V. OK THK COMMERCIAL VALUE, COMMERCIAL ADVANTAGES, AND THE SUCCESSES OF CHRISTIAN MISSIONS. Digitized by the Internet Archive -in 2016 . https://archive.org/details/domissionspayOOhood DO MISSIOI^S PAT? OB THE COMMERCIAL VALUE, COMMERCIAL ADVANTAGES, AND THE SUCCESSES OF CHRISTIAN MISSIONS. BY Rev. GEORGE HOOD, Chestek, Pa. NEW YORK: MISSION HOUSE, 23 CENTRE STREET. 1872. DO MISSIONS PAY? AMEBiCAifs are peculiarly practical ; they examine an enterprise to see if it -will pay ; if it will, they give it their hearty approval and co-opera- tion. The question of missions is not an exception. Home Missions long ago were universally acknowledged to be not only a necessary, but a paying investment. Foreign Missions have not so generally come to that point of acceptance ; but they will bear satisfactorily the same tests. It is the design of these pages to look at I. The Commercial Value of Missions. n. Incidental Advantages of Missions. TTT. Their Direct Successes. I. THE COMMERCIAL VALUE OF MISSIONS. The day we Christianize a heathen, we create in him a desire for a better physical condition. One of the first manifestations for good among the Sandwich Islanders, was the desire for clothing. The same is seen in other missions. In Africa the naked Grebbo buys an English silk hat, and regards himself as dressed, until his ideas of propriety demand additional articles of clothing. They see in the mission dwelling and family, that civilization is better than savagism ; industry, than idleness ; and cleanli- ness, than filth. So they seek knowledge, and begin to adopt the ameni- ties of life. Their laziness gradually disappears, and with it their utter desti- tution. Soap obtained from America is used to remove their superabnnd ant dirt. They see the impropriety of nakedness, and cloth and clothing are required of our manufacturers. Instead of floorless and windowless huts, they aspire to houses with doors, windows, floors and furniture ; and com- merce supplies this from a nail to a sofa. Husbandry is improved, and all kinds of farming implements, as plows, hoes, shovels, forks, etc., are de- manded, so that the value of plows alone exported from Boston to the Zulus in 1870, amounted to more than all that was expended on that mis- sion during that year. “ One missionary at Harpoot, East Turkey, has or- dered, for natives in that region, more than a hundred fanning mills. In. deed, all sorts of implements for use in agriculture and in the mechanic arts, and school furniture, to the amount of thousands of dollars a year- are passing through the mission house at Boston, ordered and paid for by the natives at the instance of the missionaries.” There is an increasing demand from the countries where we have mis- 4 DO MISSIONS PAT? sions, for almost every «kind of manufacture. During the year ending June, 1871, tiventy-five grain-mills, the first reaper, two Lamb’s knitting machines, and a hundred dollars’ worth of out-line maps were sent to East Turkey ; improved plows, mowing and reaping machines to Turkey and South Africa ; seventy-five sets of out-line maps to Ceylon, with sewing machines and cabinet organs to various fields. Such improvements have created a commerce amounting to $4,406,426, with the Sandwich Islands alone while the whole expenditure for Foreign Missions, by all denomina- tions in our country was, in 1870, only $1,633,891, less than one and three- fourths millions against a trade of $4,406,426 ; which trade has been created by our missions, and one-half of which .is with the diflferent ports of the United States. Now $4,406,426 to $1,633,891 is nearly as eleven to four ; that is, we pay out four dollars for missions in all the world, and commerce receives in return ’ trade, eleven dollars from the one mission of the Sandwich Islands. Again, the whole cost of the A. B. C. F. M. for the year 1871, for all its missions, was $420,844. The profit on the trade with the Sandwich Islands for 1871, at 15 per cent., would be $660,964. But $420,844 to $660,964 is as two to three, nearly. Now, if all the profit of that trade for the year 1871, were given to the A. B. C. F. M., whose missionaries have created it, it would pay the expenses of all their missions for 1872, and leave a surplus of $240,120 to enlarge their operations more than one-half. Again, the whole amount expended on the Sandwich Island missions, from the beginning, is $1,250,000. The profit on the trade with the Is- lands, as above, at 15 per cent., would be $660,964, which is 53 per cent, of the entire cost of civilizing and Christianizing that people ; or the profits of the commerce, which the mission has made, would now pay the whole expense, from the beginning, in less than two years. Again, the commerce between the British Possessions in Africa and the ports of New England, during the year ending June 30, 1871, amounted to $2,671,91 3. f Fifteen per cent, gain on the trade gives $400,786 profit. The whole amount expended by the American Board, in all its missions, the same year, was only $420,844 ; so that New England received in real gain, from Afi-ica alone, within $20,000 as much as the American Board expended on all its Foreign missions in the whole world ; and probably $75,000 more than the peojile of New England gave to support that Board. But there are large exportations to Africa,! Syria, Northern Turkey, India, the Islands of the Pacific and many other ports. We have no means of knowing the extent of this commerce, which Christian missions have created, but from the facts already given, we confidently claim, that the gains of trade are many times greater than the cost of missions. These exports have brought increased business profits to our manufacturers ; they have given work and comj)etence to our mechanics ; they have added to the business of railroads and vessels, increasing the wealth of individuals, * Annual Report of A. B. C. F. M., 1870. p, 91. f See Appendix — Table II. DO MISSIONS PAT? 5 companies and the nation. It has been estimated that for every dollar England expends in missions, she receives ten back in trade. We are send- ing to mission fields for the natives, in sufficient quantities to be noticed, farming implements, machinery, furniture, household utensils and conven- iences, clothing, books and various other articles ; and we receive from them importations of native productions. These increase commerce, and commerce enriches a nation by its transportation, by the sale of its exports and imports, by revenue on imported articles, and by its competition, giv- ing better articles or cheaper rates. We aflfirm, then, that missions do pay, cent for cent, dollar for dollar ; two, five, ten dollars per dollar even noAV, and that every year their commer- cial value shows an increasing ratio. n. INCrDENTAL ADVANTAGES OF CHRISTIAN MISSIONS. The first advantage, though not the greatest, we shall mention, is that Christian Missions produce and provide safe Christian ports. Our vessels are scattered over every ocean and sea, and nowhere are they free from disasters. In all waters ports are needed in which to repair damages, refit and take in water and provisions. But it needs no argument to prove that this is next to impossible among savages. Suppose a vessel sailing from Sumatra to San Francisco, to experience heavy adverse winds, with severe storms, her spars carried away, her provisions short, and pumps at work, how they would rejoice to make a Christian port of Micronesia, or reach Honolulu ? What could savages do for them ? Could they supply medi- cines and nursing for the sick, rigging or sails for the ship, or provisions for the future voyage ? But at Honolulu,* a Christian port of only thirty years, the work of missionary effort, every needed thing for the ship or crew, can be as readily supplied as in Philadelphia. The voyage to and from China, for sailing vessels, is long and irksome, and it is all the easier and safer, for these Christian ports, all the more endurable and healthy, for the fresh provisions and water, now easily obtained, where the missionary has not only brought in Christianity, but trade and commerce as well. We aver that the mere commercial advantage of these Christian ports, by fur- nishing to commerce comparative safety, comfort and health, is a good in- vestment of money, giving back ten-fold more, every year, than the entire aggregate of their cost. But the same Christian ports are needed at Alaska and on the Fox Is- lands for the North Pacific; for in 1870 our fleet of whalers numbered, according to the Protectionist, two hundred and twenty-six, averaging three hundred tons each, and most of these in the North Pacific. In the Southern Ocean, and in all waters, we need Christian ports to facilitate and increase commerce and to add to its peimanent safety and comfort. * As early as 1840 the United States Exploring Squadron, under Commodore ITilkeB spent $60,000 for supplies at this one port. See History of Sandwich Islands by Dr. Anderson, p. 177. 6 DO mSSIONS PAT? Not alone upon the highways of the ocean do we need Christianity, but also on the land. Had we sent as many missionaries into our Western Ter- ritories as we have soldiers, at one-tenth of the expense, how many scenes of bloodshed and massacre might have been spared, and the traveler or the sojourner be as safe there as here. Even the railroads across the continent would be safer, more profitable and far pleasanter, were all our Aborigines converted to Christianity. CuEiSTi.\N Missions incite enteeprise and thus facilitate intercommunica- tion. The day has come when the great highways of the world must be shortened. And this is being done. Fifty years ago a short voyage to China occupied many weary months. Now we see emblazoned, “ Round THE World in Se\’entt-four days.” We can no longer endure or afibrd the old ways of travel. They are too slow, too long. Rapid communica- tion is essential to the present condition of the activities of life. Hence the great thoroughfares must be shortened, new routes opened, and greater speed in travel attained. The first visitors to California were content to go around Cape Horn. Soon dreams of gold urged them across the Isthmus of Panama by great labor and exposure. Now it is crossed by rail ; and not content with that, commerce seeks a ship canal across the south of IMexico, from the Bay of Campeachy to the Gulf of Tehuantepec, shortening the distance to San Francisco more than 16,000 miles. And this is no light matter when the annual trade with the western coast will not be less than $300,000,000. The commerce of Europe and Asia was formerly carried on around the Cape of Good Hope. Now' a shi{)-canal across the Isthmus of Suez short- ens the distance to Calcutta, Bombay, or Canton, more than one-half. Soon that will be too long, and a railroad from Boyrut, on the Eastern coast of the Mediterranean, by Tadmor, in the Wilderness, to the Euphrates and thence to the Persian Gulf, will be demanded. This will again greatly shorten the time to Bombay. From Bevrut to the Euphrates is about 350 miles, and thence to the Persian Gulf about 500 miles — a railroad no longer than from Philadelphia to Louisville, Ky. Now, the success of new routes depends upon the civilization and Chris- tianization of the peo|)le among w’hom they are laid. Christianity creates enterprise, begets commerce, inspires energy and ensures success. Com- merce and its facilities do not prosper witli ignorance and barbarism. The light and energizing spirit of true, living Christianity are necessary. Spain is not barbarous, but for lack of vital religion she is inactive, and hence almost without railroads and lighthouses. Mexico is the same. They are each missionary fields, and must have the Bible and the true Gospel to pre- pare the way for the success of commercial enterprise. Cupidity has open- ed Australia and Neiv Zealand. But in those lands the missionary has gone with the pioneer gold digger, making his life tolerable and his work a suc- cess. But gold is not found in most heathen countries, and the Gospel must be the pioneer, and commerce and trade be content to follow in its DO MISSIONS PAT? 7 wake. As the vernal sun and rain must prepare the earth for the plow and the seed, so must the Gospel and education prepare a people for commerce and trade. Missions increase peejjanent wealth. “ God created this world not in vain ; he formed it to be inhabited.” It is Christ’s ; and we, as loyal sub- jects, are bound to bring it into subjection to him. He is our elder brother, and love to him should prompt us to subdue and beautify his domaiii. The Gospel of Jesus Christ alone has power to make the desert bud and blos- som as the rose. Its gentle reign brings peace and prosperity ; its magic touch thrills every nerve, awakes every power of man, and sets the grand- est machineiy of society at work. Some of the richest portions of the earth are yet to be subjected to civilization and to Christ. The basin of the Amazon contains over 2,000,000 square miles, over 1,280,000,000 square acres, or more than 64,000,000 farms of twenty acres each. Allow six per- sons to each farm and it gives a population of 384,000,000, or one-third of the present population of the earth. Its present population is only two or three millions, with an average of over two hundred acres to each person, when, with its vast fertility, every rood might yield bread for a man. Carry the Gospel thither and people the country with active, intelligent Christians, and what treasures of wealth will be created for commerce and for Christ ! With its plentitude of vegetation all utilized, what a magnifi- cent domain for him who created it ! Think of our own country increased ten fold in population and in wealth, and you have what the basin of the Amazon will be. We have not time to speak of those vast peninsulas. Southern Asia and Africa, the heart of the latter extending 3,000 miles east and west, and nearly 2,000 miles north and south, embracing a territory of almost 6,000,000 square miles, producing the choicest indigenous products of the Torrid Zone, and capable of supporting the entire present population of the earth. Cotton, that king of products, is perennial, the same plants lasting several years, and often giving two crops of good staple a year. What missions propose is to open such countries to commerce, to de- velope their various resources, to improve and increase their agriculture, to cultivate the arts, to establish manufactories, to enrich the world with their products, to educate and convert the people, and make them product- ive in commerce, arts, literature, civilization aud Christianity. Cheistlvn missions AH) science, art and literature. Missionaries to our Indians first explored and demonstrated the practicability of a wagon route over the Rocky Mountains. The missionary, Wliitman, saved for us Oregon and Washington Territory, and perhaps California. American missionaries have explored and mapped out Palestine, Syria, Turkey, Persia, etc.; German missionaries, Abyssinia and Eastern Africa; the English, Madagascar and the Islands of the Pacific ; the Moravians taught us about all we know of the Greenlanders aud the Esquimaux ; while Moffiit and Livingstone have been leading geographical authorities on Southern aud 8 DO MISSIONS PAT? Central Africa. In astronomy, botany, mineralogy, in collecting rare specimens of Oriental curiosities illustrative of almost unknown nations, their labors are invaluable. The learned Earl Ritter says : “ Their con- tributions, diffused through essays, quarterlies, and various other publica- tions, have become a part of the world’s knowledge.” The value of these contributions has been acknowledged by many of our most learned men. For irdportaut labors, then, in favor of science, literature, art, commerce and religion, the world of commerce and letters owes Foreign Missions a large balance over and above what they have cost. Had a World’s Congress appointed a High Commission to make the same scientific investigations, collect and communicate the same informa- tion, and set at work the same educational and philanthropic influences, to say nothing of the cultivation of morality and religion, their main work, instead of costing 85,242,716* annually, it would have required a greatly increased sum. m. — THE SUCCESS OF FOREIGN MISSIONS. It is a very common impression among those not well read in the his- tory of missions, that their support is a very doubtful kind of charity — that much of what is given never reaches the foreign field, being swallowed up in the salaries of agents and officers, rents, exchange, etc., little being left for direct mission work. Pertinent to this impression is the sarcasm of one who being asked for a donation, said, ‘‘ Here is a dollar for tlie heathen and four to get it to them.” The following statement from “ The Hand Book of Foreign Missions,” f is a definite and suflicient answer for all such objections : “ During the first seventeen years of its history, the Board expended in its administra- tion 1 1 i per cent. ; for the next seventeen years 4i per cent. ; for the last four years 4 per cent.” Our Missionary Boards will not suffer in comparison with any other charitable or commercial financial management in our land ; and if put in comparison with some of our popular commercial institutions, they will command unlimited confidence for their financial sagacity, prudence and economy. Again, there is a common impression that very little has been done by our missionaries — that they work under great discouragements, and are to be praised for the constancy of a cheerful hope, rather than for the abund- ant fruits and success of their labor. A few facts will correct this false impression. The foreign field for the past ten years has yielded more converts in pro- portion to the labor expended, than the home field. * Land of the Veda — Table IV. t Published by the Presbyterian Board of Foreign Missions. DO mSSIONS PAT? 9 The number added to the Presbyterian Church in our land in 1870 on profession of faith, compared with the whole membership was .... . 6 per cent. The gain of Foreign Missions as a whole . . 12 28 Total 81,153,154 Exports. Domestic Merchandise and Produce. Foreign Merchandise. 8152,980 81,504 .359 33 26,744 38,537 604,424 17,700 8840,385 $43,730 APPENDIX.— Table II. statement showing trade with the British Possessions in Africa during the year ended June 30, 1871, supplied by the Bureau of Statistics of the Treasury Department at Washington, D. C. Ports. Ballimore, Md Boston, Mass New Bedford, Mass. New London, Conn. New York, N. Y. . . Salem, Mass Total. Imports. $1,710,492 2,319 1,498 ...229,585 10,356 $1,960,250 Exports. Domestic Merchandise and Produce. .$16,638 .905,139 .146,067 ..23,376 .11,091,220 Foreign Merchandise. .811,843 774 .116 .$12,733 APPENDIX.— Table III. statement showing trade with Liberia during the year ended June 30, 1871, supplied by the Bureau of Statistics of the Treasury Department, Washington, D. C. Exports. Ports. Imports. Domestic Merchandise and Produce. Foreign Merchandise. Baltimore, Md $11,642 Boston, Mass New York, N. Y 62,322 $9,246 24,620 57,960 $1,396 . . .622 .1,425 ,$73,964 $3,443 Total 891,826 14 DO SnsSIOKS PAY ? APPENDIX lY. As we have referred in this tract prominently to the Sandwich Islands, for any who may douht, or wish to know concerning the present civil and religious status of that people, we copy the following brief testimonies from the Eev. Dr. Anderson’s “ History of the Sandwdeh Islands.” The Hon. C. C. Harris, Minister of Foreign Affairs, in a speech at the National Jubilee of the Islands, held at Honolulu, June, 1870, says: “In 182."), the Hawaiians were ignorant and debased. ... In 1870, we see them advanced to a high degree of Christian knowledge, general education, civ- ilization and material prosperity. The result is due for the most part, under God, to the labors of the American Missionaries.” See p. 351. The Eev. N. G. Clark, D. D., Foreign Secretary of the American Board of Missions in his address at the Jubilee of 1870, said of the Islands: “A heathen nation has become Christian ; the Bible, a Christian literature, schools and churches are open and free to all ; law and order have taken the place of individual caprice ; an independent government shares in the respect and courtesies of the civilized world ; a poor, wretched barter with a few passing ships, has been changed for a commerce that is reckoned by millions of dollars ; but more than all, and better than all, the seeds of Christian culture, ripened on this soil, have been borne by the winds and found lodgment in lands thousands of miles aw'ay — in Marquesas and in Micronesia.” See p. 348. The missionaries assembled at Honolulu in the year 1857, bore the fol- lowing testimony in their annual letter to the A. B. C. F. M. “ Our towns are rising, our roads are improving. Agriculture and in- dustry are assuming increasing importance. Our government, in its legis- lative, executive, and judiciary departments, has acquired organic form, and is moving on in the discharge of its functions. Our schools are sus- tained. Our islands are being dotted over with improved church edifices. Law is supreme ; order prevails ; protection of all human rights is nearly complete; there is little complaining or suffering in the land; shocking crimes are rare ; and it may be doubted whether the sun shines ixpon a more peaceful people.” See p. 266. As early as 1853, Chief Justice Lee, recorded this testimony: “In no jxart of the w'orld are life and property more safe than in the Sandwich Is- lands. Murders, robberies, and the higher class of felonies, are quite un- known here ; and in city and country we retire to our sleep conscious of the most entire security. The stranger may travel from one end of the group to the other, over mountains and through woods, sleeping in grass huts, unarmed, alone and unprotected, with any amount of treasure on his person, and without a tithe of the vigilance required in older and more civilized countries, go unrobbed of a penny.” See p. 267. CHKISTIANITY PROMOTES COMMERCE. “ The £3,000 we have just paid from the Samoa Islands to the Bible Society, what does that represent ? So much native produce passed into the stores of merchants. And when you hear that the Samoans give to the London Missionary Society a contribution of £1,000 a year, mark the commercial side of that ; it represents £2,000 of native produce — cocoa- nut oil, arrow-root, cotton (for the natives are now cotton-growers) — passed into the stores of merchants. It is just the same with clothing, which they require nowadays. Why do they require clothing ? Ask a young woman, selecting her dress at the counter of the merchant, what she is going to do with it ? She will stare at you for putting such a question, and, if she condescends to reply, it will be some such curt reply as this, ‘ Why should I not be as other people in the house of God on the Lord’s day ?’ Ask the young man, while he is selecting a black coat, what he is going to do with it ; he will give you the same reply, perhaps ; or, per- haps, he will tell you that, as this is the month in which they are in the habit of giving a present to their native ministers, that he is going to give this year the minister a present of a black coat. These natives now expend from £50,000 to £100,000 a-year ; and if you ask them why, simply that they may appear decent in the house of God on the Lord’s-day. Thus you perceive to what a large extent the advancement of Christianity is at the same time the advancement of the interests of commerce. Nay, more — I would say, blot out Christianity from Samoa, and send the people back to their native heathenism, and what then ? The merchants may shut up their stores to-morrow, the trading vessels may be sent elsewhere, nothing would remain there. I say, nothing would remain there. There might be a little traffic in powder and shot, spirits and tobacco — at the best a disrejjutable traffic among such a people. It would not pay expenses ; for it could only be carried on amid treachery of every name and form.” Spiritual Besults. — “ There are now, I believe, in heaven, 5,000 Samoans ; and if you could ask them to-night, they would tell you that they were led there through the instrumentality of the Missionary Society. I believe we could gather up from among our 250 villages, from among our church- going population in these villages, as many as 5,000 men ; men and women who believe that they have found peace wdth God through the Lord Jesus Christ, and are striving by the help of the Divine Spirit to live a new life ; men and women who, I believe, have just as good a hope of reaching heaven 16 CHEISTIANITT PEOHOTES COIVIMEECE. •when they die as you and I have. If one soul is of more value than a •whole world, tell me -what we have to say of these twice five thousand ? No combination of the most gifted minds is sufficient to answer the question. Eternity, and the vantage-ground of the intelligence of the angels of God, are required to form even a distant approximation to the solution of the great problem. Would that the men who speak against missions knew what they were talking about ; would that they would cease speaking on a subject of which they know so little ! For their incoherent revilings are just as absurd as might be the utterances of a man born blind, if he were to attempt to describe the colors of the rainbow. After all, it is not so much to wonder at. Tou hear these men talk about the failure of missions. The same men will, perhaps, tell you that salvation through Christ is a failure. They will tell you that the Christian Sabbath is a failure — that the preaching of the Word of God is a failure — nay, more, that the very Bible itself is a failure. The secret of it, I think, we have in the simple words of the Apostle Paul, ‘ The carnal mind is enmity against God.’ Given the carnal mind, and you can easily conclude what will follow its enmity towards God’s servants and God’s work, of whatever name and form.” — Dr. Turner. M •