Aa fem ee LIBRARY | NO. 5g. [M-KNOEDLER & CO. 556-8 FIFTH AVE. | NEW YORK acc. a Rs. F i . =o i Vi aie Wiles J ‘“ ~ os pees yam ein Pp ets a ih Fie : — eo ae — : a _— ——— ‘ Vid ON FREE PUBLIC VIEW AT THE AMERICAN ART GALLERIES MADISON SQUARE SOUTH, NEW YORK ENTRANCE AT 6 EAST 23d STREET BEGINNING FRIDAY, MARCH 20th, 1914 AND CONTINUING UNTIL THE DATES OF SALE DRAWINGS AND SKETCHES BY THE OLD AND MODERN MASTERS BELONGING TO MomONKL S. HARRISON OF KENT, ENGLAND UNRESTRICTED PUBLIC SALE AT THE AMERICAN ART GALLERIES ON WEDNESDAY AND THURSDAY, MARCH 25th AND 26th, 1914 BEGINNING AT THE HOURS OF 8.30 IN THE EVENINGS a ILLUSTRATED CATALOGUE OF ORIGINAL DRAWINGS AND SKETCHES BY THE OLD AND MODERN MASTERS THE PRIVATE COLLECTION OF COLONEL S. HARRISON OF KENT, ENGLAND TO BE SOLD AT UNRESTRICTED PUBLIC SALE ON THE DATES HEREIN STATED FOREWORD AND DESCRIPTIONS BY MR. R. EDERHEIMER THE SALE WILL BE CONDUCTED BY MR. THOMAS E. KIRBY AND HIS ASSISTANT, MR. OTTO BERNET, OF THE AMERICAN ART. ASSOCIATION, MANAGERS NEW YORK 1914 — *FUEGSTI-APUDAIG TOQUINNE "SSOULILY[ OSVI[TA “UA TION EERE Te BEG PSE eS NE EINER EIA iN nS RENEE ES o> gay “a " DE RCELSRN 2 RAEN SOR ATR AE | : BF LAT icthssame eee Ee FOREWORD HERE is nothing more fascinating to the lover of the arts than working through a collection of artist’s studies, for aside from the pleasure inherent in every individual piece, he is bound to find a number of surprises and to make some discoveries which give ample reward for his efforts. This collection has offered a number of such surprises. ‘The expected discoveries, however, were not to be mine, and for the reason that they had already been made and attested to by an excellent authority who had passed upon this collection before I had my opportunity of examination. One of the greatest surprises was the finding of the exquisite study for the shepherd by Giulio Campagnola on the reverse of the Beccafumi drawing. It is hardly necessary to state that the reverse is many times more valuable than the design shown on the front. Another such surprise was the finding of the magnificent Moeller drawing, whose authenticity has already been well established and which I may safely describe as prob- ably the finest specimen known of that highly-interesting artist, whose drawings are so very rare. As I have only recently stated in another publication, the name of the artist to whom an old drawing has been ascribed should be only of secondary importance. Collectors should buy for the intrinsic artistic merit of the design, as the most famous name, combined with all docu- mentary proof as to the pedigree, does not make a drawing valuable unless the artistic qualities can justify the author’s name. On the other hand, drawings having artists’ names of lesser importance, or of a period that does not interest us very much, may have artistic qualities which render them highly attractive to the connoisseur. Thus we find here amongst the work of such a period—the Italian work of the XVIIth century—some specimens of unusual beauty and importance. I need only mention the two exquisite Domenichino drawings and those by Pietro da Cortona. It would lead too far to mention here every item worthy of special attention. As a whole the collection is considerably above the average of one which, without being devoted to any special school or period, covers the entire field—old masters as well as modern artists. All collections naturally contain specimens which are not of the quality of the majority, but here there are relatively few representatives of a class far below the good average standard, while there are quite a number of items that rank considerably above the average. Of the older Masters, I would especially mention the Cellini, the one of the School of Raphael, the Tintorettos, the Ribera, the Rembrandt, the excellent Boucher and the Gainsboroughs ; of the modern drawings, those by Corot, Jacque, Mauve and Millet, are especially fine, the magnificent cartoons by Sir Frederick Leighton deserving special attention. The character of the entire collection interestingly illustrates the discerning taste of its owner. He certainly did not concentrate his search on famous names alone, although of course it was only natural that many of these should also find their way into his hands. As alluded to before, a great number of the drawings by the Old Masters were submitted by the owner to a very high authority for expertizing. With these attributions I am generally in accord, and in those few cases where I felt inclined to suspect a different authorship, I have adopted the attributions of this authority rather than my own. With the exception of one case (the Lambert Doomer, previously attributed to Hobbema), no new names have been given by me. In that instance I felt justified to do so for the reason that I have recently seen a number of drawings by this artist to which the one here bears a striking resemblance, and also because the previous attribution was questioned in the conscientious catalogue of Colonel Harrison. In those few cases where I considered the suggested attribution not sufficiently substantiated by the characteristic qualities of the artists named, I have attributed the ~ drawings to an *‘ unknown author.” : R. EDERHEIMER. New York, January 15th, 1914. Conditions of Sale 1. Any bid which is merely a nominal or fractional advance may be rejected by the auctioneer, if in his judgment, such bid would be likely to affect the sale injuriously. 2. The highest bidder shall be the buyer, and if any dispute arise between two or more bidders, the auctioneer shall either decide the same or put up for re-sale the lot so in dispute. 3. Payment shall be made of all or such part of the purchase money as may be required, and the names and addresses of the purchasers shall be given immediately on the sale of every lot, in default of which the lot so purchased shall be immediately put up again and re-sold. Payment of that part of the purchase money not made at the time of sale, shall be made within ten days thereafter, in default of which the undersigned may either con- tinue to hold the lots at the risk of the purchaser and take such action as may be necessary for the enforcement of the sale, or may at public or private sale, and with- out other than this notice, re-sell the lots for the benefit of such purchaser, and the deficiency (if any) arising from such re-sale, shall be a charge against such purchaser. 4, Delivery of any purchase will be made only upon payment of the total amount due for all purchases at the sale. Deliveries will be made on sales days between the hours of 9 A. M. and 1 P. M., and on other days—except holidavys—between the hours of 9 A. M. and 5 P. M. Delivery of any purchase will be made only at the American Art Galleries, or other place of sale, as the case may be, and only on presenting the bill of purchase. Delivery may be made, at the discretion of the Association, of any purchase during the session of the sale at which it was sold. 5. Shipping, boxing or wrapping of purchases is a business in which the Associa- tion is in no wise engaged, and will not be performed by the Association for purchasers. The Association, will, however, afford to purchasers every facility for employing at current and reasonable rates carriers and packers; doing so, however, without any assumption of responsibility on its part for the acts and charges of the parties engaged for such service. 6. Storage of any purchase shall be at the sole risk of the purchaser. Title passes upon the fall of the auctioneer’s hammer, and thereafter, ‘while the Association will exercise due caution in caring for and delivering such purchase, it will not hold itself responsible if such purchase be lost, stolen, damaged or destroyed. Storage charges will be made upon all purchases not removed within ten days from the date of the sale thereof. 7. Guarantee is not made either by the owner or the Association of the correct- ness of the description. genuineness or authenticity of any lot, and no sale will be set aside on account of any incorrectness. error of cataloguing, or any imperfection not noted. Every lot is on public exhibition one or more days prior to its sale, after which it is sold “as is” and without recourse. The Association exercises great care to catalogue every lot correctly, and will give consideration to the opinion of any trustworthy expert to the effect that any lot has been incorrectly catalogued, and, in its judgment, may either sell the lot as catalogued or make mention of the opinion of such expert, who thereby would become responsible for such damage as might result were his opinion without proper foundation. SPECIAL NOTICE. Buying or bidding by the Association for responsible parties on orders transmitted to it by mail, telegraph or telephone, will be faithfully attended to without charge or commission. Any purchase so made will be subject to the above Conditions of Sale, which cannot in any manner be modified. The Association, however, in the event of making a purchase of a lot consisting of one or more books for a purchaser who has not, through himself or his agent, been present at the exhibition or sale, will permit such lot to be returned within ten days from the date of sale, and the purchase money will be returned, if the lot in any material manner differs from its catalogue descrip- tion. Orders for execution by the Association should be written and given with such plainness as to leave no room for misunderstanding. Not only should the lot number be given, but also the title, and bids should be stated to be so much for the lot, and when the lot consists of one or more volumes of books or objects of art, the bid per volume or piece should also be stated. If the one transmitting the order is unknown to the Association, a deposit should be sent or reference submitted. Shipping direc- tions should also be given. Priced copies of the catalogue of any sale, or any session thereof, will be furnished by the Association at a reasonable charge. AMERICAN ART ASSOCIATION, American Art Galleries, Madison Square South, New York City. AT THE AMERICAN ART GALLERIES MADISON SQUARE SOUTH, NEW YORK UNRESTRICTED PUBLIC SALE BY ORDER OF THE OWNER First Session, Numbers 1 to 163, Inclusive WEDNESDAY EVENING, MARCH 25th, AT 8.30 O’CLOCK ITALIAN ARTISTS OF THE XVITH CENTURY BANDINELLI, BACCIO, ATTRIBUTED TO. 1. THE CREATION. Interesting pencil drawing from theycollec- ane tion of G. C. Clark. 534 x 71% inches. 1/170.) 0 BECCAFUMI, DOMENICO. 1484-1549.) © J. pea ne DIM hye 2. SKETCHES OF TWO ANGELS. Sanguine drawings. On the upper part of the same sheet a pen study, undoubtedly by another hand, and in old hand writing: Date: 1588, 3 ae ae Ferrara. On the reverse is another pen drawing which undoubtedly forms a study for the engraving, The Shep- herd, by Giulio Campagnola. The identity of this fact has also been confirmed by Mr. A. M. Hind, as per note on the mount. Of the greatest interest and importance. From the collection of Count Von Fries, 1777-1827. 714 x 484 inches. oR) iS yi NX 20 Ws y = ind /) jo a y ‘ CELLINI, BENVENUTO. 1500-1570. VC. Colerhender 3. STUDIES OF HANDS AND DRAPERIES. Sanguine draw- ing. On the reverse are ornamental designs, and another om oe piece of drapery. Signed in ink, B. Cellini. A drawing of the first importance, and especially remarkable is the one on the reverse. 614 x 51% inches. DA CIGOLI, LUIGI CARDI. 1559-1618Q), (Rieke 4. PERSEUS. A capital pen drawing, said to represent Perseus, in the catalogue of the previous owner. Signed in ink, Cigoli. va eect 11 x 7% inches. CORREGGIO, ATTRIBUTED TO. . “(a = 5. THE NATIVITY. A most interesting design in pen and sepia, most likely after the master’s composition by a Dutch or a os German artist working in Italy, as the line-work seems to be much more of the Northern character than in the Italian style. oF the pendant to the previous item, showing same stamp and fom quality. 1114 x 71% inches. THE SAME. BY CI 114. A CUIRASSIER ON HORSEBACK, GALLOPING OVER A BATTLEFIELD. Same stamp as on the two previous a Os items in lower right corner. BOUVIN, J. 1817-1888. ie Ne [3 115. A MARKET GIRL. Highly interesting and clever water color. Signed J. Bouvin, ’47, in lower right corner. fot 8 x 514 inches. 9 BORGOS (?) (Perhaps Antonio de Burgos). _Modern Spanish landscape painter. ee Q. (3 per gay 116. STUDY OF ROCKS IN PASTEL. From the -Alexander Young collection. 11 x 161% inches. bt ees CHIFFLART, FRANCOIS. 1825-190 117. A GROUP OF SOLDIERS anervene K% ee A BANKS OF A RIVER. Superb water color painting of masterly jiu oe finish. 6 x 12% inches. COROT, JEAN BAPTISTE CAMILLE. 1796-1875. 118. WOMAN AND CHILD WALKING ON A ROAD TOWARDS A VILLAGE. Magnificent drawing in black and white charcoal and wash. Signed Corot on lower border towards Lf (0 “— the left. An example of the first importance. From the J. Staats Forbes collection. 10 x 17°4 inches. FRERE, EDOUARD. 4 Jae 119. THE SEE-SAW. Charming chalk and water color drawing. Dated 1869. 814 x 1154 inches. nde FRERE, EDOUARD. (Continued) A Viraxdale 120. WOMAN DRIVING A NAIL IN THE WALL TO ATTACH = yo A CRUCIFIX, WHICH IS BEING HELD BY A fee SMALL GIRL. Water color painting. 1444 x 103% inches. THE SAME.. 8 Dive a AES OR Ee. 121. WOMEN IN PRAYER BEFORE CRUCIFIX. Large chalk and water color design. Very decorative and of high a draftsmanship. Signed and dated, 1879. ‘The above three loins oer items are from the Hargrave sale, and were previously in the Nettlefold collection. 23 x 15°84 inches. GILBERT, SIR JOHN. Be te. iGtapore: 122. THE ALARM. Water color painting. 9% x 131 inches. oe : THE SAME. cee h 123. THE MENDICANTS. Water color painting. 1214 x 914 AL 02 inches. ( vA THE SAME. VW - P. DE oe. 124. THE CAVALIER. Water color painting. 1214 x 8 inches. rv) ee HE SAME. PRA Oc La- 125. AFTER WAR—PEACE. Water color ppinting. 12% x 10 z: inches. La anes ISRAELS, JOSEPH. ¢: be, , 126. CHARCOAL STUDY OF A WOMAN. “Signed in ink, Joseph Israels, in lower right-hand corner. Interesting study. oes Qo = 2.414, x 1156 inches. JACQUE, CHARLES. Paris, 1818. 74, [4 47 127. NORMANDY SHEEP. Superb charcoal drawing of the greatest beauty. Signed, Charles Jacque, in lower right- ise & 4“ | hand corner. 734 x 13814 inches. JACQUE, CHARLES. (Continued) ff 128. FARM YARD SCENE, WITH ROOSTER AND HENS, in various colored chalk. Signed, Charles Jacque, in lower left corner. The above and the preceding are both beauti- / qo =) fal drawings from the J. Staats Forbes collection. 834 x 1314 inches. [See Reproduction. | LANDSEER, SIR EDWIN. (7. pe le 129. STUDY OF LIONS. Exquisite pencil and water color draw- ing. Signed, Sir E. Landseer, in lower right corner. 414 26 Aug x 71 inches. THE SAME. oh (eae He 130. ORIGINAL SKETCH FOR JACK IN OFFICE. Highly in- ae teresting drawing in pen and pencil. 5° x 714 inches. —_— ; THE SAME. byt ‘ 131. STUDY FOR THE PAINTING OF LORD RUSSELL ON A PONY, ACCOMPANIED BY A SERVANT IN / Oe SCOTCH GARB. Bold brush sketch in sepia. 18%@ x 231, inches. LEECH, JOHN. Wee. 132. WATER COLOR SKETCH ae JOCKEY FACING A HORSE WHICH IS JUST BEING BROUGHT OUT Op lige OF THE STABLE BY A GROOM. Signed, J. Leech, in lower corner. Clever water color sketch. 534 x 434 inches. THE SAME. a Ur go 1383. THE START OF A HORSE RACE. Water color sketch, “a signed in ink in lower left corner. 6%4 x 934 inches. LEIGHTON, SIR FREDERICK. President of the Royal Academy. 1384. PORTRAIT STUDY OF HELEN FITZMAURICE. X- ye oe quisitely finished pencil drawing, with soft delicate color- ing added. Jae gp atpo es rf) \ 201. A MOTHER AND CHILD, underneath the verses: ‘* Mamma, a don’t make me beg in vain; pray read the pretty book } ou . . . . . . . be UY — ~~ again.” Stipple engraving. Exquisitely printed in colors. Fine impression, with margin. LADY AND CHILDREN IN A LANDSCAPE, after Bunbury. WNAn- wr 202. COLORED STIPPLE ENGRAVING. Somewhat damaged‘ lower right. Fa ee e) CONDE, JOHN, after R. Cosway. Q. (Cpulhwy 203. MRS. FITZHERBERT. Famous stipple engraving, with ee de margin. 1792. GAUGAIN, T., after Barker. Mun: (3 x. 204. THE MARKET GIRL. Stipple engraving, Pe in lack. ee JEFFRYES, JOHN. yp” ee 205. THE BURIAL OF GENERAL FRASER. Stipple engrav- / 32 ing, printed in dark brown. JONES, JOHN, after-W. R. Bigg. MALU LE A 206. DULCE DOMUM, OR THE RETURN FROM SCHOOL. &; Mezzotint. Fine impression of this famous plate. g¢ THE SAME. | : 207. BLACK MONDAY, OR THE DEPARTURE FOR SCHOOL, Seat pendant of the above. Worn impression. 1790. DE LAUNEY, N., after N. Lavreince. Wi: (ae 208. QU’EN DIT L’ABBE. LE BILLET DOUX. A famous pair - of engravings of the French: ‘“ Genre gallant.” Fair im-. jh eae. pressions. SMITH, JOHN RAPHAEL, after Movlanas We hh 209. [THE PROGRESS OF LAETITIA.] A pair of stipple en- gravings, printed in brown. Margins cut away. Complete [5s — __ set is in six plates. 210. FISHERMEN. Stipple engraving, printed in black, with 3} 0° margins. TOMKINS, P. W., after M. Brown.) ()._ ve prec f 211. LOUIS XVI. WITH HIS FAMILY IN THE TEMPLE AT PARIS. Stipple engraving, printed in black, published ee 1795 (somewhat stained). WATSON, CAROLINE, after Samuel Shel’ (s Moree 212. MOTHER WITH TWO CHILDREN. Stipple engraving in $0 oval proof before letters showing the full plate margin. rd | MODERN PRINTS. APPLETON, THOMAS G., after Romney¥Vau 1 Lh aus 218. LARGE MEZZOTINT PORTRAIT OF LADY HAMILTON. Bue Ve Signed proof before letters. BAROYA, R. 1: ee Rese 214. FOUR FRAMED ETCHINGS, all signed artist’s proofs. ek ones M., after Sir Peter Lely. Q Chores. eae 215. GIRL’S HEAD. Mezzotint. Beautifully printed in colors. /( Signed artist’s proof. GUIETTE, F. | ym. (2 Mba 216. MOONLIGHT LANDSCAPE. Etching. Signed proof. J GULLAND, E. nie be 0) 217. MEZZOTINT PORTRAIT OF A YOUNG WOMAN, ae ) Sz an XVIIIth century painting. Signed proof. HADEN, SIR F. SEYMOUR. CAPALLE, 218. “THE LARK AT HEAVEN’S GATE SINGS.” ‘Etching. oot HENDERSON, WILL. Wy - (20 Mare 219. INNOCENCE. Modern mezzotint. Printed in colors. Signed artist’s proof. / 8 THE SAME. Sea eee 220. COUNTESS POULET. Large mezzotint haere full length. 26 Signed artist’s proof, with wide margin. HESTER, E. M. VY: (2. MD ame 221. BOY’S HEAD, after Greuze. Modern mezzotint. Printed in y Be. colors. Signed proof. HEWLETT, ARTHUR. >. 222. GIRL’S HEAD. Mezzotint. Signed proof with wide margins. ee HIRST, NORMAN, after Raeburn? (3 Ne 223. PORTRAIT OF MRS. IRVIN BOSWELL. Signe proof, Wee e with wide margins. i LILY, EUGENE. 224. YOUNG WOMAN, IN rae -QUARTER LENGTH, i, : STANDING IN A LANDSCAPE. Modern copy of an VG XVIIIth century stipple engraving. Beautifully printed in colors. Signed proof. EAR AMIENS. Etch- LEGROS, ALPHONSE. 225. THE BANKS OF THE SOMME, / os ing, with wide margins. MACBETH, ROBERT, after the painting by Sir Wdward Burne-Jones. 226. LE CHANT D’AMOUR. Etching. Signed proof. Note in y Ae pencil on the upper margins: ‘“ Nr. 3 last proof, Aug. 2.” MILLER, JOHN D. St. 227. MEZZOTINT HEAD OF A YOUNG GIRL, after/Greuze. 3 Fiat Signed proof on India paper, with wide ae NICOLL, FRED. ta 228. HEAD OF A GIRL, after eae Mezzotint rinte /go-C~ colors. Signed proof. NORMAN, H. wh pa cys: 229. HEAD OF A WOMAN. Mezzotint. Befutifully printed in colors. Signed proof on India paper. ee fo Sc STAMP, ERNEST, after Sir Joshua Reynolds. ave 230. LADY BETTY DELME AND CHILDREN (after the paint- oh Qe ing in the J. P. Morgan collection). Large modern mezzo- - tint, printed in colors. Signed proof on India paper. UNKNOWN ENGRAVER. Las he. (3Cox Vig 231. MEZZOTINT PORTRAIT OF A LA ppobably after a . painting by Hoppner or Gainsborough. Beautiful proof, ie with wide margins. WHISTLER, J. McNEIL. v7 Sia eon 232. LES BONNES DU LUXEMBOURG, W. 48 NURSEMAIDS IN THE LUXEMBOURG GARDENS. Lithograph. LA ec AMERICAN ART ASSOCIATION, Managers. THOMAS E. KIRBY, Auctioneer. ae Weel, Wablasrine Cnet a “Ae yn: A Kha Chath Y sp) n vu?" Pa iz 4¥ ia