IMAGE EVALUATION
TEST TARGET (MT-3)

1^^ ^ .-'■ ^ Ms

1.0

I.I

1.25

!^ 1^ lllll 10

1.8

M 1116

<:i

c^:

"71

^;;

Photographic

Sciences
Corporation

23 WEST MAIN STREET

WEBSTER, N.Y. 14580

(716) 872-4503

'.^^4

y^^

CIHM/ICMH

Microfiche

Series.

CIHIVI/ICMH
Collection de
microfiches.

Canadian institute for Historical M*' oreproductions / Institut Canadian de microreproductions historiques

Technical and Bibliographic Notes/Notas techniques et bibliographiques

The Institute has attempted to obtain the best
original copy available for filming. Features of this
copy which may be bibliographically unique,
which may alter any of the images in the
reproduction, or which may significantly change
the usual method of filming, are checked below.

D
D
D
D
D
D

Coloured covers/
Couverture de couiaur

Covers damaged/
Couverture endommagie

Covers restored and/or laminated/
Couverture restaur^ et/ou pellicul6e

Cover title missing/

Le titre de couverture manque

Coloured maps/

Cartes giographiques en couleur

Coloured ink (i.e. other than blue or black)/
Encre de couleur (i.e. autre que bleue ou noire)

Coloured plates and/or illustrations/
Planches et/ou illustrations en couleur

Bound with other material/
Relii avec d'autres documents

Tight binding may cause shadows or distortion
along interior margin/

La re liure serrie peut causer de I'ombre ou de la
distorsion le long de la marge int6rieure

Blank leaves added during restoration may
appear within the text. Whenever possible, these
have been omitted from filming/
II se peut que certaines pafies blanches ajouties
lors d'une restauration apparaissent dans le texte,
mats, lorsque cela itait possible, ces pages n'ont
pas 6t4 filmies.

Additional comments:/
Commentaires supplimentaires:

Some pages are cut off.

L'Institut a microfilm^ le meilleur exemplaire
qu'il lui a AtA possible de se procurer. Les details
de cet exemplaire qui sont peut-Atre uniques du
point de vue bibliographique, qui peuvent modifier
une image reproduite, ou qui peuvent exiger une
modification dans la mithode no/male de filmagn
sont i.idiquis ci-dessous.

I I Coloured pages/

D
D

Pages de couleur

Pages damaged/
Pages endommagies

□ Pages restored and/or laminated/
Pages restaur^es et/ou pelliculies

Pages discoloured, stained or foxed/
^' ' Pages dicoiories, tacheties ou piquies

I I Pages detached/

Pages ditachies

Showthrough>
Transparence

rri Showthrough/

I I Quality of print varies/

Quality inigale de ('impression

Includes supplementary material/
Comprend du matiriel supplimentaire

Only edition available/
Seule Edition disponible

Pages wholly or partially obscured by errata
slips, tissues, etc., have been refilmed to
ensure the best possible image/
Les pages totalement ou partiellement
obscurcies par un feuillet d'errata, une pelure,
etc., ont 6t^ filmies & nouveau de fapon A
obtenir la meilleure image possible.

This item is filmad at the reduction ratio checked below/

Ce document est filmA au taux de reduction indiqud ci-dessous.

10X

14X

18X

22X

26X

30X

12X

16X

20X

a4x

28X

32X

Th« copy film«d h«r« has b««n r«produc«d thanks
to tha ganarosity of:

M«dical Library
McGill University
Montreal

Tha imagaa appaaring hara ara tha bast quality
possibia conaidaring tha condition and lagibiiity
of tha original copy and in Icaaping with tha
filming contract spacifications.

L'axamplalra film* fut raproduit grAca A la
g^nArosIt* da:

Medical Library
McGiil University
Montreal

Laa imagas suivantaa ont §t^ raproduitas avac la
plus grand soin, eompta tanu da la condition at
da la nattatA da I'axamplaira filmA, at an
conformiti avac las conditions du contrat da
fiimaga.

Original copiaa in printad papar covars ara fiimad
baginning with tha front covar and anding on
tha last paga with a printad or iliustratad impras-
sion, or tha bacic covar whan appropriata. Ail
othar original copiac ara fiimad baginning on tha
first paga with a printad or iliustratad impras-
sion, and anding on tha last paga with a printad
or liiuatratad impraaaion.

Laa axamplairas originaux dont la couvartura •n
papiar ast imprimte sont fiimAs sn commandant
par la pramiar plat at an tarminant soit par la
darniAra paga qui comporta una amprainta
d'imprassion ou d'lllustration, soit par la sacond
plat, salon la cas. Tous las autras axamplairas
originaux sont filmAs an commandant par la
pramiira paga qui comporta una amprainta
d'imprassion ou d'lllustration at an tarminant par
ia darniAra paga qui comporta una taiia
amprainta.

Tha laat racordad frama on aach microfleha
shall contain tha symbol -^(moaning "CON-
TINUED "), or tha symbol ▼ (moaning "END "),
whichavar applias.

Un das symbolas suivants appi attra sur la
darniAra imaga da chaqua microficha, salon la
caa: la symbols — »> signifia "A SUiVRE", la
symbols V signifia "FIN".

Mapa, piataa. charts, ate may ba fiimad at
diffarant raduction ratios. Thosa too larga to ba
antiraly includad in ona axposura ara fiimad
baginning in tha uppar laft hand cornar, iaft to
right and top to bottom, as many framaa aa
raquirad. Tha following diagrama liiustrata tha
mathod:

Las cartas, pianchas, tablaaux, ate, pauvant Atra
filmAa A daa taux da rAduction diff Arants.
Lorsqua la documant ast trop grand pour Atra
raproduit an un saui cllchA, ii ast filmA A partir
da I'angla supAriaur gaucha, da gaucha A droita.
at da haut an bas, an pranint la nombra
d'imagas nAcassaira. Las diagrammas suivants
iliustrant la mAthoda.

Leltci I. I

4N EXrOSITIOW OF THE "REASONS" CONTAIN-
ED IN THE COUNTER PETITION OF THE MK-
UICAL FACULTY OF M'GILI. COLLEGE.

To the Honorable the Memberf of the Legislative

Council and Legislative Assembly.
Gentlemen,

A measure will shjr'Jy be submitted fjr your
sanction, and seemingly simple although the request
appears, which is sought to be obtained by it, it yet
involves interests of exceeding magnitude. It is not
unknown to your Honorable Houses, that curly in

owes its present hi;^h and dignified position, and that
it is to the absence of it, or the free trade principle,
that that Professional character has elsewlicre been
degraded. The fact wiiich I now assert, I shall not
leave unsupported by proof, by ample proof, but to
adduce it now would be to anticipate my subject.

^Vc may here, u jt irrelevantly, enquire into the |
nature of the " Diploma or Certificate," the privi-
lege of granting which has been petitioned for. In
limine, I observe, that a Diploma and a Certificate
are by no means one and the same thing. A Diplo-
ma is a Certificate, but a Certificate is not a Diplo-
ma ; and I use the terms in the conventional sense '

only issued by two Authorised Bodies in Great Bri- \
tain — the Societies of Apothecaries, of London'

December a petition was presented to you, signed ' in which they are employed in England. Certifi-
by the lecturers and students of a new School of j cates, according to that meaning, (and it is the |
Medicine in this ci'y, in which the petitioners prayed meaning employed by the Bodies themselves) are*
not only for an Act of Incorporati'jn, but what was
of far greater importance, the permission to grant a

diploma, or certificate, to such Students, who, after ! aiid Dublin. They are in reality Licences, or " Ccr- 1
an examination before thcmseWes, shall have becir tificates of qualification to practice," as Apotheca- J
found worthy of it. On the 9;h Dcembcr, a coun- , ries, and constitute that authority by which thef
ter petition to the above was presented to the Logis- General Practitioners of England, Ireland, and^
lative Council, by the Hon. Mr. Druneau, and to Wales, exercise their rights. Diplomas, again, are i
the Legislative Assembly by the Hon- G. Mof- j "letters testimonial," granted only by the Royal i

r ATT, cmanat.ng from, and signed by, the Professor
and Lecturers in the Faculty of Medicine of M'Gill
College. The Faculty of Medicine humbly con-
ceiving that tiie delegation of a privilege, such as
that sought for, would be injurious to the best inter-
ests of the country, deliberately expressed their opin-
ion on the matter ; and however great the obloquy
has been which they have since encountered from
those most interested in the matter, they at least
have the satisfaction of knowing, that the cause
which they have sustained — not more their own than
that of the profession at large — is approved of by par-
ties unconnected with themselves — parties who, un-
trammelled and unbiassed by party feelings, have
estimated the question oo its own intrinsic merits.

The Petition, Gentlemen, embodies two requests :
tlie one an Act of Incorporation, the other the privi-
lege to grant a Diploma. The Act of Incorporation
is one thing — the privilege to grant a Diploma is
another. The former is a matter of very little con-
sequence, but if the latter be conceded also, it tht;n
becomes a serious question. Most important inter-
ests immediately become affected — interests apper-
taining not only to tht Medical Profession generally
but to the community at large. Under the cry of
Monopoly has the banner of free trade principles
in matters of Medical science been here unfurled,
which, whatever may be the opinion entertained of
the benefits of their introduction into commercial af-
fairs, can be demonstrated to have induced the most
pernicious effects in matters of Medical Polity.
Monopoly "? I .shall prove, Gentlemen, that it is to
lliis very monopoly that the British Medical chara^ ler

Colleges of Surgeons of England, Scotland, and Ire
land, and the Faculty of Physicians and Surgeons of 4
Glasgow, expressive of the proficiency of the indivi-jl
duals who hold them i.i the particular branches spe-H
cified. Diplomas arc to Surgery what " degrees"
arc to Medicine. A Diploma, however, is not af
Degree. Degrees are honours, whether in the Fa- 1 'I
culties of Medicine, Divinity, Arts, or Law, and arei
conferred by Universities and Universities only. Inf
Great Britain, both are Licences ad practicandum,-
and the holders practice accordingly, those of the '
first as Surgeons, and those of the second as Physi-
cians.

It would be folly in me. Gentlemen, to deny the'
fact, that by establishing schools, with power to
grant Diplomas, with all the flattering seducemcnts
connected with short courses and small fees, the pe-
cuniary interests of the Universities would not suf-'
fer. I cannot for a moment believe that you, as the'
Guardians of public good, will suffer to be sacrificed
on such grounds, the higher seats of learning in this '
Province, upon the maintenance cf which the respec-
tability of the Medical Pjrofession, as well as the best,
interests of the public are essentially dependent, but'
I shall at once take higher ground, and assuming >
as my texts the " Reasons" of the Medical Faculty, .
sliall argue the question on its abstract merits.
I have the honor to subscribe myself.
Gentlemen,
Your most obedient servant,

A. Hall, M.D
! Montreal. Feb. 13. 1845. '' *'/■■''»■" '

' >!

■Ill '«.' I;

'••'^"' • Letter II.

AN EXPOSITION OF THE "REASONS" CONTAIN-
ED IN THE COUNTER PETITION OF THE ME-
DICAL FACULTY OF M'GILL COLLEGE.

Reason, I. — Because under the present circum-
stances of the Province with its comparative-
ly limited population, the Mfidicnl Schools
attached to the two Univenities of King's
College and M'Gill College are more than
sufficient for every purpose of such Institu-
tions.
Reason, II — Because the number of young men
entering the Medical Profession, although
doubtless bearing the same ratio to the aggre-
gate population as in other countries, is from
the same cause in this Province limited, and
th<!ref are insufficient of tfiemselvcs to remu-
nerate in any thing like an adequate manner
the labour of thep- teachers. Their distribu-
tion among an increased number of Schools,
will have the undeniable effect of rendering
them inefficient, by crippling their revenue,
and thereby obstructing the acquisition of the
necessai-y materials for the illustration of
their lectures.

Ieason, III. — Because one well established School,
in which every facility for the acquisition of
knowledge is affoi-ded, is preferable to a plu-

1 rality of Schools, with limited means, and
still more limited facilities.

To tilt Honorable the Members of the Legislative
I, ,. Council and Legislative Assembly.

lENTLEMEN,

It may be that from my intimate connexion with
,ie Medical Faculty of M'Gill College, any argu-
lents which I may employ, in favour of the posi-
;on which that Faculty has assumed, may be re-
arded in the light of "special pleading." So fur
s these letters are concerned, I lake this opportu-
ity of assuring you that that Faculty has nothing
hatever to do with them : they are written on my
ivn responsibility j and my only desire is a truth-
il exposition of the subject, and of the reason-
bleness of the objections o*" the Faculty. I
lall assert nothinp; that I shall not be able fully to
ibstantiate— and substantiate in the firmest man-
sr possible, by facts— a method which appeals at
ice to the understanding of every individual.
The first reason or ground of objection assigned by
le Faculty, bears every appearance of being the
qjression of their mere opinion on the matter, and
ider such supposition has been encot: itered by an
Anim of an opposite kind. It is, on the contrary,
deliberately advanced assertion, and has not been
ade without the full warranty of facta on which to
st it. The only mode, then, of testing its value is
f an appeal to statistics, to determine the ratio
hich medical schools, having the power of confer-

ring degrees or diplomas or certificates, bear to tl;
population of other countries, and to ascertain the
same with reference to our own.

In Great Britain there arc 19 Corporate Bodies,,
granting ad praclicandum certificates of some kln('
or other. From this list, however, we may, with
out improprietj-, exclude the Universities of Oxforc
and Cambridge, Trinity College, Dublin, and the
Archbishop of Canterbury, inasmuch as the annual
number of graduates in the three former is very
limited, and the power of the Archbishop of Canter-
bury is now never exercised. The number of Cor-
porate Institutions granting licences, then, will be
reduced to 15.

In the Germanic Confederation, there are 25.

In France there are 21.

In the United States, according to the American
Almanack of 1844, we have a liat of 28, all granting
degrees.

In this country there are 2 — King's Collrge and

M'Gill College.

We have now to estimate the relative proportion
of these Corporate Institutions to the populations of
the respective counirics : —

c
c

3
p

3
(»
n

o C

*ri

p s

■1

s ^-

1 ^

cu eu

_ . _ c«

f Upper C
\ Lower C

-1

93 P

b-*4

•

3 3

£.

p P

Cb CU

P P

• •

•

• •

•

• •

•

9*<

)— * h^

ki^

t-A

2 n

00* 00

S "

>u »t-

u o

tr» to

r —>

•^1

•

"oo

o m

■^

(;< ><::.

.^j

y< to

>c»

v-^-v-*.^

•

9'^

O 3

s=5-2

»C

iii

S £.o

»>

1— »

H-.

¥^

>-'

|S-

»-A

12,

P n

C. P

r n

**-.

1 00

"bi

1 c<

i;i

1 -»

1.^

It thus appears that we have already in this couu

with

will be

u O

try, nearly three liinea as many CoUcgety ccnfcr-
riiig degrees, in reference to the popiilution. at ob-
tains in Germany, France or Great Britain, and that
wc have even a greater relative proportion than is
met with in the United States, where the free trade
principle has run rampant, and where the cry of
" no monopoly" has ever been the order of the day.
Butindependent of the two Universities, we have
three medical boards, one at Toronto, Quebec, and
Montreal, which in accordance with the law, have
the power of licensing, irrespective of the Universi-
ties ; add to these again, the claim of the " New
School," with power to grant a diploma; the peti-
tion of tlw Marine Hospital of Quebec, and (as the
"sunset of LIFE," in the words of thc Scottish
seer, " gives mystical lore,") the phediction of Ihe
Montreal Medical Gazette, that thc next Session of
Parliament will witness the preferment of a claim.

223, which is a very limited number for the sup-
port of two schools, admitting tiiem to be equally
divided between both, and that all attended the lec-
tures, the latter of which is well known not to be the :
case. f

2. The inference is a matter of £ a. d. Let use
suppose, in the first place, that the students frequentn
the two existing Medicrl Schools in equal numbersji
in thc proportion of 1 1 1 1> < each. According to the pro-lj
posed Medical Bill, the pericd of study will be Iimit-i|
ed to four years, with one sessional attendance oni'I
certain branches of medical science; con»equently,|j
each lecturer will have the fourth part of that num-oi
ber annually in attendance on his lectures; givingrl
him an annual class of 27. Assuramg £3 to be theil
fee, (which is that of M'Gill College) he will reccivet;!
annually from hb class the sum of JC81 — and this for,^
a six monlhi' course of 120 lectures. But I haves^*

by a third party in this city, for powers similar to | now assumed the best feature of the case : there wilf
what the New Schoul is now demanding ; and let me be five schools, and tlie 223 students are to be divid-
ask of you, gentlemen, what will be lay what must i ed among the five ; albwing to each the large num-
be, the result of all thisl i^'ar^s then confirm thc first Uer of 44. This divided by 4 will give us by tlic ^
reasonable objecticn urged by the Medical Faculty, same rule the annual class of each lecturer, 11 stu- ;|'

Reason 2.— This contains an assertion similar | dents ; yielding him, according to the «ame scale ol ; f
in character to the preceding, and an inference ; ^^cs, the sum of £33, which is to be his « adequate ,;
drawn from it. Wc may therefore consider it under j remuneraUon" for all his toil and trouble, and out ol '
two heads. which all incidental expences connected with his ^

r. The exact number of students in medicine in jdass, are to be defrayed independently of the «ac-.
Canada, cannot be determined with any precision. ' quisition of thc necessary materials fur Uie illustra-
We may come near the truth by estimating tlieir tion of his lectures."

number according to the ratio which they bear to the
population of other countries. They " doubtless do

I have not in these statements, Gentlemen, strain-
ed a point, or tuken the slightest undue advantages

baar thc same proportion," and no reason can be ^ appears to me that I have discussed this question
asbigned why they should fall short of, or exceed that ftiirly and candidly. The pos.tiye evils which wil."
ratio. By an able writer in the last number of the ' ^^ cntaikd, require surely to be well considered be-
Quarterly Review, the number ofindividuals licensed fore a ruinous concession be made, to tlie crj
annually to practice in Great Britain is computed at \ of " "O monopoly," such " monopoly" having ir
fromS'JOtolOOO. Now as fi;ur years is then minimum i truth no existence. One certain effect will fol-
period of study, we may fairly estimate thc number of low— so surely as that concessici, L made,— thc lom-
medical students at 4000 on the lowest computation- \ P^t^te destruction of the Universities, which I havt
In tlie American Almanack for 1844, tlie number of | shjwn to be more than sufficient for every purpos< ;
students attending the difierent Schools in the United of such institutions in this Province. Canada L

States is given as 3177. The following table then
will give us a comparative view of thc number in
tliis country, estimated by the mean of the popula-
tion of the two countries divided by the mean of the
number of students : —

Population. Medical.

Ratio of students

Students

to population.

Great Britain 26,835,773

4000

1 (d) 6708

United States 17,063,353

3177

1 ^ 5370

Canada 1,199,704

196

1 ra 6120

Or estimated by the ratio whicii obtains in the
United Slates, which is considerably higher than
tlial ill Great Britain, tiuir number nill be

now an anomaly in the world, as regards the num-
ber of her Chartered Medical Schools to herpopi'la'
tion. What will she be when such schools arc mul-
tiplied %

Reason 3. — This is a self-evident proposition
or it may be viewed as a corollary to the two pre-
cedit.g reasons, and requires no demonstration noi
exposition.

I have the honor.

Gentlemen,
To subscribe myself ycurmost cbd't. scrvt.,

A. Hall, M.D

Montreal, February 17, 1345. -V

[^«r

Letter i:i.

AN KXPOSITION OF THE " REASONS " CONTAIN-
ED IN THE COUNTER PETITION OF THE ME-
DICAL FACULTY OF M'OILL COLLEGE.

Reason, IV. — Because from a desire to swell the
list ofstudtnts, and of those who annually
receive Diplomas, various temptations indc-

I pendent of pecuniary ones nay be held oul,

especially those of an inferior standard of
qualification and of assurance of license to

j practice wlien their curriculum is com-

i. pitted.

Reason, V. — Because the existing Provincial
Medical Boards Cimperfect though the Law
be under which they are constituted) are guile
adequate to the wants of the public in pre-
venting the admission of incompetent persons
to pi'actice,while they are not open to the same
temptation of grunting liienses to imper-
fectly p'-epared students, as rival Schools
would be.

ASON, VI. — Because if the privilege of granting
a Diploma equivalent to a license ad phac-
TiCANDUM be accorded, a bad precedent
would be established, and a similar boon
could not with any projmety be refused to
any number of similarly sdf constituted as-
socictions, which would assuredly have the
effect of lowering the standard of quulifica-
, tion and establishing a rivalry, nut us to
which School jvould produce thcbist educated
jnactitioners, but uhich uould grant iht:
greatest number of Diplomas.

i I
I

ft!

''o the Honorable the Members of the Legislative
Council and the Legislative Asiembhj.

i'rENTLEMEN, ,,, , ,. ,,. i

f Id continuance of our suljcct,we now arrive at llic
[^Fourth Reason" advanced by the Medical Faculty,
bd it is one that I npproacli not without feclir.gs of
Muctancc. The question which naturally arises is —
^ave practices such as are specified in the Reason
'•cvailed anywhere ? And if so, where '{ reply
■\at such proceedings have been practised in the ad-
'^ining Slates ; and I shall now substantiate what I
'ive affirmed :

^ About three years ago, an eminent Professor of

inatomy, from the United States, visited this city

ir the purpose of delivering h popular course of lec-

Bres en Anatomy. He stated to mysi If and to

liters, that he was desirous of establiahing in the

ollege to which he belonged as high a standard of

ifcdical attainment as possible, but thai it was itn-

[(ssible to accomplish that object, inasmuch as ma-

rf were permitted to get possession of biplonias at

);e Cnllege, whose qualidcations were7ieyt/subniit-

(^ to hiiri. The " Trustees" conceived it fur the

glcrest uf the Institution, in a pecuniary way, t3

gant them after the following very characteristic

»<»nn(>r: — lie was solicited by the Trustees to sign

. \ ihu conclusion of the Session, a nuiuher of blank-

Diplomas — he was requested to do this, ni>d trcourto
could hardly refuse so innucent a request. Out lliu
consequence of his doing so resulted simply in this,
the hatching of a fl jck cf M.D.V, wh?, without hav-
ing ever sulj.xted themselves to any examination,
CiJine forth to tiie world in the full-blown honors of
genuinely-made Graduates.

Again, I have tj state, upon the auth(,rity of a
Graduate in Arts of one of the first American Uni-
versities, that it is not an uneonmion practice in one,
at leastjof the minor Medical Schools in that country,
to add to its (lublislied list of Medical Students, thu
names of Students in the Faculty ofJrts, to inuko
that list as imposing as possible.

1 have further to state, and it is a matter of noto-
riety, thai French Canadian Sludents, who have
confessed their inability, when applying lor license
at the Me'iical Board in this city, to speak one word
of English, have resorted to ajme of tiio American
Border Colleges, in which not one word of French is
spoken, and that after a sessi >:ial attendance there
of a few weeks, they have received thvir degree
in Medicine.

And lastly, gentlemen, I have to state, onU I do
this on the authority of the Secretary of the Mon-
treal Medical Board, that since the organization of
lh;it board in 1839, of fifteen American Graduate's,
applicants for license to practice in this Province,
five were rejected; making one-third of the whole
number. Of one of these American Graduate^, I was
mys. If one of the examinators, uad I can testily to
his utter ignorance and inco npettncy.

Now, gentlemen, if these things are s?, mny not
tlie causes wliieh have led to them be with us, an
object of inquiry which deeply concerns us % May
we not with every justice and reason, nsk why De-
grees, the highest honours in any Faculty, arc con-
ferred on individuals utterly unworthy of them ?
Must not the preparatory examination,to which these
young men were submitted, have been but a mock-
ery 1 And is this one iota better than the awarding
of similar Degrees to individuals who never passed
any examination at all 1 Arc proceedings like tiiesu
calculated to elevate the cliaracter of any Profession
anywhere '{ Will not that Professional ciiaructcr
surely but slowly become degraded,Degrees and Di-
plomas become objects of contempt, and instead of
communicating to the holder respect and conlldcncc,
engender towards him suspicion and distrust 1
Amjng the mullitudu of causes which have con-
spired to this result, one of the most prominent, cer-
tainly, is i\vi undue pr )poraijn of tliesc Medical
Schools to the pipubilion. Each one of iheso Me-
dical Schinjls must live : every means, legitimate as
well as illegiiimate, honourable as well us disho-
nourable arc put into n.qnisiti ,n, on the ploa Ibat
llie end nill ScU.clion the nuN nx- I'hcir lixlit of

tbtiig
Surgery
Diploma
ubtained
which si
and will
with D(
Britain,
upon it i
Gentlem
sonable
why ih
not be 1
tu come \
possesaet
l»vo more
<'ornwall
'I'lien ;n(|
•I'lvantaj;

")AIPKT1

''IV ! Sci

courto
(ut tliu
ill lliid,
it liav-
natiuti,
xori of

ily of a
III tiii-
) in one,
iouiilry,
Ills, tllU
to iiittUo

of iioto-
ho have
r liceiivo
jno word
^inoricuii
S-VejitA ii
ice there
,ir dcjjrco

, and I <lo
the Moii-
Izadon of
JraduaU.'*,

Province,

the whole

itC^, I WU9

I testily to

mny not
i^ith UH, an
is '{ May
why Dc-
,arc con-
of them 1
hicli ttieiic
it a mock-
c uwarding
ever paiscd
;8 like these
i'rofussion
,1 eliaructcr
Ices and Di-
iiistuad of
eoiiftd<s"c<',
distrust 1
> iiave coii-
|niiicnt, cer-
!sc Medical
if llicse Me-
jcgiliniate as
[11 At dishu-
ic jtloa tiiat
litlr lii^U of

Students are ftctitious'y augmented in r.umbcr, and
(Jruduatcs are mad ■, no matter h»\ ; to demcnstratc
to the ivcrli), in the one case, the faciUlius which
the iiidividuiil schoul possesses for communicating
instruction, by its being a favourite rcscrt cf Stu-
dents, and in the second, tiie estimation in which
their Degree is held, by their large list of Graduates.
From this swtepi'ig denunciation, I cheerfully ex-
clude five or six of the higher Universities. The
time honored character whieh thry have eslii-
blishcd for themselves requires no such false allure-
ments for its maintenance, but to the; mass of the
petty Colleges it strictly applies. 1 desire not to
"insinuate" that similar practices would necessarily
obtain here, were the Medical Selioiils mulli,ilicd tc
ten times their number, but who could demmstrute
that they would not. Tliis much surely will be ad-
mitted, that we are men of " like passions aiid feel-
ings" witii our neighbours, and that by similar ac-
tuating causei, we would not be dissimilarly influ-
enced.

Reason, 5. — It requires no demonstration to
prove that tlie Provincial Medical Boards, uninHu-
enccd, and unaflccted by the causes which would
conspire to grant Diplcimas to improperly educated
Sludenls, would act in the most impartial manner.
They have notliing cither to gain or lose, hi the
passing; or rcj-ction of any Student ; and they are,
llierefdre, sufHcienlly " adeciuate to the wants cf ihe
public in preventing tlie uduiission of incompetent
pers'jns to practice."

Reason, G. — We now come to the nature
cf the request petitioned fur by the New School.
'J'his is the power of ecnferring a " Diploma or
Certificate." I ad nit lh;it thuy ask not for power
to grant " Degrees," but they do ask fur some-
tlihig nearly akin to it, for " Dipljmas are to
Surgery what Degrees are to Medicine." Their
I Diploma is to be a " certificate of qualification"
obtained after an examination before themselveSj
which shall be tantamount to a license to practice,
and will accordingly be placed on a perfect level
with Degrees, from the first Universities in Great
Britain, so far as subsequent permissicn to practice
up ni it is concerned. Concede this privilege once,
(ientlemen, and where are you to step 1 What rea-
s)nable objection will yju be enabled to advance
why the precedent, once established, should
not be accorded to all applicants for it in time
to come i Montreal will soo'i b;ast of three schools
possessed of similar powers ; Quebec will adi one cr
two more to the list : Tcrjiit), Kingston, Brockvillc,
Cornwall, will come in with their apjdications.
'I'hen indued v. ill be realized all tlie oveifljwinjj
ailvantaj^es which will result, from "healthy
loAiPKTiTiON," tl.c result o( the "no nionepoly"
cry! SctENCf will inlCLil Iv mimitily iiciiefitcd,

by the slrugii,Ies fer existence, and for "fameI
which all thess schoels will have to make ! PluccI
Gentlemen, by the concession of the Priyih go, upq
a level with the Universities, tic schools will drtl
the Universities uith them intj the same yawnir
gulph of degradation, which will inevitably open wi(|
before tiiem. This is a 'esult which will cerlainll
follow, and, Gi;iitlunien, 1 ask not too much of youl
hi requesting yuu to pause and ponder well the coiiJ
sequences of the concessi.n, before irrevocablj
rtcordii.g y^ur voles upon the question. Tliis letle
has exhibited the con sequences of an undue propoij
tion of schools to the pjpulation, upon the Profession
in the United States : it rests with yon,Genlltmen, 1
uinintain the respectability of the Proicssion herej
i)y av'jiding the causes which have tended to
iinpairiiieiit there.

I remain, ,^ , ,

Gentlemen, ■ .

Year obtdicnt servant, ■

A. liALL, M.D.

Montreal, Feb. 22, 1843.

Letter iV>

AN KXPOSITION OF THE " REASONS" CONTAIN-
ED IN THE COUNTER PETITION OF THE ME-
DICAL FACULTV OF M'GILL COLLEGE.

i.lEA90N, VII. — Because, suck evils in UniversUies
pussesaiiig Huyut Vfiurlers are efftctualbj ob-
viated bij t/ie general supeivisio exeiasid
by a Board of (Jovernors, uficse a. aesprin-
cipolly coiistst in the appointment ofcjficient
Teacacrs, in the eslablibhinent of tlie stand-
ard of quaiificalion for graduation, subject
to appiovul oy Her Majesty, and in causing
the faithful observance of every regulation
tending to that object.

Reason, VIII. — Because in the Petition of the
" College of Medicine" for an Act of Incor-
poration, ifc, Sfc, the petitioners have not
stated the curriculum which candidates for
their D'plomas would have to complete, nor
have they pledged themselves to the fulfil-
ment of any particular course of study, nor
have they specijied the duration of their
courses nor their nature.

Reason, IX. — Be<ause the duration of ihe course
of lectures now given in the " College of
Medicine" is tiille more than half tliat of
those delivered by your I'etitioners, viz. :
three and a half months or two courses in se-
ven moatht), while those delivered by your
Pttitioners are all of six months duration.
It is obvious, therefore, that the branches
cannot be so fully nor so explicitly taught as
those by your Petitioners.

Reason, X. — Because the power of conferring
Diplomas equivalent to a license ad prac-
TitANDUM (5 ?io/ cuj'jycd by any of the
jaatly celebratid MctiopoUlua or Provin-
dal ^'c/ioy/j in the MoUici CoH.:tri/, b,:l is

exdaxiviiy confined to the Univsrsities, the
Royal Colleges of Surifeont of London,
Dublin, and Edinburgh, the Worshipful
Company of ^pothecuriet of London, and
the Faculty of Physicians and Surv^cons of
Glasgow, the last two under certain Limita-
tions.

lb the Honorable the Members of the Legislative

Assembly.
Srntlemkn,

i Wlicrcver Corporate Mcdicil Iiislitulioiis do not
ixist in uii undue proportion to the population — it is
I Ihe interest of tluse Institutions that tlieir Degrees,
viplomus, or Certificates sliauld not be awarded to
kidividuals unworthy of thcni. These Dt!<;recs or

1 t)iplomas, then btcouics marks of merit or synibcU
' \£ honor to their possessors ; tliey arc proofs of their

lerfect competency to the full disciiargc of their pro-
essionui duties, and arc received and recognised as
iuch by the community at large. Honor and confi-
lilence are at once awarded to the hi^lder. The res-
icctability of the Profession is niaintuinci by tim
idmissiw'n into it of none but well informed, tlio-
^ 'oughly instructed persons, and this circumstance
i leccasarily acquires for the Institution in its turn
the well merited and implicit confidence of the pub-
lic. But a higher result than even this will obtain,
a result bearing in the most direct manner on Science

2 itself. The new members, thoroughly instructed,
and well grounded in every elementary department

"jof their Profession, emerge upon the tlieuire of lift
' prepared for every emergency ; aiid the foundalijii is
;jthus laid for future discoveries and improvements.
: Such, gentlemen, are the beneficial influences wiiich
il]Aai'e flowed from a regulated and due propoition cf
'i^iCorpuratc Medical Institutions to the population in
i>|Grcat Britain, France, and Germany ; three of the
finest enlightened nations on the earth, and in which
>(Medical character stands higher, and occupies a
',{more dignifl;;d position than in any otiier. The tvil
ticonsequcnces fl jwing kVom an opposite condition of
lithings, I have fully exhibited in my 1p ♦ letter. I
liwish not to draw the contrast in too strong coLurs,
1/ but I shall leave the inferences deduciable from the
u-stutemcnts which have been unfolded, to your own
gicalm and dispassionate judgments.
it. The general supervision cf a Board of Governors
ci cannot but be attended with most nalutary
e effects. They constitute a check upon licentious.
,<i nes3 in conferring Degrees on the one hand,

sion be once made,) would act in uuth niatlcrs as
l/uy pleased -, the power which would be entrusted to
thera might not be abused,but what guarantee would
Her Majesty's liege subjects here possess, that they
would not be placed under the tender mercies of in-
dividuals, whjse errors, be they those of omisaicn or
commission, would not je.pardizc their lives 1

Reasons 8 and 9.— It was stated in a " Reply"
to the "Counter-petition," that the Bill whic*!
would be submitted for your sanction. Gen-
tlemen, would contain " every particular respect-
ing the curriculum, the duration, as also the
nature of the courses of Lectures" and that these
" would be fully detailed in the Bill." — Now, the
Bill contains no information cf the kind whatever,
beyond tiie fact that the duration of the lectures is
to embrace a period cf six months, and include 120
'cclures, similar to what are now delivered in
M'Gili College. But of the " curriculum," and the
"nature of the courses" which young men wculd have
to complete, or Lllow, to obtain the diploma cr cer-
tificate, we are entirely ij^iiorant. Why the Bill
which it was said would contain a full detail of these
particulars, did not contain the same, and that too
after a sjiecific promise to that effect, we can only
conjecture. But the Bill, it appears, has as it standi,
obtained the sanction cf the Legislative Assembly ;
and to ensure its passing through the ordeal of
the Legislative Council, the word "diplema"
iins been struck out, with the obvious intention
of thereby implying that tlie " cerlificale of quuliii-
catioii,"is a matter cf no conscquenee whatever,tliat
it is not a Diploma, and may therefore be accorded
us a thing of trifling importance. If I can substan-
tiate, gentlemcn,that Diplomas are but "certificates
of qualification," and consequently that "certificates
of qualification" are Diplomas in the ordinary i^ense
of tlie term, it appears to me that I shall have
proved, that mutalo nomine, the request sougiit jor
is precisely the saoiC. 'I'hc Koyal College cf Sur-
geons of Ediiibui'gii grants a Diploma, and let us
now sec what the wordi'g of that diploma is : —

" Hisce Uteris testatur, viriim ingenicsum A. B.
Studiis pracscriptis rit6 peractis, examini sese sub-
jecisse : atque ita ad interrogata de iis respondisse,
ut muiieri tarn Chirurgico quam Pharmaceutico sus-
cipiendo omnind par esse videretur ;" which may
be thus translated ; " It is by these letters certified
that A. B., gentleman, haying completed in a

jf and are a guarantee to the public on the other, for proper and due manner the prescribed studier,
j« the maintenance of the standard of qualification, submiUed himself to examination, and so replied
^ and fv-r the faithful observance of all regulations uf- to questions concerning them, that l.e would ap-
,t fecting the arquisition of Degrees. Unfettered and pear to be, in all respects, qualified to un-
|!l uncontrolled by any superior authority, the " New (Lrtake the duties of a Surgeon and Apothecaiy."
f School of M'jdicinc," and all other schools to which ' Here, then, Gentlemen, is a Diploma cf the Royal
' a similar power would be dv-Iogatid, (*/ //^p fonf«- College ufSurgecns cf Edinburgh, and what is it,

ilcd to
would
it they
of i»-
Bicn or

Reply"
whic'i

, Gen-
rc»\'cct-
ilso tho
it these
low, the
iihatever,
cturcs is
;ludc 120
ivurcd i»
," and Ihc
rculd have
na or cor-
• the Bill
ail of these
,d that too
ve can only
ts it stands,
Assembly j
B ordeal of
" diplcnm"
IS intention
u of quuliii-
hatever,tliat
be accorded
;an substan-
"ccrlificates
"certificates
dinary sense
ll shall have
]st s-ught ijr
[ege of Jsur*
and let us
Ima is : —

Licsum A. o-
\\\\i sese sub-
reBi)ondis8e,
[laceutico sus-
^'» which may
pttcrs certified
uplcted in a
ribtd studieJ,
[lid 80 replied
|he would ap-
tlifitd to un-
Apothecavy."
cf the Koyal
Lnd what is it,

let me ask you, but a "certificate of qiialification."
It is, moreover, a license, ad practkanduin', and
what else does the New School ask for its "certificate
of qualification V They ask for a Diploma, to all
intents and purposes, and be the wording of tlic Hill
ill this respect what it may, it savours of deception
to attempt to disguise the fact.

Reason 10. — The last reason advanced by the
Faculty, why tlie power cf conferring Diplomas or
Certificates, should be denied to the " New School
of Medicine," is based upon tlie fact of the non-pos-
session of this power or privilege, by the British Me-
tropolitan and Provincial Schools of Medicine, in
number between 30 and 40. This power is restrict-
ed to 18 Incorporated Institutions at the utmost in
Great Britain, and it is this very restriction which
has produced such beneficial infiucncea upon tne
Profession there. The private sciiools in Britain
seek not a power or privilege of tiic kind . They
are satisfied with the simple recognition of their lec-
tures. And what valid grounds or reasons can be
urged, that the " New School of Medicine'* in this
city, fornr.ed, I may say, but yesterday, having cer-
tainly not yet completed their second course
of lectures, should enjoy a position which is
withheld from the British Metropolitan and Pro-
vincial Schools, nearly all of which are Schools
of eminence and celebrity, and in which a
large number of the most eminent medical men of
England, Scotland, and Ireland have considered it,
and do consider it, an honor to be teachers.

In conclusion. Gentlemen, I cannot refrain from
recording this opinion, that the question involved in
the petition of the " New School" has been made to
assume a feature, which is not warranted by any
circumstances connected with it. It has been dis-

cussed us n parly question, and has been^dccided H
the Lcgisiativn Assembly upon such grounds, nn«l
net upon its intrinsic mcritf. I have in these let
Icrs, carefully jdispassionalely, and candidly, review]
cd tlic position maintained by the Medical Facultj]
of M'Gill College. I have inquired into the validit}!
of their"reasonable object ions, "and tested, by an op
peni to figures and to facts, thry have not been fcuntij
wanting. In the tnsk which I have just complet'
cd, I have proved that we have already in thii|
country three times as many Corporate Insti-
tutions, granting Degrees, in reference to the po-
pulation, as obtains in Germany, France, or Great
Britain, and that we have actually a greater rela-
tive ratio tlian is met with in the United Staies.il
I have exhibited the efieels upon the Medical Pro-
fession, which are unavoidably concomitant with an
undue and unnecessary prcportion cf schools, — that;
that Professional Character has become degraded >
and from the examples of Great Britain, France and
Germany, I have pictured an opposite state of things,
the direct result of a due and regulated proportion.
It remains with you now. Gentlemen of the Legisla-
tive Council, to decide between the alternatives ; to
adopt the European practice, a limitation of Corpo-
rate Medical Schools, by which the rcspectab.hty of
the Profession will be maintained j or the American
one, a multiplication of such schools, by which it
will be assuredly lowered.

I have the honour to remain.

Gentlemen,
Your obedient servant,

A. Hall, M.D.
Montreal, February 25, 1845.