.3; t2i a 5i3 Oa «Si. 533. ■^2- AT PRINCETON, N. J. i> t> >r _^ -I- 1 o :v cj s- SAMUEL AGNEW, OF PHII. ADELPHIA, PA. 77^^^^(l£/. /^^^(if-: e'5^^9*'" BR 85 .W58 1850 Williams, William R. , 1804- 1885. Miscellanies i ^^,^!*^ - rn,„ae^ HLowu MISCELLANIES BY WILLIAM R. WILLIAMS. SECOND EDITION NEW YORK: EDWARD H. FLETCHER, 141 NASSAU STREET. 1850. Entered nrcording to Act of Congress, in the year 1S50, BY EDWARD H. FLETCHER, In the Clerk's Office of the District Court for the Southeru District n«" New York PREFACE, The Discourses, Reviews, and Sermons, composing the present volume, liave, several of them, been already issued separately ; and of the opening article, the present is the third edition; others of them appear now for the first time. It was thought, by some of the author's friends, that the book might find purchasers; and the writer will have been recompensed, should it please " The Great Taskmaster" to give to the desultory pages aught of usefulness, in their influence on the minds of any of their readers. For the sake of its publisher, who is also the proprietor of the copyright, the author would hope for the volume sufficient currency to save him from loss in the venture he has made. W. R. W. New York, Nov. 1, 1849. CONTENTS. Page The Conservative Principle, ---------.-.. j Appendix to the Conservative Principle, ---.-..-73 Ministerial Responsibility ---.-----.-...91 The Prayers of the Church needed for her rising Ministry, 111 The Church the Home and Hope of the Free, 129 The Strong Staff and the Beautiful Rod, --..-.. 143 The Jesuits as a Missionary Order, --- 169 The Life and Times of Baxter, 194 Christ a Home Missionary, 220 Publications of the American Tract Society, -..-.. 241 Increase of Faith necessary to the Success of Christian Missions, ---------- 261 The Preaching of another Gospel accursed, -.--... 2S3 The Sea giving up its Dead, - 297 The Lessons of Calamity, ----------...- 311 The Church, a School for Heaven, 337 The Prayer of the Church against those delighting in War, 367 Appendix — The Cagots of France, -....------ 383 THE CONSERVATIVE PRINCIPLE IN OUR LITERATURE. AN ADDRESS DELIVERED BEFORE THE LITERARY SOCIETIES OF THE HAM- ILTON LITERARY AND THEOLOGICAL INSTITUTION, MADISON COUNTY, N. Y., ON TUESDAY EVENING, JUNE 13, 1843. THE REV. JOHN S. MAGINNIS, D.D., PROFESSOR OF BIBLICAL THEOLOGY HAMILTON LITERARY AND THEOLOGICAL INSTITUTION, SMs ^Dtiress IS, AS A SLIGHT MARK OP HIGH ESTEEM AND AFFECTION, INSCRIBED BY HIS FRIEND. W. R. W. PREFACE TO THE FIRST EDITION OF THE "CONSERVATIVE PRINCIPLE," &c. Other engagements, which prevented the author from preparing this Address for the press, and for a time banished it entirely from his mind, must be, in part, his apol- ogy with the Societies who requested its publication, for its late appearance. Yet what of truth it may contain is not less true now than at the time of its delivery. Some additions made at the commencement of the Address, with regard to the proper defi- nition of literature, and the permanent influence which may belong even to its more transitory productions, will, he trusts, not be found alien to the theme. But the chief cause of delay has been the writer's consciousness how far his treatment of the subject fell below the intrinsic importance of the topic. This consciousness, had he not bound himself to publish, would have prevented his appearance even at this late hour. To prevent misconstruction he would add the remark, that a full review of our national literature in all its aspects, the more encouraging as well as the more gloomy, was no part of his design. It was his task to point out certain of the perils, and to indicate the sufficient and sole remedy. NOTE TO THE SECOND EDITION. This Address, origmally delivered before the Adelphian and JJonian Societies of Hamilton Literary and Theological Institution, has, from its theme, found more ac- ceptance than the author had at all anticipated. In preparing a second edition, ho has subjected the whole to such hasty revision as his other engagements allowed, and made some other additions both to the text and notes. New Yokk, 1844. NOTE TO THE THIRD EDITION. The present edition has some slight revisions, and considerable additions have been made to some of the notes ; but these additions are, from want of leisure, less exten- sive than the writer had wished to make them. New York, November, 1849. "V-* i( «"■' THE CONSERVATIVE PRINCIPLE IN OUR LITERATURE. Gentlemen: — In acceding to the request with which you have honored me, and which brings me at this lime before you, I have supposed that you expected it of the speaker to present some theme relating to the common- weahh of hterature ; that commonwealth in which every scholar and every Christian feels naturally so strong an interest. The studies in which you have here engaged, and which in the case of some of you are soon to terminate, have taught you the value of sound learning to yourselves and its power over others. That love of country, which in the bosoms of the young burns with a flame of more than ordinary purity and intensity, gives you an additional interest in the cause of letters ; for as you well know, the literature of the nation must exercise a powerful influence on the national destiny. Acting as it does not merely on the schools, but also on the homes of a land, it must from those fountains send out its waters of healing or of bitterness, of blessing or of strife, over the length and breadth of our goodly land. You know that it is not mere physical advan- tages that have gained or that can retain for our country its political privileges. You have seen how the physical con- dition of a people may remain unchanged, whilst the moral condition of a people is deteriorating rapidly and fatally. You remember that the same sun shone on the same Mara- thon, when it was the heritage and the battle-ground of freemen ; and when, in later and more disastrous days, it re-echoed to the footsteps of the Greek bondsman and his Ottoman oppressor. You look to literature, and other moral causes, then, as determining to some extent the future history of our land. You are aware that literature is not always of a healthy character, nor does it in all ages exercise a conservative influence. It is like the vegetation ol our 4 CONSERVATIVE PRINCIPLE earth, of varied nature. Much of it is the waving harvest that fills our garners and piles our boards with plenty ; and, alas, much of it has been, like the rank ivy, hastening the decay it serves to hide, and crumbling into speedier ruin the edifice it seems to adorn and beautify. As lovers of your country, you must therefore feel an eager anxiety for the moral character of the literature that country is to cherish. And of your number most are looking forward to the work of the Christian ministry ; and, from the past history of the world, you have learned in what mode the progress of liter- ature has acted upon that of the gospel, and been, in its turn, acted upon ; and to what an extent the pulpit and the press have sometimes been found in friendly alliance, and at others enlisted in fearful antagonism. How shall it be in your times ? By the literature of a land, we mean, it is here perhaps the place to say, more than the mere issues from the press of a nation. The term is generally applied to describe all the knowledge, feelings, and opinions of a people as far as they are reduced to writing, or published abroad by the art of printing. But it may well be questioned whether the term does not in justice require a wider application. Lan- guage, as soon as it is made the subject of culture, seems to give birth to literature. And such culture may exist where the use of the press and even of the pen are as yet unknown. Savage tribes are found having their poetry ere they have acquired the art of writing. Such were the Tonga Islanders, as Mariner found them. Tlie melody and rhythm of their dialect may have been partially developed, and their bards, their musicians, and their orators have become distinguished, ere the language has had its grammarians or its historians. The nation has thus, in some sort, its literature, ere its Cadmus has appeared to give it an alphabet. The old Gaelic poetry, on which Macpherson founded his Ossianic forgeries, was a part of the nation's literature while yet un- written. And if, as some scholars have supposed, the poems of Homer were, in the times of the author, preserved by memory and not by writing, it would be idle to deny, that, even in that unwritten state, and whilst guarded only in the recollection of travelling minstrels, they were a glorious and influential literature to the Greek people, a Kmi^a es ati to them, and to the civilization of Europe for all ensuing times. And even in nations having the use of letters, there is much IN OUR LITERATURE. never written that yet, in strictness, must be regarded as forming part of the hterature of the people. The unre- corded intercourse of a community, neither transcribed by the pen, nor multiplied by the press, may bear no inconsid- erable part in the literary culture of that people, and form no trivial portion of their literary products. Of the elo- quence of Curran and Sheridan much was never reported, or reported most imperfectly ; and yet in its effects upon the immediate hearers in courts of justice or houses of Par- liament, deserved the name and honors of literature, alike from the literary culture it displayed on the part of the speaker, and from the literary taste it formed and cherished, on the part of the auditory. Some of the most distinguished among the living scholars of France were, whilst professors in her colleges, eminent for the eloquence of their unwritten lectures. Were not even such of those lectures of Guizot, Villemain, and Cousin as never reached the press, yet really and most effectively contributions to the literature of the land? The departed Schleiermacher of Germany had the reputation of being among the profoundest thinkers and the most eloquent preachers of his time. His sermons, it is said, were never written ; nor were most of the pulpit dis- courses of a kindred spirit, Robert Hall, of England. Al- though many have been published, more must have perished. Yet were not those, which the living voice but published to a single congregation, truly a portion of German and British literature, as well as those which the press published to the entire nation, and preserved to succeeding times ? Thus the arguments of the bar, or the appeals of the pulpit, the float- ing proverbs, or the current legends of the nation, and the ballads, and even the jests, which no antiquary may as yet have secured aud written down, are expressions of the pop- ular mind, which though cast only upon the ear, and stored only in the memory, instead of receiving the surer guardian- ship of the written page, may, with some show of reason, be claimed as forming no small and no uninfluential part of the popular literature. In this sense, the literature of a land embraces the whole literary intercourse of its people, whether that intercourse be oral or written. It is the expo- nent of the national intellect, and the utterance of the pop- ular passions. The term thus viewed, comprises all the intellectual products of a nation, from the encyclopedia to the newspaper ; from the body of divinity to the primer or 6 CONSERVATIVE PRINCIPLE the nursery rhyme — the epic poem and the Sunday School hymn — the sermon and the epigram — the essay and the sonnet — the oration and the street ballad — the jest or the bve-vvord — all that represents, awakens, and colors the pop- ular mind — all that interprets, by the use of words, the nation to themselves, or to other nations of the earth. This literature not only displays the moral and intellectual advancement of the people at the time of its production, but it exercises, of necessity, a powerful influence in hasten- ing or in checking that advancement. It is the Nilometer on whose graded scale we read not merely the height to which the rushing stream of the nation's intellect has risen, or the degree to which it has sunk, but also the character and extent of the harvests yet to be reaped in coming months along the whole course of those waters. Thus it registers not merely the inundations of the present time, but presages as well the plenty or sterility of the yet distant future. The authors of a nation's literary products are its teachers — in truth or in error ; and leave behind their im- print and their memorial in the virtues or vices of all those whom their labors may have reached. The errand of all language is to create sympathy ; to waft from one human bosom the feelings that stir it, that they may awaken a cor- responding response in other hearts. We are therefore held responsible for our words because they affect the happiness and virtue of others. The word that drops from our lips takes its irrevocable flight, and leaves behind its indelible imprint. It is, in the stern language of the apostle, in the case of some, a flame " set on fire of hell ;" and consuming wherever it alights, it " setteth on fire the course of nature ;" as, in the happier case of others, that word is a message of salvation, "ministering grace unto the hearers." Reason and Scripture alike make it idle to deny the power of speech over social order and morality ; and literature is but speech under the influence of art and talent. And a written litera- ture is but speech put into a more orderly and enduring form than it usually wears. We know that God and man hold each of us responsible for the utterance of the heart by the lips. Human tribinials punish the slanderer because his words affect the peace of society; and the Last Day exacts its reckoning for " every idle word," because that word, however lightly uttered, was the utterance of a soul, and went out to influence, for good or for evil, the souls of others. IN OUR LITERATURE. 7 And if the winged words, heedless and unpremeditated, of a man's lips are thus influential, and enter into the matter of his final account, it cannot be supposed that these words, when fixed by the art of writing, or scattered by the art of printing, either have less power over human society, or are in the eye of heaven clothed with less solemn responsibili- ties. A written literature embalms the perishable, arrests the progress of decay, and gives to our words a longer life and a wider scope of influence. Such words, so preserved and so difiused, are the results, too, of more than ordinary deliberation. If malicious, their malice is malice prepense. If foolish, their folly is studied, and obstinate, and shame- less. The babbler sins in the ears of a few friends, and in the privacy of home. The frivolous or vicious writer sins, as on a wider theatre, and before the eyes of thousands, while the echoes of the press waft his words to distant lands and later times. And because much of this literature may be hasty and heedless, ludicrous in tone, and careless in style, soon to evaporate and disappear, like the froth on some hurried stream, we are not to suppose that it is there- fore of no practical influence. The English stage, in the days of the last two Stuarts, was of a reckless character ; — the child of mere whim, the progeny of impulse and license. Many of its productions were alike regardless of all moral and literary rules — the light-hearted utterance of a depraved generation : full of merry falsehoods and jesting blasphemy, fantastic and barbarous in style, as well as irreligious in their spirit. Yet he must be a careless reader of history, who, because of its reckless, trivial, and profligate character, assigns to it but a limited influence. It did, in fact, gre- viously aggravate the national wickedness whence it sprung. The trivial and the ephemeral as they float by, in glittering bubbles, to the dull waters of oblivion, may yet work irre- parable and enduring mischief ere their brief career ends ; and the result may continue, vast and permanent, when the fleeting causes which operated have long gone by. Who now reads Eikon Basilike, the forgery of Bishop Gauden, ascribed to the beheaded Charles I.? Yet that counterfeited manual of devotion is thought by some to have done much in bringing back the house of Stuart to the English throne.'^ * " Many have not scrupled to ascribe to that book the subsequent resto- ration of the royal family. Milton compares its efTects to those which were wrought on the tumultuous Romans by Antony's reading to them the will 8 CONSERVATIVE PRINCIPLE Who in this age knows the words of Lillibullero ?* Yet the author of that street ballad, now forgotten, boasted of hav- ing rhymed, by his song, the Stuarts out of their kingdom. Thus a forged prayer-book aided to restore a dynasty, as the ragged rhymes of a street song helped to overturn it. We err grievously, therefore, if we suppose that the frivolous is necessarily uninfluential, and that when the word passes, its effects also pass with it. According to Eastern belief, the plague that wastes a city may be communicated by the gift of a glove or a riband. The spark struck from the iron heel of the laborer may have disappeared ere the eye could mark its transient lustre, yet ere it expired have tired the train which explodes a magazine, lays a town in ruins, and spreads around a wide circuit alarm and lamentation, be- reavement and death. Trifles may have no trivial influence. What is called the lighter literature of the age may be even thus evanescent, yet not inefficacious. By its wide and rapid circulation it may act more powerfully on society than do graver and abler treatises, and its authors, if unprincipled, may thus deserve but too well the title which the indignant Nicole gave to the comparatively decorous dramatists and romance writers of France, in his own time ; a title which his pupil Racine at first so warmly resented, that of ^'■public poisoners.''^ Of literature, therefore, thus understood, thus wide in its range and various in its products, thus influential even where the most careless, and thus clothed with most solemn re- sponsibilities because of its influence, it is our purpose now to speak. You perceive, gentlemen, that amongst ourselves, as a people, literature is subject to certain peculiar influences, perhaps nowhere else found in the same combination, or operating to the same extent as in our own land. We are a young nation, inhabiting, and called to subdue, a wide terri- tory. Youth is the season of hope, enterprise, and energy — and it is so to a nation as well as an individual. Our of Caesar. The Eikon passed through fifty editions in a twelvemonth."— Hume. * "It may not be unworthy of notice, that a merry ballad, called Lillibul- lero, being at that time published, in derision of the "papists and the Irish, it was greedily received by the people, and was sung by all ranks of men, even by the King's army, who were strongly seized with the national spirit. This incident both discovered, and served to increase the general discontent of the kingdom." — Hume. IN OUR LITERATURE. 9 literature is likely, therefore, to be ardent, original, and at times perhaps boastful. They are the excellences and the foibles of youth. We entered, as by right of inheritance, and in consequence of our community of language, upon the possession of the rich and ancient literature of Britain, at the very outset of our national career. As a people we enjoy, again, that freedom which has ever been the indul- gent nurse of talent in all times and in all lands. The peo- ple are here the kings. And whilst some of our sovereio-ns are toiling in the field, others are speaking through the press. Our authors are all royal by political right, if not by the birthright of genius. Providence has blessed us with the Avide diff"usion of education, and the school travels, in many regions of our land, as it were, to every man's door. It is not here, if it may elsewhere be the case, that the neglected children of genius can complain that " chill penury repressed their noble rage." In addition to the advantages of the common school, our writers, publishers, and instructors, are sedulously preparing literature for the use of the masses. The popular lecturer is discussing themes of grave interest ; while the cheap periodical press is snowing over the whole face of our land its thick and incessant storm of knowledge. This knowledge, it is true, is not all of the most valuable kind. The wonders of steam are dragging the remoter por- tions of our union daily into closer contact, whilst a free emi- gration is bringing us the denizens of other lands, and the men of other tongues, until the whole world appears about to be made neighbors and kinsmen to America ; and the nation seems daily melting into a new and strange amalgam, in consequence of the addition of foreign materials from with- out, to the heterogeneous mass already found fusing within our own country. All these causes are operating, and must operate long and steadily, upon the character of American literature. It be- comes an important inquiry then, what moral shape this lit- erature is assuming under these plastic influences. You ask, as change succeeds change, and as one omen of moral progress, or social revolution, follows close upon another : " Watchman, what of the night ?" And gazing into the deep darkness of the future, you would fain read what are the coming fortunes of our people and their literature. Allow me then to dwell upon some of the evils that endanger our rising literature, and threaten to suffuse the bloom of its 3 10 CONSERVATIVE PRINCIPLE youth with their fatal virus. I would next bring before you the remedy which as scholars, patriots, and Christians, we are bound to apply to these evils, and to which we must look as our preservative against the approaching danger. Evils to be found besetting and perilling American litera- ture, and the remedy of those evils, will afford our present theme. I may' seem to dwell for a time, at least, upon the darker shades of a picture, that may, I fear, appear to some of my respected hearers, overcharged in its gloom. I must also from the nature of the subject enter into some details, that will, I must expect, severely tax the patience of all who are listening. I can only cast myself upon your indulgence ; find an apology as to the length of some statements, and the denser shade cast by others, in the wide and varied nature of the subject, and its mingled difficulty, delicacy, and im- portance ; asking the aid of Him whose blessing can never fail those that trust in Him, the author of all knowledge, and the final arbiter who will bring into judgment all our employ- ments, whether literary or practical, social or solitary. We would then dwell for a time, on some of the dangers that threaten the rising literature of our land. If the fore- ground of the landscape be dark, we trust to show in the distance the sure and sufficient remedy of these dangers ; and though night be spread on the summits of the nearer and lower mountains, we see glittering on the crest of the remoter and loftier heights beyond, the Star of Hope, that portends the coming day, and under the edge of the darkest cloud we seem to discern already the gleams of the approach- ing sun. Our country may suffer and struggle, but we trust it is not the purpose of Him who has so signally blest and so long defended us, that she should suffer long, or sink far, much less sink finally and for ever. First then among the evil tendencies that beset our youth- ful literature, and are likely to thwart and mar its progress, we would name, the mechanical and utilitarian spirit of the times. We are as a nation eminently practical in our char- acter. It is well that we should be so. But this trait in our national feelings and manners has its excesses and its con- sequent perils. Placed in a country where labor and integ- rity soon acquire wealth, the love of wealth has become a passion with multitudes. The lust of gain seems at times a national sin easily besetting all classes of society amongst us. Fierce speculations at certain intervals of years engross the IN OUR LITERATURE. 11 hearts of the community, and a contagious frenzy sends men from all walks of life and all occupations into the field of traffic. Fortunes are rapidly made and as rapidly lost. The nation seems to be lifted up as on a rushing tide of hope and prosperity. It subsides as rapidly as it had risen ; and on every side are seen strewn the wrecks of fortune, credit, character, and principle. All this affects our literature. We are in the influential classes, a matter-of-fact and money- getting race. This tends, in the minds of many, to create a distaste for all truth that is not at once convertible into wealth, and its value to be calculated in current coin. In the clank and din of our never-tiring machinery, the voice of wisdom is often drowned, and the most momentous and stirring truths are little esteemed because they cannot be rated in the Price Current or sold on the Exchange. We are impatient to see the material results of every truth, and to have its profits told upon our fingers, or pressed into our palms. So, on the other hand, if any principle, plan, or ex- pedient, be it true or be it false, will eflect our purpose, pro- duce a needful impression, and secure an end that we deem desirable, we are prone to think it allowable because it is effective. We idolize eflect. And a philosophy of expedi- ency thus springs up, which sacrifices everything to imme- diate eflects and to mere material results — a philosophy which, in practice, if not in theory, is driving rapidly against some of the very bulwarks of moral principle that our fathers believed, and believed justly, to be grounded in the law, and built into the very throne of God. Now we need not say that where this utilitarian and mechanical spirit acquires the ascendancy in our literature, it must operate dangerously on the state and the church. The prosperity which is built on gain, and the morality that is built on expediency, will save no nation. Wo to that na- tion in which Political Economy swallows up all its The- ology ; and the law of self is the basis of all its wisdom. The declining glories of Tyre and Holland, each in her day mistress of the sea, and guardian of its treasures, may read us an admonitory lesson as to the fatal blight that such a spirit breathes over the freedom, the arts and the learning of a land. We are, by the favoring Providence of God, placed under political institutions which more readily yield to and reflect the popular will, than the government and laws of other 12 CONSERVATIVE PRINCIPLE lands. The literature of our nation, more directly than that of earlier times, or of older countries, moulds the political action of the nation. Let but the spirit of expediency and of gain sway our political literature in the thousand journals of our country, and in the myriads of voters Avhom these journals educate and govern; let the same spirit possess the great parties ever to be found in a free nation, and the aspir- ing leaders who are the champions and oracles of those par- ties, and what would soon be the result? A peddling policy, that, disregarding the national interest and honor, would truckle to power and favor, carry its principles to market, and convert statesmanship into a trade. The country would be visited by an impudent, voluble, and mercenary patriot- ism, that shrinking from no artifice, and blushing at no meanness, would systematize the various arts of popularity into a new science of selfishness. The legislation of the land and its intercourse with foreign nations would be en- grossed by trading politicians ; huckstering their talents and influence to the party or the measure or the man, that should bid in the shape of emolument or ofiice, the highest price for the commodities which they vend. The expert statesman would then be he who consulted most assiduously the weather-vane of popular favor, that he might ascertain to what point his conscience should be set. And should such time ever come over our beloved land, could our liberties endure when guarded only by hands so faithless, or our laws be either wise or just, when such men made and such men administered them ? Let the same love of selfish gain pervade the pulpits of our land : let the messengers of the gospel learn to prophesy smooth thhigs, and instead of the "word in season," let them substitute the word in fashion — let them retail doctrines that admit no personal application, truths that wound not the conscience and pierce not the heart, and morals enforced by no motives of love to God, but by mere considerations of gain or honor — let them compile unoffending truisms and dexterous sophisms, and put these in place of unpalatable truths — let them listen to the echoes of popular opinion ever- more, that they may in them learn their lessons of duty ; and where soon is the gospel so administered, and where is the church, if left but to such instruction ? The far-sighted law of righi, as God ordained and administers it, would be overthrown, that in its stead might be set up the law of interest, IN OUR LITERATURE. 13 as short-sighted man expounds it ; and a creed by which the world is to be humored, flattered and adored, would be audaciously preached at the foot of a cross which ransomed that world only by renouncing and only by defying it. No — gain is not godliness. But man was made for other purposes than to coin or ex- change dollars. The fable of Midas pestered with his riches, and unable to eat because his food turned to gold, is full of beneficial in-struction in such times as ours. Man has wants which money cannot supply, and sorrows which lucre can- not heal ; although cupidity may teach him often to make expediency or immediate utility the standard of his code of morals. Conscience, too, will utter at times her protest, slip aside the gag, and declaim loudly against practices she cannot approve, however they may for the time profit. A literature merely venal will not then meet all the necessities of man's nature. And not from conscience only is the reign of covetousness threatened and made insecure. Mere feel- ing and passion lead men often to look to other than their pecuniary interests, and in quest of yet dearer objects they trample on gain, and sacrifice the mere conveniences to secure the higher enjoyments of life. But here, in this last named fact, is found the source of yet another danger to our literature. Passion is not a safer moral guide to a people than interest. 2. Let us dwell on this new inimical influence by which our literature may suffer. Our age is eminently, in some of its leading minds, an age of passion. It is seen in the character of much of the most popular literature, and espe- cially the poetry of our day. Much of this has been the poetry of intense passion, it mattered little how unprincipled that passion might be. An English scholar lately gone from this world (it is to Southey that we refer), branded this school of modern literature, in the person of its great and titled leader, as the Satanic school.^ It has talent and genius, 3 Another English scholar, whose writings may be quoted as aflbrding evidence of a re-action that has tollowed the influence of Byron, holds this language. Speaking of the heroes of Byron, he remarks: "They exhibit rattier passions personified than persons impassioned. But there is a yet worse defect ; Lord Byron's conception of a hero is an evidence, not only of scanty materials of knowledge from wliich to construct the ideal ola human bang, but also of a want of perception of what is great or noble in our nature. His heroes are creatures abandoned to their passions, and essentially, therefore, weak of mind. They must be perceived to be beings in whom there is no 14 CONSERVATIVE PRINCIPLE high powers of imagination and language, and boiling energy ; but it is, much of it, the energy of a fallen and revolted angel, with no regard for the right, no vision into eternity, and no hold on Heaven. We would not declaim against passion when employed in the service of literature. Inform- ed by strong feelings, truth becomes more awful and more lovely ; and some of the ages which unfettered the passions of a nation, have given birth to master-pieces of genius. Rut Passion divorced from Virtue is ultimately among the fellest enemies to literary excellence. When yoked to the car of duty, and reined in by principle, passion is in its ap- propriate place, and may accomplish a mighty service. But when, in domestic life, or political, or in the walks of litera- ture, passion throws oil' these restraints and exults in its own uncontrolled power, it is as useless lor purposes of good, and as formidable from its powers of evil, as a car whose liery coursers have shaken off bit and rein, and trampled under foot tlieir charioteer. The Maker of man made conscience to rule liis other faculties, and when it is dethroned, the result is ruin. Far as the literature to which we have alluded strength, except that of their intensely selfish passions — in whoni all is vani- ty ; tlieir exertions being for vanity under the name of love or revenge, and their sutierings for vanity under the name of pride. If such beings as these are to be regarded as heroical, where in human nature are we to look for what is low in sentiment or infirm in character 7" It is not the language of theologians we are now quoting, but the words we have transcribed are those of "a prophet of their own" — of a living dramatic poet — Henry Tay- lor, the author of " Philip Van Artevelde." Elsewhere he uses the aid of verse to pronounce a similar judgment. ■' Then learned I to despise that far-famed school Who ])lace in wickedness their pride, and deem Power chictly to be shown where passions rule. And not where they are ruled ; in whose new scheme or heroism, self-government should seem A thing left out, or something to contemn — Whose notions, incoherent as a dream, Make strength go with the torrent, and not stem, For '■wicked and thence iccak,' is not a creed for them. " I left these passionate weaklings ; I perceived What took away all nobleness from pride, All dignity from sorrow ; what bereaved Even genius of respect : they seemed allied To mendicants, that by the highway side Expose their self-inflicted wounds, to gain The alms of sympathy — far best denied. I heard the sorrowful sensualist complain, If with compassion, not without disdain." IN OUR LITERATURE. 15 spreads, it cherishes an insane admiration for mere talent or mental power. It substitutes as a guide in morals, sentiment for conscience ; and makes blind feeling the irresistible fate, whose will none may dispute, and whose doings are beyond the jurisdiction of casuists or lawgivers. It has much of occasional tenderness, and can melt at times into floods of sympathy : but this softness is found strangely blended with a savage violence. Such things often co-exist. As in the case of the French hangman, who in the time of their great revolution was found, fresh from his gory work of the cruil- lotine, sobbing over the sorrows of Werther, it contrives to ally the sanguinary to the sentimental. It seems, at first sight, much such an ill-assorted match as if the family of Mr. Wet-eyes in one of Bunyan's matchless allegories, were wedded to that of Giant Blood)^-man in the other. But it is easily explained. It has been found so in all times when passion has been made to take the place of reason as the guide of a people, and conscience has been thrust from the throne to be succeeded by sentiment. The luxurious and the cruel, the fierce and the voluptuous, the licentious and the relentless readily coalesce ; and we soon are made to per- ceive the fitness of the classic fable by which, in the old Greek mythology, Venus was seen knitting her hands with Mars, the goddess of sensuality allying herself with the god of slaughter. We say much of the literature of the present and the last generation is thus the caterer of passion — lawless, fierce, and vindictive passion. And if a retired student may " through the loopholes of retreat" read aright the world of fashion, passion seems at times acquiring an un- wonted ascendancy in the popular amusements of the age. The lewd pantomime and dance, from which the less refined fashion of other times would have turned her blushing and indignant face, the gorgeous spectacle and the shows of wild beasts, and even the sanguinary pugilistic combat, that some- times recals the gladiatorial shows of old Rome, have become, in our day, the favorite recreations of some classes among the lovers of pleasure. These are, it should be remembered, nearly the same with the favorite entertainments of the later Greek empire, when, plethoric by its wealth, and enervated by its luxury, that power was about to be trodden down by the barbarian invasions of the north. It is possible that the same dangerous ascendency of pas- sion may be fostered, where we should have been slow to 16 CONSERVATIVE PRINCIPLE suspect it, by the ultraism of some good men among the social reformers of our time. Wilberforce was, in the judg- ment of Mackintosh, the very model of a reformer, because he united an earnestness that never flagged with a sweetness that never failed. There are good men that have nothing of this last trait. Amid the best intentions there is occasionally, in the benevolent projects even of this day, a species of Jack Cadeism, if we may be allowed the expression, enlisted in the service of reform. It seems the very opposite of the character of Wilberforce, nourishes an acridity and violence of temper that appears to delight in repelling, and seeks to enkindle feeling by wild exaggeration and personal denunci- ation ; raves in behalf of good with the very spirit of evil, and where it cannot convince assent, would extort submis- sion. Even truth itself, when administered at a scalding heat, cannot benefit the recipient ; and the process is not safe for the hands of the administrator himself. Far be it from us to decry earnestness when shown in the cause of truth and justice, or to forget how the passion awakened in some revolutionary crisis of a people's history, has often infused into the productions of genius an unwonted energy, and clothed them as with an immortal vigor. But it is passion yoked to the chariot of reason, and curbed by the strong hand of principle ; laboring in the traces, but not grasping the reins. But set aside argument and truth, and give to passion its unchecked course, and the effect is fatal. It may at first seem to clothe a literature with new energy, but it is the mere energy of intoxication, soon spent, and for which there speedily comes a sure and bitter reckoning. The bonds of principle are loosened, the tastes and habits of society corrupted ; and the effects are soon seen extending themselves to the very form and style of a literature as well as to the morality of its productions. The intense is substi- tuted for the natural and true. What is effective is sought for rather than what is exact. Our literature therefore has little, in such portions of it, of the high finish and serene repose of the master-pieces of classic antiquity, where passion in its highest flights is seen wearing gracefully all the re- straining rules of art ; and power toils ever as under the ses- vere eye of order. 3. A kindred evil, the natural result and accompaniment of that to which we have last adverted, and like it fatal to the best interests of literature, is the lawlessness, unhappily IN OUR LITERATURE. 17 but too rife through large districts of our territory, and in various classes of its inhabitants. Authority in the parent, the magistrate or the pastor, seems daily to be held by a less firm tenure. Obedience seems to be regarded rather as a boon, and control resented as usurpation. The restraints of honesty in the political and commercial intercourse of society seem more feebly felt. In those intrusted by the state and by public corporations with the control of funds, the charges of embezzlement and defalcation have within the last few years multiplied rapidly in number and swelled fearfully in amount ; until, catching the contagion of the times, sovereign states are found questioning the obligations of their own contracts, and repmliating their plighted word and bond. In the matter of good faith between man and man, as to pecu- niary engagements, the wheels of the social machine groan ominously, as if they were, by some internal dislocation and collision, ready to tear asunder the fabric of society. Pri- vate revenge and the sudden ebullitions of popular violence, disregarding all delays and setting aside all forms, seem in some districts ready to supplant the quiet administration of the laws, and dispensing alike with judges and prisons. The laws of God, too, are often as lightly regarded as the laws of human society. In the growing facility of divorce, ihe statute of Heaven intended to guard the purity of home, and lying at the foundation of all society, is to some extent in- fringed upon : while our railroads and canals have run their lines fearlessly athwart the Sabbath ; and it seems a question whether the flaming Sinai should be allowed to stand any longer in the pathway of modern improvement. And amid such scenes of disorder and commotion, it is — scenes illustrating so fearfully the depravity, inveterate and entire, of the human heart — it is, we say, amid such scenes that hi en are rising up to remodel all society. In some of these proposed reforms there is a reckless disorganization, and in most of tliem, we fear, scarce a due appreciation, of God's primitive but incomparable institution for the social happiness of the race, the family or household. In its sepa- rate interests, its seclusion and distinctness, are involved, we cannot but think, much of the virtue, the tranquillity and the felicity of mankind. At the attempt we ought not perhaps to be so much sur- prised, as at the principles on which it proceeds. On these we look with irrepressible astonishment. They assume the 4 18 CONSERVATIVE PRINCITLE natural innocence of manj and trace all his miseries and all his crimes to bad government, to false views of society, and to ifi^iiorance respecting the true relations of man to man — ■ relations which after the lapse of so many centuries they have been the first to reveal. They would not merely over- look, but deny that melancholy truth, the Fall of Man from his original state, and his consequent native depravity ; a truth never to be forgotten by all that would exercise a true benevolence to their brother man, and by all that would build up a stable government. In denying this truth, they contradict all the experience, all the history, and shall we not add, all the consciousness of our race. A trvith which even blinded and haughty heathenism mournfully acknow- ledged — a truth which Revelation asserts so enij)hatically and so often, cannot with impunity be forgotten by any that would attempt the reform of man's condition. Vague and wild in principle, and comparatively barren of results, must all reforms be that would make all their improvements from without, and feel that none is needed within. It seems to us, in the moral economy of society, much such an error as it would be in medical science to prescribe to the symp- toms and not to the disease ; and to aim at relieving the petty details and discomforts of sickness, while unable to discover and incompetent to treat the primal, radical evil, the deep-seated malady out of which these external symp- toms spring. It is not man's condition alone that needs bettering, but his heart much more. We would honor even the misguided zeal of our brethren of the race who seek in any form to lessen the amount of human misery and wrong; but the claims of our Common Father, and the wrongs He has met at our hands, are to be acknowledged by all who would pity, with an effectual compassion, human sorrow, and remedy with an enduring relief, social disorder and wretchedness. To forget or to contradict these truths, is to reject the lessons alike of history and scripture. All reform so based is itself but a new, though it may be unconscious, lawlessness. We have said that proposals of social reform are not causes of wonder. Already human life is less secure in many por- tions of our republic t.'ian under some of the European mon- archies ; and frauds and embezzlements are less surely and less severely punished. In some of our legislatures, in the very halls, and under the awful eye, as it were, of the IN OUR LITERATURE. 19 embodied Justice of the State, brawls and murders have oc-' curred, in which our legislators were the combatants and the victims. And yet in such a state of things, when human life is growing daily cheaper, and the fact of assassination seems to awaken scarce a tithe of the sympathy, horror and inquiry, which it provoked in our fathers' times — it is in such a state of things, that by a strange paradox, a singular clem- ency for the life of the assassin seems to be springing up. In a nation lax to a ftiult in the vindication of human life when illegally taken away, the protest is made most pas- sionately against its being taken away legally ; and the abo- lition of Capital Punishment is demanded by earnest and able agitators. Would that the picture thus dark were but the sketch of Fancy ; unhappily its gloomy hues are but the stern coloring of Truth. Can the patriot, as he watches such omens, fail to see the coming judgment? Can he shut his eyes against the fact so broadly printed on all the pages of history, that anarchy makes despotism necessary ; that men who are left lawless soon fly for refuge even to a scep- tre of iron, and a law of blood ; that a Robespierre has ever prepared the way for a Bonaparte, and the arts of the reck- less demagogue, like Catiline, have smoothed the path for the violence of the able usurper, like Caesar ? Of all this, should it unhappily continue or increase, the effects must with o-rowing rapidity be seen in the injury done to our lite- rature. There is a close and strange connection between moral and literary integrity. Not only does social confusion discourage the artist and the scholar, but disjointed and anar- chical times are often marked by a want of laborious truth, and of seriousness and earnestness on the part of the popu- lar writers. A passion for frivolity, a temper that snatches at temporary triumphs by flattering the whim of the hour, and a science of agreeable, heartless trifling, spring up in such days to the bane alike of all eloquence, and of all truth. 4. Another of the perils which seem to us lying in the way of our rising literature, is a false liberalism. To a manly and Christian toleration we can never be opposed. Something of this toleration is required by our free inter- course with many lands. The wonders of steam are melting the nations most highly civilized into comparative uniformity and unity. Our colonists are the emigrants of many shores. In this audience are found blended the blood of the Celt and the Saxon, the Norman and the Roman. We are scions 20 CONSERVATIVE PRINCIPLE alike from the stock of those who fought beneath, and those who warred successively against the eagles of the old Latin empire. Our varied origin seems giving to America, as its varied learning has given to Germany, a " many-sided mind ;" a sympathy at many points with mankind, and with widely diversified forms of society. More easily than the English, the ancestors whom many of us claim, we adopt the pecu- liarities of other nations. And all this is well. But when we suffer these influences to foster in us the notion that all the moral peculiarities, and all the forms of faith, markino- the various tribes from which our country is supplied, and with which our commerce connects us, are alike valuable ; when, instead of an enlightened love of truth wherever found, we learn indifference to all truth, and call this new feeling by the name of superiority to prejudice ; when we learn to think of morals as if they were little more than a conven- tional matter, the effect of habit or tradition, or the results of climate or of the physical constitution of a people, we are learning lessons alike irrational, and perilous, and untrue.^ The spirit of Pope's Universal Prayer seems to many, in consequence of these and other influences, the essence of an enlightened Christian charity. They cannot endure the anathemas of Paul against those who deny his Lord. They would classify the Koran and the Shaster with the Scrip- tures, Some have recently discovered a truth of which those writers were themselves strangely ignorant, that the Deistical and Atheistical scholars of Fi-ance, the Theoma- 4 It is well that we should cherish an humble sense of our own fallibility ; but whatever may be true of us, God and Scripture are infallible. The Crea- tor, too, so constituted his universe, that there is truth in it, and throughout it; and he has so constituted man as to thirst with an inextinguishable longing after truth. An utter despair of obtaining it, and a general acknow- ledgment that we are altogether and inevitably in the wrong, is alike a state of misery to man, and a dishonor done to God. It may give birth to a sort of toleration, but it is the spurious toleration of Pyrrhonism, a liberality that patronizes error, but that can be fierce against the truth for as the wise and meek Carey complained, skeptics may be the most intolerant of mankind against the truth. They resent naturally that strong conviction and that ardent zeal, which they have not for themselves, but which the consciousness of truth possessed, and the benevolent desire of its general ditTusion, natu- rally inspire in the believer. They envy the votaries of the truth, their calm, immovable assurance. A Christian toleration appreciates the innate power of truth to diffuse and protect itself, and pities error, while resisting it. The liberality of skepticism denies e.xistence to truth, and canonizes error as a sufficient substitute, and sets men aflo.it on a shoreless, starless ocean of doubt. Or as a young poet of England has not infelicitously described it, it prescribes to mankind the task of conjugating falsehood through all Us moods. IN OUR LITERATURE. 21 chists wlio prepared the way for its revolution, the men who loaded the Crucified Nazarene and his religion with all out- rage, were in truth Christians, although they knew it not themselves. Just as much, it seems to us, as Nero was an unconscious Howard ; just as much as Catiline was, in mo- dest ignorance of his own merits, " a Washington, who had anticipated his time." It is worse than idle thus to confound all moral distinctions. To suit these new and more liberal views of Christianity, it has become of course necessary to revise the gospel, and to supersede at least the ancient forms of the Christian religion. Thus in a land, the literature and religion of which are becoming more and more known to some of our scholars, Strauss has eviscerated the New Testament of all its focts, and leaves in all its touching and miraculous narrations but the fragments of a popular myth — intended to shadow forth certain truths common in the history of human nature in all ages. The nation to which he belongs, and which claims to be the most profound in metaphysical speculation and in varied learning, of all the nations of our time, is revivino- in some of its schools an undisguised Pantheism, which makes the universe God ; and thus, in eftcct, gives to Job and the dunghill on which he sate, the ulcers which covered him, and the potsherds with which he scraped himself, the honor of being all, parts and parcels alike of the same all-pervading Deity. And this is the wisdom, vaunted and profound, of our times ; a return, in fact, to those discoveries described of old in a venerable volume which we all wot of, in the brief and pithy sentence — " The world by wisdom knew not God." The result of its arrogant self-confidence was blind- tenses, and cases, and teaches them mutual forbearance as the result of their common infatuation. ' " Let them alone," men cry, " / lie, thou licst, they lie : What then? Thy neighbor's folly hurts not thee!" Error is Freedom ! such the insensate shout Of crowds, that like a Paean, hymn a doubt: Indifference thus the world calls Charity. ********* ' " Battles at last shall cease." At last, not now : we are not yet at home. The time is coming, it will soon be come, When those who dare not fight For God, or for the right. Shall fight for peace !' From " The Waldenses, and other Poems ;" by Aubrey de Vere. Oxford, 1842. P. 127. 22 CONSERVATIVE PRINCIPLE ness to the great fact blazing on the whole face of creation, and deafness to the dread voice that speaks out of all history, the truth that there is a God. And hence, not so much from any singular cogency in his reasoning, as from the palata- bleness of the results which that reasoning reaches, Baruch Spinoza, the Pantheist Jew, is, after a long lapse of years of confutation and obscurity, rising again in the view of some scholars in Germany, Britain, and America, to the rank of a guide in morals and a master of religious truth. ^ When 5 Of the system of Spinoza it has been said by the acute Bayle, certainly no bigoted adherent to Christianity, and no prejudiced enemy of skepticism, that "it was the most monstrous scheme imaginable;" and again, that "it has been fully overthrown, even by the weakest of its adversaries." In a similar spirit, Maclaurin, the celebrated British mathematician, had remarked, "It does not, indeed, appear possible to invent another system equally ab- surd." {Dugald Steirart's Progress of Metaphysical Philosophy, p. 116. Am. Edition.) Stewart quotes from Colerus, the author of the earliest Life of Spi- noza, the singular anecdote, that " one of the amusements with which he was accustomed to unbend his mind, was that of entangling flies in a spider's web, or of setting spiders to fighting with each other; on which occasions (it is added), he would observe their combats with so much interest that it was not unusual for him to be seized with immoderate fits of laughter." {Ibidem, p. 351.) Stewart, we think, lays too much stress on this incident, when he finds in it a proof of Spinoza's insanity. It was, certainly, not the most amiable trait in the character of a philosopher for whom his disciples have claimed a remarkable blamelessness and even piety. We cannot ima- gine such an amusement as delighting the vacant hours, and such merriment as gladdening the heart of a Christian philosopher Hke Bayle or Newton. Trivial as it was, it betrayed the spirit, and furnished no unapt emblem, of the system he elaborated in his philosophy, where an acute mind found its anmsement in entangling to their ruin its hapless victims in a web of sophis- try, that puzzled, caught and destroyed them ; and grim Blasphemy lay waiting to devour those who fluttered in the snares of Falsehood. Yet this system, the product of such a mind, has beert recently, with loud panegyrics of its author, commended anew to the regard of mankind on either side of the Atlantic. Paulus, the celebrated Neologian divine of Ger- many, had issued, years ago, an edition of his works. Amongst ourselves and the scholars of England, such views have obtained currency mostly, it is probable, from the admiration professed for Spinoza by such men as Goethe, and others, the scholars and philosophers of Germany, for whom we have contracted too indiscriminating a reverence. Goethe's course was parado.x- ical. Rejecting revelation as impossible, for the singular reason that if it came from God it must be unintelligible to men, and declaring God as pre- sented in the teachings of Christ Jesus, to be an imperfect and inadequate conception, Goethe held that the Divinity revealed in the Bible involved difficulties which must drive an inquirer to despair, unless he were " great enough to rise to the stand-point of a higher view;" in other words, a higher point of observation than that occupied by Christ. " Such a stand-point Goethe early found in /S';';';iora; and he acknowledges with joy how truly the views of that great thinker answered to the wants of his youth. In him he found himself and could therefore fortify himself with Spinoza to the best advantage." These are the words of Eckerman {Ecberman's Convers. icitk Goethe. Boston, p. 37), who played with Goetho the part that James Boswell IN OUR LITERATURE. 23 such a form of philosophy becomes prevalent, all forms of religion are alike true, or in other words, are alike false ; and room is to be made for a new religion by which man shall worship Nature or himself. So difficult is it for the gospel to suit men's waywardness. It was the objection of the old Pagans to Christianity, as we learn from Origen, that it was too universal a religion ; that every country should of right be allowed a religion of its own ; and Chris- tianity was arrogant in asking to be received as the one faith acted to the great lexicographer and moralist of England, recording as an humble admirer, the conversations of his oracle. Of the moral character of some of the productions of Goethe we need not pause to remark. There are principles developed in his writings that needed "fortifying." We would but notice a difficulty which the language of his admirer suggests. Goethe is made to speak of Spinoza as the thinker "in whom he found himself" To us, the uninitiated, it seems hard to reconcile this test by which" he recognized and adopted his master's system, with his passionate words else- where, recorded by the same admiring Eckerman, (p. 309.) " Man is a dark- ened being ; he knows not whence he comes, nor whither he goes ; he knows little of the world, and less of himself. / know not myself, and may God protect me from it J' How the rule of the old Greek wisdom, " know thy- self,'-' might seem folly to the modern German we can conceive : and how the view of his own heart might shock and appal one who would fain idolize his own wisdom and virtue, we can, with as little difficulty, imagine. But how one who shrunk f-oni knowing himself, could, by knowing himself, recognize the truth of a system of Pantheism, is to us inconceivable. A religion that begins in dogmatic ignorance as to our own nature, and ends in dogmatic omniscience as to God's nature, does not commend itself to our reason, more than it does to our sympathies, or our hopes. An affecting proof may be gathered from the same volume (pp. 405, 407), how easily the Pantheism of the schools slides into the Polytheism of the multitude. Goethe had received a cast of a piece of statuary. A model from Myron's cow with the sucking calf, was sent him by a young artist. " Here," said he, " we have a subject of the highest sort — the nourishing principle which upholds the world, and pervades all nature, is brought before our eyes by this beautiful symbol. This, and others of a like nature, I esteevi the true symbols of the omnipresence of God." What the omnipresence of the Deity, in the system of Pantheism is, we need not linger to remark. Skep- tics have affected to wonder at the unaccountable perverseness of the ciiil- 1 dren of Israel forging and adoring their golden calf at the foot of Sinai ; but here we have the practice palliated by a master-spirit of skepticism, amid the boasted illumination of the nineteenth century. A cow with her calf is, according to Goethe, " the true symbol," of the all-pervading, all-sustaining Divinity, who comprises, and himself is, the universe. Did Pantheism but rule the schools, we can see how easily idolatry in its most brutish forms might be revived among the populace ; and the o.x-gods and onion-gods of Egypt at which even a heathen Juvenal jeered, might, amid all our vaunted advance in knowledge, receive again the worship of our scholars. Pantheism is the philosophy of Brahminism with all its hundred thousand graven images, from Ganeshu with his elephant's head to Doorga with her necklace of hu- man skulls. The men who had outgrown the Bible, and found themselves wiser than the Redeemer, might, under the auspices of Pantheism, return to the worship of Apis, and adore the gods of the dairy and the stall, as they 24 CONSERVATIVE PRINCIPLE of all countries. But now the opposers of this gospel dis- cover that it has the defect of not being universal enough ; and they wish a Avider faith, that will embrace the race, let them think as they please, and worship as they may. Thus would this school reconcile all religions by evaporating them. In Germany, the country that has most cultivated this hid- eous error, it has as yet, we believe, prevailed chiefly among portions of the literary classes, and not reached the peasant- ry ; and the nation thus affected are less prone to reduce their opinions to action, and are both more speculative and less practical than ourselves. But let such a doctrine come amongst us and grow to be popular. Let it pass from the libraries of a few dreaming scholars into our common schools, our workshops, our farm-houses, and our homes. Like an active poison released from its confinement in the dim labo- ratory of the chemist, where it was comparatively unknown and innocuous, let it be sprinkled into every pipkin simmer- ing upon the cottage hearth on either side of the Allegha- nies ; let our newspapers drop the doctrine, as a manna of death, from their multitudinous wings, around every hamlet and habitation of the land, and what were the result ? Where, in one short week, were our freedom, our peace, or our morals? all a buried wreck, submerged beneath a weltering ocean of misery and sin. The soul with no immortal herit- age — crime released from its fears of the avenger — and sor- row stripped of its hope of a comforter; the world without a Governor, and the race left fatherless, with the fact of the stood chewing their cud, or suckling their calves. Then the science and taste of the nineteenth century would be required to take, as the emblem of their aspirations, the craven Hebrews of Ezekiel's vision ; " men with their backs towards the ienijile of the Lord, and their faces towards the East."— (Eze. viii. 16.) The Christian missions of our time, assailing eastern heathen- ism, woirld be repaid by an irruption of Oriental Pantheism into our schools of philosophy; the Sufis of Persia and the Brahmins of India would re- tahate on the native lands of their Christian antagonists, and our Careys and our Martyns would be chargeable with having assailed, in the Pantheistic faith they found in the East, a higher truth than they had themselves brought from the West. A living German historian, whose works have found translation and currency in England (Schlosser), in his History of the Eighteenth Century, has intimated broadly, that the most ancient tradition makes Pantheism the original faith of the world. Thus does the philosophy that would fain soar over the head of our Saviour, to a higher and more adequate view of the Divine Nature, find itself grovel- ling at last in the very mire of beast-worship. It is, with no impaired rev- erence for his Bible, that the Christian student turns from such spectacles of human presumption and impiety, to muse on the sovereignty and adore the wisdom of Him, who thus "taketh the wise in their own craftiness." IN OUR LITERATURE. 25 redemption and the hope of the resurrection alike blotted out ; surely these are doctrines no false claims of liberality can palliate. And yet to such tremendous results is tending much of the miscalled liberality of our times. This false liberalism is aiding the lawlessness of which we have beiore spoken, in rejecting all regard to precedent, and all reverence tor antiquity. 5 But in the natural antagonism of the human mind to such excesses as these, is seen rising a fifth principle, that •of Superstition; and though opposed to the last error yet in Its own way preparing injury, from still another side,' to tfie literary interests of our nation. It may seem to some idle to talk of superstition as a peril of the nineteenth century But an age that devours so eagerly the prodigies of Animal Magnetism, is not quite entitled to talk superciliously of the superstition of their forefathers in having been believers in witchcraft. Much of the history of the human mind is but a history of oscillations between opposite extremes of error. There is naturally, in the soul of man, a recoil from the narrowness of the mechanical and utilitarian spirit, as well as from the lawlessness and the false liberalism of which we have already spoken as evils of the times ; while the deifica- tion of passion, another of those evils, makes welcome a religion of absolutions and indulgences. And in this recoil, that antiquity which these former influences would reject, this new principle would not only retain but idolize. It is difhcuit to cast off all regard for those who have preceded us. It is not easy to persuade ourselves that we are men and that our ancestors were but brutes. And there are, conse- quently, several indications in the science, literature, and art of the times, of a current setting steadily and rapidly towards reverence for the past, a regard for the imaginative and the venerable, in place of the cold idolatry of the useful; a drift- ing back of the popular mind towards the times when the Roman church was a dominant power in European civiliza- tion. The Dark Ages once spoken of in our school-boy days, are now more respectfully entitled the Middle Ages. Iheir schoolmen, once derided, are now studied by some scholars, and quoted by more. Cousin, the leading meta- physician of France, has edited an unpublished work of Abe- iara, as some of the Protestant theologians of England have been republishing treatises of Aquinas. In church music the ancient chant is revived. In church architecture, the Gothic, 5 26 CONSERVATIVE PRINCIPLE but a few years since thought uncouth and cumbrous, and ahnost but another name for barbarous, the architecture of the old time-worn cathedral, and the ruinous abbey, is now regarded as the very perfection of beauty—" the frozen mu- sic"^ of the art. In English poetry, the classical school of Pope has given place to the romantic school of Scott and Byron, in which the customs and the religious opinions of the old ages of chivalry are more or less brought again to recollection ; whilst most of the scholars of Britain seem in- clined to transfer the honors of the Augustan age of their literature from the reign of Queen Anne to the elder days of Queen Elizabeth. A powerful party in its Established Church are attempting to revive the doctrines of Laud, Han- croft, and the school of the Nonjurors ; and to develop the Catholic element in their church polity to an extent which to others it would seem must render union with, and subjection to Rome, the final and inevitable result of the general ascendency of the party. Indeed the practical cha- racter of the English mind, and their disposition to reduce to action all opinions, would seem to forbid that the prose- lytes of the new school should retain a foothold on the steep declivity where their teachers contrive to stand, by the aid of subtle distinctions. The nation once indoctrinated must rush down to Rome. By a sort of moral gravitation inherent in the Catholic system, the lesser must be attracted to the larger body, and the more recent be absorbed in the more ancient. All attempts to stay them, on such a system, would be like arresting an avalanche, mid-way on its descent, and securing it to the sides of the Alps by strips of court-plaster. In the literature of France, the contest a few years since so eagerly waged among that mercurial people between the classical and the romantic schools, would seem now to have been decided to the advantage of the latter, thus attaching the European mind, as by a new bond, to the Mediajval times. In some of the French historians, and the French are now among the best of the modern writers of history, a return has even been made to the picturesque style of the old Mediaeval chroniclers. Much of this may be, and proba- bly is, the fleeting fancy of the season. And all these things may seem to some minds but fantasies of the day, and fash- ions that are soon to pass ; but it should be remembered 6 Mad. de Stael. IN OUR LITERATURE. 27 that such fantasies have in passing shaken thrones, and sub- verted dynasties ; and that such fashions of feeling, if we call them so, have maddened whole nations, and in the days of the French Revolution armed France, almost as one man, against the rest of Europe, as in the days of the Crusades they had hurled Europe, in one embattled mass, upon Asia. Favored by these, among other influences, the Church, which is the great representative of superstition in Christen- dom — it is the Romish church we mean — is rising rapidly to some of her lost eminence and influence. She is multiplying amongst us her colleges, many of them under the charge of that order, the Jesuits, who were once the most renowned instructors of Europe. Upon the field of Foreign Missions she is jostling eagerly each successful Protestant Mission in Asia, in Oceanica, or on our own continent. De Smet, a Jesuit missionary, boasts of the hundreds of Indians bap- tized near the mouth of the Columbia River, far beyond the Rocky Mountains ; and rumors are already spread that the Papal See is to be requested to constitute Oregon into a Romish bishopric.'' But what is far more wondrous is the rejuvenescence of this Church in the old strong-holds of Protestantism in Europe. Germany, a few years since, saw scholars like the Stolbergs and the Schlegels passing over from Protestantism into the Papal communion. Scotland, over whose grey mountains seems yet brooding the stern and solemn earnestness of her old reformers — the land where Knox destroyed the monasteries, "dinging down" the rook- eries that the rooks might not return, has seen of late her Romish chapels not only, but her Romish nunneries, erected, and not left untenanted by votaries. Geneva, once the Athens of the Reformation, is itself threatened with the ca- lamity of becoming a Romish State.^ In England, the bul- "> Since created. 8 Such is the testimony of a recent traveller, a clergyman of Scotland, the Rev. Dr. Heugh, in his "Notices of the State of Religion in Geneva and Bd- gium." Glasgow, 1844, pp. 205-210. "In the Genevese territory itself, the progress of Popery is rapid beyond all precedent. For a long period subse- quent to the Reformation, there could have been few, if any, resident Catho- lics within the territory. A great and rapid change has recently taken place. During the long occupation of Geneva by the French, that is from 1798 to 1814, both infidel and Popish influence made alarming progress. In the latter year, a small additional territory was annexed, by treaty, to Geneva, and being taken from Savoy, tiie population was entirely Catholic. It was at this period that the Roman Catholic religion won the support of the State, equally with the Protestant. From that time, the activity of the Popish 28 CONSERVATIVE PRINCIPLE wark of European Protestantism, the progress of the Romish Church in numbers, wealth, boldness, and influence, within the last few years, has been most rapid. And in some por- tions of the earth, this artful and versatile power, rich in the arts of centuries of diplomacy, and so long the ally of Des- potism, and herself almost an incarnation of Oppression, clergy and their party has been unremitting ; and by the formation of schools, by domiciliary visitation, by public processions, by preaching, by the press, they are straining every nerve to reduce long rebellious Geneva to her ab- jured allegiance to the See of Rome. Far from attempting to conceal their efforts, their object, and their confident expectations, they glory in avowing them ; they already exult in their anticipated success ; and with too large a proportion of such a population as they have to do with, confidence is re- garded as the prestige of victory. It is not long since the Popish party modestly requested that the chief church in Geneva, Calvin's church, the cathedral itself, should be restored to them. Except when the eclat of a com- munion attracts a throng of Unitarian formalists, the cathedral, we have seen, is nearly empty at the usual worship of the Sabbath ; and the cold of winter is such an overmatch for Unitarian ardor, that during that season they surrender their cathedral, without a sigh, to the undisturbed possession of the fogs and frosts, inviting the few worshippers who are not quite be- numbed, to assemble m a small and more comfortable place adjoining. The Roman Catholics sought the restoration of a place of worship for which the Protestants appear to have so little need, accompanying the request with the sarcastic Intimation, that they would keep the cathedral open ail the year round, and that their numbers would keep it warm enough even during the winter's cold. The clergy, it is said, avow their conviction, that the question of occupancy is but a question of time; that there is no doubt that Geneva will soon be their own again ; and remark with good humor, that the Prot- estant motto will require no change, and will soon be fulfilled in another sense than that in which its authors meant it — ' After darkness, light!'* Tiie progress of the Popish population, completes the danger. By the annexation of the new territory, and also by a perpetual immigration of poor Savoyards, in quest of the comforts of Geneva (like Hibernian immigration into Britain), the Roman Catholics have now upwards of 27,000 out of a population rather under 60,000; and during the last five years, the Catholic population in- creased by three thousand, while that of the Protestants diminished by two hundred, the former by immigration into the territory, the latter by emigration from it. That advancing minority will become, and probably will soon become, an actual majority, and then, suffrage being universal, Geneva may, by the vote of a majoiity of her citizens, lose her rank among Protestant states, renounce by open profession the Protestantism which in fact her ministers and her people have already betrayed, and reannex herself to Rome. ********** They have Unitarianism established already, and Catholicism virtually estab- lished along with it, with the near prospect of its arriving at an ascendency, possibly an exclusive ascendency." These are not the hasty and ill-advised opinions of a foreign visitant, after the lapse of a few days of hurried observa- tion. He quotes from a publication of the distinguished Merle D'Aubigne, the author of the well-known History- of the Reformation. In a work of his, "La Question cle I' Eglise" that eminent man, himself a resident of Geneva, says : " The faith of our fathers made Rome tremble at the name of Geneva ; now, alas ! Geneva trembles at the name of Rome. * * * Are we sure * "Post tenebras, lux," the motto on the escutcheon and coin of Geneva. IN OUR LITERATURE. 29 seems coquetting with Democracy, and courting the spirit of Social Progress. It reminds one of the prediction of the excellent Bengel, who, with all his errors in the interpreta- tion of Scripture prophecy, was a scholar eminent for learn- ing, acuteness and profound piety, that the last days would witness a league of Socinianism and Romanism — the spirit of tradition and the spirit of rationalism. ^ In fact this Apos- tate Church, branded as the Babylon of New Testament prophecy, seems disguising her wrinkles, and painting her facef until it is rent*" again — rent, we mean, with some un- seemly contradictions of her old principles. Like Jezebel, in her gay old age, with tired head and lacquered eyes, she is seen looking out from her palace windows, not like the relict of Ahab, to upbraid, but to soothe and to allure the Jehu of the age — the Spirit of Radicalism, and the party of the movement, as with glowing axle, it drives the cliariot wheels of innovation over every obstacle. And literature must feel, and is already feeling, in various departments, the weight of this new element, the element of superstition amid the conflicting influences of our age. The contributions, for instance, of Romish authors to English literature, have both in amount and ability been trebled, probably, within the last twenty years. As to the cramping and degrading power of all superstition on the mind, the restraints it imposes on the that Popery, triumphant, and perched upon our high towers, will not one day, and quickly, mock with bitter derision the blindness of our citizens? The air is heavy, the atmosphere is choking, the night, perhaps the tempest, approaches. Let us enter then into our bosoms — let us reflect in that inner temple, and raising our cry to heaven, let us say. O God, save the country, for men come to destroy it. * * * * * Rome cannot change. All around us she advances. She builds altar after altar upon the banks of our lake. The progress is such amonest us, from the facility which stran- gers have In acquiring the right of citizenship, that quickly (every one ac- knowledges it) the Romish population will exceed the Protestant popidation of Geneva. * * * * Let Rome triumph at Rome, it is natural. Let Rome, as she assures herself, triumph at Oxford; the conquest will be great. But let Rome triumph at Geneva, then she will raise a cry that will echo to the extremity of the universe. Genevese! that cry will announce to the world the death of your country." It is the quotation and translation of Dr. Heugh that we here have used. 9 "Li the last times Popery and the Socinian heresy (a denial of the proper deity of Christ) will run into one another." — Memoir of John Alb. Bengel by John C. F. Biirk, translated from the German by Robert F. Walker, London, 1837, p. 301. " But though Socinianism and Popery at present appear virtually alool, they will in process of time form a mighty confluence, that will biu'st all bounds and bring every thing to a crisis." — Ibid., p. 322. 10 Jerem. iv. 30. 30 CONSERVATIVE PRINCIPLE march of science, and its violence wrought against physical as well as moral truth, let the story of Galileo tell, and let the records of Spain and her Inquisition attest. We would never forget, in speaking strongly of the errors of the Romish Church, the piety and genius that have been found in members of her communion. The memory of her Kempis, her Fenelon, her Pascal, her Arnaulds, and her Nicole, must ever remain dear to the Christian. But we would remember that to some of the best of these her chil- dren, she was but a harsh and persecuting step-mother,' and that she cast out that most able and devout body of men, the Jansenists of France, with ignominious cruelty — branding their name, suppressing their books, and sparing not their dead. Nor, while we cherish with the tenderest reverence and affection, the names of some among her saints whose shoe-latchets we are not worthy to unloose, can we forget the wrongs she has inflicted upon humanity, and her blas- phemies against God — can we blanch the long and dark catalogue of her corruptions and errors, or dare to overlook the sentence of prophecy, branding her with infamy, and dooming her disastrous splendor to a fatal eclipse, and her power to a final and utter overthrow. Here then, if we have not deceived ourselves, are perils besetting the future course of our literature, not only real but formidable. Many of the details, that were unavoidable, may have seemed to some of our hearers trivial, but in our view they are trivial, only as are the weeds which float in ihe edge of the Gulf-stream. Light and valueless in themselves, they yet serve to remind the weary navigator what coast he is nearing, and what the currents whose noiseless power is drifting his bark away from her appointed course. Did any one of these several causes operate separately, it would be more easy to prognosticate from the signs of the times, re- garding the destinies of American literature. The utilitarian and mechanical spirit would threaten our literary glories with the fate of Holland, whose early splendor of scholarship was so fatally beclouded by her subsequent lust of gain. The prevalence of passion would conform us to the imbecile, lux- urious, trifling and vindictive character that mars so much the glory of modern Italy. The reign of lawlessness would revive in our history the later ages of Republican Greece, its anarchy, violence and misery. The sway of a false lib- eralism would renew on American shores the crimes and IN OUR LITERATURE. 31 sufferings of the reign of terror in France, when Anacharsis Clootz led his motley representatives of the whole human race to do homage to the French Republic, and the Arch- bishop of Paris abjured Christianity ; as the victory of super- stition would bring us into a resemblance with the former condition of Spain, when rejoicing, as her king did, in the title of the " Most Catholic" among the subject monarchs of the Romish See, the country saw absolutism tilling the throne, and the Inquisition filling every other place. Utilitarianism, the iirst of these evil influences, would replace the Bible by the ledger, the Price Current, and the bank note list. Pas- sion, the second, would fill our hands with the viol, the song- book, and the stiletto, or perchance the bowie-knife. The third, or lawlessness, would compel every man to put on sword and pouch, and turn robber and homicide in self-de- fence, snatching what he could and standing sentry over his spoils. The reign of a liberalism, such as we have seen in Germany, would send us to the study of Polyglott grammars, and furnish us for our religious reading with a manual of Pantheistic Philosophy ; while the domination of the fifth would give us the chaplet of beads, and the Index of pro- hibited books to guide our prayers, and direct our studies ; and meanwhile the Inquisition would take under its paternal charge the erring and refractory press. But acting, as we have said, not separately, but conjointly, it is more difficult to predict the coming history of our literature. The several causes we have indicated will, when acting as antagonist forces, hardly neutralize, although they may often exaspe- rate each other; and some of them are likely ultimately to acquire the ascendency over and extinguish the others. The influence of a demoralized and demoralizing literature it is scarce possible to portray in too gloomy colors. There were days in the history of revolutionary France when it would have been difficult to say which had been the more destructive engine, the press as worked by Marat, or the guillotine as managed by Robespierre. If the one was reek- ing continually with fresh blood, and heaped up its hecatombs of the dead, the other ran with a more deadly venom, that corroded the hearts of the living. Our cheap press, from its powers of diffusive influence, would make a literature that should be merely frivolous, and not flagrantly vicious, one of no little harm to the mental soundness of the nation. A race of heroes, such as Plutarch portrays, could never grow 32 CONSERVATIVE PRINCIPLE lip if fed only on the spoonmeats and syllabubs of an elegant literature, and finding their entertainment in the lispings and pulings of a feeble sentimentalism. If the press be more than frivolous, if it have become licentious, its ravages on a reading community, and in a free country — and such a com- munity and country God has made ours — are incalculable. For character and private peace, for honesty and morals, for the domestic charities, and for life itself, there remains no asylum on earth, when such a press is allowed to run a muck against the victims that its caprice, its interest or its pique may select. There have been newspapers circulating in Christian America, that would have been hailed in the cities of the plain, on the day ere the avenging fires fell from Heaven, as the utterances of no uncongenial spirit, the work of men morally acclimated to breathe that atmosphere of putridity and death. There have been seen, as editors, men whose hearts seem to have become first ossified, and then carious, in the exercise of their vocation, alike hardened in feeling and corrupted in principle, men who had no mercy, no conscience and no shame. And such men have been not only sufi'ered but applauded, courted and bribed, while "a reading public," to use a phrase of the times, has been found to gather eagerh' around the moral slaughter-houses, over which such spirits presided ; and has delighted itself in snufling the fumes of each fresh sacrifice, feeding on the garbage, and drenching their souls in the puddles there supplied. The extent of the moral taint already spread from such foul sources of corruption, who can estimate ? Were such to become the pervading and controlling spirit of our literature, that literature, and the society which sustains it, must col- lapse and perish, a loathsome mass of festering corruption. For a profligate literature destroys itself and the commu- nity who patronize it. Let literature be sold into bondage to immorality, and its days are thenceforward numbered, as well by the very nature of the human mind, as by the laws of the divine government. Genius, when grinding, like a blind Samson, in the prison-house of vice, ultimately per- ishes in its task, and leaves no heir. It may not so seem at first. A delirious frenzy may appear to call forth fresh elo- quence and harmony, and every Muse, dissolute and shame- less, may wave aloft the thyrsus of a mad Bacchante. Science and art, and wit and eloquence, have thus aided in the erec- tion of shrines to immorality ; but they have languished and IN OUR LITERATURE. 33 died amid their toils. A profligate people soon ceases to be intelligent, and their literature loses all living power, all ability to perpetuate itself. The literature of the dead past is soon all that remains to a vicious community. And when the proudest monument of unprincipled talent and perverted genius has been completed, and stood perfect in beauty, its last chapiter -carved and fixed, its topmost pinnacle glittering on high, its last statue polished and fitted in its appointed niche, the nation may have exulted in the splendor of their immoral poetry, and eloquence and art. But that nation, even in the hour of its triumph, stands before its trophies, bereft of the talents that had aided in its work, desolate and lone, like him who reared from its ruins the city of palm- trees, the fated city over which hung the old but unslumber- ing curse of Heaven. His children fell as the walls of his new foundation rose ; and he stood at the last in the home he had reared, a solitary man, with none to inherit his labors — "For Hiel the Bethelite in those days built Jericho. He laid the foundations thereof in Abiram, his first-born, and set up the gates thereof in his youngest son Segub." Lite- rature slays its children, when building under God's curse. Talent prostituted in the cause of vice pines amid its suc- cesses and dies ; and an imbruted communit}^, it is generally seen, by a just retribution of Providence, soon buries in ob- livion the literature that has corrupted and barbarized it. Whether, then, we love the cause of letters or of religion, whether our country or its honor, whether science or piety be dear to us, we need to dread a depraved literature, and we have cause with jealousy to watch every influence that may threaten to work such corruption. We have seen that perils of this kind are not wanting amongst us. n. But where, it may be asked, is the remedy of the evils that beset us, and against these perils is it in our power to find and apply any preservative ? Such defence, we reply then, against the possible corrup- tion of our literature is not, amongst us at least, to be found in legislation. We look with jealousy on every thing that seems to abridge the freedom of the press. And, again, legislation is with us but the emanation of the popular taste. When that taste has itself become vitiated, it will of course hardly seek to reform itself, or submit to the necessary re- strictions. Nor is there a sufficient guard m education. Our newspapers are in this land almost an integral part of our 6 34 CONSERVATIVE PRINCIPLE education, and no process that reached the schools only and not the journals of the land would be sufficient. And our scholastic education is itself but the utterance of the moral taste and fashion of the times, and will therefore be very slow to detect and check its own deficiencies. Nor is there hope for us in philosophy. That never yet reached the masses, and often in the classes it has reached, it has been lilie the Epicurean philosophy in Roman society, a fermenting prin- ciple that hastened the decay and dissolution of the common- wealth. Not in general knowledge, for that may be the knowledge of evil quite as much as of good, and the intelli- gence that stores the head and neglects the heart, has cursed many, but saved none. And if all these resources are insuf- ficient, what have we left? The remedy that shall guard and purge, and invigorate and fructify our literature, must have power, and to possess power it must come from without ; not from man, not from society — but from something older, higher and mightier than society or man. But to avail with us. it must not only have power, but popular power. Our government is a govern- ment of popular opinion, and no doctrine that confines itself to the schools or to certain select classes in society, a sacer- dotal or an aristocratic class, can suffice. It must also have permanent power, and be beyond the reach of change from the changing customs and fashions of the time. And where shall such a remedy be found ; rebuking a cold utilitarianism, curbing the fierceness of passion, awing the lawless, enlight- ening and shaming the falsely liberal, and emancipating the slave of superstition 1 Looking at the variety and complexity of the evils to be overcome, where, it may be asked, shall we seek it? Human authority is insufficient, and mortal wisdom is dumb. Yet we believe that such a principle of recovery and conservatism exists, and one that has in perfection all the several elements needed to success. It has power ; for it comes from God and stretches into eternity — popular power; for it was made by the maker of man's heart, and has in all ages of history and amid all varieties of culture proved its power over the masses, and commended itself to the hearts of the people — permanent power ; for it has lasted while empires have fallen, and sects and schools of philoso- phy have risen, vaunted, flourished, faded and been forgotten. It claims all times, and its rewards and denunciations are fetched from beyond the grave and lay hold upon another IN OUR LITERATURE. 35 world. Is it again asked : Where is this remedial agent— this branch of healing for the bitter waters, the Marah foun- tains of our literature ? We answer : It is the cross of Christ. Let us not shrink to say it. The Cross of Christ is the only Conservative Principle of our Literature. Towards this point, as will be seen, all our earlier remarks have tended; and it will furnish the theme of all that yet remain to be made. Nothing else can save our literature. This can— though alone, it is sufficient. The cross of Christ," we say it again, is the only conservative principle of our lite- rature. Nor let any be startled. Bacon spoke of Theology as the haven of all science. It was said by a highly gifted woman, Madame de Stael, who cannot be charged as a pro- fessional or prejudiced witness in the matter, that the whole history of the world resolved itself naturally into two great eras, that before Christ's coming, and that which has followed his advent. And we find John von Midler, a distinguished scholar and historian of Germany, holding this language as to his favorite science, in which he had made such eminent proficiency. Animadverting on a defect of Herder in his " Philosophy of History," " I find," said Miiller, " every thing there but Christ, and what is the history of the world without Christ?" '^ And in fact the whole history of our world has looked forward or backward to the fatal tree reared on grim Gol- gotha. The oblation there made had the promise and immu- table purpose of God with it to insure its efficacy over the whole range of man's history antecedent and subsequent, and along the whole course of the Mystery of Divine Prov- idence, as seen in the government of the world. Let us, we entreat you, be understood. By the Cross of Christ we do not mean the imaged cross, as borne on the banners of the Inquisition, with the emblems of Judgment and Mercy floating over the scenes of the Auto da Fe, where the judgment was without justice, and the mercy was a mere lie. '2 JVor the Cross as borne on the shoulder of the cru- '1 Tholuck in Princeton Bibl. Repertory, vol. iv., p. 229. '2 A rugged and knotty cross, with the sword of Justice displayed on one side and the olive branch of Mercy on the other, was the device borne on the banner of the .Spanish Inquisition, and its motto was, "Arise, O Lord, and plead thine own cause." Limborchi Histor. Inq. Ainstel., 1692, (p. 370.) 36 CONSERVATIVE PRINCIPLE sader, whilst, pleading the name of Christ, he moved through scenes of rapine and massacre to lay his bloody hand on the Holy Sepulchre. Nor do we mean the cross, as, carved and. The inscription on that of the Inquisition at Goa was " Misericordia et Jus- tiiia," and its emblem a figure of St. Dominic, with the right hand profTering the olive branch and the left displaying the sword. (Ibidem.) The remark in the text, on the utter falsehood of the claims made by the Inquisition to mercy, refers mainly to its usual forms in passing judgment. As the canonical law forbids ecclesiastics i'rom shedding blood, the clerical judgts of that treniendous tribunal were accustomed in handing over the heretic to the secular courts for execution, to annex the earnest recommen- dation that he should be treated by these secular judges with mercy, and not harmed in life or limb, whilst expecting and even requiring that these exe cutioners of their will should destroy limbs and life in the fire. Llorente, in his history of the Spanish Inquisition, animadverts severely on this hollow and heartless mockery of Christian tenderness. It appears in a very prominent manner on the singular records which Limborch, an earlier and Protestant historian, published as an appendix to his History, containing the sentences of the Inquisition established at Toulouse, in France, and among whose victims were found many of the Albigenses and VValdenses. The sentences are the identical records of the Sacred Office, at Toulouse, from 1307 to 1323. "They deserved," is the remark of Gibbon (Decline and Fall, chap, liv.), "a more learned and critical editor." The elaborate work of Rev. S. R. Maitland, librarian to the Archbishop of Canterbury, upon the VValdensian history, entitled, " Facts and Documents illustrative of the His- tory, Doctrines, and Rites of the ancient Alb'igenses and VValdenses, Lon- don, 1832," lays great stress, and justly, on this record, which it describes, "as less known than it deserves to be." Speaking of other documents, Maitland remarks — " In fact, I have brought forward the public documents hitherto noticed very principally with a view to authenticate and illustrate this one, which I consider to be the fullest, and the most decisive. Of its genuineness, I believe there never has been, and never can be, any doubt." (p. 213.)* * Although we do not remember that Maitland alludes to the fact, the MS. of these records of the Toulouse Inquisition seems to have passed into Ensland. In a work ed- ited by T. Forstcr, London, 1830, and entitled, " Original LeIlPrs of Locke, Algernon Sidney, and Anthony, Lord ShnftesJiurij," a manuscript (evidently that whicii Lim- boicli u.sed), is descrilied as forming jiart of the large library of an EnsUsh merchant settled at Rotterdam, hy tlie name of Benjamin Fiirly. In a catalogue of his library, as sold by auction in 1714, the parchment volume is spoken of as being, '■•if all rarest hooks'the 7nost rare, and beyond valuation,'^ (Pref. pp. cxviii, cxix.) Having been at the sale bought in by the family, a son of Furly sold it ■' to Archhishop Seeker for the British Museimi," p. cxix. Furly. its proprietor, was one of the early Quakers, a learned man, aiidauthor, with George Fox and Stubhs. of that t^tiansc and erudite aittck on the complimentary use of the ]iluial you. in addre.-sing a singU^ individual, entitled " A Batlledorefor Teachers and Professors to team Sijigiitar and Plural ;" and was in habits of intimacy with Locke, when in Holland, and with Le Clerc and Limborch. To this remarkable Manuscript and its contents, Locke, in the correspondence pub- lished in the above volume of Forster (a Catholic descendant of the Quaker Furly), seems to allude, pp. 21, 26, 29, 30, ansum.tameii instanter requirimus et rogamus ut citra viortis periculuni et merribr'. mutila- tionem suam circa te sententiam moderetur.) A husband and wife, Walden- sians, are again committed to the mercies of the secular tribunal in the like select and chary phrases (p. 291). A similar affectionate entreaty {afftctuose rogantes) is used in delivering a female VValdensian to the chief judge of the king, the lieutenant of the seneschal of Toulouse (p. 381), and two Beguins to the same secular judge (p. 3S6), and yet two other Beguins, who are relin- quished into the same hands (p. 393). It was, then, part of the gracious etiquette of the Inquisitorial tribunal, like Pilate, at the sentence of Christ, to wash her hands clean of the blood of those she gave up. More eager than Pilate, she insisted on the penalty she required others to inflict. But chary as she was of allowing the violent death which followed to appear as her act, or to stain her records, the truth breaks out in several places on the same records; as where one Petrus Lucensis, who abjured his errors, speaks of some earlier victims of the Inquisition as having been condemned by the inquisitors and prelates of the Roman church, and " left to the secular arm and burnt" {condemnati per inquisitores et pre- latos ecclesicB Romano:, et relicti seculari bracliio et combusti), p. 360. The formula of abandonment to the secular arm was followed by the stake as its invariable sequent — " condemnati et per secularem curiam combusti," pp. 310, 313, 319, 320, 323, &c. And the inquisitors not only expected this sequent, but, as it appears from Llorente's history of the kindred Inquisition in Spain, they required and enforced it. It is from the second edition of his original work, as published at Paris, in 1S18, in 4 vols. Svo., and not from the American re-print of his abridged work, that we quote. The sentence of the Inquisition, he remarks, closes with a prayer to the judges to treat the sufferer with humanity (I. 122) ; but there were, he observes, several instances in which the secular magis- trate, choosing to take the inquisitors at their word, and to suppose their Doat, Conseiller du roi, from tlie registers of the Inquisition at Albv, Carcasoniie, Toulouse, Narboniie,