Zi f)*^ '7 Jb>i f** ****** '* RULES FOR DRAWING CARICATURAS: .WITH AN ESSAY ON COMIC PAINTING. By FRANCIS GROSE, Efq. F. A. S. Illuftrated with Twenty-one Copper Plates, Seven- teen of which etched by himfelf. The SECOND EDITION. L O N D O N: Printed for S. HOOPER, No. 212, High Holborj*. M DCC XCI. (€ntcrcU at &tmmux&^&lh) RULES FOR DRAWING CARICATURAS. THE art of drawing Caricaturas is generally confidered as a dangerous ao quifition, tending rather to make the pofleffor feared than efleemed; but it is certainly an unfair mode of reafon- ing, to urge the abufe to which any art is liable, as an argument againft the art itfelf. A 2 4 RULES FOR DRAWING In order to do juftice to the art in queftion, it fhould be confidered, that it is one of the elements of fatirical paint- ing, which, like poetry of the fame de- nomination, may be mofl efficacioufly employed in the caufe of virtue and de- corum, by holding up to public notice many offenders againft both, who are not amenable to any other tribunal; and who, though they contemptuoufly defy all ferious reproof, tremble at the thoughts of feeing their vices or follies attacked by the keen fhafts of ridicule. To obtain this art, the ftudent mould begin to draw the human head, from one of thofe drawing-books where the forms and proportions, confiituting beauty, according to the European CARICATURAS, 5 idea*, are laid down. Thefe he fhould make himfelf matter of, and endeavour * The features of the human face, and the form and proportions of the body and limbs are in particular coun- tries fubjecl: to certain peculiarities; an agreement with, or material deviation from which, conftitutes the local idea of beauty or deformity. I fay local, becaufe it does not appear that there are any fixed or pofitive ideas of either ; if there were, they muft neceflarily be the fame every- where, which is by no means the faft ; for they differ fy greatly in different places, that what is efteemed a perfec- tion in one country, is in another pronounced a defor- mity. In China and Morocco, excefflve corpulency is efteem- ed a beauty ; and among the vallies of the Alps, the na- tives return thanks to God for his partiality to them in decorating their necks with the comely goiter or craw, here lately (hewn as an objecl: of the moft (hocking deformity. Great eyes and fmall ones, white and black teeth, have each the fanclion of national admiration. Broad and flat nofes are admired in part of Africa ; and the Tartars are fo peculiarly fond of frnall ones, that it is recorded as a circum- 6 RULES FOR DRAWING to remember, and then proceed to draw from cafts in plaifter of Paris, and, if convenient, from nature. As foon as he has acquired a facility in drawing a ftancc of the great beauty of a woman in the feraglio of Tamerlane, that me was entirely without a nofe ; having no mark of that feature, except two fmall apertures thro' which me drew her breath. The fculptors of ancient Greece feem to have diligently obferved the forms and proportions conftituting the Euro- pean ideas of beauty ; and upon them to have formed their ftatues. Thefe meafures are to be met with in many draw- ing books; a flight deviation from them, by the predo- minancy of any feature, conflitutes what is called Cha- ra£ier, and ferves to difcriminate the owner thereof, and to fix the idea of identity. This deviation, or peculia- rity, aggraved, forms Caricatura. On a flight inveftigation it would feem almoft impof- fible, confidering the fmall number of features compofing the human face, and their general fimilarity, to furnifh a fuflicient number of charafterifing diftinclions to difcri- CARICATURAS. 7 head, he may amufe himfelf in altering the diftances of the different lines, mark- ing the places of the features, whereby he will produce a'variety of odd faces minate one man from another ; but when it is feen what an amazing alteration is produced by enlarging one feature, diminifhing another, encreafing or leffening their diftance, or by any ways varying their proportion, the power of combination will appear infinite. Caricatures mould be careful not to overcharge the peculiarities of their fubyj&s, as they would thereby become hideous inftead of ridicu- lous, and inftead of laughter excite horror. It is there- fore always belt to keep within the bounds of probability. Uglinefs, according to our local idea, may be divided into genteel and vulgar. The difference between thefe kinds of uglinefs feems to be, that the former is pofitive or redundant, the latter wanting or negative. Convex faces, prominent features, and large aquiline nofes, though differing much from beauty, Mill give an air of dignity to their owners ; whereas concave faces, flat, fnub, or broken nofes, always ftamp a meannefs and vulgarity. The one 8 RULES FOR DRAWING that will both pleafe and furprize him ; and will befides enable him, when he fees a remarkable face in nature, to find wherein its peculiarity confifts. In profiles, conceive a line touching the extremities of the forehead, nofe, and chin ; and in clofing the whole face, as in fig. 1, 2, 3, 4, &c. plate I. ob- ferve whether this line is angular, con- feems to have paffed through the limits of beauty, the other never to have arrived at them : the ftraight or right-lined face, which was nearly the Grecian character of beauty, being a medium between the negative of vul- gar, and the redundancy of genteel uglinefs. Perhaps this idea may arife from our early impreflions received from the portraits of the famous men of antiquity, moft of whom, except Socrates, are depifted with prominent features, or aquiline nofes. The portraits of the twelve Csefars hav6 caufed the aquiline nofe to be ftyled Roman* C ARIC ATUR AS. 9 cave, convex, right lined, or mixed, compounded of any two of them. This line being the general contour, is to be confidered as conftituting the genus, and the accidental variety in the features as forming the fpecies of the human head. The different genera of contours may be divided into the angular, as fig. 1 ; the right lined, fig. 2 ; the convex, fig. 3 ; the concave, fig. 4 ; the re£to- convexo, fig. 5 ; the convexo-reclo, as fig. 6 ; the convexo-concavo, fig. 7 ; and the concavo-convexo, fig. 8. It is to be noted, that to prevent confufion in all mixed contours, the figure firft named fhould be placed uppermoft. B lO RULES FOR DRAWING Thus, in the convex-concavo, fig. j, the upper part of the head is convex, and the lower concave. The nofe may be divided into the an- gular ; the aquiline or Roman ; the par- rot's beak ; the flraight or Grecian ; the bulbous or bottled; the turned up or fnub ; and the mixed or broken. Thcfe are expreffed in plate II. under the num- bers i, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8. Of thefe fpecies there are great and fmall, and alfo fever al varieties of the mixed or broken. Mouths may be arranged under four different genera or kinds. Of each of thefe there are feveral fpecies. The under-hung, fig. 9 ; the pouting or blub- tARICATURAS. 11 ber, fig. 10 ; the fhark's mouth, fig. 11 ; and the bone box, fig. 12. Of chins, the moft remarkable are the nut-cracker, fig. 13; the convex ad- vancing, fig. 14 ; the convex retiring, fig. 15 ; the concave advancing, fig. 16; the double, fig. 17 ; and the cucumber, nV. 18. Eyes admit of many diftin&ions. The firft are thofe of pofition with refpecl: to right lines drawn through their pupils and corners ; fome lines fo drawn and prolonged, till they meet, form an ande in the forehead, and in others concur in the middle of the nofe. According to Le Brun, moft ani- mals of the brute creation have their B 2 12 RULES FOR DRAWING eyes placed in the manner laft defcrib- ed, Fig. i, plate III. fhews a face with the eyes placed in the ordinary manner ; fo that a right line, drawn through the two pupils, and corners of the eyes, will in- terfecl; the line of the nofe,at right angles. Fig. 2, mews the pofition whereby a right line palling through the corners and pupils of the eyes, forms an angle in the forehead. Fig. 3, lines being drawn, as before mentioned, the point ol the angle is formed near the middle of the nofe. Another diflintlion in eyes, is that of their diftance from each other, the com- mon proportion being the length of an eye. CAR1CATURAS. 13 Eyes themfelves differ exceedingly in fliape as well as magnitude; and alfo in the form of their lids ; fome being globular and projecting, vulgarly called goggles; others fmall and hollow, feem- ing only like narrow flits. The Chinefe and Tartars are commonly reprefented with this kind of eyes. Eye-brows differ in fize, diftance, di- rections, and fhape ; fome being arched and raifed high on the forehead, others low and over-hanging the eye, like a pent-houfe. The mouth and eye-brows are the features that chiefly exprefs the paflions; thus, an open mouth, with elevated eye- brows, marks aftonifhment and terror. The protruded under-lip, and contracted 34 'RULES FOR DRAWING eye-brows, exprefs anger ; the corners of the mouth drawn up, laughter ; and drawn down, grief and weeping. Peculiarities of the eyes are beft {hewn in a front face • thofe of the nofe, fore- head, or chin, in profile ; for by thefe diftin&ions the different features of a face may be fo defcribed as to convey a pretty accurate idea of it; wherefore when a caricaturift wifhes to delineate any face he may fee in a place where it would be improper or impoffible to draw it, he may commit it to his me- mory, by parfing it in his mind (as the fchool-boys term it) by naming the con- tour and different fpecies of features of which it is conflrucled, as fchool-boys CARICATURAS. 15 point out the different parts of fpeech in a Latin fentence. For example, the head, fig. 5, plate III. ; the contour is convexo-con- cavo ; nofe fnubbed, mouth blubbered, chin double, eyes goggle, eye-brows pent-houfed. Fig. 4, plate III. the con- tour is compofed angular and right- lined; nofe right-lined ; eyes Chinefe ; eye-brows arched; chin retiring, &c. Many human faces have firiking re- femblances to particular animals ; con- fider what are the characleriftic marks of each animal, and procure or make accurate drawings of their hciads and features ; and from them fketch out the human face, retaining, as much as poffible, the leading character of the l6 RULES FOR DRAWING particular animal refembling your fub~ jecl. Many examples of this kind are exhibited in Baptifta Porta's Treatife on Phyfiognomy. Hogarth has alfo given fome inftances of thefe refemblances : One in the gate of Calais, where two old fifh-women are pointing out their likenefs to a flat fifh ; another in the portrait of the Ruffian Hercules, where under the figure of a bear, he has pre- ferved the lineaments of l^is poetical antagonift. In addition to what has been fuid in behalf of this art, it may be obferved, that the fludy of it, on the principles here laid down, may be fmgularly ufe- ful to portrait painters, by accuftoming them to difcover what conflitutes the CARICATURAS. If peculiar character of each perfon they are employed to paint. In like manner the contour of the body, and fhapes of the limbs, may be confidered and arranged. Hogarth, in his Analyfis of Beauty, has given an admirable method of fetching the forms and attitudes of different figures, in what may be ftyled a fhort-hand de- lineation of his country-dance. To conclude ; the author of this little piece begs it may be underflood, that the fketches given in the different plates are not to be confidered in any other light than as mathematical diagrams, illuftrating the principles here laid down. C AN AN ESSAY O N COMIC PAINTING. Various have been the opinions refpe&ing the caufe of laughter ; I mean that fpecies arifing from the contem- plation of fome ludicrous idea or object prefented to the mental or corporeal eye. . Mr. Hobbs attributed it to a firp- C 2 i 20 AN tSSAY ON pofed confcioufnefs of fuperiority in the laugher to the objecl: laughed at. Hutchifon feems to think that it is occa- fioned by a contrail or oppofition of dignity and meannefs ; and Mr. Beatie fays, " that quality in things, which makes them provoke that pleafing emo- tion of fentiment, whereof laughter is the external fign, is an uncommon mix- ture of relation and contrariety, exhi- bited or fuppofed to be united in the fame affemblage. And again, (adds he) if it be afked whether fuch a mixture will always provoke laughter, my an- fwer is, it always will, or for the mod part, excite the rifible emotion ; unlefs wken the perception of it is attended I COMIC PAINTING. 21 \^ith fome emotion of greater autho- rcty. This fyftem clearly points out a very fmiple though general rule, applicable to all compofitions of the ludicrous kind in painting — a rule comprized in thefe few words : Let the employments and properties or qualities of all the objects be incompatible ; that is, let every per- fon and thing reprefented, be employed in that office or bufmefs, for which by age, fize, profeffion, conftru&ion, or fome other accident, they are totally unfit. And if the perfons ridiculed are alfo guilty of any trilling breach of morality or propriety, the effeft will be the more complete, and will (land the tell of criticifm. J fay trifling, for 22 AN ESSAY ON great crimes excite indignation, and tend to make us groan rather than laugh. Thus a cowardly foldier, a deaf mufician, a bandy-legged dancing* matter, a corpulent or gouty running- footman, an antiquated fop or coquet, a methodift in a brothel, a drunken juftice making a riot, or a taylor on a managed horfe, are all ludicrous ob- jects ; and if the methodift has his poc- ket picked, or is (tripped, the juftice is drawrt with a broken head, and the taylor appears juft falling off into the kennel, we confider it as a kind of poetical juftice, or due punifhment, for their acling out of their proper fpheres : Though in reprefenting thefe kinds of accident, care fhould be taken COMIC PAINTING. 23 to (hew, that the fufferers are not greatly hurt, otherwife it ceafes to become lu- dicrous ; as few perfons will laugh at a broken arm, or a fra&ured fcull ; this is an overfight of which the managers of our theatres are fometimes guilty in their pantomimical reprefentations ; where, among the tricks put upon the do&or and Pierrot by Harlequin, I have feen fuch a bloody head given to the clown, by a fuppofed kick of the ftatue of a horfe, that many of the fpe&ators, particularly thofe of the fair fex, have exprelfed great horror at the fight. Of all the different artifts who have attempted this flyle of painting, Ho- garth and Coypel feem to have been the moft fuccefsful ; the works of the 24 AN ESSAY ON firft fland unrivalled for invention, expreffion, and diverfity of characters. The ludicrous performances of Coypel are confined to the hiftory of Don Quixote. Moft of the Dutch painters in this walk of painting, have miftaken indecency, naftinefs, and brutality, for wit and humour. On examining divers of Hogarth's defigns, we find he ftrongly adopted the principle here laid down. For ex- ample, let us confider the Prifon Scene in the Rake's Progrefs. How incom- patible is it for a man who poffefTes wings, and the art of flying, to be de- tained within the walls of a goal ! and equally contradictory is the idea of one fuffering imprifonment for the non-pay- COMIC PAINTING. 25 ment of his own debts, who has the fecret of difcharging thofe of the na- tion ! In the four times of the day, what can be more truly confonant with thefe prin- ciples, than the fcene near Iflington, where in the fultry heat of fummer, a number of fat citizens are crouded toge- ther in a fmall room, by the fide of a dufty road, fmoaking their pipes, in order to enjoy the refrefhment of coun- try air ? In the gate of Calais, how fine- ly does the fat friar's perfon and enthu- fiaftic admiration of the huge hrloin, mark that fenfuality fo incompatible with his profeffion ; the fundamental principles of which dictate abflinence and mortification ? In that admirable D 26 AN ESSAY ON comic print, the Enraged Mufician, the humour lies folely in the incompatible fituation of the fon of Apollo, whofe ear trained to melodious and harmonic founds, is thereby rendered extremely unfit to bear the tintimarre, or confu- fion of difcordant noifes with which the painter has fo ludicroufly and ingeni- oufly furrounded him. The picture of Grown Gentlemen learning to Dance, painted by Collet, was well conceived ; and tho' infinitely fhort of Hogarth's execution, had a very pleafing effect, both on the canvas and on the fiage, where it was intro- duced into a pantomime. In this piece every perfon was by form, or age, total- ly unfit for the part he was afting. COMIC PAINTING. 27 In addition to the rule here men- tioned, there are other inferior confi- derations not unworthy the notice of an artift ; contrail alone will fometimes produce a ludicrous effect^ although nothing ridiculous exifts feparately in either of the fubjefts ; for inftance, fup- pofe two men both well made, one very tall, and the other extremely fhort, were to walk down a ftreet together, I will anfwer for it, they would not efcape the jokes of the mobility, although alone either of them might have pafTed unno- ticed. Another kind of laughable con- trail, is that vulgarly ftyled a Woman and her Hujband, this is a large maf- culine woman, and a fmall effeminate D 2 28 AN ESSAY ON man ; but the ridicule here chiefly arifes from the incompatible ; the man Teem- ing more likely to receive protection from the woman, than to be able to afford it to her. Anachronifms have likewife a very laughable effect. King Solomon in all his glory delineated in a tie or bag-wig, laced cravat, long ruffles, and a full dreffed fuit, will always caufe a fmile ; as would alio the Siege of Jerufalem, wherein the Emperor Titus, and his aids-de-camps, fhould be reprefented in the fore ground, dreiTed in great wigs and jack boots, their horfes decorated with laced furniture, holders, and pif- tols: In the diilance, a view of the town, amidft the fire of cannons and COMIC PAINTING. 29 mortars. Our theatrical reprefenta- tions afford plenty of thefe ridiculous abfurdities, where we frequently fee the chamber of Cleopatra furnifhed with a table clock and a harpfichord, or a piano-forte ; or the hall of Marc An- tony with a large chimney garnilhed with mulkets, blunderbuffes, fowling- pieces, &c. and a piclure of the taking of Porto-Bello, by the brave Admiral Vernon, Nothing affords greater fcope for ludicrous reprefentations than the uni- verfal rage with which particular faflrions of drefs are followed by perfons of all ranks, ages, fizes, and makes, without the leaft attention to their figures or Mations. Habiliments alfo, not ridi- 30 AN- ESSAY ON culoiis in themfelves, become fo by be- ing worn by improper perfons, or at improper places. Thus, though the full-bottomed wig adds dignity to a venerable judge, we mould laugh at it on the head of a boyifh counfcl ; and though a tye-wig lends gravity to the appearance of a counfellor or phyfi- cian, it contributes greatly to the lu- dicrous equipment of a mountebank, a little chimney-fweeper dancing round the May-day garland, or one of the candidates for the borough of Garret in the proceffion to that election : a high head, and a large hoop worn in a ftage- coach, or a full-dreffed fuit and a fword at a horfe-race, are equally objects of ridicule. COMIC PAINTING. 31 Refpeaable characters, unworthily employed, are obje&s for the ludicrous pencil. Such would be a lord mayor or an alderman in his gold chain, danc- ing a hornpipe ; or a ferjeant at law, in his coif, band, and fpeclacles, Handing up at a reel or cotillon. Employments accidentally improper, may make a charafter ridiculous, and that for thofe very circumftances which in another fituation render it refpeaable ; thus, a military or naval officer dancing a mi- nuet with a wooden leg, exhibits a truly ludicrous appearance; confider the fame perfon walking or Handing, and his wooden leg makes him an ob- jea of refpea, as a fufferer in the caufe of his country. 3 2 AN ESSAY ON Befides thefe general fubje&s, there are others which, like the ftage tricks, will always enfure the fuffrages of the vulgar ; among them are national jokes, as an Irifhman on horfeback, carrying a heavy portmanteau on his head, to eafe his horfe of its weight ; a Welch- man with his goat, leek, hay-boots, and long' pedigree; a Scotchman with his fcrubbing-poft, and a meagre French- man in his laced jacket and bag, having long ruffles to his fleeves, without a fhirt. Of this kind are profeffional al- lufions; a phyfician and apothecary are lawful game by prefcription, a tay- lor by trade, and a mayor, alderman, or churchwarden, 'ex officio. COMIC PAINTING. 33 Vehicles, figns, utenfils, and other inanimate accompaniments, may be made auxiliaries to ludicrous pictures, with great fuccefs ; for example, a heavy overloaded flage-coach, dragged by four miferable jades, and dignified with the title of the Flying Coach ; the (locks ferving as a prop or fupport to a drunk- en conftable ; a mif-ipelt board or fign over the gate of an academy. Injudicious reprefentations of fublime or ferious fubje&s, have often uninten- tionally been productive of pictures highly ludicrous ; of this a ftriking in- flance occurs in a Hiftory of the Bible, adorned with plates, in one of which the following text of the 7th chapter of St. E g£ AH ESSAY ON Matthew, verfe the third, is illuftratcd : M And why beholdeft thou the mote st that is in thy brother's eye, but confi- " dereft not the beam that is in thine S! own eye ?" The ftate of thefe two men is thus delineated by the artift : one of them has in his eye a complete cattle, with a moate and its appurtenances, and in the eye of the other fticks a large beam like the girder of a houfe. Another picture ftill more ridiculous was, it is faid, to be feen not long ago in a church near Haerlem, in Holland; the fubjea was Abraham offering up his fon Iiaac, where that patriarch was drawn prefenting a large horfe piftol, which he has juft fnapt at the devoted viclim, kneeling on a pile of wood he- COMIC PAINTING. 35 fore him ; but the cataftrophe is pre- vented by an angel, who flying over his head moiftens the prime by a copious ftream produced in the fame manner as that wherewith Gulliver extinguimed the fire in the palace of the Emperor of Lilliput. We meet with another inftance of this fort of unintentionally ridiculous compofition, in the Military State of the Ottoman Empire, written by the Count de Marfigli, member of the Royal Aca- demies of Paris and Montpelier, and of the Royal Society of London. That gentleman, defirous of convey- ing the idea that he had thoroughly in. vcftigatedhis fubjea, by the commoa E 2 3^ AN ESSAY ON metaphor of having fifted it to the bot- tom, his artift has endeavoured in a vis- nette, literally to exprefs it by delineat- ing that operation ; and has reprefented the Count in a full-dreffed coat, hat, and feather, tye-wig and jack-boots, making thro' a fmall fieve, fupported by a tri- angle, little Turkifh foldiers of all deno- minations, many of whom appear on the ground in a confufed heap ; camels, horfes, and their riders, cannons and cannon balls, all tumbling promifcu- oufly one over the other. On the other fide of the piclure are fome foldiers and periwigged officers looking on, as at an ordinary occurrence. To conclude the inftances of theft accidentally ludicrous pictures, I mall COMIC PAINTING. 37 juft mention one which a gentleman of veracity allured me he faw at the Expo- fition de Tableaux at Paris. The Tub- jeer was the death of the late Dauphin, which the painter had treated in the manner following :•— ori a field bed, de- corated with all thofe fluttering orna- ments of which the French are fo pecu- liarly fond, lay the Dauphin, pale and emaciated ; by it flood the Dauphi- nefs, weeping over him in the arFecled attitude of an opera dancer. She was attended by her living children ; and in the clouds hovering over them, were the Duke of Burgundy, their deceafed fon, and two embryos, the product of as many mifcarriages ; the angel duke 38 AN ESSAY ON, &C. was quite naked, except that the order of the Saint Efprit was thrown crofs his fhouiders. T HE EN D. GETTY CENTER LIBRARY