mmmm ./A/v^A. f\/JS .' aaA' */*/*> . . ^AAA.Ai- aAAT^a <^AAf &WV\J?Vl I LIBRARY OF CONGRESS. Jl Lopgnghi ;Ya. . $ IJ UNITED STATES OF AMERICA. j ^W^aA.A, till w^MWM WS !\aA'a! iAiiaH^I Bra la'^sfiS '/AA'x'A rronT MJJdMJ i«i ximo. A'S^K W&MMkwmmm, mmmm m*mM0^mm» mmmmm^ te£i*«Sf «K«*dlt*af£fcQ!!riM TNH"i v ^^ Wmmm '^m ikMM^ mM&3 STEPS TO A LIVING FAITH : %cttct$ to an ^nfciffcrcnt 2$dicto& A TKACT FOE PAEISH USE. BISHOP OF ^CENTRAL NEW YOEK. -f- IT^N NEW YORK : E. P. DUTTON AND COMPANY, 713 Broadway. 1873. A "' \\& Entered according to Act of Congress, in the year 1873, by E. P. DUTTON AND COMPANY, in the Office of the Librarian of Congress,,. RIVERSIDE, CAMBRIDGE: STEREOTYPED AND PRINTED BY H. 0. HOUGHTON AND COMPANY. These letters were written to meet an actual inquiry. It has been thought that they might be of some further service if transferred from the periodical — " The Churchman " — where they were first printed, to a pamphlet by themselves. This does not relieve me of the responsibility of the present publication, but it accounts for it. F. D. HUNTINGTON. Syracuse, Feast of the Conversion of St. Paul, 1873. STEPS FROM A LIFELESS BELIEF TO A LIVING FAITH : BEING LETTERS TO AN INDIFFERENT BELIEVER. LETTER I. My dear Friend: You ask counsel because you need help. According to your own account, the state of your rnind is this : Intellectually, but no farther, you accept the Christian Revelation. Per- haps it would be more strictly accurate to say that you do not deny its truth, because you see no yalid reasons for denying it, or because you are not able to produce such reasons. It is rather a passive than an active assent. You are not disposed and not able to dispute the historical facts re- corded in the Christian Scriptures. You understand that for nearly eighteen hun- 6 STEPS TO A LIVING FAITH. dred years the Record of those facts has been lying in the full view of the sharpest critics and most thorough scholars of the successive generations ; that, from various motives, many gifted and learned men, all along, have done their best to discover defects in that record, or to break up the evidence of its authenticity, by every line of argument that you are able to conceive of ; that to argument they have often added ridicule, satire, and abuse, in their keenest and most fascinating forms ; and yet that none of these strenuous efforts of unbelief, whether springing from pride, ambition, impatience of religious restraint, or the passion for independent investiga- tion, have been able to make a very pro- found or lasting impression on the general conviction of the reading and thinking world that what is related in the New Testament is true. All that has been ad- duced by way of objection has been fairly met and answered by students, who have devoted their lives impartially to the in- quiry. STEPS TO A LIVING FAITH. 7 You also understand that the men who wrote these Scriptures, for the most part certainly, had the best possible opportu- nity, as eye-witnesses or otherwise, to know whether what they declared was true or not; that many of them were subjected to every kind of test and trial in their tes- timony, and suffered every kind of loss, agony, persecution, even to exile and martyrdom, for the sake of it ; that they lived consistent and pure lives, and were evidently made more upright, charitable, and devout, by what they believed and reported. All this you are ready to ad- mit. Furthermore, seeing that these Scrip- tures contain certain teachings or doc- trines, as well as narratives and statements of fact, and that the facts are the basis of the doctrines, and that the history is so interwoven with the moral and spiritual instruction that they cannot be taken apart without utterly destroying the integrity and sense of the writing, you are not pre- pared to reject the teachings themselves. 8 STEPS TO A LIVING FAITH. Some of them are plainer and easier to receive than others ; some require expla- nation ; some deal with matters that are mysterious; some are in debate among Christians. But you have learned that this is what might be naturally expected from the character of the subjects touched, from the circumstance that the text of the Sacred Books has passed through a process of translation by which shades of meaning are modified, and from the con- fessed tendency of the human mind to put constructions on language suiting it to its own preconceived ideas or preferences. You are obliged to acknowledge that, in spite of all differences and all obscurities, there is a body of well-ascertained and gen- erally received religious doctrine taught in the Bible. It is so received by a vast majority of those who have been in sym- pathy with the spirit of the Revelation, who have sought its real signification with docility, and have made a cheerful obe- dience % to its practical requirements one of the guiding lights to its interpretation. STEPS TO A LIVING FAITH. 9 Drawing an obvious distinction between those things in the subject-matter which are essential to its life, as well as essential to constitute a Christian in belief and character, and certain other things con- tained which are not so essential — a dis- tinction clearly made out within the Revelation itself — you acknowledge that there is as good an agreement respecting the former as could be reasonably ex- pected, considering the nature of religion as a spiritual reality, and considering the imperfection of words as a medium of communication. Moreover, you are aware that in certain great, ancient, and power- ful Christian organizations, claiming to have a common origin and a common interior life — claiming to be able to dem- onstrate an unbroken historical existence from the beginning, with invariable marks of identification, and therefore pronounced branches of one Church, there has come down, from the earliest Christian age, a Declaration or summary, in two con- cordant shapes, of these vei;y facts and 10 STEPS TO A LIVING FAITH. doctrines — -the essential matter of the Faith : the Creed of the Apostles. Again you observe an inseparable con- nection between the prevalence of this Faith and the welfare of our Race. In all human history since Christ came, civiliza- tion and Christianity are found together. The first never exists in its highest form without the second. The second never exerts its peculiar power freely, without producing the first. There were forms of society before Christ came, and outside of Judea, where the intellectual arts reached a rare measure of cultivation. So we sometimes speak of a Phoenician or a Greek civilization. But the term is rel- ative. No other civilization deserves a moment's comparison with the Christian. As soon as Christianity prevailed any- where, a new and higher social type was manifested. No ideal of human excel- lence has transcended the Christian stand- ard. No heroism has been more glorious, no kind of moral dignity more majestic, no domestic virtue more chaste, no mer- STEPS TO A LIVING FAITH. 11 cantile honor more immaculate, than the Christian ethics demand. It has every- where been put beyond cavil by experi- ment, that mankind are every way better for the Gospel. Go where you will and make up a catalogue of those attributes or qualities which belong to the higher social state, you discover, on comparison, that they are the very same which are emphatically enjoined in the New Testament, and that they actually appear in the world in pro- portion as the entire Christian morality, propagated and supported by the ordi- nances of the Gospel, penetrates the private life and controls the public action of the people. You are not blind to the logical inferences from this recognized law, or to the immense confirmation it lends to the claims of Revelation. This, then, is your attitude. Intel- lectually you are a Christian ; because nothing in your intellect, on the whole, denies the religion of Christ. Negatively you are a Christian ; your adherence to 12 STEPS TO A LIVING FAITH. this religion, if it can be called such, consists rather in not denying, than in pos- itively embracing and asserting it. Pas- sively and nominally you are a Chris- tian ; because, while belonging to a nation or community called Christian, you offer no conscious or intentional opposition to this religion : though you neither avow personal allegiance to it, nor make any resolute endeavor to promote or establish it. You are not an infidel, or even a skeptic. You are not an atheist, because you believe in God. You are not a pan- theist, because you believe God to be a person. You are not a rationalist, be- cause, when you reflect, you acknowledge an authority in Religion above your own or any human reason. If you reckon your- self in with any eccelesiastical or denomi- national body it is still only speculatively that you belong to it, because your prefer- ence leads to no practical result, and tastes are not convictions. You may hang loosely upon a religious society, but are not joined vitally to any. STEPS TO A LIVING FAITH. 13 You are not quite certain, I think, whether you were brought by the faith of others, as a child, into a covenant relation with the Body of Christ, in the Sacrament of Baptism, or not ; you are not concerned about that ; if you were so brought to baptism, you have taken no heed of the relation, and have done nothing to prove yourself a " very member incorporate " in the Body. Owing to some instincts that you have never taken the trouble to account for, or some traditional notions that render the Christian name respectable, you would re- , sent it as a wrong, possibly as an affront, if you should be refused that name, Chris- tian. But you do not pretend that the amount of your title to it is more than I have represented. I have taken pains to mark out your position in these respects somewhat more fully than you have done it in the few intimations you have given me, with a particular object. It is important to any right use of what is to follow that we note 14 STEPS TO A LIVING FAITH. with equal care what you receive, or con- cede, of the system of Divine Truth, and what you do not. I am especially desir- ous to have it understood that your diffi- culties are not those of an absolute un- believer. Let no reader of these papers suppose that what has here been said, inciden- tally, of the proofs of Revelation, is in- tended as a formal answer to those that deny its truth. I have only alluded to two or three lines of the manifold argu- ment. It is sadly true that the class of doubters is large, nor is it difficult to detect the causes of its recent increase. Many of these skeptics are but very superficially acquainted with the real grounds of the Christian belief. The neglect of Christian history, in our sys- tems of education, has long been amazing. We are beginning to see that it is disas- trous. What is needed as much, perhaps, as anything for the arrest of speculative un- belief, is an appreciation of our Religion in STEPS TO A LIVING FAITH. 15 its historical character. That is, Chris- tianity is a matter of fact. A notion extensively prevails that it is entirely or chiefly a matter of opinions, sentiments, feelings, interior states, or else of abstract principles. The vast importance of all these in relation to practical results and personal conduct is not to be overlooked. The end of Christianity is character ; the production in man of that likeness to Christ which is the supreme manifesta- tion on the earth of the glory of God. There the divine and human elements meet in their intended reconciliation ; the Incarnation becomes a perpetual re- deeming power ; with the second Adam is a new creation. But there is a popular confusion of ideas as respects two closely related and yet actually different things; namely, the Christianity of personal char- acter on the one hand, and, on the other, Christianity as a tangible reality outside of our personality, a whole body of facts or- ganically wrought together and ascertained as any other facts are ascertained, an ob- 16 STEPS TO A LIVING FAITH. jective, solid substance, an institution of God, a visible and definable thing that He has given to men and set up on the earth. We can look at it, study it, identify it ; it must be accounted for, for there it is. If we think we can account for it without Revelation, or in any other way than that which Revelation opens, why, we can try it. Some men have tried ; with what success you know. But if we put all this body of historical facts out of view, and undertake to conceive of Christianity as wholly a matter of internal states, or in- dividual ideas, it is obvious that there can be no certainty, no definiteness, no fixed- ness, no standard or criterion, about it. Some will agree about it, and some will differ. Logically there may be as many Christianities as there are individuals. All those internal states, dispositions, principles, that make up a Christ-like character, are the fruit of that revealed, embodied Christianity of facts, opening out from God, containing a law of authority and a life-giving energy, originating in STEPS TO A LIVING FAITH. 17 Jesus Christ born of Mary, " the Word made flesh," and disclosed in divine beauty through Him to the eyes and hearts of mankind. Around his person, and stretching down the ages from the track He trod and the cross where He died, is a broad and luminous belt of kindred, clearly attested verities, further facts, but al£ of them parts of one Whole. Were our religion to be approached more generally under this representation, it is probable that multitudes would take a new kind of interest in it, that many loose and fluctuating notions respecting it would be replaced by a settled confidence, and that to these multitudes the expres- sions " Kingdom of Heaven " and " Church of God " would take on a new significa- tion. Errors of opinion would be found to have been thrust into association with these facts by mortal hands ; but they would also be found to be separable, be- cause the tests of facts, including the origi- nal Records, the historical events, and the visible institutions are so much simpler 2 18 STEPS TO A LIVING FAITH. and more satisfactory than the tests of mere speculation. There are three classes of unbelievers : 1. Unbelievers who are so from a natural slowness and hardness to believe ; consti- tutional doubters, congenital Thomases, — who have taken little trouble to be rid of their defect, and so suffer a contin- ual loss of faith and peace. 2.* Unbe- lievers from other men's misrepresenta- tions of the Faith, from false education, from the sincere blunders of mistaken theologians, and from the bad lives and small graces of avowed but inconsistent believers. 3. Unbelievers from taste and choice, from the conceit of being sharper and wiser than the ages, from an ambi- tion to sit in the pride of individual judg- ment on Bible, Church, and all other authority, — unbelievers having in them the spirit and temper of doubt and a relish of denial. You are not, I assume, to be reckoned in with either of these classes. Yet your position is not so far removed from the skeptic's, or so secure STEPS TO A LIVING FAITH. 19 against sliding into it, as to make it un- suitable for me to remind you that for every one of these sorts of skepticism there are remedies, ready for use. ^ Be assured, that for a thorough defense of the Faith against each and all of the various forms of unbelief, ancient or modern — and the modern are not so very unlike the ancient as you may have been led to imagine — the Church, in her scholarship and her dialectics, feels entirely armed. Not all her champions are thus armed. There are honest contestants among them who know but little of the enemy's real positions, little of the real strength of their own cause ; who have never had oc- casion for the terrible encounter in their own souls, and have not studied pro- foundly the laws of the warfare elsewhere. Understand, however, that to the skeptic the Church has something to say about skepticism. I have been acquainted with a great many doubters, and I am obliged in truth to say but very few of them, con- tinuing doubters, have been willing to un- 20 STEPS TO A LIVING FAITH. dertake to satisfy their minds by what I should call a fair and reasonable amount of careful reading, of the right kind, on the Christian side. There would be little difficulty in naming two or three affirma- tive works in Christian literature on each department of modern unbelief* which would be acknowleged in any court of Letters to deserve the highest intellectual respect ; and they are such works that till they or their equivalents have been read, no man has an intellectual or moral right to determine in favor of disbelief. It would be well if, instead of jumping to the conclusion that their doubts are insoluble, minds that are tending to un- belief would apply to some competent authority for information. At present we are on a different field. Nor is the class of minds small to which you, my dear friend, belong. You will readily perceive that, though I am ad- dressing myself to an individual inquirer, and would gladly do as much if you were all alone in your difficulties, vet I cannot STEPS TO A LIVING FAITH. 21 be unmindful that there is scarcely a con- gregation or hamlet in the land where scores of men and women are not to be found who, if they were as candid as you are, would confess to the same religious dissatisfaction. In fact, I suppose that it is precisely these difficulties which at this moment create one of the most formida- ble obstacles to the spiritual power of Christ's Church and Gospel. Praise be to God that here and there a frank, thoughtful mind is moved to own the first, faintest movements of the Spirit, and seek the way of life ! You may be sure you will not be chided or discouraged by any true follower of that Christ, our only Saviour, who treated with wonder- ful love every sincere seeker of his friend- ship. I promise you as tender a sympa- thy in your troubles as one burdened, tempted heart can feel for another. Above all, do not forget that however cordially and earnestly we may strive to help one another, our first and final help is in God alone, and that simple, direct, 22 STEPS TO A LIVING FAITH. special prayer to Him is the surest path to the light. What, then, in a word, is your com- plaint ? You are not, on your own show- ing, a true disciple of the Lord Jesus Christ, in will, in heart, in life. Some- thing is wanting at the very root. You are conscious of it. Let us start at that point, then, where the Spirit of God has brought you. LETTER II. THE WANT. — ORIGIN OF THE FEELING. My dear Friend : In our conscious- ness, a Christian life begins in a sense of want. We must be dissatisfied with what we have, and with ourselves as we are, before we shall go in search of a bet- ter part, or aspire to a loftier estate. The Saviour appeals first to a feeling of the need of being saved. Self-content- ment, if such a degree of stupidity can be said to exist at all in a moral nature, is the most discouraging of conditions. There is no power of spiritual quickening in it. Neither the sensibilities nor the activities of life are born of death ; and to be absolutely self-approved is to be dead. If we say that we have no sin, we deceive ourselves, and the truth is not in us ; and the absence of truth from the 24 STEPS TO A LIVING FAITH. spiritual world is what the obscuration of light is to the physical. If you thought yourself well enough off as you are, you would not have sought for more light ; and it would be hard work to feel much esteem for your manhood. You should be thankful that you are in some measure unhappy. I remind you, observe, of what takes place in the consciousness of man. About the processes of the Divine Spirit there is a deeper mystery. We know, however, by his own plain declarations, that lie moves upon the heart according to the heart's own spiritual constitution, in con- formity with its laws, and in the ways of an everlasting order. Not only has He had a personal concern for you, separat- # ing you, in the gentle thoughts of his loving-kindness, from all other souls that ever lived, ever since you were born, but the preparations of his grace were made for you before you began to be. The Lord " loved us before we loved Him." St. Paul struck down among those pro- STEPS TO A LIVING FAITH. 25 founder things where *>ur modern medita- tions seldom drop their plummet, when he said, " According as He hath chosen us in Him before the foundation of the world." Concurrently with the course of our nat- ural, ordinary existence, the purpose of this heavenly affection has been patiently wording. It has been ever pressing to- wards us, seeking tenderly to attract us to Himself, and to fashion us into his likeness, taking advantage of every turn in the stream oL life, besetting us be- hind and before, " following," and " pre- venting," marvelously turning ordinary events, little and great, into instruments of this definite design, and often coming upon us in providences so signal, in their evident intention to make us understand his meaning, that, in our imperfect dis- cernment of the whole plan, we call them " special." Run your eye back along your past years, and candidly tell your- self whether you cannot see traces of such an assiduous goodness, a " besetting God." It will be strange if you do not then in- 26 STEPS TO A LIVING FAITH. quire of yourself what this signifies, and what you owe for it. Whether you do or not, the Grace works on, as it has from the first, infinite, unwearied, trying to fashion the poor frivolous thing, that you call your life, into the glory that is possible for it. One of Christ's most earnest efforts has been to stir up in you the sense of need which you are now willing to confess. The Spirit works within us not only " to do" but u to will," and to feel that un- less we do so " will " we die. Searching closely, we find that this grace has an outward as well as an in- ward economy. Operating immediately on the soul, it operates also mediately through the fixed channels, the conduct- ing ordinances, the life-conveying sacra- ments of a mediatorial system. St. Au- gustine and others call them " life-giving " sacraments ; and so they are ; but we must take care not to hide the original Giver, or confound even the stream of living water with the hand of Love that pours it. All the parts of this gracious system STEPS TO A LIVING FAITH. 27 are organically related to one another, being fitly joined together, compacted and articulated, each member nourished and the whole body continually enlarging by that which every joint supplieth. Je- sus Christ is the head of this complete, twofold, living organization. His incar- nation is at once the source and the type of the entire constitution, every depart- ment and organ of it being constructed on the pattern and warrant of the Heav- only Life and Grace taking a visible form in " the Word made Flesh." You can- not afford to despise the office of these mediate agents, in both awakening and filling your spiritual wants. Their sanc- tion is in the mediatorship of the Son of God, — God's unseen life becoming visi- ble and tangible, in order to impart itself to an indifferent world. Your attention may not have been much directed to them in this higher character ; for between a false spiritualistic philosophy on the one hand, and an engrossing materialism on the other, their Divine appointment has 28 STEPS TO A LIVING FAITH. been well-nigh forgotten, and accordingly much of our piety has become ghost-like, and our living carnal. But as you come to regard them in this pure evangelic light, as the first Christians did, they will put on an inexpressible beauty. You will see that God has dealt with us in the simplest way, on the most natural terms, taking us body and spirit, just as we are, and not proposing to put asunder in relig- ion what He has joined together every- where else. He reaches the unseen springs of penitence and prayer by a pathway not entirely invisible to sense. No matter how jealous you may be of at- tributing too much efficacy to external forms, you must acknowledge that nearly all those impressions that you consider as coming directly from the Spirit into the heart, are found, after all, to be borne in by some outward vehicle, or instrumen- tality - — a written text, a word spoken, a sight seen, a sorrow overtaking, an event occurring. Besides, among impres- sions that are wholly without regulation, STEPS- TO A LIVING FAITH. 29 or law, or criterion, you know that a great many run to extravagance, fanaticism, self-conceit, and religious absurdity. Jf I am not mistaken, you have sometimes laid off the responsibility of your own indifference upon the disgust and reaction occasioned by that sort of sentimentalism. "There is one Spirit and one Body." You will discover here a very merciful adaptation to our practical necessities. That of itself will invest the subject with fresh interest, I think, and will perhaps wake up a new desire to go further, and will help you to feel that St. Paul was right in calling the Christian discipleship a " reasonable service." Indeed, you will begin to wonder, I suspect, that you have not sooner recognized this twofold work- ing of the Spirit in all parts of the Bible^ as well as in the history of the Church. I have referred particularly to it here on account of its connection with the sense of want, which is the beginning of conscious Christianity in the squI. You find the want making itself felt. But 30 STEPS TO A LIVING FAITH, does it make itself felt ? There was no such motive force there. You did not call it into being. It came. You felt it. It was present by no act of your will. Whence was it ? Suppose you were brought, in the obedience of faith, in childhood, into the sacramental covenant of baptism, then this waking up of a de- sire after your true inheritance, this feel- ing after God — if haply you may find Him — is a part of the fulfillment of his baptismal promise, which He was " sure to keep and perform." The germ is springing after all. Seeds sprout that have been lying buried long. It was not an empty form. The water was not in vain, because the Spirit, and a pledge of the Spirit, and a sponsorial faith and prayer, were with it. How could it be in vain ? Whatever you may desire to do with this awakened want, be sure it is a part of your Father's faithfulness to you, and will take its place as a witness for his affection. If you were not brought into the Body sacramentally, then you STEPS TO A LIVING FAITH. 81 have only to be thankful for a yet more abundant grace. Your Lord has done more than He promised. The river has overflowed its banks to reach your lips. Beyond what you have had reason to ex- pect or claim, not being under the cove- nant, you are visited and touched by the boundless Compassion that would not leave even the Gentile without some wit- ness. You have still to say, - " 'Tis mercy all that thou hast brought My mind to seek her peace in thee." The connection, however, even then, between this gracious experience in your religious history and the initiatory sacra- ment is not, by any means, dissolved, as we shall see. What in the one case came after, in the other comes before. As the salvation before Christ came was still Christian salvation, so all the movements of the Spirit of the Saviour on the heart bear a secret relation to the revealed kingdom and its laws. As will appear, Christian grace is not complete till you are a branch on the Vine, a member in 32 STEPS TO A LIVING FAITH. the Body. You cannot too firmly believe that all the spiritual influences and pow- ers which play through our human life emanate from the person of Christ, and that all spiritual help for us centres there. The Comforter testifies of Him. It will assist you greatly if you can join with this faith a hearty conviction that the only religious progress you can hope to make will not be independent of the worship, the ordinances, the rites, the visible order of the Kingdom. At any rate, recognize in yourself, first of all, this feeling of something wanting, this restless sense of need. However it came, however you may think it came, by whatever untraceable course it found its way, take it very humbly and grate- fully as a gift of your God. Do not despise it because it is feeble. Do not distrust it because it is not constant, or not constantly remembered. You do not know what boundless blessings may come in its train. Treat it rightly, and it may be the germ of infinite gain, of a STEPS TO A LIVING FAITH. 33 harvest of vigorous virtues. Reverence your self -discontent. Taking you just as you are, it is the healthiest symptom of your soul : the finest thing in you. You are not satisfied with yourself, religiously, as a man, living in Christendom. Act accordingly and acknowledge it.