THE J. PAUL GETTY MUSELIM LIBRARY Digitized by the Internet Archive in 2016 https://archive.org/details/illuminatedmanusOOmidd ILLUMINATED MANUSCRIPTS IN CLASSICAL AND MEDIAEVAL TIMES. aonion: C. J. CLAY & SONS, CAMBRIDGE UNIVERSITY PRESS WAREHOUSE, Ave Maria Lane. ffamlnDge: DEIGHTON, BELL AND CO. Ilripjig: P'. A. BROCKHAUS. iJlcto lotft: MACMILLAN AND CO. ILLUMINATED MANUSCRIPTS IN CLASSICAL AND MEDIAEVAL TIMES, THEIR ART AND THEIR TECHNIQUE J. HENRY MIDDLETON, SLADE PROFESSOR OF FINE ART, DIRECTOR OF THE FITZWILLIAM MUSEUM, AND FELLOW OF ICING’S COLLEGE, CAMBRIDGE; AUTHOR OF “ANCIENT ROME IN 1888”, “THE ENGRAVED GEMS OF CLASSICAL TIMES” &C. CAMBRIDGE: AT THE UNIVERSITY PRESS: 1892 [A /l Rights reserved.] ©ambrtfcgf : PRINTED BY C. J. CLAY, M.A. AND SONS, AT THE UNIVERSITY PRESS. THE. J. PAUL SETTY MUSEUM L13RARY TABLE OF CONTENTS. Preface and List of Authorities. Page xiii to xix. List of Illustrations. Page xxi to xxiv. CHAPTER I. Page i to io. Classical Manuscripts written with a Stilus. Survival of classical methods in mediaeval times ; epigraphy and palaeography ; manuscripts on metal plates ; lead rolls ; tin rolls ; gold amulets ; Petelia tablet ; waxed tablets and diptychs ; tablets shown on gems and coins ; tablets found in tombs ; tablets from Pompeii ; Consular diptychs ; many-leaved tablets ; the form of the waxed tablets ; whitened boards used by the Greeks ; late survival of tablets ; “bidding the beads ; ” lists of members of guilds ; wooden book in Norway ; ivory tablets and diptychs ; inscribed Anglo-Saxon lead tablet ; “horn-books.” CHAPTER II. Page 1 1 to 30. Classical Manuscripts written with Pen and Ink. Two forms of manuscripts, the roll and the codex ; Egyptian Books of the Dead ; Book of Ani ; existing manuscripts on papyrus ; the library of papyrus rolls found at Herculaneum ; Herodotus on manuscripts ; use of parchment ; manuscripts on linen ; inscribed potsherds or ostrakaj manuscripts on leaves of trees ; Greek libraries ; Roman libraries ; a list of the public libraries in Rome ; Roman library fittings and decora- tions ; recently discovered library in Rome ; authors’ portraits ; closed bookcases ; booksellers’ quarter ; cost of Roman books ; slave scribes ; librarii of Rome. The technique of ancient manuscripts ; parchment and VI TABLE OF CONTENTS. vellum ; palimpsests ; papyrus manuscripts ; process of making papyrus paper ; use of papyrus in Greece and Rome ; ancient papyrus manu- scripts ; the qualities of papyrus paper ; the form of papyrus rolls ; the wooden roller ; inscribed titles ; coloured inks ; use of cedar oil ; black carbon ink, its manufacture and price ; red inks and rubrics ; purple ink; double inkstands ; pens of reeds and of metal ; Egyptian scribes’ palettes, pen-cases, and pens. CHAPTER III. Page 31 to 44. Classical Illuminated Manuscripts. Use of minium ; Egyptian miniatures ; illuminations in Roman manu- scripts ; Greek illuminations ; two sources of knowledge about classical illuminations ; the Ambrosian Iliad; the Vatican Virgil ; the style of its miniatures ; later copies of lost originals ; picture of Orpheus in a twelfth century Psalter; another Psalter with copies of classical paintings ; the value of these copied miniatures. CHAPTER IV. Page 45 to 61. Byzantine Manuscripts. The very compound character of Byzantine art ; love of splendour ; Gospels in purple and gold ; monotony of the Byzantine style ; hieratic rules ; fifth century manuscript of Genesis; the Dioscorides of the Princess Juliana ; the style of its miniatures ; imitations of enamel designs ; early picture of the Crucifixion in the Gospels of Rabula ; the splendour of Byzantine manuscripts of the Gospels; five chief pictures; illuminated “Canons”; Persian influence; the Altar-Textus used as a Pax; its magnificent gold covers ; the Durham Textus ; Byzantine figure drawing, unreal but decorative ; Byzantine mosaics ; the iconoclast schism, and the consequent decadence of Byzantine art. CHAPTER V. Page 62 to 79. Manuscripts of the Carolingian period. The age of Charles the Great ; the school of Alcuin of York ; the Gospels of Alcuin ; the golden Gospels of Henry VIII. ; the Gospels of the scribe Godesscalc ; Persian influence ; technical methods ; the later Carolingian manuscripts ; continuance of the Northumbrian influence ; beginning of life-study ; the Gospels of Otho II. ; period of decadence in the eleventh century. TABLE OF CONTENTS. Vll CHAPTER VI. Page 80 to 97. The Celtic School of Manuscripts. The Irish Church ; Celtic goldsmiths ; technical processes of the metal-workers copied by illuminators of manuscripts ; the Book of Kells , its perfect workmanship and microscopic illuminations ; copies of metal spiral patterns; the “trumpet pattern:” Moslem influence; absence of gold in the Irish manuscripts ; the Book of Burrow; the monks of Iona ; the Celtic missionaries to Northumbria ; the Gospels of St Cuthbert ; the Viking pirates ; the adventures of St Cuthbert’s Gospels ; the Anglo-Celtic school ; improved drawing and use of gold ; Italian influence ; the early Gospels in the Corpus library ; the Gospels of MacDurnan ; the Book of Deer; the Gospels of St Chad ; the Celtic school on the Continent ; the Psalter of St Augustine ; Scandinavian art ; the golden Gospels of Stockholm and its adventures ; the struggle between the Celtic and the Roman Church ; the Synod of Whitby ; the Roman victory, and the growth of Italian influence ; the school of Baeda at Durham. CHAPTER VII. Page 98 to 105. The Anglo-Saxon School of Manuscripts. The Danish invasions ; revival of art under king Alfred ; the Bene- dictional of Aethelwold ; signs of Carolingian influence ; the Winchester school; St Dunstan as an illuminator ; Anglo-Saxon drawings in coloured ink ; Roll of St Guthlac ; the great beauty of its drawings ; Canute as a patron of art ; the Norman Conquest. CHAPTER VIII. Page 106 to 125. The Anglo-Norman School. The Norman invasion ; development of architecture and other arts ; creation of the Anglo-Norman school ; magnificent Psalters ; the Angevin kingdom ; the highest development of English art in the thirteenth century ; Henry III. as an art patron ; the rebuilding and decorating of the Church and Palace of Westminster ; paintings copied from manu- scripts ; the Painted Chamber; English sculpture; the Fitz-Othos and William Torell ; English needlework (opus A nglicanuni ) ; the Lateran and Pienza copes ; Anglo-Norman manuscripts of the Vulgate ; the style of V1U TABLE OF CONTENTS. their illuminations ; manuscripts produced in Benedictine monasteries ; unity of style ; various kinds of background in miniatures ; magnificent manuscripts of the Psalter j the Tenison Psalter j manuscripts of the Apocalypse j their extraordinary beauty ; their contrast to machine-made art ; English manuscripts of the fourteenth and fifteenth centuries ; the results of the Black Death ; the Poyntz Horae j the Lectionary of Lord Lovel ; the characteristics of English ornament ; the introduction of portrait figures; the Shrewsbury manuscript; “Queen Mary’s Prayer- book ; ” the works of Dan Lydgate ; specially English subjects ; manu- scripts of Chronicles and Histories. CHAPTER IX. Page 126 to 146. P'rench Manuscripts. The age of Saint Louis ; archaism of costume in miniatures ; French manuscripts of the fourteenth and fifteenth centuries ; historiated Bibles ; the ivy-pattern ; the Horae of the Due de Berri ; the treasure-book of Origny Abbey ; the Anjou Horae ; costly and magnificent French Horae; their beautiful decorations ; their numerous miniatures ; the Bedford Breviary j the Bedford Missal j various styles in the same manuscript ; manuscripts in Grisaille ; manuscripts of secular works ; Cristina of Pisa; Chronicles and Travels ; Romances and Poems ; Italian influence in the south of France; the growth of secular illuminators; the inferiority of their work ; cheap and coarsely illuminated Horae j manuscripts of the finest style ; use of flowers and fruit in borders and initials ; influence of the Italian Renaissance ; the Horae of Jehan Foucquet of Tours. CHAPTER X. Page 147 to 153. Printed Books with painted Illuminations. Horae printed on vellum in Paris ; their woodcut decorations ; the pro- ductions of the earliest printers ; the Mazarine Bible ; the Mentz Psalter j illuminators becoming printers ; Italian printed books with rich illumina- tions ; the colophons of the early printers; the books of Aldus Manutius ; invention of Italic type ; manuscripts illustrated with woodcuts ; block- books ; the long union of the illuminators’ and the printers’ art. TABLE OF CONTENTS. IX CHAPTER XI. Page 154 to 182. Illuminated Manuscripts of the Teutonic School after the Tenth Century. Revival of art in Germany in the eleventh century ; the Missal of the Emperor Henry II.; the designs used for stained glass; the advance of manuscript art under Frederic Barbarossa ; grotesque monsters ; examples of fine German illuminations of the twelfth century ; their resemblance to mural paintings ; the school of the Van Eycks ; the Grimani Breviary ; Gdrard David of Bruges ; examples of Flemish miniatures ; the use of gold ; grotesque figures ; the influence of manuscript art on the painters of altar-pieces; the school of Cologne; triptych by the elder Holbein ; book illuminated by Albert Diirer ; Dutch fifteenth century manuscripts ; their decorative beauty; their realistic details ; illumination in pen outlines in blue and red. CHAPTER XII. Page 183 to 205. The Illuminated Manuscripts of Italy and Spain. Italian art slow to advance; its degraded state in the twelfth century ; illuminators mentioned by Dante ; Missal in the Chapter library of Saint Peter’s ; the monk Don Silvestro in the middle of the fourteenth century; his style of illumination; the monk Don Lorenzo; Fra Angelico as an illuminator; Italian Pontifical in the Fitzwilliam library; manuscripts of the works of Dante and Petrarch ; motives of decoration ; Italian manuscripts after 1453; introduction of the “Roman” hand; great perfection of writing, and finest quality of vellum ; the illuminators Attavante, Girolamo dai Libri, and Liberale of Verona ; manuscripts of northern Italy; their influence on painting generally; Italian manu- scripts of the sixteenth century, a period of rapid decadence ; Giulio Clovio a typical miniaturist of his time ; the library of the Vatican ; its records of the cost of illuminating manuscripts. The manuscripts of Spain and Portugal ; the manuscripts of Moslem countries, especially Persia. CHAPTER XIII. Page 206 to 223. The Writers of Illuminated Manuscripts. Monastic scribes ; the great beauty of their work, and the reasons for it ; their quiet, monotonous life ; examples of monastic humour ; no long spells of work in a monastery; care in the preparation of pigments ; variety of the schemes of decoration ; the scriptoria of Benedictine b M. C. M. X TABLE OF CONTENTS. monasteries ; their arrangement in one alley of the cloister ; the row of armaria; the row of carrels ; the carrels in the Durham cloister described in the Rites of Durham ; the scribes of other regular Orders. Secular scribes ; the growth of the craft-guilds ; the guilds of Bruges ; their rules, and advantages to both buyer and seller ; the production of cheap Horae ; wealthy patrons who paid for costly manuscripts ; women illuminators, such as the wife of Gdrard David ; the high estimation of fine manuscripts. Extract from the fourteenth century accounts of St George’s at Windsor showing the cost of six manuscripts. Similar extract from the Parish books of St Ewen’s at Bristol in the fifteenth century, giving the cost of a Lectionary. CHAPTER XIV. Page 224 to 238. The Materials and Technical Processes of the Illuminator. The vellum used by scribes, its cost and various qualities ; paper made of cotton, of wool and of linen ; the dates and places of its manufacture ; its fine quality. The metals and pigments used in illuminated manuscripts ; fluid gold and silver ; leaf gold, silver and tin ; the highly burnished gold ; leaf beaten out of gold coins ; the goldsmith’s art practised by many great artists ; the 7nordant on which the gold leaf was laid ; how it was applied ; a slow, difficult process ; laborious use of the burnisher ; old receipts for the mordant : the media or vehicles used with it ; tooled and stamped patterns on the gold leaf ; the use of tin instead of silver ; a cheap method of applying gold described by Cennino Cennini. CHAPTER XV. Page 239 to 256. The Materials and Technical Processes of the Illuminator ( continued ). The coloured pigments. The vehicles used ; blue pigments, ultra- marine ; its great value ; story told by Pliny and Vasari ; smalto blues ; “German blue;” Indigo and other dye-colours; how they were made into pigments ; green pigments ; terra verde, verdigris, smalt, leek-green ; red pigments, minium red lead, vermilion, red ochre ( rubrica ) ; murex and kermes crimson ; kermes extracted from scraps of red cloth by illuminators ; madder-red ; lake-red ; purples ; yellow pigments, ochre, arsenic and litharge ; white pigments, pure lime ( Bianco di San Giovanni), white lead, biacca or cerusa. Black inks, carbon ink and iron ink ( incaustam or encaustum and atramentum ) ; red and purple TABLE OF CONTENTS. xi inks ; writing in gold ; the illuminator’s pens and pencils ; the lead-point and silver-point ; red chalk and amatista. Pens made of reeds, and, in later times, of quills ; brushes of ermine, minever and other hair, mostly made by each illuminator for himself ; list of scribes’ implements and tools. Miniatures representing scribes ; the various stages in the execution of an illuminated manuscript ; ruled lines ; writing of the plain text ; outline of ornament sketched in ; application of the gold leaf ; the painting of the ornaments and miniatures ; preparation for the binder. CHAPTER XVI. Page 257 to 264. The Bindings of Manuscripts. Costly covers of gold, enamel and ivory ; the more usual forms of binding ; oak boards covered with parchment and strengthened by metal bosses and corners ; methods of placing the title on the cover ; pictures on wood covers ; stamped patterns on leather ; English stamped bindings ; bag-like bindings for portable manuscripts ; bindings of velvet with metal mounts ; the costly covers of the Grimani Breviary and other late manuscripts. The present prices of mediaeval manuscripts ; often sold for barely the value of their vellum ; modern want of appre- ciation of the finest manuscripts. APPENDIX. Page 265 to 270. Directions to scribes, from a thirteenth century manuscript at Bury St Edmund’s. Note on Service-books by the late Henry Bradshaw. Extract from the Cistercian Consuetudines. b 2 Painting on panel by a fifteenth century artist of the Prague school ; it represents St Augustine as an Episcopal scribe. The background and the ornaments of the dress are stamped in delicate relief on the gesso ground and then gilt. This picture, which is now in the Vienna Gallery, was originally part of the painted wall-panelling in the Chapel of the Castle of Karlstein. PREFACE. HE object of this book is to give a general account of the various methods of writing, the different forms of manuscripts and the styles and systems of decoration that were used from the earliest times down to the sixteenth century a.d., when the invention of printing gradually put an end to the ancient and beautiful art of manuscript illumination. I have attempted to give a historical sketch of the growth and development of the various styles of manuscript illumination, and also of the chief technical processes which were employed in the preparation of pigments, the application of gold leaf, and other details, to which the most unsparing amount of time and labour was devoted by the scribes and illuminators of many different countries and periods. An important point with regard to this subject is the remarkable way in which technical processes lasted, in many cases, almost without alteration from classical times down to the latest mediaeval period, partly owing to the existence of an unbroken chain of XIV PREFACE. traditional practice, and partly on account of the mediaeval custom of studying and obeying the pre- cepts of such classical writers as Vitruvius and Pliny the Elder. To an English student the art-history of illumi- nated manuscripts should be especially interesting, as there were two distinct periods when the productions of English illuminators were of unrivalled beauty and importance throughout the world 1 . In the latter part of this volume I have tried to describe the conditions under which the illuminators of manuscripts did their work, whether they were monks who laboured in the scriptorium of a monastery, or members of some secular guild, such as the great painters’ guilds of Bruges or Paris. The extraordinary beauty and marvellous technical perfection of certain classes of manuscripts make it a matter of interest to learn who the illuminators were, and under what daily conditions and for what reward they laboured with such astonishing patience and skill. The intense pleasure and refreshment that can be gained by the study of a fine mediaeval illuminated manuscript depend largely on the fact that the exquisite miniatures, borders and initial letters were the product of an age which in almost every respect differed widely from the unhappy, machine-driven nineteenth century in which we now live. With regard to the illustrations, I have to thank o 1 See pages 97 and 113. PREFACE. XV Mr John Murray for his kindness in lending me a cliclid of the excellent woodcut of the scriptorium walk in the cloisters of the Benedictine Abbey of Gloucester, which was originally prepared to illustrate one of Mr Murray’s valuable Guides to the English Cathedrals. The rest of the illustrations I owe to the kindness of Mr Kegan Paul. They have previously appeared in the English edition of Woltmann and Woermann’s valuable History of Painting , 1880-7. I have to thank my friend and colleague Mr M. R. James for his kindness in looking through the proofs of this book. He is not responsible for the opinions expressed or for the errors that remain, but he has corrected some of the grosser blunders. J. HENRY MIDDLETON. King’s College, Cambridge. XVII BOOKS ON ILLUMINATED MSS. The following are some of the most important works on this subject, and the most useful for the purposes of a student. Many others, which deal with smaller branches of the subject, are referred to in the following text. Bastard, Peintures et Ornemens des Manuscrits, classes dans an ovdre Chronologique , Imper. folio, Paris, 1835, &c.; a very magnificent book, with 163 plates, mostly coloured. Birch and Jenner, Early drawings and illuminations , London, 1879; this is a useful index of subjects which occur in manuscript miniatures. Bradley, J. W,, Dictionary of Miniaturists and Illuminators , 3 vols. 8vo. London, 1887-1890. Chassant, Paleographic des Chartes et des Manuscrits du XInie an XVI lime Siecle, i2mo. ; a useful little handbook, together with the companion volume, Dictionnaire des Abbreviations Latines et Francaiscs, Paris, 1876. Denis, F., Histoire de I Ornamentation des manuscrits ; 8vo. Paris, 1879. Fleury, E., Les Manuscrits de la Bibliothcque de Laon etudics au point de vue de leur illustration , 2 vols., Laon, 1863. With 50 plates. Humphreys, Noel, Illuminated Books of the Middle Ages, folio, London, 1849; a handsome, well-illustrated book. XV111 BOOKS ON ILLUMINATED MSS. Humphreys, Noel, The Origin and Progress of the Art of Writing ; sm, 4to., with 28 plates ; London, 1853. Kopp, Palaeographia Critica, 4 vols. 4to., Manheim, 1817- 1819; a book of much historical value for the student of Palaeography. Lamprecht, K., Initial- Ornamentik des VIII. -XIII. falirh., Leipzig, 1882. Langlois, Essai sur la Calligraphic des Mannscrits du Moyen Age et sur les Ornements des premiers livres imprimes, 8vo. Rouen, 1841. Monte Cassino, Paleografia artistica di Monte Cassino, pub- lished by the Benedictine Monks of Mte. Cassino, 1870, and still in progress. This work contains a very valuable series of facsimiles and coloured reproductions of selected pages from many of the most important manuscripts in this ancient and famous library, that of the Mother- house of the whole Benedictine Order. Reiss, H., Sammhuig dcr schonsten Miniaturen des Mittel- alters, Vienna, 1863-5. Riegl, A., Die mittelaltcrl. Kalcndcr illustration, Innsbruck, 1889. Seghers, L., Tresor calligraphique du Moyen Age, Paris, 1884; with 46 coloured plates of illuminated initials. Shaw, Henry, Illuminated Ornaments of the Middle Ages from the sixth to the seventeenth century ; with de- scriptions by Sir Fred. Madden ; 4to. with 60 coloured plates, London, 1833. A very fine and handsome work. „ ,, The Art of Illumination, 4to. London, 1870; with well-executed coloured plates. „ „ Hand-book of Mediaeval Alphabets and Devices, Imp. 8vo. London, 1S77 ; with 37 coloured plates. Silvestre, Paleographic Universelle, 4 vols., Atlas folio, Paris, 1839-1841. This is the most magnificent and costly work on the subject that has ever been produced. The English Edition in 2 vols., Atlas folio, translated and edited by Sir Fred. Madden, London, 1850, is very BOOKS ON ILLUMINATED MSS. XIX superior in point of accuracy and judgment to the original French work. A smaller edition with 72 selected plates has also been published, in 2 vols. 8vo. and one fob, London, 1850. Waagen, G. F., On the Importance of Manuscripts with Mini- atures in the history of Art, 8vo. London (1850). Westwood, J. O., P alaeographia Sacra Pictoria, royal 4to. London, 1843-5. This is a very fine work, with 50 coloured plates of manuscript illuminations selected from manuscripts of the Bible of various dates from the fourth to the sixteenth century. „ „ Illuminated Illustrations of the Bible , royal 4to. London, 1846. This is a companion work to the last-mentioned book. „ „ Miniatures and Ornaments of Anglo-Saxon and Irish Manuscripts , fob, London, 1868; with 54 very finely executed coloured plates of remarkable fidelity in drawing. The reproductions of pages from the Book of Kells and similar Celtic manuscripts are specially remarkable. Wyatt, M. Digby, The Art of Illuminating as practised in Europe from the earliest times; 4to. London, 1S60 ; with 100 plates in gold and colours. The best work on the form of books in ancient times is Th. Birt, Das antike Buchwesen in seinem Verhdltniss zur L iteratin' , 8 vo. , 1882. The publications of the Palaeographical Society, from the year 1873, and still in progress, are of great value for their well-selected and well-executed photographic repro- ductions of pages from the most important manuscripts of all countiies and periods. XXI LIST OF ILLUSTRATIONS. Fig. ^ 7 page 33- Part of the drawing engraved on the bronze cista of Ficoroni, dating from the early part of the fourth century B.C. A beautiful example of Greek drawing. ” 2 77 37- Miniature of classical design from a twelfth century Psalter in the Vatican library. 77 3 77 39- Painting in the “House of Livia” on the Palatine Hill in Rome. ?? 4 77 41. A Pompeian painting of Hellenic style, as an example of Greek drawing and composition. 77 5 77 43- The Prophet Ezechiel from a Byzantine manuscript of the ninth century A.D. 77 6 77 49. Miniature from the Vienna manuscript of Genesis. 7 7 ? Si- Miniature from the manuscript of the work on Botany by Dioscorides, executed at Constantinople about 500 A.D. for the Princess Juliana. 77 8 77 58 . Mosaic of the sixth century in the apse of the church of SS. Cosmas and Damian in Rome. V 9 77 6o. Miniature from a Byzantine manuscript of the eleventh century ; a remarkable example of artistic decadence. 77 IO 77 63- An initial P of the Celtic-Carolingian type, of the school of Alcuin of York. 77 1 1 77 64. An initial B of the Celtic-Carolingian type. ” 12 77 66. Miniature of Christ in Majesty from a manuscript of the school of Alcuin, written for Charles the Great. 77 13 77 68. A cope made of silk from the loom of an Oriental weaver. 77 14 17 71- King Lothair enthroned ; a miniature from a manu- script about the year 845 a.d. xxii LIST OF ILLUSTRATIONS. Fig. 15 page 73. Illumination in pen outline, from a manuscript written in the ninth century at St Gallen. It represents David riding out against his enemies. Figs. 16 and 17, pages 74 and 75. Subject countries doing homage to the Emperor Otho II. ; from a manuscript of the Gospels. Fig. 18, page 77 - Miniature of the Evangelist Saint Mark ; from a manuscript of the Gospels. » 19 7 ? 78. Miniature of the Crucifixion from a German manu- script of the eleventh century ; showing extreme artistic decadence. » 20 7 ? 91. Miniature from the Gospels of MacDurnan of the ninth century. » 21 77 100. Miniature from the Benedictional of Aethelwold ; written and illuminated by a monastic scribe at Winchester. 77 77 127. A page from the Psalter of Saint Louis, written about the year 1260, by a French scribe. „ 2 3 77 130. Miniature representing King Conrad of Bohemia, with an attendant, hawking. » 2 4 77 132. Scene of the martyrdom of Saint Benedicta from a Martyrology of about 1312. » 2 S 77 134 - Miniature of the Birth of the Virgin painted by the illuminator Jacquemart de Odin for the Due de Berri. The border is of the characteristic French or Franco-Flemish style. „ 26 77 142. Miniature executed for King Rend of Anjou about 1475 - „ 27 7 ? 145. Miniature of the Marriage of the B. V. Mary from a French manuscript of about 1480, with details in the style of the Italian Renaissance. „ 28 v> 146. Border illumination from a Book of Hours by Jacque- mart de Odin which belonged to the Due de Berri ; see fig. 25. >> 29 „ 155 - A page from the Missal of the Emperor Henry II. „ 3 ° 7 ) 156. Figure of King David from a stained glass window in the Cathedral of Augsburg, dating from 1065. » 3 i 77 1 57 - Miniature from an eleventh century manuscript of the Gospels, by a German illuminator. „ 32 * 59 - An initial S, illuminated with foliage of the North- umbrian type, from a German manuscript of the twelfth century. „ 33 77 160. Miniature of the Annunciation from a German manuscript of the beginning of the thirteenth century. LIST OF ILLUSTRATIONS. xxill Fig- 34 page i6r. n 35 163. „ 36 >> 164. „ 37 166. „ 33 >5 168. „ 39 170. „ 40 171. „ 4 i r 73 - „ 42 174. >1 43 176. „ 44 1 77 - „ 45 JJ 179. „ 46 180. „ 47 J? 185- n 43 187. „ 49 5 ? 196. Page of a Kalendar from a German Psalter of about 1200 A.D. Initial Y from a German manuscript of the beginning of the thirteenth century, with a most graceful and fanciful combination of figures and foliage. Paintings on the vault of the church of St Michael at Hildesheim, closely resembling in style an illumi- nated page in a manuscript. Miniatures of Italian style from a German manu- script of 1312, showing the influence of Florentine art on the illuminators of southern France. Miniature symbolizing the month of April from the Kalendar of the Grimani Breviary , executed about 1496. A page from the Book of Hours of King Rend, painted about 1480. A page from a Book of Hours at Vienna, of the finest Flemish style. Marginal illumination of very beautiful and refined style from a manuscript executed for King Wenzel of Bohemia about the year 1390. Miniature of Duke Baldwin, painted about the year 1450 by an illuminator of the school of the Van Eycks of Bruges. Retable painted by Martin Schongauer, in the style of a manuscript illumination. An altar-piece of the Cologne school, showing the influence of manuscript illumination on the painters of panel-pictures, especially retables. Wing of a triptych, with a figure of St Elizabeth of Hungary, painted by the elder Hans Holbein ; this illustrates the influence on painting of the styles of manuscript illumination at the beginning of the sixteenth century. Illuminated border drawn by Albert Diirer in 1515. Illumination from an Italian manuscript executed for the Countess Matilda in the twelfth century ; this illustrates the extreme decadence of art in Italy before the thirteenth century. Miniature of Saint George and the Dragon from a Missal , illuminated about 1330 to 1340 by a painter of the school of Giotto. An illuminated border from a manuscript by Atta- vante, of characteristic north-Italian style. xxiv LIST OF ILLUSTRATIONS. Fig. 50 page 198. A miniature from the Bible of Duke Borso d’Este, painted between 1455 and 1461 by illuminators of the school of Ferrara. „ 5 1 „ 201. A Venetian retable by Giovanni and Antonio di Murano, in the style of an illuminated manuscript. !> 5 2 1) 208. Grotesque figure from a French manuscript of the fourteenth century. „ S 3 „ 209. Miniature of a comic subject from a German manu- script of the twelfth century, representing a mo- nastic scribe worried by a mouse. » 54 213. View of the scriptorium alley of the cloisters at Gloucester, showing the recesses to hold the wooden carrels for the scribes or readers of manuscripts. „ 55 » 219. Picture by Quentin Matsys of Antwerp, showing a lady selling or pawning an illuminated manuscript. Frontispiece. Painting on panel by a fifteenth century artist of the Prague school ; it represents Saint Augustine as an Episcopal scribe. The background and the ornaments of the dress are stamped in delicate relief on the gesso ground and then gilt. This picture, which is now in the Vienna Gallery, was originally part of the painted wall-panelling in the Chapel of the Castle of Karlstein. I CHAPTER I. Classical Manuscripts written with a Stilus. BEFORE entering upon any discussion of the styles and methods of decoration which are to be found in mediaeval manuscripts and of the various processes, pigments and other materials which were employed by the mediaeval illuminators it will be necessary to give some account of the shapes and kinds of books which were produced among various races during the classical period. The reason of this is that classical styles of decoration and technical methods, in the preparation of paper, parch- ment, pigments and the like, both survived to greater extent and to a very much later period than is usually supposed to have been the case, and, indeed, continued to influence both the artistic qualities and the mechanical processes of the mediaeval illuminator almost down to the time when the production of illuminated manuscripts was gradually put an end to by the invention of printing. The word manuscript is usually taken to imply writing with a pen, brush or stilus to the exclusion of inscriptions cut with the chisel or the graver in stone, marble, bronze or other hard substance. The science of palaeography deals with the former, while epigraphy is concerned with the latter. The inscribed clay tablets of Assyria and Babylon might be considered a sort of link between the two, on account of the cuneiform writing on them having been executed with a stilus in soft, plastic clay, which subsequently was hardened by Survival of methods. The pen and the stilus. M. C. M. I Writing on metal. Lead rolls. Tin rolls. 2 WRITING ON METAL PLATES [CHAP. I. baking in the potter’s kiln, but it will be needless to describe them here. Manuscripts on metal plates. Another form of writing especially used by the ancient Greeks, which falls more definitely under the head of manuscripts, consists of cha- racters scratched with a sharp iron or bronze stilus on plates of soft tin, lead or pewter, which, when not in use, could be rolled up into a compact and conveniently portable cylinder. A considerable number of these inscribed lead rolls have been found in the tombs of Cyprus ; but none of them unfortunately have as yet been found to contain matter of any great interest. For the most part they consist either of monetary accounts, or else of formulae of imprecations, curses devoting some enemy to punishment at the hands of the gods. We know however from the evidence of classical writers that famous poems and other important literary works were occasionally preserved in the form of these inscribed tin or lead rolls. Pausanias, for example, tells us that during his visit to Helicon in Boeotia he was shown the original manuscript of Hesiod’s Works and Days written on plates of lead ; see Paus. IX. 31. Again at IV. 26, Pausanias records the discovery at Ithome in Messenia of a bronze urn ( hydria ) which contained a manuscript of the “ Mysteries of the Great Deities” written on “a thinly beaten plate of tin, which was rolled up like a book,” icacraLTepov iXrjXaa ptevov e? to A .67 tto- Tarov, tiretkucTO he wenrep r a / 3 i/ 3 Xia. This method of writing would be quite different from the laborious method of cutting inscriptions on bronze plates with a chisel and hammer, or with a graver. A scribe could write on the soft white metal with a sharp stilus almost as easily and rapidly as if he were using pen and ink on paper, and the manuscript thus produced would have the advantage of extreme durability. We may indeed hope that even now some priceless lost work of early Greece may be recovered by the discovery of similar lead rolls to those which Cesnola found in Cyprus. CHAP. I.] AND WAXED TABLETS. 3 Some very beautiful little Greek manuscripts, written on thin plates of gold, have also been discovered at various places. The most remarkable of these were intended for amulets, and were rolled up in little gold or silver cylinders and worn round the neck during life. After death they were placed with the body in the tomb. Several of these, dis- covered in tombs in the district of Sybaris in Magna Graecia, are inscribed with fragments from the mystic Orphic hymns, and give directions to the soul as to what he will find and what he must do in the spirit-world. The most complete of these little gold manuscripts, usually known as the Petclia tablet, is preserved in the gem-room in the British Museum. The manuscript consists of thirteen hexameter lines written on a thin plate of pure gold measuring i h inches by 2 § inches in width ; it dates from the third century B.C. 1 In classical times, manuscripts were of two different forms ; first, the book form, i rival;, ttivclkiov or BeXTtov, in Latin codex (older spelling candex ) ; and secondly the roll, icv\t,v8po$, /3l/3\o ( i or f3i/3\iov, Latin volitnien 2 . Manuscripts on tablets. Both the Greeks and the Romans used very largely tablets (7 riva/ces, Lat. tabulae or cerae) of wood covered with a thin coating of coloured wax, on which the writing was formed with a sharp-pointed stilus (ypacpU) of wood, ivory or bronze. The wax was coloured either black or red in order that the writing scratched upon it might be clearly visible. The reverse end of the stilus was made Hat or in the shape of a small ball so that it could be used to make corrections by smoothing out words or letters which had been erroneously scratched in the soft wax. These tablets were commonly about ten to fourteen inches in length by about half that in width. The main surface of each tablet was sunk from i to -jL of an inch 1 See Jour. Hell. Stud. Vol. in. p. nr. 2 It was not till quite a late period that the word ftifiXos was used to mean another form of book than the roll. The word cram is also used for a tablet ; see p. 30. I — 2 Gold amulets. Pctelia tablet. Waxed tablets. 4 WAXED TABLETS [CHAP. I. ! Taxed diptychs. Tablets on coins and gems. Tablets from tombs. in depth to receive the wax layer, leaving a rim all round about the size of that round a modern school-boy’s slate. The object of this was that two of these tablets might be placed together face to face without danger of rubbing and obliterating the writing on the wax, which was applied in a very thin coat, not more than of an inch in thickness. As a rule these tablets were fastened together in pairs by stout loops of leather or cord. These double tablets were called by the Greeks irlvaices tttvktol or hiirryga (from 8/9 and 7 TTvaaco) and by the Romans pugillares or codicilli. Homer (//. VI. 168) mentions a letter written on folding tablets — iropev 8 ’ 0 fe apptaTa Xvypd Tpai/ra? iv ttlvclicl 7ttvktm. Representations of these folding tablets occur frequently both in Greek and in Roman art, as, for example on various Sicilian coins, where the artist’s name is placed in minute letters on a double tablet, which in some cases, as on a tetradrachm of Himera, is held open by a flying figure of Victory. A gem of about 400 B.C., a large scarabaeoid in chalce- dony, recently acquired by the British Museum, is engraved with a seated figure of a lady holding a book consisting of four leaves ; she is writing lengthwise on one leaf, while the other three hang down from their hinge. Some of the beautiful terra-cotta statuettes from the tombs of the Boeotian Tanagra represent a girl reading from a somewhat similar double folding tablet. On Greek vases and in Roman mural paintings the pugillares are frequently shown, though the roll form of manuscript is on the whole more usual. Some examples of these tablets have been found in a good state of preservation in Graeco-Egyptian tombs and during recent excavations in Pompeii. Part of a poem in Greek written in large uncial characters is still legible on the single leaf of a pair of tablets from Memphis in Egypt, which is now in the British Museum. Though the coating of wax has nearly all perished, the CHAP. I.] OK PUGILLARES. 5 sharp stilus has marked through on to the wood behind the wax, so that the writing is still legible. Its date appears to be shortly before the Christian era 1 . Some well preserved pugillares found in Pompeii are now in the Museum in Naples; the writing on them is of less interest, consisting merely of accounts of expenditure. Though the wood is blackened and the wax destroyed, the writing is still perfectly visible on the charred surface. A more costly form of pugillares was made of bone or ivory 2 ; in some cases the back of each ivory leaf was decorated with carving in low relief. A good many examples of these tablets, dating from the third to the sixth century A.D., still exist. These late highly decorated pugillares are usually known as Consular diptychs , because, as a rule, they have on the carved back the name of a Consul, and very frequently a representation of the Consul in his pulvinar or state box presiding over the Games in the Circus. It is supposed that these ivory diptychs were in- scribed with complimentary addresses and were sent as presents to newly appointed officials in the time of the later Empire. In some cases the ancient writing-tablets consisted of three or more leaves hinged together {Tpi'irTv'^a, 'rrevTaTCTvya &c.); this was the earliest form of the codex or book in the modern sense of the word. The inner leaves of these codices had sinkings to receive the wax on both sides ; only the backs of the two outer leaves being left plain or carved in relief to form the covers. When the written matter on these tablets was no longer wanted, a fresh surface for writing was prepared either by smoothing down the wax with the handle of the stilus, or else by scraping it off and pouring in a fresh supply. This is mentioned by Ovid ( Ar. Am . I. 437); “ cera rasis infusa 1 A fine set of five tablets is preserved in the coin room in the Paris Biblio- theque Nationale ; see Revue Archcol. VIII. p. 461. 2 A well-preserved example of Roman pugillares formed of two leaves of ivory, now in the Capitoline museum in Rome, is illustrated by Baumeister, Dcnkmaler, i- P- 355- Pompeian tablets. Consular diptychs. Many- leaved tablets. 6 GREEK METHODS OF WRITING [CHAP. I. I Vaxed tablets. Whitened boards. tabellis 1 .” These tablets were sometimes called briefly cerae ; the phrases prima cera, altera cera, meaning the first page, the second page. The best sorts of wooden writing-tablets were made of box-wood, and hence they are sometimes called 7 tv^lov. In addition to the holes along one edge of each tablet through which the cord or wire was passed to hold the leaves together and to form the hinge, additional holes were often made along the opposite edge in order that the letter or other writing on the tabulae might be kept private by tying a thread through these holes and then impressing a seal on the knot. Plautus ( Bacch . IV. iv. 64) alludes to this in mentioning the various things required to write a letter, Effer cito stilum , ceram, et tabdlas et littttm. In some cases wooden tablets of this kind were used without a coating of wax, but had simply a smooth surface to receive writing with ink and a reed pen. Many ex- amples of these have been found in Egypt. The writing could be obliterated and a new surface prepared by sponging and rubbing with pumice-stone. Among the Greeks wooden boards, whitened with chalk or gypsum, were often used for writing that was intended to be of temporary use only. Charcoal was used to write on these boards, which were called XevKwfxara or 7 pa/ji/xareia \e\evKu>/j.eva~. Public advertisements and official announce- ments were frequently written in this way and then hung up in a conspicuous place in the agora or market-place of the city. Thus some of the inscriptions of the fourth century B.C., found at Delos mention that every month a \evica)/j,a was suspended in the agora , on which was written a statement of the financial management and all the expenses of the Temple 1 Lucian, who lived in the second century A.D., mentions ( Vita Luc. 11.) that when he was a boy he was in the habit of scraping the wax off his writing- lablets and using it to model little figures of men and animals. Probably he was not the only Roman school-boy who amused himself in this way. 2 Charcoal or crayon-holders of bronze with a spring clip and sliding ring, exactly like those now used, have been found in Pompeii. These and other writing materials are illustrated by Baumeister, Denhniiler, Vol. in. p. 1585. CHAP. I.] AND MEDIAEVAL SURVIVALS. 7 of the Delian Apollo during the past month. Finally, at the end of the year, an abstract of the accounts of the Temple was engraved as a permanent record on a marble stele. This was also the custom with regard to the financial records of the Athenian Parthenon, and probably most of the important Greek temples. In connection with the sacred records, the Delian inscriptions mention, in addition to the A eu/ewpara, other forms of tablets, the SeAro? and the rriva^, and also yaprai or writings on papyrus ; manuscripts of this last kind will be discussed in a subsequent section 1 . Late survivals of writing ou tablets. Before passing on to describe other forms of classical manuscripts, it may be interesting to note that the ancient waxed tablets or pugillares continued to be used for certain purposes throughout the whole mediaeval period, down to the sixteenth century or even later. Many of the principal churches, especially in Italy, but also in other countries, possessed one or more diptychs on which were inscribed the names of all those who had in any way been benefactors either to the ecclesiastical foundation or to the building. In early times, during the daily celebration of Mass, the list of names was read out from the diptych by the Deacon standing in the gospel ambon ; and the congregation was requested or “ bid ” to pray for the souls of those whose names they had just heard. The “bidding prayer” before University sermon at Oxford and Cambridge is a survival of this custom, which in the fifteenth century was termed “bidding the beads,” that is “praying for the prayers” of the congregation. In some cases fine specimens of the old ivory Consular diptychs were used for this purpose in Italian churches till comparatively late times, but as a rule they fell into disuse before the eleventh or twelfth century, as the list of names became too long for the waxed leaves of a diptych, and so by degrees vellum rolls or else codices , often beautifully written in gold and silver letters, were substituted. One of the most splendid of these lists, the 1 An Athenian inscription ( C . I. A. i. 3c) mentions accounts and other docu- ments written on mva/aa /cai 7 pafj./j.aTela. Sacred accounts. Late survivals. “ Bidding the beads.” MEDIAEVAL WAXED TABLETS 8 [CHAP. I. List of gtlild- members. Wooden Book. Bestiary. L'iber vitae of Durham, is now preserved in the British Museum ; Cotton manuscripts , Domit. 7. 2. For many other purposes, both ecclesiastical and secular, the classical waxed tablets were used in England and on the Continent, especially for lists of names, as for example in great Cathedral or Abbey churches the list for the week of the various priests who were appointed to celebrate each mass at each of the numerous altars. The British Museum possesses a very interesting late example of a waxed tablet which in shape, size and general appearance is exactly like the Roman pngillares. This is an oak tablet, about 20 inches long by 10 inches wide, covered with a thin layer of wax protected by the usual slightly raised margin about half an inch wide. Along one edge are three holes with leather loops to form the hinges ; the other leaf is lost. On the wax is inscribed a list of the names of the members of a Flemish guild ; each name is still as sharp and legible as the day it was written. The form of the writing shows that it belongs to the end of the fifteenth century. Such tablets were used both by the trade guilds of the middle ages and by the religious guilds formed for the cult of some special Saint. The most interesting mediaeval example of the classical form of manuscript made up of several leaves of waxed tablets was found a few years ago in a blocked-up recess in the old wooden church at Hopperstad in Norway. It was enclosed in a casket of wood covered with leather, and thus it still remains in a very perfect state of preservation ; it is now in the University Museum at Christiania. The book consists of six tablets of box-wood, coated with wax within the usual raised margin, and hinged with leather thongs. The outer leaves are decorated on the back with carving mixed with inlay of different coloured woods. The manuscript itself which is written on the wax is a Bestiary , dating, as its style shows, from the latter part of the thirteenth century, though the book itself is probably older. It contains lists of animals in Latin with a Norwegian translation, and it is copiously illustrated with drawings of CHAP. I.] AND IVORY TABLETS. 9 scenes from agricultural and domestic life, executed in fine outline on the wax with a sharply pointed stilus. In every detail, except of course in the character of the writing and drawings, this book exactly resembles an ancient Greek or Roman many-leaved wooden book, 7toXvtttv%ov, a very striking example of the unaltered survival of ancient methods for an extraordinarily long period. During the mediaeval period, sets of ivory tablets hinged together were frequently made for devotional purposes. This form of manuscript has no layer of wax, but the writing is executed with a pen on the thin smooth leaf of ivory. Each leaf has its margin raised, like the ancient pugillares , to prevent the two adjacent surfaces from rubbing together. These ivory tablets usually contain a set of short prayers, and they are frequently illustrated with painted miniatures of sacred subjects exactly like those in the vellum manuscripts of the same date. The South Kensington Museum possesses a very beautiful example of these ivory books ; it is of Northern French workmanship dating from about the middle of the fourteenth century. It consists of eight leaves of ivory, measuring 4.1 inches by 2§ inches in width. The six inner pages are extremely thin, no thicker than stout paper, and have paintings on both sides, the two covers are of thicker substance, about a quarter of an inch, and are decorated on the outside with beautiful carved reliefs. This remarkable work of art has on the inner leaves fourteen very delicately executed miniatures of sacred subjects, single figures of Saints and scenes from Christ’s Passion, painted in gold and colours in the finest style of French fourteenth century art, evidently executed by some very skilful illuminator. Tablets like this with as many as eight ivory leaves are rare, but a very large number of beautiful ivory diptychs still exist, with carved reliefs on the outside of very graceful style and delicate execution. Most of these diptychs date from the fourteenth century, and are of French workmanship, but Ivory tablets. Tablet with eight leaves. Ivory diptychs. Inscribed lead tablet. Horn- books. IO LEAD PLATES AND HORN-BOOKS. [CHAP. I. they were also produced in England at the same time and of quite equal merit in design and execution. Manuscripts on lead plates, like those of the ancient Greeks, were occasionally used in mediaeval times. A single lead leaf of an Anglo-Saxon manuscript from Lord Londesborough’s collection is illustrated in Arcltaeologia, Vol. xxxiv, Plate 3 6, page 438. This leaf measures 6-f- inches by 5 inches in width. On it is incised with a stilus in fine bold semi- uncial writing the beginning of Aelfric’s preface to his first collection of Homilies, which in modern English runs thus : — “ I, Aelfric, monk and mass-priest, was sent in King Aethelred’s time from Aelfeage the Bishop, the successor of Aethelwold, to a certain minster which is called Cernel, &c.” At the top of the page there is a heading in large Runic characters. Aelfric was sent by Aelfeage Bishop of Winchester to be Abbot of Cerne in 988 or 989, and this interesting page appears to be of contemporary date. It was found by a labourer while digging in the precincts of the Abbey of Bury St Edmunds. Along one edge of the leaden page there are three holes to receive the loops which hinged the plates together, but the other leaves were not found. Horn-books. One form of wooden tablet continued in use, especially in boys’ schools, till the sixteenth century. This was a wooden board, rather smaller than an ordinary school-boy’s slate, with a long handle at the bottom ; on it was fixed a sheet of vellum or paper on which was written or (in the latest examples) printed the Alphabet , the Creed, the Lord's Prayer or such like. Over this a thin sheet of transparent horn was nailed, whence these tablets were often called “ horn-books.” A good example dating from the sixteenth century is now preserved in the Bodleian library at Oxford. 1 1 CHAPTER II. Classical Manuscripts written with Pen and Ink To return now to classical forms of manuscripts, it appears to have been a long time, before the book or codex form of manuscript was extended from the wood and ivory tablets to writings on parchment or paper. It seems probable that throughout the Greek period manu- scripts on paper or vellum were usually, if not always, in the shape of a long roll ; and that it was not till about the begin- ning of the Roman Empire that leaves of parchment or paper were sometimes cut up into pages and bound together in the form of the older tablets. During the first two or three cen- turies of the Empire, manuscripts were produced in both of these forms — the codex and the volumen; but the roll form was by far the commoner, almost till the transference of the seat of government to Byzantium. The roll form of book is the one shown in many of the wall paintings of Pompeii ; but on some sarcophagi reliefs of the second century A.D. books both of the roll and the codex shape are represented 1 . Having given some account of the various classical forms of manuscript in which the writing is incised with a sharp stilus, we will now pass on to the other chief forms of manu- script which were written with a pen and with ink or other pigment. 1 See, for example, a relief on the sarcophagus of a scriba librarius or library curator which is illustrated by Daremberg and Saglio, Diet. Ant. i. p. 708. The scribe is represented seated by his book-case armarium, on the shelves of which both volumina and codices are shown. The roll form of MS. The codex form. Writing with a pen. 12 THE RITUAL OF THE DEAD. [CHAP. II. Books of the dead. Egyptian psalter. Use of papyrus. Manuscripts on papyrus ; the oldest existing examples of this class are the so-called Rituals of the Dead found in the tombs of Egypt, especially in those of the Theban dynasties ; the oldest of these date as far back as the sixteenth or fifteenth century B.C . 1 They are executed with a reed pen in hieroglyphic writing on long rolls of papyrus, and are copiously illuminated with painted miniatures illustrating the subject of the text, drawn with much spirit and coloured in a very finely decorative way. Immense numbers of these Egyptian illuminated manuscripts still exist in a more or less fragmentary condition. One of the most perfect of these is the Book of the Dead of Aui, a royal scribe, dating from the fourteenth century B.C., now in the British Museum. An excellent facsimile of the whole of this fine illuminated manuscript has been edited by Dr Budge and published by the Trustees of the British Museum in 1890. Manuscripts of this important class are not very accurately described as Rituals of the Dead ; as Dr Budge points out they really consist of collections of psalms or sacred hymns which vary considerably in different manuscripts. They appear to have been written in large numbers and kept in stock by the Egyptian undertakers ready for pur- chasers. Blank spaces were left for the name and titles of the dead person for whom they were bought. Thus we find that the names are often filled in carelessly by another hand than that of the writer of the manuscript, and some examples exist in which the spaces for the name are still left blank. Another of the finest and most complete of the funereal papyri is preserved in the Museum in Turin ; see Pierret, Le livre des Marts dcs anciens Egyptiens , Paris, 1882. Papyrus seems to have been used for manuscripts more than any other substance both by the Greeks from the sixth century B.C. and by the Romans down to the time of the later Empire. Some very valuable Greek manuscripts on papyrus are preserved in the British Museum ; among them the most 1 The ancient method of manufacturing papyrus paper is described below, see page 22. CHAP. II.] EARLY GREEK MANUSCRIPTS. 13 important for their early date arc some fragments of Homer’s Iliad of the third or second century B.C. Another papyrus manuscript in the same collection dating from the first century B.C. contains four Orations of the Athenian Orator Hyperides, a contemporary and rival of Demosthenes. In the last few years the important discovery has been made that in certain late tombs in Egypt, dating from the Roman period, the mum- mied bodies are packed in their coffins with large quantities of what was considered waste paper. This packing in some cases has been found to consist of papyrus manuscripts, some of which are of great importance. In this way the newly discovered treatise by Aristotle on the Political Constitution of Athens , and the Mimes of Herondas were saved from de- struction by being used as inner wrappings for a coffin of about the year 100 A. I). 1 Other important manuscripts may yet be found, now that careful search is being made in this direction. Unfortunately the large library of manuscripts, consisting of nearly 1800 papyrus rolls, which was discovered about the middle of the last century in the lava-buried town of Hercu- laneum, has not as yet been found to contain any works of much value or interest. These rolls are all charred by the heat of the lava, which overwhelmed the town, and the work of unrolling and deciphering the brittle carbonized paper necessarily goes on very slowly. The owner of this library appears to have been an enthusiastic student of the Epicurean philosophy in its later development, and his books arc mainly dull, pedantic treatises on the various sciences such as mathe- matics, music and the like, treated from the Epicurean point of view, or rather from that of the Graeco-Roman followers of Epicurus. All these manuscripts appear to be of about the same date, not many years older, that is, than the year 79 A.D., when the eruption of Vesuvius overwhelmed Herculaneum and Pompeii in the same catastrophe. They are written in fine bold uncial 1 Some very interesting fragments of the Antiope of Euripides have been brought to England by Mr Flinders Petrie, and have been edited by Dr Mahaffy in a collection entitled The Flinders Petrie Papyri , Dublin, 1892. Existing Greet MSS. Hercula- neum library. 14 MANUSCRIPTS ON PAPYRUS AND PARCHMENT. [CHAP. II. Papyrus rolls. Herodotus on MSS. Use of parchment. Perga - mena. characters without illumination or ornament of any kind on rolls of papyrus nine or ten inches in breadth. In their present burnt and shrunken condition the rolls average about two inches in diameter, but they were probably larger than that in their original state; see Palaeo. Soc. PI. 15 i, 152 ; the other published ‘facsimiles’ of the Herculaneum manuscripts are not perfectly trustworthy. In the time of Herodotus (c. 460 B.C.) papyrus paper or xdpTcu) 1 appears to have been used by the Greeks almost to the exclusion of parchment or other kinds of skin. In his interesting section on the introduction of the art of writing into Greece by the Phoenicians, Herodotus (v. 58) remarks that the Ionians in old times used to call papyrus rolls SapOepai or “ parchment ,” because they had once been in the habit of using skins of sheep or goats for manuscripts, at a time when papyrus paper was not to be had ; and, Herodotus goes on to say, “ Barbarians even now are accustomed to write their manuscripts on parchment." Manuscripts on parchment ; this old use of parchment for manuscripts was again introduced among the Greeks by Eumenes II., king of Pergamus from 197 to 159 B.C. At this time men had forgotten that parchment had ever been used for books, and so Varro, quoted by Pliny (Hist. Nat. XIII. 70), tells us that Eumenes invented this use of parchment ; the real fact being that he re-introduced an old custom, and stimulated the careful preparation of parchment for the sake of the great library which he was anxious to make the most important collection of manuscripts in the world. Varro tells us that he was driven to this use of parchment by the jealousy of the Egyptian King Ptolemy Epiphanes, whose enormous library at Alexandria was the only existing rival to the Pergamene collection. One of the Greek names for parchment, Perga mena , was derived from the fact of its being so largely made for the Pergamene Kings Eumenes and Attalus, both of whom were not only great patrons of 1 The book-market in Athens was called rd j3p \la, i.e. o5 rd ppUa uvia ; sec Pollux ix. 47 . Lucian, in his treatise Adversus Indoctum, gives an interesting account of the Greek book-buyers and book-sellers in his time; see § i and § 4 . CHAP. II.] MANUSCRIPTS ON LINEN AND POTSHERDS. 1 5 literature and collectors of ancient manuscripts, but were also enthusiastic buyers of pictures, statues, rich textiles and works of art of every class. The other word for parchment used for manuscripts is membrana. Manuscripts on linen ; in ancient Egypt hieroglyphic manuscripts with sacred hymns and portions of the so-called Ritual of the Dead were frequently written with a reed pen on fine linen. These manuscripts, which are often found among the mummy wrappings of burials under the Theban Dynasties, are usually illustrated with pen drawings in outline, not painted miniatures like those on the papyrus rolls. These drawings are executed with much spirit and with a beautiful, clean, certain touch. The early Italian races, Latins, Samnites and others, appear to have used linen very frequently for their manu- script records and sacred books. Among the public records mentioned by Livy as having once been preserved with the Archives in the Capitoline Temple of Juno Moneta were some of these early linen manuscripts ( libri lintei ) ; see Liv. IV. 7, 13, 20. Livy also (X. 38) describes an ancient manuscript, containing an account of the ritual customs of the Samnites, as a liber veins linteus. In historic times, however, papyrus and parchment appear to have superseded linen in ancient Rome. Ostraka Manuscripts. Lor ephemeral purposes, such as tradesmen’s accounts and other business matters, writing was often done with a pen and ink on broken fragments of pottery ( oarpara ). An enormous number of these inscribed potsherds, mostly dating from the Ptolemaic period, have been found in Egypt, and especially on the little island of Elephantine in the Nile a short distance below the first cataract. Among the Greeks too, writing on potsherds was very common , especially when the Athenian tribes met in the Agora to record their votes for the exile of some unpopular citizen, whence is derived the term ostracism {oaTpaKLcjfibp)- The word liber as meaning a book is supposed to be derived from a primitive custom of writing on the smooth inner bark Linen MSS. Early MSS. in Italy. Inscribed potsherds. MSS. on leaves. Greet: libraries. Roman libraries. 1 6 MANUSCRIPTS ON LEAVES AND BARK. [CHAP. II. of some tree, such as the birch, which supplies a fine silky substance, not at all unsuited for manuscripts. The large broad leaves of some varieties of the palm tree have also been used for manuscript purposes, more especially among the inhabitants of India and Ceylon. In early times the questions asked of the Oracle of the Pythian Apollo at Delphi were said to have been written on leaves of the laurel plant. Pali manuscripts in Ceylon are even now frequently written on palm-leaves ; and we have the evidence of Pliny that this custom once existed among some of the ancient classical races: see Hist. Nat. XIII. 69, “Ante non fuisse chartarum usum, in palmarum foliis primo scriptitatum ; deinde quarundam arborum libris. Postca publica monumenta plumbeis voluminibus, mox et privata linteis confici coepta aut ceris. Pugillarium enim usum fuisse etiam ante Trojana tempora invenimus apud Homerum.” In this passage Pliny gives a list of all the chief materials that had been used for manuscripts in ancient times, the leaves and bark of trees , plates of lead, linen cloth and waxed tablets , he then goes on to describe at considerable length the methods of making paper from the pith of the papyrus plant ; see page 22. Ancient libraries ; among the Greeks and Romans of the historic period books do not appear to have been either rare or costly as they were during the greater part of the mediaeval period. In the time of Alexander, the latter part of the fourth century B.C., large libraries had already been formed by wealthy lovers of literature, and in the second century B.C. the rival libraries of Ptolemy Epiphanes at Alexandria and of King Eumenes II. at Pergamus were said to have contained between them nearly a million volumes. Among the Romans of the Empire books were no less common. The owner of the above mentioned library at Herculaneum, consisting of nearly 1800 rolls or volumes, does not appear to have been a man of exceptional wealth ; his house was small and his surroundings simple in character. As early as the reign of Augustus, Rome possessed several large public libraries ( bibliothecae ). I he first of these CHAP. II.] ROMAN LIBRARIES. 17 was instituted in 37 B.C. by Asinius Pollio both for Greek and Latin manuscripts. The second was the Bibliotheca Octaviae founded by Augustus in the Campus Martius in honour of his sister. The third was the magnificent double library of Apollo Palatinus , which Augustus built on the Palatine Hill. The fourth, also on the Palatine, the Bibliotheca Tiberiana was founded by Tiberius. The fifth was built by Vespasian as part of the group of buildings in his new Forum Pads. The sixth and largest of all was the double library, for Greek and Latin books built by Trajan in his Forum close to the Basilica Ulpia. To some extent a classification of subjects was adopted in these great public libraries, one being mainly legal, another for ancient history, a third for state papers and modern records, but this classification appears to have been only partially adhered to. In addition to these state libraries, Rome also possessed a large number of smaller “parish libraries” in the separate vici, and the total number, given in the Regionary catalogues as existing in the time of Constantine, is enormous ; see Seraud, Lcs livres dans f antiquit e. With regard to the arrangement and fittings of Roman libraries, the usual method appears to have been this. Cup- boards (armaria), fitted with shelves to receive the rolls or codices and closed by doors, were placed against the walls all round the room. These armaria were usually rather low, not more than from four to five feet in height, and on them were placed busts of famous authors ; while the wall-space above the bookcases was decorated with similar portrait reliefs or paintings designed to fill panels or circular medallions. Pliny (Hist. Nat. XXXV. 9), speaks of it being a new fashion in his time to adorn the walls of libraries with ideal portraits of ancient writers, such as Homer, executed in gold, silver or bronze relief. The public library of Asinius Pollio was, Pliny says, decorated with portraits, but whether the great libraries of Pergamus and Alexandria were ornamented in this way, Pliny is unable to say. Magnificent medallion portraits in gold and silver were fixed round the walls of the two great The great libraries of Rome. Parish libraries. Library fittings. Library decora- tions. M. C. M. Recent dis- covery. Authors’ busts. Closed bookcases. 1 8 ROMAN LIBRARIES AND [CHAP. II. libraries of Apollo on the Palatine Hill, and probably in the other still larger public libraries which were founded by subsequent Emperors. The ordinary private libraries of Rome were decorated in a similar way, but with reliefs of less costly materials. A very interesting example of this has recently been discovered and then destroyed on the Esquiline hill in Rome. The house in which this library was discovered was one of no very exceptional size or splendour. The bibliotheca itself consisted of a handsome room ; the lower part of its walls, against which the armaria fitted, was left quite plain. Above that the walls were divided into square panels by small fluted pilasters, and in the centre of each space there was, or had been, a medallion relief-portrait about two feet in diameter enclosed in a moulded frame. All this was executed in fine, hard marble-dust stucco ( opus albarium or marmoreum'). The names of the authors whose portraits had filled the medallions were written in red upon the frames. Only one was legible — APOLLONIVS TIIYAN...No doubt the works of Apollonius of Thyana were kept in the armarium below the bust. The library at Herculaneum, which contained the famous papyrus rolls, was a much smaller room. Besides the book- cases all round the walls, it had also an isolated armarium in the centre of the room ; and this, no doubt, was a usual arrangement. The room at Herculaneum was so small that there can only have been just enough space to walk between the central bookcase and the armaria ranged all round against the wall. As the Comm. Lanciani has pointed out {Ancient Rome , p. 195), it is interesting to note that the ancient Roman method of arranging books in low, closed cupboards is still preserved in the great library of the Vatican in Rome ; which is unlike most existing libraries in the fact that on first entering no one would guess that it was a library, not a single book being visible. Of the ancient armaria themselves no example now CHAP. II.] ROMAN BOOKSELLERS. 19 exists. They were of wood, and therefore, of course, perish- able. But we may, I think, argue from analogy, that the doors of the cupboards were richly ornamented with painted decorations, thus forming an elaborate dado or podium below the row of portrait reliefs which occupied the upper part of the walls. The principal quarter in Rome for the shops of booksellers {bibliopolae or librarii) appears to have been the Argiletum, which (in Imperial times) was an important street running into the Forum Romanum between the Curia and the Basilica Aemilia; see Mart. I. 3, 117 1 2 . For ancient manuscripts or autograph works of famous authors large prices were often paid. Aristotle is said to have given three talents (about £y 50) for an autograph manuscript of Speusippus, and a manuscript of Virgil's second book of the Aeneid, thought to be the author’s own copy, sold for twenty nurei, more than £ 20 in modern value ; see Aul. Gell. Hi. 17, and II. 3. But ordinary copies of newly published works, even by popular authors, appear to have been but little more expen- sive than books of this class are at the present day. The publisher and bookseller Tryphon could sell Martial’s first book of Epigrams at a profit for two denarii — barely two shillings in modern value; see Mart. XIII. 3. It may seem strange that written manuscripts should not have been much more costly than printed books, but when one considers how they were produced the reason is evident. Atticus, the Sosii and other chief publishers of Rome owned a large number of slaves who were trained to be neat and rapid scribes. Fifty or a hundred of these slaves could write from the dictation of one reader, and thus a small edition of a new volume of Horace’s Odes or Martial’s Epigrams could be produced with great rapidity and at very small cost". Little capital would be required for the education of the Book- sellers' quarter. Cost of new books. Slave scribes. 1 The end of the Argiletum is shown in the plan of the Forum Romanum in Middleton, Ancient Rome, 1892, Vol. I. 2 One reason of this was that even the most popular authors did not receive large sums for the copyright of their works. 2 — 2 20 ROMAN BOOKSELLERS. THE TECHNIQUE [CHAP. II. Librarii. slave-scribes, and when once they were taught, the cost of their labour would be little more than the small amount of food which was necessary to keep them alive and in working order. Cicero (Att. II. 4 ) speaks of the publisher Atticus selling manuscripts produced in this way by slave labour on a large scale. The name librarius was given not only to the booksellers, but also to slave librarians, and to scribes, the latter being sometimes distinguished by the name scriptores librarii. Librarii antiquarii were writers who were specially skilled in copying ancient manuscripts. The word scriba commonly denotes a secretary rather than what we should now call a scribe. In Athens a class of booksellers, /3i/3\ioyp(t