HB 171 .A7 1853 Arnot, William, 1808-1875 The race for riches I Digitized by the Internet Archive in 2010 with funding from Princeton Theological Seminary Library http://www.archive.org/details/raceforrichessomOOarno THE RACE FOR RICHES, AND SOME OF THE PITS INTO WHICH THE RUNNERS FALL: $\x ttthttB, APPLYING THE WORD OF GOD TO THE TRAFFIC OF MEN. BY WILLIAM" ARNOT, MINISTER OF FREE ST. PETER'S, GLASGOW. AMERICAN EDITION. WITH PREFACE AND NOTES, BY STEPHEN COLWELL. j PHILADELPHIA: LIPPINCOTT, GRAMBO & CO. 185 3. Entered, according to Act of Congress, in the year 1853, by LIPPINCOTT, GRAMBO & CO., in the Clerk's Office of the District Court of the United States for the Eastern District of Pennsylvania. PREFACE TO THE AMERICAN EDITION. The little volume which we now give to the American public, has passed rapidly through several editions in Scotland. It is from the pen of an eminent minister of the Free Church in that country, Pastor of the Church of St. Peter, in Glasgow. With very slight allowance for difference of circumstances, the lessons it contains are as applicable here, as in the land in which they were first deli- vered : we believe there is as much need for these lessons here as there, although we may not admit that we are more devoted worship- pers of Mammon than the people of Scotland. It is true, there is no special lack of literature on the subject of covetousness, and the reli- gious uses of wealth; yet, there is, in the (iii) IV PREFACE TO THE production of the Rev. Mr. Arnott, a fresh- ness of diction and a vigor of thought, well calculated to make salutary impressions. It will scarcely be laid down without a thorough perusal, by those who look into it sufficiently to seize the spirit of the writer. We commend it most heartily to all who would have their souls stirred up with thoughts and suggestions, which must, if prevalent, infuse new life and energy into the Christian movements of the present day. For, although his subject is covetousness, the author, impelled by the pressure of his thoughts, has bounded away from the negative, and assumed the tone and the course of teaching which belong to the positive precepts of Christianity. He felt con- strained to declare to his hearers, not merely what they should not do, but, betaking him- self to the direct mode of exhortation, he urges what they should do. This is the natural impulse of an earnest man, and the natural action of a sound mind. The author of " Mammon " was driven to the same course by the exigencies of the same topic. He could not remain in the narrow but logical sphere of a subject which simply forbade covetousness. It may be safely assumed that AMERICAN EDITION. V no estimate of Christianity, no summary of its duties, no exhibition of its compass and bearings can be made, by those who attempt to unfold the "New Commandment" — the duties enjoined by the New Testament, from the negative precepts of the Old Testament. Such an attempt is objectionable in so many respects as to appear absurd. If the conse- quences be considered — it is perhaps worse than absurd — perhaps it is wicked. It takes the prohibitions accompanying the Ceremonial Law of the Old Dispensation, which has passed away, and develops from them the positive duties enjoined by the New Testament, which relate to the inward and spiritual: it over- looks and slights the very copious and com- prehensive instructions of our Lord, covering the whole ground of this attempted develop- ment, and the whole ground of Christian life and duty ! But it is not merely wrong to unfold the great system of the Law of Christ from the negative commands of the Old Testament, it is logically impossible. Every attempt of this kind, whatever of good it may contain, must, to the discriminating and unprejudiced mind, appear to be what it cannot fail to be, un- 1* Vi PREFACE TO THE worthy of the subject, and discreditable to the intellectual power employed upon it. To develop the law of love and kindness to our fellow-men, as taught us by Christ, from the command, " Thou shalt not kill," is a task as difficult and hopeless as that of extracting the obligation to pay our debts from the command, " Thou shalt not covet;" or the obligation to "do good and lend," from the command, "Thou shalt not steal." Those who would proclaim the great duties of Christianity, are under no necessity of teaching through nega- tive commands : it is, on the contrary, their duty, as it is their privilege, to teach and unfold the obligations of Christian life from the positive commands of our Lord himself. These enjoin every duty of man to God, and every duty of man to man, that can be con- ceived, and they virtually forbid every sin that is inconsistent with these duties: obe- dience to these injunctions, so far as perfect, casts out and excludes all lusts and passions which war against God and man, and all offences against both. It is not difficult to comprehend how much more powerfully and ally armed at all points is the Christian, who goes into the world as the ambassador of AMERICAN EDITION. Vll Christ, to tell men what they must do, than he who confines himself to telling them what they must not do. This is very plainly seen, as we have said previously, in the work before us, and also in " Mammon : " and it is the reason why both writers have frequently left the path which their subject prescribed, to treat of the social bearings of Christianity from the positive side. It would be a happy event if these two earnest Divines should both revert to the sub- ject, and, taking into view the whole Law of Christ, unfold its length and breadth, exhibit its comprehensiveness, its far-reaching wisdom, and its soul-pervading qualities ; such a de- velopment, carried boldly and firmly into the business, the maxims and philosophy of this world, would bear with it a power seldom felt in those circles. It would expose to contempt and pity many of the hiding-places of spiritual pride and selfishness, many sores of the body politic and social, and many of the hollow places in our religious systems and Christian life. It is a fact, as much to be lamented as it is to be remarked, that our English religious literature is without any respectable work on Vlll PREFACE TO THE the great commandment, " Thou shalt love thy neighbor as thyself; " or, upon the golden rule which contains the stringent law, "As ye would that men should do unto you, do ye also to them likewise." It cannot be thought, for a moment, that these laws do not deserve, for their importance, the largest development which human experience or human ability can give them. It cannot be denied that they cover the whole ground of social life, civil and religious. They embrace the whole subjects of charity and beneficence ; they include the philosophy of morals and of manners. If our religion be divided into that which pertains to our duty to God and that which pertains to our duty to man, then these two laws con- tain the fundamental doctrines of the latter, as the command to " Love God with all thy heart, and with all thy soul, and with all thy mind," contains the fundamental doctrines of our duty to God. Of course, love, in the latter case, implies faith ; for no one can love Him in whom he has not believed. Whilst our theology has largely and richly developed our duty to God, it has left the far more compli- cated subject of onr duty to man compara- tively untouched. The obligation to love our AMERICAN EDITION. IX fellow-man is not less imperative nor less a religious duty, than the obligation to love God : the degree of love enjoined is less in one case than in the other, but the duty of obedience is equally binding in both cases. Our religious duties to our fellow-men, which, by their nature and comprehensiveness, bear upon all the business and social intercourse of life, remain yet to be set forth with that method, fulness and cogency, which their im- portance demands. To assert or to suppose that this has been done, only betrays want of knowledge or want of consideration. Moral philosophy and Political Economy, which refer to the largest divisions of this subject, have, even in the hands of Christians, failed to draw their principles from the Law of Christ, even where these explicitly cover the very ground of discussion. The men of the world have decided that neither of the above- named sciences has any connection with Christianity, and Christian authors have vir- tually admitted this position by treating these subjects, without invoking the authority or the principles of Divine Truth. There are many indications that such an omission will not be much longer endured. Not a few are X PREFACE TO THE found in the pages now submitted to the reader, and not a few were contained in the pages of " Mammon." Of the latter, the fol- lowing is a specimen : " It is clear that the entire economy of salvation is constructed on the principle of restoring to the world the lost principle of love.* It was confronting selfishness, in its own native region, with a system of benevolence, prepared as its avowed antagonist by the hand of God itself." And yet, if this be so, where, in our religious lite- rature, is the explanation of " this principle of love — this system of benevolence prepared by the hand of God V Have Christians ne- glected to consider, discuss, and develop this principle, upon which " the entire economy of our salvation is constructed ?" If so, the omission is of fatal consequence, and it is no wonder that he adds — "But has its object been realized? More than 1800 years have elapsed since it was brought into operation — has its design succeeded ? Succeeded ! Alas ! the question seems a taunt, a mockery!" But why is it thus? Why has the gospel been hitherto threatened with the failure of a mere business experiment ? . . . " But who does not * Neglected, not lost. AMERICAN EDITION. XI feel that the era of effective benevolence has yet to commence ? Let him sketch the most simple scheme of benevolence which the Gospel can approve, and he will perceive that, at every step, he is writing the condemnation of the Church. The great lesson taught by our Lord's voluntary selection of a state of poverty, is yet to be fully understood, the evi- dent application of many passages of Scrip- ture to be made, doctrines startling to selfish- ness to become familiar and welcome, the word benevolence itself to be differently understood, and the whole economy of benevolence to be revised." We believe it to be a part of our religion to love our fellow-men, and to act as if we loved them : Christianity consists, not wholly in faith, nor in believing the facts set forth in the Scriptures; it consists not wholly nor chiefly in believing that Christ died for the redemption of sinners : it demands belief in what Christ taught us, and obedience to his instructions. It does not teach us that our justification will accrue from our obedience ; but it requires obedience, and no man's faith can be genuine who does not try to obey ; no faith can be safe which is not "faith working Xll PREFACE TO THE hj Jove." Our holy religion does not consist then simply in the worship of God, nor in be- lieving in God ; it consists in our duty to God and our duty to man.* Whatever may be said of the manner in which we fulfil these duties, it cannot be denied that our religious litera- ture develops far more amply our duty to God than our duty to man. It is the latter, there- fore, that we desire to bring more fully to the attention of all Christians; not to displace nor usurp the position of the former; but that the latter may receive its due share of atten- tion, honor, and obedience, as a part of that Christianity we profess. We cannot hesitate to urge these important truths, because some well-meaning persons cannot understand their importance and per- tinency, nor because they are so fearful of exalting Charity above Eeligion, or Philan- thropy above Theology, that they would banish " humanity " from religion, and leave it to take refuge among Socialists and Infidels. * If, as the term imports, Theology includes only our rela- tions with God, then, what shall we call the doctrine of our relations with our fellow-man? If we have no name pro- vided, it is some proof that the doctrine is yet to be developed, exhibiting the religious duty of man to man. If Theology is to be the term, then its domain is to be extended to cover this great subject. AMERICAN EDITION. Xlll Despite this narrow prejudice, which disables those who entertain it from forming an ade- quate conception of Christianity, we intend to keep these contemned words, Charity, Hit- manity, Philanthropy, before the Christian public. Not that we would exalt them above Christianity, but that we would assign them their due place in our religious systems. We cannot be deterred by any cry of " Human- ism," or " Socialism," or Communism," or any similar note of alarm, from believing and avowing that humanity is a religious duty, that it is enjoined upon us by Christ, in terras so explicit, so strong, and so frequently re- peated, that only those who will not see can be blind to it. "Good Master, what shall I do to inherit eternal life ?" asked the lawyer. Our Lord, after repeating the parable of the Good Samaritan, said, " Go, and do thou like- wise." His ministry was one of such constant attention to human woes and wants, that, if no higher object had been designed, if man's eternal interest had not been concerned, it must have been pronounced a life of the purest, the most unvarying, the most untiring, and the most effective humanity that was ever exhibited on earth, and that all he said was 2 XIV PREFACE TO THE as deeply fraught with lessons of humanity as all he did. It would be vain to seek, in the pages of Socialists or Humanitarians, of any degree or name, any parallel to the hu- manity practised and taught by Christ. It implies no conflict with orthodoxy or sound theology to say this. The Apostles recognized it fully ; it enters into their teachings : and the primitive Christians in a large degree ex- emplified it. We need to recognize more fully the teaching and the example of our Saviour; but this neither implies nor demands any sur- render of the great cardinal doctrines of Chris- tianity. Our position is, that we can admit the whole doctrine of Christian charity, hu- manity, philanthropy, into an Evangelical Orthodox Christianity, not only without danger of error, and without sacrifice of truth, but with positive advantage, and a new infusion of spiritual fervor and energy. Above all this, however, it is as much our duty to receive the Saviour's doctrine of humanity as any other of His doctrines. He has left us no warrant for its omission. If any duty can be enforced by the language and example of our Saviour, and by the teachings of the Apostles, those of humanity and charity can; AMERICAN EDITION. XV and, however we may characterize that huma- nity and charity which men exhibit from no motives of religion, no faith in God, and no love to the Saviour, it cannot be denied, with any just regard to the words of Scripture, that charity and humanity are essential elements of Christianity; they are, when religiously exercised, among its most important charac- teristics. They cannot, however, be what they should, unless they are religiously exer- cised — unless they are overflowings of a Christian spirit. How can we then hesitate to recommend these religious duties, and to insist that the doctrines which explain, dis- tinguish, and enforce these duties, should receive a development proportioned to their importance? How can we forget that our obligations to fulfil these duties are derived from the same Divine authority which enjoins the duties of faith, repentance, and prayer, and that, coming from that source, they are as much a part of our Christianity as those duties are. Our system of Christian doctrines should include the religious duties we owe to our fellow-men, and must include them, if it in- cludes the teachings of Christ. We cannot XYl PREFACE TO THE make up our religious system from the Epistles of Paul, nor from any other, or all the Epistles, if we omit the words of our Saviour himself. These contain, specially, the instructions which embrace our duty to our fellow-men : they are the highest fountain from which we can draw on that subject. They furnish those pervading rules and principles which search every hidden recess of the heart, and, in pro- portion as they find entrance there, cast out all the evil thoughts and emotions inconsistent with them. It is under the pressure of these, chiefly, that we are impelled to enter upon the performance of our duties to men ; and are made to perceive that these are religions duties ; and to acknowledge that no religious duties are more strongly enjoined upon us, than those we owe to the human family. We are then under the necessity of inquir- ing what all this implies — what religion re- quires us to do for our fellow-men. If our faith is to work by love, what is the work to be done? It is all comprehended in "Thou shalt love thy neighbor as thyself;" that includes all we need do for our neighbor. Our present object is, to select for remark a single topic of the duty thus intended. AMERICAN EDITION. XV11 How can we intelligently do for our neigh- bor what we would for ourselves, unless we understand his true position in life, his feel- ings, his relations, his wants, his capacities, his opportunities, his circumstances ? Are we not under the necessity of knowing, as far as practicable, all that concerns man, that we may, as far as needful, do for him as we would for ourselves ; for, that loving which is with- out doing is like that faith which is without working. We must, therefore, as our intelli- gence and opportunity permit, study the actual condition of men, with the best lights we can obtain — and we must not only ascer- tain and do what is in our power individually to do for human benefit, but we must study what is the mutual duty of men, religious, political, social, and philosophical. Nothing short of the highest attainments we can make in this knowledge, can adequately fit us for loving our neighbor as ourselves. Of course, many, nay, all, must fall short in this kind of knowledge — but that, alas! is only what befalls us in every other path of Christian duty. We are speaking of the comprehen- sive nature of Christ's instructions. We com- plain that this duty, which we owe to men, 2* XV111 PREFACE TO THE of studying their conditions in all the rela- tions and positions of life, has not been suffi- ciently held up and regarded as a religious obligation. We seek religiously all that relates to God ; we should seek religiously to learn all that can promote the highest inte- rests of men, temporal and eternal. Looking at men from this point, social and political philosophy assumes at once a more important aspect. In studying these subjects we must carry with us the authority, the doctrines, the very words of Christ. These shed at once a flood of light on themes, long darkened by opposing theories and clashing practice. When social and Christian philosophy assumes the same starting point — the best interests of men — and when this object is kept steadily in view, a system will be elaborated which must thoroughly renovate the whole fabric of society. And this benefit may be confidently expected, without any change in human nature, except that which is to be effected by its being subjected to Christian influences, under more favorable circumstances than before. We believe that the greatest obstacle to the progress of Christianity is the want of this AMERICAN EDITION. XIX application of its principles, as they are spe- cially taught by Christ, to the social condition of men. Christianity now meets in its pro- gress among men a special opposition from institutions, from maxims of business, from social systems, which are so inimical to its true spirit, and yet so firmly established, that its forward movement is, humanly speaking, impossible, and, religiously speaking, only possible with God. But how can His blessing be fully expected, unless Christians carry the principles of their Master into these institu- tions, this business, and these social systems ? They mingle in all these, and make part and parcel of them; let these principles of their Divine Master make also a part and parcel of them. Let Christians be everywhere distin- guishable by their loving one another, by their being the most earnest friends of their fellow- men, by their devotion to all that concerns the highest interests of men, temporal and eternal, and Christianity will make a progress among the masses, unknown since the days when such were the prominent characteristics of Christian men. When it is fully realized that Christians are stewards of Christ for whatever is com- XX PREFACE TO THE mitted to them, whether it be talents or wealth, or strength, or knowledge ; when it is realized that these endowments are given that they may be laid out for the benefit of the human family, it will come home more fully to the consciences of these servants in the household of Christ, that they must pre- pare themselves for the proper discharge of these obligations to their fellow-men. To that end they must not only study their interests for eternity, but their interests for time. Of all that concerns man, nothing can be indiffe- rent to them. They cannot see them suffer, from any cause, without affording, according to the nature of the case, sympathy or relief: if they suffer political oppression, they will at least try to comprehend its nature and extent, and to put forth such influences and know- ledge as may tend to relieve, if not remove the evil ; and so with every form of evil and suffering to which men are exposed, whether industrial, commercial, social, or religious. None of the ills of human life are beyond the reach of religious sympathy and succor : many cannot be reached but by public efforts ; men who suffer from political or social wrongs can only be aided frequently by the development AMERICAN EDITION. XXI and diffusion of sound political principles and a sound social philosophy. The true servant of that Master, whose efforts for human weal never flagged, cannot refuse to apply himself to that special inquiry, or to that special study which may fit him to help those who can be helped in no other way. If he believes that Christian principles are sound, he must see that they are applicable to the amelioration of human condition in every possible state of man. Knowing that Christianity enjoins sub- mission to existing powers and every ordinance of man, the student of Christian social philo- sophy will not look, except in extreme cases, to revolution and bloodshed for any relief, but endeavor to show that the best interests of both rulers and people lie in one path, that which most promotes the Christian welfare and social happiness of man. The Christian reformer will not use weapons of war, unless unavoidable; but he should be prepared to put forth his Christian principles in every emergency, social, civil, industrial, and commer- cial. He should watch the movements of the world in all these respects with intense anxiety, to observe how the best interests of men may be affected by passing events, and to learn XX11 PREFACE TO THE how they may be promoted. All legislation, all political action, all social movements, should be regarded with particular attention, in reference to their bearing upon human advantage. Such considerations as these should press upon the intelligent Christian with a weight proportioned to the importance of the interests involved.* If a Christian man * "Nearly all external religious services are means of grace, and, however needful to the progress of religion, however in- dispensable in the work of winning souls to Christ, or pro- moting our own growth in grace, they are not in themselves religion — they are not of the essence of Christianity. These means of grace are resorted to, not as Christianity, but as helps towards it : employed they should be for what they are, and not for what they are not. Building churches, praying in public, preaching the Gospel, distributing the Scriptures, publishing good books, sending forth Missionaries, and other like means of grace, are designed to lead men to Christ, and to instruct them in Christianity. They are not in themselves the main duty of Christian life. They are the introduction to it ; they are the preparation for it ; they are the guides by the way ; they are means of conversion ; they are fountains of refreshment ; they are sources of encouragement ; they are means of religious invigoration ; they are means of grace. God blesses them as such ; and Christians, if they will thrive, and grow in grace, and be fitted for the main object of the Christian life, the maintaining a pious, an earnest devotion to God, and an active life of love and benefit to the human family, must not neglect them. It is, therefore, an essential and indispensable religious duty, to do to and for our fellow- men all that is dictated by the command, to love them as ourselves ; and no amount of indulgence in the means of AMERICAN EDITION. XX111 feels impelled to stoop by the wayside, to re- lieve him who has fallen among thieves, and has been left there wounded and suffering; if he feels bound to give alms to him who is in want, to give a cup of cold water to him who is athirst, with how much interest must he regard that legislation, that policy of government, that social philosophy which de- grace can atone for the neglect of this duty, any more than any amount of kindness and love to men can atone for a neglect to ' worship God, who is a Spirit, in spirit and in truth.' " The love of God and the love of our fellow-men, are actual piety, religion, Christianity itself; the usual external services of religion, being only means to that great end, yield, there- fore, in importance, to it. It is a vital part of Christianity to love men as ourselves : it is the test by which Christ has de- clared that his disciples shall be known. ■ By this shall all men know that ye are my disciples, if ye have love one to another/ No mere means of grace, no external forms of wor- ship, no religious services, should be exalted above this great religious duty of loving and serving our fellow-men. It is to this the Apostle Paul refers, when he says, 'All the law is fulfilled in one word, even in this, Thou shalt love thy neigh- bor as thyself.' The man of God, who, in obedience to Christ, strives to fulfil this command, is discharging the highest duties of a Christian life. Under the guidance of this precept, we owe to our fellow-men what we owe to ourselves. Where is the development of this great branch of our religious duty ? Where are we specially instructed, and in detail, as to the bearing of this great law of Christianity upon all the business and relations of life ? To build a church for Christ's sake is a worthy deed, a real means of grace ; but to love our fellow- XXIV PREFACE TO THE termines the weal or woe of thousands — per- haps millions of his fellow-creatures. If the Christian must not neglect the poor and suf- fering, neither must he neglect any opportunity nor any effort to save men from poverty, de- gradation, and ignorance. We are not only to help the poor, we are to "consider the poor :" we are not only to think of our own affairs, but we are to look also upon the affairs of' others — we are to bear not only our own burdens, but also the burdens of others. men as ourselves for Christ's sake, is an act of real religion itself, not the means, but, as far as it goes, the very thing itself. To consider what we owe to and can do for all our brethren of the human family, is an actual Christian duty, to be religiously performed, from which Christians cannot escape. When, for Christ's sake, Christians are earnestly considering what they can do for the temporal and eternal interests of men, they are in the direct line of religious duty, and so when they are carrying into effect such measures as they may, in the light of the Scriptures, deem most benefi- cial to men. This does not simply include mere alms-giving. It extends to all men, rich and poor. There are corresponding duties for every position and relation of life. Those in rela- tion to the poor are chiefly dwelt upon, because they are chiefly dwelt upon in Scripture, and because the manner of life of the early Christians, furnished such ample illustrations of what they deemed their duties to the poor to be, while their minds were fresh with instruction from the lips and pen of inspiration. " They could then enforce and exemplify the truth announced by the Apostle James, that, 'Pure religion and undefined be- AMERICAN EDITION. XXV Under the Dispensation of the Gospel, God requires of man little duty that is outward merely, except that which consists in acts of mercy and kindness towards men : in no way can the renewed man render more acceptable service to God, than by kindness and love to his fellow-men ; in no path of duty can he more fully glorify his Master, than in the ministrations of love and mercy; "for love and charity is plainly the thing in which he has placed his religion ; in which, therefore, fore God and the Father is this: to visit the fatherless and widows in their affliction,' without being charged with denying or depreciating the doctrine of justification by faith. They could feed on the doctrine and go out strengthened to their Christian task