BR 60 .L52 V.A4 John Chrysostom, d. A07. The homilies of S. John Chrysostom, Archbishop of V. 'r LIBRARY OF FATHERS HOLY CATHOLIC CHUECH, ANTERIOR TO THE DIVISION OF THE EAST AND WEST. TRANSLATED BY MEMBERS OF THE ENGLISH CHURCH. YET SHALL NOT THY TEACHERS BE REMOVED INTO A CORNER ANY MORE, BUT THINE EYES SHALL SEE THY TEACHERS. Isaiah XXX. 20. OXFORD : JAMES PARKER & CO. AND RIVINGTONS, LONDON, OXFORD, AND CAMBRIDGE. TO THE MEMORY t OF THE \ MOST REVEREND FATHER IN GOD 1 WILLIMI ; LORD AECHBISHOP OF CANTERBURY, PRIMATE OF ALL ENGLAND, FORMERLY REGIUS PROFESSOR OF DIVINITY IN THE UNIVERSITY OF OXFORD, H THIS LIBRARY I OF ANCIENT BISHOPS, FATHERS, DOCTORS, MARTYRS, CONFESSORS. ; OF CHRIST'S HOLY CATHOLIC CHURCH, UNDERTAKEN AMID HIS ENCOURAGEMENT, AND CARRIED ON FOR j TWELVE YEARS UNDER HIS SANCTION, i UNTIL HIS DEPARTURE HENCE IN PEACE, IS _ 1 GRATEFULLY AND REVERENTLY I INSCRIBED. THE HOMILIES S. JOHN CHRYSOSTOM ARCHBISHOP OF CONSTANTINOPLE. THE HOMILIES OP ' y S. JOHN CHRYSOSTOM ARCHBISHOP OF CONSTANTINOPLE ON THE EPISTLE OF S. PAUL THE APOSTLE TO THE HEBREWS PUBLISHED AFTER HIS DECEASE OXFORD : JAMES PARKER AND CO. AND RIVINGTONS LONDON, OXFORD, AND CAMBRIDGE. 1877. PRINTED BY THE SOCIETY OF THE HOLY TRINITy/ HOLY ROOD, OXFORD. \ PREFACE. This volume completes tlie series of S. Chrysostom^s Homilies on the New Testament. Translated a quarter of a century ago by the Rev. T. Keble Vicar of Bisley, and revised with great labour in the use of the then existing editions by his brother, the Vicar of Hursley, it was thought best to delay the pubhcation until Dr. Field had completed the long-delayed publication of the Greek Text. This ap- peared in 1862. The editing of the text of S. Chrysostom's Homilies is attended with peculiar difficulties. Written sermons % if ever preached in those days, were the exception. Those which have been preserved to us have been generally taken down by some hearer. S.Augustine afterwards revised his, when brought to him for the purpose. In the case of S. Chrysostom^s Homilies on the Acts of the Apostles, as well as of the present volume, there are two distinct texts still extant : that originally taken down by the short-hand writer, and another, when this had been polished and made neat at a subsequent time. Dr. Field's great labour then in the Greek text of the present volume had been to restore the older form of these Homilies. He had ample material, both in Greek MSS., in a Catena published not many years ago by our Dr. Cramee, Principal of New Inn Hall, which » See an animadversion of S. Cyril details of S. Augustine's preaching. Alex, on those who committed to Fleury remarks of Atticus, Arch- writing other people's sermons and bishop of Constantinople, in the be- thus preserved what might have been ginning of the fifth century, just after less deliberately uttered as though it S. Chrysostom's decease, " His ser- had been thoroughly well weighed. " mons were indifferent, so that no De Ador. viii. t. i. 267. See also the " one took the trouble to take them constantly-occurring expressions in " down in writing." Fleury, Eccles. S. Augustine which belong to the na- Hist. xxii. 9 p.l33 Oxford translation, tural extemporaneous delivery but The extract however which S. Cyril which would be untrue in the deli- has preserved of Atticus (de recta fide very of written sermons. The Preface ad Arcadiam Marinamque, repeated to the first volume of S. Augustine on in his Apol. adv. Episcopos Orientales S. John in this Library written by the cap. 4) is eloquent and pious. Rev. H. Browne contains interesting X PREFACE. exhibit the older text (the former half of a second Catena^ compiled by Niketas ^ Ai^chbishop of Heraclea in Thrace in the eleventh century, and publisbed by the same Dr. Cramer appears to use both) ; and, of yet more importance, in Latin versions. Cassiodorus, an Italian, who lived about 150 years after S. Chrysostom, in the earlier part of his treatise, de Insti- tutione Divinarum Litterarum cap. 8. (opp. t. ii. p. 543 ed. Rotom. 1679) in describing a volume of S. Paulas Epistles, in which 13 of the Epistles had a good commentary, goes on, " But in regard to the Epistle to the Hebrews whicb '' S. John Bishop of Constantinople treated of in Greek in '^ 34 homilies, we have caused Mutianus, a most eloquent " man, to translate them into Latin, that the order of the " Epistles might not be unduly broken off.^^ To Cassiodorus then we owe the Latin version of Mu- tianus which has come down to us, and which, translated from the older form of text, has been a great assistance in the editing. It is often quoted in the footnotes. In p. 167 there is also given an extract from the 13th Homily by Facundus, an African Bishop, who lived about the same time with Mutianus, but who apparently translated the passage into Latin for himself. The short-hand writer, who took down these Homilies and thus preserved them to us, is not unknown to us. It is S. Chrysostom's dearly -loved friend the Priest Constantine or Constantius ^ For the title is. Homilies of 8. John Chrij- sostom ArchhisJwp of Constantinople on the E;pistle to the HehrewSyimhlished after his decease from notes hij Constantine Presbyter of Antioch. At the beginning of S. Chrysostom's exile in 404, when he was in Nicsea, in a Letter which he wrote to Constantius about a mission which he had set on foot at Phoenicia (Ep. 121 t. iii. pp. 721, 722 ed. Montf.), he begs him ^'not »> Dr. Cramer had published tins part inf.) from the l»aris MS. Cod. Rep^. 238 '^^ Montfaucon observe^ that the Ma- which contains the hrst half only: but nuscripts frequently interchange the the whole catena is extant in the Li- name, brary of S.Ambrose at Milan (E. 63 PREFACE. XI ''to cease having a care for tlie Churclies of Phoenicia and "Arabia and the east, and to write to'' S. Chrysostom "quite "often, and tell him how many Churches had been built "in a year and what holy men had gone into Phoenicia." Soon after, Constantius seems to have asked leave of S. Chrysostom to join him; for in his 13th letter to Olym- pias on arriving at Cocussus or Cucusus in Cappadocia, now Goksyn, his bitter place of exile, S. Chrysostom says, (ib, p. 594) " My Lord, the most pious priest Constantius, "would fain have been here long ago, for he wrote to me "begging that I would let him come.'' About this time, perhaps while Constantius was on his actual journey to Cu- cusus, S. Chrysostom writes to him (Ep. 225 p. 724), grieved at not having heard from him, and speaks of their great love for each other and of Constantius' goodness to the poor, the fatherless and widows : soon after he writes from Cucusus to Elpidius bishop of Laodicea (Ep. 114 p. 656), "the most reverend priests Constantius and Euethius are "here with us." There are extant two Letters of Con- stantius, one of them to his mother, written while he was companion of S. Chrysostom there (pp. 731 and 734). In the course of this banishment S. Chrysostom writes (Ep. 123 pp. 663, 664) about this Phoenician mission to ''the "priests and monks in Phoenicia, who were instructing the "Gentiles there," encouraging them in their work, and saying that he had given orders that all their expenses " in clothing, shoes and support of the brethren should be "bountifully supplied," and adds that they will know about his affairs from Constantius' letter. In a letter to Gerontius (Ep. 54 p. 623) written during this exile about the mission in Phoenicia, S. Chrysostom says that he had intrusted Constantius to give Gerontius all he needed whether " for "building or for the needs of the brethren." To Constantius' piety we owe the preservation of these Homilies. One very special value of them lies in the pious fervent exhortation at the end of each, on Penitence, Alms- giving, or whatever S. Chrysostom had at the time chiefly in mind, breathing forth words from a heart, filled with the Love of God and that longed for his flock to partake it. xii PEEFACE. Ho.M. I on sin and Almsgiving 2 on high tlioughts and on poverty and wealth 3 on God's gifts to eacli 4 on lieathen practices at funerals 5 on temptation 6 on Heaven 7 on old age 8 on study of Scriptures 9 on Penitence and confession of our sins 10 on relieving distress 11 on Almsgiving and giving to beggars 12 on free-will and Penitence 13 on not postponing Baptism and on a right life 14 on Thought of God and earnest prayer 15 on sin-enslavement and on untimely laughter 16 on dwelling in Heaven 17 on worthily receiving Holy Communion'^' 18 on the Might of Poverty 19 on the great Gain of loving one's neighbour 20 on slavery to possessions and on Thankfulness 21 on gossip 22 on seeking God, on His Protection and enduring Temptation 23 oii the loss of God 24 on the acquirement of Virtue 25 on not caring for things of the world nor partaking with the covetous 26 on loyalty to God 27 on the might of Prayer and on minding us that we are sinners 28 value of Affliction and on simplicity of life and adornment of the soul 29 on the Peril of Luxury 30 on helping each other in way of salvation 31 on Penitence and keeping in mind our sins 32 on the Might of mercifulness to others 33 on the value of affliction, trial, poverty, and on Thank- fulness ^ 34 on using with intensity of mind and purpose, the Grace of the Spirit. PREFACE. Xlll After the publication of Dr. Field^s text (Bibliotlieca Patrum Ecclesiae Catbolicae Qui ante Orientis et Occidentis schisma floruerunt, torn vii. Oxonii 1862) the translation was again very carefully revised by that text by the Rev. Dr. Baeeow, Principal of S. Edmund Hall : he also wrote heads for the present Preface. The headings were given (as fa"r as could be done) in the MS. and many of them have been retained; others, fitting in less well with the printed page, seemed to need a little modification. For an occasional note enclosed in brackets, the son of the one re- maining Editor of the Library is responsible. P. E. PUSEY. OxEOED, May 1877. Corrigendum. p. 182 margin /or Hab. ii. 14. correct Isa. xi. 9. and cancel note 1. CONTENTS, ARGUMENT. Page I. HOMILY I. Page 8. Heb. i. 1, 2. God, ivho at sundry times and in divers manners spahe in times past unto the fathers hy the Prophets, hath at the end of the days spoken unto us hy His 8on : whom He hath appointed heir of all things, hy ivhom also He made the ivorlds. HOMILY II. Page 18. Heb. i. 3. Who heing the hrightness of His Glory and the express Image of His person, and upholding all things hy the ivord of His power ^ when He had hy Himself purged our sins. HOMILY III. Page 31. Heb. i. 6—8, And ivhen He again hringeth in the First-Begotten into the world, He saith, And let all the angels of God worship Him. And of the angels He saith, Who malceth His angels spirits, and His ministers a flame of fire. But unto the Son He saith, Thy throne, God, is for ever and ever. Xvi CONTENTS. HOMILY IV. Page 47. Heb. ii. 5 — 7. For unto Angels He hath not imt in subjection the world to come, ivhereof we spealc. But one in a certain place tes- tified, saying, What is man that Thou art mindful of him., or the son of man that Thou visitest him ? Thou hast made hhn a little lower than the Angels. HOMILY V. Page 63. Heb. ii. 16, 17. For verily He taheth not hold of Angels, hut of the seed, of Abraham He taheth hold. Wherefore in all things it behoved Him to be made like unto His brethren. HOMILY VI. Page 76. Heb. iii. 7 — 11. Wherefore, as the Holy Ghost saitli, To-day if ye luill hear His voice, harden not your hearts, as in the provocation m the day of temptation in the wilderness, luhen your fathers tempted Me, proved Me, and saiv My icorhs forty years. Wherefore I luas grieved ivith that generation, and said. They do alway err in their heart, and they have not hnown My ways. So I sivare in My ivrath. If they shall enter into My rest. • HOMILY VII. Page 87. Heb. iv. 11—13. Let us labour therefore to enter into that Rest, lest any man fall after the sani^ example of unbelief. For the ■ word of God is quiclc [i. e. living] and poiverful, and sharper than any tiuo-edged sword, and pierceth even to CONTENTS. XVll the dividing asunder of soul and spirit, and of the joints and marrow, and is a discerner of the thoughts and in- tents of the heart, neither is there any creature that is not manifest in His sight, for all things are nalced and opened unto the eyes of Him luith Whom ive have to do. HOMILY Viri. Page 100. Heb. v. 1—3. For every high jpriest talcen from among men, is ordained for men in things pertaining to God, that he may offer both gifts and sacrifices for sins : %uho can have compassion on the ignorant and on them that are out of the way, for that he himself also is compassed with infirmity ; and by reason hereof he ought, as for the people so also for himself to offer for sins. HOMILY IX. , Page 114. Heb. vi. 1—3. Wherefore leaving the p>rinciples of the Doctrine of Christ, let us go on unto perfection, not laying again the founda- tion of repentance from dead works, and of faith towards God; of the doctrine of baptisms, and of laying on of hands : and of resurrection of the dead, and of eternal judgment. And this we ivill do, if God p>ermit. HOMILY X. Page 127. Heb. vi. 1, 8. For the Earth which drinheth in the rain that cometh oft ' upon it, and bringeth forth herbs meet for them by whom it is dressed, receiveth blessing from God. But if it bear thorns and briars it is rejected, and nigh unto cursing, whose end is to be burned. YOL. VII. b Xviii CONTENTS. HOMILY XL Page 138. Heb. vi. 13—16. For ivlien God made promise to Abraham., because He could swear by no greater, He sware by Himself, saying. Surely blessing I will bless thee, and multiplying I will multiply thee. And so after he had ^patiently endured, he obtained the promise. For men verily swear by the greater, and an oath for confirmation is to them the end of all strife. HOMILY XII. Page 150. Heb. vii. 1 — 3. For this Melchisedec, King of Salem, Priest of the most High God, luho met Abraham as he was returning from the slaughter of the Kings, and blessed him : to ivhom also Abraham ga.ve a tenth jp art of all; first being by inter- pretation King of Righteousness, and after that also King of Salem,, ivhich is. King of Peace, yjithout father, ivith- out mother, without genealogy, having neither beginning of days, nor end of life, but made like unto the Son of God, abideth a Priest continually. HOMILY XIII. Page 160. Heb. vii. 11 — 14. Jf therefore perfection ivere by the Levitical jpriesthood (for under it the people have received the laivj ; what further owed was there, that another priest should arise after the order of Melchisedec, and not be called after the order of Aaron ? For the priesthood being changed, there is of necessity a change also of the laiv. For He of ivhom those tilings are spoken, pertained to another tribe, of which no ynan gave attendance at the altar. For it is evident that our Lord sprang out of Judah, of which tribe Moses spake nothing concerning priests. CONTENTS. XIX HOMILY XIV. Page 174. Heb. viii. 1, 2. Now of the things ivhich ive have spoheyi this is the sum. We have such an High Priest; who is set down at the right hand of the throne of the majesty in the heavens : a minister of the sanctuary and of the true tabernacle which the Lord 2^ itched, and not man. HOMILY XV. Page 187. Heb. ix. 1 — 5. Then verily the first [covenanf] had also ordinances of divine service, and a vwrldly Sanctuary. For there ivas a taber- nacle made.; the first, wherein was the Candlestick, and the Table, and the Shewbread; ivhich is called the Sanctuary. Ayid after the second veil, the tabernacle which is called the Holiest of all ; ivhich had the golden censer, and the Arh of the Covenant overlaid round about with gold, wherein was the golden pot that had manna, and Aaron's rod that budded, and the tables of the covenant ; and over it the Cherubims of glory, shadowing the Mercy -seat, of which we cannot now speah particularly . HOMILY XVI. Page 198. Heb. ix. 15 — 18. And for this cause He is the Mediator of the New Testament, that by means of death for the redemption of the trans- gressions that were under the first Testament, they which are called might receive the promise of an eternal inherit- ance. For where a testament is, there must also of ne- cessity be the death of the testator. For a testament is of force when men are dead, since it hath no force at all whilst the testator liveth. Whereupon neither was that first [testamenf] dedicated without blood. XX CONTENTS. HOMILY XVII, Page 207. Heb. ix. 24—26. For Christ is not entered into the holy places made ivith hands, which are the figures of the true, hut into Heaven itself, noiv to appear in the presence of God for us. Nor yet that He should offer Himself often, as the High Priest entereth into the Holy place every year with blood of others, for then must He often have suffered since the foundation of the world. But now, once, at the end of the world , hath He appeared to put away sin hy the sacrifice of Himself. HOMILY XVIII. Page 218. Heb. X. 8—18. Above luhen He said, Sacrifice and offh'i7ig, and burnt-offer- ings, and lofferingl for sin. Thou ivoiddest not, neither hadst pleasure [therein], which are offered hy the Law, then said He, Lo ! I come ta do Thy ivill, God. He taheth away the first, that He may establish the second. By the ivhich will we are sanctified', by the offering of the body of Jesus Christ, once for all. And every priest standeth daily ministering, and offering oftentimes the same sacri- fices, which can never take aiuay sins. But this [man] after He had offered one sacrifice for sins, for ever sat down on the right hand of God, from henceforth expecting till His enemies be made His footstool. HOMILY XIX. Page 226. Heb. X. 19—23. Having therefore, brethren, boldness to enter into the holiest by the blood o/ Jesus^ by a new and living way ivhich He hath consecrated for us, through the Veil, that is to say, His flesh, and having an High Priest over the house of God, let us d.raw near ivith^ true heart, in full assurance of Jadh, liavmg our hearts sprinkled from an evil conscience, and our bodies washed with pure ivater, let us hold fast the profession of our hope without wavering. CONTENTS. XXI HOMILY XX. Page 233. Heb. X. 26, 27. For if we sin wilfully , after we have received the knowledge of the truth, there remaineth no more sacrifice for sins, hut a c'ertain fearful looking for of judgment, and fiery indig- 7iation luhich shall devour the adversaries. HOMILY XXI. Page 243. Heb. X. 32—34. But call to remembrance the former days, in which after ye ivere illuminated, ye endured a great fight of afflictions ; partly, whilst ye luere made a gazing stock both by re- joroaches and afflictions, and partly whilst ye became companions of them that were so used. For ye had com- passion on those icho were in bonds, and took joyfully the spoiling of your goods, knowing that ye have for yourselves in heaven a better and an enduring substance. HOMILY XXII. Page 253. Heb. xi. 3, 4. Through faith ive understand that the worlds were framed by the word of God ; so that things which are seen ivere not made of things which do appear. By faith Abel offered unto God a more excellent sacrifice than Cain, by lohicli he obtained ivitness that he was righteous, God testifying of his gifts; amd by it he being dead yet speaketh. HOMILY XXIII. Page 2(>1. Heb. xi. 7. By faith Noah, being warned of God of things not seen as yet, moved loithfear, prepared an ark to the saving of his house; by the which he condemned the world, and became heir of the righteousness vjhich is by Faith. Xxii CONTENTS. HOMILY XXIV. Page 275. Heb. xi. 13—16. These all died in faith, not having received the promises, hut having seen them afar off, and embraced them, and confessed that they were strangers and pilgrims on the earth. For they that say such things, declare plainly that they seeh a country. And truly if they had been mindful of that country from luhence they came out, they might have had opportunity to have returned. But now they desire a better country, that is, an heavenly ; wherefore God is not ashamed to be called Their God, for He hath for them a city . HOMILY XXV. Page 285. Heb. xi. 17— 19. By faith [^Abrahani] ivhen he ivas tried offered np Isaac and he that had received the promises offered up his only- begotten son, of ivhom it was said, In Isaac shall thy seed be called : accounting that God was able to raise him up even from the dead; from whence also he received him in a figure. HOMILY XXVI. Page 296. Heb. xi. 20—22. By faith, concerning things to come Isaac blessed Jacob and Esau. By faith, Jacob tuhen he was a dying blessed each of the sons of Joseph, and worshipped leaning on the top of his staff. By faith, Joseph when he died made mention of the departing of the children of Israel, and gave com- mandment concerning his bones. HOMILY XXVII. Page 309. Heb. xi. 28—31. By faith, he hept the Passover and the spi'inlcling of blood, lest he that destroyed the first-born shoidd touch them. By faith, they passed through the Bed sea, as by dry land; CONTENTS. xxiii which the Egyptians assaying to do, were drowned. By faith, the walls of Jericho fell down, after they had heen compassed about for seven days. By faith, Bahah the harlot perished not ivith them that believed not, having received the spies with peace, HOMILY XXVIII. Page 320. Heb. xi. 37, 38. They wandered about in sheep-shins, in goat-shins, being destitute, afflicted, tormented {of whom this world was not worth])) ; wandering in deserts, and mountains, and dens, and caves of the earth. HOMILY XXIX. Page 339. Heb. xii. 4 — 6. Ye have not yet resisted unto blood, striving against sin. And ye have forgotten the exhortation which speaheth unto you as unto children. My son, despise not thou the chastening of the Lord, nor faint ivhen thozi art rebuked of Him. For whom the Lord loveth. He chasteneth : and scourgeth every son whom He receiveth. HOMILY XXX. Page 349. Heb. xii. 11—13. No chastisement for the present seemeth to be joyous, but grievous, nevertheless afterward it yieldeth the peaceable fruit of righteousness to them ivhich have been exercised thereby. Wherefore lift up the hands which hang down, and the feeble hiees : and malce straight paths for your feet, lest that ivhich is lame be turned out of the ivay, but let it rather be healed. Xxiv CONTENTS. HOMILY XXXI. Page 357. Heb. xii. 14. Folloiv peace ivith all men, and holiness without ivhich no one shall see the Lord. HOMILY XXXII. Page 366. Heb. xii. 18—24. For ye are not come unto a fire that might be toucJied and that burned, and unto blachiess, and darlzness, and tempest, and the sound of a trumpet, and the voice of words, ivhich voice they that heard entreated that the word should not be spohen to them any more. {For they could not endure tliat which ivas commanded. And if so much as a beast touch the mountain, it shall be stoned. And, so terrible was the sight, that Moses said, I exceedingly fear and quake.) But ye are come unto Mount 8ion, and unto the city of the Living God, the Heavenly Jerusalem ; and to myriads of Angels, in festive gathering, and to the Church of the first-born which have been enrolled in Heaven; and to God the Judge of all ; and to the spirits of just men made perfect: and to Jesus the Mediator of the New Covenant: and to the blood of sprinMing that spealceth better things than Abel. HOMILY XXXIII. Page 376. Heb. xii. 28, 29. Wherefore we receiving a Kingdom that cannot be moved, let us have grace [or gratitudel, whereby we serve God ac- ceptably with reverence and godly fear. For our God is a consuming fire. HOMILY XXXIV. Page 387. Heb. xiii. 17. Obey them that have the rfde over you, and submit yourselves. For they watch for your souls, as they that my.st give ac- count, that they may do it with joy, and not with grief, for tJiis is unprofitable for you. HOMILIES OF S. JOHN CHRYSOSTOM ARCHBISHOP OF CONSTANTINOPLE ON THE EPISTLE TO THE HEBEEWS PUBLISHED AFTER HIS DECEASE,, FROM NOTES BY CONSTANTINE PRESBYTER OF ANTIOCH. THE ARGUMENT. [1.] The blessed Paul writing to the Romans, saith, (i) Inasmuch then as I am the Apostle of the Gentiles, I magnify Rom. xi. mine office ; if by any means I may provoke to jealousy them ^^» ^^• that are my flesh : and again, in another place, For He Gal. ii. 8. that wrought effectually in Peter to the apostleship of the circumcision, the same wrought effectually in me toward the Gentiles. If therefore he were the Apostle of the Gen- tiles (for also in the Acts, God saith to him. Depart ; for Actsxxii. / will send thee far hence unto the Gentiles), what had he * to do with the Hebrews ? and why did he also write an Epistle to them ? And especially as besides, they were evil-disposed towards him ; as is often from many places to be seen. For hear what James saith to him, Thou seest, brother, how many ib. xxi. thousands of Jews there are ivhich have believed .... and 2^' ^^* these all have been informed of thee that thou teachest men to- forsake the Law. And oftentimes he had many disputings concerning this. Thus (a person might enquire) considering that he was so VOL. VIJ. B Argument, 2 Why should the Apostle of Gentiles learned in the Law (for he was instructed in the Law at the feet of Gamaliel, and his zeal in the cause thereof was great), and that herein he was particularly able to confound them ; why did not God send him to the Jews ? Because on this very account they had been made more vehement Acts xx'ii. in their enmity against him. Foi* they will not endure thee, ^^'^^* saith God unto him. But, Depart far off to the Gentiles^ inasmuch as they ivill not receive thy testimony concerning lb. 19, Me. Whereupon he himself saith, Yea, Lord, they know that 20- I imprisoned and beat in every synagogue them that believed on Thee ; and when the blood of Thy martyr Stephen was shed, I also was standing and consenting unto his death, and kept the raiment of them that slew him. And this is the very thing which he says is a sign and argument of their not believing him. For thus it is: when ^ iOvovs a man starts off from any sort of people ^, if he be one of the least and of those who are nothing worth, he doth not much vex those from whom he is departed. But if he be among the distinguished or very earnest partizans, or those who sympathise with them, he exceedingly grieves and vexes them beyond measure; in that he especially overthrows their system, in the judgment of the many. And besides this, there was something else in addition. What now might this be ? That Peter and the others were with Christ, and also saw signs and wonders ; but he having enjoyed none of these advantages, but being with Jews, all at once deserted, and became one of them. Which thing especially promoted our cause. For while they seemed to bear witness from mere favour, and a person might have said that in loving regret for their master, they testify these things : the special witness of the resurrection was of all lb. ix. 4, men this man, who heard a voice only. For this cause thou ^^^^' ' seest them waging passionate war with him, and practis- ing all for no other purpose than to slay him and raising seditions. The unbelievers then on this account listened to him with evil dispositions, but the believers, what was their motive? Because in^reaching to the Gentiles he was con- strained to preach Christianity purely. And if haply he were found [doing it] even in Judeea, he cared not. For write to the Jews, 3 j Peter indeed and they that were with him, inasmuch as Heb. they had to preach in Jerusalem, where men^s zeal was i great, of necessity bade them keep the Law : whereas this man was quite at liberty. The converts too from the Gen- tiles were more in number than the Jews, inasmuch as they were without ^. And this enfeebled the Law, and they had ' ! no longer so great reverence for it, although he preached ^ | all things purely. At least it is with respect to this i that they seem to shame him by numbers, saying. Thou Actsxxi. j seest, brother, how many ten thousands of Jews there are which are come together. On this account they hated him and turned away from him, because they have been in- lb. 21. formed, it ^m^, concerning thee, that thou teachest men to forsake the Law. [2.] Why then, not being a teacher of the Jews, doth he send an Epistle to them ? (And where abode those to whom he sent it ? As it seems to me, in Jerusalem and j Palestine.) How then doth he send them an Epistle ? | Just as he baptized, though to baptize was not his assigned \ duty. For (saith he) Iivas not sent to baptize: not however, i cor. i. that he was forbidden, but he doth it, as somewhat over ^^• and above his work. And how could he fail to write to these, for whom he Rom. ix. was willing even to become accursed? Accordingly he * said^. Know ye that our brother Timothy is set at liberty ; Infra ■ with whom, if he come shortly, I will see you, ''"*' ' , (For as yet he was not seized and imprisoned. Two years then he passed in prison at Rome. After this he was set free. Then having gone into the parts of Spain, he also perhaps saw the Jews. And then he returned to Rome, and then was slain by Nero. The Epistle to Timothy then was later' than this Epistle. For there he saith. For /2Tim.iv. ^ : am now ready to be offered, and there also he saith. In my j^^ jg, i first answer no man stood with me.) \ » The chosen people being- / The Ben. editor observes that it Father, and that-S. Chrys. here as in had been said that b Qe6s with the ar- other places argues that it is used of tide is used in Scripture only of the the Son. Honour to the Son our duty. Angels minister to us. 35 [4] ver. 13. But to which of the Angels said He at any time, HEB.i.i4. Sit thou on My right hand until I shall have made thine enemies thy footstool ? Behold^ again he encourages them, inasmuch as their enemies were to be worsted, and their enemies are the same also with Christ's. This again belongs to Sovereignty, to Equal Dignity, to Hono.ur and not weakness, that the Father should be angry for the things done to the Son. This belongs to His great Love, and honour towards the Son, as of a father towards a son. For He that is angry in His behalf how is He a stranger to Him ? Which very thing he saith also in the second Psalm, He that dwelleth in heaven shall laugh Ps.ii.4,5. them to scorn, and the Lord shall have them in derision. Then shall He speak unto them in His ivrath, and vex them in His sore displeasure. And again He Himself saith. Those g. Luke that would not that 1 should reign over them, bring hither ^^'^'^' beforeMe, and slay them. For that they are His own words, hear also what He saith in another place, Hoiv often would I ib. xiU. have gathered thy children together, and ye would not ! Be- ^^^ ^^• hold, your house is left desolate. And again. The kingdom s. Matt. shall be taken from you, and shall be given to a nation bring- '^^^' ^^' ing forth the fruits thereof. And again, He that falleth upon ib. 44. that stone shall be broken, but on ivhomsoever It shall fall. It will grind him to 'powder. And besides. He who is to be their Judge in that world, much more did He Himself repay them in this. So that the words Till I make thine enemies thy footstool are expressive of nothing but honour towards the Son. ver. 14. Are they not all ministering spirits, sent forth to minister for them who shall be heirs of salvation ? What marvel (saith he) if they minister to the Son, when they minister even to our salvation ? See how he lifts up their minds, and shews that the honour which God has for us is great, inasmuch as He has assigned to Angels who are above us this ministration on our behalf. As if one should say, for this purpose (saith he) He employs them ; this is the office of Angels, to minister to God for our salvation. This therefore is an angelical work, to do all for the salvation of the brethren : or rather it is the work of Christ Himself, for He indeed saves as Lord, but they as servants. And we d3 36 Angels wait on us, the Son took flesh for us. HoM.3. though servants are yet Angels' fellow-servants. Why gaze ye so earnestly on the Angels (saith he ) ? they are servants of the Son of God, and are sent many ways for our sakes, and minister to our salvation. And so they are partners in service with us. Consider ye how he ascribes no great difference to the kinds of creatures. And yet the space between angels and men is great ; nevertheless he brings them down near to us, all but saying. For us they labour, for our sake they run to and fro : on us, as one might say, they wait. This is their ministry, for our sake to be sent every way. (3) And of these examples as the Old [Testament] is full, so also is the New. For when Angels bring glad tidings to the shepherds, or to Mary, or to Joseph ; when they sit at the sepulchre, when they are sent to say to the dis- Acts i. ciples, Ye men of Galilee, why stand ye gazing up into heaven, when they release Peter out of the prison, when they discourse with Philip, consider how great the honour is ; when God sends His Angels for ministers as to friends, when to Cornelius [an Angel] appears, when [an Angel] lb. V. 20. brings forth all the apostles from the prison, and says. Go, stand and speak in the temple to the people the words of this life ; and to Paul himself also an Angel appears. Dost thou see that they minister to us on God's behalf, and that they minister to us in the greatest matters ? wherefore Paul 1 Cor. iii. saith. All things are yours, whether life or death, or the world, or things present, or things to come. Well then the Son also was sent, but not as a minister, nor as one discharging a task, but as a Son, Only-Begotten, and having the same will with the Father. Rather indeed. He was not sent: for He did not pass from place to place, but took on Him flesh : whereas these change their places, and leaving those in which they were before, come there- after to others in which they were not. And by this again he incidentally encourages them, saying. What fear ye ? to us Angels are ministering. [5.] And now having spoken concerning the Son, both what related to the EfTonomy, and to His power as Creator, and to His sovereignty, and having pointed out His co-equal dignity, and that as absolute Master He ruleth not men Danger greater in neglecting the Gospel than the Law. 37 only but also the powers above, he next gives them exhor- Heb.u.b . tation, having made out his argument, that we ought to give heed to the things which have been heard, ch. ii. 1. Wherefore we ought to give more earnest heed to the things lohich we have heard. Why more earnest ? Here he meant more earnest than to the Law: but he suppressed the actual expression of it, and yet makes it plain in the course of reasoning, not in the way of counsel, nor of exhortation. For so it was better. ver. 2, 3. For if the word spoken by Angels (saith he) ivas stedfast, and every transgression and disobedience received a just recompense of reward; how shall ive escape if we neglect so great salvation, which at the first began to be spoken to us by the Lord, and ivas confirmed unto us by them that heard Him ? Why ought we to give more earnest heed to the things which we have heard? were not those former things of God, as well as these? Either then he meaneth more earnest than [to] the Law, or very earnest; not making comparison, God forbid. For since, on account of the long space of time, they had a great opinion of the Old Covenant, but these things had been despised as yet new, he proves (more than his argument required) that we ought to give attention to these rather. How ? By saying in effect. Both these and those are of God, but not in a like manner. And this he shews us afterwards : but for the present he treats it somewhat superficially, but after- wards more clearly, saying; For if that first covenant ^«c? infra vUi. been faultless, and many other such things: for that which j* ,„ decayeth and waxeth old is ready to vanish away. But as yet he ventures not to say any such thing in the beginning of his discourse, nor until he shall have first occuj^ied and possessed his hearer by his fuller [arguments.] Why then ought we to give more earnest heed ? Lest at any time, saith he, ive should leak away — that is, lest at any time we should perish, lest we should fall off*. And here he points out the grievousness of this falling off*, in that it is a difficult thing for that which hath leaked out to return again, inasmuch as it hath happened through wilful negligence. And he took this form of speech from 38 Our greater peril. In ivhat senses ivas the word HoM. 3. the Proverbs. For, saith he, my son [take heed] lest thou 2wVx ^^^^ away, shewing both the easiness of the fall, and the grievousness of the ruin. That is, our disobedience is not without danger. And while by his mode of reasoning he points out that the chastisement is greater, yet again he leaves it in the form of a question, and not in his conclu- sion. For indeed this is to make one^s discourse inoffen- sive, when one does not in every case of one's own self infer the judgment, but leaves it in the power of the hearer to give his own sentence: and this would render them more open to conviction. And both the prophet Nathan doth it in the Old [Testament], and in Matthew Christ, S. Matt, saying. What will He do to the husbandmen of that vine- XXI. 40. y^j, J p g^ compelling them to give out their sentence them- selves : for this is the most complete victory. Next, when he had said, For if the word ivhich was spoken by Angels was stedfast — he did not add, much more that by Christ : but letting this pass, he said what is less. How shall we escape, if toe neglect so great salvation? And see how he makes the comparison. For if the word which was spoken by Angels, saith he. There, hy Angels, here, by the Lord — and there a word, but here, salvation. Then lest any man should say. Thy sayings, O Paul, are they Christ's ? he proves their credibility, both from his having heard it all of Him, and from its being now spoken by God ; since not merely a voice is wafted, as in the case of Moses, but signs are done, and facts bear witness. (4) [6.] But what is this. For if the word spoken by Angels was stedfast? For in the Epistle to the Galatians also he Gal. iu. saith to this effect. Being ordained by angels in the hand of Acts vii. tt Mediator. And again, Ye received a law by the disposition ^^' of Angels, and have not kept it. And in every place, he saith it was given by angels. Some indeed say that Moses is signified; but it is not reasonable. For here he says Angels in the plural : and the Angels too which here he speaks of, are those in Heaven. What then is it ? Either Exod. he means the Decalog;ue only (for there Moses spake, and God answered him), — or that angels were present, God dis- posing them in order, — or that he speaks tltus in regard of all things said and done in the old Covenant, as if Angels spoken by Angels. 39 had been partakers in them. But how is it said in another Heb.jj.S. place, The Laiv was given by Moses, and here by Angels ? s. John i. For it is said, And God came down in thick darkness^. ^^^^ For if the word spoken by angels was stedfast. What is xix. 16, was stedfast? True, as one may say; and faithful in its * proper season ; and all the things which had been spoken came to. pass. Either this is his meaning, or that they prevailed, and the threatenings were coming to be accom- plished. Or by the word he means injunctions. For apart from the Law^ Angels sent from God enjoined many things : for instance at Bochim, in the Judges, in [the history of] Judg. ii. SampsoUc For this is the cause why he said not '^the Law" ^* ^^' ^' but the word. And he seems to me haply rather to mean this, viz., those things which are committed to the manage- ment of angels. What shall we say then ? The angels who were entrusted with the charge of the nation were then present, and they themselves made the trumpets, and the Exod. other things, the fire, the thick darkness. And every transgression and disobedience, saith he. Not this one and that one, but every one. Nothing (saith he) remained unavenged, but received a just recompence of reward, i.e. punishment. Why now spake he thus ? Such is the manner of Paul, not to make much account of his phrases, but indifferently to put down words of evil sound, even in matters of good meaning. As also in another place he saith. Bringing into captivity every thought to the 2 Cor. x. obedience of Christ ^ And again he hath put the recompence ^' for punishment ^, as here he calleth punishment reward. ^ Rom. i. If it be a righteous thing, saith he, with God to recompense 2 xhess. tribulation to them that trouble you, and to you who are i- 6, 7. troubled rest. That is, justice was in no degree violated, but God went forth in its behalf, and caused the penalty to come round on them that had sinned, though not all their sins are made manifest, but only where the express ordinances were trangressed. How then shall we, saith he, escape if we neglect so great « This last clause seems unconnected words IVIiat shall we say, down to as it stands here. If there were MS. tJiick darkness. authority one should be glad to transfer ^See S. Chrys. on the passage, 2 Cor. it a few lines lower, after,The manage- x. 5 [p. 242 O.T.]. The expression ment of Angels : ra Sia rwv ayyiXicu fff/)^/t'«7^ was the "word of evil sound." oiKovoixr}B4uTa, or to place here the 40 The greatness of our salvation. Attested by God. HoM. 3. salvation! Hereby he signified, that that other salvation was no great thing. Well too did he add the word So great. For not from wars (saith he) will He now rescue us, nor bestow on us the earth and the good things that are in the earth, but it will be the dissolution of death, the destruction of the Devil, the kingdom of Heaven, everlasting life. For all these things he hath briefly expressed, by saying, if we neglect so great salvation. [7.] Then he subjoins what makes it all credible. Which at the first began to be spoken by the Lord : that is, had its beginning from the very fountain itself. It was not a man who brought it over ^ into the earth, nor any created power, but the Only-Begotten Himself. And was confirmed unto us by them that heard [Him^ . What is confirmed ? It was believed '^^ or, it came to pass. For (saith he) we have the earnest ^ ; that is, it hath not been extinguished, it hath not ceased, but it is strong and prevaileth. And the cause is, the Divine power works therein. It means they who heard from the Lord, them- selves confirmed us. This is a great thing and trustworthy : s. Luke which also Luke saith in the beginning of his Gospel, As they delivered unto us, which from the beginning were eye- witnesses and mhiisters of the Word. How then was it confirmed? what if those that heard were forgers ? saith some one. This objection then he over- throws, and shews that the grace was not human. If they had been forgers, God would not have borne witness to them; for he subjoined (ver. 4.) God also bearing witness with them. They indeed also bear witness, and God beareth witness too. How doth He bear witness? not by word or by voice (though this also would have been worthy of belief) : but how ? By signs, and wonders, and divers miracles. s Yit, ferried it over : Sie7rop0jU€U(rej/, dary order towards that loftier height* the word is specially applied to messages and moving those of the first order to between earth and Heaven, by Pseudo- come forth in the way of sympathy Dionys. Areop. de Celesti Hierarchia, and care for their inferiors." c. 15. 6. "The Angelsare called Winds, ^iiriaTf^vQ-f]. Dmiaeus suggested eVto-- to express their rapid power of making rdsQr), it was accredited, but there is things, how it reaches almost to all no MS. authority for the change, things without time; and thehkmotion ' S. Chrys. seems to have had in in the manner of those who ferry over, view 2 Cor. i. 2 1 , 22, where " confirm- from above downwards, and again ing" is connected .with "the earnest from the lower parts up the steep, of the Spirit." both drawing out the things of secon- i.2. Miraculous and ot he?' gifts various according to God' swill. 41 - (Well said he, divers miracles, declaring the abundance of HEB.ii.4. the gifts : which was not so in the former dispensation, neither so great signs and so various.) That is, we did not i believe them simply, but through signs and wonders : i wherefore we believe not them, but God Himself. ^ And bij portionings of the Holy Ghost, according to His oivn will. ' What then, if wizards also do signs, and the Jews said that He cast out devils through Beelzebub ? But they do not s. Luke such kind of signs : therefore said he divers miracles : for ^^* ^^' \ those others were not miracles, [or powers ^], but weakness ^ Suj/a^ets j and fancy, and things altogether vain. Wherefore he said, by portionings of the Holy Ghost according to His own will. [8.] Here he seems to me to intimate another thing (5) \ also. For it is likely there were not many there who had gifts, but that these had failed, upon their becoming rather slothful. In order then that herein also he might comfort > them, and not leave them utterly to fall, he referred all to i the will of God. He knows (he says) what is expedient, and for whom, and apportions His grace accordingly. Which kind of thing also he does in the Epistle to the Corinth- j ians, saying, God hath placed every one of us, as He willed. iCor.xii. i And again. The manifestation of the Spirit is given to every l^' - ! man to profit ivithal. i According to His will. He intimates that the gift is ] according to the will of the Father. But oftentimes on account of their unclean and slothful life many have not i received a gift, and sometimes also those whose life is good and pure have not received one. Why, I pray you ? Lest they might be made haughty, that they might not be puffed up, that they might not grow more negligent, that they might not be more excited. For if even without any gift, the mere consciousness of a pure life be sufficient to lift a man up, much more when the grace is added also. i Wherefore to the humble, to the simple, it was rather ] given, and especially to the simple : for it is said, in simpli- Acts ii. , city and gladness of heart. Yea, and hereby also he rather '^^' I urged them on, and gave them a spur, if they were growing negligent. Inasmuch as the humble man, and he who 42 Why ive should be content without higher gifts. HoM. 3. imagines no great things concerning himself, becomes more earnest when he has received a gift, in that he has obtained what is beyond his deserts, and thinks that he is not worthy thereof. But he who thinks he hath done anything very well, reckoning the matter to be his due, is even puffed up. Wherefore God dispenseth this for [men's] good : which one may see taking place also in the Church : for one man hath the word of teaching, another hath not power so much as to open his mouth. Let not this man (he says) be 1 Cor. grieved because of this. For to every man the manifesta- '"** tion of the Spirit is given to profit withal. For if a man that is an householder knoweth what he will entrust, and to whom, much more God, who is acquainted with the Hist.Sus. mind of v[\Qn,who knoweth all things or ever they come into being. One thing only is worthy to be grieved for, Sin: there is nothing else. Say not thou, Wherefore have I not riches? or. If I had, I would give to the poor. Thou knowest not, if thou hadst them, whether thou wouldest not be more covetous. For now indeed thou sayest these things, but being put to the trial thou wouldest be different. Since also when v/e have satisfied ourselves, we think that we are able to fast ; but when we have gone without a little space, other thoughts come into us. Again, when we are out of the way of drunkenness we think ourselves able to master our appetite, but no longer so, when we are caught by it. Say not thou. Wherefore had I not the gift of teaching ? or. If I had had it, I should have edified innumerable souls. Thou knowest not, if thou hadst it, whether it would not be to thy condemnation, — whether envy, whether indolence would not have disposed thee to hide thy talent. Well then, thou art now free from all these, and though thou S. Luke give not the portion of meat, thou art not called to account : xii. 42. 1^^^ then, thou wouldest have been responsible for souls innumerable. [9.] And besides, neither now art thou without God's gift. Shew thou in that which is little, what manner of person thou wouldst nave been, if thou hadst had the lb. xvi. other. For if (saith he) ye prove not faithful in that lohich is little, how shall atiy one give you that which is great ? We should use well whatever gifts we have. 43 Give such proof as did the widow ; she had two farthings ^, HEB.ii.4. and she cast in all^ whatsoever she was possessed of. o^oxovs Dost thou seek riches ? shew that thou art above minding the few things, that I may trust thee also concerning the many things. But if thou art not even above these, much less wilt thou be above the other. Again, in speech, shew that thou canst use as may be requisite exhortation and counsel. Thou hast not external eloquence, thou hast not store of thoughts : but neverthe- less these common things thou knowest. Thou hast a child, thou hast a neighbour, thou hast a friend, thou hast a brother, thou hast kinsmen. And though publickly before the Church, thou art not able to draw out a long discourse, to these thou canst give exhortation in private. Here, there is no need of rhetoric, nor of discourses long drawn out : shew thou in these, that if thou hadst skill of speech, thou wouldest not have neglected it. But if in the small matter thou art not in earnest, how shall I trust thee concerning the great ? For, to prove that this is what every man can do, hear what Paul saith, how even to lay people he hath committed this charge; Edify, saith he, each one of you the other, as i Thess. also ye do. And, Comfort ye one another with these words. ^' V* God knoweth how He should distribute to every man. Art thou better than Moses ? hear how he shrinks from the hardship. Am I, saith he, able to bear them ? for Thou Num. xi. saidst to me, Take them up, as a nursing -father would take ^^' up the sucking -child. What then did God ? He took of his spirit and gave unto the others, shewing that neither when he bare them was the gift his own, but of the Spirit. If thou hadst had the gift, thou wouldst perchance ^ have been lifted up, perchance wouldst thou have been turned out of the way. Thou knowest not thyself as God knoweth thee. Let us not say, To what end is that? on what account is this ? When God dispenseth, let us not call Him to account : for this [is] of the uttermost impiety and folly. We are slaves, and slaves far apart from our Master, know- ing not even the things which are before us. [10.] Let us not then busy ourselves about the counsel ^ TtoKXaKis see Mr. Field's note. 44 Charity the highest gift ; HoM. 3. of God, but whatsoever He hath given, this let us guard, though it be small, though the very last, and we shall be altogether approved. Or rather, none of the gifts of God is small : art thou grieved because thou hast not the gift of teaching ? Then tell me, whether, thinkest thou, is the greater, to have the gift of teaching, or the gift of driving away diseases ? doubtless this latter. But what? tell me; doth it not seem to thee a greater thing to give eyes to the blind than even to drive away diseases ? But what ? tell me; doth it not seem to thee a greater thing to raise the dead than to give eyes to the blind ? What again, tell me ; doth it not seem to thee a greater thing to effect this by shadows and napkins, than to do it by a word ? Tell me then, which wouldst thou? raise the dead with, shadows and napkins, or have the gift of teaching ? Doubtless thou wilt say the former, to raise the dead with shadows and napkins. (6) If then I should shew to thee, that there is another gift far greater than this, and that thou dost not receive it when it is in thy power to receive it, art not thou justly deprived of those others ? Yea and this gift not one or two, but all may have. I know that ye open wide your mouths and are amazed, at being to hear that it is in your power to have a greater gift than raising the dead, and giving eyes to the blind, doing the same things which were done in the time of the Apostles. And haply it appears to you even past belief. What then is this gift ? charity. Nay, believe me ; for the word is not mine, but Christ's, speaking by Paul. For 1 Cor. what saith he ? Covet earnestly the best gifts : and yet shew ^^' ^^' I unto you a more excellent ivay. What is this, yet more excellent ? What he meaneth is of this kind. Some Corin- thians were inclined to have high thoughts about their gifts, and they who had tongues, the least gift, were puffed up against the rest. He saith therefore. Do ye by all means desire gifts ? I shew unto you a way of gifts not merely Ib.xiii. 1, excelling but far more excellent. Then he saith. Though I ^' speak with the tongues q)^ Angels, and have not charity, I am nothing. And though I have faith so as to remove moun- tains, and have not charity, I am nothing. attainable by all, 45 Hast thou seen the gift? Covet earnestly this gift. This HEB.ii.4. is greater than raising the dead. This is far better than all the rest together. And that it is so, hear what Christ Himself saith, discoursing with His disciples. Hereby shall S. John all men knoiv that ye are My disciples. And shewing in what ^^"* respect. He mentioned not the miracles, but what ? If ye have lone one ivith another. And again He saith to the Father, Hereby shall they know that Thou hast sent Me, ifih. xvH. they be one. And He said Himself to His disciples, A new ?,^* ... commandment I give to you, that ye love one another. Such 34. an one therefore is more venerable and glorious than those who raise the dead ; with reason. For that indeed is wholly of God^s grace, but this, of thine own earnestness also. This is of one who is a Christian indeed : this shews the disciple of Christ, the crucified, the man that hath nothing common with earth. Without this, not even martyrdom can be of any avail. And as a proof, see this plainly. The blessed Paul took two of the topmost virtues, or rather three ; namely those which consist in miracles, those in knowledge, those in life. And without this those, he said, are nothing. And how these are nothing, I will say. Though I give my goods to l Cor. feed the poor, saith he, and have not charity, I am nothing. ^"^* ^' For it is possible not to be charitable even when one feeds the poor and exhausts one's means. [11.] And indeed these things have been sufficiently de- clared by us, in the place concerning Charity ^ : and thither we refer the readers. Meanwhile, as I was saying, let us zealously seek the Gift, let us love one another : and we shall need nothing else for the perfect acquisition of virtue, but all will be easy to us without violent labours and we shall do all perfectly with much diligence. 'But see, even now,' it is said, 'we love one another. For one man hath two friends, and another three.' But this is not to love for God's sake, but for the sake of being be- loved. But to love for God's sake hath not this as its principle of Love; but such an one will be disposed towards all men as towards brethren ; loving those that are of the same faith as being genuine brothers ; Heretics and Hea- 1 His Homily on 1 Cor. xiii. 3. [pp. 444 sqq. O.T.] is referred to. 46 By loving those not Christians we imitate God. HoM. 3. then and Jews, brothers indeed by nature, but vile and unprofitable, pitying and wearing himself out for them and shedding tears. Herein we shall be like unto God if we love all men, even our enemies ; not, if we work miracles. For even God we regard with admiration when He worketh wonders, yet much more, when He sheweth love towards man, when He is long-suffering. If then even in God that Love is worthy of much admiration, much more in men is it evident that this rendereth us admirable. This then let us zealously seek after: and though we may be not able to drive away a fever, we shall be no way inferior to Paul and Peter and those who have raised in- numerable dead. But without this Love, though we should work greater miracles even than the Apostles themselves, though we should expose ourselves for the faith to dangers innumerable : there will be to us no profit from any. And these things not I say, but he, the very nursling of Charity, knoweth these things. To him then let us be obedient; for thus we shall be able to attain to the good things pro- mised, of which may we all be made partakers, by the grace and mercy of our Lord Jesus Christ, with whom to the Father and also to the Holy Ghost, be the glory, now and for ever and world without end. Amen. HOMILY ly. Heb. ii. 5 — 7. For unto Angels He hath not put in subjection the world to come, whereof we speak. But one in a certain place tes- tified, saying, What is man that Thou art mindful of him, or the S071 of man that Thou visitest him ? Thou hast made him a little lower than the Angels. [1.] I COULD have wished to know for certain whether any of you hear with suitable attention the things that are said, whether we are not casting the seeds by the way-side : for in that case I should have made my instructions with more cheerfulness. For we shall speak, though no one hear, for the fear which is laid on us by our Saviour. For, saith He, testify thou to this people ; even if they hear not, thou see Ezek. shalt thyself be guiltless. If however I had been persuaded "^' ^^' of your earnestness, I should have spoken not for fear only, but should have done it with pleasure also. For now in- deed, even if no man hear, even if my work, so long as I fulfil my own part, brings no danger, still the trouble [I take] is not attended with pleasure. For what profit is it, when though I be not myself open to blame, no one is benefited? If on the other hand any were likely to be attentive, the advantage we shall receive, will not be so much from avoiding punishment ourselves as from your progress. How then shall I know this ? Having taken notice of some of you, those [I mean] who are not very attentive, I shall question them privately, when I meet them. And if I find that they retain any of the things that have been spoken (I say not all, for this would not be very easy for 48 Will examine Ms hearers as to what he has told thera, HoM. 4. you), but even if [they retain] a few things out of many, it is plain I should have no further doubts about the rest. And indeed we ought, without giving notice beforehand, to have attacked you when off your guard. However it will be pretty well, even if in this way I should be able to attain my purpose. Nay rather, even as it is, I can attack you when you are off your guard. For that I shall question you, I have forewarned you ; but when I shall question you I do not as yet make evident. For perhaps it may be to-day ; perhaps to-morrow, perhaps after twenty or thirty days, perhaps after fewer, perhaps after more. Thus has God also made uncertain the day of our death. Nor hath He allowed it to be clear to us, whether it shall befal us to-day, or to-morrow, or after a whole year, or after many years ; that through the uncertainty of the expectation we may through all time keep ourselves firm in virtue. And that we shall indeed depart. He hath said, — but when, He hath not yet said. Thus too I have said that I shall question you, but I have not added when, wishing you always to be thoughtful. And let no man say, I heard these things four or five weeks ago, or more, and I cannot retain them. For I wish the hearer to retain them in such a way as to have his recollection perpetual and not apt to fade, nor yet that he should reject with scorn what is spoken. For I wish you to retain them, not, in order to tell them to me, but to have profit yourselves ; and this is that which is to me the matter of serious interest. Let no one then say this. [2.] However, I must now begin with what follows in the epistle. What then is set before us to speak on to-day ? For not to angels, saith he, did He put in subjection the ^ r^v fi^^- woi'ld to come^, to hereof we speak. Is he then discoursing concerning some other world ? no ; but concerning this. For, on this account he added whereof we speak, that he might not allow the mind to wander away in search of some other. In what sense then does he call it the wo7'ld to Rom. V. come ? Exactly as he also says in another place. Who is ^toO €A the figure of him thatlvas to be ^ when he is speaking about Aoj/Tos Adam and Christ in the Epistle to the Romans; calling Christ according to the flesh Him that was to be in respect All things subjected to man, i. e. to Christ. 49 of the times of Adam (for [then] He was to be). So now Heb.jj.s. also, since he had said, hut when He hringeth in the First- begotten into the world: that thou mightest not suppose that he is speaking of another world, it is made certain from many other considerations and from the very fact itself of his saying to come* For the world was to be, but the Son of God ever was. This world then which was about to exist, He put in subjection not to Angels but to Christ. For that this is said with reference to the Son (he means) is evident : for surely no one would assert the other alter- native, that it was said in reference to Angels. Then he brings forward another testimony also and says, but one in a certain place testified, saying. Wherefore did he not mention the name of the prophet, but concealed it ? Yea, and in other testimonies also he doth this : as when he saith, but when He bringeth in again the First-Begotten supra i. 6, into the world, He saith, And let all the angels of God wor- ' ' ship Him. And again, I will be to Him a Father, And of the Angels He saith. Who maketh His angels spirits. And, Thou, Lord, in the beginning hast laid the foundations of the earth : — so also here he saith, but one in a certain place testified saying. And this very thing (I conceive) is the act of one that conceals himself, and shews that they were well acquainted with the Scriptures ; his not setting down [I mean] the name of him who uttered the testimony, but introducing it as familiar and obvious. What is man that Thou art mindful of him, or the son of man that Thou visitest him ? Thou madest him a little loiver than the angels: Thou crownedst him with glory and honour^, (ver. 8.) Thou hast put all things in subjection under his feet. Now although these things were spoken of human nature (2) generally, they would nevertheless apply more properly to Christ according to the flesh. For this. Thou hast put all things in subjection under his feet, belongs to Him rather than to us. For the Son of God visited us when we were nothing : and after having assumed what was derived from us ^ and united it to Himself, He became higher than all. JjJ' r]u2iymg,if we holdfast the confidence and the glorying of the hope firm unto the end, « iroi-fiffas. Referring to what is implied in ver. 2. that Moses was faithful to Him that made liim. Human affections attributed to God. 69 implying that they had even made a beginning ; but that HEB.iii.5. there is need of the end ; and [it is necessary for them] not simply to stand, but to have their hope firm in full as- surance of faith f without being shaken from their position by their trials. [5.] And be not thou astonished, that the [words] Him- supra selfheing tempted are spoken more after the manner of men. ^^' i^- For if of the Father, who was not made flesh, the Scripture saith. The Lord looked down from heaven, and beheld all the Ps. xiv. sons of men, that is, accurately acquainted Himself with all ^' things ; and again, / icill go down, and see whether they do Gen. altogether according to the cry of them ; and again, God ^^^^ ' cannot endure the evil ways of men, [saith] the divine Scrip- 5 (?) ture, shewing forth the greatness of His wrath : much more of Christ, who even suffered in the flesh, are these things said. For inasmuch as many men consider experience more to be relied on than any thing else for [the attainment of] knowledge, he wishes to point out that He that has suffered knows what human nature suffers. fVhence ^ holy brethren (he saith whence instead of " for ' <^0ej/ this oxm^q''), partakers of an heavenly calling — (seek nothing here, if ye have been called yonder — yonder is the reward, yonder the recompence. What then?) Consider the Apostle and High Priest of our coyifession, Christ Jesus, who ivas faithful to Hljn that made Him, as also Moses [was faithful] in all His house. (What is who ivas faithful to Him that made Him? it is, well disposed towards Him, protecting what belongs to Him, not allowing them to be lightly carried away, as also Moses in all His house) that is, know who your High Priest is, and how great He is, and ye will need no other consolation nor encouragement. Now he calls Him Apostle, on account of His having been sent, and high priest of our confession, that is of the Faith. This One also was entrusted with a people, as the other with the com- mand and guardianship of a people, but a greater one, and upon higher grounds. For a testimony of those things which shall be spoken. What meanest thou? Doth God receive the witness of man ? Yes, certainly. For if He call to witness heaven and earth and hills (saying by the prophet. Hear, O heaven, and Is. i. 2. 70 The blessings promised us are objects of Hope, HoM. 5. give ear, O earth, for the Lord hath spoken, and Hear ye Mic. VI. ravines ^, foundations of the earth, for the Lord hath a con- troversy with His people) much more men ; that is, that they may be witnesses, when [these] themselves [the Jews] are shameless. ver. 6. But Christ as a Son. The one takes care of the property of another, but this One of His own. And the glorying of the hope. Well said he of the hope. For since the good things were all in hope, and yet we ought so to hold it fast, as even now to glory as for things which had already come to pass : for this cause he says, the glorying of the hope. Rom.^'iii. And adds, hold it, firm unto the end. For by hope ive ^.^' have been saved ; if therefore we have been saved by hope, lb. 25. and «re waiting with patience, let us not be grieved at the things that are present, nor seek already those that have been promised afterwards ; For (saith he) hope which is seen is not hope. For since the good things are great, we can- not receive them here in this transitory life. With what ob- ject then did He even tell us of them beforehand, when He was not about to give them here ? In order that by the promise He might refresh our souls, that by the engage- ment He might strengthen our zeal, that He might anoint [preparing us for our contests] and stir up our mind. For this cause then all these things were done. (4) [6.] Let us not then be disturbed, let no man be dis- turbed, when he seeth the wicked prospering. The recom- pence is not here, either of wickedness or of virtue ; and if in any instance there be [here arecompence] of wickedness or of virtue, yet is it not according to desert, but merely as it were a taste of the judgment, that they who believe not the resurrection may yet even by things that hapj)en here be brought to their senses. When then we see a wicked man abounding in wealth, let us not be cast down ; when we see a good man in affliction, let us not be troubled. For yonder are the crowns, yonder the punishments. f S. Chrys. had mention^ hills " Hear ye hills" (^ovuol) according to ()3oui/ol) as called to witness by God: the Alexandrine MSS. of the LXX. or in the verse preceding- this (Micah vi. " ye mountains" (uprj according to the 1) occur the words, " let the hills hear Vatican) " the judgment of the Lord, Thy voice"; and this verse itself runs and ye ravines," &c. In what sense we are rewarded and punished here. 71 Yea and in another point of view, it is not possible either HEB.iii.6 . that a bad man should be altogether bad, but he may have some good things also : nor again that a good man should be altogether good, but he may also have some sins. When therefore the wicked man prospers, know thou that it is for evil on his own head. For, for this cause does he receive his recompence in this life, that having here received the reward of those few good things, he may hereafter be entirely punished yonder. And happy is he most of all who is punished here, that having put away all his sins, he may depart approved, and pure, and without having to be called to account. And this is what Paul teacheth us when he says, For this cause many \_are'\ weak and sickly among you, i Cor. xi. a7id a good many sleep. And again, / have delivered such ^' ^ an one to Satan, And the prophet saith, for she hath re- Is. xl. 2. ceived of the Lord's hand her sins double ; and again David, Behold mine anemies that they are multiplied above the Ps. xxv. hairs of my head^, and [ivith] an unjust hatred have they ^^' hated me : and forgive Thou all my sins. And again an- u,. ig. other: Lord, our God, give peace unto us; for Thou hast is. xxvL rendered all things to us again. '^• These however are [the words] of one shewing that good men receive here the punishments due for their sins. But where are the wicked [mentioned] who receive their good things here, and there are utterly punished ? Hear Abraham saying to the rich man. Thou didst receive good things, and s. Luke Lazarus evil things. What sort of good things ? For in ^^^' ^' this place by saying thou receivedst ^, and not thou " hadst ^ oTreAa- given V^ he shews that it was according to what was due to f JJ^^^gy him that each was treated, and that the one was in pros- perity, and the other in adversity. And he saith. Therefore he is comforted here (for thou seest him pure from sins) and thou art tormented. Let us not then be perplexed when we see sinners well off here ; but when we ourselves are afflicted, let us rejoice. For this very thing is paying off the penalty ^ of sins. ^ ewTtrrtj [7.] Let us not then seek relaxation: for Christ promised tribulation to His own disciples : and Paul saith. All who 2 Tim. ^ Hi. 12. g The words " above the hau's of my head" are part of another Psalm, xl. 12, or Ixix. 4. 72 Trials to be borne nobly but not provoked. HoM.5. will live godly in Christ Jesus, shall suffer persecution. No 1 ffKa^i. noble-spirited wrestler, when in the lists \ seeks for baths, and a table full of victuals and wine. This is not the con- duct of a wrestler but of an effeminate sluggard. For the wrestler contendeth with dust, with oil, with the heat of the sun's ray, with much sweat, with pressure and constraint. This is the season for the contest and for fighting, there- fore also for being wounded, and for being made bloody^ and for being in pain. Hear what the blessed Paul saith, 1 Cor. ix. So fight /, not as one that beateth the air. Let us consider that our whole life is engaged in combats, and then we shall at no time seek rest, at no time shall we feel it strange when we are afflicted : no more than a boxer feels it strange, when he is engaged in combat. Another season is the season for repose. It is by tribulation we must be made perfect. And even if there is not any persecution, nor tribulation, yet are there other afflictions which befal us every day. And if we do not endure these, we should scarcely endure lb. X. 13. those [other]. There hath no temptation taken you, it is said, but such as is common to man. Let us then pray in- f deed to God that we may not come into temptation ; but What if ^Ye have come into it, let us bear it nobly. For that indeed is the part of prudent men, not to throw themselves upon dangers, but this latter of men of noble spirit and true philosophers. Let us not then lightly cast ourselves upon rashness [dangers], for that is rashness; ngr yet if led into them, and called by circumstances, let us give in, for that is what CO- cowardice. But if indeed the Gospel^ call us, let us not wardjce 2 K-itpvyfia decline the trial ; but in a simple case, when there is no reason, nor need, nor necessity which calls us in connection what dis- with religion, let us not run to [trials] . For this is mere P^^y display, and useless ambitiousness. But should any of those things which are injurious to religion occur, then even if it be necessary to endure ten thousand deaths, let us in no respect decline the trial. Challenge not trials, when thou findest the things that concern religion succeed as thou desirest. Why di*awest thou needless dangers upon thyself which bring no advantage? These things I say, because I wish you to observe the Christian soldier ready and watchfaL 73 laws of Christ who commands us to pray that we enter not HEB.iii.6. into temptation, and commands us to take up the cross and ^' ^^^' follow Him. For these things are not opposed to oneib. xvi.* another, nay on the contrary they are exceedingly in har- ^^* mony. Do thou be so prepared as is a valiant soldier, be continually in thine armour, sober, watchful, ever expecting the enemy : do not howxver breed wars, for this is not [the act] of a soldier ])ut of a mover of sedition. But if on the other hand the trumpet of religion call thee, go forth im- mediately, and make no account of thy life, and enter with great zeal into the contests, break thou the phalanx of the adversaries, bruise the face of the Devil, set up thy trophy. If how^ever religion be in no wdse suffering, and no one laying waste our doctrines (those I mean which relate to the soul), nor compel us to do anything displeasing to God, do not thou interfere needlessly. The life of the Christian must be full of bloodsheddings ; I say not in shedding that of others, but in being prepared to shed his own. Let us then pour out our own blood, when it is done for the sake of Christ, with as great readiness of mind, as one would pour out water (for the blood which circulates around the body is w^ater), and let us put off our flesh with as much good temper, as one even would a gar- ment. And this shall we do, if we be not bound to riches, if not to houses, if not to' affections, if we be detached from all things. For if they who live this life of [earthly] soldiers bid farew^ell to all things, and whithersoever war calls them" there present themselves, and make journeys, and endure all things with ready mind; much more ought we, the soldiers of Christ, so to have prepared ourselves, and to set ourselves firm against the w^ar of the passions. [8.] There is no persecution now, and God grant that one may never arise : nevertheless another war there is, that of -the desire of money, of envy, of the passions. Paul describing this war, saith. We wrestle not against flesh and Eph. vi. blood. This war is ever at hand. For this cause he wishes i^. us to stand ever armed. For in that he does wish us to stand ever armed, he says, Stand, having girded yourselves ib. 14. about. Which itself also belongs to the time present, and expresses that we ought ever to be armed. For great is the 74 Our armour : the girt loins : the breast plate^ and helmet. HoM.5. war through the tongue, great that through the eyes ; this then we must keep down — great [too] is that of the lusts. For this cause he begins at that point to arm the soldier Eph. \\. of Christ : for stand, saith he, having your loins girt about, and he added ivith truth. Why ivith truth ? Because lust Ps. is a mockery and a lie : wherefore the prophet saith. My xxxviii. loins are filled with mockings. The thing is not pleasure, but a shadow of pleasure. Having your loins, saith he, girt about ivith truth; that is, with true pleasure, with tem- perance, with orderly behaviour. For this cause he gives this advice, knowing the unreasonableness of sin, and wish- Ecclus. i. ing that all our members should be hedged round ; for unjust ^^' anger, it is said, shall not be guiltless. Moreover he wishes us to have around us a breastplate and a buckler. For wrath is a wild beast which easily springs forth, and we shall have need of walls and fences innumerable, to overcome, and to restrain it. And for this cause God has built this part [of our body] with bones, as with a kind of stones, more than any other part, placing them as a support around it, so that wrath might not at any time, having broken or cut through, easily injure the whole man. For it is a fire (it is said) and a great tempest, and no other part of the body could endure this violence. And the sons of the physicians too say that for this cause the lungs have been spread under the heart, so that the heart being itself [put] into something soft and tender, by beating as it were into a sort of sponge, may continually be rested, and not [by striking] against what is resisting and hard, [I mean] the sternum, receive hurt through the violence of its beatings. We have need therefore of a strong breast- plate, so as to keep this wild beast alway quiet. We have need also of an helmet ; for since the reasoning faculty is there, and from this it is possible for us either to be saved, when what is right is done, or it is possible for Eph. vi. us to be ruined — for this cause he says, the helmet of salva- 1^- tion. For the brain is indeed by nature soft and tender ; and for this cause it is itself also covered above with the scull, as with a kind of^hell. And it is to us the cause of all things both good and evil, according as it determine what is fitting, or what is not so. Yea and our feet too and our Armour needed for hands and feet, 75 hands need armour, not these hands, nor these feet, but as HEB.iii.6. before those of the soul — the former by being employed about what is right, the latter, that they may walk where it behoves [them] . Thus then let us thoroughly arm our- selves, and we shall be able to overcome our enemies, and to wreathe ourselves with the crown in Christ Jesus our Lord, with whom to the Father and also to the Holy Ghost be glory, might, honour, now and for ever and world with- out end. Amen. HOMILY VL Heb. iii. 7 — 11. Wherefore, as the Holy Ghost saith, To-day if ye will hear His voice, harden 7iot your hearts, as in the provocation 171 the day of temptation in the ivilderness, when your fathers tempted Me, proved Me, and saw My works forty years. Wherefore I was grieved with that generation, and said. They do alway err in their heart, and they have ^ as not known My ways. So^ I sware in My wrath. If they shall enter into My rest. (1) [1.] Paul, having treated of hope, and having said that supra jf^ ^^g jjig Jiouse, if IV e hold fast the confidence and the rejoici7ig of the hope firm unto the end ; next shews that we ought to look forward with firmness, and this he proves from the Scriptures. But do you be attentive, because he has expressed this in a manner somewhat difficult and not readily to be comprehended. And therefore we must first make our own statements, and after we have briefly made you acquainted with the whole argument, then direct our discourse to the actual words of the Epistle. For you will no longer have need of us, if you have once understood the scope of the Apostle. His discourse was concerning Hope, and that it behoves us to hope for the things to come, and that for those who have toiled and suffered here there will assuredly be some reward and fruit and refreshment. This then he shews from the prophet ; andnvhat saith he ? Wherefore as the Holy Ghost saith, To-day if ye ivill hear His voice, harden not your hearts, as in the provocation, in the day of temp- The three Rests : The Isy^aelites refusing to enter Canaan. 77 tation in the wilderness : when your fathers tempted Me, HEB.iii.7. proved Me, and saw My works forty years. Wherefore I was grieved with that generation, and said, they do alway err in their heart, and they have not known My ways. So^ ^n& I sware in My wrath. If they shall enter into My rest. He says that they are three rests : one, that of the Sab- bath, in which God rested from His works ; the second, that of Palestine, into which when the Jews had entered they would be at rest from that their great affliction and labom^s ; the third, that which is Rest indeed, the kingdom of Heaven ; which those who obtain, do indeed rest from their labom's and troubles. Of these three then he makes mention in this place. And with what object did he mention the three, when he is treating of the one only ? That he might shew that the prophet is speaking concerning this one. For he was not speaking (saith he) concerning the first. For how could he be speaking of what had taken place long before ? Nor yet again concerning the second, that in Palestine. For how could he ? for he says. They shall not enter into My rest. It remains therefore that it be this third. [2.] But it is necessary also to lay before you the his- tory, to make the argument more clear. For when after they had come forth out of Egypt, and had accomplished a - long journey, and had received proofs innumerable of the power of God, both in Egypt, and in the Red Sea, and in cf. Acts the wilderness, they determined to send spies thoroughly to ^"' ^^' search out the nature of the land ; and these went and re- turned back, admiring indeed the country, and saying that it abounded in excellent fruits, yet that nevertheless it was a country of strong and invincible men : and the ungrate- ful and senseless Jews, when they ought to have called to mind the former mercies of God, and how when they were hemmed in in the midst of so many Egyptian armies. He rescued them from their perils, and made them masters of their enemies' spoils ; and in the wilderness clave the rock, and bestowed on them that abundance of waters, and gave them the manna, and the other wonderful things which He had wrought; [when they ought, I say, to have remembered this,] and to have trusted in God, they considered none of xiv. 3. 78 The Kingdom of Heaven is the Rest implied. The Warning is for us, HoM. 6. these things, but being struck with terror, just as if nothing had taken place, they said, we wish to go back again into cf. Num. Egypt, /or God hath brought us out hither (it is said) to slay us, ivith our children and wives. God therefore being angry that they had so quickly cast off the memory of all that had been done, sware that that generation, which had said these things, should not enter into the Rest ; and they all perished in the wilderness. When David then (he means) speaking at a later period, and after these events, after that generation of men, said. To-day, if ye ivill hear His voice, harden not your hearts, that ye may not suffer the same things which your forefathers did, and be deprived of the Rest ; he evidently [said this] on the supposition of there being some [future] rest. For if they had received their Rest (he says) why does He again say to them. To-day if ye will hear His voice harden not your hearts, as your fathers did ? What other rest then is there, except the kingdom of Heaven, of which the Sabbath was an image and type ? [3.] Next having set down the whole testimony (and this is. To-day if ye will hear His voice, harden not your hearts, as in the provocation in the day of temptation in the ivilder- ness, when your fathers tempted Me, proved Me, and saw My works forty years. Wherefore I was grieved with that generation, and said. They do ahvay err in their heart, and they have not known My ways. So I sware in My ivrath. If they shall enter into My rest, he then adds : ver. 12. Take heed, brethren, lest there be in any of you an evil heart of unbelief in departing from the Living God. For from hardness unbelief ariseth : and as in bodies, the parts that have become callous and hard do not yield to the hands of the physicians, so also souls that are hardened yield not to the word of God. For it is probable besides that some even disbelieved as though the things which had been done were not true. On this account he says, Take heed lest there be in any of you an evil heart of unbelief in departing from the Living God. For since the argument from things future is not so persuasive as that from the past, he reminds them of the history, in which they had wanted faith.. For if your fathers (saith he) because they did not hope as they ought Sin is the parent of unbelief. 79 to have hoped, suffered these things, much more will you HE.iii.i5. [suffer]. Since to themselves also is this word addressed : for. To-day (saitli he) is " ever," so long as the world lasts. [4.] ver. 13. Wherefore exhort ye one another daily, while it is called to-day. That is, edify one another, raise yourselves up : lest the same things should befal you. Lest any one of you be hardened by the deceitfulness of sin. Seest (2) thou that sin produces unbelief ? for just as unbelief is the parent of an evil life, so also a soul, ivhen it is come into a Prov. dei^th of evils, becometh contemptuous ^, and having become f^"^" ^* contemptuous it endures not even to believe, in order there- )f the sacerdotal tribe, nor a priest on earth. How then was He a Priest? some one may say. And just as in the Epistle to the Romans, having taken What Christ has in common ivith their High Priests, 101 up an argument of which they were not easily persuaded, Heb.v.4. that Faith effects that which the labour of the Law had not strength for, nor the sweat and toil of [a man^s] course of life, he betook himself to the Patriarch and referred the whole [question] to that time : so now in this place also he opens out the other path of the Priesthood, shewing its superiority from the things which happened before. And just as, in [the matter of] punishment, he brings before them not Hell alone, but also what happened in the case of their fathers ^, so now here also, he first establishes this \^^V- "»• . . .7 &c. position from things present. For it were right indeed that earthly things should be proved from heavenly, but when the hearers are weak, the opposite course is taken. [2.] Up to a certain point he lays down first the things which are common [to Christ and their High Priests], and then shews that He is superior. For comparative ^ ^ ^ f "t^ excellence arises thus, when in some respects there is *^^"^'" community, in others superiority ; if not, it is no longer comparative. For every High Priest taken from among men, this is common to Christ, is ordained for men in things pertaining to Godj and this also, that he may offer both gifts and sacri- fices for the people, and this too, [yet] not entirely: what follows however is no longer so : who can have compassion on the ignorant, and on them that are out of the way, from this point forward is the superiority, inasmuch as himself also is encompassed with infirmity ; and on account of this [infirmity^ he ought as for the people, so also for hhnself, to offer for sins. Then also [there are] other points : He is made [Priest] (he says) by Another and does not of Himself intrude into [the office]. This too is common (ver. 4) And no man taketh this honour to himself, but on being called of God as was Aaron, Here again he deals gently with ^ them in another point, ^eepavei- [saying] that He was sent from God : which Christ was " wont to say throughout in discoursing with the Jews. He g. john that sent Me is greater than I, and, / came not of Myself, xii. 49 ; He appears to me in these words also to hint at the yni 42.' priests of the Jews, as being no longer priests, in that they 102 Christ's appointment, tears, love. HoM. 8. were intruders and corrupted the law of the priesthood ; (ver. 5) So Christ also glorified not Himself to be made an High Priest, On what occasion then was He appointed (saith one) ? for Aaron's appointment was many times shewn as in the [matter of the] Rod, and when the fire came down and destroyed those who wished to intrude into the priesthood. But in this instance, on the contrary, they [the Jewish Priests] not only suffered nothing, but even are in high esteem. Whence then [is His appointment shewn] ? He shews it from the prophecy. He has nothing [to allege] that is cognizable by sense, nothing visible. For this cause he affirms it from prophecy, from things future ; But He that said unto Him Thou art My Son, to-day have I begotten Thee. What has this [appointment] to do with [His being] the Son ? Yea (saith he) it is a preparation for His being appointed by God. (ver. 6) As He saith also in another place, Thou art a Priest for ever after the order of Melchisedech. Unto whom now was this spoken ? Who is after the order of Melchisedech ? No other [than He] . For they all were under the Law, they all kept sabbaths, they all were cir- cumcised; one could not point out any other [than Him]. [3.] ver. 7, 8. Who in the days of His flesh, when He had offered up prayers and supplications with strong crying and tears, to Him that was able to save Him from death, and was heard in that He feared ; though He were a Son, yet learned He obedience by the things which He suffered, Seest thou that [he doth] nothing else than set forth His anxious care [for us] and the exceeding greatness of His love ? For what means the [expression] with strong cry- itig ? The Gospel no where saith th,is, nor that He wept when He prayed, nor yet that He uttered any cry. Seest thou that it was* a condescension ? For it was not in the Apostle [merely] to say that He prayed, but also ivith strong crying. And having been heard (saith he) in that He feared; although He were a S^n, He learned obedience from the things which He suffered, (ver. 9, 10) And being made per- feet He became the Author of eternal salvation to all them Explanation of His Praying, being heard, learning. 103 that obey Him : called of God a High Priest after the order Heb.v.8. of Melchisedech. ' Be it that [He entreated] with crying, why also strong [crying^ and tears ? Having offered (he saith) and having been heard in that He feared. What sayest thou ? let the Heretics ^ be ashamed. The Sox of God was heard in that He feared. And what more could any man say concerning the prophets ? And what sort of sequence is it to say, He ivas heard i7i that He feared, though He ivere Son, yet learned He obedi- ence from the things tvhich He suffered? Would any man say these things concerning God ? why, who was ever so mad ? and who, even if he were beside himself, would have uttered these things ? Having been heard (he says) in that He feared, He learned obedience from the things which He suffered. What obedience ? He that before this had been obedient, as a Son to His Father, even unto death, how did He afterwards learn [obedience] ? Seest thou that this is (2) spoken concerning the Incarnation ? Tell me now, did He pray the Father that He might be saved from death ? and was it for this cause that He was exceeding sorrowful, and said, If it be possible, let this cup s. Matt. pass from Me? yet no where prayed the Father concerning ^^ ^^* His resurrection, but on the contrary Himself openly de- clares. Destroy this temple and within three days I will s. John raise it up. And, / have power to lay doivn My life, and I\{^]^ ^g^ have power to take it again. No man taketh it from Me, I lay it down of Myself. What then is it ; for what pur- pose did He pray ? (And again He said. Behold we go up to ^^^^^' Jerusalem, and the Son of Man shall be betrayed unto the 19. chief priests and scribes, and they shall condemn Him to death. And they shall deliver Him to the Gentiles, to mock, and to scourge, and to crucify Him : and the third day He shall rise again, and said not, " My Father shall raise Me up again^^). How then was it that He prayed concerning this ? But further, for whom did He pray ? For those who had believed on Him. And what he means is to this effect, 'He is readily lis- tened to.' For inasmuch as they had not yet the right » Heretics who denied the reality of our Lord's Human Nature. 104 Suffering path to perfection. Milk. HoM. 8. opinion concerning Him^ he said that He was heard. Just S. John as He Himself also when consoling His disciples^ said. If ye loved Me, ye would rejoice, because I go to My Father, and My Father is greater than I. But how did He not glorify Himself He who made Himself of no reputation, see Gal. He who gave Himself up ? For, it is said. He gave Himself 1 Tim ^P f^^ ^^^^ ^^^^' -^^^ again, Who gave Himself a ransom ii. 6. for us all. What is it then ? Thou seest that it is on ac- count of the flesh that He speaks lowly things concerning Himself: So in this place also, Although He were Son, He was heard in that He feared, saith [the Apostle] . He wishes to shew, that the success was of Himself, rather than of God's favour. So great (saith he) was His reverence, that even on account thereof God had respect unto Him. He learned, he saith, to obey God. Here again he shews cf. supra }iow great is the gain of sufferings. And having been made 53^ 72.' perfect, he saith. He became the Author of salvation to them that obey Him. But if He, being the Son, gained obedience from His sufferings, much more shall we. Dost thou see how many things he says in his discourse about obedience, that they might be persuaded to it ? For it seems to me that they would not be restrained. From the things, saith hQ, which He suffered He continually learned to obey God. And being made perfect through His sufferings. This then is perfection, and by this means must we arrive at per- fection. For not only was He Himself saved [thereby] , but this became to others also an abundant supply of salvation. For being made peyfect He became Author of salvation to them that obey Him. [4.] Being called, saith he, of God High Priest after the order of Melchisedech : (ver. 11) Of whom we have many things to say and hard to be uttered [or. explained] . When he was about to proceed to speak of the difference of the Priesthood, he first reproves them, pointing out both that this his so great condescension was milk, and that it was because they were children that he dwelt longer on the lowly subject, that [namely] which has relation to the flesh, and speaks [about Him] ^s about any righteous man. And see, he neither kept silence as to the doctrine altogether, nor did he utter it. For the one [he did] that he might Difficulty arising from their dulness, how managed, 105 raise up their thoughts, and persuade them to be perfect, He.v.ii» and not to allow themselves to be deprived of the great doctrines ; the other that he might not overwhelm their minds. Of whom, he saith, we have many things to say and hard to be explained, seeing ye are dull of hearing. Because they do not hear, on this account it is that the doctrine is hard to be explained. For when a person has to discourse with men who do not go along with him nor apprehend the things that are spoken, he cannot well explain the subject to them. But perhaps some one of you that stand here, is puzzled, and thinks it a hard case, that owing to the Hebrews, he him- self is hindered from hearing the more perfect doctrines. Nay rather, I think that perhaps here also, with the ex- ception of a few, there are many such [as they], so that this may be said concerning yourselves also : but for the sake of those few I will speak. Did he then keep entire silence, or did he resume the subject again in what follows ; and do the same as in the Epistle to the Romans ? For there too, when he had first stopped the mouths of the gainsayers, and said. Nay but, Rom. ix. man, ivho art thou that repliest against God ? he then sub- ^^• joined the solution. And for my own part I think that he was not even altogether silent, and yet did not speak it out, in order to lead the hearers to a longing [for the knowledge]. For having mentioned [the subject], and said that certain great things were stored up in the doctrine, see how he frames his reproof in combination with panegyric. For this is ever a part of Paul's wisdom, to mix painful things with kind ones. Which he also does in the Epistle to the Galatians, saying. Ye did run ivell; who did hinder Gal. v. 7. you? And, Have ye suffered so many things in vain? if ih.m.i. it be yet in vain, and, / have confidence in you in the Lord. lb. v. 10. Which he says also to these [Hebrews], But we are per- infra vi. suaded better things of you, and things that accompany ^• salvation. For these two things he effects, he does not overstrain them, nor suffer them to fall back ; for if the examples of others are sufficient to raise up the hearer, and to lead him to emulation ; when a man has the example 106 He repeatedly tries to utter higher doctrine but defers them. HoM. 8. [drawn] from his own conduct and is bidden to emulate himseif, the possibility [of his doing it] is already therein implied. He therefore shews this also, and does not suffer them to fall back as men utterly condemned, nor as being alway evil, but [says] that they were once even good ; (ver. 12) for when for the time ye ought to he teachers, saith he. Here he shews that they had been believers a long while ago, and he shews also that they ought to instruct others. [5.] At all events observe him continually travailing to introduce the discourse concerning the High Priest, and supra iv. still putting it off. For hear how he began : Raving a great High Priest who hath passed through the heavens; and omitting to say in wh^t manner He was great, he says again, supra Por every High Priest taken from among men, is appointed lb. 5. f^^' ^^^ ^^ things pertaining to God. And again. So Christ also glorified not Himself to be made an High Priest. And lb. 6. again after saying. Thou art a Priest for ever after the order lb. 7. of Melchisedec, he again puts off [the subject], saying, Who in the days of His Flesh offered prayers and supplications. (3) When therefore he had been so many times repulsed, he says, as though he were excusing himself. The blame is with you. Alas ! how great a difference ! When they ought to be teaching others, they are not even simply learners, but the last of learners, ver. 12. For when for the time ye ought to be teachers, ye have need again that some one ^ teach ^ the you the very first elements ^ of the oracles of God. Here he of the nieans the Human Nature [of Christ]. For as in external begin, literature it is necessary to learn the elements first, so also here they were instructed first concerning the human nature [of Christ]. Thou seest what is the cause of his uttering lowly things. So Paul did to the Athenians also, discoursing and saying. Acts xvu. The times then of wnorance God ivinked at : but now com- 30 31 'f ^ ' * mandeth all men every where to repent, because He hath appointed a day in the which He will judge the world in righteousness by that Man whom He hath ordained, whereof >». ^Tiva. The common editions have the Epistle, where Lachman adopts Tti'o,"that one teach you whicli be &c." the reading rfra. as is read in the received version of Dulness, whence. Milk^^e dwelling on Chris fs HumanNature. 107 He hath given assurance unto all men, in that He hath He. v. 12 . raised Him from the dead. For this cause, if he says any thing lofty, he expresses it briefly, while the lowly state- ments are scattered about in many places through the whole Epistle. And in this very way too His loftiness is indicated ; since the extreme lowliness [of what is said] forbids the suspicion that these things relate to His Divine Nature. | So in this place also the safe ground was kept ^. ; But what produces this dulness ? This he intimates ] especially in the Epistle to the Corinthians, saying, For 1 Cor. iii. ' whereas there is among you envy and strife and divisions, ^* are ye not carnal ? But observe, I beseech you, his great wisdom, how on each occasion he addresses himself in a way corresponding to the distempers before him. For there [in the case of the Corinthians] the weakness arose chiefly from ignorance, or rather from sinful acts ; but here [in j the case of the Hebrews] not from sins only, but also from j their continual afflictions. Wherefore he also uses expres- I sions calculated to shew the difference, not saying, ye are j become carnal, but dull: in that case carnal, but in this j the pain is greater. For they [the Corinthians] indeed were not able to endure [his reproof] , inasmuch as they were carnal : but these were able. For in saying. Seeing ye are supra | become dull of hearing, he shews plainly that formerly they ^^^' ' I were sound in health, and were strong, fervent in zeal, i which he also afterwards testifies respecting them, [6.] And are become such as have need of milk, not of strong meat. On every occasion he calls the lowly doctrine milk, both in this place and in the other. When, saith he, for [i. e. because q/*] the time ye ought to be teachers : that j very thing because of which especially ye are become faint and supine, [I mean] because of the time, because of that | especially ye ought to be strong. Now he calls it milk, on account of its being suited to the more simple. But it is injurious to those who are more perfect, and the dwelling j on these [lowly] things is hurtful to them. So that it were { not right that practices pertaining to the Law should be introduced^ now or the comparison made from these [points], = That is, he took care to provide thing-s concerning- Christ. \ ag^ainst being understood to refer to ^ The allowing the observances of j His Divine Nature, when he said lowly the law, as M^eJl as the dwelling- thus j 108 Milk, child^sfood. Word of righteousness. ^^^^•^• . that He was a High Priest, and offered sacrifice, and needed crying and supplication. Wherefore see how these things are unhealthful^ to us; but them at that time they nourished, being in no respect unheal thful to them. So then it seems the oracles of God are true nourishment. Amos For I will give unto them^ he saith, not a famine of bread, nor a thirst of ivater, but a famine of hearing the word of the Lord. I Cor. iii. I gave you milk to drink, and not meat ; He did not say, I fed you, intimating that such [nourishment] as this is not food, but that the case is like that of little children who cannot be fed with bread. For such have not drink given them, but their food is to them instead of drink. Moreover he didnotsay,"ye have need," butz/ecfre become such as have need of milk and not of strong meat. That is, ye willed [it] ; ye have reduced yourselves to this state, this need. ver. 13. For everij one that part aketh of milk is unskilled in the word of righteousness for he is a babe. What is the Word [^doctrine'] of righteousness ? He seems to me here to S. Matt, hint at conduct also. That which Christ also said. Except ^' ' your righteousness shall exceed the righteousness of the Scribes and Pharisees, this he says likewise, unskilled in the word of righteousness, that is, he that is unskilled in the philosophy that is above, is unable to embrace a life ^6.KpovKa\ perfect and exact ^. Or else by righteousness he here means lifvo"' Christ, and the high doctrine concerning Him. That they then were become dull, he said ; but from what cause [they were so], he did not add, leaving it to them- selves to know it and not being willing to make his discourse hard to bear. In the case of the Galatians on the contrary Gal. i. 6 ; ^G both may^velled and stood in doubt, which tends much iv. 20. more to encourage, as it is the language of one who would never have expected that this should happen. For this is [what] the doubting [implies]. Thou seest that there is another infancy. Thou seest *T€\€t(J- that there is another full age^. Let us become oifull age TtjS -v. on the Human characteristics of our « irpon-ia-Tarai. Said of that which Lord, were suited for the beginners, cannot be digested or cause§ nausea, but would be injurious to us. Hoiv to discern good and evil ; i.e. true and false teaching. 109 in this sense : It is in the power even of those who are He.v.14. children, and young persons, to arrive at ihdit full age : For it is not of nature but of virtue. [7.] ver. 14. But strong meat belongeth to them that are of full age [perfect], even thern ivho by reason of use have their senses exercised to discern both good and evil. Those persons had not their senses exercised, nor did they knoio good and evil. He is not speaking now concerning life [and conduct] , when he says to discern good and evil, for this is possible and easy for every man to know, but con- cerning doctrines that are wholesome and sublime, and those that are corrupted and low. The babe knows not how to distinguish the bad and the good food. Oftentimes at least it puts even dirt into its mouth, and takes what is hurtful; and it does all things without discernment; but not [so] that which is of full age. Such [babes] are they who listen to all things without distinction, and give up their ears indiscriminately : which seems to me to imply blame on these [Hebrews] also, as being lightly carried about, and now giving themselves to these, now to those. Which he also hinted at near the end [of the Epistle], say- ing, Be not carried aside by divers and strange doctrines. Infra xiii. This is the meaning of to discern good and evil. For the j'^^ mouth tasteth food, but the soul trieth words. xxxiv. 3. [8.] Let us therefore ourselves also learn this lesson. (4) Do not thou when thou hearest that a man is not a Heathen nor a Jew, straightway believe him to be a Christian ; but examine also into all the other points; for even Mani- ch6eans, and all the heresies, have put on this mask, in order thus to deceive the more simple. But if we have the senses of the soul exercised to discern both good and evil, we are able to discern such [teachers]. But how do our senses become exercised? By continual hearing ; by experience of the Scriptures. For when we set forth the error of those [Heretics], and thou hearest to-day and to-morrow ; and ascertainest by testing that it is not right, thou hast learnt the whole, thou hast known the whole : and even if thou shouldest not comprehend to-day, thou wilt comprehend to-morrow. 110 Chief heresies named. Safeguard in Scripture and The Faith. HoM. 8. That have, saith he, their senses exercised. Thou seest that it is needful to exercise our hearing by divine studies, so as not to be addressed in a strange language ? Exercised, saith he, for discerning, that is, to be skilled. One man says, that there is no Resurrection ; and an- other looks for none of the things to come ; another says there is a different God ; another that He has His begin- ning from Mary. And see at once how they have all fallen 1 €| o/A€. away from want of moderation ^, some in the way of excess, ■^^ "* others in that of defect. As for instance, the first Heresy cf. S. Ire- ... . naeus iv. of all was that of Marcion, this introduced besides [the true] fok^n^T ^ different God, which has no existence. See the excess. ' After this was the [heresy] of Sabellius, saying that the Son and the Spirit and the Father are One K Next that of Marcellus and Photinus, which also taught the same things. Moreover that of Paul of Samosata, saying that He had His beginning from Mary. Afterwards that of the Manicheeans ; for this is the most modern of all. After these the heresy of Arius. And there are others too. But on this account have we had the Faith handed down to us, that we might not be compelled to engage with in- numerable heresies, and to be troubled [therewith], but whatever any man might have endeavoured either to add to or take from it, that we might hold to be spurious. For just as those who give the standards [measures] do not oblige [people] to busy themselves about measures innumerable, but bid them keep to that which has been given them ; so also in the case of doctrines. [9.] But no man is willing to give attention to the Scrip- tures. For if we did give attention, not only should we not be ourselves entangled by deceit, but we should also set others free who are deceived, and should draw them out of dangers. For the strong soldier is not only able to help himself, but also to protect his comrade, and to free him from the malice of the enemy. But as it is, some do not even know that there are any Scriptures. Yet the Holy Spirit indeed made so many wise provisions in order that they might be safely kejH. And look at it from the first, that ye may learn the un- ^ '4v. The common texts add Trpcaw-rrov, " one person." Gon^ scareinpreserving the Scriptures,men^sneglect of them. Ill speakableloveof God towards man. He inspired the blessed He. v. 14. Moses ; He engraved the tables, He detained him on the mount forty days ; and again as many [more] to give the Law. And after this He sent prophets who suffered woes innumerable. War came on ; they slew them all, they cut them to pieces, the [sacred] books were burned. Again, He inspired another admirable man to publish them, Ezra I mean, and caused them to be put together from the re- mains. And after this He arranged that they should be translated by the seventy. They did translate them. Christ came. He acknowledges them ; the Apostles disperse them among men. Christ wrought signs and wonders. What then after so great painstaking ? The Apostles also wrote, even as Paul likewise said, they were written i Cor. x. for our admonition, upon whom the ends of the world are ^^' come. And again Christ said. Ye do err not knowing the s. Matt. Scriptures : And again Paul said. That through patience and ^^"' ^^* comfort of the Scriptures we may have hope. And again, 4. All Scripture is given by inspiration of God, and is profit- 2 Tim. Hi. able. And let the word of Christ dwell in you richly. And J,^j jj. the prophet, he shall meditate in His Law day and night, 16. and again in another place. Let all thy communication he ecc/us in the law of the Most High. And again, How sweet are ix. 15. Thy words unto my throat. (He said not to my hearing, but jqs. to my throat) more than honey and the honeycomb to my mouth. And Moses saith. Thou shall meditate in them con- Deut. vi. tinually, ivhen thou risest up, when thou sittest, when thou '^' liest down. Be in them, saith he. And innumerable things i Tim. one might say concerning them. But notwithstanding, after ^^' so many things there are some who do not even know that there are Scriptures at all. For this cause, believe me, nothing sound, nothing profitable comes from us. [10.] Yet, if any one wished to learn military affairs, of necessity he must learn the laws affecting military affairs. And if any one was disposed to acquire the knowledge of steering or of carpentering, or any thing else, of necessity he must learn the [principles] of the art. But in this case they will not do anything of the kind, and that, notwith- standing this is a science which needs much wakeful atten- tion. For that it too is an art which needs teaching, hear 112 Bible neglected: spiritual things uncaredfor, temporal lost. HoM. 8. the prophet saying. Come, ye children, hearken unto me, Ps.xxxiv. / ^iii i^dQji yQy^ the fear of the Lord. It follows therefore certainly that the fear of God needs teaching. Then he lb. 12. saith. What is man is he that ivould have life ? he means Ib.13,14. the life yonder; and again. Keep thy tongue from evil and thy lips that they speak no guile; turn aside from evil and do good, seek peace and pursue it. Do you know who it is that said these things, a prophet or a writer of history, or an apostle, or an evangelist ? For my own part I do not think you do, except a few. Yea and these themselves again, if we bring forward a testimony from some other place, will be in the same case as the rest of you. For see, I repeat the same statement expressed Is. i. 16, in other words. Wash ye, become clean, put away your wickednesses from your souls before Mine eyes, learn to do well, seek out judgment. Keep thy tongue from evil, and do good: learn to do well. Thou seest that virtue needs to be taught ? For this one saith, / will teach you the fear of the Lord, and the other Learn to do ivell. Now then do you know where these words are in [the Scripture] ? For myself I do not think you do, except a few. And yet every week these things are read to you twice or even three times : and the reader when he goes up [to the desk] first says whose the book is, [the book] of such a prophet, and then says what he says, so that it shall be more intelligible to you and you may not only know the contents of the Book, but also the occasion of what is written, and who it was that spake these things. But all in vain ; all to no purpose. For your interest is wholly on things of this life, and of things spiritual no ac- count is made. For this cause not even do those [worldly] matters turn out according to your wishes, but there also many diffi- S. Matt, culties [befal you] . For Christ saith, Seek the Kingdom of VI. 33. Qoci^ and all these things shall be added unto you. These things He said, shall also be given in the way of addition : but we have inverted the order and seek the earth and the good things which 'are in the earth, as if those other [heavenly] things were to be given us in addition. For this cause we have neither the one nor the other. Let us then Who seek spiritual, ivillhave temporal ; nor lose all. 113 at last wake up and become coveters of the things which He. v. 14. shall be hereafter ; for so these also will follow. For it is not possible that he who seeks the things that relate to God, should not also attain human [blessings] . It is the declaration of the Truth itself which says this. Let us not then act otherwise, but let us hold fast to the counsel of Christ, lest we fail of all. But God is able to give you compunction and to make you better, in Christ Jesus our Lord, with whom to the Father and also to the Holy Ghost be glory, power, honour, now and for ever and world without end. Amen. VOL. VlJ. HOMILY IX. Heb. vi. 1—3. Wherefore leaving the principles of the Doctrine of Christ % let us go on unto perfection, not laying again the founda- tion of repentance from dead works, and of faith towards God ; of the doctrine of baptisms, and of laying on of hands ; and of resurrection of the dead, and of eternal judgment. And this we will do, if God permit. You have heard how much Paul found fault with the Hebrews for wishing to be always learning about the same supra V. things. And this he did with good reason : For when for the time ye ought to he teachers, ye have need again that ^ Tcb o-Toi- some one teach you the elements of the first principles^ of the ^'\'''^' oracles of God. I am afraid that this might very appropriately be said to you also, that luhenfor the time ye ought to be teachers, ye do not even maintain the rank of learners, but ever hearing the same things, and on the same subjects, you are in the same condition as if you heard no one. And if any man should question you, no one will be able to answer, excejDt a very few who may soon be counted. But this is no trifling loss. For oftentimes w^hen the teacher wishes to go on further, and to touch on higher and more mysterious doctrines, the want of attention in those who are to be taught does not permit him [to do so]. For just as in the case of a grammar-master, if a boy is continually being taught the first elements without retain- ^ rhv K6yov ttjs apxh^ '''ov Xpicrov. substitutes for this, tj apxh fov \6yov. Literally " the discourse of the begin- "the beginning- of the doctrine," as the ning of Christ; "but presently S.Chrys. words are translated in our Version. Same truths repeated as for their good, not for display. 115 ing them, it will be necessary for him to be continually HE.vi.1.3. dinning them into the boy, and he will not leave off teach- ing, until the other has been able to learn them accurately, for it is great folly to lead him on to other things, without having put well into him w^hat comes first ; so too in the Church, if while we constantly say the same things you learn never the more, we shall not ever cease saying the same things. For if our preaching were a matter of display and am- bition, it would have been right for us to pass quickly from one subject to another and to be continually digressing, as having no thought for you yourselves, but only for your applauses. But since it is not to this that we have devoted our zeal, but our labours are all for your j)rofit, w^e shall not cease discoursing to you on the same subjects, till you succeed in learning them. For I might have said much about the Gentile superstition, and about the Manichgeans, and about the Marcionists, and by the grace of God have given them heavy blows, but this sort of discourse is out of season. Since to persons who do not as yet know ac- curately what concerns their own selves, to persons who have not yet learned that to be covetous is evil, who would utter such discourses as those, and lead them on to other subjects before the time ? We then for our part shall not cease to say the same things, whether ye be persuaded or not. We fear however, that by continually saying the same things, if ye hearken not, we may make the condemnation heavier for them that are disobedient. I must not however say this in regard to you all ; for I know many who are benefited by their coming into this place, who might with justice complain loudly against those others, as insidiously injuring them^ through their' iveSpev- ignorance and inattention. However not even thus will they be injured. For hearing the same things continually is useful even to those who know them, since by often hearing what we know, we are more deeply affected. We know, for instance, that Humility is an excellent thing, and that Christ often discoursed about it ; but when we also listen to His very words and the reflections made upon I 2 avTOus 116 Need of securing the elements and foundation of the Faith. HoM.9. them, we are yet more affected, even if we hear them ten thousand times. [2.] It is not out of place then for us also to say now to you, Wherefore leaving the beginning of the doctrifie of Christ, let us go on unto perfection, vapxi) What is the beginning of the doctrine'^ ? He sroes on to Tov \oyov . . state it himself saying, not laying again (these are his words) a foundation of repentance from dead works, and faith toward God, of the doctrine of baptisms and of laying on of hands, of the resurrection of the dead, and of eternal judgment. But if this be the Beginning, what else is our doctrine save to repent from dead ivorks, and through the Spirit to receive the faith ^ in the resurrection of the dead, and eternal judgment ? But what is the Beginning ? The Be- ginning, he says, is nothing else than this, when there is not also a strict life. For just as for one who is entering on the study of grammar, it is necessary to be instructed in 2 or the the Elements " first, so is it for the Christian also to know letters . . these things accurately, and to have no doubt concerning them. And should he again have need of teaching, he does not as yet possess the foundation. For one who is firmly grounded ought to be fixed and to stand steady, and not be moved out of his place. But if a person who has been catechized and baptized is going ten years afterwards to learn again about the Faith, and that we ought to believe in the resurrection of the dead, he does not yet possess the foundation, he is again seeking after the beginning of the Christian religion. For that the Faith is the foundation, and the rest is the building, hear [the Apostle] himself 1 Cor. iii. saying ; / have laid the foundation and another buildeth lb 12 thereupon. If any man build upon this foundation, gold, silver, precious sjtones, wood, hay, stubble. Not laying again (saith he) a foundation of repentance from dead works. (2) [3.] But what is, let us go on unto perfection ? Let us henceforth proceed (he means) even to the very roof, that is, let us have the most e^ellent life. For just as in the case ^ The Faith ; tt/o-tis with the Article in this place and a little below means the Creed ; as we say "the Belief." TVe are not to be ever beginning anew in Religion. 117 of the letters the Alphabet ^ contains the whole^, and as the Heb.vj.i. foundation holds together the whole building, so also does '^^ ^^^'^ full assurance concerning the Faith maintain purity of life. And without this it is not possible to be a Christian, any more than for a building [to exist] without foundations ; or for a man to become skilled in literature without the letters. Still if a person should be always going round about the letters, or if he should be [always engaged] about the foundation, not about the building, he will not yet have gained any thing. Do not thou however think that the Faith is depreciated by being called elementary : for it is indeed the whole power : for when he says, For every one that useth milk is supra v. unskilled in the ivord of righteousness, for he is a babe, it * is not this which he calls milk. But to be still doubting about these things is [a sign] of a feeble mind, and one that needs many discourses. For these are the wholesome doctrines. Since we call him a petfect man [i.e. of full age] who with the faith has a right life ; but if any one has faith, but yet does evil, and is in doubts concerning [the faith] itself, and brings disgrace on the doctrine, him we shall with reason call a babe, in that he has gone back again to the beginning. So that if we have been even ten thousand years in the faith, and yet are not firm in it, we are babes ; when we exhibit a life not suitable to it ; when we are still laying a foundation. [4.] But besides [their way of] life he brings another charge also against these [Hebrews], as being shaken from their position, and needing to lay a foundation of repent- ance from dead ivorks. For when a man changes from one thing to another, giving up this, and choosing that, he ought first to condemn himself, and to depart from [what he held] in disposition and then to pass to the other. But if he in- tends again to lay hold on the first, how shall he touch the second ? What then is to be said of the Law (saith one) ? we have condemned it, and again we go back to it. This is not a shifting about, for here also [under the Gospel] we have a law. Do ive then (he saith) 7nake void the law through Rom. iii. faith ? God forbid, yea ive establish the Laiv. I was speak- ^^' 118 Holy Baptism once for all, HoM.9. ing concerning evil deeds. For he that intends to pursue virtue ought to condemn wickedness first, and then go in 1 SeT^ai pursuit of it. For repentance had not the power to make ^ them clean. For this cause they were straightway baptized, that what they were unable to accomplish by themselves might be effected by the grace of Christ. Neither then is repentance sufficient for purification, but it is necessary to receive baptism. At all events, after having previously condemned the sins one had committed and given a deci- sion against them, it was necessary to come to baptism. But what is the doctrine of baptisms ? The expression is used not as if there were many baptisms, but one only ^. Why then did he express it in the plural number ? because he had said, not laying again a foundation of repentance. For if he had again baptized them and catechised them ' H apxvs afresh, and after having been baptized anew ^ they were being taught what things ought to be done and what ought not, they would be in the way to remain perpetually un- corrected. And of laying on of hands. For thus did they receive Actsxix. the Spirit, tvhen Paul had laid his hands on them, it is ^- said. And of the resurrectioii of the dead. For this is both effected in baptism, and is affirmed in the confession. And of eternal judgment. But wherefore saith he this ? Because it was likely that after having already believed they would either be shaken from [their faith], or would i/7}<|/aTc lead evil and slothful lives, he saith, be wakeful. It is not open to them to say, If we live slothfully we will be baptized again, we will be catechized again, we will again receive the Spirit, even if now we fall from the faith, we shall be able again by being baptized, to wash away our sins, and to attain to the very same state as before. Ye are deceived (he saith) in supposing these things. [5.] ver. 4, 5. For it is impossible for those rvho have been once enlightened and have tasted of the heavenly gift, and have been made partakers of the Holy Ghost, and have tasted the good word of God, ^d the powers of the ivorld to come, and have fallen aivay, to renew them again unto repentance, • That is, the Apostle repudiates the teaching of more than one baptism. Repentance may be repeated ; not Baptismal renewal. 119 crucifying "^ unto themselves the Son of God afresh, and HEB.vi.6. putting Him to an open shame. And see how touchingly^ and positively [forbiddingly] he ^ ^vrp^. begins, hnpossible. No longer (he would say) expect that '^'^"^"^ which is not possible (for he said not, It is not seemly, or, It is not expedient, or. It is not lawful, but impossible, so as to cast [them] into despair), if ye have once been al- together enlightened. Then he adds, and have tasted of the heavenly gift. If (3) ye have tasted (he says) of the heavenly gift, that is, of for- giveness. And been made partakers of the Holy Ghost, and tasted the good word of God (he is speaking here of the doctrine) and the powers of the world to come (what powers is he speaking of ? either the working of miracles, or the 2 Cor. i. earnest of the Spirit) and have fallen away, to renew them again unto repentance, seeing they crucify to themselves the Son of God afresh and put Him to an open shame. Renew them, he saith, unto repentance, that is, by repentance, for unto repentance is by repentance. What then, is repentance excluded? Not repentance, God forbid ! but the renewing again by the Washing ^. For ^ 5'« he did not say, impossible to be renewed unto repentance, and then stop, but added how, impossible [by] crucifying afresh. To be renewed, that is, to be made new, for to make men new is [the work] of the Washing only : for (it is said) thy youth shall be renewed as the eaglets. But it is [the Ps.ciii.5. work of] repentance, when those who have been made new, have afterwards become old through sins, to set them free from this their old age, and to make them strong^. ^Q^vr^ppovs brmg them to that former brightness however, is not m Sav. Ben. its power ; for there the whole was Grace. [6.] Crucifying to themselves, saith he, the Son of God afresh, and putting Him to an open shame. And what he means is this. Baptism is a Cross, and our old man was Rom. vi. crucified with \Him'\, for we were made conformable to the jj^ ^ ^^^ likeness of His death, and again, ive were buried therefore Phil. iii. loith Him by baptism into death. Wherefore, just as it is not ^^^ ^,5 •> S. Chrys. exposition requires this renew them by crucifying- afresh," and ^• literal translation of the participle. " seeing they crucify afresh." He gives two explanations of it, " to 120 Second Baptism is cy^ucifying Christ afresh. HoM.9. possible that Christ should be crucified a second time, for Rom. vi. this is to put Him to an open shame ^. For if death shall no more have dominion over Him, if He rose again, by His resurrection becoming superior to death ; if by death He wrestled with and overcame death, and then is crucified again, all those things become a fable and a mockery. He then that baptizeth ^ a second time, crucifies Him again. But what is crucifying afresh ? [It is] crucifying over again. For just as Christ died on the cross, so do we in baptism, not as to the flesh, but as to sin. Behold two deaths. He died as to the flesh ; in our case the old man was buried, and the new man arose, which had been made conformable to the likeness of His death. If therefore it is 1 S. B. necessary to be baptized [again^], it is necessary that this same [Christ] should again die. For baptism is nothing else than the putting to death and the rising of that person who is baptized. And well said he, crucifying afresh unto themselves. For he that doth this, as having forgotten the former grace ^, and ordering his own life carelessly, acts in all respects as if there were another baptism. It behoves us therefore to take heed and to be cautious. [7.] What is, having tasted of the heavenly gift? it is, " of the Remission of sins :^' for this is of God alone to bestow, lb. 1, 2. and the grace is a grace once for all. What then? shall toe continue in sin that grace may abound? God forbid! But if we should be always going to be saved by grace we shall never at any time be good. For here where there is but one grace, even so we are indolent, should we then cease sinning if we knew that it is possible again to have our sins washed away? For my part I think not. In this place he indicates that the gifts are many : and to explain it, "Ye were counted worthy (he says) of forgive- ness so great, for he that was sitting in darkness, he that was at enmity, he that was at open war, that was alienated, « The common editions add ovtus baptizeth himself." S. Chrys. however ouSe )3a7rTt(r0^;/at," so neither [is it pos- is speaking- of a Bishop who repeats sible] to be baptized [a second tinue] ." baptism. The apodosis is wanting^ in the older ^ X«p'^- The word is used throug-h- text, as it is in several other places. out this passag-e in the sense of Re- f The later texts add kavrhu, "that mission,asexplainedinthenext clause. Hoiv can privileges, so great, be restored, if cast away? 121 that was hated of God, that was utterly lost, this man hav- Heb.vjA ing been suddenly enlightened, counted worthy of the Spirit, of the heavenly gift, of adoption as a son, of the kingdom of heaven, of those other good things, the mysteries that are not to be spoken of; and who does not even thus become better, and yet when he was indeed worthy of perdition, had obtained salvation and honour, as if he had successfully accomplished some great things; how could he possibly be again baptized ? On two grounds then he said that the thing was impos- sible, and he put the stronger last : first, because he to whom such [blessings] have been vouchsafed, and who has be- trayed all that was granted to him, is not worthy to be again renewed, neither^ is it possible that Christ should again be crucified afresh : for this is to put Him to an open shame. There is not then any second Washing : there is not [indeed] . And if there is, there is also a third, and a fourth; for the former one is continually disannulled by the later, and this continually by another, and so on indefinitely. And tasted, he says, the goodioord of God ; and he does not unfold it ; and the powers of the ivorld to come, for to live as Angels and to have no need of earthly things, to know that this is the means of our introduction to the en- joyment of the worlds to come ; this may we learn through the Spirit, and enter into those sacred recesses. What are the powers of the ivorld to come ? Life eternal, ansrelic conversation. Of these then we have alreadv re- ceived the earnest through our Faith from the Spirit. Tell me then, if after having been introduced into a Palace, and having had all things therein entrusted to thee, thou hadst then notwithstanding betrayed all, wouldest thou have been again entrusted with them ^ ? [8.] What then (you say)? Is there no repentance ? There (4) h The longer text in Sav. and Ben. nuine text, as also in other works of adds, Sevrepcf Se on oh, " and secondly S. Chrys. because it is not &c": the shorter text ' The common texts add ra eKe7, has only ovZe omitting "secondly." "the things in heaven." But S. Chrys. There are many other instances of a is speaking of present privileges here similar negligence of Style in the ge- on earth. 122 Repentance a Medicine. Its vi7'tue and co^nponent parts. HoM.9. is repentance, there is however no second baptism : but Repentance there is, and great is the force it has, in that it is able to set free from the burden of his sins, if he will, even him that hath been utterly immersed in sins, and to establish in safety him who is in danger, even though he should have come unto the very lowest depth of wicked- Jer. viii. ness. And this is evident from many places. For, saith "*• one, doth not lie that falleth rise again ? or he that turneth away, doth not he turn back to [God'] ? It is possible, if we have the will, that Christ should be formed in us again : Gal. iv. for hear Paul saying. My little children of ivhom I travail in birth again, until Christ be formed in you. Only let us lay hold on repentance. For behold the kindness of God to man ! we ought on every ground to have been punished at the first ; in that having received the natural law, and also enjoyed innumer- able blessings, we have not acknowledged our Master, and have lived an unclean life. Yet He not only has not punished us, but has even made us partakers of countless blessings, just as if we had successfully accomplished some great things. Again we fell aw^ay, and not even so does He Ingre- punish US, but has given us the medicine of repentance, medicine which is Sufficient to put away and blot out all our sins ; of repent- provided only that we know the nature of the medicine, and in what manner we ought to apply it. Of what nature then is the medicine of Repentance ? and the first how is it made up ? First, of the condemnation of our Fs. xxxu. Q^n sins ^ ; For (saith he) my iniquity have I not hid ;■ And, / will confess against myself mine iniquity unto the Lord, and Thou forgavest the impiety of my heart. And again, Isaiah Declare thou at the first thy sins, that thou may est bejusti- Prov fi^^' ^^d. The righteous man is an accuser of himself at the xviii. 17. first speaking. the se- Secondly, of great humbleness of mind : For it is like a cond golden chain; if one have hold of the beginning, all will follow. Because if thou confess thy sin as one ought to confess, the soul is humbled. For conscience turning it on ifl-uo-Tpe- itself^ causeth it to be ST*bdued. fhe third Other things too must we needs add to humbleness of ^ The common texts add koI a-rrh i^ayopevaeuis, "and [of] from confession." Tears, alms, forgive, aid souls and bodies, be meek. 123 mind if it be such as the blessed David knew, when he said, Heb.vj.g. A broken and humbled heart Godivill not despise. For that Ps. li. 17. which is broken does not rise up, does not strike, but is prepared to be ill-treated and itself riseth not up. Such is Contrition of heart : though it be insulted, though it be evil entreated, it remaineth quiet, and is not eager to take vengeance. And after humbleness of mind, there is need of intense the fourth prayers, of many tears, tears by day, and tears by night : for, saith he, every night ivill I wash my bed, I will ivater ib. vi. 6. my couch with my tears. I ara weary with my groaning. And again. For I have eaten ashes as it were bread, and lb. di. 9. mingled my drink with weeping. And after prayer thus intense, there is need of much the fifth almsgiving : for this it is which especially gives strength to the medicine of Repentance. And just as in the case of the aids administered by physicians there are medicines into which many herbs are put, but one that is essential, so also in case of Repentance this herb is the most essen- tial, yea, is every thing. For hear what the Divine Scripture saith. Give alms, and all things shall be clean. And again, S.Luke By almsgiving and acts of faithfulness ^ sins are purged away, prov.xvi. And, Water will quench a flaming fire, and alms will do away 6. with great sins. iii. so. Next not being angry with any one, not bearing malice ; the sixth the forgiving all men's trespasses. For, saith one, Man Ib.xxviii. retaineth wrath against man, and yet seeketh healing from the Lord. Forgive that ye rnay be forgiven. ^:^^^^ Also, the converting our brethren from their wandering, t^e • ' For, it is said "^ Go thou, and convert thy brethren, that thy seventh sins may be forgiven thee. And from one's being in close ^^^j^^j^ relations with^ the priests, and if, it is said, a man hath S.James committed sins it shall he forgiven him. To stand forward V^^^\^ in defence of those who are wronged. Not to retain anger : oIk^'iws to bear all things meekly. * [9.] Now then, before you learned that it is possible to i/calTTtVTeo-ij/. [These same two words which go to mal€iv ^^^ prayers intense : another with continual weeping : ano- serlous- thcr with downcast^ countenance. For not even is this ls!^?vii. which is so small a matter, unprofitable ; for / saw (it is 17, 18. said) that he ivas grieved and went downcast^ and I healed his ways. But let us all humble our own souls by almsgiving and forgiving our neighbours their trespasses, by not remem- Remem- bering injuries, nor avenging ourselves. If we continually er sms reflect on the things we have done amiss, no external cir- cumstances will have power to make us elated : neither riches, nor power, nor authority, nor honour ; nay, even should we be seated in the imperial chariot itself, we shall sigh bitterly : Since even the blessed David was a King, Ps. vi. 6. and yet he said. Every night I loill wash my bed, [&c] : and he was not at all hurt by the purple robe and the diadem : he was not puffed up ; for he knew himself to be a man, and inasmuch as his heart had been made contrite, he went mourning. Vanity of all earthly ; the Consulate. 125 [10.] For what are all things human ? ashes and dust, HEB.vi.6 . and as it were spray before the wind ; a smoke and a shadow, and a leaf driven here and there; and a flower; a dream, and a tale, and a fable, wind and air vainly puffed out and dispersing ; a feather that hath no stay, a stream flowing by, or if there be aught of more nothingness than these.. For, tell me, what dost thou esteem great ? what dignity thinkest thou to be great ? is it that of the Consul ? for the many think no dignity greater than that. Let me tell thee that he who is not Consul is not a whit inferior to him who is in so great splendour, who hath been held in so great admiration. Both one and the other are of the same dignity ; each of them alike, after a little while, is no more. When was he made [Consul] ? for how long a time? tell me : for two days ? Nay, this takes place even in dreams. But that is [only] a dream, you say. And what is this ? for (tell me) what is by day, is it [therefore] not a dream ? Why do we not rather call these things a dream ? for just as dreams when the day comes on are proved to be nothing ; so these things also, when the night comes on, are proved to be nothing. For night and day have received each an equal portion of time, and have equally divided the whole of duration. Therefore as in the day a person rejoices not in what happened at night, so neither in the night is it possible for him to reap the fruit of what is . done in the day. Thou hast been made Consul ? So was I in the night ; only I was so in the night, thou in the day. And what of this ? Not even so hast thou any advantage at all over me, except haply its being said. Such an one is Consul, and the pleasure that springs from the words, gives him the advantage. I mean something of this kind, for I will express it more plainly : if I say ' Such an one is Consul,' and bestow on him the name, is it not gone as soon as it is spoken ? Of such kind also are the things themselves; no sooner does the Consul appear, than he is no more. But let us suppose [that he is Consul] for a year, or two years, or three or four years. Where are they who were ten times Consul ? Nowhere. 126 Earthly glory compared with that of the Saints. ^"^^•^- But it is not so with Paul. For he was even living con- tinually : he did not live one day, nor two, nor ten, and twenty; nor thirty [days] ; nor ten and twenty, nor yet thirty years — and die. Even the. four hundredth year is now past, and still even yet is he illustrious, yea much more illustrious than when he was alive. And besides these things indeed [are] on earth, but the glory of the saints in heaven what discourse could represent ? Wherefore I entreat you, let us seek this glory ; let us pursue after it, that we may attain it. For this is the true glory. Let us henceforth separate ourselves from the things of this life, that we may find grace and mercy in Christ Jesus our Lord : with whom to the Father, together with the Holy Ghost, be glory, power, honour and worship, now and for ever, and world without end. i\.men. HOMILY X Heb. vi. 7, 8. For the Earth which drinketh in the rain that cometh oft upon it, and bring eth forth herbs meet for them by whom it is dressed, receiveth blessing from God. But if it bear^ thorns and briars it is rejected, and nigh unto cursing, whose end is to he burned. Let us listen to the oracles of God with fear, with fear and much trembling. For (it is said) Set^ve the Lord with Ps.ii. II. fear, and rejoice unto Him ivith trembling. But if even our joy and our exultation ought to be ivith trembling, of what punishment are we not worthy, if we listen not with terror to what is said, when the things spoken are themselves fearful, such as those now [uttered] ? For having said that it is impossible for those ivho have fallen away to be baptized a second time, and to receive the remission which is [given] through the Washing, and having pointed out the awefulness of the case, he goes on to say, for land which has drunk in the rain that cometh often upon it, and bringeth forth herbs meet for them by whom also it is cultivated, partaketh of blessbig from God. But if it bear thorns and thistles, it is rejected ^, and near to a i i^sSKijuos curse ; ivhose end is for burnina. repro- bate Let us then fear, my beloved ! This threat is not Paul's, these are not the words of man : they are the words of the Holy Ghost, of Christ that speaketh in him. Is there a The received version is necessarily " land which hath drunk in &c partak- altered here : S. Chrysostom's com- " eth of blessing- &c. But if it bear mentary will be more readily under- " thorns and thistles, it is reprobate, stood if it is kept in mind that the exact " and nigh unto a curse, whose end translation would be as below : " The " is for burning." 128 Fearful warnings as to privileges abused. Rain; Thorns. HoM. 10. then any one that is clear from these thorns ? And even if we were clear, not even so ought we to be confident, but to fear and tremble lest at any time thorns should spring up in us. But when we are wholly and throughout thorns and thistles, whence is it (tell me) that we are con- fident ? and are becoming supine ? what is it which makes us inert ? If he that thinketh he standeth ought to fear lest 1 Cor. X. he fall ; for (he saith) Let him that thinketh he standeth, take heed lest he fall; he that hath fallen, how anxious ought he to be that he may rise up again ! If Paul fears, \h.\x.27 . lest that by any means, when he had preached to others, himself should be a castaway ; and he who had been so ap- proved is afraid lest he should become disapproved"^ : what pardon shall we have who are already disapproved, if we have no fears, but fulfil our Christianity as a custom, and Rom. i. to clear off a duty. Let us then fear, beloved : For the ^^' lorath of God is revealed from heaven. Let us fear, for it is revealed not against impiety only but against all unright- eousness. What is against all unrighteousness? [against all] both small and great. [2.] In this passage he intimates the loving-kindness of God towards man : and the teaching [of the Gospel] he supra V. calls rain: and what he said above, when for the time ye ^^* ought to be teachers, this he says here also. Indeed in many places the Scripture calls the teaching rain. For (it Is. V. 6. says) I will command the clouds that they rain no rain upon it, speaking of the vineyard. The same which in another Amos place it calls a famine of bread, and a thirst of water. And p" Ix^* ^§^^^5 "^^^ river of God is full of waters. 9. For land, saith he, ivhich hath drunk in the rain that Cometh often upon it. Here he shews clearly that they had received and had drunk in the word, yea and had often en- joyed this, and yet not even so had they profited. For if (he means) thou hadst not been tilled, if thou hadst enjoyed no rains, the evil would not have been so great. For (it S.John is said) If I had not come and spoken unto them they had XV. 22. ^ aSoKi/xos. In the original it is one accepted. It means rejected after test- and the same word which inth^text, ing-, as in ease of metals: which may Heb. vi. 8, is translated rejected, in 1 take place, as S. Chrys. implies in this Cor. ix. 27, a castaway ; it is in this passage, either here or hereafter ; clause opposed to SdKifios, approved, either for a time or for eternity. Thovns )iot to be left : fruits grow because God bids them. 129 7iot had sin. But if thou hast often drank and received Heb.vj.s. [nourishment], wherefore hast thou brought forth other things instead of fruits ? For (it is said) I waited that it Is. v. 2. should bring forth grapes, and it brought forth thorns. Thou seest that everywhere the Scripture calleth sins thorns. For David also saith, I ivas turned into mourning Ps.xxxii. when a, thorn ivas fixed in me. For it does not simply lxX) come on us, but is fixed in ; and even if but a little of it remain in, even if we take it not out entirely, that little portion of itself in like manner causes pain, just as in the case of a thorn. And why do I say, ^ that little of itself? ' even after it has been taken out, it leaves therein for a long time the pain of the wound. And much care and treatment is necessary, that we may be perfectly freed from it. For it is not enough merely to take away the sin, it is necessary also to treat the wounded place. I fear however that the things said [here] apply to us more than to others. For, he saith, land which hath drunk in the rain that cometh often upon it. We are ever drinking, ever hearing, but ivhen the sun is risen we straightway lose S. Matt, our moisture, and for this cause we bring forth thorns. ^"^* ^' What then are the thorns ? Let us hear Christ saying, that the care of this world, and the deceitfulness of riches, choke lb. 22. the word, and it becometh unfruitful. [3.] For land which hath drunk in the rain that cometh oft upon it, he saith, and bringeth forth meet herbs. Because (2) nothing is so meet as purity of life, nothing so suitable as the most excellent life, nothing so meet as virtue. And bringeth forth (saith he) herbs meet for them by whomit is cultivated, partakes of blessing from God. Here he says that God is the cause of all things, giving the heathen a quiet blow, who ascribed the production of fruits to the power of the earth. For (saith he) it is not the hands of the husbandman which stir up the earth to bear fruits, but the command which comes from God. For this cause he ssiys,2)artakes of blessing from God. And see how in speaking of the thorns, he said not, "bringing forth ^ thorns," nor did he use this word expres- ^rUTovaa sive of what is good and useful ; but what said he ? bearing ^ ^ iK instance, inasmuch as they were greatly to be condemned and he could not praise them from things present, he does it from things future [that He stimulates them to increased earnestness, 131 ye will be none otherwise minded, lie says) : he said not, ye He.vj.io . are, but ye will be none otherwise minded. But in this place he encourages them from things present. We are persuaded better things of you, beloved, and things that be- long to salvation, though we thus speak. And since he was not able to say so much [as he would] from things present, he confirms his consolation from things past ; and says, ver. 10. For God is not unrighteous to forget your work, and ^ the love, which ye have shewed towards His name, in that ye have ministered unto the saints and do minister. O how did he here recover their spirit, and give them fresh strength, by reminding them of former things, and bring- ing them to the necessity of not anticipating that God had forgotten [them] . (For he cannot but sin who is not fully assured concerning his hope, and says that God is un- righteous. Accordingly he obliged them by all means to look forward to those future things. For a man who has become desponding owing to the present state of things, and has given up exerting himself, may be restored by [the prospect of] thiTigs future.) As he himself also said in writing to the Galatians, Ye did run ivell : And again Have ye suffered so Gal. v. 7. many things in vain ? if it be yet in vain. "^* And as in this place he puts the commendation together with the reproof, saying, When for the time ye ought to be supra v. teachers, so also there, / marvel that ye are so soon re- Gal. i. 6. moved. The commendation [is mingled] with reproof. For it is respecting great things that we marvel, when they fail. Thou seest that praise is concealed under the accusation and the blame. Nor does he say this concerning himself only, but also concerning all. For he said not, I am persuaded, but we are persuaded better things of you, even good things (he means). He says this either in regard to matters of con- duct, or to the recompense. In the next place, having said above, that it is rejected and nigh unto a curse, and that it shall be for burning, he says, we do not by any means say this of you. For God is not unrighteous to forget your work, and your love. <= Sav. and Ben. here, and in other These words are probably not part of places where the text is cited, insert the sacred text. They are not referred Tov kSttov the labour of love &c. to by S. Chrysostom. K 2 132 In tender language he exhorts them as to the future. HoM. 10. [5.] With what object then did we say these things ? (ver. 11, 12) But we desire that each of you shew the same zeal for the full assurance of hope unto the end, that ye be not slothful, but followers of them who through faith and patience inherit the promises. (3) We desire, he says, and we do not therefore merely labour for, or even so far as words go, wish this. But what? We desire that ye should hold fast to virtue, not as con- demning your former conduct (he means), but fearing for the future. And again he did not say, ' not as condemning your former conduct, but your present ; for ye have fainted, ye are become too indolent;' but see how gently he indicated it, and yet at the same time did not wound them. For what saith he ? But tve desire that each of you shew forth the same zeal unto the end. For this is the admirable part of Paul's wisdom, that he does not expressly say that they had given in, that they had become negligent. For when he says. We desire that each of you — it is as if one should say, I wish thee to be always in earnest ; and such as thou wert before such to be now also, and for th^ time to come. For this made his reproof more gentle and easy to be received. And he did not say, '^ I will that," which would have been expressive of the authority of a teacher, but what is ex- pressive of the affection of a father, and what is more than " willing," ive desire. All but saying. Pardon us, even if we say what is somewhat distasteful. We desire that each of you shew forth the same zeal, for the full assurance of your hope unto the end. Hope (he means) carries us through : it recovers us again. Be not wearied out, do not despair, lest your hope should be in vain. For he that worketh that which is good hopeth also that which is good, and never at any time despairs of himself. ^aK{ji)}v That ye may not become dull"^. Still '^ that ye 77iay not supra V. become; and yet he said above, seei7ig ye are become diill ^ of ^^' hearing. Observe however how he limited the dullness ^ vuiQpoi. The same word is translat- "without quickness in perception or ed slothful and dull in tliese two pas- energy in action.'^ sages. It means " sluggish," " stupid" His tenderness embraces eachr Patient loaiting. 133 to the hearing. And in this place he insinuates the very HE.vi.l2. same thing ; instead of " that ye may not continue in it," he says [this] . But again he leads it on into that future time for which as yet they had no account to render; say- ing in effect "that ye may not become too slothful:'^ since for that which is not yet come we could not be subject to account. For he who in regard to the present time is exhorted to be in earnest, as being remiss, will perhaps become even more slothful, but he who is exhorted with reference to the future, not so. We desire (saith he) that each of you. Great is his affection for them : he cares equally for great and small ; moreover he knows all, and overlooks no one, but displays the same tender care for each, and equal value for all : from which cause also he the rather persuaded them to receive what was distasteful in his words. That ye be not slothful, he saith. For just as inactivity is hurtful to the body, so also inactivity as to what is good renders the soul more supine and feeble. [6.] But followers (he saith) of them, ivho through faith and patience inherit the promises. And who they are, he says afterwards. He said therefore, "Imitate your own former well-doings." Then, lest they should say. What [well-doing] ? he leads them back to the Patriarch : bring- ing before them examples of well-doing indeed from their own history ^, but of the thought of being forsaken, from ^ oUoe^v the Patriarch ; that they might not suppose that they were disregarded and forsaken as being of no account, but might know that this is [the portion] of the very noblest men to make the journey of life through temptations ; and that God has thus dealt with great and admirable men. Now we ought (he says) to bear all things with patience : for this also is believing : whereas if He say that He gives and thou immediately receivest, how hast thou also be- lieved? since in that case this no longer [comes] of thy faith, but of Me, He says, who have given [what I promise at once] . But if on the other hand I say that I give, and give after an hundred years, and thou hast not despaired ; then hast thou accounted Me worthy to be believed, then thou hast the right opinion concerning Me. Thou seest 134 " Ministering to the Saints^ HoM. 10. that oftentimes unbelief arises not from want of hope only, but also from faintheartedness^ and want of patience, not from condemning him who made the promise. For God (he saith) is not unrighteous to forget your love and the zeal which ye have shewed toward His Name, in that ye have ministered unto the saints, and yet do minister. He testifies great things of them, not deeds only, but deeds 2 Cor. done with alacrity, which he says also in another place, and ^"*' ^' not only so, but they gave themselves also to the Lord and to us. Which (he saith) z/e have shewed toivardHisName,in that ye have ministered to the saints, and yet do minister. See how again he soothes them, by adding and yet do mi- nister. Still even at this time (he says) ye are ministering, and he raises them up by shewing that they had done [what they did] not to them [the saints], but to God. Which ye have shelved (saith he) ; and he said not " unto the saints," but toivards God, for this is toward His Name. It is for His Name's sake (he means) that ye have done all. He ^airoXav- therefore who willingly takes from, you the fruit of ^ so '^^ great zeal and love, will not at any time despise you nor forget you. (4) [7.] Hearing these things, let us, I beseech you, minister to the saints. For every believer is a saint in that he is a believer. Though he be a person living in the world, he 1 Cor. is a saint. For (he saith) the unbelieving husband hath been ^"' * sanctified by the wife, and the unbelieving wife by the hus- ba7id. See how the faith makes the saintship. If then we see even a secular person in misfortune, let us stretch out a hand [to him] . Let us not be good to those only who dwell in the mountains ; they are indeed saints both in life and in faith ; these others however are saints by their faith, and many of them also in life. Let us not, if we see a monk [cast] into prison, in that case go in ; but if it be a secular person, refuse to go in. This last is also a saint and a brother. What then (you say^ if he be unclean and polluted [are S. Matt, we to help him] ? Listen to Christ saying, Judge not that vh. 1. ye be not judged. Do thou act for God's sake. Nay what ShewkindnesseventoJewsandheathens; the Good Samaritan, 135 am I saying ? Even if we see a heathen in misfortune, we HE.vi.i2. ought to shew kindness to him, and to every man without exception who is in misfortunes, and much more to a be- liever who is in the world. Listen to Paul, saying. Do Gal. vi. good unto all men, but especially to those who are of the ^^' household of faith. But I know not whence this [notion] has been intro- duced, or whence this custom hath prevailed. For he that only seeks after the solitaries, and is willing to do good to them alone, and with regard to the others on the contrary is over-curious in his enquiries, and says, '^unless he be ^ worthy % unless he be righteous, unless he work miracles, ^ I stretch out no hand : ' [such an one] has taken away the greater part of charity ^, yea and in time he will in turn ^ f^^^Mo- utterly destroy the very thing itself. And yet that is merciful- charity which [is shewn] towards sinners, towards the guilty. "^^^ ^T For this is charity, not the pitying those who have done ing well, but those who have done wrong. [8.] And that thou mayest understand this, listen to the Parable: A certain man (it saith) went down from Je- S.Lukex. rusalem to Jericho, and fell among thieves : and when they ' ^' had beaten him, they left him by the way-side, having bruised him exceedingly. A certain Levite came, and when he saw him, he passed by ; A priest came, and when he saw him, he hastened past; then a certain Samaritan came, and great was the care he bestowed upon him. For he bound up his lb. 34. ivoimds, dropped oil on them, set him upon his ass, brought him to the inn, said to the host Take care of him (and observe lb. 35. his great liberality) ; and I, says he, will give thee whatso- ever thou shall expend. Who then is his neighbour? He, lb. 37. it is said, that shewed mercy on him. Go thou then also, He saith, and do likeivise. And consider what a parable He spake. He said not that a Jew did [so and so] to a Samaritan, but that a Samaritan displayed all that liber- ality. Having then heard these things, let us not have care only for those that are of the household of faith, and Gal. vi. e 4av iJ-v V ^I'os, eau fi^ 77 SiKaios. read by Mutianus. Ifit be omitted, the Mr. Field retains /i^ in these clauses, passage would run thus, " and says, If in accordance with the common edi- " he be worthy, if he be righteous [I tions, though all theMSS. omit the ne- " will help him] . Unless he work mi- gative in the fii'st clause, and the best " racles I stretch out no hand " &c. ; MSS. in the second also, and it was not which seems to give a good sense. 136 Enquire not out, nor speak of the faults of the afflicted. HoM^JO. neglect the rest. In this way then thyself also, if thou see any man in affliction, be not curious to enquire further. ^rbStKai'- His being in affliction involves a just claim on thy aid ^. fioT}eda5 F^^ if when thou seest an ass choking thou raisest him up, and dost not curiously enquire whose he is, much more about a man one ought not to be over-curious in enquiring whose he is. He is God's, be he heathen or be he Jew ; since even if he is an unbeliever, still he needs assistance. For if indeed it had been committed to thee to enquire and to judge, thou wouldst have well said thus, but, as it is, his misfortune does not suffer thee to search out these things. For if even about men in good health it is not right to be over-curious, nor to be a busy body in other men^s matters, much less about those that are in affliction. [9.] But on another view what [shall we say] ? Didst thou see him in prosperity, in high esteem, that thou shouldst say that he is a wicked and worthless person ? But if thou seest him in affliction, do not say that he is wicked. For when a man is in high credit, we fairly say these things ; but when he is in calamity, and needs help, it is not right to say that he is wicked. For this is cruelty, inhumanity and arrogance. Tell me what was ever more iniquitous than the Jews. But nevertheless while God punished them, and that justly, yea, very justly, yet He approved of those who compassionated them, and those who rejoiced over Amosvi. them He punished. For they ivere not grieved, it is said, at the affliction of Joseph. Prov. And again it is said Redeem [Ransom'] those who are XXIV. 11. y^fj^^y iQ ^g slain : spare not. (He said not, enquire curiously, and learn who he is ; and yet, for the most part, they who are led away to execution are wicked,) for this is in a special way a charity. For he that doeth good to a friend, doeth it not altogether for God's sake : but he that [doeth good] to one who is unknown to him, this man acts purely for God's sake. Do not spare thy money, even if it be ne- cessary to spend all, yet give. 2 hyxo/xe- But we, when we see persons in extreme distress ", bewail- vovs JYig themselves, suffering things more grievous than ten thousand deaths, and oftentimes unjustly, we [I say] are sparing of our money^ and unsparing of our brethren ; we Hopeful patience of the fisherman, and husbandman. 137 are careful of lifeless things, and neglect the living soul. HE.vi.l2. And yet Paul says, in meekness instruct those that oppose 'i Tim. W. i themselves, if peradventure God should give them repent- ' ' i ance to the acknowledging of the truth, and they should | awaken out of the snare of the devil who have been taken \ captive by him, at His will. If peradventure, saith he ; thou seest of how great long-suffering the word is full. Let us also imitate Him, and despair of no one. For the fishermen too, when they have cast many times [sup- \ pose it], have not succeeded; but afterwards having cast I again, have gained all. So we also expect that ye will all i at once shew to us ripe fruit. For the husbandm too,na after he has sown, waits one day or two days, and is a long while in expectation: and all at once he sees the fruits springing up on every side. This we expect will take place in your case also by the grace and mercy of our Lord Jesus Christ, with whom to the Father and also to the Holy I Ghost be glory might honour now and for ever and world without end. Amen. HOMILY XI Heb. vi. 13—16. For when God made promise to Abraham, because He could swear by no greater, He sware by Himself, saying, Surely blessing I will bless thee, and multiplying I will multiply thee. And so after he had patiently endured, he obtained the promise. For men verily swear by the greater, and an oath for confirmation is to them the end of all strife. Having boldly reflected on the faults of the Hebrews, and sufficiently alarmed them, he consoles them, first, by his commendations, and secondly (which also is the stronger ground), by the [thought] that they would certainly attain the objects of their hope. Moreover he draws his consola- tion, not from things future, but again from the past, which indeed had more power to persuade them. For as in the case of punishment, he alarms them rather by those [viz. things future], so also in the case of the prizes [set before them], he encourages them by these [viz. by things past], shewing [herein] God's way of dealing. And that is, not to bring in what has been promised immediately, but after a long interval of time. And this He does, both to present the greatest proof of His own power, and also to lead us to Faith, that they who are lining in tribulation without receiving .the promises, or the rewards, may not faint under their troubles. And omitting all [the rest], though he had many whom he might have mentioned, he brought forward Abraham both on account of the dignity of his person, and because this had occurred in a spebial way in his case. Infra xi. ^^^^ Y^* ^^ *^^^ ^^^ ^^ *^^^ epistle he says, that all these, 13. having seen the j^romises afar off, and having embraced Abraham'' s patient waiting. He sware by Himself. 139 thera, received them not, that they without us should not be HE.vii.i6. made perfect. For when God made promise to Abraham, Icwq'^^* (he saith [here]), since He could swear by no greater, He sware by Himself, saying. Surely blessing I ivill bless thee, and multiplying I will multiply thee. And thus after patiently enduring, he attained the promise. How then does he say at the end [of the Epistle] that he received not the pro- mises, and here, that having patiently endured he obtained the promise ? In what sense did he not receive ? in what sense did he obtain ? He is not speaking of the same things in this place and in the other, but makes his consolation twofold. God made promises to Abraham, and whereas after a long space of time He gave the things [spoken of] in this place, those others [He has] not [given] yet. And so after he had patiently endured, he obtained the promise. Seest thou that the promise alone did not effect the whole, but the patient waiting as well ? In this place he alarms them, pointing out that oftentimes a promise is hindered of its effect through faintheartedness ^. And this i hxiyo. he had indeed shewn through [the instance of] the [Jewish] '/'"X'"" people : for inasmuch as they were fainthearted, for that cause they obtained not the promise. But now he exhibits the contrary, and that in the case of Abraham. Afterwards near the end [of the Epistle] he proves something more also : [viz.] that even though they had patiently endured, they did not attain ; and yet not even so are they indignant. [2.] For men verily sivear by the greater, and an Oath for confirmation is to them an end of all strife. But God because He could swear by no greater, sivare by Himself, Well, who then is He that sware unto Abraham ? Is it not the Son ? No, saith one. Yea indeed most certainly it was He: however I shall not dispute [thereon]. So when He [the Son] sweareth the same oath. Verily, verily, I say unto you, is it not plain that it was from His not being able to swear by any greater ? For as the Father sware, so also the Son sweareth by Himself, saying. Verily, verily, I say unto you. He here reminds them also of the oaths of Christ, which He was constantly uttering. Verily, s. John verily, I say unto thee, he that believeth on Me shall never die. '^^' ^^• What is, And an oath for confirmation is to them- an end 140 God's condescension, a?id accommodatio?i to our iveahiess. HoM.ii. of all strife? it is instead of, "by this every doubtful ques- tion is solved : " not this, or this, but every one. God, however, ought to have been believed eA- en without an oath: (ver. 17) wherein (saith he) God being willing more abundantly to shew unto the heirs of promise the im- 1 6>fo-t- mutability of His counsel, confirmed it [lit. mediated ^] by an oath. In these words he comprehends also the believers. For this cause he mentions also this pro^nise which was made to us [Christians] in common [with them]. He me- diated (saith he) by an oath. Here again he says that the Son was mediator between men and God. (ver. 18) That by two immutable things, in which it was impossible that God should lie. What are these two? The speaking and promising; and the adding an oath to the promise. For inasmuch as among men that which is [con- firmed] by an oath is thought more worthy of credit, on this account He added that also. (2) Thou seest that He regardeth not His own dignity, but how He may persuade men ; and He endures to have un- worthy things said concerning Himself. That is [He did this] wishing to impart full assurance. And in the case of Abraham indeed [the Apostle] shews that the whole was of God, not of his patient enduring, inasmuch as He even endured to add an oath, since He by whom men swear, by Him also God sivare, that is by Himself. They however swear [by Him] as one greater [than themselves], but He as by one not greater. And yet He did it. For it is not the same thing for man to swear by himself, and for God [to do so]. For man has no power over himself. Thou seest then that this is said not more [with refer- ence] to Abraham than to ourselves : that we (saith he) might have strong consolation, ivho have fled for refuge to lay hold on the hope set before us. Here too again % having patiently endured he attained the promise. • 2 €7rej5rj Now lic mcans, and he did not say "when" He swore.^' " at the very time * This ohservation seems to be siig- on the Apostle's statement that this that" gestetl by the words the hope seij)e- oath was made that we might have fore t(s : i.e. this is another instance consolation, we, now, at this time ; of obtaining' a futm'e blessing by pati- not Abraham, to whom the oath was ent waiting-. The next clause bears originally made. Hope as an anchor keeps the soul from drifting. 141 But what the oath is, he plainly shewed, by speaking of the HE.vi.20. swearing by a greater. But since the race of men is hard of belief^ He condescends to the same [things] with our- selves. As then for our sake He swears, although it be unworthy of Him that He should not be believed, so also did [the Apostle] make that other statement : He learned supra v. from the things lohich He suffered, inasmuch as men think ^' this more worthy of reliance — the going through the actual experience [of things] . What is the hope set before us ? from these [past events] (saith he) we conjecture the future. For if these came to pass after so long a time, so certainly these others will. So that the things which happened in regard to Abraham give us confidence also concerning the things that are yet to come. [3.] (ver. 19, 20) Which \hope'\ we have as an anchor of the soul both sure and stedfast, and which entereth into that within the veil : ivhither the forerunner is for us entered, even Jesus, made High Priest for ever after the order of Melchisedec. He points out, that whilst we are still in the world, and not yet departed from [this] life, we are already among the things that have been promised. For through hope we are already in heaven. He had said, '' Wait ; for it shall surely be." Afterwards giving them full assurance, he saith," nay rather by hope" [&c] \ And he said not, " We are within," but " It hath entered within," which plainly was more true and more persuasive. For just as the anchor when it is dropped from the vessel does not allow it to be carried about, even if ten thousand winds agitate it, but being fastened and dropt makes it steady, so also does hope. And see how exceedingly suitable an image he has dis- covered : For he said not. Foundation ; which would not have been suitable ; but. Anchor. For that which is on the surf, and seems not to be very firmly fixed, stands on the water as upon dry land, and is shaken and yet is not shaken. For in regard to those who are very firm, and philosophic, Christ with good reason made that statement, saying. Whosoever [&c.] hath built his house on a rock. s. Matt. But in respect of those who are giving way, and who ought ^'"' ^^' ^ Sav. and Ben. add ^Stj eVuxere, " ye have already attained it." 142 Hope a needed anchor. Forerunner includes us, HoM. 11. to be carried through by hope, Paul hath suitably set down this. For the surge and the great storm toss the boat; but hope suffers it not to be carried hither and thither, although winds innumerable agitate it : so that, unless we had had this [hope] we should have long since been sunk in the sea. Nor is it only in things spiritual, but also in the affairs of this life, that one may find the power of hope great. For instance, in merchandise, in husbandry, in a military expedition, unless a person from the first sets this before him, he would not even touch any work. But he said not simply Anchor, but sure and stedfast [i.e.] not shaken. Which enter eth into that within the veil; instead of "which reacheth through even to heaven.'^ [4.] Then after this' he introduced the Faith also, that there might not only be hope, but an exceeding real and true [hope]. For after the oath he sets down another thing too, even demonstration by facts, in that the fore- runner is for us entered in, even Jesus. But a forerunner is a forerunner of some one, as John was of Christ. Now he did not simply say. He is entered in, but where He is entered in a forerunner for us, as though we also ought to attain to it. For there is no great interval between the forerunner and those who follow : otherwise he would not be a forerunner at all ; since the forerunner and those who follow ought to be in the same road, and to arrive after [each other]. Being made an High Priest for ever after the order, he saith, of Melchisedec. Here is also another consolation, if our High Priest is on high, and far better than those among the Jews, not in the kind [of Priesthood] only, but also in the place, and the tabernjicle, and the covenant, and the person [of the Priest] . And this also is spoken with refer- ence to that which, is according to the flesh. (3) [5.] , It is right then that those whose High Priest He is, should be very greatly superior. And as the difference is great between Aaron and Christ, so great should that be , , ^ which is between us and the Jews. For see, we have our 2 evaia victim ^ on high, our priest on high, our sacrifice^ on high : oVsacrif ^^* ^^ bring such sacrifices as can be offered on that altar, ficing." Sphntual sacrifices preferred from the beginning. 143 no longer sheep and oxen, no longer blood and steamy HE.vi.20. savour. All these things have been done away ; and there has been brought in in their stead the reasonable service. Rom. xii. But what is the reasonable service? the [offerings made] ^' through the soul; those made through the spirit f God, it s.John is said, is a Spirit, and they that worship Him must ivorship ^^'* ^'^^ Him in spirit and in truth); things which have no need of a body, no need of instruments, nor of special places, whereof each one is himself the Priest, such as, moderation, tem- perance, mercifulness, enduring ill-treatment, long-suffer- ing, humbleness of mind. These sacrifices one may see in the Old [Testament] also, shadowed out beforehand from the first. Offer to God, Ps. iv. 5. it is said, a sac7'ifice of righteousness ; Offer a sacrifice of Ps. 1. 14. praise ; and, a sacrifice of praise shall glorify Me, and, the lb. 23. sacrifice of God is a broken spirit ; and ivhat doth the Lord ^^'^ ^■. g require of thee but to hearken to Him.^ Burnt-offerings and Ps.xl.6,7. sacrifices for sin Thou hast had no pleasure in : then I said, Lo I come to do Thy ivill, O God I and again. To what pur- Jerem. pose do ye bring the incense from Sheba? Take thou away Xmos V from Me the sound of thy songs, and I ivill not hear the 23. melody of thy viols. But instead of these I will have mercy Hos.vi.6. and not sacrifice. Thou seest with what kind of sacrifices infra xiii. God is well pleased. Thou seest also that already from the ^^' first the one class have given place, and these others have come in their stead. These therefore let us bring, for those other indeed are [the offerings] of wealth and of persons who have [posses- sions], but these of virtue : those from without, these from within : those any chance person even might perform ; these only a few. And as much as a man is superior to a sheep, so much is this sacrifice superior to that ; for here thou offerest thy soul as a victim. [6.] And other sacrifices also there are, which are indeed whole burnt-offerings, the bodies of the martyrs : there both soul and body [are offered] . These have a great sa- vour of a sweet smell. Thou also art able, if thou wilt, to bring" a sacrifice such as this. For what, if thou dost not burn thy body in the fire ? yet in a different fire thou canst ; for instance, in that of 144 The sacrifices of martyrdom; Self-denial; alms-giving. HoMji. voluntary poverty^ in that of affliction. For to have it in one's power to spend one's days in luxury and expense, and yet to take up a life of toil and bitterness, and to mor- tify the body, is not this a whole burnt -offering ? Do thou mortify thy body, and crucify it, and thou shalt thyself also receive the crown of this martyrdom. For what in the other case the sword accomplishes, that in this case let a willing mind effect. ^ Let not the desire of wealth burn, or possess you. On the contrary let this unreasonable appetite itself be utterly consumed and quenched by the fire of the Spirit ; let it be cut in pieces by the sword of the Spirit. This is an excellent sacrifice, not needing a priest, but only himself who brings it. This is an excellent sacrifice, performed indeed below, but forthwith taken up on high. Are we not amazed that of old time fire used to come down and consume all ? It is possible now also that fire may come down far more wonderful than that, and consume all ' rh. Trpo- fi^Q presented offerings ^ : nay rather, not consume, but bear them up to heaven. For it does not reduce them to ashes, but offers them as gifts to God. [7.] Of such a kind were the offerings of Cornelius. Actsx. YoY (it is said) thy prayers and thine alms are come up for a manorial before God. Thou seest [this] most excellent union. Then are we heard, when we ourselves also hear Prov. the poor who come to us. He (it is said) that stoppeth his ears that he may not hear the poor, his prayer God will not Ps. xl.l. hearken to. Blessed is he that considereth the poor and needy : the Lord will deliver him in the evil day. But what day is evil except that Day, which is an evil day to sinners ? What is meant by he that considereth ? He that under- standeth what it is to be a poor man, that has become thoroughly acquainted with the affliction of the poor man. For he that has become acquainted with his affliction, will certainly and immediately have compassion on him. When thou seest a poor man, do not hasten past, but immediately reflect what thou wouldct have been, hadst thou been he. What wouldst thou not have wished that all should do for thee ? He that considereth (saith he). Reflect that he is Si7i and clanger of not sympathising with the Poor, 145 a free-man like thyself, and shares the same noble birth ^E.vi.20. with thee, and possesses all things in common with thee ; and yet oftentimes he is not on a level even with thy dogs. On the contrary, while they have their full, he often-times lies down to sleep in hunger, and the free-man is more dishonoured than thy slaves. But they perform needful services for thee. What, I ask, are these ? That they serve thee well ? Suppose then I shew that this [poor man] too performs services in thy need, far greater than they do. For he will stand by thee in the Day of judgement, and will deliver thee from the fire. What do all thy slaves do that is like this ? When Tabitha died, who raised her up ? the slaves who stood around or the poor ? But thou art not willing to put the free-man on an equality even with thy slaves. The frost is hard, and the poor man is cast [on the ground] in rags, well-nigh dead, with his teeth chattering, both by his looks and his dress calculated to move thee : and thou passest by, warm and full of drink; and how dost thou expect that God should deliver thee when thou art in misfortune ? And oftentimes thou sayest this too : " If it had been myself, and I had found one that had done many wrong things, I would have forgiven him ; and does not God for- give ?'' Say not this. Him that has done thee no wrong, whom thou art able to deliver, him thou neglectest. How shall He forgive thee, who art sinning against Him ? Is not this deserving of hell ? And how amazing! Oftentimes a body that is dead, insensible, no longer perceiving the honour [done to it], thou adornest with vestments innumerable, of varied colours and wrought with gold ; whilst that which is in pain, and lamenting, and tormented, and racked, by hunger and frost, thou neglectest; and givest more to vain glory, than to the fear of God. [8.] And would that it stopped here; but immediately accusations are brought against him who applies [for aid] ? For why does he not work (you say) ? and why is he to be maintained in idleness ? But (tell me) is it by working that thou hast what thou hast, didst thou not receive it as an inheritance from thy fathers ? And even if thou dost VOL. VII. L. 146 Charges brought against beggars cruel and foolish, HoM.ii. work, is this a reason why thou shouldest reproach an- other ? Hearest thou not what Paul saith ? For after 2 Thess. saying, He that worketh not, neither let him eat, he says, lb. 13. ^^^ y^^ ^^ y^ ^^^ weary in ivell doing. (4) But what say they ? He is an impostor^. What sayest eineeT'ns thou, o man ? callest thou him an impostor, for the sake of a single loaf or of a garment ? But (you say) he will sell it immediately. And dost thou manage all thy affairs to perfection ? But what ? are all poor through idleness ? is no one so from a shipwreck ? none from lawsuits ? none from being robbed ? none from dangers ? none from ill- ness ? none from any other difficult circumstances ? If however we hear any one bewailing such evils, and crying out vehemently, and looking up naked towards heaven, and with his hair long, and clad in rags, at once we call him. The impostor ! the deceiver ! the swindler ! Art thou not ashamed ? Whom dost thou call impostor ? Give nothing, and do not accuse the man. But (you say) he has means, and yet makes himself this figure. This is a charge against thyself, not against him. He knows that he has to deal with cruel people, with wild beasts rather than with men, and that, even if he utter a pitiable story, he attracts no one's attention : And on this account he is forced to assume also a more miserable guise, that he may melt thy soul. If we see a person coming to beg in a respectable dress. This is an impostor (you say), and he comes in this way that he may be supposed to be of good birth. If we see one in the contrary guise, him too we think dishonest. What then are they to do ? O the cruelty, O the inhumanity ! And why (you say) do they expose their maimed limbs ? Because of thee. If we were compassionate, they would have no need of these artifices : if they persuaded us at the first application, "they would not have adopted so many arti- fices. W>xO is there so wretched, as to be willing to cry out so much, as to be willing to behave in an unseemly way, as to be willing to make public lamentation, with his wife destitute of clothing, wi^h his children, to sprinkle ashes on himself. How much worse than poverty are these things ? Our own need of food and of forgiveness. 147 Yet on account of them not only are they not pitied, but He.v-.'jo. are even accused by us. [9.] Shall we still then be indignant, because when we pray to God, we are not listened to ? Shall we then still be vexed, because when we entreat we do not persuade ? Do we not tremble for fear, my beloved ? But (you say) I have often given. And art thou not always eating ? and dost thou drive away thy children that are often begging of thee ? O the shamelessness ! Dost thou call a poor man shameless ? And whilst thou art not shame- less when plundering, he is shameless when begging for bread ! Considerest thou not how great are the necessities of the belly ? Dost not thou do all things for this ? dost thou not for this neglect things spiritual ? Is not heaven set before thee and the kingdom of heaven ? and thou fearing the tyranny of that [ap petite] endurest all things, and think- est lightly of that [kingdom] . This is shamelessness. Seest thou not old men maimed ? But O what trifling ! " Such an one (you say) lends out so many pieces of gold, and such an one so many, and yet begs." You repeat the stories and trifles of children ; for they too are always hearing stories of this kind from their nurses. I am not persuaded of it. I do not believe this. God forbid it should be so. Does a man lend out money, and so go a begging when he has abundance ? For what purpose, tell me ? And what is more disgraceful than begging ? It were better to die than to beg. Where does our inhumanity stop ? [And if it be so] what then? Do all lend money? are all impostors? is there no one really poor ? " Yea (you say) and many." Why then dost thou not assist those persons, seeing thou art so strict an enquirer into their lives ? All this is an excuse and a pretence. Give to every one that asketh of thee, and from him that S. Matt. would borrow of thee turn not thou away. Stretch out thy ^' ^^* hand, let it not be closed up. We have not been consti- tuted examiners into men^s lives, since so we should have compassion on no one. Why is it that when thou callest upon God thou sayest. Remember not my sins ? So then, if that person even be an exceeding great sinner, make this allowance in his case also, and do not remember his sins. L 2 148 God^s mercifulness. Professed Monks and Clergy, HoM. 11. It is the season of kindness not of strict enquiry ; of mercy not of calculation. He wishes to be maintained : if thou art willing, give [him something] ; but if thou art not will- ing, send him away without adding questions to put him Va^"" ^^ ^ difficulty ^. Why art thou wretched and miserable ? why dost thou not even thyself pity him, and also turnest away those who would ? For when such a one hears from thee. This [fellow] is a cheat ; that a hypocrite ; and the other lends out money ; he neither gives to the one nor to the other ; for he suspects all to be such. For you know that we easily suspect evil, but good, not [so easily]. S. Luke [10.] Let us be merciful, not simply so, but as our hea- venly Father is. He feeds even adulterers, and fornicators, and sorcerers, and what shall I say ? persons having every species of wickedness. For in so large a world there must of necessity be many such as well [as others] . But never- theless He feeds all ; He clothes all. No one ever perished of hunger, unless one did so of his own choice. In this way let us be merciful. If a person be in want and in ne- cessity, help him. But now as it is, we are come to such a degree of unrea- sonableness, as to act thus not only in regard to the poor who walk up and down the alleys, but even in the case of T«r ^^^^ ^^^^ ^^^^ ^^ [religious] solitude ^. Such an one is an avSpuu impostor, you say. Did I not say this at first, that if we give to all indiscriminately, we shall always be compassion- ate; but if we begin to make over-curious enquiries, we shall never be compassionate ? What dost thou mean ? is a man an impostor in order to get a loaf? If indeed he asks for talents of gold and silver, or costly clothes, or slaves, or anything else [of this sort], one might with good reason call him a swindler. But if he ask none of these things, but only food and shelter, things which are suited to a phi- losophic life % tell me, is this the part of a swindler ? Cease we from this unseasonable fondness for meddling, which is Satanic, which is soul-destroying. For indeed, if a man say that he is on the list of the Clergy, or calls himselfs^ Priest, then busy thyself [to en- ■^ 6 (f)i\o(ro(pUs 4ar\, i.e. of the ascetics or solitary life. God looks to our dispositions, not those lue relieve, 149 quire] , make much ado : since in that case the communi- HE.vi.20. eating ^ without enquiry is not without danger. For the ^ ^oivuvia risk is about matters of importance, for thou dost not give but receivest. But if he want food, make no enquiry. Make enquiry, if thou wilt, how Abraham displayed his hospitality towards all who came to him^ If he had been over-curious about those who came to him for refuge, he would not have entertained angels. For perhaps not think- Infra ing them to be angels, he would have thrust away them too with the rest. But inasmuch as he was used to receive all, he received even angels. What? Is it from the life of those that receive [thy bounty] that God grants thee thy reward? Nay [it is] from thine own purpose, from thy abundant liberality; from thy lovingkindness ; from thy goodness. Let this be [found], and thou shalt attain all good things, which may we all attain, through the grace and mercy of our Lord Jesus Christ, with Whom to the Father and also to the Holy Ghost, be glory power honour, now and for ever and world without end. Amen. HOMILY XII. Heb. vii. 1 — 3. For this Melchisedec, King of Saletn, Priest of the most High God, who met Abraham as he ivas returning from the slaughter of the Kings, and blessed him : to whom also Abraham gave a tenth part of all ; first being by i?iter- pretation King of Righteousness, and after that also King of Salem, which is, King of Peace, loithout father, ivith- out mother, without genealogy, having neither beginning of days, nor end of life, but made like unto the Son of God, abideth a Priest continually, Paul wishing to shew the difference between the New and Old Covenant^ introduces the subject in many different places; and shoots from afar, and ringeth in the ears of 1 StoKwSw- r]^jg-| hearers ^. and exerciseth beforehand. For at once, even from the introduction of the Ej^istle, he laid down supra i. this as a foundation, saying, that to them indeed He spake by prophets, to us by The Son, and to them at sundry times and in divers manners, to us through the Son. Afterwards, having discoursed concerning the Son, who He was and what He had wrought, and given an exhortation to obey Him, lest we should suffer the same things as the Jews ; lb. vi. 20. and having said that He is High Priest after the order of Melchisedec, and having oftentimes wished to enter into [the subject of] this diiference, and having used much pre- paratory management ; and having rebuked them as weak, and again soothed and recovered them to feelings of confi- dence ; then at last he introduces the discussion on the difference [of the two dispensations] to ears [as it were] The superiority of Melchizedek^s Priesthood, Titles. 151 in their full vigour. For he who is depressed in spirits H^-^^-^' would not be a ready hearer. And that you may under- stand thisj hear the Scripture which saith, They hearkened ^ ' ^^' not to Moses for littleness of spirit ^. For this cause having ^ 0X170 first cleared away their despondency by many considera- l^^j'"" tions, some fearful, some more gentle, he then from this hearted- point .enters upon the discussion of the difference [of the **^** dispensations] . [2.] And what saith he ? For this Melchisedec, King of Salem, Priest of the Most High God. And, what is espe- cially worthy of admiration, he shews the difference to be great by the Type itself. For as I [before] said, he con- tinually confirms the truth from the Type, from things past, on account of the weakness of the hearers. For (saith he) this Melchisedec, King of Salem, Priest of the Most High God, ivho met Abraham returning from the slaughter of the Kings, and blessed him, to ivhom also Abraham assigned a tenth part of all. Having concisely set down the whole narrative, he contemplated ^ it mystically. pt](tT' And first from the name. First (saith he) being by inter- drew out pr elation King of righteousness : for Sedec means righteous- ^l^^"^^' ness; and Melchi, iiCi/i^ ; Melchisedec, King of j^ighteousness. senses. Thou seest his exactness even in the names ? But who is King of righteousness, save our Lord Jesus Christ ? King of righteousness. And after that also King of Salem, from his city, that is. King of Peace, which again is [character- istic] of Christ. For He has made us righteous, and has made peace for things in Heaven and things on earth. What Col. i. 20. man is King of Righteousness and of Peace ? None, save only our Lord Jesus Christ. [3.] He then adds another distinction, Without father, without mother, ivithout genealogy, having neither beginning of days nor end of life, but made like unto the Son of God, abideth a priest continually . Since then there lay in his way [as an objection] the [words] Thou art a Priest for ever, after the order of Melchisedec, whereas he [Melchi- sedec] was dead, and was not Priest for ever, see how he exj)lained it mystically. 'And who can say this concerning a man^? I do not assert this in fact (saith he) ; the meaning is, we do not know 152 In luhat sense ivithout Father ^c. Figure and Reality. HoM. 12. when ^ [or] what father he had, nor what mother, nor when he received his beginning, nor when he came to an end. And what of this (saith one) ? for does it follow, because we do not know it, that therefore he did not die, [or] had no parents ? Thou sayest well : he both died and had parents. In what sense then [was he] without father, ivithout mother? In what sense having neither beginning of days nor end of life ? In what sense? [why] from its not lata'i ^^i^g expressed ^. And what of this ? That just as this man is so, from his genealogy not being given, so is Christ from the very nature of the reality. (2) See here is the without beginning. See here is the ivithout end. As in case of this man, we know not either begin- ning of days, or end of life, because they have not been written; so we know [them] not in the case of Jesus, not because they have not been written, but because they do not 2 Tirros exist. For that indeed is a figure ^, and therefore [we say] 3 axrideia ^bccausc it is not written,^ but this is the reality ^, and there- fore [we say] ' because it does not exist.' For just as in regard to the names also (for there King of Righteousness and of Peace are appellations, but here the reality of things actually existing) so these too are appellations in that case, in this the reality of things actually existing. In what sense then hath He a beginning ? Thou seest that the Son ^ &uapxov is without beginning ^, not in respect of His not having a 5 cuTiou cause ^, for this is impossible : for He has a Father, other- wise how is He Son ? but in respect of His not having be- ginning or end of life. But made like unto the Son of God. Where is the like- ness ? That we know not of the one or of the other either the end or the beginning. Of the one because they are not written ; of the other, because they do not exist. Here is the likeness. But if the likeness were to exist in all res- pects, there would no longer be figure and reality ; but both 6 eiKSpwv would be figure. [Here] then just as in representations^'^ « Mr. Field reads trSTe making a in painting ; the word ef/cwi/, as our double question. The other eTiitions " likeness," being applicable to both, have -TTOTe " at all." The passage is considerably altered in '' The comparison is not between the the conimon editions so as to avoid living object and the picture, but be- an apparent difficulty, tween representations in drawing and His superiority implied inreceiving Tithes and in Blessi7ig . 153 [by painting or drawing] , there is somewhat that is like and HE.vii.5. somewhat that is unlike. By means of the lines indeed there is a likeness of features ^, but when the colours are ^ X"pa- put on, then the difference is plainly shewn, and [that] part is like and part is unlike. [4.] ver. 4. Noiv consider (saith he) hoiv great this man is to whom even the Patriarch Abraham gave the tenth of the spoils -. Up to this point he has been applying the type : ^ <^hoice henceforward he confidently shews him [Melchisedec] to be more glorious than the very realities which existed among the Jews. But if he who bears a type of Christ is so much better not merely than the priests, but even than the forefather himself of the priests, what should one say of the reality ? Thou seest from what a superabundance [of proof] he shews the superiority. Now consider (saith he) how great this man is to lohom even the Patriarch Abraham gave a tenth out of the choice por- tions. Spoils [taken in battle] are called choice port ions ■\ ^««po- And it cannot be said that he gave them to him as having a part in the war, for on this account (he said) he met him returning from the slaughter of the kings, for he had staid at home (he means), and yet [Abraham] gave him the first- fruits of his labours. ver. 5. And verihj that are of the sons of Levi who receive the office of Priesthood, have commandment to take tithes of the people according to the law, that is, of their brethren, although they are come out of the loins of Abraham. So great (he would say) is the superiority of the priesthood, that they who from their ancestors are of the same dignity, and have the same forefather, are yet far better than the rest. At all events they receive tithe from them. When then one is found, who receives tithes from these very per- sons, are not they indeed in the rank of laymen, and he among the Priests ? And not only this ; but neither was he of the same dig- nity with them, but of another race : so that he would not have given tithes to a stranger unless his dignity had been great. Astonishing ! what has he accomplished ? He has made quite clear a greater point than those relating to faith which he treated in the Epistle to the Romans. For there 154 Great superiority of Melchizedek, type of Christ. HoM. 12. indeed he declares Abraham to be the first father both of our polity and also of the Jewish. But here he is exceed- ing bold against him, and shews that the uncircumcised person is far superior. How then did he shew that Levi paid tithes ? Abraham (saith he) paid them. ' And how does this concern us ? ' It most particularly concerns you : for you will not be so contentious as to say that the Levites are superior to Abraham, ver. 6. But he whose descent is not counted from them, received tithes of Abraham. And after that he did not simply pass on, but added, and blessed him that had the promises. Inasmuch as through- out, this it was that was regarded with reverence, he shews that Melchisedec was to be reverenced more than Abraham, from the common judgment of all men. (ver. 7) And ivith- out all contradiction, saith he, the inferior is blessed by the superior, i. e. in the opinion of all men it is the inferior that is blessed by the superior. So then the type of Christ is superior even to him that had the promises, (ver. 8) And here men that die receive tithes : but there he ofivhom it is testified that he liveth. However lest we should say, Tell us, why goest thou so far back ? he says, (ver. 9) And as I may so say (and he did welLin [thus] softening it) Levi also who receiveth tithes was tithed in Abraham, How ? (ver. 10) For he was yet in his loins when Melchisedec met him, i. e. Levi was in him, although he was not yet born. And he said not the Levites but Levi. Hast thou seen the exceeding superiority ? Hast thou seen how great is the interval between Abraham and Mel- chisedec, who bears the figure of our High Priest ? And he shews that the superiority had been caused by authority, not necessity. For the one paid the tithe, which indicates the priest: the other gave the blessing, which indicates the superior. This superiority passes on also to the descendants. In a marvellous and triumphant way he cast out the supra V. Jewish [system]. On this account he said. Ye are become dull, inasmuch as he wished to lay these foundations, that they might not start away. Such you see is the wisdom of ^Jfxpd\. Paul, first preparing theih well, he so leads ^ them into what he wishes. For the human race is hard to persuade, and needs much attention, even more than plants. Since in that 12. Ail Salvation depends on ourselves. 155 case there is [only] the nature of material bodies, and earth, HE.vii.iO . which yields to the hands of the husbandmen: but in this there is will, which is liable to many alterations, and now prefers this, now that. For it readily inclines to the side of evil. [5.] .Wherefore we ought always to guard ourselves, lest (^\ at any time we should fall oft' to slumber. For Lo (saith one) he that keepeth Israel shall neither slumber nor sleep, Ps. cxxi. and Bo not suffer^ thy foot to be moved. He did not say, ^• ^^ be not moved '^ but do not thou suffer, &c. It depends then on ourselves to allow [this], and not on any other person. For if we are willing to stand stedfast and unmove- i Cor. able, we shall not be shaken. ^''' ^^• What then ? does nothing depend on God ? All indeed depends on God, but not so as that our free-will is im- paired. ^ If then it depend on God (saith one), why does He blame us' ? on this account I said, ^so as that our free- will is not impaired.' It depends then on us, and on Him. For we must first choose what is good ; and then He j contributes what [comes] from Himself^. He does not T^Trap'^' anticipate our wishes ^\ lest our free-will should be impaired, ^"-y^o^^ But when we have made our choice, then great is the assist- ^ ^^^ ance He contributes to us. How is it then that Paul saith, not of him that ivilleth, Rpm. ix. if it depend on ourselves also, nor of him that runneth, but of God that sheiveth- mercy ? In the first place, he did not introduce it as his own opinion, but inferred it from what was before him and from what had been put forward^ [in the discussion]. For after •^ In Psalm cxxi. 3 (cxx. 3. Sept.) Israel ought not to slumber or sleep, where we have " He shall not suffer " The Alex. MS. has wcnil^i in the &c. the LXX. have, ju)? S&jtjs eis aoKov third verse. Thv '!T6^a hies in war, has his right hand J [S. Cyril Alex, speaks too of those have nought to bring to tlieir Master, who put off Baptism till they are old Glaph. 273 b c] and receive forgiveness through it but Contr^ast between being just saved, and highest in glorij. 171 stained with blood ; then when the time arrives, suppose HE.vii.28. that (from the same rank in which the thief also was) he is at once conducted to the imperial throne and the purple ; but suppose that the other remains there where he was, and merely of the royal mercy does not pay the penalty of his deeds, let him however be in the last place, and let him be stationed under him who is [now] a King. Tell me, will he be able to endure his despair when he sees him who was [ranked] with himself ascended even to the very highest point of dignities, and made thus glorious, and master of the world, while he himself still remains below, and has not even been freed from punishment with honour, but through the grace and mercifulness of the King ? For even should the King forgive him, and release him from the charges against him, still will he live in shame ; For surely not even will others admire him : since in such instances of forgiveness, we admire not those who receive the gifts, but those who bestow them. And in such proportion as the gifts are greater, the more are they ashamed who re- ceive them, when what they have done amiss is great. With what eyes then will such an one be able to look on those who are in the King's courts, when they exhibit their sweatings out of number and their wounds, whilst he has nothing to shew, but has his being saved itself of the mere lovingkindness of God ? For just as if one were to beg off a murderer, a thief, an adulterer, when he was going to be led away for execution, and were to command him to stay at the porch of the King's palace, he will not afterwards be able to look any man in the face, although he has been set free from punishment : so too without ques- tion is this man's case. For do not, I beseech you, suppose that because it is called a palace ^, therefore all are to attain the same things. ^ ^«o-'- For if here in Kings' courts there is the Prefect, and all who but Sav. are about the King, and also those who are in very inferior ^«^iAeia, stations, and occupy the place of what are called Decani ^ dom. (though the interval be so great between the Prefect and the k " The Ae/caj/ol at Constantinople Jamqiie ordine certo were liotors, and had the charg-e of Tiu-ba decanorum, cursorum, in rebus burying the dead : they are otherwise ag-entum, called fimerumelato7'es,lecticarit,ves- Cumque palatinis stans Candida turba pUlones, libitinarU, KOTTiarai. CoriY>^ns tribunis." Suicer, Thes. Eccles. lib. iii. says cited by Mr, Field. 172 God^s commandments not burdensome :^ Instances. HoM. 13. Decanus) much more shall this be so in the royal court above. And this I say not of myself. For Paul layeth down an- other difference greater even than these. For (saith he) as many differences as there are [in passing] from the sun to the moon and the stars, and the very smallest star, so many also [will be the differences] of those in the kingdom of Heaven] . And that the difference between the sun and the smallest star is far greater than that between the De- canus (as he is called) and the Prefect, is evident to all. For while the sun shines upon all the world at once, and makes it bright, and puts out of sight the moon and the stars, the other perhaps does not even appear, not even in the dark. For there are many stars w^hich we do not see. When then we see others become suns, and ourselves have the rank of the very smallest stars, which are not even visible, what comfort shall we have ? Let us not, I beseech you, let us not be so slothful, let us not be so inert, let us not barter away the salvation of God on an easy life, but let us make merchandise of it, and increase it. For even if a person be only a Catechumen, still he knows Christ, still he is acquainted with the Faith, still he is a hearer of the divine oracles, still he is not far from the knowledge. He knows the will of his Lord. Wherefore then does he procrastinate? wherefore does he delay and postpone ? Nothing is better than a good life whether here or there, whether in case of the Enlightened or of the Catechumens. [11.] For tell me what burdensome command have we enjoined you ? Have a wife (saith He) and be chaste. Is this difficult ? How ? when many, not Christians only but Heathens also, live chastely without a wife. That which 1 iirepfiai- the heathen goes beyond ^ for vain glory^s sake, thou dost "^^ not even keep for tlie fear of God. Give (saith He) to the poor out of what thou hast. Is this burdensome ? But in this case also heathen condemn us, who for vain-glory only have emptied out their whole possessions. ^ Use not filthy language. Is this difficult? For if it had not been enjoined, ought we not to have done right in this respect, to avoid appearing degraded ? For that the con- Yet every thing burdensome ivhen good ivill is wanting, 173 trary conduct is against the grain, I mean the using filthy HE.vii.28 . language, is manifest from the fact that the soul is ashamed and blushes if it have been led to say any thing of that kind, and it will not even utter such things, unless by chance a man be drunk. For when sitting in a public place, even if thou doest it at home why dost thou not do it there ? Because of those that are present. Why dost thou not readily do the same thing before thy wife? That thou mayest not insult her. So then thou abstainest from doing it, lest thou shouldest insult thy wife ; and dost thou not blush at insulting God ? For He is every where present, and heareth all things. Be not drunken, saith He. For this very thing of itself, is it not a chastisement ? He did not say. Put thy body on the rack, but what ? Do not make it so wild ^ as to take ^ifcrpax-n- away the authority of the mind : on the contrary make not ^'^^^ provision for the lusts thereof. xiii. 14. Do not (saith He) seize by violence what is not thine own ; do not over-reach ; perjure not thyself. What la- bours do these things require ! what sweatings ! Speak evil of no man (saith He) nor accuse [any] falsely. What toil is there here? Nay rather the contrary is a ' labour. For when thou hast spoken ill of another, imme- diately thou art in danger, in suspicion, [saying] Did he of whom I spake, hear ? whether he be great or small. For should he be a great man immediately thou wilt be indeed in danger ; but if small, he will requite thee with as much, or rather with what is far more grievous ; for he will say evil of thee in a much greater degree. It is nothing diffi- cult, nothing burdensome which we have enjoined on us, if we have the will. And if we have not the will, even the easiest things will appear burdensome to us. What is more easy than eating ? but from great effeminacy many persons make a difficulty even of this, and I hear many say, that it is weariness even to eat. None of these things is wearisome if thou hast but the will. For every thing depends on the will- ing, after the grace from above. Let us then be willing to do things that are good, that we may attain also to the good things which are eternal, in Christ Jesus our Lord, whom to the Father and also to the Holy Ghost be glory, might honour now and for ever, and world without end. Amen. HOMILY XIV. Heb. viii. 1, 2. Now of the things which ive have spoken this is the sum. We have such an High Priest ; who is set down at the right hand of the throne of the majesty in the heavens : a minister of the sanctuary and of the true tabernacle which the Lord pitched, and not man. Paul mixes the lowly things with the lofty, ever imitat- ing his own Master, so that Avhat is lowly becomes the path to what is lofty, and through the former we are led by the hand to the other, and when we are amid the great things we learn that these [lowly ones] were a condescension. This accordingly he does here also. After declaring that He offered up Himself, and shewing Him to be a High Priest, what does he say ? But as the sum of ivhat has been spoken, we have such an High Priest, who is set doivn on the right hand of the throne of the majesty. And yet this is not [the act] of a Priest, but of Him to whom the other ought to be Priest. A minister of the sanctuary, not simply a minister but a minister of the sanctuary. And of the true Tabernacle, which the Lord pitched and not man. Thou seest the condescen- ' See sion. Did he not a little before make a wdde separation ^, supm l" saying : Are they not all ministering spirits ? and for this 14. cause (he saith) it is not said to them, Sit thou on my right ' ' hand, on the view that He that sitteth is not a minister. How is it then that he here says, a minister, and a minister of the Sanctuary ? for he means here the Tabernacle. See how he raised up the minds of those Jews who be- lieved. For as it was likely that they would b^e imagining, that we have no such tabernacle [as they had], see here Chris fs Priesthood real ; iiecessarnly exercised in Heaven, 175 (saith he) is our Priest, Great, yea, much greater than that HE.viii.3. other, and who has offered a more admirable sacrifice. But [they might say] is not all this mere talk ? is it not a boast, and merely said to win over our minds ? on this account he established it first from the oath, and afterwards also from the tabernacle. For this difference too was manifest : but the Apostle thinks of another also besides, which (saith he) the Lord pitched [or made firm] and not man. Where are they who say that the heaven whirls round ^ ? where are they who declare that it is spherical ? for both of these notions are overthrown here. But (saith he) for the sum of what has been spoken. By the sum is always meant what is most important. Again he brings down his discourse ; having said what is lofty, henceforward he speaks fearlessly. [2.] In the next place that thou mayest understand that he used the word minister of the manhood, observe how he again gives a further intimation of it : For (saith he) every high priest is ordained to offer both gifts and sacri- fices, ivheref ore it is necessary that this one also have some- lohat to offer. Do not now, because thou hearest that He sitteth, sup- pose that His being called High Priest is mere idle talk ^ ^ '''^'^'"' For the former, viz. His sitting, belongs to the dignity of the Godhead-, but this other to His great loving-kindness ' T^sa^i- toward man, and His tender care for us. On this account ©jr he repeatedly urges'^ this very thing, and particularly dwells ' ^'^"'"^^ upon it : for he feared lest that other [truth] should over- throw it^. On this account he again brings down his discourse to this subject: since some were enquiring for what purpose He died. He was a Priest. But there is no Priest without a sacrifice. It is necessary then that He also should have a sacrifice. And in another way ; Having said that He is on high, he affirms and proves that He is a Priest from every con- sideration, from Melchisedec, from the oath, from offering * Sive?o-0at. The common editions Sun Moon and Stars moved throug-h it. read kiueladai. Savile observes that •> That is, lest the belief of His God- it was the opinion of S.Chrys. that the head should undermine our belief in heaven was stationary, and that the His true Manhood. 176 Our Sacraments and Services are the Heavenly things, HoM. 14. sacrifice. From this last point he next frames another necessary syllogism. For if (saith he) He had been on earth, He would not be a Priest, seeing that there are priests who offer the gifts according to the Law, If then He is a Priest (as He really is), we must seek some other place for Him. For if He had been indeed 07i earth, He ivould not have been a priest. For how [could He be] ? He offered no sacrifice, He ministered not in the Priest's office. And with good reason, for there were the priests. Moreover he shews, that it was not even possible that [He] should be a priest upon earth. For how [could He be] ? There was no rising up against [the appointed Priests], he means. [3.] At this point it is necessary to apply our minds at- tentively, and to consider the Apostolic wisdom. For again he points out the difference of the Priesthood. JVho (he saith) serve the example ^ and shadow of the heavenly things. What are the heavenly things he is here speaking of? The spiritual things. For although they are performed on earth, yet are they nevertheless worthy of the Heavens. ^ eay- For whcn our Lord Jesus Christ lies slain ^ [as a sacrifice], Revfv.^r when the Spirit is with us ^, when He who sitteth on the 9,i2.xiii. right hand of the Father is here^, when sons are made by 2'jrapayl- tlic Washing, when they are fellow-citizens of those in vvrat ^ Heaven, when we have a country, and a city [a home], and ^ej/Tov. o ^j^^2;enship there, when we are strangers as to things here, * how can all these be other than heavenly things? But what ! Are not our Hymns heavenly ? Is it not [the fact] that the very things which the divine choirs of unbodied powers sing on high, these we also who are below utter in concert with them? Is not the altar also heavenly ? How? It hath nothing carnal, all the things which are placed there ^ be- come spiritual. The sacrifice does not disperse into ashes, or into smoke, or into steamy savour, it makes [the elements] that are placed there bright and splendid. How again can the rites which we celebrate be other than heavenly ? For s. John when He says. Whosoever sins ye retain they are retained, XX. 23. •= v-iro^elyiJ.ari Xarpevovcri. " shadow," i.e. " do service to and minister in *■ to irpoKelfxeva. The Sacred Ele- " that system which is a sample and ments there set before God. All tended to shew the superiority of the New Covenant, 177 \ ivhosoever sins ye remit, they are remitted : when they HE.viii.6. • have the keys of heaven, how can all be other than \ heavenly ? Who (saith he) serve the sample and shadow of heavenly things, as Moses ivas teamed, ivhen he was about to finish \ the tabernacle, for see, saith He, thou shall make all things '\ according to the pattern shelved to thee in the mount. In- asmuch as our hearing is less ready of apprehension than our sight (for the things which we hear we do not in such \ wise lay up in our soul, as those which we see with our very eyes}, He shewed him all. Either then it is this that he means by the sample and shadow, or else he [speaks] of the Temple. For, he went on to say, ^ee (His words are), , thou shall make all things according to the pattern^ shewed ^rvirov \ to thee in the mount. Was it then only what concerned the I furniture of the temple that he saw, or was it also what J related to the sacrifices, and all the rest ? Nay, one would j not be wrong in saying even this ; for The Church is hea- venly, and is nothing else than Heaven. [4.] (ver. 6) But now hath He obtained a more excellent ministry ^, by how much also He is Mediator of a better ^^''^o'^P- \ covenant. Thou seest (he means) how much better is the vice as I one ministration than the other, if one be a sample and ^''^^** figure, and the other truth [and reality] . But this did not \ at all profit the hearers, nor cheer them. On this account 1 then he says what especially cheered them : Which has been established upon better promises. Having raised them up by speaking of the place, and the priest, and the sacri- fice, he next lays down also the wide difference of the covenants, having indeed before also said that [the first] was weak and unprofitable. see supra And observe what safeguards he sets down, when in- * ' ! tending to find fault with it. For in that other place after \ saying, according to the power of an endless life, he then supra , said that there is a disannulling of the commandment going ijJJ'jg/ | before; and then after that, he set forth somewhat great, saying, by which ive draw nigh unto God. And in this place, ib. 19. after leading us up into Heaven, and shewing that instead of the temple, we have Heaven, and that those things were • figures of ours, and having by these means exalted the j VOL. VII. N i 178 The New Covenant ; the better promises. HoM.14. Ministration [of the New Covenant]^ he then proceeds naturally to exalt the priesthood. But (as I said) he sets down that which especially cheers them, in the words, Which has been established upon better promises. Whence does this appear? Inasmuch as the one was cast out, and the other introduced in its place : for the reason why it is of force is that it is better. For supi-a vii. just as he says. If perfection were by it, lohat further need ^^' were there, that a different priest should arise, after the order of Melchisedec ? so also in this place he used the same syllogism saying (ver. 7) For if that first covenant had been faultless, there should have been no place sought for the second; [faultless'], that is, if it made men faultless. For it is because he is speaking of this that he did not say, But finding fault ivith it, but (ver. 8, 9) But finding fault with them. He saith, Behold, the days come, saith the Lord, when I will make a new covenant with the house of Israel and with the house of Judah: not according to the covena it that I made with their fathers in the day when I took them by the hand to lead them out of the land of Egypt: because they continued not in My covenant, and I regarded them not, saith the Lord. Yea verily. And whence does it appear that [the first Covenant] came to an end ? He shewed it indeed also from the Priest, but now he shews more clearly by express words that it has been cast out. But how is it upon better promises ? For in what way, tell me, can earth and heaven be equal ? But do thou con- sider % how he speaks of promises there [in that other cove- nant] also, that thou mayest not bring this charge against ib. 19. it. For in that former place also, he says a better hope, by which ive draw nigh unto God, indicating that there was a Hope there also ; and in this place better promises, inti- mating that there also He had made promises. But inasmuch as they were for ever making objections, he says. Behold! the days come, saith the Lord, when I will establish a new covenant with the house of Israel and with the house of Judah, He is not speaking of any old " 0€(ipei used of contemplating and discerning' tlie mystical sense of the Old Testament. The New Covenant expressly promised; is the Christian. 179 Covenant : for, that they might not have [occasion] to heMu.10. assert this, he determined the time also. Thus he did not say simply, according to the covenant which I made with their fathers, lest thou shouldest say [it was] the one made with Abraham, or that with Noah : but he declares what [covenant it was], not according to the covenant which I made ivith their fathers in the Exodus. Wherefore he added also, in the day that I took them by the hand, to lead them forth out of the land of Egypt; because they continued not in My covenant, and I regarded them not, saith the Lord. Thou seest that the evils begin first £rom ourselves (they themselves first, saith he, continued not in [the covenant^ ) and the negligence is from ourselves, but the good things from Him; I mean the [acts] of loving-kindness. He here introduces, as it were, an apology shewing the cause why He forsakes them. [5.] (ver. 10) For this, saith he, is the covenant which I will make with the house of Israel after those days, saith the Lord; I will put ^ My laws into their heart, and on their miyids will ^ give I lurite them, and I ivill be to them a God, and they shall be to Me a people. Thus it is concerning the New [covenant] that He says this, because His words are, 7iot according to the covenant which I covenanted. But what other difference is there beside this^? Now if any person should say that the difference is not in this respect, but in respect to its being put into their hearts ; [saying that] He makes no mention of any difference of ordinances^ but points out the mode of its being given : for no longer (he saith) shall the covenant be in writings, but in hearts ; let the Jew in that case shew that this was ever carried into effect. However he would not find it [possible to do so] ; for it was made a second time in writings after the return from Babylon. But I, on the other hand, shew that the Apostles received nothing in writing, but received [it] in their hearts through the Holy Ghost. And for this f That is, besides the covenant being- ference, and that the promise in the in itself a new one, different from the Prophecy is that the Mosaic law shall Mosaic, there is also, he says, the dif- be given into the heart, and that this ference in the mode of giving it, the was fulfilled by the reformation of the one being written, the other put into people : as for instance after the Cap- the heart. The Jew is supposed to tivity. allege that this second is the only dif- N 2 180 Other interpretations of the voord New ; HoM. 14. cause also Christ said. When He cometh, He ivill bring all ^: *^g|l" things to your remembrance^ and He shall teach you. [6.] (ver. 11; 12) And they shall not teach (saith he) every man his countryman ^, and every man his brother, saying, Know the Lord : for they shall all know Me from the least of them even to the greatest of them. For I ivill be merciful to their unrighteousnesses, and their iniquities and their sins I will remember no more. Here is also another sign. From the least even to the greatest of them (he says) they shall know Me, and they shall not say, Knoiv the Lord. At what time hath this been^ulfilled save at the present ? For our [religion] ^ is manifest : but theirs [i. e. the Jews^] was not manifest, but had been shut up in a corner. [A covenant] is then said to be new, when it is a different one and shews that it has some advantage over the old. 'Nay surely, says one ^, it is new also in this case when part ' of it has been taken away, and part not. For instance, ' when an old house is ready to fall down, if a person leaving ' the whole, has patched up the foundation, straightway we ' say, he has made it new, when he has taken some parts 2 see Is. ^ away, and brought others into their place. For even the ^^ V 'l^^^ven also is thus called new'^, when it is no longer of XXVUL23. ' brass, but gives rain ^ ; when it is not unfruitful; not, when STToAirrji/. The common editions have interpretation of the "new heaven" is ■TTArjo-ioi/, as has the common text of the incorrect, iii. That the Prophecy dis- New Testament, hut there also Scholz, tinctly foretells a substitution. The Lachmann, Tischendorf read iroXiT-nvy common editions have changed the which is the word used in Jeremiah, character of the passage by substitut- according to the Vatican MS. It is ing 6.KKws Se Kaivh for Kaivr] two lines used by the LXX. to translate the above, and /catj/r? 5e Kal avTTjr. for 'l5oy Hebrew for " neighbour." Kaivr) r. in this place ; by omit- ^ 'iSoi;, (p-ncrl, koL avrr) kolivt] rvyxa- ting cprjal at the end of the objection; veL. This is the argument of an objec- and substituting 'iva SeL^fj for iav ovv tor, who alleges that the promise of a Set|aj. New Covenant was fulfilled by the ' The Verona edition, one Catena, modification and renewed efficacy of the MSS. which Mr. Field usually fol- the Mosaic system, such as occurred lows, and the Latin Versions of Mu- after the Captivity: He alleges two tianus and the later translator, all give senses in which the word " New " the text which is here translated : orav might be applied without implying the /xtik^ti xa^Kovs ^, ctAA.' uerhuSiS^' orav substitution of another system in place /u?? aKapnos, ovx orav fx^ra^ArjOfj, ovx of the old, (i) as a repaired house is said bVay ra /xeu avrov i^atpedij, ra Se jueVp. to be new, and (ii) according to his in- Mr. Fieldsays that he hnsnolens volens terpretation, as the Heavens are new, admitted into the text the "amended" when after long drought tlTfey again readings of the common editions, cJraj/ give rain. S. Chrys. replies, i. That firfK^ri X' V, a. v. 5i5<^, koI t] yo ofioicos after the Captivity the Covenant was Kaivr),oTav fx^ a.fi^ovxorav jxiiTafiKriSfi, still, as of old, unfruitful. ii.That this Koi oJkos ovtw Kaivhs '6rav rafikvK. A. inadmissible, 181 ^ it has been changed ; not, when portions of it have been HE.vm.i2 . ' taken away, and portions remain. And in this sense, says ' he ^, he hath well termed it a New Covenant.^ ^'^T^' If then I shew that that covenant had become Old in this Sav. &c. respect, that it yielded no fruit ? And that thou mayest ^™-*^^^ know this exactly, read what Haggai says, what Zachariah, what the Messenger^ [says], when the return from the ^ 6 •'A77e- Captivity had not yet fully taken place ; and what charges achi^^'" Esdras brings. How then did [the people] receive him ^^ ? And how did no man enquire of the Lord, inasmuch as they ^SeeMal. [the priests] themselves also transgressed, and knew it not ch.ii, iii. even themselves ^} Dost thou see how thy [interpretation] ^^f^'- is broken down*, whilst I maintain my own: that this [cove- rh