\^vf^-^;^vr; INDIANAPOLIS RECREATION SURVEY MARCH NINETEEN HUNDRED FOURTEEN GV 431 .15 N3 Copy 2 PREPARED FOR THE INDIANAPOLIS CHAMBER OF COMMERCE BY THE PLAYGROUND AND RECREATION ASSOCIATION OF AMERICA INDIANAPOLIS RECREATION SURVEY PREPARED FOR THE GENERAL .CIVIC IMPROVEMENTS COMMITTEE OF THE INDIANAPOLIS CHAMBER OF COMMERCE JANUARY-MARCH— 1914 COMPILED UNDER THE DIRECTION OF THE PLAYGROUND AND RECREATION ASSOCIATION OF AMERICA . FRANCIS R. NORTH, Field Secretary 3 \ ^ -^^ V JUL 17 1914 TO THE BOARD OF DIRECTORS, Indianapolis Chamber of Commerce. Gentlemen : The movement initiated some two months ago by the General Civic Improvements Committee and approved by your Board, to have made a recreation survey of Indianapolis, under the supervision of the Playground and Recreation Association of America, has accomplished results w^orthy of your further consideration. The survey has been conducted by Francis R. North, Field Secretary of the national organization. His report is herew^ith appended. Its perusal shows that he has made an exhaustive and thoughtful study of our recreation facilities, indoor and outdoor, for children, ^^outh and adults; that commendable progress has been made, and a great deal more might be accomplished at a very slight expenditure; that in view of the city's rapid growth very much more should be undertaken for the healthful recreation and happiness of the people — young as well as older. The report should prove a powerful stimulus in the interest of an adequate and proper recreation development of the city. Respectfully submitted, FRANK B. WYNN, Chairman General Civic Improvements Committee. CONTENTS Page INTRODUCTION 5 PART ONE— Recreation Needs 7 I. Facilities for Outdoor Recreation in Neighborhoods 7 II. Home and Neighborhood Conditions 10 III, The Need of Organized Play and Recreation 11 IV. Commercial Recreation 12 V. Recreation Provided by Private Organizations 15 PART TWO— Public Facilities 17 I. Uses of Parks, Playgrounds, Baths— 1913 17 II. Possible Uses of Parks and Playgrounds 19 III. School Property — Present and Possible Uses 24 IV. Public Libraries 29 V. Streets , 29 VI. Present Supervision of Recreation 29 PART THREE— Summary of Needs 31 PART FOUR— Administration 35 PART FIVE— Recommendations 37 I. Next Steps in Securing Recreation Facilities and Supervision, ... 37 II. Future Development of an Adequate Recreation System^ 39 APPENDIX— 41 A. The Recreative Value of Commercial Recreations and Their Control 41 B. Tables 44 C. Maps 60 Introduction In December, 1913, an invitation was extended to the Playground and Recreation Association of America to send a field secretary to study recrea- tion conditions in Indianapolis and to make a report on the same in the form of a recreation survey. Mr. Francis R. North spent tw^o months and a half in this w^ork. The survey has been done under the auspices of the General Civic Improvements Committee of the Chamber of Commerce, of which Dr. Frank B. Wynn is the chairman. The purposes of the report have been (a) to find out where the districts are that are fundamentally most in need of outdoor play and recreation facilities and good indoor recreation as a means of fostering home and neighborhood life (b) to show what facilities and what kinds of recreation are already provided by public authorities, by private organizations, and by commercial enterprises, (c) to show what facilities and what kinds of rec- reation are needed and where, (d) to show how facilities now owned by the city may be utilized for play and recreation, and what are the needed addi- tions, (e) to explain the needs in the way of organization and administra- tion of public recreation, (f) the function and possibilities of privately con- ducted recreation, (g) the position of commercial enterprises and the correct public attitude toward them, (h) The report concludes with a summary of definite recommendations. The beginnings already made in organized public playgrounds, in public baths, in the recreative use of parks, and in neighborhood recreations furthered by private enterprise are a tribute to the energj- and foresight of groups of citizens and officials who have realized the significance of a movement abso- lutely fundamental in building solid citizenship and in providing right living conditions. Many of the recommendations here given are based upon plans already conceived and initiated. Where changes in policy are advocated, they are put forward as construct- ive suggestions and not as criticisms. The rapid growth of many of our large ^ 5 INDIANAPOLIS RECREATION SURVEY cities has brought similar problems that have had to be met by similar sug- gestions and changes. It would have been impossible to secure the information here given with- out the valuable help of many to whom grateful acknowledgement is given. POINT OF VIEW — Every city has its own problems, and its own con- ditions to meet. Between the influence of the home and that of the school, in the case of the children, and that of the business occupation, in the case of those older, lies the influence of the leisure time — a tremendously important factor. The educational necessity of play-life in children has been increas- ingly recognized. Surroundings which make good or bad play conditions, profitable or demoralizing uses of spare time, make or mar the task of the school and the home. The play-life is frequently the determining influence as to whether a child shall grow up into healthy, vigorous manhood or wom- anhood, with good ideals, and a normal outlook upon life. Likewise, good habits of leisure for young men and women and adults, chances for a whole- some outlet for abounding spirits, and for normal means of self-expression in profitable work and good social life, must not be denied. The alternatives have too often been lives lived below their best possibilities, not to mention actually bad social and moral conditions. In making the studies outlined above only actual facts have been sought. The congestion in the city proper means different conditions from those in outlying districts. The purpose has been to get correct observation and testi mony, and to avoid any generalization not clearly substantiated by the facts. PART ONE Recreation Needs of Indianapolis I. FACILITIES FOR OUTDOOR PLAY AND RECREATION IN NEIGHBORHOODS: 1. Distribution of Population As a basis for a correct understanding of the size and nature of the leisure time problem of the city it is necessary to know the population and how it is divided as to locality. It is particularly desirable to know where population is congested and needed play and legitimate recreation likely to be hampered or made impossible because of lack of facilities, and where freer and more open conditions prevail. The estimated population in the directory of 1913 is 265,000. The school census of 1913 shows that children and jouth from five to twenty-one years of age number 55,127. In 1910 the school population represented 22.1 per cent, of the entire population of 233,650. Counting all the adults and the infants under five years, the total population is usually about five times the school census figures. The area of the entire city can be divided into the following types accord- ing to the number of the school population dwelling within the average tract of forty acres, including the streets and alleys. The table also shows the per cent, of school population dwelling in the various types. School Population Per cent, of in 40 acres School Population Type I In districts with 301 to 500 dwell 10 per cent. Type II In districts with 251 to 300 dwell 13 per cent. Type III In districts with 201 to 250 dwell 19 per cent. Type IV In districts with 151 to 200 dwell 13 per cent. Type V In districts with 101 to 151 dwell 26 per cent. Type VI In districts with 51 to 100 dwell 10 per cent. Type VII In districts with 1 to 50 dwell 9 per cent. A map of the printed document in the Appendix shows the location of these types. Eight of the school census districts showing the heaviest congestion 7 INDIANAPOLIS RECREATION SURVEY (Types I and II) lie south of the Union Station to the Belt Railroad and between Shelby Street and the White River ; two of these districts lie either side of Military Park, and one on either side of Indiana Avenue to the north and west of the capitol; one lies west of the River about School No. 52, and another is to the eastward of East Street, between Massachusetts Avenue and Washington Street — between Schools Nos. 1 and 9. The districts represented by Types III and IV, while they do not show the average youthful population as dense as in the first types, are for the most part in closely settled districts where the space is nearly taken up with build- ings and their lots. Owing to the large size of certain census districts, Types III to VII contain certain small areas with a much greater density than indi- cated. Examples of this are the districts immediately north of Massachusetts Avenue and between College Avenue and Roosevelt Avenue, about Schools No. 10, 26 and 55, the foreign settlement south of West Washington Street near School No. 5, and several rapidly growing parts of the city immediately north of East Washington Street. It is to be observed that most of the resi- dential part of the city north of Ohio Street and below Fall Creek is in Type III, that wholesale and business districts in the center of the city are in Types- IV, V and VI, because comparatively few children and youth have their homes there, and that most of the outlying open districts are naturally in Types V, VI and VII. Of the school population, 8.5 per cent, is colored (4,708). The num_ber of foreign-born residents has received large additions in recent years. In two neighborhoods south of West Washington Street, and in one to the north, it forms a considerable proportion. Generally speaking, the population in other parts of the city is American-born. These facts must be taken account of in providing for outdoor play and indoor recreation. 2. Need of Play Space for Children Visits to all the school districts of the city have resulted in a tabulated statement of the needs of" each district. This study has given a basis for cer- tain general conclusions. PRIVATE PLAY SPACE— In the central or closely settled residential sections of the city the private play space available for the active play of chil- dren has practically disappeared. No measured survey is needed to show this fact — close acquaintance with the city makes it evident. Where open ground still remains in these districts, whether in small or large plots, most of it is not usuable for play. Subtract small lawns and gardens and clothes yards, where play is not allowed, storage yards, the vacant lots that are un- graded or not to be entered, and the remainder is small indeed. This remain- der in most districts is private yard space. Now when it is remembered that 8 INDIANAPOLIS RECREATION SURVEY the private yard space, when available, is usually cut up into small individual plots, it means (1) that games requiring space are precluded, and (2) that the plots are usually "private" and can do nothing for most of the children who have no yards. This condition prevails in substantially all of the central districts and other neighborhoods represented by Types I, II, and III. In other residential districts having more yard space, the same difficulties are encountered. The street being the only place with combined space is pre- ferred, and all but a few vacant lots are ungraded or otherwise not available. In the .more open districts, mostly in Types V, VI, and VII, a larger per cent, of the total space is free for play, but the suitably graded lots are few. PUBLIC PLAY SPACE NEEDED— The first need is to make use of suitable space in schoolyards, or small parks owned by the city. In the moje crowded districts, w^here practically all the children are forced to the streets for play, the need is to acquire play space where there is none. In the greater portion of the settled parts of the city where private yards are alone available, and most children prefer the street, the need is to get the use of or acquire space in areas large enough for play. In other large portions of the city where there are lots that are^ not used because they are not graded, the need is to get the use of, acquire or lease land which can be operated as a playground. Similar needs should^be anticipated in the outskirts of the city in the direc- tion of growth. It is to be noted that 23 per cent, of the \outhful population of the city live in the heaviest types of congestion '^(I and II), 19 per cent, in Type III, 13 per cent in Type IV^, 26 per cent, in Type V, and only 19 per cent, in the outlving sections with more open space are represented by Types VI and VII. 3. Need of Larger Spaces for Youth and Adults: Sizable fields are needed for the active boys that yearn for baseball and the vigorous sports of youth. Play space for small children is sadly lacking in parts of the city, but much less can be said for the available fields for boys and youth and adults. Careful experiments in many cities in the use of play- grounds for small children show that from 75 per cent, to 95 per cent, usually come from one-fourth to one-third of a mile from the playground. This is as it should be, for children's playgrounds are neighborhood adjuncts. In the case of fields, an easy fifteen minutes walk to the ground, or one-half to three- quarters of a mile, is the length of the ''attractive radius" for most of the boys and youth. Except on special occasions, the average boys find something else to do, easier and nearer at hand, rather than go great distances to a field. With this standard in mind, the city has very few open grounds available for the sports of youth. Just a few" districts are near Park grounds which INDIANAPOLIS RECREATION SURVEY are used by the boys of the neighborhood. In some of the outskirts open fields are available, but where most of the people dwell there are no fields of suffi- cient size for the sports of youth. It is therefore not surprising that the aver- age youth gets an outlet for his energies in other directions. The evils of loafing and of wasted leisure hours are largely traceable to this deficiency. What applies to boys and youth applies also to the adult uses of fields, impos- sible in most of the districts where workingmen dwell. From the careful examination of every part of the city and the studies in population it appears that fully 80 per cent, of the people live in districts where there are no avail- able spots for games requiring space. II. HOME AND NEIGHBORHOOD CONDITIONS The play of children and the legitimate and necessary social recreations of youth ought naturally to be associated with the life of a good home and where there is a good type of neighborhood life. But where home life has little hold and the neighborhood life is not an uplifting social force, the need for organ- ized recreation becomes acute. In general, the greatest needs are in the dis- tricts showing heavy tj^pes of congestion, and particularly where homes with few rooms, and no open spaces, are the rule. But this is not always the case. A study of housing conditions gives a clearer index of social needs. In the absence of information based on any previous study of this kind, an inquiry was instituted with the help of the Parent-Teachers' Association. Informa- tion from parents in most of the school districts was supplemented by inter- views with the principals of the various grammar schools. The results are shown in Table VII in the appendix, giving conditions as reported in each of the sixty-five school districts. In twenty-eight of these, home and neighborhood recreation facilities are not meeting the needs, as they are classed as "poor" or "very poor." Twelve districts are classed as "poor to fair," and twenty-four as "good" or "fair." Evidently from one-third to one-half the schools are located where the need for better uses of leisure is unquestioned. A few instances illustrate how social conditions rather than congested conditions are the test of a neighbor- hood's need. In a district where the houses are mostly roomy and well-kept, and where open fields are plentiful, a certain "corner" is a general loafing place and has a notoriously bad effect on the way in which spare time of great numbers of boys and young men is spent. Several settlements in the city's outskirts have poor housing conditions and little in home life that is attractive. On the other hand certain central neighborhoods where there is almost no yard space and where the need of play space for children and youth is great, are in some respects the best parts of the city, as far as the adequacy of life within the home is concerned. 10 INDIANAPOLIS RECREATION SURVEY It need hardly be added that the recreation problem of the city is by no means confined to those of school age (over 55,000). A large number of infants under six years get the benefit of parks and playgrounds. When work is over, the leisure of young people and adults must be provided for. III. THE NEED OF ORGANIZED PLAY AND RECREATION OBSERVATION OF CHILDREN OUTDOORS— Owing to the time of year (mid-winter) it has been impossible to make a normal observa- tion of the outdoor occupations of Indianapolis children. But this is not nec- essary in order to verify certain uniform conclusions reached in every similar survey that has been made. In the parts of the city where organized play- grounds are not operated in the summer, the great majority of children seen are on the streets, and a very small percentage in private yards and vacant lots. The street is the inevitable play space for the child without a yard, and is a Mecca for all children (yards or no). The other children are there and there's "something doing." Street play is inevitable in districts without yards or wher6 yard space is cut up into small plots, or where the rule is "Keep off the grass." Even in districts provided with grounds the children will be in the streets as long as-the streets are the most attractive spots. In this state of affairs lies the need not only for "play space," but the equally essential need for the well organized, attractive playground. Observations as to what children do — when seen out of doors — in ordinary city conditions, discloses a gieat need. A large proportion (it usually varies from 40 per cent, to 60 per cent. ) are not playing, but idle. A small num- ber, much greater in some districts than others, are working; and the re- mainder are playing. In the survey recently made in Detroit, playing was interpreted liberally to cover all sorts of play, not merely games, and but 38.3 per cent, of the 3,051 children observed were playing. An average of 54.7 per cent, were doing nothing, and 7 per cent w^ere working. The play seen, when analyzed, is often disorganized fooling. Under the hard conditions in some districts, wholesome play is difficult. Many people thoughtlessly declare that children" play naturally. The truth of the matter is that they have the "instinct to play," the desire for self-expression. The form it takes — a game, or some social play, or sport, or work — all depends upon the opportunity and knowing how. EDUCATIONAL SIGNIFICANCE— Where children are in idleness or misusing the precious playtime, influences are at work which are counter- acting the effects of school training. Right use of play constitutes an educa- tional opportunity. After school, freed from the more or less artificial re- straints of the school room, the boy or girl has not only the necessary chance for more fresh air and exercise, but the golden opportunity to exert individual 11 INDIANAPOLIS RECREATION SURVEY initiative. He is in a sense the arbiter of his own fortunes and in his real world of conduct. In well-conceived play and games, and the industrial oc- cupation in which he delights, is the chance for self-development. Through the social games and team play come the valuable lessons in co-operation which are the veritable beginnings of civic life. Very rarely there exists in a neighborhood a well developed play tradition, opportunity for play and work, and a natural and more or less consistent leadership in wholesome activities handed down from group to group or through families. In the city this is seldom the case — in the congested districts almost never, except where well-organized activities have been purposely established. Time and energy and money must be devoted to this part of the educational process to perfect the product and keep it from being mutilated. JUVENILE DELINQUENCY— The records of the Juvenile Court show that there were 461 cases brought before the court from April 1, 1912, to March 31, 1913. Fully as many more complaints against offenders w^ere handled outside without becoming recorded cases. That much of delinquency is but a misuse of leisure or due to the absence of normal and natural occupa- tions in certain districts is evident from an interesting map prepared by the court in connection with this survey. It shows the districts from which juv- enile offenders come, and gives a fairly accurate idea of the parts of the city that are most in need of good recreation facilities. Wards 1, 5, 11, 12 and 10 (in that order) show the greatest number of cases. A study of the map shows the exact districts in these and other wards. The cost of the Juvenile Court last year was $12,658.65. Indianapolis' share in support of delinquents in the two State industrial schools brings the total to $21,246.65, and this takes no account of the cost of caring for delin- quents by other agencies. While it may not be feasible to reduce this expend- iture, it is surely good policy to have an adequate recreation system that can prevent many of the conditions through which such cases arise. Probation officers are among the best advocates of organized recreation, because of their first hand knowledge of the causes of delinquency. In two districts of the city the court records show a much smaller number of cases than formerly, a condition ascribed to the presence of a settlement, a boy's club and play- grounds. The presence of recreation centers in the South Side of Chicago, according to a study by Allen T. Burns, was coincident with a 28.5 per cent, decrease of delinquency within half a mile of the centers. Table III in tlie appendix of this report shows the classification of offenses and the months in which they were committed. IV. COMMERCIAL RECREATION In planning for an adequate recreation system for a city it is necessary to know the kinds of amusements and recreations already being provided and the 12 INDIANAPOLIS RECREATION SURVEY numbers being reached. The possible facilities that can be utilized must also be ascertained. A recreation system consists of home and neighborhood life, the commercial amusements, the recreative opportunities provided by private effort, and those furnished by the city. The first element of the recreation system — home and neighborhood life — has been touched upon. It remains to discuss the present conditions in the other three, beginning with commer- cial recreation. The extent of commercial recreations is discussed here. The discussion of their recreative value and the maintenance of standards is in the Appendix of the report. 1. Elxhibition Amusements The total number of amusement houses in Indianapolis is 93. These can be classified as follows: 3 legitimate theaters (drama, opera, etc.) ; 5 vaude- ville houses (including two where motion pictures are a large factor) ; 2 burlesque theatres; 70 motion picture houses, and 13 air domes. All of the theatres, vaudeville and burlesque houses are located in the center of the city; 22 of the motion picture shows are within the mile square, and 48 are in other parts of the city and have more of a neighborhood character. Prac- tically all the air domes are outside the mile square. A complete list of the commercial exhibition amusements, with location and type of house is in Table II in the Appendix. The modern rapid development of the motion pic- ture business, combined with theatrical performances, presents the largest single factor in. the consideration of how the people are spending their leisure. While it is impossible to give exact figures of attendance at these amuse- ments, a conservative estimate well within the actual figures can be given. Visits to most of the theatres, interviews w^ith men engaged in the local busi- ness as to conditions in these and other bouses, detailed reports of visits from more than half the motion picture shows, and knoweldge of similar conditions elsewhere form the basis of the estimate of attendance in the winter season. Table I in the Appendix gives the capacity and estimated attendance. It will be seen that there is a total seating capacity of 40,814, w^ith an aver- age vreekly attendance of 420, 507. Great care has been exercised to insure figures within the facts. Motion picture houses run continuously, and the daily attendance is represented by a figure several times the capacity of the house. The average capacity of the motion picture houses visited was 378. Some of the most successful down-town houses show daily admissions running from three to several times capacity. Most houses are nearer the lower fig- ure. This report will err on the side of a conservative estimate. Reports from local managers and observations here make the method used in similar reports In Milwaukee, Kansas City, and Detroit a safe basis of figurina:. For the dow^n-town houses the seating capacity has been multiplied by 20 (a 13 INDIANAPOLIS RECREATION SURVEY figure lower than the average of Kansas City), to get the average weekly at- tendance. (It is to be remembered that houses here are open seven days a week, with larger attendance Saturday and Sunday). The capacity of the neighborhood houses had been multiplied by 8.5, the average times per week for the same type of house in Milwaukee. The vaudeville and burlesque houses together run an equivalent of at least 60 performances* a week, making allowance for the fact that two of the houses are on the continuous perform- ance basis. Multiplying their capacity by eight would be within the figures. The variety in number and success of performances at legitimate drama and opera, makes five times the seating capacity a conservative figure. 2. Pool and Billiard Rooms With the exception of the theatres and motion pictures, the pool rooms of the city represent the largest single factor in attracting men in their leisure time. Last year (1913) 471 licenses were issued. The number in force at the present time is considerably less than this, and there have been a number of changes in proprietors. In several cases where pool rooms were being used merely as blinds for gambling, law enforcement has made it unprofitable to continue business. About thirty per cent, of the rooms are located in the center of the city within the mile square. It is impossible to tell the exact attendance at pool rooms, because of its constantly changing character. A large number have been visited, and close estimates have been made. On the weekly basis, careful estimates place at- tendance in winter at 190,000, being reduced very largely in summer time till it is probably not much more than twenty per cent, of that figure. The pool room is not merely a place for playing pool and billiards — it is a social gathering place, and the on-lookers are as numerous as those who actually play. Practically all of the rooms have a rather fixed group that frequent them. While in many instances the class of patrons is of the best, in general this is not the case, and not a few rooms are gathering places for some of the worst elements of the city. While most all have some drop-in trade, about twenty per cent, appear to be exclusively dependent upon their regular patrons. Inside the mile-square practically one-third of the places where pool tables are located are in saloons. Two-thirds are straight commercial pool rooms, for pool and billiards, and among these are several respectable enterprises. In the out-lying sections of the city where the rooms are located in neighbor- hoods, almost two-thirds are in connection with saloons. The other one-third are mostly small pool rooms offering this t^^pe of amusement to the men of a rather distinct neighborhood. Not a few of this latter class are in connec- tion with cigar stores. In 1913 the total number of tables in commercial pool rooms and saloons was 925. Of these, 425 were in the center of the city, and it is fair to infer 14 INDIANAPOLIS RECREATION SURVEY that slightly more than 45 per cent, of the entire attendance at pool rooms is in that section. Most of the large, well-appointed places, where men seek this form of amusement under the best conditions that exist, are in this part of the city. Tables in outlying sections numbered as follows: Northeast, 136; Northwest, 157; Southeast, 142; Southwest, 65. 3. Bowling Most of the bowling in Indianapolis, which is inconsiderable compared with many cities of the size, takes place on alleys in clubs and associations. In most of them the alleys are public, in the sense that anyone who pays for his game can play. Strictly commercial alleys, unassociated with other enter- prises, are located at but two small establishments. Six alleys at the Y. M. C. A., 20 at private athletic and social clubs (Marion Club, Democratic, Turvereins, etc.) 4 in connection with churches, and 4 at other locations. No attempt has been made to make careful count of those participating. Evi- dently the total attendance is not large compared with other amusements. The conditions under which bowling takes place have been much improved, largely because institutions have taken it up. Most all who bowl are devot- ees of the game itself. Alleys usually have about the same patronage during the season. 4. Public Dances The numbers attending "public dances" can be judged by the fact that there were 411 licensed dances in the first eight weeks of this year. Fully half of these were public in the sense that the public generally might gain admission on the payment of a fee. This would indicate an attendance of at least 4,000 weekly, not counting the large number of private dances — at which invitations are restricted. The great majority of halls are let to parties managing dances. At three halls the management operates dances regularly each evening, and several others are run two and three times a week. A number of clubs make a practice of running public dances for profit in hired halls — weekly or more frequently. The importance of dancing as a form of public amusement is such that the subject is given separate discussion in the Appendix. V. RECREATION PROVIDED BY PRIVATE ORGANIZATIONS ASSOCIATIONS, SETTLEMENTS, CHURCHES— The physical social and intellectual pursuits organized and furthered by philanthropic and co-operative organizations constitute a most important factor in providing for the leisure of young and old. The total weekly attendance at institutions 15 INDIANAPOLIS RECREATION SURVEY that have well equipped buildings, is estimated at 26,345. This does not include purely social, musical, athletic or political clubs. Large buildings equipped for recreation purposes, centrally located, are the two Y. M. C. A.'s, the Y. W- C. A. Three Turnvereins, and two social and athletic clubs have well equipped buildings for active indoor recreations and social uses. General neighborhood, philanthropic enterprises with buildings used for recreation purposes (some large, some small) are in six locations; Christ- amore Settlement, Lauter Memorial and Butler Memorial (Boys' Clubs), the Foreigners' House of the Immigrants Aid Association, and the Harley Gibbs Settlement. The Jewish House is a combined city and neighborhood house supported by Jewish people. There are two churches with vestries or parts of church buildings devoted more or less regularly to organized sports and other recreations under paid leadership. Four mission houses connected with religious bodies, furnish social and other recreation as part of their work. Five churches have rooms used by clubs for sports more or less regularly each week under volunteer leaders, and a number of others have some one activity in the form of clubs for boys or girls meeting weekly. Certain other organizations, such as the Woman's Department Club and the Bo5^s' Club have furnished leadership for the use of public libraries and in parts of school buildings for neighborhood recreation. The eight Young Men's Institutes are among the clubs with rooms for their own and affiliated with churches. Table VII shows the extent of the equipment and the weekly attendance at most of the buildings nan>ed above. CO-OPERATIVE CLUBS, ETC.— No attempt has been made to esti- mate the influence of the recreative features furnished to members and friends at social, musical and athletic clubs of the city, that have well- equipped plants. These are naturally restricted as to membership by the pay- ment of fees and other considerations. The city has favoring circumstances in the impetus given to physical train- ing through the Turnvereins and especially by the presence of the Training School of the North American Gymnastic Union, in the building of the German House. The athletic organizations maintained by boys and 5^oung men for partici- pation in baseball and other outdoor sports indicate the amount of athletic interest in the city seeking facilities for play. At this early date an employee of one of the leading sporting firms has listed the names of 86 baseball teams. These are figured at less than one-half the eventual total, as many boys and \()uths teams do not organize till the baseball fever comes. The great major- ity have no home grounds or courts and are mostly dependent on use of out- lying parks. Among the teams mentioned 38 are in regularly organized leagues. The thirty basket ball teams listed do not begin to exhaust the list. 16 PART TWO Public Facilities L USES OF PARKS, PLAYGROUNDS, AND PUBLIC BATHING IN 1913 1. The Uses of Park Property It is of course impossible to estimate the use of the squares and breathing spaces of the city or many of the voluntary uses of the scenic parks, but where the parks of the city are equipped for sports and have been subject to permit, estimates can be made that indicate the amount and variety of present uses. Riverside Park has seven baseball diamonds, and these and other spaces are available for football and other field sports. Two 18-hole and one 9-hole golf course ofiFer good opportunity for this popular pastime. The Park has nine tennis courts, and canoeing is another of its active recreations. Garfield Park has three diamonds and four tennis courts. At Brookside Park are two diamonds, space for one football field, and six tennis courts. There are three courts at Spades Place. Ellenberger's Woods has two tennis courts and a six-hole golf course. Children's play spaces — in some cases with apparatus and matron in charge — are provided at Garfield Park, Military Park, Spades Place, Highland Square, Indianola Square, and McCarty Place. It is estimated that 30,000 boys and men played in regular baseball games on park grounds in 1913. There were 35 organized football games. No esti- mate is made of practice games, and no figures are available for tennis, golf and canoeing, all of which are popular. THE PRESENT PARK SYSTEM— Table IV gives the area of park lands owned by the City of Indianapolis, and indicates the way in which the spaces are used for active sports. 2. Activities of the Recreation Department of the Board of Health Last summer the supervised playgrounds and baths operated by this depart- ment included six bathing establishments and eight playgrounds. BATHS — Between June 28th and August 31st the baths had a total at- tendance of 124,581 ; river baths with tents on the shore were located at 16th Street and Fall Creek, 10th Street and the River (colored), Capitol 17 INDIANAPOLIS RECREATION SURVEY Avenue and 24th Street, Hanson Avenue and the river, and at Norwood (colored). The most popular bath in the city was the large out-door pool on Delaware Street on the former site of the gas works. At all of these points life-guards and attendants were stationed, and at several of them spe- cial hours were reserved for girls and women. PLAYGROUNDS — Playgrounds were operated next to ■ the Lauter Memorial Building on Greeley Street, in West Indianapolis, on South Meridian Street, opposite the Boys' Club Building, on English Avenue, not far from School No. 39, on the Court House grounds, on the grounds of the Christamore Settlement, at Brighton Beach (colored), in Norwood, and in Brightwood on the grounds of the water works opposite School No. 51. A director and lady assistant were on each of these grounds from July 14th to August 31st. At five of the grounds adjacent buildings were used, and on three portable toilets were erected and water connections put in. Four of the playgrounds were open from 9 A. M. to 6 P. M. On four grounds arc lights were placed so that they could be open in the evening. The total attendance for the summer was 71,661. The summer activities closed with a play festival at Garfield Park on August 27th. The use of the club house at Brightwood has continued through Fall and Winter, afternoons and evenings, under directors. It has provided a place for boys' clubs, women's clubs, and gymnasium classes, shower baths,- etc. One of the city kindergartens makes use of it. Directors of the department are working in co-operation with the Boys' Club in con- ducting gymnasium at Butler Memorial and Lauter Memorial Buildings. At two locations — on Harding Street in West Indianapolis and Ringgold Street on the South Side — this department has secured grounds for playground purposes. THE IMPORTANCE OF BATHING FACILITIES— Thus far pub- lic baths have been carried on in only temporary locations, but a large number of people have taken advantage of them. The importance of good bathing places in a city can hardly be overestimated. They are ^ sanitary provision and at the same time furnish a splendid type of recreation. From the stand- point of cleanliness, public baths are indispensable. From the standpoint of an exercise, swimming is incomparable. Many cities have been generous in their provision for public out-door beaches, swimming pools and floating baths, and in-door baths and natatornims. Some have gone so far as to re- quire a knowledge of swimming before a High School diploma is granted. The policy of the department in establishing inexpensive headquarters at several points on the banks of the streams and seeing that the latter are patrolled, has proved a measure of safety. The next step should be for the city to establish a public bathing and swimming establishment which can be 18 INDIANAPOLIS RECREATION SURVEY permanent, well-constructed according to the most modern standards, and a model for similar developments at other points. Much of the indoor bathing can be inexpensively provided in parts of school buildings, in field houses, and in neighborhood houses used for recreation. CO-OPERATION WITH PRIVATE AGENCIES— The principle of providing trained leadership in connection with bo5'S' clubs, settlements, and other agencies furnishing recreations to the people, is a valuable one. It means that these opportunities can reach a much larger number of children and young people than if confined to public property. A LARGER MAINTENANCE FUND— The law passed last year pro- vides for the supervision of public playgrounds and other organized recrea- tions by the Board of Health, and sets aside a portion of the tax levy for this purpose, equal to from one to two cents on every one hundred dollars of tax- able property. This means that there is available a considerable maintenance fund for recreation purposes. The expenditures last yesLr were $11,133.21. The amount available this year is about four times that sum. IL POSSIBLE USES OF PARKS AND PLAYGROUNDS 1. Best Uses for Different Types of Property In considering the uses of public property for recreation and the possible additions, it is necessary to have in mind the various kinds of parks, play- grounds and baths, and the provisions for indoor recreations which may exist in a city. PRESENT TYPES OF PARK PROPERTY— The connecting boule- vard system as the basis of the plan of park development for the city has a fundamental economic and esthetic value that should be well understood. In the course of Its development It will provide most parts of the city with sites for different kinds of recreation grounds. The other types of park property within the city limits are, first, the squares or breathing spaces, not intended for active recreation (except In some cases for the play of small children), such as University Park or Military Park; second, the larger scenic and pic- nic parks (such as Garfield Park and Riverside Park), and third, park grounds for active sports, subject to permit or other arrangements, as at the two larger parks mentioned and at Brookslde Park. THE "PLAY PARK" or "RECREATION CENTER"— A fourth type of park, the neighborhood play park and recreation center, with provision for active sports for all ages the year-round, equipped with a field house, on a large field, and with smaller play spaces organized under trained leadership — does not yet exist In Indianapolis, though such a plan has been proposed for Wlllard Park and suggested In other localities. An organized recreation 19 INDIANAPOLIS RECREATION SURVEY center of this kind, located near to a thickly populated district has an exten- sive use by large numbers in a district, and is a playground and recreation development to be distinguished on the one hand from the more distant parks, and on the other from the close in-town breathing spaces laid out with formal walks, but with little or no provision for active games and sports. CHILDREN'S PLAYGROUNDS— In providing organized play spaces in settled districts, distinctions should be made among the various uses to which such grounds can best be put. First, children's playgrounds and larger ''play fields" should be carefully distinguished. The former, whether separate or as part of a larger district field, are a neighborhood proposition, and should be confined to the use of the smaller children of not more than eleven to twelve years of age. The little ones ought not to go far from home, usually not more than a fourth to a third of a mile. Below the age of eleven, boys and girls can use the same kind of apparatus and can play many of the same games. The older active boys need larger spaces, and they do not mix well with the smaller children. For this reason the children's playground should consist of an entirely separate space, either a ground by itself or a part of a larger ground separated from the "play field" by some distinct line of division. BOYS' AND GIRLS' PLAYGROUNDS— A second type of playground is that for the active boys from ten or eleven to fifteen or sixteen. These ''boys" playgrounds" do not need to be of the size of a regulation field, but they do need to be large enough for active games like baseball and football, and for athletic contests, even if the diamonds have to be smaller and the distances shorter than on a regulation athletic field. Boys of this age can cover a pretty good distance and will be attracted to a well-equipped ground ten or fifteen minutes walk from home or school as long as there is "something doing." "Boys' playgrounds" can be on a space of their own as a separate ground, or as a part of some of the larger fields. Playgrounds for girls from twelve up, and including young women, have become an important factor in recreation systems. Custom or the total lack of proper facilities has too often denied to girls the exercise and play which are their natural right. Spaces for girls can, in some instances, be provided in connection with children's playgrounds, or on some of the more park-like areas of a city, where tennis, playground ball, basket ball, field hockey, and other outdoor exercise can be provided for girls and young women without the difficulties of administration which would be present in connection with a field used by large nimibers of boj^s and men. PLAY FIELDS— The athletic fields used by older boys and men for regulation baseball, football, athletics and other sports, are the fourth type of ground. It is this type, the " play field," that is most conspicuously lacking in Indianapolis. BATHING — In the development of parks, play fields and playgrounds 20 INDIANAPOLIS RECREATION SURVEY the possibility of certain other types of recreation needs to be kept in mind. Important among these are outdoor bathing pools, river-baths, indoor swim- ming pools, and indoor baths of different, types. INDOOR RECREATION— Wherever a suitable public building is in a district where indoor recreations are needed to foster neighborhood and supplement home life, it is a possible recreation asset, and in the erection of needed structures in connection with outdoor sports their possible indoor uses should be considered. The year-round "recreation center" consists of a field house, not merely as an adjunct to a playfield, but with gymnasium, assembly hall, and smaller rooms for indoor uses. ORGANIZED METHODS— At least three important points should be kept in mind in providing centers of recreation. (1) They should be devel- oped according to the best esthetic standards, furnishing recreation in sur- roundings that are as far as possible, beautiful. (2) Experience in many cities has taught that four-fifths of the patronage of fields and recreation centers comes from within a half or three-quarters of a mile. For small children the corresponding distance is smaller still. Playfields and recreation centers must be established in or near the settled districts. (3) Organized methods under trained leadership^ are absolutely necessary to make grounds consistently useful. This applies alike to playgrounds, playfields, and recreation centers, and to the varied recreative uses of parks. 2. Location of Playfields and Recreation Centers ALONG PARKWAYS— The plans of the Park Department for a sys- tem of connecting parkways along the banks of the White River and three of its tributaries (Fall Creek, Rogue's Run, and Pleasant Run), means — parkways, and in some cases larger park spaces, within at least a mile and a half of every part of the city. The civic benefits of this basic development are large, indeed. To furnish facilities for active recreation, particularly fields of sufficient size near to the domicile of the people is another important func- tion. In the eventual development of the parkways along the streams there are several points where such fields can be located. Among these are the proposed Merritt Playground on White River, and one or two points further down the stream, and four points along Fall Creek where the development is to be widened sufficiently. On Pogue's Run, Brookside Park can be de- veloped into a splendid organized recreation center with room for several fields and .playgrounds. A similar plan should be devised where the stream passes through the Technical Institute grounds. The same principle can be applied to the acquisition of property along Pleasant Run. OTHER CENTERS NEARER TO MORE POPULOUS DIS- TRICTS — But playfields or recreation centers located along these streams 21 INDIANAPOLIS RECREATION SURVEY cannot adequately reach some of the large centers of population between them, where the first needs lie. Pogue's Run is on the average two and a half miles from Fall Creek or Pleasant Run. At most a three-quarter mile radius cov- ers the real sphere of influence of- a field or recreation center. Consequently other property, right in the populous districts needing recreation needs to be acquired and developed. Playfields are much needed on the South Side in wards 12, 11, and 10, and in the region south of them that is too far from Garfield Park. More specifically these districts are (1) the South Meridian Street neighborhood below the Manual Training High School, and the neighborhood nearer the river about School No. 12, (2) the southeast neighborhood between Willard Park and Garfield Park, (3) the eastern part of the South Side which would be well-served by the operation of a recreation center at Willard Park. Other needs are (4) in the northeast part of the city in Ward 1, near School No. 55, (5) in the northwest part of the city traversed by Indiana Avenue, (.6) north of Washington Street near School No. 52, and in West Indianapolis (southwest part of the city) between the river and School No. 49. This outlines the needs that are most pressing. In these districts the Park Department already has available undeveloped property, viz. at Willard Park, at the Merritt Playground and north of School No. 49. It is planning to acquire property on the South Side. By applying a three-quarter mile radius from the possible location for fields, along the streams and from' centers placed in the districts named, it will be seen that there will still be large portions of the city without accessible means for active recreation. Such districts should eventually be provided for by the purchase of fields, or by the enlargement of school yards. Children's playgrounds for an immediate neighborhood might be part of a fully devel- oped recreation center, but these serve so small a territory, and are so natur- ally and economically connected with school administration that they should be furnished for the most part in school yards. PLAYFIELD EQUIPMENT— A typical playfield for youth and adults has a field large enough for baseball, football, hockey, track athletics, tennis, and other sports suitable to open fields, with a possibility of skating in winter. It has bathing facilities, and a swimming pool, if possible. Separate spaces should be provided for the sports and games of girls and women, and there may be separate children's playgrounds. Good surfacing, shade, and a land- scape plan satisfying to the eye are essentials. In the field house are the office of the director, baths and lockers, drinking water, toilet facilities, etc. A fully developed field of the "recreation center" type, has an indoor gymnas- ium, club rooms, social rooms, and sometimes opportunities for work as well as play. 22 INDIANAPOLIS RECREATION SURVEY NEED OF A TYPICAL RECREATION CENTER— Obviously the best plan for Indianapolis is to develop one center w^ell — a center w^hich can be typical for similar later developments. This can well be done at Willard Park, a v^^ell-located tract of suitable size. Evidently with this policy in mind the Park Department has considered such a plan for this park. Of the other proposed locations that in the central South Side is more central to needy districts. In this or other locations there is the possibility of co-operating with school authorities, or with private organizations in the use of adjacent buildings to serve as field houses. 3. Organized Methods Applied to the Larger Parks The Park Department has made a good beginning in stimulating the use of its scenic parks and the spaces where active recreation is available. Base- ball leagues have been formed, other sports have been organized, and golf and canoeing and children's park play spaces put in charge of instructors or attendants. Leadership and organized methods applied to the "popular sports" and a variety of other activities possible in parks, but less well- known, will mean a still larger use. The group and social uses of the parks by clubs and organizations, families and individuals from every part of the city will be much increased when by such means they become acquainted with the possible benefits the parks can be to them. 4. Policy as to Use of Other Park Spaces Most of the small green spots and breathing spaces are not adapted for a large, active, recreation use. At best these can be used only for the play of small children. This is true of such spaces as University, St. Clair, High- land, Morris, and Indianola Squares, McCarty Place, Noble Place, etc. Two or three of these have increased use because adjacent to schools and libraries. The larger scenic parks, such as Riverside and Garfield, can constantly in- crease in the kind of recreative uses to which they are put. This is also true of points along Fall Creek, Brookside Park, and Ellenberger's Woods. The great variety of sports and volunteer recreations now possible in these parks will greatly profit by organized methods reaching to the people, ac- quainting them with facilities, and making it natural and easy to make use of them. In providing district playfields, rapid development is needed in a few cases with pressing needs and gradual development at other points. The former are Willard Park, a new South Side field, the Technical grounds, Merrit Playground, fields in Ward 1, and a field for colored 5^outh to the north of Wards 5 and 6. The latter applies to the available fields along the park- ways and others to be acquired between. 23 INDIANAPOLIS RECREATION SURVEY At each of the grounds that can become playfields the policy should be to provide first the ball-fields, athletic grounds, tennis courts, and other facilities that can be used with little supervision. In the well-settled neighborhoods (as at Wlllard Park, for example) a field house and organized leadership should also be provided as soon as possible. The amount of supervision and the facilities should increase with the growth of the neighborhoods affected. Field houses (with baths, lockers and toilets) should be planned for to in- crease the use and ejfficiency of grounds. In a thickly settled neighborhood without good indoor recreations the advisability of a more fully equipped plant with a variety of indoor uses should be considered. In acquiring property for recreation purposes there should always be kept in mind the possibility of enlarging school yards in the districts where fields will be needed. Certain of the residential districts where open fields have disappeared or are fast disappearing, are cases in point. The parks are too remote. The obvious need is to forestall the future by having at least one very large school yard (more than two acres). Where this cannot be done a separate field is a necessity. III. SCHOOL PROPERTY 1. Schoolyards SIZE OF SCHOOLYARDS— The sixty-five grammar schools of the city have been visited in order to determine the size and present and possible uses of the school yards. Table V in the Appendix shows the size of each and the number of square feet per capita with the children enrolled in each school. The two large high schools have no play space. Seven of the grade schools have less than thirty feet per child. This amount of space Is the absolute minimum established by the London school board. It is too low to apply to most American cities. Ground used con- stantly for play purposes accommodates about three hundred children per acre. Such use does not permit large space games, but confines active play to basketball. Indoor baseball, group games, etc. Making due allowance for the fact that much of the time the ground will be used by only a portion of the children, 50 to 75 square feet per child seems a reasonable minimum. One-half of the schools of Indianapolis have less than 50 feet per child. It must be kept in mind that the population Is growing, the schools are being crowded, and that the need for sizable yards will be greater as time goes on. SCHOOLYARDS NATURAL CHILDREN'S GROUNDS— School- yards must not only be adequate for the recess play of the school children, 24 INDIANAPOLIS RECREATION SURVEY but they are the natural children's plaj^grounds for most neighborhoods, after school during term time, and in summer when school is not in session, and the school building, with its drinking water, toilets, and other conveniences, is an essential adjunct to both these uses. The play of children has been increasingly recognized as a part of their education. This, and the fact that the natural play time during most of the year is immediately after school, makes the schoolyard the logical and economical play space. In Indianapolis the yards are kept open for play until 4 P. M. in Spring and Fall, as well as for usual recess play. In many other cities they are open regularly in summer and for a longer period afternoons and on Saturdays in term time. The ordinary schoolyard is of such small size that it can be used only as a playground for small children, mostly below eleven or twelve years of age. Active boys of older age, and youth and adults, should be accommodated at some larger playfield, unless the yard is exceptionally large. SUPERV^ISION — There is need of supervision on playgrounds, not only for the purpose of controlling the grounds and giving an equal opportunity to all, but because the activities of children and youth need to be in the hands of people who understand them and their needs. Play leadership is becoming as much of a profession as other branches of teaching. Through the depart- ment of physical training in the schools in co-operation with the recreation department of the city, it ought to be possible to introduce the kind of system which has been so successful in many other cities. It will prove of great benefit to the children in the neighborhoods in which they reside and add to the efficiency of the plan of education. EQUIPMENT OF SCHOOLYARDS— Practically every school in the city has play apparatus in its schoolyard. In all cases this has been provided by the cildren, their parents and the teachers. The typical equipment con- sists of swing frames, giant strides (or Maypoles) and travelling ladders. Some have horizontal bars, basketball standards, see-saws, tether poles, sand boxes, etc. A few only have little or no equipment. In nearly every case there are a number of basketballs or footballs and frequently other play ma- terial. In these respects the majority of the schools are fairly well provided. But the fact that apparatus and materials for play have been provided by the districts themselves has operated to the disadvantage of some of the schools in needy sections. Some of these that need equipment most have the least of it. For this reason each of the yards ought to be brought up to a standard equipment by the city. There are certain features that are fundamental essentials to a good play- ground. The ground should be well surfaced, and easily drained and dust- less. There ought to be shade, and if possible seats for parents and others. For a ground to be well managed a fence is necessary. The use of rooms in 25 INDIANAPOLIS RECREATION SURVEY the school building, as- well as the toilets, drinking water, etc., adds to the efficiency of a play center. GREATEST NEEDS — In general such playgrounds for small children will be of use mostly to children within a quarter or a third of a mile from the school building. There are approximately 30 of the yards that are so situated that the need is pressing. A list of these has been furnished to school and recreation authorities. Every schoolyard in a settled district will be increasingly needed as a playground. 2. School Buildings indoor' EQUIPMENT— Table VI in the Appendix shows the schools of the city that have indoor equipment such as auditoriums or gymnasiums, large corridors, extra rooms, and other facilities which can be used for recrea- tion purposes outside of school hours. About one-half (32 buildings) have good or fair rooms for general meetings. Three are adjacent to libraries. In most districts needing organized neighborhood recreations, the school build- mg has equipment that can meet part of the need if properly supervised. Almost without exception the schools have pianos, and most of them have more than one. Several have piano players or phonographs. All the schools in which there are sixth, seventh and eighth grades, have wands, dumb bells and clubs for classes of fifty or more. Twenty schools have manual training benches, accommodating twenty to twenty-five pupils, and nineteen have sim- ilar equipment for cooking. A few have sewing rooms, and several have arrangements for other forms of industrial work such as printing. Most buildings have been erected without special features for physical exercise. PRESENT USES — Thirty-eight of the schools have parent-teacher associa- tions. In many buildings meetings of parents or entertainments are held more or less frequently. In five school districts teachers and others have given a large amount of time to the supervision of valuable recreative activities for the children and young people of the community. In one instance a large amount of this activity is of an industrial character, but at the same time a well organized boys' club and other organizations have grown out of the enter- prise. In another case teachers have given time to the supervision of basket ball in one of the assembly halls, and an active parent-teachers' association has conducted a series of entertainments more frequently than is the case in most schools. At another school the principal has secured the assistance of outside organizations in the support of classes in manual training and domes- tic science. These cases are mentioned to illustrate the fact that work of this kind seems to be limited largely by the amount of volunteer service that prin- cipals and teachers can give to it. At present the principal is naturally held responsible for everything that goes on in the building. Additional activities 26 INDIANAPOLIS RECREATION SURVEY, mean more time and energy on the part of principals and teachers, outside of the regular school hours. EXTENDED USES POSSIBLE— In the course of recreation survey ot the city there has been encountered a general desire for the use of school build- ings f,or recreation purposes. This is quite natural when 139 other com- munities are already using their school buildings in this way. They are proving to be the means of meeting just the kind of needs shown in the sur- vey. It is an inspirng sight to see large numbers of young people and adults in profitable pursuits and amusements in buildings of this kind. A com- munity spirit is engendered by the feeling of proprietorship which the people have in the use of a public building. A gymnasium of an assembly hall can be used for physical training, athlet- ics, and games. A game room or reading room, and possibly a department of the public library can be located in other parts of the building. Some rooms can be used for clubs of various kinds (social, musical, literary, debat- ing, etc.). Under the right leadership industrial activities can be included, such as sewing, cooking, and millinery for girls, manual training, photogra- phy, etc., for boys. The assembly room is used for lectures and entertain- ments, and for various social activities. School buildings are sometimes used for a supervised evening study hour, for children who have no suitable place at home. SUPERVISION — Here, as in the case of playgrounds, the secret of suc- cess is good leadership. The best plan is to have a trained organizer who can act either as assistant to the principal of the school, or at least in thorough co-operation with school policy. It is much better to have two or three such centers started in the right neighborhoods as a typical demonstration of the good use of these buildings which otherwise are unused assets in the late after- noon and evening. The obvious places for such well-developed centers are in the schools in needy districts where some few activities have already been started. It is a mistake to have all the buildings opened to recreative uses unless strong leadership is guaranteed. A trained supervisor of the social and recreative uses of school buildings can inaugurate intensive work in a few centers under trained assistants. These leaders will furnish types of work which can later be duplicated in other places. At the same time such a super- visor can be of great assistance in planning and co-operating with Parent- Teachers' Associations In the occasional uses of other buildings. In the course of the survey the school districts with the greatest needs have been studied and the results made available for school authorities and the Federa- tion of Parent-Teachers' Associations. 27 INDIANAPOLIS RECREATION SURVEY V 3. Suggestions for Development of Recreative Uses of the School Plant A policy which would improve the facilities in 'school yards and school buildings with the double purpose of making more efficient the present school activities and making the school plant available for neighborhood uses, will take into account the following considerations: (a) School yards should be enlarged in many cases so that they will pro- vide at least for a per capita space of 50 to 75 square feet. Where other fields are far from the district, the enlargement of the school yard into a playfield is by far the best solution of this phase of the recreation problem of the district. School No. 55 is a good example of such a location. (b) Should the Technical Institute grounds come into possession of the school authorities, suggestions already in mind should be followed; a stadium for high school athletic fields and a neighborhood recreation field for that part of the city. This is a splendid location for the first typical girls' and women's recreation fields. The grounds are so large that many acres can be kept in their natural state of beauty. As Pogue's Run passes through a por- tion of the grounds, a co-operative plan will doubtless be worked out with the Park Department so that the recreation features can be developed in accordance with a scheme that is consistent with the extension of. the boulevards. (c) The schoolyards have a good start in the matter of play apparatus, yet certain schools are still poorly equipped. Every yard should be well sur- faced, and most every yard should be fenced. (d) The use of school buildings for evening recreation centers should be demonstrated and put on a firm basis by opening a few buildings under trained leadership. (e) New buildings that are to be erected should be planned with the idea of recreation in mind, both for uses in school hours and the so-called extended use of the building. This can usually be done without much additional expense. Auditoriums can be planned so that they can be used as gymnasiums, if it is not possible to have a separate room for that purpose. Rooms with mov- able seats will be available both day and night, and can have a larger variety of uses than the ordinary schoolroom with fixed desks. A corridor should always be large enough for physical exercise. The industrial plant (manual training) is always a double asset. Baths are needed in several districts where it is economy to provide them in school buildings. (f) Indianapolis has a good start in the policy of intra-school athletics as opposed to an over-development of highly competitive forms of sport. Yet there is much room for stimulating athletics in the grade schools, — sports of a kind that do not require severe training. With a well-directed system of 28 INDIANAPOLIS RECREATION SURVEY school playgrounds and convenient high school fields, emphasis can be placed upon still more of the wholesome games and sports in which every one can take part. This will mean much in bringing up children with healthy bodies, hygienic habits, and a normal outlook upon life. IV. PUBLIC LIBRARIES In three ways the public library and its branches give an important contri- bution to the recreational life of the city: through the supply of good read- ing matter, through lectures and story-telling hours, and by giving the use of auditoriums for club meetings, social gatherings, gymnastics, choruses, enter- tainments, etc. Five of the Branch Libraries are in well-.equipped buildings near to schools (three immediately adjacent) and offer good opportunities for co-operation with the school plant and w^ith organizations interested in the welfare of the community. All these have halls well adapted for recreational uses. These uses are indicated in Table IX in the Appendix. The library build- ings have shown large possibilities in the way of more club uses, lectures, social gatherings, etc., where good leadership has been available. The begin- nings already made are largely due to work done by the Woman's Depart- ment Club, with the co-operation of teachers and local organizations and of the Boys' Club. This work of the Woman's Department Club has been highly commendable. V. STREETS Many of the streets in settled parts of the city are inevitably the only play space for children for some time to come. To secure other adequate play space at once in all such portions of the city would mean prohibitive expense. Several cities have met a sim.ilar situation by reserving certain of the streets where there is light traffic so that children can play there in safety at specified hours. The recre?.tion departments of such cities, or people interested in these special districts, have seen that proper supervision has been provided at such time in order to insure safety and to stimulate the children in the best u:e of the streets. Frequently parents have taken great interest in this phase of the matter. VI. PRESENT SUPERVISION OF RECREATION IN INDIANAPOLIS DIVIDED CHARACTER— Three of the departments of the city gov- ernment give more or less supervision to recreation facilities, at present. The Recreation Department of the Board of Health has had its directors and as- 29 INDIANAPOLIS RECREATION SURVEY sistants in charge of eight playgrounds and six bathing 'places in summer, and has a few indoor activities the year round. The Park Department gives a. limited amount of supervision through the issuance of permits for the use of ball fields, the operation of golf links and tennis courts, and such time as its officials can give to organizing leagues among the teams using the fields. In the schools a successful system of intra-school athletics has the assistance of some of the teachers of the high schools, in such time as they can give to it after school hours. School yards of the grade schools are open for an hour after school with regular day-school teachers in charge. They are not organ- ized playgrounds. Several private organizations are also doing a great deal in the way of furnishing recreations of a good tj^pe. Several of these have furnished supervision for activities conducted in public buildings. On the whole the divided character of the supervision of recreations in Indianapolis is the greatest obstacle to the full use of the facilities the city now has. A similar obstacle is the lack of a common policy among private organizations. NEED OF TRAINED DIRECTORS AND YEAR ROUND AC- TIVITIES — Next to its divided character the greatest need of Indianapolis, compared with other cities, is the emplo5'ment of trained recreation leaders in charge of centers of recreation in neighborhoods. Men and women trained to this work, knowing intimately the needs of the neighborhood and. living in it make the recreation center a valuable reinforcement of home life and school work. The summer playgrounds and baths have demonstrated how great num- bers can be given good opportunities for play, and swimming and bathing, by means of organized methods. In one locality where a club house has been secured, the first year-round activities have been made possible. The Park Department has extended its facilities for free public use, and has begun the organized use of ball fields in parks. The good results of this kind of service indicate the large possibilities of a regular system of trained supervision in all recreative uses of parks. Teachers with other tasks have done a good deal to direct sports and other uses of leisure in the school system. Success- ful extension in this department of school work will also depend on more paid supervision by supervisors and leaders who give their entire time to recreation leadership. 30 PART THREE Summary of Principal Needs SPECIFIC NEEDS IN BRIEF—l. Children's playgrounds can be se- cured economically by making school ^ards available. These grounds need trained supervision after school hours, in the open season, and through the summer. Several schoolyards need to be enlarged. They are too small for recess use or for adequate after-school play. 2. There are in the city no recreation centers or ''play-parks." ' Playfields — either separate or as parts of parks — are needed in the more populous dis- tricts. These are needed mainly for youth and adults. 3. In order to standardize the recreation service and show what is possi- ble, the city needs a large well-equipped recreation center and playfield, or- ganized to meet the needs of a large number of people ; a well surfaced, fenced and equipped schoolyard as a model children's playground ; and perma- nent outdoor and indoor bathing establishments of approved type. 4. In acquiring large playfields as distinguished from children's play- grounds, it will be a measure of economy for the Park Board and the School Board to co-operate in a well-understood policy. Some fields are available on park land connected with the boulevard system. Some must be separate park properties. Others can well be enlarged schoolyards. 5. The recreative uses of the outlying parks can be still further extended by more organized methods. 6. The use of school buildings as rocial and recreation centers will meet important community needs in certrin parts of the city. Such centers need trained leaders in charge, acting for the community and under school author- ity. It is logical to develop the first centers in schools that already have con- siderable use of the plant. Communit}- uses of buildings by parent-teacher associations and others should be encouraged. 7. More public bathing facilities are needed — (1) River baths such as have been operated, with permanent houses where possible; (2) outdoor pools in connection with centrally located playfields with field houses; (3) shower baths (and tub baths) in field houses or school buildings; (4) the first indoor pool or natatorium in a central location. 8. In planning new school buildings, provision should be made for physi- cal training In school houses and for the extended use of the building as a community center. This means an auditorium easily accessible and with INDIANAPOLIS RECREATION SURVEY adequate exits, arranged so that it can be used as a gymnasium, unless a sep- arate gymnasium is provided ; wide corridors and convertible rooms add much to the use of a building. Basements can be arranged for shower baths and locker-rooms. 9. Private philanthropic organizations furnishing recreation need a com- mon understanding to prevent duplication and to co-operate with public authorities in developing an adequate recreation system. 10. The greatest fundamental need is a unified administration of all the city's recreation facilities. SUPERVISION AND LEADERSHIP EMPHASIZED— Both play- grounds and recreation centers need resourceful and usually trained leader- ship. Sometimes the main emphasis has been put on the acquisition of fa- cilities without realizing the importance of supervision. No greater mistake could be made. The increasing number of cities with well-established, successful year-round public recreation systems are furnishing cumulative experience showing the necessity of securing trained directors to get the greatest possible use from the city's facilities. The organized summer play- grounds in Indianapolis have illustrated this principle. But there is an added advantage when year-round positions are created and the recreation leader becomes identified with the interests of a community or neighborhood. One city has a bare field without apparatus. Day after day scores of boys can be seen on it engaged in a variety of active sports with all the vim we have a right to expect from vigorous boys; and groups of girls on another part of the ground — the result of organization by a trained director and an assistant. Equipment is very desirable, but some ideally furnished grounds have shown disappointing results and stilted activities, because of incompetent leadership. Playgrounds have been monopolized by a few rowdies — or made unfit places for play because of no leadership. Many cities are exercising great care in the selection and training of those who have charge of play and recreation centers. These are in a true sense educational centers, for the play and the industrial work given in them are but different forms of natural and desirable activity. For this reason they should be in charge of leaders who fundamentally understand the importance of making the playtime join with home and school in the interest of complete education. NEED OF AN ADEQUATE SYSTEM— In furnishing an adequate system for Indianapolis there are certain favorable conditions, — a growing park system as a physical basis for many recreation activities, unused assets in the school yards and buildings, a system of supervised playgrounds and baths and increased funds for supervision maintenance. The nature and size of the present task is indicated by the fact that more 32 INDIANAPOLIS RECREATION SURVEY than half the population of school age (over 55,000) live in neighborhoods without permanent provision for outdoor play, and that little more than a beginning has been made in providing neighborhood indoor centers of recrea- tion. Recreation for young people over school age and for adults is important. Men and wom.en must' live as well as earn a living. The large majority of the population will be increasingly dependent upon the public recreation sys- tem for a large part of their recreational life. Predictions place this popula- tion at 305,000 in 1920 and 414,000 in 1932. The relation of good recreation to the bad influences that exist in a city, to delinquency and crime and vice, ought to be well understood. It is bad business to be spending thousands on court procedure, jails and reformatories, when smaller sums spent on constructive measures will remove many of the causes. Give the young people lots of open air, teach them good habits of exercise, and furnish them with vigorous play and joyous work, and they will habitually do these things. Active and virile boys and 5^oung men, healthy and vigorous girls and young women, with a fair outlook upon life, thrive iii a city that holds to Its natural resources and stimulates outdoor recreations, normal home and social pleasures, elevating intellectual pursuits and other refining influences in the hours of leisure. In connection with the educational system of the city hundreds of thous- ands of dollars are already being spent In the careful training of children and young people In the schools. It is poor economy to exercise great care up to one o'clock or four o'clock, and then turn youth and children on the streets to have a large part of the w^ork undone. An efficient educational system must make sure that the leisure time is operated In thorough co-operation and Is sustaining the work of the home and of the school. Hundreds of cities have recognized this fact by Incorporating supervised play and recreation into the school system, or at least under school supervision. A good recreation system — Including parks, playgrounds, baths and other recreation centers — Is a business asset for a city In the same sense that a good school system or a good transportation system Is an asset, because It makes the city a better place in which to live. The fact that lives are happier, and citizens of all ages are healthier, and that their outlook upon life is brighter, would be justification enough for an adequate recreation system, even were these other compelling reasons not operative. 33 Part Four Administration PART FOUR Administration UNIFIED ADMINISTRATION NECESSARY— In order to make use of the facilities that the city has, and to make the needed improvements, unity of action through a unified method of administration of recreation is the first essential. The Park Department has large resources in its parks and playfield sites, and its ability to acquire more fields. The School Com- mittee has its school buildings and its school yards. The Recreation Depart- ment of the Board of Health is charged with the supervision of play and recreation activities and has a considerable fund for the purpose. To get the facilities used implies a w^orking arrangement between the departments. A study of successful recreation systems in 28 cities of over 100,000 where a similar problem exists (the utilization of the resources of all departments by a unified sj^stem for supervision of activities) shows that eight of these cities have a commission, a public recreation committee, or a similar arrange- ment by which a single specially created recreation board directs recreation activities and other boards are represented; and that in two other cities a private organization uses public funds to administer the recreation facilities of the city. In eight cities Park Boards and School Boards provide for super- vision of activities, and in five of these a single general superintendent has directed the activities of both departments. In five cities the supervision of recreation activities is In the hands of the park department. While it is true that the form of administration has varied, it is likewise true that the plan of a single board or at least a common understanding by which the supervision of all recreation activities becomes unified, is absolutely necessary to bring the best results. Without some such plan a broad recrea- tion policy which meets needs in their order, and combines the resources of a city under uniformly effective supervision, is impossible. SUCH A PLAN FOR INDIANAPOLIS— A committee representing health, park, and school boards and the citizen interest appears to be the logical means of developing an adequate, unified, recreation policy in India- napolis. This, of course, implies the working out of definite arrangements consistent with the duties and policies of the boards represented. A similar plan is now in operation in a number of cities. 35 INDIANAPOLIS RECREATION SURVEY The Health Board in Indianapolis has funds for securing directors and organizers of play and recreation activities. The Park Department has not only parks and playfields, but the planning ability and the working force to make recreation grounds beautiful. The School Board has not only grounds and buildings, but the educational point of view that is fundamental in a recreation system. A public recreation committee, even with a quasi-legal status can constantly plan for recreation activities in regular meetings, always securing the approval of the boards concerned before View ^policies iare initiated. A common system of supervision under a representative board means econ- omy and efficiency in developing the recreation system. The consideration that there is possibility of friction in the use of the same facilities by two dif- ferent boards is more than offset by the useless expense involved in purchas- ing new facilities, thus duplicating suitable property already owned by the city. For this reason present facilities should be used, the exact powers of each board in relation to a given proposition clearly defined, and all boards brought to share in the working out of a common policy. An analogous case is the development of traffic and convenience in living by different boards using streets (water, electric, gas and transportation systems all involved) without obtaining new facilities elsewhere at great expense. Furthermore, the feasibility of such a plan as far as play and recreation are concerned, is attested by its successful operation In a number of cities. ESSENTIALS — The experience of other cities points to these essentials in developing a permanent, successful recreation system: (1) A superintendent, and an Increasing number of recreation directors devoting their entire time to this work. This supervisory force should be as competent as possible, trained by experience and schooling for this particu- lar work, devoting themselves exclusively to the needed activities of children, youth and adults in leisure time. (2) Regular and sufficient furnls for the maintenance and supervision of recreation. (3) A permanent board In charge of the work. The recreation superin- tendent needs the backing and the active Interest of a board or committee whose members have a primary Interest in the success of the recreation sys- tem and who in combination represent its various elements. 36 PART FIVE Recommendations I. NEXT STEPS IN SECURING RECREATION FACILITIES A UNIFIED PLAN AND POLICY— A policy in keeping with plans of the public and private authorities concerned with recreation, leads to the following suggestions for the immediate future. These involve as a first step, natural and suitable working arrangements between various authorities, pub- lic and private, now controlling facilities. Administration from this stand- point has been discussed. PLAYGROUNDS ' FOR CHILDREN— The operation of children's grounds in summer at locations where there is free use of grounds and ad- jacent buildings, viz: the Court House, Christamore Settlement, opposite Butler Memorial on South Meridian Street, next to the library at Norw^ood, and at Brightwood Clubhouse. Summer use of a number of schoolyards selected from the following: Schools No. 7, 12, 31, 22, 39, 9, 26, 2, 5, 24, 52, 53, and others. One or two of these to be surfaced and equipped as model school yard grounds. Another possible location is near School 16 and the Lauter Memorial Building. If possible, after school hours and Sat- urdays, in the open season. Spring and Fall, trained play-leaders should be placed on school yards. Children's playgrounds on park spaces adjacent to thickly settled districts need play-leaders, in case no schoolyard organized as a playground is near; for example, Military Park, Spade's Place, etc. PLAYFIELDS FOR YOUTH AND ADULTS— WiUard Park, to be graded and equipped for baseball and other sports, so that an organized field can be operated; then the completion of the plan for a recreation center there as a standard for this type of play-park. A South Side field to be purchased near the most thickly settled part of the South Side, and to be graded, equipped and organized. A colored boys' playground has been recently acquired on Almont Street in Ward 1, and will be operated. Playfields west and north of the Capitol are needed. The Merritt Playground should soon be im- proved. Another location is needed further east to serve the colored popula- tion^ either side of Indiana Avenue. BATHING AND SWIMMING — Supervised swimming places in sum- mer on the banks of streams and other locations to be continued, as they are 37 INDIANAPOLIS RECREATION SURVEY an economical method of serving large numbers. Outdoor pools ought to be a part of the improvement of certain playgrounds or playiieids. A central, permanent, year-round bathing establishment is much needed (see Future Development), and the plan for its location and improvement should be made. An economical means of giving bathing opportunities to children (and adults as well) in some districts is by installing shower baths and tub baths in school buildings. RECREATIVE USES OF LARGER PARKS— At Riverside, Garfield and other parks more of ihe organized methods such as have already been initiated to stimulate baseball and other field sports, tennis, golf, canoeing, family-parties, picnic groups, etc., etc. A trained supervisor is needed for this purpose, with directors at Riverside, Garfield, Brookside, Willard Park, etc. INDOOR NEIGHBORHOOD CENTERS— (1) Needed neighbor- hood recreations and useful occupations can be increased indoors by the use of school buildings after school hours and evenings. The Parent-Teachers' Association, in co-operation with other representative organizations, is study- ing local needs and approved methods so as to present a feasible plan. The employment of trained leadership is the first essential. The good uses made of the libary buildings has been demonstrated by the Women's Depart- ment Club, and should be extended. (2) Private organizations with ade- quate buildings can organize more needed activities in their communities. SUPERVISION — (1) The employment of permanent, trained direct- ors and supervisors. This is essential to develop a year-round recreation sys- tem such as exists in other cities and is needed here. Such directors are needed to develop the recreative uses of parks, to administer the recreation center or play-park and field house with indoor activities, and in order to carry on the more extended use of school buildings. (2) Training courses with consequent increased efficiency of directors, play-leaders and assistants on playgrounds. Similar courses for those wish- ing to engage in play and recreation leadership. PRIVATE ORGANIZATIONS— In the course of the survey it was found that a plan had some time ago been suggested for federating the work of private organizations doing neighborhood work. This would admirably ■meet one of the needs of the situation. At present, organizations doing work for children and 3^oung people, and some settlement associations, are independently extending their activities. A common plan is needed to increase the number of effective neighborhood centers under trained leadership and prevent duplication. Plans for common sources of support through contributions, or at least saving in managerial expense, can be worked out. At the same time the individual identity of organizations and their 38 INDIANAPOLIS RECREATION SURVEY vested interests can be preserved, if desirable or necessary. Such a common organization will be of inestimable help to the public recreation system. It can conduct recreation activities on a larger scale, and can co-operate with and supplement public playgrounds and recreation centers just as individual organizations are doing in a measure at the present time. II. FUTURE DEVELOPMENT OF AN ADEQUATE RECREATION SYSTEM After the next steps suggested have been instituted, the further progress in securing adequate facilities for the recreation of young and old in India- napolis should be made with the following objects in view: (1) Increasing the number of children's playgrounds year by year by operating more schoolyards in summer. In many districts in Spring and Fall these yards, now open till 4 P. M., should be under play-leaders and open for a longer time. (2) Additional playfields, a half-mile radius covering the natural district served. The Merritt Playground, the ground at West Indianapolis, at Brookside Park, and at locations on Fall Creek, are the next natural points in the present park system. But to meet needs in their order, new park and school properties should be considered in a common policy. The next devel- opment should be at the Technical Institute grounds, with fields for High School pupils and a community center for all ages. Certain enlarged school yards can serve as fields. (3) Additional indoor recreation centers planned for districts as needed, by the use of school buildings, field houses and club houses. In this case, also, a half-mile radius usually covers the natural district served. (4) Bathing facilities — A permanent bath-house, outdoor and indoor baths, at the Military Park site. In time the temporary summer river baths made permanent, by acquiring sites and erecting bath houses. Outdoor pools near the field houses of playfields in congested districts. Basements or other parts of school buildings fitted with baths, and new buildings planned with this possibility in view. (5) New Activities — Two influences, the increase in the number of peo- ple engaged in recreation leadership as a profession here, and suggestions from the park and recreation development in other large cities will suggest numbers of new activities. Outdoors, among the children, these are count- less. Indoor games and other pursuits likewise have great variety. In play- parks and scenic parks, baseball, football, golf and tennis are always the "popular" sports; but more of other games like outdoor bowling, cricket, field-hockey, and lacrosse come with organization. Winter sports are possi- ble in season. Regular music festivals and pageants may become organized 39 INDIANAPOLIS RECREATION SURVEY parts of the recreation system. Trained leadership and the increasing empha- sis on the educational bearing of recreation bring certain industrial activities prominently forward. Manual training, domestic science, and other useful pursuits as equipment and leadership are provided, should become more com- mon at recreation centers. (6) Commercial recreations, being the largest factor in furnishing amuse- ments, must maintain high standards through co-operation or by control. This result can be best obtained in Indianapolis if present laws are enforced and well intentioned managers encouraged to conduct amusements of the best class. But civic bodies concerned with this matter should keep informed of conditions and co-operate to prevent deterioration. If conditions should make it necessary, an additional system' of inspection and censorship in connection with granting or withholding licenses is possible. A thorough discussion of the principles that underlie municipal regulation of commercial recreation is contained in the March, 1914, issue of "The Playground." 40 APPENDIX A. The Recreation Value of Commercial Recreations and Their Regulation. B. Tables. C. Maps. A. The Recreation Value of i Commercial Re- creations and their Regulation MOTION PICTURES — To estimate the social effect of motion pictures is as difficult as to estimate that of the modern newspaper, because of the various elements to be considered. The quality of films supplied has im- proved and it has become possible for judicious managers to show^ on the average better subjects than formerly. In most houses a certain number of distinctly educational films appear. The great majority are comic or romantic drama, w^ith the "feature films" becoming more numerous. These vary from those of the highest excellence to an objectionable form of over-heightened melodrama. A fair statement of the good that should be recognized and the influences that should be avoided in the motion picture show^s is about as follow^s: Their great popularity and the large combined attendance means that here is a tremendous social force. Its attractive powder is due to the fact that for a few^ cents one can suddenly become the absorbed w^itness of stirring scenes. The oJieap admission has made the motion picture house in a real sense the people's theatre. Family groups frequently attend, especially in the neighbor- hood houses. The impression made by an appeal to the eye constitutes an educational opportunity w^hen the right subjects are displayed. On the other hand, the same powder to impress makes the bad film a source of evil. A mediocre form of amusement results from the superficial character of a num- ber of films that are classed as "drama." Lov^^ standard of taste may result from the exaggerated sentimentality and heightened melodrama of some films. By co-operation v^^ith managers w^ho realize these points, or by censorship, if that should become necessary, the best standards need to be maintained. Working people (and the motion picture is largely an adult amusement) evidently find value in the physical rest and new mental occupation after hard work. On the other hand, for the young especially, the habit of attendance 41 INDIANAPOLIS RECREATION SURVEY at any form of passive amusement ought not to take the place of active recreation. POOL ROOMS — A good indication of conditions under w^hich pool and billiards are played is derived from a study of 56 of the dow^n-tov^^n places. More than 25 per cent, of these are in small rooms. One-third of the rooms are in the basement or in a second story, the remainder being on the first floor. In tw70-thirds the ventilation is decidedly poor, and in a larger propor- tion the lighting facilities are not good. Careful estimates as to the attitude of the managers of pool rooms toward gambling and the admission of minors, shows that less than 20 per cent, are strict in this respect, and that the remain- der are either indifferent, lax, or consistently loose in their management. Giving due credit to a few places that are being well-managed, and where every effort is made to run a respectable place, the fact remains that the average pool room cannot be entered without encountering bad langauge and atmosphere, and incipient gambling. The latter evil seems almost inseparable from the great majority of pool rooms. (The large number of games played on a table readily lend themselves to wagers, and side bets by the bystanders and onlookers are frequent. Places with cigar stands usually have a dice box.) In fact, a large number of establishments would prove unprofitable without the opportunity for these things. Even where the management is strict, gambling can go on without being detected, or can be conducted in such a way that it is not natural or easy to restrict it. Pool and billiards are games of skill that are in themselves attractive, the former especially to young men, and the latter to a smaller number of de- votees. They ought to be provided under good conditions. Establishments that have as the basis of their trade the pure attraction of these games, and nothing else, are not numerous. The democracy of the pool room, the fact that it provides a center where men can do about as they like and find companionship, is an element in its attraction to great numbers. It is for this reason that everything possible should be done to provide good attractive meeting places for -men under the very best of conditions, with something active that they like to do. Large numbers evidently do not get the social companionship they want without resorting to the poolroom or the saloon. A considerable proportion seek rooms in bad surroundings because they like them. Evidently the social con- dition which is at the basis of this problem will not be materially improved without a persistent campaign of education affecting the habits of young men. PUBLIC DANCES — Visits to a number of public dances show much variety in character. In several instances proprietors are managing well-con- ducted affairs with every attempt to observe tlie proprieties and prevent the attendance of undesirable persons. In others there is laxity, particularly in regard to tlie surroundings of tlie dance. The general admission of the public 42 INDIANAPOLIS RECREATION SURVEY at such dances means a certain inevitable percentage of questionable charact- ers. In a few cases this laxity is noticeable, particularly at late hours, in the kind of dancing, drinking, and general unconventional conduct. In considering the dance as a form of amusement, a sound point of view is necessary. It must be recognized that dancing in its broadest sense is popular in response to two natural instincts, — the desire for expressing abounding spirits in motion and rhythm, and the mutual desire of young men and women for companionship and social acquaintance. These may often be met in other ways, but the dance is popular because it has this double attraction. On account of the danger of evil being encountered by those who seek innocent pleasure, it is essential that dancing shall take place under the best possible conditions. This can be achieved by regulation, and by constructive meas- ures. Neighborhood centers with all kinds of activity are needed. If danc- ing is included, this kind, w^ith a natural basis of acquaintanceship, is the best sort. Because of the large floating population that inevitably patronize "down town" dances, it is also necessary to safeguard their character by regu- lation. It is likewise to be noted that municipal dances as operated in other cities are another means of meeting this phase of the public amusement situation. MAINTENANCE OF STANDARDS— Though the law does not pro- vide for the inspection of motion picture films in Indianapolis, the situ'ation in that respect is much better than in many large cities. The licenses for amusement houses refer only to matters pertaining to the buildings, their location and arrangements for safety and sanitation. Without any outside regulation other than official and public opinion, several of the best motion picture houses have set a standard in the character of the films displayed that^ has had a good effect on the general standard of all the houses. Most all of this business is locally owned and managed. Thus far it has been possible for fairly good standards to prevail, through the initiative of the managers themselves. The outright objectionable film has been the exception. It appears occasion^.Uy. Under present conditions, it seems possible for the leaders of enlightened public opinion to gain through co-operation a standard that other cities have had to maintain through a system of film inspection. How- ever, the business is so large and its influence so important that public opin- ion, represented by public authorities and civic organizations, should be in- formed as to conditions, and ready with suggestions as to improvement. Should conditions change for the worse, a system of film inspection is advisable. Such systems are in operation in Cleveland, Detroit and Kansas City. An ordinance of 1906 requires each dance not held In a private residence to be licensed. The character of the public dance in Indianapolis can be and has been to an extent controlled through the licensing power in the hands of 43 INDIANAPOLIS RECREATION SURVEY the Police Department. To have the requisite knowledge on which to base the granting or withholding of a license, so as to guard the character of dances, most cities have found it necessary to authorize the presence at public dances of an officer or some person representing the licensing authority. In Indianapolis this is not required. An ordinance of 1913 requires the presence of a matron at all public dances, and it is the practice for those managing dances to have such a person present. The success of the authorities in carry- ing out the intent of this ordinance appears to depend upon the extent to which such matrons act in the interest of the public. The effect of this regu- lation depends upon the co-operation of those managing the affair. They hire the matrons who are naturally responsible to them first. Among the regulations that have proved effective elsewhere in meeting some of the bad conditions that exist are the following : ( 1 ) Absolute prohibition of the sale of liquor at a public dance, or in the building where such a dance is held. (2) No granting of return checks, so that saloons in the neighbor- hood may not be patronized in intermissions. (In some instances a number of intermissions are lengthened to allow drinking). (3) Reasonable hours of closing. (4) Regular inspection by police, not only to regulate the dance, but- to report conditions on which licenses can be withheld or other penalties imposed. The activity of police authorities in suppressing gambling has already had marked effect on the conditions in poolrooms. In several instances the failure of proprietors to renew poolroom licenses has been due to this activity. Evi- dently the worst poolrooms cannot conduct business at a profit without gam- bling. Rigid enforcement of law must be the chief means of improvement in conditions at it puts a premium on men seeking amusement in respectable places. ■ ' B . Tables TABLE ] .. ' CAPACITY AND ESTD4ATED ATTENDANCE AT EXHIBITION AMUSEMENTS Type Houses Capacity Weekly Attendance Motion Picture Shows in Center of Town 22 8,316 166,320 Neighborhood Motion Picture Shows 48 18,142 154,207 Vaudeville and Burlesque (in two motion pictures combined) 7 9,400 75,200 Legitimate Drama and Opera 3 4,956 24,780 80* 40,814 420,780 *(Not counting 13 air domes.) 44 INDIANAPOLIS RECREATION SURVEY TABLE II LIST OF THEATRES AND MOVING PICTURE SHOWS WITH LOCATION AND TYPE OF HOUSE AS GIVEN BY THE CITY CONTROLLER'S DEPARTMENT LOCATION NAME TYPE OF HOUSE — A— 19 S. Addison St. — B— 1660 Bellefontaine St. Blaine & Howard Blake & Ohio Blaine & Howard 443 N. Blake — C— 2451 Central 2959 Central 4005 Cornelius Ave. 19th & College 2407 College 19th & College — D— Del. btw. Market & Ohio N. Delaware Hilltop Amusement Co. Emerald Theatre Cap. City Amusement Co. Stratford Theatre Comique Columbia Theatre Hench Opera House Airdome Moving Picture Airdome Airdome Moving Picture Moving Picture Moving Picture Moving Picture Airdome Motion Picture Motion Picture Motion Picture Burlesque 801 S. East 1129 S. East — F— 505 Fulton St. 951 Ft. Wayne Ave. — G— Gale & 25th — H— Hudson & 16th Appollo Theatre Fotoplay Amusement Co. Motion Picture Motion Picture Airdome Moving Picture Moving Picture People's Amusement Co. Moving Picture 443 Indiana Ave. Our Theatre Moving Picture 524 Indiana Ave. Columbia Theatre Moving Picture 784-6 Indiana Ave. Moving Picture 521 Indiana Ave. Moving Picture 118 S. Illinois St. Moving Picture 131 S. Illinois St. Moving Picture 111. btw. Md. & Ga. Majestic Burlesque 19 S. Illinois St. Vaudette Motion Picture 2175 N. Illinois St. Motion Picture 134-38 N. Illinois St. Motion Picture 119 N. Illinois St. Crystal Motion Picture 135 N. Illinois St. Lyric Motion P. & Vaude. Illinois & New York Colonial Motion P. & Vaude. 45 INDIANAPOLIS RECREATION SURVEY LOCATION NAME TYPE OF HOUSE — K— 15-17 Kentucky Ave. Family Theatre Vaudeville — L— London & 30% Sts. Motion Picture ~M— 16-18 W. Market St. Royal Theatre Motion Picture 113 W. Market St. Starland Theatre Motion Picture 2508-10 W. Michigan St. Motion Picture 2540 W. Michigan St. Palace Amusement Co. Motion Picture 2208. W. Michigan St. Motion Picture 2627 W. Michigan St. West Side Theatre Motion Picture 2129 E. Michigan St. Motion Picture Mass. Ave. & St. Clair Idle Hour Amusement Co. Motion Picture 430-32 Mass. Ave. Iroquois Amusement Co. Motion Picture 922 Mass. Ave. Motion Picture 858 So. Meridian Princess Amusement Co. Motion Picture Meridian & Kansas Motion Picture 1751 So. Meridian St. Motion Picture 1101 So. Meridian St. Oriental Theatre Motion Picture Martindale & 19th Sts. Atlas Theatre Motion Picture Monument Place. English Opera House Theatre & Opera —N— New Jersey & Mass. Ave. Shubert Murat Theatre & Opera Northwestern & 25th St. Motion Picture 2628 Northwestern Motion Picture Noble & Michigan Noble Theatre Motion Picture 4020 E. New York Airdome 711 W. New York Airdome 733 N. Noble 1223 Oliver Ave. Liberty Amusement Co. Airdome Savoy Theatre Motion Picture — P — 1106 Prospect St. Motion Picture Penn. htw. Market & Ohio B. F. Keith's Vaudeville — ^R — 1502 Roosevelt Motion Picture Roosevelt & 16th Airdome Raymond &- Shelby Airdome — s— 1117 Shelby Motion Picture 1319 N. Senate Motion Picture Sixteenth & Yandes Airdome 1320 E. 16th Motion Picture — T— 2735 E. Twenty-fifth Motion Picture 2116 E. Tenth Hamilton Amusement Co. Motion Picture 2127 E. Tenth Airdome 2925 E. Tenth Pastime Theatre Motion Picture Talbot & 22nd North Side Amusement Co. Motion Picture 46 INDIANAPOLIS RECREATION SURVEY LOCATION NAME TYPE OF HOUSE — U— 1075 Udell St. — V— 533 Virginia Ave. 1044-46 Virginia Ave. 733 Virginia Ave. — V^— 2104 E. Washington St. 2206 E. Washington St. 2442 E. Washington St. 2700 E. Washington St. 130 E. Washington St. E. Wash, near N. Jersey 504 E. Washington St 431 E. Washington St. 1248 E. Washington St. 136 W. Washington St. W. Washington St. 3005 W. Washington St. 430 W. Washington St. Wash. & Capitol Ave. Wash, near Illinois St. 1202 N. West St. Motion Picture Continental Amusement Co. Motion Picture Motion Picture Virginia Theatre Motion Picture Cosmos Theatre Tacoma Electric Theatre Twilight Theatre Bijou Gayety Scenic Theatre Vista Amusement Co. Gem Theatre Manhattan Theatre Best Theatre Lyceum Theatre Alhambra Manilla Theatre Motion Picture Motion Picture Motion Picture Airdome Motion Picture Vaudeville Motion Picture Motion- Picture Motion Picture Motion Picture Motion Picture Motion Picture Motion Picture Theatre Motion Picture Motion Picture SHOOTING GALLERIES AND SKATING RINKS LOCATION 428 Indiana Ave. . Galleries 116 S. Illinois St. Galleries 852 Massachusetts Ave. Galleries 527 Massachusetts Ave. Galleries 635^ W. Washington St. Galleries Riverside ^ Galleries Riverside Rink 47 INDIANAPOLIS RECREATION SURVEY TABLE III JUVENILE DELINQUENCY IN INDIANAPOLIS, APRIL 1, 1912, TO MARCH 31, 1913 Facts furnished by Miss Isabelle Somerville -. )>■'»,■>«-•" CLASSIFICATION OF OFFENSES Offenses Against Property Petit Larcency ... 160 Grand Larcency 4 Trespass 3 Burglary 4 Housebreaking . . 3 Receiving Stolen Goods 1 Arson 2 Malicious trespass 19 196 Offenses Against Public Order Idling and Loitering 26 Incorrigibility .... 103 Shooting in city limits 2 Truancy 40 Carrying Concealed Weapons 2 Jumping on cars ..11 Drunkeness . .• 1 Disorderly conduct 8 Profanity 2 Running Away. . . 3 Gaming 9 Immorality 27 Offenses Against Persons Assault and Battery 30 Drawing Deadly Weapons 1 234 Total 461 SUMMARY BY MONTHS Boys April, 1912 36 May, 1912 38 June, 1912 33 July, 1912 37 August, 1912 21 September, 1912 24 Girls Boys Girls 5 October, 1912 ... .. 30 .7 14 November, 1912 .. .. 31 12 11 December, 1912 .. .. 28 5 10 January, 1913 . . . .. 36 6 11 February, 1913 .. .. 27 8 11 March, 1913 .... .. 15 5 189 62 167 43 Total, 461 48 INDIANAPOLIS RECREATION SURVEY TABLE IV PARK LANDS— AREA AND EQUIPMENT FOR ACTIVE RECREATION Matron and NAME OF PARK ACRES ^?^1' Tennis Golf Children's Fields Courts Holes Canoeing Pia- Space Riverside (1) 930 8 9 45 X X Garfield (1) 128.52 3 4 X Brookside (1) 93.05 5 6 X Woollen's Garden (1) .... 44 Ellenberger's Woods (1) ... 31.70 1 2 6 Military Park (owned by X State (2) 17.3 Willard Park (3) 14.71 ♦ Fall Creek Parkway 190.19 White River Parkway 45.55 (Geo. Merrit Playground 36.22) (3) Brookside Parkway 34.09 • Pleasant Run Parkway .... 52.24 Burdsal Parkway 11.49 Spades Place (1) 10.4 3 X University Sq. (owned by State) 4 St. Clair Sq. (owned by State) 3 y Greenlawn 8 Highland Square (2) 3.98 " X Morris Square (2) 1.95 X Indianola Square (2) 1.62 X McCarty Place (2) 1.22 X Noble Place 95 Fletcher Triangle 73 Irving Circle 53 (1) Scenic Parks with Active Sports. (2) Squares with children's play space. (3) Undeveloped fields or play parks. 49 III ^ IB ^ a 05 CS .„ fa. 6Q fl05 (- 0) g <5 ft« o o 02 ?5 COtJi ^ CO W in r-( (N CO t-h rt iM (M (M W (N r-l !M CO O'-lN'*THO«DOi( NiHc6t-^ri*OOo6'COU5 C^(:OiX>t-COI:--*COCO«5COt-TtilOCD«OiN»Or-l-*THCO?DlO(NCOCOW* tJH^OCDiNWIOtHiHCDIN r-tweo-^io^or^ooffic iMCOCC'Hc-lOO.HeO'-tiHMCH »0 rHr-M00MrgeOr-l(NC^rHlH© rl C^ WW N ■*■* NW NN oot-ooeo T-! ,H 05lOOOCOrMW5«Dr-l'*OiWOOlO»Ct-MOO T-l,HC0lCCDC0»0T-lCDlCl-00(N«0O(M«?»OrH00(N tH 63 oo-*b-ooO'*worHU5eo(Mooo© oifflooo -^o r3 5P OO00(MOOOC0iHiM(M00l^0i< >1 X X M t< ^ X >< M >^. X>< y. MX X xxxx X X >i XX X XXX xxxM KMtHTN-H ^■^^THrt^^T-l(N^c^ ^i-i ^ ^(N' oo CO CO oo >-^ o ^ o r; o o •^ !«i _5 X X i«l M t- O — :^ ^ in lO o o o -sD :c OOOr^-nOOOO ^ ^„. w. 1-lrM^ X X -* rt< Oi-: ............. OOi^OO (M CO (MM iHCO M (M s to •a d 1 ^ &0 60 fl fl 1- «5 H L-5 o o o xo CD X o l-t- o « X--; X X •-; X >< X X X « o O O 3 l.O o S i-t o LO o oo X lOTjf^Ct ■* -C>Tt1C0 •* CD cot- o ^ ^ i t/ i»i>i . < h > li HIS Map represents the location of the youthful population (5 the school census districts. 21 years), based on Areas showing an avr rage of 301 to 500 in 40 acres •■ 251 to 300 " " 201 to 250 " 151 to 200 " 101 to ISO " 51 to 100 " to 50 " Certain parts of large outlying districts marked VI and VII have portions in them where the con- gestion is much greater than indi- cated. As far as the play of small children is concerned these belong to more congested types. . In other respects they are better sit- uated because of open districts near at hand Parks and cemeteries are not included in the reckoning of areas. Streets and alleys are included.