p 1 1 i | i •1 i mmmm 1 i I Digitized by the Internet Archive in 2014 / https://archive.org/details/trueprinciplesofOOpugi_0 London.rnnli.ihrd hy John r. ■..,;■&>. ;/...■:. iioihoin.i&ii. THE TRUE PRINCIPLES OF $otntrt or Christian Srdjitrcrure : SET FORTH IN TWO LECTURES DELIVERED AT ST. MARIE'S, OSCOTT, BY A. WELBY PUGIN, ARCHITECT, AND PROFESSOR OF ECCLESIASTICAL ANTIQUITIES IN THAT COLLEGE. M.CCM.XLI. Enntton : PRINTED BY W. HUGHES, KING'S HEAD COURT, GOUGH SQUARE. THE INK SUPPLIED BY MESSRS. SHACKELL AND LYONS. WE LIST OF PLATES. Frontispiece. Plate I. Columns and Buttresses . .... to face p. 3 II. Ancient and Modern Masonry . . . . . . 18 III. Metal-Work 20 IV. Ornamental Iron -Work . . . . . . . 21 V. Almery in a Reliquary Chamber ...... 32 VI. Ancient and Modern Roofs 34 VII. Gable Ends— Ancient, &c 39 VIII. Ancient Wood -Work 40 IX. General Prospect of St. Mary Magdalen College, Oxford . . 51 47 Wood-Cuts. 31 Vignettes. 78 PRINCIPLE S OF POINTED OR CHRISTIAN ARCHITECTURE. that all ornament should consist of enrichment of the essential construction of the building. The neglect of these two rules is the cause of all the bad architecture of the present time. Architectural features are continually tacked on buildings with which they have no connexion, merely for the sake of what is termed effect ; and ornaments are actually constructed, instead of forming the decoration of construction, to which in good taste they should be always subservient. In pure architecture the smallest detail should have a meaning or serve a purpose; and even the construction itself should vary with the material employed, and the designs should be adapted to the material in which they are executed. Strange as it may appear at first sight, it is in pointed architecture alone that these great principles have been carried out ; and I shall be able to illustrate them from the vast cathedral to the simplest erection. Moreover, the architects of the middle ages were the first who turned LECTURE I. ^ (& object of the present Lecture is to set forth and explain the true principles of Pointed or Christian Architecture, by the knowledge of which you may be enabled to test architectural excellence. The two great rules for design are these : 1st, that there should be no features about a building which are not neces- * sary for convenience, construction, or propriety ; 2nd, B PRINCIPLES OF POINTED OR the natural properties of the various materials to their full account, and made their mechanism a vehicle for their art. We shall have therefore to consider ornament with reference to con- struction and convenience, and ornament with reference to architectural propriety. Construction must be subdivided and treated under three dis- tinct heads, — stone, timber, and metal ; brick might indeed be added, but as the principles of its construction are similar to those of stone, I shall not make any distinction ; and as for plaster, when used for any other purpose than coating walls, it is a mere modern deception, and the trade is not worthy of a distinction. To begin with stone. A pointed church is the masterpiece of masonry. It is essentially a stone building ; its pillars, its arches, its vaults, its intri- cate intersections, its ramified tracery, are all peculiar to stone, and could not be consistently executed in any other material. Moreover, the ancient masons obtained great altitude and great extent with a surprising economy of wall and substance ; the wonderful strength and solidity of their build- ings are the result, not of the quantity or size of the stones employed, but of the art of their disposition. To exhibit the great excellence of these con- structions, it will be here necessary to draw a comparison between them and those of the far-famed classic shores of Greece. Grecian architecture is essentially ivooden in its construction ; it originated in wooden buildings, and never did its professors possess either sufficient imagination or skill to conceive any departure from the original type. Vitruvius shows that their buildings were formerly composed of trunks of trees, with lintels or brestsummers laid across the top, and rafters again resting on them. This is at once the most ancient and barbarous mode of building that can be imagined ; it is heavy, and, as I before said, essentially wooden ; but is it not extraordinary that when the Greeks commenced building in stone, the properties of this material did * wooden Bua^^e origin of Greek riaU-2. Zr>ndon.j!tML,AM by John n r eah<.6°JIioh tfalhern.184. CHRISTIAN ARCHITECTURE. 3 not suggest to them some different and improved mode of construction ? Such, however, was not the case ; they set up stone pillars as they had set up trunks of wood ; they laid stone lintels as they had laid wood ones, flat across ; they even made the construction appear still more similar to wood, by carving triglyphs, which are merely a representation of the beam ends.. The finest temple of the Greeks is constructed on the same principle as a large wooden cabin. As illustrations of history they are extremely valuable ; but as for their being held up as the standard of architectural excellence, and the types from which our present buildings are to be formed, it is a monstrous absurdity, which has originated in the blind admiration of modern times for every thing Pagan, to the prejudice and overthrow of Christian art and propriety. The Greeks erected their columns, like the uprights of Stonehenge, just so far apart that the blocks they laid on them would not break by their own weight. The Christian architects, on the contrary, during the dark ages, with stone scarcely larger than ordinary bricks, threw their lofty vaults from slender pillars across a vast intermediate space, and that at an amazing height, where they had every difficulty of lateral pressure to con- tend with. This leads me to speak of buttresses, a distinguishing feature of Pointed Architecture, and the first we shall consider in detail. — Plate I. It need hardly be remarked that buttresses are necessary supports to a lofty wall. A wall of three feet in thickness, with buttresses projecting three feet more at intervals, is much stronger than a wall of six feet thick without buttresses. A long unbroken mass of building without light and shade is monotonous and unsightly ; it is evident, therefore, that both for strength and beauty, breaks or projections are necessary in architecture. We will now examine in which style, Christian or Pagan, these have been most successfully carried out. Pointed architecture does not conceal her construction, but beautifies it : classic architecture seeks to conceal instead of decorating it, and therefore has resorted to the use of engaged columns as breaks for strength and effect ; — nothing can be worse. A column is an architectural member which should only 4 PRINCIPLES OF POINTED OR be employed when a superincumbent weight is required to be sustained without the obstruction of a solid wall ; but the moment a wall is built, the necessity and propriety of columns cease, and engaged columns always produce the effect of having once been detached, and the intermediate spaces blocked up afterwards. A buttress in pointed architecture at once shows its purpose, and diminishes naturally as it rises and has less to resist. An engaged column, on the contrary, is overhung by a cornice. A buttress, by means of water tables, can be made to project such a distance as to pro- duce a fine effect of light and shade. An engaged column can never project far on account of the cornice, and all the other members, neces- sarily according with the diameter of the column, would be increased beyond all proportion. I will now leave you to judge in which style the real intention of a buttress is best carried out. Flying Buttresses. I have yet to speak of flying buttresses, those bold arches, as their name implies, by which the lateral thrust of the nave groining is thrown over the aisles and trans- ferred to the massive lower but- tresses. Here again we see the true principles of Christian architec- ture, by the conversion of an es- sential support of the building into a light and elegant decoration. Wbp can stand among the airy arches of Amiens, Cologne, Char- tres, Beauvais, or Westminster, and not be filled with admiration CHRISTIAN ARCHITECTURE. 5 at the mechanical skill and beautiful combination of form which are united in their construction ? But, say the modern critics, they are only props, and a bungling contrivance. Let us examine this. Are the revived pagan buildings constructed with such superior skill as to dispense with these supports ? By no means ; the clumsy vaults of St. Paul's, London, mere coffered semi-arches, without ribs or intersections, have their flying but- tresses ; but as this style of architecture does not admit of the great principle of decorating utility, these buttresses, instead of being made ornamental, are concealed by an enormous screen, going entirely round the building. So that in fact one half of the edifice is built to conceal the other. Miserable expedient ! worthy only of the debased style in which it has been resorted to. 6 PRINCIPLES OF POINTED OR It is proper to remark that the cluster of pinnacles at A are not carried up for mere ornament, but, by their weight, to increase the resistance of the great pinnacle at the point of thrust. We will now proceed, in the second place, to consider groining and vaulting, which are solely adapted to stone construction. A groined ceiling is divided into compartments by means of ribs spring- ing from caps or corbels, and uniting in bosses placed at the intersections ; the spaces between the ribs are termed spandrils : the word boss signifies a spring of water, and has doubtless been applied to the key-stones of vaults, as the ribs seem to spring or separate from them. Here again the great principle of decorating utility is to be observed. A stone ceiling is most essential in a large church, both for durability, security from fire, 1 and conveyance of sound. It is impossible to conceive stone ceilings better contrived than those of the ancient churches ; they are at once light, substantial, beautiful, and lofty. 1st. They are light, because, their principal strength lying in the ribs, the intermediate spaces or spandrils are filled in with small light stones. 2nd. They are sub- stantial, for all the stones being cut to a centre and forming portions of a curve, when united they are capable of re- sisting immense pressure, the keys or bosses wedging all together. 3rd. They are beautiful, for no ceiling can be conceived more graceful and elegant than a long perspective of lines and arches radiating from exquisitely carved centres. 4th. They are lofty, not only on ac- count of the elevation at which they are placed, but that their construction permits the cleres- tory windows to be carried up level with the crown of the arch in the intermediate spaces. 1 Within the last few years the roofs have been burnt off the cathedrals of Rouen, Chartres, and Bruges ; and, owing to the strength of the stone vaulting, the interiors of these churches have scarcely been injured ; while York Minster has twice been completely * . 5^ CHRISTIAN ARCHITECTURE. 7 In the groining of the later styles we find a great departure from the severe and consistent principles I have been describing. Henry the Seventh's Chapel at Westminster is justly considered one of the most wonderful examples of ingenious construction and elaborate fan groining in the world, but at the same time it exhibits the commencement of the bad taste, by constructing its ornament instead of confining it to the enrichment of its construction. I allude to the stone pendants of the ceiling, which are certainly extravagances. A key-stone is necessary for Pendant. the support of arched ribs ; the older architects contented themselves with enriching it with foliage or figures, but those of the later styles allowed four or five feet of unnecessary stone to hang down into the church, and from it to branch other ribs upwards. This is at most an ingenious trick, and quite unworthy of the severity of Pointed or Christian architecture. 2 gutted within a short period through the want of a stone groining ; and yet a mere wood and plaster ceiling has been again constructed ! 2 This is one among many other symptoms of decline apparent in the later works in the pointed style. The moment the flat or four-centred arch was introduced, the spirit of Christian architecture was on the wane. Height or the vertical principle, emblematic of the resur- rection, is the very essence of Christian architecture. It was to attain greater elevation with a given width that the pointed arch was employed ; and the four- centred arch does not possess equal advantage in this respect with the old semi ; and although some of the later buildings, as King's College Chapel, Cambridge, still retain the principle of internal height, with the use of the depressed arch, yet who can avoid being struck with the inconsistency of 8 PRINCIPLES OF POINTED OR In the third place, we will proceed to the use and intention of pinnacles and spiral terminations. I have little doubt that pinnacles are considered running up walls to a prodigious elevation, and then, instead of carrying out the principle, and springing a lofty groin, losing a considerable increase of height by a flattened thrusting arched ceiling ; the form of which is a sort of contradiction to the height at which it is commenced. I do not make this observation by way of disparaging the merits of this stupendous building, but merely to show the early decay of the true principles of pointed architecture which may be traced even in that glorious pile. We not unfrequently find the bulbous form employed in the Tudor period : this, which afterwards became the prevailing form of the Dresden and Flemish steeples, is of the worst possible taste ; and why P Because M it is a form which does not ''\ result from any consistent t mode of constructing a co- vering, and, on the contrary, re- quires by its shape to be constructed, as will be seen by the annexed sketch ; by the side of which I have placed a spire, the severe form and decoration of which are quite con- sistent with the true principles of rendering the necessary roof or covering of a tower elegant in ap- pearance, without departing from essential construction for the sake of ornament. One of the greatest defects of St. Paul's, London, is its fictitious dome. The dome that is seen is not the dome of the church, but a mere construc- tion for effect. At St. Peter's the dome is the actual covering of the building, and is therefore constructed in that respect on the true principle ; but, as will be perceived by the an- Bulbous Covering or Steeple, in the debased style. Spiral Covering or Steeple, in the Christian style. CHRISTIAN ARCHITECTURE. by the majority of persons as mere ornamental excrescences, introduced solely for picturesque effect. The very reverse of these is the case ; and I shall be able to show you that their introduction is warranted by the soundest principles of construction and design. They should be regarded as answering a double intention, both mystical and natural : their mystical intention is, like other vertical lines and terminations of Christian architecture, to represent an emblem of the Resurrection ; their natural intention is that of an upper weathering, to throw off rain. The most useful covering for this purpose, and the one that would naturally suggest itself, is of the form represented in the annexed figure : only let this essential form be decorated with a finial and crockets, and we have at once a perfect pinnacle. Now the square piers of which these floriated tops form the terminations are all erected to answer a useful purpose ; when they rise nexed section, the upper part of St. Paul's is mere imposing show, constructed at a vast expense without any legitimate reason. From the various symptoms of decline which I have shown to have existed in the later pointed works, I feel convinced that Christian architecture had gone its length, and it must necessarily have destroyed itself by departing from its own principles in the pursuit of novelty, or it must have fallen back on its pure and ancient models. This is quite borne out by existing facts. Now that the pointed style is reviving, we cannot successfully suggest any thing new, but are obliged to return to the spirit of the ancient work. Indeed, if we view pointed architecture in its true light as Christian art, as the faith itself is perfect, so are the principles on which it is founded. We may indeed improve in mechanical contrivances to expedite its execution, we may even increase its scale and grandeur ; but we can never successfully deviate one tittle from the spirit and principles of pointed architecture. We must rest content to follow, not to lead; we may indeed widen the road which our Catholic forefathers formed, but we can never depart from their track without a certainty of failure being the result of our presumption. Section of the Dome of St. Paul's. 10 PRINCIPLES OF POINTED OR from the tops of wall buttresses, they serve as piers to strengthen the parapet, which would be exceedingly weak without some such support. Fig. S. Their utility on the great piers which resist the flying buttresses has been already mentioned under the head of buttress. At the bases of great spires, the clusters of pinnacles are also placed to increase strength and resistance ; in short, wherever pin- nacles are introduced in pure pointed architecture, they will be found on examination to fulfil a useful end. The same remarks will apply to the crocketed and floriated terminations of staircase and other turrets, which are in fact ornamented roofs ; and I need hardly remark that turrets were not carried up without a legitimate reason. Every tower built during the pure style of pointed architecture either was, or was intended to be, surmounted by a spire, which is the natural covering for a tower ; a flat roof is both contrary to the spirit of the style, and it is also practically bad. There is no instance before the year 1400 of a church tower being erected without the intention at least of being covered or surmounted by a spire ; and those towers antecedent to that period which we find without such terminations have either been left incom- plete for want of funds, weakness in the sub-structure, or some casual impediment, — or the spires, which were often of timber covered with lead, have been pulled down for the sake of their material. 3 In fine, when towers were erected with flat embattled tops, Christian architecture 3 The following glorious churches have been stripped of their spires since the views in Dugdale's Monasticon were taken: — Hereford Cathedral, Worcester Cathedral, Southwell Minster, Rochester Cathedral, Ely Cathedral, Ripon Minster, Finchal Abbey, and Lincoln Cathedral. It is to be remembered that these views were taken above a century after the lead- stripping and spire-demolishing period commenced. CHRISTIAN ARCHITECTURE. 11 was on the decline, and the omission of the ancient and appropriate ter- mination was strong evidence of that fact. Towers surmounting gate- houses were never terminated by spires, for, being originally built for defence, the space at top was required for that purpose. This is the real reason why square-topped and embattled towers are said to be of a domestic character ; so that even by persons unacquainted with the use and intentions of spires, they are associated with the idea of ecclesiastical architecture. The pitch of roof in pointed architecture is another subject on which some useful observations may be made. It will be found, on examination, that the most beautiful pitch of a roof or gable end is an inclination sufficiently steep to throw off snow without giving the slate or lead covering too perpendicular a strain, which is formed by two sides on an equilateral triangle. If this form be departed from, the gable appears either painfully acute or too widely spread. All really beautiful forms in architecture are based on the soundest principles of utility. Practical men know that flat-pitched roofs, which are exceedingly ugly in appearance, are also but ill calculated to resist the action of weather. In slated roofs especially, gusts of wind actually blow under and lift up the covering : when the pitch is increased to its proper eleva- tion, the whole pressure of the wind is lateral, and forces the covering closer to the roof. 12 PRINCIPLES OF POINTED OR I now come to speak, in the fourth place, of mouldings, on the judicious form and disposition of which a very considerable part of the effect of the building depends. Mouldings are the enrichment of splays of doorways, windows, arches, and piers, of base and string- courses, of weatherings , and copings, and they are y introduced solely on the principle of decorating the useful. I will first point out the necessity of these splays and weatherings, and then proceed to consider the form and application of mouldings to them. It will be readily seen that without a splay a considerable portion of light would be excluded, and that this form of jamb is necessary to the use and intention of a window. In a doorway the convenience of splayed sides must be evident for ordinary ingress and egress. This form of jamb is therefore necessary to the use and intention of a doorway. The advantage of piers splayed, or placed diagonally over square ones, both for elegance and convenience, must be evident to all ; the arch mould over them is consequently splayed. This form of pier and arch mould is therefore necessary for both piers and arches. Great increase of solidity and strength is gained by projections at the Square Piers supporting Arches. Splayed Piers supporting Arches. CHRISTIAN ARCHITECTURE. 13 base of a building as sets-off ; but were these projections ll left flat at top instead of being bevelled off, they would rji I become lodgments for water. The splayed or bevelled form is therefore necessary for base moulds. Strings and copings, the very inten- tion of which is to throw off water, must be sloped, for the same reason. The use of the splayed form being now demonstrated, I will proceed to consider the mouldings used to enrich it. All mouldings should be designed on the principle of light, shadow, and half tint; and the section of a moulding should be of such a form as to produce various and pleasing gradations of light and shadow. Monotony should be care- fully avoided, also all cutting shadows near the outer edge, which have a meagre effect. The original splayed form should never be lost sight of in the sinkings of the mould, which ought not to be so extravagantly deep as to produce both a real and apparent weak- ness in the jamb. All the mouldings of jamb are in- variably sunk from the face of the work. A projecting mould in such a situation Examples of ancient jamb Moulds. would be a useless excrescence, and contrary to the principles of pointed architecture, which do not admit of any unnecessary members. A hood mould projects immediately above the springing of the arch to receive the water running down the wall over the window, and convey it off on either side. This projection 14 PRINCIPLES OF POINTED OR Examples of ancient Jamb Moulds. answers a purpose, and therefore is not only allowable but indispen- sable in the pointed style ; but a projection down the sides of jamb, where it would be utterly useless, is never found among the monuments of antiquity. Modern Jamb Mould, weak and wiry. French Jamb Mould of the late styles, extravagantly hollowed. The mouldings round an arch are generally more sub- divided than those of the jamb. This is carrying out the same principle that may be observed in vegetation, where the solid trunk spreads and divides as it rises upwards. The use of caps at the springing of arches is to receive the different moulds of jamb and arch, which could not be suc- cessfully united by any better means than foliated and moulded projec- tions. Hence, in the later pointed continental churches, where the same moulds run up the jambs and round the arches without interruption, caps are entirely omitted ; and the same thing is observable, under similar CHRISTIAN ARCHITECTURE. L5 circumstances, in the nave of Crowland Abbey, Lincolnshire. The next class of mouldings I will notice are those belonging to base moulds, weatherings, and strings. I have shown above that the bevelled form is necessary for these projections ; but when the weathering is of any depth, it is evident that the inclined plane cut by the horizontal joints of the masonry will produce what are technically called feather-edged joints, at aaa, which would be easily broken by the action of frost, and the joints themselves would Caps at the transition from Jamb to Arch Mould. be penetrated by water. A M, To obviate this, all the varied and beautiful Ancient examples of Base Moulds and Weatherings. 16 PRINCIPLES OF POINTED OR moulds of weatherings have been introduced, by the form of which the stones are strengthened at the joints, and they are protected from the action of water by the over- hanging mould throwing it off to the next bevel. These observations will apply equally to string- courses and copings. Another important consideration relative to mouldings, and by which their profile should in a great measure be regulated, is the position in which they are placed with relation to the eye of the spectator. The CHRISTIAN ARCHITECTURE. 17 Ancient Profiles of Corbel Moulds. slope of weatherings themselves is deter- mined by this principle, the pitch increasing with the height that they are placed from the ground. Were this not attended to, the upper water table would be lost to a spec- tator, unless he was at a considerable dis- tance from the building. In corbel moulds the profile should be so formed as to gain projection with strength, Modern and Weak Corbel Mould. avoiding deep hollows and un- necessary nozings. The apparent width of a string- course placed above the eye de- pends almost as much on the top bevel as on its actual width ; for d IS PRINCIPLES OF POINTED OR string-courses of equal width, with different bevels, will vary considerably to the eye. Every moulding in a pointed building must be designed and shaped on these consistent principles. The severity of Christian architecture requires a reasonable purpose for the introduction of the smallest detail, and daily experience proves that those who attempt this glorious style without any fixed idea of its unalterable rules, are certain to end in miserable failures. Another most important, but now most neglected part of masonry, is the jointing of the stones. All bond and solidity is frequently sacrificed for what is called a neat joint, by setting one stone on end to form a jamb (Plate II. fig. A), when the same space in good old constructions would have been occupied by five or six stones tailing into the wall, and lying in their natural bed (fig. B) ; a point which should be most strictly attended to. Or, if the jambs are built in courses, they are made as uniform as possible, like rustics (fig. C). By this means the effect of the window is spoiled ; the eye, owing to the regularity of these projections, is carried from the line of jamb to them, while in the old masonry (fig. D) the irregular outline of the stones does not interfere with the mouldings of the window. Another point to be remarked in the ancient masonry is the smallness of the stones employed : now, independently of this being the strongest mode of construction, it adds considerably to the effect of the building by increasing its apparent scale. Large stones destroy proportion; and to illustrate this I have given two representations of the same piece of architecture differently jointed. Figs. E, F. Not only are the stones which are used in the ancient buildings exceedingly small, but they are also very irregular in size, and for the same reason as I have before mentioned, that the jointing might not appear a regular feature, and by its lines interfere with those of the building. Plale II. Ze/ido/iJ'ui/is/ieci bv John Wca/e. jff.Ifigh J/oliorn.iS.u. CHRISTIAN ARCHITECTURE. 19 In the early buildings the work was carried up in regular beds : there were as many joints in a detached pillar as in the wall, and equal space was occupied by the mortar in every part of the building. The joints of stone tracery should always be cut to the centre of the curve where they fall ; and if the joint crosses three or four different curves, its bed should vary with those curves ; and without this is rigidly ad- f hered to in the construction .'*{) ♦3? if 1$ 19 of stone tracery, the work must be devoid of the neces- sary strength. Any of the great circular or mullioned windows of the ancient cathedrals will fully illustrate this principle. Images in these northern countries were, with some very few excep- tions, placed in niches under canopies. This is really necessary to pre- serve the sculpture from the injuries of weather, and it is much more consistent than leaving the venerable image of a saintly or royal per- 3&e 20 PRINCIPLES OF POINTED OR sonage exposed to all the pelting of the pitiless storm. Detached images, surmounting buildings, are characteristic of southern and Italian archi- tecture, and are much better suited to the climate of Milan than that of England. Having now, I trust, successfully shown that the ornamental parts of pointed stone buildings are merely the decorations of their essential construction, and that the formations of mouldings and details are regu- lated by practical utility. I will endeavour to illustrate the same principles in ancient metal and wood- work. We now come to the consideration of works in metal ; and I shall be able to show that the same principles of suiting the design to the material and decorating construction were strictly adhered to by the artists of the middle ages in all their productions in metal, whether precious or common. In the first place, hinges, locks, bolts, nails, &c, which are always concealed in modern designs, were rendered in pointed architecture rich and beautiful decorations; and this not only in the doors and fittings of buildings, but in cabinets and small articles of furniture. The early hinges covered the whole face of the doors with varied and flowing scroll-work. Of this description are those of Notre Dame at Paris, St. Elizabeth's church at Marburg, the western doors of Litchfield Cathedral, the Chapter House at York, and hundreds of other churches, both in England and on the continent. Plate III. figs. 1 and 3. Hinges of this kind are not only beautiful in design, but they are practically good. We all know that on the principle of a lever a door may be easily torn off its modern hinges by a strain applied at its outward edge, (fig. 2.) This could not be the case with the ancient hinges, which extended the whole width of the door, and were bolted through in various ON METAL-WORK. riate m. -Londvnl'ufilished by John R r eale...i£.Kig?vJ£oltt