"^^ es. ' ' ■ v_. Digitized by the Internet Archive in 2010 with funding from Research Library, The Getty Research Institute http://www.archive.org/details/examplesofgothic01pugi EXAMPLES OF (gotI)ic ^[rcliitecture: SELECTED FROM VARIOUS ANTIENT EDIFICES IN ENGLAND: CONSISTING OF PLANS, ELEVATIONS, SECTIONS, AND PARTS AT LARGE; CALCULATED TO EXEMPLIFY THE VARIOUS STYLES, AND THE PRACTICAL CONSTRUCTION OF THIS ADMIRED CLASS OF ARCHITECTURE: \ ACCOMPANIED BY By a. PUGIN,— ARCHITECT. THE LITERARY PART BY E. J. WILLSON, F.S.A. SECOND EDITIOX, WITH CORRECTED PLATES. LONDON: HENRY G. BOHN, YORK STREET, COVENT GARDEN. M.DCCC.XXXVIII. LONDON: PRINTED EY JAMES SIOYES, CASTLE STREET, LEICESTER SQUARE. PREFACE. With feelings of the greatest satisfaction, I am at length enabled to present my Work to the Public in a finished state, and I trust that it will be found fully answerable to the conditions announced at the commencement,* and worthy of the flattering encouragement with which it has been carried on. An apology is due to my sub- scribers for the delay that has taken place in the publication of the letter-press. That delay has been a subject of deep anxiety and uneasiness to me, though beyond my power to avoid, without injury to the work itself; being occasioned principally by the illness and various avocations of the gentleman who had undertaken the literary part of the volume, and who, no less than myself, was extremely desirous of making the "Examples of Gothic Architecture " a truly valuable work, without sparing any pains or expense that might con- duce to its perfection. My thanks are most gratefully offered to the subscribers to my work, and particularly to the many gentlemen professionally engaged in architecture, without whose liberal encouragement and patronage I should not have ventured to undertake the publication. * The number of Plates has been increased from seventy-two, as originally proposed, to seventy-five, with a corresponding addition to the descriptive part of the subjects. IV PREFACE. To Mr. John Le Keux, whose talents are too well known to admit of praise from me, I am much indebted for the satisfactory execution of many of the engravings. Mr. Willson will accept of my acknowledgments for his friendly and zealous co-operation, not only in the literary department, but also in the choice and arrangement of the subjects, as well as the general plan of the work. With the assistance of this gentleman, and relying on a continuance of the kind encouragement of my patrons, I intend to commence a second series of " Examples of Gothic Architecture," in a volume of corresponding character to the present. The conditions of publication of the new series being stated in the accompanying prospectus, it is unnecessary to repeat them. Many sketches and drawings have been prepared for this work, and subscriptions are most respectfully solicited. Every endeavour will be used to render the second series of " Examples " equal, if not superior, to the present ; and arrangements made for publishing the letter-press in successive portions at the same periods with the plates, in order to prevent any disappointment at the conclusion of the work AUGUSTUS PUGIN. 105 Great Russell Street, Bloomsbury, London, July 1831. 3i^emarfes ON (^otj)ic ^rcf)itecture AND iBoticnt 3>mitation^. In the selection of the subjects for this work, a preference has been given to such as appeared most likely to afford useful lessons to the modern artist ; and, with this view, the early varieties of style which distinguish the works of the twelfth and thirteenth centuries have been passed over ; the oldest of these " Examples " being dated in the reign of Edward I.* The omission of any exainples of the Early Pointed or Lancet Style, will perhaps be censured by some critics, who may insist that a few subjects of that beautiful style ought to have had a place. In extenuation of any such charge, it may be pleaded, that the present work does not offer the display of a complete series of examples in all the successive variations of style ; but merely exhibits a selection of such as have appeared best suited * See Plate V. of JMerton College, Oxford ; and the description at page 2. VI INTRODUCTORY REMARKS. for imitation, particularly in domestic architecture, for which the lancet style is peculiarly inconvenient. With this purpose in view, the "Examples" have been chiefly taken from habitable buildings; civil architecture of the Gothic style being much less generally understood than ecclesiastical. The colleges of the Univei'sity of Oxford have supplied a large share of subjects, and the excellence of most of those selected will, it is hoped, sufficiently justify their insertion; the works of those venerable and scientific prelates, Wykeham, Waynflete and Chichele, being considered by the best judges as pre-eminent models of archi- tectural excellence, wherever they have escaped the injuries of time and barbarous alterations. The palatial halls of Eltham and Croydon exhibit fine specimens of the open timber roof; especially the former, where the bay- windows are also of exquisite beauty. The stately entrance of Oxborough hall is a superior example of semi-castellated architec- ture ; and a charming variety of rich details will be found in the Plates of East Basham and Thorpland halls, and the rector's house at Great Snoring, in Norfolk. These three mansions are all con- structed with brick, and their ornaments shew what patient and skilful workmanship may effect, even in the humblest materials ; but, without recommending an imitation of such elaborate works, their beautiful forms may be advantageously transferred to stone, which, both in colour and substance, must always hold a superiority over brick. To the description of the principal subjects, some sketches of their history have been prefixed, in order to give a mqre compre- hensive knowledge of the buildings from which the particular Examples have been taken ; and small ground-plans have been intro- duced for the same purpose. The above statement will explain the plan and intention of the present work ; and some observations on the history of the Gothic or Pointed style of architecture, and its modern practice, will now be given, in continuation of the introductory essays prefixed to the two volumes of " Specimens." INTRODUCTORY REMARKS. Vll In one of those essays the study of ancient architecture was compared to that of the dead languages, and some points of analogy were briefly noticed, in order to illustrate the principles of compo- sition.* To pursue a similar idea, the "Examples of Gothic Archi- tecture," as well as the "Specimens," may be aptly compared to collections of personal memoirs, original letters, wills, or other documents of genuine history ; whilst books of modern architectural designs rather resemble fictitious narratives, or historical romances. No inferiority of merit is here imputed to such productions, nor is it intended to raise an invidious competition with any works of that description : the only aim is to shew that their merits are of a different order. Here is no claim to invention. Fidelity must con- stitute the chief value of the work ; and, bearing this consideration always in mind, the strictest attention has been paid to the display of every subject exactly as it exists ; or, where the original has become imperfect, to ascertain, by a careful examination of those parts which yet remain entire, how much is wanting to restore the whole to a complete state, and so to represent it. Such a task must, of course, be frequently attended with difficulty, and, in certain instances, could not be performed without trusting something to imagination ; but no liberty of this sort has been taken where the original authority could be obtained. However, after using all practicable care and diligence, some inaccuracies may perhaps be discovered, and for these the indulgence of the public must be solicited. The approbation which has been shewn towards the "Specimens" makes it unnecessary to say much on the utility of works of this description. It is only through the medium of accurate prints that a thorough knowledge of the architecture of the middle ages can be obtained ; as by the same means the classic orders of Greece and Rome have at length become properly understood. Very few artists have opportunities of visiting and making an actual examination of any considerable number of the original * Remarks on " Gothic Architecture," in Vol. I. of" Si^ecimens," page xx. via INTRODUCTORY REMARKS. sul)jects; and the variety of invention which these edifices display is so immense, and their details are frequently of such a rich and complicated design, that a patient and experienced hand is necessary to* produce a faithful picture. Moreover, a comparison of different subjects is frequently required, in order to discover and elucidate the principles of their design. The want of these aids occasioned the failures of Sir Christopher Wren, Hawksmoor, Kent, and other architects of the two last centuries, in their Gothic works. The elements of the style had not then been investigated, their knowledge was limited to superficial observation, and consequently they produced mishapen abortions of taste. — But, it may be asked, are we to be confined to a servile imitation of ancient models? By no means. Such restriction would be absurd. Nevertheless, while so many bald and imperfect designs are continually produced, even in the metropolis, to the disgrace of the modern Gothic school, it must be acknowledged that there is something to be learned, before our works shall bear a comparison with those of our forefathers. The trusting too much to invention, without sufficient science, has produced an infinity of contemptible designs. The Gothic Architecture of Batty Langley is universally condemned, and very justly;* but other artists * See " Gothic Architecture improved l^y Rules and Proportions, in many grand Designs of Columns, &c. &c. by B. and T. Langley. To which is added, an Historical Disserta- tion on Gothic Architecture," in 4to. 'We number of plates is sixty-two ; all produced by the brothers, Batty and Thomas Langley, and dated in the years 1741, 1742. The prefatory dissertation is signed with the initials B. L., and occupies seven pages. In it the author states, that he had assiduously employed himself for upwards of twenty years in recovering the rules of our ancient architecture, which had been lost for many centuries, in order to restore and publish them for the good of posterity, &c. Sucli an instance of perverted ingenuity was perhaps never exhibited by any other person ; for it is hardly conceivable, that a man should study the ancient buildings of his own country for twenty vears, and then produce nothing but a parcel of strange inventions, totally unlike what had ever been practised. The same architect also published, besides his opus magnum, "The Builder's Director or Bench-Mate, being a Pocket Treasury of the Grecian, Roman, and Gothic Orders of Architecture ;" with several other works of a small size. His Gothic designs are execrable ; but his manner of displaying the details of Italian archi- tecture is very neat and useful. IXTRODUCTORY REMARKS. IX ought to take a part in his shame ; for, long since the unlucky pub- lication of his " Five Gothic Orders," some inventions, scarcely less barbarous, have been put forth by certain architects, who must after- wards have blushed at their early productions. Unfortunately, some of these wretched works, after being discarded from the library, have found their way into the workshop, or the mechanic's lodging, and there they may continue to disseminate false taste, where it is not likely to be soon corrected.* Since the revival of the Gothic style, in the reign of George III., no abatement of public favour towards this beautiful species of architecture has been hitherto manifested ; on the contrary, a great number of country-seats, for the residence of the nobility and gentry, has been raised within the last few years, in imitation of castles, abbeys, and mansions of the fifteenth and sixteenth centuries. A prodigious sum has been expended in the repair and embellishment of the royal castle of Windsor. Some of the principal colleges at Oxford have been repaired with a commendable attention to their original style, and many grievous injuries inflicted on those venerable edifices have been amended, though not with uniform correctness. The University of Cambridge has received still greater improvements, by the erection of some magnificent buildings, mostly in the style of the fifteenth century. Many new parochial churches and chapels have been erected, in order to accommodate the increased population of the metropolis, and of some provincial towns, in professed imitation of our old ecclesiastical architecture. The repair of several cathedrals has been prosecuted with becoming liberality, and a strictness of architectural propriety heretofore unknown. Amongst these works the chief place must doubtless be given to the restoration of the * I very lately saw a workman of good talents diligently employed in modelling from a most barbarous design, — a genuine specimen of the Lamjleian Gothic school, though published by a celebrated architect. This ingenious man had been favoured with the use of the book by his master, who had much better have committed it to the fire. b X INTRODUCTORY REMARKS. choir of York Minster, after its destruction by an incendiary, mad with fanaticism. We may justly expect to see this superb structure renovated in all its former beauty, since public munificence has provided ample funds for the work. Winchester and Peterborough cathedrals, the collegiate church of Beverley, and some other prin- cipal churches, have received very considerable reparations ; and many of our ancient parochial churches have participated in the general improvement.* This extensive revival of Gothic architecture has excited a more attentive study of its proportions and peculiarities, and knowledge has in its turn diffused a better taste. Not only are such gross ano- malies as the chapel of Lincoln's Inn, and the towers of Westminster Abbey, condemned as barbarous, and unworthy of true genius ; but even the imperfect efforts of some later architects, who professed to admire and follow the style which Inigo Jones and Sir Christo- pher Wren avowedly despised and neglected, — even these are now censured, and have their faults exposed. When the cathedrals of Hereford, Durham, Salisbury, and Lichfield, were altered agreeably to the taste of the late Mr. James Wyatt, only a few professed antiquaries dared to remonstrate. Mr. Gough, Sir Henry Englefield, Dr. Milner, and John Carter, openly censured the gross violations of antiquity committed in those churches :f but their interference was generally treated with ridicule, or resented with indignation. Salisbury and Lichfield were thought to be much improved by the demolition of their altar-screens, the throwing open of the smaller * The state of the greater mimljer of country cluirches, however, is very deplorable. They are either neglected, and become unfit for use, from the damp and dirty state into which they have gradually fallen ; or are disfigured and mutilated by tasteless and penurious attempts at repair. It is hard to say wliich of these modes of destruction is the worst ; but, between the two, many noble monuments of the taste and piety of past ages, which will never be replaced, are daily sinking into ruin. t See the " Gentleman's Magazine" for 1789, 1790, 1796, &c.— Dr. Milner published " A Dissertation on the INIodern Style of altering Ancient Cathedrals." Second edition, 4to, 1811. IN'TllODUCTORY REMARKS. Xl chantries, and the removal of the ancient tombs from the graves to which they belonged, in order to range them in rank and file. These barbarisms were praised and admired, because the public mind was ignorant on the subject. Fortunately, a partial check was put to the progress of innovation, and Durham Cathedral was saved from the completion of its intended improvements. The magnificent rere-dos of the high altar, the episcopal throne, the western chapel, called the "Galilee," and the "Nine Altars" at the east end, were left untouched ; but the chapter-house, which had no equal in its peculiar style, was sacrificed for the erection of a common square parlour ; and the pencil of the indefatigable John Carter has pre- served all that is left to posterity of that most curious edifice. Such havoc could not be committed with impunity in the present day, or at least it would soon become a subject of general and severe animadversion ;* for the study of ancient architecture is not now confined to the mere antiquary, but has become almost a part of polite education, and no architect can make any creditable pretensions to professional knowledge without an intimate acquaintance with the varieties of the Gothic style. The revival of Gothic architecture seems almost peculiar to this country; scarcely any thing having been done on the continent in the construction of modern buildings after this manner, and but little in the investigation of ancient monuments. Tliis backward- ness of taste in our neighbours is mortifying to the English student ; as undoubtedly a great fund of curious information, relative to the practice of architecture during the middle ages, will be brought forth whenever the study of the Gothic style shall become general on the continent. One important fact has been abundantly evinced ; viz., that there are no solid grounds for the pretensions advanced by certain writers to the pointed arch as our national invention, in * This may be inferred from the excitement shewn on the proposed removal of tlie ancient rooddoft, now used for the organ, in York Minster. Those gentlemen who are advocates of that measure, would do well to peruse the " Dissertation" referred to in the last note. Xll INTRODUCTORY REMARKS. consequence of which they presumed to apply the denomination of " Engllsli Ai'c/iitecture" to the cathedrals and other edifices in which it prevails. The origin of the pointed arch, after the most earnest and active researches, still remains a very obscure question ; but the period of its becoming a prominent feature in the architecture of Europe seems to have been incontrovertibly ascertained ; and all the variations of style successively prevalent in England, from the time of its introduction to the latest use of the pointed arch, have been minutely traced, and their respective ages discovered by the evidence of historical records, or satisfactory analogy. Whether the architects of France or Germany preceded their English brethren in the march of invention, or not, must remain unsettled till the monuments of those countries shall have been thoroughly investigated, and their proportions and details exemplified by geometrical delineations ; for the verbal descriptions of travellers are of very little practical use, and perspective views can seldom be relied upon, — critical accuracy in such productions being too commonly regarded of small import- ance in comparison with a pleasing effect. The ancient architecture of Normandy has undergone a tolerably accurate examination, and some of its principal monuments have been made familiar to the English architect, through the exertions of his own countryman.* This commencement will, it is hoped, stimulate the French nation to undertake the task of investigation on a liberal and extended scale. The Society of Antiquaries of * " Account of a Tour in Normandy," by Dawson Turner, Esq. F.R.S. 2 vols. 8vo, 1820. " The Architectural Antiquities of Normandy," by J. S. Cotman. Folio, 1820. " Specimens of the Architectural Antiquities of Normandy," by Augustus Pugin, Architect. 4to, 1828. The latter work is on a similar plan to the English "Specimens of Gothic Archi- tecture." It contains eighty plates, in which are disiilayed some edifices of great interest to the architectural student ; particularly the two abbeys erected at Caen by William the Conqueror and his Queen Matilda, the cathedral of Bayeux, and the exquisite church of St. Ouen at Rouen, together witli some beautiful specimens of domestic architecture, of a style quite unlike any thing in England. INTRODUCTORY REMARKS. Xlll Normandy have published a few essays, illustrative of the history of some early buildings in that province,* but the study of Gothic architecture in France is still in its infancy, and may be dated half a century later than in England. Nor has the inquiry been ex- tensively prosecuted in Germany, where, however, some highly interesting facts have been brought to light, particularly in the dis- covery of several ancient and original designs for Gothic edifices of great splendour, f whereas scarcely any thing of the kind has been found in England of earlier date than the reign of Queen Elizabeth, although many such drawings were undoubtedly preserved in the libraries of the cathedrals, monasteries, and colleges previous to the ravages of the sixteenth century. :|: The comparison of the Gothic style, as seen in the cathedrals and other principal edifices of the continent, with the monuments of it in our own country, would furnish matter for a very interesting inquiry. But as even a hasty discussion of such an extensive subject would exceed the limits of this essay, it shall for the present be left untouched, and a conclusion be put to these Remarks on Gothic Architecture. || EDWARD JAMES WILLSON. Aewport, Lincols, May 14, 1831. * " Memoires de la Societe ties Antiquaires de la Normandie," 8vo. 1824, 1825, 1826, &c. t Dr. George Mollers, of Darmstadt, has published several scientific works on the architecture of the middle ages in Germany. An essay on the origin and progress of Gothic architecture, prefixed to one of his works, has been translated from the German, and published in the English language, by Messrs. Priestley and Weale, 1824. See also Boisseree on the Cathedral of Cologne,