491 F84 T7 I 8 fyxmll WLnivmih) ff itog BOUGHT WITH THE INCOME FROM THE SAGE ENDOWMENT FUND THE GIFT OF 34ciwg W. Sage 1891 Cornell University Library GN491.F84 T7 Totemism, by J.G. Frazer 9 1924 029 870 197 TOTEMISM A 11 rights reserved. ! f\ I i.M'i V Ml (,/;i;y TOTEMISM J. G. FRAZER, M.A. FELLOW OF TRINITY COLLEGE, CAMBRIDGE, AND OF THE MIDDLE TEMPLE, BARRISTER- AT-LAW. EDINBURGH: ADAM & CHARLES BLACK. MDCCCLXXXVIT. I 1 { i '. \ Y't ID-; ^tr^~ A-M-^ll Jr NOTE. Shcce the late J. F. M'Lennan first pointed out the importance of Totemism for the early history of society, various writers have treated of the subject and added to his materials, but no one, I believe, has tried to collect and classify all the main facts, so far as they are at present known. Accordingly, when the Editors of the new edition of the Encyclopaedia Britannica did me the honour of asking me to write the article Totemism, I had to do the work of collection and classification for my- self, with very little help from my predecessors. The materials grew under my hand till it became clear that only a selection of them could be given within the limits of an Encyclopaedia article. I venture, however, to put forth my full collection of facts bearing on savage Totemism, in the hope that it may help to lighten the labours of those who are working in the same field. On the question of the traces of Totemism among the civilised races of antiquity, I have collected a certain amount of evidence, but it is still too fragmentary for publication. I hope at a future time to examine the evidence fully. I regret that Mr Andrew Lang's Myth, Ritual, and Religion did not reach me till after my little work was passed for the press. A comprehensive work on Tattooing, by Mr W. Joest, is just announced by Messrs Asher and Co. of Berlin. JAMES G. FBAZEE. Uth October 1887. Cornell University Library The original of this book is in the Cornell University Library. There are no known copyright restrictions in the United States on the use of the text. http://www.archive.org/details/cu31924029870197 CONTENTS. Totem defined, p.l; orthography of totem, 1 sq. ; totem distinguished from fetich, 2 ; kinds of totems — elan totem, sex totem, indi- vidual totem, 2 ; religious and social sides of totemism, 2 sq. I. Clan Totems, 2-51 ; 57-82. Religious side of Totemism. — Descent from the totem, 3-7 ; marks of respect for the totem, 7-11 ; split totems, 10 ; totem taboos, 11-13 ; cross totems, cross-split totems, 13 sq. ; totem animal kept in captivity, 14 ; dead totem mourned and buried, 14 sq. ; totem not spoken of directly, 15 ; effects of acting disrespectfully to totem, 1 6-18 ; Samoan mode of appeasing offended totem, 18 ; Australian food taboos, 18 sq. ; diminished respect for totem, 19 sq. ; totem respects the clansman, 20 ; totem tests of kinship, 20 sq. ; totem ordeals and oaths, 21 sq. ; totem cures, 22 sq. ; totem omens, 23 sq. ; putting pressure on totem, 24 ; inanimate totems, 24-26 ; assimilation of a man to his totem by wearing skin, &c. of totem, 26 sq. ; by dressing hair in imitation of totem, 27 ; by knocking out or tiling teeth, 27 sq. ; by nose-sticks, 28 ; by tatooing, 28 sq. ; by painting, 30 ; totem carved or painted on huts, canoes, grave-posts, &c, 30-32 ; birth ceremonies, 32 sq. ; marriage ceremonies, 33-36 ; death ceremonies, 36 sq. ; initiation ceremonies at puberty, 38-47 ; social side of these ceremonies, 38-40 ; totem dances at initia- tion, 39 sq. ; other animal dances, 40-42 ; religious side of initiation ceremonies, 42-47 ; food prohibitions, 42-45 ; admission to life of clan by blood-smearing, &c, 45 sq. ; resurrection, 46 sq. ; new birth, 47 ; totem killed as piacular sacrifice, 48 sq. ; religious associations of North American Indians, 49 sq. Till CONTENTS. II. Sex Totems, 51-53. III., Individual Totems, 53-56. Social side of Totemism. — Blood feud, 57 sq. ; exogamy and endogamy, 58-69 ; phratries in America, 60-64 ; origin of phratries and of split totems, 62-64 ; fusion of clans, 64 ; phratries in Australia, 64-67 ; equivalence of tribal subdivisions throughout Australia, 67-69 ; Aus- tralian traditions as to origin of tribal subdivisions, 69 ; rules of descent, 69-79 ; female and male descent iu Australia, America, Africa, and India, 69-72 ; indirect female and male descent in Australian subphratries, 72- 74 ; sons take totem from father, daughters from mother, 74 sq. ; transition from female to male descent, transference of children, or of wife and children, to husband's clan, 76-79 ; cannibalism, 79-81 ; arrangement of totem clans in camp, village, and graveyard, 81 sq. IV. SUBPHBATKIC AND PlIEATRIC TOTEMS, 82-84. V. SUBTOTEMS, 85-87. Subtotems, clan totems, subphratric and phratric totems, how related to each other, 87 ; transformation of totems into anthropomorphic gods with animal attributes, 87-90 ; transformation of totem clans into local clans, 90 sq. Geographical diffusion of totemism, 91-95 ; origin of totemism, 95 ; influence of totemism on animals and plants, 95 sq. ; literature of totemism, 96. ADDENDUM. 47. The pretence of killing a youth at puberty in order that he may be born anew from his totem (the wolf), is probably the meaning of a ceremony described in Adventures and Sufferings of John M. Jewitt (Edin., 1824), p. 135 sq.; of. 37, 47. On initiation as a new birth, see also A. Bastian, Zut naturwissenschaftlichen Behandlungsweise der Psychologie, p. 128 sq. TOTEMISM. A totem is a class of material objects which a savage re- ■ gards with superstitious respect, believing that there exists ' between him and every member of the class an intimate and altogether special relation. The name is derived j from an Ojibway (Chippeway) word totem, the correct spelling of which is somewhat uncertain. It was first introduced into literature, so far as appears, by J. Long, an Indian interpreter of last century, who spelt it totam. 1 The form toodaim is given by the Eev. Peter Jones, him- self an Ojibway; 2 dodaim by Warren 3 and (as an alterna- tive pronunciation to totem) by Morgan; 4 and ododam by Francis Assikinack, an Ottawa Indian. 6 According to the abbe Thavenet 6 the word is properly ote, in the sense of "family or tribe,'' possessive otem, and with the personal pronoun nind otem "my tribe,'' kit otem "thy tribe." In 1 Voyages and Travels of an Indian Interpreter, p. 86, London, 1791. 2 History of the Ojebway Indians, London, 1861, p. 138. 3 "History of the Ojibways," in Collections of the Minnesota Historical Society, vol. v. (St Paul, Minn., 1885) p. 34. 4 Ancient Society, p. 165. 6 See Academy, 27th Sept. 1884, p. 203. 6 In J. A. Cuoq's Lexique de la. langue Algonquine (Montreal, 1886), p. 312. Thavenet admits that the Indians use ote in the sense of " mark " (limited apparently to a family mark), hut argues that the word must mean family or tribe. 2 TOTEMISM. English the spelling totem (Keating, James, Schoolcraft, 1 <&c.) has become established by custom. (The connexion between a man and his totem is mutually beneficent ; the Uotem protects the man, and the man shows his respect for the totem in various ways, by not killing it if it be an animal, and not cutting or gathering it if it be a plant. j As dis ting uished from a fetich, a totem is never an iso- ' lated individual, but always a class of objects, generally a species of animals or of plants, more rarely a class of inanimate natural objects, very rarely a class of artificial objects. 1 Considered in relation to men, totems are of at least three kinds : — (1) the clan totem, common to a whole clan, and passing by inheritance from generation to generation ; (2) the sex totem, common either to all the males, or to all the females of a tribe, to the exclusion in either case of ' the other sex; (3) the individual totem, belonging to a single individual and not passing to his descendants. Other kinds of totems exist and will be noticed, but they may perhaps be regarded as varieties of the clan totem. The latter is by far the most important of all ; and where we speak of totems or totemism without qualification, the reference is always to the clan totem. The Clan Totem. — The clan totem is reverenced by a ' body of men and women who call themselves by the name of the totem, believe themselves to be of one blood, de- scendants of a common ancestor, and are bound together by common obligations to each other and by a common 1 Expedition to Itasca Lake, New York, 1834, p. 146, &c. Petitot spells it todem in his Monographic des Deni-DindjiS, p. 40; but he writes oUmisme in his Traditions Indiennes du Canada Nord-ouest, p. 446. TOTEMISM. 3 faith in the totem. Totemism is thus both a religious and a social system. In its religious aspect it consists of the relations of mutual respect and protection between a man and his totem ; in its social aspect it consists of the rela- tions of the clansmen to each other and to men of other clans. In the later history of totemism these two sides, the religious and the social, tend to part company ; the social system sometimes survives the religious ; and, on the other hand, religion sometimes bears traces of totemism in countries where the social system based on totemism has disappeared. How in the origin of totemism these two sides were related to each other it is, in our ignorance of that origin, impossible to say with certainty. But on the whole the evidence points strongly to the conclusion that the two sides were originally inseparable ; that, in other words, the farther we go back, the more we should find that the clansman regards himself and his totem as beings of the same species, and the less he distinguishes between conduct towards his totem and towards his fellow- clansmen. For the sake of exposition, however, it is con- venient to separate the two. We begin with the reli- gious side. Totemism as a Religion, or the Relation between a Man and his Totem.- — -The members of a totem clan call them- selves by the name of their totem, and commonly believe themselves to be actually descended from it. Thus the Turtle elan of the Iroquois are descended from a fat turtle, which, burdened by the weight of its shell in walking, con- trived by great exertions to throw it off, and thereafter gradually developed into a man. 1 The Bear and "Wolf clans of the Iroquois 1 Second Annual Report of the Bureau of Ethnology, Washington, 1883, p. 77. 4 TOTEMISM. are descended from bears and wolves respectively. 1 The Cray- Fish elan of the Choetaws were originally eray fish and lived underground, coming up occasionally through the mud to the surface. /Once a party of Choetaws smoked them out, and, treat- ing them kindly, taught them the Choctaw language, taught them to walk on two legs, made them cut off their toe nails and pluck the hair from their bodies, after which they adopted them into the tribe. But the rest of their kindred, the cray fish, are still living underground. 2 ^ The Carp clan of the Outaouaks are de- scended from the eggs of a carp which had been deposited by the fish on the banks of a stream and warmed by the sun. 3 The Ojibways are descended from a dog. 4 The Crane clan of the Ojibways are descended from a pair of cranes, which after long wanderings settled on the rapids at the outlet of Lake Superior, where they were transformed by the great spirit into a man and woman. 5 The Black Shoulder clan (a Buffalo clan) of the Omahas were originally buffaloes and dwelt under the surface of the water. 6 The Osages are descended from a male snail and a female beaver. The snail burst his shell, developed arms, feet, and legs, and became a fine tall man; afterwards he married the beaver maid. 7 The clans of the Iowas are descended from the animals from which they take their names, namely, eagle, pigeon, wolf, bear, elk, beaver, buffalo, and snake. 8 The Moquis say that long ago the Great Mother brought from the west nine clans in the form of deer, sand, water, bears, hares, tobacco-plants, and reed-grass. She planted them on the spots where their villages now stand and transformed them into men, who built the present pueblos, and from whom the present clans are descended. 9 The Californian Indians, 1 Timothy Dwight, Travels in New-England and New-York (London,, 1823), iv. p. 184. 2 Catlin, North American Indians, ii. p. 128. 3 Lettres fidifiantes et Curieuses, Paris, 1781, vi. p. 171. i A. Mackenzie, Voyages through the Continent of North America, p. cxviii; Bancroft, Native Races of the Pacific States, i. 118. So with the Kaniagmuts, Dall, Alaska and its Resources, p. 404 sq. 6 Morgan, Anc. Soc., p. 180. 6 Third Ann. Rep. of Bur. of Ethnol., Washington, 1884, pp. 229, 231. Another Buffalo clan among the Omahas has a similar legend (ib., p. 233). 7 Schoolcraft, The American Indians, p. 95 sq. ; Lewis and Clarke, Travels to the Source of the Missouri River, 8vo, London, 1815, i. p. 12. 8 Schoolcraft, Indian Tribes, iii. 268 sq. 9 Schoolcraft, Ind. Tri., iv. 86. With the Great Mother Mr TOTEMISM. 5 in whose mythology the coyote or prairie-wolf is a leading personage, are descended from coyotes. At first they walked on all fours; then they began to hare some members of the human body, one finger, one toe, one eye, &c, then two fingers, two toes, &c, and so on till they became perfect human beings. The loss of their tails, which they still deplore, was produced by the habit of sitting upright. 1 The Lenape or Delawares were descended from their totem animals, the wolf, the turtle, and the turkey; but they gave precedence to the Turtle clan, because it was descended, not from a common turtle, but from the great original tortoise which bears the world on its back and was the first of living beings. 2 The Haidas of Queen Charlotte Islands believe that long ago the raven, who is the chief figure in the mythology of the north-west coast of America, took a cockle from the beach and married it; the cockle gave birth to a female child whom the raven took to wife, and from their union the Indians were produced. 3 The Kutchin trace the origin of their clans to the time when all beasts, birds, and fish were people ; the beasts were one clan, the birds another, and the fish another. 1 The Arawaks in Guiana assert that their clans are descended from the eponymous animal, bird, or plant. 5 Some of the aboriginal tribes of Peru (not the Inca race) were descended from eagles, others from condors. 6 Some of the clans Morgan compares the female deity worshipped by the Shawnees under the title of "Our Grandmother" (Anc. Soc, p. 179»). 1 Schoolcraft, op. cit., iv. 224 sq., cf. v. 217 ; Boscana in A. Robinson's Life in California, p. 298. Mr Stephen Powers, perhaps the best living authority on the Californian Indians, finds no totems among them (Tribes of California, p. 5). See, however, pp. 147, 199 of his work for some traces of totemism. 2 Brinton, The Lenape and their Legends, p. 39. 3 Geological Survey of Canada, Report of Progress for 1878-79, p. 149b sq. ; F. Poole, Queen Charlotte Islands, p. 136 ; Ausland, 6th October 1884, p. 796. Among the neighbouring Thlinkets the raven (Jeshl) is rather a creator than an ancestor. See Holmberg, " Ethno- graphische Skizzen ueber die Voelker des russischen Amerika," in Acta Soe. Sc. Fenniem, Helsingfors, iv. (1856) p. 292 sq. ; Baer and Helmersen, Beitr. zur Kenntn. des russ. Reiches, i. p. 104. So with the wolf in North-West America; it made men and women out of two sticks (Baer and Helmersen, op. cit., i. 93). In Thlinket mytho- logy the ancestor of the Wolf clan is said never to appear in wolf form (Holmberg, op. cit., p. 293). 4 Dall, Alaska, p. 197. 5 Im Thurn, Among the Indians of Guiana, p. 184. 6 Garcilasso de la Vega, Royal Commentaries of the Incas, pt. i. bk. i. chs. 9, 18. 6 TOTEMISM. of western Australia are descended from duck?, swans, and other water fowl. 1 The Geawe-gal tribe in New South "Wales believe that each man is akin to his totem in an unexplained way. 2 The Santals in Bengal, one of whose totems is the wild goose, trace their origin to the eggs of a wild goose. 3 In Senegambia each family or clan is descended from an animal (hippopotamus, croco- dile, scorpion, &c.) with which it counts kindred. 4 The inhabitants of Funafuti or Ellice Island in the South Pacific believe that the place was first inhabited by the porcupine fish, whose offspring became men and women. 5 The Kalaug, who have claims to be considered the aborigines of Java, are descended from a. princess and a chief who had been transformed into a dog. 6 Some of the inhabitants of the islands Ambon, Uliase, Keisar (Makisar), and Wetar, and the Aaru and Babar archipelagoes, are descended from trees, pigs, eels, crocodiles, sharks, serpents, dogs, turtles, &c. 7 Somewhat different are the myths in which a human ancestress is said to have given birth to an animal of the totem species. Thus the Snake clan among the Moquis of Arizona are descended from a woman who gave birth to snakes. 8 The Bakalai in western equatorial Africa believe that their women once gave birth to the totem animals ; one woman brought forth a calf, others a crocodile, hippopotamus, monkey, boa, and wild pig. 9 In Samoa the prawn or cray fish was the totem of one clan, because an infant of the clan had been changed at birth into a number of prawns or cray- fish. 10 In some myths the actual descent from the totem seems to have been rationalized away. Thus the Bed Maize clan among the Omahas say that the first man of the clan emerged from the water with an ear of red maize in his hand. 11 A subclan of the Omahas 1 Sir George Grey, Vocabulary of the Dialects of South- Western Australia, pp. 29, 61, 63, 66, 71. 2 Fison and Howitt, Kamilaroi and Kurnai, p. 2S0. 3 Dalton, Descriptive Ethnology of Bengal, p. 209 ; Asiat. Quart. Rev., July 1886, p. 76. 4 Revue d' Ethnographic, iii. p. 396, v. p. 81. 5 Turner, Samoa, p. 281. 6 Baffles, History of Java, ed. 1817, i. p. 328. 7 J. G. F. Biedel, De sluik- en hroesharige Rassen tusschen Selebes en Papua (The Hague, 1886), pp. 32, 253, 334, 414, 432. 8 Bourke, SnaJce Dance of the Moquis of Arizona, p. 177. 9 Du Chaillu, Explorations and Adventures in Equatorial Africa, p. 308. 10 Turner, op. cit., p. 77. 11 B. James, Expedition from Pittsburgh to the Rocky Mountains, London, 1823, ii. p. 48 sq. ; Third Ann. Rep. of Bur. of Ethnol. p. 231. TOTEMISM. 7 say that the reason" why they do not eat buffalo tongues and heads is that one of their chief men, while praying to the sun, once saw the ghost of a buffalo, visible from the flank up, rising out of a spring. 1 Two clans of western Australia, who are named after «. small species of opossum and a little fish, think that they are so called because they used to live chiefly on these creatures. 2 Some families in the islands Leti, Moa, and Lakor reverence the shark, and refuse to eat its flesh, because a shark once helped one of their ancestors at sea. 3 The Ainos of Japan say that their first ancestor was suckled by a bear, and that is why they are so hairy. 4 Believing himself to be descended from, and therefore akin to, his totem, the savage naturally treats it with respect. If it is an animal he will not, as a rule, kill nor eat it. In the Mount Gambier tribe (South Australia) " a man does not kill or use as food any of the animals of the same sub- division with himself, excepting when hunger compels; and then they express sorrow for having to eat their wingong (friends) or tumanang (their flesh). When using the last word they touch their breasts, to indicate the close relation- ship, meaning almost a part of themselves. To illustrate : —One day one of the blacks killed a crow. Three or four days afterwards a Boortwa (crow) named Larry died. He had been ailing for some days, but the killing of his leingong hastened his death." 5 Here the identification of the man with his totem is carried very far ; it is of the same flesh with him, and to injure any one of the species is physically to injure the man whose totem it is. Mr Taplin was reproached by some of the Narrinyeri (South Australia) for shooting a wild dog ; he had thereby hurt their ngaitye (totem). 6 The tribes about the Gulf of Car- 1 Third Report, p. 231. 2 Grey, Vocabulary, 4, 95. 3 Riedel, op. cit, p. 376 sq. * Reclus, Nouv. Geogr. Univ., vii. p. 755. 5 Stewart in Fison and Howitt, Kamilaroi and Kurnai, p. 169. 6 Native Tribes of South Australia, p. 64. 8 TOTEMISM. . pentaria greatly reverence their totems ; if any one were to kill the totem animal in presence of the man whose totem it was, the latter would say, " What for you kill that fellow 1 that my father ! " or " That brother belonging to me you have killed ; why did you do it 1 " x Again, among some Australian tribes " each young lad is strictly forbidden to eat of that animal or bird which belongs to his respective class, for it is his brother." 2 Sir George Grey says of the western Australian tribes that a man will never kill an animal of his Icohong (totem) species if he finds it asleep ; " indeed, he always kills it reluctantly, and never without affording it a chance to escape. This arises from the family belief that some one individual of the species is their nearest friend, to kill whom would be a great crime, and to be carefully avoided." 3 Amongst the Indians of British Columbia a man will never kill his totem animal ; if he sees another do it, he will hide his face for shame, and afterwards'demand compensation for the act. Whenever one' of these Indians exhibits,; his totem badge (as by painting it on his forehead), all per- sons of the same totem are bound to do honour to it by casting property before it. 4 The Osages, who, as we have seen, believe themselves descended from a female beaver, abstained from hunting the beaver, " because in killing that animal they killed a brother of the Osages." 5 The Ojibways (Chippesvays) do not kill, hunt, or eat their totems. An Ojibway who had unwittingly killed his totem (a bear) 1 Jour. Anthrop. Inst, xiii. p. 300. 2 lb., p. 303. 3 Grey, Journals of Two Expeditions of Discovery in North- West and Western Australia, ii. p. 228. 4 R. C. Mayne, British Columbia, p. 258. Lewis and Clark, i. p. 12. TOTEMISM. 9 described how, on his way home after the accident, he was attacked by a large bear, who asked him why he had killed his totem. The man explained, apologised, and was dis- missed with a caution. 1 Being descended from a dog, the Ojibways will not eat dog's flesh, and at one time ceased to employ dogs to draw their sledges. 2 Some of the Indians of Pennsylvania would not kill the rattlesnake, because they said it was their grandfather, and gave them notice of danger by its rattle. They also abstained from eating rabbits and ground-hogs, because " they did not know but that they might be related to them." 3 The Damares in South Africa are [divided into totem clans, called " eandas " ; and according to the clan to which they be- long they refuse to partake, e.g., of an ox marked with black, white, or red spots, or of a sheep without horns, or of draught oxen. Some of them will not even touch vessels in which such food has been cooked, and avoid even the smoke of the fire which has been used to cook it. 4 The negroes of Senegambia do not eat their totems. 6 The Mundas (or Mundaris) and Oraons in Bengal, who are divided into exogamous totem clans, will not kill or eat the totem animals which give their names to the clans. 6 1 J. Long, op. cit., p. 87. 2 A. Mackenzie, loc. cit.; Bancroft, i. 118. The dog does not appear in the list of Ojibway totems given by Morgan (A. S., p. 166) and P. Jones (Hist, of Ojehvay Indians, p. 138). 3 J. Heckewelder, "Account of the History, Manners, and Customs of the Indian Nations who once inhabited Pennsylvania and the neighbouring States," in Trans. Amer. Philos. Soc, Philadelphia, 1819, i. p. 245. This, combined with the mention of the ground-hog in the myths of their origin, points, as Heckewelder observes, to a ground-hog tribe or clan (ib., p. 244). 4 C. J. Anderson, Lake Ngami, p. 222 sa. 6 Revue d' Elhnographie, iii. p. 396. 6 Dalton in Trans, lithnolog. Soc., new series, vi. p. 36 ; Id., 10 TOTEMISM. A remarkable feature of some of these Oraon totems is, that they are not whole animals, but parts of animals, as the head of a tortoise, the stomach of a pig. In such cases (which are not confined to Bengal) it is of course not the whole animal, but only the special part which the clansmen are forbidden to eat. Such totems may be distinguished as split totems. The Jaganuathi Kumhar in Bengal abstain from killing or injuring the totems of their respective clans (namely tiger, snake, weasel, cow, frog, sparrow, tortoise), and they bow to their totems when they meet them. 1 The Badris, also in Bengal, may not eat of their totem, the heron. 2 The inhabitants of Ambon Uliase, Keisar (Makisar), Wetar, and the Aaru and Babar archipelagoes may not ea,t the pigs, crocodiles, sharks, serpents, dogs, turtles, eels, &c, from which they are respectively descended. 3 When the totem is a plant the rules are such as these. ■ A native of western Australia, whose totem is a vegetable, " may not gather it under certain circumstances and at a particular period of the year." 4 The Oraon clan, whose totem is the leaf of the Ficus Indicus, will not eat from the leaves of that tree (the leaves are used as plates). 5 Another Oraon clan, whose totem is the Kujrar tree, will not eat the oil of that tree, nor sit in its shade. 6 The Bed Ethnol. of Bengal, pp. 189, 254; As. Quart. Rev., July 1886, p. 76. Among the Muncla totems are the eel and tortoise ; among the Oraons the hawk, crow, heron, eel, kerketar bird, tiger, monkey, and the leaves of the Ficus Indicus. 1 As. Quart. Rev., July 1S86, p. 79. 2 Dalton, Ethnol. of Bengal, p. 327. 3 Riedel, op. tit., pp. 61, 253, 341, 414, 432. 4 Grey, Journals, ji. 228 sq. 5 Dalton, Ethn. of Bengal, p. 254; As. Quart. Rev., July 1886, p. 76. 6 Dalton, op. cit., 254; Id., in Trans. Ethnol. Soc., vi. p. 36; As. Quart. Rev., loo. cit. TOTEMIRM. 11 Maize clan of the Omahas will not eab red maize. 1 Those of the people of Ambon and Uliase who are descended from trees may not use these trees for firewood. 2 The rules not to kill or eat the totem are not the only- taboos ; the clansmen are often forbidden to touch the totem or any part of it, and sometimes they may not even look at it. Amongst the Omaha taboos are the following. (1) The Elk elan neither eat the flesh nor touch any part of the male elk, and they do not eat the male deer. 3 (2) A subelan of the Black Shoulder (Buffalo) clan may not eat buffalo tongues nor touch a buffalo head (split totem). 4 (3) The Hanga clan is divided into two subclans, one of which may not eat buffalo sides, geese, swans, nor cranes, but they may eat buffalo tongues ; the other may not eat buffalo tongues but may eat buffalo sides (split totems). 5 (4) Another subelan may not touch the hide of a black bear nor eat its flesh. 6 (5) The Eagle subelan, curiously enough, may not touch a buffalo head. 7 (6) A Turtle subelan may not eat a turtle, but they may touch or carry one. 8 (7) Another clan may not touch verdigris. 9 (8) The Buffalo-Tail clan may not eat a calf while it is red, but they may do so when it turns black ; they may not touch a buffalo head ; they may not eat the meat on the lowest rib, because the head of the calf before birth touches the mother near that rib. 10 (9) The Deer-Head clan may not touch the skin of any animal of the deer family, nor wear moccasins of deer skin, nor use the fat of the deer for hair-oil ; but they may eat the flesh of deer. 11 (10) A subelan of the Deer-Head clan had a special taboo, 1 E. James, Expedition from Pittsburgh to the Rocky Mountains, ii. p. 48 ; Third Rep. Bur. Ethnol., p. 231. 2 Riedel, op. cit., p. 61. 8 James, op. cit., ii. 47; Third Rep., 225. 4 Third Rep., 231. . 5 Third Rep., 235. 6 lb., 237. 7 lb., 239. There seems to be a cross connexion between the Eagles and the Buffaloes among the Omahas; for a. subelan of the Buffalo clan (the Black Shoulder clan) had a series of eagle birth- names in addition to the buffalo birth-names common to the whole clan (ib., 231 sq. ). 8 lb., 240. James (op. cit, ii. 49) says they " do not touch turtles or tortoises. " 9 James, loc. cit.; Third Rep. , 241. 10 James, loc. cit. ; Third Rep. ,244. 11 James, loc. cit.; Third Rep., 245. 12 TOTEMISM. being forbidden to touch verdigris, charcoal, and the skin of a wild cat. According to others, the whole Deer-Head clan was forbidden to touch charcoal. 1 (11) Another clan does not eat a buffalo calf. 2 (12) Another ,cran does not touch worms, snakes, toads, frogs, nor any other kind of reptiles ; hence they are some- times called Reptile People. 3 Of the totem clans in Bengal it is said that they "are prohibited from killing, eating, cutting, burning, carrying, using, &c," the totem. 4 The Keriahs in India not only do not eat the sheep, hut will not even use a woollen rug. 5 Similarly in ancient Egypt (a nest of totems) the shepp was reverenced and eaten by no one except the people of Wolf town (Lycopolis), and woollen garments were not allowed to be carried into temples. 6 Some of the Bengal totem taboos are peculiar. The Tirki clan of the Oraons, whose totem is young iniee, will not look at animals whose eyes are not yet open, and their own offspring are never shown till they are wide awake. 7 Another Oraon clan objects to water in which an elephant has bathed. 8 A Mahili clan will not allow their daughters to enter their houses after marriage ; a, Kurmi clan will not wear shell ornaments ; another will not wear silk ; another give children their first rice naked. 9 The Bechuanas in South Africa, who have a. well-developed totem system, may not eat nor clothe themselves in the skin of the totem animal. 10 They even avoid, at least in some cases, to look at the totem. Thus to a man of the Bakuena (Bakwain) or Crocodile clan, it is "hateful and unlucky" to meet or gaze on a 1 Third Sep., 245 sq. Verdigris was thought to symbolize the blue sky. 2 Third Rep., 248. 3 James, ii. 50 ; Third Rep., 248. 4 As. Quart. Rev., July 1886, p. 75. 6 V. Ball, Jungle Life in India, p. 89. 6 Herod., ii. 42, 81 ; Plut., Is. et Os., §§ 4, 72. Again the sheep was worshipped in Samos (Aelian, N. A., xii. 40; Clem. Alex., Protrept. , 39) ; and Pythagoras, a native of Samos, forbade his followers to wear or be buried in woollen garments (Herod., ii. 81 ; Apuleius, De Magia, 56). 7 Dalton in Tr. Ethnol. Soc., vi. 36. For the totem, Id., Ethnol. of Bengal, p. 254; As. Quart. Rev., 76. The reason of the taboo is perhaps a fear of contracting blindness. Some North American Indians will not allow their children to touch the mole, believing that its blindness is infectious (J. Adair, History of the American Indians, p. 133). 8 Tr. Ethnol. Soc, vi. 36. 9 As. Quart. Rev., July 1886, p. 77. 10 Cusalis, The Basutos, p. 211. TOTEMISM. 13 crocodile ; the sight is thought to cause inflammation of the eyes. So when a Crocodile clansman happens to go near a crocodile he spits on the ground as a preventive charm, and says, "There is sin." Yet they call the crocodile their father, celebrate it in their festivals, swear by it, and make an incision resembling the mouth of a crocodile in the ears of their cattle as a mark to distinguish them from others. 1 The puti (a kind of antelope) is the totem of the Bamangwats, another Bechuana clan ; and to look on it was a great calamity to the hunter or to women going to the gardens. 2 The common goat is the sacred animal (totem ?) of the Madenassana Bushmen ; yet " to look upon it would be to render the man for the time impure, as well as to cause him undefined uneasiness. " 3 A Samoan clan had for its totem the butterfly. The insect was supposed to have three mouths ; hence the Butterfly men were forbidden ' ' to drink from a cocoa-nut shell water-bottle which had all the eyes or openings perforated. Only one or at the most two apertures for drinking were allowed. A third would be a mockery, and, bring down the wrath of his butterflyship. " 4 Cross Totems. — Another Samoan clan had for its totem the ends of leaves and of other things. These ends were considered sacred, and not to be handled or used in any way. It is said to have been no small trouble to the clansmen in daily life to cut off the ends of all the taro, bread-fruit, and cocoa-nut leaves required for cooking. Ends of yams, bananas, fish, &c, were also carefully laid aside and regarded as being as unfit for food as if they had been poison. 5 This is an example of what may be called a cross totem, i.e.., atotem which is neither a whole animal or plant, nor a part of one parti- cular species of animal or plant, but is a particular part of all (or of a number of species of) animals or plants. Other examples of cross totems are the ear of any animal (totem of a Mahili clan in Bengal) ; 6 the eyes of fish (totem of a Samoan clan) ; 7 bone (totem of the Sauks and Foxes in North America) : 8 and blood (totem of the Blackfeet Indians). 9 More exactly, such totems should be 1 Livingstone, Missionary Travels and Researches in South Africa, p. 255 ; John Mackenzie, Ten Years North of the Orange River, p. 135m; Casalis, The Basutos, p. 211. 2 J. Mackenzie, op. cit., 391 sq. ; cf. Jour. Anthrop. Inst, xvi. p. 84. 3 J. Mackenzie, op. cit.. 135. 4 Turner, Samoa, p. 76. 5 lb., 70. 6 As. Quart. Rev., July 1886, p. 77. 7 Turner, op. cit, p. 74. 8 Morgan, A. S., p. 170. 9 lb., p. 171. 14 TOTEMISM. called cross-split totems ; while the name cross totem should be reserved for a totem which, overstepping the limits of a single natural species, includes under itself several species. Examples of such cross totems are the small bird totem of the Omahas, the reptile totem of the Omahas, 1 and the big tree totem of the Sauks and Foxes. 2 Sometimes the totem animal is fed or even kept alive in captivity. A Samoan clan whose totem was the eel used to present the first fruits of the taro plantations to the eels; 3 another Samoan clan fed the cray-fish because it was their totem. 4 The Delawares sacrificed to hares ; to Indian corn they offered bear's flesh, but to deer and bears Indian corn ; to fishes they offered small pieces of bread in the shape of fishes. 5 Amongst the Narrinyeri in South Australia men of the Snake clan sometimes catch snakes, pull out their teeth or sew up their mouths, and keep them as pets. 6 In a Pigeon clan of Samoa a pigeon was carefully kept and fed. 7 Amongst the Kalang in Java, whose totem is the red dog, each family as a rule keeps one of these animals, which they will on no account allow to be struck or ill-used by any one. 8 Eagles are kept in cages and fed in some of the Moqui villages, and the eagle is a Moqui totem. 9 The Ainos in Japan keep eagles, crows, owls, and bears in cages, and show a superstitious reverence for them ; the young bear cubs are suckled by the women. 10 The dead totem is mourned for and buried like a dead elnnsman. In Samoa, if » man of the Owl totem found a dead owl by the road side, he would sit down and weep over it and beat his forehead with stones till the blood flowed. The bird would then be wrapped up and buried with as much ceremony as if it had been a human being. ' ' This, however, was not the death of the god. He was 1 Third Rep., 238, 248. 2 Morgan, A, S., 170. 3 Turner, op. cit., p. 71. 4 lb., p. 77. 5 Loskiel, History of the Mission of the United Brethren in North America, i. p. 40; De Sohweiuitz, Life of Zeisberger, p. 95 sq. 6 Native Tribes of South Australia, p. 63. 7 Turner, op. cit., p. 64. 8 Raffles, Hist, of Java, i. p. 328, ed. 1817. 9 Bourke, Snake Dance of the Moquis of Arizona, pp. 252, 336. 10 /. A. I., ii. 252, 254; Id., iii. 239; Rein, Japan, i. 446 sq.\ Siebold, Ethnol. Stud, ueber die Ainos, p. 26 ; Scheube, Der Baeren- cultus und die Baerenfest der Ainos, p. 44 sq. Young bears are similarly brought up (though not suckled) by the Giljaks, a people on the lower Amoor, who are perhaps akin to the Ainos (Scheube, Die Ainos, p. 17; Revue d ' Ethnographie, ii. p. 307 sq.). TOTEMISM. 15 supposed to be yet alive, and incarnate in'all the owls in existence. " * The generalization here implied is characteristic of totemism ; it is not merely an individual hut the species that is reverenced. The Wanika in eastern Africa look on the hysena as one of their ancestors, and the death of a hysena is mourned by the whole people ; the mourning for a chief is said to be as nothing compared to the mourning for a hysena. 2 A tribe of southern Arabia used to bury a dead gazelle wherever they found one, and the whole tribe mourned for it seven days. 3 The lobster was generally considered sacred by the Greeks, and not eaten; if the people of Seriphos (an island in the .ffigean) caught a lobster in their nets they put it back into the sea ; if they found a dead one, they buried it and mourned over it as over one of themselves. 4 At Athens any man who killed a wolf had to bury it by subscription. 5 A Californian tribe which reverenced the buzzard held an annual festival at which the chief ceremony was the killing of a buzzard without losing a drop of its blood. It was then skinned, the feathers were preserved to make a sacred dress for the medicine-man, and the body was buried in holy ground amid the lamentations of the old women, who mourned as for the loss of a relative or friend. 6 As some totem clans avoid looking at their totem, so others are careful not to speak of it by its proper name, but use descrip- tive epithets instead. The three totems of the Delawares — the wolf, turtle, and turkey — were referred to respectively as "round foot," "crawler," and "not chewing," the last referring to the bird's habit of swallowing its food; and the clans called themselves, not Wolves, Turtles, and Turkeys, but "Round Feet," " Crawlers," and "Those who do not chew." 7 The Bear clan of the Ottawas called themselves not Bears but Big Feet. 8 The object of these 1 Turner, op. cit., p. 21, cf. 26, 60 sq. 2 Charles New, Life, Wanderings, and Lahowrs in Eastern Africa, p. 122. 3 Robertson Smith, Kinship and Marriage in Marly Arabia, p. 195. 4 Aelian, JY. A ., xiii. 26. The solemn burial of a sardine by a river- side is a ceremony observed in Spain on Ash Wednesday (Folk-Lore Record, iv. 184 sq.). 5 ayeipti ainif ra wpbs tt)v Ta. 134. 6 The Eev. R. H. Codrington in Trans, and Proc. Roy. Soc. of Victoria, xvi. p. 136. The Banks Islanders are divided into two exogamous intermarrying divisions with descent in the female line (ib., p. 119 sq.), but these divisions seem not to possess totems. TOTEMISM. 57 Social Aspect of Totemism, or the relation of the men of a totem to each other and to men of other totems. (1) All the members of a totem clan regard each other as kinsmen or brothers and sisters, and are bound to help and protect each other. 1 The totem bond is stronger than J the bond of blood or family in the modern sense. This is expressly stated of the clans of western Australia and of north-western America, 2 and is probably true of all societies where totemism exists in full force. Hence in totem tribes every local group, being necessarily composed (owing to exogamy) of members of at least two totem clans, is liable"' to be dissolved at any moment into its totem elements by the outbreak of a blood feud, in which husband and wife must always (if the feud is between their clans) be arrayed on opposite sides, and in which the children will be arrayed against either their father or their mother, according as descent is traced through the mother, or through the father. 3 In blood feud the whole clan of the aggressor is * responsible for his deed, and the whole clan of the aggrieved is entitled to satisfaction. 4 Nowhere perhaps is this solidarity carried further than among the Goajiros in Colombia, South America. The Goajiros are divided into 1 James in Narrative of the Captivity and Adventures of John Tanner, p. 313 ; P. Jones, Hist. Ojebway Indians, p. 138 ; Oeol. Sur. of Canada, Hep. for 1878-79, p. 134b; H. Hale, The Iroquois Book of Mites, p. 52; A. Hodgson, Letters from North America, i. p. 246; Morgan, League of the Iroquois, p. 81 sq. 2 Grey, Journ. , ii. 231 ; Report of the Smithsonian Inst, for 1866, p. 315; Petroff, Rep. on Alaska, p. 165. Other authorities speak to the superiority of the totem bond over the tribal bond (Morgan, League of the Iroquois, p. 82 ; Mayne, Brit. Columh., p. 257 ; American Antiquarian, ii. p. 109). 3 Grey, Journals, ii. 230, 238 sq. ; Smithsonian Rep. , loo. cit. * Fison and Howitt, 156 sq., 216 sq. Sometimes the two clans meet and settle it by single combat between picked champions {Journ. and Proc. R. Soc. N. S. Wales, 1882, p. 226). 58 TOTEMISM. some twenty to thirty totem clans, with, descent in the female line ; and amongst them, if a man happens to cut himself with his own knife, to fall off his horse, or to injure himself in any way, his family on the mother's side immediately demand payment as blood-money from him. I " Being of their blood, he is not allowed to spill it without paying for it.'' His father's family also demands com- pensation, but not so much. 1 J To kill a fellow-clansman is a heinous offence. In Mangaia " such a blow was regarded as falling upon the god [totem] himself ; the literal sense of " ta atua " [to kill a member of the same totem clan] being god-striking or god-killing." 2 | ^ (2) Exogamy. — Persons of the same totem may not marry or have sexual intercourse with each other. The Navajos believe that if they married within the clan " their bones would dry up and they would die." 3 But the penalty for infringing this fundamental law is not merely natural; the clan steps in and punishes the offenders. In Australia the regular penalty for sexual intercourse with a person of a forbidden clan is death. It matters not whether the woman be of the same local group or has been captured in war from another tribe ; a man of the wrong clan who uses her as his wife is hunted down and killed by his clansmen, and so is the woman ; though in some cases, if they suc- ceed in eluding capture for a certain time, the offence may be con- doned. In the Ta-ta-thi tribe, New South "Wales, in the rare cases which occur, the man is killed but the woman is only beaten or speared, or both, till she is nearly dead ; the reason given for not 1 Simons in Proc. R. Geogr. Soc, Nov. 1885, p. 789 sq. Simons's information is repeated by W. Sievers in his Reise in der Sierra Nevada de Santa Marta (Leipsic, 1887), p. 255 sq. 2 Gill, Myths and Songs of the South Pacific, p. 38. 3 Bourke, Snake Dance of the Moquis of Arizona, p. 279. TOTEMISM. 59 actually killing her being that she was probably coerced. Even in casual amours the clan prohibitions are strictly observed ; any violations of these prohibitions "are regarded with the utmost abhorrence and are punished by death." J Sometimes the punish- ment stops short at a severe beating or spearing. Amongst some of the Victorian tribes, " should any sign of affection and courtship be observed between those of 'one flesh,' the brothers or male relatives of the woman beat her severely ; the man is brought before the chief, and accused of an intention to fall into the same flesh, and is severely reprimanded by the tribe. If he persists and runs away with the object of his affections, they beat and ' cut his head all over, ' and if the woman was a consenting party she is half killed. " 2 An important exception to these rules, if it is correctly reported, is that of the Port Lincoln tribe, which is divided into two clans Mattiri and Karraru, and it is said that though persons of the same clan never marry, yet "they do not seem to consider less virtuous connexions between parties of the same class [clan] incestuous." 3 Another exception, which also rests on the testimony of a single witness, is found among the Kunandaburi tribe. 4 Again, of the tribes on the lower Murray, lower Darling, &c, it is said that though the slightest blood relationship is with them a bar to marriage, yet in their sexual intercourse they are perfectly free, and incest of every grade continually occurs. 6 In America the Algonkins consider it highly criminal for a man to marry a woman of the same totem as himself, and. they tell of cases where men, for breaking this rule, have been put to death by their nearest relations. 6 Amongst the Ojibways also death is said to have been formerly the penalty. 7 Amongst the Loucheux and Tinneh the penalty is merely ridicule. " The man is said to have 1 Howitt in Rep. of the Smithsonian Inst, for 1883, p. 804 ; Fison and Howitt, pp. 64-67, 289, 344 sq.; J. A. I., xiv. p. 351 sq. 2 Dawson, Austr. Abor., p. 28. 3 Nat. Tr. of S. Australia, p. 222. 4 Howitt in Ann. Hep. of the Smithsonian Inst, for 1883, p. 804. 5 Jour, and Proc. R. Soc. N. S. Wales, 1883, p. 24; Transactions of the Royal Society of Victoria, vi. p. 16. 6 James in Tanner's Narr., p. 313. 7 Collect. Minnesota Eistor. Soc, v. p. 42. i/ 60 TOTEMISM. married Lis sister, even though she may be from another tribe and there be not the slightest connection by blood between the two." 1 J In some tribes the marriage prohibition only extends to a man's own totem clan ; he may marry a woman of any totem but his own. This is the case with the Haidas of the Queen Charlotte Islands, 2 and, so far as appears, the Narrinyeri in South Australia, 3 and the western Aus- tralian tribes described by Sir George Grey. 4 Oftener, however, the prohibition includes several clans, in none of which is a man allowed to marry. For such an exogamous group of clans within the tribe it is convenient to have a / name ; we shall therefore call it a phratry (L. H. Morgan), defining it as an exogamous division intermediate between the tribe and the clan. The evidence goes to show that in many cases it was originally a totem clan which has undergone subdivision. Examples. — The Creek Indians are at present divided into about j twenty clans (Bear, Deer, Panther, "Wild-Cat, Skunk, Racoon, | Wolf, Fox, Beaver, Toad, Mole, Maize, Wind, &c. ), and some clans have become extinct. These clans 'are (or were) exogamous; a Bear might not marry a Bear, &c. But further, a Panther was prohibited from marrying not only a Panther but also a Wild-Cat. Therefore the Panther and Wild-Cat clans together form a phratry. Similarly a Toad might not marry a member of the extinct clan Tchu-Kotalgi ; therefore the Toad and Tchu-Kotalgi clans formed another phratry. Other of the Creek clans may have been included in these or other phratries ; but the memory of such arrangements, if they existed, has perished. 5 The Moquis of Arizona are divided into at least twenty-three totem clans, which are grouped in ten 1 Ann. Rep. Smithson. Inst, for 1866, p. 315. 2 Geol. Sur. of Canada, Rep. for 1878-79, p. 134b. 3 Nat. Tr. of S. Austr., p. 12; J. A. I., xii. p. 46. 4 Grey, Journ., ii. p. 226. Gatschet, Migration Legend of the, Creek Indians, p. 154 sj. TOTEMISM. 61 « phratries ; two of the phratries include three clans, the rest com- prise two, and one clan (Blue-Seed-Grass) stands by itself. 1 The / Chootaws were divided into two phratries, each of which included 1 ' four clans ; marriage was prohibited between members of the same phratry, but members of either phratry could marry into any clan of the other. 2 The Chickasas are divided into two phratries — (1) the Panther phratry, which includes four clans, namely the Wild- Cat, Bird, Fish, and Deer ; and (2) the Spanish phratry, which includes eight clans, namely Racoon, Spanish, Royal, Hush-ko-ni, Squirrel, Alligator, Wolf, and Blackbird. 3 The Seneca tribe of the Iroquois was divided into two phratries, each including four clans, the Bear, Wolf, Beaver, and Turtle clans forming one phratry, and the Deer, Snipe, Heron, and Hawk clans forming the other. Originally, as among the Choctaws, marriage was prohibited within the phratry but was permitted with any of the clans of the other phratry ; the prohibition, however, has now broken down, and a Seneca may marry a woman of any clan but his own. Hence phratries, in our sense, no longer exist among the Sonecas, though the organization survives for certain religious and social purposes. 4 V The Cayuga tribe of Iroquois had also two phratries and eight clans, but one phratry included five clans (Bear, Wolf, Turtle, Snipe, Eel) and the other included three (Deer, Beaver, Hawk). 6 The Onondaga-Iroquois have also eight clans, unequally distributed into two phratries, the Wolf, Turtle, Snipe, Beaver, and Ball forming one phratry, and the Deer, Eel, and Bear clans forming the other. 6 Amongst the Tuscarora-Iroquois the Bear, Beaver, Great Turtle, and Eel clans form one phratry ; and the Grey Wolf, Yellow Wolf, Little Turtle, and Snipe form the other. 7 The AVyandots (Hurons) are divided into four phratries, the Bear, Deer, and Striped Turtle forming the first; the Highland Turtle, Black Turtle, and Smooth Large Turtle the second ; Hawk, Beaver, and Wolf the third ; and Sea Snake and Porcupine the fourth. 8 The phratries of the Thlinkets and the Mohegans deserve especial attention, because each phratry bears a name which is also the name of one of the clans included in it. The Thlinkets are divided as follows : — Raven phratry, with clans Raven, Frog, Goose, Sea- 1 Bourke, Snake Dance, p. 336. 2 Archmologia Americana, Trans, and Collect. Americ. Antiq. Soc, vol. ii. p. 109; Morgan, A. S., pp. 99, 162. 3 Morgan, A. S., pp. 99, 163. p 4 Morgan; op. cit., pp. 90, 9J »/. 5 Morgan, op. cit, p. 91. 6 Morgan, op. cit, p. 91 sq. 7 Morgan, op. cit, p. 93. 8 First Rep., p. 60. 62 TOTEMISM. Lion, Owl, Salmon ; Wolf phratry, with clans Wolf, Bear, Eagle, Whale, Shark, Auk. Members of the Raven phratry must marry members of the Wolf phratry, and vice versa. 1 Considering the prominent parts played in Thlinket mythology by the ancestors of the two phratries, and considering that the names of the phratries are also names of clans, it seems probable that the Raven and Wolf were the two original clans of the Thlinkets, which afterwards by subdivision became phratries. This was the opinion of the Russian missionary Veniaminof, the best early authority on the tribe. 2 Still more clearly do the Mohegan phratries appear to have been formed by subdivision from clans. They are as follows : 3 — Wolf phratry, with clans Wolf, Bear, Dog, Opossum; Turtle phratry, with clans Little Turtle, Mud Turtle, Great Turtle, Yellow Eel; Turkey phratry, with clans Turkey, Crane, Chicken. Here we are almost forced to conclude that the Turtle phratry was origin- ally a Turtle clan which subdivided into a number of clans, each of which took the name of a particular kind of turtle, while the Yellow Eel clan may have been a later subdivision. Thus we get a probable explanation of the origin of split totems ; they seem to have arisen by the segmentation of a single original clan, which had a whole animal for its totem, into a number of clans, each of which took the name either of a part of the original animal or of a subspecies of it. We may conjecture that this was the origin of the Grey Wolf and the Yellow Wolf, and the Great Turtle and the Little Turtle clans of the Tuscarora- Iroquois (see above, p. 61) ; the Black Eagle and the White Engle, and the Deer and Deer-Tail clans of the Kaws ; 4 and of the Highland Turtle (striped), Highland Turtle (black), Mud Turtle, and Smooth Large Turtle clans of the Wyandots (Hurons). 6 This conclusion, so far as concerns the Hurons, is strengthened by the part played in Huron (and Iroquois) mythology by the turtle, which is said to have received on its back the first woman as she fell from the sky, and to have formed and supported the earth by the accretion of soil on its back. 6 1 A. Krause, Die Tlinlcit-Indianer, 112, 220; Holmberg, op. cit., 293, 313; Pinart in Bull. Soc. Anthrop. Paris, 7th Nov. 1872, p. 792 sq. ; Petroff, Rep. on Alaska, p. 165 sq. 2 Petroff, op. cit, p. 166. s Morgan, op. cit, 174. 4 Morgan, op. cit, p. 156. 5 First Rep., p. 59. 6 Ret des Jes., 1636, p. 101; Lafitau, Moeurs des Sauvages Ameriquains, i. p. 94 ; Charlevoix, Hist, de la Nouv. Fr., vi. p. 147; T. Dwight, Travels in New England and New 1'ork, iv. p. 180 sq. Precedence was given to the Turtle clan among the Iroquois (the kindred TOTEMISM. 63 This explanation of the origin of split totems is confirmed by the custom of calling each member of a clan by a name which has some reference to the common totem of the clan. Thus among the birth- names x of boys in the Elk clan of the Omahas the following used to be given to sons in order of their birth — Soft Horn, Yellow Horn, Branching Horn, &c. Amongst the men's names in the same clan are Elk, Standing Elk, White Elk, Big Elk, Dark Breast (of an elk), Stumpy Tail (of an elk), &c. Amongst the women's names in the same clan are Female Elk, Tail Female, &c. 2 Amongst the names of men in the Black Shoulder (Buffalo) clan of the Omahas are Black Tongue (of a buffalo), He that walks last in the herd, Thick Shoulder (of a buffalo), &c. 3 And so with the names of individual members of other clans. 4 The same custom of naming i clansmen after some part or attribute of the clan totem prevails | also among the Encounter Bay tribe in South Australia; a clan totem of that tribe is the pelican, and a clansman may be called, e.g., Pouch of a Pelican. 5 Clearly split totems might readily arise from single families separating from the clan and expanding into new clans, while they retained as clan names the names of their individual founders, as White Elk, Pouch of a Pelican. Hence such split totems as Bear's Liver, 6 Head of a Tortoise, Stomach of a Pig (see above, p. 10); such taboos as those of the subclans of the Omaha Black Shoulder clan (see above, p. 11); and such sub- clans as the sections of the Omaha Turtle subclan, namely, Big Turtle, Turtle that does not flee, Bed-Breasted Turtle, and Spotted Turtle with red eyes. 7 Finally, Warren actually states that the of the Hurons) (T. Dwight, op. cit., iv. p. 185; Zeisberger in H. Hale, Tlie Iroquois Booh of Rites, p. 5in), the Delawares (Brinton, The Lenape and their . Legends, p. 39; De Schweinitz, Life of Zeis- berger, p. 79), and the Algonkins(Leland, Algoiiquin Legends of New England, p. 51m) ; and Heckewelder (op. oil., p. 81) states generally that the Turtle clan always takes the lead in the government of an Indian tribe. In the Delaware mythology the turtle plays the same part as in the Huron mythology (see above, p. 5). 1 "Two classes of names were in use, one adapted to childhood and the other to adult life, which were exchanged at the proper period in the same formal manner ; one being taken away, to use their ex- pression, and the other bestowed in its place " (Morgan, A. S. , p. 79). 2 Third Rep., p. 227 sq. 3 /*., 232. 4 lb., 236, 237, 238, 239, 240, 241, 243, 244, 245, 246, 247, 248, 250 ; Morgan, A. S., p. 169m. 5 Nat. Tr. of S. Austr., p. 187. 6 P. Jones, Hist. Ojebway Ind., p. 138. 7 Third Rep., p. 240 sq. 64 TOTEMISM. numerous Bear clan of the Ojibways'was formerly subdivided into subclans, each of which took for its totem some part of the Bear's body (head, foot, ribs, &c), but that these have now merged into two, the common Bear and the Grizzly Bear. 1 The subdivision of the Turtle (Tortoise) clan, which on this hypothesis has taken place among the Tuscarora- Iroquois, is nascent among the Onon- daga-Iroquois, for among them "the name of this clan is Hahnowa, which is the general word for tortoise ; but the clan is divided into two septs or subdivisions, the Hanyatengona, or Great Tortoise, and the Nikahnowaksa, or Little Tortoise, which together are held to constitute but one clan." 2 On the other hand, fusion of clans is known to have taken place, as among the Haidas, where the Black Bear and Fin- Whale clans have united ; 3 and the same thing has happened to some extent among the Omahas and Osages. 4 We may also suspect fusion of clans wherever apparently disconnected taboos are observed by the same clan, as, e.g., the prohibition to touch verdigris, charcoal, and the skin of a cat (supra, p. 11 sq.). Fusion of clans would also explain those totem badges which are said to be composed of parts of different animals joined together. 5 In Australia the phratries are still more important than in America. Messrs Howitt and Fison, who have done so much to advance our knowledge of the social system of the Australian aborigines, have given to these exogamous divisions the name of classes ; but the term is objection- able, because it fails to convey (1) that these divisions are kinship divisions, and (2) that they are intermediate divisions ; whereas the Greek term phratry conveys both these meanings, and is therefore appropriate. 1 1 Collections of the Minnesota Historical Society, v. p. 49. 2 H. Hale, The Iroquois Book of Rites, p. 53 sq. 3 Geol. Sun. of Canada, Rep. for 1878-79, p. 134b. 4 Third Rep., p. 235 ; American Naturalist, xviii. p. 114 5 Acad., 27th Sept. 1884, p. 203. TOTEMISM. 65 We have seen examples of Australian tribes in which members of any clan are free to' marry members of any clan but their own ; but such tribes appear to be excep- tional. Often an Australian tribe is divided into two (exogamous) phratries, each of which includes under it a number of totem clans; and oftener still there are sub- phratries interposed between the phratry and the clans, each phratry including two subphratries. and the sub- phratries including totem clans. We will take examples of the former and simpler organization first. The Turra tribe in Yorke Peninsula, South Australia, is divided into two phratries, Wiltu (Eaglehavvk) and Miilta (Seal). The Eaglehawk phratry includes ten totem clans (Wombat, Wallaby, •j Kangaroo, Iguana, Wombat-Snake, Bandicoot, Black Bandicoot, Crow, Rock Wallaby, and Emu); and the Seal phratry includes .six (Wild Goose, Butterfish, Mullet, Schnapper, Shark, and Salmon). The phratries are of course exogamous, but (as with the Choctaws, Mohegan, and, so far as appears, all the American phratries) any clan of the one phratry may intermarry with any clan of the other phratry. 1 Again, the Wotjoballuk tribe in north-western Victoria is divided into two phratries (Krokitch and Gamutch), each of which includes three totem clans ; the rule of intermarriage is the same as before. 2 The Ngarego and Theddora tribes in New South Wales are divided into two phratries, Meriing (Eaglehawk) and Yukembriik (Crow) ; and each phratry includes eight totem clans. 3 In Australia, as in America, we have an instance of a tribe with its clans arranged in phratries, but with an odd clan unattached to a phratry. This occurs in western Victoria, where there are five totem clans thus arranged : First phratry, . I (1) Lon g- Billecl Cockatoo clan. 1 J I (2) Pelican clan. Second phratry, . j (3) Banksian Cockatoo clan. * ( (4) Boa Snake clan. (5) Quail clan. 1 Fison and Howitt, p. 285. 2 Howitt in Rep. of the Smithson. Inst, for 1883, p. 818. 3 J. A. I., xiii. p. 437m. E 66 TOTEMISM. Hero clans 1 and 2 may marry 3, 4, 5 ; 3 and 4 may marry 1, 2, 5; 5 may marry 1, 2, 3, 4. 1 But the typical Australian tribe is divided into two exogamous pliratries; each of these phratries is subdivided into two sub- phratries ; and these subphratries are subdivided into an indefinite number of totem clans. The phratries being exogamous, it follows that their subdivisions (the subphratries and clans) are so also. The well-known Kamilaroi tribe in New South "Wales will serve as an example. Its subdivisions are as follows : 2 — Phratries. Subphratries. Totem Clans. Dilbi. | Kupathin. -J Muri. 3 1 Kubi. I Ipai. \ Kumbo. ) Kangaroo, Opossum, Bandicoot, Padi- melon, Iguana, Black Duck, Eagle- hawk, Scrub Turkey, Yellow- Fish, Honey-Fish, Bream. Emu, Carpet-Snake, Black Snake, Red Kangaroo, Honey, Walleroo, Frog, Cod-Fish. In such tribes the freedom of marriage is still more curtailed. A subphratry is not free to marry into either subphratry of the other phratry ; each subphratry is restricted in its choice of partners to one subphratry of the other phratry; Muri can only marry Kumbo, and vice versa ; Kubi can only marry Ipai, and vice versa. Hence (supposing the tribe to be equally distributed between the phratries and subphratries), whereas under the two phratry and clan system a man is free to choose a wife from half the women of the tribe; under the phratry, subphratry, and clan system he is restricted in his choice to one quarter of the women. 1 Dawson, Austr. Abor., p. 26 sq. 2 J. A. I., xii. 500. 3 The names of the subphratries here given are the names of the male members of each. There is a corresponding female form for each, formed by the addition of tha to the masculine. Thus Muri — Matha (contracted for Muritha), Kubi— Kuhitha, Ipai— Ipatha, Kumbo — Butha (contracted for Kumbatha) (Fison and Howitt, p. 37»). In a tribe of western Victoria the feminine termination is heear (Dawson, Austr. Abor., p. 26) ; in a Queensland tribe it is an (Fison and Howitt, p. 33) ; in some tribes it is un or gun (Ridley in Brough Smyth, ii. p. 288). The tribe at "Wide Bay, Queensland, appears to have five subphratries, with male and female names (Ridley, loc. cit. ). In some tribes the male and female names of the sub- phratries are distinct words (see J. A. I., xiii. pp. 300, 343, 345). In describing the rules of marriage and descent these feminine forms or names are for simplicity's sake omitted. TOTEMISM. 67 The Kiabara tribe, south of Maryborough in Queensland, will furnish another example i 1 — Phratries. Subphratries. Totem Clans. Dilebi (Flood-Water), j Cubatine (Lightning), -j Baring (Turtle). Turowine (Bat). Bulcoin (Carpet-Snake) Bundah (Native Cat). |: Here Baring marries Buudah, and Turowine marries Bulcoin, and vice versa. A remarkable feature of the Australian social organiza- tion is that divisions of one tribe have their recognized equivalents in other tribes, whose languages, including the names for the tribal divisions, are quite different. A native who travelled far and wide through Australia stated that " he was furnished with temporary wives by the various tribes with whom he sojourned in his travels ; that his right to these women was recognized as a matter of course ; and that he could always ascertain whether they belonged to the division into which he could legally marry, ' though the places were 1000 miles apart, and the langu- ages quite different.' " 2 Again, it is said that " in cases of distant tribes it can be shown that the class divisions cor- respond with each other, as for instance in the classes of the Flinders river and Mitchell river tribes ; and these tribes are separated by 400 miles of country, and by many intervening tribes. But for all that, class corresponds to class in fact and in meaning and in privileges, although the name may be quite different and the totems of each dissimilar." 3 Particular information, however, as to the 1 J. A. I., xiii. 336, 341. 2 Fison and Howitt, p. 53 sq. ; cf. Brough Smyth, i. p. 91. 3 J. A. I., xiii. p. 300. 68 T0TEM1SM. equivalent divisions is very scanty. 1 Hence it often happens that husband and wife speak different languages and continue to do so after marriage, neither of them ever thinking of changing his or her dialect for that of the other. 2 Indeed, in some tribes of western Victoria a man is actually forbidden to marry a wife who speaks the same dialect as himself ; and during the preliminary visit which each pays to the tribe of the other neither is permitted to speak the language of the tribe whom he or she is visit- ing. 3 This systematic correspondence between the inter- marrying divisions of distinct and distant tribes, with the rights which it conveys to the members of these divisions, points to sexual communism on a scale to which there is 1 For a few particulars see Fison and Howitt, 38, 40 ; Brough Smyth, ii. 288; /. A. I., xiii. 304, 306, 346, xiv. 348 sq., 351. 2 Nat. Tr. of S, Austr., p. 249. 3 Dawson, Austr. Abor., 27, 30 sq. ; of. Fison and Howitt, p. 276. The custom observed in some places of imposing silence on women for a long time after marriage may possibly be a relic of the custom of marrying women of a different tongue [of. Haxthausen, Transkaukasia, i. 200 sq. ; ib., ii. 23 ; Krauss, Siidsl., p. 450; Hahn, Albanes. Sttid., i. 147). Hence too perhaps the folk-lore incident of the silent bride (of. Grimm, Kinder und Hausindhrchen, No. 3; Crane, Popular Italian Tales, p. 54 sq. ). In a modern Greek folk-tale which presents some points of resemblance to the legend of Peleus and Thetis the silent bride is a Nereid ; hence Schmidt conjectures with great probability that the expression of Sophocles, quoted by the scholiast on Pindar, Nem., iv. 60 (a66yyovs yd/xovs), means that Thetis was silent during her married life (B. Schmidt, Volksleben der Neugriechen, p. 116). Amongst the Caribs the language of the men differed to some extent from that of the women (see Rochefort, Hist, des lies Antilles, p. 350; LaBorde, " Relation de l'origine, &c. , des Caraibes," in Rec. de divers voyages faits en Afr. et en I'Amer., Paris, 1684, pp. 4, 39; Humboldt, Reise in die Aequinoctial-Gegenden des Neuen Continents, iv. 204 sq. (Hauff's German trans.); Im Thurn, Among the Indians of Guiana, 186 ; Lucien de Rosny, Les lies Antilles,^23, 261). So amongst the Mbayas in Paraguay (Azara, Voyages daAsl'AmSrique Meridionale, ii. p. 106). In the Booandik tribe, Soutlfciustralia, persons con- nected by marriage talk to each other in a Tow whining voice and use words different from those in common use (Mrs James Smith, The Booandik Tribe, p. 5). TOTEMISM. 69 perhaps no parallel elsewhere, certainly not in North America, where marriage is always within the tribe, though outside the clan. 1 But even in Australia a man is always bound to marry within a certain kinship group ; that group may. extend across the whole of Australia, but nevertheless it is exactly limited and defined. If endo- gamy is used in the sense of prohibition to marry outside of a certain kinship group, whether that group be exclusive of, inclusive of, or identical with the man's own group, then marriage among the totem societies of Australia, America, and India is both exogamous and endogamous ; a man is forbidden to marry either within his own clan or outside of a certain kinship group. 2 Native Australian traditions as to the origin of these various tribal divisions, though small credit can be given to them, deserve to be mentioned. The Dieri tribe has a legend that mankind married promiscuously till Muramura (Good Spirit) ordered that the tribe should be divided into branches which were to be called after objects animate and inanimate (dogs, mice, emus, iguanas, rain, &c. ), the memhers of each division being forbidden to inter- marry. 3 The tribes of western Victoria, whose totems are long- billed cockatoo, pelican, banksian cockatoo, boa snake, and quail, say that their progenitor was a long-billed cockatoo who had » banksian cockatoo to wife ; their children, taking their clan from their mother, were Banksian Cockatoos ; but, being forbidden by the laws of consanguinity to marry with each other, they had to introduce "fresh flesh," which could only be done by marriage with strangers ; so they got wives from a distance, and hence the introduction of the pelican, snake, and quail totems. 4 (3) Rules of Descent. — In a large majority of the totem tribes at present known to us in Australia and North 1 First Rep. , p. 63. Between North-American tribes " there were no intermarriages, no social intercourse, no intermingling of any kind, except that of mortal strife " (Dodge, Our Wild Indians, p. 45). 2 Of. First Rep., loc. cit.\ As. Quart. Rev., July 1886, p. 89 sq. 3 Nat. Tr. o/S. Austr., p. 260 sq. 4 Dawson, Austr. Abor., p. 27. 70 TOTEMISM. America descent is in the female line, i.e., the children belong to the totem clan of their mother, not to that of their father. In Australia the proportion of tribes with female to those with male descent is as four to one ; in America it is between three and two to one. The table which follows is a very rough one. For instance, the western Australians, given as one tribe, no doubt include many ; and it is possible that the western Victorian tribes given on Dawson's authority may include some tribes mentioned separately by other authorities. Table of Male and Female Descent. Australia. — Female Descent. — 1, "West Australians (Grey, Journ., ii. 226; Brough Smyth, ii. 267); 2 and 3, Ngarego and Theddora (/. A. I., xiii. 437); 4, Wakelbura (J. A. L, xii. 43); 5, Kunandaburi (ib.); 6, Mukjarawaint (ib.); 7, Yerrunthully (/. A. 1., xiii. 339, 342); 8, Koogo-Bathy (ib., 339, 343); 9, Kombinegherry (ib., 340, 343); 10, Wonghibon (Id., xiv. 348, 350); 11, Barknji (ib., 349, 350); 12, Ta-ta-thi (ib.); 13, Eeramin (ib.); 14, Wiraijuri (Id., xiii. 436); 15, Wolgal (ib., 437); 16, "Wotjoballuk (Smithson. Sep. for 1883, p. 818); 16-26, western Victorian tribes, ten in number (Dawson, Aust. Ab., 1 sq., 26) ; 27, Wa-imbio (Fison and Howitt, 291 ; Brough Smyth, i. 86) ; 28, Port Lincoln tribe (Nat. Tr. of S. Aust, 222); 29, Kamilaroi (Fison and Howitt, 43, 68) ; 30, Mount Gambier tribe (ib., 34) ; 31, Darling River tribe (ib.); 32, Mackay tribe, Queensland (ib.). Male Descent.— 1, Turra (Fison and Howitt, 285; J. A. I., xii. 44); 2, Narrinyeri (J. A. 1., xii. 44, 508; Nat. Tr. of S. Aust., p. 12); 3, Kulin(/. A. I., xii. 44, 507); 4, Aldolinga (/. A. I., xii. 506) ; 5, "Wolgal (ib.) ; 6, Ikula— partly male (J. A. I., xii. 509) ; 7, Kiabara (J. A. I., xiii. 336, 341); 8, Mycoolon (J. A. I., xiii. 339, 343) ; a large tribe or group of tribes (no names given) to the south of the Gulf of Carpentaria (/. A. 1. , xii. 504). The Gourn- diteh-Mara have male descent, but among them the rule of exogamy has disappeared (Fison and Howitt, p. 275 sq. ). "With regard to the Kurnai in Victoria, after all the explanations of Messrs Fison and Howitt, it remains uncertain whether descent in that tribe is female or male. The existence of sex totems among TOTEMISM. 71 them (which Messrs Fison and Howitt took as evidence that descent was "male as to boys, female as to girls") proves nothing. The tribe is organized in local districts, and apparently a man may take a wife neither from his father's nor his mother's district (Fison and Howitt, p. 226 sq.). How deceitful inferences from local prohibi- tions may be appears from Dawson's account of the western Vic- torian tribes. Among these tribes a, man may not marry into his father's tribe (which seems to be a local division). From this one might infer that descent was male. But in addition to these local exoganious divisions, there are among these tribes totem clans, and children belong to their mother's clan and may not marry into it. Therefore in these tribes descent is after all female (Dawson, Aust. Abor., p. 26). America. — Female, Descent. — 1, Thlinkets (A. Krause, Die Tlinket-Ind. , p. 231 sq.); 2, British Columbians (Mayne, Br. Columb., 258); 3, Haidas (Geol. Surv. of Canada, Hep. for 1878-79, p. 134b); 4, Loucheux (Smithson. Rep. for 1866, p. 315); 5, Kutchin (Dall, Alaska, p. 197); 6, Iroquois (Morgan, League of the Iroquois, 83; Id., A. S., 64); 7, "Wyandots or Hurons (First Report, 60; Morgan, A. S., 153); 8, Bella Coola Indians, British Columbia (Original-Mittheil. , 4c, i. p. 186); 9-17, Creeks, Semi- noles, Hitchetes, Yoochees, Alabamas, Coosatees, Natchez (Gatschet, Migration Legend of the Creek Indians, p. 153 ; Morgan, A. S., 160 sq. ; Archwologia Americana, ii. p. 109); 18, 19, Choctaws, Cherokees (Archmol. Amer., loc. cit. ; Morgan, op. cit., 162, 164) 20, Lenape or Delawares (Morgan, op. cit, 166, 172); 21, 22 Otoes and Missouris (Morgan, op. cit., 156); 23, Mandaus (Morgan op. cit., 158); 24, Minnitarees (ib., 159); 25, Upsarokas or Crow: (ib., 159); 26, Chickasas (ib., 163); 27, Menominces (ib., 170) 28, Munsees (ib., 173); 29, Mohegans (ib., 174) ; 30, Pequots (ib.) 31, Narragansetts (ib.); 32, Moquis (Bourke, Snake Dance, p. 230) 33, Goajiros . (Proc. Roy. Geogr. Soc, December 1885, p. 790) 34, Arawaks (Brett, Ind. Tr. of Guiana, 98 ; Im Thurn, Among the Indians of Guiana, p. 185). Male Descent— 1, Omahas (Third Rep., 225; Morgan, op. cit, 155); 2, Punkas (Morgan, loc. cit); 3, Iowas (Morgan, 156); 4, Kaws (ib.); 5, Winnebagoes (Id., 157); 6, Ojibways (Id., 166; Collect. Minnesota Eistor. Soc, v. p. 42); 7, Pottawatamies (Morgan, op. cit, 167); 8, Miamis (Id., 168); 9, Shawnees (Id., 169); 10, Sauks and Foxes (Id., 170); 11, Blood Blackfeet (Id., 171); 12, Piegan Blackfeet (ib.); 13, Abenakis (Id., 175). As to the totem tribes of Africa, desceut among the Damaras is 72 TOTEMISM. in the female line, 1 and there are traces of female kin among the Beehuanas. 2 Among the Bakalai property descends in the male line, but this is not a conclusive proof that descent is so reckoned ; 3 all the clans in the neighbourhood of the Bakalai have female descent both for blood and property. 4 In Bengal, where there is a considerable body of totem tribes, Mr Bisley says that after careful search he and his coadjutors have found no tribe with female descent, and only a single trace of it in one. 5 Colonel Dalton, however, states that the Kasias in Bengal are divided into exogam- ous tribes with descent in the female line ; and with regard to this people he mentions, on the authority of Colonel Yule, that " some individuals have a superstitious objection to particular kinds of food, and will not allow such to be brought into their houses. Is not this superstition, " asks Colonel Dalton very properly, "con- nected with their tribal divisions as amongst the Oraons of Chota Nagpur and the Beehuanas of Africa, who cannot eat the animal after which their tribe is named?" At least if this is not totemism, it is uncommonly like it. 6 In the exogamous clans or " mother- hoods " of the Garos in Bengal descent is also in the female line, and some of the Garo legends point to totemism. 7 It is remarkable either that these examples should have been overlooked by Mr Risley and his coadjutors or that both these tribes should have exchanged female for male kinship within the fourteen 8 years which elapsed between the publication of Colonel Dalton's work and Mr Risley's paper. With regard to the other undoubtedly totem tribes of Bengal (Oraons, &c), we may take it on Mr Bisley's authority that descent is in the male line. In the Australian tribal organization of two phratries, 1 Anderson, Lake Ngami, p. 221. 2 Casalis, TJie Basutos, p. 179 sq. 3 Because property may descend in the male, while kinship is traced in the female line, as with the natives of western Australia (Grey, Journals, ii. 230, 232 sq. ) and some Victorian tribes (Dawson, Austral. Aborigines, 1, 26). In Mota, Banks Islands, where kinship is traced in the female line, landed property descends in the female line (i.e., to sister's children), but personal property in the male line (i.e., to sons); but the practice is for the sons to redeem the land with the personal property. See the Rev. E. H. Codrington in Trans, and Proc. Roy. Soc. of Victoria, xvi. pp. 119 sq. 4 Du Chaillu, Journey to Ashango Land, 429 ; Id. , Equat. Afr. , 308 sq. 6 As. Quart. Rev., July 1886, p. 94. 6 Dalton, Ethnol. ofBeng. , p. 56 sq. 7 Dalton, op. cit. , 60, 63. Or seven years, if we accept the statements in the Indian Antiquary viii. (1879) p. 205 ; but these may be borrowed from Colonel Dalton. TOTEMISM. 73 four subphratries, and totem clans, there occurs a peculiar form of descent of which no plausible explanation has yet been offered. It seems that in all tribes thus organized the children are born into the subphratry neither of their father nor of their mother, and that descent in such cases is either female or male, according as the subphratry into which the children are born is the companion subphratry of their mother's or of their father's subphratry. In the former case we have what may be called indirect female descent ; in the latter, indirect male descent. But it is only in the subphratry that descent is thus indirect. In the totem clan it is always direct ; the child belongs to the clan either of its mother or of its father. Thus in the typical Australian organization, descent, whether female or male, is direct in the phratry, indirect in the sub- phratry, and direct in the clan. To take examples, the following is the scheme of descent, so far as the phratries and subphratries are concerned, in the Kamilaroi. Phratries. Male. Marries Children are Dilbi. [ Kupathin. J Muri. Kubi. Ipai. Kumbo. Kumbo. Ipai. Kubi. Muri. Ipai. Kumbo. Muri. Kubi. This is an example of indirect female descent, because the children belong to the companion subphratry of their mother, not to the companion subphratry of their father. But in the totems the female descent is direct ; e.g., if the father is Muri-Kangaroo and the mother is Kumbo- Emu, the children will be Ipai-Emu; if the mother is Kumbo-Bandicoot the children will be Ipai-Bandicoot. 1 1 Fison and Howitt, p. 37 sq.; J. A. I., xiii. 335, 341, 344. 74 TOTEMISM. The following is the scheme of descent in the Kiabara tribe : J — Phratries. Male. Marries Children are Dilehi. j Cubatine. 4 Baring. Turowine. Bulcoin. Bundah. Bundah. Bulcoin. Turowine. Baring. Turowine. Baring. Bundah. Bulcoin. This is an example of indirect male descent, because the children belong to the companion subphratry of their father, not to the companion subphratry of their mother. We have no information as to the totems, but on the analogy of indirect female descent we should expect them to be taken from the father. This at any rate is true of a large tribe or group of tribes to the south of the Gulf of Carpentaria ; their rules of marriage and descent, so far as concerns the subphratries, are like those of the Kiabara, and the totems (which at the lower Leichhardt river are the names of fish) are inherited from father to son. 2 In some Australian tribes sons take their totem from their father and daughters from their mother. Thus the Dieri in South Australia are divided into two phratries, each of which includes under it sixteen totem clans (Caterpillar, Mullet, Dog, Eat, Kangaroo, Frog, Crow, &c.) ; 8 and if a Dog man marries a Eat woman, the sons of this marriage are Dogs and the daughters are Eats. 4 The Ikula (Morning Star)' 1 tribe, at the head of the Great Australian Bight, has, with certain exceptions, the same 1 J. A. I., xiii. 336, 341. 2 J. A. I., xii. 504. Mr Howitt, to whom we are indebted for this information, omits to give the names of the tribe and its subdivisions. s /. A. I., xii. 500. 4 Letter of Mr S. Gason to the present writer. TOTEMISM. 75 rule of descent. 1 The tribe includes four totem clans, namely, Budera (Root), Kura (Native Dog), Budu (Digger), and Wenung (Wombat). The rules of marriage and descent are as follows : — Male. Marries Children are (m.) 2 Budera... \ (f.) Kura (m.) Budera; (f.) Kura. (m. ) and (f. ) Budera. (m. ) Kuru ; (f . ) Budera. (m.) and (f.) Kura. (m.) Budu; (f.) "Wenung. (m.) Wenung; (f.) Budu. or (f. ) Wenung or (f.)Budu (f.) Budu Here, in all cases except two, the son takes his totem from his father, the daughter from her mother. The ex- ceptions are where Budera (m.) marries Wenung (f.), and where Kura (m.) marries Budu (f.) ; in both which cases the children, whether sons or daughters, take their father's totem. This, combined with the fact that no male of Budu or Wenung is allowed to marry a female of Budera or Kura, points, as Mr Howitt says, to a superiority of Budera and Kura over Budu and Wenung. It is obvious that the totems of the Dieri and Ikula are not sex totems. A sex totem is confined to members of one sex j whereas all the totems of the Dieri and Ikula are common to both men and women. It is of these totems (and not of sex totems) that it may be said in the words of Messrs Fison and Howitt, that descent is " male as to boys, female as to girls." 3 1 J. A. I., xii. 509. 2 m. =male; f. =female. 3 /. A. I., xii. 45. Tha opposite rule of descent (sons belong to 76 TOTEMISM. Besides the tribes whose line of descent is definitely fixed in the female or male line, or, as with the Dieri and Ikula, half-way between the two, there are a number of tribes which are wavering between female and male descent ; amongst whom, in other words, a child may be entered in either his mother's or his father's clan. After the researches of Bachofen, M'Lennan, and Morgan, we may be sure that such a wavering marks a transition from female to male descent, and not conversely. Among the Haidas, children regularly belong to the totem clan of their mother ; but in very exceptional cases, when the clan of the father is reduced in numbers, the newly born child may be given to the father's sister to suckle. It is then spoken of as belonging to the paternal aunt, and is counted to its father's clan. 1 Amongst the Dela wares descent is regularly in the female line ; but it is possible to transfer a child to its father's clan by giving it one of the names which are appropriated to the father's clan. 2 A similar practice prevails with the Shawnees, except that with them male descent is the rule and transference to the mother's clan (or any other clan) by naming is the excep- tion. 3 In the Hervey Islands, South Pacific, the parents settled beforehand whether the child should belong to the father's or mother's clan. The father usually had the pre- ference, but sometimes, when the father's clan was one which was bound to furnish human victims from its ranks, the mother had it adopted into her clan by having the the mother's, daughters to the father's family) is observed in the islands of Leti, Moa, and Lakor (Riedel, op. cit., pp. 384, 392). 1 Oeol. Surv. of Canada, Rep. for 1878-79, p. 134b. 2 Morgan, A. S., p. 172 sq. 3 lb., 169. TOTEMISM. 77 name of her totem pronounced over it. 1 In Samoa at the birth of a child the father's totem was usually prayed to first ; but if the birth was tedious, the mother's totem was invoked ; and whichever happened to be invoked at the moment of birth was the child's totem for life. 2 These modes of effecting the change of kin touched only the children ; others affected the children through the mother ; they were transferred to their father's clan by the previous transference of the mother. This, as M'Lennan has observed, was perhaps the intention and doubtless must have been the effect of the custom in Guinea of dedicating one wife to the husband's Bossum or god. 3 The transfer- ence of the wife to the husband's clan seems to have been the intention of smearing bride and bridegroom with each other's blood. 4 Amongst some of the totem clans of Bengal the bride is transferred to the husband's clan by ceremoniously eating or drinking with him. 5 Another mode is to purchase the woman and her offspring. 1 Gill, Myths and Songs of the South Pacific, p. 36. 2 Turner, Samoa, p. 78 sq. The child might thus be transferred to a clan which was that neither of his father nor of his mother (see above, p. 55). 3 M'Lennan, Patriarchal Theory, 235 sq. ; Bosman's " Guinea'' in Pinkerton's Voyages and Travels, xvi. 420. 4 Dalton, Eth. ofBeng., p. 220. In some parts of New Guinea bride and bridegroom draw blood from each other's foreheads (S. Miiller, Reizen en Onderzoekingen in den Indischen Archipel, i. p. 105). In Bengal the ceremony appears to have usually degenerated into smearing each other with red lead (Dalton, op. cit, 160, 194, 216, 253, 319). The blood of animals, when used for this purpose, as by the Dyaks, may be a substitute for that of the bride and bridegroom ; possibly it may be the blood of the totem (Perelaer, Ethnogr. Beschrijv. der Dajaks, p. 52 ; Tijdschrift v. Indisehe Taal- land- en Volkenkunde, xxv. (1879), p. 116; Ausland, 16th June 1884, p. 469; Journals of James Brooke, Rajah of Sarawak, i. p. 2Q4 ; Carl Bock, Read- Hunters of Borneo, p. 222). 5 Dalton, op. cit, 193, 216; cf. Lewin, Wild Races of South- Eastern India, 177 sq. 78 TOTEMISM. Amongst the Banyai on the Zambesi, if the husband gives nothing, the children of the marriage belong to the wife's family ; but if he gives so many cattle to his wife's parents the children are his. 1 In the Watubela Islands between New Guinea and Celebes a man may either pay for his wife before marriage, or he may, without paying, live as her husband in her parents' house, working for her and her parents. In the former case the children belong to him ; in the latter they belong to his wife's family, but he may acquire them subsequently by paying the price. 2 So in Sumatra. 8 Similarly in some Californian tribes, the husband must live with his wife's family and work for them till he has paid the full price for her and her children ; the children of a wife who has not been paid for are regarded as bastards, and treated with contempt. 4 The couvade or custom in accordance with which the husband takes to his bed and is treated as an invalid when his wife has given birth to a child, is perhaps a fiction intended to transfer to the father those rights over the children which, under the previous system of mother-kin, had been enjoyed by 1 the mother alone. 6 The same may possibly be the intention of the apparently widespread 1 Livingstone, Travels in S. Afr. , 622 sq. ; cf. M 'Lennan, Patri- archal Theory, 324 sq. 2 Eiedel, De sluik- en kroesharige rassen tusschen Papua en Selebes, 205 sq. 3 Maraden, Hist, of Sumatra, 257 sq. ; Schreiber, Die Battas in ihrem Verhdltniss zu den Malaien von Sumatra, p. 34 ; Junghuhn, Die Battalander auf Sumatra, ii. 131 sq. 4 Bancroft, Native Races of the Pacific States, i. 350. 5 This is the view of Baehofen, Mutterrecht, 255 sq. ; Giraud- Teulon, Les origines du manage et de la famille, 138 sq. ; Post, Die Anfange des Stoats- und Rechtslebens, 18; and (with some limita- tions) Zmigrodzki, Die Mutter bei den VoUeern des arischen Stammes 270. TOTEMISM. 79 custom of men dressing as women and women as men at marriage. Thus in the Greek island of Cos the bridegroom was attired as a woman when he received his bride. 1 In Central Africa a Masai man dresses as a girl for a month after marriage. 2 Argive brides wore false beards when they slept with their husbands. 3 The Alsatian custom of men dressing as women and women as men at the vintage festival is clearly part of an old marriage ceremony. 4 But perhaps all these mummeries are to be otherwise explained. Lastly, the transference of the child to the father's clan may be the object of a ceremony observed by the Todas in southern India. When the wife has gone seven months with her first child she retires with her husband to the forest, where, at the foot of a tree, she receives from her husband a bow and arrows. She asks him, " What is the name of your bow ? " each clan apparently having a dif- ferent name for its bow. The question and answer are repeated three times. She then deposits the bow and arrows at the foot of the tree. The pair remain on the spot all night, eating a meal in the evening and another in the morning before they return home. 6 As a'rule, perhaps, members of the same totem clan do not eat each other. To this, however, there are large exceptions. The Kurnai and Maneroo observe the rule, eating their slain enemies but not their slain friends. 6 But tribes about the Gulf of Carpen- 1 Plutarch, Qu. Or., 58. 2 J. Thomson, Through Masai Land, 442. 3 Plutarch, De mul. virt. , 4. 4 Mannhardt, Der Baumkultus, 314. For forms of marriage as means of communicating fertility to the fields, cf. ib., 480 sq. ; Id. , Mythol. Forsch., 340; Wilken in De Indische Gids, June 1884, pp. 958, 962. 5 Marshall, Travels Among the Todas, 214 sq. The Todas have male descent for themselves, but retain female descent for their sacred cattle {ib., 132). 6 Fison and Howitt, 214, 218, 223 sq. 80 TOTEMISM. taria after a battle eat their slain friends but not their enemies; and amongst them children, when they die, are eaten. 1 Some Victorian tribes kill their new-born children, eat them, and give them to their elder children to eat, believing that the latter will thus possess the strength of the babes in addition to their own. 2 In some parts of New South Wales it was the custom for the firstborn child of every woman to be eaten by the tribe as part of a religious ceremony. 3 The eating of aged relations 4 is intelligible on the principle that " the life is not allowed to go out of the family. " Some of the Vic- torian tribes, who ate their relations but not their enemies nor members of a different tribe, asserted that they did so, not to gratify their appetites, but only as a symbol of respect and regret for the dead. They only ate the bodies of relations who had died by violence. 6 The Dieri have exact rules according to which they partake of the flesh of dead relations ; the mother eats of her chil- dren and the children eat of their mother ; but the father does not eat of his offspring, nor the offspring of their father. 6 This custom points to the time when the Dieri had female kinship, when there- fore the father, as a member of a different tribe, had no right to partake of his child. The eating of dead relations is parallel to the custom of smearing the person with the juices which exude from their decaying corpses. 7 The object of these and similar ceremonies (see above, p. 45 sq. ) is to keep the life, regarded as incarnate in the body and blood of the kinsmen, within the circle of the kin. Hence in some tribes at circumcision boys are laid on »• platform, formed by the living bodies of the tribesmen, 8 and when the tooth is knocked out they are seated on the shoulders of men on whose breast the blood flows and is not wiped away. 9 The blood of the tribe is not allowed to be spilt on the ground, but is received on the bodies of tribesmen. Bleeding is a native Australian cure for headache, &c. ; but in performing the operation they are very careful 1 /. A. I., xiii. 283. 2 Trans. Bthn. Soc, new series, i. 289. 3 Brongh Smyth, ii. 311. 1 For examples, see Journals of James Brooke, Rajah of Sarawak, i. p. 209; Garcilasso de la Vega, Royal Commentaries of the Incas, I. i. 12; Riedel, o#. cit., p. 267; Herodotus, iv. 26; Mela, II. i. 9. 6 Dawson, Austr. Abor., 67. 6 Nat. Tr. of S. Australia, p. 274. 7 Fison and Howitt, 243 sq. ; Riedel, op. cit., p. 308. 8 Nat. Tr. of S. Austr., 230; Brough Smyth, i. 75«; Eyre, Journals, ii. p. 335. 9 Collins, Account of the English Colony of N. S. W., London, 1798, p. 580. TOTEMISM. 81 not to spill any of the blood on the ground, but sprinkle it on each other. 1 Similarly when bleeding is done as a means of pro- ducing rain, the blood is made to flow on men, not on the ground. 2 Another form of transferring the blood, i.e., the life of the kin, is seen in an Australian funeral ceremony; the relations gash them- selves over the corpse till it and the grave are covered with their blood ; this is said to strengthen the dead man and enable him to rise in another country. 3 Among some South American tribes the bones of deceased relations are ground into powder, mixed with a liquid, and so swallowed. 4 When a North American tribe is on the march, the members of each totem clan camp together, and the clans are arranged in a fixed order in camp, the whole tribe being arranged in a great circle or in several concentric circles. 5 When the tribe lives in settled villages or towns, each clan has its separate ward. 6 The clans of the Osages are divided into war clans and peace clans ; when they are out on the buffalo hunt, they camp on opposite sides of the tribal circle ; and the peace clans are not allowed to take animal life of any kind ; they must therefore live on vegetables unless they can obtain meat in exchange for vegetables from the war clans. 7 Members of the same clan are buried together and apart from those of other clans; hence the remains of husband and wife, belonging as they do to separate elans, do not rest together. 8 It is remarkable that among the Thlinkets the body 1 Angas, Savage Life and Scenes in Australia and New Zealand, i. 110 sq. 2 Nat. Tr. of S. Aust., 111. " Brough Smyth, ii. 274; Grey, Journ., ii. 332; J. A. I., xiii. 134 sq. 4 J. G. Miiller, Gesch. der Amerik. Urreligionen, 289 sq. ; A. R. Wallace, Travels on the Amazon and Rio Negro, p. 498. Artemisia drank the ashes of Mausolus (Aulus Genius, x. 18 ; Valerius Maxi- mus, iv. 6, 5). On the question of American cannibalism, cf. Miiller, op. cit., p. 144 sq. ; R. I. Dodge, Hunting Grounds of tlie Great West, p. 420. 6 First Rep., 64; Third Rep., 219 sq. ; American Naturalist, xviii. p. 113 sq. 6 Gatschet, Migration Legend of the Creek Indians, 154; Bourke, Snake Dance, 229; Acad., 27th Sept. 1884, p. 203. 7 The Bev. J. Owen Dorsey in American Naturalist, xviii. p. 113. 8 Adair, Hist. Amer. Ind., 183 sq.; Morgan, A. S., 83 sq. ; Brinton, The Lenape and their Legends, 54 ; Id. , Myths of the New World, 87ra ; A. Hodgson, Letters from North America, i. p. 259 ; Dalton, Eth. of Beng., 56 ; cf. Robertson Smith, Kinship and Marriage in Early Arabia, 315 sq. F 82 TOTEMISM. must always be carried to the funeral pyre and burned by men of another totem, 1 and the presents distributed on these occasions by the representatives of the deceased must always be made to men of a different clan. 2 Here we must revert to the religious side of totemism, in order to consider some facts which have emerged from the study of its social aspect. "We have seen that some phratries, both in America and Australia, bear the names of animals ; 3 and in the case of the Thlinkets and Mohegans we have seen reason to believe that the animals which give their names to the phratries were once clan totems. The same seems to hold of the names of the Australian phratries, Eaglehawk, Crow, and Seal, or at least of the two former. For Eaglehawk and Crow are clan totems in other tribes, and are, besides, important figures in Australian mythology. Eaglehawk and Crow, as names of phratries, " extended over a large part of Victoria and over the greater part of the extreme west of New South "Wales." 4 They are clan totems of the Dieri in South Australia, 5 the Mukjarawaint in western Victoria, 6 and the Ta-ta-thi and the Keramiu tribes in New South "Wales. 7 The eaglehawk is besides a clan totem of the Kamilaroi in New Soutli "Wales, 8 the Mycoolon in Queensland, 9 the Barinji in New South "Wales, 10 and the Kuinmurbura in Queensland. 11 The crow is further a clan totem of the Turra tribe, 12 and the Mount Gambier tribe in South Australia, 13 the Kunandabiiri in Queensland, 14 and 1 Holmberg, op. tit., 324. 2 Krause, Die TlinMt-Indianer, 223. 3 As among the CMckasas, Thlinkets, and Mohegans in America; and the Turra, Ngarego, and Theddora tribes in Australia (see above, pp. 61 sq., 65). The subphratries of the Kiabara also bear animal names. See above, p. 67. 4 J. A. I., xiii. 437, n. 1; Fison and Howitt, 322. 6 J. A. I., xii. 500; Id., xiii. 338. 6 Id., xii. 45. 7 Id., xiv. 349. 8 Id., xii. 500, xiii. 335. '■> Id., xiii. 303, 339. 10 Id., xiv. 348. 11 Id., xiii. 336, 344. 12 Id., xii. 45. 13 Fison and Howitt, 168 14 /. A. I., xii. 45, xiii. 338. TOTEMISM. 83 of the Wonghibon in New South Wales. 1 Among the Dieri the eaglehawk was supposed to inflict a penalty for violating a rule in connexion with the knocking out the teeth at initiation. 2 Among the Kurnai the eaglehawk is greatly reverenced; his plumes and talons were used in necromancy ; and he figures in their stories in company with the little owl. 3 The Kurnai also reverence the crow as one of their ancestors, 4 and consult it as a bird of omen. 6 According to a Victorian myth, the crow and the eaglehawk were the progenitors, or among the progenitors, of the human race, and now shine as stars in the sky. 6 According to another Victorian myth the eagle and the crow were the creators of the world, and divided the Murray blacks into two classes (clans or phratries), the Eaglehawk and Crow. 7 Further, there are traces in Australia of the splitting of totems. Thus in the Ta-ta-thi tribe in New South Wales there are two Eaglehawk elans, namely the Light Brown Eaglehawk and the Brown Coloured Eaglehawk, one in each of the two phratries. 8 Amongst the Kamilaroi there is a Kangaroo clan and a Red Kangaroo clan, one in each of the two phratries. 9 In the Kunandabiiri tribe in Queensland there are totem clans — Brown Snake, Speckled Brown Snake, Carpet-Snake, also Rat, Kangaroo Rat, and Bush Rat. 10 In the MtLkjarawaint in western Victoria there are White Cockatoo and Black Cockatoo, also Buff-coloured Snake and Black Snake ; u in other Victorian tribes there are the Long-Billed Cockatoo and the Banksian Cockatoo ; 12 in the Wakelbiira in Queensland there are Large Bee and Small Bee in different phratries ; 13 in the Mycoolon there are Whistling Duck and Black Duck. 14 From all this we should infer that the objects from which the Australian phratries take their names were once totems. But there seems to be direct evidence that both . the phratries and subphratries actually retain, at least in some tribes, their totems. Thus the Port Mackay tribe in 1 Id., xiv. 348. 2 Nat. Tr. of S. Austr., 267. 3 Fison and Howitt, 323. * J. A. I., xv. 415. 6 Id., xvi. 46. 6 Brough Smyth, i. 431. 7 Id., i. 423 s?. o .A .4. /., xiv. 349. 9 Id., xii. 500. w J. A. I., xii. 45. 11 lb 12 Dawson, Austr. Abor., p. 26. 13 J. A. I., xiii. 337. 14 lb., 339. 84 TOTEMISM. Queensland is divided into two phratries, Yungaru and Wutaru, with, subphratries Gurgela, Burbia, Wungo, and Kubera ; and the Yungaru phratry has for its totem the alligator, and Wutaru the kangaroo ; 1 while the sub- phratries have for their totems the emu (or the carpet snake), iguana, opossum, and kangaroo (or scrub turkey). 2 As the subphratries of this tribe are said to be equivalent to the subphratries of the Kamilaroi, it seems to follow that the subphratries 3 of the Kamilaroi (Muri, Kubi, Ipai, and Kumbo) have or once had totems also. Hence it ap- pears that in tribes organized in phratries, subphratries, and clans, each man has three totems — hisjDhra-tryJtotem, '•'his sub phratry totem, and his clan totem. If we add a sex totem and an individual totem, each man in the typical Australian tribe has five distinct kinds of totems. What degree of allegiance he owes to his subphratry totem and phratry totem respectively we are not told ; indeed, the very existence of such totems, as distinct from clan totems, appears to have been generally overlooked. But we may suppose that the totem bond diminishes in strength in proportion to its extension; that therefore the clan totem is the primary tie, of which the subphratry and phratry totems are successively weakened repetitions. 1 Fison and Howitt, 38 sq., 40. The Rockhampton tribe (Queens- land) has the same phratries, but its subphratries are different (/. A. 1., xiii. 336). 2 Fison and Howitt, p. 41. The totems of the phratries and sub- phratries are given by different authorities, who write the native names of the subphratries differently. But they seem to be speaking of the same tribe; at least Mr Fison understands them so. 8 The names of the Kamilaroi phratries, Dilbi and Kupathin, are clearly identical with Dilebi and Cubatine, the names of the Kiabara phratries (see above, p. 67), and the latter mean Flood-water and Lightning. Are these phratric totems both of the Kamilaroi and Kiabara ? TOTEMISM. 85 In these totems superposed on totems may perhaps be discerned a rudimentary classification of natural objects under heads which bear a certain resemblance to genera, species, &c. This classification is by some Australian tribes extended so as to include the whole of nature. Thus the Port Mackay tribe in Queensland (see above, p. 83 sq.) di- vides all nature between the phratries ; the wind belongs to one phratry and the rain to another ; the sun is Wutaru and the moon is Yungaru ; the stars, trees, and plants are also divided between the phratries. 1 As the totem of Wutaru is kangaroo and of Yungaru alligator, this is equivalent to making the sun a kangaroo and the moon an alligator. The Mount Gambier tribe in South Australia is divided into two phratries (Kumi and Kroki), which agaiD are subdivided into totem clans. Everything in nature belongs to a totem clan, thus : 2 — ■ Phratries Totem Clans. Includes Kumi. •« Kroki. ■ I 1. Miila=Fish-Hawk. 2. Parangal = Pelican. 3. Wa=Crow. 4. WIla=Black Cockatoo. 5. Karato=A harmless Snake. 1. Werio= Tea-Tree. 2. Murna=An edible Koot. 3. Karaal= Black crestless Cock- atoo. Smoke, honeysuckle, trees, &c. /Dogs, blackwood trees, fire, frost 1 (fern.) /Rain, thunder, lightning, winter, \ hail, clouds, &c. Stars, moon, &c. / Fish, stringybark trees, seals, \ eels,