THE CONSOLATION OF Philosophy. LONDON, Printed by James Flesher for the Author, 1664. The Preface and Occasion of this Melancholic Divertisement. ALthough many may and needs must remember the Sadness of the late Times, which called the greatest Knaves on earth Honest men, and the justest Loyalty on earth Treason, and which rewarded and punished both Titles as preposterously as they named them, forgetting the holy Prophet's woes against such Hypocritical Misnomers: yet 'tis as much to be remembered that all have not the like causes of memory; some Families being but so wounded as easily curable; others died in the place; to others— Haeret lateri lethalis arundo. Among these last Tho. Coningsby of North-Mimms in the County of Hartford, of a most ancient Family, and as plentiful Fortune, having been high-Sheriff of that County in the year 1638, was, (upon the Confidence of Loyalty the late Blessed King had found and tried in him) by a Commission sent from Redding, again made his Majestie's high-Sheriff in the year 1642▪ and together with his Commission received this gracious Letter following under that King's own hand of Blessed Memory. CHARLES R. TRusty and wellbeloved, We greet you well, and do hereby give you Our assurance, that although We have at this present made choice of you to be Our high-Sheriff of Our County of Hartford, We have done it out of no other respect then as a mark and testimony of Our Favour, and Confidence of the utmost of your Service in these Times, wherein We intent to employ Persons of greatest Integrity and known Affections to Us, and the good of Our Kingdom; of which you have formerly given sufficient testimony. And although it may bring upon you great Expense and Trouble; yet We are confident you will not value it, in regard of Our Service, and the good of that Our County; which shall not be forgotten by Us on all occasions. So We bid you hearty farewell. From our Court at Redding this 11 ●h of Novemb. 1642. Soon after he received also a Writ and Proclamation, sent from Oxford, which declared the late Earl of Essex and his Adherents Traitors, and authorised him to array the County for the King's Service. The like Command other Sheriffs received: and the Sheriff of Essex that then was did thereupon address himself to the Parliament, as if he would beg leave of them to execute the Writ against them, and entreat their favour to declare them to be (what they were) Traitors. For which treacherous Flattery he had their Fatherhoods thanks, was caressed, made their Treasurer, grew rich, and to complete his reward is now Sir Baronet. But Mr. Coningsby, of another temper; according to his trust and place; executes his Writ at S. Alban, and was there with the peril of his life (happy if he had then perished) taken Prisoner by Cromwell, (who had the thanks of the House too for his exploit) is carried to London, committed to London-house, where he continued Prisoner till the year 1643. and was then adjudged (by a then Committee-man, now a real Judge) to be within their Ordinance for Sequestration, though made after his fact, by virtue of those words (Whoever have or shall:) as if he could have divined that any such transcendent Impudence would appear in the world, as would confirm Wickedness, and punish Duty by a Law. And yet if he could, he could not have failed in his Duty; for he knew not fear. This was quickly smelled out by that famous Vulture Sir Will. Brereton, who alleged it against him, and that he had sent one of his Sons into the King's Army (true, but not proved:) and thereupon got the Sequestration and Plunder of his Estate; robbing him at once of more than two thousand pounds. They seized also on his Real Estate, which then was not less than fifteen hundred pounds per annum. After this he is removed from London-house to the Tower, where with much barbarous usage he was held seven years more, under several Gaolers; when at last broken and languishing in Body through Restraint, and Sickness contracted by it, his Son, by a pious deceit of bribing underhand, and being bound for him, (who would never have consented to his own Safety on those terms, for his Generous Soul scorned to petition Rebels) gained him into the Country, where he found as great objects for his Grief as he did in thraldom itself. For than he saw how during the time of his Imprisonment they had, besides his Goods and Rents, wasted and destroyed his Woods and Houses, to the value of more than three thousand pounds; and that in this seeming Liberty he did but behold his own and his family's Ruin at a nearer view, the Sequestrators and their Harpies continuing before his face to prey upon him and their own Masters too, the lesser Vermin preying on and cheating the greater, converting (as was afterwards made appear against them before the King's Commissioners sitting at the Savoy) more than two thousand pounds out of his Estate, from the general Sink to their own particulars, as he in the Satirist, — damnatus inani Judicio (quid enim salvis infamia nummis?) Exul ab octavo Marius bibit, & fruitur Diis Iratis, at tu— In this just disdain he offers to contest his Right against them at Law: But they, as if this had been the higher Crime, got an Order to imprison him again, and breaking open his Daughter's house, in the greatest inhumanity imaginable seized on him, being very sick and weak, enforce him to ride to London in great torment, and have him committed Prisoner to the Serjeant's man; where growing weaker than ever, and more discomposed, he is again by the same religious craft gained into the Country by his Son with a nominal Liberty; where soon after he was, in the year 1654., (after twelve years worrying) finally released by Death. He was the Son of Sir Ralph Coningsby, who had for the more immediate Stem of his House Sir Humphrey, a Wise and Learned Judge in the Reign of King Henry the Seventh, but as to his remoter Root, was lineally descended from a long and Noble Race of Ancestors that were Barons of this Kingdom both before and after the Conquest. He was of a middle Stature, his Hair black, his Complexion ruddy, his Eyes black, full, and exceedingly piercing; in all so Comely, that those who knew his youth would say, as the Prince of Poets does of his Deiopeia, that he was praestanti Corpore: but for his Spirit; so great and undaunted, that it was not at all to be bowed by Terrors or Miseries, disdaining in the whole story of his Life to submit his native and gallant Freedom to the frowns of any that were but his Fellow-subjects, though in greater authority, as was often proved. Once in a long Suit he had about a right of his Predecessors in Enfield Chase, with no worse man than King James, the Judge then sitting required him to produce his Evidences in Court. He said he would produce so much as concerned the matter in hand. The Judge said he would make him produce the whole, and that he would, if he could, pick a hole in them. To which he replied, That it were better the Skin were plucked over his ears, then that he should sit on that Bench to that purpose. The King being told it, and that it was taken as an Affront and Contempt of his Authority, swore by his Soul, (his usual Oath) that Coningsby said right, and that he should have right. He was of a nature so severely and superlatively just, that he would wrong no man; and, though it were to his prejudice, did not seldom protect others from wrong: and when he observed any man of Power do wrong, he used to say, That man has kindled a Fire will burn his own House. Out of this apprehension, when he was leaving the world, though he pardoned all personal Injuries, yet he did prophetically bequeath the old Cause and its Fautors to that Destiny some of them came to, the Gallows, saying, as a well-built Christian might, That it was impossible that the righteous God should permit them to go unpunished always. But Cur bonis viris mala fiant is yet a riddle. He was a person of admirable Parts; but such are too commonly the more unfortunate; and among his Misfortunes it was not the least, that he had such Parts, and wanted a Profession to stir them, and keep his large Soul from rust and Idleness. His last and great Character, which speaks him born for this trying Age, was, that he lived and died Honest, preferring his Conscience and Loyalty to his Life, Liberty and Estate; choosing rather to leave his Family which was numerous, but dear to him, (for a better Father never lived) poor and distressed, then rendered infamous and stained by any unworthy act of his. His Misfortunes ended not with his Life; for after his Death his Estate was adjudged by the Rebels to be sold, (by the name of Tho. Coningsby deceased) and his Son could not enjoy it but by purchase: by which means, together with his Piety in supplying and preserving his Father, and his own constant Sufferings, he contracted such heavy Debts, that he was enforced to sell above one thousand pounds a year, with his best House, (built by his great Grand father, Sir Henry Coningsby, upon the most noble part of his Inheritance) worth more than ten thousand pounds, not considerable in purchase. Sure no man can think he could do this without the greatest reluctancy and regret in the world, being the sad Presage of the utter extinction and fall of that Family, and the just cause of sorrow to succeeding generations, which more concerns him then his own Calamity: for as to himself, he yet inherits his Father's Mind, though not his Possessions. Fatum sub pedibus dedit superbum. In the midst of the Calamitous Times, (not forgetting his addresses to him who only can help) to alleviate his troubled Mind, he made English Lipsius his Constantia; so deceiving tedious hours, till it pleased Heaven to restore the King. Many then expected a Law de Repetundis, at least against such as were able and fatter Villains: but instead of this other things were done, in favour of some indeed, but to the prejudice (which was the foulest Partiality) of others, (as was made too apparent before the Commissioners at the Savoy as before.) Upon this rushed in a Deluge of Vices, whose rage broke down the former Banks, and divided the Affections of those whom former Miseries seemed to have fast bound; thereby showing that Fortune only, not Honesty, was both their Pilot and Cement, and that they held together more out of Destiny than Virtue; of all men the most to be detested. This did the Son of this suffering Father dearly prove, and as sadly consider: for that he having better Principles of Honour and Honesty from him whose Blood he glories in, and being willingly defective in what those people boast of, Impudence and Falsehood, he found no worse recompenses from any then those should most have assisted him. They said he was too great a Sufferer to be relieved; and some, that had they had Honour should have most lifted him up, bandied against him. This made him accuse Fortune in the fit. But now humble and wiser reflections on Providence, by which it comes to pass that what seems most otherwise proves often for our good, and considering the Person and Fate of our most Gracious Sovereign, who but a few months before His happy Restauration (when He was entertained with the highest Caresses imaginable) passed through the States of Holland unregarded, and was in other places worse used; considering this, and the giddy rollings of Fortune, with the rude insultations she makes on the Highest and Worthiest of men, retiring to recreate himself, he (as you see) put the brave and stout BOETHIUS into an English dress; which though ruder and courser than it should have been, is so much the more like his own Condition, and gives himself satisfaction, though not others: a poor satisfaction and pitiful comfort to a lost Family; yet he leaves it as a Relic of his Honest Mind, reposing his trust in Almighty God, who when he pleases can raise up those are cast down lowest: at least by this Posterity will know how, and in what unhappy Times, and for what cause it was the Storm came upon him and ruined him, and learn to decline the fondness of this mutable World, and seek the never-sading Treasure. PARENTALIA in memoriam nobilissimi T. C. Arm. Hartford. facta. COnduntur sub his moenibus sicut decet Templi ful●ra, Ossa magnanimi Heröis, Thomae, Radulphi Conings by Militis filii dignissinti, Qui talis vivus fait qualem vetat Pictas mori; Et vix credent Posteri seculo isthoc vixisse, Nisi quòd 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 gerat certissimum, honestam miseriam. Summae Probitatis reum summa Infelicitas probat, Virúmque ad optima natum, quia sustalit pessuma. Acerrimus Aequi bonique sed nunquam turbidus Assecla▪ Justitiae cultor strenuus, nec non minùs Pacis; Assertor Patriae, sed nullus desertor Regis; Libertatis publicae Vindex, sed fine Perduellionc; Civis eximius, sed non deterior Subditus. Pro Jure veteri dimicavit contra novam Praerogativam; Quod Jacobus Rex Carolúsque sentiunt, diligúntque simul; Nempe integram dignoscentes fidem, etiam sic con … … tem. Ob haec, personâ Regiâ indutus, quando Regem ipsum Satagit profanum Vulgas (vah nefas!) exuere, Non deserit Principem quem prius gravem habuit, Minùs oppressum ferens, quàm opprimentem Dominum; Qui justum expertus, neminem aptiorem duxit Justis qui plectat poenis concitatam Plebem. Hujus vesanam Rabiem dum coercere accinctus Vicecomes fidus fortiter officio fungitur, Eheu! rebellibus armis violatus libertate priv●tur, Per Conciliabulum istud quod ●ueri libe●os prae se tulit. Saevitiam cujus carnificinámque impiam Variis rapinis carceribúsque refertam; Quae divina omnia humanáque raepit atque excuti●, Piè dedignans, animo infracto pertulit. Scilicet, Bona sua perdere maluit quàm Virtutem; Nec moratur Fortunas, unici Aestimator Honoris. Pudet Haereditatem emere taentis Majoribus relictam, Vel cauponari terras quas sola Pietas prodidit; Ditiorem se reputans propter jacturas tales, Magisque beatum dummodo innocenter pauperem. At non sic pris●ae Fidei Pacisque Raptores, Qui gr●gem tantum deglubentes esuriunt adhuc, Et ferculis tot plenis absorptis, manent sordidum pecus; Non enim repl●tur haec mala Bestia vel maledicta. Ità demum proscissis Legibus Legúmque Patrono, Serenissimo Dei Uncto sacrilegè trucidato, Libertate, Fide, rebus Sacris pessundatis, Corruentibus Ecclesiâ funditus aetque Republicâ, Circumspicit omnia, caeterùm nil dignum vitâ intuens, Heu! perfidus terras fugit, coelum spirans, Martyris penè nomen adeptus, at Confessoris haeud dubi●. Illic fulgens Anima ditescit nunquam spolianda, Et pace fruitur quae spernit turbas Parricidales; Indè jam Orco maturum Senatulum despicit, Atque ipsis nequ●ores Daemonibus Latrones ridet. Vitâ functus est Octob. 1 ●●, Sepultus 5 to, Annóque Aetatis 63. Incarcerationis 12. Salutis Hum. 1654. On the same. SO then, He's quit at last, and now hath gained What baffled Justice never had obtained; Has finished all at once, and found a friend By whom two Compositions meet one end. That of his Humane frame which they so oft Had torn and bruised is sor'd one half aloft, Where they must never reach it, nor come nigh, B'ing so weighed down with Blood and Villainy. And for the other, though refined and grown Purer than their Souls by Affliction, So that like agile Vapour seem it might To have made ready for the Spirits flight, And cast off all its grosser weight, that so It might keep pace and with like vigour go As did its swift Companion; yet because, Breaking none else, he would keep Nature's Laws, See, here it falls among the noble dust Of old progenitors alike good and just, And fitly with Sir Harry and Sir Ralph Now mingling Ashes sleeps as calm and safe: Whose honest bones did welcomly give way For his, that were as stout and true as they, And seemed in their cold Mother's lap to kiss And hug each others common fame and bliss. Where let them rest, till that auspicious Morn Shall dawn, will all their Loyalty return. And now this broken thus and thus dissolved, The second bursts, wherein he was involved, The Body Politicks Chain, or rather Snare, In which three Nations bound and tortured are; That tearing Engine, on whose hooks we find None caught, but leave their skin and flesh behind; Our English Inquisition, which exceeds That under which th' Hesperian Sinner bleeds: For there unhappy wretches only weep For breaking Laws, but here because they keep: There if they take Estates they take Life too; A civil Cruelty; but we undo, And rob, and swallow all that should preserve, Then shake whole Families off to beg and starve. We do not at once the spreading Oak, Nor kill his goodly pride at one fair stroke; But pill and bark it first, and so 'tis pined, And dies inglorious torn with every wind. Which barbarous Zeal none but a Jesuit can Defend, or viler Presbyterian; None but the Rabbi Sme●, whose vafrous Name Will Guido and his Tribe excuse in shame; Who are now Brethren, and by dire consent Have knit so fast a League 'twixt them and Trent, That though they look big on't and face it still In other points, yet both are one in Ill: Whilst to resist, depose and murder Kings, Are not proclaimed now such horrid things As our ●ame simple Fathers held, who were Too innocent to be Godly, and did fear God more than needs; and who, if they lived now, And would not humbly to this Idol bow, Would not for swear, and plunder, and rebel, And freely at their Order run to Hell, Must through the dire Committees furnace pass, Though seven times hotter than the Prophet's was. And so did this great Hero prove, who felt Their twelve-years Limbo, whose hot flames did melt And eat up both his Body and his Land, Though he scorned both, that he might Loyal stand. But now the kinder Grave hath all acquit, Disdaining that the State out-spoiled it, And grew more ravenous and dreadful more By their new Tophets than was his before: So that 'twas harder Villanage to get Through their two Halls, then pay old Nature's debt; And the deep wounds of Death were looked upon As milder fate than Sequestration. On wh●ch the Prince of Terrors jealous grew Lest they would rival his Dominion too, And cloud his Name, which, before theirs, none durst Of all things Horrible deny the first. Therefore he served against them here, who hath So long obeyed their irreligious wrath, Rescuing this Martyr from the Harpies rape, Just as their eager throats did widest gape. For which we thank him, and shall thence begin Fair hopes that he who their long friend hath been May now turn foe, and pay back their base fears With as much ruin and as many tears As they have caused: unless they can as well Covenant with Death as they have done with Hell. M. S. D. D. G. THE FIRST BOOK Of the CONSOLATION OF PHILOSOPHY. I That was wont to sing full merrily, Am forced sad tones to howl in misery: The tattered Muses bid me for to write A mournful Song, while they with tears indite▪ No terror could affright these Sister's free, But of my griefs Companions they would be. The glory of my happy youth does give Some comfort to the cares in which I live. Unwelcome age (that never-failing thief) Intrudes himself, and mixes with my grief. My hairs untimely from my head do fall, My skin is lose, and joints do tremble all. That death is happy that blithe Youth does spare, But comes when called by one oppressed with Care. Alas! he will not close the weeping eye, And deaf he is to souls in misery. Whiles fickle Fortune fanned me with her wing, Each hour fear of death with it did bring. But now that she has changed her cozening face, Death takes delight to come a Tortoise pace. O friends, why did you oft me happy call? He ne'er was firmly seated that could fall. While thus I musing lay alone, Designing how t'express my moan, Above my head appeared to me A Woman of bright majesty, With Eyes that shined clear and bright, And pierced beyond all common sight; Of lively colour and full strength, Although her years had drawn a length Beyond what any mortal does. Her Stature too was various, Sometimes o'th' common size of men; But to the heavens she would then Lift up her head, and pierce the sky, Deluding the beholder's eye. Her Robes were made of finest thread, And without seam were perfected: And, as I after came to know, With her own hands she woven them so. Like as old Pictures do appear In smoky rooms, their colour were: And in the lower bordering The letter TWO was weaved in green; And in the upper see you might The letter Θ weaved in white. Between the letters there were set As 'twere a ladder up to get, So climbing the degrees, to move From Earth below to Heaven above. But some rude hand her Robe did tear, And every one catcht for a share. In her Right hand a Book she held, A Sceptre did her Left hand wield. When she the Muses had descried, They standing all by my bed's side, As willing for to comfort me, On them she cast an angry eye, And, Who unto this languishing Sick man, said she, these whores did bring? With poisons they his fancy please, But give no Physic him can ease. These, these are they that Reason's corn Destroy, with planting fruitless thorn; These trouble, not relieve, the mind: And could you none but this man find? Had you but only drawn apart A rude, profane or vulgar heart, I had not cared; but to ensnare Him who has been my only care, In Wisdome's School brought up and nursed? Go, go, ye Sirens, go accursed, And leave this sick man's cure to me. This said, th'whole choir did agree In one sad look, confessed that they For shame did blush, so went away. Tears dazzled had my eyes, and I Affrighted all this while did lie; Wondering who this same should be Commanded with such majesty: And silently I did me bear, Expecting what next I should hear. She me approached, and did sit down On my bed's side; then with a frown She me beheld, who grieved did lie, And on the ground had fixed my eye. But thus, she seeing me in pain, Of man's disquiet did complain. O how (cast down with care) men's minds oppressed are, Who leaving bright daylight, Run grovelling in the night, While clogged with things below, Vexations on them grow? He, while he lived free, The heavenly Orbs did see, The splendour of the Sun, And course of the cold Moon, What course each wandering Star Through each Orb did bear. All these he firmly knew, And all the causes true: How shrill loud Winds do make The Pontic Sea to quake, What spirit rolls the world, How Hesperus that's hurled Down nightly, shines each morn; Who 'tis that does adorn The Earth i'th' Spring with Flowers; Who giveth fertile Showers, Makes Autumn's grapes to swell. He wont was to tell Dame Nature's secret laws; But now knows not the cause Why he oppressed does lie, With sad and downcast eye. The foolish world him took, Thence on it he does look. What boots it though, said she, to chide? 'Twere better Physic were applied. Then fiercely she on me did look, Art thou the child, said she, I took, Fed thee with milk and many a cate, Until thou cam'st to man's estate, Then gave thee Arms, which had kept thee (Hadst thou kept them) unconquered, free? Dost know me? what, is't shame or fear Does make thee silent? would it were Ingenuous Shame; but I do see 'Tis stupid Fear oppresses thee. But when not only silent I But speechless seemed, than she, to try My health, upon my breast she laid Her hand: Danger there's none, she said; A lethargy (the common ill Of minds seduced from good to ill) He has, he's stupefied; but lo, When come to's self, he will me know. Let's wipe from's eyes (that so he may) This cloud of mortal things away. Her vestment then folding in plies, She wiped therewith my watery eyes. Darkness left me now and night, my sight came to me clear: Just as when bright Phoebus' light at noon cannot appear, For that clouds have round about the hemisphere beset, So fixed, that it is a doubt the Heaven's motion's let: Boreas sent from Thracian den i'th' evening retrives The light o'th' Sun, whose beams then strike the beholder's eyes. So sorrow's clouds being dispelled, I looking up, found I beheld And knew the face that brought me cure: Then looking on her, Thou art sure My Nurse that brought me up, said I, Th' all-powerful Philosophy. Art thou from heaven also sent To exile, that thou dost frequent These solitudes? or art thou come Me to accuse, as falsely some Already have? Darling, said she, Why shouldst thou think I will leave thee, And not part of the burden take Which thou dost bear for my name's sake? Philosophy would sure be shent, If she should leave the Innocent. Fear would me seize, as if in sight Some hideous thing did me affright. What? 'tis but now as it has been; Wisdom full often has been seen By wicked manners to be torn. Of old, (our Plato not yet born) How oft have I with Foolishness Had strong contests? wise Socrates, His Master, for me did see die, Yet dying gained the victory. Stoics and Epicures by name Unto his wisdom have laid claim, And others too what came to hand (Though I did call and did withstand) Did catch as pray, they tore my Coat Which with my own hands I had wrought, And every one did get a part, Believed they'd all, they did departed. 'Mongst these, 'cause something did appear Like me, Imprudence thought they were Of mine; so the mad multitude She did pervert with Errors rude. Perhaps thou dost not know the flight Of Anaxagoras, nor spite That Socrates endured, nor The torments Zeno suffered, for That they were strangers: yet thou knowst That glorious memory can boast The Canii, Sorans, Seneca's; Recent are the fames of these. Why was't these Virtuous men did fall? 'Cause in my manners they were all Instructed, lose minds could not like Their manners, so to theirs unlike. So that no wonder 'tis at all, If in the conflict they do fall Whose Maxims are for to displease The bad, whose number's numberless, Yet to be scorned, for that no guide But ERROR, who draws them aside, They have; who if 'gainst us in sight He do draw up, and us does fright, Our chieftain presently does place Her forces in a secure place. They instantly in vain employ Themselves, our strength for to destroy; While we above sit and deride Their plunderings and foolish pride. Thus from their fury we retire, Sat safe, where Folly can't aspire. Who in a quiet state With an undaunted look Can trample on proud Fate, Good and bad Fortune brook, Not him the foaming threats Of rough Seas yelling death, Nor Vesuvus fierce heats That strive to stop his breath, Nor Lightning wild, which coming from above Full oft high towers does consume, can move. Do not for Tyrant's care, Who without force do rage, Nor hope thou, nor yet fear: Their fury thou'lt assuage. But who does trembling stand, Wishing for what's not sure, Has left for to command, And must (enslaved) endure. The fool has made a Chain, and 'tis most fit That he that made it should be bound with it. Dost thou yet understand? or do I to a Goose yet velvet show? Why dost thou weep? why tears dost shed? Speak, show thy Reason is not dead. If thou'lt be cured done't be shy Thy wounds to show. My mind's force I Collecting then, this answer made, Does not fell Fortune me invade? What need I further it declare? This place itself does make't appear Is this at all like to that place Which thou didst choose for thy solace, My Library, where thou and I Oft did descant on the beauty Of things both humane and divine? Did I then thus my arms entwine? Or did I thus dejected look, When we disclosed hid Nature's book; When with thy Jacob's staff thou me Instructed'st in Geometry, And didst describe the spangled Sky, That I should guide my life thereby? And is this all that they do earn That thee do serve? did not I learn From Plato's mouth, as thy decree, Those Commonwealths should happy be, Where either wise men bear the sway, Or else, where to wise Guardians they Committed are? by him also Thou with good arguments dost show, That honest men endeavour should To sit at helm, and not be fooled, Nor let lewd Citizens to grow, Who would the good quite overthrow. This thou me taught'st, and I desired To practise what thou hadst inspired. Thou and my God (who thee did place In wise men's minds) are witnesses That nothing but the good o'th' State Brought me to be a Magistrate. Hence all my mischiefs grew, 'cause I With wicked men could not comply. The wicked ones I did offend; Though ne'er so great, I them contemned. I could not Conigastus brook When he the goods of poor men took. How oft Triguilla (though he were The King's great Houshold-officer) Have I restrained from ills before, Such as were passed made him restore? How often did I interpose My power, with hazard, to save those Who marked were for sacrifice By the Barbarians cruelties? No man did ever me withdraw From doing right: that without Law By Pillage and by Taxes rife The people suffered, was my grief, As much as theirs. Before the King In a great Famine I did bring The Praetor, urged the heavy rate Laid on Campania, and that State Saved from impov'rishing. I drew Paulinus Consul (when a crew Of ravening wolves did go about Him to devover) safely out. When Cyprian Albin did accuse, Him till his trial to excuse I did myself to th' hate expose Of his accuser. All these foes For others cause I now do prove. My safety then should others move, Since that there is no way for me Now left, by Courtiers to be free, 'Cause I was good. But by what way Was my fall wrought? why, even they Who Basil had accused before, And him displaced, now being poor, They him did hire me to accuse. Opilio also they did use, And lewd Gaudentius, two that were For cheating banished, and for fear Did take Asyle; the King advised Did judge them to be stigmatised, If not soon gone: yet these 'gainst me Were heard: unheard-of cruelty! Was it my cause, or their offence, Made them so righteous evidence? Fortune (if not to see me blamed, At least so basely) was ashamed. But what great Crime? in short 'twas this; I wished the Senate's happiness. And how? I stood in the defence O'th' Senate, quashed the evidence Prepared to make them Traitors all. Now judge you whether that I shall Rather this heinous crime deny, And so shame thee, or justify It as a truth. I'll be no liar, I did and ever wilt desire. Shall I confess it an offence? I then must own the evidence. But was't a crime to wish them well? Their own Decrees 'gainst me do tell That it was so: but Folly's elf (Which ever does belly itself) Can't change the merit of the cause. Nor ought I by Socratic laws To hid the truth, or grant a : If so, then in what fault am I? But this to thee and all wise men I leave to judge; yet with my pen I'll write it down, that all may know, Present and future, what I do. Why should I name those Letters feigned, By which I falsely was arraigned The Roman liberty to hope? The craft of them had been laid , If the confession▪ might that day (Which in all business most does sway) Of my accusers have been ta'en. 'Las! hopes of freedom none remain. I well may wish, but answered had In Canius words, when it was said By Caius Caesar, he was one That wrought the Conjuration Which was contrived against him, If I had knowned ', thou hadst not been. But sorrow has not so me dulled, Only to whine because Vice would 'Gainst Virtue strive: but I admire Her to o'ercome he should aspire. Weakness may prompt us unto ill: But that we should conceive our Will (God seeing) against Innocence Should conquer, monstrous is to sense. From hence one of your family, Not ill, thus reasoned, If there be A God, from whence does evil come? If none, whence good? but to come home, Grant wicked men, who sought the blood O'th' Senate, and of all were good, Sought mine, who did the Senate serve; From them too did I it deserve? When did I either say or do, But thou didst me instruct thereto? Thou knowst, not dreading danger, how The Senate's good I did avow, Whenas th'insatiate greedy King Did (at Verona) cause to bring Albinus Treason on them all, That in his guilt they all might fall. That all these things are true thou knowst, That of myself I ne'er did boast. For he does lessen his good name, Who by a brag does catch at fame. But see th'event: for Virtue true, I'm paid with what to th'Wicked's due. When free confession at a Bar Is made, those Judges cruel are Who humane frailty don't respect, Nor on false Fortune do reflect. Had I burnt Churches, killed the Priests, Made righteous blood run through the streets, Yet present I should have been tried; But now five hundred miles aside I by the Senateam condemned (Because that I did them defend) To death and to proscription. O worthy that ne'er any one Should so offend! but they did see Of my great guilt the dignity; Which for to blind they did allege, Falsely, that I by Sacrilege My conscience had defiled, t'attain My honours: but thou knowst that gain Of Worldly things thou far away Didst from my mind remove, nor may It be believed, who in thy sight Does live, can such a crime commit. This Pythagorean daily thou Into my ears and thoughts didst sow, FOLLOW THOU GOD: nor was it right That he should use an unclean sprite, Whose excellence thou mad'st so free, That like to God he seemed to be. At home my innocent Retreat, Of honest Friends the concourse great, The sweet society I held With holy Symmachus, dispelled Even suspicion of such crimes. But O the wickedness o'th' times! They with this crime did me asperse, 'Cause with thy doctrine and manners I was replete: so not enough That thou no help shouldst me allow, But for me too thou shouldst be torn. One evil more not to be born Was, that most men did think it right, They not the Cause, but Fortune's spite Beholding, crying all things down But what th'Event does happy crown. Who Fortune leaves, it haps to those Their good esteem they first do lose. To think on't is vexation great, How busily the Vulgar treat. And 'tis most true, The heaviest weight Of adverse Fortune is, that straight Who is accused, and falls thereby, Is thought to suffer worthily. And I from my estate thrust out, Stripped of my honours, and no doubt Of my good name, thus suffer must For goodness punishments unjust. Besides, methinks I plainly see The wicked making jollity, And egging each trapanning knave, No matter how, the good t'enslave; Who by my fall deterred, do lie Open unto their villainy: Who dare do mischief 'cause that they Unpunished are, and will for prey. This to the innocent is hard, Not only for to be debarred Of safety, but of his defence. Then loud to cry is no offence. O thou most High, that sittest on thy eternal Throne, Who to th' whole Sky gav'st rules for it to move alone, That mad'st the Moon by th' Sun's reflex to shine so bright, Small Stars to drown, he from her hid, to lose her light. One Star thou mad'st t'attend the Sun each night new born, Which then invades the circle to bring up the morn. When Winter does the trees divest, to have short light; When Summer clothes them, than thou dost contract the night. Throughout the year the seasons ruled are by thy power: What's nipped by th' Bear, the West-wind's fresh again restore; And when benign Arcturus gravidates the earth, Then thou dost bring hot ripening Sirius to the birth. All things we see by thy fixed law thou dost direct; And can it be that Man alone thou shouldst neglect? How, or from whence, is't fickle Chance does him pursue, And Innocence receive the hire to th' wicked due? That wicked men set in high place the good deride, Whilst in a den bright virtue's forced her head to hid, And the Just man a villain's deemed, whilst perjuries Do him crapan, and neatly-close-composed lies? But if that they get strength, insulting they none spare, But make a prey of mighty Kings whom all do fear. Thou that guid'st all, behold this miserable Earth, And the no small part of it, Man, thy dearest birth. Fortune's his foe, but thy great power her rage can lay. Then us below, as thou above dost, rule we pray. When I with grief had this snarled out, She smiled, and nothing moved, No doubt (Said she) I made, when I did see Thee weep, thou wert in misery, And banished, but how far from home, Hadst thou not told me, I'd not known. But from your Country, as 've said, You are not banished, but have strayed. Or if you'd rather think it true, 'tis you yourself has banished you: For no man living else could do't. Remember that your offspring's root Is not Athenian Anarchy, But in one King blest Monarchy, Who joys in many Subjects free, Does none thrust out, by's laws to be Guided, and's justice to obey Is the full sum of all we pray. Dost thou not of thy Country know The ancient law, the which does show That no man can be banished thence That there would make his residence? For who within its bounds does keep, Can't fear he can deserve to sleep In exile: but who would it quit, Quits therewithal desert and wit. So not the place, but thy disguise Me moves. For why? I do not prise Thy Library so richly wrought, But thy own Mind with Virtue's fraught, Which not of Books, but Knowledge great, I once with care had made the seat. Thou hast with truth spoke thy good will To th'common good, but with small skill Thou hast thy own deserts laid out. That thou art honest none do doubt: All know the falsehood they did use. Thou hast done well not to accuse, But gently, thy accusers hate, Because all tongues do it relate. Thou blamest the Senate's foul decree, Thou grievest they have accused me, Bewail'st the loss of my good name, And then Fortune dost exclaim. With bitterness thou dost complain, That virtue's recompensed with pain. At last thou thy sharp verse dost close With prayer, on earth, for heaven's repose. By all which plainly we may see Sadness and grief distracteth thee. So that in this mind thou art in, With easy things we must begin. Those perturbations that thee swell A gentle handling may dispel. So fitted them for to endure, With sharper medicines we'll thee cure. Who seasons does not know, But does i'th' Solstice sow, 'Tis fit he should want Bread, And be with Acorns fed. No Violets you'll find, When Frost the earth does bind; Nor on the withered tree Fresh branches will you see. 'Tis Autumn, all can tell, When Bacchus' clusters swell. God does unto each time A proper use assign; And it so fast has bound, Nothing can it confound: But what does it forsake, A sad account does make. With a few questions first must I, With your good leave, you move and try; That so I may know your disease. Ask me, said I, e'en what you please, I'll answer make. Then she replied, Dost think that Chance this world does guide? Or thinkest thou Reason does it rule? Then said I, I am no such fool To think rash Chance at all can move Such certainties; 'tis God above To his own work does sure preside, Nor will, nor have I it denied. 'Tis true, said she, you so did sing When Man you grieved to be the thing Only from care Divine left out. But of the rest you made no doubt. And truly I do wonder how You can be ill, that this do know. But we will higher seek to find, For that I guests something's behind. Then tell me, since thou dost believe That God to th' world does order give, By what means does he govern it? I cannot frame an answer fit, Since scarce thy scope by me's conceived. Then I, said she, was not deceived, Thinking a breach was open left By which disturbances in crept. But canst thou tell of things the ends, Or unto what whole Nature tends? I've heard, but grief makes me forget. Dost know who all things did beget? Yes, God, said I. And how can't be That you the Rise, yet End don't see? Troubles of mind ('tis often found) Do man in's Reason much confound, But not destroy. Answer me than, Dost thou remember thou'rt a Man? Why yes, said I, most perfectly. And canst thou tell what 'tis to be A Man? Strange question asked, as though Me rational I did not know, And mortal too; I do confess. Dost thou, said she, know nothing else? Why, no: Then thy disease is plain, Self-ignorance does cause thy pain. And now the cause I have found out, Thee for to cure I do not doubt. Confounded by Oblivion vile, Thou grievest thy plunders and exile: Not knowing of all things the close, Thou vile men happy dost suppose: Forgetting how the world is swayed, Thou thinkest that Chance has thee betrayed. Not cause of Sickness hence alone, But Death itself may easily come. That yet thou dost in safety live, To God thou'rt bound thy thanks to give. Of Health a symptom great I find By th'sense thou hast of the world's mind, That Chance therein does not abide, But Godly Reason does it guide. Then do not fear, this spark so small In thee life's fire kindle shall. But for yet 'tis not time t'apply Strong remedies, therefore will I (Knowing by nature minds up take Opinions when they truth for sake, From whence Disturbances arise, And darken their truth-seeing eyes) This cloud of Errors dissipate, Or gently it attenuate. From falshood's darkness so set free, Truth's glorious splendour thou may'st see. In clouded sky the Stars no light can give. When Winds blow high, at Sea we scarce can live. A Flood down hill with ready current goes, But does stand still when Rocks do it oppose. So Truth's bright charms if thou wilt clearly see, Clouds, Rocks and Storms must first removed be. Nor Hope, nor Fear, nor Joy, nor Grief obey; Minds clouded are and. biased where these sway. THE SECOND BOOK. WHile silently on me she gazed, Her modesty my attention raised. Then she began; If truly I The causes of thy grief espy, Thy former Fortune thou dost grieve, The change of which thou dost believe Thy Mind has altered. I well know The many wiles of this siend foe. Most friendly she does ever use Those whom she most means to abuse, With saddest grief them casting down, When unexpected she does frown. But if thou wilt but lay to heart Her manners, nature, and desert, In her was nothing worth thy cost, Nor by her haste thou gained or lost. But this into thy mind to bring, I think will be an easy thing. With my wise say thou wert wont (When she thee courted) her to hunt. But nothing new does us come nigh Without the mind's reluctancy. Hence 'tis that thou a while art gone From thine own quiet station. But time it is that thou do take Some pleasing Cordials, thee to make More fit strong medicines to receive; Soft, sweet Persuasives I conceive, Which only then have their right use, When they our dictates don't abuse. With them let music's sweet delight Strike notes now solemn, and now light. What is't, I pray, has wrought this teen? Hast thou ought new, not heard of seen? If thou blamest Fortune for this change, Thou errest; her nature is to range: She her own law has kept with thee, In keeping Mutability. Such was she when she thee did lure, And with false joys did thee allure. Her double Deity to thee Discovered is, which few else see. And if you like her, don't complain; If not, then do thou her disdain. And this which now does thee oppress, Should cause thy ease and quietness. She thou has left; if not, 'tis sure Thou never couldst have been secure. Do fading joys so rich appear? Are Fortune's smiles to thee so dear? Why, thou canst neither trust her stay, Nor brook that she should go away. Then if that none can her retain, Nor let her go without great pain, What is this slippery Deity, But index of Calamity? For what time present does commend, Prudence regards not, but the End. And who both ways her nature meats, Nor kindness hopes, nor fears her threats. With a contented mind then bear What's done in Fortune's theatre, Since thou art under her command. For with what reason can it stand, She should not her own freedom use, Whom for thy mistress thou didst choose? Thou at thy Fortune may'st repine, But canst not change one stroke i' th' line. If Sails to th' winds committed are, The Ship no certain course can steer; Nor thou to thy designed Port go, But thither where the winds do blow. Thou sow'st thy ground good Corn to bear, But ofttimes comes a barren year. Fortune's thy Mistress, her obey. But thou her turning wheel wouldst stay. Fool of all fools! if once that she Stands still, she Fortune leaves to be. While thus with haughty pride she does run round, And like a torrent all does drowned, Cruel, she without awe on Kings does tread, And falsely smiling mounts the abject head. She hears no plaints, nor cares for pain, But laughs at them that do complain. Those who her trust she cousin's, by her power. Showing them blest and cursed the selfsame hour. But yet let Fortune have fair play, Then judge if ought but right she say. Why dost thou daily me accuse, O man? how do I thee abuse? What is't that from thee I have ta'en? Choose thy own Judge, 'fore him complain. Of Wealth and Honours me implead; I willingly will back concede All that thou ask'st, if it can be shown That any mortal them does own. When first to live thou didst begin, Naked and poor I took thee in: With my own goods I cherished thee, For which thou now dost rail at me. I brought thee up with tenderness, And with abundance did thee bless. Well; now from thee these things are rend: Be thankful I so long them lent; And not complain that thou art crossed, As if thy own goods thou hadst lost. No violence on thee does light; Wealth, Honours, Pleasures are my right; Me for their mistress they do own, With me they come, with me they're gone. Thou rashly dost to them lay claim, And falsely dost thy loss proclaim. Shall only I be barred my right? The Heavens we see do bring forth Light, And it again with Darkness hid. Each year the Earth decks as a bride, With Fruits, and Leaves, and Flowers gay; Then with chill Frosts nips them away. Calm Seas and quiet now entice, Now into horrid Storms do rise. Yet me (that fickle am by kind) Insatiate Man to him will bind. I, having power, i' th' world do play, And sporting turn a wheel always; Pleasing myself to see how I The high turn down, the low bring high. If thou do for thy pleasure climb, To throw thee down is my pastime. And yet no injury to thee, To use my own, I being free. Dost thou not know rich Croesus sat, Whom Cyrus great did fear of late, Himself had burnt in his rich tower, Had Heavens not quenched it with a shower? Hast thou forgot how pious Paul Did grieve his prisoner Perses fall? What do all Tragedies deplore But Fortune's turning Kingdoms o'er? When yet a youth, wert thou not taught That at Jove's threshold there were wrought Two Vessels, one replete with Ills, The other Goodness wholly fills? What if too much thou took'st of one, If yet from thee I am not gone? What if this change a just cause be That thou shouldst better hope of me? Then faint not, nor desire to be, Where all are subject, only free. If as the sands the Seas cast up on high, Or as the bands of Stars i' th' spangled sky, If so with Wealth rich plenty should us store; Yet want of pelf vain man would still deplore. If God each one Honours and Wealth should grant; Still they would moon Honours and Wealth to want. Rapine does still insatiately require: No bridle will hold in untamed desire. None have so much but still desire more: He's never rich that thinks that he is poor. If Fortune thus to thee should say, How couldst thou answer her, I pray? Now if thou canst thy plaints defend, Speak forth, and I'll attention lend. Then I; These are but specious shows, Music and Rhetoric, God knows, Which while we hear do only please; But to deep Griefs do give no ease. When from the ear the sound is gone, Grief more the heart does work upon. 'Tis true, said she; these foments are Applied but only to prepare To cure thy unruly grief. But that which must bring thee relief Must deeper pierce, which I'll apply When 'tis fit time the same to try. To be in misery to profess, Is to forget thy Happiness. Thy Father dead thou wert took in By the chief men, and joined in kin (Alliance which is only good) First to their love, and then their blood. Who did not emulate thy joys Blest with such Father, Wife, and Boys? But these as common I pass by; Nor will I name the dignity With which thy Youth did Age excel: The top of thy blessed Hap I'll tell. If that in mortal things we see Aught that is blessed, can it be A cloud the light should so obscure That memory should not endure? When thy two Sons thou didst behold Carried from home, Consuls enrolled, The Senators them waiting on, And people's acclamation; When thou the King's praise didst dilate Before them placed in chairs of state; When thou 'twixt them, while throngs did press, Triumphal largess didst disperse: While Fortune thus did favour thee, While of her bounties she was free, While none so much her minion was, Thou her good words didst give, I guess. Let thee and Fortune reckon now. What though that she has bend her brow? Number thy Joys and Sadnesses, Thou happy yet will't thee confess. And if that thou do therefore moon, Because thy Joys are past and gone: Like reason bids thee mourning stay, Since sorrows also pass away. Art into th' world but newly come? Dost look here for Elysium? What's in this life of certainty, When every hour men do die? And could we Fortune's self insure, She could but until death endure. What difference then, whether by dying Thou leave her, or she thee by flying? When Phoebus galloping amain scatters his orient light, The lesser Stars to fly are fain from his all-dazling sight. When Zephyrus doth gently blow, the Earth a blush puts on; But ruffling Austere he doth throw death's paleness her upon. When courted with a gentle grace, the Seas are smooth and clear: But then put on an angry face, when Boreas does appear. If nothing in this world be sure, but all to change is bend; Trust if thou wilt to Fortune's lure; trust what's not permanent. But know that every thing that's made lies under this decree, To rise, to flourish, and to fade, and then no more to be. Lady of Virtues, than said I, All thou hast said is verity: A prosperous swift course I had, Which to remember makes me sad: For of all mischief that is seen, The worst is to have happy been. Opinion thee does vex, said she; From which the things themselves are free▪ If the vain name of Loss thee stound, Let's see how much thou dost abound. If thou the best dost still retain, How canst thou of misfortune plain? If thou keep'st still of Fortune's store What is most rich, thou art not poor▪ Thy Father, mankind's ornament, Best Symmachus, to Virtue bend And holy Wisdom, for whose health Thou wouldst lay down thy life and wealth, He safe from injuries does moon Thy miseries, as if his own. Thy Wife does live, commended high For modest wit and chastity; No more to say, her father's like, For thee does live, though in dislike Of life: in which one thing I grant Thou full felicity dost want; For that she wishing thy relief, Does pine away herself with grief. Thy Children, who have Consuls been, Maintain th' uprightness of their kin. Since Life then is the thing most rare, For which all mankind does take care; How blessed wouldst thou thyself confess, If thou knewest thy own happiness, Enjoying still, as't does appear, What then life's self is far more dear? Then cease to grieve, and things miscall, Since Fortune has not shipwreckt all. That Anchors stick, and sound's the Rope, Gives comfort now, and future hope. Pray God they hold, and still be sound; For if they hold, we shall not drowned. But thou dost see how we are torn, How overboard our goods are born. I'm glad, said she, thou moved art, And that thy grief is but for part. But I thy niceness can't digest, And plaints, 'cause thou'rt not wholly blest. For who so full content can find, That something won't displease his mind? Humane affairs still doubt procure, Or never gained, or never sure. One does abound, but's shamed by's Birth; Another Noble, wanteth earth. One stored with both wails single life: Another happy in a Wife Wants Children, and does grieve to see Another Child his Heir must be. Another having Children store, Grieves they are wicked, or else poor. So none with Fortune are content, But their Condition still lament. They're ignorant, her have not tried; And they that have, can't her abide. Add, those men that most happy are, Have quickest sense of their ill fare: If Fortune but a little frown, With smallest gusts they are cast down. An easy thing distracts the state Of those that are most fortunate. How many dost thou daily see, Would think themselves in heaven to be, If they the least part did possess Of that which yet thy life does bless? This place which thou call'st Banishment, The Natives live in with content. So nothing's ill, but what's so thought; And unless so, there's happy nought. Who is so happy, but (if he Once angry grow) a change would see? With what a world of bitterness Is seasoned humane happiness? Which though it please whileed does remain, Yet none could ever it retain. See then the miserable bliss That in all mortal things there is, Which stay not with those are content, Nor please the froward while they're lent. Why mortals then seek bliss without, The which within they need not doubt, Is for that Error them does drowned, And Ignorance does them confound. The centre of true bliss I'll show. Dost thou to any thing more owe Then to thyself? why, no: then why Enjoyest thou not thyself wholly? In doing so thou shalt enjoy What Fortune's self can't take away. And that these casual things do owe No Blessedness, thou thus may'st know. If Blessedness be the chief Good By Humane Reason understood, And that the chiefest Good is not Which does depend upon a lot; For that that same excel it must Which Chance nor Power out can thrust: 'Tis manifest that Bliss is higher Than Fortune's fopp'ries can aspire. This more; Who Happiness does row, Or knows she'll change, or does not know. If he don't know, what blessedness Can be in ignorant blindness? And if he know, his fears are still He shall her lose, since go she will. So being in fear continually, 'Tis sure he happy cannot be. And if her loss he can neglect, So that no way it him deject, 'Tis a poor Bliss that will not cross Him that enjoys it, in the loss. But since by many ways thou'rt known To be a person who does own That humane minds not mortal are, And that this one thing more is clear, That Death this Happiness does end; Then if no further it extend, No doubt but all mankind that die, By Death fall into misery. But we have many known that have Sought Blessedness even in the grave, By Death not only, but have so By torments and afflictions too: Then in this Life what can us bless, Whose end only gives Blessedness? Who would him seat With caution great, Where is no fear That Winds should tear, Nor Waves that threat A downfall great; Let him not fly To Mountains high, Where Winds that blow May overthrow; Nor on Sands rear Which cannot bear: But set him down In a low ground, Where Winds that roar Can't turn him o'er. Thus quiet he, May happy be, Scorning their rage Throughout his age. But since that I these foments find Already sink into thy mind, I stronger medicines now will try. Grant Fortune's goods had certainty: What's in them that is worth the while, Or well considered is not vile? Are Riches thine, or of such count? Does Gold or Money so surmount? Why, in the spending, these by far (Then in th' acquist) more glorious are. Base Avarice is hated still; Bounty does mouths with praises fill. And since Wealth can with no man stay, Wealth's precious then when given away. For should one man keep all the store, All other men must needs be poor. Words without Cost all men may spare, But Riches spent diminished are. Why, then 'tis of necessity, Who parts with's Wealth, he poor must be. How poor a thing is Riches then, Which cannot be enjoyed by men? Nor without making many poor Can any man make up a store. Does Jewels lustre thee entice? If ought be in them of great price, 'Tis from the Jewels, not the Men. Why so admired, I wonder then. What in a senseless thing can seem So fair, that Reason so't should deem? Which though they by creation are, In their degree, exceeding fair; Yet far below thee they are placed, Nor do deserve to be so graced. Do pleasant Fields else thee delight? Why not? no doubt 'tis a fair sight. So does the Sea delight the eye, The Sun, the Moon, the Stars, the Sky. But what are all these things to thee? Darest thou at all boast their beauty? Dost thou sweet May adorn with flowers? Is Earth made fertile by thy showers? Why of vain joys dost so much make? External, for thine own dost take? Fortune will never make that thine Which does by Nature thee decline. The Earth no doubt her fruits does bring To nourish every living thing. And if enough will thee suffice, Scorn Fortune's superfluities. Nature with little is content; And if on her there more be spent, 'Twill or not please, or hurtful be With nauseous satiety. Dost thou delight for to appear In several Suits gorgeous and dear? If they at all the fancy raise, The stuff or Tailor has the praise. Will many Servants make thee blest? If bad, they are a household pest: If good, another's probity, Pray, what shall that redound to thee? By all which it is plainly shown, What thou countest thine is not thine own. And if no beauty be in these, Why should they anger thee, or please? And if by nature they are fair, And so thee please, what needest thou care, Since thou may'st all their beauty see, Though they possessed by others be? For they not precious are therefore, 'Cause thou hast made them of thy store: But thou hast them in great esteem, Because that they do precious seem; And huntest them with great earnestness, For fear that want should thee oppress▪ In this thou art deceived also, Since still thou want'st to make a show: For this of all hands we must grant, They that have most, they most do want. Who nature only would suffice, Cares not for superfluities. Have you no inward sweet content, On outward things you are so bend? Or how is your condition free? With a divine soul dost agree, To boast the glory of thy state In goods that be inanimate? Their own contents each other thing: But you, whose Mind from Heaven does spring, With low things would yourself adorn, Whereby you your Creator scorn. God would have Man all things excel: He, them to serve, himself does sell. For if that good more precious is Then that which does that good possess, And you base things your good esteem, You truly them to serve do seem. Which justly does upon you light, Of Man not having the foresight, To know, all things he does excel Whenas himself he does know well: And if himself he cease to know, He puts himself the Beasts below. For Ignorance the nature is Of Beasts, but 'tis of Man the vice. You do yourself but make a scorn, When you with what's not yours adorn. For what is seen we only prise; What's hid, in its own ordure lies. I do deny that good to be Which does the owner injury. Am I in this deceived, or no? I'm sure that thou wilt not say so. But oft who Riches do possess, By them are brought to heaviness. Since every rogue does think that he Has right to them as well as thee. And thou who now thy throat dost fear, And for false goods dost take such care, If thou those goods away wouldst fling, Before the Thief thou'dst leap and sing. Then worldly Wealth great joy has sure, While whoed enjoys can't be secure. Happy that Age who their own Fields did till; Can Hunger's rage with Acorns easily fill; Did not their Wine with honey mixed confound, Nor made them fine with Tyrian die unsound; Who on the grass did take their quiet rest, Drink Water was, and under Pines did feast: When dangerous Trade, which with it Wealth did bring, Was not yet made of Vice the fatal spring. No Trumpets did the Soldier's minds elate, No weapons hid in wounds through mortal hate. What could invite men then to kill and slay? For none would fight if it were not for pay. O would again those manners might return! But love of gain like Aetna's fire does burn Ah! who was he that first did treasures find? Man lived free they in their cells confined. Of powers and of dignities, Which you extol unto the skies, Not knowing truly what they are, I will unto thee now declare. If they in wicked hands do light, Not Aetna's flames can show such spite, Nor Inundations do such harm. Of this let Consuls power warn, Which first ta'en up for Liberty, So great a burden grew to be, Your Fathers sought to lay't aside, As Kings before were for their pride. And if by chance (as 'tis but rare) Honours conferred on good men are, What is in them that can delight But Courtesy and doing right? So that there is no honour due To Dignity without Virtue. For Virtue only does confer Honour on those in power are. And what is this desired thing? What does this glorious Power bring? Did you but see, you would deride Those poor things to which you preside. O things of Clay! if among Mice The itch of Honour should entice, And one for highest place should crowd, Would it not make you laugh aloud? For if the Body thou look on, What poorer thing is made then Man, Who oft destroyed is by a Fly, Whom oft a Worm does cause to die? Now none can greater power have, Then this poor Body to enslave, Or that which far inferior is, The goods of Fortune, fools chief bliss. For no man the free Mind commands, Nor moves, which firm on Reason stands. When once (we read) a Tyrant King By cruel torments sought to bring A bold free spirit to relate Who with him did confederate, With's teeth he did his tongue displace, And threw it in the Tyrant's face. So to his virtue bravely he Did turn the Tyrant's cruelty. What to another can one do That he himself's not subject to? Busiris who his guests did kill, His blood great Hercules did spill. And Regulus, who oft in bands The Poeni led, they bond his hands. Then what great power is in man, Who his own harms not hinder can? Again, if that in Dignities Any essential good there lies, The wicked could not them attain: For these are rules that are certain, Things naturally contrary, And things opposed cannot agree. Since bad men than we see oft-time Unto these dignities to climb, We may affirm in them to be No good, they do so well agree. So may be put on the same score The rest of Fortune's goodly store; For that most often they them share Who of all men most wicked are. These things may be considered too: They valiant are, valiantly do; Who's swift, we nimble-footed call; And Music makes men musical; Physic Physicians, a sweet tongue To Rhetoricians does belong. Nature gives all in all respects What's proper, not contrar' effects. And in all things that are her due All opposition does eschew. But Wealth can't Avarice repel; Nor Power make him not to swell, Whom vicious lusts do strongly bind In fetters not to be untwined. And Dignities which bad men gain Make them not worthy, but the stain Of their unworthiness does show. That this is so, we come to know Because to things a name you rear Which their effects will no way bear. For these are neither Wealth, nor Might, Nor Dignities so called of right: But if their right names they do bear, They are Vexations, Trouble, Care. Lastly, who's wise the like concludes Of all false Fortune's interludes, In which, as it is manifest, There's nothing good, nought that makes blest: Which neither to good men are sent, Nor make them good to whom they're lent. What ruins did he make that Rome did fire, The Fathers brought to stake, and to aspire His Brother's blood caused spill, Mother to die, That he might gaze his fill where he did lie! Ah! cruel sure was he, without a tear Her entrails torn could see that did him bear. Yet this man did bear sway from the Sun's rise, Unto where ends the day i' th' western skies; From where congealed to ice men wine do eat, To where the world not nice stark naked treat. And would this power vast his mind assuage? No; he with sword did waste, with poison rage. Thou knowst, said I, Ambition ne'er To worldly greatness did me rear. But being stored with Learning, I Thought fit in silence not to die. Then she replied, This is the thing That oftentimes great wits does bring (Even such as at high virtue aim) To hazard all on Fortune's game. Desire of Glory and high place Puts on a seeming lovely face: But how they vile, nay nothing are, By what I'll show will plain appear. First then, by demonstrations all Which we call Astrological, 'Tis plain, to heaven's vast extent The whole Earth's bulk is but a point, So small, that to the Globe if we Compared, it nothing seems to be. Of this small point not the fourth part (Well known by Geometric art) With living creatures planted is. From whence take Lakes, and Bogs, and Seas: Consider this, thou wilt find then There's scarce an atom left for Men. Then if of this small point thou art Shut up within the smallest part, How poor a thing is thirst of Fame, Or perpetrating of a Name? Or how can Glory great be found Cooped up within so narrow bound? Next let us add this one thing more▪ This little point is filled with store Of Nations, who all are at strife In manners, language, course of life: 'Mongst whom Fame is not greatly spread, 'Cause commerce is prohibited, Travel is hardly undergone, And to be tongue-ty'd's vexation. Then for a single Man a name To get, is hard, when Towns want fame. Tully in his time does relate, The fame of Rome was not dilate Beyond mount Caucasus, yet she Then the World's Mistress seemed to be. Thou than dost see how straight and poor The glory is thou labourest for. That fame, dost think, Rome could not gain, One Roman should to it attain? Besides, as Nations divers are, Their Laws and manners differ far: For what one people think worth praise, Another with chastisement pays. So that whoever takes delight In Fame's high busie-winged flight, (Which in most Countries can't have vent,) Let home-spread glory him content. That Fame called Immortality Must in one Nation tethered be. More famous men forgot have died Then are by Writers dignified. Or can Records eternize men? No; Time consumes Writers and them. But you immortal call that same Which is indeed but future fame. Consider but th'infinity, Of ever-blessed Eternity, And you will find the joy you seek Is not a mote in a bright week. Ten thousand Years let be the case, With it compare one Moment's space; Yet definite both spaces are, Though small, they some proportion bear. Then multiply this manifold, Yet no comparison will hold. Finite things 'mong themselves may be Compared, not with Infinity. Then though that time do fame long spare, It with Eternity compare, Thou'lt find it is not only small, But seemeth not to be at all. But you think nought can you commend, If vulgar praise don't it attend. Conscience nor Virtue you regard; From vulgar mouths you seek reward. Learn how he truly did deride One swelled with this vainglorious Pride. Injuriously he did contend With one who Virtue did pretend, Called himself a Philosopher: And now, said he, it shall appear Whether that name you rightly use, And more and more did him abuse. All which he patiently did bear, Seeming no whit for it to care. At last insultingly said he Now that 'tis true you plainly see. But bitingly he did reply, Thy foolish tongue does thee descry. But at what is't brave men do aim, Such as by Virtue only claim? (For these are only worth my breath) What is't that they gain after death? For if (the which we credit not) Men in the Grave do wholly rot, No Glory sure the Grave retains, If nought of him whose 'tis remains. But if a soul unspotted, free From this Earth's prison upward flee, Enjoying Heaven, she'll despise All earthly sought-for vanities. Who headlong does upon vainglory run, And does suppose chief Good to build thereon, Let him behold the spacious Heaven fair, And the pinfold of Earth with it compare: And if with Fame this spot he cannot fill, He will with shame condemn his towering will. Why should fond Pride its self aim for to free From that which tried no mortal man can be? Though Fame do fly to Regions far remote, With titles high; death Glory values not. But high and low suffer alike Death's groans. Who now can show Faithful Fabricius bones? Where's Brutus wit, and rigid Cato's care? In some small script 'tis only said, they were. Then by Records a Name is only shown, A toy of words, the Man lies still unknown. But thee to quell, if thus to live thou choose, Let me thee tell, a second Death pursues. But lest that thou shouldst think that I Am Fortune's utter enemy; I'll grant there is a time that she Deserves of men esteemed to be, When she herself does open lay. Well understand me what I say: For 'tis a wonder I relate, The which I scarce can explicate. To be great truth I do aver, Then Good, Bad Fortune's better far. For She deceives most certainly In promising Felicity: But This does Fortune truly show Inconstant, changing to and fro. She falsely cheating men does fool; But This presides in wisdome's school, She does men's minds in fetters bind, Falsely pretending to be kind; But This from bondage sets them free By making known th' uncertainty. So One you see to be a blast, The Other sober and steadfast: One foolishly deceived with lies, The Other grown by practice wise. In fine, the Happy man still strays From the direct into byways: Whereas the Other to the right Reduces men by a clear light. And dost thou think it a small thing, That this harsh fortune thee does bring To know who faithful is to thee, Discovers false friends treachery? She parting, with her goes her train; But thy true friends do still remain. This to have known at how dear rate Wouldst thou have bought when fortunate? Then leave to moan that thou hast lost Thy Wealth, since thou canst truly boast That thou thy faithful Friends canst tell, Which does all Treasure far excel. Constant though, the world Change does evermore; Seeds i'th' earth though hurled, Forced are to restore; Phoebus to make Day Riding gloriously, Phoebe for to sway, The small light o'th' sky; Seas bounded to be, Though the Earth above: This rare Concord he Made that is all Love. Let him lose the rain, All things Love combine, Hurry do amain To wars intestine: Social Loves are lost Which fair order keep, And the World is tossed As Ships in the deep. People joined in peace, He for them does care: Jarrs he makes to cease 'Twixt the Married pair. Laws he does prescribe, Binding faithful friends, Which them fairly guide Unto honest ends. Happy are they sure That thus guided are By that Love so pure Guides the Heaven's fair. THE THIRD BOOK. HER Song did so much ravish me, That stupefyed I seemed to be. But recollecting, O thou blessed, Said I, reducer unto rest! How have these thy instructions free And pleasant singing cherished me? So that henceforth I think I shall Fell Fortune's strokes not fear at all. And those Remedies the which thou Both harsh and bitter called'st but now, I do not henceforth hate to prove, But cordially I them do love. Then she replied, When I did find That thou didst my instructions mind, Then did I know thou wouldst comply Not onl' in form, but seriously. Those which remain that nature bear, Tasted they by't, sweet swallowed are. But that which thee does now invite With so much pleasure and delight, How much wouldst thou it more intent If thou the scope didst comprehend? Why, what's the final drift? said I. What? perfect true Felicity; Which thou dost dream for to attain, But cheated art with fancies vain. Then I replied, I th' humbly pray Me this to show without delay. Most willingly I will, said she: But first I must declare to thee Things contrary, that thou thereby Mayst know true Bliss more perfectly. Who will a good Ground till, All Weeds he first must kill, And then most certainly He shall grow rich thereby. Who sweet would taste, he must His palate first disgust. Stars than do shine most bright When darkest is the Night. And when Morn does appear The Sun does shine most clear. So thou from darkness free, Most clearly then wilt see; Dark Error laid aside, Bright Truth will be thy guide. Then she a while did six her eye, Her thoughts retiring inwardly. At last, O how are men, she said, With many cares disquieted? All several ways do play their game, Yet all at the same End do aim; That is, chief Good, which I define To be Man's ultimate design: The which indeed the chief Good is, All others being comprised in this▪ But if in all it don't agree, The chiefest Good it cannot be; For that there's something left without The which may cause desire and doubt. By which 'tis evidently shown, Chief Good has all Perfection. This for to get, men sev'rally, As I have said, themselves apply: To which men's minds most certainly Have natural propensity; But Error makes men to esteem What is not such, so such it seem. So Plenty some esteem the ground, Thence toil in Riches to abound. Others high Honours and great Place, Not spoke to, but, If't please your Grace. Others with Power and Command To rule do love, or near to stand. But who of Fame make most account, In Peace and War seek to surmount. Many in Mirth chief Good would find; These to all Pleasures are inclined. There are which seek for to acquire All these with different desire. As some do Riches love, only That Power and Pleasure they may buy. Some Power seek, thereby to gain Great Riches or a lasting Name. To these or other the like end All humane actions do intent: As Honour or a popular name, Thereby for to advance a fame; A Wife and Children pleasure bring. But Friendship's such a holy thing, Not to be named in Fortune's throng, To Virtue onlyed does belong. All other things do men invite For Power, or else for Delight. All goods o'th' Body easily To what is said referred may be. As Strength and all proportions fair An active body do declare: Beauty and bold Activity Do give Renown; Health, Jollity. By all which, all may plainly see, All men do seek Felicity. For what each man does most prefer, That his chief Good he does declare. But we chief Good define to be Beatitude. Then blest is he (At least so to himself does seem) Enjoys what he does most esteem. Lo then what 'tis that does express The All of humane Happiness; Wealth, Honour, Power, Glory, Pleasure. Which only by the Epicure Considered, made him to decree Pleasure his chiefest Good to be; For that from's mind each other state Seemed all delight to alienate. But to men's studies I'll revert, Which though they do their minds pervert, Yet still chief Good is the design. But as a man o'ercome with wine Cannot find his direct way home; So Self-conceit them overcome. But how can they be said to err, Who not to want do endeavour? For is there any state more blest Then that with Plenty is possessed, Which not on others does depend, And which its own self can defend? Or can those men be said to err, Who still the best things do prefer? No; for can that an ill be thought Which by all mortal men is sought? Must Power not be counted good? Must feeble it be understood Which does all other things surmount? Must Fame too be of no account? Why, all men must acknowledge this, What most excels most famous is. I were a fool, if I should tell This Blessedness does so excel, That it nor trouble has nor care, Nor subject is to grief or fear; When smallest things for to acquire That bring delight, men do desire. Hence 'tis they Riches do procure, Power, Rule, Glory, and Pleasure; That by these things they may obtain Respect, Delight, and splendid Fame. That it is Good than it is plain, That men do hunt with so much pain. To which how Nature does impel, Demonstratively all may tell; Since though to various studies bend, In this End, Good, they all consent. Kind Nature the whole World does guide, with Gordian knot does bind, Does certain Laws for it provide, Which now to warble is my mind. Although the Libyan Lions are with easy fetters bound, And take their meat at hand, and fear Their angry Master's whip and frown: Yet if they once do taste of gore, their nature then is seen; They hideously do yell and roar, And tear the ground, and fiercely grin. Then scorning both the whip and call, themselves they do untie, And on their Masters they do fall, Tearing them piecemeal greedily. The Bird used on the trees to sing, if he in cage be penned, Though best of dainties you him bring, Yet to his nature he will bend. And if that once he do get out, and in the woods be free, All your enticements he will flout, And chant his tunes melodiously. If that by force a tender Plant be made to ground to bend, Do you but once let lose your hand, It upward presently will tend. The Sun each night falls in the West, yet still he does return, Leaving all mortals to their rest, Till he again salutes the Morn. All things obliged are by this law, and joy thereto to bend; All do a perfect circle draw, Join their beginning with their end. So faintly you, O sons of Earth, Yet truly fancy your first birth; And the true ends of Bliss foretold, Though darkly, in each thought behold▪ Nature to good all men does lead, But various Error does misled. Consider if the course men tend Can bring them perfect Bliss i'th' end. For if that Wealth or Honour can, Or ought like, make a happy man, Then we'll confess they happy are Who do of these get greatest share. But if that they their promise scant, If much of what is good they want, Do they not openly confess They bring but a false Happiness? First thee I will interrogate, Who didst with Wealth abound of late. With all that Wealth didst ever find Thou couldst possess a quiet Mind? 'Tis true; my Mind was never free, But something still did trouble me. Was it not 'cause thou couldst not have Something thy Lust or Will did crave; Or else because thou couldst not get Rid of what fain thou wouldst be quit? 'Tis true, said I. Then the presence Of this thou soughtest, of that th' absence. I do confessed. And does not he Want who still does desire? said she. 'Tis true, said I. Then she replied, Who wants can't for himself provide. Why not, said I. And thou when rich Didst suffer this tormenting itch. I did. It seems that Wealth than can't Or give sufficient, or bar want. Yet this it promised. Nay, what's worse, Money in'ts nature has that curse, That none to keep it has the skill, But 'twill away against his will. I it confess. How canst deny't, When daily it is forced by might? Hence 'tis so many are outlawed For Monies kept by might or fraud. 'Tis true. Then Wealth does want, said she; And to be kept must guarded be. I grant. But none this guard would have Were't not his Money for to save. No doubt. The case is altered then: For whereas Wealth was thought by men Sufficient all things to upbraid, Itself does want fewer aid. But is there any means that may This Want from Riches drive away? Can Hunger, Wealth, or Thirst endure? Or Winter's Cold can Riches cure? Yes, Wealth has power, you will say, Thirst, Hunger, Cold to drive away. 'Tis true, thus Wealth may bring supply To Want, but not make't not to be. If Want with Wealth must be supplied, And never will be satisfied; If Want do always gape and crave, Wealth is to Want a very slave. A little Nature will suffice, But there's no bound to Covetise. Then if that Wealth can't Want confounded, Nay if that Wealth makes Want abound, What Devil is't possesses thee, To think Wealth has sufficiency? Though the Rich man With Gold abound, Yet no Wealth can Desire bound. Though rich adorned With nations spoil, Hundred beefs horned Do till his soil; Yet Care will still Oppress his mind: So makes his Will, Leaves all behind. But Dignity does this afford, Makes honourable and adored: And Magistrates no power want To root out Vice, and Virtue plant. But they do not Vice abrogate, But Vices more accumulate. Whence 'tis that we do oft misprise The wicked that to Greatness rise. Catullus Nonius Scab did call, Though placed i'th' chair Magisterial▪ Dost thou not see how Dignity Does add unto the infamy Of wicked men, which less would show If Honours did not make it grow? Thou didst refuse to be elate Unto the glorious Chair of state, If Decorate were with thee joined, When thou didst see his sordid mind. For Honours we can't him respect Who of himself deserves neglect. But if a man with Wisdom we And Goodness do replenished see, We give him all the honours due To sacred Wisdom and Virtue; In whom alone it is innate Her goodnesses to propagate. Which worldly Honours cannot do, For that no proper good they ow. Again, if that a gen'ral scorn Does make men sordid and forlorn, Then Honours that don't bring Respect, Must bring Contempt and sore neglect. If Honours make men evil fare, Bad men with Honours even are, While they the Honours do defile. But further, listen yet awhile, And thou shalt see this painted place Can give small comfort, no true grace. 'Mong the Barbarians let be seen A man that oft has Consul been, They won't with reverence 'bout him throng: But if to th' place it did belong, It would not cease the same to be In any Nation or Country; As Fire is in all parts Fire. But for their Worth does rise no higher Then what Opinion does it give, It therefore can no longer live, When it does come for to be seen 'Mongst them who Honours don't esteem. And do they any better fare At home, whence they derived are? The Praefectship of old had power, Now but a Name and burden sour. Who for the people did provide, Was much esteemed, now vilifyed; For that some bad men were accused, That they that honour had abused. But as before I have made known, That Honour proper good has none, But from Opinion takes repute, As men the same do execute: If Honours then don't give respect, If ev'ly used they cause neglect, If change of times do them deface, And if Opinion them disgrace, If in themselves no beauty be, What pleasure can they give to thee? Though Nero fell, Proud and cruel, his body did adorn With Tyrian silk, Stones white as milk, he was the people's scorn. Though he did grace Proud men with place the Senate to keep under, Yet for to guests, Honours could bless by him bestowed, 's a wonder. Can Kingdoms than make men be great? Or can King's favours men elate? Why not, if they would always be? But these to change we oft do see. Time's past and present do show clear To Misery King's subject are. Is not that Power then most vain Which its own self cannot sustain? And if that Kingdoms make men blest, Of it the loss does them divest. Nay, if in Rule they are confined, Why, that brings trouble to their mind. There is no universal Crown, The vastest Kingdom has a bound: Where others power does it pin, There does anxiety begin, And makes them hapless; by which count Kings ill their good does far surmount. The which a Tyrant having tried, Great Princes fears he did deride, By pointing down a Sword i'th' air, Hung by a slender threatening hair. Is not then Power a fine thing, That can't of fear remove the sting? Who would, but can't, securely rest, How by their Power are they blest? And wouldst not thou that Power upbraid Which would, but cannot, be obeyed? Canst thou him mighty think to be, Who if not guarded is not free; Who, though to him they reverence bear, Yet he of them stands still in fear; Who with great Power to be graced, I'th' hands of Servants must be placed? And can Kings favours any save, When Kingdoms so much weakness have? These, oft disfavour do throw down, And oft they perish with the Crown. Think but how Seneca once fell, Whom cruel Nero did compel To choose his death; yet he had been Both Friend and Master unto him. And did not Antoninus send His Soldiers for to make an end Of Papinianus, whom before He favoured, Courtiers did adore? Both these their Power would have quit; And Seneca (if he'd thought fit) His wealth to Nero had resigned, And privately himself confined. But Greatness did them both destroy, Nor a poor wish could they enjoy. Is not then Power a fine thing, Which Fear to th' owner still does bring; Which is not safe to be enjoyed, Nor laid aside can harms avoid? What trust in such a Friend can be Who only c●●rts Prosperity? If Adverse fortune comes, than he Of Friend soon proves an Enemy. What greater plague can Pluto send, Then the feigned smiles of a false Friend? Who would be Great must his own Passions rule, Must not submit himself to be By Lusts enthralled, that should be free. Though he commands from Ind to farthest Thule, Yet if Care conquer him and plaints, He subject is, and Power wants. How false and filthy too is Fame! Which made the Tragic Bard exclaim, O Glory, Glory, for thy hire thou'rt cursed by those did thee desire. For many men have gained a Name By vulgar, false-opinioned Fame: Then which what can more base appear, When they must blush their praise to hear? But though the people true Worth sing, What to a Wise man does this bring, Who seeks not good by popular fame, But a good Conscience makes his aim? Then if a Name to propagate Men purchase would at so great rate; They sure would think't great injury Should not this Name extended be. But, as before I have declared, From many Nations is debarred A private Fame: nay more, what here Praiseworthy is, is slighted there. But I this windy popular Fame Do not think worthy for to name, Which without judgement is up blown, And lasts not to be called one's own. And now who is't that does not see How vain a thing's Nobility, Whose Glory, if we rightly weigh, Is not his own does it enjoy? Nobility that is not new, Is praise that is to Parents due. If Praise it be that Fame does give, They who are praised in Fame do live. Then if thy own Worth thee don't praise, Another's Worth cannot thee raise. Which since 'tis so, the good that is In Nobleness is only this; That he that's born of high estate, Is bound not to degenerate. All humane kind living, From one beginning spring, One governs every thing, the Father high. He made the Sun so bright, To th' horned Moon gave light, Made Earth of Men the site, set Stars i'th' sky. In Man he, him to grace, A heavenly Soul did place; So of a noble race all mortals are. From whence then is this cry, I'm born of Parents high? Each man i'th' Deity has equal share, Unless that he with vices base and foul Degrade his noble high-descended Soul. Of Luxury what shall I say, Whose appetite bears greatest sway? Yet not without anxiety, And 's cursed in the satiety. What sad diseases does it bring? What horrid pains do from it spring, As 'twere the fruits that it does bear? I skill not in these pleasures rare. But all shall find, them don't refrain, That Pleasure's end is certain pain. And if that these can make men blest, I see no cause t'exclude the Beast. Who wholly does himself apply These Pleasures for to satisfy. But of all Pleasures of this Life, The best is Children with a Wife. Yet feelingly one did repeat, My Children are my torments great. There's no Condition this can free, Thou long hast tried it true to be. That saying of Euripides I do acknowledge me does please, Who did proclaim Sterility A happy Infelicity. All Pleasure has this great malignity, To wound and to torment who have it had, like to the Bee, Who having lost her Honey does grow mad, And stings and swells the robbers, though she die. Then surly there is no doubt But who goes this way, does go out Of's way to Blessedness, nor can These Goods him render Happy man. Nay, these are Ills, I'll briefly show. Dost thou endeavour Rich to grow? Thou from another it must gain. Wouldst thou to Dignities attain? Thou must beseech the giver's grace, And to excel, thyself debase. Dost thou desire Power to have? Thou makest thyself to plots a slave. If thou great Glory do procure, Envy thee renders unsecure. Wouldst thou a life of Pleasure lead? Who would not Luxury down tread, And think it base to have his Mind To so base service be confined? And who the body's Beauty prize, How build they on uncertainties? Can they the bulk o'th' Elephant, Bull's strength, or Tiger's swiftness vaunt? See Heaven's firmness, space, and fire, Then leave these low things to admire. Nor yet are these worth thy least thought With him compared that them wrought. Then Beauty is but a frail thing, More fading than the Floweri'th ' Spring. Of which learned Aristotle cries, If one could see with Lynceus eyes, And with those eyes could penetrate The entrails nasty sordid state, The fair-framed Alcibiades Would the beholder nothing please. Thou canst not then thy Nature prize, But the infirm beholders eyes. 〈◊〉 of thy Body be as proud 〈◊〉 thou canst wish, so't be allowed That three day's Fever can destroy The thing in which you so much joy. From which we briefly may collect, These Goods which promise such respect, Nor can their promise keep, nor show That they do any goodness owe; So that they men nor bring to rest, Nor are at all, men by them blest. O how does Ignorance Erroneous ways advance! You seek not Trees for Gold, Nor Vines for crystals cold: You do not climb a Hill Fishes with nets to kill, Nor go to th' Ocean clear, To hunt the Fallow-deer. You careful are to know The times of ebb and slow; And in what coasts are bred White Pearls, where Coral red; What part o'th' Sea the Fin, What Shellfish does lie in. But what you most should mind, Chief Good, in that y'are blind: And seek for that below, Which 'bove the Stars does grow. They're cursed not to be wise, Who Wealth and Honour prize; Which when with pain 've got, Then Goods they know they're not. The forms of false Felicity As yet I've only showed to thee; Which if that thou do clearly know, I will true Bliss now to thee show. I see, said I, that no Wealth can Sufficient be for any man; No Kingdoms, howsoever great, Can give a Power that's complete; No Dignities, full Reverence; Nor Glory, wished for Eminence: No Pleasures can give Perfect Bliss. knowst thou the causes of all this? Methinks I see a glimmering: But you a clearer light may bring. The reason's plain; for that 'tis tried That humane Error does divide What's simple, perfect, and what's true, And it to Falsehood gives as due. Dost thou think what's in nothing scant, That the same thing can power want? Why not, said I. Thou thinkest then right: For if in aught it want full might, In that 'tis of necessity It must by others succoured be. That's true. Then the condition Of Power and Enough's all one. So't seems. What thinkest thou then? is't sit To slight this, or to honour it? Why, it to honour, there's no doubt, Since best of things it brings about. Why then, unto Sufficiency And Power let's add Dignity, And then these three but one appear. We must it add, if truth we'll hear. And now, said she, thinkest thou that this Obscure and base, or famous is? Consider too (since you do grant That is most glorious nought does want,) Whether this Glory▪ do want Fame, Which to itself it cannot frame, And so does seem to come below. I must needs grant it Famous too. Why then, in this we must agree, Fame differs not from th'other three. We must. Then that which nought does want, That which in Power is not scant, That which has Fame and Glory high, That is most pleasant certainly. But see, said I, I no way can, How Grief should seize on such a man. No; by what's said, we must confess That man does perfect joy possess. And this too's of necessity. Power, Fame, Respect, Sufficiency, And Pleasure, have a several name, But all in substance are the same. 'Tis true, 'tis of necessity. Then this you'll grant, man's pravity Divideth what is simple, pure: Which while he strives for to procure By part, the which no parts contains, Nor whole nor part to him remains. How's this? said I. Who Wealth would have, Flies Want, but Power does not crave; Had rather live obscure and vile, From all delights himself exile, Then part with what he cannot hold, His dear-beloved darling, Gold. But by these means, most certainly, No man can have Sufficiency; Whom Power leaves, or Cares molest, Or Baseness hides, can have no rest. Again, who would to Power rise, Wastes Wealth, and Glory does despise; And without Power, Honour too Nor Pleasures can at all him woe. And yet when he has all his will, There's many things he wanteth still. Sometimes he Necessaries wants, Sometimes is vexed with Cares and Plaints; Of which since he can't rid his mind, He wants that Power he designed. With the same reason we may measure All Honour, Claritude, and Pleasure. For since that every one's the same With all the rest, he is to blame Does unto any one aspire, Losing thereby his own desire. What then? said I. If one address Himself to all, can they him bless? No, we have showed they cannot do't, Since they their promise can't make good. Nor can they Bliss bring to effect, Since each has singly his respect. I do confess that nothing can Then this be truer taught to man. The causes then and form, said she, Thou see'st of false Felicity. Now bend thy mind but contrary, And thou true Bliss shalt soon espy. When thou the causes of false Bliss Didst open, thou didst then clear this. For if I rightly construe thee, That's perfect, true Felicity, Which does sufficient render, and Gives Pleasure, Fame, Respect, Command. Further to make it plain to sight, That I do understand thee right; I do acknowledge that which shall Do truly one, performs them all: And then no doubt but this must be True, perfect, full Felicity. O happy thou that dost think so, If one thing more thou'lt add thereto! What's that? said I. Dost think there is In mortal things this perfect Bliss? Why not, said I; for thou hast made It out so plain more can't be said. Why then these things but represent The image of true Good, but can't Confer this perfect Good on men. I do agree, I answered then. Since that thou than hast so much gained, To know true Good from what is feigned, Of all remains this is the sum, To know from whence this Good does come. Why, that from thee I do expect. On Plato than I must reflect, Who taught, for things that least do weigh We ought the Heavenly Aid to pray. What then dost think is fit to do The sovereign Good to come unto? We must our prayers to him address, Who does all good beginnings bless. Thou rightly hast advised, said she; Then sung this Song melodiously. O thou that dost with Reason high all things in order guide, Thou whose bright Throne's above the sky, Yet governest all the world beside: Thou from all time makest Time to flow, Yet thou dost still remain; Thou giv'st to all things here below Alternate courses, joy and pain. No cause external thee did move this mighty work to frame: Only from thy internal Love, From envy free, it freely came. Th'examples of all things that are thou from above didst bring: For thou that art the fairest Fair, To thy fair Mind form'dst every thing, Commanding perfect All to be, Perfect to be each Part; Making the Elements to agree Which Nature does so widely part. Thou joyn'st the Moisture with the Flame, the Water with the Earth; Lest that the Fire all should tame, And Earth should not bring forth its birth. Thou in fit stations ordered hast the Soul that all does move; And so adaptly hast it placed, It's threefold nature joins in love. Which Soul two several Orbs does sway, them rolls with motion round, Winding about to its first way, Circles the Mind'bove all profound. By th' same command this Soul it drives Celestial motions all, Gives being to the lesser lives, And fosters all things on this Ball. 'Bove all thou dost in chariots high our Souls cause for to ride; Making some fit to pierce the sky, Whiles others things terrestrial guide. The which, when they have run their round, by thy command benign, With thy eternal fire crowned They back to thee return again. Blessed Father, to thy glorious Throne let my dull mind ascend: Thou that the fountain art alone Of Good, grant I behold the end. And when that I have found this Light, grant that on thee I may My mind fast fix with cleared sight, Casting all earthly things away. Surround me with thy splendid Rays: for rest I thee attend, For which all pious men thee praise, Who art Beginning, Way, and End. Now that the forms are understood Of perfect, and imperfect Good; I think it reason for to show In what this perfect Good does grow. In which we first ought to inquire, Whether that Nature can acquire Such Good as is before defined; Lest, contrary to what's designed, We be deceived with a show Of Truth and Knowledge, nothing so. But that there is, none can deny, A fountain of Felicity. For whatsoever imperfect is, 'Tis but what does Perfection miss. Whence follows, if in any kind Something imperfect we do find, In it then of necessity Something that's perfect there must be. For where Perfection there is none, There can be no Imperfection. Nor from a lame imperfect thing Does Nature her beginning bring; But from what perfect is in all She does into defection fall. Which if't be so, as I've made plain, That there's imperfect, brittle, vain Felicity of Good, than who Can doubt but there is perfect too? Most rightly thou concludest, 'tis so. But where it dwells, said she, thus know. The common thought of humane kind Does prove that the most heavenly Mind, Which over all things does preside, Is good; nor can it be denied: For then God better who can guests, Than whom there better nothing is? So Reason, that does evidence That God is good, makes plain to sense That he is perfect; for else he Can not of all things ruler be. Something there is would him excel, In whom true perfect Good does dwell: Which must more ancient be also; For perfect things we all do know Before imperfect were: so then In infinitum we must run, Unless that we do God confess To be replenished with Goodness. But we before concluded this, What's perfect Good, that is true Bliss: Therefore 'tis of necessity True Bliss in the high God should be. This is so strong a truth, said I, None can gainsay it certainly. But mark, I pray thee, then said she, How thou approv'st inviolably That the high God we did profess To be replenished with Goodness. How's that? said I. Thou dost not sure Presume that this same Father pure Did so receive this chief Goodness, With the which he replenished is, That it from any other came: Nor dost thou think but 'tis the same To be God, who hath this Goodness, And the thing had, true Blessedness. For if that God did it receive, He's better sure that did it give. But we do worthily confess God all things does excel, all bless. But since of God we now do treat, If Goodness have in him a seat By nature from a divers cause, If he obeys fewer laws, Let him who can bring forth to light, Who did these divers things unite. Lastly, whatever thing is divers Cannot be that from which it differs. Wherefore what from the chiefest Good To differ may be understood, In its own nature's not the same; Which wicked were of God to name, Than whom there nothing better is▪ For nought can better be then his Beginning; which if understood, Then God to be the chiefest Good (Who is the first substantially) We may conclude most certainly. 'Tis true, said I. But I did press That chiefest Good was Happiness. You did. Then God we must confess Is th' only real Happiness. By thy first precepts I did gain, But these have made them far more plain. Thus than more firm I'll make't appear: Two sovereign Goods that are Cannot subsist, for that 'tis plain That two Goods cannot be the same; So we must neither perfect grant, While one Good does the other want. And what not truly perfect is, That cannot be the chief Goodness. Wherefore the chiefest Good, we see, Not possibly can divers be. But we the chiefest Good aver God and Beatitude both are: Then that the highest Bliss must be That is the highest Divinity. Nothing is in itself more true, Nothing more firmly can accrue To Reason, nothing said can be More worthy God's high Majesty▪ Farther, as Geometricians use All kind of knowledge to refuse But what their Propositions Infer by Demonstrations; So I will this same give to thee As it were a Corollary. As men by gaining Blessedness, Do gain thereby what does them bless, And Bliss is high Divinity; Then who gets this does get to be, As it is plain and manifest, Thereby most happy and most blessed. As men by Justice Just are said, By Wisdom men are Wise men made: So likewise of necessity Men Gods are by Divinity. Then who does gain this Blessedness, He then a God can be no less. I, but there can but one God be. That's true in nature verily; But yet there may be more than one By God's participation. Call you this a Corollary? A precious one it is, said I. But there is one more precious yet, Which Reason does persuade to knit. What's that? said I. Since it seems plain That Bliss does many things contain, Whether all these do conjugate In Parts to make this Blessed state; Or one Part of them does complete, For all the rest, this Bliss so great. I would, said I, that thou wouldst clear These things more in particular. Why, we aver that Blessedness, Said she, is the chiefest Goodness. 'Tis true, said I. The same thou may'st, Said she, add unto all the rest. For it is chief Sufficiency, Chief Power, and chief Dignity, Chief Honour, and chief Pleasure too. And what have all these Goods to do, This Power, and Sufficiency, And all the rest of that degree? Are they but parts of Blessedness? Or do they Good entire comprise? I see what 'tis you go about: But how, said I, will you make't out? Why thus; If all these members be Of ever-blessed Felicity, Then each from other far escarts: For this the nature is of Parts, Of many, one entire to frame; But these are all one and the same. For these indeed no members be: For if, than this Felicity Would of one member be conjoined; Which cannot be. That's true, I find: But what remains I do desire. 'Tis plain that all things do aspire To Good: therefore Sufficiency Is sought, 'cause Good therein does lie; And Power, deemed Good to procure. The same of Honour, Fame, Pleasure. The sum and cause of all desire Is this then, Good for to acquire. For what nor Good, nor Good is like, That has a general dislike. And contrary, what are not so By nature, if they make a show, They as true Goods desired are. So that the Sum, the Scope, the Care Of whatsoever desired is, Must be believed to be Goodness. For for what cause a thing is sought, That end to compass must be thought. As if a man for Health do ride, Though pleased his prancing Horse to guide, Yet more th' effect, his health, does take. So all things sought for Goodness sake Are not themselves so much desired, As Goodness self, to be acquired. But we already did profess That same for to be Blessedness For which all other things are sought: That therefore they are sought, we taught. By which it plainly does appear, Goodness and Bliss the same things are. I see no reason but 'tis so. But we did also plainly show That God and Bliss is the same thing. You did, said I. Thence then does spring, That God's whole substance placed is In Goodness self, that's perfect Bliss. Come hither all you that are ta'en In Lust's deceitful wicked chain, Whose minds mind nought but for to gain things terrestrial. Here from your labours you may rest, Here is a port with quiet blessed, Here is the refuge that is best for wretches all. The Gold that Tagus does afford, Nor what rich Hermus' banks has stored, Nor Gems of which the Indian's lord, the Mind can clear; But rather it obnubilate: For that which here gives best estate, And does men's minds most elevate, from earth they tear. In mines cannot be found that light Which does adorn the Heaven's bright, And which does pierce with so much might the souls impure. Which Light to whom it shall appear, Will his dark soul so fully clear, That thenceforth he may justly swear the Sun's obscure. With strongest Reason I agree, All things, said I, composed be. But how much more wouldst it esteem If Goodness self, said she, were seen? Why infinitely, said I then, Because by it I God should ken, Who Goodness is. Why this, said she, By reasons true I'll show to thee; Let but those things remain which I Already proved have certainly. They shall, said I. I've showed, said she, Those things which by most sought for be Nor true Goods, nor yet perfect are, Because amongst themselves they jar▪ For if one from another swerve, They cannot perfect Good preserve, Which only then is true and right, When in one form they do unite. For that which is Sufficiency, The same is Power, Dignity, Fame, and Pleasure. If then that these Bened all the same, 've nought that please▪ Then this a truth all must confess, What's discrepant is not Goodness. And if by being one they do Goodness become, than it is so That therefore they come good to be By the obtaining Unity. So't seems, said I. Then all that's good, To be good by 's understood By Good's participation. So 'tis, said I. Then to be one, And to be good, you do declare To be the same; for those things are Of the same substance whose effects By nature have the same respects. I can't deny't. knowst thou, said she, That all that is, so long will be As it is one, but perishes When Unity in it does cease? As how? said I. Why thus, said she; In Living creatures we it see, It does a living thing remain While Soul and Body are the same. But if that these asunder fall, No longer we do so them call. The Body too, while we it find With all the parts in one conjoined, The humane species seems to be: But if divided, Unity Being distraught, it is no more The thing that it appeared before. And so all other things we see Are lost by losing Unity. In all things I can think upon, This is no supposition. Why, is there any thing, said she, That does desire naturally To leave to be, and for to come To nothing, or destruction? In Living creatures, than said I, Who have nature's activity To will and nill, I do not find (Unless some outward force them bind For to obey) any 'ntention Of free and willing destruction. All living things their health defend, Shunning to come unto their end. But what of things called vegetal To think, I do not skill at all. But this too thou may'st also know, When Herbs and Trees thou findest to grow In Places for their nature fit, Wherein if they be firmly set, Their nature will not let them dry, Nor but by course of Nature die. In Plains, on Hills, in Fens some spring; Others hard Rocks, some Sands forth bring: Transplant but these, and presently They whither do away; and die. For Nature every thing does give What's fit, and willingness to live. And do not all these things get birth By thrusting down their heads i'th' Earth? The which does nourishment infuse To th' Root, and that does strength diffuse To th' Stock: what part most tender is, Within, like marrow, placed is: The Wood, like bone, this does secure, Then Bark to make it to endure. Again mark Nature's careful heed, Who multiplies all things by Seed; By which she seems for to endeavour To make them for to live for ever. And things that are Inanimate Seem to desire that same state Which most does tend to their welfare. Hence Levity does Flame up rear, By Weight the Earth is downward pressed, For that these motions suit them best. What does with every thing agree, That it conserveses most perfectly. And things by opposition Are brought unto destruction. Again, what's Hard, as Stones, defend Strongly their parts, resist their end. What Liquid is, as Air and Water, As soon unite as they do scatter. Fire does all division fly. Nor do we now at all descry The motions of the knowing Soul, But the intentions natural. Such are, how we our meat digest, Yet not thereon do think the least. Not knowing it, we breath in sleep. So does the creature a force keep Of preservation, not by th' will O' th' Soul, but Nature's principle. For Death, which Nature does abhor, Is by the Will oft pleaded for. The Generative act again, By which only all things remain, Sometimes is bridled by the Will, Though Nature do desire it still. Wherefore this self-affection grows, Not from the Will, but Nature's laws. For Providence did give to all Things that she made a natural Desire to remain, and this The chief cause of remaining is. Wherefore there is no reason thou Shouldst doubt that every thing should bow, By nature, up its self to bear, And all corruption do defer. I now confess I clearly see What seemed before incertainty. Moreover that which does desire To be, said she, that does aspire To be but one, which away ta'en, Being itself will not remain. That's true, said I. All things, said she, Then do desier Unity. This I did grant. But I said this, One is the same that Goodness is. You did. Then all things Good design, Which thus we truly may define; Good is the thing all things desire. Nothing, said I, can be thought higher. For either nothing does preside; Or if that any thing beside This Unity, all things would run Headlong into Confusion. And if that any thing there be Which to arrive at all agree, That thing must needs be understood To be the chief of all that's good. O how I do rejoice, said she, That thou this point of verity Dost apprehend? by this thou hast Discovered what before thou saidst Thou didst not know. What's that? my friend. What is of all things the true End. For that's the thing all things desire. And since then Good there's nothing higher, We must ingenuously confess, The End of all things is Goodness. Whoever with a knowing mind Will seek the perfect Truth to find, And will not be deceived, nor tread The paths that into Error lead, Let him look upon His own discretion, And bind his Notions in a round, Let him teach his Will, But only this skill, With its own treasures to abound. And then what lately hid did lie In clouds of Error, will thereby Break into splendour far more bright Than Phoebus' in's most glorious light. The thick Body's shade As yet has not made A full Eclipse upon the Mind: If Learning do glow, Seeds of Truth will grow, While inwardly they comfort find. If any one should question thee, Couldst thou an answer make him free? Was ever any one yet found With Reason's light did so abound, Unless God in love Him inspired from 'bove, And gave him a Prophetic strain? Give Plato his due, Who says 'tis full true, What's learned we can recall again. With Plato greatly I comply, For thou into my memory Now twice hast those instructions brought Which I'd not known hadst thou not taught: Once Sickness from me did them hid, Nor with my grief would they abide. Look back on what is said, said she, And then into thy memory Will be recalled with much ease What not to know thou didst confess. What's that? said I. How and which way God does this worldly fabric sway. I do remember then, said I, This same to know I did deny. What thou in this wilt say, although Far off I see, yet it to know More plainly, I desire from thee To hear expressed. Thou shalt, said she. But lately thou didst grant to me, God the world's Governor to be. I did, and do it now assever, Nor do it doubt, nor will do ever: And I will briefly tell thee why My Reason does with this comply. The World that's framed of many a part Can not have been reduced by art Into one form, unless that One Alone had made the Conjunction. Again, though they conjoined are, Their natures disagree so far, They would this Concord break again, Unless that One did them contain. Nor could Dame Nature certainly, Keep on her course so orderly, Nor keep her motions so direct In time, and place, and in effect, Unless a perfect Unity, Disposed of this variety. And this same One, whate'er it be, Which all things made, does all agree, I by the name of God do call, A name that used is by all. Since thou of these things thus dost think, Thou art, said she, even at the brink Of perfect true Felicity, And may'st again thy Country see. But our proposals let's review. Did we not grant Bliss did ensue Sufficiency, and did confess That God is that same Blessedness? 'Tis true we did. Why then, said she, The World to govern wanteth he External help? if so, than he Has not a full Sufficiency. That cannot, said I, be denied. Then he alone does all things guide That must by all be understood. But God I showed to be chief Good. I do remember that beside. Then he as Good does all things guide, As well as by himself, and this Of rule the very Rudder is Which does this worldly Vessel guide, And safely makes all things abide. I grant, and I before did see, Though dimly, this sound verity. I do believe't. But now I find Thou dost more strictly bend thy mind The truth to see: but I'll declare What shall more plainly make't appear. What's that? said I. Since we confess God does rule all things with Goodness, And that all things to good incline By nature, and not by design, Who doubt can but they governed be Not forced, but voluntarily, And that each thing most freely does To's ruler's will its self dispose? This to be true I do esteem; Nor would the guidance happy seem, If that it should a yoke impose, Not leave a freedom to dispose. Then what does Nature's law obey Goes not from God a devious way. Why, no. And if it should, said she, What profit could it reap thereby, Since we most powerful him grant, 'Cause he alone does nothing want? Why, none. Then there's nothing which would Or can resist this chiefest Good. Nothing, I think. Why then, said she, That the chief Good we must agree, Which firmly all things govern does, And sweetly does the same dispose. How these results not only do The height of Reason to me show? But thy words placed are so right. They give to me a high delight. Henceforth then imprudence and folly Will never vie with things so holy. Hast thou not heard, said she, the tale How Giants Heaven did assail? But them this power did confound, And worthily them threw to ground. But wilt thou that I farther yet Thy intellect with reasons whet? By this collision there's no doubt There will some sparks of Truth fly out. Do as you please. There's none, said she, Doubts God Omnipotent to be. None well in's wits. The word is so, Omnipotent can all things do. That's true. What then? can God do Ill? Why not, said I. Then follow will That Ill is nothing, since that who Can all things, cannot Evil do. Dost me delude, me thus to bring Into a labyrinth with reasoning? Thou me always dost put in doubt While thou thyself go'st in and out At pleasure: or dost complicate A winding circular estate Of the simplicity Divine? For but even now thou didst define, Beatitude chief Good to be, And that placed in the Deity: That God himself is this Goodness, As also perfect Blessedness. Hence followed, None can happy be That is not one o'th' Deity. Thou saidst the form of this Goodness The very substance of God is. This Good to be but one you taught, For that by all things it is sought. You farther also did decide, That God by good this World does guide: And that all things do with their will Obey; that Nature has no ill. To prove all this thou didst not bring Reasons which do at distance spring, But such as nigh and proper are, One still confirming the other. Why then I do not mock, said she; For by God's help that's proved, you see, For which we did agree before The heavenly aid for to implore. Such is the form of this Divine Substance, that it does not decline To outward things, nor does at all Accept things that are external. Of which Parmenides does say, A round is equal every way. And if that I have not gone far For reasons to prove this matter, But only have made use of those Which fitly from itself arose; Thou hast no reason me to blame, Since Plato taught the very same: Speech that to matter is applied To th' matter ought to be allied. Thrice happy is the man that can goodness clearly once behold, Thrice happy surely is the man whom earth's ties do not hold. Orpheus he Full mournfully his dear-beloved Wive's death did 'plain; While he did play Woods ran away, and Rivers fixed did remain. The Hind without all fear did lie close unto the Lion's side, Nor was the Hare scared with the cry, nor when she the Dogs espied. Yet inwardly, The fire did fry, and he who all things else could tame, Can not appease This fierce disease, nor quench this all-devouring flame. Full highly than he did complain, the Gods without mercy were, And his dear Wife for to regain, unto Hell he did repair. With measured feet And music sweet he did the hellhounds all disarm; His mother she, A Goddess free, did teach him how he them should charm. He did his grief before them lay, his lost Love did sadly mourn, And Pluto's self did humbly pray her to him for to return. With his sweet Song The Fiends among he Cerberus did chief move, Who him let in; Then all being for to solicit for his Love. Now Ixtion not turns the Wheel, Tantalus his Thirst forgets, Nor Titius does the Vulture feel, music all their torments lets. The shady King, When he did sing, could not deny to grant his boon, Give him, said he, Eurydice, with Music us he has o'ercome. But lest that he too high should swell, with this law I will him tie, If he look back on her in hell, he shall lose her instantly. But who with law Can Lovers awe? Love is a thing that has no bound. He by twilight Of her had sight, lost her, and did himself confound. This Fable does all them concern who to virtue do arrive, And then forget what they did learn, back again to darkness drive. Who does know Bliss, Yet will with this vain world give trouble to his mind; All he did gain With so much pain, by looking back, he lost will find. THE FOURTH BOOK. PHilosophy with a sweet voice Did sing this song, and kept a choice Decorum both in word and look; When I abruptly undertook (Not having yet my grief laid by) To speak: O light of truth, said I, Whatever yet thou hast laid forth Appears to be of divine worth, By reasons not to be repelled. Thou saidst these were from me with held By extreme grief, and yet but so, That heretofore I did them know. But of my grief the greatest cause Is this, to know that God, who laws To all does give, is good; then how Can Ills or be, or go? This which does so much trouble me, I leave to be admired by thee. A greater yet (for to be plain) Is this, while wickedness does reign, Virtue has no reward at all, But stead thereof the wicked call It Vice, and punishments inflict. But that it should be a delict, And God should see't, who all does know, All power has, who will not do Any thing but what's very good, May be admired, not understood. That's right, said she, if that it were As thou dost think, it would more scare Then sight of ugliest monsters would, To think the Heavenly Father should In his well-ordered house respect The basest, and the best neglect. But 'tis not so: for if that that thou Our late Conclusions dost avow, By his help of whom now we speak Thou'lt know the Wicked are but weak, The Good are potent; and that Vice Is punished, Virtue held in price. The Good enjoy a happy state, The Wicked are unfortunate▪ More may be said of the like strain Will make thee henceforth not complain. And since the form of perfect Bliss By me unto thee shown is, And that thou knowst where it is placed, The time I will no longer waste, But I to thee the way will show, How thou unto thy home may'st go. I will give wings unto thy Mind, By which thou shalt a safe way find, (Set free from all disturbances) Unto thy Country with much ease: Triumphantly thou home shalt ride, My skill and knowledge thee shall guide: For I have Wings of subtle make, which if the Mind puts on, 'Twill soon above the Pole ascend, and Earth not look upon. 'Twill soon pass through the Airy globe, and clouds will leave behind, With nimble course the Fire 'twill pass o'th' Sun, that mortals blind. The region cold that Saturn rules will not at all it stay, 'Twill pass the Stars that paint the sky so bright i'th' Milky way. And having past the highest sphere, and left the Pole so bright, Upon the highest Orb 'twill stand, enjoying clearest light; Whereas the King of Kings does hold the Sceptre and the reins, And on his throne of Glory set all evil he restrains. If thou unto this place do come, which now thou hast forgot, This is my Country, thou wilt cry, here, here I claim my lot. Whence if that thou do look upon the place thou left'st behind, All the fell Tyrants on the earth thou wilt in exile find. Thou promisest great things, said I, Of which thou me wilt certify I make no doubt: but I thee pray, In clearing them make no delay. First, you do this acknowledge then, There's Power always in good men; And that all bad men are without All Power, thou canst make no doubt; Since one the other does make plain, For good and bad are wholly twain. If Goodness do no Power want, Then Evil Weak we needs must grant. And if Ill's Weakness does appear, Then Goodness Strength by its made clear. But that more easily there may Be credit given to what I say, My proofs I equally will bring, Now this, now that side marshalling. There are two things which in effect In men's affairs bear chief respect; That's Will, and Power: if these two Be not entire, all will not do. No man will go about to try What to his Will is contrary: And if that he no Power have, In vain his Will does strive or crave. Hence 'tis that if thou one dost see Who would get that that had can't be, 'Tis want of Power does restrain That he that thing does not attain. Why this, said I, none can deny. Thou must confess then equally, That he who does whate'er he will Has Power the same for to fulfil. 'Tis true. For it does Power show, According to the Will to do. The Will abridged, o'th' contrary, Does show an Imbecility. I it confess. But dost, said she, Remember that we did agree, In all intentions of the Will, Though diversely it use its skill, Still Blessedness by it's designed? I do. But dost thou bear in mind, That Blessedness is the true Good; By which it must be understood, Who Bliss does seek, means Good thereby? I do remember it, said I, And in my mind I hold it still. Then all men, whether good or ill, With one and the selfsame desire Do unto Goodness still aspire. That's certain truth. And so is this, That who gets Goodness he good is. But good men get what they desire. 'Tis true. And evil lose their hire; For if that they do Good obtain, They do no longer ill remain. 'Tis so. Then since they both desire Good, and the one does lose his hire, And th' other not, than it is plain That Power with good men does remain, Weakness with ill. whoever with sense The nature weighs and consequence Of these things, must agree thereot. She than replied, If there be two To whom by nature the same thing Proposed is; if one do bring The same to pass by a right course, The other strives by ways are worse The same to do, but can't complete The work, but onlyed imitate; Which of these two most Power has, Dost think? Although that I do guess What 'tis you mean, yet I would fain Have you describe it yet more plain. To move by walking (thou'lt not then Deny) is natural to men. 'Tis so, said I. Nor canst deny But 'tis the feet move naturally. I can't. Why then, if one do use His feet, another does refuse This natural means, and he will go Upon his hands; which of these two Wilt thou the stronger deem to be? Make out the rest; for surely he Who goes the true and natural way, To be the strongest all will say. Why so, said she, the chiefest Bliss, Which equally proposed is To good and bad, the good apply To get by Virtue naturally; The bad by Lusts (but all in vain) Seek this chief Good for to attain. Dost think they can? Why not, said I; The sequel plainly does't descry. Then what is proved makes appear, The good are strong, the bad weak are. 'Tis right, said she, and by this scope I do (as wont Physicians) hope Good strength of nature, since I find. To Knowledge a so ready mind. I will therefore more reasons bring. See if bad men have any thing, Who cannot unto that arrive To which their nature does them drive. And if their power in this be scant, Consider how much strength they want. For they no small rewards desire, But to the top of Bliss aspire, To which they no way can attain, Though night and day they take great pain. Which proves the strength of those are Good: For as it must be understood That he that runs and wins the goal Most able is; so thou must hold His power greatest, does acquire The utmost end of his desire. Which for the wicked cannot do, It plainly does their weakness show, Who leaving Virtue, follow Vice. Is't Blindness that does them entice? Why, what's more weak than Ignorance? Or do they know't, yet Lusts advance? This their intemperance Weakness is, And they are overcome by Vice. Or do they knowing, willingly Leave Virtue, and to Vices fly? By this from Strength they are so free, That thus they leave at all to be. For who the common end of all Does leave, leaves being therewithal. This to be strange perchance may seem, That wicked men, whom all do deem The greatest part of humane kind, Thus to be nothing we should find. Yet so it is. The wicked I For to be ill do not deny: But I do also say withal, That simply they are not at all. For though a carcase does make known This is a man, he's simply none. So wicked men I ill allow, Yet them to be I disavow. That is which order does retain, And keeps his nature: what does strain And swerve from it does leave to be (At least) what it is naturally. But ill men act, (though evilly) Thou sayest, and I it not deny. But this their Power not from Strength, But Weakness will appear at length. They can do ill, but not good too; If good, than they could not ill do. So that such Power does plainly show That they indeed can nothing do. For we before did this agree, Ill in itself nothing to be. Since nothing then a wicked man Can do but ill, he nothing can. 'Tis so. But yet that more certain This may appear, by being more plain, We said (thou knowst) a while before The chiefest Good had greatest Power. You did. But it no ill can do, Said she. That's true. But dost thou know Any so mad, to think that men Can all things do? No. Yet they can Do evil. Yes; I would to God They tethered were that they could not. Since then this Power can all things do, And wicked men cannot do so; The Power than we must confess Of those do ill is much the less. Moreover Power counted is Among those things that do bring Bliss: And all those things to Good refer As to the top of their nature. But 'tis not possible that Ill At all should strive Good to fulfil. Therefore 'tis not to be desired. But Power is to be acquired. Then sure the possibility Of doing ill no Power can be. All which most plainly does confirm Good Powerful, Evil infirm. What Plato said, then does stand true, That only wise men they can do What they desire; they that do Ill, Do only exercise their will, But cannot unto that arrive Which they desire, for that they strive By wicked means for to obtain That good which they desire to gain. But of their end they needs must miss, For Wickedness leads not to Bliss. What though thou mighty Kings dost see, In Purple shining gloriously, mounted upon their Thrones of state, With armed men circled about, With a bend brow threats belching out, confounding others with proud hate? Yet look, thou inwardly wilt find, That fetters strong these Lords do bind: by Lusts their hearts are poisoned, So lie tormented by Excess. Then Anger does their minds possess: so a vexatious life they lead. One while they're wearied out with Grief, Then Hope does give them no relief. When thou dost see one thus assailed, ne'er wonder he cannot aspire To Good, the top of his desire, by so many fell Tyrants quailed. Thou than dost see they dirty are Who follow Vice, and they are fair Virtue embrace: so that 'tis plain, Good have reward, and Wicked pain. And 'tis but just it should be so: For every thing a man does do Is for reward; as who does run A race, he does expect the Crown. And we have showed that Blessedness Is that same Good for which all press. Then Good does (as reward) attend All humane actions in the end. 'Tis Good gives a good man esteem, 'Tis Good that so entitles him. So men are Vicious called from Vice: But Virtue always has a price. And though the Wicked rage and rail, The wise man's Crown will never fail: Let wicked men fret and repine, Their proper Virtue still will shine; Which dark would be, or rather none, If it were borrowed, not their own. For every man may claim his right, Or it may forced be by might. But 'cause that each man in regard That he is good has a reward, By consequence, if Good he leave, He a reward shall not receive. Lastly, if all Reward be sought Because it good to be is thought, Who him rewarded won't confess, That Good and Virtue does possess? But what reward? no mean one sure, But even the fairest and most pure. Remember that Corollary Which lately I did give to thee. Since Blessedness is the chief Good, And it must needs be understood, Who of this Goodness is possessed Must of necessity be blest; And that for to be blest, must be To be a God, we did agree: Then the reward the good partake (No time can end, no power shake, Nor wickedness can overthrow,) Is to be Gods. Which since 'tis so, Then wicked men can't be without Perpetual pain, there is no doubt. As Good and Ill are contrary, Reward and Pain so disagree. whate'er the good receive as gain, The bad receive as much in pain. Goodness to th' good a reward is, The bad with horror punished is. And he who finds but little ease, Can't doubt but he has some disease. Then if they this would call to mind, Themselves in pain they sure would find, For that they are not only tainted With Ill, but strongly are infected. But see by way of contrary, How wicked men tormented be. For all that is, to be but one, And that one good, to thee is known. Whence follows that whatever is Must needs be good: and so from this, Whatever Goodness does decline Does leave to be: thus then rejoin, The wicked are not what they were. But yet the shape of men they bear. I but by being wicked then The nature quite 've lost of men. For since that only Virtue can Lift Mortals up above what's Man, It of necessity does follow That Vice does cast them far below. So that if thou with Vice do see A man transformed, no man is he. Whoever does with griping wrest Another's goods, he is a Beast, And thou a Wolf may'st well him call. He who perpetually does brawl, And live unquiet, none does spare, Unto a Dog thou may'st compare. Who does by Fraud and Cheating live, The name of Fox thou well may'st give. Who in fierce Anger all does tear, A Lion's mind he sure does bear. Whom vain and idle Fear does strike, To Hare or Hind thou may'st him like. Who has a slow and stupid head, Like to an Ass his life does lead. Who is unconstant, wavering, From Birds he's no way differing. Who is with filthy Lusts besmeared, To th' filthy Sow may be compared. So he that does bright Virtue fly, To be a man does leave you see. Not being with divine right blest, He is transformed into a Beast. While that Ulysses did command his ten-years wand'ring Fleet, The East-wind drove them to the land Whereas they did fair Circe meet, And Sirens with their voices sweet. This Lady had in magic skill, skilled in all herbs that grow. Such liquor she to them did fill, And Siren's them enchanted so, That none could possibly them know. Like unto Swine she some did make, and some like to the Bear. Some did the shape of Lions take: These in their fury nothing spare, But with their teeth and claws do tear. Some Wolves, who when they up did lift their voice to weep, did howl, Some like to Indian Tigers swift, Who though endued with a mild soul, To live were forced for prey to prole. Though witty Hermes pitying the Captain, him did save, And unto him did Moly bring, She all the others did enslave, While they to tipole still did crave. Now beasts, to feed and walk like men they strove, but all in vain; Acorns good food, lodging a Den: For why, there nothing did remain Of voice, or body, like humane. Only their Minds were still the same; which grieved for to discern Their Bodies so exposed to shame. A weak it is and feeble Charm, That Bodies can, and Minds not harm. Man's strength is placed inwardly; if poisons take the Mind, They more deface Humanity: For though to th' Body they seem kind, The Soul they cruelly do grind. I do confess indeed, said I, That ill men without injury May into Beasts be said to swerve, Though humane shape they still conserve. But I'd not have their cruel will Have power to th' good for to do ill. Nor have they, as I▪ le show, said she, In place convenient unto thee. For if that same which seems a power Were ta'en away, 'twould be a cure, And so their punishment would ease. For it though credit some won't please, Yet wicked men are worse far When their desires perfect are, Then if they could not bring to pass Whatever their desire was. If ill to will be a great curse, In him ability is worse: Upon it too we may reflect When ill does come unto effect▪ And who is guilty of these three, Endures a threefold misery. I grant, said I; but would to God That they this misery had not, Or that they quickly might it lose▪ Sooner perhaps then you would choose, (Said she) or they do think 'twill be. And yet compare Eternity, Nothing in this life can be long. And if ost-times design of wrong Be frustrate by untimely end, This to their pain some ease does lend. For if that Wickedness do reign, The longer wicked, more the pain. Then he more wretched sure would be, If Death from ill did not him free. For if that we do right profess O'th' misery of Wickedness, As 'tis eternal, so 'tis right That it is also infinite. This thy illation, than said I, By me can hardly granted be: And yet I think it is no more Than has been granted heretofore. Thou rightly thinkest, but whosoever To make Conclusion shall forbear, Must show the Premises not true, Or that they do not raise a due Conclusion; or else otherwise What from the Premises arise If he do grant, he has no cause On the Conclusion for to pause. There's one thing more I will conclude, Which will no less seem strange and rude, Yet follows necessarily From what is agreed already. What's that? said I. Why, wicked men, When punished, are more happy, then If they at all not punished were. Nor do I go about to rear Up a position that to all Is known, that wicked manners are By Punishments restrained, and Fear Men to be honest does compel, Beside th' Example does do well. But for another reason I Judge them unhappy do go free, Though of Example there were none, Nor of Correction reason shown. What may that other reason be? Have we not granted this, said she, The bad unhappy, good are blest? Why yes, said I. Then if some rest, From Misery, some good do come, Is he not better than such one To whom no good does come at all, But lives in pain perpetual? Why, yes. But if to's misery More pain and greater added be, Is he not more unhappy yet Then he that does some easement get? Why yes, said I. Then wicked men When they are punished do find then Something that's good; for Punishment Is good, b'ing Justice instrument. And then not punished for to be Is further ill; Impunity To be an ill by 's confessed, 'Cause Right it does and Justice wrest. I can't deny't. The wicked then Are far more miserable, when That pain does them unjustly spare, Then when they justly punished are. For this to Justice does belong, The other is to Justice wrong. None can deny't. Nor none, said she, One good, the other ill to be. All this does follow, than said I, From what before we did agree. But after Death for Souls dost thou No punishment at all allow? Yes marry, and that great, said she; And them twofold I think to be: One sharp and a dire punishment, The other a mild purgament. But these to treat of I not mean: The ground and reason of this theme Was only that it might be seen (What thou didst most unworthy deem) In wicked men no Power to be; And further too, that thou mightst see, That they who ills do perpetrate Do never punishments escape: And also that thou may'st conceive The Power (for which thou didst ask leave Soon for to end) not long to be; If long, 'twere the more unhappy; And most unhappy yet of all, If that it were perpetual. I said before, the wicked than Are far more miserable when That pain does them unjustly spare, Then when they justly punished are. The consequence of which is this, Their punishment most grievous is, When they seem punished not to be. To so great reasons I agree. But if to men they be referr'd, Who'll judge them worthy to be heard? 'Tis true, said she; for their dim eyes To the clear light of truth can't rise. So like they are unto the Owl, Whose sight Night brightens, Day does foul. For while they on their own lusts look, And not into the secret book Of things, they judge impunity Of Ill a Happiness to be. But know this as a firm award, Thou needest no Judge thee to reward If Virtue thou and Good follow; Thou on thyself dost it bestow. Again, if thou thyself apply To Vice, thou needest no enemy: Thyself to judge thou wilt be free, Thou wilt thine own tormentor be. As if by turns thou shouldst uprear Thy sight unto the Heaven's fair, And then again shouldst cast it down Upon the filthy miry Ground, Even the very sense of Sight Would now show dark, and then show light. I, but the vulgar thus don't see. I prithee what is that to me? Must we be ruled, or with them join, Who to be Beasts we do define? What if a man that lost his sight, Forget should that he ere saw light, And should believe that he has all Perfection that is natural? If I should unto this agree, I surely were as blind as he. But when will this be credited By those who done't believe what's said, That they are much more unhappy, That do, then suffer injury? The reason I would know, said I. Thou canst not sure, said she, deny, That who with a wicked intent Does ill, does merit punishment. And it does many ways appear The wicked miserable are. All this is true. Then it is plain, They are unhappy, deserve pain. So 'tis, said I If then, said she, The case referred were unto thee, Which wouldst thou punish, him that did The wrong, or him that suffered it? No question I would certainly Him punish did the injury. Then more accursed he seems to thee Who did, then took the injury. It follows so. From this therefore, And from like reasons many more, 'Tis plain that who does injury Upon himself brings misery. What need then Orators make moan, Judges to move to compassion O●… them that in afflictions are, And the wrongdoer not to spare, Whereas in truth they pity aught All those that have injustice sought? Who should a mild, not angry way Accused be, that so they may By counsel, as to patients foul, Cut off a part to save the whole. Who this considers would not use Defence, but rather would accuse Himself; and he who wicked is, If he of Virtue and of Bliss Can but a little glimmering see, And know he might delivered be From Vice's filth by punishment, Would surly be well content To suffer pain, and would refuse At all an Advocate to use; But would to his Accuser's hate And Judge's doom himself prostrate. By which he wholly would abate, In wise men, all inveterate hate. For none but Fools the Good decry; And they're more fools the Bad envy. As by disease the Body's pined, So Vice does macerate the Mind. And if that Sickness stir up love, Much more should they compassion move Where Wickedness the Mind does seize, For this is much the worse disease. Whence is't with so much eagerness ye do Pursue your fate? would you death woo? He is at hand: if Lion, Tiger, Bear, Serpent, nor Boar won't do't, yourselves you'll tear Whence does this cruelty proceed, Thus one another to make bleed? If 'cause Opinions differ you blood spill, This cause no reason has but depraved Will. Then learn to love the good, pity the ill. Here I do plainly see, said I, What is or the felicity, Or misery that does attend The good, or wicked does offend. But yet I am not satisfied, But that there's good and bad beside. For what wise man would banished be, Live poor and ignominiously, Rather than rich and honoured? This 'tis makes Wisdom credited, Whenas the governor's renown To th' people is transmitted down. Besides that Prisons, Whips and Racks, By Law provided for the backs Of wicked Citizens, do I Admire much they changed should be, And Punishments should good destroy, While as the ill rewards enjoy. I pray render me a reason Of this unjust confusion. For I myself should wonder less, If I thought Chance all things did press. But now I much astonished am, When I consider that they come From God, that he does distribute Oft-times what's pleasant to the good, What's sharp to th' bad, again that he The good keeps short, to th' bad is free. Unless I may the cause discern, Why all's not Chance I ne'er shall learn. No marvel, said she, if any thing, The cause not known, confusion bring. But though the cause thou dost not know Why that things are disposed so; Yet since the World must God obey, ne'er doubt but he does rightly sway. Who does not know Arcturus course, What him about the Pole does force, How slow Boötes guides his horse, Why he so late to bed does go, I'th' morn himself so soon does show, Must needs the rest o'th' Heavens not know. What is't that when the Moon's i'th' full Her glorious light from her does pull, Whose splendour all the Stars did dull? The reason being hid to some, Made them with Kettle and with Drum And Cries unto her aid to come. None wonders that strong Winds do raise The waves, nor that the Snow not stays When looked upon by Phoebus' rays. These things seem easy to be known: Those things the mind do vex alone Which seldom unto it are shown. Things sudden do the vulgar move: But if blind Error we remove, They no way wonderful will prove. 'Tis so, said I: but since that thou The hidden cause of things canst show, I thee desire to bring to light The reasons so wrapped up in night. Above all others pray thee tell (Me for to ease) this miracle. Then she a little smiling said, Thou hast a suit unto me made Which to perform a matter is So difficult, best skill may miss. The matter it is so abstruse, One doubt resolved, thousands produce: Like Hydra's heads they do increase; Nor will they come to any peace, Unless they purely be calcined, With a quick fire of the Mind. For in this we must explicate Mild Providence, and rugged Fate, Unlooked-for Chance, divine Cognition, , and dark Predestination. The weight of these thou well may'st guests. But thee to cure since I profess, Though time be short, I'll use it so That thou in part shalt them all know And if my verse delights thy ear, Thou must the same awhile forbear, Till I do utter orderly Some reasons. As you please, said I. Then she, as if she new began, Her speech to me this wise did frame. The generation of all things, All Nature's changing proceed, All whatsoever things do move, The Cause, Form, Order from above. The high Mind set composedly I'th' tower of true Simplicity, Thence issues out a firm decree How every thing shall governed be. Which for that purely 'tis divine, We do it Providence define. But if to th' things we it refer, Which by this Mind disposed are, We call it Fate. That this is clear▪ By both their natures will appear. For Providence that Reason is Divine, which constituted is In God himself, who all does guide: But Fate in low things does abide. By Providence Fate orderly Disposes all things variably. Providence does all things unite, Though divers, or though infinite. Fate singly does them cause to move, As Time or Form or Place approve▪ So temporal things for to know right United into God's foresight, Is Providence; and the same union By time digested and made known, Is Fate: distinct, they have one End; For one on th' other does depend. Order of Fate is guided by Providence's simplicity. For as a good Artificer, (Does a form in's mind decipher,) In time and order brings to pass What but before in his mind was: So God does by his Providence Dispose all things i'th' future tense; And what things he does so dispose, Fate does in order them disclose. Then whether Fate's web woven be By Spirits which immediately Serve Providence, or by the Soul, Or Nature which does serve the whole, Or by the motions of the Spheres, Or Angels, or the Devil's cares, Or some, or all of these, yet hence Full clear it is that Providence Is an unmoved and simple form Of such things as are yet unborn, But Fate's an engine movable, The which does orderly fulfil What the divine Simplicity In time does order for to be. Whence all things that do Fate obey To Providence allegiance pay. And Fate must unto it submit; For under Providence are set Some things which Fate itself surmount. Among the which we well may count Such as are sixth unmovably Nigh the all-ruling Deity. For as when many circles spin About one centre, that within To th' centre's stableness comes nigh, And is as 'twere the hinge whereby All those that placed are without Do make their motions round about; But that which outermost does turn, A great circumference does run, The more it from the centre goes, The larger spaces from it grows; But what to th' centre is fast knit, Does stableness enjoy with it: So all those that are placed far From the first Mind, perplexed are With more and greater snares of Fate; And he enjoys a freer state Who out at distance does not lie, But to the centre does draw nigh. And if unto the high Mind he Can fixed be by stability, Above all second things he's born, And Fate's necessity may scorn. Wherefore as we Discourse do find To be the product of the Mind; And what begotten is, we see Is still the fruit of the same tree; Eternity produces Time, And Circles from the Centre climb: So moving Fate has a firm ty To Providence's certainty; Which does alone the Heavens move, Which joins the Elements in love, Which makes all growing things proceed From the corruption of the Seed, Which does men's acts and fortunes chain In links that firm and sure remain. Then since they claim their principle From Providence , It must be of necessity, They have immutability. And then all things best governed are, When the divine Mind takes the care, And with his own Unmovedness Represses their Confusedness. Hence 'tis that though this Order seem To you to be of small esteem, For that all things confused appear; Yet God hereby does take such care, That he disposes all to good. This 've already understood: For ill, as ill, there's none takes care, No not those that most wicked are; But they with wicked error do Seek good which way so ere they go. But if chief Good the centre be Of this same Order, certainly, It no man can turn out o'th' way. I but Confusion 'tis, you'll say, Good men to have Prosperity, And then again Adversity; And Wicked men for to enjoy Their will, and then again annoy. But are there any men that live So wise, that they can sentence give Who wicked are, and who upright? Or must they be so 'cause they say't? How comes it then to pass there lies In judgements such incertainties, So that whom one thinks worthy gain, Another censures unto pain? But let us grant that some man can Discern the good from the bad man. Can he also the temper see O'th' Soul? with it these may agree. Who ignorantly then does say He wonders, as well wonder may Why to one's body that is sound Sweet things are only proper found; T'another's thats as sound as he, Sharp things and bitter do agree. Some sick men are with Lenitives, And some are cured with Corrosives. But the Physician that does know Each temper, and can reason show Of this man's health, that man's disease, No admiration does himself. Now of the Soul is Verity The index of Salubrity, And Vice the Sickness of the same. Then who, than God, a fit can Physician be, who knows so well Good to conserve, bad to expel? Who does from his high Throne of Bliss See what for each man fitting is; And what is fit he does assign Him, by his Providence divine? This all the wonder is of Fate; When he that knows the best estate, Most knowingly for it does care, The ignorant astonished are. But now in brief I will explain What humane Reason can attain Of secrets purely divine. Whose Virtue thou thinkest most to shine, Who most serves Truth and Equity, The eye of Providence does see Quite otherwise: hence Lucan does Ingeniously admonish us, The Victor's cause the Gods did please, The Vanquished, Cato. If in these Then transitory things thou see What thou thinkest evil done to be; Believe 'tis dimness of thy sight, But divine order is still right. But if there any be so just That God and man approve him must; Yet possibly his Mind's so weak, His Innocence he will forsake, If him in Bliss it won't maintain, But rather is the cause of pain. This man the alwise God does spare, Foreseeing that he cannot bear Adversity, so growing worse It would be unto him a curse. Another man so virtuous is, So like to God in Holiness, Him Providence does not think fit In any case for to afflict, So that so much as Sickness she Should him assail, will not agree. For as one who me far excels From sacred knowledge freely tells, The Carcases of Holy men Of Virtue are composed. And then As it does often happen that Virtue does good men elevate, It is to keep the wicked low, Which otherwise would all o'erflow. Again she mixes one with tother, As she does see minds them can bear. Some she does prune, some she does mow, Lest they too rank should overgrow With long Prosperity, some she With hardships suffers vexed to be, That so the Virtues of the Mind By Patience may assurance find. What's easy to be born, some fear, Others do ssight what they can't bear. These she afflicts with Misery, That they their strength of mind may try Some for the glory of a Name, Do catch at Death, to purchase Fame. Others, by strange enduring pain, By their example have made plain That Virtue cannot conquered be By all this worldly misery. Which things since right and orderly They are disposed, no doubt can be But that they do the good procure Of them that do the same endure. Now that the wicked do enjoy Sometimes their will, and then annoy, From the same causes doth arise. That they are punished, none that's wise Can wonder, or condemn; for why, It does both others terrify, And does mend them: besides the joy The wicked have aloud does cry To th' good, that they should learn thereby How vain a thing's Prosperity. I also more consider this; Perhaps one's nature so fierce is, That Poverty would make him worse: Then him to free from this fame curse, Kind Providence for remedy Stores him with Money plenteously. Another who does Vice affect, Upon his fortunes does reflect. And fears the loss would more displease, Then now the spending does him please; Does change his life, and while he fears To lose his state, his Vice forbears. One lately raised to Happiness, With Pride does on destruction press. To others there is Power lent For to inflict dire punishment, The good thereby to exercise, The wicked thereby to chastise. For as no correspondence can Be between a good and wicked man; So do the wicked still deny Among themselves for to comply. And how can it be otherwise, Since they being guilty of Vice, Within themselves perplexed are, And being mad, they none do spare? From whence by Providence is oft This miracle seen to be wrought, That ill men, ill men good do make; For that from them they damage take: So hating of their wickedness, They fly to Virtue for redress, Detesting for to be like them Whom they do hate above all men. For only strength that is divine Can out of evil good refine. Which it does do in this respect, By giving it a good effect. For Order does all things entwine; And what from Order does decline, Does so but seem, keeps the right way: For where that Providence does sway, There sure can no Confusion be. But it cannot be showed by me, How God, who does to all preside, Does by his Providence them guide. Let it suffice that we do see That God, who did Nature decree, By mortals must be understood For to dispose all things to good. For that all things he does produce He to his likeness does reduce: And does all Evil banish by Course of fatal necessity From out his kingdom: so that we Considering the Deity, Must know on earth ill can't abound, Since no place for it can be found. But I do see you weary are, This weighty burden for to bear; Though't reason be, prolixity Must needs be tedious unto thee: Therefore I thee to recreate Some verses sweet will modulate. Take them as a refection, Thy journey better thou'lt go on. If thou the Laws of the most High Wilt with a knowing mind descry, Behold the motions are above, How they do keep both peace and love. Though Phoebus be hot, Yet he doth not his Sister Phoebe's cold restrain: But they mutually Do friendly comply, to warm and cool the Earth again. Nor does the Pole, on which the world Is turned, desire to be hurled Into the Sea, although he see All other Stars there drenched ●o be. The Evening-star Does always prepare the coming of the shady Night: The Morn-star does bring The joyful tiding of every Day's approaching light. So that they do perpetually In Love agree and Unity: This Love does banish from the Stars All discord, strife, and civil wars. By this Unity Th' Elements agree, so that the moist yields to the dry, The cold joins in love With Fire that's above, and weighty Earth below does lie. This Love and this blessed Unity Causes the Spring so gay to be, Causes the Summer ripe the Corn, And Autumn to blow Plenty's horn, That well drive away Cold Winter we may: gives us all things that life sustain; And when that we die, Brings us presently to our beginning back again. While their Creator set on high Does govern them full orderly; As King and Lord he all does sway, So from their order they can't stray. Yet he by his will Can make that stand still whose order is to flow amain; And that make to stray Whose order to stay, for none his power can restrain. But did not he the creatures bound, And them compel into a round, They soon exorbitant would grow, And would all order overthrow. 'Tis Love mutual To good drives them all, and makes them that they do remain. ‛ Tis. Love is the thing That all things does bring to their beginning back again. Dost thou the consequence now see Of all I have declared to thee? What's that? said I. Even all, said she, Fortune, what ever, good to be. And how, said I, can that same be? Attend, and thou shalt see, said she. Since that all Fortune, mild or hard, Conferred is or for Reward, Or trial of the good; or for The Punishment o'th' wicked, or For their correction; it is plain 'Tis good, 'cause just, or for 'tis gain. Thou truly dost the question state; And if I Providence and Fate (As thou to me hast lately taught) Consider, it is firmly wrought. But I do think it may be placed Among those things that time do waste; For thou didst lately tell to me, Some things believed may not be. Let this be one. For why? said she. Because that men do commonly Assever they ill Fortune have. And if that thou the same do crave, The vulgar speech I'll not refuse, But all humanity will use. Do as you please, said I. Then she; Dost thou not think that good to be That profitable is? I do, Said I. Thou canst not then but know That all whatever does correct, Or trial make, 's good in th'effect. 'Tis true, said I. It must be good, Or else thou hadst not understood This their condition for to be Who, virtuous, with adversity A war do wage, nor those that do, From Vice reclaimed, Virtue pursue. 'Tis plain, said I, unto me now. But prithee further, what thinkest thou Of what the good have as reward? Does the rude vulgar think that hard? Why not, said I; but good, as ' 'tis. But what do they think then of this, What bitter is, and does restrain By punishment the wicked man? Do they think this same good to be? No, but the worst of misery. Then see, said she, how following The Vulgar's foolish bellowing, That same thing now is visible, That you would have incredible. As how? said I. The consequence Of this is plain to every sense, That they who Virtue do possess, Or towards her are in progress, Their Fortune is concluded good; But by the Vulgar's understood, That they who wicked do remain Bad Fortune have, if they have pain. It follows so. But who is wise, Said she, does think Adversities To be a trial, does make head, And no more does the issue dread, Then does the valiant Chieftain do When to the battle trumpets blow. The difficulty is the thing Which unto both does honour bring: One seeks in Glory for to rise, The other is esteemed Wise. And Virtue does its name derive From Vis, 'cause it does strongly strive. And you who in the progress are Towards Virtue, surely do take care Not to be pampered with delights, Nor to be pined with affrights: But 'gainst both Fortunes you put on A conquering resolution. Lest you Delights should overflow, Or Sorrows should you overthrow, You strongly do a Mean endeavour. For it is sure that whosoever Or short does stay, or further go, May have Felicity in show, But never shall reward obtain, For all his labour and his pain. But if you will uprightly live, You to yourselves your Fortune give. For whatsoever Fortune ill Does seem, it is good Fortune still: For it the good does exercise; Or else correct, or punish vice. What greater pleasure on the earth is found, Then with strong Difficulties for to cope, And then with victory for to be crowned? Of this stout Agamemnon had great hope, When before Troy he ten whole years did lie; Filled with disdain, he thought the time not long, And ended it with glorious victory, By fire expiating his Brother's wrong. Which rather then he would not bring to pass, He sacrificed his only Daughter dear, Who to the Gods o'th' Wind a victim was, That Neptune safe the Grecian Fleet might bear. Ulysses his Companions did bewail, Whom cruel Cyclops in his den did eat; But he with blindness did the Cyclops quail, Then joy did mitigate his sadness great. Great Hercules renowned is for toil: He did the proud ambitious Centauris tame, And from the raging Lion took the spoil, And men-devouring Birds he made his game. He from the watchful Dragon did fetch out The Golden Apples, and did Horses feed With Kingly flesh; the Hell-dog led about, And from the monster Hydra the world freed. He made swift Achelous back to go, And quelled Antaeus on the Libyan sand: He did the fiery Cacus overthrow, Nor could the huge-tusked Boar his force withstand. With his stiff neck and brawny shoulders he The heavens upheld. For these he gained at last Up to the Gods translated for to be, So who the heavens upheld, the heavens hold fast. These high examples let brave minds regard. Who toils in Virtue, has a sure reward. THE FIFTH BOOK. WHen this was said, she did begin Quite other matters to wove in. Then I, her interrupting, said, Thy exhortation is well laid, And aught observed for to be Coming from thy authority. But since that I do find it true Now by experience, that which you Of Providence to me did tell, That many questions thence would swell, From thee I do desire to know Whether that Chance or be, or no, And what it is. I will, said she, Make good my promise unto thee; And unto thee the way will show, How thou in safety home may'st go. The things I was about to say, Although that they much profit may, Yet they from our set purpose were; But I did offer them, for fear Lest with these heavy burdens pressed, Thou shouldest tyre for want of rest. Of that, said I, no fear can be, They rather ease do bring to me. Besides, if thy discourse appear With Truths on all sides to be clear, Of all which does thereof arise There's no man sure will doubt that's wise, Thy way, said she, I'll follow then; And in this manner she began. If that without a Cause be lent Unto rash motion an Event, If any one this Chance do call, I do aver there's none at all: And a vain voice it is alone, Without signification. For where can Chance have any room Where God to order all does doom? That Nothing does from nothing rise, Is truth confirmed by th' ancient wise, Even by those could nothing tell Of the effecting principle; But all their knowledge only was Material subject, nature, cause. But if that any thing doth spring From no Cause, it does from Nothing Seem to come: but if this can't be, Then neither can there possibly Be that same Chance lately defined. And what, said I, can we then find In the whole world nothing at all That Fortune we or Chance may call? Or is there something (lies unknown To th' Vulgar) by these terms is shown? In Aristotle's Physics thou Truly mayest the reason know. As how? said I. When any thing, Says he, by accident does bring To light some other thing than was Intended by the moving cause, This is called Chance: as if a man For tillage does plough up a lawn, And does a hidden treasure find, 'Tis presently to Chance assigned; But wrongly, since it does not pass From nothing, for it causes has; The which, 'cause they were not foreseen, A Chance does make it for to seem. For if the Husband man had not The ground broke up, nor the other put The treasure there, it had not been found. Now thou dost see the cause and ground; It does from several causes come, Not from the Agent's intention. For neither he that hide the gold, Nor he that did the plough-staff hold, Intended it should come to pass; But, as I said, it only was Concurring causes that did bid The one dig up what th' other hid. Then Chance by us may be defined, Event from Causes that are joined. Now Causes do concur and grow From a Connexion which does flow From that inevitable Read Which does from Providence proceed, Which does all things (seen in the close) In time and place rightly dispose. Among the rocks whereas those people dwell Who do with mocks their enemies all quell, Whilst flying they Do with their deadly darts Their followers slay, them piercing to the hearts, There Tigris does, there does Euphrates rise; This one way goes, that th' other swiftly flies. Should they unite and both together run, With all the might of Floods that to them come, There's nothing could their raging force withstand, Destroy they would all the whole neighbouring land. Trees they would tear from out the firmest ground; They nought would spare, but all things would confound; If not consigned their channels for to keep, By that high Mind that law gives to the Deep. It is just so with Fortune's raging spite; Who all does know, does force her to do right. I do it understand, said I, And with thy judgement do comply. But with thy Causes dost thou To man at all allow? Or does this fatal Chain up tie men's minds, that they move not freely? No, there's no nature reasonable, But is endued with . What things soever Reason do By nature use, use Judgement too, By which they with a lively sense Easily discern the difference 'Twixt what is good and what is bad; What's to be left, what's to be had. Then who of Reason has the skill, He freedom has to will, or nill. But I'll not say that unto all This Freedom is alike equal: For that the substances Divine Have Judgements that are clear and fine, Wills uncorrupted, and what they Do will, they by their Power may. But it is of necessity That humane minds most free should be, When they in speculation are Of the High God: less when they care For th' body take▪ least when that they Let earthly vanities them sway. But yet their greatest bondage is, When they do sell themselves to Vice: Reason's possession than they quit; And putting from their eyes the light Of Truth, they into darkness fall, And lewd affections worst of all; To which consenting, they do bring Upon themselves a languishing, And they by this their being free Throw themselves into slavery. Yet still high Providence does see All things from all eternity, And to the merits of each state Does give, as they're predestinate. All things does he Both hear and see. Homer did sweetly sing bright Phoebus' praise: Yet he cannot look in the Earth's dark ways; Nor can he pierce with's eye the Ocean clear. To him that made the Sky all things appear; No Earth does stand between his knowing sight, Nothing by him's unseen i' th' darkest night. With one thought of his mind he clear does see Whatever was designed or ere shall be. Then he that does behold the total sum, He truly may be called the brightest Sun. I now, said I, confounded am Far more than when that you began. How can that be? said she: yet I Conjecture where your doubts do lie. These things, said I, too much oppose To be believed, That God foreknows All things that are, or ere shall be, And to believe the Will is free. For if that God does all things see, And by no means deceived can be, It is a necessary case, What he foresees must come to pass. Wherefore if from eternity Not only deeds, but counsels he And darkest thoughts of men foreknew, Then a cannot be true. For there no Act can be alone, But Will also there can be none, Hid from the divine Providence, In his unerring prescience. For if that things another way Then was foreseen quite alter may, Foreknowledge certainly there's none, But rather an Opinion. Which to believe of God above Is impious. Nor do I approve The reason, which some men resolve This knotty question does dissolve. They say that nothing comes to pass ‛ Cause it foreseen or foreknown was; But contrary, for that 'twould be, High Providence did it foresee. If so, the same necessity As well is for the contrary. For 'tis not necessary that What is foreseen must therefore hap; But this does necessary seem, Whatever does hap, it was foreseen. As if we laboured for to know Which of these two the cause should show; Whether Foreknowledge rises from Necessity of things to come, Or the Necessity does grow From the Foreknowledge. But I'll show That howsoe'er things ordered be, Th' event of things is necessary, Though Providence don't seem it infer Necessity. For if that there One sit, and I him sitting view, That he does sit I do think true: Again, if that my thought be true, That he does sit must be true too. In both then there's necessity, To sit, and also true to be. But therefore sure he does not sit, Because that I so think of it: But therefore I so think of it, Because 'tis true that he does sit. So though the cause of truth proceed But from one part, yet there is need Of relative community, Or we this point shall ne'er agree. We must make the like inference Of Future things, and Providence; Who 'cause things must be, does foresee, But her foresight don't make them be. So necessary it does seem That things to come should be foreseen, Or else what things God does foresee Should fall out necessarily. So take't which way soe'er you will, It must needs overthrow . Besides, is't not preposterous, That worldly things should be the cause Of God's eternal Prescience? And pray what other is't in sense, To say, because that things must be, That therefore God does them foresee, Then for to say, what's come to pass, Of Providence the great cause was? Besides, if I do know a thing, I know also it has being: And if that I know aught shall be, I know it necessarily. Whence follows that no man can shun What in Foreknowledge must be done. Lastly, if any one conceive A thing to be, that may deceive, That is no Knowledge certainly, But Opinion's uncertainty, Which from the truth of Knowledge is Far discrepant. Then truth it is, That if a thing be for to be, But yet not of necessity, It cannot possibly be shown, That the same thing could be foreknown: For Knowledge is a thing so pure, It not false mixture will endure; So that if aught conceived be By it, it is of certainty. For this cause Knowledge cannot lie, Because that of necessity Whatever it does apprehend Must be the same unto the end. How then? by what means can God know That things uncertain will be so? For if he thinks that things will be Inev'tably, that may not be, He is deceived: which for to speak Or think of God is wicked, weak. Again, if so that he foresee Things as they are, such for to be, Or not to be, to come to pass, Or not to come, what skill, alas, Is this, which does not comprehend What stable is or sure i'th' end? It as ridiculous must be As was Tiresias Prophecy; What▪ I say, or sure must be, Or sure it is it must not be. In what does Divine Providence Excel the skill of humane sense, If that, as men, uncertain he Does judge th' event of things to be? But if that nought uncertain can Be unto him that is certain, Then the event must certain be Of whatsoever he does foresee. Which thing all Liberty expels From humane actions and counsels; If all these without falsity The Heavenly Mind does surely see, And them does bind and does constrain Unto events that are certain. This granted, what confusion Must all humane affairs put on? In vain Rewards propounded are To th' good, Pains to the ill, if there Be no free motion of the mind, But Necessity does it bind. And that will high Injustice seem Which we most just do now esteem, The wicked for to punish, or The good reward; since neither's for Their own delict or probity Received, but of necessity. Virtue or Vice there will be none, But of all things confusion. And then, (than which there nothing can Be more blasphemous thought by man) If Providence do all things guide, And humane Will to it be tied, It follows that our Vices must Be laid on him that is most just. Nor will there any reason sway Why either we should hope, or pray. For what does hope or prayer avail, If the determined end can't sail? No conversation there will be 'Twixt Mortals and the Deity. For if no hope at all remain, To pray will be esteemed but vain. But if by just Humility We have access to th' Deity, And by it do of grace partake, Which is the only means can make Us happy, and by which men can With God have Conversation, By which they to that light are joined Inaccessible by mankind, And do there by all good obtain; If that, I say, prayer be made vain By holding of Necessity, Then by what other means shall we Stick fast unto, and be made one With the great Prince of Union? All men it must to ruin bring, If (as thou didst but lately sing) They from their fountain severed are, And in the Deity don't share. How does Erinnys break the league of things? What spirit is't that such contention slings Between two truths, such mighty warfare brings? How is't that singly things do clearly stand, But joined so dark are, none them understand? Or is't, that all truths do go hand in hand? No but the Soul, that here is but a guest, With cloudy members of dull flesh oppressed, Cannot attain to know what things are best. Why should she then with zeal burn like to fire? Why hidden ways of Truth should she desire, Whenas she here can nought but doubts acquire? If she the things that she desires does know, Why then with scruples does she vex them so? Why does she toil so much them to re-know? If she knows not, why does she, being blind, Seek them to know? who ever wished to find He knew not what, or sought to catch the wind? What if she find them? yet they being found, How shall she know their natures for to bond, When she herself in ignorance is drowned? Or for that she first came from God above, Must all things which here and above do move No Causes have, but what she does approve? She now with cloudy flesh is mantled o'er; And though some things of what she knew before She does retain, her knowledge is but poor. Yet who seeks Truth, he does not do amiss; Though he can't come to know't, yet he gains this, That he not wholly thereof ignorant is. Some things he does to memory commit; High thing●●e does admire, and high wit He scans with reason, and retains what's fit▪ This, said she, is an old complaint, Canvased and scrutined by that acquaint Distributer of Divination, Cicero; and thyself art one That much has toiled in't: but as yet There's none of you has had the wit Sufficiently to find it out. The reason of it is, no doubt, 'Cause blindness of Humanity Can't see Divine Simplicity, Nor comprehend the notions great Of heavenly things in her conceit: To which if that she could attain, There would not doubt at all remain. But I the same with my best skill Open to lay endeavour will. But first I must those doubts remove Are by thee moved, and do thee move. And first I do demand of thee, Why thou not reason it to be Dost think, that nothing comes to pass 'Cause it Foreseen or Foreknown was. It only seeks for to maintain Prescience, don't restrain; Nor it at all the cause to be Of the Event's necessity. Dost thou bring any arguments For the necessity of Events, But 'cause that God does them Foresee They must be of Necessity? But if Foreknowledge does not bring Necessity upon the thing, As thou thyself didst late express, When thou the same thing didst confess, How is't, of things voluntary That the Event must certain be? I will thee an example show, Thereby the consequence to know. Suppose there were no Prescience, Couldst thou, dost think, affirm in sense, That what proceedeth from the Will, Necessity does it compel? Why, no. Let's then again suppose Prescience, and that it does impose On nothing a Necessity. The Freedom of the Will will be As absolute the same alone, As if Prescience there were none. But thou wilt say, Although there be By Prescience no necessity Of the Event, a sign it is Things so to happen cannot miss. By the same reason, the same thing Had happed had no Prescience been. A Sign does always something show, But does not cause it to be so. Wherefore who this does not allow, Must first demonstratively show, That certainly nothing can be But it is from Necessity, Before that he can make't appear Foreknowledge does this title bear. If there be no Necessity, Then Prescience no Sign can be Of what is not. Besides proofs must Not upon men by Signs be thrust, But by firm Reasons, proofs well wrought, From causes necessary brought. But by what means may things not be; Which for to be God does Foresee? 'Tis true there is no means, but that What God Foresees to be must hap. For though I don't believe at all What God Foresees must not befall, Yet though it must befall, say I, It is not of necessity From its own nature. This to be A truth I'll plainly show to thee. There's many a thing before our eyes, While doing, that this truth descries. As he that drives a Coach or Cart, Does many things to show his art. For should Necessity compel, In vain the Artist should excel. So other things conclude may we Not to be of necessity. Which as 've no necessity Of being, before that they be, So they without necessity Do happen, when they come to be. It follows then some things be free, In th' event, from Necessity. And yet there's none will say what's done, Before 'twas done, was not to come. By this th' event of things is shown For to be free, although Foreknown, For as there's no necessity Of knowing things that present be, ●ut as they're done, or left undone; Just so it is of things to come. But likely 'tis thou dost suppose There no Foreknowledge is of those Things whose events not necessary, Because their natures disagree. For thou may'st think of Prescience Necessity the consequence; And if there's no Necessity, Then no Foreknowledge can there be; For Knowledge nought can comprehend That is not certain in the end. And if th' event uncertain be, And it as certain we foresee, 'Tis plain that Knowledge it is none, But dark and cloudy Opinion. For otherwise a mind to bear Of things, or Causes, than they are, Thou thinkest it much averse to be To Knowledge's integrity. The cause of which thy error's this, Because thou thinkest that what known is, By its own force and nature's known; But the contrary shall be shown. All that is known, is not known by The force that in itself does lie; But the force lies, as I suppose, I' th' faculty of him that knows. That this a perfect truth must be, I'll by example show to thee. Suppose a body round to be, The Eye this body's form does see, The Hand it feels; that it is round We by two ways have found. The Eye it viewing with sight clear, Unto the Mind its form does bear: The Hand, by joining to the thing, And round about it compassing, Does so the roundness of it find, And it conveys unto the Mind. So Sense a Man does one way see, Imagination diversely, Reason a way not like these other, And understanding quite another. By Sense the figure as 'tis placed In the material thing's embraced. Imagination form does see Without Materiality. But Reason yet does higher fly, Considers universally The Species of every kind, In the particulars assigned. But Understanding yet more high Does soar, and fixes its bright eye, While it with knowing beams does pierce Above the frame o' th' Universe, And with pure sight o' th' Mind does see The simple form from all these free. So 'tis, that the superior Comprehends the inferior; But the inferior in no wise To the superior can arise. So that the Sense no Sense can find, If it to th' Matter be not joined; Imagination cannot see Of Kind th' Universality; Neither can Reason comprehend Of simple Forms the utmost end: But Understanding, from an high Once casting down her knowing eye, Does strait the simple forms conceive Of all things that are underneath; But she the Forms discerneth so, As none o' th' rest can them so know. Reason's Univeriality, Sense's Materiality, Imagination's Form, all these She comprehendeth with much ease; Yet Reason does and Sense refuse, Nor does Imagination use, But with one stroke o' th' mind does she See and know all things Formally. The same thing Reason, whenas she Beholds Universality, Imagination does not use, And totally does Sense refuse, Yet things Imaginable and Sensible she does comprehend. For Reason does describe truly Thus her Universality. A Man's a creature animal, That's two-footed, and rational. This is a notion known to all Int self to be universal; Yet it Imagination does And Sense contain, every man knows: Though it no use at all does make In all the notions it does take Of Sense, or Imagination, But Rational conception. Imagination does the same: Though she all Forms and Figures frame I' th' mind, by sense of Touch and Sight, Yet they laid by, she judges right Of things, not by any reason Of Sense, but Imagination. Then dost thou not now plainly see, I' th' knowledge of all things that be, All their own Power and Faculty Do use, not theirs, they are known by? Nor is this any injury; For since all Judgement judged must be The act of him the judgement gave, 'Tis necessary he should have Full power unto him consigned, Not by another be consigned. The ancient Chairs and Schools were filled with old men and obscure, Who into th' minds of men instilled Outward things only, did procure To th' Mind Ideas that were sure. As when we have in readiness a paper that is white, We wont are on it to impress Letters that do resemble night; So we the Minds Ideas write. But if the Mind no motions make that are her proper own, But does from outward things them take, Like Glasses show but what is shown, Whence she sees all things would be known; Whence she all single things beholds, or them divided knows; Whence 'tis that she all things enfolds, What from the highest Heaven flows, And what on the Earth's surface grows: With this same knowledge she with Truth does Falsehood gall. No Knowledge sure can be so great Which does from outward Objects fall, As that which comprehends this all. Yet living creatures Passions have, which do the Mind excite; Each Object does attention crave, Both of the Hearing and the Sight: And this their forms does bring to light. And thus the Mind to outward things her knowledge does apply: Not that the outward Object brings Unto it any novelty, For it kn●w all intrinsicly. And if in Bodies it be so, Their outward forms by Sense to know, The outward Object must reflect Upon the Sense and it affect; And that we do the Passions find Precede the Actions of the Mind, And do provoke the Soul to stir Those inward forms lie hid in her; If that these bodies right to know, The Mind to Passions this does owe, Although she Passions do at length Subdue by her own force and strength; How much more do those things that be From Corporal Affections free, The outward Objects not attend, But to the Mind their powers bend? Wherefore there is of Knowledges Like difference as of Substances. Some creatures motionless, have Sense, But they want all other science; As Shellfish, which to rocks stick fast, And thence do nourishment exhaust. The Beasts and Birds that use motion, Have Sense and Imagination, By which they fit things covet do, And seek all dangers to eschew. Reason does only Man define, And Understanding is divine. So that same Knowledge excels sure Which excels of its own nature, And does not only its own show, But does all others Objects know. If Sense and Imagination Then should rise up against Reason, And this same their contest should be, There's no Universality, As Reason thinks she does behold, And thus their argument should hold; Whatever thing is Sensible, Or that is Imaginable, That Universal cannot be: If Reason's judgement true then be, Then nothing can be Sensible, No nor yet Imaginable; For many things to her are known Subject to Imagination And Sense; then vain is the conceit Of Reason, which does Objects treat That in their natures Single be With her Universality. Thus Reason's answer would be free, That in Universality She does behold what's Sensible, And what is Imaginable, But their weak Knowledge cannot fly Up to Universality, 'Cause they no Knowledge have at all 'Bove Figures and Forms Corporeal. Then certainly we must affirm, That Knowledge for to be most firm, As also to be most perfect, Which knows both Form and the Effect. In this contention, surely we, Endued with Reason's faculty, That have Imagination And Sense also to work upon, Cannot in reason but attest, That Reason's cause is much the best. Just so it is, when Reason does Think that God's Understanding knows Things yet to come no otherwise Then she does think she them descries: For thus thou sayest, If th' event be Not certain and necessary, Then a Foreknowledge of the same Also can no way be certain. Hence, of these things thou dost allege That there can be no Foreknowledge; And if there be, nought certainly Can hap, but of necessity. If as we have of Reason part, God Judgement would divine impart, As we already did conclude All Sense and Thought for to be rude, 'Cause they to Reason would not yield, So Reason must submit the field To th' Understanding Divine Mind. Then granting that our Reason's blind, Let us unto that height aspire, Where Reason, when she has got higher, Will see those things, and plainly too, Which in herself she could not do; Which is, that those things which have no Certain event, God does Foreknow; And that Opinion this is none, But rather highest notion, Bound up in that Simplicity That by nothing can bounded be. On earth what several kinds of creatures are! Poison the Serpent lines. yet he is fair: His skin no soil will take, though he does creep, Yet he does furrows make, and dust does sweep. Birds use their wings to fly upon the wind, And in the air full high a passage find. Beasts going on the ground, their steps appear, By which in Woods oft found, they hunted are. All several formed you see in Nature's book; Yet all in this agree, on Earth they look Man only does erect his stately crown, To th' Earth gives no respect, nor eye throws down. If Earth don't thee inchant, thy Form does teach, For all things thou canst want to Heaven to reach. But if thou Earth do love, and to it trust, Thy Body will above thy Soul be thrust. Then as to thee before was shown, whate'er is known, it is not known By its own nature, but by his By whom it comprehended is. Let's now the Divine substance see With care and with sobriety; That seeing it, we may also Know what it is that he does know. First then, God is confessed by all That Reason have, to b' eternal. The thing that must considered be Is, what is this Eternity. For this will unto us declare What's knowledge and what's nature are▪ Eternitie's full possession Of life, without conclusion. This unto us will plain appear If temporal things we do compare. All things that live do proceed from Times past, go on to time to come; And there's no one that can embrace At one instant all the whole space Of his whole Life, knows not next day, Nor is what he was yesterday. Nor in this very present day Does he of's Life more time enjoy, Then one moment transitory, In which to Move, or Speak, or Die. Then none of time can be more free Than Time can make himself to be. Though that (as Aristotle said O'th' World) it no Beginning had, No End shall have, if Life, I say, With Time endure should for aye, It could not rightly be a thing That might be called Everlasting. For though that Life were infinite, It could not at one time unite All its whole course, being barred from All the whole time that is to come. Then that same which does comprehend All that whole Life which has no end, All that is passed knows certainly, All that's to come does plainly see, That same must the Eternal be. And this is of necessity; For that he in himself alone Has all perfect possession, Makes all things present him assist, And also carries in his fist The all and whole infinity Of Time, that has mobility. But very largely they mistake, Who from Plato's opinion, take This frame to be coeternal With him that framed this same All, Because that Plato this has penned, It nor Beginning had▪ nor End: And they do think to prove by this, The World (as God) Eternal is. For it is one thing for to have Life without end, which Plato gave To th' World, and it is another (As 'tis easy for to gather) At one instant for to embrace The whole and every part o'th' space Of this same Life, the which is plain Only in God for to remain. Nor yet does the Creator seem Then Creatures older to have been By time's stretched measured Quantity, But by's nature's Simplicity▪ The world does strive to imitate God's present motionless estate; And since he cannot equal it, By motion he does vie with it, And stead of God's Simplicity, He, by infinite quantity Of time that's past and time to come, Does with him for the garland run. And since at once he can't embrace The whole and every part o'th' space Of his whole Life, by being still, He seems in part to have his will, Binding himself to each moment, That so he may be permanent; And unto all it question, can This answer truly make, I am. More words to speak he cannot stay, But to make't good he takes his way Of everlasting journeying, His Being so continuing; So going on, all that long space (He can't at once) he does embrace Wherefore if that of Plato we Will followers exactly be, We must high God Eternal call, And th' Universe Perpetual. Since then by nature it is so, That every judgement that does know Which under it is placed, and that God still enjoys a present state, And that his Knowledge does surmount All that can be in Time's account, And that he ever does remain, And in Simplicity does reign, And does the spaces infinite Of past and what's to come unite, And that they all unto him are As if they now at present were; If thus thou wilt God's Prescience Consider with an upright sense, Thou certainly wilt find, that he Does rather all things present see, Then that he does at distance roam At any thing that is to come. And for this cause, not Previdence It called is, but Providence; Because he from his high Aspect Has all the world in his Prospect. But why dost thou require should be Of those things a necessity Which the Divine mind does foreknow, And yet of Men thou dost not so? If thou a thing do present see, Does thy sight make't Necessity? Why no. Than if so be we dare Low things with High for to compare, As thou dost things at present see, So God does with's eternal eye. Nor does this Foreknowledge alter Or the property, or nature; Yet he in present does them see, As they in time to come will be, And with one glance of's mind does know What things must necessary flow, Also what things besides must be That are not of necessity. As when at once you with your eyes See a Man walk, and the Sun rise; Though at one glance you do descry Them both, yet you know certainly, That one is of necessity, The other's but voluntary. So God beholding from above Things that unto their end do move, Does not alter their quality, Or make them of necessity; Yet he does them all Present see, As they in Future are to be. So that Opinion this is none, But rather highest notion 'Stablish'd in truth, when he does see That such a thing shall certain be, And yet withal he it does know Not from necessity to flow. If unto this thou do reply, What God sees of necessity Must come to pass, and me wilt tie Unto this word Necessity; I will confess it is most true, But such a truth as none can view Not well skilled in Divinity. For that may be necessary, If so that it referred be Unto the high Divinity, Which in its proper nature weighed May free and absolute be said. There's a twofold Necessity: One Simple, that All men must die; The other is Conditional, And may, or it may not befall; As if thou see a man to go, That he does go must needs be so. Then it is of necessity; For what thou knowst, that needs must be. But the Condition does not draw Simply with it that needful law; It does not from the Nature grow, But the Condition makes it so. Necessity did not compel Him for to go, or to stand still; But if he go, it then must be That he goes of necessity. Just so, if Providence do see Ought Present, 'tis necessary, Although that in'ts own property There is not a necessity. But God at present does see all That by freewill shall e'er befall. And this, if we do God respect, Is necessary in th' effect, By that condition which alone Is tied to the Divine notion. But if that it considered be In its own Nature, it is free. Without all doubt those things shall be Which Divine Providence does see: And yet of them there are some still Proceed, not forced, but from freewill, Which do not lose their nature, though By being they must needs be so; Because it might have been so, that Their being never might have happed. But what makes matter though they be In no manner necessary, If by that same condition Which is placed in God alone They do so happen for to be As if they were necessary? Just as I said awhile ago, The Sun does rise, a Man does go: Which while they do so, it can't be But their so doing must needs be: But yet before these came to pass, One of them necessary was, The other not. So every thing God present sees, time forth shall bring; But some from th' agent's power shall be, And others from necessity. Then rightly we do hence declare, If things to God referred are, Then they are of necessity; But if that by themselves they be Considered, they are wholly free From the bond of necessity. Just as it is of every thing That only have of Sense being, If you to Reason them refer, Then they all Universal are; If by themselves you them consider, They then all singular appear. But thou wilt say, If so it be That I to change my will am free, frustrate Providence, if so I change from what she did foreknow? I answer, Thou indeed art free In thy own mutability; But whether thou do change or no, Or whatsoever 'tis thou dost do, Providence (that continually Is present) still the truth does see, And thou her Prescience canst not shun, No more than th' eye that sees things done, When freely thou thyself dost change To actions that are new and strange. But than thou'lt say, Shall I suppose That I God's knowledge can dispose? And if I this, now that will do, Will God his Knowledge vary so? No; for God's Foresight does prevent All future things, makes them present. Nor, as thou thinkest, at all does he Now one thing, now another see; But with one present look does see, And know thy mutability. Which things God does not comprehend Because such things shall have such end, But this divine Simplicity Is proper to the Deity. By which also that doubts made clear, Which thou didst lately seem to fear, That it is an unworthy thing That we should God's Foreknowledge bring On humane actions to depend Since that its force does comprehend At present all that is future, And to each thing appoints measure; But he receives nothing at all From whatsoever happen shall. Since than that all these things are plain, to mortals does remain; Nor are those Laws unjust which do Propound Rewards and Pains unto All the free actions of the mind, Nor to necessity them bind. Th' all-knowing God too still is free, Who from above does all things see; And the present eternity Of this his sight does still agree With all the qualities that shall In all our future actions fall, Giving Rewards and Punishments To good and unto bad intents. Nor are your hopes or prayers in vain; If unto God you do not feign: If they be faithful and cordial, They'll not be ineffectual. Forsake then Vice, and Virtue prize, And let your hopes to th' height arise, Your humble prayers to God direct, They will produce a blessed effect, If from dissimulation free. And is't not of necessity That you in all things should do well, Since in your Judge's eye you dwell? THE END.