^c:i^ u t/ m^^' ■■'H'^ii^ RECOMMENDATION. THE " Sceptics Manual,** while going through the press, has been seen by Dr. S. S. Smithy of Princeton College, and the Rev. James Armstrong, of Trenton, both of whom, have sent the Publisher special written testi- monies of their approbation. A part of the language of one, which is also the opinion (in sulDstance) of the other, is, that " the nature of the work deserves approbation ; also the manner in which it is treated ; and the great object it is calculated to promote.*' The same writer also adds : " I am inclined to think it promises great usefulness ; espe- cially if those for whom it is intended, could be prevailed upon to give it an attentive and unprejudiced perusal.'* This work is well adapted to the confirma^ tion and edification of Christians, though it is more particularly designed for the instruction ^f Unbelievers. ^*Iie that heiircth reproof getteth understanding.'- ; SCEPTIC'S MAmi AL. OR CHRISTIANITY VERIFIED . Being a new method of Appeal to the UnderstaAd= ings and Consciences of Deists, Jews, Sceptics, and Formal Professors : Tor the truth, power, and efficacy of the Christian Religion ; demonstrated in three parts : BY THE TRUTH OF THE HOLY SCRIPTURE3> BY THE CERTAINTY Ot THE MANIFESTATION OF THE SPIRIT, AND BY THE INFLUENCE AND POWER OF RELIGIOlj', AS EXEMPLIFIED IN THE CONVERSION OF tNOT^- RIOtrS SINNERS, AND IN THE LIVES OP DISTINGUISHED SAINTS. ** He that heareth reproof getteth xindetstanding!''' Paov. PHILADELPHIA: PUBLISHED BY J. F. WATSON, S. W. Comer of Third and Chesnut-streeta. assr PREFACE. IT is intended in the following pages, to oflfey to "Unbelievers, after their own manner of rea- soning, reasons for the truth and certainty of th« Christian Religion, both in its theory, and in it$ *' power," deduced from, and confirmed by, datUy to be found m their own judgments and consciences. Those who disbelieve the Bible, do not allow their opponents to urge their arguments from prennses, which their minds already reject, it is therefore the purpose here to convince them from " topics of rea- son" in which they can at once give their consent. — In this manner the Bible is demonstrated to be true. It is next endeavoured to show, ftoxv it is that God, who is a Spirit, " and whom no man hath seen at any time," doth yet as certainly ?ctid perceptibly mani- fest Himself to the mind^ as does the radiance of the natiu'al sun to our outward senses at noonday. This being a doctrine of vital importance to Christianity, though little regarded by some theoretical christians, is here proposed to the reason and understanding of all objectors, and enforced by suitable Scripture concurrence. Finally, as Religion is a Sa^'ptvr a! service, and is an affection and feeling of the heart, wrought there, perceptibly and preternaturally by the Holy Ghost, to the sure and certain evidence and consolation of all true Believers, it is endeavoured to show the energy and transforming effect of that spiritual power in convincing and convicting of Sin, and m " changing the heart," by exhibiting the operations of that spirit iv PREFACE. in the death of convicted Smners, dying in despair ; in Sinners reformed ; and in Saints who lived and died in the assurance of Faith.-^The persons selected for this evidence, are such as are best known to the literary world, and to the truth of whose lives his- tory has affixed her sufficient testimony. This work is chiefly derived from the Wi'itings of Leslie, Fletcher, and Si|rapson. t,..«,^ PART I. A •& OF THE BY Mr, CHARILES LESLIE. ' " METHOl) WITIL THE lXALETTERT<)ASKlENa , . INTROBtJCTION METHOD WITH THE DEISTS. THE controversy between Deists and Christians, ijnot so much respecting- the morality or ethics of tlie gospel, (for honest Deists admit its precepts to be pure, and of real importance to the well being- of society) as it is a dispute concerning- the integrity and validity of the bible itself Christians kno-uj it to be an inspired book, because, besides its other evidences, it has ** demonstration and power.'* Biit Infidels imagine it a delusive forgery, imposed upon the credulity of Christians, by the craft of designing The vaKdity of the bibi.e, being therefore, the chief matter at issue, the force of the following ar- guments of Leslie, supported (for this occasion) by notes, chiefly from Fletcher, are pm-posely limited to that kind of appeal to the understanding of unbe- lievers, which will best encounter and subdue tlteir unbelief and prejudices. The excellence of the moral and perceptive part of the gospel, is comparatively an easier task to prove. Its beneficial, and even purifying tendency, has been already conceded in a very remarkable manner, by X ^ INTRODUCTION. both Rousseau and Bolingbroke.* If however, fur- ther information is required upon this subject, the honest inquirer may find his utmost scruples amply combatted, by looking- into Mr. Bogue's excellent "'Essay on the Divine authority of the New Testa- ment," a little book drawn up as as'ift to the infidels of France, and most admirably adapted to subdue the anti-christian prejudices of any people. Till yovi convince an Infidel that the word of.»GOD is indeed genuine, you but " beat the air,"- to urge him to read it as his great rule of life ; but when convinced... 7je knows, he must not only study it, but must obey it, or perish. * Even Paine has not scrupled to say, that " Jesus Christ was a virtuous, and an amiable man ; that the morality he preached and practised, was of the most benevolent kind ; and that it has not been exceeded by any." Similar concessions have been made, at different times, by Blount and Tindal, and by Mor- gan, Toland, Chubb, jind otjiers. STIORT AND EASY IVIETHOT) WITH THE DEISTS. SIP, I, IN answer to your's of the 3d instant, I much condole with your unhappy circum- stances, of being placed amongst such com- pany, where, as you say, you continually hear the sacred scriptures, and the histories therein contained, particularly of Moses, and of Christ, and all revealed religion, turned into ridicule, by men who set up for sense and reason. And they say, that there is no greater ground to believe in Christ than in Mahomet : that all these pretences to reve- lation are cheats, and ever have been, among Pagans, Jews, Mahometans, and Christians : that they are all alike imposi- tions of cunning and designing men, upon the credulity, at first, of simple and mi- thinking people ; till, their numbers increas- ing, their delusions grew popular, came at last to be established by laws ; and thea. 12 EASY METHOD the force of education and custom gives a bias to the judgments of after ages, till such deceits come really to be believed, being received upon trust from the ages forego- ing, without examining into the original and bottom of them. Which these our moderit men of sense, (as they desire to be esteem- ed) say, that they only do ; that they only have their judgments freed from the slavish authority of precedents and laws, in mat- ters of truth ; which, they say, ought only to be decided by reason : though, by a pru- dent compliance with popularity and laws, they preserve themselves from outrage, and legal penalties ; for none of their complex- ion are addicted to sufferings, or martyr- dom. Now, sir, that which ydu desire frorh me, is, some short topic of reason, if such can be found, without running to authori- ties, and the intricate mazes of learning, which breed long disputes ; and which these men of reason deny by wholesale, though they can give no reason for it, only suppose that authors have been trump- ed upon us, interpolated, and corrupted, so that no stress can be laid upon them : though it cannot be shown wherein they are so corrupted ; which, in reason, ought to lie upon, them to prove, who alledge it,;" WITH THE MIISTS. 13 otherwise it is not only a precarious, but a guilty plea : and the more, that they refrain npt to quote books on their side, for whose authority there are ; no better, or not so good grounds. However, you say, it makes your disputes endless, and they go away with noise and clamour, and a boast, that there is nothing, at least nothing certain, to be said on the Christian side. Therefore you are desirous to find some one topic of reason, wdiich should demonstrate the truth of the Christian religion, and at the same time distinguish it from the impostors of Mahomet, and the old Pagan world; tl^at our Deists may be brought to this test, and be either obliged to renounce their reason, and the common reason of mankind, or to submit to the clear proof, from reason, of the Christian religion : which must be such a proof, as no imposture, can pretend to, otherwise it cannot prove the Christian re- ligion not to be an imposture. And w^hether such a proof,: one single proof, (to avoid confusion,) is not to be found out, you desire to knov»^ from me. And you say, that you cannot imagine but there must be such a proof, because every truth is in itself clear, and one. And therefore that one reason for it, if it be the true reason., must be sufficient ; and if suffi- 14 EASY 3IETHQD cient, It is better than many ; for muliipUcity confounds, especially to weak judgments. Sir, you have imposed a hard task upon me. 1 vvish I could perform it. For though every truth is one ; yet our sight is so feeble, that we cannot (always) come to it directly, but by many inferences, and laying -^^of things togethfe-r. But I think, thaty in the case before us, there is such a proof as you require ; and ' I will set it down as short and plain as I ■''■can. -' ii; First, then, I'-sappbse that the truth of the doctrine O'f 'Christ will be sufficiently Evinced, if the matters of fact which are ■fiscorded of him in the gospels, be true : for i-ftis miracles, if true, do vouch the truth of what he delivered. The same is to be said as to Moses. If he brought the children of Israel through the Red Sea, in that miraculous manner which is related in Exodus, and did siich other wonderful things as are there told of him, it must necessarily follow, that he was sent from God : these being the strongest proofs we can desire ; and which every De- ist will confess he would acquiesce in, if' he saw them with his eyes. Therefore the stress of this Cause will depend xipon the proof of these iti^tters of fact. WITH THE DEJSTS. 15 1. And the method I will take, is, Firsts To lay down such rules, as to the truth qi ^ matters of fact in general, that, where they all meet, such matters of fact cannot be false. And then, Secondlij^ to show, that all , these rules do meet in the matters of fact of , M-oseSy and of Christ : and that they. do not meet in the matters of fact of Mahomet, of the heathen deities, or can possibly meet in any. imposture, Avhatsoever. 2^ The rules ace these. I. That the matter of fact be such, as that men's oiitward senses, their eyes and ears, may be judges of it, II. That it be done publicly, in the face of the world. III. That not only public monu- ments be kept up in memory of it, but some outward actions be performed. IV. That such monuments, and such actions, or observances, be insti- tuted, and do commence from the time that the matter of fact was done. 3. The twQ first rules make it impossi- ble for aay^such matter of fact to be impo- sed upon men, at the time when such mat- 15' EASY METltOT5 tef'^of fact was said to be done, because ev^n^ Irian's eyes and senses would contra-^"" diet it; For example, suppose any man f-.hould pretend, that yesterday he divided the Thames, iin presence of all the people of London, and carried the whole city, men, women, f»nd children, over to Soutliwark, on dry lard ; the waters standing like walls on bo^th. sides : J say, it is morally impos- sible, that he could persuade the people of luondon that this was true, when every man woman, and child, could contradict him, and say, 'that this was a notorious falsehood; for that they had not seen the Thame's so divided, or had gone over on dry lafid. Therefore I take it lor granted, (and, 1 sup- pose, with the allov/ance of all the Deists, in the world) that no such imposition could be put upon men, at the time, when such public matter of fact was said to be don^. 4. Therefore it only remains tliat suck matter of fact inight be invented some time after wiien the men of that generation whei-ein^the thin^ was said to be done, are all past and gone ; and the credulity of after ages might be imposed upon, to believe that things were done in former ages 'which were not. , '*' ■'*'• An^rfor thi«,' the two last rules seture AVXTH THK DEISTS. 17 lis as much as the two first rules in the tormer case ; for whenever such a matter of fact came to be invented, if not only monuments were said to remain of it, but likewise that public actions and observances were constantly used, ever since the matter of fact was said to be done, the deceit must be detected, by no such monuments appear- ing, and by the experience of every man, woman, and child, who must know that no such actions, or observances, were ever used by them. For example, suppose I should now invent a story of such a thing- done a thousand years ago, I might perhaps get some to believe it : but if I sa}- that not only such a thing was done, but that from that day to this, ev^rv man at the age of twelve years had a joint of his little finger cut off; and that every man in tlie nation did want a joint of such a finger ; and that this institution v/as said to be part of the matter of fact done so many years ago, and vouched as a proof and confirmation of it, and as having descended, without interrup- tion, and been constantly practised, in me- mory of such matter of fact all along from the time that such matter of fact was done : J say, it is impossible I should be believed in such a case; because every one could contradict me, as to the mark, of cutting off B 2 13 EASY METHOD a jomt of the firi^er';''afid that being part of n'ly original matter of fact, must demon- str^ite the whole to be false. in. Let us now come to the second point, to shov/, that the matters of fact of Moses, and of Christ, have all these rules or marks before mentioned : and that neither the matter of fact of Mah- lowed me, that he could not have persuad- ed 600,000 men, that he had brought them ■6tit of Egypt, through the Ked sea ; fed them forty years, without Thread,' by raira* culcus irianna ; and the other matters of fact recorded in his books, if they had not been true ; because every man's senses that were then alive, must have contradicted it: and therefore he must have imposed upon all their senses, if he could have made them believe it, when it was false, and no such things done. So that here are the first and seconcl of the above mentioned four marks. For the same reason, it was equally im- possible for him to have made them receive his five books as truth, and not to have rejected them, as a manifest imposture, which toid of all these things as clone be- WITH THE DEISTS. 19 fore their eyes, if they had not been so done. See how positiv^ely he speaks to them, Deiit, xi. 2 — 8. Arid know ye this day : for I speak not imth your children which have not knoxvn^ and which have not seen the <:hastisement of the Lord your God^ his greatness^ his mighttj hand^ and his stretch- ed-out arm ; and his miracles^ and his acts which he did in the midst of Egypt^ unto Pharaoh the king of Egypt ^ and unto all his land ; and what he did unto the armij of Egypt^ unto their horses^ and to their chariots^ how he made the water of the Red sea to overjiorv them as they pursued after yoii^ and how the Lord hath destroyed them unto this day ; and rvhat he did unto you in the ruilderjiess^ until ye came unto this place ; and what he did unto Dathan and Ahiram^ the sons of Eliah^ the son of Rhu- ben : hoiv the earth opened her mouthy and sxvallowed them up^ and their households^ and their tents^ and all the substance that was in their possession^ in the midst of all Israel, But your eyes have seen all the great a^ts of the Lord^ which he did^ Sec. From hence we must suppose it impos- sible, that these books of Moses, if an im- posture, could have been invented, and put upon the people who were then alive )Yhen all these things -were said to be done. "^ 20 EASY iVtETIIOJ> The utmost therefore, that even ii supfios? can stretch to, is, that these books wey^ wrote in some age after Moses, and put out in his name. And to this I say, that if it was ro, it was impossible that those books should have been received as the books of Moses, in that age wherein they may have been supposed to have been first invented. Why ? Because they speak of themselves as delivered by Moses, and kept in the ark from his time. And it came, to pass^ -when Moses had made an end of writing the words of this laxu in a book^ until theij -were finished ; that Moses commanded the Levites ■which bear the ark of the covenant of the Lor d^ sayings take this hook of the laiv^ and put it in the side of tJie ark of the covenant of the Lord your God^ that it may be there for a rvitness against thee^ Deut. xxxi. 24, 25, 26. And there was a copy of this book to be left likewise with the king. And it shall be when he sitteth up- on the throne of his kingdom^ that he shall write him a copy of this law in a book^ out of that -which is before the priests the Le- vites. And it shall be with him^ and he shall read therein all the days of hi^- ife; that he may learn to fear the Lord his God^ to- keep ^llMe words of this law^ and these stakUtes^ iq do themy Deut. xvii. 18, 19. AVITH THE DEISTS. *2l Here you see that this book of the law speaks of itself, not only as an history or relation of what things were then done ; but as the standing and municipal law and sta- tutes of the nation of the Jews, binding the king as well as the people. Now, in whatever age after Moses you will suppose this book to have been forged, it was impossible it could be received as truth ; because it was not then to be found, cither in the ark, or with the king, or any where else : for when first invented, every body must know, that they had never heard of it before. And therefore they could less believe it to be the book of their statutes, and the standing law of the land, which they had all along received, and by which they had been governed. Could any man, now at this day, invent a book of statutes, or acts of parliament, for England, and make it pass upon the nation as the only book of statutes that ever they had known ? As impossible was it for the books of Moses (if they were invented in any age after Moses) to have been received for what they declare themselves to be, viz. the statutes and municipal law of the nation of the Jews ; and to have persuaded the 2^ EASY METHOD Jews, that they had owned and acknow- ledged these books, all along from the day of Moses, to that day in which thy were first invented : that is, that they had owned them before they had ever so much as heard of them. Nay, more, the whole nation must, In an instant, forget their former laws and government, if they could receive theses books, as being their former laws. And they could not otherwise receive them, because they vouch themselves so to he. Let me ask the Deists but this one short question, was there ever a book of sham laws, which were not the laws of the nation, palmed^ upon any people since the world began ? If not» with what face can they say this of the book of the laws of the Jews ? Why will they say that of them, which they confess impossible in any nation or among any people ? * But they must be yet more unreasonable. For the books of Moses have a further de- monstration of their truth, than even other law books have ; for they not only contain the laws, but give an historical account of their institution, and the practice of them from that tirtie : as of the passover, in: me- mory of the death of the first-born in Egypt* and that the same day, all' the first-born of Israel, both of man and beast, were, by a * ^umb. viii. ir, 18. AVXTH THE DEISTS^. >^2J perpetual law, dedicated to Crod ,* and the -ijfevites taken for all the first-born of the -iehildren of Israel : that Aaron's rod which fibiidded; was kept in the ark, in memory bf ^#ie rebellion and wonderful destruction of ■^Korah, Dathan, and Abiram : and for the r^^nfirmation of the priesthood to the tribe 'Aif J^evi : as likewise the pot of manna, in -=4iEiemory of their having been fed with it -forty years in the wilderness : that the bra- zen serpent was kept (which remained to the days of Hezekiah, 2 Kings xviii. 4) in memory of that wonderful deliverance, by -onlyiooking upon it, from the biting of the ~^ery serpent. Numb. xxi. 9 : the feast of '-Pentecost, in memory of the dreadful ap- .-'pearance of God upon mount Horeb, ^c, xVnd besides these remembrances of par- ticular actions and occurrences, there were other solemn institutions in memory of their deliverance out of Egypt, in the general, which included all the particulars ; as of • the Sabbath, Deut, v. 1 5 ; their daily sacri- ^-fices, and yearly expiation ; their new moons -and several feasts and fasts. So that there • were yearly, monthly, weekly, daily remem- brances and recognitions of these things. And not only so, but the books of the same JMoses tell us, that a particular tribe (of Levi) was appointed and consecraled 24 EASY METHOD by God, as his priests; by whose hands, and none other, the sacrifices of the people were to be offered, and these solemn insti- .tLitions to be celebrated: that it was death for any other to approach the altar: that their high priest wore a glorious mitre, and magnificent robes of God's own contrivance, rJwith the miraculous Urim and Thummim in his breast-plate, whence the divine res- ponses were given"^ : that, at his word, the king, and all the people, were to go out, and to come in : that these Levites were likewise the chief judges, even in all civil causes ; and that it was death to resist their sentence! . Now, whenever it can be suppo- sed, tliat these books of Moses v/ere forged, in some ages after Moses, it is impossible.^ they could have been received as true, un- less the forgers could have made the whole nation believe, that they had received these books from their fathers ; had been instruct- ed in them when they were children, and had taught them to their children; moreo- ver, that they had all been circumcised, and did circumcise their children in pursuance ftp, what was commanded in these books ; that they had observed the yearly passover, the weekly sabbath, the new moons, and all these several feasts, fasts, and ceremo- *^Vx/7^. xxvi). 21. fBeit-t. xVii. 8. 1-31 C^rorj.xxili.4- UIXH THE DEISTS, 25 nies, commanded in these books : that they had never eaten any swine's flesh, or other meats prohibited in these books ; that they **i h^d a magnificent tabernacle, with a visible ■'priesthood to administer in it, which w^as confined to the tribe of Levi; over whom was placed a glorious high priest, clothed with great and mighty prerogatives ; whpse — death only could deliver those that.w^ere -'^^fled to the cities of refuge'* ; and that these priests were their ordinary judges, even in civil matters : I say, was it possible to have persuaded a whole nation of men, that they had known and practised all these things, if they had not done it? oy^ secondly^ to have received a book for truth, which said they had practised them, and appealed to that practice ? so that here are the third and fourth of the marks above men- tioned. But now let us descend to the utmost de- gree of supposition, viz* That these things were practised before these books of Mo- £es were forged : and that these books did only impose upon the nation, in making them believe, that they had kept these obser- vances in memory of such and such things as were inserted in those books. * Xiutib. XXXV. 25, ?8, . C oG EASY METHOI) -• ■ . ' . /■ Well^ then, let us proceed upon thi$ sup- position, however groundless. And now, "*ViU not the same impossibilities occur as in ■^^ the former casei* ioi\ firsty this must sup- '•■•pose that the Jews kept all these obseryan- • Ce^ in memory of nothing,.or without know- ing any thing of their original, or the rea- •^bn why they kept them: whereas these Very observances did express the ground - and reason of their being kept ; as the;pass- over, in memory of God's passing over "'the children of the Israelites, in that night wherein he slew all the first-born of JE«ypt; and so of the rest. But, iSeeofidlfjy IjQt us suppose, contrary both to reason and matter of fact, that the Jews -did not know any reason at all why they kept these observances ; yet was.it possible to put it upon them, that they had kept these observances in memory of what they had never heard of before that day, when- soever you will suppose that these books of 3Ioses were first forged ? For example, suppose I should now forge some romantic story, of strange things done a thousand years ago ; and, in confirmation of this, should efideavour to pursuade the Christian world, that they had all along, from that day to this, kept the first day of the week AVITH THE DETSTS. 27 in memon: of such a hero, an Apollonins, a Barcosbas, or a Mahomet ; and had all been baptised in his name ; and swore by his name, and upon that very book, (which I had then forged, and which they never saw before) in their public judicatures ; that this book was their gospel, and law, which they had ever since that time, these thou- sand years past, universally received and owned, and none other : I would ask any Deist, whether he thinks it possible, that such a cheat could pass, or such a legend be received, as the gospel of Christians ? and that they could be made believe, that they never had had any other gospel ? the same reason is as to the books of Moses : and must be as to every matter of fact which has all the four marks before mentioned. And these marks secure any such matter of fact as much from being invented and imposed in any after ages^ as at the time when such matters of fact were said to be done. Let me give one very familiar example more in this case. There is the Stonhenge in Salisbury plain, every body knows it ; and yet none knows the reason -why those great stones were set there, or by whom, or in- memory of what. • Now, suppose I should^, write a book to- morrow, and tell there, thatthcse stones were 28 , EASY METHOD set up by Hercules, Polyphemus, or Gara- grtntua, in memory of such and such of their adtions ; and for a further confirmation of this, should say in this book, that it was wrote at the time when such actions were done, and by the very actors themselves, or eye- witnesses ; and that this book had been received as truth, and quoted by authors of the greatest reputation in all ages since ; moreover that this book was well known in England, and injoined by act of parlia- ment to be taught our children ; and that we did teach it to our children, and had been taught it ourselves when we were chil- dren : I ask any Deist, whether he thinks this could pass upon England ? and w^hether if I or any other, should insist upon it, we should not, instead of being believed, be sent to "Bedlam ? Now let us compare this with the Ston- hengc, as I may call it, or twelve great stones set up at Gilgal, which is told in the 4th chapter of Joshva. I'hcre it is said, V. 8. That the reason why they were set up was, that when their children, in after ages, should ask the meaning of it, it should be told them. And the thing iiv memory of which they were set up, was such as could not possibly be imposed upon that nation, at that time WITH THE DEISTS. 29 when it was said to be done, it was as won- derful and miraculous as their passage through the Red sea. And withal free from a very poor ob- jection, which the Deists have advanced against that miracle of the Red sea : think- ing to salve it by a spring-tide with the con- currence of a strong wind happening at the same time ; which left the sand so dry, ap that the Israelites, being all foot, might pass through the oozy places and holes, which, it must be supposed, the sea left behind it : but that the Egyptians, being all horse and chariots, stuck in those holes, and were in- tangled, so that they could not march so fast as the Israelites : and that this wras all the meaning of its being said, that God took off their (the Egpytians) chariot- wheels, that they drove them heavily. So that they would make nothing extraordi- nary, at least not miraculous, in all this action. This is advanced in Le Clerc's disserta- tions upon Genesis^ lately printed in Hol- land.^ And that pan, with others of the like tendency, endeavouring to resolve other miracles, as that of Sodom and Go- morrah, &c. into the mere natural causes, ' I.c Clerc lived to recant his opmion. 30 EASY METHOD are put into English by the well known T». Brown, for the edification of the Deiats in England. ^ - • Bat these gentlemen have forgot, that 'the Israelites had great herds of manv thou- sand cattle with thtm ; which would be apter to stray, and fall into those holes and oozy places in the sand, than horses, with riders, who might direct them. '^ ; But such precarious and silly supposes are not worth the answering. If there had been no more in this passage through the Red sea than that of a spring-tide, &c. it had been impossible for Moses to hav.e made the Israelites believe that relation gtv^en-of it "in Exodus^ with so many parti- culars, which themselves saw to be true. , • And all those scriptures which magnify this action, and appeal to it as a full de- monstration of the miraculous power of (jod, must be reputed as romance or le- gend, I say this for the sake of some Christi- ans, who think it no prejudice to the truth of the Holy Bible, but rather an advantage, as renderingiit more easy to be believed, if they can solve whatever seems miraculous in it, by the power of second causes ; and so to make all, as they speak, natural and easy. Wherein, U' they could prjevail, the WITH THE DEISTS. CI natural, and easy result would be, not to believe one word in all those sacred ora- cles : for if things be not as they are told in any relation, that relation must be false,; and if false in part, we cannot trust to it, either in whole, or in part. Here are to be excepted mistranslations and errors, either in copy, or in press. But where there is no room for supposing of these, as where all copies do agree, there we must either receive all, or reject all : I mean in any book that pretends to be writ- ten from the mouth of God ; for in other €ommbii histories, we may believe part, and ^Z^ect pai"t, as we see cause, ^t,; But to return : The passage of the Isra- elites over Jordan, in memory of which those stones at Gilgal were set up, is free from all those little carpings before-men- tioned, that are made as to the passage through the 1R.g(\ sea ; for notice was given to the ,Isr,aelites the day before, of this great miracle to be done, yos/i. iii. 5. It was ,,done at noon-day, before the whole nation. ^,And when the waters of Jordan were di- ^'.Vided, it Avas not at any low ebb, but at .'^the time when that river overflowed all his banks, v. 15. And it was done, not by winds, or in length of time, which winds must take to do it ; but all on the sudden : ^2 EASY METHOD As soon as the feet of the priests that bare the ark^ were dipped in the brim of the xva- ter^ then the waters which came doxvnfrom above^ stood and rose up upon an heap^ very far from the city Adam^ that is beside Za~ retan^ and those that came down toxvard the sea of the plain^ even the salt-sea failed^ and xvere cut off: and the people passed over rig'ht against Jericho* The priests stood in the midst of Jordan, until all the armies of Israel had passed over. And it came to pass^ xvhen the priests that bare the ark of the covenant of the Lord^ "were come up out of the midst of Jordan^ and the soles of the priests'* feet xvere lift upon the dry kmd^ that the xuaters of Jordan returned unto their place^ and foxved over all his banks^ as they did before. And the people came up out of Jordan on the tenth day of the first months and encamped in GilgcU in the east border of Jericho* And those twelve stories xvhich they ' took out of JordaUy did Joshua pitch in GilgaL And he spake unto the children of Israel^ sayings When your children shall ask their fathers in time to come, saying, What mean these stones ? then ye shcill let your children knoxv, saying, Israel came over this Jordan on dry land* For the Lord your God dried up the waters of Jordan from b fore you, until ye^xveve WITH THE DEISTS. 33 passed over ^ as the Lord your Gcd didto tlie Red sea^ which he dried up froni before uSy until xve were ^one over ; that all the peo- ple of the earth might' know the^hand of the Lordy that it is mighty : that yemight fear the Lord your God for ever, chap. iy. trom V. 18. ^ If the passage over the Red sea had been only takmg advantage of a sprmg-tide,' or the like ; how would this teach all the peo^ " pie of the earth, that the hand of the Lord ' was mighty ? How would a thing no more remarkable, have been taken notice of through all the world ? How would it have taught Israel to fear the Lord, when they mu&t know, that, notwithstanding of all these big words, there was so little in it ? How could they have believed, or re- ceived a book as truth, which they knew told the matter so far otherwise from what it was ? , But, as I said, this passage over Jordan, which is here compared to that of the Red sea, is free from all those cavils that are made as to that of the Red sea ; and is a further attestation to it, being said to be- done in the same manner, as was that of the Red sea. Now, to form our argument, let us sup- pose, that there never was any such thing 54 KASY METHOD as that passage over Jordan ; that these stones at Gilgal were set up upon some other occasion, in some after age ; and then that some designing man invented this book of Joshua^ and said, that it was wrote by Joshua at that time ; and gave this stonage at Gilgal, for a testimony of the truth of it : Would not every body say to him,' We know the stonage at Gilgal ; but we never heard before of this reason for it, nor ofc; this book of Joshua : Where has it been • all this while ? and where, and how came you, after so many ages, to find it? Be- sides, this book tells us, that this passage over Jordan was ordained to be taught our children, from age to age ; and therefore that they were always to be instructed in the meaning of that stonage at Gilgal, as a memorial of it : but we were never taught it when we were children, nor did ever teach our children any such thing : And it is not likely chat could have been forgotten, while so remarkable a stonage did conti- nue, which was set up for that, Jlnd no other end. And if, for the reasons before given, no such imposition could be put upon us as to the stonage in Salisbury plain"; how much less could it be as to the gtonage at Gilgal ? And if, where we know not the reason \nTH THE DEISTS. 35 ot a bare naked monument, such a sham reason cannot be imposed ; how much more is it impossible to impose upon us in ac- tions and observances v/hich we celebrate in memory of particular passages ; how iinipossible to make us forget those pas- sages which we daily commemorate, and persuade us, that we had always kept such institutions in memory of what we never heard of before ; that is, that we knew it before we knew it. And if we find it thus impossible for an imposition to be put upon us, even in some things which have not ali the four marks before-mentioned ; how much more impos- sible is it, that any deceit should be in. that thing where all the four marks do meet ? This has been showed, in the first place, as to the matters of fact of Moses. - 2. Therefore I come now, secondly^ to show, that, as in the matters of fact of Moses, so likewise all these four marks do meet in the matters of fact which are re- corded in the gospel of our blessed Saviour. And my work herein will be the shorter ; because all that is said before, of Moses ^and his books, is every way applicable to Christ and his gospel. His works and mi- racles are there said to be done publicly, in the face of tlie world ; as he argued to , .;56 , EASY METHOD h.)^SiCC}istYS, Ispake open^ly to the world, and iji secret have I said nothings John xviii. io. It is told, Acts lu 41. that three thou- ^/sahd at one tjme, and, Acts iv. 4. that above ^^^ 'iive thousand at anotlier time, were con- y ertedji upon conviction of what themselves f liad'Seen, what had been done publicly be- ,jfpi*e their ej^es, w^herein it was impossible ' to have ' imposed upon them. Therefore J here.\v^ere the two first of the rules before- ineritioiifed.* ' * The instantaneous conversion of thousands was .wrought by means of public appeals to notorious matter ^f fact. Hear the lang-uage of the Apostles to tlie Jews : 21iis ye ymirsehes Know, Acts it. 24. Ye KNOW the thingg done thvoiigh all Jwffea, Acts X, 37, 38. The king knoweth these 'things.. Tlds thing ivas li or done in a corner. .^ Acts xxvi. 26. Now jf Christianity is not founded upon indubitable facts, might you not as well believe, that twelve men broke loose from Bedlam, last year, brought thousands of Deists over to Christianity, by saying to them, " Je knoxv^' — what you are perfect strangers to; that is, *' Ve kno-iv" — that we are a pack of bedlamites ? If the gospel is forged, you believe that the Co- rinthians, &c. handed do v/n to posterity, as a sacred treasure. Epistles where St. Paul mentions their amazing conversion from gross immoralities; con- gratulates them about the spiritual or miraculous gifts, in which they abounded, 1 Cor. xii. 1. and gives them particular directions, how to use ihe gift of tongues to edification ; when yet they were totally imrxquainted with any such things? ' ' , If you believe ^vit!^ some infidels, that tliS history ■■ ■ ■■■-■■:- '■;. :.:iij 1 • .;.; WITH THE DEISTS. ^f *rhen for the two second : Baptism and the Lord's supper were instituted as perpe- tual memorials of these things : and they were not instituted in afar ages, but at the i-ery time when these things were said to be done ; and have been observed without interruption in all ages through the whole Christian world, down ail the way from that time to this. And Christ himself did ordain apostles, and other ministers of his gospel, to preach, and administer these sa- craments, and to govern his church ; and that always, even unto the end of the world.* Accordingly they, have continued of Christ is " a mere fable," and that there never was such an extraordinary person, you believe that the Heachens, the Jews, and the Mahometans, have agreed with the Christians, their sworn enemies, to carry on a most amazing- imposture For Pliny, Ta- citus, Lucian, and Suetonius, heathen authors, who lived soon after Christ, make express mention of him : as do also Mahomet, many of the Rabbies, and Julian tlie Etnperor, that powerful and crafty apos- tate, Av'ho not only never denied Christ's existence, but openly acknowledged that Paul, Mark, Mat- thew, and Petei*, were the authors of the g-ospels and epistles, which bear their name. Now is not this a» ridiculous as to believe, that the Pope, the Mufti, and the inquisitors, have laid their heads with Messrs. Voltaire, Hume, and Rousseau, to favour a forgery subversive of popen-, mahometanisni, and ijpfideiitv ? • ^atth. xxviJU. 20^ P 38 EASY METIIOET by regular succession, to this day ; and, no doubt, ever shall, while the earth shall last* So that the Christian clergy are as notori- ous a matter of fact, as the tribe of L^vi among the Jews. And the gospel is as. much a law to the Christians," as the book of Moses to the Jews : and it being part of the matters of fact related in the gospel, tliat such an order of men were appointed b}' Christ, and to continue to the end of the vvorld.; consequently, if the gospel was a fiction, and invented (as it must be) in some ages after Christ; then, at that time when it was first invented, there could be no such order of clergy as derived them- selves from the institution of Christ ; which lYiust give the lie to the gospel, and demon- strate the whole to be false. And the mat- ters of fact of Christ being pressed to be true, no otherwise than as there was, at that time, (whenever the Deists will suppose the gospel to be forged) not only public sacra- ments of Christ's institution, but an order of clergy likewise, of his appointment, to administer them ; and it being- impossible there could be any such things before they were invented, it is as impossible that they, should be received wheri invented. Aiid therefore, by what was said above,' it was as impossible to have imposed upon man. WITH THE DEISTS. 39 kind In this matter, by inventing of it in after ages, as at the time when those things were said to be done. 3. The matters of fact of Mahomet, or what is fabled of the Heathen deities, do all want some of the aforesaid four rules, whereby the certainty of matters of fact is demonstrated. First, For Mahomet, he pretended to no miracles, as he tells us in his Alcoran, chap. 6, &c. and those which ^^re commonly told of him, pass among the Mahometans themselves but as legendary fables ; and as such, are rejected by the wise and learned among them, as the le- gends of their saints are in the church of Rome. See Dr. Prideaux's Life of Ma- homet, p. 34. But, in the next place, those v/hich are told of him do all want the two first rules before-mentioned. For his pretended con- verse with the moon ; his mersa, or night- journey from Mecca to Jerusalem,, and thence to Heaven, &c. were not performed- before any body. We have only his own v/ord for them. And they are as ground- less as the delusions of Fox, or Muggleton, among ourselves. The same is to be said, in the second place, of the fcibles of the Heathen gods, of Mercury's stealing sheep, Jupiter's turn- 40 «. EASY METHOD ing himself into a bull, and the like : be- sides the folly and unworthiness of such senseless pretended miracles. And more- over, the wise among the Heathen did reckon no otherwise of these but as fables, which had a mythology, or mystical mean- ing in them ; of which several of them have given us the rationale^ or explication. And it is plain enough, that Ovid meant no other by all his metamorphoses. It is true, the Heathen deities had their priests : they had likewise feasts, games, and other public institutions in memory of them. But all these want the fourth mark, viz. That such priesthood and institutions should commence from the time that such things as they commemorate were said to be done, otherwise they cannot secure after ages from the imposture, by detecting it at the time when first invented, as hath been ar- gued before. Bat the Bacckanalia, and other Heathen feasts, were instituted many ages after what was reported of these gods was said to be done, and therefore can be no proof of them. And the priests of Bac- chus, Apollo, &c. were not ordained by these supposed gods, but were appointed by others, in after ages, only in honour to them. And therefore these orders of priests are no evidence to the truth of the matters of fact which are reported of their gods. WITH THE DEISTS. 41 IV. Now to apply what has been said, vou may challenge all the Deists in the world to show any action that is fabulous, which has all the four rules or marks be- fore-mentioned. No ; it is impossible. And, to resume a little what is spoke to before, the histories of Exodus, and the gospel, could never have been received, if they had not been true ; because the insti- tution of the priesthood of Levi, and of Christ, of the sabbath, the passo\'er, of cir- cumcision, of baptism, and the Lord's sup- per, &c. are there related, as descending all the way down from those times without interruption. And it is fall as impossible, to persuade men that they had been cir- cumcised, baptized, had circumcised, or baptized their children, celebrated passo- vers, sabbaths, sacraments, 8vC. under the government and administration of a certain order of priests, if they had done none of these things, as to make them believe that they had gone through seas upon dry land, seen the dead raised, &c. And without be- lieving of these, it was impossible that either the law or the gospel could have been received. And the truth of the matters of fact of Exodus and the gospel, being no othei'wise pressed upon men, than as they have orac- D 2 42 ^ASY METHOD tised such public institutions, it is appeal- ing to the senses of mankind for the truth of them : and makes it impossible for any to have invented such stories in after ages, without a palpable detection of the cheat, when first invented; as impossible as to have imposed upon the senses of mankind at the time when such public matters of fact were said to be done. V. I do not say, that every thing which wants these four marks, is false ; but that nothing can be false which has them all. There is no manner of doubt that there was such a man as Julius Caesar, that he fought at Pharsalia, was killed in the senate house, and many other matters of fact of ancient times, though we keep no public observances in memory of them. But this shows, that the matters of fact of Moses, and of Christ, have come down to us better guarded than any other mat- ters of fact, how true soever. And yet our Deists, who would laugh any man out of the world, as an irrational brute, that should offer to deny Caesar or Alexander, Homer or Virgil, their public works and actions, do, at the same time, value themselves as the only men of wit and sense, of free, generous, and unbiassed judgments, for ridiculing the histories of WITH THE DEISTS. 45 Moses and Christ, that are infinitely better attested, and guarded with infallible marks, which the others want. VI. Besides, tliat the importance of the subject would oblige all men to inquire more narrowly into the one than the other. For what consequence is it to me, or to the world, v/hether there was such a man as Caesar : whether he beat, or was beaten at Pharsalia ; whether Homer or Virgil wrote such books ; and whether what is related in the Iliads or -Sineids, be true, or false ? It is not two-pence up or down to any man in the world. And therefore it is worth no man's while to inquire into it, either to op- pose or justify the truth of these relations. But our very souls and bodies, both this life and eternity, are concerned in the truth of what is related in the Holy Scriptures ; and therefore men would be more inquisi- tive to search into the truth of these, than of any other matters of fact, examine and sift them narrowly, and find out the deceit, if any such could be found : for it concern- ed them nearly, and was of the last import- ance to them. How unreasonable, then, is it to reject these matters of fact, so sifted, so examin- ed, and so attested, as no other matters of fact in the world ever were ; and yet to 44 EASY METHOD think it the most highly unreasonable, even to madness, to deny other matters of fact, which have not the thousandth part of their evidence, and are of no consequence at all to us whether true or false ? VI T. There are several other topics, from whence the truth of the Christian re- ligion is evinced to all who will judge by reason, and give themselves leave to con- sider : As the improbability that ten or twelve poor illiterate fishermen should form a design of converting the whole world to believe their delusions; and the impossibility of their effecting it, without force of arms, learning, oratory, or any one visible thing that could recommend them ; and to impose a doctrine quite opposite to the lusts and pleasures of men, and all worldly advantages or enjoyments ,• and this in an age of so great learning and sa- gacity, as that v/herein the gospel was first preached : That these apostles should not only undergo all the scorn and contempt, but the severest persecutions, and most cruel deaths, that could be inflicted, in at- testation to what themselves knew to be a mere deceit and forgery, of their own con- triving. Some have suffered for errors which the}^ thought to be truth ; but never any for what themselves knew to be lies. WITH THE DEISTS. 45 And the apostles must know what they taught, to be lies, if it was so ; because they spoke of those things which they had both seen and heard, had looked upon and han- dled with their hands, tri*it«, his coartrers, and no doubt a vast number of WITH THE BEISTS. 5.I This is particularly insisted on, in the Method tvith the Jexvs. And even the De- ists must confess, that that book we call the Old Testament^ was in being, in tTie hands of the JeAvs, long before our Saviour came into the world.* And if they will be at th(2 pains to compare the prophecies that are there of the Messiah, with the fulfilling of them, as to time, place, and all other circumstances, in the person, birth, life, death, resurrection, and ascension of our idolatrous worshippers : O altavy altar ^ thus sa^8 the JLn rd, behold, a child sJuiR be born tinto the house rtj Dnvidy Josiah by name, -aho shall bum men*s bonei i/pon thee: and this is the sig'n : Behold, this very da y, the attar shall be rent, mid tlie ashes that are upon it scattered. King Jeroboam inflamed \vith ang'er, stretched forth his hand against the man of Godj say- in^-^ to his guards, Lay Iwld on him : But his extend^ ed hand -was dned up so that Jte coiddnot pull it in ag^ain to Mm : the rending of the altar, and the scatter- ing- of the iire, instantly took place ; and the capital pro phecy ^as exactly fulfilled by pious king Josiah, as Tou may see by comparing 1 Kings xiii. 1, with 2 kings xxiii. 15. Can we rciv^^onably suppose, that books, containing accounts of inch public events, would have been received as divine by a divided peo- ple^ if tlieir authenticity had not been coniii*med. by tndnbitable matter of fact ? * Their wonderful preservation of that book, and consequently the prophetic histoiy of Christ, whom Ihey reject, is itself a proof, that infinite wisdom even overrules enemies toJ^bear reluctant testimony to the truth. 52 EASY METHOD blessed Saviour, they will find this prove what our apostle here calls it, a light l;hm' ing in a dark place^ until the daij dawn^ and the daij-€tar arise in your hearts, W hich God grant. Here is no possibility of cje,-, ceit or imposture. ' ;* j Old prophecies, and all so agreeing, coilld not ha\'e been contriyecj to countenance; a new^chtat ; and nothing could be a che|vt> that could fulfil all these. j ; , For this therefore, 1 refer the Deists jto the Method xvith the Jezvs. \ • J desire them likewise to look there, \9e<^^, 11, and consider the prophecies given iiO long, a^'o, of which they see the fulfilling it this day, with their own eyes, of •the state of the Jews, for nvany ages past, and at present ; without a king, or priest, or terii.f pie, or sacrifice, scattered to the four winds, fyifted.as with a sieve, among all nations ; yet preserved, and ahvays so to be, a dis- tinct 'people from\ ail; others of the whole cjar-th. "^t'hereas those jnighty monarcl]ies .which oppressed the Jews, and which c<;m- manded the world,, in their turns, and hii.d the greatest humah prospect of perpetuity^ v/ere to be extinguished, as they have been, even that their na^mes should be blotted out fj-pm under Heaven, As likewise, that as reniarkabie,.j9Lpm WITH THE DEISTS. 5:; blessed Saviour, concerning the pres^erva- tion and progress of the Christian Churchy when in her swaddling-clothes, consisting only of a few poor fishermen ; not by the sword, as that of Mahomet, but under all the persecution of men and hell; which yet should not prevail against her. But though I offer these, as not to be slighted by the Deists, to which they can show nothing equal in all profane history, and in which it is impossible any cheat can lie ; yet I put them not upon the same foot as the prophecies before-mentioned of the marks and coming of the Messiah, which- have been since the world began. (" And that general expectation of the whole earth at the time of his coming, insisted upon in the Method xvitli the JezvSy sect, 5. is greatly to be noticed. But, I say, the foregoing prophecies of our Saviour, are so strong a proof, as even miracles' would not be sufficient to break their authority. I mean, if it were possible that a true miracle could be v*rought in contradiction to them : for that would be for God to con- tradict himself. But no sign, or wonder, that could if^' sibly be solved, should shake this evidence. It is this that keeps the Jews in their ob- E 2 54 EASY METHOD stinacy./ Thobgh they caimot deny the mat- i ters ol'ifact done by our blessed Saviour to I be truly miracles, if so done as said ; nor i can they deny that they were' so done, be-^ cause they have all the four marks before-/ mentix^ned : yet they cannot yield! Why ? Because they think that the gospel is in_ contradiction to the law. Which if it were, the cousbquence would be unavoidable, that both could not be true. To solve this, is the business of the Method with the Jews* But the contradiction Mhich they suppose, is in their comments that they put upon the, law ; especially they expect a literal fulfil- ing of those promises of the restoration of Jerusalem, and outward glories of the church ; of v/hich there is such frequent mention in the books of Moses, the Psalms^ and ail the prophets. And many Christi- ans do expect the same, and take those texts as literally as the Jews do. We do believe, and pray for the conversion of the Jews. For this end they have been so miraculously preserved, according to the prophecies so long before of it. And when, that time shall come, as they are the most honourable and ancient of all the nations on the.jearth ; so will their church return to Ipe the mother christian church as she was at first ; and Home must surrender to Jeruaa- WITH THE DEISTS. 5S lem. Then all nations will flow thither ; and even Kzekiel's temple may be literaily built there, in the metropolis of the whole earth ; v/hich Jerusalem m.ust be, when the fulness of the Gentiles shall meet with the conver- sion of the Jews : for no nation will then contend -with the Jews, nor church with Jerusalem far supremucv. All nations will be ambitious to draw their original from the Jews,- whose are the fathers, and from ithom, as concerning the flesh, Christ camev ' Then will be fulfilled that outward gran- deur and restoration of the Jews, and of Jerusalem^ which they expect, pursuant to the prophecies. They pretend not that this is limited to any particular time of the reign of the Mes- siah. They are sure it will not be at the beginning ; for they expect to go through great conflicts and trials with their Mes- siah, (as the Christian Church has done,) before his final conquest, and that they come to reign v/ith him. So that this is no ob- struction to their embracing of Christianity. They see the same things fulfilled in us, which they expect themselves ; and we ex- pect the same things they do. I tell tins to the Deists, lest they may think that the Jews have some stronger arguments- than they know of; that they ^ ^6 EASY METHOD are not persuaded by the miracles of oiir blessed Saviour, and by the fulfilling of all the prophc'cies in him, that were made con- cerninq; the Messiah. As 1 said before, I would not plead even miracles against these. And if this is suliicient to persuade a Jew, it is much more so to a Deist, who labours not under these objections. Besides, I would not seem to clash with that (in a sound sense) reasonable caution, used by Christian writers, not to put the issue of the truth wholly upon miracles^ without this addition, when not done in contradiction to the revelations already given in the Holy Scriptures. And they do it upon this consideration^ That though it is impossible to suppose, that God would work a real miracle, in contradiction to what he has already re- v^ealed ; yet men may be imposed upon by false and seeming miracles, and pretended revelations, (as there are many examples, especially in the church of Rome,) and so may be shaken in the faith, if they keep BOt to the Holy Scriptures as their rule. We are told, 2 Thess, ii. 9. of hhn whose coming' is after the ivorking of Satan., with ail poiver, and signs., and lying wonders ; and Rev, xiii. 14. xvi. 14« and xix. 20» of Wmr THE DEISTS. 5t the devil and false prophets working mira- cles. But the word in nil these places is only Semeia^ signs^ that is as it is rendered; Matth, XXV. 24 j which, though sometimes it may be used to signify real miracles ; ye^'niot always, not in these places : for though every miracle be a sign, and a won- der ; yet every sign, or wonder, is not a miracle. X. Here it may be proper to consider a common topic of the Deists, who, when they are not able to stand out against the evidence of fact, that such and such mira- cles have been done, then turn about, and deny such things to be miracles, at least that we can never be sure whether any wonderful thing that is shown to us, be a true or a false miracle. And the great argument they go upon, is this, That a miracle being that which exceeds the power of nature, we cannot know what exceeds it, unless we know the utmost extent of the power of nature ; and no man pretends to know that : therefore that no man can certainly, know whether any event be miraculous; and, consequent- ly, he may be cheated in his judgment be- twixt true and false miracles. To v/hich I answer. That men may be so cheated ; and there are many examples of it. 58 EASY METHOD But that though Ave may not always know when we are cbc^ated ; yet wc can certainly tell, in many cases, when we are not cheat- ed. For though we do not know the utmost extent of the power of nature, perhaps in any one thing ; yet it does not follow, that we know not the nature of any thing, in some measure ; and that certainly too. F'or example : though I do not know the utmost extent of the power of fire ; yet I certainly know, that ic is the nature of fire to burn ; and that when proper fuel is administered to it, jt is contrary to the nature of fire not- to consume it. Therefore if I see three men taken off the street, in their common wearing apparel, and, without any prepara-* lion, cast into the midst of a burning fiery furnace ; and that the flame was so fierce, that it burnt up those men that threw them m ; and yet that those who were thrown in should walk up and doNvn in the bottom of the furnace, and I should see a fourth per- son with them, of glorious appearance, like the Son of God ; and that these men should come up again out of the furnace, without any harm, or so much as the smell of 6re upon themselves, or their cloaths : I could not be deceived, in thinking there v/as a stop put to the nature of fire as to these ^ATTH THE DEISTS. 59 raen ; and that it had its effect upon the men whom it burned, at the same time. Aeraixi, though i cannot tell how won- derful and sudden an increase of corn might be produced by the concurrence of many' causes ; as a warm chmate, the fertihty of the soil, &c. yet this I can certainly know, that there is not that natural force in the breath of two or three words spok n, to multiply one small loaf of bread, so fast, in the breaking of it, as truly and really, not only in appearance and show to the eye, but to fill the bellies of several thousand hun- gry persons ; and that the fragments should be much mpre than the bread was at lirst. So neither in a word spoken, to raise the dead, cure diseases, &c. Therefore, though we know not the ut- most extent of the power of nature ; yet we can certainly know what is contrary to the nature of several such things as we do know. And therefore, though we may be cheat- ed and imposed upon in many seeming mi- racles and wonders ; yet there are some things wherein we may be certain. But further, the Deists acknowledge a God of an almighty power, who made all things. Yet they wpuld put it out of his power. 60 EASY METHOD to make any revelation of his will to man- kind. For if we cannot be certain of anjr miracle, how should we know when God sent any thing extraordinary to us ? Nay, how should we know the ordinary power of nature, if we knew not what ex- ceeded it ? If we knew not what is natural, how, do we know there is such a thiiig as nature t tiiat ail is not supernatural, all mi- racles, and so disputable, till we come to downright scepticism, and doubt the cer- tainty of our outvv'ard senses, whether we see, hear, or feel, or all be not a miraculous illusion? Which because I know the^ Deists are not inclined to do, therefore I will return to pursue my argument upon the conviction. of our outward senses ; desiring only this, that they would allow the senses of other men to be as certain as their own. Which they cannot refuse, since without this they can have no certiiinty of their own. - Xi. Therefore, from what has been said, the cause is summed up shortly in this : That though we cannot see what was done before our time ; yet, by the marks which I have laid down concerning the certainty of matters of fact done before our time, we may be as much ass'ured of the truth of them, as if we saw them with our eyes ; be- WITH THE DEISTS. 61 cause whatever matter of fact has all the four marks before-mentioned, could never have been invented, and received, but upon the conviction of the outward senses of all those vv^ho did receive it, as before is de- monstrated. And therefore, this topic, which I have chosen, does stand upon the conviction even of mens outward senses. And since you have confined me to one topic, I have not insisted upon the other, which I have only named. XII. And now it lies upon the Deists, if they would appear as men of reason, to show some matter of fact of former ages, which they allow to be true, that has greater evidence of its truth, than the matters of fact of Moses and of Christ, as no other matters of fact of those times, however true, have, but these only : and I put it upon them to show any forgery that has all these marks. This is a short issue. Keep them close to this. This determines the cause all at once. Let them produce their Apollonius Tya- nseus, whose life was put into English by the execrable Charles Blount ;'^ and com- pared, with all the wit and malice he was * Who became his ovn exeeutioner. 62 EASY METHOD master of, to the life and miracles of our blessed Saviour. Let them take aid from all the legends in the church of Rome, those pious cheats, the sorest disgraces of Christianity; aiid which have bid the fairest, of any one con- trivance, to overturn the certainty of the Iniracles of Christ, and his apostles, and the whole truth of the gospel, by putting tiieni all upon the same footing ; at least, they are so understood by the generality of their devotees, though disowned and laughed at by the learned, and men of sense, among them. Let them pick and choose the most pro- bable of all the fables of the Heathen dei- ties ; and see if they can find, in any of these, the four marks before-mentioned. Otherwise let them submit to the irrifra- gable certainty of the Christian Religion. XIII. But if, notwithstanding of all that is said, the Deists will still contend. That all this is but priestcraft, the invention of priests, for their own profit, &c ,* then they will give us an idea of priests far different from what they intend : for then we must look upon these priests, not only as the cunningest and wisest of mankind, but we shall be tempted to adore them as deities, who have such power as to impose at their WITH THE DfelStS. 65 pleasure, upon the senses of manic irid, to make them believe, that they had practised such public institutions, enacted them b}^ laws, taught them to their children, &c. ivhen they had never done an\' of these things, or ever so much as heard of them before : and then, upon the credit of their believing that they had done such thin than any historj^ extant in the Heathen world. The Heathens, in imitation of him, pretended, likewise, to their revelations. But I have given those marks which distin- guish them from the true. None of them have those four marks before mentioned. Now, the Deists think all revelations to be equally pretended, and a cheat ; and the priests of all religions to be the same con- trivers and jugglers : and therefore they proclaim war equally against all, and are equally engaged to bear the briint of all. And if the contest be only betwixt the Deists and the priests, which of them are the men of the greatest parts and sense, let the effects determine it: and let the Deists yield the victory to their conquerors, who^ by their own confession, carry all the world before them. XYII. If the Deists say, That this is because all the world are blockheads, as well as those priests who govern them ; that all are blockheads, except the Deists, who vote themselves only to be men of sense ; this (besides the modesty of it) will spoil their great and beloved topic, in behalf of what they call natural religion, against the revealed, viz. appealing to the common rea- son of mankind. This they set up against revelation : think this to be sufficient for all WITH THE DEISTS. 69 the uses of men, here or hereafter, (if there be any after state) and therefore that there is no use of revelation. This common rea- son they advance as infallible, at least as the surest guide; yet now cry out upon it when it turns against them. V/hen this common reason runs after revelation, as it always has done, then common reason is a beast; and we must look for reason, not from the common sentiments of mankind, but only among the beaux, the Deists.* XYIII. Therefore if the Deists would * J\''ot many J^i'oble, not many Wise are called, says the Apostle; nevertheless some of both, even at the rise of Christianity, openly stood up for its truth. Among the noble we find Joseph, a member of the great Jewish council, Dionysius, one of the Judges at Athens, and Flavius Clemens, a Roman Senator; and among the -adse, Quadratus, Avis c ides, and Athenagoras, Athenian Philosophers; CiemenSj Ar- nobius, Ammonius, Annatolius, &c, men of great learning at Alexandria; and at Rome, Jostin martyr and TertuUian, both famous apologists for the reli- gion of Jesus, the latter of whom in the second cen- tury told the Roman governors, that their corpoi-a- tions, councils, and armies, and the emperor's palace, were full of Christians : nor is this im.probable ; since so early as St. Paul's days tJie saints of desar's house- hold saluted those of the Roman provinces. PMl. iv. 22. How credulous are they who can beLeve that persf.ns of such rank and learning, could be deliided by Jewish fishermen, into the worship of a crucified impostor I 70 BASY METl^D avoid the mortification, (which >vill be very uneasy to them) to yield, and sul>mit to be subdued and hewed down before the priests, whom of all mankind they hate and despise ; if they would avoid this, let them confess, as the truth is, That religion is no invention of priests, but of divine original: That priests were instituted by the same author of religion ; and that their order is a perpetual and living monument of the matters of fact of their religion, in- stituted from the time that such matters of fact were said to be done ; as the Levites from Moses; the apostles and succeeding fclergy from Christ to this day: That no Heathen priest can say the same : they were not appointed by the gods whom they served, but by others m after ages : they cannot stand the test ol the four rules be- Fore mentioned; which the Christian priests can do, and they only. Now, the Christiani priesthood, as instituted by Christ himself^ and continued by succession to this dhy^ being as impregnable and flagrant a testi- mony to the truth of the matters of fact of Christ, as the sacraments, or any other public institutions ; besides that, if the priesthood were taken away, the sacra- hients, and other public institutions, which are administered by their hands, must fall WITH THE DEISTS. 71 with them : ihereiore the devil has been most busy, and bent his greatest force, in all i'-j^cs, against the priesthood; knowing, that if that goes down, all goes with it. X'X. And now, last of all, if one word of advice vvoald not be lost upon men \\ ho think so unme^surably of themselves as the Deists, you may represent to them, what a condition they are in, who spend that life and sense which God has given them, in ridiculing the greatest of his blessings, his revela.tiono of Christ, and by Christ, to re- deem those from eternal misery who shall beli&ve in him and obey his laws : and that God, in his vvonderful mercy and v/isdom, has so guarded his revelations, as that it is past the power of men or devils to counter- feit: and that there is no denying of them, unless we will be so absurd as to deny, not only the reason, but the certainty of the outward senses, not only of one, or two, or three, !)ut of mankind in general : That this case is so veiy plain, that nothing but want of thought can hinder any to discover it : That they must yield it to be so plain, un- less they can show some forgery which has all the four marks before set down. But if they cannot do this, they must quit their cause, and yield a happy victory oyer themselves ; or else sit dovvn undqr all tnat ^2 EA-SY METHOD ignominy, vAth which they have loaded the priests, of being, not only the most perni- cious, but ^what will gall them more) the most inconsiderate, and inconsiderable of mankind. Therefore let them not think it an un- dervaluing of their worthiness, that their whole cause is comprised within so narrow a compass, and no more time bestowed upon it than it is worth. But let them rather reflect, how far they have been all this time from Christianity, whose rudiments they are yet to learn ; how far from the way of salvation ; how far the race of their lives is run, before they have set one step in the road to heaven; and therefore how much diligence they ought to use, to redeem all that time they have lost, lest they lose themselves for ever: and be convinced, by a dreadful experience, when it is too late, that the gosy^el is a truth, and of the last consequence.^^ * It is exceedingly remarkable, that the more humble and holy people ai-e, the more they read, admire, and value the scriptures; and on ^he con- trajy, the more self-conceived, worldly-minded, and wicked, the more they neg-lcct, despise, and asperse them. As for the objections which are raised ag-ainst their persplcui'y and consistency, those who are both pious and learned, know, .hut chey are »-eneral- ly founded on prepossession, and the want of undet- WITH THE DEIS.T3. 73 ;....i-.v.ling in spiritual things; or on our ignorance of sevei'ul customs, idioms, and circumstances, which were perfectly known when those books were writ- ten. Frequently also the immaterial error arises merely from a wrong punctuation, or a mistake of copiers, printers, or translators; as the daily discov- eries of pious critics, and ingenuous confLSiions of unprejudiced enquirers, abundantly prove. Sect. XlX:h is omitted, as containing sentiments not essential to the subject of the letter, PART II. SIX LETTERS SPIRITUAL MAMFESTATION SOX OF GOD. Bv THE Rev. JOHN FLETCHER, Vicar of JMaddey. I am not mad, most noble Festus ; but speak the words of truth and soberness. Acts xxvi. 25. Wisdom is justified of her children. Matt. xi. 19. G 2r IXTRODUCTION TO THE MANIFESTATION OF THE SPIRIT. HAVING in the " method with infidels" demon- strated, as it is believed, the truth and certain xialidity of the Holy Scriptures, we come next, in order, to prove the certiiinty of the manifestation of the Spirit of the Son of God to the souls and percep- tions of men. This is a doctrine every where taught in those Scriptures ; and its belief is therefore vital to Chris- tianity, Fletcher has, we conceive, proved the sound- ness of this doctrine in a most inimitable manner. A« it is matter but little better understood by some Professors, than it is misconceived by all Unbelievers, (for some Professors " have the form of godliness, hut deny the poiver thereof;") it is therefore sustain- ed throughout, by the confession of Faith of the Episcopal Church, (of which he was an eminent Pastor,) as well as by the word of God. Were the doctrine of regeneration more inforced, and of course better understood, even among many of those who assume the name of christians, Iniidelity would be spoiled of many of its weapons against Christianity. Sceptics have often but too much rea- son to cry out mystery ! mystery ! when they find tjlose wbo sk)uld be al^tb to speak intelligibly q£ tb« ixxx IXTRODUCTION. w«^(» birth ! a^to'^^ally ignorant, of the Scriptural ac- ceplation of being" "born again" as was Nicodcmus, the marveHing- " masier in Israel." The operation of the nciu birth (" being born again") is Ihe gi*and commission which the Holy Ghost the Comforter w:is sent to effec-.. For this, Christ, the Son of God gave up Jus life upon the Cross ! Let its importance ihercfore be estimated by the means taken to cause it ! Proportionate to the meavs must be the end. Tlie End is, that millions and millions of the human race have felt tliis rene^val in their hearts hy spiritual tokens, so sensible and certain, that had there been no Bible revelation, they would not have been the less certain of their commu- nion and fellowship with God by his spijit. This is strange doctrine to the unbeliever, all of whom we may ask without expectation of answer, " whojuith' believed our report?" The trutli, is,^ " Spiritval thing's are Spirituality discerned,*' and thosfe who have '*eyes which see not, and ears that hear not," are as preposterous in their endeavours at spiritual dis- cernn>ents, as would be the blind at setting them- selves up for judges of colours. So sure it 'is, that *''the world, by (i^s) wisdom, knows not God." But," God has imparted this sure and certain testimony to the really good and great in every nation in Christen- dom : and the End which we would now wish to make of this gracious jneans is to avail ourselves of the evidence whicii the manifestation affords, of offer-, ing certain and rational assurance to the understand-:, ing of Deists in general, and Jews in particular, thaCr^ Christ Las really risen, and that the Comforter has ac- tually come ! The witnesses for this truth, are nume- rous, and evr at hand! Yea, they are actually living- throughout Christendom, and will be living en the earth to the end of time. TJiey are to be found in al- most every societ} nnming the name of Jesus'! sure, certain, witnesses iu-e they, to whom the evidence im- INTRODUCTION. Isxxi parted has been so grom, ilial tliey would not cease to believe, were the same manner of internal evi- dence perpetuated, though there should be no Kible ! These are truths which every Christian " k-iiorjs" because he has " the witness of the Sph'it, tcstifyiug" with his Spirit, that he has pns.ied from death unto iife." This tlien is Ihe vital doctrine to chargx; home most upon unbt;lievers ; but how shall they believe who have no spiri-ual faculties with which to a})prc- tiend ? There is certainly an impediment on t/ieir part. But there is yet ample means for preliminary convincemeut, if they will be governed b} svch rules as prevail in every other kmd of received testimony. The evidences i1k;ti, are sucli, as may be found in every objectors city, village, or neighbourhood. There many have borne testimony to all around, tJiat a sensible preternatural change has been wrought upon their heart. — That they know that all their former sinful affections and desires have been totally- changed for those that are pure and holy — indeed, the world itself acknowledges the change of tlieir manners and conduct ; they see and confess the re- form of a notorious debauchee and drunkard — Whea challenged with these obvious facts, the answer of the unbel'.ever is, it is mere €iiihat God who is a Spiri^, and whom no man hath seen at any time, should have a sure and certain means of imparting" a knowledge of himself to his creatures ; or rather would it not be Hranjer if lie coi/W not, or even wouWnot? Anyrhing contrary to this scripturaf, and even necessary means of keeping- up the intercourse between God,Hnd his creaturts, since bpirit must communicate with spirit, W'juid be making tlic christian dispensation less locl- come and less " glorwus,^^ (which is the revei-se of the promise) ihan it was under the Mosa'c Era. Then Christ came jn person and revealed hmiseif : but no-w iiiat he has risen, we have only the meaiis of behold- ii g him^'in letters cast at the foundery and impressed .'•t the printer's ! And how many are they of us who cannot avail ourselves even of these helps; some have no money, and some cannot rei'd. Alas ! if thert- be no vavifesiation of the Spirit, wiio does not say, " Loid we beseech thee, brmg us back to the times of Moses, whence thou didst converse with thy people : they btheld thy glory, and received thy answers Irom between the cherubim ; but we, alas, can nei- tlier see thee, feel tliet;, nor communicate wivh thee !" Reader be not self-willed and obsthiate : but prepare thy heart for the reception of the truili as it will be ofttred in the fodowing paues, which was written for one, wlio, Ijke } ou, could not believe that Crod's spirit could dxvell in liie hearts of men ! * If objectors 7vi.ll still obstinately persist in imbe- lirf, we will ask sucli, even on their own vieiy of thing's, to discover some cause for tlie effects thus exhibiied, which philosophy (which is never .contrary io religion) may sanction. Surely we know of no delusion (if it be such) in any manner analogous • Men both sane and insane, at the same time ! LETTER I. God, for purposes worthy of his wisdom, maniffsfs uinisclt, sooner or ia.ler,"io all iiis since) e i'oliowers, in a spiviniul itianncr, whitk thf li-orld knows not cf. SJK, WIIKX I had the pleasure of seeing you lust, you seemed ^urprhtd to hear me say, that rhe Son of God, for purposes worthy of his \\ isdom, mctn'ifests himself, sooner or later," to all his sincere followers, in a spiritual manner, which the world i