Class. Book,. 'jjj ArZ c_ (kipyiigM - COMRIGHT DEPOSflC. THE OUTPUT OF PROFESSIONAL SCHOOLS FOR TEACHERS THE OUTPUT OF PROFESSIONAL SCHOOLS FOR TEACHERS BY CHARLES E. BENSON PROFESSOR OF EDUCATION, THE UNIVERSITY OF OKLAHOMA. BALTIMORE, MD. WARWICK & YORK, Inc. 1922 COPTBIGHT, 1922, By Warwick & York, Inc. ©CI.A6S6814 OCUO'22 TO THE MEMORY OF H. K. Wolfe ACKNOWLEDGMENTS I wish to acknowledge here my indebtedness to those who have helped to make possible this study. I am under obligation to the Presidents and their office staffs of the institutions from which data were secured. Without their assistance the study could not have been made. It would be impossible to record here the names of all who have contributed to this investigation, however, justice demands that I mention a few: Dr. M. R. Trabue and Dr. W. H. Kilpatrick have made valuable suggestions in the method and arrangement of the material. To Dr. W. C. Bagley, under whose direction the study has been made, I am under special obligation. His suggestive criticisms as the work progressed has been of incal- culable value, but even more than this, the opportunity of working with and receiving assistance from the master mind in this field of study is an obligation I am unable to meet. I would be unjust not to mention my wife, without whose encouragement and actual assistance in the monotonous statistical work of the study, this report would have been impossible. C. E. B. The names of the institutions are not given in the tables or figures. The key is on file in Teachers' College, Columbia University, New York City, N. Y., and the key letter repre- senting an institution will be sent, upon request, to the respons- ible head of the institution. VI CONTENTS PART I. PROBLEM AND METHOD Page Chapter I. The Problem Stated 1 1. The need of the study. (a) To answer the questions: 1. What kind of schools do graduates of professional schools enter? 2. What types of teaching positions are s«rved? 3. What relation is there between curricula completed and teaching positions served? 4. In what proportion do graduates enter supervised and un- supervised schools? 5. What is the period of service of the trained teacher? 6. What becomes of those who do not teach? Chapter II. Sources op the Study 3 1. Criteria of selection of professional schools to be studied, (a) Data available. (6) Typical schools. 2. Method of securing the data. (a) Questionnaire method impossible. (&) Personal visits to the schools. (c) Records. 1. Variability of records. 2. Assistance of the Presidents and their office staffs. 3. Alumni records useful. (d) Method of tabulation. „ (e) Statistical methods used. (/) Variability of records. 3. Criticisms of problem and method. PART II. RESULTS OF THE STUDY Chapter III. The Types of Schools Served 6 1. Rural. 2. Village. 3. City. 4. Private. 5. Parochial. 6. Normal School or College. The Proportions in Which Graduates Enter Supervised and Un- supervised schools 19 1. Supervised. 2. Unsupervised. vii viii Contents Page Chapter IV. The Specific Administrative, Supervisory, and Teach- ing Positions Filled by the Graduates 23 1. Administrative. 2. Supervisory. 3. Teaching. Chapter V. The Distribution op the Graduates According to the Curricula Completed 43 1. General. 2. Differentiated. (a) Growth of differentiated curricula during the period studied. (&) Growth of "Specific training for Specific work." Chapter VI. The Actual Length op Teaching Service 56 1. Graduates of 1910. (a) From the two-year curricula. (&) From the three-year curricula, (c) From the four-year curricula. 2. Graduates of 1915. (a) From the two-year curricula. (&) From the three-year curricula, (c) From the four-year curricula. Comparison of the Tenure of Trained Teachers with that of the General Teaching Population Chapter VII. What Becomes of the Remaining Graduates?. . . 70 PART III. INTERPRETATIONS AND CONCLUSIONS. SUGGESTIONS Chapter VIII. Interpretations and Conclusions 80 1. There is evidence of inequitable distribution of graduates to the different types of schools. 2. The increasing tendency is to enter the city schools. 3. There is no evidence of a demand for certain curricula at present offered. 4. The dominant demand is for teachers in the elementary grades. 5. There is a slight increase in the proportion of the two-year graduates going into high-school positions. 6. There is a noticeable tendency toward an increase of differentiated curricula. 7. An increasing proportion of the graduates going into the primary and intermediate grades are receiving specialized training. 8. During the period studied the relative distribution of the gradu- ates to supervised and unsupervised schools remains practically unchanged. 9. Graduates of professional schools for teachers have a much longer period of service than the general teaching population. 10. In each period studied a significant proportion of the graduates do not teach the first year. 11. Student accounting seems to be inadequate. 12. There is little evidence of cooperation of the schools with their alumni. Contents ix Page Chapter IX. Suggestions 86 1. Institutions for the professional preparation of teachers should inform themselves and their respective state departments definitely with regard to the distribution of their graduates. 2. Differentiated curricula should in the main be limited to the clear demands of the field. 3. Responsibility of the institution does not end with the graduation of the student. 4. Student accounting should be placed upon a business basis. 5. Records of graduates should include the following data: (a) Brief history of the graduate's training previous to entering the school. (b) The curricula completed. (c) Scholastic attainments as measured by grades or marks. (d) Judgments of instructors as to proficiency for particular teach- ing position. (e) The placement of the graduate upon completion of curricula as to: 1. Type of school entered. 2. Teaching position. 3. Other occupation. (/) Success of the graduate. (g) A continuous record of the graduate's work covering successive 2 positions held, subsequent study, degrees received, other occu- pations entered. (h) Method of securing this information. 6. Self survey of the institutions covering a period of years would offer helpful suggestions for the improvement of the service of the school to : (a) The institution. (&) The taxpayer. (c) The student. (d) The children. (e) The service. INDEX OF TABLES No. Page 1- 7 Types of schools entered 7-14 8 Number in one-room schools 17 9-12 Distribution to supervised and unsupervised schools 19-22 13-17 Distribution in administrative positions 27-31 18-19 Distribution in supervisory positions 32-33 20-26 Distribution in teaching positions 35-41 27-34 Curricula completed 46-50 35 Proportion receiving specific training for the work entered 52 36-38 The actual teaching service. Graduates of 1910 58-59 39-41 The actual teaching service. Graduates of 1915 60-64 42-44 The actual teaching service of male graduates 65-68 45-51 Distribution of those who do not teach. 72-78 No. Contents INDEX OF FIGURES Page 1- 2 Types of schools entered 15-16 3 Distribution into one-room rural schools 18 4 Distribution into supervised and unsupervised schools 21 5 Distribution of administrative positions filled 34 6 Distribution of supervisory positions filled 34 7 Distribution into specific teaching positions 42 8 Curricula completed 51 9-11 Specific preparation for specific work 53-55 12-14 Actual teaching service. Graduates of 1910 57 15-22 Actual teaching service. Graduates of 1915 61-63 23-28 Actual teaching service of male graduates 66-67 29 Proportion who do not teach 71 30 Distribution of those who do not teach 79 PART I. PROBLEM AND METHOD Chapter I THE NEED OF THE STUDY The following is a report of a study of the distribution of the graduates of a selected group of schools engaged in the professional preparation of public-school teachers. The output of the two, three, and four-year curricula for the years of 1910, 1915, and 1920 were studied to answer the following questions: 1. What kinds of schools do graduates enter the first year after graduation? 2. What types of teaching positions are served the first year after graduation? 3. What relation is there between curricula completed and teaching position served? 4. In what proportion, do graduates enter supervised and unsupervised schools? 5. What is the period of service of the trained teacher? 6. What becomes of those that do not teach? At the present time in many institutions there is no adequate information available to answer the above questions. Very few schools keep a record of where their students go immediately upon graduation and where they are located in later years. It is believed that definite information of this nature will enable the schools to do their work in a more business-like manner. Certain definite tendencies during the periods investigated are shown by the study. It shows clearly the inequitable distribution of the graduates into rural, village, and city schools. There is evidence that some of our public teacher-training institutions are becoming exclusively training schools for the cities and fail to serve other fields of public education. The study reveals the fact that teacher-training institutions do not offer specific training nor specific guidance. Most of the graduates go out with a preparation to be "general practitioners. " They are not specifically prepared for any particular field of service. 1 2 Output of Schools for Teachers It is time to take account of the output of each curriculum to see whether it warrants a separate curriculum or is to be regarded only as a byproduct. What is the output of each curriculum? Is there a place for the graduate? Is the demand of the district served sufficient to maintain or establish this or that special curriculum? The investigation indicates that a significant percent of those graduating from teacher-training institutions cannot be depended upon to enter the teaching field the first year after graduation. The question arises at once, where do they go? The periods of service of the graduates since their graduation show some rather encouraging results of training when well-prepared teachers are contrasted with the general teaching population. There are very few studies of an accurate character regarding the actual output of professional schools for teachers. It is obvi- ously important for an administrator of such a professional school to have complete information as to where the students are actually going immediately after graduation, their particular work, and the success they are achieving with the preparation they have for the specific work in which they are engaged. Information of this kind will enable the proper evaluation of the work of the institution. A knowledge of these facts will aid the administrators and those in charge of the placement of the students to serve the public more efficiently. Chapter II THE SOURCES OF THE STUDY A group of professional schools for teachers were selected from which to secure the data for the study. The criteria used in the selection were: 1. That there was in each school some assurance that the data were available. 2. That the institutions should in the aggregate be typical of teacher-training schools of the country as a whole. The data were secured from the following schools: State Normal School, Oshkosh, Wis. State Teachers College, Cedar Falls, la. State Normal School, Trenton, N. J. State Normal School, Farmville, Va. State Normal School, Bridgewater, Mass. State Normal School, Richmond, Ky. Rhode Island State College of Education, Providence, R. I. State Normal School, Charleston, 111. State Teachers College, Greeley, Colo. State Normal School, Plymouth, N. H. State Teachers College, St. Cloud, Minn. State Normal College, Dillon, Mont. State Normal School, Indiana, Penn. State Normal School, Kalamazoo, Mich. Maxwell Training School, Brooklyn, N. Y. Teachers College, University of Cincinnati, Cincinnati, Ohio. State Teachers College, Cape Girardeau, Mo. State Teachers College, Albany, N. Y. Harris Teachers College, St. Louis, Mo. State Teachers College, Kearney, Nebr. Teachers College, University of Nebraska, Lincoln, Nebr. State Normal School, Oswego, N. Y. Since the data from the schools above named were tabulated additional data have come in representing 930 graduates from the following institutions : 3 4 Output of Schools for Teachers State Normal School, Terre Haute, Ind. State Normal School, Willimantic, Conn. Miami University, Oxford, Ohio. State Teachers College, Ellensburg, Wash. The results from these institutions agree very closely with the results from the selected group studied. This gives data for approximately 10,000 graduates. This number should be sufficient to show a fair degree of accuracy of the trends in teacher-training. Method of Secueing the Data It was found that the questionnaire method would not bring the desired information, excepting in the case of the State Teachers College, Greeley, Colo., and the State Normal College, Dillon, Mont., and in the latter case only for the graduates of 1920. Per- sonal visits were made to the other schools during May, June, July, August, and September, 1921. The following data were secured for each graduate : 1. The kind of school entered the first year after graduation. 2. Whether it was a supervised or unsupervised school. 3. The specific administrative, supervisory, or teaching position entered the first year after graduation. 4. The curriculum completed by each graduate. 5. The period of service since graduation of the graduates of 1910 and 1915. 6. The occupation of the graduate who did not teach. The original records of the institutions were used. In most of the schools it was necessary to go to several sets of records to get the data. In some cases it was impossible to secure the information for a few of the graduates. The alumni records were in some places found useful. Method of Tabulation The data for each graduate from the two, three, four, and five- year curricula for the years studied were compiled on record sheets from which the totals of each institution were computed. The data were computed separately for the male graduates. Statistical Method Employed The tables for each year studied are given in percents. In computing the percentages for the types of schools entered, for those who did not teach, and for the curricula completed, the total Problem and Method 5 output for each year was used. In the other tables the percentages were computed from the number entering teaching the first year after graduation. Tables are given for each year studied. The figures are of the trend and bar-graph types showing the tendency of the particular data secured. The Variability op the Records The variability of the records was so great in the different institutions that the study would have been impossible but for the kindness and assistance of the presidents and their office staffs. An encouraging feature of the investigation was the interest taken by those who assisted, and the increasing attempts that are being made to collect the information for each graduate on a composite record sheet. Criticism of the Problem and Method Several criticisms can be made of the study. One is that the institutions studied do not cover a sufficiently wide geographical area, and another that the data should have been secured from a larger number of graduates. It is believed that additional data from a wider area would have but slightly modified the general results. Interesting geographical comparisons could have been made if data from a wider area had been collected. The data from a larger number of graduates would probable have changed the percents in a small degree, but the general tendency, it is believed, would not have been changed. These criticisms were foreseen. That they were not met was due (1) to the impossibility, because of the expense and time, of covering more territory. The distance traveled approximates fifteen thousand miles. (2) Because the data were not available. Several schools were visited where no records were kept that would give the information desired. The topic is so large and the labor of securing the data and working up the material was so severe that the criticisms could not be fully met. An enormous amount of time and labor were expended on the 8790 cases used. This study is a mere introduction to the field. Other studies are needed before final conclusions can be derived. PART II. RESULTS OF THE STUDY Chapter III THE TYPES OF SCHOOLS IN WHICH GRADUATES TEACH The investigation found that graduates enter as teachers, the first year after graduation, the following types of schools: Rural, Village, City, Private, Parochial, and Normal School or College. Table 1 indicates a great variation in the distribution of the graduates entering the different types of schools. It shows a rather constant tendency for the different years studied. There is a significant increase in the number graduating in 1915 over that in 1910. The output in 1920 although greater than 1910, does not equal that in 1915, and is less than the expected increase for the five- year period. This can be accounted for by the conditions caused by the war. Distribution of the Graduates RURAL SCHOOLS Two-year Curricula A rural school, as used in this study, is either a one, or two-room, or consolidated school in the open country. The total output of the institutions studied in 1910 was 1604. Of these 9.7 percent entered rural schools. In 1915 nine percent of the 2353 graduates entered this field of service, while in 1920 the proportion is decreased to six percent of the 2079 graduates. (Table 1) (Figure 2). These data are for all types of rural service. It was found that 5.2 percent of the graduates of 1920 entered one- room rural schools. A supplementary investigation was made in thirty-eight additional institutions in widely scattered sections of the country to ascertain the proportion of the graduates of 1920 going into one-room rural schools. The fifty-five schools from which data were secured had 5524 graduates. Of these 444, or 8 percent, entered one-room rural schools the first year after gradua- tion. (Table 8) (Figure 3). 6 Results of the Study W EC o o H o OQ « p O « H p I Q H H w £-> S o SO M E-i P « g H H « PU o * O 00 N ^ a> CO IN 00 "-I CO ■"!< b- CO H h t)(D«)S OMtOHOOHOO-JH rH rt rt CO i-l CM r-< CO 115 [■BUIJO^ «3 O 93aj[0Q JO •qOg |BUIJOJ<[ ItflqOO.TBJ ITS O ~. ^■BAUJ CO AJQ N t>«4nNIID M "3 lO lO CD CO Oi INh00(OO10)OTtllNCO • 33BIHA N«5NO>!O00(NNNtOC0CO 00 C3 • ■ OS COWO^fflNCOOlCOtOINCOHTllOO • • rt rt (N CM tM r-l . . sg^.'enp'Bjg jo laqnin^j ^CONt-COiO'JlCOCOtDiONINCOtO • • tDOlMCOHHCOHCOOCONlO^N 7-1 CNCNi-H H IN H IN N rt CM • • CO >o co CM o o SuiqoBaj, m ^t cot>-Tt( osTti tji m ti • • a> MOO»S«OtOOO«(DNNilJ ^ i-l rt COrt rt CM CM ■* • • 9S8 n°o Jo •qog psraao^j • • Ttl a> • • i(3 CD • 00 N • • N • • t> • -CO • • N CO • rt.. .. psiqooxBj co a^BATIJ CO aid 00 CO a 00 CO N to 1(3 d) • > 00 CO'*M10NM»01I1000N'J001 • • s io co n h ci Hcqeom^eocoiN • • 83B in A U5 H H 00 N t>- CO IQ r-t 03 • • oo" CM Ht»NO)iOSO'#iOOO' 03 lOCSNtOOONOtONN^ (N CN CO • • CM i-t rM IT3 CM rt . . ea^BnpBJQ jo loqum^j CONOlCCMOOONHO^lOiOOl^ • • rtlC3IOrtrtt-'O>OI--'*INrtlOCO00 • • tA CM rt r-, -^ ^ CM • • T(l O to a .2 a . CO • C i •*' OJ IN oj' OJ OJ pjiqooj'ej . . . . tO 1 9^'BAUj; • CO . . to l> ^10 to 00 CO b- OS to t- to US OJ CO 00 CM to o OS © US CO CO U3 93T3IHA CO CM il tO OJ ■* o « n h OJ CO CO to IH ■ OJ OJ OJ co IBITIH • • 00 • •* sa^Bnp'BjQ jo jgqranj^; CO 00 to 00 OJ CO to O CO US CO IN TfH OS ll US US us OS il SmqOBgj, i-H H OJ TX US CO O Tt< CO to CO IN H il us . us • 1^ 838HOO jo iBrajo^ •* tO • OJ • CO • US CO • © 00 i-l • tH • CM 00 • Aid M< OJ © © i* CO OJ to US © Os t~ CO © CO n CM i-l CO 00 IN 00 to aSBfliA US IN CO • iH tO to CO OJ CO n © © 1> • 00 to CO Tf CO Tt< • US i-i 00 I'Bjn'a; to ■ IN ■ iH . sa^npejo jo jaqmn^i CO US t~ i-l t» i-l to iH IH to tO 00 00 US 00 co co o os Suiqoraaj, iH . i-H 00 00 b- • to 00 OJ 00 ■ 00 OS CO ■* • H . H W CO • aS3 n°o JO (BUIJO^ • • iH T* . t~ . OS OJ . • OS IH . Tj( . *HO US • N il N (D co © us US • CO IN to tO • IH • © CO OS "* • 93BHIA •* 1-1 . . © to O OS US • ** ■ CO O OJ • il • IBiny . . . t* . © sa^BnpBJQ jo jaqum^j i-l r-t o«Wr i 1 "c Results of the Study 11 o o w o GO P o t-H O « ■ & o H * SniqoBaj, 833 n oo jo jbuijo^ OS • • IBtq0OJ'B < J *VO IN • • aS^jnA CO • • CM . . sa^npijjQ jo jaqmn^ CM ; : amqoBax CO . . CD '. '. CO • ■ 339H0Q jo jeuijojij CM . . P4 pq "5 o 12 Output of Schools for Teachers a o o X u m o H m < < a P u a M P u « Q H S 1 »o H i-l o CD • CO 00 • • —i CO >0 t- CO • i-i >h • • CO •* S9^Enp'Bjr) jo jaquin^j HMOSOOOOOiOHS i-i cn i-i io >o ih in lO IN O OS SmqO'eax CD tO CD OS CO -00 • O • lO H ^1 115 115 ■ • IN • IN lO CO JO p3UU0j\J CD • • ■* • o JBiqOOJB,-! 00 *ho . . . to U5 oo 115 • -00 • O ") O h 8 h . ■ • (N IN IN CO OOCM jBjn^j CO • • • CN • l> OS CO • O CO • • "O -00 • sa^enp'BJQ jo jsqtunjvi 05 .allOOfOOlH-jl - >> O .2 o » u 03 -_. CO o £ h C3 o 3 -O 73 a g 1° M 03 > >> O M o C R T U 1 11 54.6 27.3 100. 18.1 1 1 100. 100. 2 6 2 3 66.6 33.3 100. 33.3 50. 33.3 50. 33.3 Total 12 50. 25. 25. 2 100. 13 38.5 46.2 15.3 14 Output of Schools for Teachers < p Q s S3 P o P3 00 H OS r(l CO IO Smqonax ^°N CO 00 CO 10 CO CO • CO CO CO 00 CO CD • CO tH CO CN i-l i-H . d CO CN P n na JOJ poqog 8331100 10 IBUIJOJsI 33.3 16.6 CO* AIO • IN CO lO ■* N • • CO CO 00 CO i-l • CO CN 00 t)I • 00 CN aS^tiTA 66.6 43.8 42.9 25. TjH CO sa^BnpBio jo laquin^; CO CO CO t^ CO CN • o © OS grnqo'eax *0£j 100. 14.2 50. 66.6 OS CO jraiqoojBjj • •* 00 T)l A!0 71.6 16.6 100. 33.3 os CN Ttl 83B[nA . . CO • - • . . O CO • • . • • O i-i • • • CO OS IBing . . . co . • . . . . co • • . 00 Tfi sa'j'enpBio jo laqranj^ N t» i-l CO CN CO • CN cct o a O tf O fc Ph > £ "3 -»a O H Results of the Study 15 Figure 1. THE PROPORTION OP GRADUATES ENTERING DIFFERENT TYPES OF SCHOOLS FROM VARIOUS CURRICULA. 1910 - 1915 - 1920. Two-year Curricula." Three-year Curricula. 55J6 50 40 30 20 10 1910 1915 1920 55# 50 40 30 20 10 1910 / / V / >s / - ^ 1915 1920 Four-year Curricula 55^ 50 40 30 20 10 „- ■^ *^ y s / 1 = Male Graduates Two-year Curricula 1910 1915 1920 55# 50 40 30 20 10 1910 \ V v. l^^^^"- \ 1915 1920 Rural- Village City Private Normal School or College 1- Negligible percent for other types of schools. \ "16 [Output of Schools for Teachers Figure 2. THE DISTRIBUTION OP GRADUATES PROM THE TWO-YEAR CURRICULA OP SPECIFIC INSTITUTIONS AS TO DIFFERENT TYPES OF FIRST SERVICE. Institutions Rural Village City Percent O 10 100 £ 1910f W 1915P 1920b 1910 1915 1920 1910 U 1915 1920 Results of the Study 17 Table 8. — The Graduates from the Two-year Curricula for 1920 Who Entered One-room Rural Schools Institutions Number of Graduates Number Entering One-room Rural Schools Percent I 28 16 67. Q 27 14 61.9 s 76 32 42.1 z 39 16 41. AA 54 20 37. BB 41 15 36.5 M 31 11 35.6 CC 90 29 32.2 DD 66 18 27.2 EE 65 17 26.1 FF 146 37 25.3 GG 24 6 25. C 117 27 23. HH 72 12 16.6 II 64 10 15.6 JJ 43 6 14. O 96 12 12.5 KK 48 5 10.4 LL 270 21 7.7 B 260 20 7.7 J 121 9 7.4 MM 91 6 6.6 NN 112 7 6.2 G 144 9 6.2 K 122 6 5. OO 276 13 4.7 F 53 2 4. PP 256 10 4. QQ 52 2 4. RR 113 4 3.5 Y 66 2 3.4 SS 125 4 3.2 TT 154 5 3.2 UU 32 1 3.1 VV 70 2 2.8 WW 152 4 2.6 XX 76 2 2.6 YY 40 2.5 U 93 1.8 zz 57 1.7 A 72 1.4 X 80 1.2 D 83 1.2 R 263 3 1.1 W 324 3 .9 E 33 T 121 AAA 125 BBB 49 CCC 19 DDD 5 EEE 193 FFF 17 GGG 144 HHH 134 Total 5524 444 8. 18 Output of Schools for Teachers Figure 3. THE PROPORTION OP THE GRADUATES OP 1920 PROM THE TWO-YEAR CURRICULA TOO ENTERED ONE -ROOM RURAL SCHOOLS THE FIRST YEAR AFTER GRADUATION. Institution^ 5 10 20 30 40 60 6 ° I Q 8 Z AA BB M CC DD EE FF GG C H JJ KK LL B J asu. NN G K 00 F PP u a a, a GO u o D.T3 ft 3 CO I* H a 11 T3 V ft m u o D. t3 S 5 tn in P k A 109 94.5 5.5 163 97. 3. 71 93. 7. C 47 95.9 4.1 92 95.7 4.3 108 73.2 26.8 E 54 42.7 57.3 36 16.6 83.4 32 18.7 81.3 G 211 83.4 16.6 257 66. 24. 120 81.7 18.3 J 97 21.7 78.3 212 51. 49. 115 62.6 37.4 K 76 27.7 72.3 115 37.4 62.6 113 47.7 52.3 M 45 11. 89. 31 45.2 54.8 31 13. 87. o 51 25.5 74.5 114 36.8 63.2 89 38.2 61.8 R 119 42. 58. 224 29. 71. 214 43.9 56.1 T 36 33.3 66.6 104 35.5 64.5 105 43.8 56.2 U 119 52.1 47.9 216 42.1 57.9 92 46.8 53.2 W 96 58.4 41.6 200 65. 35. 195 72.1 27.9 Y 40 47.5 52.5 44 57. 43. 55 61.9 38.1 X 50 42. 58. 118 31.3 68.7 63 47.5 52.5 B 151 56.3 43.7 163 53.1 46.9 238 65.6 34.4 D 79 83.6 16.4 F 47 85.2 14.8 Total 1300 54.8 45.2 2089 52.2 47.8 1767 60.2 39.8 20 Output of Schools for Teachers UNSUPERVISED An unsupervised school is defined as one that is visited or inspected only occasionally. Most rural and village schools come under this classification. There is a small decrease in the number entering unsupervised schools of the graduates from the two-year and three-year curricula. The increase of the number going into unsupervised schools from the four-year curricula is due to the large number going into princi- palships of village and consolidated schools. Table 10. — The Distribution (in Percents) of the Graduates from the Two-year Curricula as to Supervised and Unsupervised Schools Entered the First Year after Graduation 1910 1915 1920 Institutions M * .9 S g TS a '> u to a 3 3 a> a -g M K.S a J3 -9 » a o3 9 Q> a 3 W CD a >a m * § •§ M n .9 -9 ° 8 03 9 oj T3 (O ID '> u a 3 w u a D.T3 3 0) 03 03 o -g C R o T B E G U 16 32 93 43 8 8 6 56 2 2 34 4 4 4 47 88.3 100. 25. 49. 11.7 75. 100. 51. 49 13 2 20 6 7 13 92. 54. 50. 50. 86. 77. 8. 46. 50. 50. 100. 14. 23. Total 48 65. 35. 93 62.4 37.6 110 75.4 24.6 Results of the Study 21 Figure 4. THE PROPORTION OF THE GRADUATES FROM VARIOUS CURRICULA GOING INTO SUPERVISED AND UNSUPERVISED SCHOOLS. Two-year Curricula. 1910 1915 1920 Three-year Curricula, 1910 1915 1920 Four-year Curricula. 1910 1915 S = Supervised U - Unsupervised 1920 22 Output of Schools for Teachers Table 11. — The Distribution (in Percents) op the Graduates from the Four-year Curricula as to Supervised and Unsupervised Schools Entered the First Year after Graduation 1910 1915 1920 Institutions to M.9 CD rj X o a os 2 "> *3 '> M O a CO u a P. T3 a •§ 60 H.S s « CO hi 01 3 M a cs 5 ® at m f u a> Pi 3 CO H a> 3 v p > C 9 100. 10 100. O 1 100 4 50. 50. 27 70.3 29.7 R 18 89 11 31 41.9 58.1 57 47.3 52.7 N 41 56 44 53 45.2 54.8 80 55. 45. P 25 100 56 100. 35 97.2 2.8 V 28 78 6 21 4 70 31.4 68.6 135 31.1 68.9 G 6 83.4 16.6 B 49 89.8 10.2 143 95.8 4.2 K 2 100. W 8 75. 25. Total 122 77 8 22 2 279 63.1 36.9 487 63.9 36.1 Table 12. — The Distribution (in Percents) of the Graduates from the FrvE-YEAR Curricula as to Supervised and Unsupervised Schools Entered the First Year after Graduation 1910 1915 1920 T3 T3 ■a Institutions u .3 GQ M.S n .9 M ■s C9 2"« 11 J3 s o> CB rt P BT3 a « CO 3 to a =3 g a, 3 cu a cs g <3 a 3 CO a 3 CO a "g 3 CO g-P V 3 100. 20 75. 25. P 25 95. 5. B 19 100. Total 44 97.5 2.5 Chapter IV THE SPECIFIC ADMINISTRATIVE, SUPERVISORY, AND TEACHING POSITIONS FILLED BY THE GRADUATES Administrative Two-year Curricula The number of graduates entering administrative positions the first year after graduation is very small. In 1910, of those teaching, 5.9 percent went into this type of service. These came from nine of the twenty-two schools studied. In 1915 the proportion decreased to 4.8 percent. These were from eleven schools. There is an increase in the number of schools sending their students into this kind of work for 1920, but the proportion drops to 2.9 percent. The majority of those entering this work become principals of village schools. Of the total number of graduates for the three years studied one percent became ward principals. (Table 13.) Three-year and Four-year Curricula Tables 14 and 15 show clearly that the graduates of these cur- ricula do not enter, to any extent, administrative positions. Of those who do the majority become high school principals. There is a slight increase for the three years studied in the number entering this work from the four-year curricula, 11.7 percent in 1920 as compared with 7.3 percent in 1910. MALE GRADUATES Two-year Curricula In 1910 nearly one half (49.1 percent) of the male graduates entered administrative work. In 1915 this percent dropped to 39.6. There is a further decrease to 28.4 percent in 1920. The village principalships for 1910 and 1915 received over 30 percent. In 1920 only 13.6 percent go into this particular type of administra- tive work. There is a small increase in the number going into superintendencies in 1920 as compared with the other two years studied. (Table 16.) 23 24 Output of Schools for Teachers Four-year Curricula Of the male graduates in 1910 from these curricula 38.5 percent entered administrative work: in 1915 the proportion increased to 51.6 percent: in 1920 it decreased to 35.1 percent. The majority go into superintendencies. (Table 17.) SUPERVISORY The number of graduates going directly into administrative work is small but the number entering supervisory work is still smaller. In 1910 less than one fourth of one percent of those completing the two-year curricula went into this type of service. This increased to one percent in 1915, and to three percent in 1920. Two thirds of these became supervisors of music. (Table 18.) The few from the four-year curricula going into this work became in most cases supervisors in the kindergarten or elementary grades. One graduate of the 8790 became a supervisor of penmanship. (Table 19.) Teaching Positions KINDERGARTEN Two-year Curricula The number going directly into kindergarten positions approxi- mates for each of the three years studied two percent of those teaching. The number of schools sending kindergarten teachers into active work was smaller in 1920 than in either 1910 or 1915. The institutions sending out teachers for this type of service are located either in or in close proximity to large cities. PRIMARY AND INTERMEDIATE "Primary" grades were defined as grades one and two: "Intermediate" as grades three, four, five, and six. Of the two- year graduates who teach approximately 68 percent in 1910 entered these two fields of service. The same proportion holds for 1915: and in 1920 it had dropped to 62 percent. Nearly 31 percent entered the primary grades each year and the decrease in 1920 is a decrease in the number going into intermediate grade work. (Tables 20, 21, 22.) Results of the Study 25 GRAMMAR The grammar grades were defined as seventh and eighth. It is apparent that normally about six percent of the graduates who teach have their first experience in these grades. This is the proportion for 1910 and 1920: in 1915 there was a slight increase. This may perhaps be compensated by the slight increase among those entering junior high schools in 1920. (Table 22.) JUNIOR HIGH SCHOOL In 1910 one institution sent graduates out to do junior high school work: in 1915 this number was increased to three: in 1920 there were eight schools some of whose graduates entered the junior high school service. The proportion is very small reaching only 2.1 percent in 1920. (Table 22.) HIGH SCHOOL The high schools are receiving as many of the two-year graduates as are the grammar grades : when those entering the special fields of manual training and household arts are included the total number going into secondary service are however, twice the number entering the upper grades of the elementary school. In 1920 nearly 13 percent engaged in some type of high school work. This is a marked increase over 1910 when the proportion was only 6.3 percent. (Tables 20, 21, 22.) A few of the two-year graduates enter the special fields of manual training, household arts, agriculture, etc. RURAL— ALL GRADES The teacher who teaches in a one-room rural school has been classified as teaching all grades. There were 7.8 percent in 1910 entering this type of service. In 1915 the proportion was only 6.5 percent and in 1920 it had decreased to 4.5 percent. (Tables 20, 21, 22.) Three-year Curricula In 1910 of the graduates teaching 39.7 percent went into work below the high school. This proportion was increased to 56.2 percent in 1915, but fell in 1920 to 40.2 percent. For the three years studied about 33 percent went into high school work. The primary and intermediate grades received nearly as large a proportion. (Table 23.) 26 Output of Schools for Teachers Four-year Curricula More than 70 percent of the four-year graduates in 1920 entered some type of high-school work. This proportion is a little higher than in 1910 and considerably higher than in 1915. There was a marked decrease in the number entering the elementary-grade work from 1910 to 1920. (Table 24.) MALE GRADUATES Two-year Curricula Two of the male graduates from the two-year curricula went into work below the grammar grades. In 1910, of those teaching, 21.8 percent enter high-school work. In 1920 this proportion increased to 63.2 percent. Those going into the special field of manual training has increased from 9 percent in 1910 to 44.7 percent in 1920. There had been a decrease of those entering rural work (one-room) from 21.6 percent in 1910 to 3 percent in 1920. (Table 25.) Four-year Curricula It is significant that the graduates of the four-year curricula enter only the academic high-school work or the work of the gram- mar grades. In 1910 the grammar grades received 10.6 percent but in 1920 only 3.2 percent of these graduates. In 1910 the high schools received 26.4 percent and in 1920 34.4 percent. (Table 26.) Results of the Study 27 < a o o 2 « p O « H & O E-| o jodioutjjj H Ifl H »0 • CN jBdionu^ cn oo oo » >a • M lO O .-h CM TH ' «' ij! . ei « H H CN CN CO ^napna^nt -jadng . . . i-H lO ■ • H Ol (O • . . . tH . • *lOIN«lOMOOOSN NOMNHHWOOHOOlOllOOMN'* rH iH iH IH CN . • • • CO o psdiouuj ^napua^ni -jadng Sutqo'eax jaqum^j .2 "3 a 0«OEHfflHO& "3 o Results of the Study 29 to bn O W ? I W 2 o H o IN IBdiauuj; t^ CN JBdlOUUJ looqag q3 !H cn m ■-1 CO 00 CO judtouuj IN t-- CO ^uopua^ni -jadng "13 t« CO CO CI 00 CN SuiqOEOj, jaquin^ S N O IS C5 ^uapua^m -jadng . . •* 00 • • • G> CO CO • o • co Sni^DBaj, jaqran^ O "* ^ M (O O « .-H CO >Q >D N 05 • OS IN o psdiouuj pjBjVi 00 p3diouu,j looqog q3; H CO CO pjdiouiij 00 ^napna^ni -aadng CN • • iH IN Suiqoeaj, aaqain^i OH 00 H 11) 00 • ■ • • H ■* IN N • • • • IN IN Institutions OOHH'&PH>OfflM£ 1 c 30 Output of Schools for Teachers o H m < < ►h P U « « P u « |Z| &H o o H p H Q «! H « W Eh o s Pi e In < M3 ■« P £h m W o w CO • •» • lO 00 to' • - b. CO • • © -IN • • CO • • -i-H Saiqotfax jaqran^j COCOCOCO'Tjt'-IOJlCiOO CO © OS ^uapua^ui -jadng jtyanoQ IN • • m p3dtOUIJ(J pjB^ m |BdioniJ,j looqog q3jH • • © • • ■* in -co 00 IN • -CO ■ • •* IN ■ K> jBdionuj t~ «5 IN ifl napna^ni -jadng it^unoQ lO • • . m • ■ • _; pjdjonuj • CO • • • «© . . rH © . TJH . . .CO . • tH pdionuj looqog qSjH • co • • • t*- • • m © U5 ■ t* . . .115 • ■ •<* . . . . . T« psdionuj TH CO CO IN CO icioeoomcoooiN }aapua:jin. -jadng 12.5 28.6 © SnrqoBax jaqran^; ^MiooO'jia'Oioo CSJ i-l rH rH IN © EQ a o m a r,SO«EHpl^^X -t- C Results of the Study 31 X a < o H m < < >-) P o « « P U s S3 w o h P p P <■> M fa H o H « w H H o In M < in « Cfi * P H O tn 3 « O fa M w m H H § H Eh S3 Ik O w IT) £ (3 O S3 P y t-H Ci) DO « w Ph CM w S3 »» •«! S3 o B H P 3 H 03 HH Q H a H 1 i i-i H hI o CN 0) iH jaoqjo CN c< ludiouuj looqog qa;H lO CN CN CO* pjdiouuj; US CD • CN 00 )nopuo}Ui -jadng 45.4 16.6 16.6 25. oo' auiqoraaj, laqumfj rt N CO H lO * o> US OS trB8Q . . . . © . OS £ ~a t 32 Output of Schools for Teachers o GO Ch P DC t> O « o « i O H a 03 £ h t> Eh o ^ © OS SniABjQ 00 t* »H O (N in ci r-I ~ o;snj\[ -# 00 ■* iH CO CO ■ N i(5 ■* to iH ■ csi SapBJQ if-rB^aauiajg; . 00 ■ ■ ■ o o ua^jeS -jgpuijj • • • 00 • o ^mqoraaj, jaqmn^j HltlNOiOMHOlrtliOniOOMIlOfliN t»O»«rtH»00HO0)01'0OC)N^ rtrtiHrt (NrHrH (M o 1> 05 3UIAH3JQ (N o rt oisnj\[ _; -japmjj o o Suiqacaj, jaquin^ eO Smpea'ji i-H © -< • ■ StIIAi'BJQ 00 © OIStlJ\[ © sap^aQ ^JB^uaxnaja CD © na^iB3 -japing OH»H01'*"0") • • i-H IN IH rH . rt • • © O co CO c _o "■+3 h3 a «> >> >> 0. Institutions fe J C8 (,.1 M 3 m M 60 S3 w a SI a a CD a _a CI 0> L S G CB 2 2 O o XI o a -d X o

J3 X> o a a) a JS Z 05 Ml s •a a 9 >> S a OS I 00 u 03 a a 09 O XI >-9 O o A > o > GO i * ! 13 M _ a 2 "3 .2 m "3 a a? — to "*< 55 — -a oS os h [1910 A 109 10.1 43.2 44.1 1. 1.6 C 47 25.6 42.6 19.2 2.1 10.5 E 53 32. 26.5 7.5 30. Gt 211 2 8 43.1 41.2 2.4 .5 1.5 .5 7.5 J@ 97 22.7 K 76 1 3 36.6 34.1 13.3 1.3 13.3 M 45 2.3 8.9 15.6 55.6 51 7.9 11.8 21.6 9.9 2. .2 27.5 R 119 9 3 39.5 16.8 3.4 7.6 .8 4. .8 4. T 36 27.8 27.8 25. 5.4 2.7 .... 8. 1 U 119 8 11.8 49.6 10.1 12.6 2.4 .8 W 96 13 6 16.7 16.7 11.5 10.5 5.3 12.5 1.1 Y 40 12.5 45. 12.5 17.5 X 50 26. 36. 8. . 10. 4. B 151 1 9 13.3 32.5 12.6 1. 9 11.9 6. 2.7 9.3 H# 461 4 49.7 49.9 L 100 36. 54. 9. 1. Total 1861 2.6 31.7 36.5 5.9 17 3.9 1.2 1.2 .17 .05 7.8 #An approximately equal number go into the primary and intermediate grades, statistical purposes the number was divided equally. £ Teaching position unknown for 1. @ Teaohing positions unknown for 75. For 36 Output of Schools for Teachers H H o < P O 5 « p o K < H |H I o o P q « SO § i g « as < s « s ° P3 ,-. H u to J CO < Eh S9pBJ3 Jiy piny S3SSBIQ {■Bioadg nonBonpa pjiaiannnOQ sjiy pioqasnojj SuiaiBax p3nuuj\[ t ooqog q3t H poqog qStjj jomnf 8-£ J«nnn«JQ a^.'Btparaja^ui jSiramuj; uaiieSiapuig; SntqOBaj, jaqumjsj r-l rt r-l (N N i-l 00 CO O ■ 00 "5 ri ri J) N N • d H« N M t(I lO •* 115 MMMHNNlOHOlffl U5 00 00 N U5 MN *H(0 00 >0 CO CM CO »N(BNN«JHTjlTtl^tDO'Jl00niOO Hi t- -CO -H • • • • • CM CM CO i-l CO • •* tH CM w w O H g-£ JBUini'BJQ —i ■* CO COCOitft^t-.TtllOOOiH CO00CO 00 C5 Nt»H CO HCtlOCSHHOOlNHMONH (> i-l i-H iH iH CM 9-5-^-8 ajBipauiJa^ui CO i-H CM CMCM ■* CO lOiOlOCO if (O M Tt< 00 CO O l> 00 tO CO OfflHOffli»0000t0rt00i0 TjfCOiHiHCMCMlOCOi-iCOiH CM • • t- . • • •■>* ■ . • • m n • • id » cm' w CO w O o P S « H CO t-H Q w W H 1 a Suiqauax jaqranj^; H 00 IN t- O M OlOMHCS^iONiOiOMOOOSSM C a a o O a _o .2 § 01 3 a a fa hi 5° 1910 C R 16 32 34.7 6.3 25. 6.3 18.8 6.3 34.4 6.3 12.5 18.8 Total 1915 C R O T B 48 34 4 4 4 47 4.3 16.7 53. 12.6 12.5 11.8 34.1 10.5 17.7 23. 3. 75. 21.3 4.2 6.3 25. 100. 4.3 8.4 100. 2.1 6.3 11.8 2.1 Total 1920 C o T B E G U 93 49 13 2 20 6 7 13 2.3 4.1 25.9 18.4 5. 14.3 21.6 36.8 6.5 24.5 7.7 8.2 15.4 15 38 69 1 5 3 3.3 7.7 10. 7.6 7.7 50. 66.6 28.6 7.7 33.3 57.2 5.4 5.4 6.2 Total 110 1.9 10. 16.4 11.9 5.5 12.8 2.8 7.3 6.4 2.8 Results of the Study 39 o l-t m o < w H p o S o E 2 §8 P Q Eh « H « < ■ 3 b H I a Ph fcj o H g W « O Eh Is 5 g Ph Eh IIV l«-mH CN OS CO lO CO tH b- CO - ajn^nouSy oo as • CO CO to noi^Bonpa to ■ OS CO • i-H CO • CN t» -00 -iHtOTfl •rH -OOr-lTH IN [BtOJararaoQ tH tO • H lO • OS t-l r-i • d •* 2.2 '3.'6 2.6 i!6 2.8 00 pioqasnou lO CO •*' CN d OSlOOOiHXOO >o OS TUCNOOOO •* •>. rH to iH CO 47.1 44.5 35.8 65. 90.6 42. 100. 12.5 CN 115 looqog qSijj joiunf . . . .00 • -TH . . . ,,h • .CN |> .to • • -OS • • • CO •••■*• ■ 00 8-Z co torn CN W l~- CN • CN i-i ■ 8.1 40. 25. 3.3 io.'s 6. 33.3 6.3 "5 • 00 OS t> Tj< ■* . . b- • i-l CO CN CN iH . • CN 9-S-f~S a^Bipani -ja^uj TH CD • CO i-i d -dco i-H -CN co • -io -com oo CO • -CD -C0-. • • • CO -i-Hi-lCN •■* . . uo;jb3 -japuig .U5 . . os ■ ■ ■ oo • • • • ■ -CNO • - • IO . .COM -t- • • CN • -tHIO . . . CO autqo'eaj, iaqran^j OS i-l 00 »H tC 00 T-C^CNCN CXI O T(4 i-H IN CO O CO OS CN i-i COiOiOb- M< 00 b- CD o oo >n CO IN 00 r» CN "3 00 CO CO •* CN rtH OS 00 Institutions O ■*- c &H Sootffco^om -3 ■*- c gO«^PM>MWlS "3 c Eh 40 Output of Schools for Teachers O Ph « H fa ° H S 2 o 1— I £> s « o CM SapBJQ nv F-ma 33.3 7.7 20. co aiiHinoiiSy ,_; psioiatnniOQ 4.8 12.5 CO • b- CD 00 00 "O ■ MO HI O NO N O N 00 ■* ■* H poqos qSjH 33.3 15.4 23.9 20. 62.5 m oo 8-2, J'BraUI'BJQ ^ 3uit[0B9X .raquin^i COMM^i-lNlOOO 7-1 CM -* CO O m 05 . . . ■* CO ■* o o o • • • ■* o o pspiauiuiOQ 00 uoi^eonpg CO jooqog q3ijj JOiunf CN © • sassBiQ pspadg CN Sniureix • • m CO N • CO in CN • ■ 00 M» N ") • "5 co co co "^ looqog q3t H • CO CN ■ -i tH OS o sapBJQ nv U5 t> ■ • • ■ CO CN m co co • • • ■ o • psioadg - SnraiBJX p3nni3}\[ . . .in co co ■ • OS . • • CN w o CO • • . . . h et h n • ■ looqog q3;H . .h -in • m ■* -co oo CN • CO -CM • CO CO 'ON ■ rt • iH • CN rH ■ CN g-2 ivwiweiQ . !> . . . t> . • m • 00 • • O -CO • • . m . • • 9-S-^-S g^eipauiia^ni CO • CN m • o • CN SuiqOBax jgqtnn^j ■*coiooo"*C5>oioa> 5 H w » m a ?! u n « KH a H Pn m fc O a o H P a a H 0? HI Q a W H o en uoi'j'Bonpg CO ui CO 8jn^inou3y CO co aniniBJX 6.7 5.9 12.5 10.6 50. s poxps qS!H 26.8 35.4 12.5 58. CO 8-Z 6.7 100. CM CO Suiqo^3X jaqran^ m n oo h a ■* CO 05 looqos q3tH CO • CO t> TH t- • CO • 00 CO 00 CO • N h IOH • CO us 8-Z xexavamiQ 66.6 50. Sniqoisaj, jaqum^j CO ■ N CD N (O • O I'Bin'jj • -t- • • • • . . CO • • • • CO jBioiararaOQ CO in poips qSi H 28.6 100. 16.7 33.3 co" CM 8-Z iBrarasij) . . . © . . . co d Smqo'Bax jaqran^j; I- iH CO o £ 1 c t- 42 Output of Schools for Teachers Figure 7* THE PROPOR TION OP GRADUATES PROM VARIOUS CURRICULA GOING INTO DIFFERENT TYPES CF TEACHING POSITIONS. Kindergarten Primary 1910-2. 6p 1910-31.7 1915-2, P 1915-32.3 1920-2. lk 1920-30.3 Two-year Curricula. Intermediate 1910-36.! 1915-35.7P 1920-31. 8* Grammar 1910-5.9| 1915-8. 1920-5. Junior H.S. 1910- 1915- 1920- Manual Training Household Arts Rural 1910-1. 2* 1910-1. 2p 1910-7.8* 1915-2. P 1915-2. P 1915-6. 5F 1920-3. !*■ 1920-1. 8P 1920-4. 5* or h.b. Kign Bcnooi Manual Training Household - .17) 1910-3. 9p» 1910-1. 2* 1910-1. 2p - .26 1910-4. «■ 1915-2. P 1915-2. P -2.1 P 1920-5. 5U 1920-3. lU 1920-1. 8P Three-year Curricula. Kindergarten Primary Intermediate Grammar 1910- | 1910-16. 7(« ■■■ 1910-12. 5P*b 1910-10.51 1915-2. 3k 1915-25. 9U I' 1915-21. 6ph 1915- 6.5 1920-1. 9k 1920 10. U ■ 1920-16, 4Ua*» 1920-11.91 E High School 1910-23. 1915-15. 1920-12. Manual Train, Household Arts 1910-4. 2ha 1910- I 1915-3.3P» 1915-7. 6P- 1915-2.8W 1915-7. 2>Um Rural 1910-6.3p 1915- 1920- )-6.3p» J-5.4U 1-2. 8U Kindergarten Primary 1910- ,9f 1910-15. 1915- 2.5k 1915 1920- 1.6» 1920 ergarten Primary Intermediate Grammar Junior H, - ,9» 1910-15. 6pm 1910- 6.6s- 1910-8.1^ 1910- , - 2.5k 1915- 6.4N 1915- 10.4N— 1915-7, 6p» 1915- .7^ - 1.6* 1920- 4.7b 1920- 6,lk* 1920-2. k 1920-1.81 Junior H.S. 1910- 1915- 1920- High School 1910-65, Swm 1915-47. lLa 1920-55.2Ui Manual Train, Household Arte Phy,Educati>on 1910- I 1910- I 1910- *9f 1915- .7 1915-9. km 1920- .7 1920-2.2k 1915-7.lU» 1920.-2. k Grammar 1910-5. 1915 1920 :!:f Male Graduates Two-year Curricula. High School Manual Training 1910-12. 8mm 1910-9. 1915-15,1P^ 1915-25,71 1920-18. 5La» 1920-44,71 Sural 1910-21,6 1916-11.4 1920- 3. Grammar 1910-10. 6vm 1915-14. 9k» 1920- 3.2ki Pour-year Curricula, High School 1910-26.41 1915-25.61 1920-34. 4i Chapter V THE DISTRIBUTION OF THE GRADUATES ACCORDING TO THE CURRICULA COMPLETED General Two-year Curricula The investigation shows that in 1910 general or undifferentiated curricula were completed by 86.4 percent of the graduates. This proportion decreased to 72.3 percent in 1915 and to 56.5 percent in 1920. (Tables 27, 28, 29.) Three-year Curricula The graduates of the three-year curricula whose work was undifferentiated constituted 88.2 percent in 1910, 37.5 percent in 1915, and 22.2 percent in 1920. (Table 30.) Four-year Curricula The tendency toward differentiation is not so marked among the four-year graduates. The number finishing undifferentiated cur- ricula was 86.6 percent of the total teaching in 1910. In 1915 there was a decrease to 66.6 percent and in 1920 an increase to 80.4 percent. (Table 31.) MALE GRADUATES There was a decrease from 89 percent in 1910 to 47.6 percent in 1920 among the male graduates completing general curricula. This refers to the two-year graduates. Among the four-year graduates there is very little differentiation. Practically all take the "general course." (Figure 8.) Differentiated Curricula The growth in the number of different curricula offered has been both striking and significant during the ten year period. This holds true also for the number of graduates from these differentiated curricula. In 1910 only 13.6 percent completed one or another of the specific programs of study. In ;1915 this proportion had increased to 27.7 percent, and in 1920 to 44.4 percent. The three-year and four-year curricula are more frequently "general" in their character than the two-year curricula. The 43 44 Output of Schools for Teachers male graduates received specific training in six different curricula besides the "general course." The majority prepared for work in the field of manual training. The Growth of "Specific Training for Specific Work" Two-year Curricula Table 35 and Figure 9 give facts concerning the growth of specific training for specific work. A perfect correlation between training and teaching position would be represented by a rating of 100 percent for each. It is evident that the tendency is moving in this direction. The primary and the high-school teachers have made the most rapid advances. Teachers of special subjects have been receiving the most specific training. In 1920 of those teaching in the intermediate grades 10 percent had special preparation for their work as against 5 percent in 1915 and 1.7 percent in 1910. In the grammer grades 16.9 percent were specially prepared for their positions and in the rural field 1.8 percent. Less than one half of the teachers in the primary and intermediate grades had special preparation for the work they entered. The following distribution of 52 graduates in 1915 of one in- stitution with their special preparation indicates a rather common practice : Three graduates from the commercial curricula, three from the physical education, nine from household arts, three from manual training, and one from drawing, taught the first year after gradua- tion in the primary grades. Two graduates from the physical education curricula, seventeen from household arts, three from drawing, nine from manual training, and one from music taught in the intermediate grades. One graduate from the physical education taught in the kindergarten. One from the manual training taught in the grammer grades. These 52 graduates taught in fields for which they were not prepared as against eight graduates of special curricula who went into fields for which they were prepared. Three-year and Four-year Curricula The graduates of the three-year curricula show a much higher correlation for specific work than do the two-year graduates. (Figure 10.) The correlation for the four-year graduates is low. In 1920 only 5.9 percent of those entering high school work had special preparation. (Table 35) (Figures 10, 11). Results of the Study 45 Table 27. — The Distribution (in Percents) of the Graduates from the Two-year Curricula as to Specific Curricula Completed Institutions o J U 03 a a S3 a u 09 M u V 13 (3 0J 03 >> l* 03 ■si >> 03 1 Pi a c w „ K ° o o ■a-S 9 CO 1-5 o o J3 W M K a 2 i '5 3 >> T3 J3 fc] 2 S3 If bo a '5 s3 Q >> u 03 3 1910 A C E G J K M O R T U W Y X B H L 113 52 59 218 118 78 50 57 171 40 124 116 55 69 284 461 113 89. 100. 100. 87.2 100. 100. 100. 97.5 25.2 100. 100. 41.4 100. 100. 81. 99.6 100. 17. 3.9 .4 11. 3.7 20. 25.1 .8 9.4 3.5 1.5 .6 12. 1.5 .9 .3 6.9 1.2 4. 4.9 1.2 4.1 13. 1.8 .5 1.2 4.7 2.4 .9 .5 3.5 2.4 1.8 .3 Total 2178 86.4 1.9 2. 2.8 1.1 .09 .8 .15 1.6 1.3 .7 .7 .05 Table 28. — The Distribution (in Percents) of the Graduates from the Two-year Curricula as to Specific Curricula Completed Institutions a> 31 a os 5 "- 1 "ol M 03 C a o s © h 03 M a -a a 3 a 03 >i M is u o3 o a ■v .9 S a C >> 03 a 02 Si M B a o 11 >> T3 Ph w "3 '8 01 £ S o O M — , (3 H 03 03 ,H 2^ 2 "3 .a o M 13 c3 Q 1915 A 164 95.7 4.3 C 93 6.5 37.5 44.1 11.9 E 37 100. G 267 81.3 4.5 1.9 1.2 10. .4 .8 J 218 100. K 115 34 10.5 38.3 32.2 18.3 .7 M 100. o 118 268 93.3 21.6 .9 1.5 .9 1.5 4.3 20.9 .9 5.2 R 6. .4 39.9 1.5 1.5 T 106 100. u 235 227 52 93.2 36.6 100. 6.8 11.9 5.3 W 14.1 36. 1.8 1.8 3 fi Y X 143 69.3 .7 25 9 .7 3.5 B 276 63. 4.7 7.6 1.8 8.3 .7 .9 2.9 4.7 1.8 3.3 H 445 96.4 3.6 L 75 100. Total 2873 72.3 1.5 2.2 8.5 1.7 1.6 3.6 .3 .4 2. 3.5 1.1 7 46 Output of Schools for Teachers o ►H « O « Q K H Q H 3° Eh & H o « M O IBjny »H tO tH N 05 00 05 1H TH CO tH ft N XJBiqji •^ ...... o ajn^poiiay .1-1. . . : '. '. co' '■ '• '• ^ SniAS.'BJQ 00 ... . .05 to I ! ! '. '. '. rH TjJ 00 oisnj^ co . . 05 . r-i r>. » . . H 1(5 .co m'ti t» pjoqasnoH CO^TtliHCO . t» CON co i> to n -co tht)i * . . 00 . . tH CO . ■* "5 • • CO IN a^'Bipgraia^ni 19.4 4.2 19.4 14.8 7.5 6.5 ■*' &xemxij_ .00 t» to 05 CO 00 • . M (8 M< n to a too . . o b* 05 r-ioO'*'* .tdto'ooo .ddSNOONO 05000000 .INIOCOO .COOCO^ltDOOSO to U5 sa^BnpBiQ jo jaqmn^j MNM'JlHNHtOCiJHMHJtDOOrotCNM t>rHCOTt< t» CO . . . rH to 1© • . ■ . . . . . . . N t~- . . . 00 . . . t-t . . . rj4 . . . t>. Xjbuiuj -n^.re&i3puTg; ■* . . . . 1(5 ... . 16.7 19.7 00 U814BSj3pat3 . . . . a> . . . . N pjI8U3£) © CO O 00 88.2 50. 62.4 37.5 3.2 81.1 25. 62. tO ■* ^< Oi K5 CO to O tDtO^rHtOCOlO IN U3 H c a 'a a> a (H CJ a 9 >> 03 a p.. a> 03 0) £ 0) o o a m M a a 3 3 c g 2 a m [3 u OJ a a o o o em > T) Ph W 05 - a a s Is 'o a a o O o> H p a fag < *3 1910 J 9 100. M 25 100. O 15 100. R 10 70. 20. 10. T 4 100. U 20 100. W 19 42.2 31.6 26.5 Y 11 100. X 14 100. Total 127 89. 1.6 4.8 4.8 1915 G 2 50. 50. J 11 100. M 6 100. 27 92.6 3.7 3.7 / R 10 60. 30. 10. T 8 100. U 58 70.7 29.3 W 55 5.5 45.5 43.7 5.5 Y 11 100. X 27 96.3 3.7 Total 215 63.7 12.1 21.9 2.3 1920 E 1 100. G 2 100. J 4 100. M 3 33.3 33.3 33.3 16 75. 6.3 18.7 R 5 40. 60. T 4 100. U 21 4.8 85.6 9.6 W 83 41. 2.5 26.6 1.3 25.4 6.1 Y 11 100. X 14 64.3 21.5 7.2 7.2 Total 164 47.6 .6 15.9 .6 28.1 3.6 1.8 1.8 50 Output of Schools for Teachers Table 33. — The Distribution (in Percents) op the Male Graduates from the Three- year Curricula as to Specific Curricula Completed 1910 1915 1920 Institutions O $ h 08 v 3 si >o a 2 5° *3 u a a o o si a g .g .O "O 1 2 1° "3 u » a a> O W- 1- ° ° s "3 « a o 3 CQ 1-9 » h 03 -56.5« Two-year Curricula. Kindergarten ■MM 1910-1.9| ■MB 1915- 1920- >-1.9|i 3-1. 5k >-1.7p Kndg-Priw. 1910-2 B 1915-2. 2k 1920-2. 5 hi Primary 1910-2.8 1915-8.5 1920-11. Intermediate 1910-1. 1915 1920 Commercial 1910- 1915- 1920- 41UBUABVO Jl-Lfc>.U o\*ii\j*jm ii^uuaii iil -l.lt 1910- .81 1910-1. 6t -1.7P 1915-3. 6P 1915-2. P -4. b 1915-4. 6P 1920-2. 6P Household Arte 1910-1.3|i 1915-3.51 1920-2.21 I Music 1910- 1915- 1920- I 1910- I 1910- .7i 1910- I - .4* 1915-1. 6k 1915-1. lfc 1915- -2.2» 1920-2. 3b 1920-1. 7t 1920-2.1* Rural 1910- 1915- 1920- General 1910-88.2 1915-37.5 1920-22.2 Three-year Curricula. Elementary Grades ■■■■■» 1910- 1915-21. 8p 1920-42. High School 1910- 1915-20.1 1920-13.8 Manual Training 1910-3. 4p 1915- 1920- 1-3. 4p >-1.7> >-1.4P Household Art3 1910- , 1915-10. )m» 1920- 6.9N General 1910-86.61 1915-66. 6l 1920-80.41 Pour-year Curricula. Elementary Grades ■MOT 1910-13.41 ■» 1915-14. 5P BBMW 1920- 1.81 High School 1910- 1915-5. 6h 1920-5. 3P t Household Arts 1910- I 1915-11. zmm 1920- 8.2P"> General 1910-89. I 1915-63.7 1920-47.61 Male Graduates Two-year Curricula. High School ■■M 1910- 4.8P » 1915-12.1 1920-15.9* Manual Training 1910- 4.8| 1915-21.9 1920-28. l| Commercial 1910- 1915- 1920- 5-2. 3k )-3.6b General 1910-90. 4j 1915-88. 1920-86. Pour-year Curricula. 52 Output of Schools for Teachers Table 35. — The Proportion op Those Teaching Who Have Had Specific Training for Their Work Two-year Curricula Type of Service 1910 Number Teaching Specific Training 1915 Number Teaching 'Specific Training 1920 Number Teaching Specifio Training Kindergarten Primary . ; Intermediate Grammar Junior High School High School. . Manual Training. . , Household Arts Agriculture Commercial Physical Education Music Drawing Rural 45 341 400 55 14 18 57.8 20.8 1.7 18.2 64.3 100. 49 808 863 207 iii 49 49 "8 5 22 7 94. 25.3 5. 9. '40.' 6 77.6 98. ibb'.' 80. 100. 100. 42 585 640 101 33 112 61 37 1 34 11 27 7 83 81. 37.8 10.5 16.9 3.4 68.8 90.2 97.3 100. 94.2 82. 92.6 71.5 1.8 Three-year Curricula 1910 1915 1920 Types of Service Number Teaching Specific Training Number Teaching Specific Training Number Teaching Specific Training "2 "4 100. 100. 'is "5 4 100. 80. 100. 2 10 18 14 1 8 7 100. 60. 83.3 85.7 100. 100. Physical Education 100. Four-year Curricula Types of Service 1910 Number Teaching Specific Training 1915 Number Teaching Specific Training 1920 Number Teaching Specific Training Kindergarten Primary. Intermediate High School Manual Training. . Household Arts. . . . Agriculture Music Drawing Physical Education 19 74. 62.5 7 16 21 112 25 85.8 87.5 57.2 4.4 '92!' 100. 100. 28 210 7 31 4 3 1 6 85.8 25. 5.7 42.8 45.2 25. 33.3 100. 83.3 Results of the Study 53 Figure 9. THE PROPORTION TEACHING THE KIND 01 WORK FOR WHICH THEY HAD MADE SPECIFIC PREPARATION. $Pl» e SB CUr & CUla 75 190. Kindergarten Primary Intermediate Grammar 191 191 19201 191C 1911 19 2( 191 191 192 Of 1910: 191 192 !0P" :o""» 1910J Junior High School 19ia 19 20b High School Manual Training Household Arts Agriculture Commercial 191C 1911 19201 191M 1919 1920* 1910(1 191* 10* 1920* 1910 1915 1920 19101 19151 19201 19101 Physical Education 19151 19201 Music Drawing Rural 19101 1915 19201 19101 1915 1920 1 19101 1915 1920 1 54 Output of Schools for Teachers Figure 10* THE PROPORTION TEACHING THE KIND OP WORK FOR WHICH THEY HAD MADE SPECIFIC PREPARATION. Kindergarten Primary Intermediate High School Manual Training Household Arts Three-year Curricula. 0%. 1910 1915 1920 -2A 1910, 1915 19201 1910 1915 1920 1910 1915 1920 1910i 191H 1920P 1910| 19151 1920|i 19101 Physical Education 19151 19201 Commercial 1910 1915 1920 -50- 25 100 Results of the Study 55 Figure 11. THE PROPORTION TEACHING THE KIND OP WORK FOR WHICH THEY HAD MADE SPECIFIC PREPARATION, Fou year pC| urricufa. 1910 191 1920 1910 191 1920 Kindergarten Primary Intermediate High School Manual Training Household Arts Agriculture Music Drawing 1910 Physical Education 1915 1920 Chapter VI THE ACTUAL TEACHING SERVICE Graduates of 1910 Two-year Curricula The period of teaching service was determined for 1208 graduates of 1910. The variation among the institutions is wide. In one school the records show that 80.5 percent of the graduates of 1910 were still teaching eleven years later. This is the largest proportion found among the nineteen schools studied offering two-year cur- ricula. At the other extreme we find only 16.3 percent of the class of 1910 of one of the schools still teaching in 1921. The median period of actual service for all schools was found to be 9.5 years. The records also show that 42.7 percent of the 1910 graduates taught through the school-year 1920-21. More than 50 percent had taught through nine years, and 75 percent had taught through five years. (Table 36) (Figure 12). Three-year Curricula The number of graduates from these curricula is too small to permit the drawing of conclusions. Of the few for whom the data were secured only 24.4 percent had taught continuously from gradua- tion through the school-year 1920-21. (Table 37) (Figure 13). Four-year Curricula The facts relative to the actual period of teaching service for 133 graduates of 1910 from four-year curricula were obtained. The median period of service to data was found to be 10 years, and 47.7 percent were still teaching in 1921. The variation is not so great among the different institutions as in the case of the two-year cur- ricula. The range is from 72 percent of graduates of 1910 still teaching to 27.5 percent. (Table 38) (Figure 14). 56 Results of the Study 57 Figure 12. THE DISTRIBUTION OP 1208 GRADUATES OP 1910 WHO ENTERED SERVICE PROM THE TWO-YEAR CURRICULA AS TO PERIODS OP SERVICE SINCE GRADUATION. Periods of service 1 year 2 years 3 " 4 " 5 " 6 " 7 " 8 " 9 " 10 • 11 " oj ( 2 5 5( l 7 5 10< ^^^*- ^^* Pi sure 13. THE PERCENTILE DISTRIBUTION OP 56 GRADUATES OP 1910 WHO ENTERED SERVICE PROM THE THREE-YEAR CURRICULA AS TO PERIODS OP SERVICE SINCE GRADUATION. Periods of service. ^ 0% 25 50 1 year 2 years 3 " 4 " 5 ■ 6 " 7 ■ 8 ■ 9 ■ 10 ■ 11 " . 75 100 Figure 14. THE PERCENTILE DISTRIBUTION OP 133 GRADUATES OP 1910 WHO ENTERED SERVICE PROM THE POUR-YEAR CURRICULA AS TO PERIODS OP SERVICE SINCE GRADUATION. Periods of service. , 1 ye^.r 2 years 3 " 4 " 5 " 6 " 7 " 3 " 9 ■ 10 " 11 " 25 50 75 100 58 Output of Schools for Teachers Table 36. — The Distribution (in Percents) op the Graduates op 1910 from the Two-year Curricula as to the Periods of Service Since Graduation Institutions * s a) 3 a g 1° u 03 eo >> CO M OS CO >> IN 03 CO >> CO u 03 CD m 03 O >> «5 m 03 co CO CQ FH 03 CD >i CQ Fh 03 CD >> 00 CQ U 03 co >> ca u 03 CS O CO u 03 CO >> 1-1 A C E G J K M O L R T U W Y X 75 50 41 39 84 57 42 52 102 159 37 120 101 46 50 153 2.6 2. 2.4 36. 1.9 2.4 8.1 6.7 3. 17.4 1.3 4. 2.4 3.4 4.8 7.6 15. 7.2 10.8 5. 10. 8.7 5.2 8. 7.2 2.5 1.2 5.1 7.2 7.6 9.6 8.1 5. 14. 13.1 8. 7.2 14. 2.4 2.5 5.1 2.4 3.8 5. 10.8 21.6 6.7 8. 6.6 4. 1.9 2.6 18. 14.4 5. 1.2 6.8 2.4 5.7 6. 15. 13.5 13.4 8. 8.7 8. 4. 1.3 4. 2.4 5. 2.4 3.4 5.7 5. 4.2 2.7 8.4 3. 8. 4.6 3.9 4. 2.4 4.8 2.4 9.5 9. 7.2 5.4 5. 5. 6.6 8. 1.9 6. 2.4 7. 19.8 3.4 14.4 7.6 1. 4.8 2.7 10. 2. 6.6 4.6 2.6 2. 2.4 10. 3.6 5.1 4.8 9.5 3. 9.6 2.7 4.2 7. 4.4 6. 7.2 2. 4.8 2.5 10.8 6.8 9.6 5.7 10. 3.6 8.1 3.4 4. 6.6 1.9 80.5 36. 56.8 28.5 56.2 60.9 52. 34.7 46. 26. 16.3 32.5 36. 21.5 58. B 5.3 11.8 50.1 Total 1208 4.3 6.7 6.8 5.8 8.4 4.1 4.9 5.8 5.8 4.7 49, 7 Table 37. — The Distrkution (in Percents) op the Graduates op 1910 fromjthe Three-year Curricula as to the Periods of Service Since Graduation 13 -f^» CD 03 CO p Institutions a g u 03 03 f. 03 03 S 03 03 03 CO CD CO CO CO CO CD CD CD CD CD >> >> 1° >> >> >> >i >. >> >> >5 >> o 1-4 rH CM CO ■* 10 CO t» 00 OS 1-1 R 39 2.5 10. 5. 5. 12.5 7.5 12.5 5. 10. 30. C 17 6. 6. 6. 6. 12. 6. 40. 18. 56 3.6 9. 3.6 5.4 10.8 9. 9. 5.4 19.8 24,4 Results of the Study 59 Table 38. — The Distribution (in Percents) of the Graduates of 1910 from the Four-year Curricula as to Periods of Service Since Graduation Institutions CO 3 >-, 03 1 2 08 0) >) 03 09 (N co OS S >, CO GO 03 3 CO 03 (U t» 00 u 03 0) >> CO 03 0J S» CO 0] 3 >. GO h (fl CS >. 05 OS a 3 >> o CO H 03 >, N V P O c R 46 30 25 1 10 21 6 14 6 1 4.4 3.3 14.1 2.2 3.3 4. 10. 4.7 2 4 2 7 2.2 9. 4. 100. 30. 9.4 15. 6.6 8. 10. 11. 29.7 4. 4.4 6.6 8. 9.4 6.6 6.6 4.7 2.2 4.7 50. 27.4 72. 50. 34.2 Total 133 3 7 4.4 3.7 1 s 8.2 8.9 10.1 5.9 4.4 1.5 47 7 Graduates of 1915 Two-year Curricula Data concerning the actual period of teaching service of 2053 graduates of 1915 were secured. The variation is not so great as for the graduates of 1910. There is a range of from 94 percent of the graduates of one institution teaching through the six years to 38.9 percent of the graduates of another. It was found 56.9 percent had taught from graduation through the school-year 1920- 21, that the median period of service for the entire number was six years, and that only 25 percent had taught less than three years. (Table 39) (Figure 15). Three-year Curricula The number of graduates from the three-year curricula is small: The median period of service to date is six years. (Table 40.) Four-year Curricula It was possible to secure the data for 262 graduates of the four- year curricula. The median period of service to date is six years: 51.9 percent taught through the school-year of 1920-21. More than 40 percent completed four years of service out of the possible six years of teaching to date. (Table 41) (Figure 17). 60 Output of Schools for Teachers MALE GRADUATES OF 1910 Two-year Curricula The median period of service, to date, of the 106 male graduates of 1910 was nine years. More than 34 percent taught through the school-year 1920-21. A little more than 50 percent were still teaching nine years after graduation. (Table 42) (Figure 26). Table 39. — The Distribution (in Percents) of the Graduates op 1915 from the Two-year Curricula as to Periods of Service Since Graduation Institutions 0Q HI +^ a g ►3 O u 03 <0 >> e3 to U u e3 0> >> M U 03 (O >> oa u 03 a> >> £ i— 1 > CO o3 to CO cd CO CO t* o3 CD >> CO M 03 CD >> co (4 03 R C T 4 6 35 4 25. 16.6 5.6 16.6 2.8 25. 16.6 2.8 25. 5.6 25. 16.6 17.2 25. 50. 33.6 66. 25. Total 49 8.2 6.2 4.1 8.2 16.4 56.9 Table 41. — The Distribution (in Percents) of the Graduates of 1915 from the Four-year Curricula as to Periods of Service Since Graduation co CD HJ U o3 Institutions CD 3 a g Fh 03 co s- 03 co 03 CO u e3 CO 03 CO 03 CD CD CD CD CD CD ►lo >> >» >> >> >> >> & i-H 3 •2 -° a g 1° OS >> 03 >> to 03 (O >> CO (0 M a a >> OQ M 03 >, «5 03 V TO 03 TO t* 03 01 >> 00 TO U 03 >> 05 TO 03 01 >> O TO 03 W 16 6.3 25. 6.3 6.3 6.3 12.5 12.5 25. T Y 4 6 25. 33.3 50. 16.6 25. 16.6 16.6 16.6 U 20 10. 5. 5. 10. 10. 10. 5. 5. 40. J M R X o 4 23 9 9 15 25. 4.4 25. 13.1 50. 4.4 4.4 11.1 4.7 26. 39.3 22.3 11.1 20. 44.5 13.4 22.3 6.6 66.6 6.6 6.6 13.4 13.4 20. Total . 106 3.8 4.8 8.5 5.7 5.7 4.8 9.5 6.6 6.6 9.5 34.5 66 Output of Schools for Teachers Figure 23. THE PERCENT OP THE MALE GRADUATES OF 1910 WHO HAVE TAUGHT CONTINUOUSLY SINCE GRADUATION THROUGH THE SCHOOl- YEAR 1920-21. Institutions q«g Two-year Curricula. 20 40 60 80 Figure 24. THE PERCENT OF THE MALE GRADUATES OF 1915 WHO HAVE TAUGHT CONTINUOUSLY SINCE GRADUATION THROUGH THE SCHOOL-YEAR 1920-21. Institutions Two-year Curricula, Q£ 20 40 J R M Y X u w T 60 80 Figure 25. THE PERCENT OF THE MALE GRADUATES OF 1915 7.110 HAVE TAUGHT CONTINUOUSLY SINCE GRADUATION THROUGH THE SCHOOL -YEAR 1920-21. Institutions ojS Four-year Curricula. 20 40 60 60 Results of the Study 67 Figure 26. THE DISTRIBUTION OF 106 MALE GRADUATES OF 1910 WO ENTERED SERVICE FROM THE TWO-YEAR CURRICULA bS TO PERIODS OF SERVICE SINCE GRADUATION. Periods of service. 1 year 2 years 3 " 4 " 5 ■ 6 " 7 ■ 8 ■ 9 " 10 " 11 " 0% 25 50 75 100 Figure 27. THE DISTRIBUTION OF 184 MALE GRADUATES OF 1915 WHO ENTERED SERVICE FROM THE TWO-YEAR CURRICULA AS TO PERIODS OF SERVICE SINCE GRADUATION. Periods of service. 1 year 2 years 3 ■ 4 " 5 " 6 " f, 2 5 50 75 10( Figure 28. THE DISTRIBUTION OF 44 MALE GRADUATES OF 1915 WHO ENTERED SERVICE FROM THE FOUR-YEAR CURRICULA AS TO PERIODS OF SERVICE SINCE GRADUATION. Periods of service. o% 25 1 year 2 years 3 " 4 " 5 ■ 6 " 50 75 100 68 Output of Schools for Teachers Table 43. — The Distribution (in Percents) of the Male Graduates op 1915 from the Two-year Curricula as to Periods of Service Since Graduation Institutions o « a g oa 02 U 03 03 >> CM to u aj CO 02 S-i 03 CD 02 U 03 03 !>> CO Eh 03 03 >> CO W T Y U J M R X G 47 7 10 48 9 6 9 20 26 2 15. 14.6 22.2 5. 7.7 50. 27.7 28.5 10. 29.2 11.1 33.3 11.1 15. 15.4 8.6 57. 20. 14.6 33.3 10. 7.7 17.1 20. 8.4 16.7 25. 7.7 8.6 10. 11.1 5. 42.4 50. 23.5 14.3 40. 33.3 55.6 50. 55.6 40. 19.3 Total 184 10.9 22.3 13. 11.4 10.9 31.5 Table 44. — The Distribution (in Percents) of the Male Graduates of 1915 from the Pour-year Curricula as to the Periods of Service Since Graduation o ® Eh 03 Institutions 03 J3 S g ►50 u 03 03 03 03 03 !h 03 03 03 Sh 03 03 >> 03 U 03 03 >> 03 fH 03 03 >> £ l-H .OSTt(CNt>05* CO 00 CM o OS P 8 ia CM UMOtn[TI£l euot^Bdnooo CO CM paiixBj^; (>.... t* CM • 00 00 CO ■<* • • 00 . CM »H • • • CM CO Tj< IO . rH rH tH CO • • ainojj ye panreuia'jj • • W CO OS CO HHU5^l«03«» .CO CO . . 00 >-l H<(10HNMrHWN10 • tH . . CM tH • iH SnnnjB^ OS o - U0 N paja^ng • • t- CO • • 00 ■ 00 OltO CO N • • i-H . CO • ■ O-OSTt<- •• CO . . .rH . . . CO CM ■ ■#■■>.. ssouisnfj 00 ..■*. . • • • 00 00 00 rt< • • -1 TH CM • -CO •■* • • • 'H H IO« . . sa^BnpBif) jo jaqum^j CONOOOOSOOONHO*«3iOO>*HCO HUJlOrtH(»lOll5NT)lolHiOlOII0(OH r-l CM Tl THrHlH CNTjfiH CO CM CQ a .2 3 CQ a l-H liOBObXSoPihP^MBW^ "o •4- c E- Results of the Study 73 Table 46. — The Distribution (in Percents) op the Graduates op 1920 from the Two-year Curricula as to Occupations Entered Other Than Teaching the First Year after Graduation Institutions •sl a g 1° 00 oj a n 14 t- o 03 13 9 El a '1 s T3 S "S o] u 1 a 01 1 1 >> a 00 •2 » is T3 O s A 72 1.4 C 117 .9 4.5 2.7 E 33 3.1 G 144 .7 16. J 121 1.6 6.4 1.6 K 122 3.3 2.5 1.7 M 31 O 96 4.2 2.1 1.1 R 263 .4 5. .4 13. 8 T 121 13.3 U 93 1.1 W 324 1.8 .6 .9 4.3 3 .3 .3 31.2 Y 66 1.6 9. 4.8 1.6 1 6 X 80 2.5 3.8 8.8 3.8 2 5 B 260 8.5 H 237 L 113 8.9 D 83 4.9 F 53 3.8 7.6 Total 2429 .4 1.4 1.2 3.9 .4 .08 .04 .04 5.7 .04 74 Output of Schools for Teachers o I— I Ph o CM OS P a ia 00 t~ p3UIBJ\[ CO t^ araojj ^b panrema^j 10.8 25. 7.7 6.7 CO co poqog -JOJ.J -no^j paja^ug 00 • • • t» ,-. . . ' to •* looqog •jojj paia^a 00 • • • • co ssantsng 25. 38.5 ts ■* Sa^'BTipBIQ jo laqum^j co co •* ih co co m US iH CM rH rt co 10 OS : [ nMonijan. suoi^Bdnooo . . 00 • ■ • Snitaj'Bj . . io • • • OS P 8 ?a 00 . . io • • . CM • • H ■ . . 00 paiiiBj\[ CD • • ... IO . . CO • • • CO CO ataojj 33.3 4.5 loo qog ■jojj'paia^na . . . . CM • • • . . . . o • • ■ CO CO ssauisng . . . . CO • • • 00 Sa^'BTip'BJQ jo aaqranjvi t^ CD »S< •* OS • • • CO CO • ■ • o CM o os paijjBj^ poqog -}Oid - U0 N paja^ug >o' iooqog •jojj paja^ng IO 00 sa^'Btip'BJO jo jaquin^j OS U5 a 3 a OPhOEh«WOP> c E- 1 Results of the Study 75 < « P3 P U « « ^ O M P o fe W « H < E-i „ a «j 03 ffl § w 5 a r, tf O Eh o CN as patQ cs t~ OS M patxrej^ CO smoH ?« panrsinaH rH W Tt< ■* CO CN CS * w lO N rH rH iH looqog jojj -uo^[ pa-ia^ng CO lO 14 • • OS rH Tj( . . co poqag •joi co • • { OS : N * : ^ -; ' ' 1 nMon^nfi suorjednooo os Al}SintJ\[ CO pauircj^ . . H UJ . b- . "5 . . ITS rH . rH . araoji ye pauiBraay; ■* >o •* . t^ • tH 00 O O CO • Suiuire^ !>..!>.... co t. . . i-l . . . . jooqag joji pajaing ■* . •*■«•■ OS CN in . h ec • ih • • poqog joij pa-ia^ag . .00 • • • ■* • t^ . . oo • • • co • ssamsng • • CN t- CO t- ■ o • • N H tO H H . sa^'BTip'BJQ jo jaquinjvj Mil) SH h H 00 • rH tJ< CD CO 00 iO oo CO CO o OS UMOni[n|^ suoi^dnooo t- CN "* paiwej^; • CD lO -CO -* U5 . . tH CO .CD . . CM • rH araojj ye paureraag . . CO lO OS o co • "* ,HMN looqog jojj -uon paja^ng . . jooqog •jojj paia T ug • ■ N W • • 00 • • OS rl • . ssauisng CO . . .CO • t» sa^Bnp^iy jo jaqnin^i' rH rH CN 00 O CO rH CN CO CN ^ t~ 1 CO c o "3 a O O P3 r5 Pk r* P )r a 'S E- 76 Output of Schools for Teachers fc o H •4 fa P u u O o H on . W CO d . . i-l 00 . . . . © .1-1 . .i-l . . . . i-l . C E- Results of the Study 79 Figure 30. THE DISTRIBUTION OF THE GRADUATES FROM VARIOUS CURRICULA WHO DID NOT TEACH THE FIRST YEAR AFTER GRADUATION. Two-year Curricula. Business 1910-1. Ill 1915- .6k 1920- .4b Prof. I 1910- 1915- 1920- School Non-Prof .School 3.4b»i 1910-1. Ill ■1.6b 1915-1. 2L 1.4b 1920-1. zm Remained at Home 1910-4. 6 MB 1915-3. 2 Li 1920-3. 9 !■ Marri 1910- 1915- 1920- ed ■:!F Business 1910- 1 1915-1. 8b 1920-4. 5b i Three-year Curricula. Prof. School Non-Prof .School 1910-8. :hbi 1910-5.1 bB 1915-6. 3bHB 1915-6. 3 km 1920-2. 3b: 1920-1.4 6 Remained 1910- I 1915-4. 5L 1920-6. 3b at Home ; Married 1910-5. lb 1915-3. 6b 1920- ,7b ■ Business 1910-3. b 1915-1.71 1920-2. \ ■ Four-year Curricul; Prof .School 1910-1.81 1915-1. 7b 1920-1. lb 1. Non-Prof .School 1910-4.2 taw 1915-2.9 in 1920-1. 6k Remained 1910-3.61 1915-7.11 1920-5.41 at Horn* i Married 1910-15.4 1915- 1.5 1920- 1.3 I Business 1910-6. 3k 1915-5.5 1920-4.21 ■■ Male Graduates Two-year Curricula. Prof .School 1910-4. 7 an 1915-1.86^ 1920-7. Zhmm Non-Prof .School 1910-4. 7BBB 1915-6. 5bBi 1920-3. to Business 1910-14.: 1915- 8. 1920-13.; Vmmmm Four-year Curricula. Prof .School m 1910-9. 4Mb 1915-4. ^ ■ 1920-5. bw Non-Prof .School 1910-14.2BSBVBB 1915-12. '—inn 1920- 6.6bBB PART III. INTERPRETATIONS AND CONCLUSIONS. SUGGESTIONS Chapter VIII INTERPRETATIONS AND CONCLUSIONS 1. There is evidence of an inequitable distribution of the gradu- ates to the different types of schools. The 1920 report of the Commissioner of Education has the following statement: "The rural schools of the country comprise a vast organization. Of the 20,853,516 children enrolled in the schools, 12,266,915 are in the rural schools, with an average daily attendance of 8,788,600, while the cities enroll only 8,586,601 and have an average daily attendance of 6,760,314." 1 It was found from a study of a large number of teacher-training institutions that only eight percent of the graduates of 1920 entered one-room rural schools, and that only six percent of the selected group studied entered any field of service in the open-country. Comparing this with the large percent entering urban schools it is evident that the rural children do not receive a just proportion of the output of the schools that prepare teachers. A large proportion then of American children do not have the services of trained teachers. If this tendency is continued a few years longer at the rate of the past ten years the rural schools will entirely be without professionally-trained teachers, meaning by such teachers those who have completed at least two years of study beyond high school graduation. It is a well known fact that the rural population is not so much concerned over the lack of trained teachers for their children as are the educational leaders. Coffman, in "The Social Composition of the Teaching Population" 2 made the following statement in 1911, which is even more clearly justified today than when he made it: "The tragedy of the public school situation is the tragedy of the rural school. That the public mind through sheer inertia and by legal sanction permit persons with inadequate and indifferent training to enter this field of labor, has been the great misfortune and handicap of the rural school." 1 Report of the Commissioner of Education, 1920, p. 39. 2 The Social Composition of the Teaching Population, Coffman, L. D., p. 86. 80 Interpretations and Conclusions 81 This critical situation is probably due in part to the fact that the best of the graduates of the institutions training teachers have seldom entered the rural field of service. The rural people as a rule have never had the opportunity of seeing the specialist at work in their schools. When the rural population insists on having trained teachers the normal schools and teachers colleges will provide adequate facilities for the training of such teachers. There is evidence from our findings, however, that a few institutions are. doing very much more than others to stimulate this demand, for they are sending goodly proportions of their graduates into the rural service even under present conditions. 2. The increasing tendency is to enter the city schools. More than one half of the graduates of 1920 who taught the first year after graduation entered the service of the city schools. This is more than for either of the other two years studied. This holds true of the output of all curricula. The number of male graduates of 1920 who entered city schools is 50 percent more than in 1910. There are several reasons for this condition. The last census show that approximately four percent more people live in urban com- munities than in the open country. City school administrators are accepting the work of teacher-training institutions more and more, indeed the professional schools are approaching the standards demanded by city school systems to such an extent that some of them are now becoming exclusively the training schools for the cities in their districts. The social and economic conditions of the cities are so much better than of the communities where other types of schools are located that the graduates often seek urban employment regardless of the fact that higher salaries are sometimes offered in the smaller schools. There is a feeling that a teacher ranks higher socially who teaches in the city than the one who teaches in the rural or village schools. The city children are securing the benefit of teachers with standard training more and more, because the people of the city are demanding better trained teachers and are able and willing to provide the means sufficient to secure them. 3. There is no evidence of a demand for certain curricula at present offered. It is time to take account of the output of each curriculum to see whether the demand warrants a highly specialized preparation or is sufficient to justify only attention in one or more courses offered in connection with less specific curricula. The following 82 Output of Schools for Teachers questions should be answered by each institution in the light of the demands of its district: What is the output of each curriculum? Can the graduates of each curriculum be placed in positions for which they are trained? Is the demand of the district served large enough to warrant the establishment or continuance of the cur- riculum? There is evidence that certain institutions have added certain specific curricula merely to compete with other institutions without taking into account the real demand or lack of demand for the output of such curricula. Some institutions offer differentiated curricula from which they graduate but one or two students each year or perhaps several students who are unable to find appoint- ments in their specialized fields and consequently go into work for which they are not prepared, while at the same time these institu- tions leave undifferentiated the preparation for the primary and intermediate grades where the greatest demands are made. The professional education given by schools for the training of teachers should clearly be differentiated according to the demands in the field of service to be entered by the prospective teacher. 4. The dominant demand is for teachers in the elementary grades. Of the graduates of 1910 from the two-year curricula who taught the first year after graduation the proportion that taught in the grades below the high school was 84.5 percent. In 1915 it was 84.8 percent and decreased to 74.6 percent in 1920. From these figures it seems that the function of teacher-training institutions offering two-year curricula still lies chiefly in supplying the demands of the elementary grades. 5. There is a slight increase in the proportion of the two-year graduates going into high-school positions. While a comparatively small number completing the two-year curricula enter high school work, with this rather limited prepara- tion, there is a marked tendency in this direction. In 1910 only 6.7 percent entered some type of high school work: in 1915 the proportion increased to 9.5 percent: in 1920 to 15 percent. The increasing number of special subjects, such as manual training, household, and the commercial branches, account for the greater part of the increase. With the growing demands of the first eight grades it seems that the entire output of the two-year curricula should be placed in work below the high school level, and that the three-year and four-year curricula should be developed to the point where they can take care of the demands of the high schools in both the academic and the special subjects. Interpretations and Conclusions 83 6. There is a noticeable tendency toward an increase of differ- entiated curricula. There was a 25 percent increase in the number of differentiated curricula offered in 1920 over the number offered in 1910 in the two- year program of studies. In the institutions studied eleven differ- entiated curricula were offered in work below the high school level in 1910. This number increased to nineteen in 1915, and to twenty- three in 1920. There was an increase from five differentiated curricula in 1910 and 1915 to seven in 1920 in high school work. In 1910, of the institutions studied, five were offering some differ- entiated curricula: in 1915 this number increased to eleven, and in 1920 to thirteen. There is sufficient evidence to justify the conclusion that differ- entiated curricula will soon be offered in all the schools for the training of teachers. 7. An increasing proportion of the graduates going into the primary and intermediate grades are receiving specialized training. The proportion of the graduates of the two-year curricula for 1910 who had completed some specific curriculum for work in grades I- VI was 8.5 percent. In 1915 this increased to 13.9 per- cent, and to 19.7 percent in 1920. But the completion of specific curricula does not mean that the graduate will enter the specific field of teaching that the training calls for. Of the 786 graduates in 1910 who entered the elementary grades 104 or 13.2 percent had special training for either primary or intermediate work. In 1915 the number increased to 1720 of which 293 or 17 percent had specific preparation, and in 1920 out of 1267 graduates 322 or 25.4 percent had specific training for the specific work they entered. From these data it may be concluded that there is a steady and gratifying increase in specific training for those undertaking class- room work in either the primary or the intermediate grades. 8. During the period studied the relative distribution of the graduates to supervised and unsupervised schools remains practically unchanged. During the years studied the proportion of graduates going into supervised and unsupervised schools have changed very little. The slight change that has taken place is in favor of a larger number entering supervised schools. While this is partly due no doubt to the fact that there has been provided supervision for more of the rural and village schools in some states, leaving these out the 84 Output of Schools for Teachers increase is largely to be attributed to the fact that there has been an increase in the number entering city schools. 1 9. Graduates of professional schools for teachers have a much longer period of service than the general teaching population. The fact that the general teaching population has a teaching service of from four to five years and that the graduates of the two- year curricula of 1910 have a median service to date (1921) of 9.5 years is evidence of the value of training in lengthening tenure. Further, that nearly 60 percent of the graduates of the two-year curricula of 1915 were still actively engaged in school work six years after completing their college work is evidence that training means continued service. The only conclusion that can be derived is that the service will be benefited by the longer tenure and that training, to the graduate level of two years, will increase the tenure at least 100 percent. 10. In each period studied a significant proportion of the gradu- ates do not teach the first year. The investigation shows that only 84.6 percent of the output of the institutions studied enter teaching the first year after gradua- tion. It is significant that fifteen out of every one hundred gradu- ates fail to enter the teaching service. If this is true for the country at large the loss to the teaching profession is of much concern. The greatest loss does not come from those who continue their education, but from those who use the institutions as finishing schools and then remain at home. 11. Student accounting seems to be inadequate. It is an interesting fact that in only one of the institutions 2 visited a composite record of each graduate since the opening of the school was kept. This school had on a single card the information set forth in this study. When the records of this school are con- trasted with those of the others it is evident that student accounting in general can be greatly improved. In most of the schools visited 1 With the trained and the untrained teacher working side by side in the same system of schools it is necessary to have some supervision, not so much for the trained teacher as that the work of the two may approach the same value to the system and the service. 2 The State Teachers College at Charleston, 111., keeps a cumulative record of each graduate on a 3 X 5 library card. The following data are recorded: Name of the graduate; year of graduation; curriculum completed or special emphasis given to a particular field; school entered immediately after graduation; specific teaching position ; successive teaching positions ; subsequent study ; degrees received ; marriage ; death; other occupation entered if not teaching. Both sides of the card are used. This was the simplest and most effective record found. The information is kept up to date by sending a return postal card each year to each graduate. Interpretations and Conclusions 85 it was necessary to go to several sets of records before all of the information wanted could be gathered together on a single record sheet. In the majority of the institutions visited an attempt is being made to place student accounting upon a business basis. The proper placement of the graduates is an important function of the school. In order to do this well it is necessary to have avail- able the record of the prospective teacher or the teacher in service to recommend him or her properly for a position or promotion. 12. There is little evidence of cooperation of the schools with their alumni. It is a noticeable fact that the professional schools for teachers fail to utilize the latent force and power of a well organized, united, and interested alumni. In a few places some of the data desired were obtained from the alumni records, but it was found that most of the alumni records consisted merely of the name, year of gradua- tion, and the address of each alumnus. A study of this kind could not have been made from the records of the alumni, save in one institution. Would it not be fortunate if the teacher-training institutions could organize their alumni for specific purposes which will unite them into a working body for their own good and the good of their institutions? Chapter IX SUGGESTIONS 1. Institutions for the professional preparation of teachers should inform themselves and their respective state departments definitely with regard to the distribution of their graduates. The annual report of each institution should contain the dis- tribution of the graduates as to kinds of schools entered, the teach- ing position, and the occupation entered by those who do not teach. A knowledge of the actual disposition of the graduates is needed by the state to help it solve the problem of supply and demand. It is only by a careful inventory of this kind that these schools can tell whether they are meeting the demands of their districts. 2. Differentiated curricula should in the main be limited to the clear demands of the field. Every institution should offer differentiated curricula in the primary, intermediate, and upper-grade or junior high-school fields of service. It is evident from the study that every institution has its greatest demand in these fields and especially in the primary and intermediate grades. This statement is true for institutions that train for the general teaching service. There are few that train especially for high-school teaching or some special part of the service, and it is clearly justified in them to offer differentiated curricula for the particular fields into which their product will go. It must be regarded, however, as a serious mistake for an institution to main- tain, as such, a curriculum that puts out only one or two graduates a year and particularly to offer curricula that encourage students to prepare for fields in which the demand is negligible. The best service that any institution can render to its district is to prepare well-trained teachers for the positions demanding such teachers. This demand should determine the extent of differentiation offered by the institution. 3. The responsibility of the institution does not end with the graduation of the student. The institution's responsibility for its graduates apparently ceases in many places on commencement day, and in some 86 Suggestions 87 instances interest in their success ceases as well. A feeling of respon- sibility and a genuine interest on the part of the institution in the success of each graduate will do much to establish a united, well organized, and active alumni. The success of every graduate is in turn the success of the institution, and the failure of each one reflects on the school sending the student out into active labor. 4. Student accounting should be placed upon a business basis. Every business concern of any proportion knows where its products go, it keeps a record of success and of the demands that success creates. Alterations, corrections, and eliminations are made to suit the customers and to meet the growing demands. Teacher-training institutions can profit by a study of some of the efficient business methods used by large concerns. It is believed that institutions would do well to keep a composite record of each student giving a complete history of the case. 5. The records of graduates should include the following data: (a) A brief history of the graduate's training previous to entering the school. This should include the high-school record, experience in any occupation or previous experience in teaching if any. (6) The specific curriculum completed in the institution. If only a general curriculum was completed the special emphasis given to any particular field of service should be noted. (c) The scholastic attainments as measured by grades or marks. (d) The judgments of instructors as to proficiency for a par- ticular teaching position. These judgments should be made by the instructors in the academic subjects as well as by the teachers of the training school, and the director of training. (e) The placement of the graduate upon completion of training as to: 1. The type of school entered. 2. The specific teaching position. 3. Other occupation if not teaching. (/) The success the graduate is meeting in the particular position entered as found by follow-up inquiries to supervisory officers. (g) A continuous record of the graduate's work covering suc- cessive positions held, subsequent study, degrees received, other occupations entered. This can be done with very little trouble by sending every year a return postal card to each graduate. 6. It is suggested that each institution make a self survey cover- ing a period of years to ascertain the facts relative to their gradu- 88 Output of Schools for Teachers ates. It is believed that the results of such a survey would offer helpful suggestions for the improvement of the service of the insti- tution to: (a) The institution itself. It is only by knowing the success with which the school is meeting the demands of its district that it can evaluate its services. (6) The taxpayer. Public teacher-training institutions are under obligations to the taxpayer and should be in a position to render to them an account of their accomplishments. To be able to show that each one gets returns for the money invested in the school. (c) The student. By having accurate information of former students the institu- tion can render more effective service to the prospective students and teachers. The strongest factor in the upbuilding of any insti- tution is a contented, happy, well satisfied body of students and graduates. For an institution to be able to render specific service to the graduates and in turn to the student will be the most effective advertisement that can be secured. (d) The children. The slogan of the National Educational Association, "A com- petent and well trained teacher for every school in the land," is the most optimistic educational philosophy we have. This could well be the slogan for every teacher-training institution as far as its district is concerned. How much more effective an institution would be if it could send into every teaching position a well pre- pared teacher for the specific work to be taught. This would indeed be a benefit to the children who will be the final judges of the teacher's work. (e) The service. If teaching is ever to be a true profession those engaged in it must rise above the present plane of limited preparation of a vague, general character that is supposed to fit one in two years for any field of teaching service. It must rise above the induction of misfits into teaching positions. It must rise above a tenure of only a few years. A survey of the actual output of the institutions with the view of improving the service will aid in finding the weakest links and should offer suggestions for improvements that will raise the teaching service to a recognized profession.