■ WW 4* IH • •. LIBRAEY Theological Seminary, PRINCETON, N. J. Case, vI^X .D Shelf, Book, No, A DONATION &a^M ]£J&&gA&M deceived ^r, /S7f. < ; o r r> • Mr. SMYTH's SERMON Preach'd to the SOCIETIES FOR Reformation of Manners. 1727. (J) SERMON To the SOCIETIES FOR Reformation of M a n n e r s, Preach'd at S A LTER"$-H ALL, OnMoNDAY, June z6 y 1727. By George Smyth, M. A. PubliQi'd at their Requeft. LONDON: Printed for Eman, M a t t h e vr s, at the Bible mPttter-Nofter-Roiv, 17*7* T O Sir Daniel Dolins, KnL S I R, F you (hall fee jit to favour Urn following Difcourje with a Reading, you will find it endeavours to vindi- cate the Defign of Reforming a vicions Age ; and the Methods made ufe of by -the Societies for that Purpofe. This is done in the best Manner the Author could; and (as He conceives) upon iht furest and most indifputable Grounds. It farther pre fumes to offer fuch Advice to the .' * of theje Societies, as (if followed) wo. go a great Way towards obviating all Mifreprc tat ions of their Undertakings various Re- fieBions upon their Perfons. A DISCOURSE proceeding upon t ViewSy cannot apply any whither mare proper I \ Patron The Dedication. Patronage, than to a Civil Magiflrate y authorized by his Majesty^ CommiJJion to put in Execution the Penal Laws against Vice and Im- morality ; duly qualiffd for the Difcharge of] the Trufi reposed in him \ and who makes Qonfcience of doing tt with Diligence and Faithfulnefs. Such an One will readily Countenance any well-meant At tempt on the Side of Virtue, and for the Good of the Community. If upon perufal of the Difcourfe I now take leave to offer , Tou [ball judge it to be of that Kjnd, it may be jure of fiich a favourable Reception, as if it be not , lfhould be ajjjam'd to ask. I HAVE often thought withpleafure of the many whole fome Laws we have againfi Vice and Profanenefs \ and of the wife Provifwn made for ; the due Execution of them. But one car?t help being grieved to fee thefe Good Laws jo often • lying dor merit \ andfo many of thofe, who (if I mi flake not) are fworn to fee them executed, auite care- lefs and unconcern d about the Matter. A S I have the Happinefs to live in your Neigh- bourhood^ and as you are pleased to allow me the Ho- nour of converfing with you, I can y t want Oppor- tunities of obferving, with how much Prudence and %gal^ with what difvnterefted Views, and with how Pub lick a Spirit, Tou are conflantly emplofd in doing Good y and being Ufeful to Mankind in a great } / ariety of Ways ; and particularly in Difcharging the Office of a Juflice of the Peace. And as you decline no Opportunity of being Serviceable in the World, fo it carft be imputed to any Remiffnefs in you The Dedication, ToUj that thofe who are within the Reach of your Authority y are not more throughly reformed in their Manners, and more useful Members of Society. IT is upon thefe Accounts you are fo much be- loved and honoured ; and when your Brethren in the Commijfion for this County , jbew'd their parti- cular Regard to you, by appointing you Chairman in fever al of their Sejjions ; as the Choice they made was generally approved; fo the folemn and infiruBive Charges you delivered upon thofe Oc- cafionsj are plain Evidences how ft a P erf on you are, not only to bear his Majesty'/ Com- miffion y but to Prefide among thofe whodofo. I A M One , among Many , who fmcerely wifk the Continuance of your Health and Ufeful- nefs. Tou will fuffer me to add (what I am under particular Obligations not to forget) my hearty Prayers for your Pious Lady and hopeful Children. May the kind Providence of GOD conduff you and them through this World) in Honour y Health, and Plenty ; and may you All obtain Ever- lafling Happinefs in the World to come. I am, Honoured SIR, Your moft Obliged, Humble Servant, Clapton, July 8th, i7*7« George Smyth. [5 ] Rom. XIV. Ver. \6. Let not then your Good be Evil fpoken of. A M well aware that this Cau- tion was given by the Apoiile, with a fpecial View to the par- ticular Cafe and Circumftances referred to in the Context. There were Divifions among the Chri* jlians at Rome, as well as in other Churches, occafionM by the different Sentiments of the Jewtjb and Gentile Converts. The Former were over zealous for the Rites and Ceremonies of Mofes his Law, warmly infifted upon the Ne- ceffity of being Circumcifed, and obferving the Ritual as well as the Moral Precepts of it. The Gentile Converts, on the other Hand, exprell too great a Contempt of thele Things, confidering the State of the Church at that Time, and the Weaknefs of the Believing B Jews, Jews, who could not yet be wholly brought off from their Regard to them. St. Paul was well apprized of the Mifchiefs which would follow, whilft every one was obftinate in his own Way, and neither Side would make any Allowances to the other : And the Chapter of which my Text is a Part, feems purpofely calculated to prevent, or to heal them. With this View he gives proper Advice both to the Strong and Weak ; chat is, thofe who thought themfelves free from all Obligation to fuchOb- fervances ; and thofe who imagined they were ffcill Binding. He cautions the Former againft making ufe of their Liberty, to the Offence of the Latter; and the Latter againft Forwardnefs to cenfure and condemn the Former for ufing their Liberty. The Inftances particularly re- ferred to, are, the Eating without fcruple, or abftaining from certain Meats ; and the ob- ferving, or not obferving certain Days. The Sum of what he fays, as to both, is, that where Men are fincere and upright, God re- ceives and owns both thofe who eat, and thofe who abftain ; thofe who do regard Days, and thofe who do not : And that fince both are accepted of God, neither Side fhould be forward in cenfuring and condemning the other. At ver. 14. the Apoftle tells us what were his own private Sentiments as to the Matters in Difference \ 1 know and am perfuaded by the Lord JefuSj that there is nothing unclean in itfelf ' j that all Meats may be us'd indifferent- [7] ly by us Chrijlians : However, if any Man thinks that fome are unclean, they are un- clean to him ; his Confcience, tho' miftaken in this Point, ftill obliges him to aft accord- ing to the Diftates of it ; and thofe who are better informed, fhould out of Charity abftain from that, the Doing which would fhock and ftumble him, and perhaps tempt him to renounce the Cbrijlian Faith. Ver. 15. If thy Brother be grieved with thy Meat^ now rvalkeH thou not charitably : Dejiroy not him with thy Meat for whom Chrift dfd. And then follow the Words of my Text, Let not then your Good be Evil fpoken of That is, Let not the perverfe, or unfeafonable Ufe of your Chriftian Liberty fwhich is in itfelf Good, a great Advantage and Privilege) give occafion to any to take Offence at it, or fpeak Evil of it. The Context plainly leads us to this re- ftrain'd Meaning of the Words ; and you may eafily perceive that in that View, they are nothing to the Purpofe upon which we are now met : I muft therefore take leave to con- fider them independently ; and without any Regard, at prefent, to their Connection with the reft of the Apoftles Difcourfe : And fo they will be found to contain this general and very ufeful Caution, to which we Ihould have a conftant Regard in the whole of our Con- duel, and which is die very Thing meant by St. Paul, only apply'd to a particular Cafe ; . Not to give occafion to other People, by any [8] any imprudent, or unwarrantable PraQices of our own, to entertain an ill Opinion, or fpeak Evil, or any way to oppofe, that which is really Right and Good. I know not how I can better perform the Service you exped from me, than by endeavouring to aflift your Meditations upon this Subjeflt. To which Purpofe, the following Things may not un- fitly be confider'd. I. The Goodnefs of the Defign in which you are engaged, and of the Methods by which you are purfuing it. II. That this, like moft other good Things, is liable to be mifreprefented and Evil fpoken of. III. That it is incumbent upon you, to take Care that no juft Occafion be given to any Body to do fo. Which will lead me IV. T o fuggeft to you fuch Things by way of Advice, as will (if duly regarded) go a great Way towards preventing others from fpeaking Evil of your Good ; at leaft, will pre- vent you from giving them any juft Occafion to do fo. L e t us confider, I. T h e Goodnefs of the Defign in which you are engag'd, and of the Methods by which you are purfuing it. For unlefs thefe can be fully juftify'd, unlefs it can be plainly fhewn that what you are doing, is really right and fit to be done, it may and ought to be condemned ; and all that [9] that you can do, won't prevent its being Evil fpoken of — ■ I am perfuaded this may be done, to the Satisfaction of any confiderate unprejudiced Perfon : And I the rather under- take the doing it upon this Occafion, becaufe if I fucceed herein, it may be of fome Ufe, on the one Hand, towards filencing the loud Clamours that have been raised againft you ; and on the other Hand, to encourage your Diligence and Stead inefs in carrying on your Defign, and to fortify you againft the Oppo- fition and Calumny you may meet with. Your known avowM Defign, is, to re- form the Manners of a corrupt Age •, to fup- prefs Vice, Profanenefs, and Immorality. The Methods usM for this End, are, not only your own perfonal Good Example ; fea- fonable Reproof, where you have Opportuni- ty to give it, and it is likely to be of any Ser- vice; InftruCtion and Admonition, by difper- fing fuch Books as are calculated to inform the Ignorant* to convince and reclaim the prefumptuoufly Wicked : But farther, the Dete&ing, Informing againft, and Profecut- ing the Offenders in this Kind, before the Civil Magistrate, in order to their Suffering thofe Penalties, to which by the Laws of the Land they are fubje&ed. A s to the Defign itfelf, to reform Mens Manners, and fupprefs Vice and Immorality ; furely one may venture to pronounce, without Hesitation, that it is a very Good One. Tho' if it L 10] it be true, (as we find now and then an Au- thor hardy enough to affert it) that Virtue and Vice are mere Arbitrary Things : That the Moral Virtues are the Political Off-tyring which Flattery begets upon Pride : That there is no Reality in the P U LC H RU M & HO N E- STU M : That they defend entirely on Fajhion and Cuftom, and are altogether as precarious and uncertain: If thefe AfTertions, I fay, and fuch as thefe, be true, all Talk of fupprefling Vice, and all Endeavours to reform Manners, are idle and impertinent ; the whole Defign is founded upon a Miftake, and inftead of going about to reform other Folks Manners , you would do well to inform your own Judgments a little better. Nay, if what one of thefe Authors advances be true, that Private Vices are Publick Benefits ; it will follow (and he has almoft drawn the Conclufion ready to our Hands) that by fupprefling thefe Vices, if ever you fhould do it,- you take the moft ef- fectual Method to diffolve Society, to break up Communities, and fend Men fingly, or in very fmall Tribes, into Caves and Deferts, to ftarve by themfelves, and make a much lefs confiderable Figure in G o d's Creation than fo many Brute Beafts. I confess it appears to me, that a Man muft have a Head very odly turned, a very wrong Caft of Mind, to be capable either of forming, or admitting fuch a wild Scheme ; and excepting thofe who find it favourable to their Vices, I believe there are [«] are very few Perfons that ever gave in to it. All the reft of Mankind have own'd, that there is in the Nature of Things, and antece- dent to all pofitive Determination-, a neceffary and eternal Difference between Moral Good and Evil : And fo long as Mankind continue to have any Senfe of that Difference ; the re- (training of Vice, and making Men morally better, muft be thought a good and laudable Defign. And as the Defign itfelf abfolutely con- fider'd, is certainly very Good and Laudable; fo are the Means by which you are purfuing it. No Body, I fuppofe, can have any Thing to objeft againft Reproof, Inftru&ion, Per- fuafion, as proper Means among others to pro- mote it. The only Difficulty (if after all there be any Difficulty in the Cafe) is, with refpeQ: to the other Methods mentioned, as made ufe of by you for fupprefling Vice : I mean, the Detecting, Informing againft, and (where there is need) Profecuting the Guilty before the Civil Magiftrate ; in order to their fuffering thofe Penalties, to which the Laws of the Land fubjeft them : And entering yourfelves voluntarily into Societies for this Purpofe. T h a t we may be the more throughly fa- tisfy'd of the Fitnefs and Goodnefs of theft Methods; it will be of ufe to obferve, that thofe vicious Practices which you aim at fup- prefting ; may be conlider\l, either as Offen- five [i* ] five and Difhonourable to the Blefled God, Violations of His Law, and Deftru&ive of the Offender's belt Interefts in both Worlds : Or they may be confider'd, as injurious to Society, of which we are Members. For tho' there is no Reafon to doubt but that Vice and Immorality are faulty every way, both as being Offenfive to God, Prejudicial to the Sinner's Perfonal Interefts, and Inju- rious to the Society of which he is a Member; yet it is upon this latter Account principally, if not only, that they are punifhable by the Civil Magiftrate ; and that you are juftifiable in Detecting and Informing againft them, in order to their being punifh'd. The Offenfivenefs of Vice and Immora- lity to the BlefTed God, is indeed fufficient to raife our Indignation againft it, and engage our moft zealous Endeavours for reftraining it, by all thofe Methods which Religon pre- fcribes. The great Mifchief the Offender does hirpfelf by it, is enough to awaken our Charitable Pity, and engage us to do all that we fitly may, to prevent fuch Mifchief. And here I fuppofe, that the gentler Methods . of Inftru&ion and Perfuafion, Admonition and Reproof, are the moft Proper, and the only juftifiable Ones. But then, if we carry our Thoughts farther, and confider thefe Evil-Pra&ices, as being injurious to Society; Methods of another Kind are not only ufeful and juftifi- able, [ n ] able, but neceflary too : And I don't queftion,- before I have done, I fhall make it very plain, that your Methods are of that Kind. I f any Perfon be difpos'd to deny, or doubt of it, his doing fo mud be owing to an Apprehenfion, either that the Vices you would reform, do not properly fall under the Cognizance of the Civil Magiltrate ; that he need not, and therefore that he ought nor, to enaft, or execute Laws againft them : Or that whatever he may, or ought to do ; yet that private Perfons, fuch as moft of you are, ought not to intermeddle, much lefs to com- bine in Societies, as it were purpofely to take the Bufincfs out of his Hands ; at leaft, to do that which he, by Virtue of his Office, is obliged to do, but which no Body expects from you. If either of thefe Pretences can be made good ; it muft, I think, be own'd,- that your Methods are quite wrong ; you had e'en as good disband, and let Vice grow up, 'till it becomes, what, if let alone, it will foon be, unmanageable and outrageous. — Let us enquire a little what there is in them, and whether they will not admit of a very fatis- fafrory Anfwer. Possibly fome Perfons may be ready to think, that thofe Vices- which you are a (Tilt- ing the Civil Magistrate to reform, don't properly come under his Cognizance ; tint he need not, and therefore, that he Ought not to make, or execute penal La infl C them. . C *4 ] them. Suppofe particular Perfons fhould in- dulge themfelves in Vice and Immorality : One Man profanes the great Name of G o d, and wickedly curfes himfelf, or his Neigh- bour : Another furfeits upon the Bounties of Providence, and makes a Practice of drink- ing 'till he loofes his Reafon, and all com- mand of himfelf : A Third defiles himfelf with a common Proftitute, or fquanders away his Subftance at a commonGaming-Houfe : And a Fourth, it may be, is chargeable not with one of thefeExcefTes only, but with all of them, and it may be feveral others as bad. But what is all this to the Civil Magistrate, may it be faid ? If fuch Practices are fas is fup- pos'd) offenfive to the Bleffed God, He knows how to punifh them, without the Ma- giftrate's Help ; if they are injurious to the Offender, the Offender will fooner, or later, find the ill Confequences of them : In the mean Time, as he is his own worft Enemy, and hurts no Body but himfelf, the Civil Ma- giftrate is no way concerned, and therefore need not intermeddle. I can eafily guefs what fober Perfons will think of this Kind of Reafoning ; but fince it pafTes for very folid and fubftantial with thefe who are in mod Danger by it : I will take leave to fuggeft the following Con- siderations, which will fully anfwer it. 1. The Civil Magiftrate not only may, but is, by Virtue of his"" Office, obliged to pre- vent [15] vent as much as in him lies, and to punifh as often as is expedient, every Thing that is injurious to the Community over which he prefides. He is veiled with Authority and Power for this very Purpofe : And without this, Civil Government, inftead of being be- neficial, would be burdenfome. He is the Mi- mfier of G D, to the Society, for good : A Re- venger to execute Wrath trpon him that doth Evil. Rom. 13. 4. Kjngs as fuprewe, and Gover- nors, a&ing by their Authority, are defigned for the Punifhinent of Evil-doers. 1 Pet. 2. i^, 14. This I fuppofe will not be much conteftedL I add therefore, 2. That Vice and Immorality, parti- cularly thofe Kinds of them which you are endeavouring to fupprefs, are manifeftly inju- rious to Civil Society, and therefore neceflari- ly come within the Cognizance of the Civil Magiftrate. Whatever may be pretended to the contrary, the Experience and Obfervation of all Ages will juftify this Affertion. The Offender is his own word Enemy, it is faid, and all the Mifchief he does by his vicious Practices, is to himfelf : Why fuppofe this were true, it would not prove what is defignM by it. For, every particular Perfon Hands related, and is under Obligations, to the Community of which he is a Member : He is not at Liberty to do himfelf what Mif- chief he pleafes, or to render himfelf burden- fome to Society, and unfit to perform that C 2 Duty C i6 3 Duty and Service he owes it : If he does fo, he may juftly be reftrain'd, or punifh'd by the Civil Magiftrate. No Man, for Example, is, or ought to be, allow'd to murder himfelf, and care is taken to fet a Mark of Infamy upon thofe who do fo : The Reafon is plain, becaufe in Society no Man has an abfolute Propriety in, or Command over himfelf : Every Man owes his Life and all the Service he can do, to the Society of which he is a Member. And the fame Reafon holds good in Proportion, as to any other Mifchief a Man may do himfelf, by which he becomes uncapable of being fo ferviceable to the Com- munity, as otherwife he might be. For my own Part, it appears very plain to me, that even upon this Foot, the Civil Magiftrate may, and ought to interpofe, to reftrain and punifh Vice; as being thus injurious to the Offenders in their own Perfons, and making them lefs ufeful in Society than they might otherwife be. But then I muft add moreover, that it is abfolutely falfe in itfelf, and a Contra- diction to daily Experience, to fay, that Of- fenders in this Kind hurt no Body but them- felves. Does not he who fquanders away his Eftate at a Gaming-Table, impoverifh his Family, and help to ruin his Creditors, as well as himfelf? Does not the profane Cu- ftomary Swearer go a great Way towards forfeiting (that which every Member of So- ciety [17] ciety is obliged carefully to maintain) his Cre- dibility as a Witnefs ? For why ftiould that Man be believed upon his invoking the tre- mendous Name of God on the moft iblemn Occafion, who fcruples not to do the fame Thing upon the moft trivial One ; and very often it may be when he knows the Falfhood of what he would this Way confirm ? Are there no Breaches of the publick Peace, no Broils and Quarrels, no Blood-fhed and Mur- der, confequent upon Drunkennefs and Lewd- nefs ? Or do thefe Confequences fo feldom happen? Or is the Community fo little injurd by them, that it is not worth while to make Laws to prevent and punifh them ? Has the Civil Magiftrate no Bufmefs to reftrain the bad Example of fuch vicious Perfons ; when we daily fee the fatal Effe&s of it upon thofe (efpecially of the younger Sort) who have been foberly educated ; and who, if they had not been mis-led, might have continued Inno- cent and Virtuous ? With the good Leave of thofe whom I am endeavouring to confute and convince ; we will take for granted, what Solomon obferves, and the Hiftory of the World juftihes ; That by the Bleffing of the Up- right the City is exalted, and that it is oyerth by the Mouth of the Wicked. Prov. n. 11. That Righteoufnefs exalteth a Nation^ and that Sin is the Reproach of any People. Pov. 14. 34. That the great G o n, as Governor of the World, ordinarily finds Ways to punifh Com- munities [ i8] munities as fuch, for overgrown Wickednefs, conniv'd at by thofe who might have reftrain'd and punifh'd it. Can all this be true, and yet the Civil Magiftrate have nothing to do in thefe Affairs ? I hope there is no need to ftay any longer on fo plain a Point. I only add in the j. And laft Place. That the Civil Ma- giftrate can take no other effe£hial Way for fupprefling and punilhing Pra&ices thus per- nicious to the Community, but by making and executing penal Laws againft them. The gentler Methods of Reproof and Per- fuaGon won't do in many Cafes ; G o d knows they are available in but very few Cafes ! But befides ; they are not ftri&ly fpeaking, the Province of the Civil Magi- ftrate : He may, indeed, as a private Perfon, as a Good-Man, or a Chrijlian, try what Good he can do this Way : But as Civil Magiftrate, he bears the Sword of Juftice, and ought not to bear it in vain : His Bufinefs is to execute Wrath again fl Evil- Doers. True, indeed, he is to fee that the Punifhment be not difpropor- tionate to the Offence, at leaft, that it do not exceed it ; but that I think cannot with Mo- defty be pretended, with refpeft to our Laws ; which to be fure deal tenderly enough with this Kind of Offenders. B y this Time, I hope, the Pretence that Vice and Immorality don 7 t come under the Cognizance of the Civil Magiftrate is fuffici- ently C 19] ently obviated. But granting this, (may it be further argu'd) How does this juftify private Perfons in afTociating themfelves in the Manner, and for the Purpofes, that a few bufy officious Perfons have done of late Years ? Suppofe that Magiftrates may, nay, fuppofe if you will, that by Virtue of their Office they are obligM to do this Work ; yet ftill it belongs only to them to do it ; and it favours a little of Pragmaticalnefs in private Perfons to take the Work out of their Hands, and engage in an Affair which they have no Call to meddle with. The Magistrate is the Minijier of GO D, attending continually upon this very Things and for any Body elfe to en- gage in it, is a prefumptuous Encroachment upon his Office. Add to all this, that a Man muft be very Sour and Ill-natur'd, who won't fuffer his Neighbour to Swear, or Curie, to get Drunk, or commit Uncleannefs, without prefently Informing againfl, and making him pay for it ; efpecially, if he be fo officious as to fpend any of his Time in going up and down, purpofely to detect fuch Offenders. I would not give a hard Name to any Thing that does not deferve it ; but furely one may venture to fay, that this Pretence is both Falfe and Invidious ; Falie, becaufe in- ftead of interfering with, you areAffiihnt, and a£l in Subordination to the Civil Magi- strate. Invidious, becaufe, inllead of charging you with Sournels and Ill-nature, what you do [ 20 ] do in this Kind, ought to be imputed to your Humanity, a benevolent Regard to Mankind, and the Welfare of Society ; at leaft, 'till there is better Evidence that it proceeds from fome worfe Principles, than has ever yet been produced againft the Body of you. Your Societies cannot with any Appear- ance of Truth be charged with invading the Province of the Civil Magiftrate, or taking the Work out of his Hands. Every Body knows where the Power of enacting Laws is lodgM among us ; and when they are enacted, every Body is agreed, what is the Province of thofe who are Commiflion'd to fee to the Ex- ecution of them. They are to receive Infor- mations againft Offenders ; to examine and weigh the Evidence for and againft them ; to judge whether the Proof offered be fuffici- ent to convi£t them ; and in Cafe they be convicted, to take Care that the Penalty which the Law annexes to their Crime, be inflicted upon them. All this is fo properly their Bufinefs, that it would no doubt be Cri- minal Infolence in any Body elfe to meddle in it. And I dare anfwer for you, that as you never did, fo you never will expofe yourfelves to fuch a Charge. Again, with re- fpe£t to the Crimes we are now fpeaking of, it farther falls within the Magiftrate's Pro- vince, to direct proper Precepts and Warrants to inferior Officers, to detect Offenders, and bring them before him, in order to Convi£ti* on [21 ] on and Punifhment : Nay, where the Crimes fall within his own Notice, he need not (I fuppofe; ftay 'till he receives Information from others, but may, and, I think, ought, to proceed as the Law dire£h againft them. Can it be faid that you go about to prevent, or obftruft: them herein ? So far from it, that you would heartily rejoyce to fee them more univerfally inclined to it, and diligent in it. The Cafe is thus. We have ex- cellent Laws made againft Vice and Immora- lity ; but be they never fo good in themfelves, the Community receives no Benefit by them, any further than they are put in Execution. We have Magistrates Commiffion'd; and in- ferior Officers appointed to take Care that they be executed. But all the World knows, that will very feldom be done, if no other Breaches of them be punifhfd, but fuch as fall within the immediate Notice of the Ma- gistrate, or the inferior Officers. Private Per- fons therefore, not only do not invade their Province, but they are Affiftant to them, and do an Action in its Nature and Tendency, Good ; when out of Regard to the Welfare of the Community, they deteft, inform a- gainft, and profecute in a legal Way, fuch a9 break the Laws. And, if lingle Perfons may laudably do it, I cannot conceive why they may not join in Societies, in order to do it the more pffeQually* All this is (o reafon- able in itfelf, fo agreeable to our Laws, and D 10 C 22 ] fo far from being an Encroachment on the Magistrate's Province, that in every Reign (that has had Opportunity for it) fince the firft Inftitution of your Societies, private Subjects, as well as thofe in Office^ have by Royal Pro- clamation been call'd upon to be very vigilant and ftrift in the Difcovery and effedual Pro- fecution of fuch Offenders. Nay, your So- cieties have not only been approved and ap- plauded by Perfons of the greateft Piety and Judgment Abroad, but have been Counte- nanced by thofe of higheft Rank and Autho- rity at Home, as very ferviceable to thefe Ends. Thefe are plain Declarations what is their Senfe about this Matter. But after all, I fhould not have mentioned either Royal Pro- clamations, or the Countenance of the greateft Men upon Earth, if I had not alfo been fully fatisfy'd of the Fitnefs and Commendablenefs of the Thing in itfelf. Does any Man need a particular Commiflion to authorize, or jufti- fy him to do Service to the Community ? Or rather, is not the Being a Member of it, both a Commiifion and an Obligation to do it all the Good, and be Serviceable to it in all the Ways we poflibly can, in our feveral Stations? And furely it is the mod unrighteous Thing in the World, to reckon any Man Unfriendly, or Ill-natur'd, for doing fo. For, befides that prudent well-manag'd Endeavours to fupprefs Vicc^ and reform Mens Manners, are the molt friendly Oftice that can be done the Offenders [*3 ] Offenders themfelves : Befides this, f fay, it is to be confider'd, that our Obligations to the Community of which we are Members, are fuperior to thofe we are under to any particu- lar Perfons ; and where the Intereit of both are inconfiftent (which by the Way, is far from being the Cafe here) we are principally to regard and advance the Former. What has been faid, is, I conceive, fully fufficient, not only to vindicate, but to fhew the Goodnefs of the Defign in which you are engag'd, and of the Methods by which you purfue it. I muft take notice however, II. That this, like moil other good Things, is liable to be Mif-reprefented and Evil fpoken of. So you have found by long Experience, and folam afraid you will al- ways find. There will be little Occafion to enlarge under this Head : It would indeed be to no Purpofe to mention all the little Cavils and Obje&ions that are made againft your Defign ; the injurious Reflexions, and bafe Reproaches that are caft upon your Perfons : The Latter need not be regarded, and the Former have been often anfwerM. If I be not much miftaken, I have obviated every Thing that has the Appearance of a Difficul- ty in this Affair ; and faid enough to convince any unprejudiced Perfon, that thole who fpeak Evil of your Defign, do it without a Caufe. Neither you, nor I, however, are to exped that all Mouths will immediate- D2 ly [ 2 4 ] Iy be ftop'd ; far from it : The vicious Part of Mankind will always be ready to Mif-re- prefent, and do what they can to oppofe you : They are too fond of their pernicious Indulgences, to be eafily reclaimed from them, or to be filent when Attempts are made to reftrain, or punifh them. Nay, and befides thefe, there will be found even among thofe who are not themfelves chargeable with any Kind of that Immorality which you would help to reform ; a Number of indolent un- a&ive Perfons , who from fome unhappy Principles, or unreafonable Prejudices, will declare againft what you are about, either as Imprudent, or Impracticable, orUnfeafonable; and fo not only do nothing in it themfelves, but endeavour to difcourage and difcounte- nance others. Thus you are to expeft it will always be : You ought to reckon upon it, that both thefe Sorts of Perfons will watch for your Halting ; they'll examine ftriftly your Per- gonal Character ; pry narrowly into your Meafures ; watch every Step you take, in a Work that fo directly thwarts their Inclina- tions. Every little Slip you make, any Im- prudence, or Rafhnefs, they can charge you with, will be magnify'd and improved to your Difadvantage : Above all, if they can difco- ver any Thing Illegal in your Proceedings, they will in all likelihood make you fuffer for it, and become unalterably prejudiced, both againft your Perfons and your Defign. Give me leave therefore to put you in mind. III. [*5 ] III. That it is incumbent upon you to take Care that no juftOccafion be given to fpeak Evil of your Good. — . — You may, I think, be throughly fatisfy'd of the Good- nefs of the Caufe in which you are engaged, and the Fitnefs of the Methods by which you are carrying it on : It is not, however, impofli- ble, that it mould fuffer upon your Account, or by your Mif-management. Far be it from me, to infinuate, either that it has done fo, or that there is any likelihood it will do fo, by the Bulk, the Majority of you : And yet a Cau- tion of this Kind can't fairly be thought Im- proper : The leaft poflible Danger is enough to juftify the giving it. O f how much Importance it is that you do take fuch Care, is to be meafur'd by Confidering and Comparing together, on the one Hand, the great Benefit which would accrue, both to the Community in general, and to particular Per fons, by the Succeefs of your Attempts for reforming a vicious Age : And on the other Hand, the Tendency which any ill Conduct of yours will have, to defeat your good Defign, and prevent the Succcfs of all your Endeavours. Weigh, on the one Hand, the Advantages of having Vice fup- prefs'd, Profanenefs and Immorality diicoun- tenanc'd, good Order and Regularity of ex- ternal Behaviour maintained : And on the other Hand, the unhappy Influence which Mif-management on your Part, will have towards [ 2 <5] towards blafting your own avow'd ; Defign, and preventing thofe Advantages which would, refult from a regular Profecution of it : And you will thence be able to make a true Eftimate of how great Moment it is, that you be careful to give no Occafion to have your Good Evil fpoken of. And as the taking fuch Care is all that is in your Power, (for, if this notwithftanding, any will Mif-reprefent your Defign , and afperfe your Perfons, you can't help it) fo this is all that can be fuppos'd to be defignM by the Caution in the Text. But then thus much is plainly incumbent on you, and mod reafon- ably expe&ed from you. That I may con- tribute what I can to your Afliftance therein : You will bear with me whilft I proceed to what I proposed. IV. T o fugged: to you a few Things by Way of Advice. After fo many Perfons of diftinguifh'd Worth, both of the eftablifh'd Church, and of thofe who Diffent from it ; who have gone before me in this Service, and who have generally thought fit to fay fome- what to you by Way of Dire&ion : It will not be expe&ed I fhould have much that is new to offer in that Kind \ you will excufe me, therefore, if I fhould only be able to bring ufeful and pertinent Hints to your Remem- brance j for I defpair of urging them with greater Advantage than has been often done. i, The n, i. Then, I would recommend it as of great Importance for the cutting off all Occa- fion of fpeaking Evil of your Defign, or of yourfelves as engaged in it : That you be very careful of your own moral Chara&er. I mean, not only that you be yourfelves free from thofe Vices, which you endeavour to reftrain and punifh in others, as pernicious to Civil Soci- ety : But from every Thing elfe that is in its own Nature Immoral, and Unbecoming the Dignity of Human Nature ; even tho' it fhould be of fuch a Kind, as is not, or cannot be provided againft, or punifh'd by Human Laws. I know very well that as to the Community, the Effe£t is in fome refpeft pretty much the fame ; whether the Profe- cution againft any Vice be carryM on by a Virtuous Perfon, or by one who is himfelf chargeable with the fame, or other Vices : I know too, that when an Information is brought againft an Offender in this Kind, the Accufer's being as bad as the Accufed, won't ftop the Proceedings of Juftice : The Civil Magiftrate won't advert to the Badnefsof the Accufer^s Character, unlefs it be in fuch Cafes where it abates, or deftroys the Credibility of hisTeftimony. It is, therefore, with a dif- ferent View, and upon quite another Account, that I would recommend Pcrlbnal Virtue to thofe who would contribute towards the Re- formation of others. It is in iliort this • That the Penalties which by their Mc^ns, and in C( Confequence of their Informing and Profe- cuting, areinfli&ed on Offenders, may work the more kindly with them, and produce the better Effeft upon them : That their Minds may not be four'd, and irritated, and fet againft all Purpofes of Amendment, by fee- ing themfelves accused; and it may be con- victed too, by thofe who have as great Faults as themfelves, ftand in as much need of being reformed, and deferve every Whit as well to be punifh'd. Consciousness of Innocence and Virtue, as it qualifies, fo it emboldens a Man to reprove Vice, and ftand up for the Refor- mation of Manners : And where fuch Vir* tue and Innocence are Confpicuous in any One's Chara&er and Conduft, they naturally beget Veneration, and doalmoft irrefiftably ftrike an Awe upon the Minds, even of the Vi- cious. Bad Men refent much better the being admoniftiM, reprov'd, or even punifh'd by the Hands, or at the Inftigation of fuch a Man, than by One like themfelves : The Stomach loaths the Medicine prefcrb'd, or given by fo improper a Hand. In this View, therefore, you fee, how much the Commu- nity is interefted in the Perfonal Virtue, both of Civil Magiftrates, and of thofe who are Afftftant to them in the Execution of the penal Laws againft Vice. The threatened Penalty may have much the fame Effed to reftrain from offending ; and it may be as cer- tainly [29] tainly infli&ed on the Offender by a vicious, as by a virtuous Magiftrate : But the Offender won't be ib likely to be reclaim^ from his vicious Courfes in one Cafe, as in the other ; which yet is one main Defign, both of threat- ning and infli&ing thefe Penalties. Punifh- ment infli&ed by fuch a Hand will fhew more of Power than Juftice, in him that intfifts it ; and be more likely to harden and terrify, than to foften and win upon him that fuffers it. 2. I would farther take leave to re- commend upon this Occafion, univerfal Bene- volence to Mankind, and a conftant uniform Regard to the Interefts and Welfare of Soci- ety, and thefe fuperior to all other Temporal Aims, as the Governing Principles of our Behaviour, in Civil Life. This is what one would wifh to find in every Man ; and the more of it is to be found in any Man, the more ufeful and valuable a Member of Society will he be. But it is peculiarly re- quifite, I had almoft faid indifpenfably ne- ceffary in a Magiftrate, and in thofe who take your Methods to reform a vicious Age. It is the very EiTence of Patriotifm ; and this, with a fair Opportunity to difplay it, is that for which Mankind deferve to be reverenced while they live, and to be had in remembrance when they die. Cultivate then this virtuous Difpofition ; it does not lie out of the Reach of the Meaneft of us, E tho' [30] tho' Perfons of high Birth, and exalted Sta- tions, have moft Opportunity to difcover and be extenfively Ufeful by it. Remember, a narrow felfiflh Spirit difcover'd in any Part of your ConduQ:, will fully your Chara&er ; prevent much of the Succefs, and fpoil all the Merit of your Labours. The. Ground upon which I have been endeavour^ t p prove that Vice and Im* morality come witiiin the Cognizance of the Civil Magiilrate ; and to vindicate the Me- chods you take to get it reftrain'd and pu- nifh'd, is its pernicioufnefs to Society : For this Reafon, and upon t^is FoifttdatiOtt, I think the Com Vi finitj . oHig'd to you for the Pains and Ex pence yofif are at, in de- tecting, informing againii, and profecudng fuch Delinquents. This, therefore, is the Thing you fhould keep conftantly in View ; and a Regard to the Welfare of Society, is the Principle that fhould animate and Influence you in the whole of your Conduft. But with how ill a Grace muft that Man pretend to proceed upon this Founda- tion, who after ail knows nothing what a Publick Sprit means ; has none, or but a very inferior Regard to Publick Good ; has no Feeling of the Relation in which he ftands, and the Ties he is under to the Community ? It may by furely foretold, your Enemies will fpeak Evil of you, (indeed, they may with good Reafon do fo) i[ you aft upon any Principles Principles without thefe ; or are influenced by any lower Confiderations. I would farther recommend j. Disinterestedness, A Free- dom from all Mercenary Views, and Expecta- tions of Profit and Advantage to yourfelves ; other than what will of Courfe accrue to you in Common with the Reft of the Reform'd Community. This poflibly may feem to be a very needlefs Piece of Advice, and fo I believe it is to the Majority of your Number, who are known to be fo far from being Gainers by the Caufe you are engaged in, that you fpend your own Money and Time, without Recompence, and very often with- out Thanks too. It may appear the more needlefs alfo, upon Account of a Declara- tion which I find the Societies have made for feveral Years fucceflively, upon Occafion of its having been insinuated, that it is not Re* formation of Manners which is intended, but the Getting of Money from Delinquents, "It is declared to the World, that fuch a u Charge upon thefe Societies is abfolutely " Falfe. It is own'd there have been fome u bafe and wicked Perfons (not engaged, "or in the leaft concerned in the Societies tor u Reformation of Manners) who have ex* u torted Money from Offenders, and fome* " times from honeft Men : But all fuch * Pra&ices are utterly detefted by thefe Soci- " eties, (who, as is well known, have Uriel E 2 " ly [ 3*1 c 'ly enquired after fuch Perfons, and when ic difcover'd have brought them to punifh- u meat) nor do they know, or believe, that ic any engagM with them are chargeable there- " with. And to prevent as much as pofltble f c all Sufpicion of a mercenary Defign, or Prin- ? ciple, in any that aft in the Bufinefs of u Reformation, the Gentlemen con- iQ cern'd have all along recomended it, and, u indeed, infifted upon it with thofe of the " Societies who have given Informations " againft Vice, or Profanefs, that they fhould il never receive that Part of the Penalty 16 which the Law allows the Informer ; and u it hath not come to their Knowledge that iC any one Perfon of thofe Societies have a£ted iC otherwife. However, if at any Time here- iC after it fhould happen that any Perfon, or Ci Perfons concerned in any of the Societies u for promoting Reformation of Manners " fhould be chargeable with any of the evil 44 Practices before-mentioned, or even with <; taking the Reward which the Law allows " them , it is humbly requefted that notice u may be given them of it. " Upon this Declaration T which every Body has Reafon to believe True, becaufe ic might fo eafily be difprovM if it were Falfe , you ought not fo much as to be fufpected of doing any Thing of this Kind. The Meaning of the Advice, therefore, as to this particular is only that you would go on as you have done hitherto, and keep your felves [ 33] felves equally free from all mercenary felfifh Views of every Kind. For, the firft Mo- ment any Thing of this Sort is difcover^d, it will bid fair for blading your Endeavours : And tho' it fhould never be difcover'd, yet, if there really be any Thing of this Kind, it will fpoil the Acceptablenefs of your Ser- vice with the Bleffed God; and quite wipe out the Merit of it, with refped to the Com- munity. 4. Whenever you are employed in this Work, and in every Step you take in it, keep yourfelves free from Malice and Paflion, and angry Refentment. Do nothing in this Kind out of private Pique, or Per- fonal Difguft, or to revenge Peribnal Injuries, or Affronts, received from any Man. With- out due Care to this Purpofe, it will be im- pofTible to avoid giving Occafion to have your Good Evil fpoken of: You'll but expofe yourfelves to the Pity of good Men, and the Contempt and Scorn of bad Ones. What have any Man's private Refentments, or Perfonal Wrongs to do in an Affair of this Nature, in which the Community is fo nearly interefted, and the Carrying on of which can never be juftify'd, if it be not lubiervient and even neceiTary to the Welfare of that. Somewhat a-Kin to this is what I would take leave to recommend yet farther. 5. Impartiality; purfuing and carrying on your Defign, without refped to Per- c 34 : Perfons ; without favouring and excufing one Man, and being very ftrift and fevere upon another, whilft yet their Cafes are exactly the fame, and in all Reafon and Juftice, they ought to be proceeded againft in the fame Manner. Not that it is neceffary, or indeed advifeable, that all Offenders {hould [ be dealt with alike ; far from it; the making "a Difference between them, is not always be- ing Partial. Some are more frequently and more flagrantly Guilty than others ; fome may probably be won by the gentler Methods of Admonition and Reproof, or by a Penalty infli&ed, fo as that few Perfons fhould come to the Knowledge of it ; who it may be would have been hardened and ruin'd, if they had been exposed, and dealt with in a rough Way. Others are already fo impudently Wicked, and hardened in their Sins, that there is little, or no Hope of quite reforming them ; all that can be done is to reftraia, and make publick Examples of them. Again, 6. I think it may with great Certainty be recommended as a very ufeful Piece of Advice, and a})folutely neceffary to prevent all Occafion ef fpeaking Evil of you ; That you fhould not in any Inltance, or upon any Occafion, provoke, or lead Perfons to the Commiffion of Crimes, with the Defign of Informing againft them, and getting them punifhM tor them afterwards. To fay the beft of this, it is being firft the Occafion of Mifchief, [35] Mifchief, that you may afterwards have the Opportunity of repairing it : But to fay that of it which it deferves, it is bafe and barba- rous, and what none but a treacherous falfe- hearted Perfon can ever do. If ever any fuch Thing has been done by any of thofe who pretended to be of your Number, yet the Body of you ought in all Reafon to ftand clear of the Charge ; for I find it ex- prefsly recommended to thofe who give In- formations againft Profanenefs and Debauch- ery, and particularly to the Members of your Societies ; cc Not to ufe any Artifice to " provoke, or draw in others to the Breach of Ci the Laws, in the Inftances there above- a mention'd, or any of the like Kind, that a they may have anOccafion to inform againlt " them. " It is among other prudential Me- thods in a Book entitled, a Help to a National Reformation, printed and difperfed at your Expence. Once more 7. And laftly, you fhould be very Care- ful that all your Proceedings be fuch as the Laws of the Land Countenance, and will Juftify. To pretend to do any Thing of this Kind for theWelfare of Society, by any Methods contrary to, or inconfiftent with thcknown and eftablifh'd Laws of that Society, canies Abfurdity in the very Face of it. The doing thus , befides the Trouble and Inconveni- encies it would bring upon yourfelves, would open £&1 open the Mouths of every Body againft you, and effe&ually defeat your v/hole Under- taking- And thus I have endeavoured, with all Faithfulnefs, to perform that Service which you were pleas'd to require of me. If what has been faid may but ferve to exite a clear Perception, and fix a Rational Convi&ion in your Minds of theGoodnefs and Ufefulnefs of your Work ; there will be the lefs Need to add any Thing elfe for your Encouragement to go on without being weary of thus Well- doing, or fainting in your Minds. If the Advice which has been given you be received with Candor, and followed with Care, there will be the lefs Likelihood of your being Mif- reprefented and Abus'd : There will be no Danger of your giving any Occafion to be Evil fpoken of: And you may go on with the fairer ProfpeQ: of that Succefs, which, I think, all Virtuous Perfons, and Lovers of their Country, muft heartily wiflh you. Give me leave to fhut up this Difcourfe with a general Refle&ion. W e are hence led to adore the Goodnefs of G o d to Mankind in the Institution of Civil Government ; and particularly to blefs Him upon Account of the happy Con- ftitution under which we live ; the good Laws by which we are governed ; the Wife and Prudent, the Mild and Gracious Ad- miniftration, L 37 J miniftration, both of our late Sovereign of BlefTed Memory, and of our prefent King, whom God long preferve. Mankind, who have all along liv'd in Society, can't conceive of the Horror and Defolatenefs of living out Of it. And thofe that live under the Influ- ence of fuch a Conftitution and Laws as ours, are not always fenfible enough of the Ad- vantage they enjoy above thofe, who live under an Arbitrary Government; whofe Lives and Properties, whofe Liberties Civil and Religious, are held precarioufly, at the Will of a Tyranical Prince ; or infring'd by the Pride and Infolence of a more Tyranical Church. May I not add too, that fome of thofe among ourfelves, who were affected by, and fuffer'd under the Mif-Condu£t of fome former Reigns, are not enough thank- ful to God and their King, for the Bleflings they enjdy'd in the late Reign, and which we have the comfortable Profpeft: of having continu'd to us, and increafed upon us in This. How can one forbear fuch Reflections asthefe, fin the Circumftances we are at prefent in) at the Clofe of a Dif- courfe, wherein our Thoughts have been employed about what may contribute to the Welfare of Society, and the Uierulnels of Government and Magistracy, for the fuppreffing Vice, which is fo mauifeftly pernicious to it. ■* And I reckon unoa F * it,. [38] it, thcfe would not have been unwelcome Re- flexions to an Affembly o£?roteftantDijfenters y even tho' they had arifen lefs naturally from our Difcourfe, and the Occafion of it. FINIS. -> Princeton Theological Semmary-Speer Libranr 1 1012 01011 5089 Jff