E359 13M21J ■'■,■,■.■ -N '.* ■'* ■■. . . .'J ■4 ■'1 ^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^Kfli f '''■'.'...'.'. .■■' '-'•n^^^^H^I ■'J ha LIBRARY OF CONGRESS DDDD5Dfl2Db7 ■' "V/ .'^'- \>/ =«'• %/ .^b*^^^. .'^ y \ ^^ u o< .0- .^^ 0- o. THE (/I SPEECH OF HIS EXCELLENCY GOVERNOR STRONG DELIVERED BEFORE THX LEGISLATVBE OF MASSACHUSETTS; OCTOBER 16, 1812. WITH THE DOCUMENTS, WHICH ACCOMPANIED THE SAilE. PRINTEt) BY OTJDER OF THE HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES. boston: prijited liv russell and cutler, • • ft • ./ ■;'■ 9 /I ' ; if SPEECH. Gentlemen of the Senate — and Gentlemen of the House of Rej)resentatwes, THE period aj^aiii approaches when Elec- tors of a President and Vice-President of the United States are to be appointed, and you have now as- sembled that you may execute the important trust, of directing the manner of tlieir appointment on the part of tliis State. I hope that nothing will interfere to prevent an impartial discharge of this publick duty. The language of the Constitution on this subject is im- perative. ^' Each State sIimII appoint, in such manner as the Legislature thereof may direct, a number of E- lectors." This form of expression was necessary ; for it is obvious, that if the States should neglect to ap- point Electors, the National Government would be at an end. In addition to this, the Constitution lias re- quired, that the members of the State Legislatures, and all executive officers shall be bound by oath or affirm- ation to support the Constitution. A¥e have taken this oath ; and have also sworn impartially to. perform all the duties incumbent on us as members of the State Government. Should this duty be neglected, the peo- ple of this state would, on this important occasion, lose their political consequence, and be deprived of the rights of citizens. By a letter of the 12ih of last June, the Secretary of War requested me, by direction of the President, to order into the service of the United States, on the re- quisition of Major- General Dearborn, such part of the quota of militia from this State, detached conform- 4 ably to the act of the 10th of April last, as he might deem necessary for the defence of the sea-coast. On the S2d of Jnne I received a letter from Gen. Dear- born, informing me that war was declared against G. Britain, and requesting me to order forty-one compa- nies of the detached militia into the service of the U. States for the defence of the ports and harbours in this State, and the harbour of Newport in the State of R. Island ; and stating that the companies were intended for the following ports and harbours, in the following proportions : — For Passamaquoddy five companies^ for Maciiias one company, for Castine three compa- nies, for Damariscotta and Wiscasset two companies, ^for Kennebunk one company, for Portland five compa- nies, for Marblehead, Salem, Cape- Ann and Newbu- ryport, four companies, for Boston twelve companies, and for Rhode-Island eiglit companies. I also receiv- ed from Gen. Dearborn two other letters of June 26 and June 2d, on the same subject. The Constitution of the U. S. declares that, ^^ Con- gress may provide for calling forth the militia to exe- cute the laws of the Union, suppress insurrections and repel invasions," and the act of Congress of April 10th authorizing a detachment of 100,000 of tlie militia, empowers the President to " call into actual service any part, or the whole of said detachment in all the exigencies provided by the Constitution.'' From these clauses in tiie Constitution and law of April lOtJi, the President derives his autliority to call the militia of the States into actual service ; and except in the exi- gencies above mentioned he can have no authority by the Constitution to do it. But there was no sugges- tion, either in the letter from tlie War Department,, above referred to, or in those from Gen. Dearborn, lliat this State or Rhode-Island was invaded, or in im- minent danger of invasion ; or that either of the exi- gencies recognized by the Constitution and law of the United States existed. If such declaration could have been made with truth, it would undoubtedly have been made. Gen. Dearbokn plainly suppo^tl, that in consequence of the act declaring war, he was authorized by virtue of the power given him hy the President, to require any part or the whole of our detached militia to ])e called out and marched to such places in this and the other States as he might think proper. If this construction of the Constitution is correct, the President and Con- gress will be able at any time, by declaring war, to call the whole militia of the U. S. into actual service, and march them to such places as they may think fit, and re- tain them in service as long as the w ar shall continue. It is declared indeed by the aforesaid act of April 10th, that the said detachment shall not be compelled to serve a "longer time than six months after they arrive at the place of rendezvous.'^ But if the mere act of declaring war gives a right to the National Government to call the? militia into service and detain them six months, it must give a right to detain them six years, if the war contin- ues so long ; and the National Government has the same authority to call out the whole, as a part of the militia. Heretofore it has been understood, that the power of the President and Congress to call the militia into ser- vice, was to be exercised only in cases of sudden emer- gency, and not for the purpose of forming them into a standing army or of carrying on offensive war. But according to the above construction, the right to employ the militia is made to depend, not upon contingencies which the National Government might be unable to foresee or provide against, but upon its own act — upon the existence of a state of war, which the Government has a right to declare as often, and continue so long, as it may think proper. Although many of the most important attributes of sovereignty are given by the Constitution to the Gov- ernment of the U. vS. yet there are some which still be- long to the State Governments ; of these, one of the most essential is tlie entire control of the militia, except in the exigencies a])ove mentioned ; this has not been delegated to the United States — it is therefore reserved to tlie States respectively ; and whenever it shall be taken from tlieni;, and a consolidation of the military force of the States shall be eifected, the security of the State Governments will be lost, and they will wholly depend for their existence upon the moderation and for- bearance of the National Government. I have been iiilly disposed to comply with the require- ments of the Constitution of the United StPctes and the laws made in pursuance of it, and sincerely regretted that any request should be made by an Officer of the National Government to which I could not constitution- ally conform. But it appeared to me that the requisi- tion aforesaid was of that character ; and I was under the same obligation to maintain the rights of the State, as to support the Constitution of the U. S. If the de- mand was not warranted by the Constitution, I should liave violated my duty in a most important point, if I liad attemped to enforce it, and had thereby assisted in withdrawing the militia from the rightful authority of the State. Besides, if the measure was not required by the Constitution, it would have been oppressive, as the militia must have been called from their occupations to places remote from their homes, and detained in the service during the busy season of the year. I, therefore, on the third day of July, issued a general order ; and on the same day wrote to Gen. Dearbokx, that I had directed the Adjutant- General to furnish him with a copy of it ; and that after mature reflection I had en- deavoured, in that order, to pursue the course which my duty, in relation to the request contained in his letter of June 2Sd, required of me. Afterwards, by a letter of July lath, Gen. Bear- BOiiN informed me, that having received orders to leave the sea coast, where he was ordered for the purpose of taking the necessary measures for placing the towns and garrisons in a state of defence against the invasion or attack of tlie enemy, and to repair to Albany, it be- came his duty to request me .to order out such part of the detached militia as the 'present state of ivar re- quired , the number being stated in his letter of the 22d June ; and that as other objects would require the ser- vice of a great part of tlie regular (roops. it Avould be- come his duty to order them from the seaboard. This letter I had no opportunity of answcrins; before Cxen. Dearborn left the State. But I presumed if this State was in danger of invasion, that tlic regular troops would not be ordered to Albany, and if tliey were so ordered, that the militia were not liable to be called in- to service and stationed in tlie forts of the U. States to do garrison duty, when no danger of invasion appear- ed. On the S7th of July, I received a letter from the. Secretary of War, of the 21st of that month, stating that orders had been given to Gen. Dearborn to move the regular troops to the nortliern frontier, leaving a sufficient number to man the guns in the garrisons on the seaboard, and renewing the requisition ^.foresaid. In Ihi^ letter he says, " The danger of invasion which existed at the time of issuing the order of the Presi- dent, increases.'' This expression was peculiarly guarded, as the order of the President was issued be- fore war was declared. However, as this and the last letter of Gen. Dearborn, seemed to imply that there Avas some danger of invasion, and as the measures to be taken on my part were of importance, I thought it expedient to convene the Council, and request their advice on tlie subject of the foregoing letters. The Council advised, that they were unable from a view of the Constitution of the tlnited States, and the docu- ments aforesaid, to perceive that any exigency existed which could render it adviseable to comply with the said requisition. But as upon important questions of law, and upon solemn occasions, tlie Governor and Council liave autliority to require the o])inion of the Justices of the Supreme Judicial Ccurt, that it was ad- viseable to request fhe opinicui of tlie Supreme Court upon tlie following questions, viz. 1st. Whether the Commanders in Ciiief of the militia of the several States, jiave a rigbt to determine w lieth- er any of the exigencies contemplated by the Constitu- iicn of the United States exist, so as to reqiiire them 8 10 place the militia, or any part of it, in the service of the United States, at the request of the President, to be commanded by him pursuant to acts of Congress ? Sd. Whether, when either of the exigencies exist, authorizing the employing the militia in the service of the United States, the militia thus employed, can be lawfully commanded by any officer but of the militia, except by the President of the United States ? After the above request was made to the Supreme Court, a person deputed by the inhabitants of Eastport and Robinstown, on our eastern boundary, applied to me, representing that there were many lawless people on the borders, from ^vhom they had serious ap- prehensions of an attack, and requesting that a number of the militia miglit be stationed in those towns. The Council ad\ased that three companies of the detached militia should be called into the service of thelUnited States for their protection. On the 6th August I issu- ed an order for that purpose, and directed that two of the companies should be stationed at Eastport, and one company at Robin stov/n, until the President should otherwise direct : and the same day, by a letter to the Secretary of War, informed liira of the transactions a- foresaid — and having received the opinion of the Judg- es on the above questions, inclosed to him their answer. A copy of that {)])inion and the letters and papers above referred to, will be laid liefore you by the Secretary. Soon after the declaration of war, several towns on the sea coast applied to the Governor and Council for arms and ammunition, as many persons who were ex- empt from military duty, were destitute of the necessa- ry means of defence. Agreeably to the advice of the Council, they were, in some instances, furnished with those articles. By inspecting the returns of the Quar- ter-Master-General, you AA ill )je convinced of the ne- cessity of obtaining a further supply of small arms and military stores, and the more so, as our defence on the seaboard seems almost wholly to be confided to the mi. litia. We have in this state several hundred miles of ,sca coast, a numljcr of islands near the coast are iuhab. 9 Ued by oiu- citizens, and more than one Imndred of oitr towns may be approached by tiie enemy's sliips. It is oi)vions therefore that only a maritime defence can af- ford them full security. Still, however, We sliould era- ploy such means as we possess for their protection, and lo this end, it will be necessary that the whole militia «^hould be armed and equipped in the best possible manner, and ready to march at tiic sliortest notice, and in case of invasion that arms should be in readiness for every man who is able to bear them. In tliis w ay it is probable tliat our defensive force, and the general se- »*urity of the seaboard will be as great, as if portions of the militia were drawn from every part of the State, and stationed in a few of the large towns on the coast. While the A¥ar, in which we are unliappily involv- ed, continues, it is to be carried on only in the name and by direction of the public. The people cannot act of themselves except for the defence of their posses- sions and territories. Without the commission or par- ticular onler of the Government, they have no right to commit hostilities or undertake any oifensive expedi- tion. In modern warfare the troops alone carry on the war, Avhile the rest of the people peaceably fol- low their callings ; and if they refrain from hostilities, iiave generally but little to fear from th.e enemy's arms. For many years, and until within a late period, the nations of Europe have made war Avith moderation and generosity, and in a manner which proved they liad not forgotten, that their enemies were men, and inight afterwards become friends. Indeed war is so dreadful in its effects, and so destructive to human happiness, that the law of nature allows of it only in the utmost extremity ; and requires, that when it is resort- ed to, the persons engaged in it shall endeavor to mi- tigate its horrors as far as their safety will permit, by the exercise of justice and humanity. These princi- ples of the law of nature are confirmed by tiie precepts of the Christian religion. Whatever sentiments may prevail amons; the people of this State concerning the justice or expediency of the i6 present War, I hope and trust that they will perforih the duties enjoined on them hy our Constitutions and Laws, and that tliey will do nothing to obstruct the (Grovernment in the constitutional measures they may think proper to adopt. If those measures are thought to be unjustifiable or particularly injurious to this part of the Union, let us cherish a confidence in the wis- dom and the justice of the otlier States, and wait with patience for the remedy provided by the Constitution. In the mean time, let us regard with abhorrence those violent personal outrages, which are fatal to the peace and disgraceful to the character of any people ; let us be watchful and determined to prevent tumults and disorders of every kind, by which our internal tranquil- lity would be endangered, and be as willing to in- dulge in others the right of expressing their opin- ions of publick measures, as we are to exercise that right ourselves. I shall readily co-operate with you. Gentlemen, in any measures that may be thought conducive to the defence and tranquillity of the State, and the preserva- tion and security of the Union ; and may the God of our Fathers protect us in tliis calamitous period, and guide us in the Avay of duty and asfety. CALEB STRONG, October i% 1813. DOCUMENTS. WAR DEPARTMENT,; June 12, 1812. Sir, I am directed by the President to request Yoiu* Excellency to order into the service of the Uni= ted States, on the requisition of Major Greneral Dear- born, such part of the quota of militia from the state of Massachusetts, detached conformably to the act of April 10, 1812, as he may deem necessary for the defence of the sea coast. With great respect, I have the honour to be Your Excellency's Obedient servant, W, EUSTIS. His Excellency the Governor of the 7 State of Massachusetts. ^ HEAD QUARTERS BOSTON June 22, 1812. To His Excellency Caleb Strong. Sir, I have received instructions from the Pres- ident of the United States, to call on vour Excellen- cy for such part of the quota of the militia of Massa- chusetts, which was detached conformably to the act of Congress of April 10, 1812, as I may deem neces- sary for the defence of the lea-coast ; and I now have the honour of requesting your Excellency to order IS fourteen companies of Artillery, and twenty -j? deliver you herewith the letters above mentioned. 1 am, Gentlemen, with great respect, Your most obedient servant. CAUEB STRONG To liis E.vcellency the Governor and the Honoura- ble Council of the Commonwealth of Massachu- setts. The undersigned. Justices of the Supreme Judi- cial Court, have considered the several questions proposed by your Excellency and Honours for their opinion. By the constitution of this State, the authority of commanding the Militia of the Comnionweakh is vested exclusively in the Governor, who has all the powers incident to the office of Commander in Chief, and is to exercise them personally or by subordinate officers under his command, agreeably to the rules and regulations of the constitution and the laws of the land. While the Governor of the Commonwealth remain- ed in the exercise of these powers, the federal con- stitution was ratified, by which was vested in tlie Congress a power to provide for the calling forth llie Militia, to execute the laws of the Union, suppress insurrections and repel invasions; and to provide for governing such part of them as may be employed in the service of the United States, reserving to the 2S States respectively the appointment of the oflBcers. The federal constitution further provides, that the President shall be commander in chief of the army of the United States and of the Milida of the several States, whtn called into the actual service of the Uni- ted States. On the construction of the federal and state consti- tiif.ion must depentl the answers to the several ques- '' .ons proposed. As Ihe Mililia of the several States may be employed in the service of the United States for the three specific purposes of executing the laws of the Union, of suppressing insurrections and repelling invasions,the opinion of the Judges is requfcsted,wheth- er the Commanders in Chief, of the Militia of the sev- eral States have a right to determine whether any of the exigencies aforesaid exist, so as to require them to place the Militia, or any part of it, in the service of the United States, at the request of the President, to be commanded by him pursuant to acts of Congress. It is the opinion of the undersigned, that this right is vested in the Commander in Chief of the Militia of the several States. The federal constitution provides, that when either of these exigencies exist, the Militia may be employ- ed, pursuant to some act of Congress, in the service of the United States ; but no power is given either to the President or to the Congress to determine tha either of the said exigencies do in fact exist, as this power is not delegated to the United States by the federal constitution, nor prohibited by it to the States, it is reserved to the States respectively ; and from the nature of the power it must be exercised by those with whom the States have respectively entrusted the chief command of the Militia. It is the duty of these commanders to execute this important trust agreeably to the laws of their several States respectively, without reference to the laws or oflicers of the United States, in all cases, ex- cept those specially provided in the Je^leral cousti. ^3 tiition. They must therefore determine when either of the special cases exist ohliging them to relinquish the execution of this trust, and to render themselves and the Militia subject to the command of the Presi- dent. A different construction, giving to Congress the right to determine when these special cases exist, authorizins; them to call forth the whole of the Mili- tia, and taking them from the Commanders in Chief of the several S-ates and subjecting them to the com- mand of the President, would place all the Militia in effect at the will of the Congress and produce a military cousolidatiou of the States, wi hout any con- stitutional remedy against the intentions of the peo- ple when ra ifying the federal constitution. Indeed since the passing of the act of Congress of February 28, 1795, c. 101, vesting in the President the power of calling forth the Militia wh^M the exigencies men- tioned in the constitution shall exist, if the President has the power of determining when those exigencies exist, the Alilitia of the several States is in fact at his command and suhjocl, to his controul. No inconveniences can reasonably be presumed to result from the construction which vests in the Com- manders in Chief of the Militia in the several States the right of determining when the exigencies exist obliging them to place the Militia in the service of the United Spates. These exigencies are of such a nature, that the existence of th«m can be easily as- certained by or made known to the Commanders in Chief of the Militia ; and when ascertained, the pub- lic interest will induce a prompt obedience to the acts of Congress. Another question proposed to the Consideration of the Judges is, whether, when either of the exigencies exist authorizing the employing of the Militia in the service of the United States, the Militia thus employ- ed can be lawfully commanded by any officer but of the Militia, except by tke President of the United States. 24 The federal constitution declarer that the President shall be the Comiiiander in Chief of the array of th^ Uiiited States. He may undoubtedly exercise this eomniaud by officeirs of the army of the United States by him commis^^ioned according to law. The Presi- dent is a,lso declared to be the Commander iu Chief of the Militia of tke several States, when called into the actual service of the United States. The officers of Uie Militia are to be appointed by th0 States ; au Commander in Chief. . \ Eastern Detachment Orders^ hy Maj. Gen. Sewall. Augusta, August 11, 1812. In obedience to the General Orders of the 5th inst. the three Companies of Infantry hereby designated to march to Eastport for the defence of that frontier, will fee, the detached Company in the neighbourhood of iJ3 iCastporfc, under the command of Captain Tliomas Yose^ jun .of Robbinstown,the detached Company i n the interior iieiglibourhood of Penobscot river, under the command of Captain Joshua Chamberlain,* of Orriniijton, and the detached Company in the same neigliboiirhood under tlie command of Captain Thomas George,* of Brewer, which will form a Battalion, to l)e commanded by Major Nathan Low, of Deer Isle ; Adjutant Moses Adams, of Els worth, and Quarter Master Jeremiah Knowlton, are also hereby attached to the Battalion and directed to perform the duties of their respective offices therein. On receipt of these orders the troops composing the several Companies aforesaid, will be supplied with the necessa- ry provisions &c. by the Selectmen of their respective towns, according to the directions prescril)ed in the mi- litia law ; and being completely armed aud equipped as the law directs will immediately march for Eastport, under the command of the said detached Captains, until they shall be joined by Major Low, from v.iiom they will then take further orders. On the arrival of any of the said Companies at Eastport, Colonel Shead, of that place, is hereby requested to afford all the aid and ad- vice which may be necessary for the judicious disposi- tion or comfortable accommodation of the troops, espe- cially until the Major Commandant shall arrive. A strict attention to the orders of the Commander in Chief is hereby enjoined on the Officers and men of this detac- ment relative to their conduct on the march, and at the place of destination. Boston, August 21, 1812, Hon. William Eustis, Secretary at War. Sir, I mentioned in my letter to you of the 5th of Au- gust, that I had tiiat (lay issued an order for calling out three companies of the detached MiUtia, to be * These Captains names were inserted at Bangor by the adTice of Gen. Blak?. J jnarcbed immediately to Passamaqiiodd y. for the de^. fence of that frontier, and to he commanded hy a JNla- jor. I direcied that two of tlie companies should he stationed at Eastport,and one company at Rohhinstown, until the President should direct otherwise, unless, in the mean time, the Major w ith the advice of Brigadier General Brewer, who lives in Rohhinstown.and to whom I wrote on the subject, should think a dili'erent dispo- sition of the companies would be more advantageous. I have this day received a letter from (General Sew- all, dated the 17th instant, in which he says, that he had designated the detached company in tlie neigh- bourhood of Eastport, under the command of Captain Thomas A-^ose, jun. of Robl)iustown, tlie detaclied com- pany in the interior neighbourhood of Penobscot River, under the command of Captain Joshua Chamberlain, of Orrington, and the detached company in the same jieighbourhood, under the command of Captain Tho- mas George of Brewer, to form a Battalion, to be com- manded by Major Nathan Low, of Deer Isle, and di- rected them to march immediately to Eastport, and that they would pro])ably march the next day. I shall immediately write to Major Low, and direct him to conform to the above instructions in dis])osing of thft companies, until tiie President of the United States shall otherwise direct. I am, Sir, with respect, Your most obedient servant, CALEB STRONG. Boston, August 25, 181?, Major Nathan Low, Sir, By the time you receive this letter you A^ ill prob- ably have arrived at the post assigned you by General Hewall. The whole of the troops ordered to march to Eastport and Robbinstown, will also probably have I'ffachad the places of their destination, and 1 presume YOU will find tliom "well armed and equipped. Two t-ompanies will he stationed at Eastport, and one at Robbinstown; until the President of the United States sliall direct otherwise, unless in the mean time you, witli the advice of Bri2;adier General Brewer, shall think a different disposition of them more advanta- geous. The President of the United States liavino; been du- \y apprized of your being ordered to Eastport, you will probably soon receive orders from him for the regula- tion of your future conduct, while employed on the present command. But it will be j)roper for you to write to the Secretary at AVar, and inform him of vour situation, as soon after you arrive at Eastport as may be. I would recommeiul to you, strict attention to the comfort, convenience and discipline of the troops under your command. As the extent of frontier committed to vour care is great, the duty of the troops may be severe. But you will endeavour to adopt such modes of doing guard and other duty, as shall render it as light as pos- sible, consistently with the safety of the troops and of the posts. And when the men are not on other duty, you will see that they are disciplined from time to timej, so as to be qualified to act their part well as soldiers. On the cleanliness of the men in their quarters and in their persons, their health will in a great measure de. pend. I cannot therefore too earnestly recommend la you the most vigilant attention to it. From the intructions you may have already received from Major General Sewall a!»d from the General Or- der of August 5th, you Avill perceive that the object of your command, as it respects the British nation, is mere- ly defensive — this object you Avill strictly fiiUil. At the same time you Avill endeavour to secure the ])eace- able citizens of the frontier, you are ordered to defend, against the robberies and depredations of unprincipled individuals, whatever characters tliev Jiiav assume. Should any circumstances arise in the course of your « « »'nmmautl which you may deem ])roper for me to be ae 36 quainted with, you will make your commuuication to me througli tlie Adjutant General until tlie United States assume the control of your detachment, you will also make weekly returns of your Battalion to the Ad- jutaut GeneraFs Office in Boston. I am, Sir, with esteem, Your most obedient servant, G, STKOXG. \ >. 89 w .V T • O, • >> 5> ♦^^ 'K. V^' '^^im^^r.\ ^^M rS ^oV V'O^ ^oV^ >* • \0 '7', - i .0 ^ * 6 « < 'J^ o o • » ° h* * ,** *W* / -% --^ L» «> '♦ -O- ^' %', WERTBQQJ^INDING ^"^ /iaj^' *^rr i<. .^' o;^-- ^^^^ ^V5^>. %...' oC^EX'. ^ ':'■:■'') I M!t'iii!i'! I 1 i I'.j ;ii;l!>miHK>M!!fll!:!