9 U?^ 1 17 .M3S PROGRESS REPORT ON THE STRENGTH OF STRUCTURAL TIMBER. CIVIL ENOINEER IN THE BUREAU OF FORESTRY. United States Department of Agriculture, BUREAU OF FORESTRY.— Circular No. 32. GIFFORD PINCHOT, Forester, U. S. Department of Agriculture, Bureau of Forestry, Tfashington, D. C, August 8, IG04. Sir: I have the honor to transmit herewith a paper entitled "Progress Report on the Strength of Structural Timber," by Dr. AV. Kendrick Hatt, Civil Engineer in the Bureau of Forestry, and to recommend its publication as Circular No. 32 of the Bureau of Forestry. Very respectfully, GiFFORD PixcHOT, Forestcr. Hon. James Wilsox, Secretary of Agriculture. PROGRESS REPORT OX THE STRENGTH OP STRUCTURAL TIMBER. The Bureau of Forestry has received man}" requests from lumber operators, engineers, and architects for the partial results of the tim- ber tests now being carried on by the Bureau to determine the mechanical properties of the various commercial timbers of the United States. The present circular is issued in response to this demand, and contains, among other things, the results of cross-bending tests on about 250 large beams of structural timber. These results are being added to from da}" to day, and the figures given below will t>e modified in later publications in accordance with the results of further tests. The tests here presented are, however, safficiently numerous to indicate the structural values of the various species specified in Table I, and to serve as a basis for a revision of opinion, particularly with regard to the strength of such species as loblolly pine and west- ern hemlock. A more formal publication will follow shortly in the form of a bulle- tin, in which a detailed account of the methods and machines used in obtaining these results will be given, the individual tests tabulated, and a thorough analysis of the results themselves presented. The data on hand will allow the formulation of certain relations between the knots and strength and between the rate of growth and strength, and will form the basis for an intelligent revision of the present rules for the inspection and grading of timber. 3 TIMBER TESTS OF THE BUREAU OF FORESTRY. In arranging these tests the Bureau of Forestry has limited its pres- ent programme (1) to those species that promise to be on the market for an indefinite period, (2) to actual market products, and (3) to such purely scientific work as forms the basis for correct methods of test. The present knowledge of the structural value of the timbers of the United States in the form of large sticks is astonishingly meager. What tests have been made have been incomplete and defective in many respects. After the programme of the Bureau of Forestr}^ is carried out there will exist authoritative and complete information con- cerning the mechanical properties of the commercial timbers of the United States. One object of the tests is to aid in the framing of definite inspection rules for the various grades of structural timber. Special problems, like the determination of the proper species and sizes for forest products, such as box lumber and cross-arms for poles, are undertaken in cooperation with corporations whenever the results fit in .with the general interests of forestry. Such information not onl}^ results in economy of design, but also clears away misconceptions and promotes the removal from specifications of man}^ clauses which prevent the use of timber of high structural merit. The programme also includes tests to determine the effect of artificial seasoning, such as is used in the operations preliminary to the preserv- ing processes, and the effect of the presence of the preservatives themselves. A limited amount of work of a purel}^ scientific nature is carried on, involving a critical examination of the methods used in the general programme, and assuring that the programme will be guided to its most useful end. The timber tests of the Bureau of Forestr}^ have been made at the following timber-testing stations, in cooperation with the laboratories of the respective institutions whose equipment is made available for this work: University of California, Berkeley, Cal., L. E. Hunt in charge; Purdue University, Lafayette, Ind., W. K. Hatt in charge, H. D. Hartley, assistant: Division of Tests, Bureau of Chemistry, Washington, D. C, H. S. Betts in charge; Yale Forest School, New Haven, Conn., J. W. Toume}- in charge, H. D. Tiemann, assistant. The programme of the work, as planned at the present time, is as follows: Tests to determine properties of structural timber: Series I. Tests of the mechanical and physical properties of timber in forma found on the market. The material will be of actual sizes and grades of commercial produ{;ts. The purpose is to determine moduli for design; to determine the value of woods now considered inferior; to determine the lialjility to knots, and the reducing factors due to these; to arrange a table of standard weights, and rules of inspection and grading; and jnirtly to compare the properties of species from different regions. Tests to determine the effect of variations in the conditions: Series II. Effect of rate of application of load, including impact tests. Series III. Effect of moisture. Studies of the effect of technological processes: Series IV. Preservatives. Series V. Methods of seasoning. Series VI. Fire retardants. In Series I, for instance, the structural value of the loblolh^ pine and of the Pacific Coast timbers will be fully determined. These spe- cies are tested in the form of large sticks, such as bridge stringers, in which knots, crooked grain, and other defects that occur in structural sticks are present. The origin of the sticks and their condition of seasoning are carefull}^ described. Photographs of the stick are taken and drawings made, locating all the knots and showing the amount of heart, sap, wane, etc. The sticks are graded by an experienced lum- ber inspector. The analysis of the tests of a large number of sticks will serve to determine relations between strength and kind and num- ber of knots, and between strength and rate of growth. In an investigation of a wood like red gum (Liquidamhar styraci- fluci) the tests include not only building material, such as floor joists, but also an examination of the merits of the wood in the form of small clear stock, such as is used for carriage construction, implements, etc. The ability of the wood to withstand the operations of steaming and bending is also investigated. In the case of this timber, the tests have been made on specimens taken directly from the forest. It is the intention to test structural timber generalh^ in the green state. Certain sticks will be set aside, for the length of time necessary for a thorough drjing, in order to develop the defects arising during seasoning. The question of the distribution of moisture in the large sticks and the relative strength of green lumber and lumber that has been onh^ partially dried on the surface will be taken up. It is appar- ent that lumber dealers do not keep large sticks on hand long enough to allow them to dr}^ out thoroughly, and it does not seem at the present time that the surface dryness increases the strength of these large sticks in any marked degree. SPECIES UNDER INVESTIGATION. The species under investigation at the present time are: The Pacific Coast red fir {Pseudotsuga taxifolki)^ otherwise called Oregon pine or Douglas spruce; the western hemlock {Tsuga lieteropliyllci)\ the red gum {Liquidamhar styvaciflaa)\ the longleaf pine {Pinus palustris)'^ and the loblolly pine {Pinus txdct). Later on, the redwood {Sequoia sempervirens) and western yellow pine {Pinus ponderosa) will be tested. DESCRIPTION OF TESTS. TESTS OF LOBLOLLY PINE. Loblolly pine has not only a wide range of distribution but also a wide range of structural merit. It is found locally on the markets of Washington, D. C, and Norfolk, Va., under the name of Virginia pine, in small sticks 8 by 8 inches or 10 by 10 inches in cross section, showing almost entirelj^ sapwood of so rapid a rate of growth that sometimes only 4 rings occur in 3 inches. This is second-growth timber, grown since the civil war, and usually very knotty. The same species occurs on the Charleston market, whence it is shipped to Philadelphia and the North under the name of North Carolina pine. In this case it is forest-grown lumber of large size, fairl}^ free from knots, and of a high order of structural merit. The lobloll}^ pine as a tree is prolific, grows vigorously, and success- fully holds its place in competition with other species in the forest. The operations of conservative forest management, such as are under- taken by lumber companies that look upon their forest holdings as part of their capital and reap periodic harvests of timber from them, con- cern themselves in the Southern States notablj^ with loblolly pine. It is, therefore, a timber that engineers and architects may expect to find on the market for an indefinite period. The chief objection to lob- lolly pine is that, being usually sapwood, it decays rapidly when exposed. It is, however, a timber that may be treated with preserv- atives very successfully, on account of its open grain. For such treatment many of the inferior timbers can be used more successfully than the more solid timbers like longleaf pine. Tables I, 11a, 115, lie, and III give the results of tests on loblolly pine obtained on the market of Washington and from a mill at Charles- ton, S. C. The 8 by 8 inch green Virginia pine entered in the tables was cut about March, 1903, and tested about one month after cutting. This timber was "sap-stained." It has been shown that this staining, or "bluing," does not injure the sti'ength of the wood. The modulus of rupture of these beams was 3,281 pounds per square inch, the modulus of elasticity 729,000 pounds per square inch, and the dry weight per cubic foot 26.3 pounds. The 8 by 8 inch and 4 b}^ 8 inch air-dried Virginia pine were cut in Staffoi'd Count}^, Va., and had been dr3^ing in the j^ard for two years and one year, respectively. The 8 b}^ 8 inch showed a modulus of rupture of 4,874 pounds per square inch, a modulus of elasticity of 1,104,000 pounds per square inch, and a dry weight per cubic foot of 28.8 pounds. The 4 by 8 was timber of denser structure and of slower growth than the 8 by 8 inch. The air-dried pieces show a modulus of rupture of 0,319 pounds per square inch, a modulus of elasticity of 1,219,000 pounds per square inch, and a dry weight per cubic foot of 29.4 pounds. Part of the 4 by 8 inch stuff was soaked to bring it to the green state, in order to obtain the relations between air-dry and green tim- ber. Tlie moisture was increased from 19.4 per cent to 46.3 per cent. The modulus of rupture of the soaked timber w^as decreased about 20 per cent, and the modulus of elasticity about 2 per cent. This Virginia pine is usuall}^ second-grow^th timber, showing all sap- w^ood on faces, very knotty, and w^ide ringed. It is not a timber for important engineering structures, but is used in the minor work of architects. The 8 by 14 inch North Carolina pine was cut from the holdings of a lumber companj^ near Charleston, S. C, about September 1, 1903, sawed September 15 to 18, 1903, and tested from tw^o to five months after. sawing. It is an average air-dry timber showing sapwood on all four faces, of "square edge" grade according to the standard inspection rules of 1902 of the Georgia Saw^mill Association. The timber represents good structural timber, such as is used in ware- houses, mills, and other structures where the conditions do not demand longleaf pine. The modulus of rupture was 6,187 pounds per square inch, the modulus of elasticity 1,479,000 pounds per square inch, and the dr}^ weight per cubic foot 31.2 pounds. The distribution of moist- ure at the center of these 8 by 14 inch North Carolina sticks was determined by sawing out a section 1 inch thick halfway between the ends, dividing it into nine parts by cutting lengthwise and crosswise at the quarter points, and determining the moisture in the several parts. The average of the results on the ten sections from as many sticks is shown in Diagram I. The figures in the various parts of the section show the percentage of moisture in each part. 14 inclies 32.6 per cent. 31.9 per cent. 29.3 per cent. 30.7 per cent. 39.6 per cent. 33.2 percent. 28.6 per cent. 30.9 per cent. 29 per cent. Average 31.7 per cent. Diagram I.— Distribution of moisture in cross section midway of the length of North Carolina lob- lolly pine sticks. (Average of ten sections taken from sticks 8 by li inches by 16 feet.) TESTS OF LONGLEAF PINE. Longleaf pine has been for a long time the standard timber of con- struction, not only on account of its strength, hardness, and durability, but also on account of the long lengths of heartwood that can be obtained free from knots. At present the difficulty in obtaining long- timbers of this wood has led manufacturers, notably in the case of car sills, to consider the efficiency of splices or to use the Pacific Coast 8 woods. Longleaf pine timber has been tested very largel}^ not only in the form of small sticks, but more rarely in large sticks as well. In the markets at present any hard pine, whether longleaf, short- leaf, or loblolly, which shows a close-ringed, hard texture, goes under the name of longleaf pine. The names Georgia pine and Alabama pine are often used to designate timber coming from virgin tracts of longleaf pine in those States. The tests quoted represent longleaf pine sticks of an excellent mer- chantable quality, the better part of them being nearly clear stock. Some of the sticks from Georgia were obtained in the New Haven market, having been shipped there from southern Georgia, and hav- ing been in the New Haven market for from three to six months. The remainder were obtained in yards at Washington, D. C, whither the sticks were shipped from Clinch Count}^, Ga., about one 5^ ear before testing. The longleaf pine from South Carolina was also excellent material. It is very noticeable in the tests that longleaf pine tends to check upon drying out and to fail by longitudinal shear. This is one reason for the belief that an engineer is not justified in using unit stresses larger than those obtained by tests upon green timber. The modulus of rupture of the Georgia longleaf was 8,384 pounds per square inch, the modulus of elasticity 1,820,000 pounds per square inch, and the dry weight per cubic foot 42.9 pounds. In the case of both longleaf and loblolly pine, small sticks were sawed from the uninjured portion of the large sticks after testing. Further tests were made on these small sticks to determine the rela- tion between the strength of the large and the small sticks, the relative strength of pieces of various rates of grjwth, and the effect of moist- ure when the variations due to knots and defects were eliminated. These minor tests were also made on sticks cut from red fir and west- ern hemlock, as noted below. Table III shows a comparison of these tests on the smaller sticks sawed from the larger sticks with the tests on the large sticks. It appears from this table that the modulus of rupture of the small clear sticks 2 by 2 inches in cross section is on an average about 30 per cent higher than that of the sticks from which they were cut. This increase varies from 100 per cent to 2 per cent. The modulus of elasticity, however, of small beams is only 92 per cent of that .of the large beams. These values are based on a comparison of the average results of tests of sticks of various grades. Of course, the small clear sticks are rel- atively strong(u* than the parent sticks when the latter are of second grade— that is, contain large knots. Further facts may be determined from an inspcH'tion of Table IH. It is reserved for a future bulletin to fornuilate rules governing the strength as affected by knots, crooked grain, rate of growth, and moisture. TESTS OF RED FIR. The red tir of the Pacific Coast is known commercially under various names. In California and Oregon it is usuall}^ designated as Oregon pine; in the region of Puget Sound as 3"ellow fir, Douglas spruce, and Puget Sound pine; while in northern Oregon and southern Washing- ton, along the Columbia Kiver, and in the eastern markets the name red fir is gradually becoming established and universal. Botanically, the timber is derived from a single species, Pseudotsuga taxifolia. The range of its growth extends from Lower California to central British Columbia, and from the Pacific Ocean to the Rocky Monntains. It reaches its best development in western Washington and Oregon, between the summit of the Cascade Mountains and the Pacific. Almost pure forests are found here, which frequently yield from fifty to one hundred thousand board feet per acre. In these regions the tree will average 5 or 6 feet in diameter at the butt, with a height up to 300 feet. The trunk of the tree is straight, and readily clears itself of branches. It is possible, therefore, to obtain exceptionally large and long pieces for structural purposes. Sticks 21: inches square and up to 100 feet long are regularly listed and obtainable in the merchantable grades. The possibility of procuring long and large pieces, combined with the exceptional strength and stiffness of the material compared with its weight, renders the red fir an ideal structural timber. Being almost entirely heartwood, the red fir is durable on exposure to the weather. In the green logs from mature trees the sapwood is distinguished as a narrow light-colored ring, extending, usually, not more than 2 inches beneath the bark. In the seasoned timber one seldom encoun- ters sapwood that is distinguishable; and although the adopted grading rules allow, for the merchantable grades, sapwood only on the corners, lumbermen have no difficulty in meeting the requirements. Small trees var3^ing from 1 to 3 feet in diameter are unsurpassed for spars, owing to the straightness of the trunk, the small angle of taper, and the length obtainable. Lengths from 50 to 110 feet are found on the market, while even longer ones are easily obtain- able. Red fir is used on the Pacific Coast to the exclusion of other species for piling for docks and foundations for heavy structures in soft ground. The standard dimensions for this purpose are 12 inches in diameter and from 60 to 70 feet long. The wood of the red fir varies in color from a light yellow to a pro- nounced red; and in grain from one so coarse that there are sometimes not more than -1 or 5 rings per inch in small trees or in heartwood to a fine, even grain with upward of 40 rings per inch. The rings are usually strong!}^ marked, the summer wood being very dense and dark in color, while the springwood is much softer; and the wide-ringed wood is somewhat spongy. Owing to this marked difference in the 10 texture of the alternate rings and to the long, regular fiber, the wood splits easil}^, especially when dry, rendering it unlit for box shooks. This same characteristic makes it particularly^ pleasing for inside finish, paneling, etc., when slash-sawed. The porous springwood readily absorbs wood stains, wdiile the dense summer rings are little affected, giving a beautiful finish in every shade desired. Since it is comparativel}^ free from resin and pitch pockets, the wood is adapted to dr^^-kiln seasoning. It is cut into ever}' form of lumber, from rough structural timbers, used in the framing of heavy constructions of all kinds where strength and durability are required, to the fine-grained, clear stock of flooring. The mechanical tests, a summary of the results of which is given in Tables I to III hereafter, were made upon market products. The sticks were graded by an experienced lumber inspector according to the Pacific Coast standard of 1900. As has been the experience in the timber tests of the Bureau of Forestry with other timbers, the grading of the inspector was found to correspond closely to the average results of the mechanical tests. The sizes given in Table I are those usualh^ used in railroad work, in bridge and trestle construc- tion, and in car construction. Reference to the origin of the three shipments in Table I is omitted until the results of the tests are complete. Shipment B was of poorer quality than A and C. It is evident from Table I that red fir is of varied quality, and that specifications need to be drawn somewhat more carefully than in the case of longleaf pine to exclude the wider-ringed quick growth and knotty sticks. Taking the 6 by 8 inch and 8 by IG inch sticks of ship- ment C as representing an average quality of red fir, and including select, merchantable, and seconds, it appears that the modulus of rup- ture is 7,790 pounds per square inch, the modulus of elasticity 1,783,000 pounds per square inch, and the dry weight per cubic foot 28.5 pounds. The average rate of growth was nearly 19 rings per inch; that is to say, the tree added 1 inch to its radius, or 2 inches to its diameter, in 19 years. It does not appear from the results of the tests that there is an}' marked difference in the strength of fir of red and 3'cllow color, pro- vided the sticks have the same rate of growth and are equally free from defects. A series of tests on small clear sticks of straight grain indicates that a rate of growth corresponding to 21 rings per inch 3-iclds the greatest density and strength. These red fir sticks were tested from six months to one 3'oar from the time of sawing. They were kept in a shed and sprinkled to pre- vent drying out. The exterior parts of the beams contained less moisture than the center, but the difference was not marked. An 11 examination of the distribution of the moisture throughout the cross section of the six 8 by 16 inch beams showed relations which are exhib- ited in Diagram II. A 1-inch cross section taken midway of the stick was divided into 9 parts at third points, as shown, and the moisture in the several parts of the sections determined. The figures recorded in the diagram are the average percentages of moisture found in each part. •< If) inches. > 22.7 per cent. 24.2 per cent. 22.6 per cent. 25.1 per cent. 27.2 per cent. 24.5 per cent. 22.3 per cent. 24.8 per cent. 22.4 per cent. Average 23.9 per cent. Diagram II. — Distribution of moisture in cross section midway of the length of red fir sticks. (Average of six sections taken from sticks 8 by IG inches by 16 feet.) TESTS OF WESTERN HEMLOCK. The introduction of western hemlock to the market as a building material has met with man}^ obstacles. Without doubt the one offer- ing the greatest opposition to. the introduction has been the strong prejudice aroused hy the name of hemlock, which is merited only by the Eastern species. So great is this prejudice even now that, although large quantities of the timber are cut and sold, it is sold under false or fictitious names, such as Alaska pine and Washington pine, spruce, or fir. Western hemlock, as such, has no market standing. Western hemlock reaches its best development in Washington, in the region lying between the summit of the Cascade Mountains and the coast, but is also found from Alaska to central California and as far east as Idaho and Montana. The tree, where conditions have best favored its growth and development, will aA^erage 4 feet in diameter at the butt and 200 feet in height. The trunk is straight and C3^iin- drical, but does not readily clear itself of branches. This causes the defect of small knots in the timber and makes it impossible to obtain much clear lumber except from large trees. The small proportion of clear sticks of hemlock in Table I is noticeable. The wood of the mature tree is hard, straight and even grained, and nearly white in color. The sour odor of the lumber is unmistakable. There is not the marked difference in either color or hardness between the spring and summer rings that is noticeable in red fir. The wood does not split readily, and is light and tough. These quali- ties make it especially suitable for box manufacture. Knots are rather frequent, often dark brown to almost black in color, but usu- all}^ tight and sound. The regular and even structure of the wood and the total absence of pitch render it capable of rapid kiln drying at high temperature without injury. 12 For flooring, molding, paneling, and all inside finish western hem- lock makes a superior lumber, not easily scratched, susceptible of a high polish, and of excellent wearing qualities. The results of the mechanical tests, although the data are not as 3'et sufficiently numerous for positive conclusions, indicate a qualit}^ of timber averaging about 70 per cent of the strength of red fir of the same grade, and suitable for all except the heaviest structures. The tests of western hemlock recorded below were made upon tim- bers cut on the west slope of the Cascade Mountains, in Lane Count}^, Greg., and tested from two to six months after sawing. The sticks were stored in a shed and sprinkled from time to time. It is difficult to apply to the western hemlock the grading rules adopted for red fir. Their application throws most of the hemlock sticks into the "seconds'^ grade. New rules should be made for western hemlock to bring the better qualit}^ of sticks into the "merchantable" grade. The average of the results shown in Table I gives a modulus of rupture of 5,530 pounds per square inch, a modulus of elasticit}^ of 1,261,000 pounds per square inch, and a dry weight per cubic foot of 26.8 pounds. The rate of growth of these sticks was 10.2 rings per inch. RESULTS OF TESTS IX GENERAL. SUMMARY OF TABLE I. A digest of the results in Table I may conveniently be shown in the following table, which presents the strength and stifi'ness of beams such as are found in the market and are used'lw engineers. More detailed information will be found in Table I. The modulus of rup- ture is a factor which represents fairh^ well the strength of the timber. The modulus of elasticity is a factor which represents its stiffness. Summary of Table I, showing cross-hcncUng strength of structural timber. Species. Grade. Average number of .sticks. Time sea- soned. Moist- Weight per cubic foot. Modulus of rup- ture. Modulus of elas- ticity. ure. As tested. Dry. Red fir: Shipments A and 0. Select 22 29 16 14 15 25 36 44 41 121 30 20 26 Monlhs. I 6 to 12 1 ^ I Pa- cent. f 22.6 \ 20. 8 1 19.5 1 27.6 26.5 1 26.2 \ 'He 23. 6 32. 2 37.2 26.7 Pounds. 37.1 34. 5 31.9 30.9 33.7 35.1 34.7 34. 8 33.8 33. 4 35.4 42.8 53. 3 Pounds. 30.2 28. 4 26.7 24.2 26. 6 27.8 27.9 28.4 27.4 27.8 26. 8 31.2 42. 1 Pounds per square inch. 8,810 7,730 6,290 6, 250 5,340 4,280 7, 780 6, 920 5, 070 6, 580 5, 505 6, 187 8, 210 1,000 lbs. per square inch. 1 , 925 Merchantable Seconds 1,825 1 630 Select 1,280 ShipmentB.... Shipments A, B, and C. ■^Merchantable [Seconds Select 1,320 1,400 . 1 , 675 Merchantable Seconds 1,660 1 1,490 Average of All grades 1,570 sliipmentsA, B, and C. Western hornloek do 3 to C. 3 6 to 12 1 "60 North Carolijia loblolly pine. Longleai pine S>iuare edge :Mcrchantablc 1,479 1,790 ^ 13 This table is not considered to be a final statement of the relative structural value of the various species tested. The great ranoe of values found in tests of timber render it necessaiy to perform tests on a large number of sticks. Furthermore, the moisture condition of the beams varies somewhat in the different species entered in Table I. The question of the effect of a longer time of dr3^ing in inci'easing or decreasing the strength of beams has not been satisfactorily investi- gated. Certain elements of the question may be noted. The moisture content is different in green timber of various species; for instance, about 50 per cent of the dr}^ weight in the case of red fir, and up to 100 per cent in the case of loblolly pine; so that the same moisture content in these two species does not represent an equal degree of seasoning. Again, the red fir seasons more rapidly in the dry climate of California than does the loblollv pine in the moist climate of the Atlantic Coast. It is surprising how much moisture is found in well-seasoned timber. Attention is called to the fact that sticks of longleaf pine 10 b}- 12 inches in cross section which had been dr^^ing in the Washington 3'ard for one 3^ear contained 35 per cent of moisture, and that sticks of loblollj^ pine from Virginia, 8 b}' 8 inches in cross section, that had been dr^'ing in the same situation for two 3^ears and were almost black on the sur- face, contained 31 per cent of moisture. The small sticks dr3^ out more uniformh' than do the large sticks, and after the moisture has been reduced to nearl3^ 26 per cent the strength begins to increase upon a further reduction of moisture. The laws expressing the rela- tion of strength and moisture in the case of small sticks, however, do Eot necessarih' apph' to large sticks. It is believed that the tests quoted in the above table were made on timber as delivered to the engineer under the ordinar3^ conditions of the market. A future bulletin will present the results on the individual sticks and give full information concerning the proportion of the results falling within a given range of strength. Photographs of the sticks will also be published. STRENGTH AXD COMPRESSIOX. Table lla contains the results of tests in compression parallel to the fiber of various species of timber. These are on material derived from the beams listed in Table I. Tlie3^ are to be regarded as minor tests. The Bureau of Forestr3^ has not 3^et installed a testing machine of sufficient capacity to allow tests on full-sized columns. Table 11^ contains the results of tests in compression at right angles to the fiber. Loads were applied to a steel plate for 4 inches aloug the stick under test, and measurements were taken to determine the amount of yielding of the stick in the direction of the loading due to crushing of the surface or general compression of the stick. The elastic limit of the wood under this kind of loading is given in Table 11^. The values represent the strength of wood against the bearing- pressure of a washer. 14 LONGITUDINAL SHEAR. When a beam becomes weakened b}^ wind-shakes or season checks it is apt to fail under longitudinal shear. That is to say, it splits from the end of the beam toward the center, instead of failing in tension or compression at the center of the span. The liability to failure under long'itudinal shear decides the strength of a beam of short span. Table lid indicates the strength of the various sticks in longitudinal shear. The strength is given in pounds per square inch of horizontal section of beam. The strength of the area of wood actually sheared off is greater than these values. The latter include the effect of openings in the wood between the fibers due to checks, etc. The values are those that should be used in desig-ninor beams to carrv loads. SHEARING STRENGTH. The results of the tests to determine the actual shearing strength of the wood will be found in Table 11^^. These tests were made on small test pieces, a projecting bead on each of which was sheared off. The test piece was so designed as to yield a failure in true shear without an accompanying failure in compression or bending. TESTS OF RED GUM.^ Red gum is found in abundant quantities, principally in the river bottomlands of all the Mississippi Valley States south of the Ohio River and east of Texas, where the stumpage is estimated to be greater than the combined stumpage of all the other hardwoods, and along the swamps of the Atlantic Coast. Although at the present time a comparatively small amount is being cut, owing to the great care necessary in seasoning the wood, its future is most promising. As a forest tree the red gum is very tall and straight, varying, according to soil and climatic conditions, from 30 to 60 inches in diameter at the stump, and in height to the first limb from 40 to 80 feet. The percentage of waste, in comparison with other hardwoods, is very small, and for clear, wide lumber this is as valuable a tree as poplar or cottonwood. Red gum is now being used extensivel}^ for barrel staves, for which purpose it is rapidly replacing elm. Some tight barrels are being made from red gum, but, owing to the more favorable properties of the oaks for this purpose, its future use will probably be limited for some time to the slack barrel. Another important use of red gum, where strength is an essential feature, is in the manufacture of tobacco and canncrs' boxes and for crating for heavy machinery. For boxes the wood has, within the last few years, been used along with sycamore, poplar, and cottonwood. a Also called sweet gum and star-leaved gmn. 15 Owing to the value of the clear, wide lumber cut from the red g'lim loo", it is too expensive a wood to use for construction timber while the suppl}" of pine, fir, and hemlock is so great. However, the red o'um has local uses for building material, such as joists, sills, and common frames. The material is usually cut from the heart of the tree, which, on account of shakes, etc., is not used for other purposes. Results of tests on a few of these joists are shown in Table IV. The supply of red gum timber for this use is so limited that it is hardly available for general engineering construction. The tests of red gum, quoted in Table V, are on 4 by 4: inch sticks sawed from trees selected from the forest b}^ agents of the Bureau of Forestry in the Tennessee River bottoms at Hollywood, Ala. Both mature and 3^oung trees are represented. These tests form part of a series which will eventually cover the Atlantic Coast and the Missis- sippi Valley ranges of the tree. It will be noticed that there was a considerable number of culls from the logs. Fifty-three per cent of the heart pieces sawed out were discarded. The results of compression tests parallel to the grain on specimens of red gum cut from 10 trees at Risco, Mo., are added to Table V. The tests include an examination of the relative strength of the wood at various parts of both young and mature trees from various localities, which will form a portion of a general bulletin on red gum to be issued in the near future by the Bureau of Forestry. In the tables given in this circular the strength of the red gum is given as ascertained from the general run of the trees from the Tennessee River bottoms at Hollywood, Ala. Five mature and 5 immature trees were cut. Three logs 16 feet long were taken from each trunk. Four by four inch test pieces were cut from a plank which was sawed from the trunk, to include the center of the heart of the tree. Part of the material is to be tested green, part kiln-dried, and part air-dried, in cross bending, compression parallel to the fiber, and compression at right angles to the fiber. An analysis of the results will attempt a determination of the relative strength of the fiber throughout the height of the tree, and of the relative strength from the heart center to the bark. While it is possible to ascertain these relations in the case of a tree of straight-grained trunk like the coniferous woods, the present indications are that it is impracticable to obtain all these rela- tions in the case of cross-grained woods like red gum. The outcome of the work depends on the degree to which the cull material from the heart near the butt of the tree is excluded on account of shakes, rot, etc. The following table shows the relative percentage of culls in heart- wood and sapwood of the specimens cut from logs procured in Alabama and tested in cross bending, as reported in Table V: 16 Culls in red gum logs used In cross-he) idlng tests. Hcartwood. Sap wood. Total. 32 69 53 16 17 6 48 Total number of specimens tested 86 Per cent of waste in culls 44 The general procedure in taking samples of red gum from various parts of the country is to select a bolt from the trunk at a distance from the ground sufficient to avoid rot and shakes. This bolt will furnish test pieces for the determination of the strength of the heart- wood and sapwood. The problem of determining the proportion of merchantable material in a tree is for the inspector, forester, or mill man — not a problem for the testing machine. The test pieces from the bolt will also serve to determine the difference of strenp-th between vigorous young trees and mature trees. That portion of the results of the tests on the Alabama logs which is of interest in connection with this circular is given in Table V. This table gives a general summary of the strength of red gum heart and sap pieces. The logs were shipped from Alabama to the timber-testing station of the Bureau of Forestry at Lafayette, Ind., and there sawed up into 4 by 4 inch test pieces. The green pieces were tested as soon as possible after sawing. The time elapsing from the sawing of the logs until the end of the tests was about five weeks. The test pieces were kept at the moisture of green timber by a cover of sacking, which was sprinkled day by day. Each test piece was put in a moist closet for two days preceding the actual test. As timber has to dr\^ to a degree of moisture below 33 per cent before any subsequent drying begins to affect the strength of the fiber, and the average moisture of these green specimens was 86.4 per cent, it is evident that the values given are those for green timber. The partially kiln-dried material was the result of an attempt to dry some of these 4 by 4 inch gum sticks in a kiln without subsequent air dr3^ing. The kiln drying consisted of the following operations: The sticks were steamed for forty - eight hours with live steam, producing a temperature in the kiln of 110° to 125° F. The steam was then shut off", and the kiln heated for 35 days to a temperature var^^ing from 85° F. on the first few days to 150° and 160° F. at the last. Checking and twisting were most noticeable during the first four or five days in the kiln, after which no large increase was observed. It was noticed upon removal from the kiln that the surfaces of all the timber were apparently drv, having the convex surface peculiar to kiln-dried timber. Upon cutting into the pieces it was found that the heartwood had dried only to a depth of three-quarters of an inch. The sapwood had dried from a depth of 1\ inches to thorough dryness. Subsequent kiln-drying 17 tests on 2 by 2 inch red gum heartwood stock have shown satisfactory^ results. In the latter case a much slower and drier heat was given the specimens, which were afterwards steamed and bent into carriage- wood stock. To determine the effect of close piling on green wood 34 specimens- of heartwood and 22 specimens of sapwood were close-piled in a green condition in the laborator}^ and allowed to remain for six months, developing sap-stain and fungus growth. These specimens were afterwards tested. The results of the tests on this "blued'' timber are compared in Table VI with the results of the tests given in- Table V. As has been shown in previous tests with pine, both in. German}^ and in the United States, the effect of this "bluing" is not detrimental to the strength of the timber. It was desired to ascertain if red gum had the mechanical proper- ties which woidd fit it for use in the vehicle industry. Factor}^ tests. showed that this wood could be steamed and bent, and that it took a. good linish. A series of tests was made of hickory in comparison, with red gum. Table VII shows the relative bending and compression, strength of the four grades of dr}' commercial hickorv. The speci- mens were all kiln-dried and then seasoned in the laboratory to nearly the same per cent of moisture. The results are all based on. specimens nominall}^ 1^ inches square in cross section by 30 inches, long, selected b}" an expert grader in the mill yard, all specimens free from knots, cross grain, and other defects. The strength of the red gum in Table VII represents tests on clear heartwood practically 2^ inches square in cross section by 30 inches long', kiln-dried to 13.. 5 per cent moisture. The actual values obtained in the tests are increased b}^ 12 per cent so as to represent the strength of this red gum at 8. per cent of moisture, in order to form a fair comparison with the hickor3^ The difference between red gum and hickory is more marked in. impact tests than in tests under gradual loading. Torsion tests. bring out very well the difference in the structure of the two woods. The better grades of hickory develop a long fiber, which "brooms out'^ after rupture, the test piece submitting to a large degree of twisting before rupture. Red gum, on the contrary, opens up longitudinally at a small angle of twist, showing a crooked grain and short fiber. The results of a careful examination of the mechanical properties of the red gum indicate that it is inferior in strength to the poorest grade of hickory. Further discussion will appear in the bulletin on red gum. 5168— No. 32—04^2 APPENDIX. NOTES ON TABLE I. The moisture in the beams was determined by the section method. An inch section was sawed from the middle and from one of the quar- ter points of the span and dried at 100'^ C. to a constant weight. To determine the amount of moisture driven off by the saw a section one- half inch thick was sawed next to the section 1 inch thick. It appears that the difference between the moisture at the middle and the one- quarter points of the span is negligible, and that the moisture driven off from a 1-inch section by the saw is also negligible. A very careful examination of longleaf pine and red fir shows that the same is true of the correction to the moisture per cent due to the volatile oil driven off from the sections in the oven. The per cent of moisture is computed with reference to the dry weight of the wood. The annual rings per inch are a measure of the rapidit}^ of growth. A ring consists of the light springwood and the dense summer wood added by the tree in one year. Thus 20 rings per inch means that the tree added 2 inches to its diameter in twenty years. The dry weight per cubic foot is the number of pounds of wood in 1 cubic foot. The weight of 1,000 feet board measure may be obtained by multiplying the weight per cubic foot b}^ 83^. The modulus of rupture and the fiber stress at elastic limit are meas- ures of the strength of the wood in cross bending, and the modulus of elasticity is the measure of the stiffness in cross bending. The method of computing these is described in Bulletin No. 8 of the Bureau of Forestry. The elastic limit is the real elastic limit, not the apparent elastic limit defined in Bulletin No. 8. Loads were applied continu- ousl}^ at a speed of one-quarter inch per minute for beams 6 b}^ 8 inches in cross section and at a speed of one-eighth inch per minute for beams 8 by 16 inches in cross section. RULES FOR INSPECTION AND GRADING. The rules of inspection and grading referred to in this circular are here reproduced. From the classification and insj^ection rules for yellow pine lumber, adopted by tlie Georgia Sawmill Association at Jacksonville, Fla., 1902. MERCHANTABLE INSPECTION, 1902. Dimension sizes. — All square lumber shall show two-thirds heart on two opposite sides; other sizes shall show two-thirds heart on faces, except for lengths exceeding 18 19 40 feet, then to show half heart on two opposite sides or faces for the additional length — all free from round shakes that show on the surface or through shakes or unsound knots. STANDARD INSPECTION, 1902. « Dimension. — Shall be square edge, except that sizes 10-inch or over may have 2-iiich wane one-third the length on one corner, or one-sixth the length on two corners, or one-ninth the length on three corners, or one-twelfth the length on four corners; wane to be measured on face side. All free from round or through shakes or unsound knots. From the Pacific Coast standard grading rules for Douglas fir, adopted WOO. MERCHANTABLE. This grade shall consist of sound, strong lumber, free from shakes, large, loose, or rotten knots, and defects that materially impair its strength ; well manufactured and suitable for good substantial constructional purposes. ^Yill allow — Occasional variations in sawing or occasional scant thicknesses, sound knots, i:)itch seams, and sap on corners, one-third the width and one-half the thickness. Defects in all cases to be considered in connection with the size of the piece and its general quality. SECONDS. This grade shall consist of lumber having defects which exclude it from grading as merchantable. Will allou- — Knots and defects which render it unfit for good substantial constructional pur- poses, but suitable for an inferior class of work. Shall be sound, strong lumber, good grain, well sawn. ^Y^ll alloic — In sizes 6 by 6 and less, knots not to exceed 1 inch in diameter; sap on corners one-fourth the width and one-half the thickness; small pitch seams when not exceed- ing 6 inches in length. In sizes over 6 by 6, knots not to exceed 2 inches in diameter, varying according to the size of the piece; sap on corner not to exceed 3 inches on both face and edge; pitch seams not to exceed 8 inches in length. Defects in all cases to be considered in connection with the size of the piece and its general quality. DESCRIPTION or BEAMS. The limits of this circular will not allow a detailed description of the sticks the results of tests of which are given in Table I. The stick whose modulus of rupture corresponds to the average modulus of rup- ture of the merchantable or square edge grade in Table I is selected for description in each case. HISTORY OF SHIPMENT '^'a" RED FIR. Cut in township 17 south, range 2 east, Willamette Meridian, on McKenzie River, west slope Cascade Mountains, Lane County, Greg. Shipped from Coburg, Oreg., May 8; received at Berkelev, Cal., May 25, 1903. "Called "square edge" in Charleston and in this circular. 20 INDIVIDUAL DESCRIPTION OF TIMBERS TESTED. Red fir, shipment '^A,^^ 6 by 8 average select. Rings per inch, 13; color, medium 3^ellow; imperfections: Side a, one weather check; side J, pitch seam; side ^, pitch seam, weather checks; side c/, pitch seam, weather checks. Red fir, shipment "^1," 6 by 8 inaximinn select. Rings per inch, 20.5; color, medimn yellow; imperfections: Side ^, three knots 0.5 to 0.7 inches in diameter, small weather checks; side J, clear; side i\ weather checks; side d^ clear. Red fir, shipment 'L-1," 6 by S minimum select. Rings per inch, 21; color, medium yellow; imperfections: Side a^ weather checks; side ^, pitch seam; side c, one-half -inch knot and weather checks; side d^ pitch seam. Red fir, shipment "^1," 6 by 8 average merchantable. Rings per inch, 22; color, medium red; imperfections: Side a^ 2 knots about 1 inch in diameter, weather checks; side J, 1 knot 3 by 2^ inches, broken out; side (?, 6 knots 1 to li inches in diameter, checks; side d^ 1 small knot. Red fir, shipment '',.4," 6 by 8 ma.vimum merchantable. Rings per inch, 22; color, medium yellow; imperfections: Side a., clear; side J, clear; side c, two ^-inch sound knots; side <:/, clear. Red fir, shipment ".-I," 6 by 8 minimum merchantable. Rings per inch, 25; color, medium yellow; imperfections: Side a, one i-inch sound knot; side 5, clear; side ^, 8 knots from i to 1 inch in diameter; side d^ 2 knots. Red fir, shipment "A,'' 6 by 8 average seconds. Rings per inch, 8; color, medium red; imperfections: Side «, 16 sound knots i to 2 inches in diameter, check; side J, 4 knots 1 to li inches in diameter, sound; side , 5 knots i to li inches in diameter, 2 loose, weather checks; side c\ 5 knots k to li inches in diameter, 1 loose, weather checks; side d, 11 knots i to 2 inches in diameter, 3 loose, weather checks. Lohlolly pine, 8 by 8 average square edge, green. History: From Urban Wharf, King and Queen Count}', Ya. ; in yard one week. Rings per inch, 2.6; color, light yellow; imperfec- tions: Side a, 11 knots from 1 to 3 inches in diameter, all sap; side 5, 6 knots about 2 inches in diameter, all sap; side «*>^ 0^T'^^ _rt>> • a> as ^. o ^^®'-IK) »iOO OICO'^ lOOO ©OOCO ^oo o o t-» "^ '^^ -h^-* _i,iOC0 -(LO-^ Per cent. f 86.4 ^ 120. 7 [ 52.8 t^OO »aTj oo oi c^i o 50 cc i- I— lO CT> oi lO i^ x ^n o i-< _r_r th _r eo _r rn -- ei _r K •^SlOCO r»COCO i=H(Ml> ■.flOO Si,iS^^ 2^--=^ M<^^ S'-^'^ =^"^«°°^" o'-^'^' ^'^'^ ccS"^" ^^asCJOC «Dt-'# ©C^-::H ODOCO ©(MOO ^,-^^^8 2?^§ ;S!$S gg8?§ *'E^s ©OrtI D.00O ^ t^j t^j ^ "^ >^ C5 ^"^ ^' rJoT-* .h:-u'<'(N «rOM" © "M c-i u; 00 c -.J ■^t^ o oo !>. O O uO ^ o to rO O !M © CO iH ©t>0 ©Oi !ooo (MCO 'O ■a a' a OJ 13 g o) s g :;:; !& sss ^OCl- (I^CCl^ W be .'£ a; §gS ^gl^ © o c i: ^^c^co o^cot^: g^-a^.2 fH'^ 1-1'"' S««5-< S'O^' !^ _lii e*^^^. *^-'^'- III ®^.°^ ^1 ^15;* S3 -^2^ ^rgg^ ©^S ;3'43 c^--^oSS ©o^ 5q?aS T-I^l> mC'"'" ■■Tco^^ ^.Co'rH *l^r^' ®?JS- !N (N (M 51 1 s riiii lis §ii ill ^^1 s ^ si^^^i ^^-"-" ^'-- ps 3"^" III i's X)CO d^^'^" o ^g'^ pH " " CC^^ Ti^^ rH-MC^ OJO.T-HCO ©gs^ ■3'> b (»°!'". ^GOi-_ IpCO^ aS'S d • • cS'bo"^ .55 g §Sg ^^S3 © o g ;^ g ,^ OJ 00 00°^'^' 30=^'^ ood'^ 00 S o^" o CO 00 CO § III _^ —- . —^ ^ ; : ; •A : : : ! ; : : : : i 1 1 :ia^ :gg :ag y <) ^gs ^• ; . lb ib uO fe) a o o\ (M' c\ c-i U X y, X ^ o lO iq lO lO ',, r-i rH r-i rH ^ a H >< >^ X oi « lO lO lO lO J -^ . --^ '-* --* C^J V : ^ o St : o 1 tH o ^ • ■^ .2^ j o i'. 'r't >. ._J^ a t-i t-i' a o O o o fcc ^^ ^ ^ ^ CJ c o o t3 (D t? s 5 s p: LIBRARY OF CONGRESS 019 418 316 1 i LIBRARY OF CONGRESS 019 418 316 1