been led a miss By error of their own wrecchednesse For why that order which that doth proceed Fro sovereign good/ it may no wight myslede ¶ But unto this peradventure wilt thou say What confusion may there worse be sith good & bad indifferent alday Now have they wealth & now adversity Now that they love/ now that they wolden i'll But wilt thou trow that men be now so wise That every thing must be as they devise ¶ As whom them lust to jugen good or bad Of very force it must be needs so In man's doom discord full oft is had For of these one man/ these will demen loo That he is worthy moche peyn & woe And these will dame him worthy thank & meed And yet the one must be deceived need ¶ But let us graunten here that any wight The good & bad may verily discern Now trowest thou that they been of such a might For to enserche the Innermest thought Of man's ghost & all that he hath wrought And clearly jugen thereof every doubt As men are wont of bodies here without ¶ As for to juge their attemperure Of diversity of their complexion As greatly wondereth every creature That knoweth not by clear inspection There kendes ne their dysposytions why these accordeth well with things sweet These other most have sour & sweet forlete ¶ And seek folks been y cured oft Some with sharp things sickerly And some by thing that esy is & soft But this the leche knoweth verily That knoweth the manner of the malady There temperure & manner of their hele Of this discord he wondereth never a deal ¶ And what may be the health of thy courage But honest & virtue most of price what sickness may thy soul do damage But unhoneste & cursedness of vice But now what creature may be so wise To saven health & a voyden heaviness No wight but god in certain as I guess ¶ He is the very leche of man's mind That fro the waiting of his purueyance He seethe what is acordant to the kende Of everych that he hath in governance And for them so he maketh ordinance To everych as belongeth to his health whether that you dame it woe or wealth ¶ Than is this noble wonder to your thought And merueyl of this order destynal when god all cunning/ hath that work wrought it stoneth them that knoweth nought at all For man's cunning certain is but small And man's reason little may dyffyne Of things in the sovereign thought divine ¶ peradventure thou wilt demen of a wight That he is Just & true in his intent yet in the purueyance of god's sight There falls all another judgement And a doom that is fer dyfferent Loo as Lucanus my familiar In his books written of this matter ¶ The cause convyct as Cato 'gan devise He deemed best/ that was Pompeius But loo the gods judged other wise They deemed Just the cause of julius Wherefore they maden him vyc●oryous So things done outwardly to thy sight Yet is it done by ordinance of right ¶ But yet as to thine opynable wit it seemeth overthorte confusion But peradventure I suppose yet Here is some man of such condytion That in the doom is no dystynction But god & man accordeth all in one In judgement that error is there none ¶ But upon hap so feynt his courage is That if there fall him other than he would it should him causen for to done a miss And to forlete his good custumes old By which/ fortune might he not with hold where fore the wise dyspensation Regarding to his dysposytion ¶ And seeing that by such adversity He should be moche apeyred & y shent For why he spareth him of his pity And giveth him so as is convenient That he may keep him true & Innocent And these loo stont in virtue perfetly And as a saint is joined god full nigh ¶ Of these the high divine purueyance Would dame it as for sin & felony To put upon him harms or grievance He will him nought be harmed bodily Ne be desesed by no malady Thus said one that of wisdom was fulfilled That virtue hath a saints body builded ¶ And often when astate of worthiness And governance is given to the wise That is for to rebuken & repress The vice that would encressen & a rise And some he ruleth in another wise And as him liketh enterchaungeth both Right as best is for them it is the sooth ¶ And some he suffereth softly to be grieved Jest they outrage in their wealths long And some with sharp showers to be moved That virtue of their courage ever a 'mong By use of patience be proved strong And be confirmed by that exercise And some because of very cowardyce ¶ Full nedeles of moche thing they dread which they may well perform the sooth to sayen And these loo is full hardy in his deed Presuming more than he may sustain To these expedient it is there again To know themselfen by experience And these loo for a name of excellence ¶ Full manly with death he hath it boght And so he hath sustained pains sore As for example ever to be thought That men may seyn by things done be fore That virtue hath Inuict been evermore And is not harmed by adversity But if defaute of men themselfen be ¶ How ryghtuously disposed all a bout And loo how well these things been ydone Ho so looketh this/ he may not been in doubt And for their profit when they falls to For to the wicked that betydeth so That now they have desese & now their lust To these same causes may be wist ¶ But when they been in pains & distress There is no wight that wondereth never a deal For why they all will suppose & guess That 〈◊〉 pains were deserved well And these pains that these wrecches feel Maketh other wrecches pains for to fere And often foul vices to forbear ¶ And also for their own amendment But things falling lusty to their chyre it giveth men a mighty argument what they should demen of these wealths here sith they to wrecches be familiar And certainly I suppose as in this That god despenseth with their frowardness ¶ For some men been their loo peradventure That been so importune in their malice And eke so overthrowing of nature That need them maketh fallen in to vice But than this prescyence that is so wise A genst the perel of this malady By worldly plentey maketh remedy ¶ Loo these beholdeth on his consciens Defouled so with sin & cursedhede And saith how great a dysconuenyence Than is between his fortune & his deed peradventure he falls so in dread Jest that the use of thing that doth him ease He may forfete & by his sins lose ¶ He changeth than his customs everichone Him feareth so his fortune to forlete And all his vices he forsaketh soon And these hath loo these worldly wealths great To which in sooth his meret is unmeet And suddenly the wrecche is overthrown And set at nought as his deserts awen ¶ And some have power & authority Loo whom them lust to punysshen & dystrayn So that it may unto the good be An exercise of virtue the sooth to sayen And to the wicked man a cause of peyn For right as good & bad dyscordeth ever Right so bad themself accordeth never And why not/ sith it falteth every day That they dyscorden in themselfen so There conscience repreveth them always And often time it falls that they do Some deed/ that when the time is over go themself they deemeth in their own thought That better had that deed been unwroght ¶ This purueyaunce if you it understood it worcheth here a wonder to your heart By bad men the bad he maketh good And fro their vices wonderly convert For when the fowls feel them felfen smert when other wrecches hath them harmed sore it falls that they hateth them there fore ¶ And while they coveyt unto s●che men To be unlike/ that useth such unright To fruit of virtue they resorteth than For only this is thing of gods might Right as it liketh him/ it is but light That bad thing is good as he devyseth when good effects of the bad a riseth ¶ For why in order all thing embraceth And what that fleteth fro this ordinance In to another order then it passeth For in the realm of certain purueyaunce That mighty god hath in his governance There may no thing be done uncertainly Ne but it have a skyleful cause why ¶ For unto man in sooth it langeth not To know all his wondered engine As of the works which that been wrought So by the high purueyaunce divine Ne them with words fully dyffyne No creature hath that habylyte But only this sufficeth/ it to see ¶ That god the first founder of nature All thing to good desposeth he & dresseth So far forth that in every creature The lekenesse of himself he empresseth And for to kepen this/ loo he represseth All wicked things fro his governance A voiding it by fatal ordinance ¶ For why if thou mark well in thy mind The purueyaunce that all thing desposeth There is no thing that thou shalt bade find Though so be that thy wits so supposeth For every thing wythyn it self encloseth Some manner cause of good it is no dread where of some other goods shall proceed ¶ But yet whyler I see the wexen faint As for the wyghtes of my question This long process hath the sore atteynt Some sweet thing of delectation Thou askest for a recreation Have taste of this & strenger shalt thou be Than/ & hegher to ascend after me Metrum uj. Capitulum xj. Si vis celsi iura tonantis. Phia loquitur. TOo if thou wilt behold ententyfly with all the clear myghtes of thy mend The laws of our sovereign god on hay Up in to heaven thou must thy wits sand There every thing doth keep his course of kende The stars with a righteous allyaunce They keepeth there there old governawce ¶ And loo the bright son it is no doubt The cold moan letteth never a deal And Vrsa which that meveth round a bout The pole artyke right as it were a wheel Her old course she keepeth wonder weal Though other stars move in to the west To a byden there a 'bove she liketh best ¶ And Hesperus the eve star clear Loo showeth himself before the dark night And the lusty star Lucifer He bringeth by este again the day light This perdurable course they keepeth right Thus all dyscord by enterchaunged love Loo is exiled from the heaven a 'bove ¶ This same accord of love by stounds meet Attempereth eke the fighting elements That drought may accord with the weet That hete & cold may have convenience And though they keep there kendly resistance The light fire yet algates up asceudeth And the heavy earth contrary way descendeth ¶ And by causes of the self reason Sweet flowers springeth lustily In the fair first summer season And so the hot summer suyngly Maketh the corn to rypen hastily And so autumpnus bringeth forth his blede Lusty fruits folks for to feed ¶ This same attemperaunce it is no nay The winter so be dweth with the rain All leaving thing it norysseth sooth to say And eft with death retorneth down again The whiles sitteth the maker sovereign well & ground both lord & king is he La/ & wise juge of equity ¶ The reins of the world he hath in hand So making it to meven & to go A resting eft he maketh it to stand For thing that fletteh ever to & fro But if that he enstabelysshe it so Compelling it to moven in to round it must needs faylen fro his ground ¶ And fro the order which they now observe This love comen to every creature coveteth them to kepen & conserve The end of good that ground is of nature For in other wise may they not endure But love return them in to unyte Of god on high that caused them to be Prosa seven. Capitulum xiij. jam ne igitur vides. Phia loquitur. ANd sayst thou not ꝙ she what sueth here Upon all that we have rehearsed now Boeus) I asked what phia) ꝙ she it is full That all fortune is good boeus) y asked how (clear Phia) Full soon ꝙ she that shall I show the now Thou understandest well that this is sooth That every fortune justey is or loath ¶ Yet been they given for an exercise Of virtue to the good or else thus As for a guerdoning unto the wise Or they been given to the vicious To punish them that been malicious Or to correct them of their mysdede This is the very cause it is no dread ¶ And all that ever is Just & profitable wilt thou not hold it good Boeus) I said yes For why it sueth right as reasonable To that you have rehearsed here y wys Of purueyance & destiny ere this Full firmly your sentence is y knytte But saeth me one thing if you liketh yet ¶ As you have put be fore a little oer Acounteth fortune now in this degree you sayden that a rude comyner Can not believe/ ne will it not see Phia) And whereto shall I speak of that ꝙ she Boeus ꝙ I this speech of men is used wide That evil fortune to some men doth betide ¶ Phia) And wilt thou ꝙ she that we negh near un to the comen used speech than Jest them seem that I go to far A boven all the comen use of man Boeus) As liketh you ꝙ I Phia) & she began Demest thou not good that causeth good to encresse Boeus) yes ꝙ I for sooth I may juge no less ¶ Phia) Now all that virtue is enforced by Other that correcteth any deed Doth it not profyten) Boecius) yes ꝙ I Phia) Than is it good ꝙ she wythouten dread Boecius) In sooth ꝙ I this must I grant need Phia) But this ꝙ she to them doth aperteyn That grounded been in virtue the sooth to seyn ¶ That taketh bateyl with such adventures whythstanding them with mighty patience Or it pertaineth to though creatures That have led their life in insolence And so to virtue doth their diligence There to enforced with adversity Boecius) & this ꝙ I may not denied be Phia) But when ꝙ she fortune of lustynesse To good men is given for their meed Is it then bad? will these folks guess Boeus) I said nay full right they will it rede That this fortune is good wythouten dread Phia) And what ꝙ she when fortune anguysous Is bestowed upon the vicious ¶ To peyn them for their sins ryghtuously whether will they dame it good or nought Boeus) Good will they not jugen it ꝙ I But wrecchednesse the worst that may be thought Phia) Behold ꝙ she now where we been brought As suing this vulgar opinion In to a marvelous conclusion Boeus) I asked what Phia) it sueth here ꝙ she Of that we have confessed plenerly Lo that there may no wicked fortune be To such that haveth virtue perfetly Or to though that encresseth aught there by Or tho that doth in virtue first begin To virtue so converted fro their sin ¶ And they that dwelleth in their wickedness what fortune that them fall of well or woe it is myschef to them & wrecchednesse Boeus) In sooth ꝙ I it sueth well there to Though no man will it grant yet is it so Phia) For why she said a wise & perfect man Should not so sore grogen than ¶ When fortune as a foo doth 'em assail Right as a strong man should him not dysdeyn When that he hyreth rumour of battle But thereof should he be full glad & fain For such distress a matter is certain For to confirm these one in sapience These other in astate of excellence ¶ For than her name virtue useth right All only when it stont in this degree when it enforceth of his proper might To be not overthroen by adversity And to you that in encrece of virtue be it belongeth not to lede a lusty life with every fortune have you taken stryffe ¶ And a bateyl wonder sharp & keen Look how you can you keep in this distress To set yourself in a mighty mean So that her sorrows no thing you oppress Ne that you be not by her lustynesse Corrupt/ for all that a 'bove this mean a riseth Or is beneath/ felicity despiseth ¶ And shall no meed as for his labour take For in your own hands put is it your proper fortune/ which you will make For if it seem sharp unto your wit Loo exercise of virtue giveth it Or else you converteth fro your sin Or punysseth you that will a bide theryn AGamenon the vengeour of heleyve A bateyl held of ȝerus twice five So he destroyed troy & wan again The same helyve that was his broad wyffe But when he first 'gan stir him to that stryffe Him lacked wind to sail on the flod And soon he boght it with his daughter blood ¶ And so he made himselfen pyteles In sacrifice he sloo his daughter dear Also when that noble Vlixes In the see had sailed many year He wept his main with a ruthful cheer For Poliphemus daring in his den So fersly had devoured all his men ¶ But Vlixes full warily 'gan espy when that this Poliphemus was a sleep And suddenly than put he out his you And Poliphemus though be 'gan to lepe And for malice & anguish weyle & weep where of Vlixes was full blithe & glad In vengeance of the harms that he had ¶ And Hercules gate him a noble name By labours which that hard were & great first the proud Centaurus made he tame The Lion fierce out of his skin he gete And Arpyas eke with aroes he sheet And golden apples wych the dragon kept He gate them while the cruel dragon slept ¶ And Cerberus the foul hound of hell with a three fold cheyn he bound full last And dyomede the tyrant fierce & fell He made his horse devour him at last Upon the serpent Idra fire he cast And so he brent him in to asches cold That no man his venem noyen should ¶ When Achilaus made himself by craft I like to a bull with Hercules to fight Than Hercules his horns him be raft And fully him despoiled of his might Achilaus in to a river right For shame he leapt & hid himselfen there And on the land he darest no more apere ¶ Antheus the geaunt of Libie That on the ground his myghtes would renwe Thus Hercules him sloo full manfully Upon his breast & to the ground him thrwe And Cakus' the thief that was untrwe He sloo/ & Euanderus Ire he pesed That of Cakus' often was desesed ¶ And over this he sloo the mighty bore with hoos foom his shoulders marked were But than his last labour furthermore was when he on his neck heavens bear And of this labour he deserved there That heaven for to have to his meed you mighty men to this you taketh heed ¶ Now hasteth you the high way to wend Right as you may by this example see you nice men & mased in your mind why will you not fight a genste adversity with virtue/ sith you may so syker be Ho so in earth hath the victory He shall be worthy to the heaven on high Explicit Liber Quartus. ¶ In this chapytre Philosophia confermeth her exhortation/ by example of three mighty men/ of singular deeds that they had done. Agamenon. Vlixes. & Hercules. And for cause often times men escheweth great acts for lack of courage/ which courage is blemesshed or oppressed: by three things in special. There fore he rehearseth of these werryours, certain deeds/ in which they showed the might of their courage not hurt ne blemesshed by none of these causes. One thing is that often letteth & wythdraeth the force of man's courage/ fro mighty and manly deeds/ that is tendrenesse of heart and affection that he hath other to worldly things which he delighteth upon/ Other to wife & children/ kindred/ or frenshyppe/ which he keepeth not to dysplese in wythdraing his presence/ neither in any other thing/ that might be cause of morning or heaviness. But against this carnalyte/ he putteth the example of Agamenon. That when he was sailing towards the sege● of Troy/ when he came to the isle of Aulydes/ him lacked wind. Then was it showed him by wycches & dyvynours/ that if he would have wind: he must slay his daughter Ephigenie/ & brenne her in sacrifice to the plesance of Dyane. And not wythstanding that he loved his daughter passing all thing/ yet in hope of victory/ he put a way the tendrenesse of faderly affection/ and made his heart pyteles to his dear daughter/ & so sloo her in sacrifice. And so had he wind to his will/ & suyngly the victory as he desired ¶ The second thing that letteth a man's courage is: when he hath seyn many perish for a certain purpose: which himself desireth/ and few or none atteyn it with prosperity. Again this a basshement/ he putteth the second example of Vlixes. which when he had x. years erred sailing in the see after the destruction of Troy & suffered many miss adventures/ & specially in transformation & losing of his feloshyppe: by the cursed enchaunteresse Circe's. Here he tellethe how the great giant Poliphemus with one ye in his frount/ had devored & destroyed his people/ And not wythstanding the myscheffe that all his people had suffered/ yet Vlixes a basshed him nought/ but waited when this giant was a sleep/ & suddenly put out his ye: And theu was he syker of him/ that he might harm him no more. & so he venged the murder of his main▪ ¶ The moralyte of this fable/ is this. Poliphemus is as moche to say/ as losing of fame: And he that recketh not of his fame/ may well be called one yeed. For he regardeth not that is to come: ne that is passed. but only to his present lusts. But Vlixes the wise man/ hath regard both to that is gone: & to that that is to come/ & quencheth in himself this one is of these present lusts. And though so be that all the world for the more part/ by ravesshing of this one you/ peresseth/ foloing these momentaney lusts: and unnethes any man is that can or will refrayn them: yet Vlixes the wise man: will stop this you/ & not excuse him by the comen excuse of wrecches saying: Ho is he that may withstand his desires/ sith so many mighty men & wise have been dyscomfete of their lusts. But he will myghtly repress these passions by good governance▪ And so venge himself upon his ghostly enemy. ¶ The third thing that a basseth the courage: is cowardyce: when a man haldeth himself unable to the labour that he puryoseth/ and his might unsuffycyant & unmeet to resist that: that wythstandethe his will & enteut. Agenste this cowardyce: philosophia Inducethe the twelve. labours of the mighty man Hercules/ which seemeth to every man's hiring far to exceed the might of any man▪ yet not wythstanding/ Hercules a basshed never his courage: but mightily performed his intent & purpose. wherefore as philosophia concludeth he was rewarded with a sovereign geft/ and made a bright shining star in the heaven a 'bove. ¶ By these mighty manues labours/ is given to us an example/ that there may no thing a basshe the courage of a wise man: where by he should leave the labour of virtuous leaving/ ne bodily exercise in virtue shall not seem him overhard to his might/ but that he may perform his intent & lust. so shall his desire be enforced with desire & full hope to heavenly joy. ¶ The first labour: the proud Centaurus made he tame: Of these Centaurus is said be forn/ That Ixion gate them of a cloud/ when he would have oypressed juno. But what wise that Hercules tamed them/ it is expressed by the commentor thus. when that these Centaurus in a certain time were come to gedres in the mount of Pheloe to a pley that was called Palestra/ which we call wrestling/ Hercules so sore asset them in wrestling/ that they bledde. ¶ Also another time Hercules coming out of spain was logged in the den of Tyro Centaurus that was one of the ●heffe masters. And as this Tyro handled an aroe/ with which Hercules had slain a serpent the venomous aroe fell upon his foot/ and made him a wonde/ that was uncurable. The third time it fell that Hercules with his love Deiamra turning toward his country/ come to the river of Hevenun/ And when he tarried for carriage of his wife: Neffus Centaurus bade him swim over before: & he would bring her after. And when that Hercules was come to land/ he looked after his wife/ & he saw Centaurus a bout for to oppressen her/ And a none with a venomous aroe he shut him thoro the heart & s●we him. And thus he tamed the proud Centaurus. ¶ To the litceral truth of this tale. Ixion that was called the father of the Centaurus/ was the first that ordained horsemen for to ride in grece/ and gathered of them a hundred & wasted sore the country. And when the rude people did see them so smartly pry●k●ng in and out/ they wend it had been bests/ half horse and half men. And at last these mighty Hercules fought with them & destroyed them. ¶ By these Centaurus geten of the cloud may be understand such men as been exalted in to high astates/ not by meret of their virtues/ but by favour of lordship/ & by their vain pleasance. They been half bests & half men/ bestly in their leaving/ raveners & extortioners: & like men in pleasance to their lords Hercules the virtuous shall spare none offence of their high astates/ ne dread of their tyranny/ but boldly reprove them of their vices/ & make them to look as men should. ¶ The second of Hercules was that he strepte the Lion out of his skin. The truth of this labour was this: There was a passing hugy Lion in the forest of Nemeas: which sore afraid the people of the country. which Lion hercules' slwe/ & strept the skin: & bore with him in sign of urctory. By this Lion is understand/ proud & fierce tyrants: that delighteth all in raven and pyling of the people/ having no pity upon the power. These men a virtuous man should spoil of there pour/ & suffer none such to bear astate of office. ¶ The third labour was that he sher the herpyas with aroes. ¶ Syneus put out the yees of his sons/ because they had accused their stepmoder of adultery. wherefore by Jugement of gods he was blinded himself/ and had certain fowls about him with maiden heads/ that defoyled his table & bore a way his meet. These fowls Hercules slwe and drove out of country ¶ By these Herpyas may well be understand rennets or riders over the country/ covered under lordship/ as menstrelles & joculers and such other/ that cometh in to households of worthy men/ & eateth and devoreth their vytelles'/ And but they have also geftes/ they ubyl defoule the table/ despising the people/ And when they been passed/ speak vylenously by all the household. Such people a virtuous man should not cherysshe for fere of words/ but rebuke them of this foul manners/ and so destroy that foul vice and unhonest usage. ¶ The fourth labour was: that he gate the golden apples fro the dragon. As Lucanus feyneth Athlaus had seven. doghters'/ which had a gardenful of golden apples/ which garden was taken to keep to a dragon/ that always was waking. But Hercules by craft made this dragon to sleep/ and so bore a way the apples: and brought them to Euristeus the king. By these seven. doghters of Athlaus/ been understand the seven. arts liberal. These damseles have a garden/ that is the lybrary disperse a monges clerks. Appel trees been books/ the apples been subtle sentence of wisdom/ which the waking dragon/ that is the sensualyte of man hath to keep. which is ever waking to lusts and delights/ and so letteth the soul fro cunning. But Hercules the virtuous man oppresseth his sensualyte by good governance so that it letteth him nought fro study/ And so by his good business he getteth the fruit of all the seven. science. ¶ The u labour was when he bond Cerberus the foul hound of hell. Of these Cerberus the fable is this. Pirritous would wed the queen of hell. And he called Hercules & Theseus/ & other mighty men to help him. And when they came to hell/ jest Cerberus the porter should let them of their purpose/ Hercules bound him with a cheyn of adamant: The queen of hell may well be called worldly worship/ which Pirritou desireth. But he taketh wise men to his counsel. And Cerberns with three heads Hercules bindeth/ That is Pride/ Avarice/ and Lechory. These three head sins letteth a man to be worshypful/ where for the virtuous man bindeth & restreyneth them with a triple cheyn of virtues. And when that these vices be so repressed by virtues/ a man may not fail to be worshypful. ¶ The vi. labour was that he made diomed to be eten of his own horse. The fable is this. Diomedes king of Trace/ fed his horse with man's flesh: wherefore he used to slay his gests for his horse. But at last came Hercules and slwe him/▪ And made his horse to eat him. And finally sloo the same horse. This Diomedes betokeneth a wastour that pylleth and despoyleth the people/ for to maintain his great a ray/ which passeth the suffysaunce of his astate. But a virtuous man shall besey himself for to destroy such manner levers/ & compel them for to leave by their own good: But when they may not continue that a ray without raven and robbery/ their horse and there a ray bringeth them to nought. so that of need they must leave it and leave as they may. ¶ The seven. labour was/ that he brent the serpent Idra. In the river of Learn was a serpent with many heads/ And ever if one were cut of/ there wax ●ii. therefore. And when that Hercules had shot him & no thing a veiled/ at last he made a bout this serpent a hugey heap of vood: & after set it a fire & so brent this serpent. This fable is toched be fore & in part declared ¶ The viii. labour is of Achilaus. the fable is this. Hercules and Achilaus wressheled together for the maiden Dianer/ & when that Achilaus felled himself at the worse/ he turned himself suddenly in to a serpent/ & slypte out of his hands. And Hercules eftsoons caught him & was in point to weary him. And then Achilaus turned himself in to a bull. So Hercules a none took him & threw him to the ground & break his horn. & he for shame leapt in to the water & hid him. The truth of this fable is this Achilaus is a river be tween grece & Calcedoyne. In this Calcedoyne reigned a king named Genus/ hose daughter Hercules ravished. And coming to this river when he might not pass it he stopped an arm of it & dried it/ & so he passed with his love. By this kings daughter may be understand virtue/ which Hercules the mighty man coveteth for to have. Achilaus betokeneth the sensualyte/ which in youth hyley wythstandeth a man that would be virtuous. But first the sensualyte as a serpent assaileth him by many side ways/ And when this mighty man hath overcome all though serpent's deceits/ he torneth in to a bull with two. horns/ Lechory/ & gluttony. But this one horn of Lechory/ the virtuous man breaketh & utterly destroyeth. & then is the sensualyte overcome/ For the other horn of gluttony will lightly of a virtuous man be put under by good governance. So this bull lepeth in to the river. the sensualyte is repressed & keleth himself by penance/ and so winneth the mighty man virtue to his love. ¶ The ix. labour is of Antheas the great geaunt/ which was geten of the earth/ And ever as he toched the earth/ he renewed his strength with which geaunt Hercules wrasteled/ But always when he seemed dyscomfeted/ falling to ground he become as fresh as he was before Than Hercules percevyug this took him in his arms/ & laid him on his breast/ and so strained him to death by strength: & so cast him to the ground/ & thus destroyed he the geaunt. By these Antheus may be understand worldly covetyce/ which encresseth & renueth his strength by toching of the ground. For covetyce will not be quenched by plenty of worldly good/ but rather is there by renewed & enforced. Hercules' then the virtuous man/ streyneth this covetise wythyn his breast/ & with draeth it utterly fro worldly good/ & so he quencheth the lust that he had there on/ & putteth it holely in virtue & in wisdom. ¶ The x. labour is of Cakus' the theffe of Libya which Hercules dyscomfeted & slwe. The fable is this. There was in the mount Aucentyne a monster/ that spete fire at his mouth/ robbing & despoyling the people of the country. And he was the son of Vulcan/ by whom evander king of the land was greatly a noyed. And Hercules coming by that country/ bringing with him out of spayn great plenty of bests/ this Cakus' stale iiii. bolles & as many keyn: & droe them in to his den by the tails bacward/ that the stappes should not be seen Inward. And Hercules by estimation espied where they were/ and so droe Cakus' out of his den/ and sloo him. and so he esed the king destroying his enemy. ¶ The moralyte is thus. By this Cakus' may be understand pride. He speteth fire at his mouth/ high words of malice and menace: He is Vulcanus son. For that vice is appropryat to the devil that first it found. He wasteth and devoreth and steleth all that he may/ and so harmeth the country▪ For a proud man wasteth moche in his a ray & other expenses/ that all that been a bout him been noyed there by. evander the reason that is king of the soul may not overcome him/ for he will not worche by him/ He dareth in his den: sitting in man's heart/ he steleth iiii. bolles of Hercules he oppresseth the iiii. cardynal virtues/ & as many keyn/ all other virtues that been under them. For a proud man is myghtles/ untemperate/ unware & unrighteous. This theffe Hercules that is consciens espieth: and draeth out this theffe pride out of the heart/ and sleyth & destroyth him/ and so hath he his bests again/ that be virtues. And reason that was over come/ now regneth in the soul as king in ●pece and rest. ¶ The xi. labour is of the bore that Hercules s●we. In archadia was a mighty bore that wasted the region sore. which Hercules hunted and at last this bore turned unto Hercules & smote him in the shulder/ and marked it with the foom of his mouth. By these bore may be understand the vice of the flesh/ which wasteth foul a man his substance: These vices Hercules the mighty chaseth and hunteth/ in will to destroy them: But this bore torneth and assaileth Hercules: For it chanceth oft/ that a full mighty man in virtues: that pursueth & hateth all vices/ is assailed & repted with the sin of the flesh/ & peradventure is marked falling theryn. But one vicious deed beryveth not the habit of virtue: but ma●●●h a man more ware: and diligent for to keep himself/ and so at last he overcometh his flesh and sleyth this bore of lust and like. ¶ The twelve. labour was this: after the fable of Duyde. Athlas the mighty geaunt/ in the geauntes battle/ fighting a genst the gods above/ bore heaven upon his shulder: And when that he saw Hercules come to him/ after his other labours/ he was weary of fighting & also of this burden/ prayed him to help him to bear heaven/ And he took and bore it mightily. whereby he deserved to be made a fair star in heaven. The truth was this. Athlas was a cheffe astronomer/ wherefore he was said that he bore heaven/ the cunning of heavenly things. But when Athlas died/ which death is a rest and a refreshing to the virtuous/ Hercules took heaven upon his shulder. The moralyte may be thus. The battle of geauntes is the enforsing of ghostly myghtes a genst the gods a 'bove/ that is a genst natural inclination to vices/ which is caused by constellations/ But a genst these inclinations/ he may fight best/ that hath cunning of astronomy. For to search the myghtes of the planets for certain times/ and knoweth also how these vycious inclinations becaused. But at last he must leave the labour of astronomy compelled by age/ when all his passions been cessed: and then Hercules taketh heaven upon his shulder: and giveth him holly to heavenly contemplation. And so he deserveth by this labour specially to be made a citizen of heaven. ¶ Loo thus must every mighty man that wild seruen heaven. first loath and abhor the monsters of sin: both in himself: and also in other: and at last leaving all outward occupation/ give him holly to serve god: in prayer and contemplation: and so many he be syker of all that he desireth. ¶ To whom so ever the moralyte of these fables be plefaunt or unlusty were you well that they lacketh all in some things lytteral truth. But a fable lacking lytteral truth unexponed: is nought else but a losing. And as holy scripture saeth/ all that ever doth or speaketh losing/ shall be partners of the pit of hell. wherefore after my simple cunning/ I have moralysed them in my manner: leaving the correction to other that been clerks and more cunning in that science. For sith it aperteneth not to holy wryt: every man without offence: may say that him seemeth most like to truth. Explicit Liber quartus. Sequitur Liber Quintus Boetij de consolatone Phie. WHen she had said she 'gan herself high To other things treted for to be your noble exhortation ꝙ I Full worthy it is of high authority But yet while oer as I remember me you did speak of divine prescience How hard it is I have experience ¶ And all belapped with demands feel Encomberous to any man's wit Full dangerous is that matter with to deal But now I pray you that you say me yet if hap be aught/ what manner thing is it Phia) I speed me ꝙ she for to pay my debt Of things that while oer I thee behete ¶ And for to set the in a ready way So that thou might return in to thy land This matter that thou askest sooth to say Though it be good to know & understand Loo yet this purpose that we have on hand Somewhat it is impertynent there to And furthermore it is to dread also ¶ Jest of thy ways that thou faint & fail As for thy journey that is overgone And jest thou suffice not to thy travail To that thou hast hereafter for to done Boeus) Then dread you not ꝙ I let me alone For this shall be right as a time of rest To hire of thing that me delighteth best ¶ And namely sith your process all a bout By dysputation so formally Concluded is/ it may not been in doubt Of that you will enducen suyngly Phia) Right as thou wilt ꝙ she right so will I And she be 'gan to declare in this wise what ever he be ꝙ she that will devise ¶ That hap is such a thing that should be fall wythouten cause or skyle of governance Than say I thus/ that hap is naught at all But an Idel name & of no vaylaunce sith god hath set all thing in ordinance Now should there any place then be To worken things in uncertainty ¶ For tru●y nogh this sentence hath be hold Loo that there may no thing be done of naught This sentence revoked never fathers old Of one beginner all thing must be wrought yet this was not the conceit of their thought though all thing have a maker pryncypal They did mean of subject materyal ¶ For that they put as for a fundament And that hath ever reason of nature Than will it suen clear and consequent This may well perceive every creature if any thing were done by adventure wythouten causes where of to proceed Than must it come of naught it is no dread ¶ But sith this may not be in no manner Than hap may not be called sickerly such as we dyffyned have while ere Boecius) what is there than no manner thing ꝙ I That chance or hap is called skylefully Or such a thing there is to folken unknown where to these name belangeth as you trow ¶ Phia) yes mine Aristoteles ꝙ she In his book of physyke naturel Breffely he showeth what thing it should be Full nigh the truth dyffyneth he it full well Boeus) And how ꝙ I phia) Lo this is every deal ꝙ she that writeth Aristoteles Of this matter/ & it is no less ¶ As often as there is a work wrought As for a certain purpose of intent And then of other causes unbethoght Betydeth other wise than was be meant Loo hap this may be called verament As if it lust a man to delffe his land And hid theryn a some of gold he found ¶ Of such a thing men deemeth sickerly Loo that a sudden adventure it is yet came it not of no thing pardey But proper causes were be forn ywis The concourse of wych causeth this Butt for it fell unware & unbethought it seemeth folk that hap ●ut hath wrought ¶ For but the telyer had dolue his ground And eke the hyder put it in that stead Thou mayst well seyn the gold had not be found As in that manner wise it is no dread These causes been of adventurous deed when that they meet & been assembled so wythouten certain purpose to be do ¶ For he that dalf & he that hid it there Purposed not thou mayst suppose it well That gold to have been found in that manner Never one of them bethoght it never a deal But right as I have said it so befell That in the same place where these it hid That other dalf & found as it betide ¶ Now then in short to make an end of all And to make a final dyffynytion Loo hap is such a thing that doth befall No thing purposed of entention Of divers causes meeting in to one In things that for somewhat were wrought But unto that that is be fall/ nought ¶ But this uneschevable ordinance which that the well head proceedeth fro Of the high divine purueyaunce wythouten which there may no thing be do That maketh these causes to concurren so That all thing desposeth kendly In proper place & times certainly Metrum j Capitulum ij. Rupis achimenie scopulis. Phia loquitur. TIgris and Eufrates springeth both Out of a nag rock of Ermeny Out of one well head to say the sooth where men been wont to fyghten wonderly In flight they harmeth them that sueth nigh There sharp darts in their breast fyxing So when they fleyth their foes moste noing ¶ These rivers both been disjoined soon And runneth in to divers streams great And after that they fallen in to one where that they in another place meet The ships than & stocks that their fleet In either of these streams down a long it happeth that they meet ever a 'mong ¶ This water thus Implieth & 〈◊〉 Thus meddling many chances fortunel But of that shevey earth it so behappeth The wych this water sueth/ weet it well That fleting order ruleth every deal Right so is hap unruled as deemeth you But nevertheless it hath a law of certente Prosia ij. Capituln iij. Animaduerto inquam. Boecius loquitur. TO this ꝙ I full well accord I can And that you say I may it well believed But in the order of these causes than The wych so suyngly to gedres cleveu This would I see/ if you could show or preven if in out choice is any liberty Other else that this cheyn of destyne ¶ Constreyneth all the movyug of our wit Phia) ꝙ she in sooth then were it all a miss That will I show & clearly proven it For why/ no kenned that reasonable is whythouten liberty may been ywis For all that kendly reason usen may May demen & dyscern it is no nay ¶ And by himself he knoweth kendly what thing is to desire & what to fleen And what thing that he deemeth verily That worthy is desired for to be That thing loo seeketh & desireth he And what he judgeth worthy to be forsake That will he leave/ & that other take ¶ Then every thing that reason hath certain Of will & nel hath liberty thereto But all y leke/ in sooth will I not sayen For divine substances standeth not so The judgement is wonder clear of though There will is incorrupt/ there might is priest And speedy to all that them liketh best ¶ But moste in freedom is the soul of man when he is set in contemplation And fully fyxen all his thoughts can In high divine speculation And less if that his occupation In worldly thing dystracteth aught his mind And less when flesly bounds doth him bind ¶ But when a man is given unto vice Than is he utterly bond & thrall When he hath set his reason at no prise And wilfully hath let it fro him fall His liberty is then jest of all When that his sight in worldly wrecchednesse Is cast fro light of sovereign sothfastnesse ¶ He begenneth then to wax dark & dull Of that foul cloud of Ignorance Of foul affections than he shall be full Encumbered with the vice of inconstance That trobeleth him with anguish & grievance To wych when he consenteth in his wit In servage then himselfen hath he knit ¶ In manner of his proper liberty A caytyf is becomen in conscience But never the later he that all may see As by his high eternal prescience All thing governing by his excellence He hyreth & saith well every thought & deed And so he will desposen for their meed Metrum ij. Puro clarum lumie. Phia THe noble poet honey mouth Omere Loo of the son singeth on this wise And saith/ for all his bright beams clear The see/ ne land yet may he not suffice To persen thorough/ so may we not devise Of him that hath this wide world wrought The heavy earth him wythstandeth nought ¶ from far & high all thing he saith a none He is not let by clouds of the night For all that is/ was/ or shall be done At one's is it all beforn his sight sith he alone with his beams bright So all things may behold & see We may well sayen a very son is he Prosa iij. Capitulum u. Tum ego en inquam. Boecius loquitur. I said then/ a greater doubt now Confoundeth me then did be fore ywis Phia) Of what ꝙ she art thou in doubt now Now right in sooth conject I what it is Boecius) full hugely ꝙ I repugneth this That god may known all thing oer it be And that our will may stand at liberty ¶ sith god be forn saith all that shall be do And his sight loo may be deceived naught Of very for'rs then need it must be so That prescience hath seyn that is to be wrought And not only work/ but will & thought Of every wight he knoweth plenerly Than is no freedom in our arbytry ¶ For why there may be nother thought ne deed That pnrueyaunce beforn ne saith it all He faileth not there of/ it is no dread But all that ever he wot betyden shall All that he saith beforn it must befall And if it may be turned other wise it was not seyn be fore at my devise ¶ Than shall this be no very prescience But as an uncertain opinion But sickerly this were a foul offence Of god to feelen that conclusion And some men supposeth that this question May been assoiled thus/ as they believe But their reasons can I not apprene ¶ Loo thus they sayen/ a thing that shall betide Betydeth not for god provideth so But god that thing to comen doth provide And saith beforn all thing that shall be do And thus a geynward should the causes go That god foreseyth this thing that shall be wrought But of need it shall vetyde naught ¶ They sayen also that thing that shall befall In god's sight provided is it need Loo this answer assoyleth naught at all This doubtful question it is no dread Only to this intent it doth proceed Loo of ij. divers things to enquere wych of them the cause of other were ¶ Whether that the prescience of god a lone Causeth thing to fallen nedely Other else thing that needs shall be done Loo causeth prescience in god on high This is no very answer sickerly To that that I intend for to show But nevertheless my purpose standeth true ¶ How ever it standeth of this ordinance That wych of these the cause of other be A thing that is forseyn by purueyaunce Of need it must betide as seemeth me Though it be so that this necessyre Be not y caused of this prescience As in effect there is no difference ¶ As if I sit & thou supposest it Than needs sooth is thine opinion But my sitting is not caused yet As needful by thy estimation And right so if thou torn it up so down if thou supposest sooth of that I do Eke of necessity than is it so ¶ necessity then must there been in both un to that point loo here we been brought In me of sitting & in the of sooth yet wottest thou well that therefore sit I nought As for that sooth opinion in thy thought But rather thus/ be cause that I sat Loo thine opyvyon was sooth in that ¶ Than is this truth caused of the deed And so in both there is necessity Loo in the same wise we may proceed Of this purueyaunce as seemeth me For 'cause these things shall here after be There fore by purueyaunce he saith it all And yet therefore doth it not befall ¶ And never the later all that shall betide Of god it is provided nedefully And eft again all that he doth provide Of need it doth befallen certainly And all the freedom of our arbytry Loo this sufficeth to destroy clean Here appeareth well how masedly we mean ¶ That adventure of things temporel Should causen his eternal prescience But this would been a folly thing to feel with reason hath it no convenience For it would suen of their evidence That things past long time seyn Should causen god that is our sovereign ¶ As if I know a thing that present is while I it know needs is it so Right so a thing that shall been after this if I it know/ of need it must be do it sueth well we may not go there fro And so my purpose may not be removed That thing prescite/ may not been exchued ¶ For if I dame thus of a certain thing And is not so/ it is no question Not only is that conceit no cunning But error of a false opinion And wonder far is that suspection And divers fro the truth as I suppose But ho can save it with a better gloze ¶ For if there shall a certain thing be wrought And shall not fallen of necessity But is uncertain to betide or nought it is not known to been as seemeth me For knowing/ with falsehood may no wise be In no manner conjoined ne deceived But it must been that knowing hath conceived ¶ And other wise may it not be done For loo that is the very cause why That in a knowing error is there none sith troth then standeth nedefully And knowing comprehendeth verily what than a 'vaileth that we been a bout How knoweth god a thing that is in doubt ¶ For if that god a certain thing devise For to be done that no wight may exchwe And yet it may betyden other wise A perilous error here of will there sue That god's judgement should been untrue But loo of god our high sovereign Full felones is/ thus to think or sayen ¶ And if he knoweth things for to be So that they may betide indifferent As be or not be/ then can I not seyn But this is an uncertain judgement The prescience of god omnip●otent what thing is it I can it not defend That may no thing in certain comprehend ¶ Than should there be no manner difference As seemeth in mine estimation between the high divine prescience And Tyresyes dyvynation Of whom Ouyde maketh mention what ever I say she said/ it shall be fall Other else shall it not betide at all ¶ what better shall this purueyance be Than the opinion of a man's wit That deemeth things in uncertainty And so uncertainly betydeth it Over all thing we must believed yet That god is very well & syker ground In whom no thing uncertain may be found ¶ Than every thing in certain shall betide Thyt is before seyn in his purueyance Than is no liberty in man's side Ne in our chesing is no chevysance divine thought may have no varyance wythouten error he beholdeth all And bindeth us to thing that must befall ¶ And have we once fully geten this He may perceven ho so taketh heed Man's life in what myscheffe it is And standeth ever in heaviness & dread why should there any man receiven meed Or any surfetour be put in peyn All this will semen but a thing in veyn ¶ sith that no wilful moving of their ghost Of liberty they naught deserved han And things that now been commended most As very wrong they must be deemed than For virtue to rewarden any man Or punyssshen any wicked skylefully There neither hath deserved willingly ¶ Butt necessity them hath constrained To things that of certain must be done Than vice & virtue is but thing feigned Ne in our works meret is there none But an undyscrete confusion There is no thing that worse may be thought sith all thing in order forth is brought ¶ Of purueyaunce/ ne unto man's wit No thing is lefful/ & our vices wood Loo unto god they been referred yet which that very auctor is of all good And furthermore if that this error s●ode whereto should we prayen aught or trust when we may no thing win that us lust ¶ if all that ever we can desire or say One certain order unreversed knetteth Then whereto should we hopen aught or pray sith purueyaunce faileth not ne fletteth That every thing so at a certain putteth This only merchandise is voided than That used is between god & man ¶ Prayer & hope should been unprofitable But with the price of Just humility we getteth of god a meed unestimable For only that hath ever the manner be That every man may have hab●lyte with god to speak & neghen to that light That pierced may not be with man's sight ¶ By very reason of this prayer meek To him we be conjoined verily Before or then we gete that we beseke And if we should assenten utterly That thing to come must fallen nedefully This hope & trust of which we spoken beforn Is thing of naught & all our labour loren ¶ How should we then to that prince a 'bove Aprochen or be knette by any mean if that we may deserve of him no love And all our labour is not worth a been But all mankend standeth disjoined clean As fro their head departed all with wrong Right as while oer you said in your song Metrum iij. Capitulum uj. Que nam discors. Boecius loquitur. WHat manner cause of wonder dyscordance So hath disjoined thus in this manner Our liberty & gods purueyaunce That neither may to other neyghen near What god this battle hath devised here Be tweve ij. truths here of have I wonder That sooth enough been while they been a sounder ¶ But loo they may not been together set And yet dyscord in truths is there none Full certainly they been to gedres knette But man's soul that so is overgone Enclosed thus wythyn flesh & bone That soppressed hath her fiery light That she yet may not lyften up her sight ¶ These sotel knots to be hold & see The flesly bounds doth it so oppress But why so fervently desireth she The notes for to find of sothfastnesse And that she seeketh so with business wot she that herself knoweth it But ho desireth a knawen thing to weet ¶ Ho may desire a thing & knoweth it naught if he ne knoweth what seeketh he so blind Or ho may seek that is not in his thought Or if he seek it/ how shall he it find Or how shall he remember it in his mind How may he known when he findeth this And wot not of what manner form it is ¶ when that the soul is sole & separate Behalding on that sovereign thought on high Then may he see/ that now he may nat All thing in some & also singularly But now she is enclosed bodily Some part of this sight she hath forlete But utterly she hath not all forget ¶ For why the some she haldeth as I trow But not so every thing in specyalte He than that these truth would know All knoweth he not/ thou mayst well se Ne all the truth forget hath not he But loo the knowing of the general Maketh him to labour for the special ¶ This some then wych she haldeth here In her thought remembering oft again She seeketh in that sovereign mirror clear wheat every sooth may syngul●rly be seen Enforsing her with labour & with peyn Forgeten thing/ if that she may it find To put it to the treasure of her mind Prosa iiij. Capitulum seven. Tum illa vetus inquam. Phia loquitur. SHe said then/ this is an old complaint And a full comen used question To Marcus Tullius it samed quaint As by his book of dyvynation He had there with great occupation And of thyself full long it hath be sought And none of you as yet ne fonud it naught ¶ Ne suffysantly have not declared it And sickerly the cause may this be That the dyscours of a man's wit May not atteyn to so high degree To demen of that high symplycyte which is in divine purueyaunce He is not soothly of that suffysaunce ¶ And if this might be thought or comprehended Thou shouldest then be never a deal in doubt But at last I hope I shall amend it if that I may my matter bring a bout This error of thy heart to a voyden out But first I will a voyden & dyspreven Conceits/ which the to this error moven ¶ But first I ask the the cause why Thou holdest this reason not effectuel Of them that shown that your arbytry Algates in his freedom standeth well sith presciens constreyneth never a deal By need/ things which that shall be done But is contingeut for to be or none ¶ Loo makest thou any other argument Of thing to fallen of necessity But for 'cause that god omuipotent Knoweth it/ that it shall here after be it may not be undone as seemeth the And yet this presciens causeth naught The same thing of need to be wrought ¶ That granted thou while oer if thou have mend why is it then that voluntary deed So is constrained to a certain end That thing to comen must be fallen need But that I may the to the truth lede To see what sueth here by consequence I put this case there were no prescience ¶ Will then thine argument a vaylen aught The wych in prescience thou groundest so That things wych of free will should be wrought That any need compelleth them there to Thou wilt not trow that Boecius) I said no Phia) Now set we ꝙ she prescience again So that of need it do no thing constreyn ¶ Than standeth absolute the same will Hole in his liberty/ this wottest thou well But I suppose thou makest me this skyle Though prescience necesseth never a deal Thing to come in stounds temporel Thou sayst it is a very sign true Of thing that must as necessary sue ¶ Right so thou might concluden as by this Though that there were no prescience at all That things wych to come hire after is necessarily it must be fall For only every sign shown shall A thyug that is or after shall be seyn But yet that sign maketh it not to be ¶ And if that prescience a sign were Of every thing that needs must come first it needeth us to shown hire That no thing falls but needs it must be done And if it be not so than knowest thou soon That sign may there none be verily without a thing betokened be there by ¶ But to confirmen fully all a bout And sadly to susteyn our intent we may not seek signs of without Ne fyxe us in a foreyn argument But of causes full convenient And necessary/ behoveth us to proceed if that we should in our purpose speed ¶ But this thou wilt replyen here again How may that thing not fallen sayest thou me which that is provided & foreseyn By purueyaunce here after for to be As chance that I couth none other see But thing that prescience doth provide we trowed that it were not to betide ¶ But rather this intended I for to prove That though a certain thing befall so yet of proper kende we do believe So was it not necessed to be do This lightly master thou understanden loo As many a thing▪ is subject to our sight The while it is be forn us present right ¶ As when a charre is ruled readily And how it torneth we be hold full well And so of other crafts suyngly Doth any thing this crafts men compelle Or any of these works canst thou tell Or if they be constrained to be wrought Boecius) Nay ꝙ I they be compelled naught ¶ Then ydel were the craft of any man if every thing were compelled for to move Phia) sith things while they been she said them Been not coacted to be/ thou wilt believe Loo by that same reason now mayst thou prove That before though same things be Not for to comen of necessity ¶ Full many a thing shall been it is no dread And is to come it sueth well by this That utterly is absolute of need I trow that no wight this will sayen y wys That any thing that now in present is was not to come unto the time it fell Though they beforn of god were known well ¶ In sooth yet been they freely to be fall For rygh as very knowing & science A present thing compelleth naught at all Right so it standeth eke of prescience As thou mayst see by like convenience Though god this thing to comen doth provide yet is it not compelled to beryde ¶ But loo of this thou sayest me/ doutest thou sith things wych that shall here after been Be not to come as necessary now How is that thing fore seyn thou canst not seyn it seemeth the that this dyssoneth clean To foreseyn thing it must needs sue necessity/ thou canst it not exchwe ¶ And if necessity should be forfended Loo foreseyn is there no thing utterly Ne naught by knowing may be comprehended But thing that must betyden verily And if there aught betide uncertainly And is fore seyn full certain as it were Thou sayest/ no very knowing is there there ¶ But as a dark & opynable thing And for to trowen other wise or guess Than very sooth/ that callest thou no cunning But a weening of unstableness And loo the cause of all this error is That you trow the cause of knowledge to be In the thing & not in the knower perdie ¶ But in contrary wise it standeth right For every thing that known is by wit it is not known by his proper might But by his might that comprehendeth it As by example mayst thou feelen yet For of a thing that round is verily Loo sight & feeling knoweth it diversly ¶ The sight beholdeth the form fro a far At one's comprehending every deal But he that feeleth is conjoined near un to that compace for to know it well All a bout the sides must he feel And all that roundness so he knoweth than Loo/ diversly known is a man ¶ The comen wits jugen of without Imagination another wise And reason other wise it is no doubt Intelligence passeth all these Every of them so as he may suffice The comen wits knoweth naught at all But forms of subject materyal ¶ Imagening all only comprehendeth The form of man as unmateryally Reason then a boven this transcendeth Of man's kende he deemeth singularly with universal sight full sotelly But all these passeth yet intelligence As by a sight of heyer excellence ¶ He passeth all a 'bove these kendes here The compace of the university And he beholdeth in that exsampler The mirror of the high eternyte The form of man in his symplycyte But most it is to taken hide in this That the same might always that higher is ¶ Loo all the lower comprehendeth well But they may ascenden naught again To know & comprehend never a deal Of though that been a 'bove sooth to sayen For their comen wit may not up attain To things wych been Immateryal They may perceiven never a deal at all ¶ And furthermore Imagination Vnyversal kendes may not seyn Ne reason may have none Inspection Of forms/ wych that pure & simple been Intelligence comprehendeth clean And as it were/ beholdeth fro on high These forms he perceiveth plenerly ¶ conceiving than this form pryncipal He deemeth after/ all that is in man As he hath in the exsampler Ideal conceived/ that none other may ne can The university of reason knoweth he than And also forms of Imagening And eke materyal sensible thing ¶ And reason yet in this he useth naught Imagination ne comen wit But with a sotel smyting of the thought Full formally so he beholdeth it And more plenerly to speaken yet The sovereign high divine intelligence Over all things hath prospycience ¶ When reason doth behalden aught or see As in his comen kende universal Imagening/ no thing yet useth he neither the comen wits never a deal And never the less he comprehendeth well All thing that Imagenable is And all that comen wit may know y wysse ¶ Thus reason his conceits strong & stable Of universal loo deffyneth he Man is a best two. footed reasonable Loo/ this knowing as every man may see Universal must it needs be And this thing also to every man's wit Imagenable & sensible is it yet ¶ But reason this beholdeth kendly No thing by Imagination Ne by the comen wits sickerly But only hath consideration By dyscours & by conceit of reason But this Imagination begin doth In the comen wits his works in sooth ¶ Forms for to shappen & devise And yet these comen wits all without sensible things/ in a wonder wise He saith/ & them compaseth all a bout Not sensyblely/ it is no doubt But by Imagination of mind Of knowing loo/ here mayst thou see the kind ¶ That not the might of thing that known is But proper might/ the knower useth need And skylefully for every doom y wysse Loo of the juge/ it is the proper deed So than of reason/ if thou take good hide The work of man is no foreyn might But proper myghtes useth every wight Metrum iiij. Capitulum ix. Quondan porticus attulit Phia loquitur. Some time in the porches of Athenes were old clerks dark in their courage which in their time were called stoicenes That in the porches had maden their stages Desputing/ that the forms & Images Of bodily substances/ as they guessed were in to a man's soul impressed ¶ As men been used to written & portrayen Letters in a pagyn fair & clean In wych beforn were no notes seyn But this a mased thing is for to mean For if the soul of man/ so as they ween Of his proper might Implieth naught But suffereth to been prented in his thought ¶ subjecteth to the notes as it were That bodies doth in them enpressen so And vain Images representeth there Right as a mirror is I woned to do But all this knowing whence cometh it fro By wych not only things corporal But also forms Immateryal ¶ He saith & so beholdeth singularly As in her high conceits speculatyffe And knowing things then suyngly So he dyvydeth by a negatyffe And after wards by an affyrmatyffe These same things that divided be Assembleth & again compouneth he ¶ And so this way he enterchaungeth oft For now to pryncypal proposytions Loo/ his intent he lifteth up a loft And falls after to conclusions Referring then his own intentions And saith what things will of other sue Repreving so the false by the true ¶ Than is he rather 'cause efficient And more of might than thing that lieth oppressed In manner like a matter patient That notes hath so in himself Impressed But that thou have this matter more expressed There goth before a manner sufferance wythyn the lively bodily substance ¶ wych that the myghtes of the soul excyteth And maketh the to understand & lere As when that light in to thine yeyn smiteth And maketh the for to behalden there Or when a voice hath souned in thine ere And so commoveth the to hearken aught Then been stirred the myghtes of thy thought ¶ And things which that were yet kendely wythyn thyselfen hid/ it is no doubt Thou then appliest in thy fantasy To these other notes of without And thus remembering in thyself a bout though foreyn Images than addeth he To forms which that hid wythyn the be Prosa u Capitulum ix. Quod si in corporibus. Phia loquitur. THough that object qualyteys than Commove & stir our foreyn Instruments wych I call the comen wit of man That of wythouteforth giveth judgements And goth before the ghostly sentementes A manner sufferance corporal For to excyte the ghostly might with all ¶ And styren so the working of the mind To forms wych arrested so were wythyn So that the courage may them feel & find And though the wits all this work begin The knowing of these bodies for to win And bringeth him to a manner remembrance The soul is subject to no sufferance ¶ But he deemeth of his proper might These passions that in the body been How moche more such a ghostly wight That fully is all absolute & clean In whom may none affection be seyn Of any thing to be feled bodily His proper might shall usen kendly ¶ And foreyn myghtes shall he usen naught For to discern objects of without But by the working of his own thought He winneth his conceits all a bout And by the same skyle it is no doubt Full many fold of knowing mayst thou find In substances/ divers in there kende ¶ The feeling may be called one of though which have bests that been unmeveable That wit they have all only & no more As shell fish & such that cleven stable In cleffes/ as to them is covenable And so such other shylle fish of the see which in divers places norysshed be ¶ But knowing of Imagination movable bests have & doth it sue The wych in manner haveth affection Some manner thing to coveyt or exchwe But reason to dyscernen false & true Only to man it hath convenience As only doth to god intelligence ¶ Than is it so as every man may see That this knowing most worthy is & high wych of his own kendly property Not only that pertaineth kendely un to his own knowing properly He knoweth well/ but furthermore yet The subject knoweth he of every wit ¶ But what if comen wits stood again And in this wise peradventure answer And would unto dyscours of reason sayen Loo/ that this universal/ no thing were That reason seemeth he beholdeth there For all that ever Imagenable is Or comen wits may perceive y wysse ¶ it is not universal in no wise Now/ or the judgement of reason than Must be sooth/ if he will thus devise That no thing may be sensible to man Or for he wot well that these wits han Subjects many/ divers/ that they know His own conceving fallace must he trow ¶ When that he saith & comprehendeth well Thing that sensible is & singular Behalding it right as universal To this if reason would aunsweren hear That she herself beholdeth well & clear By reason of universalyte Albina that these other may perceive & see ¶ for wits ne Imagination May no way comprehenden sickerly These universal things of reason For they may not exceeden properly As by their own knowing kendly Shappes & figures corporal A boven that may they no thing at all ¶ In knowing then of things at the last it is to give credence to the judgement That most perfect is & stedefaste And we that have this reason excellent And comen wit to demen thing present And Imagination also Should we not reason here assenten to ¶ But man's reason is alike in this As towards divine intelligence Right as imagining or wits is To reason of a man's conscience That weeneth that divine prescience May no manner thing behalde as he troweth That is to come/ but as himselfen knoweth ¶ For loo/ this argument thou makest me if things that hereafter shall be done Not certain ne necessary be For knowing may not fallen there upon For prescience sayest thou is their none And if so is that prescience be There falls naught but of necessity ¶ But if we might partners been Loo/ of the domes of divine thought Right as we may by very reason see That Imagening sufficeth naught Ne comen wits to perceiven aught The judgement of reason as we dame Full Just it should man's reason seem ¶ To be subject & undercast always un to divine thought/ I am certain A rise we there fore fully if we may To that intelligence sovereign And if we may in to that height atteyn Loo there shall reason feel & known well That in it self he may do never a deal ¶ Loo/ that is this as in what wise & how The things that betydeth thus uncertainly This prescience saith it well enough Dyffyned in his thought eternally Not by guessing opynablely But by sovereign science of symplenesse whom terms may not closen ne compress Metrum u Capitulum x. Quam varijs terras. Phia loquitur. These bests in their kendes dyfferent Full diversly on earth doth they glyden Somme on their body strecching & extent Creeping upon their breasts down they slyden And in the dust a forwe they dyvyden And some by very lightness of their kind with their wings planeth in the wind ¶ And long spaces of the air on high So in their flight/ they swymmeth as it were And sum been glad to keep themselfen nigh This ground a low & set their stappes here In green fields/ there is all their cheer And some to walk in woods & forestes And though so be that all these wild bests ¶ Been divers in their shappes & figure All their faces been inclined yet un to the ground showing their nature And the kendly dullness of their wit Loo/ only kende of man reverseth it For man's head a riseth up on height And even upright his body standeth streght ¶ And under him the earth beholdeth he whether dotest thou/ or art thou in a sweven Thou earthly man thy figure teacheth the That lifteth up thy visage in to heaven And thy frount in to the air full even On earthly thing thou shouldest not set thy love But set it holly in the heaven a 'bove ¶ There shouldest thou be there is thy kendly place Thou hast of the earth but thy bestly kende And yet loo thou wilt bring thyselfen base And so with bests set thyself behind Lete not the noble nature of thy mind Be plounged down & to the ground y pyght sith that thy body standeth even upright Prosa uj. Capitulum xj. Quoniam igitur uti. Phia loquitur. sith every thing as I have showed now right That wist or known is in any way it is not known of the proper might Of that self thing it is no nay But of the kendly might/ the sooth to say Of though that doth it know or comprehend Now let us then behalden & intend ¶ So as our simple kende may suffice what thing is that astate of excellence Of divine substance/ & in that wise Than somewhat may we know of his science This is the used general sentence Of all/ that by reason doth discern They say that god himself is eterne ¶ But now what thing is this eternyte it needeth first to known sickerly And after that we may behalde & see The science and the nature plenerly So as we may suffysen symplely Of god that is our prince & sovereign Eternyte is this as clerks sayen ¶ it is a perfect hole possession At one's of a life intermynable This is declared by comparison Of thing that is by times variable For all that leaveth in time it is unstable Present yet is/ the time a gone is passed To time coming hyeth it full fast There may no thing be set in time & space As clerks have devised here be forn That all at once may his life embrace For why as yet/ he faileth of to morn And yesterday is passed & forlorn And in the same day that present is Of your life you have no more y wysse ¶ But this moment transitory loo That thing that hath this dysposytion His times for to over passen so Though that it were of such condytion By Aristoteles tradition That said this world never began Ne never here after shall an end han ¶ Though that it might as Aristotel seemed To infinite it selfen so extend Eterne it may not ryghtuously be deemed Though it were infinite wythouten end At one's all it may not comprehend Ne clyppen all these spaces temporel For of time to come yet hath it not a deal ¶ But he that of the life intermynable The fullness comprehendeth verily possessing it at one's perdurable Fro whom no thing doth lacken verily For time to come he hath it presently Ne time passed fro him is there none Is/ & was/ & shall be/ all is one ¶ Eterne he may be called well by right To himself present and peerless And all way present is be fore his sight The moble space of times endless But they rehersen Plato/ nevertheless His conceit they reporteth all a miss And of his meaning faileth foul y wysse ¶ Loo Plato saith this world hath ever ybe ¶ As clerks have deffyned/ Time is measure of moving of before & after. This measure is taken most commonly after the moving of the E●noctial whos moving is the swiftest that is possible. The which line is divided in to CCC.lx. even parts. Of which parts/ everich is called a degree. The measure of a rising of xv. degrees/ is called an hour natural. The measure of a rising of xxiiii. hours/ is a day natural. The measure of CCC. lxv. days & vi. hours of encresse and certain mynutes/ is called a year. By which times: the perdurabelte of this world of before & after/ is measured usyngly. sith than that measure of moving is called time/ then sueth it: that before the world moved/ there was no time: But god eternally is/ er any thing moved: or any time were/ and shall be after that all mevynges cesseth: For his being is measured by no moving of before & after/ for himself is unmeveable/ ne his being hath no regard to before & after For all times present/ passed/ and to come: been to him verily present Ne his being is not measured by succession of times. For he hath his being unmesured all at one's. which is called his eternyte. There fore is god called Inmensus. But the perdurabelte of the world is measured by moving of the heaven/ which is called time: And longer than heaven meveth/ shall there be no tyme. Than is it so that the being of god is called erernyte. The being of this world is named perpetuyte. Then is this the conceit of Plato saying that the world hath ever been/ That is to mean/ as long as any thing hath moved. And as long as any thing meveth: or any time is/ so long it shall endure in such being as it now hath. And after that all moving and all times cesseth/ the world renewed shall endure in life interminable. For so saith our lord. Ecce nova facio omnia. ¶ This interminable life/ is the eternal being of our creator▪ to whom as to their end/ all thing shall be reduced: and at him as at their final end: rest & abide. Therefore saith plato as is in the text alleged/ that the world hath ever been: that is to say: sith any time was. and it shall never while any time is/ cessen of his meaning. So moving & time shall cessen both at one's. And the world than shall not end by destruction or torn in to naught/ for god and nature did never thing in vain. Ne god noughteth never thing that he made but the corruption of one thing/ is the generation of another thing. So that at last every corruptible thing retorneth in round in to the Elements/ that it was first form of. And there fore the author saith/ that the intent of temporel things that so mevethe in round/ casts & intendeth by leading of nature/ to counterfete the perdurable life of god. For kendly every creature coveteth: to conform him to his make/ at jest in being. where fore of nature every thing wythstandeth in that it may/ his own corruption & division of his parts. And when it is corrupt and resolved in to his first matter/ which is the elements/ which been cleped the sedes of earthly things then been they apt as they were be fore to be matter and to cloth other divers forms. And so been they perpetuate/ by their chaungeabelte in to an endless compate. For these things if they fail in there individues/ yet in their universals they a bideth ever: after time that they once be. And the matter of the singulers/ torneth into other things/ after that nature worcheth. Than is this the conceit of the clerk in the letter. Every creature as is before said/ coveteth of nature/ for to counterfete his maker. But for cause these earthly things of feebleness and contraryoustey of their matter/ may not endure/ but needs be resolved/ therefore they take that they may of being/ enduring by succession of times. where that god endureth (not by temporal succession) but hath his being separate fro creatures all at one's so that towards him naught is to come/ ne naught over passed/ But all that is/ was/ and shall be: is be fore him present. Than having regard to the eternyte of god/ which hath his being all at one's unmesured by succession of times/ there is no purueyaunce ne foresyght/ but he saith all by present knowledge/ & in him/ is none other sight but cunning. For all knowing of present and passed/ noteth imperfection of creatures that be passing and corruptible. And it needeth naught/ ne is convenient/ to conform his eternal insyght to our temporal estimation/ that all thing deemeth by before and after as we have over being. But it accordeth better/ and is more kendly/ that the creature submit all his wit/ and conform all his knowing holly to his maker/ with out whom he is naught/ can naught/ ne hath naught at all/ that aught oweth to be cleped. ¶ sith it is so then that every judgement/ must sue the nature of the juge/ that is of him that knoweth/ it needeth not them to bynden things to fall necessarily/ ne to weet the knowing of god for to compel though things to betide/ be cause that he saith it presently as he all beholdeth/ no more than for to wit me the moving of the son/ by cause I see it move/ or for to wit me the death of a man because cause I see him die. For the moving of the son is caused absolutely of the first ordinance of him that made it for to move. But that I now see it move/ it proceedeth of my own fire will/ presupposed that I have my yees hole & liberty to see all present objects that falls to my lust. And to an end it shall never be brought They say therefore it hath eternyte As even alike with god that hath it wrought But yet all one in certain is it naught A life interminable for to lede As Plato thought himself it is no dread ¶ it is another to enclosen all At once so this life intermynable For all that is/ or was/ or ever shall At him it is present & permenable He fleteth naught but always standeth stable Loo/ of divine thought the state is this No creature may been alike y wisse ¶ And yet for that you shall not demen here That god is elder as in time of space Than creatures made of his power But this loo shall you jugen in this case That god himselfen always is & was Before/ er any formed creature In proper symplenesse of his nature ¶ And the intent of things temporel That always meveth so contynuelly They cast to counterfeten every deal The perdurable life of god on high That changeth not but standeth presently But when it may not even it self there to There very stableness they falls fro ¶ And meveth then out of symplycyte Decressing out of present then a none To infinite and endless quantity Of time to come & time that is a gone But when he may not bring it in to one Albina his life at one's for to have it willeth thus it selfen for to save ¶ And there it may not been a bout y brought So all his life at one's for to gete yet in as moche as it endeth naught This lyffe it doth not utterly forlete But it seemeth that it volde counterfete The sovereign life of god omnipotent In so moche as he somewhat hath present ¶ And so it bindeth him to a little stound To have a manner perdurablenesse In which no time of space may be found But for it hath a manner lekelynesse Of the eternal life that present is it seemeth how so ever hyt flee or fleet That in present ever a bideth it ¶ And for it may not after his delight A byden/ but for such a little space it taketh always of times infinite And for it may not all his life embrace At one's/ as his princypal purpose was Passing forth the life he keepeth so For cause he may ne can none other do ¶ And if we should by names him discern To suen Plato where he said well He said that god himself is eterne Loo/ & the world should be perpetuel Of this mayst thou conceiven then full well sith every judgement that shall be true it must the nature of himselfen sue ¶ To comprehenden things of without And thestate of sovereign god on high standeth ever in one it is no doubt Algates in himselfen presently His knowing then surmounteth sickerly All thing/ that hath moving in difference A biding in his symplycyte of presence ¶ And so encloseth spaces infinite Of time that was & shall here after be But to though spaces hath he no respect But to his own hole eternyte By knowing of his high symplycyte All thing in presens of his sight He saith it as it were do now right ¶ if thou consydre that prescience in thy though By wych he knoweth all things so This prescience shalt thou referren naught As to a thing that after shall be do But very science shalt thou dame it loo Of present time that never faylen may Ne out of presens pass never a way ¶ For why it is not called prevydence But rather is it called purueyaunce That all things knoweth in presence In wych knowing there is no variance Fro our knowing/ it hath full great distance For we beholdeth lo things here But fro on high beholdeth he all in fere ¶ sith every judgement must suen than The nature of the knower kendely wherefore is it that thou askest than That all must fallen necessarily That seyn is in divine sight on high sith men the present things that they seyn Maketh naught/ of need for to be ¶ Loo/ may thy sight of things here present Make them to fallen of necessity Boeus) I said nay Phia) ꝙ she right so it stint Of god's purueyaunce/ as seemeth me All though there may no comparison be For the prescience of a man's thought To god's prescience may be lekened naught ¶ For right as you beholdeth with your sight That in this time present is y don Rygh so he saith in his eternal light So/ that thing to coming is there none As in his sight/ ne no thing over go where fore his prescience (it sueth well) The nature of things changeth never a deal ¶ For sith he saith though things presently Right as they shall here afterward befall The judgement of things sickerly His knowing confundeth no thing at all For all thing that betide here after shall whether needful or contingent be the end At one's all he saith it is in his mind ¶ Right as thou sayst a man go on the ground And the son also in heaven a rise And both thou behaldest in one stound yet canst thou well dyscernen & devise Loo that that this man wych walketh in this wise He doth himself willingly that deed But yet in sooth the son a riseth need ¶ Ne the sight of god that is so clear That all thing doth him be nethen see Of these worldly things that been here Destorbeleth never a deal the quality which in the sight of his eternyte Ben present now/ but to the sight of man Theridamas time they shall here afterwards han ¶ And here of cometh this conclusion That what he wot that shall here after sue it is no fallace nother opinion But very science suffysant & true By wych he knoweth that it is not due As of necessity to fallen so But than thou sayest a thing that shall be do ¶ And is provided in divine thought it may not unbetyde/ it is no dread And thing that so may be exchwed naught Than of necessity/ it falls need And so thou wilt me bynden to the deed As by this word/ that is necessity And loo as truth/ I will it grant the ¶ But this uneath may feelen any wight Ne well conceiven in this earthly life But if he had a conceit & a sight Of god/ & fully were contemplative But unto this I answer the belyve when that thing that so to comen is To divine science/ referred is ¶ Loo/ necessary is it sickerly But in the manner of that proper kende when that thou it behaldest verily necessity doth it in no wise bind For ij. necessyteys shalt thou find Of which that one is simple/ weet it well And that other is conditional ¶ That every man is mortal of nature This is necessity of symplenesse But when thou knowest a man peradventure That walketh of his own wylfulnesse That man's walking necessary is with this condytion y put there to The while it is known to be so ¶ For thing that known is in man's thought As for the time it may none other be But this condytion sufficeth naught with him to drawn this symplycyte For well thou wottest that this necessity Cometh not of kendly dysposytion But of that accydent condytion ¶ And necessity doth him not compelle To walken/ he that walketh willingly But while he goth/ this will I grant well Loo that he walketh vecessaryly And in the same wise sickerly what purueyaunce as present doth provide So of necessity it doth betide ¶ And yet that thing as of his proper kende Truly doth not of necessity befall But all that god beholdeth in his mind That so of liberty betyden shall He beholdeth it as present all And so referred to divine sight As necessary they been a counted right ¶ But this is only by condytion Of the knowing of divine wit But when these things have relation un to their own proper kende yet All absolutely then betydeth it No thing compelled of necessity Ne it forleteth naught his liberty ¶ So than it shall befallen doubtless All that god to comen doth provide And moche thing shall fallen nevertheless That only shall of liberty betide So that they standeth free fro either side And though they be to come yet may we cheese So proper nature doth they not forlese ¶ There kende is this/ be forehand oer they were Of liberty they might have been undo But what force is it wilt thou say me hire where they come of necessity or no sith of divine science is it so In all wise it doth befallen this Right even as thing that necessary is ¶ Loo this/ as I a little here beforn Purposed by example plenerly Of the son that riseth by the morn And of a man that walketh willingly Till time they be in doing presently They may well be undone it is no dread But that one was to betyden need ¶ But sickerly that other needed naught So all that he beholdeth as present Right so wythouten doubt it shall be wrought But that the son riseth verament Loo of necessity it hath dessent But the man to walken or to gone His own choice it standeth all upon ¶ Now then in this we have said but right That when these things so referred be un to the knowing of divine sight Loo then they falls of necessity But referred to their quality Full absolute in liberty they stand As out of all necessary bond ¶ As all that appeareth to the comen wit if that they be referred to reason Universal than in sooth is it And if thou set in thine entention The property of their condytion So then thou feelest it as singular But if it be (thou sayest) in my power ¶ My purpose for to changen as me lust Loo than shall I a voyden purueyaunce By which the same is known & wist But I shall answer to thine allegiance Thy purpose mayst thou change at thy pleasance But this might for to done or do it naught And all that divers changing of thy thought ¶ The very present truth of prescience Every deal beholdeth presently And thou mayst not a voyden his presence No more than thou mayst a void verily The behalding of a present ye Though that thou wouldest thyselfen torn or wend As liketh to the free will of thy mind ¶ But here thou makest this objection if god's science may be changed so At my proper dysposytion As when I this now/ & now that may I do Than may I enterchaungen to & fro Loo his science by stounds at my will Nay for sooth/ that mayst thou not by skyle ¶ For why the knowing of divine sight Goeth before that thing that shall befall And before the proper presence right Loo of his knowing he retorneth all That ever was/ or been here after shall Ne as thou weenest he altereth naught His presence by stounds of thy thought ¶ As now this thing & now that thing to know But he abiding every wit compaseth The changing of thy thoughts all a row with one sight all at one's he enlaceth He goth also before & all embraceth His might also/ that all comprehendeth And eke his sight that to so fer extendeth ¶ All things to behalden presently He hath them not received so as we Of thing that is to comen suyngly But of his proper high symplycyte whereby it may full well assoiled be That thou while ere a geynst me hast y put Vnsembly sayest thou is it to thy wit ¶ That thing to come of our unstableness Should the cause been of his science But of his cunning loo the might is this He closeth all with knowing of presence Of divers time he hath no difference And all thing in to certain hath he brought To things passed oweth he right naught ¶ sith it is so/ I may concluden now That in every mortal creature The liberty abideth hole enough And standeth fully in their own cure And laws which that medes doth measure To though men that been good & virtuous And also pains to the vicious ¶ Then for unryght they may not been arected sith every man his own will is at As by necessity no thing y letted But that he may deseruen love or hate And god himselfen sit a 'bove algate And every thing he knoweth oer it be As present in his high eternyte ¶ In us behalding every thought & deed That is/ or shall be done/ in full certain And to the good men he desposeth meed And to the wicked punishment & peyn To trust in god it is no thing in veyn And preyours/ if they ryghtuously be led Believe it well/ they may not been unspedde ¶ withstand thou vice/ & give the to vertu To righteous hope/ thou life up thy courage And for thy needs/ if thou wilt pursue Humble preyer send in thy message Up to thy god/ it faileth not his wage Ne doubt the naught/ thou shalt be sped full soon For he refuseth never a lowly boon ¶ And look that thou my counsel not forget Dyssymule not/ but do thy business The need is thine/ also the charge is great That thau be found in virtue & prowess sith all thy work is open & express un to the presence of the juge on high That all thing doth behalden plenerly Explicit Liber Quintus Boecijs De consolation Phie Deo gracias. Collectis in sequentibus cuiuslibet linee primis litteris/ non solum Translatoris sed & transferri procurantis/ nomina cum cognominibus/ investigare poteris. Nomen transferri procurantis. EVer more exalted be thou lord on high Lawly which of thy benygnyte In flesh and blodde apering willingly So piteously were peyned on the tree And sufferest/ that grievous was to the Be bledde with all thy blodde for man's sake Ever more exalted be thy majesty Thine heart blood/ our ransom wouldest thou make Cognomen. ¶ Blysful lord I pray the heartily ere I departed of this mortalyte Rescue me fro my perilous enemy Keeping me fro his cursed cruelty Eternally to set my thought in the Lust of sins fully to forsake Endless god which art both one & iij. yn to thy cure for ever I me betake Nomen Translatoris. Tyelde you thanks lady Sapience Of that this work you to an end y brought Have you the worship & the recompense And I no deal/ I have deserved naught None other lust desire I in my thought Ne naught coveyt I but your Influence Eternally/ so that I may be brought sovereign lady in to your presence Cognomen Translatoris. with all my heart to do you reverence And service/ such as of me may be wrought Lawly under your obedience To please you if I sufficed aught With all my heart/ as ever I have besoght No thing coveyt I of your excellence Eternally but that I may be brought My sovereign lady in to your presence Here endeth the book of comfort called in latyn Boecius de consolation Phie. Enprented in the exempt monastery of Tavestok in Denshyre. By me Dan Thomas Richard monk of the said Monastery/ To the instant desire of the right worshypful esquyer Master Robert Langdon. Anno d. MDxxv. Deo Gracias. Robertus Lanhdon. blazon of Robert Langdon, Esq.