y^\ »°*i ft O • • - ■** ,0 V ,•**. %3 -4.* t -'"- ^0 *o » » * <5v <*> » ^ 0* *« °«. > ^ ^ u. *y- oV o "W / V-^V \/^V v^V °°* >* '^-0' <> ^ ^°^ ,0' 4 o ;- * *k. ^« v*^ ^9 ^ v ^ v v ^ v ^ V %* o V .^v A -. "\/ /Jtg(, ^^ ,^Jj^. "\/ '^ tot*. °°^ .-/* ?££%>• \. * c ° ** ^ ,*>^ THE ORIGIN OF M'FI N G A L. By Hon. J. HAMMOND TRUMBULL. President of the Connecticut Historical Society. MORRISANIA, N. Y i 8 68. ] s INTRODUCTORY NOTE. The following paper, originally published in The Historical Magazine, for January, 1868, has been reproduced in this form for the use of the Author and his friends. H. B. D. MORRISANIA, N. Y. John Trumbull, the author of M' , Fingal y after his admission to the bar in Connecticut, 1 prosecuted the study of law at Boston, in the office of John Adams, from November, 1773, till September, 1774, During this period, as the 1. For the Life of Trumbull, see the Memoir prefixed to the Hartford Edition of his Poetical Works (1820, two vol- umes, octavo), Everest's Poets of Connecticut, and Duyok- inok's Cyclopaedia of American Literature, i. 308-312. The following Notes, preserved by President Stiles in his Itinerary [MS.], make a considerable addition to what the poet has elsewhere told us of himself and to the gleanings of his biographers : " Memoirs Jno. Trumbull Esq., Poet. (Ex ore John Trum- "bull, MayU, 1788.) " 1750, Apr. 24 N. S. born at Westbury " [now Watertown\. " iEt 2. Began Primer and learned to read in half-year, " without school. Mother taught him all the primer "verses, and Watts' Children's Hymns, before [he could] "read." "^Et. 4. Read the Bible thro'— before 4. About this time " began to make Verses. First poetry [he read was] " Watts' Lyrics, and could repeat the whole,— and the " only poetical book he read till set. 6. " Mt. 5. Attempted to write and print his own verses. "Sample, — large hugeous letters. This first attempt " at writing, by himself, and before writing after copy. " Scrawls. " Mt. 6. In Spring began to learn Latin and learned half "Lilly's Grammar before his father knew it: catched it, "as his father was instructing Southmayd" [William; grad. Yale, 1761; son of Capt. Daniel, of Waterbury.] " Same Spring, was 6 yrs. old. Learned Quce genus by " heart in a day. Tenacious memory : quick, too. " Mt. 9. On a wager laid— to commit to memory one of " Salmon's Pater Nosters in a quarter of an hour — he ef- " fected it, reciting by memory the P. N. in Hungarian Memoir prefixed to the revised edition of his Works informs us, ' ' he frequently employed his ' ' leisure hours in writing essays on political sub- jects in the public gazettes; which had, per- 4 ' haps, a greater effect from the novelty of the ' ' manner and the caution he used to prevent any "discovery of the real author." Shortly after his return to Connecticut, lie became a contributor to the Hartford Courant, -then published by Ebenezer Watson, and afterwards by Hudson & " and Malabar, in Salmon ; and retains it to this day. I " heard him repeat the Hungarian. "MX.. 7)4. In Sept. 1757, entered Yale College— having fitted " for College in one year and half; having learned Cor- "dery, Tally's XII Select Orations, Virgil's Eclogues, and " all the jEneid (not Georgics,) and 4 Gospels in Greek."* " Mt. 8. Read Milton, and Thompson's Seasons— Telemachus " —the Spectators. These, all the poetical and belles [Uttres-] " books till set. 13. " Mt. \.%y z . Sept. 1763. Entered College again and resided " there. Before this, read Homer, and Horace, and Tully " Be Oratore Versified half the Psalms before set. 9, when " he first saw Watts' Psalms, and laid aside (and burnt) his "own. Before 4 set., upon first reading Watts' Lyrics, he " cried because he despaired of ever being able to write " Poems Ike Watts. "^Et. 17. Grad. at Y. C. and resided as Dean's Scholar till [he] "took [his] 2d degree. Then lived one year at " Wethersfield. " Mt. 21. Elected Tutor Y. C. and in office 2 years. " 1773. Resigned Tutorship, having studied law one year. " 1774. One year studied law under Dr. John Adams in Bos- ton ; and left, Sept. 1774. "1775. Fall, wrote two first Cantos of M'Fingal ; printed, "Jan. 1776. "1782. Jan. to April, wrote the rest of M'Fingal ; printed, " September." " At the Commencement in this Town the 14th Instant, " . . among those that appear'd to be examined for Ad- " mission was the Son of the Rev'd Mr. Trumble, of " Waterbury, who passed a good Examination, altho' "but little more than seven Years of Age; but on Account " of his Youth his Father does not intend he shall at "present continue at College." — Connecticut Gazette, No. 129, September 24, 1757. Goodwin. 2 Gage, — whose early confidence in his ability " to play the lion" had much abated since his arrival at Boston, in May, 1774, — was now apparently relying more upon the pen than the sword, to awe America to submission. In M'Fingal (Canto ii., p. 31) Trumbull retraces " The annals of the first great year: " While, wearying out the Tories' patience, " He spent his breath in proclamations ; " While all his mighty noise and vapour " Was used in wrangling upon paper ; " While strokes alternate stunn'd the nation, " Protest, address, and proclamation; "And speech met speech, rib clash'd with fib, " And Gage still answer'd, squib for squib." Into this wordy warfare, Trumbull entered with spirit and success. Imitations in burlesque of Gage's magnificent and turgid Proclamations, " In true sublime of scarecrow style," had occasionally appeared in the newspapers of Boston and in Connecticut. At so fair a mark, ridicule could hardly miss its aim ; and these squibs were perhaps quite as popular and effective as if their versification had been smoother or their wit more refined. The Proclamation of the twenty-fifth of July, 1774, "for the Encouragement of Piety and " Virtue," &c, and that of the twenty-eighth of 2. In 1772, while a Tutor of Yale, he published the first Part of The Progress of Dullness, — a poem " designed to expose "the absurd methods of education which then prevailed;" a second Part, with another Edition of the first," was printed in January, 1773 ; and the third Part appeared in July. In May, 1772, he had published in the Courant, An Elegy on the Death of Mr. Buckingham St. John, one of his earliest and most intimate friends. Shortly before leaving Boston, (August, 1774,) he wrote An Elegy on the Times, which was printed in one of the Boston papers. All these publications were anonymous. 8 September, proroguing the General Courtof Mas- sachusetts, were thus re-produced, in doggerel, and printed (one, or both, perhaps, being copied from a Boston paper, ) in the Courant, of the third of October. In the Boston Gazette of the fourteenth of November, a Proclamation prohibiting com- pliance with the requisition of the Massachusetts Provincial Congress, for the payment of taxes to a Receiver of their own appointment, &c, ap- peared in Hudibrastic verse : " Since an Assembly most unlawful, " At Cambridge met, in Congress awful, " October last, did then presume " The powers of government to assume; " And slighting British administration, " Dar'd rashly seek their own salvation," &c. This was re-printed the following week in the Courant, and in several other newspapers. Whether this and other similar compositions, published in the Courant, in 1774, were from Trumbull's pen, is not certain. His characteristic i" caution to prevent discovery" has rendered it cmpossible to convict him of the authorship, ex- c ept upon the internal evidence. In some publi- ations of the following year, such evidence is more direct ; and in one instance, at least, it is positive and conclusive. On the nineteenth of June, 1775, the Courant published Gage's Proclamation of the twelfth, extending free pardon to "the infatuated rnulti- " tude," on their return to allegiance, but pro- scribing Samuel Adams and John Hancock, with "all their adherents, associates, and abettors," and establishing Martial Law throughout Massa- chusetts. The Proclamation re-appeared in the same paper, on the seventeenth of July, in bur- lesque verse, as "Tom Gage's Proclamation, " Or blustering Denunciation, " (Replete with Defamation,) " Threat'ning Devastation, " And speedy Jugulation, " Of the New English Nation . . " Who shall his pious ways shun ?" ending in due form, with " Thus graciously, the war I wage, " " As witnesseth my hand . . . Tom Gage." "By command of Mother Cary, " Thomas Fluoker, Secretary." This burlesque may have been previously pub- lished elsewhere. Its merit is too slight to im- part any interest to the question of its origin. It appears, however, to have attained a transient popularity and was widely copied by the patri- otic press. It may be found (reprinted from the Pennsylvania Journal, of the twenty-eighth of June,) in Moore's Diary of the Revolution, vol. i., pp. 93-94. In the G our ant of the seventh and \ the fourteenth of August, another version of the Proclamation made its appearance ; and this last was unquestionably written by Trumbull. It is somewhat remarkable that not only the evi- dence of authorship, but the composition itself, should have escaped the observation of so many diligent gleaners of the newspaper literature of the Revolution. It is more surprising that no~\ Editor of M'-F'ingal has detected in the burlesque Proclamation the origin of the "modem epic," to which more than fifty of the two hundred and sixteen lines of this earlier composition were transferred by its author. In a letter to the Marquis de Chastellux, Trum- » bull states that "the poem of M'Fingal was "written merely with a political view, at the; ' ' instigation of some leading members of the "first Congress, who urged [him] to compose a 10 "satirical poem on the events of the Campaign 1 ' in the year 1775." The Memoir prefixed to the Edition of 1820, adds, that the friends at whose solicitations the first Canto was written, " imme- ' ' diately procured it to be published at Philadel- " phia, where Congress was then assembled." It made its appearance in an octavo pamphlet of forty pages, — printed by William and Thomas Bradford, -f-in January, 1776, but with the date of 1775. '"At this time, the author "had also 1 • formed the plan of the [whole] work, sketched " some of the scenes of the third Canto, and "written the beginning of the fourth" — the first Canto, as originally published, was subse- quently divided into two. VThe composition was suspended until after the surrender of Comwallis had established the success of the Revolution, when the poem was completed and published, in Hartford, by Hudson & Goodwin, on the tenth of September, 1782. Before the close of the year, (December 28, ) a second edition was issued by a rival Hartford Publisher, Nathaniel Patten, 3 with- out the author's consent. 3. Nathaniel Pattkh — for many years an enterprising, not over-scrupulous, publisher at Hartford, was originally a book-binder.' He had removed from Boston to Norwich, in the Spring of 1774, and after carrying on business at the latter place for two years, came to Hartford in the summer of 1776,— opening a shop as binder, stationer, and book- seller. After a few years he began to publish on his own account. It is worth noting, that Patten's piracy of M'Finpal led to the enactment by the General Assembly of Connecticut, in January, 1783, of a law of Copyright, securing to authors the exclusive right of publishing and vending tlieir works for fourteen years. Patten's edition ot M'FtngcU was ad- vertised in the Courant, on the seventh of January, 1783, with the statement that " this ingenious work has lately 11 been sold for the extravagant price of Half a Dollar, but " will now be offered at one third less." In the same num- ber of the Courant appeared an article of two columns, probably from Trumbull's pen, on the importance of en- 11 The Proclamation Versified was published, as has been mentioned, in August, 1775. So large a portion of it is re-produced in the first three Cantos of M'Fingal, that the latter poem may be said to have grown directly out of the former. That it was the appearance of this burlesque which induced the Author's friends to urge him to the composition of a longer and regularly con- structed poem, in the same measure and a similar vein, is hardly doubtful. Among the prominent members of the Congress of 1 775 , to whom Trumbull was personally known, and whose solicitation was likely to have weight with him, — besides the Delegation from his own State, including Oliver Wolcott, Roger Sherman, and Silas Deane, — were John Adams, his in- structor in law, and Thomas Cushing, in whose family he had lived while in Boston. They were not mistaken in their estimate of his genius and of the service which, in that "period of terror " and dismay," his wit, humor, and satiric power might render to the friends of American liberty, " to inspire confidence in our cause, to crush the ' ' efforts of the Tory party, and to prepare the "public mind for the Declaration of Indepen- "dence." With these objects in view, as his Memoir informs us, he wrote the first part of M'-Fingal. Its success abundantly justified the judgment of his friends. Its popularity was un- couraging productions of genius by ensuring to Authors the profits arising from the sale of their writings. The writer alludes to the " great discouragement to a writer, on the " first publication of his work, to see some mean and un- " generous Printer seizing [if] out of his hands, re- 11 printing it in so mangled and inelegant a manner that the " author must be ashamed of the Edition, and defrauding "him of the profits of his labors." On the meeting of the General Assembly, a few days afterwards, a petition was preferred, and the enactment of " An Act for the Encourage- " ment of Literature and Genius" was procured. 12 exampled ; and that the favor with which it was received, at- home and abroad, was not attribu- table merely to the interest of its subject or the seasonableness of the publication is sufficiently proved by the fact, that ' ' more than thirty im- " pressions" had been called for before 1820, and that then, as now, it had not only its established place in every good library, but had become the prey of "newsmongers, hawkers, peddlers, and " petty chapmen," who, as the Author complains, republished it at pleasure, without his permission or knowledge. In the Notes appended to this re-print, those portions of the burlesqued Proclamation which were afterwards incoqDorated in M'Fingal are indicated by references to the Author's Edition of the complete poem, {Hartford, 1782), except when another Edition is particularly mentioned. The suppression, after the publication of the first Canto, of the name of Daniel Leonard, as the author of the letters of Massacliusettensis, and the substitution of William Smith for Isaac Low, in the humorous description of proceedings in New York, are perhaps worthy of special notice. {See Notes 4 and 9.) A copy of the genuine Proclamation, from a broadside in the library of George Brinley, Esq. , is prefixed to the imitation, that it may be seen how closely and skilfully Trumbull followed his copy. GENERAL GAGE'S PROCLAMATION, FROM A BROADSIDE IN THE COLLECTION OF GEORGE BRINLEY, ESQ., OF HARTFORD, CONN. By His Excellency the Honourable Thomas Gage, Esquire, Governour and Com- mander-in-Chief in and over His Maj- esttfs Province of Massachusetts Bay, and Vice- Admiral of the fame : A PROCLAMATION. WHEREAS, the infatuated multi- tude who have long suffered them- felves to be conducted by certain well known incendiaries and traitors, in a fatal progrefsion of crimes againft the conftitu- tional authority of the State, have at length proceeded to avowed Rebellion ; and the good effects which were expected to arife from the patience and lenity of the King's Government have been often fruftrated, and are now rendered hopelefs, by the in- fluence of the fame evil counfels ; it only remains for thofe who are inverted with fupreme rule, as well for the punifhment of the guilty as for the protection of the 16 well-affected, to prove they do not bear the fword in vain. The infringements which have been committed upon the moft facred rights of the Crown and People of Great Britain, are too many to enumerate on the one fide, and are too atrocious to be palliated on the other. All unprejudiced people, who have been witneffes of the late tranfactions in this and the neighbouring Provinces, will find, upon a tranfient review, marks of premeditation and confpiracy that would justify the fulnefs of chaftifement ; and even thofe who are leaft acquainted with facts, cannot fail to receive a juft impref- sion of their enormity, in proportion as they difcover the arts and afsiduity by which they have been falfified or concealed. The authors of the prefent unnatural re- volt, never daring to truft their caufe or their actions to the judgment of an im- partial publick, or even to the difpaflionate reflection of their followers, have uniform- ly placed their chief confidence in the fup- prefsion of truth ; and while indefatigable and fhamelefs pains have been taken to ob- ftruct every appeal to the real intereft of the people of America, the grofsest forgeries, cal- umnies and abfurdities that ever infulted hu- man underftanding have been impofed upon 17 their credulity. The Prefs, that diftinguished appendage of publick liberty, and, when fairly and impartially employed, its beft fup- port, has been invariably proftituted to the most contrary purpofes ; the animated lan- guage of ancient and virtuous times, calcu- lated to vindicate and promote the juft rights and interefts of mankind, have been applied to countenance the moft abandoned violation of those facred blefsings ; and not only from the flagitious prints, but from the popular harangues of the times, men have been taught to depend upon activity in treafon, for the fecurity of their persons and properties ; till, to complete the hor- rid profanation of terms and of ideas, the name of God has been introduced in the pulpits, to excite and juftify devaftation and mafsacre. The minds of men have been thus grad- ually prepared for the worft extremities. A number of armed persons, to the amount of many thoufands, afTembled on the 19th of April laft, and from behind walls and lurking holes, attacked a detachment of the King's Troops, who not fufpecting fo confummate an act of phrenzy, unprepared for vengeance, and willing to decline it, made ufe of their arms only in their own defence. Since that period, the rebels, 18 deriving confidence from impunity, have added infult to outrage ; have repeatedly fired upon the King's mips and fubjects, with cannon and fmall-arms ; have pof- sefsed the roads, and other communications by which the Town of Boflon was fupplied with provifions; and with a prepofterous parade of military arrangement, they af- fect to hold the Army befieged ; while part of their body make daily and indif- criminate invafions upon private property, and, with a wantonnefs of cruelty ever in- cident to lawlefs tumult, carry depredation and diftrefs wherever they turn their fteps. The actions of the 19th of April are of fuch notoriety as muft baffle all attempts to contradict them, and the flames of build- ings and other property from the Iflands and adjacent country, for fome weeks paft, fpread a melancholy confirmation of the fubfequent afsertions. In this exigency of complicated calami- ties, I avail myfelf of the laft effort with- in the bounds of my duty, to fpare the efFufion of blood, to offer, and I do hereby in His Majesty's name offer and prom- ife, his moft gracious pardon to all perfons who fhall forthwith lay down their arms and return to their duties of peaceable fubjects, excepting only from the benefits 19 of fuch pardon, Samuel Adams and John Hancock, whofe offences are of too flagi- tious a nature to admit of any other con- fideration than that of condign punifh- ment. And to the end that no perfon within the limits of this offered mercy may plead ignorance of the confequences of refufing it ; I, by thefe prefents, proclaim not only the perfons above-named and excepted, but alfo all their adherents, afsociates, and abettors, meaning to comprehend in thofe terms, all and every perfon and perfons, of what clafs, denomination or defcription foever, who have appeared in arms againft the King's Government, and fhall not lay down the fame as afore- mentioned ; and likewife all fuch as fhall fo take arms af- ter the date hereof, or who fhall in any wife protect or conceal fuch offenders, or aflist them with money, provifion, cattle, arms, ammunition, carriages, or any other necefsary for fubsistence or offence ; or fhall hold fecret correfpondence with them by letter, mefsage, fignal, or otherwife, to be Rebels and Traitors, and as fuch to be treated. And whereas, during the continuance of the prefent unnatural rebellion, justice cannot be adminiftered by the common law 20 of the land, the courfe whereof has for a long time paft been violently impeded, and wholly interrupted ; from whence refults a necefsity of ufing and exercifing the Law- Martial ; I have therefore thought fit, by the authority vested in me by the Royal Charter to this Province, to publifh, and I do hereby publish, proclaim and order the ufe and exercife of the Law-Martial, within and throughout this Province for fo long time as the prefent unhappy occafion mail necefsarily require ; whereof all perfons are hereby required to take notice, and govern themfelves, as well to maintain order and regularity among the peaceable inhabitants of the Province, as to refift, encounter and fubdue the Rebels and Traitors above-defcribed, by fuch as mall be called upon for thofe purpofes. To thefe inevitable, but, I trust, falutary meafures, it is a far more pleafing part of my duty to add the afsurance of my pro- tection and fupport to all who, in fo trying a crifis, mall manifeft their allegiance to the King, and affection to the Parent State ; fo that fuch perfons as may have been in- timidated to quit their habitations in the courfe of this alarm, may return to their re- fpective callings and profefsions; and ftand diftinct and feparate from the parricides of 21 the Conftitution, till God in his mercy fhall restore to his creatures in this distracted land that fyftem of happinefs from which they have been feduced, the religion of peace, and liberty founded upon law. Given at Bojion, this 12th day of 'June, in the fifteenth year of the reign of His Majefty GEORGE the Third, by the Grace of God, of Great Britain, France and Ireland, KING, Defender of the Faith, &c. Annoque Domini, 1775. THOMAS GAGE. By His Excellency's command : Thomas Flucker, Secretary. GOD fave the KING. GAGE'S PROCLAMATION Of June 12, 1775, IN BURLESQJJE VERSE. / BY JOHN TRUMBULL. Reprinted from THE CONNECTICUT COURANT of August 7th and 14th, 1775. WITH ILLUSTRATIVE NOTES, By J. Hammond Trumbull, Esq_., President of the Connecticut Historical Society. By THOMAS GAGE, whom British frenzy Stiled Honourable and Excellency, O'er Mafsach'itfetts fent to Jland here Vice- Admiral and Chief Commander, TVhofe Power Gubernatorial fill Extends as far as Bunker-Hill, Whose Admiralty reaches clever Full half a mile up Myftic River 1 , — Let ev'ry Clime and ev'ry Nation Attend, once more, A PROCLAMATION. W HEREAS th' infatuated creatures, Still led by folks whom we call Traitors, — 1. " Tho' Gage, whom proclamations call " Your Gov'rnor and Vice-Admiral, " Whose pow'r gubernatorial still " Extends as far as Bunker's hill ; " Whose admiralty reaches clevei*, " Near half a mile up Mystic river," etc. APFingal (1782), Canto 2: p. 37. " Can any one" — asked a writer in the Constitutional Gazette, Nov. 25th, 1775, — " read with a grave face the high sounding 11 additions newly granted to General Gage (vide the public " prints) ? To appoint a man Governor over a country as 26 Whom, had we dar'd, we'd have you know We (hould have hang'd a year ago, — Advancing in progrefsion fatal 2 Have now proceeded to give battle, And with deep wounds, that fate portend, Gaul'd many a foldier's latter end ; And all the good effects we hop'd From fear and patience, now are dropped, — The good effects, we mean, of gaining Whate'er you had was worth obtaining, — The good effects we saw in vifions Of Lordfhips, Penfions, Pofts, Commis- sions, — All which, by following those fame elves, You've kept moft vilely for yourfelves, — It but remains for us who ftand Inverted with fupreme command, To prove we do not bear or {how you The fword in vain....So woe be to you ! " large as China, while he remains iu ' durance vile,' in a " little nook, scarce a mile and a half in diamet- r, and cannot "obtain a pig from Hog Island, nor a truss of straw from "Noddle Island,* though both within three miles of him,— " puts him much in the condition of a Moorfields' monarch, "who, with a crown and sceptre, pretends to give laws to " mighty nations." 2. " Now rising in progression fatal, " Have you not ventur'd to give battle ? " And with deep wounds that fate portend, " Gaul'd many a reg'lar's latter end ?" M'Fingal, Canto 3 : p. 57. * Probably referring 10 the expedition to Hog and Nod- dle Islands, on the twenty-seventh of Mav," preceding, which had not only proved unsuccessful but led to the loss of several marines and one of the King's armed schooners. —Ed. Hist. Mag. 27 But first 'tis fit it fhould be feen What arrant knaves ye all have been; What horrid crimes ye've been committing 'Gainft Parliament and Crown of Britain ; Denied the facred right to thefe Of calmly robbing whom they pleafe ; That any man with half an eye Your plots and mifchiefs may efpy ; And thofe who nothing know befide 'em May fee the pains ye took to hide 'em. Did ye not fcare each printing prefs, And make e'en Rivington* confefs ? Stop ev'ry printer bold and wife Who dared to publifh Tory lies ? 3. In a letter addressed to the Congress at Philadelphia, in May, 1775, Rivington admitted that " by the freedom of his "publications during the present unhappy disputes, he had " brought upon himself much public displeasure and resent- " meut. . . .A few weeks ago he lhad'] published in his paper " a short apology, in which he assured the public that he "would be cautious for the future of giving any further "offence," &c. His confession and apology were so far ac- cepted that on the seventh of June folloAving, the Provincial Congress of New York recommended that he be permitted to return to his house and family, and that he should not be molested in person or property. His reformation was not permanent. His repeated offences so exasperated the Whigs that, about three months after this ' Proclamation' was pub- lished, a party from Connecticut, led by Captain Isaac Sears, marched to New York, and entering Rivington's office, destroyed such copies of his obnoxious publications as they could rind there, and carried off his types and print- ing materials to New Haven. Trumbull alludes to this expedition, in the Third Canto of 31'Fingal. " All punishments the world can render "Serve only to provoke th' offender," — argues the Tory ; Squire, and he tauntingly asks his perse- cutors, " Has Rivington, in dread of stripes, " Ceas'd lying, since you stole his types ?" 28 Nay, when myfelf in proclamation, Spread wholefome falfhood thro' the na- tion, Altho' the lies I ufed to fcatter Were of the nobleft fize and water, Did ye not all refufe to credit, As tho' fome common liar had faid it ? v - Did not my fcribbler-gen'ral ftrain hard, xMy Majsachufettenfis, L d, 4 4. In transferring this line to the first Canto of M'Fingal (Phil. 1775), Trumbull wrote the name of Leonard, in full,— with this Note: " One of the Mandamus Council in Massa- " chusetts Bay, author of a course of Essays, under the signa- " tare of M.\8s\ciiusiiTTF.Nsi3; for which, and his other good " services he has had a place given him, with a salary of £200 " sterling." But in the first Edition of the completed poem [1782], the name and the Note are omitted: — "Did not our Massaoiu-gettexsts " For "nr conviction strain his senses ? " Q - „ ev'ry moment he could spare 1 lOra cards, and barbers, and the fair; " Aud while he muddled all his head, " You did not heed a word he said." [p. 18.] The revised edition of 1S20 has only this Note for Massaohu- bKTTENsis: "A course of Essays under that signature was '■ published in Bostou, in the latter part of 1774 and begin- *' nine of 1775. It was the last combined effort of Tory wit " and argument to write down the Revolution." These Essays, which are said to have ''excited great exul- " tation among the Tories and many gloomy apprehensions "among the Whigs, - ' are now chiefly interesting as having called forth the fi amir able History of the Dispute with Amer- ica, published by John Adams, under the signature of Novangmjs, in the Boston Gazette, between December, 1774, and April, 1775. Mr. Adams, as is well known, believed that he recognized in the letters of Massaohusettf.nsis, the style of his old friend and correspondent, Jonathan Sewall: aud it was not until after his publication of the revised edi- tion of Novanot.us, in 1819, that he discovered his error. Works of J. Adams, iv. 9, 10; x. 178. It appears that Trum- bull— who was a student of law, in Mr. Adams's office in 29 Write, ev'ry moment he could fpare From cards and gallanting the fair, To reafon, wheedle, coax or frighten Your rebel folks from fchemes of fighting, — Scrawl, till he muddled quite his head ? And did you mind a word he faid ? Did not my grave Judge S ... 11 hit 5 The fummit of newfpaper wit, Fill ev'ry leaf of ev'ry paper Of Mills and Hicks and Mother Draper ; 6 Boston, when the first Essay of MASSAciitrsETTExsrs was given to the press, — made a better guess at the authorship, — rightly ascribing it to Daniel Leonard, of Taunton. Leo- nard, on the testimony of Mr. Adams, " was a scholar, a " lawyer, and an orator, according to the standard of those " days He wore a broad gold lace round the rim of his "ha', he made his cloak glitter with laces still broader, he " had set xxp his chariot and pair, and constantly travelled in " it, from Taunton to Boston The discerning ones soon " perceived that wealth and power ram ?ye charms to a "heart that delighted in so much finer,, " ndulged in "such unusual expense." Works, x. 194, 195. 5. "Did not my grave Judg-e-Sauaill hit," &c. Transferred, with the seven lines following, to M'Fingal, Canto 1 [p. 19],— where Sewall is described, in a foot-note, as " Attorney-general of Massac husetts Bay, a Judg e of Ad- "minrrr, ringr'--, Hiipf ftrlvisftr^nrl MrfV-mlh'iliiVii-mnVpr ; " niit hor of a, farce caller! th e ^Americans Routed, and of a ~ ( " gfeat variety of essays on the Ministerial side, in the Bos- " ton newspapers." Until seduced by the arts of Hutchinson, he had been the " cordial, confidential and bosom friend " of Adams, — " as ardent an American, and as explicitly for re- sistance to Great Britain." Preface to Novanglxts, Edit. 1819. Though his perversion to Toryism made him justly odious to his early friends, acknowledged excellence in his profession and his reputation as a writer and public speak- er should have spared him the contemptuous epithet with which Trumbull— possibly for the rhyme's sake, — dismisses " that xoitof water-gruel " A Judge of Admiralty, SewalL" 6. Nathaniel Mills aud John Hicks were the proprietors of the Massachusetts Gazette and Boston Post Boy (formerly 30 Draw proclamations, works of toil, In true fublime and fcarecrow ftyle ; Write farces too, 'gainft right and freedom, All for your good, — and none would read 'em ? My friends at York, did ye not hamper, And make each tory fcribbler fcamper, 7 From C . . . . r, 8 to that fenfeless prater, From folly's rear-guard, fly led Mercator ? The Boston Weekly Advertiser), from 1773 to the commence- ment of hostilities, in 1775. Margaret, widow of Richard Draper, (who died in 1774), continued the publication of the Boston Weekly News Letter, until the evacuation of the town by the British, in 1776, when she accompanied the army to Halifax. She subsequently received a pension from the British government. 7. " There never was a more total revolution at any place " than at New York. The Tories h;ive been obliged to fly. "The Province is arming ; and the Governor dares not call "his prostituted Assembly to receive Lord North's foolish " plan. Two of the Delanceys, Watts, Cooper, Rivington, " Colonel Philip*, and the rest of the Tory le .d'ers are fled ; "some to England, and some to private place? in the " country, where they are not known." Letter from a Gentle- man in Philadelphia, May 22, 1175— American Archive*, IV. ii. 669. " The character of the New Yorkers is no longer suspicious. " The few Tories among them are silent; the cry of "liberty is irresistible Rivington follows their fortunes — [that of the Tory refugees'] and his printing shop, which " forged calumny and sedition for the whole continent, is "shut up." Wm. Hooper to Samuel J. Johnston, May 23, 1775— Ibid, 679. "No people can be more despised, nor more frightened, " than those here who have been inimical to their Country, " particularly the eleven Members of the House. Mr. Riving- " ton has made a recantation; President Cooper has de- " camped," etc. Letter from New York, April 30— Ibid, 449. 8. " Have not our Cooper and our Seabury " Sung hymns, like Barak and old Deborah ?" M'Fingal, Canto 1, p.. 16. " I could not half the Scriblers muster " That swarm'd round Rivington in cluster ; 31 Raife fuch a tumult, blufter, jarring, That, midft the clafh of tempefts warring, L.w's weathercock, with veers forlorn, Could fcarcely tell which way to turn ? 9 What difappointments fad and bilkings, Awaited poor departing W s ; 10 "Assemblies, Councilnien, forsooth; "Brush, Cooper, Wilkius, Chandler, Booth," etc. Ibid, p. 18. In a note, Cooper is characterized as " a writer, poet, and " satyrist of the same stamp as Parson Peters,— and " President of the College of New York." Not even by the mob which compelled Dr. Cooper to resign his Presidency and to seek his safety in flight, was he subjected to so griev- ous and undeserved indignity as by this coupling of his name with that of " the fag-end man, poor Parson Peters ! " 9. Isaac Low, a prominent merchant of New York, had been a Delegate to the first Continental Congress, one of the earliest subscribers of the Association, and the Chairman of the general Committee for the City and County, in 1774. But his timidity and lukewarmness gave offence to more zealous patriots ; and he, with his conservative colleagues, gradually lost influence and position in the Committee, until, after wavering for a time between the two great parties, he rested in confirmed Toryism. The allusion to his " weathercock" policy in the summer of 1775, was omitted from the first Canto of M'Fingal, published in the autumn of that year : and was subsequently transferred by the Author, in the third -canto of the completed poem [1782,] to William Smith, the Chief-justice, who, like Mr. Low, had first espoused, then abandoned the popular cause :— " Such a tumult, bluster, jarring, " That mid the clash of tempests warring, " Smith'.* weathercock, with veers forlorn, " Could hardly tell which way to turn." 10. No one of the " Tory scribblers" of New York was more obnoxious to the patriots, than Isaac Wilkins. He had been one of the leaders of the Tory majority in the Pro- vincial Assembly of 1774-5, and in a s;.eech in that body had denounced "the ill-judged, tyraunical and destructive mea- sures of the Congress," and declared the Boston Port Bill "the mildest chastisement that could possibly have been "inflicted, considering the nature of the offence" of the Mas- sachusetts patriots. He was suspected of a share in the authorship of A Friendly Address to all Reasonable Ameri- 32 What wild confufion, rout and hobble, you Made with his farmer, Don A. W. n How did you 'fore committees drag it, And anfwer it with fire and faggot ? Still bent your own fide to advance, You never gave us equal chance, That all the world might fee and tell Which party beat at lying well ; cans, The American Querist, and the essays of A. W. tier, mentioned in the following note. Shortly after the battle of Lexington, Mr. Wilkin:-, with other prom- inent Tories, escaped the fury of the Whigs of New York, by taking refuse on hoard a British vessel of war, in which he sailed for England. On the eve of his departure, May 3, 1775. lie published a farewell address to his countrymen, declaring that he was about to" leave America and every " endearing connection, because he would not raise his hand "against his Sovereign, nor would he draw his sward 11 against his Country." Fobob's American Archives, IV. ii. 479. // 11. The anti-revolutionary pamphlets of i: A. W. Fabmeb," printed by Rivington, had been extensively circulated in New York and Connecticut, in the winter' of 1774-5. In February, 177;'). the Committee of Suffolk County, N. Y., re- solved. " that all those publications which have a tendency "to divide as, raid thereby weaken our opposition to "measure-; taken to enslave us, ought to be treated with the "utmost contempt by every friend to his country; in pu- " ticular the Pamphlet entitled A Friendly Address, dbc, and "those under the signature of A. W. Farmer, and many- "others to the same purpose, which are replete with the " most, impudent falsehoods, and the grossest misrepre- sentations; and that the authors, printers, and abettors of "the above and such like publications, ought to be es- teemed and treatei as traitors to their country, and " enemies to the liberties of America." Foeob'b American Archives IV. i. 1258. When c:>;>ie Shall from my arm, which is not fhort, Obtain protection and fupport, Such as I give the Bofton tories Who ftarve for heeding thus my ftories, 20. " There is no market in Boston; the inhabitants are " all starving," wrote anl English soldier, April 30th, 1775: " the soldiers live on salt provisions, and the officers are " supplied by the men-of-war cutters, who go up the creeks " and take live cattle and sheep wherever they find them " Duty is so hard that we come off guard in the morning, and " mount picket at night." Fokok's American Archives, IV, ii. 441. " We heard yesterday, by one Mr. Rolston, a goldsmith, " who got out from Boston in a fishing schooner, that the " distress of the troops increases fast, their beef is spent, " their malt and cider all gone ; all the f;esh provisions they "can procure they are obliged to give to the sick and "wounded," etc. Pennsylvania Journal, Aug. 2,— in Moork's Diary of the Revolution, i, 113. Gage was doing his best to procure supplies. Captain Wallace, in the Rose, sloop-of-war, with two tenders, was plundering the sea-coast towns; and early in August, he was dispatched with a more considerable fleet, to the neighborhood of Stonington and New London, Connecticut. The day before the first portion of the burlesque Proclama- tion appeared in the Courant, August 6th, this fleet carried off from Fisher's, Gardiner's and Plum Islands, about eight- een hundred sheep and one hundred head of cattle. On their return to Boston, " with these trophies of victory, the " bells, we hear," [says the Essex Gazette, August 17], " were " set to music, to the no small joy and comfort of the poor, " half-starved Tories."— Caulkin's Hist, of New London 275 :, Fbothingham's Siege of Boston, 236. 40 Or venture each his worthlefs head, Condemn'd to 'lift and fight for bread. J And all the tory-refugees May now go home whene'er they pleafe ; We've no occafion for fuch fluff; We've Britifh fools and knaves enough : Whene'er they dare, without remiffnefs, Let them go off about their bus'nefs ; Yet not with whigs and rebels link'd, But ftill ftand feparate and diftinct, Till Mercy aid your people undone, — And Heav'n difpatch me back to London ! • ^ .r ■y -%. W.: y^u. V A** . < ^M|li^ « t S ^n o o> v, «• T-K a"* * « l^ 1 4- -t V V ^°^ 1? ^ & •^ ■ " • A ^> c\ aP -;••- > v ^ , ^ A **r(\^X/k ^ v^' * 'SS'K Deacidified using the Bookkeeper process ^ <3 •jS^W'V^it *V^ Neutralizing agent: Magnesium Oxide A-^ " ^^£i^^ o c, vP * 6 Treatment Date: Sept. 2009 A . "-S8&T^ ,** ^ PreservationTechnologies A WORLD LEADER IN COLLECTIONS PRESERVATION 1 1 1 Thomson Park Drive 5% AUG 7 3