mmMmmmm^ m;ir^:i§^ OF THE REFORMATION, ON ®S^EI^ S)®©!©®!??, BY WILLIAM MACKRAY, MINISTBR OF THE GOSPEL STERLING, SCOTLANl^, **The Cause of Man.*' — Cowper. ^PRINTED AWD PUBL.ISHJSD BY ROBERT HESBIT, No. 3 Frankfort Street. 1833; PREFACJK. 'While the Author of this essay was pursuing his studies in the University of Aberdeen, the Trustees of Mrs. Blackwall proposed for her Biennial Prize, the Question — -^What has been the effect of the Reformation in Religion, on the state of Ci- vil Society in Europe ?" A few pages, chiefly with a view to his own improvement, he wrote on this subject, and unexpectedly, proved the successful Candidate. After his Essay was publicly read in Marischal College, several persons who heard it. expressed their desire, that it should be published. In various parts of Europe — not excepting our own kingdom — the interests of Popery have lately experienced a considerable revival. The number of its avowed disciples, and of its secret friends, has greatly increased ; ^vhile. in all its territories, and in all the departments of its hierarchy, there is a combined and vigorous movement against Pro- testantism throughout the world. — In these circum- stances, it is the imperative duty of every genuine Protestant to rouse himself from slumber, and, b^ PREFACE. every legitimate means and in the temper of triip charity, to give his aid in the defence and estabUsh- ment of that interest which involves at once the glory of God, and the temporal and eternal welfare of mankind. For Popery is the bane of society, and in proportion as it obtains in the world, th(t condition of men becomes degraded and nnhappy. If, under the favor of Almighty Ggd, this Essay shall be the means of inducing or cherishing a v.arni regard to the cause of the Reformation, and a de- sire to behold the blessings of that great Revolu- tion valued and extended, the object of its publica- tion will be abundantly realized." The Author of the following admirable treatise, having restricted his views of "the bright and bliss- ful Reformation" exclusively to Europe — the Edi tor of the Protestant has added a supplementar} chapter to illustrate and confirm Mr. Mackray's theories, by evidence deduced from the history xif the American continent. JVew Yorh, 19 Novcmhcr, 1830. CONTENTS. Introduction. Page 6 — 23. Chapter I. effect or the reformation on civil liberty. importance of Liberty to Human Happineg?. Not really enjoyed in thr States of Europe before the Sixteenth Century. They would have re- mained strangers to it but for the Relbrmation. Papal Rome. Spiritu- al Supremacy of the Popes. Their temporal dominion. Ignorance, the source of Papal Domination. Means employed by the Pontiffs for the establishment of their power. The Papal system protected by re- ligious belief The Church the protectress of civil tyraimy. Luther. Flis opposition to tiie Court of Rome. Tetzel. Sale of Indulgences. Luther denounces them. Is anathematized. His magnanimous con- duct. Th6 translation of the Holy Scriptures forwarded the Reforma- tion. Plostility of the Church of Rome to the reading of the Scriptures. Rapid spread of the Reformation. It partially overthrew the spiritual supremacy of the Pontiffs. Destroyed their secular domination. The Mvcrthrovv^ given to the power of Rome alTected civil government. Writings ot" the Reformers. Advocates for the rights of the peoj)Ic. Sentiments of Luther. Melanchton. Zuinglius. Knox. Calvin. View of the cliange produced by the Reformation on the liberties ot vlie states of Europe, England. Her condition posterior to it. Scotland. The Reformation the dawn of genuine liberty. Knox. The Cove- nanters. Consolidation of British liberty. Holland. Sweden. Denmark. Germany. Switzerland. Geneva. Italy. France. Spain. Pp. 25—76. C. K. effect of the reformation on national prosperity. rhe Reformation has impressed the minds of the people with the duties which they owe to their rulers. The Papal system entwined with the afiairs of Government. The interest of the Church deemed of para- mount importance. Vengeance of the Popes against the princes and nations by whom they were oflended. Excommunication. Interdict. Nations thrown into confusion by these instruments of Papal wrath. Principle which lay at the foundation of all this preposterous. Abol- ished by tlie Retbrmation. All interference of a foreign poAver with the internal afiairs of States^ excluded. The Reformation has impressed on tliG minds of Rulers the duties which they owe to their subjects. Oatii, to be faithful to Rome, led to persecut'on. Happier system in- troduced by the Reibrmation. Princes raised above the control of Home. Harmony of feeling, and of interest produced between Pra Testant princes and their people. Charles IX. Elizabeth. Bartholomew massacre. Tlie Reformation abolished many customs and. institutions. CONTENTS. wiiich corrnpted llie morals, and impoverished Tiie resources of iUr Slates of Europe. Mona.chism. Dimimitioii of the mimber of testival.-^ and hohdays. The Reformation imposed a powerful check on crime. Doctrine oi"indulgence?. Doctrine of the right of sanctuary. Abohshed in Protestant lands. Beneficial effect of the Reformation on the inter course of states with each other. Pp. 77—116 C. III. EFFECT OF THE REFORMATION ON SOCIAL LIFE. Social morality promoted by the Reformation. Morality essential to hap- piness. Superstition its enemy. Popish superstition. Corruption ol manners. The progress of literature would hav^e furnished no remed} for the prevailing evils. The Reformation a recurrence to Christian principles and Christian purity. A revolution in social morality forced upon Papists. The Reformation gave security to the intercourse of so cial lile. Principles of Popery opposed to it. The virtue and peace oi' domestic life in the power of the Clergy. Auricular confession. Abom inations practised under this doctrine. "Abolished in Protestant lands. The Reformation effected an auspicious change in the people. Ten- dency of the Romish system to destroy generous feelincr. Awfully in tolerant. The temper of popery the reverse of that by which domestic' society can be rendered happy. Charity the peculiar spirit of the Re- formation. Pp. 117—126, C. lY. EFFECT OF THE REFORMATION ON THE rROCRESS OF KNOA^'LEDGE. Value of knowledge to man. Its importance to national dignity and vir- tue. Melancholy state of knowledge before the 16th century. The pa pal system hostile to learning. The Reformation naturally tended t(> stimulate knowledge. Discussions originated by the Reformation pro- moted knowledge. Noblest works of genius were produced by Pro- testants. Study of literature forced upon the Papists. Knowledge can- not be encouraged by Rome. Protestant States most eminent for liter ature. Progress of knowledge since the Reformation. Great efforts in the present age to promote improvement. Rome is opposing the pro gress of knowledge. Her efforts will be finally unsuccessful. ^Tniversai spread of knowledge anticipated. Pp. 127—132 C. V. EFFECT OF THE REFORMATION IN AMERICA. European Settlements. Civil Liberty. National Prosperity. Social Lift^ Progress of Knowledge. Recapitulation. Pp. 133—141. INTRODUCTORY Few evenls in tlie liislory of mankind liavc been of greater importance than the Reformation, and few have derived theij' orio-in from more inconsiderable occurrences. Wonderful in- deed would the intelligence have been regarded by the contem- poraries of Tetzel, that the ebullitions of the zeal of that impru- dent fanatic were to kindle a flame, which would burn till it had utterly consumed the great fabric of spiritual despotism, that the oppressors of Europe had been rearing for a thousand years, — and that they were to give birth to a revolution whose influence would be felt in the remotest regions of the world, and by the latest generations of mankind. Great as is the importance which we now attach to the Reformation, the circumstance by which it was introduced would seem to t!ie men v/ho beheld it one of those ephemeral transactions in human history, which, when a few years have passed awa^y-, are forgotten — like a twinkling ta- per cast upon the ocean, which, after the glimmer of a moment. is swallowed up for ever. They were too near the scene of ac- tion, — their attention was too much directed to insulated por- tions of the plan which was in process of developement before them, to obtain a comprehensive view of it as one great whole. Their case with respect to the Reformation resembled that of a traveller, in reference to some beautiful but extensive landscape. He might, in passing over it, mark successively its varied aspect, and the loveliness of its individual parts ; but its beauty as a whole, arising from the splendid assemblage of charming ob- jects which it exhibits, it would not be possible for him. duly to 8 INTRODUCTORY. estimate, unless, betaking himself to some commanding emi- nence, his eye could cast its glance over the entire scene — the landscape would burst on him in all its loveliness, and appear in the richness of its combined beauty. It would have been ne- cessary for the men who were contemporary with Luther and Tetzel to look at the transactions which were passing under their notice from an eminence in the moral and political, analogous^ to that v/hich we have supposed in tlie material M-orld, ere lhe\ could have estimated, according to its just magnitude, their pe- culiar importance. Such an eminence do we occupy. At the distance of three hundred years from that memorable revolution which distinguished the 16th century, we can trace the causes-' from which it originated ; — we can discern its commencemeni amid a multiplicity of unnoticed, and apparently unimportant, occurrences ; — we can follow it in the various stages of its developement ; — we can mark the impulse whicli it has given 10 human affairs, and the features which it has impressed on liuman society ; and thus are we precisely in that situation whence it may be viewed in ail the variety of its bearings, and estimated according to its unspeakable moment. We should seek to gain acquaintance with the history of this most interesting ©f all the revolutions that have taken place In modern times, and we should investigate the benefits whicli it has been the means of conferring on the world ; — that thus our belief in the providence of that Almighty Disposer of events, whose interposition it striking!}- displays, might be strengthen- ed, and that a higher tone might be given to those feelings oi gratitude which it is our duty to cherish, in the first place to- wards the Supreme Agent, and then towards those illustrious in- dividuals, to whom, under God, the world is indebted for thai ffreat sum of intellectual, moral, and political good which it lia- derived from the Reformation. Regarding man as a moral and immortal being, the circum- stance which, above all others, entitles the event of which we are treating to our orrateful remembrance, is the change which it lias accomplished in rcUg'ioii, — in rescuing mind from tlie chains INTRODUCTORY. , 9 which spiritual despotism liad been for ages'laboring with dread- ful success to wreathe around it; in teaching it to scan its un- alienable rights, and spurn subjection to any power save that of its Creator; in fetching forth from the darkness where success- ful villany had doomed it to dwell, and setting open to the in- habitants of every land, that Book by which life and immortalit} are brought to light ; in short, in exhibiting Christianity in her native glory, disrobed of those dark and degrading superstitions hy which, during many generations, her loveliness had been ob- scured. But, even when viewed independently of its reference to religion — when regarded altogether as to the influence which it has exerted on civil and political affairs — it has been pro- ductive of alterations of so much moment in man's social con- dition, as to render it one of the most interesting and important events which history relates. It has not merely thrown over the face of society a few superficial and transitory embellish- ments ; it has imparted to it, substantial and permanent improve- ment. Man, in every character in which he can be viewed, and iw every pursuit in which he can engage, has experienced its power. To it we look back as the source of all the liberty with which Europe is blessed. It has poured light on the duties and the interests of rulers, and of their subjects. Na- tions are indebted to it for the removal of numberless evils whicli iiindered their prosperity, and for the confidence which charac- terizes their mutual transactions ; whilst individuals and families experience its influence in the security which it has imparted to domestic enjoyment. And literature and the progress of know- ledge have derived from it an impulse, greater than from any other event recorded in the history of the world. The Refor- mation is the era from whtch modern science has dated her rapid and unparalleled triumphs. But it was not to be expected that the Reformation, whicli operated so extensively and so powerfully in changing the reli- gious, the political, and the social condition of ihe states of Eu- rope, would have been unattended by any consequences of an Injurious description. This world is not the scene of unmingled 10 INTRODUCTORY. good. The character and circumstances of man in liis present state of existence are such, that every event which takes place in his history must, like the symbolical cloud in the desert of Si- nai, have a dark, as well as a bright side, — must have a portion of evil mixed up with all the good of which it is productive. In the history, even of Christianity, we lind the most striking illus- tration of the truth of this maxim that can possibly be conceived. Its introduction is, unquestionr.bly, the most important and aus- picious event that ever had been, or ever will be, recorded in the^ annals of tlie human race. Its motto is the song of angels. Glory to Gcd in the highest, peace on earth, good will to men.'' In the history of Christianity are destined to be more than reali- zed the brightest visions that ever prophet announced, or rap- tured poet sung; scenes of peace, and felicity, and joy, "such as earth sav/ never, such as heaven stoops down to see." Never- theless, the introduction of Christianity Avas not unaccompanie([ with disastrous effects. Its nature and its tendency are good, — without any mixture of evil. Yet did its divine author, our blessed Lord and Saviour, declare respecting it, " I come not to send peace on earth, but a sword ; for I am come to set a man at variance against his father, and the daugliter against her mother, and the daughter-in-law against her mother-in-law ; and a man's toes shall be those of his own household." Wars, and persecu- tions, and outrage, and bloodshed to a most awful degree were, accordingly, its consequences — consequences, hov/ever, of which it is innocent, and which are attributable solely to the de- pravity of those Vvho, when the light shone among them, were unwilling to receive it. Now, if even the introduction of Chris- tianity, the most memorable and blissful event that is recorded in the whole history of man, v*as the innocent occasion of many disastrous transactions, it is by no means wonderful, that th(^ Reformation from Popery, which was just tlic restoration ol genuine Christianity, should have been followed by some conse- quences of a similar nature. The opponents of Christianity, in the primitive ages of her history, eagerly laid hold of this facL and talked of it as a demonstration that Christianity had been a INTRODUCTORY. 11 curse, and not a blessing, to mankind ; and their example has been imitated by the enemies of the Reformation. They have told us of a multitude of evils, of which that revolution has been productive, and they have attempted to persuade us that these are of such magnitude as never to be atoned for by the benefits which it has conferred ; but nothing could be more illiberal, or more unjust. Many of the alleged evils which are attributed to the Reformation, are found, on inquiry, to be productive of good. Not a few of the injurious occurrences with Avhich it is blamed, are unjustly laid to its charge ; and those real evils which it has occasioned, are infinitely counterbalanced by the numberless substantial benefits with which it has been attended. We are told, that the Reformation has operated with mischiev- ous efiect on the tranquillity of civil and political society. It has been productive of many fierce and disastrous wars in all the countries of the western world. Germany, and France, and Britain, we are assured, have all been the scenes of the desperate and long continued struggles to which it gave birth. Now, we answer, that the guilt of these unhappy conflicts, cannot be charged on the Reformation ; and although it were true that these hostile transactions were excited and encouraged by the Reformation, they bore such a character, and have been produc- tive of such beneficial consequences, that, notwithstanding all the atrocities by which they were distinguished, and the obstruc- tions which, for a time, they laid in the way of social improve- ment, they are blessings to mankind. Let it be supposed, that those contests by which, during the sixteenth and seventeenth centuries, the nations of Europe were convulsed, with all the evils which they occasioned, are to be laid to the charge of the Reformation ; who, that thinks of the character which they bore, and of the eftects which they produc- ed, will hesitate to admit that they have been, on the whole, auspicious events? The love of freedom, and a noble determina- tion to recover the long-lost rights of men, originated them, and stimulated their continuance. The foes of the Reformation in- deed, have often stigmatized them as contests of rebellion, but \'Z INTRODUCTORY. the stigma is slanderous and unjust. They were contests for re- jigion, and liberty, and truth— all that is dear to man in this world, and in the world to come. Even although they had been unsuccessful, we should have honored them in our remembrance, and the scenes in which they were waged should be venerated as the fields of glorious, though fruitless fight. But these con- tests were not, in general, unsuccessful : attended, doubtless, they were, with awful, and extensive, and long-lasting devasta- tion, whose details fill us with regret and horror ; but they ter- minated in the overthrow of the oppressor, the breaking asund- er of fetters, and the bringing forth of the enslaved to light and liberty. Should protestant Germany consider even the century of warfare which the Reformation cost her, too mighty a price for the substantial advantages she has derived from it ? Would the Belgian provinces be content again to submit to the imperial yoke, if the blood and treasure which they expended in gaining their freedom could be restored? Is there any patriot of our own land, who, when he thinks of the years, and ages even, of internal convulsion, by which she was rent in consequence of the Reformation, imagines that she purchased, by too costly sacrifi- ces, her freedom, her happiness, her glory? In short, is there any man of sound intelligence, who will cast his eyes over the nations of Europe, and mark the independence of mind, the activity of thought, the elevation of character, the refinement of manners, by which they are generally distinguished, and contrast all this with the condition of Europe in the dark ages, and then say that the sacrifices which were made in accomplishing this mighty change have been beyond"its value? Impossible. Put- ting the blessings of restored Christianity out of the question, the Reformation has been attended with a multiplicity of other benefits to the nations of Europe, and, indeed, to the world at large, which amply compensate for all the toils, and perils, and woes, which were experienced in conflicting for its establishment. But the guilt connected with these scenes of warfare and out- rage cannot be laid to the charge of the Reformation. Those onlv, are to be blamed for these things, who resisted the improve- INTRODUCTORY. U ruents, and the just rights, which the people had become en- lightened enough to appreciate and to demand. Mildness an4 peace are the characters which the friends of the reformed faith always desired to bear ; persuasion and argument the only arms they were anxious to employ. Nor would any other ever have been employed, if the despots of the age had listened to the voice of reason and of truth. They, certainly, had no right to prevent the degraded millions who were their subjects, from be- coming enlightened, and free, and happy. Rather ought they to have made common cause with their people ; and if they had done this, which it w^as at once their duty and their interest to do, the peace of the world would not have been interrupted. But they set themselves to oppose the Reformation ; they at- tempted its overthrow. The ruin of its friends — the wretched- ness of mankind, would have been the consequence of their suc- cess. Resistance was necessary — resistance was made ; not those, however, who resisted, but those whose aggressions rous- ed that resistance — the enemies of the Reformation, and they alone, must bear the guilt of all the evils of which it was the innocent occasion. It is affirmed, farther, that the Reformation has operated with injurious effect on literature, and on the fine arts. These com- plaints are destitute of foundation. It is not true — that the ebullition of popular indignation which burst forth against the ancient system, was attended with the extensive destruction of literary works. The monasteries, at the time of the Reforma- tion, seem to have been any thing but the abodes of learning ; and the Reformers were too much distinguished as literary men themselves, and too anxious to see the streams of knowledge pouring their fructifying waters along the desolate heritages of the earth, to recommend measures by which injury would be done to the interests of learning. What though some monuments of Grecian and Roman genius have perished, and some magnificent specimens of architecture have been turned into ruins, and some opportunities thereby been taken away from our men of science, of exercising literary 14 INTRODUCTORY. acumen, and gratifying literary taste ? What matters all tlii?, when in the room, and by the means of these disadvantages, there has been obtained the shining forth of Christianity, in her unadulterated and glorious simplicity, and the breaking asunder and casting away of the vilest and most grievous manacles that ever enslaved the body and the soul of man ? The general influence of the Reformation, has not been hostile to learning. What literature had Europe, that was worthy of the name, before the sixteenth century ? What literature has Europe still, that is not either the immediate offspring of the Reformation, or mainly indebted to it for its lusture and perfec- tion ? Have not all the great literary works, which have made their appearance in modern times, been the production of men who were either Protestants, or had felt, though they refused to acknowledge, their obligations to the potent, rousing, and en- nobling influence of the Reformation. The fine arts have been, to a certain extent, unfavourably affected by the Reformation. Not merely in consequence of those operations of positive destruction, which took place in va- rious parts of Europe, but chiefly, in virtue of the change which has been eflfected in religion ; in the expulsion of all that ex- ternal pomp and magnificence by which the system of the dark ages was distinguished ; and by means of which encouragement, to an incredible extent, was given to the arts, especially those of architecture, painting and sculpture. " When a pompous worship requires magnificent temples, imposing ceremonies, and splendid decorations ; when religion presents to men's eyes the sensible images of the objects of public worship ; when it rests on a sacred mythology; when the earth and heavens are peopled with supernatural beings, to v/hom the imagination may lend a form ; then it is that the arts, encouraged and ennobled, attain the height of their glory and perfection. The architect, called to honors and fortune, conceives the plan of those temples and cathedrals, the sight of which imposes a religious awe, and of which the walls are adorned with the finest productions of art. This temple, those altars, are ornamented with morble and pre- INTRODUCTORY. 15 •lous metals, which sculpture has formed into angels, saints, and the images of illustrious men. All the different apartments are decorated and filled with pictures. In one place is Jesus expir- ing upon a cross ; in another he is shining on Mount Tabor, in all the divine Majesty. Art, so nearly allied to what is ideal, and which delights in ascending to heaven, repairs thither to seek for its most sublime creations ; John, a Cecilia, and par- ticularly a Mary, that patroness of all tender and ardent souls — - that virgin model of all mothers, — the intercessor of grace plac- ed between man and his God — that Elysian — that august aud interesting being — whom no other religion offers any thing that resembles. During those solemnities, the finest stuffs, precious stones, and embroideries, cover the altars, the vases, the priests, and even the partitions of the sacred place. Music completes the charm by the most exquisite strains, and the harmony of various instruments. Those powerful encouragements are re- peated in a thousand different places. Capitals, parishes, the numerous convents, even the most humble congregations, strive lo excel in splendor, and to captivate all the faculties of the de- vout and religious mind. Thus a taste for the arts becomes gen- eral, by means of so powerful an exciting cause. Artists multi- ply, and vie with one another in their efforts. The celebrated schools of Italy and Flanders flourished under that influence, and their beautiful productions which have come down to us, afford abundant testimony of the greatness of the encouragements which they derived from the Popish worship." A scene of a different kind has been introduced by the Refor- mation. The union which existed between religion and the arts lias been broken down. The magnificence of popish worship has been abolished, as inconsistent with the institutions of Jesus Christ, and a simple yet dignified ritual introduced into the church, which forms a striking contrast to all the foolish pa- geantry of what was called the Christian worship of former times. This change has been, in a religious point of view, most beneficial to the Christian world. It has trampled in. the dust iha idolatry of Romanism ; has dissolved the enchantment of the L6 INTRODUCTORY. imagination, by which men were deluded, and withdrawing the attention of the worshippers from splendid, but unmeaning forms, has directed it to that which is of infinitely greater importance, — the religion of the heart. But, while this change has benefit- ed the great cause of scriptural piety, it has, at the same time, done disservice to the arts. It has annihilated one of their most powerful stimulants ; has diminished their popularity, and ex- cluded them from a scene, of all others the most eminently adapted to call forth, and furnish scope for their noblest tri- umphs. Superb temples are not now deemed indispensably necessary for the worship of Deity ; the productions of the chisel and the pencil are banished from the house of God as unseemly decorations ; and the world, having lost its reverence for the patronage of saints and angels, no longer expends its treasures on their statues. The influence of the Reformation has, undoubtedly, in respect of these things, been unfavorable to the progress of the fine arts. But religion is of infinitely greater importance to mankind than the arts ; and, rather than behold it corrupted and debased, we should be content that they should perish and be forgotten. Sup- pose the Reformation not to have taken place, then art would have continued to be encouraged, to flourish, to accumulate its trophies, and to advance towards higher degrees of eminence and glory. ' But at what expense would all this have been ob- tained? At the expence of dishonored, degraded Rehgion, and the perpetuated ignorance, deception, and misery of mankind ! The fine arts were, to a certain extent, identified with that mon- strous corruption of Christianity which had usurped her name, and were not the least powerful of those means by which that mystery of iniquity was cherished and upheld. But v»^ho would wish to see the arts prosper, at the expense of all the dearest in- terests of mankind ? Who would not rather that they should be shorn of some of their splendor, than that their fascination should go down to succeeding generations with its power unim- paired, by which, in the most momentous of all concerns, men were deluded and destroyed ? Who, in ihort, deem.s not the vin^ INTRODUCTORY. H dication of religion, the restoration of luiadulteraied Christianity, and the establishment of menial freedom, blessings of such in- conceivable magnitude, as inlinitely to counterbalance the par- tial and temporary restraint which, in contending for their en- joyment, was imposed upon the arts ? In thus depriving the arts of one important mean of their prosperity, the Reformation has offended in company with Christianity, and the very same defence which triumphantly vin- dicates the latter, serves for the vindication of the former. Tu a far greater extent than ever was the case under Popery, did the religion of the Greeks exercise a fostering influence over the arts. When we contemplate it as Christians, it is the object of our utter contempt and abomination, exhibiting, in a m.ost me- lancholy manner, how stupid and depraved the human mind is, when unenlightened and unrenewed by Him who created it. But when we look upon it with a scienlitic eye ; when we behold it €allin