rs peyeeaparom phe & papar z ~ st re, ee vf - the Cheologicay gy ag’ Miy | ty | PRINCETON, N. J. . 1 | ih, woe | br s® / SF BT 1101 .P35 1877 Palmer, Ray, 1808-1887. Hints on the formation of religious opinions 1B eed ae ON THE FORMATION OF RELIGIOUS OPINIONS. ADDRESSED ESPECIALLY TO YOUNG MEN AND WOMEN OF CHRISTIAN EDUCATION. BY REV. RAY "PALMER, D. D,, ‘Hold fast that which is good.”—1 Tusss. v. 21. NEW YORK: A.S. BARNES & COMPANY, 1877, Digitized by the Internet Archive ‘a in 2022 with funding from | Princeton Theological Seminary Library https ‘//archive.org/details/hintsonformationC ae . : oe oe Preface. Tue following discourses are not addressed to positive unbelief. A different method would be necessary in order to the hopeftil treatment of this. They were prepared for the benefit of those who, having been educated into a full belief of the Christian faith, have found themselves, on coming to maturity, or afterwards, disturbed with inward questionings and doubts. The design ‘was, by hints in relation to some of the more important subjects, to assist such in giving their thoughts a right direction, and in confirming themselves intelligently in their early religious convictions. The reader will not expect to find | in popular addresses the completeness of discussion 7 which belongs to the class-room, but only such a style of treatment as the occasion and the special ‘end in view demanded. In the present state of vi PREFACE. the popular mind, there are doubtless great num- bers of the best educated young people of our country who, whether they avow it or not, are in the state of uncertainty and hesitation to which we have referred. To such it is hoped these pages may have an interest, and render some timely aid. , R P. : a Contents. L Evils of a state of Scepticism, «-. wae Il. Nature of Reasoning and of Proof, eee III. Responsibility of Men for their Opinions, ... IV. The Practical Value of Opinions, eRe V. Belief in the Being of God, eee Bae VI. Argument from Design for the Divine Existence, VII. The Christian Revelation to be Presumed Divine, VIII. Christianity authenticated in the Experience of its Power, IX. Christianity a Religion of Facts, ase X. Mystery no Obstacle to Faith, ... nee XI. The Highest Evidence may not produce Belief, XII. The Dark Things of Life in the Light of Revelation, XIII. The Gospel the Sole Hope of the World, .. XIV. Good to be chosen as a Guide, ..- ae XV. The Value of a Life as related to our Time, 128 146 164 178 193 209 231 247 RELIGIOUS OPINIONS. ik Gils of w State of Scepttcism. Hes. xiii. 9: Be not carried about with divers and strange doctrines : for it is a good thing that the heart be established with grace. ] HAVE been for some time proposing to myself to address to the congregation, more particularly to the younger portion of it, some thoughts on the formation of religious opinions, The vital importance of the topic as related to the present state of the popular mind, and the consideration that there is growing up among us so large a class of intelligent young persons, many of whom have enjoyed superior advantages of education, have seemed to render it specially proper that our attention should be turned in this direction. I am aware that a full and thorough discussion of the subject would involve the treating of some questions too abstruse and difficult for popular discourse ; but without proposing to say all that 9 EVILS OF A STATE OF SCEPTICISM. such a discussion would require, it may at least be possible to give such hints as may be useful to the thoughtful and candid inquirer. This is what I shall attempt to do. The importance to be attached to the forming of opinions, in any case, will of course be proportioned to the intrinsic moment of the matter to which they relate. The fact that we gather here from week to week is itself an acknowledgment that, in our judgment, the things per- taining to religion are things of the gravest import. Itis a virtual avowal that we are convinced, at least in our understandings, that our religious responsibilities are most weighty and solemn in their bearing, our religious interests the most sacred and precious of all the interests of our being, and religious truth, of course, of all truth the most highly to be prized. Whatever directly con- cerns our characters and training as the responsible crea- tures of God and the heirs of immortality, does certainly demand our earnest consideration. The present topic of discourse will be that which is naturally suggested by the text: the evils of an habitually unsettled and fluctuating state of mind, as compared with the fixed stability which rests on the solid foundations of truth, thoroughly examined and cordially received and held. | It would seem hardly to be expected, where ample means of religious knowledge are enjoyed, that such a state of mind should be a common thing. The habitual study of Christianity in its sacred records and in its prac- tical results, from childhood up to adult years, would gradually, it might naturally be supposed, lead to a full EVILS Of A STATE OF SCEPTICISM. 1] and satisfying conviction of its truth, or else to the de- cided and conclusive rejection of it as a false and worth- less system. The fact, however, it is certain is quite otherwise. Perhaps in nothing does the perverted condi- tion of our moral nature more appear than in the inapti- tude which men naturally exhibit to comprehend truths which are spiritual in their nature, and the difficulty with which they are brought to feel their reality, and to per- ceive their practical applications in relation to themselves. This want of susceptibility to the truths pertaining to God and religion, was recognised by Socrates and Plato, by Cicero and Seneca, as well as by Paul and John. Deism not less than Christianity has encountered and acknowledged it. It is, indeed, too plain to be denied. It is a fact that stands out in prominence on the bistory of the race. that the clearness with which the moral and spiritual truths which most concern 1nen are perceived, and the strength of the impression which they make; are not at all in proportion, generally, to the evidence with which they are attended. Hence doubt very frequently exists where the materials of certainty are ample. Of those who are educated under religious light and influence, and who are led in early life to accept Christi- anity, a very considerable number sooner or later find themselves to have reached a state in which they are dis- posed to question almost everything pertaining to religion, More commonly this crisis arrives in advanced youth, or on the verge of manhood. Up to that time the mind has been content to take as truth, on the authority of others, and with but little question, whatever may have been 12 EVILS OF A STATE OF SCEPTICISM. taught it. It has acquiesced, without serious difficulty, in the statements of parents and teachers as to what were the claims of duty; and has generally taken it for granted, however little it may practically have felt their power, that the views in which it has been trained to rest are sound. But now there comes a change. Of the views and impressions which childhood entertained on a variety of subjects, advancing years and knowledge have shown many to be erroneous. In respect to others, it is now perceived that although they may be true, they have been received without examination, and retained by the force of habit or authority, and not from an apprehension of the evidence by which they are made certain. It is not strange that such discoveries should beget a doubting spirit—a disposition to doubt even with as little reason and as little justice as was exhibited before in yielding an assent. In this state of mind the inquirer is inclined to quéstion everything, as he once was to believe everything. He has found a few things, or, if you please, many things, to be false, and so he is afraid to believe that anything is true. He passes, by a not unnatural process, from the extreme of credulity to the extreme of scepticism. ' No wonder that, in such a state of feeling, the truths of religion and its claims should come to be questioned with a greater or less degree of earnestness; and inasmuch as they make a strong appeal to the conscience on the mere statement of them, and aside from all proof, and also involve, if they are what they seem, the highest of all interests, it is only natural that the result should be an inward strife, perplexed and troubled thoughts, and a rest- EVILS OF A STATE OF SCEPTIC/SM. 13 less uncertainty of mind whenever these subjeets are con- sidered. As an aggravation of the evil, too, it is just at this same period that the youthful heart begins to feel the temptations that solicit appetite and kindle passion, attracting to self-indulgence and the pursuit of worldly pleasure. It is perceived that religion speaks with a grave and earnest voice; that she commands self-discipline and self-restraint; that she forbids to make life a mere chase after selfish gratifications, and insists that great and difficult duties should be undertaken and laboriously dis- charged. Here, then, are reasons to the young just be- ginning to look out on life’s illusions, for wishing that the teachings of religion may not, after all, be true; and the excited wish is likely to exert a powerful influence on the judgment, and greatly to increase the difficulty of weighing these teachings with candid impartiality. Be- tween a doubting frame of mind and the drawing of inclination on the one hand, and the wants of the soul and the urgent power of religious truth, upon the other, the individual hesitates, and balances, and wavers, and seems to himself to be standing among shifting sands, where he can plant his feet on nothing that is firm. At this point one of three things must happen: Either the mind must become utterly lost to truth, and settle itself on the ultimately fatal grounds of false opinion; or it must drift on unfixed, full of uncertainty, and driven now this way and now that on the troubled sea of doubt ; or, lastly, it must lay hold of the strong cable of sound evidence, and intelligently and deliberately cast anchor on the sure foundations of the truth. There are doubtless 14 EVILS OF A STATE OF SCEPTICISM. some who do succeed in confirming themselves in false- hood beyond the chance of recovery. We are sure, also, that there are those who gain a hold on truth which nothing can relax, and which permanently sets their hearts at rest. But how large a number fall into the interme- diate class, the class of perpetual doubters !—of unstable souls, who habitually live in the disastrous twilight of uncertain speculation, and are carried about by diverse and strange doctrines, always catching at a new absurdity to relieve the weariness of dwelling on the last; who, in short, are very much in the condition of Milton’s fallen angels when they— “ Reasoned high Of Providence, fore-knowledge, will, and fate, And found no end, in wandering mazes lost.” What can be more deplorable than this unnatural, this morbid bewilderment of the soul? A rational nature was surely never made to live in a realm of phantoms that for ever mock.it by putting on new shapes. Such a state is, of all things, to be dreaded. For, in the first place, it must needs be an exceedingly unhappy state. To all minds that have received even a moderate degree of cultivation, it is a source of positive pleasure to have, on all important subjects, clear views and well-defined opinions. The healthful faculties de- light in reaching and grasping truth when excited to in- quiry. They are gratified at being able to settle things with certainty. So, on the contrary, it is painful to the sound mind to grope about in the “ everlasting fog”—to be threading backward and forward the mazy labyrinths EVILS OF A STATE OF SCEPTICISM. 15 of vague inquiry, which chases shadows and catches at emptiness, finding nothing solid on which it can rely. This, we say, is the constitutional law of the mind, let the subject about which it inquires be what it may. But if the matter in question be one on the right un- derstanding of which great consequences are depending, there must be, in addition to the doubtfulness, the pain of anxious apprehension. The fear of what calamities may, soon or late, result from failure to ascertain the truth, will often haunt the mind and mingle more or less with all its thoughts. Religion, it is clearly seen, if it be any- thing, is of the highest imaginable interest ; and to miss the truth in such an affair, may, it cannot but be felt, in- volve irreparable loss, disaster that nothing can retrieve. Here is a most effectual cause of disquiet to the soul. How can a man have inward peace, when it is wholly un- certain, in his view, whether he is the offspring of an In- finite Mind, or of a blind chance; whether he has a nature essentially angelic, or is only a better sort of brute; whether he has any certain guide to duty, or is left to find it out by accident; and whether, if he survive the tomb, his happiness or misery will, or will not, be then at all affected by his present character and conduct? Rest con- tent with such questions as these unsettled! A fool may a man of reflection cannot. You might as well rest content on a stormy sea, when you know not whether your ship be sound or rotten; your chart and compass re- liable or worthless; the hoarse murmur which you hear, the howling of the wind, or the roar of the surf that beats on the fatal rocks! Nothing but profound stupidity can 16 EVILS OF A STATE OF SCEPTICISM. give the mind that lives in a state of wavering uncertainty respecting the essentials of religion anything that really deserves the name of peace. It is also evident, still further, that a state of chronic scepticism tends greatly.to enfeeble both the character and the mind. There is a very cnmmon mistake on this point. It is no unusual thing to meet with those, more particu- larly among young men, who have the notion that there is something indicative of a superior mind in a state of doubt. They imagine it a mark of originality and pene- tration to be sceptical about those things which others confidently believe—to be starting difficulties in oppdsi- tion to all opinions; and so they are led rather to culti- vate an unsettled habit of mind, than ‘to endeavour to escape it. But the truth is just the reverse of this. A really vigorous and healthful mind cannot be satisfied to continue long in a dubious state, when, as is true in the matter of religion, the materials for forming fixed conclu- sions areat hand. A strong mind presses on to a decision. It is content only when getting at results. A sceptical habit—observe I do not say a season of temporary ques- tioning, but a chronic habit of doubting—most generally indicates a want of mental energy to lay hold of evidence and to appreciate its force; a lack of the strength of mind required in order to rise above the prejudices and biases that embarrass and tend to warp the judgment. It be- trays an intellectual feebleness already existing and likely to perpetuate itself. For when the mind has been allowed, and rather en- couraged, to wander among the mists of doubt; to loak EVILS OF A STATE OF SCEPTICISM. 17 rather after difficulties, than after proofs; it seems to be- come incapable of logical deduction and unsusceptible to the effect of evidence. Having accustomed itself to waver, it cannot, when it would, decide; or, if it has in any case decided, it cannot hold to its decision. What yesterday it examined and concluded to be true, it is to- day, just as much as ever, disposed again to question. There is a manifest enfeebling of the power by which the mind, when in a vigorous state, makes use of evidence to establish itself with collected firmness on the solid ground of truth. That it should be so results from well-known laws of mind. It will also be true that in proportion to this loss of force of intellect, there will be likewise a loss of general force of character. He who is unable to decide with promptness, will not be able to execute with vigour. The habitual vacillation of the mind will be sure to exhibit itself in a feeble, time-serving, irresolute course of action. There is no class of truths which operates so powerfully in forming the whole character as religious truths. There are no motives which produce such energy of purpose as the motives which religious faith supplies.