An ANSWER to a Seditious Libel, called, A Declaration from the people of GOD, called QUAKERS, &c. Wherein is discovered, that their Meetings are Seditious Conventicles, and that they are not clear from Dangerous practices against Church and Realm.  
Quakers Declaration. That the Quakers Meetings are not Seditious Conventicles, and therefore ought not to be suppressed.  
TO answer this, we shall consider what the Act intends by a Seditious Conventicle; Where persons above the age of sixteen, shall be present at any Assombly, Meeting, or Conventicle, under colour or pretence of any exercise of Religion, in other manner than according to the Liturgy and practise of the Church of England; at which Meeting there shall be five or more assembled, besides those of the same household, shall incur the penalty, &c. Now that the Quakers do not exercise any part of Divine Worship, according to the Liturgy and practise of the Church of England, is easily proved from their own confession, in a seditious Pamphlet published by them about the year 1664. entitled, The Reasons why the people of God called Quakers, cannot join with the Church of England in any part of their worship: in which Pamphlet they do most blasphemously deride and mock at our worship, and Liturgy of the Church, making use of the several Sentences in our daily Confession, for reasons of their Schism and Separation from our Church.  
Q. D. Neither have been or are our practices dangerous, &c.  
Ans. That your practices have been and are dangerous, I shall easily prove: That they have been dangerous, Germany hath well experienced, by the rebellion of David George, the first of your Sect, whose Followers had they not been timely suppressed, had set the whole Empire in flames; such another was John of Leiden, and Cobs Faction in England, which had not the least share in our late Rebellion. And if you should pled that you are not guilty of the Fact, yet there is Sedition and Rebellion implied in the Doctrine you teach at your Conventicles; you preach against dignities and Titles of Honor, calling them Antichristian, contrary to Scripture commands; your preaching down dignities, implies that you would pull them down too, if it were in your power, as your Brethren before mentioned attempted; for it cannot be supposed that such persons, who believe all persons to be equal, and will allow of no reverence or worship to any man, but that they will upon any advantage make use of their power to pull down whatsoever contradicts their belief or practise.  
Q. D. So the things that belong to Caesar, we give to Caesar.  
Ans. 1. To the King belongs obedience, honor and Tribute; if you give to Caesar what belongs to him, you must render him obedience, you must obey his Laws, and those either actively or passively, but you are content with neither; else what means this Pamphlet of yours; but if you say you obey him passively, passive obedience is not always lawful; if you pled your Consciences will not let you obey them actively, but you are willing to obey them passively; you must have a care of a great error, for passive obedience is onely required, when things contrary to the Word of God are commanded; it is not necessary that all things commanded by authority, must have a command or president in Scripture; for many things are left indifferent to the discretion of Gods Vicegerents, as Kings, and other subordinate Officers; a power is likewise in the Governors of the Church, to impose such things as they shall find necessary to be observed in the public worship of God; and this we may infer from those words of the Apostle, The rest will I set in order when I come: So that whatsoever is commanded by authority if it be not contrary to the word of God, must be obeied actively, and not passively; for what advantage will it be for you another day, when you shall excuse your non-obedience by saying, you suffered; certainly you can expect no other Answer than, Who hath required these things at your hands? if you suffer for your faults, what thanks have you?  
2. To the King belongs Honor; Honor the King( saith holy Scripture,) but this you preach against; the best language he can get from you, is thou and thee, as if he were your fellow. This error of yours proceeds from a mistake of Christs words to his Apostles. Call no man Master, for one is your Master, Jesus Christ. Christ never intended by this doctrine, that his Apostles should give no man his due Title and Honor, but puts them in mind of their duty to him, who had called them from other Masters and from other employments, that they might be diligent in his Service. Call no man master, i.e. Serve none else but him who hath called you from a worldly to a spiritual employment. The next thing that belongs to Caesar, is Tribute; we shall not deny but that you pay Taxes, because you are compelled; but if you do it willingly, your obedience in this, will not excuse your disobedience in all things else: So that all that belongs to Caesar, you do not give to Caesar.  
Q. D. That which belongs to God, we give to God.  
Ans. Here you likewise fail: What hath been once dedicated to God, and hath been set apart for the maintenance of his Service and Worship, doth belong to God, and therefore must be given to him: Now, to whom God hath assigned this payment, to them it must be paid; but to his Ministers God hath assigned this payment, and hath allowed by his Word, That they that wait at the Altar, should live of the Altar; and they which preach the Gospel, should live of the Gospel: So that whosoever refuses to pay tithes and other maintenance given to the Ministers of the Church of England, for their performance of the Service of the Church, and established by the Laws of the land; doth not give to God the things that belong to God.  
Q. D. His Worship in Spirit and Truth which is his due.  
Ans. Here you allege that which is but the lesser part of his due, for his whole due; for what advantage is it for the Lord of Hosts to be worshipped and honoured by us, who are as worms in his sight? Saul thought himself very zealous for Gods worship, when he saved part of the spoil of the Amelekites, that should have been destroyed, to sacrifice it to the Lord; but for this his Kingdom was given from him, and God tells him by his Prophet Samuel, Obedience is better than sacrifice; 'tis Obedience God desires rather than Sacrifice or Worship. God commands you to be obedient to Authority; and no pretence of Worship, can excuse you from this necessary Duty of Obedience: So that while you are not obedient, you neither give God nor Caesar his due.  
Q. D. We do not meet under colour or pretence to plot or contrive Insurrections, &c.  
Ans. We have but your bare word for it; I have proved that your party hath been guilty of Insurrections, and that the Doctrines you teach at your Meetings, are Seditious and Heretical, serving as fire to foment and kindle flames of Rebellion, whensoever the least gale of opportunity or advantage, shall blow off those embers that do at present cover them.  
Q. D. And were not the Magistrates &c. enjoined by their oaths before, to look after the preservation of the peace against all such seditious Meetings, as much as this Act doth require?  
Ans. It is true, the Magistrates were enjoined by their Oaths before to prevent such seditious Meetings, and we have many Laws against such; but the reason why they were not put in execution, hath been the negligence of inferior Officers, who should have informed and convicted Offenders before those Magistrates. Against this negligence, obstructing the execution of the Laws, the King and Parliament have provided by this Act, inflicting penalties upon the several Officers that shall neglect the performance of their duty.  
Q. D. Now if 4 besides the family may meet that are seditious spirits, may not many such seditious Meetings do more hurt, than if there were two or three hundred together? for then they might speak out their minds to one another, which they could not do before hundreds of mixed people.  
Ans. 'tis true, there is danger enough in your small Meetings, but much more in your greater Meetings of hundreds; for by lessening your Meetings we may better secure both Church and State. This will be a means to secure our Church, by hindering many silly and ignorant people, that did use to run into your Meetings, partly to behold your antic tricks in your silent Meetings, or else out of curiosity to hear some new Doctrine, which have at last been seduced by you, being taken with that gilded shell of Religion which you there present them with. We shall also better secure our State, by thus lessening your Meetings; for 10 or 12 can make no great disturbance in a place, a Constable may suppress these: But where 5 or 600, or more, shall meet, and finding an opportunity, make an Insurrection, these may set a whole City on flames, before a strength can be got together to suppress them.  
Q. D. If this Act had been made in the time of the Jews, would it not have taken hold of Christ and his Apostles?  
Ans. No, it would not have taken hold of Christ or his Apostles; For the Liturgy of the Church of England is agreeable to the Word of God, and according to the practise of Christ and his Apostles: Now none are offenders by this Act, but such as meet together, and exercise some Religious Worship, contrary, or not agreeing with the Liturgy of the Church of England. Christ or his Apostles would never offend against their own Doctrine and practise, therefore this Act could not have taken hold of them, but rather have protected them.  
Q. D. Are any to be credibly informed against and suppressed, but such as are known to be seditious?  
Ans. What needs this query? You see what the Act has determined to be Sedition; I have already proved you to be guilty of that; and you are known to be such, according to the intent of the Act; and therefore ought to be informed against, and suppressed.  
Q. D. Whether the liturgy doth not allow of people to meet together to worship God in spirit and in truth, without limitation of time, place or number?  
Ans. It doth; but then it must be according to the form and method there prescribed, viz. public Prayer in places set apart for the public Worship of God; neither doth it limit the Worship of God in private, there being in the liturgy prescribed forms as well for private as public Worship.  
WE shall now examine your places of Scripture, that you bring to prove your Meetings in Barns, Fields, &c. to be lawful.  
Your first is out of Malachy, In every place offering shall be offered to my name. This hath relation to the calling in of the Gentiles; for then Sacrifices and Prayers were offered up to the name of God no where but in Judea; but the Prophet prophesying of the coming of Christ, and Conversion of the Gentiles by his Gospel, saith, In every place offerings shall be offered to my name, i.e. in every country or Nation, in places dedicated to my name, offering shall be offered to my Name: this every place cannot be taken in the large or general sense, for then it must take in hell, where Sacrifices shall never be offered to the Name of God.  
Q. D. 2. place of scripture. I will that men pray every where, lifting up holy hands without wrath or doubting.  
Ans. The Apostle saith this, to take away doubts of Christians, that by reason of persecution could not be present at the public places of Gods Worship; who might fear that their Prayers might not be so soon heard, when they were alone, as when the whole Congregation of Christians were mutually joined together in Prayer. We find David thus doubting and bemoaning himself,( when he was forced to flee from Saul) that he could not come to the House of God, envying the sparrows and swallows that lodged therein.  
Q. D. 3. place. Wheresoever two or three are gathered together in my name, I will be in the midst of them.  
Ans. God the Father in the Old Testament, claiming a propriety in those places dedicated to his Name and Service, calling them His Houses, and promising to hear the Prayers of his People that should be made in those places: And God the Son in the New Testament, claiming the same propriety, and severely punishes such as had profaned this his House; it might have raised some doubts in the Disciples, when the Temple and other places of Worship were destroyed, where they should then meet to perform their Worship to God; Christ foreseing this, and knowing likewise that they should be scattered abroad by reason of Persecution, tells them, That wheresoever two or three should be gathered together in his name, he would be in the midst of them.  
And as it was in the times of the Law, whilst the People was under Persecution and traveling, God was contented to dwell in Tents and Tabernacles▪ But no sooner was the People peaceably settled in the Land of Canaan, but God puts them in mind to build him an House, which might be a fixed Place, where all might come to worship him, and at the Dedication he did miraculously show his acceptance of it: So during the time of the Persecution of the Gospel, Christ was pleased to accept of the Services of his Church in any Place; but when it was peaceably settled, he puts it into their hearts to build him Houses, that should be dedicated and set a part for his peculiar Service. And now all persons ought to perform their public Worship in these Places, that are by Authority set apart and dedicated for the Service and Worship of God.  
Thus have I proved your Meetings to be seditious, according to the intent and meaning of the Act, and therefore ought to be suppressed: And that your practices have been, and are dangerous: That the things which belong to Caesar, you do not give to Caesar; nor to God, the things that belong to God: I have likewise proved, That your Doctrine tends to the fomenting and stirring up of insurrections and Rebellion: And that there was a necessity for this Act, notwithstanding the former Acts against you, and that for the better security of our Church and Kingdom: I have likewise answered those places of scripture you bring, to prove( though misapplied) your Meetings in Barns, Fields, &c. to be lawful.  
As for your POSTSCRIPT, I shall take no other notice of it, but onely this, That your Definitions agree very well with your practices, and that you are guilty of all things contained therein, either in posse or esse, and therefore ought to be prevented.   

LONDON, Printed ( With Allowance,) Anno Dom. 1670.