AN ANSWER To a Paper, called, The Case of the Auditors and Receivers of His MAJESTY 's Revenue. WITH A Brief Description of the Ancient Course of the EXCHEQVER for bringing in the Crown-Revenues. AS ALSO, Some Reasons wherefore the Augmentation-Revenue of the CROWN may be charged in the Great Roll of the Exchequer, and brought in by the SHERIFFS. Humbly offered to Consideration. LONDON, Printed by W. G. 1662. A TABLE of the Contents. THe Course held for the Crown Revenue before H. 3. time. pag. 1 How it shall be levied. Magna Charta. pag. 4 How all Accomptants ought to be called to Account, and make payment. Stat. 51. H. 3. pag. 4 Establishment made 54. H. 3. suitable to the said Statute. pag. 4 Statute 10. E. 1. confirming the said Establishment with some Additions. pag. 5 How foreign Accounts were taken in all former times. pag. 5 How and by whom in what manner Tails of the Exchequet ought to be allowed. pag. 6 How the Revenue is to be charged, and how discharges are made in the Great Roll. pag. 6 The Tenor of the Summons of the Exchequer. pag. 6 Tails not being rejoined shall be reputed as null. pag. 7 How lost Tails shall be Innovated. pag. 7 The right use of the Tallies pag. 7 How the Sheriff not acquitting the Debtor shall be dealt with. pag. 7 How the Clerk so offending shall be punished. pag. 7 The Authority of the great Roll. pag. 7 The Comptrolment Roll and the singular use thereof. pag. 8 Engrosser, controller, and Remembrancers Duties. pag. 9 The Ancient established Comptrol, and how confirmed. pag. 9 Answers to the Auditors Objections. pag. 9 Many Accounts taken, but not engrossed, and many imbezilled. 24 H. 7. pag. 10 Accounts of the demiseable Crown Lands to be delivered into the Pipe. Stat. 6. H. 8. pag. 10 Establishment made 38. H. 8. and confirmed 7. E. 6. pag. 10 Accounts to be engrossed and delivered into the Augmentation Court. pag. 11 Auditors might take Copies thereof within their Circuits. pag. 11 Augmentation Court dissolved and annexed to the Exchequer. Stat. 1. Ma. pag. 11 Establishment then made by Authority of Parliament. pag. 12 Accounts to be yearly Ingrossed, declared and delivered into the Pipe, there to remain. pag. 12 Accounts of the Augmentation Revenue delivered by Mittimus to the Engrosser. pag. 13 Auditors undue proceed being no Officers of Record. pag. 14 In admitting and dismismissing Accomptants to and from their Accounts unsworn. pag. 15 In not suffering the Accomptants Tails to be rejoined. pag. 15 In not Engrossing, not Declaring, and not delivering up those Accounts they have taken. pag. 15 Many Supers and Debts have thereby long time depended, to the prejudice of Prince and People. pag. 15 Many rents have been and are omitted to be charged. pag. 15 One Account in the great Roll, will comprehend 100 Accounts now taken by the Auditors. pag. 17 Five times more brought in yearly by the Summons then by all other the Process of the Exchequer. pag. 18 How the Statute 51. H. 3. hath been and is observed. pag. 18 Answers to the Mischiefs objected. pag. 19 H. 6. Writ proving Sheriffs the only useful Receivers. pag. 21 The Lords of the Council report therein. pag. 22 Sir R. Cottons Learned advice. pag. 25 The Ancient Course OF The EXCHEQUER. THAT by the ancient Establishment and Ordinances of the Excheques, and by the Statutes of this Realm, all the Revenues of the Crown of England, both Certain and Casual, within the Government, Rule, and Survey of the Court of Exchequer, from the time of King Stephen, until about the 25. year of Queen Elizabeth, were yearly drawn down from the Offices of the Remembrancers there, and were charged in the great Roll of the said Court by the Engrosser of the said great Roll, according to his Oath in that behalf, which in ancient times was done thus. All the Farm Rents, In Libro Nigr Scac. In Mag. Rot. Scac. in temporibus R. Steph. H. 2. Rich. 1. & Reg. Johan. with the Issues and Profits of the Ancient Demeasn and Escheat Lands of the Crown arising within every County, were charged in the said great Roll in one entire Body, called, Firma Comitatus, and under one gross sum for the whole, the Particulars whereof were contained in another distinct Roll for that purpose. And the Sheriff of each County (who anciently were Earls in divers Counties, and sometimes the King's Eldest Son, for so Prince Edward, the Son of Hen. 3. for the Counties of Bedford and Bucks, for divers years together, in the time of his Father's Reign) was charged to answer the same at the Exchequer of Easter, and at the Exchequer of Michaelmas yearly; and if the Sheriff failed to appear at his prefixed day to be sworn to his Account, he forfeited for every days failer C s. But if after his being sworn to Account, he departed (not having finished the same) without Licence of the Court, his Lands and Goods were to be seized into the King's hands, and the Issues and Profits thereof were to be answered, without any deduction to be had for the same upon his account. Afterwards King Hen. 3. (who Reigned almost an old man's age) being no doubt well acquainted, as well with the Accounts of the Crown-Revenues which were made in his own, his Fathers, his Uncles, and his Grandfather's time, which are safely preserved without blemish to this day. As also with those special Dialogues which Gervasiuc Tilburiensis had Penned and Dedicated to his Grandfather King Hen. 2. in the twentieth year of his Reign, touching the Original Institution and Dignity of the Exchequer Court, and the singular use of which the Authentic great Roll and Tails of that Court were, as well for bringing all the Revenue under one due Cheque and Control, as for the Subjects Discharge: And not unmindful of the Statutes (which himself had made) of Magna Charta, and of the Statute of the Exchequer in the 51 year of his Reign, did by and with the advice and consent of his Great Council (to wit, his Brother Richard King of the Romans, Walter Archbishop of York, Geoffrey Bishop of Worcester, Prince Edward the King's Son, who succeeded his Father in Government; William the Valencia the King's Brother, Roger de Mortuo, Mari, Philip Basset, Henry de Allen, Robert Aquylin, Albert Wallerand, and other great men who were of the King's Council) establish and provide a certain form (suitable to the said Statute of the 51 of Henry the 3 d. to be from thence held in writing the said Great Roll, wherein the Bodies of the Counties (called in the Roll Firma Comitatuum, which consisted, as before hath been shown, of the ancient Demeasn and Escheat Lands and Rents of the Crown, and amounted unto 10700 l. per Annum) were to be written: afterwards the Sheriffs was to be charged with the Farm of the Profits of the County. Next that was to be written all Farms, as well the greater as the lesser, and all determined Debts likewise, all great Debts, and other known Debts unto the Title in the said Roll of Nova Oblata, (which distinguisheth the new Farms and Debts from the old) and after that Title was to be written, all Debts contained in the Originals, as well great as little, wherewith the Sheriffs were charged by their Answers or Returns. The said word Originals signifying the Records, Extracts, Inquisitions, Seizures, and Certificates, delivered to, or remaining in, the Remembrancers Offices of the Exchequer, which form (being no other in substance than what was before that time observed in writing the said great Roll) was afterwards confirmed by Statute 10 E. 1. with some additions, which hath been constantly held, and so is at this day; and the Remainder of those ancient forms of Counties are now in charge, and consist of many small Vicounted Rents of sundry natures. And furthermore all yearly, foreign, Lib. Rub. Scac. p. 279. cap. 3.6, 7, 8. Ib. p. 287. cap. 1, 2, 3. and other Accounts of Escheaters, Receivers, Collectors, Guardians, Customers, and other Accomptants whatsoever, taken by the Autitors of the said Court, of, and for any branch of the said Revenues, whether Certain or Casual, were anciently Ingrossed in Parchment, and declared before the Treasurer and Barons of the said Court, or some of them; and being so declared, the particulars thereof were delivered into the King's Remembrancers Office to be there safely kept for the use of the Crown; & the said Accounts were briefly entered in the Rolls of States and views of Accounts in the Remembrancers Offices, and were immediately after delivered to the said Engrosser, to be by him, after full Examination (all things proving clear) Ingrossed and charged, and the Debts and Supers therein contained, set forth in the said Roll. And by the course of the Court, no Talley ought to be allowed until it be first rejoined and tried with its Counterfoile, by the Deputy Chamberlains before the Barons in open Court, and the Deputy Chamberlains are sworn to deliver the Tail (proving true) immediately to the Engrosser of the great Roll, who likewise is sworn to make present allowance thereof, which is done in great Letters, by digesting the Substance thereof in writing in the Roll, as ancient Establishment hath ordained. Nothing is charged in this Roll, but from the original Records remaining with the Remembraners, and what is charged in the great Roll, is no ways dischargeable, but by the King's Letters Patents or Writs, under the Great Seal or Privy Seal, or else by judgement of Court; And every Rent and Debt thus charged, is according to Magna Charta cap. 8. first written forth in the Summons of the Exchequer, directed to the Sheriffs, half yearly to be levied, who by the Statute of the Exchequer, 51. H. 3. are to answer so much thereof as is thereby leviable at the Proffer; or else upon finishing his account; and that the Summons of the Exchequer is no weak process, as the Gentlemen in their Case have set forth, will appear by the ensuing Tenor thereof, as Gervasius Tilbu. riensis hath it in the said Dialogues under this Title; Unde fiunt Summonicones Scaccariiss. Henricus Rex Anglorum illi vel illi vic. Salutem vide sicut teipsum & omnia tua diligis quod sis ad Scaccarium ibi vel ibi in Cro. Sci. Michael vel in Cro. Clausi Pasche & habeas tecum ibi quicquid debes de veteri firma vel nova & nominatim haec debita Subscripta de ill. X. marc pro hac causa & sic deinceps annotatis debitis illic seriatim cum causis que in Major Annal. Rot. continentur proferuntur minores quoque perambulantium Judicum Rot. ex quibus excipiuntur quae in singul. Com. Domino Regi labour, & industria ipsorum, & hiis taxatis a majoribus in Summonitionibus annotantur quibus per ordinem digestis terminatur Summonico per haec verba; Et haec tecum habeas in Denariis, & Brevibus, & Taliis, & Quietanciis vel capientur de firma tua Teste illo vel illo ibi ad Scaccarium. And those who will not deliver their Tails to be allowed, Stat. 10. E. 1. shall be answerable for the whole Debt they had paid, and their Tails shall be reputed for Null. And by an Establishment made Ann. 14. E. 1. It was provided for the Indemnity of King and Subject, that when any Tail of the Exchequer happened to be lost (necessity urging the same to be innovated) the foil or Counterpart thereof should be damned, and that new Tails should be made as in times then passed in such cases had been accustomed to be done; which course hath ever since continued, as witnesseth the Rolls thereof remaining in the Tailey Court in the Lower Chequer. And this point hath been the longer insisted upon, because that the very life blood of the Exchequer lies as it were wrapped up in the due and right use of the Tails of the Exchequer, being the chief heartstrings of the said Court, for bringing the whole Revenue under one certain Check and Control, which of late years hath been much infringed, as will hereafter be shown, and which hath ushered in a hundred inconveniences to the no little prejudice of the Crown and the Subject, as may easily be made to appear. And the Sheriff that shall not acquit the Debtors of the Moneys which he hath received upon his next Account, Stat. westm. 1. E. 1. cap. and be thereof attained, shall pay the Plaintiff thrice as much as he received, and make Fine at the King's pleasure. The writing of this Roll is to be in Great Letters, Lib. Nigr. Scci. Jervas'. Tilbur. and the Authority of the same is such, That if by chance the Inggrosser thereof fortune to mistake in writing the same, either in Name, Number or Cause, wherein the Greatest force of the writing consisteth, he may not presume to scrape it out, but by drawing a small line underneath it, Cancel it, and write in order what is requisite, for the writing of the said Roll hath the same Privilege, with Charters and other Letters Patents, and may not be raised or scraped. The aforesaid great Roll hath always had a particular controller established over it, The Comptrolment Roll. who writeth and keepeth yearly a Counter Roll or Comptrollment Roll of the said great Roll, and of every particular Branch of the Revenues therein charged; And also of all Discharges and Allowances therein made, and writeth forth process from the said Great Roll, every Hillary and Trinity Term yearly, directed to the Sheriff or Sheriffs of every County and City, and Town made County, for levying the Revenues therein charged: The Duty of the Engrosser and comptroller. And the Engrosser (together with the said controller) attend the Barons at all Apposals, upon return of process, and urge the speedy answering of the said Revenues, and enter the Awards of the Court in the said Rolls, charging the Sheriff in great letters with whatsoever he is to be charged; and discharging all Farmers and Debtors in the said great Roll, and Comptrolment Roll, of all such moneys, as Sheriffs answer upon Account, without their further charges and trouble; And all Debts and Sums of moneys continuing charged in the great Roll, as not being answered upon the Summons of the Exchequer, are immediately scheduled to and written out in process of Extent by the Remembrancers; and also all Debts, Stat. 37. E. 3. cap. 4. Inquisitions and Seizures of Lands, which were discharged by Judgement of Court, or Grants from the Crown in the said Remembrancers, offices, are acquitted in the said great Roll, and the Debts paid and answered in the great Roll are discharged in the said Remembrancers Offices. All dead Farms and desperate Debts, Stat. 10. E. 1 whereof there is no hopes, are removed out of the said great Roll, and written in another Roll for that purpose Ordained, called the Exannual Roll: But are continued in yearly process to be levied; and such of those Debts as the Sheriff's answer or become revived, are written again in the said great Roll, and there paid or discharged. And it is lawful for the said controller, Lib. nig. Sccii. G. T. to admonish the said Engrosser what he ought to amend: But if he persist and will not alter what is done amiss, he may call him before the Barons, that by them may be determined what is fitting to be done; for the said great Roll may not be altered, but by the common consent of all the Barons, whilst the Exchequer sitteth. And agreeable hereunto are these several subsequent Statutes; viz. The Statute of Westminster 1. 3. E. 1. cap. 19 Statute of Rutland 10 E. 1. The Articles of the Exchequer, made An. 16 E. 2. The Ordinance of the Exchequer, made An. 19 E. 2. Stat. 37. E. 3. cap. 4. Stat. 1. R. 2. cap. 5. Stat. 5. R. 2. cap. 14. Stat. 6. H. 4. cap. 3 Stat. 34 & 35 H. 8 cap. 16. Stat. 2. F. 6. cap. 4. Stat. 1. Ma. cap. 10. Stat. 21. Jac. cap. 5. and that of 8 Aug. 1649. for the Customs and Navy Accounts, cum multis aliis. NOW FOR ANSWER TO THE CASE. The Gent. Penners of the Auditors and Receivers Case, the better to countenance some of their former and irregular proceed, cite 3 Acts of Parliament. The first of those 3 Acts they cite was Ann. 6. H. 8. (which expired An. 14. H. 8) they say that in the preamble thereof there is mention of great pressures upon the Subjects from the Officers of the Pipe: Where in truth there are no such words in the said preamble, but contrariwise it is there mentioned that divers Receivers Accounts which had been take before 24. H. 7. were then not Ingrossed, and others imbeziled and miscarried; by reason whereof both the Receivers and Kings Tenants were Subject to great Vexations in the Exchequer; and therefore and for some other causes, it was provided by that Act, that all Accounts to be afterwards taken of that Revenue, should be yearly engrossed in Parchment, and delivered to the Barons to be entered with the Remembrancers, and filled in the Pipe, there (by the express letter of the Act) to remain of Record perpetually, as well for the King's security as for the clear discharge of the Accomptants, their Heirs and Executors for ever, which was accordingly done, as by the very Accounts so taken (yet remaining of Record in the Pipe) may appear; and the very like provision was again enacted in the subsequent Act made Ann. 14. H. 8. touching the Accounts of that Revenue made before the Surveyors general of the said Kings demiseable lands, for they had not above 2 or 3 Fee-farm Rents within their Survey. 2. Stat. 7. E. 6. The second Act cited is 7. E. 6. cap. 1. & 2. which the Auditors say they have observed all along to this day (which if they had, the Crown had been much better served, and the Subject freed from Many great Grievances and Inconveniencies as shall be shown; For though the first Chapter of that Act hath a prospect only, providing how and when the Receivers and Bailiffs should pay their Moneys, and perfect their Accounts, upon pain of forfeiture of their Offices and Fees: And providing likewise that the Auditors taking the accounts, shall not refuse, extract or delay the taking their accounts so as they may be dispatched in due time, upon pain of Forfeiture of their Offices and Fees, also Enabling the Receivers and Bailiffs to Distrein for the Rents arrear, and Impowering the Barons to Amerce Sheriffs for neglects and contempts: Yet the second Chapter of the said Act hath not only a Prospect, but likewise a Retrospect, confirming the Letters Patents made by King H. 8. in the 38. year of His Reign, and all and every thing and Article therein contained, as if the same had been done by Act of Parliament; by which he dissolved the Courts of general Surveyors, and the Court of the Augmentations, and erected thereof one other new Court, called the Court of Augmentation and Revenues of the King's Crown; and thereby did ordain, that the Recievers should account upon Oath yearly, and that their Accounts should be yearly engrossed in Parchment by the Auditors; and that the Keeper of the Records of that Court, should have the keeping thereof after they should be engrossed; and that only the Clerk of the said Court, should make the Copies and Constats of the same, and that the Auditors and their Deputies, when, and as often as they should have necessity, to have access to the Accounts of their Circuit, might make Copies out of the same, as often, and when necessity required. And furthermmore it was thereby enacted, That the said King E. 6. might at any time during his life, dissolve as well the said Courts, as also the Courts of first Fruits and Tenths, and the Courts of the Duchy of Lancaster. The third and last Act vouched, St. 1 M. c. 10. is 1 Ma. But they set not forth the effect thereof, which had they done, they must have shown that the said Queen was thereby empowered to dissolve and determine every of the last before mentioned Courts, and to unite and annex the the same to any other of her Courts of Record, as if the same had been done by Act of Parliament; PROVIDED, That if she should annex the said Courts or any of them unto her Court of Exchequer, That then all things within the Survey of the said Courts so annexed, should be ordered in like manner, to all intents, as the said Court of the Exchequer there, was, or aught to be by the Common Laws and Statutes of this Realm: By vigour and authority of which Act, Recited in the St. 1. Eliz. c. 4. the said Queen by 4 several Letters Patents under the great Seal, whereof 2 dated the 23. the other the 24 days of January in the first year of her Reign, did not only dissolve the said Courts of Augmentations, and of first Fruits and Tenths, and the Jurisdiction and authority thereof: But also did annex the same Courts so dissolved, to the said Court of Exchequer, there to be and continue as a Member, and parcel of the said Court of Exchequer, and did appoint all the Revenues then answerable in the said late Count of Augmentations, to the Order and Government of the said Court of Exchequer, in such manner and form as was then used, and had of other her Highness' lands then in the Order and Governance of the said Court of Exchequer. AND FURTHERMORE it was expressly provided, ordained, and established, by the said late Queen, in a certain Schedule, signed with her Highness' hands to the said Letters Patents annexed. inter all. That all Crown Rents, Article. 1. etc. within the Survey of the Augmentations and Revenues of the Queen, should be received and levied by the Sheriff of every County, where the same did lie or by any other person or persons that the Treasurer or the Court should appoint. That the Accomptants for the said Augmentation Revenne, Article. 8. should appear in the Exchequer in every Hillary Term, and be swom to their Accounts for the year ended at Michaelmas before, and make and finish the same Accounts before the 24. day of February than next following. That the Auditors taking the same should deliver the same yearly Accounts engrossed in Parchment, Article. 9 authorized & allowed by the hands subscribed of the Lord Treasurer, Chancellor, Under-Treasurer, and Barons of the said Exchequer, or by three of them at the least, whereof the Lord Treasurer or Vice-Treasurer to be one, into the Office of the Pipe, within the said Court of Exchequer, before the 20 day of March than next following, SO as further Process might be thereupon made, if the case should so require. That the said Accounts should remain in the charge the said Clerk of the Pipe. ArtIc. 15. And it was also thereby further established and ordained, Artic. 13. that all Accounts, and Declarations of Accounts, which then were in the said dissolved Court of Augmentations, should be and remain in the charge of the said Clerk of the Pipe in the Exchequer, in such place as the Treasurer and the said Court should appoint. Artic. 22. And for that the order, establishment, and uniting of this Court be perfectly established with exercise, proof, and experience of the same, the Queen's Highness is pleased, that the Lord Treasurer and the said Court of Exchequer should have full power and authority from time to time, to amend, reform, and correct any clause or article aforesaid, and to add to, or diminish any thing that shall be found necessary for the amendment of the same; and to make such further orders from time to time as to the Court shall be thought expedient. And upon this weak foundation and pillar is the whole Fabric and Superstructure of the Auditors erected. And shortly after, all the Accounts of the said Courts of Augmentation and General Surveyors, were sent by Writ of Mittimus to the Treasurer and Barons of the Exchequer, and delivered unto the then Clerk of the Pipe; and divers other like Accounts of the said Revenue taken by the Auditors of the Exchepuer for divers years since, were afterwards delivered unto one John Wooly Eschequer-Clark of the Pipe, to whom the late Queen Elizabeth by her Letters Patents under the Great Seal, in or about the 25 year of her Reign, granted the Office of keeping of all the Accounts, as well of Ministers as of Receivers, and of all other Accomptants whatsoever in the Exchequer of the said Queen, her Heirs and Successors accountable. All which Accounts so delivered (though few in number to what they ought to be) came by succession to the now Engrosser of the said great Roll, and are remaining in his charge and safe custody, kept by themselves in a large public noted room, as the Law requireth, commonly called, The Augmentation-Office in the Exchequer at Westminster, by force of the aforesaid Statute and Letters Patents, Anno prime Mariae, and of the Articles and Ordinances of Annexation thereupon made, and also of certain other Letters Patents under the Great Seal of England in that behalf made and granted by the late King CHARLES to the now Engrosser. By all which it plainly appears, that none who were Auditors, either of the late Court of Augmentations, late Court of General Surveyors of the King's Lands, or of the Court of Exchequer, were ever thought fit to be entrusted by any known Laws with the keeping of any of the Accounts of the Revenues of the Crown; it being most improper for any to have the custody of Accounts taken in the Exchequer, who are no Officers of Record, nor can issue out Process, nor give any Legal Discharge thereupon. And yet notwithstanding all the said established Laws, The Auditors undue proceed. Ordinances, and Letters Patents, divers of the former and now Auditors of the said Exchequer, who took the Accounts of the said Augmentation-Revenues, have detained above nine parts of ten parts of the engrossed and declared Accounts of the same Revenue, taken by them and their predecessors since prima Mariae, with the Tallies thereupon, and refuse, protract, and delay to bring them to the view of the said Remembrancrs' Clerk of the Pipe, and controller, and Deputy Chamberlains, whereby they might be controlled, but have and do detain them in their own private custodies, as if they were their own Evidences, and have given the Accomptants before their appearing yearly in the Exchequer to be sworn to their Accounts, or that their said Accounts and Tallies were controlled, insignificant Discharges, and forced them tot ache Duplicates of their whole Accounts, because they were no way impowered to give them Quietus ests; and by this usurpation have not only kept many thousands of considerable Debts for many years together out of Process, until they became pardoned by the former and the late Acts of General Pardon; but through their neglects divers hundreds of Fee-farm Rents, reserved payable to the Bailiff or Receivers (only accountable before them) upon sundry Letters Patents granted since 20 Eliz. (for all Rents of Monastery Lands from 1 Mar. until about that time, were reserved payable, ad Receptum Scaccarii tantum, and charged in the great Roll) have not been, nor are yet put in charge, to the great prejudice of the Crown: the which their remissness hath occasioned many inconveniencies; as first, their not engrossing in Parchment many yearly Accounts, taken of Receivers, Collectors, and Bailiffs: Secondly, their not declaring divers of those yearly Accounts they have engrossed in Parchment before the Lord Treasurer, Chancellor, and Barons, as the Articles of Union and Annexation enjoineth for many years together, so as no Process could be issued in due time, to recover the Debts and Supers therein. In every of which particulars they have wilfully failed, quite contrary to the Articles of Union and Annexation, which by the Statute of 1 Mar. are of like authority as if the same had been established by Act of Parliament) and to the no little dissatisfaction to most people in England, who have had any urgent occasions to resort for matter of Record, Evidence, or Satisfaction to the said accounts, which now lie confused and dispersed, which hath been, and may prove, not only hazardous to the Crown, but to the Subjects, in evidencing their just Title, Contrary to the true intent and meaning of the common Laws and Statutes of this Realm, and the Tenor of the aforesaid Letters Patents of Queen Mary, Queen Elizabeth, King James, and the late King Charles, granted to the successive engrossers of the great annual Rolls of the Exchequer. An Answer to the Objected Mischiefs which will ensue, as to His Majesty's Advantage, and the Subjects Interest, in case the Bill now under Consideration should take Effect. Object. 1 THat the Revenue will be thereby taken from the View and Control of the Lord Treasurer, Chancellor, and Barons of the Exchequer, and put into the manegery of the Pipe, without any Control. Answ. If it shall be thought fit that the Revenue, now in the managery of the Auditors and Receivers, which consists chief of Fee-farm Rents, Tenths, perpetual Pentions, and other dry Rents, which are no ways improveable, as well of divers ancient Demeasn and Escheat Lands of the Crown, and Forrest-Lands, Bishops Lands, and other Lands gotten by Exchange, and Lands that came by Attainder or Purchase, that were long time together accounted for in the great Roll; as also of Monastery and Chantry Lands, shall be charged in the great Roll, than not only those Rents, but also all other Rents, now charged in the said great Roll, being once particularly and distinctly charged in the Roll, within every Hundred and Division out of which they are issuing; and that the same be declared before the Lord Treasurer, Chancellor, Under-Treasurer, and Barons, and be computed and cast up in one entire sum within every division, and the Sum Total of the whole certain Revenues in every County be engrossed in the Roll (which may be exactly performed within the Compass of one year) than the true state of the said Revenue both in point of charge and discharge, will come more certainly entirely and readily, to the view and Control of the aforesaid Supreme Officers of the Court in one account within every County, than it hath at any time heretofore in hundreds of accounts done, and be under the ancient Control of all the aforesaid chief ministerial Officers of the said Court, entrusted for and under them, and will be brought in according to law, and the accounts thereof will be engrossed, heard, and determined in a judicial way, and no part thereof discharged but by judgement of Court, or by the King's Letters Patents or Writs, under the Great or Privy Seal. Object. 2 That the Summons of the Pipe is a weak process, and that Debts are not Scheduled in a year or two for stronger process to be thereupon made, and that the Usage and Course of the Exchequer ever have been and are repugnant to the Statute 51 H. 3. Answ. The Summons of the Pipe is no weak process, as is unadvisedly Asserted, for it transcends all other commands in any of the King's Writs, for enjoining the Sheriffs to the performance of what is therein required, and there hath ever been five times more money yearly levied and answered upon this process, then upon all other the process of the Court, and it ought to be the first process for levying the King's Debts, unless the Supreme Officers of the Court, do for some extraordinary cause, order that process of extent should issue; and Debts not answered upon the Summons are forthwith put into the Schedula Pipe, and sent to the Remembrancer for stronger process. And the constant usage, practice, and course of the Exchequer, hath always been, and yet is agreeable to the Statute of 51 H. 3. varying in this point, only that of late years (when the Crown Revenues within the Sheriff's Collection was much impaired) the Cursitour Baron (who was introduced but in the time of E. 2. in ease to the other Barons) hath performed that Service at the Sheriffs Proffers, Apposals, and dismission out of Court, which before was Enacted to be performed before the Treasurer, Chancellor, and Barons, and is no ways repugnant thereunto, as the Auditors have missuggested. Object. 3 That the Allowance to Sheriffs for levying the Revenue will exceed the present charge. Answ. If the Wisdom of Parliament shall think fit that His Majesty give some reasonable Allowance for levying this Revenue, (the charge of the account being to be paid by Sheriffs) this will come far short of the great charge the Crown is at, by Auditors, Receivers, Collectors, Stewards, Bailiffs, Woodwards, Messengers, etc. which (as the Learned Author Sir Robert Cotton in his Book called Cottoni Posthuma pag. 181. amongst other things well observes) amounted to above 12000. l. per Annum. Object. 4 The hazard by Failer by Sheriffs cannot be less then by Receivers. Answ. It is notoriously known how many Receivers in the time of Queen Elizabeth, King James, and the late King Charles, have failed for very great Sums of money, which were either never paid or else not paid at such a rate per annum as the Interest amounted unto, but it cannot be proved that ever any one Sheriff failed in that kind. Object. 5 That the Crown is like to be at loss by arbitrary allowances subject to no Control. Answ. The Crown is neither like to be (nor indeed can be) at any loss by arbitrary allowances in the Sheriff's accounts, subject to no Control (as is very absurdly suggested;) First, because no allowance or discharge is there made, but by Warrant of the Lord Treasurer, or Chancellor, or by virtue of the King's Writs, or judgement of Court as aforesaid. Secondly, by reason the said Account must be under the ancient due and legal Comptrollment before set forth and mentioned. An Answer to the Mischiefs objected as to the Subject. Object. 1 THe Sheriff will be at excessive Charge and Trouble in giving Security. Anse. The Sheriffs trouble to give security for every 100 l. will easily be provided for by the wisdom of Parliament: For the Sheriff being chosen every year per Magnates & Proveres regni, are persons of quality and solvent Estate, within their own Counties and usually elsewhere. And a Recognizance (if there were no other security) makes all the Sheriff's Estate liable: Beside, if provision be made that every Tenant and Farmor that pays 50. l. rent and upwards, may pay his Rent half-yearly into the Receipt, much of the Security will be taken off. Object. 2 The taking off the Sheriff's charge will be expensive. Answ. The Expense of taking his charge yearly from the Pipe for this whole Revenue will be very inconsiderably more than the usual Fees formerly paid for the Revenue now in charge there. Object. 3 So will the yearly rental prescribed by the Act. Answ. If the Sheriff make the rental himself (as he may if he please) the Charge will be nothing. Object. 4 The Burden of passing the Sheriffs Account, and Quietus will be insupportable. Answ. The Account will be very little longer, and the burden and trouble in passing the same much less then formerly, when the Foreign account of Seizures was in use. Object. 5 It will be a great trouble to the Sheriff to collect so many small Rents dispersed, within the time of his office. Answ. If the several small Rents be collected by the petty Constables in every Parish, and by them paid to the High Constables of every Hundred, and by the High Constables paid over to the Sheriff, the Rents will be much better and easier collected and paid, then heretofore, without any trouble to the Sheriff. Object. 6 The Sheriff endangered by entering into Recognisance. Answ. The Sheriff having finished his Account the Recognisance is of no manner of force, whereby to endanger him or his Security, or their Posterity. Object. 7 If a proportionable Reward be allowed to the Sheriff for levying the Revenue, it takes away the Bread from the Auditors and Receivers and casts it to the Sheriff. Answ. The reward will be proportioned to the Sheriff, by the wisdom of the Parliament. But in what sense this may be a taking away the Auditors bread who are the King's Servants, and casting it to the Sheriff, is not understood. Indeed, the greatest reward the Sheriff is like to have, will prove but as the Crumbs of those Numerous and liberal allowances made to Auditors, Receivers, etc. Object. 8 His Majesty's Farmers and Tenants will be sore vexed and burdened in double payments for levying, and discharge in the Great Roll. Answ. His Majesty's Farmers and Tenants will be by the course of the Exchequer clearly and absolutely discharged at the years end upon Record in the Great Roll of all such moneys as they pay to the Sheriff, without any manner of vexation trouble or charge for the same. Object. 9 That the Auditors and Receivers will be divested of their Rights and Freeholds. Answ. It is hoped they will be had in consideration (if any alteration be) by the wisdom and Justice of Parliament. Now to prove that the Sheriffs have always anciently been the only Receivers of the Crown Revenues and other Receivers avoided as needless and unprofitable, there needs no other proof to make it unquestionable, but that one Writ of 16. Hen. 6. directed to the Treasurer and Barons of the Exchequer, which was seconded by an Act of Council in the time of Queen Mary. The tenor of the said Writ anno 16. Hen. 6. Henricus Dei gratia Rex, etc. Thess. & Baron. de Scaccar. salutem. King Hen. 6. Writ. Cum monstratum sit nobis qualiter dilectus nostr. Robertus Whittingham Chivaler hab. officium Receptoris generalis omnium terr. etc. que fuerunt Iohannis nuper Ducis Bedford. Auunc. nostri carissimi defunct. & quod officium predict. non est ad commodum nostrum, quia vadia & feoda quae ea de causa de nobis percepta sunt possunt bene fore omissa. Et quod Vicecomites nostri possunt bene levare Revenciones in manibus nestris existen prout fuit ante hoc tempus. Ideo vobis mandamus quod dictum Robertum exoneretis ab officio predicto, etc. By which it appears that this one extraordinary Receiver in the time of King Hen. 6. was deemed a burden and unnecessary charge to the Crown, and therefore according to the constant course of the Exchequer, thought fit to be discharged of his Receipts, and the same to be transferred to the Sheriffs, prout fuit ante hoc tempus, which was so done accordingly. The like we shall find in the third and fourth year of King Philip and Queen Mary, in a report made to their Majesties by the then Lords of the Council, upon some question (after the annexation of the Court of augmentations to the Exchequer) whether the Sheriffs or Receivors were the fittest. Ministers for receiving the Rents and Revenues of the Crown; and whether the Duchy Court of Lancaster ought not to be annexed to the Exchequer, and all Manors to be demised in gross with their casualties at a certain Rent, for cutting off all superfluous expenses. The Report is as followeth. SVmus in priori opinion, The Report to King Philip and Queen Mary. quod Vicecomes sit maxim idoneus qui recipiat annuos ridditus vestrarum Majestatum infra limites suorum officiorum, & de illis respondeat vestris Majestatibus. Et ad id quod dicitur Vicecomites male jam respondere de iis quae eorum fidei committunter putemus id eo fieri, vel quia officiarii Scaccarii non urgeant neque instent prout eorum officii est, vel quia ab initio male eliguntur: Et utrique huic malo facillime succuritur si Visecomites bene Eligantur. Et quod Vicecomites sint ad hanc rem maxim idon ei, movemur iis rationibus quae sequuntur. Vetera exempla hujus regni cum optime & cum maximo honore regeretur ostendunt quod omnes annui redditus coram solvebantur per Vicecomites. Nec putamus quod Vicecomites (presertim si bene eligantur) erunt tam tardi in pecuniis solvendis computisve redaendis, quam Receptores & sunt & semper hactenus fuerunt. Vicecomites (quorum officium annuum est) & annuatim computa reddunt, non possunt celare pecunias vestrarum Majestatum quemadmodum Receptores solent. Receptores enim (quorum officium perpetuum est) debita prioris anni solvunt ex redditibus sequentis, quae fraus vitabitur si Vicecomites perficiantur huic Cure: ac etiam annue expense quae nunc fiunt pro multis officiariis cessabunt. Visecomites eliguntur de honestioribus, Equitibus, sive Generosis singulorum Comitatum: Receptores sunt plerunque homines nullius estimationis. Vicecomites Eliguntur annuatim per vestras Majestates ex consensu Magnatum & Judicum Regni: Receptores autem assumuntur per privatos favores amicorum. Sumus etiam in priori opinione quod terrae & possessiones Ducatus Lancastriae, possunt bene reduci ad Scaccarium: Et quod fieri potest salvis etiam omnibus Colonis sive tenentibus dict. Ducatus, suis libertatibus, privilegiis & consuetudinibus quibus omnibus frui & gaudere possunt, Coloni & Tenentes predicti, non minus integre in Scaccario, quam nunc fruuntur in Curia Ducatus, & ad hanc opinionem movemur iis rationibus. Annue expense quae fiunt pro multis Officiariis Ducatus cessabunt. Terrae & possessiones Ducatus Lancastriae, cum sint in multis & seperatis Comitatibus possunt earum possessionem annui redditus per Com illorum Vicecometes uno labore colligi simul cum aliis redditibus. Cum Ducatus Lancastriae jam descenderit ad Reginam unacum Corona, non videmus quare non debeant ejusdem Ducatus terrae & possession. gubernare in Scaccario quemadmodum possessiones Principat. Walliae, Ducatus Cornub. Eboraci, & eorum consilium. Nobis etiam non videtur praejudiciale sed valde utile vestris Majestatibus quod Maneria & cum illis omnia casualia locentur ad firmam, reservatis Boscis, Wardis, Maritagiis, Miner. & Advocationibus Ecclesiarum. Idem quoque putamus de sylvis ceduis quos subboscos diximus, quos utile putamus ad firmam dimittere & movemur ad hanc opinionem iis rationibus. Si locentur Maneria atque omnium aliorium generum terrae & possessiones cum casualibus & subboscis annui redditus vestrarum Majestatum erunt certi qui nunc incerti sunt. Annui sumptus reparationem Senescallorum eorum qui Nemora custodiunt, & multorum aliorum officiar. cessabunt. Multi annui redditus, & multa servicia, quae nunc partim, dolo malo, partim, negligentia Senescallorum Balliorum & aliorum officiar. non exiguntur et ita paulatim pereunt: semper solventur cum firmarii & propter privatum lucrum suum, & propter obligationem qua tenebuntur diligentius illa curabunt. Miseri Coloni, sive pauperiores tenentes quibus variis artibus extorquentur pecuniae tam per officiarios quam per eorum famulos, honestius tractabuntur si dicta Maneria cum casualibus & sylve cedue dentur ad Firmam honestis viris. Lucra etiam illa quae ex casualibus & subboscis proveniunt, & nunc malis artibus extorquentur per Officiarios, venient directe ad usum vestrarum Majestatum, atque id sine ullo praejudicio pauperiorum Colonorum qui plus favoris semper invenient in vicino firmario honesto quam in extraneis emptoribus, Baliis, vel silvarum custodibus. Et preterea potest aliis modis satis provideri contra firmariorum avaritiam, contra Officiariorum vero infinitas frades aliter provideri non potest, idque longa experientia nimis cognitum est. As by the said Report remaining in His Majesty's Library at White-Hall, Vernon. p. 67. amongst other things) may appear. Whereby it is most evident of what use and estimation Sheriffs (being but for a year) have always been, for bringing in the Revenues of the Crown; especially if they be well chosen, and held to the performance of their duties by the Officers of Exchequer: with 〈◊〉 ●●●ther observation, How remiss the Receivers were in those days, and had ever been in paying what they received, and making their accounts in due time. And suitable thereunto is the prudent advice of that learned person Sir Robert Cotton in his book entitled Cottoni Posthuma, printed in 1651. Page 179, Sir Robert Cotons' advice. in his Treaty of improving the Revenues of the Crown, who writeth to this effect, that in case the demiseable lands of the Crown, per annum 32000 l; should be passed in Fee-farm they would (one with the other) be advanced to a triple Rent. And again in these express words (page 181) that if the Purchaser, or Farmer, pay his rent, into the Receipt himself half-yearly and strike there his Tally, it will cut off at once, so many unnecessary Receivers, Auditors, Stewards, Bailiffs, etc. as stand the King in yearly above 12000 l. And as for other deuce or Revenues, which now fall under the charge of these Officers, the Collection and payment may be (as it hath been with the rest from the time of King Henry 2. until of late days) laid on the Sheriffs of the Shires; and all the accounts left to the two Auditors of the priests to draw up, and Clerk of the Pipe to enter in Magno Rotulo, as in all former time. For (saith the same Author) it must seem strange to all men of Judgement, that it should be with these Officers (who had their beginning but since the 25. year of King Henry 8. by addition of his new Revenue of 150000 l. from the suppressed Monasteries) otherwise then with all things in nature and reason, cessante causa, cessat effectus, not to be discontinued. When as all Crown-annexed-lands, that gave them their just employment, are for the most part passed, from the Sovereign into the Subject's possession. These are the express words of that learned Author in his book aforesaid. All which is humbly offered to Consideration, etc. FINIS.