%. ^/%^.^^''-^^ /v ^ ^ ^^^ .o^^.^^^^-*^^ IMAGE EVALUATION TEST TARGET (MT-3) ^4 ^^SS' is^ ///// !<' O ,:^-w^. -Is V. 1.0 !.l Jfii^ IIIIIM 1^ 1^ III 2.2 !^ IJi^ III" i li^ IIIIIM 1.8 L25 iU nil 1.6 7] % V v^^ '/ Ef l\ CIHM/ICMH Microfiche Series. CIHM/ICMH Collection de microfiches. Canadian Institute for Historical Microreproductions Institut Canadian de microreproductions historiques 1980 Technical Notes / Notes techniques The Institute has attempted to obtain the best original copy available for filming. Physical features of this copy which may alter any of the images in the reproduction are checked below. L'Institut a microfilmd le meilleur exemplaire qu'il lui a 6t6 possible de se procurer. Certains d6fauts susceptibles de nuire d la quality de la reproduction sont not6s ci-dessous. D Coloured covers/ Couvertures de couleur n Coloured pages/ Pages de couleur □ n Coloured maps/ Cartes gdographiques en couleur Pages discoloured, stained or foxed/ Pages d^colordes, tachet6es ou piqudes Tight binding (may cause shadows or distortion along interior margin)/ Reliure serrd (peut causer de I'ombre ou de la distortion le long de la marge intdrieure) D D Coloured plates/ Planches en couleur 0Show through/ Transparence Pages damaged/ Pages endommagdes n Additional comments/ Commentaires suppldmentaires Bibliogsaphic Notes / Notes bibliographiques n Only edition available/ Seule Edition disponible Bound with other material/ Reli^ avec d'autres documents Cover title missing/ Le titre de couverture manque D D n Pagination incorrect/ Erreurs de pagination Pages missing/ Des pages manquent Maps missing/ Des cartes gdographiques manquent D Plates missing/ Des planches manquent D Additional comments/ Commentaires suppldmentaires I The images appearing here are the best quality possible considering the condition and legibility of the original copy and in keeping with the filming contract specifications. Les Images suivantes ont 6t6 reproduces avec le plus grand soln, compte tenu de la condition et de la nettet6 de I'exemplaire film6, et en conformity avec les conditions du contrat de fllmage. The last recorded frame on each microfiche shall contain the symbol —*' (meaning CONTINUED"), or the symbol V (meaning "END"), whichever applies. Un des symboles suivants apparaftra sur la der- nldre Image de cheque microfiche, selon le cas: le symbols — ► signifle "A SUIVRE", le symbols V signifle "FIN". The original copy was borrowed from, and filmed with, the kind consent of the following institution: Library, National Museums of Canada Maps or plates too lerge to be entirely included in one exposure are filmed beginning in the upper left hand corner, left to right and top to bottom, as many frames as required. The following diagrams illustrate the method: L'exemplaire filmd fut reproduit grSce d la g6n6rosit6 de I'dtablissemant prdteur suivant : Bibliothdque, Musses Nationaux du Canada Les cartes ou les planches trop grandes pour dtre reproduces en un seul cliche sont filmdes i partir de Tangle supdrieure gauche, de gaurhe d droite et de haut en bas, en prenant le nombre d'images ndcessaire. Le diagramrne suivant illustre la mdthode : 1 2 3 1 2 3 4 5 6 F IJE WAR' NOTES 1 i' ox PRIMITIVE MAN IN ONTARIO. >^: By ID.A.-VIID BO'YILiE l5KI\(i AN APPKXDIX. To TIIK UKPOUT OK TIIK .MIMSTKK OF KDUCATIOX Foil OXlAlllO. PRINTED BY oRhER OF THE LEOISLATIVE ASSEMBLY. ^■■^iii^' NATTai>iA.u. l^luSEUM OF CAKAuA TORONTO : 4 WARWICK BROS. & RUTTER, PRINTERS, Er. ., 68 and 70 FRONT ST. WEST. 189D. 008453 • « • • • • • • • • • • f ^tv^fii CONTENTS. Introductory from " Priniitivo Culture Contents Illu.strations Preface W'lieiicii Cduie the Indians / ... .\b(>rii,dnes i>f Ontario Sociiil Condition Fond Reliijion Medicine Men . Secret Soeietii'.s Biiriivl Cu.stonis Earthworks Pottery Cliiy Pii.fH Flaked Tools Stone Pipes Stone Hammers, . . Stone A.Nes or Celts Chisels (i'lUges Slate Knives Shell ()l)jects " Ceremonial '' «)bjects Stone Tul)L's lione Tools, etc Horn Implements Teeth 'J'otenis Miscellaneous Stune Carvinj^ Copper Implements, etc. Stone Discs Conclusion Appendix P.\OE. 1 iii. V. 3 5 12 14 . Hi 17 . . 18 . 19 . . 1!) . . 20 21 . ;J2 . 41 . 48 51) 't7 . 50 60 . 01 03 . 65 09 . 72 79 . 81 . 81 . 82 . 84 . 85 90 91 9:i '5 AG?. i ILLUSTRATIONS. 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. fi. 7. 8. 9. 10. 11. 12. 13. 14. 15. Ifi. IS. 19. 20. 21. 22. 23. 24. 25. 2ti. 27. 28. 29. 30. 31. 32. 33. 34 35. 36, 37, 38, 39, 40, 41, 42, 43. 44. 45. 46. 47. 48. 49. 50. Cliiy maak from pipe. Clay vessel. Patterns of fragments of pottery. Patterns on fragments of pottery. Small clay vessel. Small clay cup. Clay bowl. Cl.ay bowl (fragment). Clay bowl. Clay liowl. Clay vahe (re.stored). Clay bowl. Clay spoon. Large clay disli (rest')reci|. Clay pipe, long stem. Small clay pipe. Small clay pipe. Clay pipe, oval stem. Clay pipe bowl. Clay pipe. Clay pipe bowl. Clay pipe bowl. Clay pipe, perfect. Clay pipe, large. Fragment of clay pipe. Clay pipe, perfect. Clay pipe, perfect. CI:'y pipe bowl, human body. Human head from clay pipe. Clay pipe bowl, human head. Clay pipe bowl, human head. Clay pipe bowl, human head. Clay pipe, double human face. Clay pipe, human head, with headdress. Clay pipe bowl with human face. Clay pipe bowl of unusual form. Base of 37, showing human face. Clay pipe, human head and body. Clay pipe, human face awry. Clay pipe, human face looking upwards, mouth of face the bowl. Clay pipe, human face looking upwards, one eye the bowl. Clay pipe, pinched face and grotesque body. Clay iiipe, human face. Clay pipe, human figu-e with hat. Clay pipe, human face. Clay pipe, human body. Clay pipe, human head. Clay pipa, owl-like human face. Clay pipe, wolf's head (?). Clay pipe, fox's head (?). 52. Clay pipe, owl's head. 53. Cl»y pipe, eagle's head. 54. Clay pipe, double snake. 55. Clay pipe, snake's head. 56. Curved Hint knife. 57. Curved Hint knife. 58. Curved flint knife. 59. Curved Hint knife, 60. Curved Hint knife. 61. Unsymmetrical Hint knife. 62. Ijarge (piartzito spear. 63. Large (juart/.ite spear. 61. Large (juartzite spear. 65. t^uartzite spear. 66. Large chert tool. 67. Flaked knife, 68. Very finely Haked tool. 69. Flaked hoe or spade. 70. Coarsely Haked tool. 71. Flaked knife, 72 Neckless barbed arrow, 73. Neckless barbed arrow. 74. Arrow with notched neck, 75. Small necked arrow. 76. Fancifully shaped arrow. 77. Double notched lance. 78. Double pointed anow (?). 79. Flint saw (?). 80. Scraper. 81. Small drill. 82. Drill. 83. Drill. 84. Drill, edges bevelled only on one side. 85. Unfinished stone pipe, 86. Unfinished stone pipe. 87. Unfinished old form of stone pipe. S8. l^nfinished platform pipe. 89. Platform stone pipe. 90. Stone pipe for wooden stem. 91. Stone pipe for wooden stem, 92. Stone pipe for wooden stem. 93. Stone pipe for wooden stem. 94. Stone pipe for wooden stem. 95. Stone pipe for wooden stem. 96. Stone pipe for wooden stem. 97. Stone pipe for wooden stem. 98. Stone pipe for wooden stem. 99. Stone pipe for wooden stem. 100. Stone pipe, short stem. 101. Stene pipe, long stem. 102. Stone pipe, short stem. 103. Stone pipe for woodep stew. VI. lOJ, Stonr |>i|"', lircai Ktcni, liroken. 105. Stone pipf, iiKuJern a))|ifiirani'i>. 106. Ston*' pipe for wooden Hteui. 107. .Small Htone pipf, lOS. Stone pipe, IV >•// modern looking?, 10!t. Stone pipe, nioilern. 11(». Disc pipe. 111. Disc pipe, back of IKi. 112. Dine pipe, catiliiiite. 113. Stonr pipe, liiiiiian tij,'ure. 114. Stoiif i>i|ie, well curved luniian liiad. 115. Well carM'd human and animal heads from a stone pipe. IKi. Stone pipe, hnnian head. 117. Stone pil»', human head, lis. Stone pipe, Inimiin face, 119, Stone i>ipe, human heail. V20. Stone jiipe, hinnan Huuie seated. 121. White stone pipe with long stem. 122. White stone pipe. 123. I'ntiiiiiihi'd red stone pi|ie, eaghV head. 121 .Stone \>\\h; duck. 125. Stone pipe, ea>;le, 12(i. Stone jiipe, pantleT (?l. 127. Stone pipe, hear. 12iS. Stone pijie, owl. 129. Stone pipe, hawk. 12!)i(. .Stone pipe, li/ard. 130. Stone pii)e, animal. 131. Ston'- pipe, monkey (':}. 132. .Stone i)ipe, bird form. 133. Stone hammer. 134. Stone hannner, or perliap.'*, luavy i-inker. 135. Stone hammer with s(|Uaro face. 130. I'ntiiiislud celt. 137. Slightly grooved celt. 138. Deeply grooved celt. 139. Long stone chisel. 140. Stone axe, with coin entional human figure. 140((. Stone axe, with raised pattern. 141. Stone gouge. 142. Stone gi ii,','e. 143. Stone gfjuge. 144. Gouge and chisel. 145. Small stone g()ug(<. 14(>. Slate knife. 14()((. Slate knife with handle. 147. Slato knife with notchi-d neck. 148. Slate knife with serrated neck. 149. Mussel shell rubbed thin. 150. Mussel shell, jioiuted. 151. Busycon perversune. 152. Shell gorget. 153. Shell gorget. 154. Shell pin. 155. Shell gorget. 156. Slate tablet. 157. Small slate tablet. 168. Small ulate tablet. 159. Fine elate tablet. KiO. 1(11. 1(12. 1(13. 1(14. l')5. IfUi. I(i7. 1(18. 109. 170. 171 172. 173. 174. 175. 17(!. 177. 178. 179. 189. ISl. 182. 184. 1S4,/ 18.-), 180. 1B7. 188, l,yt. l»(i. 191. 192. 192<( 19-J/, 193, 194. litj. 190. 197. 198. 199, 200. 201. 202. 203. 204. 20'). 200. 207. 208. 20!). 210. 211. 212. 213, Untinished Hlate tablet. Small slate tablet. Slate tabl.t. Very small tablet, Slate tablet. Slate tablet. Notched slate tablet. Small slate tablet. Uniinished "banner stone ' or winged ob ject. " I'laiiner " or "butterlly " stone, " Banner " fctone. Horned " liauner" stone. i lorned " banner " stone. Apparently uniinished "banner" st'iie. Small " banner " stone. Unsyminetrical "banner" stone, " Ceremonial " axe. Bird amulet with large eyes. Bird iimulet, eyeless. Bird amulet with huge lyes. Bird amulet, eyeless, knot on he.id. Biar anndet. Bar amuli't. Bur amulet of \ery peindiar form, with a pro jection on the upper side and holes below from b ittoiii to side. Under sidu of 183. Bone harpoon or spear, one barb. Bone harpoon or spear, three barbs. Bone hai'|)uon, tliree double barbs. Bone tish hook. Bone needle, or awl, or pin. I'loiie netting needle. Bone pin. Bone pin. I'eforated leg lioiic. . Bone sf;rai)er. Bone scraper. Bone scrajier, knife form. Bone comb. Bone comb. Bone comb or line-marker Bone comb or line marker. 15on(! with tally marks, lione i)i[)e bowl. Bone marker. 15()ne line-marker. Bone line-marker. Bone line-marker. Bone pendant, tish. Bone pendant, mask. Bone pendant, human figure. Bone urnament ['!}, Bone, rubbed down. Horn chisel with hole. Horn cl'.isel, large. Horn Miong rounder or smoother. Horn arrow-shaft straightener. Horn arrow-shaft straightener. 214. 21,5. 210. 21 .S 219. 220, 220, 217. 22.-1. 229, !3U. 2H1. 232, 233. 231. l'3li. 237, 238. 239, K'fd (J a [no below 214. Ilnni ■irrow-j'liuftstrnisrhtpiier. '2U>. Heai'i* tuotli. 21(1. Ih'M iir wolf totem. 21S HfiiMT or otter totciii. 21 !l. Turtle totem. 220. Slate gorRet {':k •-'21. Sliite gorpet (:'). 222. Slate K'orgot I?). 22S. Slate t-'orget ('.'). 224. Slate gorget (?l. 22r). Slate ejriirop (?i. 22(!. Fibre twister i':\, 227. Fibre twister, end \ lew. 22.-!. Stone perforator ('.'). 229. Stone (?), VM. Small paint cup. 2;^]. Slate tube, lidllowed on one side, 232. Slate pebble, well bored. 2.'W, Carveil gypsum. 284. Carved human head in limestone w35. CoppiT s|)ear. l'H(i, C'oppir spear. 2H7. Copper speai'. 2.'i8. .Small copjier spear tip. 2.'{!(. Copper spear. VII. 2)0. C()p|)er a\e or chisel. 241. Copper ehise!. 212. Small copper knife. 243. Copper knife, modern foriu. iM4. Copper knife, modern fMrm. 245. Large eopper tool with siniUMis edge, an1. Copper arn.w or small spear. 262. Copper axe or chisel. 258. Copper a\e with speck of native silver. 254. Copper chisel 255. Copper axe. 25(1. Cojiper pend.mt. 257. Copi)er beads and pendant. 258. Copper ornament, 2,5I>. Copper (sheet) beads, on leather. 2(iO. Stone di.sc, hollowed. 2'!1. Stone disc, plain. 2(iS. Discoidal |iendant ('.'|. 2(iS. Discoidal pendant (r), Fig. 1. MaHk from clay piiie. FiDP! I'lhnitni Ciilhiii. liy K. 15. 'I'ylor. vol. ii., p. 400: "(Jnintod that iiivlii"ed to lie oil an ethnologist's writing table, is to him a very typu of primitivo culture, simple yet crafty, clumsy yet i>uri>oseful, li>w in artistic levid yet fairly st>irteil nn the ascent toward higliest tli'velopment — what then ^ Of couise the history and prehistury of man take their i>r(ipur jplaccs in the genei'al scheme of knowledge. Of cuurse the doctrine of the world-hmg evolution uf civilization is line which philosophic minds will take up with eager intero&t, as a theme nf .ibstract science. liut beyond this, such research has its iiractical side, as a source of power destined to influence the cuurse uf modern ideas and actions. To estal)lish a connection l)etween what unculturetl ancient men thought and did, what cultured modern men think and do, is not a matter of inapplicable theoretic knowledge, for it laises the issue, how far are modern upiniun and conduct based on the strong ground of soundest modern knowledge, or liuw far unly on suih knuwledge as was available in the earlier and ruder .'stages uf cultiu'e where their types were shajjed. It has to be maintained that tlie earlier history of man has its l)earing, almost igniired as that bearing has been by those wiiom it ought most stringently to efl'ect, on some uf tlie deeitest and must vital points uf our intellectual, industrial and social state " If we sttrvey the state uf educated o{)inion, nut within the limits of some special school, bur in the civilized world at large, on such subjects as relate to man, his intellectual and mural nature, liis place and function ' Ids fell>w men and in the universe at large, we see exist- ing sidii by side, as if of eiju; '■ , uiiiniuus uiost diverse in real authority. Some vouched jni' by dir and positive evidence, hold their gmund as s(did truths. Others, though founded iiw ciudest theories of the lower culture, liave been so modified under the inHuence of advanc- ing knowledge, as tu atlbrd a satisfactcry fr.unewurk for recognized facts ; and positive science, mindful of the origin of its own philoi>ophic schemes, must admit the validity of such a title. Oiho.s, lastly, are opinions belonging jiruperly to lower intellectual levels, which have held their plac? into the higher by mere force uf ancestral tradition: these are survivals. Now it is the DiMctical office of ethnography to make known to all whom it may concern the tenure of opin- iun.s in the public mind, to show what is received on its uwn direct evidence, what is ruder ancient doctrine re-shaped to answer modern ends, and what is but time-honored superstition ill the garb of modern knowledge." (1 I'.M.) PREFACE. Mfuiy tcaclitTs and otiitTs without cither time t»i' oijportuuity tn jl('^n^^(' tlie nmnei'dus works tliat liavc appcaivd, and arc a|ipoaring, on tlic .siil)jcct of priini- ti\e liFc in America, and who arc jiarticulai'ly desii-ous to know sonicthinrmer case an elevation of Heiings sea-bed to the extent of one hundred feet would form a land coiineetion, while in the latter there would be re(piii'e(l an upward movement of not less than three thousand feet to unite Norway, Iceland, Oreenland and the continent of America.. The same forces, however, ari' as cajialile of performing the greater as the lesser elevation, and it is nr.doulited that, in past ages the kind has risen and fallen in many places thousands of feet l)Ut why should we lie e.xpoeted eithei' to give rein to our imagination as to the route liy whieh man found his way to this continent, or to limit it as to the number of his landing places ' I'pholders of the various theories have, t(,> their own satisfaction, proved the possibility of voluntary ami involuntary migrants having reached Amei'ica, overland and by way of both oceans, from places 7,000 or S.OOO miles apart, and as much as H.ilQO miles by .sea from their point of l)servanci's and ciisti)nis, is most emphatically a native and not an imported article He belongH to the .K iierican continent as striccly as its opossums and armadillos, its mai/.e and its golden- rod, or any niemhers of its aboriginal fauna and Hora belong ti: it. In all probability he came from the Old World at some ancient period, whether pre-glaoial or postglacial, when it was possible to come by land; ■\nd here in all probability, until the arrival of wiiite men from Kurope, he remained undisturbed by later comers, unless the Kskimos may have been such. There is not a particle of evidence to suggest any con- nection or intercourse betweiii aboriginal A.nieric.i and .Vsia within any such jieriod as the lait twenty thousand years, except in so far as there may perhaps now and then liave been slight surges of Kskimo tribes back and forth across liering strait."--The Disc \ erv of America, p. 20, bv .lohii Fiske, Boston and New York, 1892. - 1 . . 1 tlmt is actually suggestive of this possibility ? Language lends no color to one common orijiin, neithiT does physique. In manners and customs thTe was quite as much variance as could ho found among similar savage peoples anywheie else in the world. Their resemblances to each other were human — not continental ; the natives were superstitious, vindictive and bloodthirsty, but even in these characteristics there was nothing to indicate a single centre of distribution. A few groups possessed the potentiality of advancement, but the majority were appar- ently at a standstill, while .some seemed to have become degraded from a former, not very high condition. It is (juite true that all this may have lieeii lnought about as the result of diti'erentiation from a coimiion stock duriuLi,' a pi'riod rxtending from the ice age to these diiys, l)ut it is ;it least (juite as reasonable to suji])ost' a variety of origins as the cause of the variations. If we admit the possibility, even at ly one man. beif Hricsen s xoyage was more ihan enndated by a crew that sailed in l.S.").S from Norway lo ("bieago in a large open galley eonstiucted on the ancient Viking model. Kxci'vone knows of the 2,0()ii mile Voyage made liy ('aptain liligli and bis companions in a ship's l)oat. when tliey Were sent adrift by the IJounty nnitineeis. A fiiend of my own acc(iini)lishe(l the distance between \'ork Factory ami Knglaiid in toni'teen days, the vessel measuring only sixty tons, and being deeply laden with tisb-oil. It is true that in all these instances, tbo>e in connnaixl knew where they were going, and except in IMigb's case were accordinixly well pro\ideil, bnt it is not at all inconceivable that iHimerous involuntary tri]i> were made by coast natives aci-oss both oceans, and. of conrse lia\iMg ivacbiMi .\meriea the voyageis were here to stay. It is not impossible that Polynesian >ea-rovers made oecasional Ioul; voyages along the coa> that tliese innni- '.'■rants made long voyages, but at most that thev crosscil lJrIiriiiL;'s straits. It is not impossible that tlie first migrations took p. ace at a time when what is now the channel of Behring's straits was occupied by an isthmus. The climate of those northerti shoics nuist then have lieeii much milder than at the ))resentday, for no cun-ents tVoni the frozen ocean could h:ive penetrated into the PaciHc. That the severance of Asia from Ameiica was, geologically speaking, very recent, is .shown by the fact that not only the straits but the sea which bears the name of Hehring is extraordinarily shallow, so much so indeed that whalei-s lie at anclu/r in the nndille of it. I!ut it is always dangerous to rely on geological events which themselves i'e(|uire more accurate proof. We tlieivfore prebi- to assuii.".; that at the tinn' at which the Asiatics passed over into America, l>ehiing's straits already possessed theii' [)r<'sent character. ... • i'liit the proof that the aborigines of America took this roa post-glK/iial pcrioilX- Dr. liabenicht also recognizes this condition of altairs and places it during the 'old stone ' aye in Europeij which corresponds to the ])ositioii assigned it liy McOee.' Citing other pioofs of a geological cliaracter, ])r. Brinton says : '" In con- sequence of such facts, the most careful Ih'itish geologists of to-day hold that the land connuunication, which certainly existed between Europe and North Ainerica * The evidences of a vast ice-.sheet once coverinff the whole of East Cape are plainly visible. See Dr. I. C. Rossc, Mtili'iif and Aiit/ini/hildi/ird/ Xnti « 'in Alanka, ]>. 2!>, Wasliingtnn, 1888. t I'Ik /kxcnit (if Afaii, \i. I'^i). I)r, Umloliih Hocrne.'*, howiver,.has recently argued that the discovery of such simian forms in the American tertiary as fhe AiKtiitomnrphux hoiiuninilun, Cope, renders it proba- ble that the aiitlirojioid ancestor of man lived in North America. The Anaptomorphus was a lemur rather than a monkey, and liad a dentition very human in character. i(.^uoted by G. F. Wright in the Ic Aiic in Atm ric:i, p. 583, i? He further sliows that at that time both northern Russia and northern Siberia were under water, which would effectually dispose of any ansiimed migration oy way of tlie latter. tauii unab ing 1 • >up COMCl art n anim disco tjneii Ine >■ discu pose( r It CO 1)V la it is upon 4 ] H < ireei IS no lu'sia i ] a""e a •i ot dri "> ago, H they wher ". ; •P ' are opi bv mea ■ exiflten on this ', which RiKid r the col( 5 dame et A +M i IK ■1- ■ 1894. •sliould I he Ipi'o- "lat + in Eocene times by wiiy of Iceland and Greenland, which was then a part of the American continent, eontintied to exist throuj^h the Miocene and IMiocein* ejiochs. This land briili^c formed a barrier of separation lietweeti the Arctic and Atlantic oceans, so that the ti;mperature of the hi;4her latitudis was much lailder than at present."' Ill a paper " On the N'arious Supp(»sed Relations batwecp t!ie American and Asian ilaces," read by Dr. lirintr-ii before tlie Aiithropulii^^ical ( 'onj^ress in (!hi<'an'o, even stronj^er exi)ression is i;ivcii by him in opposition to the Asiatic (jri^in of thf Aiiit'i'icaJi race. There "s room here to (piote oidy a few seiiteiiccs. The paper opens thus : " The isolation of I'.ie American lace fi'om the earliest pre- liistoric tin<.es seems to have been so complete, that any positive evidence that it was perceptibly intiuenced in its development, cithei- physical or psychical, by any (jflier race, is exceedingly scant, if it exists at all. As for myself, thoULfh cer- tainly w;llinics are skilfully and dis- passionately handled, and with an amount of independence and originality ((uite refreshinj;. Tln' following is the conchiding paiagraph under the; head of Testi- mony of Etlinogra[)hers and others : " I'inally, l do not thiid-c that such cumula- tive evidence is to be despised. All intelligent tivivellers are struck with the similarities existing between our west coast Indians and existing eastern Asiatics. It is true tliat those who have noted these resemblances have resorted to absiud theories to account tbr them: but false theoiy and good eni])iric results are not incomjiiitible. It is well known that «jur Kskimo have peopled a portit)n of north- eastern Asia, following tlie 'antage, ovi-n this would count for very little, as they must have made deflections both to reach resting places and to keep in view the Ifindnmrks by which they were guided. It is not clear from Prof. Mason's article vvhethei'he pre-supposes the eastern ciiiist of Asia to have been peopled durirg the early >oyages of the Indo-Malays. At all events, it eithei- was, or it was n.)t. If it was not, then the adventurers from the south would take possession bit l>y bit, until in the course of sojue centuries they reached Bering's stiuits. Meanwhile considerable differentiation must have taken place, so much so, that by the time offshoots fnjia these settle- mi'iits I'eached America, the variance between them and the pioneer voyagers would necessarily bi' very great, in language by natural laws, in manners and customs as the I'esult of changed environment. If", however, we are to undei- stand that, peopled or not peopled as this coast may have been, tlu; \)ioneer adventurers ]iursneil contimious and consecutive voyages from the Malayan arcliipelago along the eastern coast of Asia to the wesb-rn coast of North America, wc must hesitate before acknowledi^iiig eiil'cr its probability or its |?ossibility. ( )ii(! more point in i'l'of. Mason'-- napermay be considered. In bis foot note, which has here l)een <|Uoted, be avows his intention of trying to avoid anything tliiit "demands certain geological cbanges,'' and elsewhere he says •' let us not imagine any sulmiergence of the ocean l)ed, nor any geological nor pliysiogiaphi cal ciianges. nor any accidents out of the daily human (■N|ierience." This is very ^ool, but does be not ovi'rlook these conditions when lie writes, 'The evif tlir arcii witliin tlic limits ol' Ontario wiis (i(.'('U])ifil liy Viirii)us triln's lic'li»iii,MM;^f to the Alt^oiikiaii t'iiiiiily. Next in {iiiiiit od, and thoii' country re-occupicfl hy others or loft wholly desolate, within a comparatively lew years. In Ontario the Alijoidvins appear to have l>een )"presented hy a few trihes and l)anils in tho Ottawa valley, aiiout Lake Nipissiuj^, and aloni;' the north shores of Huron ami Superior. Kast, south and northwest they were nuno numerous. "They were Alt^onkins who n'reeted Jaci|Ues Oartitii'as his .ships ascended the St. Lawrence. The first British colonist founil sa\ ai^es of the same race hunting ami lishiiiif aloni;- the coasts and inlets of Virginia; and it was the daui^hter of an Algonkin chief who inteireded with her father for tlie life of the adventurous Hunlishman. They were Alyonkins who . waited war aL;ainst the I'uii- tans of New Kni;lanil They Were .Mn'onkins who, undei- the n'reat tree at Kensinuton, made the covenant with William I'enn ; and when French .li'suits and fur-traders explored the Wahash and the Ohio, they found (Jieir valleys tenanted hy the same far extemh.Ml race. At the present day the ti-aveller. per- chance, may find theua pitchiiiL; their liark lod;^fs alorn^- tlu; heaeli at Mackinaw, sjieariuij; fish amonu' the rapids of St. Maiy s, or skimminu' the waves of Lake Superior in their larch canoes.'"' 'J'he f(»rep;()iim' ipiotatiou suffices to show how widely sjircad wei'e peo}»le of this ifreat family, lait the opeiiinn' seuteuce, if taken hy itself, would lead us to conclude that the AJLioukiiis were the oidy Indians with whom ("artier came into contact in f">;i"). Such, however, is tiot the L;'eiH.'i'al opinion. I)i'. Horatio Hale says: ■ ('artier found Indians (.if the lluron-Ii'()(piois stock at Hochi.'la,i;a, anuel)ec. Centuries In-fore his time, accord- ing- to the native tra