* o « o ^ •^^ .^^ »!v: '♦ '^ .-1°^ .HO, 9.^ ^^^. - * ^ •^ o .0^ A 9. o > <^^ . \{ 'i °o Chicago, Illinois, January, 1905. To the Governor of Illinois: Sir: — The undersigned members of the Illinois Battlefield Commission, appointed by Governor John R. Tanner, under an act passed by the General Assembly of Illinois, approved by the Governor June 9, 1897, and followed by supple- mentary acts, to locate positions and erect monu- ments on the battlefield of Shiloh in honor of the Illinois Troops engaged in the battle, have the honor of submitting a report of what has been accomplished in pursuance of their duties under said acts. Respectfully submitted; Gustav A. Bussey, Israel P. Rumsey, Thomas A. Weisner, Isaac Yantis, Benson Wood, George Mason, Timothy Slattery, J. B. Nulton, A. F. McEwen, Sheldon C. Ay res. Commissioners . ILLINOIS AT S H I LO H REPORT OF THE X U \ n 'i ■ Shiloh Battlefield Commission AND CEREMONIES AT THE DEDICATION OF THE MONUMENTS ERECTED TO MARK THE POSITIONS OF THE ILLINOIS COMMANDS ENGAGED IN THE BATTLE The Story of the Battle, by Stanley Waterloo t Compiled by Major George Mason, Secretary of the Commission Illinois at Shiloh THE BATTLE OF SHILOH The Battle of Shiloh, fought April 6 and 7, 1862, was one of the great battles of history, one the importance and quality of which will be more and more recognized as time passes. It was a battle in which were included half a dozen bloody smaller battles, it was a battle where con- ditions were such that there was almost the closeness of conflicts in medieval times, and where regiments and brigades of raw recruits showed in desperate struggle with each other what American courage is. It was a bat- tle fought on a rough wooded plateau, down and up deep gullies and amid thick underbrush and heavy timber, where artillery duels were fought at simple musket range. It was a battle saved only at the eleventh hour and, finally, one so potent in its results that it may possibly have changed entirely the issue of a mighty war. Such was the Battle of Shiloh. At the beginning of the year 1862 the Confederacy was practically in command of all territory south of the Ohio River. Its line of defense extended east and west across the state of Kentucky, from Columbus on the Mississippi River to Bowling Green on the east, and the army thus stretched across the state was under the direction of one of the ablest commanders the War of the Rebellion pro- duced, General Albert Sidney Johnston. Under him were capable subordinate commanders, and strategic points were well fortified and garrisoned with heavy forces. There seemed open but one possible available route for s 6 ILLINOIS AT SHILOH invasion of the region thus occupied, and provision had been made for closing this to the Northern army. The Tennessee and Cumberland rivers running north and parallel, in a general way, empty into the Ohio River, and fear of their ascent by war vessels with an accompany- ing land force had led the Confederates to the erection of two forts, one on each river, at a point where the streams were but twelve miles apart and where a force from one could at any time readily reinforce the other. These defenses were Fort Henry, on the Tennessee, and Fort Donelson on the Cumberland. Such was the situa- tion in the eastern part of the Mississippi Valley at the beginning of the year 1862. In February of the same year the situation changed vastly, to the Confederate disad- vantage, because of the daring and generalship of one man — General U. S. Grant. The man who later became the central figure upon the stage of war had at that time obtained only moderate recognition, but he asked and received permission to at- tempt breaking the Confederate line at Fort Henry, as- sisted by Commodore Foote with a fleet of gunboats. The story of the taking of Fort Henry and the subsequent reduction of Fort Donelson is part of the history of the Civil War familiar to all Americans. Grant, the wisely daring, had attained the end he had in sight. The practi- cal center of this line of the Confederacy was broken. It was inevitable that Johnston should retreat and re- establish the line of defense farther south, and he recog- nized the fact. There was a retirement of his force and a new front was established along the line of railroad ex- tending right across the Confederate states from the Mis- sissippi river to the Atlantic Ocean and crossed by another railroad, even more important, extending north and south. No better base of operations could have been selected. Troops, munitions and supplies could be transported all THE BATTLE OF SHILOH along the two lines and there were many points where Nature had so adjusted the land surface that a few well directed regiments could defend a passage against an army. In a queer old sleepy town named Corinth, situated in the northern part of the state of Mississippi, not far from the Tennessee line and twenty-two miles from the Ten- nesse river, was a little plot of ground. It did not differ in appearance from any other plot of ground in the vicin- ity and was not over five feet square, yet it was for the possession of this little piece of soil that twenty thousand men were killed and wounded in one of the most desper- ate battles in all history. The reason that these few feet of ground was sought for at such awful cost was that it was enclosed like this by iron rails. > ^^1 Me O 5 o Me MPHis & Charleston JR. What was Fought for — Plot of Ground 4 Feet 8^ Inches Square. MPHis & Charleston R R. o w M ?? O 5 o ?^ R. The Two Railroads' Intersection, Giving Control of Transportation. 8 ILLINOIS AT SHILOH The less than five feet square was merely the land in- cluded within the crossing of two railroads. The entire South lay practically between the Mississippi and the At- lantic ocean and between the Ohio river and the Gulf of Mexico. As already mentioned, from the Mississippi river to the Atlantic coast, ran a railroad — the Memphis & Charleston line. From the Ohio river to the Gulf of Mexico ran another railroad — the Mobile & Ohio. It can be seen that east and west and north and south these two railroads were the means for transportation, in times of peace, of all things in connection with great commerce, and, in times of war, for the hurrying forward from any point, north, south, east or west, of all that pertained to war, men and provisions and munitions of every sort. Hence, the general who absolutely controlled the few feet square, where these two railroads crossed, owned all means of swift transportation, while his opponent had no such vast advantage. Well was this understood by Al- bert Sydney Johnston, the Confederate leader, and by Ulysses S. Grant, commander of the Army of the Tennes- see. Grant was to the north. He saw his way up the Tennessee and used it, utilizing all means of transporta- tion to "land an army within not many miles of that little piece of ground, and part of that army had reached Pitts- burg Landing — where there wasn't any landing, save on the soil, and where there were only three houses then. So the sleepy town of Corinth thus became the object in the great scheme of military operations taking place in Western Tennessee. To it there came Johnston, with Beauregard as his chief lieutenant, and by the end of March there was assembled at and near Corinth some 50,000 men. Gen. Leonidas Polk, "the fighting bishop," and Braxton Bragg, with their commands, joined the Con- federate chieftain, and there it was generally thought, North and South, that the Southern forces were to await THE BATTLE OF SHILOH 9 attack from the advancing Northern hosts. In their ren- dezvous at Pittsburg Landing on the Tennessee river, the Northerners were gathering under the immediate com- mand of General Charles F. Smith, whose fatal illness was destined to place in supreme authority over that field, Gen- eral U. S. Grant, the newly crowned and promptly perse- cuted victor of Fort Donelson. In that army, encamped upon the plain which came to be called Shiloh, from a rude log church which stood two and one-half miles back from the Tennessee river, were many men of either side whose names afterward shone in the pages of American history. General William T. Sherman, General Albert Sydney Johnston, General Lew Wallace, General B. M. Prentiss, Colonel Robert Inger- soll, General Braxton Bragg, Generals Hurlbut, McCler- nand, McArthur and William H. L. Wallace, these are some of the names which uprear themselves like living forms, from the maze of blood and battle, as one reads this tale of how men fought upon this field on the 6th and 7th of April, 1862. General Halleck, at St. Louis, had designated Savannah, on the eastern bank of the Tennessee, nine miles below Pittsburg Landing, as the rendezvous of the armies of the Tennessee and of the Ohio, but General C. F. Smith, who was upon the ground himself, and to whom discre- tionary power had been given, had selected Pittsburg Landing as the place for the great camp, and General Grant, when he arrived, recognized the strength of the position and adopted it. Official headquarters remained, however, at Savannah. In the later days of March Pittsburg Landing was a busy place. Regiments and brigades were daily arriving. Many of the troops were newly enlisted, undrilled, in some cases un-uniformed and unarmed and in others with old muskets of the pattern of by-gone days. But the victors of lo ILLINOIS AT SHILOH Fort Donelson were there, McClernand's Division and C. F. Smith's Division, while Lew Wallace's Division was at Crump's Landing, five miles down the river. The Union position at Pittsburg Landing was natur- ally defended on all sides but the southwest, the side fac- ing toward Corinth. On the east flowed the Tennessee river, its bank at this time at the Landing being a steep decline of more than eighty feet. The north side of the camp was covered by Snake creek, which empties into the river a little below the Landing. Owl creek, a tributary of Snake creek, enclosed the northwest side. To the southeast side Lick creek flov^s into the river above the Landing, and at the time of the battle in April, the volume of water in all these streams was greatly swelled by backwater, the river being swollen by the spring floods. The space included between these boundaries measures something over three miles in either direction. The ground is uneven, crossed and gashed by deep ravines and gullies, and in 1862 it was thickly wooded. Small roads, shown and named in the accompanying maps, in- tersected the plateau, and an occasional half-cleared field, or open place with a log house, let in daylight through the general tangle of forest and underbrush. On the road run- ning out toward Corinth, near the right of the position, was the rude log meeting-house known as Shiloh Church, from which the battlefield took its name. Here, and along the right to the crossing of Owl creek by the road leading from Pittsburg Landing to Purdy, a village some miles to the northwest, was the fifth division of the Army of the Tennessee, commanded by General William Te- cumseh Sherman, The division was made up of raw re- cruits, many of whom had never been under fire. Their leader was as yet undistinguished from the other promi- nent generals of the Union Army. On this field he was to THE BATTLE OF SHILOH ii become a figure to compel the respect and admiration of the entire country. Sherman's first brigade was command- ed by Colonel J. A. McDowell, the 2nd by Colonel David Stuart, the 3rd by Col. J. Hildebrand, the 4th by Colonel R. P. Buckland. The ist and 2d battalions of the 4th Illinois cavalry, and Battery "B" and Battery "E" of the 1st Illinois Light Artillery were attached to this division. On Sherman's left, and somewhat overlapping his rear, was McClernand's division, the ist. next to him Prentiss', the 6th, while Stuart's brigade, of Sherman's command, held the extreme left, on Lick creek. Prentiss' division was made up of unassigned troops arriving at Pittsburg Landing on and after the 26th day of March, 1862. The ist brigade was of four regiments commanded by Col. Everett Peabody, and had been thor- oughly organized. The 2d brigade, only partially organ- ized, was commanded by Colonel Madison Miller. Three regiments had reported and were in camp. Other regi- ments were on their way up the river. The i6th Iowa infantry reported for duty on the 5th, but did not disem- bark until the morning of the 6th. The 15th Iowa and 23rd Missouri arrived at the Landing Sunday morning, and the 23rd reported to General Prentiss at the "Hor- net's Nest" about 9:30 a. m. (The 15th and i6th Iowa were, by General Grant's order, sent to McCler- nand early in the day.) The nth Illinois cavalry, the 5th Ohio battery, Hickenlooper's ; the ist Minnesota and Munch's batteries and the i8th Wisconsin infantry, not brigaded, were attached to Prentiss' division. McClernand's division was composed of three infantry brigades and Stewart's and Carmichael's Illinois cavalry, Battery "D" ist Illinois light artillery, and Battery "E" 2nd Illinois light artillery, and the 14th Ohio battery. Perhaps a mile and a half to the rear, stretching from Pittsburg Landing across to Snake creek, the divisions 12 ILLINOIS AT SHILOH of Hurlbut and C. F. Smith were stationed. General Smith was lying ill at Savannah, and was soon to die. His division was commanded by General William H. L. Wallace. Movements of the enemy were possible by the road which runs westward from Crump's Landing to the little town of Purdy. Lew Wallace remained at Crump's and along the Purdy road to watch that point of danger. By a road parallel with the Tennessee river he was con- nected with the Union reserve by a bridge over Snake creek. Hurlbut's three brigades were commanded, the ist by Colonel N. G. Williams, the 2nd by Colonel James C. Veatch, the 3rd by Brigadier General J. G. Lauman, and attached to it were the ist and 2nd battalions of the 5th Ohio cavalry, the 13th Ohio battery, Mann's battery, Missouri light artillery, and the 2nd Michigan battery. General Smith's old division, the 2nd, under command of Brigadier General- W. H. L. Wallace, comprised three brigades of infantry, and Company "C" of the 2nd U. S. cavalry, Company "I" 4th U. S. cavalry, and Com- panies "A" and "B" 2nd Illinois cavalry, with Battery "A" 1st Illinois light artillery (Willard's), and Batteries "D," "H" and "K," ist Missouri light artillery. Colonel James M, Tuttle commanded the ist brigade, Brigadier General John McArthur the 2nd, and Colonel T. W. Sweeney the 3rd. Colonel Morgan L. Smith, Colonel John M. Thayer and Colonel Charles Whittlesey were the brigade command- ers of General Lew Wallace's division, and attached to it, were Battery "I" ist Missouri light artillery, the 9th Indiana battery, the 3rd battalion, 5th Ohio cavalry, and the 3rd battalion, nth Illinois cavalry. There were present an aggregate of 39,830 Union sol- diers, officers and men at Pittsburg Landing, and in the 3rd division at Crump's, 7,564. GENHRAL B. M. PREXTISS, AS HE APPEARED IX LATER LIFE. THE BATTLE OF SHILOH 13 As has been indicated, the only quarter in which the Union Army was open to the enemy's assaults was its front, between Owl and Lick creeks, where the road from Corinth to Pittsburg Landing comes in. Later on in the war this line would have been well defended by entrench- ments of earth, and batteries of artillery. Now there was no attempt at anything of the kind. The Union Army, and the Confederate Army as well, were yet to learn the art of building defenses. Shiloh taught more than one of the terrible lessons that had to be. learned before the con- flict between the states had run its course of devasta- tion. This was the situation in the early April days of 1862. The two armies lay little more than twenty miles apart, and, North and South, the people awaited events. The Army of the Tennessee, soon to be joined by the Army of the Ohio, with General Buell in command, drilled and received arms and uniforms while it waited. The united forces were expected to move upon Corinth upon the order of the head of the army. General Halleck, when all should be ready. THE "ARM OF THE SOUTH." Albert Sydney Johnston, perhaps at this time the very "arm of the South" with instant recognition of the situa- tion, took into his hands the reins of power, carrying all before him by his forcible reasoning, and planned an im- mediate attack upon the camp at Pittsburg Landing. This was what the great Confederate leader saw: if he could wipe out the Northern forces already landed, and about equal to his own, before Buell, nearing Grant at Savannah, came up with his reserves, he could smash the Northern advance into the South and change, perhaps, the face of history. He seized the opportunity and moved his army from Corinth upon Pittsburg Landitig. 14 ILLINOIS AT SHILOH On the 3rd day of April, 1862, Johnston issued orders for the forward movement. Northeast the army marched, straight northeast from Corinth, the Army of the Mis- sissippi. Steadily tramped the infantry, steadily tramped, or floundered, or crept over muddy roads, and heavily clanged along the artillery; on the flanks and fronts sped the cavalry. Onward, under their intrepid leader, the whole army, horse, foot and guns, moved forward, the heads of columns touching Mickey's on the Corinth road, eight miles from Pittsburg Landing. Johnston had planned the attack on the Landing at sunrise, April 5th, but sunrise of that day did not see his army within striking distance. It was nearly nightfall of the 5th when the weary soldiers arrived and began forming in line of battle where they bivouacked to await the morning. Sunday dawned, bright and glorious, and the movement was resumed. On they came, Hardee's corps first, spread far out beyond the line of the road, Clerburne's brigade on the left, its flank at Widow How- ell's near Winningham creek, Wood's brigade next, extending across the road, Shaver's brigade on the right, with Gladden's brigade from Wither's division reaching and crossing the Bark road. On they marched, and eight hundred feet to the rear of Hardee's line came Bragg, with Chalmers, Jackson, Gib- son, Anderson and Pond, their lines overlapping and out- standing beyond Gladden on the right and Clerburne on the left. And then came Polk's corps, and Breckinridge's in columns by brigades following the road, and Steward, Russell, Johnson and Stephen, with their brigades, under Polk, and Trabue, Bowen and Stratham, under Breck- inridge. Away down in McCullar's field on Lick creek, on the extreme right of the advance, was Clanton's cavalry, with Avery's, Forest's and Adam's cavalry guarding Greer's £KlO OSNJL i6 ILLINOIS AT SHILOH inanity's sake — to surrender with the remnant of his force. On Saturday afternoon, April 5th, General Prentiss, whose division occupied the advance position of the left center of the camp, sent out, in addition to his usual ad- vance guard, a small force of infantry under Colonel Da- vid Moore. Late in the evening this force returned, after an extended reconnoissance, and Colonel Moore reported "some activity in front." Prentiss was impressed. He showed soldierly percep- tion then, as later he showed sacrificing wisdom and stub- born courage in the fight. At 3 o'clock Sunday morning he again sent out three companies to reconnoiter, this time from the 25th Missouri infantry and under command of Major Powell. Out on the Corinth road the detach- ment went in the darkness and, at 4:55 o'clock that morn- ing, the fringes of the forces touched and the fighting of the fearful day began. The force under Powell encoun- tered the Confederate pickets under Major Hardcastle, of Hardee's corps, in the woods near what was known as Fraley field, and a brisk engagement, lasting an hour and a half, ensued between these outposts. Here began the bloodshed of the day, to be augmented thousands of times before the sun set. At half past six o'clock in the morning the Confeder- ates of General Wood's brigade came sweeping in force upon the scene. Hardcastle and his pickets fell back to their places in the line. The grand general advance of the Confederate army had begun and Powell's little force was driven back to what was known as Seay field. Here came up reinforcements for Powell, though, of course, al- together insufficient. There were four companies of the i6th Wisconsin infantry which had been on picket duty near by, and five companies of the 21st Missouri infantry under Colonel Moore. They joined Powell, Moore took THE BATTLE OF SHILOH 17 command and sent back to Prentiss for the remainder of his regiment. Prentiss at once sent Peabody's brigade, which joined Powell's detachment at the southeast corner of Rhea field, the field to which point Powell had slowly withdrawn, fighting. With the arrival of reinforcements the strug- gle became more fierce. Meanwhile the casualties were becoming serious. Americans were killing each other swiftly. Fighting stubbornly, Peabody, now in command of the advanced portion of the Union forces, was driven back be- fore the advancing host. He did well against over- whelming odds, but was compelled to fall farther and farther with each fresh rush of the enemy. By this struggle the Confederate advance on the left had been delayed until nearly 8 o'clock, and information of what was going on in the front had reached the natural soldier, Prentiss. His division was at once formed for battle and awaited the coming onset. Peabody fell back to the line with Prentiss and the onset came at once. It was a furious one. Then began the first bloody fighting of the day on an extensive scale. To a clearing known as Spain field, Prentiss sent forward Miller's brigade of his division, some three hundred yards in advance of his main force, the advance being supported by two batteries, Hicken- looper's on the left and Munch's battery to the right of what was known as the Eastern Corinth road. The clash came without delay. The Confederates attacking were composed of Glad- den's brigade and the left of Chalmer's brigade. They came furiously, in superior force, and Miller and the batteries were forced back to join the main line, where Prentiss, fearing to be outflanked, had arrayed the regi- 1 8 ILLINOIS AT SHILOH ments of his division in their camps. The second attack soon came, made now by the brigades of Gladden and Shaver, assisted by a part of Wood's brigade and Chal- mer's right. Here ensued slaughter among both officers and men. Colonel Peabody, of the Union forces, who had accom- plished such gallant work in the morning, was killed, and General Gladden, of the charging Confederate forces, was mortally wounded. Charge after charge was made by the Confederates, who were repulsed viciously more than once, but they came in thousands, and though they, at the last, were compelled to charge over their own dead and wounded, the force of Prentiss could no longer, in the position it occupied, withstand the deadly battering of overwhelming numbers. At 9 o'clock Prentiss withdrew his force to the Union reserve line in the rear, taking a position at the left of General W. H. L. Wallace. He thus now occupied an advanced position in the left center of the Union force. Here was a wooded area with thick undergrowth and a sunken road next to a ridge which made a natural intrenchment ; here was a location so admirably adapted for defense that Prentiss never left it to go farther to the rear. The place received the name of "The Hornet's Nest" from the Confederates. It was now between 9 and 10 o'clock. Meanwhile there were furious happenings on the right flank of the Union army, where General W. T, Sherman was in command. SHERMAN AND McCLERNAND. While the pickets and advance guard of Sherman, like those of Prentiss, were engaged with the enemy's out- posts in distant fields and in the thick woods, where the strength of the attack could not be observed, the main body of troops in camp were at breakfast, or mustered THE BATTLE OF SHILOH 19 for Sunday morning inspection. Some regiments were just disembarking from the river boats, and from the Landing more than one regiment was, a few hours later, marched directly into action. General Sherman's division, being stationed in the ad- vance on the main road leading to Corinth, at Shiloh Church, felt the onset of the Confederates in force early Sunday morning. The advance guard was driven in be- tween 6 and 7 o'clock, and before that hour the whole di- vision was up in arms and forming in line of battle. On the Friday before, Sherman's pickets, posted a mile and a half out on the Corinth road, had been driven in by Confederate cavalry, and one lieutenant with seven of his men had been captured by the enemy. A detach- ment of Sherman's cavalry drove the Confederates back five miles, killing several of them. Had the little battalion of Union cavalry started out on such an errand on Satur- day, and pursued their way as far, they would have seen something to make them gallop back and report to head- quarters with a rush. On Saturday the Confederate cavalry had been "again very bold — coming well down to our front," says Gen- eral Sherman, in one of his reports; yet Sherman did not believe the enemy contemplated anything beyond "a strong demonstration." The pickets had heard men talk- ing in the woods, and the men of McDowell's brigade on the right could, Sunday morning at sunrise, plainly see the enemy swarming in the woods across Shiloh branch. The new recruits, of whom much of Sherman's division was made up, had begun to feel that now, indeed, they were "in the enemy's country." Sherman's line of battle had for its left center Shiloh Church. Here he posted Taylor's battery, with its cap- tain, S. E. Barrett in command. Waterhouse's battery he planted on a ridge to the left and front with a clear 20 ILLINOIS AT SHILOH range toward the enemy over open ground. Two guns of this battery were in the advance at Rhea field. Sher- man's 3rd brigade, under Colonel Hildebrand, and his 2nd brigade, Colonel Buckland commanding, were formed across the road, Hildebrand on the left, Buckland on the right. McDowell's brigade constituted his right wing. At the bridge across Owl creek, one gun of Behr's bat- tery was posted, and McDowell's line of infantry extended to the left behind Shiloh branch and the gullies leading into the stream. Eight companies of the 4th Illinois cav- alry were posted in an open field to the left and rear of Shiloh Church. When giving orders for his own division to form, Sher- man had sent word to General McClernand to support him, and to General Hurlbut to go to the support of Prentiss. Colonel Stuart, commanding Sherman's second brigade, was guarding the ford over Lick creek, away to the left, separated from his division by the breadth of the whole field. He was to fight a battle of his own that day. General Sherman, with his staff, rode along the left of his line a few minutes after 7 o'clock. As he passed the 53rd Ohio infantry, in Rhea field, he was fired upon by the enemy's pickets, who were concealed in the bushes which lined Shiloh branch, a stream which flowed along Sherman's entire front. Thomas D. HolHday, of Company "H," 2nd Illinois cavalry, Sherman's orderly, was killed by this fusilade from the thickets already held by the enemy. The gulley of the stream gave the ad- vancing Confederates cover, but as they crossed the Union men were so posted as to get a telling fire at them as they ascended the rising ground on the Union side. A Confederate battery opened upon the Union line and the 53rd, after firing two rounds, fell back into the woods, and THE BATTLE OF SHILOH 21 the two guns of Waterhouse's were recalled to the main battery. General Sherman now saw the glistening bayonets of heavy masses of infantry to his left front in the woods beyond Shiloh branch and became convinced, for the first time, that the enemy designed to make a determined at- tack upon the whole Union camp. All along the line of Sherman's division, even on the extreme right, the Con- federates were advancing. Every man of the attacking force was headed straight for the Landing. A large body of Confederates crossed the open field in front of Waterhouse's battery unmolested, as they displayed what was taken for the American flag, and wore uniforms simi- lar to those of the Union forces. All doubt was dispelled, as Sherman watched the heavy masses of men marching obliquely to the left, and noted other battalions pressing directly upon him. He saw that the enemy intended passing his left flank to fall upon McClernand and Prentiss, and he heard the sound of musketry and artillery announcing that Prentiss was en- gaged. General McClernand's 3rd brigade had reached the field, and it was posted to protect Waterhouse's bat- tery and the left of the line. The Confederates pressed forward impetuously, giving the "Rebel yell," something as yet unknown to Sherman's raw recruits, but after- ward to be recognized on many a bloody field. Raith's brigade held its ground in support of the bat- tery, and this command soon had to hold the left alone, for Hildebrand's command practically disappeared, though Colonel Hildebrand, himself, remained with a por- tion of his regiment, the 77th Ohio infantry. The vigor- ous advance of the Confederates from the left and front in overwhelming numbers with a severe fire, told upon the command and, with a stubborn resistance, it finally 2 2 ILLINOIS AT SHILOH gave way and fell back, followed closely by the enemy, who captured three of Waterhouse's guns. Sherman's left thus turned, and with the enemy pressing heavily upon his whole line, the general still held Shiloh Church and sent urgent orders to Buckland and McDowell to hold their ground. These brigades were already engaged with the enemy all along Shiloh branch. Sherman held fast, inflicting heavy punishment upon the Confederate forces, which attacked him with tremen- dous vim and force. Clerburne's Confederate brigade, in attempting to cross the marshy ground of Shiloh branch, received the concentrated fire of Raith's and Buckland's brigades and was repulsed with heavy losses, the 6th Mississippi losing over 70 per cent, in killed and wounded. Anderson's brigade of Bragg's corps, now came to the attack, but this command, too, was hurled back with severe losses. The enemy then advanced in overwhelming numbers, Clerburne, Anderson, Johnson, Russell and Wood and, at 10 o'clock drove Sherman's remaining two brigades and Raith's, across the Purdy road. The camps of Sherman's three brigades and three guns were lost. In this fight at Rhea field and around Shiloh Church, the Confederate General Clark, who commanded a divis- ion, and General Johnson, who commanded a brigade, were severely wounded. The stubborn resistance of Sherman was of untold value to the Union army, as he disputed the direct road to the Landing, and in holding back the enemy for two hours gave the forces posted near the Landing time to get on the field and ready for action. The capture of the three guns of Waterhouse's bat- tery elated the spirits of the Confederates. They began to note the thousand incidents of battle, stirring, grim or pathetic. General Vaughn, who came up to the aban- THE BATTLE OF SHILOH 23 doned Union guns with the 13th Tennessee infantry, the regiment which claimed their capture, saw an affecting scene upon that field of carnage. A dead Union ofificer lay upon the ground near the guns, and, keeping guard over the dead body, was a pointer dog that refused to al- low any one to approach the mortal remains of its mas- ter. The majority of Union soldiers were not, at this hour of the day, closely observant of the small events of bat- tle, tragic or comic. They had no time for contempla- tion. A fighter on that day. Lieutenant Lemmon, of the 49th Illinois, asked in later years, as to certain details of the battle, could but respond: "Well, I don't know just how it was, only the Rebs wouldn't let us stay anywhere, Sunday, and we did the same thing to them next day." Behr's battery, of McDowell's brigade, was lost as it came with McDowell's troops on Sherman's order to McDowell and Buckland to fall back to the Purdy road. Sherman met the battery at the cross roads, and ordered it to immediately unlimber and come into battery action to cover the withdrawal of Sherman's forces. Captain Behr gave the order, but immediately after doing so, he was shot, and fell dead from his horse. The men aban- doned five out of the six guns, and fled in disorder. The Confederates had gained the bridge across Owl creek, but McDowell had not become seriously engaged with them when he received the order to retire and form wnth the division on its new line. Thus McDowell's camp fell into the hands of the enemy. Raith's brigade, which was made up of four Illinois regiments, the 17th, 29th, 43rd and 49th, lost heavily dur- ing the first sharp encounter at and around Shiloh Church. General Sherman, in his official report, declares that his division "was made up of regiments perfectly new, nearly all of them having only recently received their o-uns at Paducah. None of them had ever been under fire, 24 ILLINOIS AT SHILOH nor had they ever seen heavy masses of the enemy, bear- ing down upon them as they did on that morning," at Shiloh. His 3rd brigade, he admits, "did break much too soon," but he insists that from them could not be ex- pected the coolness and steadiness of older troops. Of Colonel Hildebrand, the brigade commander, Sherman says : "He was as cool as any man I ever saw, and no one could have made stronger efforts to hold men to their places than he did." After the disorganization of his command he acted as aide for General McClernand until night fell upon that Sunday of struggle and threatened disaster. REVIEW FIELD AND CORINTH ROAD. The sound of heavy firing was heard in McClernand's camps, that is, on the right wing, before there was any call to arms. The division was placed along the Corinth road, stretching from within a half mile of Shiloh Church to Jones' field. In the camp of the i8th Illinois regiment in Jones' field the men were in line for Sunday morning inspection, awaiting the reviewing officer, when numbers of men, mostly without arms, were seen hurrying across the northern part of the field toward the Tennessee river. The confused appearance of these stragglers aroused officers and men, and a messenger was despatched to ask explanation for this flight of strangers across the camp. The messenger quickly returned and reported that the fleeing men were from Sherman's command at the front. They said that Sherman's division was "all cut to pieces," that the "woods were full of Rebels," and urged the mes- senger himself to run for his life. Scarcely had the appearance of clouds of stragglers running through the lines been explained to McClernand's excited men, when the order came for the division to move to the front. THE BATTLE OF SHILOH 25 Nearer the engagement, in the camp of Marsh's bri- gade, the first news of a serious attack on the camp came in the form of a shell from one of the enemy's batteries as it passed directly over the camp of the 20th Illinois infantry, whose camp was on the left of the road. The long roll beat, and the brigade formed and moved into place, its left touching Review field, and extending to the right toward Sherman's left. Hare's brigade was formed in the edge of the woods skirting the open field on the left of Marsh, Hare's right touching the northwest corner of Review field, where McAllister's battery was planted. Burrows' battery was at the center of Marsh's command, and Dresser's battery was stationed at its right, near Water Oaks pond. Veatch's brigade, of Hurlbut's division, was sent to reinforce McClernand, and it formed behind Marsh's brigade. The Confederates attacked McClernand's position with great vigor, and in tremendous force. Polk led a com- bined force of seven brigades against Sherman and Mc- Clernand. The right of this attacking line of Confeder- ates extended across the farther edge of Review field and became engaged with W. H. L. Wallace's troops at Dun- can House, and at the same time Stephen's brigade en- gaged Tuttle and Prentiss at the "Hornet's Nest." As Hare's brigade was moving into line with large masses of the enemy in plain view across the field, the left companies of the 13th Iowa infantry overlapped the right companies of the i8th Illinois infantry to the rear, and fired through the i8th. Colonel Crocker ordered the for- mation rectified, remarking that there appeared to be "plenty of rebels there to be shot at, without our pepper- ing one another!" With the first volley from the enemy serious work be- gan. Raith's brigade, falling back with Sherman, joined 26 ILLINOIS AT SHILOH Marsh on the right, and all along the line from left to right, away out beyond the cross-roads, where Sherman was stubbornly fighting, a fierce contest raged. At ii o'clock Hare, Marsh and Veatch were forced back, losing Burrow's battery, one gun from McAllister's battery and one from Schwartz's battery, which had joined McCler- nand's right. Sherman still held the right, tenaciously, and McCler- nand, rallying his forces, made a new stand, but again he was pressed back, losing four guns from Dresser's battery. He had been driven through his own headquarters and his losses were great, but again he rallied and drove the Confederates back, recoving his headquarters, and captur- ing Cobb's Kentucky battery at noon. It is impossible to give an account of the swaying tides of battle as they swept, back and forth, in Shiloh's field. One surviving officer of the 20th Illinois infantry declares that his regiment passed backward and forward over its own regimental camp ground seven times. It was as if two huge Titans were gripped in a wrestler's embrace, now staggering onward, now reeling back, now swaying blindly from right to left. The charges were swift rushes, ending in fights at close quarters, and then came charges of the same character from the opposing side. Meantime Sherman was grimly holding the right, but at 10 o'clock his whole line, hard pressed in front and flanked on the left, had fallen back, some parts of it in great disorder. McDowell's brigade retained its organi- zation, and rallied at McClernand's right, at the new line beyond the crossing of the Purdy and Hamburg road with the Corinth road. Buckland's brigade, in falling back, had become disorganized and scattered. A frag- ment of the 70th Ohio infantry, with its colonel, rallied and joined Raith's brigade. Now raged a terrific con- flict for "four long hours," reported General Sherman, THE BATTLE OF SHILOH 27 and here General Grant came at 3 p. m. to look over the ground personally. The brave Raith had fallen mortally wounded, the 43rd Illinois infantry, surrounded, had cut its way out with great losses. The whole command had suffered severely. By 4 o'clock the situation had become untenable, and Sherman and McClernand determined to fall back to the north and rear, selecting a new line along the Savannah road, with a view to guarding the bridge by which General Lew Wallace was still anxiously ex- pected. This movement was not executed without diffi- culty, the enemy's cavalry threatening the retreating col- umns and following them closely. Sherman and McClernand repulsed the cavalry, but the Confederate infantry came on, pressing hotly, yet was held in check at Jones' field for a time by the Union infantry and artillery. At 4:30 p. m. Colonel Hare was wounded, and Colonel M. H. Crocker, of the 13th Iowa, took command of Mc- Clernand's ist brigade. The fighting continued and the withdrawal of the Union troops was forced, until, at last, they faced about, with Perry field in front of them, and the Savannah road in their rear, and then the men in blue kept the Confederates at a respectful distance during the closing hour of the day. Raith's and Veatch's brigades shared the fortunes of the right wing all day, and bivouacked with it Sunday night. One of the officers of the 20th Illinois infantry, who fought all day in Marsh's ranks, gives a reminiscence of the last engagement in his vicinity: "We made the final stand just at dusk, when it com- menced to rain. We were expecting an attack from the enemy, who were maneuvering in our front, but who in- stead charged a battery to our left, and were repulsed. General Sherman, with a handkerchief tied i^round his hand, was with General McClernand. ****** 28 ILLINOIS AT SHILOH They both witnessed the charge from the left of our regi- ment, General McCIernand standing, and General Sher- man sitting on a stump." General Sherman received a painful wound in the hand during Sunday's battle, but he was able to ignore his suffering and kept his post. He was again wounded, dur- ing the battle, according to General Grant's official re- port, but Sherman himself is silent as to his own personal sufferings and services, while he carefully reports what befell to and what was accomplished by and endured by his command, singling out officers and organizations for warm and generous praise. By tracing Sherman's retreat around by the right, and north of the center of the map of the field and noting the sharp pursuit by Trabue, Wharton and other Confeder- ates, it can be seen how, while Prentiss, W. H. L. Wallace and Hurlbut were holding the center at tremendous cost of life, the Confederates had completely flanked them by the right, and were now directly in the rear of the line of defense which was curving back on each side from the "Hornet's Nest." The wide wheel by the right to the rear, Sherman on the outer rim of the Union forces, McCIernand on his left, both fighting one engagement after the other with pursuing Confederates, was made by the two divisions in almost total ignorance of what was going on at the center. It was known to Sherman and McCIernand that the left had been driven in, but as late as April 24th, when McCIernand made his extended official report, to the com- manding general, he does not seem to have found out that Prentiss was not driven out of the "Hornet's Nest" and taken prisoner until 5 o'clock Sunday afternoon. On the other hand, regiments and detachments from the left and center were surprised, when marching to the rear on Sunday afternoon, to encounter Confederate THE BATTLE OF SHILOH 29 troops who were on their way to attack the rear of the Union center. Soon after 3 o'clock Wharton's cavalry, coming up Tighlman's creek, came upon and exchanged shots with the 52nd Illinois infantry which had been ordered to the right to reinforce McClernand. At the camp of the 15th Illinois infantry this regiment was en- gaged, as was Veatch's brigade, in the repulse of Pond's Confederate cavalry at 4:50 p. ra. The whole right and rear west of the Savannah road at this time swarmed with Confederates — cavalry and infantry. Along that road, kept open for General Lew Wallace, no reinforce- ments came during all the long day of hard fighting, re- sistance and disaster. After dark Lew Wallace and his division arrived. Night closed in. The rain fell in torrents. The ex- hausted men of the ist and 5th divisions stood, or sat with their backs to trees, all night. Only those tired to almost the point of exhaustion, lay down upon the soak- ing ground in merciful oblivion of all that was passing in the fields and woods over which they had been driven during the long day of battle. PRENTISS AND WALLACE HOLD THE CENTER. General W. H. L. Wallace had scarcely formed his line that Sunday morning, when it was attacked by the left of Shaver's brigade. Tuttle, riding at the head of his brigade along the eastern Corinth road, had discovered the Con- federates in the woods beyond Duncan field. He had at once turned the head of his command to the right and formed it in line in the old road behind Duncan field, just to the right of the place which the Confederate soldiers that day named "The Hornet's Nest." Of Sweeney's brigade, the 7th Illinois infantry and the 58th Illinois in- fantry, were on Tuttle's right, and the 8th Iowa infantry was some distance to his left. 30 ILLINOIS AT SHILOH About 9:30 a, m. Confederate artillery stationed in Re- view field opened fire upon Wallace. Almost simultane- ously the enemy's infantry attacked Tuttle's left, the 12th and 14th Iowa regiments. These commands, partially protected by timber, made a gallant stand, driving the enemy back with severe losses. Re-forming, and under cover of artillery fire, the Confederates renewed their attack. Stephen's brigade, a little later charged through the field. Wallace opened upon the enemy's line with artillery and musketry, repulsing him before he had passed the middle of the open space. Thus began the long struggle to hold the center of Shiloh plain. The position was, happily, a strong one. Better could not have been chosen, though, as a matter of fact it was not chosen, but resorted to by Wallace, and then by Prentiss, through the stress of an immediate necessity. For hours the Confederates dashed against this line, Prentiss at the center, Wallace on the right, and Hurlbut and McArthur holding them off in advance cf the left, until the left was finally driven back to Prentiss' line. Again and again the Confederates charged upon the Union line. Stephens, Stewart and Gibson, with infantry and artillery, and their frenzied bravery made little im- pression, so far as they could see. Only as the day wore on the Union ranks, from continuous hammering on both flanks, curved around, making a bend at its southern point and stretching back north. Wallace kept his line and held the road to the landing in his unyielding grip. One of the memorable incidents of the day was the strong defense made by the 9th Illinois infantr}--, one of the most perfectly drilled regiments then in the field, and well-disciplined in addition, just as was the 7th, which only lost less because accidentally protected by the ground it held. The regiment was on the left of Hurlbut's line THE BATTLE OF SHILOH 31 with Willard's battery between, and McArthur's command on its left. When Hurlbut's troops gave way the Con- federates fell furiously upon this regiment, but the 9th unflinchingly met its foe and, though cut of¥ from the Union line on either side, it succeeded in holding back the assaulting column of the Confederates, assisting in the holding of the line of retreat. Under the force of overwhelming numbers the regiment retired slowly and in good order, fighting every step. "We sidled away," writes the survivor of another brave Shiloh regiment. "I remember distinctly thinking we wouldn't be shot in the back," From the southwest had come the Army of the Con- federates, straight across the broken ground, and through woods and over ravines and gullies, every man of them accurately aimed for the Landing. Every southern sol- dier knew where he wanted to be, and every northern soldier knew that his business was to keep the southerner from reaching the goal of his desires. The situation of Prentiss and Wallace was now one of the first importance. General Grant ordered them to hold the center at all haz- ards, and it was their intention to obey the order. Sherman and McClernand on the right had disappeared, Stuart and McArthur held the left, and Hurlbut kept up the struggle at the Peach Orchard, soon to be referred to. At the old sunken road, "The Hornet's Nest," and at Duncan field, the on-coming Confederates still met Wallace and Prentiss. Nothing could break their line, when once its swaying, charging regiments got into the spirit of the engagement. Bending back at both ends, but solid at the center, the Union line made its defense, holding back the attacking forces for five hours, and more. Four times the enemy charged upon the Union position, with a pounding accompaniment of artillery, and each 32 ILLINOIS AT SHILOH time the attack was repelled with infinite spirit. The losses of the Confederates were great, and it became dif- ficult for their officers to rally them and lead them to re- newed attack. THE PEACH ORCHARD. The battle in the so-called Peach Orchard, was the most deadly of the battles within a battle on the wood-clad and irregular field of Shiloh. It was the first of the gigantic deadly grapples of the day at close quarters. Here came the first crucial test of the struggle between nearly ninety thousand Americans. Here was intelligent blood shed. The first crisis of the gory day had come and was recognized in all its importance by the brilliant Southern general in command. He had his plan — and it was excel- lent — he must turn the Union left by the fiercest of all fighting and seize the Landing. Then he would have at his mercy the disheveled Union forces, driven into the marshes to the north, and would have crumpled into fragments the army of invasion. Grant, with the remnant of his force under Buell and Nelson on the other side of the Tennessee river, would be an entity not to be feared but to be pressed. The war would continue, not in Ken- tucky or Tennessee, but in Ohio. The thing to do was to crush the army encamped at Pittsburg Landing. The rest must follow inevitably. One feels almost sorry that the light of a military genius so great should have been snuffed out on the fatal day of Shiloh. He w^as right in his conception of an op- portunity, but there were other Americans existent, with military gifts as great as that of Johnston, and there were rugged, plain fighters from the farms and workshops as ready to do or die as the splendid Southerners whom Johnston led. THE BATTLE OF SHILOH 33 The chivalry of the South was to be met by the sturdy manhood of the North. There was bloody work at hand. Perhaps neither Gettysburg nor any other battlefield of the war furnished a greater scene of courage and carnage than that afforded in and about that "Peach Orchard" — a field with a few peach trees at one side. It was an exhibi- tion of American valor not yet tempered by discretion or anything of knowledge of the art of fighting. It was simply an exhibition of valor, and it was splendid! Perhaps a mile and a quarter from the Landing was an open field through which ran the road from Pittsburg Landing to Corinth. At 8 o'clock General W. H. L. Wal- lace encamped near the Landing, but hurrying to the front at the first alarm, had taken his ist and 3rd brigades and three batteries of artillery and placed them in posi- tion just east of this open space, which is named Duncan field. Sweeney's brigade was posted north of the road. Tuttle's brigade was formed in the wood and brush fring- ing the field, its left in an old road which wound its way curvingly from the Corinth road southward, and then bent eastward to reach the Hamburg and Savannah road. Three batteries were placed on a ridge back of Tuttle's command. Here at the left of Wallace, Prentiss took his third po- sition a few minutes after 9 o'clock, and here he was joined by the 23rd Missouri infantry, which added about 600 men to his fragment of a division. In Prentiss' morn- ing fights and retreat his command had dwindled to less than a thousand men, but those men gave a good account of themselves before the night fell. General Hurlbut hurried out to the support of Prentiss, taking his ist and 3rd brigades and his artillery along the Hamburg road. Hurlbut commanded in person, and as he drew near the rear and left of Prentiss' second line 34 ILLINOIS AT SHILOH the regiments of Prentiss' division drifted by, and through Hurlbut's command, in broken masses, the enemy follow- ing close upon the flying troops. Hurlbut put his troops in line of battle at Peach Or- chard field, Williams' brigade along the south side, and Lauman's brigade along the west side of the field, with its right in the woods near the sunken road. The artillery was planted in the field. General McArthur, commanding the 2nd brigade of W. H. L. Wallace's division, had been called upon for three of his regiments to serve in different parts of the field and had been ordered to the support of Stuart and he moved, with the 9th and 12th Illinois infantry and Wil- lard's battery, along the same road taken by Hurlbut. Stuart was stationed some distance to the left and front, McArthur formed his line just east of the Peach Orchard, and some distance from Stuart's right, with Willard's battery just off the road to the left, then the 9th and 12th Illinois infantry. Thus the Union troops were formed on the left for the protection of the center. Along this line and at Peach Orchard raged a fierce battle for many hours. Prentiss was in slow retreat, passing Hurlbut's right, and the Confederates were following him closely to his last stand — the sunken road at the right of the Ham- burg and Savannah road, where he continued his defense of the center. In the Peach Orchard, as already ex- plained, Hurlbut formed the first brigade along the south- ern side of the open ground, the 3rd brigade continuing the line with an obtuse angle around the western side of the field, and extending some distance into the brush and timber. Three batteries were so placed as to command the approaching enemy. In this position the right of Chalmer's and Gladden's Confederate brigades in hot pur- suit of Prentiss, attacked Hurlbut's waiting lines. THE BATTLE OF SHILOH '^ v 35 The fight opened with fire from three Confederate bat- teries which were now occupying Prentiss' abandoned camps. A shell from one of these batteries blew up a caisson belonging to Myer's 13th Ohio battery, and the men stampeded, abandoning their guns, but volunteers from Mann's battery, Missouri light artillery, rescued the frightened horses and spiked the pieces, so that the lost battery should not be of use to the enemy, if captured. Colonel Williams, commander of the ist brigade, was dis- abled by a cannon shot which killed his horse and ren- dered him helpless for the remainder of the battle. Lauman's brigade was now engaged, and it held its ground by a steady and continuous fire, driving back the enemy in confusion after a half hour's fight. Meanwhile Hurlbut saw the glimmer of bayonets at the left and front of the 1st brigade, and prepared for the onset of a superior force. The left of the line, held by the 9th and 12th Illi- nois and Willard's battery, was sharply attacked, and at the same time a strong force of steady, well-drilled troops formed in columns, doubled on the center and came over the open ground in front. They advanced to within four hundred yards of Williams' brigade, now commanded by Colonel Pugh, and then Mann's and Ross' batteries opened upon them, while four regiments of infantry, thrown forward slightly to flank them, gave them a sharp fire of musketry. The alert, brisk defense soon drove the Confederates back to cover, and upon the field they left many dead and wounded. Some of the rear of Prentiss' retreating forces now joined Hurlbut's line, and held it while ammunition was supplied to Williams' and Lauman's brigades, Ross' and Mann's batteries keeping up a steady and effective fire. With renewed energy Hurlbut's men resumed the battle, and until half past one they held their position on two sides of the Peach Orchard. To the left, across the road. 36 ILLINOIS AT SHILOH McArthur's two regiments were fighting their own bat- tle. Hurrying to Stuart's support Sunday morning, Mc- Arthur at lo o'clock ran into Jackson's Confederate brigade, which was headed for the Landing. The opposing forces became hotly engaged; there was a stubborn contest until about 2 o'clock, with unyielding vigor on each side. General Johnston, having assumed personal command of the right of his army, determined to break the stubborn resistance of McArthur, and of Stu- art, who held the extreme left with a sturdy grip. Bow- en's brigade was sent to support Jackson, and was closely followed by Stratham's, Stephen's and Gladden's brigades, in an attack upon Hurlbut in the Peach Orchard. Stuart was forced back, McArthur's left was exposed and he was driven over to Hurlbut. A new line was formed at the north side of the Peach Orchard, Lauman's brigade being transferred to Hurlbut's left in support of McArthur. Here McArthur was severely wounded and taken from the field. At half past two o'clock p. m., General Johnston — the Confederate leader — while in front of McArthur's lines, was struck by a minie ball and killed. After his death the command of the Confederate advance on the Union center was turned over to General Ruggles. Hurlbut, after a gallant stand at his second position, w^as compelled by the forces of Clanton, Chalmers, Jack- son and Bowen, who steadily pressed upon the left, to draw back to the left of Prentiss' line. At 4 o'clock p. m. Hurlbut's line was extended from the broken ground at his left across the Hamburg and Savannah road, joining Prentiss on his right. Meanwhile Stuart, at the extreme left of the Union line, was bitterly engaged and overmatched by the Confederate forces of Generals Chalmers and Jackson. To crush Stu- art meant the turning of the Union flank and the opening of a path to Pittsburg Landing. But Stuart made a stub- THE BATTLE OF SHILOH 37 born resistance while to his right the Peach Orchard's deadly struggle was in progress and Prentiss was holding the sunken road, the "Hornet's Nest," and so the force attacking Stuart was not as overwhelming as it might have been. There was good fighting where he was, though not of such magnitude as in and about the Peach Orchard and in front of the "Hornet's Nest." But the ghastly struggle was at the Peach Orchard. The Union center must be broken to make effective the flanking movement around the Union left which Johnston had in mind as the way of seizing the Landing. He came in person to direct the fight in and about that open field destined that day to become famous as one of the greatest of stages of slaughter in the history of warfare. It was here the great general who had conceived the grand attack was killed, shot in the leg and bleeding to death from a severed artery. Seven times were charges made by the Confederates across the field and seven times were they repulsed, but at last force in numbers prevailed, and Hurlbut and Mc- Arthur were compelled to retire, falling back toward the Landing, toward which Stuart at the extreme left re- treated almost simultaneously. There was fighting at the Peach Orchard! As a result of the desperate advances and retreat, the green field was literally carpeted with the slain. No wonder that Grant, in his memoirs, said of the scene upon that field : *T saw an open field in our possession the second day, over which the Confederates had made repeated charges the day before, so covered with dead that it would have been possible to walk across the clearing, in any direction, stepping on dead bodies without a foot touching the ground. On one part bushes had grown up to a height of eight or ten feet, there was not one of these left un- pierced by bullets. The smaller ones were all cut down." 38 ILLINOIS AT SHILOH It was somewhat to the left of the Union center that there was what has become known in American history as the "Bloody Pond." It was a sheet of water about a city's block in extent and exists in the forest of Shiloh battle- field today, shallow and sluggish but still water, possibly water from some of the springs so abundant in the coun- try where the great struggle took place. Here, to as- suage their thirst and lave themselves, limped or crawled the desperately wounded, of both forces, as the tide of battle shifted. The water became red, and hence the name of "Bloody Pond." But though the "Bloody Pond" was encircled by the dead at nightfall, its cool waters un- doubtedly aided in the saving of many lives. And so between 2 and 4 o'clock Hurlbut, McArthur's two regiments and Stuart fell back to near the Landing, the stubborn Prentiss remaining in his "Hornet's Nest" to be captured in the end after having saved the center all the day. THE "HORNET'S NEST." The Confederate General Ruggles, who had taken the place of General Johnston, determined to concentrate his artillery upon the hitherto impregnable center. At half past three o'clock p. m., he placed ten batteries between Duncan field and Review field, and facing due east. To support these batteries he brought up the brigades of Gibson, Shaver, Wood, Anderson and Stewart, with the 38th Tennessee and Crescent regiment of Pond's brigade, and with these forces once more attacked the Union line. The concentrated fire of sixty-two guns drove away the Union batteries, but could not dislodge the infantry from its sheltered position in the old road. Of the batteries it may be remarked here that, where all did well, Willard's battery, commanded by Lieutenant P. P. Wood, particu- larly distinguishing itself in the battle of Shiloh. It was THE BATTLE OF SHILOH 39 engaged continuously during the engagements of both days. Its loss was thirty men killed and wounded, and the fact that it went into the second day's battle with but three pieces, was only because of lack of men and horses. There was a remarkable incident connected with the re- tirement of this battery from the Peach Orchard. A gun on which were two wounded artillerymen was being hauled away by a single horse, when it became "stalled" in the mud. Eager to save their comrades and the gun, members of the battery seized the spokes of the wheels but could not move the piece. In the midst of their heav- ing a minie ball struck the horse at the junction of the tail and body, and its tremendous leap took the gun out of the mire. Both of the wounded men and the gun were saved. A terrific onslaught upon the left cut off Hurlbut and McArthur, driving them back, first to the left of Pren- tiss, then to the rear, leaving Prentiss' remnant and Wal- lace's depleted ranks to deal with the whole of Bragg's forces on the left, while their right was assailed by Polk and Hardee who had chased McClernand and Veatch to the Hamburg road and then turned upon Wallace, who was hammering them from the front. Flanked, and about to be surrounded, Wallace attempted to with- draw by the left flank, and succeeded in getting Tuttle and two of his regiments to the rear. Wallace, himself, in passing the lines closing behind him, was mortally wound- ed, and Prentiss, and what remained of his division, and four of Wallace's regiments — which were trying to force their way to the Landing — were captured. There were not left many of the heroic band of fighters to be carried away as prisoners of war. The remnants of regiments which had begun the morn- ing repelling the early attacks of the enemy, had lost heavily in the first engagements, on their retreat, and af- ter they were entrenched in the old road. Falling back 40 ILLINOIS AT SHILOH with Prentiss, to his third line, were about two hundred of the 21 St Missouri infantry and about one hundred of the I2th Michigan infantry, these being remnants of Pea- body's shattered brigade. Fragments of the i8th Wiscon- sin infantry — about three hundred men in all — with a few handfuls of men whose organizations had been completely broken up. These, with the 23rd Missouri infantry, formed the material of which Prentiss made his last line at the Hornet's Nest. These regiments reported nine hundred and four offi- cers and men captured or missing. Wallace's four cap- tured regiments reported twelve hundred and sixty-seven officers and men captured or missing. A total of two thousand one hundred and seventy-one made prisoners of war by the surrender of Prentiss, General Prentiss himself being one of the captured officers. THE DEFENSE OF THE LANDING. The heroic stand of Prentiss and Wallace in the old road near Duncan field had served the Union cause well. Prentiss was a prisoner in the hands of the enemy, and W. H. L. Wallace lay mortally wounded upon the field held by the Confederates, but the stubborn fight, waged from half past nine in the morning until half past five in the afternoon, taking the whole strength of the Confeder- ates to subdue the spirited resistance, had saved the day to the Federal Army. General Grant showed his wonderful generalship on the day at Shiloh. With headquarters at the Landing, he kept ammunition moving toward the front all day, and had visited in person every part of the Union Army in its various battles. He was with Sherman and McClernand in their stubborn fight at the cross-roads, he visited Pren- tiss and W. H. L. Wallace in the "Hornet's Nest," and talked with McArthur, on the left of the Peach Orchard, THE BATTLE OF SHILOH 41 encouraging them to hold the left center at all hazards. He sent messengers to Lew Wallace, who, with his com- mand was wandering in the mazes of the swamps and winding roads north of Snake creek, and he collected and arranged, with careful precision, the boats for transport- ing Buell's army across the river when its detachments should arrive. At 2 o'clock p. m., when a desperate and apparently losing fight was raging all along the lines, with the right of the army not whipped, but disorganized, the left being slowly driven in, and the center severely pressed by over- whelming forces. General Buell arrived by boat from Savannah, in advance of his army. His first inquiry, wrote John A. Rawlins, then Grant's Assistant Adjutant General, was: "What preparations have you made for retreating?" To which Grant replied: "I have not yet despaired of whipping them, General." General Lew Wallace's division from Crump's Landing was still anxiously looked for, and General Nelson's divi- sion of Buell's army might also arrive at any moment by the wagon road from Savannah. So, from Commander- in-Chief down to every private in the ranks, every heart was buoyed up by the hope of reinforcements by fresh, well-drilled and disciplined troops. It is now known that through misunderstandings as to the road to be taken, and also by reason of the condi- tion of the roads themselves, Wallace's division was de- layed while making the most strenuous exertions to get upon the field of battle. General Wallace marched with his columns, at noon, from Crump's Landing, not quite six miles from Pittsburg Landing, by the river road, but after going some distance along the road which comes in two miles or more from the river, Wallace learned from General Grant's officers sent to hurry him, he must take the river road. He turned back, thus delaying 42 ILLINOIS AT SHILOH his arrival, as he had to march fifteen miles altogether, over bad roads. He came over Snake creek on the Savan- nah road, arriving a little after dark, when the fighting and carnage of Sunday were over. General William Nelson, commanding the 4th division of the Army of the Ohio, left Savannah at i 130 p. m., Sunday, April 6th, and marched by land to the point op- posite Pittsburg Landing. "The anxiety of the soldiers to take part in the battle which was going on, on the left bank of the river enabled me to achieve the distance" (nine miles) "notwithstanding the dreadful state of the road over a lately overflowed bottom, in four hours," re- ported General Nelson. At 5 o'clock p. m. tlie head of his column, Amnion's brigade, landed and marched up the bank at Pittsburg Landing, and took up its position in the road, says Nelson, "under fire of the Confederate ar- tillery, so close had the enemy approached the Landing." General Nelson and Colonel Ammon, commanding the loth brigade of Nelson's division, described the situation at the Landing in their official reports as desperate. The fire of a semicircle of artillery, totally unsupported by in- fantry, was the only check to the audacious approach of the enemy, whose advance had crossed Dill branch pro- tected by the fire of Gage's Confederate battery upon the heights on the farther shore. At this critical hour Prentiss and Wallace were mak- ing their last fight, assisted by Hurlbut, and every avail- able fragment of the commands which had been driven in from the front. General Grant and his aides had met the flying Union soldiers, and, whenever there was any semblance of order or organization, had gathered the bands of fugitives together under an officer, and sent them back along the road toward the "Hornet's Nest." But Hurlbut could no longer hold his line, and was already THE BATTLE OF SHILOH 43 heading toward the Landing to prevent being cut off from the river by the troops of the enemy which he saw forming on his left. Down upon the river bank a crowd of panic-stricken soldiers clamored to Nelson's arriving troops, crying out that the day was lost, and the Union army whipped. There were ten thousand or more of these runaways, Nelson and Ammon reported. For the moment the Landing was defended by the batteries alone, Chief of .\rtillery Webster having formed them as they came in from the field. Generals Grant, Buell and Nelson were on the ground, each cool, alert and unshaken in determination to hold the lines which were forming out of the chaos of defeat, by the soldiers who remained in organizations under cool, watchful officers. At the Landing General Grant sent the 36th Indiana infantr>' and part of the 6th Ohio infantry, Ammon's ar- riving brigade, to support the left of the artillery, Stone's battery, about one hundred yards to the left of the road. The line was formed quickly, Generals Buell and Nelson assisting. Two regiments were placed in position behind the crest of the hill, their left protected by a deep ravine with water in it, the right about three hundred yards from the Landing. One man of the 36th Indiana infantry was killed while the regiment was forming. The Confederates came up the hill out of the Dill branch ravine, and received, as they advanced, the fire of the Indiana regiment. The artillery and the guns of the boats on the river now opened upon the Confederates. They fell back, rallied, advanced again and were once more driven down hill, and as dusk came on, they crossed the ravine to their own lines. Meanwhile the Hornet's Nest had fallen into the enemy's hands and the Confederate army, weary with a 44 ILLINOIS AT SHILOH long day's fighting, were being urged forward by confi- dent and persistent officers, who saw victory within their grasp. Small detachments of Gladden's and Anderson's ad- vance formed at the head of the ravine, and Colonel Lind- say, of the 1st Mississippi cavalry, charged upon and cap- tured Ross' battery as it was withdrawing from position near Hurlbut's headquarters. These gathering clans were dispersed by the infantry fire of the Union forces which were now centering about the batteries planted along the main road leading from the Landing. The gunboats on the river opened fire, throwing their great shells far back over the enemy's forces, doing little physical damage, but their work told in its demoralizing ef- fect upon the exhausted officers and soldiers of the Confed- eracy. The impression that a mighty artillery defense would be made at the Landing, assisted by the destroying guns on the river boats, seized upon the minds of the Southerners. General Braxton Bragg, who was on the field near the Landing, strained every nerve to form his columns and continue the fight. Filled with enthusiastic ardor after the triumphs of the day, Bragg saw no remote prospect of defeat. As soon as the scattered Confederate troops had been gathered and formed, after the series of terrible and finally successful assaults upon the posi- tion of Prentiss and W. H. L. Wallace, the order was given to "Move forward at all points and sweep the enemy from the field." Bragg's Confederates, he says in his report, although greatly exhausted by twelve hours of incessant fighting, without food, responded with alacrity. Over upon the plateau at the Landing hurried preparations were under way for a stubborn defense. The available Union forces were massed behind the batteries, and for the first time that day the Federal troops were in a continuous line of THE BATTLE OF SHILOH 45 battle. The line reached from the Landing out to the Hamburg and Savannah road, and stretched north along the Hamburg and Savannah road to Snake creek and south nearly to the Corinth road. With calm determination Grant, Buell and Nelson awaited attack, w^hile the boom of the gunboats' fire shook the air, and an occasional volley of musketry marked the movement of the Confederates on the left in the skir- mishes along Dill branch. The expected conflict did not come. At dusk General Beauregard, the Confederate commanding general, now occupying the Union camps at Shiloh Church, sent or- ders to General Bragg and his brigade commanders, with- drawing all the Confederate forces out of reach of the Union fire. Night fell upon the field covered with dead and wound- ed, foes lying side by side. The Confederates, such as were unharmed, revelled in the rich spoils of the cap- tured camps, the loot of which contributed in no small degree to the demoralization of the victors, nothing break- ing up discipline and organization more surely than the division of the spoils of war among any band of victorious soldiery. The Confederates and the Federals alike counted their heavy losses, and in some cases succored their wounded, and prepared for the morrow. All night the great guns of the boats on the river threw their missiles far into the field, compelling the withdrawal out of range of Beaure- gard's army. Lew Wallace's division and Nelson's and Crittendon's were within the Union lines. All the even- ing the transports on the river had made their rounds from shore to shore with Buell's army marching onto the vessels and standing ready to march ofif without break- ing rank. During the night Buell's artillery and Mc- Cook's division arrived, and Rousseau's brigade followed, 46 ILLINOIS AT SHILOH early Monday morning. A drenching rain fell and South- ern and Northern soldiers — wearied and worn — lay out on the ground, oblivious or wakeful, making ready for the morrow. General Grant passed the night under a tree, his head upon a saddle. He had given orders for a general advance upon the enemy at daybreak. General Bragg, in the captured camps, brooded oVer the ruin of all his hopes of ultimate victory. "The battle is lost," he had exclaimed, when a staff officer brought Beauregard's order for his withdrawal at dark. MONDAY'S BATTLE. At dawn Monday morning there was a general move- ment of the whole Federal army forward. The Union forces had made their line during the night from the Landing out to and extending to the right along the Ham- burg and Savannah road to Snake creek. Lew Wallace was at the extreme right, and at his left were Sherman's,. McClernand's and Hurlbut's broken brigades. During the night the remainder of General Nelson's and General Crittendon's divisions of the Army of the Ohio had arrived upon the field. General Crittenden formed his line with his right resting upon the Corinth road. General Nelson, to his left, formed his men across the Hamburg road; the 2nd Iowa infantry and the 15th Illinois infantry extended the line to the overflowed lands along the river. Two brigades of General McCook's di- vision arrived at 8 a. m. and formed on Crittendon's right. Boyle's brigade of Crittendon's division was held in re- serve. The reinforcing troops were fresh, as compared with those who had been fighting all day Sunday, but the hur- ried march to the fields over muddy roads had been ex- tremely fatiguing, and the Army of the Ohio had by no THE BATTLE OF SHILOH 47 means fared easily by the way. McCook's men had marched twenty-two miles Sunday, and a portion of them had stood all night in the streets of Savannah, in a driving storm. The troops of both Grant's and Buell's armies were soaked with rain, having been without shelter dur- ing Sunday night, but no word of complaint was heard from the grim fighters who stood ready at daylight Mon- day, to redeem the fortunes of yesterday. Down on the banks of the Tennessee at the Landing and all along the river, were stragglers and refugees whose shameful cowardice embarrassed the brave rein- forcing troops who had almost to fight their way up the road to the field of battle. These runaways filled the air with their complaints and cries, calling out to the coming soldiers that the Union army was whipped. In con- temptuous silence the fighters of Buell passed them by on their way to join the fighters of Grant on the plateau above, where was to come, to the Union cause, before the sun should set, victory as overwhelming as that which had been inflicted upon the Federal army during Sunday up to the repelling of the enemy at the Landing at night. Besides Buell's 20,000 men and Wallace's 7,000, it has been estimated that there were some ten thousand of Grant's troops who had fought the previous day, and who were now again in line of battle. To meet this force Beauregard had perhaps 20,000 or 25,000 men, for the Confederate losses had been heavy, and their forces had been much demoralized and scattered by the looting of the Federal camps captured the day before. And the Confederates in line were wearied by the terriffic strain of Sunday's battle. The battle opened soon after daybreak. Nelson ad- vanced along the Hamburg road to attack Hardee, in Stuart's camp, out beyond the Peach Orchard. Next on the left of Chalmers, of Hardee's corps, was Jackson's 48 ILLINOIS AT SHILOH brigade. Then came Stewart, Clerburne, Stratham, Mar- tin and Trabue, the last two along the southwest side of Duncan field, Trabue extending across the main Corinth road. Anderson's, Gibson's, Wood's and Purcell's bri- gades, under Ruggles and Cheatham, extended the Con- federate line in a northwesterly direction to Jones' field. Breckinridge commanded the center, and Bragg the ex- treme left. Lew Wallace's division was early in the fray and by 7 o'clock had forced its way across Tighlman creek and had taken the heights to the south of it, driving Pond's forces back. Wallace now extended his right until he reached the Confederate left fiank. Hazen, Crittendon and McCook advanced upon Polk and Breckinridge, and a stubborn fight took place upon the field occupied by W. H. L. Wallace and Prentiss on Sunday. Again the "Hor- net's Nest" became a scene of devastation. General W. H. L. Wallace was found, still alive, lying upon the ground where he had fallen the day before. He was taken to Savannah, Tennessee, where he died four days later. Another fierce battle raged on the Corinth road south- west of Shiloh Church. Bragg was on the defensive here for the Union forces sought to get a firm hold upon the road and so cut off the Confederate connections with Cor- inth. For six hours a fight as severe as any that had raged on Sunday, was fought here. McCook's division carried off the honors of this part of the field. The stubborn fight of Nelson and Crittendon embarrassed the Confed- erates opposed to McCook, as reinforcements had to be sent to the center, thus weakening their left. The Union line pushed steadily, and it pushed hard. Along the whole Corinth road from the "Hornet's Nest" region to Shiloh Church the fighting was continuous and severe, and it was borne in upon the Confederate leader, Beauregard, that his only course was to retreat. He be- THE BATTLE OF SHILOH 49 gan his retrograde movement with great skill, keeping up a stiff fight to cover his withdrawal, and by 4 o'clock he and his army were in full retreat toward Corinth. The losses of the Army of the Ohio show what a hard fought battle was that of Monday. There were killed, 241; wounded, 1,807; missing, 55; making a total of 2,103 casualties. The total casualties of the two days' battle in the Union army were 13,047. The total casualties in the Confederate army in the two days' battle were 10,699. The total loss at Shiloh in both armies, 23,746. FINALE. Thus the battle was fought. North and South had met in deadly conflict, and in both North and South, Rachel mourned her children, and would not be comforted. The American people were appalled at this first great clash of great armies, this battle in which ninety thousand Americans warred with each other two long days. The determined fighting on both sides had been a reve- lation. Men now clearly saw the war as it really was to develop, a long, a bitter struggle, with stubborn bravery and valor to spare on each side. If raw troops could fight as they had fought at Shiloh what would come when the fresh volunteers should be seasoned veterans? It is true, there was deep mortifica- tion in the North over the early and complete demoraliza- tion of many of these new and untrained soldiers, but the shame was tempered by pride in those other troops who had fought bravely all day, never flinching, even in the face of the most terrible fire of musketry and artillery. In the South, too, there was murmuring over the Con- federates who, unable to resist the temptation offered them by the camps they had captured, stayed behind their commands, and made off with such spoils as they could 50 ILLINOIS AT SHILOH carry. And there was, too, in the South bitter comment upon the conduct of the battle by the Confederate com- manders, Bragg charging Beauregard with having sac- rificed the Confederates by his order to desist from a renewed attack on the Union position at the Landing Sunday night. In the Northern press there were fierce attacks upon General Grant. The "Surprise at Shiloh" was a stock theme for editorials and leading articles, and there is no end, yet, to the printed fighting over the Battle of Shiloh. But the truth remained. There on the rolling, wooded, deep-ravined field of Shiloh a great battle had been fought and won for the Union cause. On each side great men had led armies of youthful volunteers against each other, and after two days of struggle one brave army had been sent whirling back along the road toward its stronghold at Corinth. The Confederacy was jammed back. The Union army was on its advance into Mississippi. North and South alike felt that the death of General Albert Sidney Johnston was a severe and irreparable blow to the cause of the Confederacy. He fell at a crucial mo- ment, as he was about to lead a grand charge against the Union center, the "Hornet's Nest." McArthur had fallen back, all but two companies of the 9th Illinois Infantry. These two companies, stationed in the ravine where they had fought for many hours, did not receive orders to fall back; they continued firing upon the enemy who could be plainly seen from their vantage ground, and it is sup- posed that a ball from this last of McArthur's line struck General Johnston. "Men," General Johnston is reported to have said, a few minutes before his death, "Men, they are stubborn," al- luding to the Union defenders. "We must use the bayonet !" He spurred for the center of the Confederate line and cried, "I will lead you!" THE BATTLE OF SHILOH 51 Under a large oak tree in front of the ravine held by the 9th Illinois detachment, as he sat upon his horse, ready to lead the charge, Johnston was struck by a minie ball. Governor Harris of Tennessee noticed the pallor of the stricken chieftain and asked if he were wounded, "Yes," answered Johnston, deliberately, "and I fear seriously." These were his last words. Harris, assisted by others, led his horse back to the shelter of a small ravine, and lifted him from his saddle. Here he died. The most simple care, a tourinquet, would have saved his life. The ball had severed an artery in the leg, and he bled to death. What might have happened, had the fiery, impetuous and magnetic leader lived to throw himself and his com- bined brigades against the Union left at three o'clock that Sunday afternoon, no one can say. Hurlbut was defend- ing the Hamburg and Savannah road where it runs along east of the center of the "Hornet's Nest." The infantry and field artillery were all engaged in different parts of the field. At the Landing there were the siege guns, but little force to defend them. Had the Confederate right suc- ceeded in making a break through the Union left and gaining the direct road to the Landing the tide of victory would have carried them far. It was ruled otherwise. The more one studies the history of Shiloh's field, the more strong grows the conviction that every Union sol- dier who stood in his place and fought that day con- tributed to the success of the cause dear to him in no faint degree. Everywhere and always the one and only thing to do was to stand and deliver the fire of the regi- ment, company, battalion or even the determined group of five, ten or twenty men formed out of fragments of commands, and lighting under some brave officer. To stand and fire, fall back, rally and fall back again, fire — with dropping comrades, the ranks closing, the few re- 52 ILLINOIS AT SHILOH maining touching elbow and shoulder, this was the method, these were the tactics, which won Shiloh. They served at the "Hornet's Nest," and all around that center, to hold off the Confederate onset, in all its frenzied strength, until five o'clock. Had the Union center given out earlier, who can tell what disaster might have re- sulted? Jefferson Davis afterward declared that "the fortunes of a country hung by a single thread of the life that was yielded at Shiloh." Such was the passionate belief of many of the Southern people, but no one in the North ever harbored such an idea, although the victory of Shiloh was there appreciated at its full value. Among the many men who laid down their lives for their country at Shiloh, General William H. L. Wallace will always be remembered, with poignant regard. His well fought battle on the right of the "Hornet's Nest" was one of the spectacular contests of the day. He fell, mor- tally wounded, shot through the head and apparently dead, near the road to the Landing, as he withdrew with his troops at half past five Sunday afternoon. He was left on the field, and the enemy failed to recognize him or to see that he was still living, though it is reported that during the night a Confederate soldier gave the dying Union general a drink of water. There was one witness to the terrors of Shiloh, a woman, and none other than the wife of this hero who was left for dead upon the field Sunday night. April 29th, 1862, the stricken widow of General Wallace wrote to a relative an account of her experiences on a boat at Pittsburg Landing, where she had arrived Sunday morning, April 6th, on a visit to her husband. She de- scribed the incidents that came under her own eyes during the battle, and the last days and death of her heroic hus- band. This letter has been preserved, and from its pages THE BATTLE OF SHILOH 53 the Shiloh Military Park Commission has been allowed to take such notes as may interest the public. "Something prompted" her, so the wife wrote, to go to her husband, and without notifying him she left her home in Illinois on the night of the first of April. Meeting some friends on the journey, went up the Tennessee river on the Steamer "Minnehaha" under the protection of the Chaplain of the 20th Illinois Infantry, arriving at Pitts- burg Landing before daylight, Sunday morning, April 6th. Sending word to General Wallace of her arrival, Mrs. Wallace remained on board of her steamer, awaiting him. She heard firing on shore as the morning sun shone over the Spring landscape, but thought nothing of it. The first intimation she had that there was a battle on shore was when she saw wounded soldiers brought on board of her steamer. They were carried, she says, by twos and threes and fours until they were too many to be counted. Many of those who were brought in, pale and bleeding, were known to Mrs. Wallace. They all "told the same story of the irresistible strength of the enemy, and the awful slaughter of our men." The wife was told that her husband was upon the field in the midst of the raging battle. She tried to send a message to him by a captain who was going ashore and into action, but he had been gone less than an hour when he was brought back suf- fering from two painful wounds. All day the devoted wife remained on board of "The Minnehaha," and before noon the boat was crowded with the wounded, whose sufferings Mrs. Wallace tried to assuage as best she could, by assist- ing the nurses, and the less helpless wounded, who cared for those beyond self-help. She heard that her husband was in command of General Smith's old division. She kept up good courage, hoping 54 ILLINOIS AT SHILOH and praying for his safety. At one time, about four p. m., "The Minnehaha" and all the other boats which had been sent to take the wounded, had to cut their ropes, and swing out into the stream to save themselves from being swamped by the rush of panic-stricken men who, if allowed way, would have instantly swamped every steamer. Mrs. Wallace was sitting on the upper deck. Every place on the boat was taken by the wounded. The roar of cannon and musketry was almost deafening. She had not heard, for hours, from her husband. She saw on the opposite shore the advance of Buell's army. Her steamer was used to ferry the fresh soldiers across the river, and with the new-comers new hope entered every breast among the despairing wounded soldiers on the boat, as well as the stubborn fighters on shore. "Over and back, over and back," went the boat, fer- rying across Buell's advance. As Mrs. Wallace, hopeful and brave, was greeted, as the boat touched the Landing, by the chaplain who had accompanied her on her way South. He brought news to her too terrible for him to tell, and she read his message in the faces of those around her. The blow stunned her. She heard the story with stony calm; her suffering, she says, came afterward. "Wallace's division," they told her, "was falling back under orders, Wallace leading them, having just been flanked by the enemy. The command was still under a cross fire of rebel musketry. Wallace's attention had just been called to some move of the enemy, and he rose in his stirrups to see more clearly, and then, taking his foot from out one stirrup, prepared to dismount. He had been shot without the knowledge of any one around him. He fell, with his face to the ground in full view of his whole division." His friends — among them an orderly, "one who loved him," carried the body about a quarter of a THE BATTLE OF SHILOH 55 mile forward, and then to avoid death or capture they laid him down out of the reach of tramping feet, and left him. The enemy held the ground where he lay. All night Mrs. Wallace nursed the wounded on board "The Minnehaha," it was a relief to her to be active and helpful to the sufferers around her. On Monday morn- ing about ten o'clock word came to her that General Wallace had been recovered and brought to the river, and that he was still breathing. "He who was dead was alive again." Though mortally wounded, General Wallace had been taken to a boat near his wife. She went to him and, although he seemed unconscious to all around him, he knew her. She nursed him, and during his last days he remained conscious of her presence — until his death in Savannah, four days after the battle. Such was the experience of one woman in the midst of the horrors of Civil War. The wounded were taken on boats to Savannah, and as soon as possible the worst cases were sent on to hos- pitals on the Ohio river at Evansville, New Albany, Louis- ville and Cincinnati. The Sanitary Commission and Sol- diers' Relief Societies sent boats fitted up for hospital uses, and were of great service in other ways in caring for the army of wounded men which came from Shiloh. The dead were buried on the field, Union and Confed- erate, by General Grant's orders. General Sherman, twice wounded, had three horses shot under him during the two days' battle. It is notable, the manner in which Sherman pronounces upon the men who flinched and ran away from him early Sunday morning. He does not rave about "Cowards," but reports the facts, and makes excuses for the runaways, telling how new and green they were, not drilled at all, some of them not acquainted with the use of arms. Sherman showed his grand qualities of mind and heart in the most trying situa- 56 ILLINOIS AT SHILOH tion a commanding officer can face, not only in his hand- ling of the situation, but in his account of it afterward. Some of the volunteer officers commanding divisions and brigades exhausted the language of vituperation in describing the demoralization and rout of portions of their commands. General Nelson also commented, with great heat, upon the crowds of scared runaways on the river bank, as he landed Sunday afternoon. Grant, like Sherman, took the disasters of retreat and defeat the first day stoically. War is a grim trade. Men are sifted and tried in it as nowhere else. The veteran knows that some hearts will fail when the fiery test of battle comes. Mag- nanimity is a mark of greatness. Referring to Sherman, a veteran wrote, long after the war ended: "I first saw him at Shiloh. He seemed dis- gusted and mad, at the way the rebels came pouring out of the woods, world without end, and driving us back, in spite of all we could do. Though he was wounded he kept riding around as if he despised the bullets and shells." Halleck, at St. Louis, complained of Grant because the full reports he desired did not come promptly to his hand. But the people of the North and President Lincoln in Washington knew that they had a man at the head of the Army of the Tennessee, and never, from the day when the Confederate Army was sent back over the road to Corinth, to the last day of the War of the Rebellion, did Grant lose the confidence he had earned in the first cam- paign in Tennessee. Shiloh set the teeth and clenched the fist of the defend- ers of the Union. The enemy was driven into Mississippi, and the great fight for the control of the Father of Waters was pushed farther south. From its shores the great sweep of the Union armies around by the left was to be made. Stanley Waterloo. Report of the Commission DETAILS OF LEGISLATION, EXPENSE AND WORK ACCOMPLISHED. By Major George Mason, Secretary. The Act of Congress entitled "An Act to establish a national military park at the battlefield of Shiloh" was approved December 27, 1894, and is as follows: Be it enacted by the Senate and House of Representa- tives of the United States of America in Congress assembled, That in order that the armies of the Southwest which served in the Civil War, like their comrades of the Eastern armies at Gettysburg and those of the Central West at Chickamauga, may have the history of one of their memorable battles preserved on the ground where they fought, the battlefield of Shiloh, in the State of Ten- nessee, is hereby declared to be a national military park, whenever title to the same shall have been acquired by the United States and the usual jurisdiction over the lands and roads of the same shall have been granted to the United States by the State of Tennessee; that is to say, the area inclosed by the following lines, or so much there- of as the commissioners of the park may deem necessary, to wit: Beginning at low-water mark on the north bank of Snake creek where it empties into the Tennessee river; thence westwardly in a straight line to the point where the river road to Crumps Landing, Tennessee, crosses Snake creek ; thence along the channel of Snake creek 57 58 ILLINOIS AT SHILOH to Owl creek; thence along the channel of Owl creek to the crossing of the road to Purdy, Tennessee; thence southwardly in a straight line to the intersection of an east and west line drawn from the point where the road to Hamburg, Tennessee, crosses Lick creek, near the mouth of the latter; thence eastward along the said east and west line to the point where the Hamburg road crosses Lick creek; thence along the channel of Lick creek to the Tennessee river; thence along low-water mark of the Tennessee river to the point of beginning, containing three thousand acres, more or less, and the area thus inclosed shall be known as the Shiloh National Military Park : Provided, That the boundaries of the land author- ized to be acquired may be changed by the said commis- sioners. Sec. 2. That the establishment of the Shiloh National Military Park shall be carried forward under the control and direction of the Secretary of War, who, upon the pas- sage of this Act, shall proceed to acquire title to the same either under the Act approved August first, eighteen hun- dred and eighty-eight, entitled "An Act to authorize the condemnation of land for sites of public buildings, and for other purposes," or under the Act approved February twenty-seventh, eighteen hundred and sixty-seven, en- titled "An Act to establish and protect national ceme- teries," as he may select, and as title is procured to any portion of the lands and roads within the legal bounda- ries of the park he may proceed with the establishment of the park upon such portions as may thus be acquired. Sec. 3. That the Secretary of War is hereby authorized to enter into agreements whereby he may lease, upon such terms as he may prescribe, with such present owners or tenants of the lands as may desire to remain upon it, to occupy and cultivate their present holdings upon con- dition that they will preserve the present buildings and REPORT OF THE COMMISSION 59 roads and the present outlines of field and forest, and that they only will cut trees or underbrush under such regu- lations as the Secretary may prescribe, and that they will assist in caring for and protecting all tablets, monuments, or such other artificial works as may from time to time be erected by proper authority. Sec. 4. That the affairs of the Shiloh National Military Park shall, subject to the supervision and direction of the Secretary of War, be in charge of three commissioners, to be appointed by the Secretary of War, each of whom shall have served at the time of the battle in one of the armies engaged therein, one of whom shall have served in the Army of the Tennessee, commanded by General U. S. Grant, who shall be chairman of the commission; one in the Army of the Ohio, commanded by General D. C. Buell; and one in the Army of the Mississippi, com- manded by General A. S. Johnston. The said commis- sioners shall have an office in the War Department building, and while on actual duty shall be paid such compensation out of the appropriations provided by this Act as the Secretary of War shall deem reasonable and just; and for the purpose of assisting them in their duties and in ascertaining the lines of battle of all troops engaged and the history of their movements in the battle, the Sec- retary of War shall have authority to employ, at such compensation as he may deem reasonable, to be paid out of the appropriations made by this Act, some person recognized as well informed concerning the history of the several armies engaged at Shiloh, and who shall also act as secretary of the commission. Sec. 5. That it shall be the duty of the commission named in the preceding section, under the direction of the Secretary of War, to open or repair such roads as may be necessary to the purposes of the park, and to ascertain and mark with historical tablets or otherwise, as the Sec- 6o ILLINOIS AT SHILOH retary of War may determine, all lines of battle of the troops engaged in the battle of Shiloh and other historical points of interest pertaining to the battle within the park or its vicinity, and the said commission in establishing this military park shall also have authority, under the direction of the Secretary of War, to employ such labor and services and to obtain such supplies and material as may be necessary to the establishment of the said park under such regulations as he may consider best for the interest of the government, and the Secretary of War shall make and enforce all needed regulations for the care of the park. Sec. 6. That it shall be lawful for any State that had troops engaged in the battle of Shiloh to enter upon the lands of the Shiloh National Military Park for the pur- pose of ascertaining and marking the lines of battle of its troops engaged therein : Provided, That before any such lines are permanently designated the position of the lines and the proposed methods of marking them by monu- ments, tablets, or otherwise shall be submitted to and approved by the Secretary of War, and all such lines, designs and inscriptions for the same shall first receive the written approval of the Secretary, which approval shall be based upon formal written reports, which must be made to him in each case by the commissioners of the park: Provided, That no discrimination shall be made against any State as to the manner of designating lines, but any grant made to any State by the Secretary of War may be used by any other State. Sec. 7. That if any person shall, except by permission of the Secretary of War, destroy, mutilate, deface, injure, or remove any monument, column, statues, memorial structures or work of art that shall be erected or placed upon the grounds of the park by lawful authority, or shall destroy or remove any fence, railing, inclosure, or other REPORT OF THE COMMISSION 6i work for the protection or ornament of said park, or any portion thereof, or shall destroy, cut, hack, bark, break down, or otherwise injure any tree, bush, or shrubbery that may be growing upon said park, or shall cut down or fell or remove any timber, battle relic, tree or trees growing or being upon said park, or hunt within the lim- its of the park, or shall remove or destroy any breast- works, earthworks, walls, or other defenses or shelter on any part thereof constructed by the armies formerly en- gaged in the battles on the lands or approaches to the park, any person so offending and found guilty thereof, before any justice of the peace of the county in which the offense may be committed or any court of competent jurisdiction shall for each and every such offense forfeit and pay a fine, in the discretion of the justice, according to the aggravation of the offense, of not less than five nor more than fifty dollars, one-half for the use of the park and the other half to the informer, to be enforced and recovered before such justice in like manner as debts of like nature are now by law recoverable in the several counties where the offense may be committed. Sec. 8. That to enable the Secretary of War to begin to carry out the purpose of this Act, including the con- demnation or purchase of the necessary land, marking the boundaries of the park, opening or repairing neces- sary roads, restoring the field to its condition at the time of the battle, maps and surveys, and the pay and expenses of the commissioners and their assistant, the sum of seventy-five thousand dollars, or such portion thereof as may be necessary, is hereby appropriated, out of any moneys in the Treasury not otherwise appropriated. Disbursements under this Act shall require the approval of the Secretary of War, and he shall make annual report of the same to Congress. Approved, December 27, 1894. 62 ILLINOIS AT SHILOH Following the Act of Congress, different states having troops engaged in the great battle took steps for per- petuating the memory of their heroes who took part in the contest on that field. Illinois, as the State by far the most heavily represented on the Northern side, acted generously through her legislature in making the neces- sary appropriations, as evidenced by the following acts, and what was eventually accomplished under their direc- tion. The heroes of Shiloh are sleeping well. Appended are the acts: THE ACTS OF THE ILLINOIS LEGISLATURE UNDER WHICH THE COMMISSION WAS FORMED. 40th Assembly, Senate No. 222, March, 1897. A BILL For an Act authorizing the appointment of a commission to ascertain and mark the positions occupied by Illinois troops at the battle of Shiloh and to make an appro- priation to pay the personal expenses of the commis- sion. Section i. Be it enacted by the people of the State of Illinois represented in the General Assembly, That the Governor of this State be and he is hereby authorized to appoint a commission of ten persons, not more than five of whom shall be selected from the same political party, each of whom participated in the battle of Shiloh, who shall serve without pay and whose duty it shall be to co-operate with the national commission in ascertaining and marking the position occupied in said battle by each regiment, battery, and independent organization from this State which were engaged there, and for this pur- pose they shall avail themselves of the knowledge and assistance of representatives of such regiments, batteries and other organizations. REPORT OF THE COMMISSION 63 Sec. 2. The sum of one thousand dollars is hereby appropriated to pay the personal expenses of the members of said commission in the discharge of their duties as aforesaid, and the Auditor of Public Accounts is hereby authorized to draw his warrant upon the state treasury for so much of the sum herein appropriated as may be necessary for the use aforesaid, on bills of particulars certified by said commission and approved by the gov- ernor, and the state treasurer shall pay the same out of any funds in the state treasury not otherwise appropri- ated. Approved, June 7, 1897. i 41st Assembly, Senate No. 381, March, 1899. A BILL For an Act to provide for the erection of monuments to mark the positions occupied by Illinois volunteers in the battle of Shiloh, Tennessee, and to make an ap- propriation to pay for the same and to pay the expenses of the commissioners. Section i. Be it enacted by the people of the State of Illinois represented in the General Assembly: That for the purpose of perpetuating the memory of those who participated in, and designating by proper monuments and markers of granite the positions of the several com- mands of Illinois volunteers engaged in the battle of Shiloh, Tennessee, and to cover the actual expenses of the commissioners appointed by virtue of an Act of the Fortieth General Assembly, for the purpose of locating positions occupied by the volunteers from this State on the battlefield of Shiloh, the sum of sixty-five thousand dollars ($65,000.00) or so much thereof as may be neces- sary, be and the same is hereby appropriated out of any money in the state treasury not otherwise appropriated. 64 ILLINOIS AT SHILOH Sec. 2. That the commissioners heretofore appointed to mark the position occupied by the IlHnois troops in the battle of Shiloh or those who may hereafter be ap- pointed are hereby authorized and empowered to make contracts for the construction, delivery and erection upon said battlefield of one monument for each regiment and detached organization and one monument for each bat- tery of Illinois volunteers who participated in said battle, such monuments to be made entirely of granite and ap- propriately inscribed, at a cost of not exceeding seven hundred and fifty dollars for each of said monuments complete and placed in its final position, and one monu- ment that shall appropriately represent the State of Illi- nois. The site of such monument and cost thereof shall be left to the discretion of the commissioners: Provided such cost shall not exceed the sum of ten thousand dol- lars ($10,000.00). There may also be erected, marking the spot where Major General W. H. L. Wallace fell, a suitable memorial or monument, the cost not to exceed one thousand ($1,000.00) dollars, and said commissioners are hereby further authorized and empowered to contract for the construction, delivery and erection on said battle- field of not more than one hundred and twenty -five (125) granite markers, such markers not to exceed in cost the sum of seventy-five (75) dollars each. Sec. 3. That for the services of said commissioners required to be performed under Section 2 of this Act there shall be no compensation, but said commissioners shall receive the actual expenses incurred by them in the prem- ises to an amount not exceeding in the aggregate the sum of three thousand (3,000) dollars, to be paid out of the appropriation hereby made. Sec. 4. The Auditor of Public Accounts is hereby authorized and directed to draw his warrants on the treasury upon the presentation to him of proper vouchers A-. GENERAL ALBERT SIDNEY lOHNSTON FELL. REPORT OF THE COMMISSION 65 certified by the said commissioners and approved by the Governor and Adjutant General in payment for said monu- ments and markers, when contracted, delivered and erected in the places designated by said commissioners, and that one-half of the sum hereby appropriated shall be paid out of the taxes levied for the year 1899 and the other half out of the sum so appropriated shall be paid out of the taxes levied for the year 1900. Approved, April 24, 1899. 42d Assembly, Senate No. 159, February, 1901. A BILL For an Act to amend Sections One, Two and Four of an Act entitled "An Act to provide for the erection of monuments to mark the positions occupied by Illinois volunteers in the battle of Shiloh, Tennessee, and to make an appropriation to pay for the same, and to pay the expenses of the commissioners," approved April 24, 1899, in force July i, 1899, be amended so as to read as follows, to wit : Section i. That for the purpose of perpetuating the memory of those who participated in, and designating by proper monuments of granite the positions of the several commands of Illinois volunteers engaged in the battle of Shiloh, Tennessee, and to cover the actual expenses of the commissioners appointed by virtue of an act of the Fortieth General Assembly, for the purpose of locating the positions occupied by the volunteers from this state, on the battlefield of Shiloh, the sum of sixty-five thousand dollars ($65,000.00), or so much thereof as may be neces- sary, be, and the same is hereby, appropriated out of any money in the state treasury not otherwise appropriated. Sec. 2. That the commissioners heretofore appointed to mark the position occupied by the Illinois troops in the 66 ILLINOIS AT SHILOH battle of Shiloh, or those who may hereafter be appointed, are hereby authorized and empowered to make contracts for the construction, delivery and erection upon said bat- tlefield, of one monument for each regiment of infantry, and one monument for each battery of Illinois volunteers who participated in said battle; such monuments to be made entirely of granite and appropriately inscribed, at a cost of not exceeding seven hundred and fifty dollars for each of said monuments complete and placed in its final position, and one monument that shall appropriately represent all the detachments of Illinois cavalry who par- ticipated in the battle. The cost of such monument not to exceed the sum of three thousand dollars ($3,000.00). One monument shall be erected that shall appropriately represent the State of Illinois. The site of such monu- ment and the cost thereof shall be left to the discretion of the commissioners: Provided, Such cost shall not exceed the sum of twenty thousand dollars ($20,000.00). There may also be erected, marking th'e spot where Major- General W. L. Wallace fell, a suitable memorial or monu- ment, the cost not to exceed one thousand (1,000) dol- lars. Sec. 4. The auditor of public accounts is hereby author- ized and directed to draw his warrants on the treasury upon the presentation to him of proper vouchers signed by the president and secretary of the Shiloh Battle Field Commission, and approved by the governor and adjutant- general in payment for said monument and expenses. Approved, April 8, 1901. 43d Assembly, Senate No. 400, March, 1903. A BILL For an Act to provide for the dedication of the monu- ments erected by the State of Illinois on the battlefield of Shiloh. REPORT OF THE COMMISSION 67 Whereas, the State of Illinois has heretofore appro- priated the sum of sixty-five thousand dollars to be ex- pended in the erection of suitable monuments on the battlefield of Shiloh, and, Whereas, these monuments and the work connected therewith is nearing completion, and. Whereas, no provision has been made in the acts here- tofore passed for the dedication of said monument, there- fore. Section i. Be it enacted by the people of the State of Illinois represented in the General Assembly: That the Illinois Shiloh Battlefield Commission is hereby author- ized to expend from the unexpended balance of the sixty- five thousand dollars heretofore appropriated, such sum or sums as may be necessary for the purpose of dedicating the said monument provided, such sum or sums shall not exceed five thousand dollars of said unexpended balance. Sec. 2. For the purpose of compiling and publishing a report of the commission the sum of one thousand dol- lars or so much as may be necessary, is hereby authorized to be expended out of such unexpended balance hereto- fore appropriated. Sec. 3. Whereas, said commission will be ready to dedicate said monuments prior to July i, 1903, therefore an emergency exists and this act shall be in force and take effect from and after its passage. Approved, May 4, 1903. THE COMMISSION. The Illinois Shiloh Battlefield Commission as appointed in conformity with the foregoing Act: John A. McClernand, Springfield, 111. Major General U. S. Vols. George Mason, Chicago, 111. Adjutant 12th 111. Infty. Vols, and Bvt. Major. 68 ILLINOIS AT SHILOH Gustav A. Busse, Chicago, III. Captain Co. G, 57th 111. Infty. Vols. Israel P. Rumsey, Chicago, 111. Captain Battery B, ist 111. Lt. Artillery. Timothy Slattery, Onarga, III. Captain Co. I, 55th 111. Infty. Vols. Thomas A. Weisner, Rockbridge, 111. Captain Co. F, 14th 111. Infty. Vols. J. B. Nulton, CarroUton, III. Col. 6ist 111. Infty. Vols. A. T. Galbraith, Flora, 111. Col. 48th 111. Infty. Vols. A. F. McEwen, Litchfield, 111. Sergt. Co. H, 9th 111. Infty. Vols. Isaac Yantis, Dalton City, 111. Co. H, 41st 111. Infty. Vols. Sheldon C. Ayres, Galesburg, III. Co. D, 17th 111. Infty. Vols. (Appointed to succeed Col. A. T. Galbraith, deceased.) Benson Wood, Efftngham, III. Capt. Co. C, 34th 111. Infty. Vols. (Appointed to succeed Gen. Jno. A. McClernand, de- ceased.) ORGANIZATION OF THE COMMISSION. The commission appointed by the Governor held its first meeting at Springfield, 111., September 15, 1897, and organized by electing Major General John A. McClernand president and Major George Mason of Chicago secretary and treasurer. At this meeting it was deemed advisable to visit the battlefield at an early day and by personal inspection and research determine so far as we were able the camp sites and battle lines occupied by Illinois troops, on the days of the battle, October 6-7, 1862, and that we REPORT OF THE COMMISSION 69 might be assisted in these efforts the following circular letter inviting the co-operation of old soldiers was freely distributed through the mails: Chicago, Oct. 25, 1897. Dear Sir: The Shiloh Battlefield Commission appointed by Gov- ernor Tanner, Sept. 14, 1897, for the purpose of marking the positions of Illinois organizations on the battlefield invite members of those organizations who participated in the battle to communicate to the secretary such knowl- edge as they may possess that would be of service. The commission will leave Paducah, Ky., Saturday evening, Nov. 13, at 5 p. m., going and returning by steamer to Pittsburg Landing, Tenn. Any member of an Illinois organization who may feel disposed to meet the commission at that time will be wel- come. The members of the national commission will be with us at that time and it is expected that Governor Tanner and other distinguished gentlemen will accom- pany the commission. Communications to the secretary should be addressed to Major George Mason, 100 N. Clinton St., Chicago. (Signed) John A. McClernand, Pres. 111. Commission. The entire commission visited the field on this occasion, and accompanying them on the invitation extended in the above circular were the following gentlemen, all of whom were deeply interested in the matter and most of them participated in the battle: Col. and ex-Congressman Isaac Clements of Carbon- dale, 111. Hon. David Revell, member of the state legislature. 70 ILLINOIS AT SHILOH Judge Benson Wood, Effingham, 111. Capt. E. McAllister, Plainfield, 111. Wm. Cluett, Esq., representing the 57th 111. Vol. Infty. Mr. E. M. Williams, Springfield, 111. Capt. Eben Swift, 5th U. S. Cavalry, a member of Gov- ernor Tanner's staff and representing him on this occa- sion. Including the members of the commission, the following organizations were represented on this visit: 9th, I2th, 14th, 34th, 41st, 48th, 55th, 57th and 6ist regiments of Infantry and Batteries B and D, ist 111. Light Artillery. The camps and lines of battle of these several com- mands were definitely located, subject to such modifica- tion and changes by the national commission as would seem warranted by further evidence. The camps and lines of battle of the following organizations were also satisfactorily located: 15th, 46th, 28th, 32d, i8th, 20th and 45th infantry. There were still a considerable number of organizations with whose movements and camps we were not familiar and it was deemed advisable to send out another circular. Accordingly the secretary prepared and mailed to a large number of old soldiers the following: Chicago, Dec. 6, 1897. Dear Sir: ■ The Shiloh Battlefield Commission asks your assistance in locating the command to which you belonged in the various positions occupied during Sunday and Monday, April 6 and 7, 1862. This end, we think, may be accom- plished by a statement from you or some member of your organization giving the brigade and division to which you belonged, and if you were at any time detached or sent REPORT OF THE COMMISSION 71 away from the brigade for service elsewhere, were you to the right or left of the main Corinth road, and about how far from the landing or from brigade or division head- quarters? What regiment or command was immediately on your right and left? Will you in this manner try to locate each position in which you engaged the enemy that day? What was your position about 4:30 p. m. Sunday, and about how many men of your command were in line at this time? Did you occupy this position all night? ******** The secretary will be obliged to you if you will send him the names of surviving officers and men of your com- mand and their post office address whom you think will be interested in this matter. Respectfully, George Mason, Secretary. To this circular many replies were received which were of great assistance in determining and locating on the map prepared by the national commission all the organiza- tions credited to the State of Illinois and who were in any way identified with the battle. During the winter of 1898 and 1899 these locations received the approval of the national commission and the commission felt justified in making its report to the Governor. Accordingly, in January, 1899, a copy of the map, together with the fol- lowing report and recommendation, was presented to the Governor : His Excellency John R. Tanner, Governor of the State of Illinois. Dear Sir: The commission appointed by you under the authority of the legislature to mark the positions of Illi- nois troops in the battle of Shiloh, April 6 and 7, 1862, 72 ILLINOIS AT SHILOH have completed the work assigned to them and have the honor to submit their report. Your commission, consisting of Major General John A. McCIernand, Colonels J. B. Nulton and A. T. Gal- braith, Major George Mason, Captains Timothy Slattery, Thos. A. Weisner, Gustav A. Busse, Israel P. Rumsey and Messrs. Isaac Yantis and A. F. McEwen, met at Springfield, 111., Sept. 15, 1897, and organized by elect- ing Major General John A. McCIernand president and Major George Mason secretary and treasurer. At this meeting it was determined that we should visit the battle- field at as early a day as practicable, inviting members of all the Illinois organizations who participated in the battle to meet us there and assist in locating camps and lines of battle. Accordingly your commission, on the i6th day of November, 1897, visited the battlefield and were joined by representatives of several Illinois organizations, the national commission and others interested. Three days were spent upon the field, every portion of which was visited. One by one the old camps were picked out, and starting from thence we followed the route taken on Sunday, April 6, 1862, to the position each occupied in the first line of battle. Thirty-five years had made many changes in roads and scenery, but as the changes were noted and the old roads and localities were patiently pointed out, the original appearance gradually unfolded and we were able to recog- nize scenes and localities that had left their impress on our memory. The round rings where Sibley tents had been pitched were still plainly visible in places. Graves where the dead had been buried with a scarce legible head board, the peculiar formation of the ground, were all studied earnestly and carefully and the patient explanation of the evidences found by the national com- REPORT OF THE COMMISSION 73 mission brought the picture back to us of that April morning, not clearly, however, and doubtful points were discussed by each group at our respective quarters. Many places were visited a second and third time, until doubts were cleared away and we felt that we could justly and conclusively determine the location of those organiza- tions with whose movements we were identified. Since the return of the commission, by correspondence and reference to the reports published in Vol. 10, Official Record, War of the Rebellion, every organization has been assigned a position, both for camp and line of battle, near- ly the entire number with great accuracy and unanimous concurrence. In the battle Illinois had 28 regiments of infantry, 10 batteries of artillery and 6 detachments of cavalry. One of these regiments of infantry was at this time known as the 14th Mo. or Birge's Sharpshooters (armed with deer rifles), but was afterwards credited to the State of Illi- nois and designated 66th Illinois. Shiloh was pre-eminently an Illinois battle. Her loss in killed and wounded numbered 3,957, while the total loss in killed and wounded of the entire Union forces on this field was 10,162. Of this total number upwards of 7,800 were killed or wounded on the first day. But five divisions participated in this first day's battle, and all belonged to the Army of the Tennessee. Of these five divisions four were commanded by Illinois generals. The 1st by Major General McClernand, the 2d by Major General W. H. L. Wallace, the 4th by Major General S. A. Hurlbut and the 6th by Major General Benj. M. Prentiss. It was in this first day's battle that General W. H. L. Wallace was killed. The great importance of this battle is a matter of his- tory. It made permanent our advance line through northern Mississippi and western Tennessee, strengthen- 74 ILLINOIS AT SHILOH ing our hold upon Kentucky, hitherto a border state. The action of the national government in acquiring- possession of this battlefield, approximately 3,700 acres, converting this ground into a national park and inviting the co-opera- tion of the states whose sons made it sacred by their heroism and lives gives Illinois an opportunity to be fitly represented by suitable monuments to her soldiers and by historic tablets and permanent markers define the lines of battle she occupied on those eventful days. Some of our sister states have made suitable appropriations to commemorate the achievements of their troops. We respectfully recommend, therefore, to your excel- lency the entire appropriateness of the General Assembly of the State of Illinois making an appropriation that will be creditable to her dignity and patriotism, and beg to submit our estimate of amount necessary to carry out this object, amounts which in our judgment are conservative and necessary to accomplish the desired result: 28 regiments of infantry, 10 batteries of artil- lery, 6 detachments of cavalry, at $750.00. . $33,000.00 125 tablets and markers, at $75.00 9.375-00 State monument 10,000.00 Personal expenses of commission 3,000.00 Office expenses, including advertising and pre- miums for design 3,000.00 Monument for Gen. W. H. L. Wallace 1,000.00 To which should be added for embelishing the ground and unforeseen expenses 15,000.00 Total $74,375-00 In discharge of their duty your commission has ex- pended the following sums, as shown by vouchers in the hands of the state auditor: REPORT OF THE COMMISSION 75 Sept. 15, 1897, traveling expenses of ten com- missioners to Springfield, 111., first meeting. . .$ 96.61 Nov. 12 to 18, 1897, traveling expenses of com- mission to Shiloh battlefield 538.57 Total $ 635.18 Returning to the treasury an unexpended balance of 364.82 Amount appropriated $1,000.00 Trusting that this report and our labors in the discharge of our duty may meet your approval, we have the honor to be, Very respectfully, John A. McClernand, President. George Mason, Secretary. February, 1899. Immediately following this report a bill was prepared and introduced in the Senate by Senator Milchrist. This bill. No. 381, 41st Assembly, passed both houses and received the Governor's approval, April 24, 1899. Early in June the Governor expressed to our former president. General McClernand, his wish that the commission as first constituted should take up the work of erecting suit- able monuments as contemplated by the recent act of the legislature. Accordingly, on the i6th of June, 1899, the commission again met in Springfield and by resolution the organization as originally effected was continued. The commission at this meeting adopted for the regimental and battery monuments the design for Illinois monuments already erected at Chickamauga and a committee was ap- pointed to draft specifications and make plans for the approval of the national commission and the War De- partment to have them printed and bids asked for the work erected on the field. 76 ILLINOIS AT SHILOH The following circular and specifications were printed and mailed to contractors and granite men: REGIMENTAL AND BATTLE MONUMENTS. The Shiloh Battlefield Commission will entertain pro- posals for the erection of regimental monuments on the battlefield of Shiloh, located near Pittsburg Landing, Tennessee, on the Tennessee river. Proposals must in- clude delivery and erection complete on foundations fur- nished by others, and at points on the field to be desig- nated by the commission. Details of construction must conform with the design and specification accompanying this. The commission reserves the right to reject any or all proposals. Time of delivery to be named in proposal. Proposals will be sealed and received by Major George Mason, secretary, loo N. Clinton street, Chicago, on or before September 13, 1899, <^^ t)y the commission, at Springfield, 111., up to 10 a. m., September 15, 1899. A. F. McEwen, George Mason, G. A. Busse, Committee. SPECIFICATIONS. Material. — First-class dark Ouincy or dark Barre granite, free from checks, spots, discolorations or imper- fections of any kind, each monument to consist of two pieces, base and die. Base. — To be 7 feet 4 inches long, 4 feet 2 inches wide, I foot 6 inches high, 8 cut face, 10 cut bevel or wash around top, extending 7 inches back and about 23^ inches drop. REPORT OF THE COMMISSION 77 0^^^i "^-^■«^.i5aa.«*""« '^'V SPECIFICATIONS. Die. — To be 6 feet 2 inches long, 3 feet wide, 4 feet high. The ends quarry face and margined, back and top quarry- face, the back paneled to receive a bronze tablet about 22x36 inches, the other side to be highly polished and bearing four lines of 3-inch sunk letters (about 60), being appropriate inscription to be furnished by the Illinois commission for each monument. Bevel around top of die to go 4 inches back from front and 9 inches down from top, and on the bevel and on the face of each die the word Illinois to be cut in raised polished letters 5 inches high and y% inch raise. The bevel around the die to be 12 cut work and the wash around the base to be 10 cut work. A margin of 10 cut work i^ inches wide to run around face and ends of die and a margin of i^ around the top. Die to be firmly set on face with wedged lead joint. Bronze panel to be furnished by the commission and set by the contractor. 78 ILLINOIS AT SHILOH Thirteen bids were received and considered at a meet- ing held in the Sherman House, Chicago, Oct. i8, 1899, and the contract awarded to the Culver Construction Co., at $470.00 for each monument, the commission consider- ing them the lowest responsible bidders. THE STATE MONUMENT. The following circular letter was prepared and sent to artists and monument builders generally: BATTLE MONUMENT. To be Erected in the National Military Park at Shiloh, Tennessee, for the State of Illinois. Competitive designs are solicited by the Illinois Battle- field Commission for which will be paid to the person or firm submitting the design that shall be accepted the sum of two hundred and fifty dollars. All unsuccessful designs will be returned to the artist presenting them. The conditions governing this competition are : 1st. Cost. The design submitted shall be for a monu- ment having an approximate cost of ten thousand dollars. 2d. Materials to be granite and standard bronze. 3d. Drawings. Each drawing shall consist of a plan and elevation drawn to a scale oi i}^ inches to the foot and may be accompanied by a perspective in colors or not, at the option of the artist. 4th. Estimates. Detailed estimate shall accompany each drawing, showing the exact size of each piece and cubic contents, with approximate weights of each and esti- mate of the total cost of the granite parts. 5th. A separate schedule giving dimensions and weights of the standard bronze parts and estimated cost. The commission reserves the right to reject any or all designs submitted. REPORT OF THE COMMISSION 79 The commission will meet for the consideration of de- signs submitted at the Leiand Hotel, Springfield, 111., at 10 a. m., September 15, 1899. Designs and accompanying communications may be presented at this meeting or sent to Major George Mason, 100 North Clinton street, Chicago, on or before September 13, 1899. A. F. McEwen, George Mason, G. A. Busse, Committee. Replying to this circular, designs were submitted by Messrs. Sherman & Flavin, Henry C. Sierks, Grant Marble Co., Geo. Craig, Jas. McConnell, D. G. Mozely & Co., R. W. Bock, Julia M. Bracken, Chas. G. Blake & Co., Hill & Woltersdorf, Paul Cornell, Jr., and J. Upton Grib- ben. Several meetings of the commission were held and all the designs submitted received the consideration of each member. Finally, at a meeting held at Springfield, 111., January 3, 1900, the design submitted by R. W. Bock of Chicago was adopted, subject, however, to some modifica- tions and enlargement, provided the commission would be allowed to expend a larger sum than the legislature had appropriated for that purpose, which seemed quite prob- able in view of the fact that the national commission had volunteered to erect all markers other than that of the first line of battle, thus relieving us of a very considerable expense. To bring this about the legislature was asked to amend the bill passed by its predecessor and allow an expenditure on the state monument of a sum not exceed- ing $20,000.00. This bill, Senate Bill No. 159, 426. Assembly, was approved April 8, 1901. Drawings and specifications were then prepared and proposals invited for: 8o ILLINOIS AT SHILOH First : The granite pedestal. Second: The bronze work. The following specification for the granite work was adopted : SPECIFICATIONS FOR MONUMENT ERECTED BY THE STATE OF ILLINOIS. One quality of best Barre, Vermont, granite to be used for the entire granite work. It must be uniform in color and texture and even-grained and all the best lO steel cut fine, hammered work. It must be free from sap, knots, streaks, rust or any defects whatever. Point the bottom of pieces comprising the base course to a level and set in a full bed of Dykerhoff or Puzzalon cement, or other cement of equal quality. Each course must be leveled as set and not propped from beneath to make it horizontally level, and both upper and lower side of course must be level and parallel with each other; all interstices must be flushed with liquid cement so as to make one compact mass of the whole. All courses above the bottom course to be set on lead bearings, and well bedded in cement mortar. Mouldings, members, arrises, as well as all vertical and horizontal joints are to be cut clean, sharp and true ; every detail to be absolutely first-class in execution, and all sur- faces to be absolutely true and level. After all the granite is set, caulk all joints with wedged lead. Lead must be well driven and then cut smoothly to the granite, making even and uniform joints. Countersink for bronze panels where shown on the plans, the correct sizes of which will be furnished espe- cially, otherwise adhere strictly to the figures on the plans throughout. Box each piece of granite securely before loading on the cars at Barre. The bid must include freight, hauling and setting and, REPORT OF THE COMMISSION 8i in fact, everything except the foundation, bronze work and the letters. All sunk letters to be charged for extra, at the following rates : For letters up to i^ inches in length, 15c each. For letters 2 inches to 2^ inches in length, 25c each. For letters 2^ inches to 3 inches in length, 30c each. After all the granite work is set and properly caulked, clean thoroughly until every spot of dirt is removed ; then clear the lot of all the debris which has accumulated dur- ing the erection of the work. All the granite work must conform to the plans and cover the full dimensions as given in the figures. The setting of the bronze work as shown in the accom- panying drawings should also be included with the granite work, and the method of fastening the same shall be de- termined by the principals of the monument. The person or firm to whom contract for this granite work is awarded must furnish a bond covering the full amount of the bid. Course. Items. Contents, Cu. Ft. Weight. Each. Total. Each. Total. A 4 pes, each stone 11 1 444 18,537 74,148 B I pc. each stone 135 135 11,272 22,545 B 2 pes. each stone 88 176 14,696 29,392 C 2 pes. each stone 126 252 21,042 42,084 D 2 pes. each stone 113 226 18,871 37,742 E 2 pes. each stone 106 212 17,702 35,404 F 2 pes. each stone 104 208 17,378 34.736 G 2 pes. each stone 116 232 19,372 38,744 H 2 pes. each stone 81 162 13,527 27,054 I 2 pes. each stone 73 146 12,191 24,382 J I pc. each stone 65 65 10,855 10,855 2,438 377>o86 82 ILLINOIS AT SHILOH Crushing test of Barre granite official here in Chicago, 17,360 pounds to the cubic inch, generally counted 18,000 pounds at Barre. Note. — These contents and weights of the monument are based on 167 pounds being used as a cubic foot, Barre granite. No allowance made for sinking of bas relief. Bids on these specifications and accompanying draw- ings were asked for and resulted in opening bids at Pitts- burg Landing, Tenn., on the 15th day of October, 1901, from the following individuals and firms: George Craig, Galesburg, 111. Joseph Pajean & Son, Chicago. Sherman & Flavin, Chicago. Chas. F. Blake & Co., Chicago. Culver Construction Co., Springfield, 111. One of the foregoing bids was rejected because it failed to comply with the requirements of our advertisement in the following particulars: No price made on this monument, but the cavalry monument included with it. No time set for its completion. Plans and specification not returned or made a part of the proposal. By a unanimous vote the contract was awarded to the Culver Construction Co., they being the lowest responsible bidder for the work. The following specifications for the bronze work was adopted : The bronze work shall consist of accurate reproductions in United States standard bronze of all full size plaster models made by the sculptor for this monument, as shown and described in the accompanying blue print. The re- productions shall be made in as few pieces as possible, REPORT OF THE COMMISSION 83 according to approved methods for securing high-grade art bronze castings and as accompHshed in art bronze foundries. The bronze castings shall be free from holes, spongy spots or other imperfections. All sand, core irons and other foreign substances shall be removed from the inte- rior of the castings, which shall be thoroughly cleansed. The bronze castings shall be carefully hand finished by competent chasers who shall follow the directions of the sculptor. All bronze work shall be given an artistic patina by proper chemicals and not colored with lacquers or paints. The crowning figure shall be anchored in position on pedestal by i^-inch bronze rods, or such other method as may be determined by the commission. The inside casting of figure and plinth shall have the necessary braces to make it perfectly strong and secure when placed in position. The bas relief, seal and torches shall be fas- tened to the granite in their proper positions by bronze dowels. The plaster models shall be taken from the studio of the sculptor by the bronze foundry, who shall be responsible for their safe keeping and return to the sculptor. The sculptor,. Richard W. Bock, will have personal supervision of the work, and all the details of construction will be subject to his approval. The work shall be open to inspection by the commission or sculptor at any time dur- ing its manufacture. The founder shall give bond in the full amount of the contract for the faithful performance and completion of the work. Bids on these specifications and accompanying draw- ings were opened at Pittsburg Landing, Tenn., October 15, 1901. The American Bronze Foundry Co. of Chicago were the lowest bidders for the work and were awarded the contract. 84 ILLINOIS AT SHILOH At the same time and place bids were received and action taken on the cavalry monument designed in ac- cordance v^^ith the Act of the 42d Assembly, Senate No. 159. The following specifications for both granite and bronze having been submitted. SPECIFICATIONS FOR STONE WORK. Use one color of best Barre granite, sound, even- grained, of uniform color, free from sap, knots, streaks, rust or any defects whatever. It must be uniform in color and texture and all the best 10 steel cut fine hammered work. Point bottom of base course to a level and set in full bed of Dykerhoff or Puzzalon cement. All courses above the base course to be set on lead bearings and each course leveled as set, not propping to level after granite is set ; caulk all joints with wedged lead. Lead must be well driven and then cut smoothly to the granite, making even and uniform joints. Countersink to receive the bronze panels where called for on the plans and adhere strictly to the sizes given. Box securely be- fore loading on cars at Barre. The bid must include all the granite work, the sunk letters, freight, hauling and setting, and, in fact, every- thing except foundation and the bronze work, but it shall belong to the granite work to fasten or set the bronze work. After all the granite work is set and properly caulked, clean thoroughly until every spot of dirt is re- moved; then clear the lot of all debris which has accumu- lated during the erection of the work. All granite work must be strictly in accordance with the plans, and the execution in every detail must be first- class. All mouldings, members, arrises, as well as all vertical and horizontal joints, are to be cut clean, sharp and true. REPORT OF THE COMMISSION 85 The person or firm to whom contract for this granite work is awarded must furnish a bond covering the full amount of the bid. SPECIFICATIONS FOR BRONZE WORK. The bronze work shall consist of six inscription tablets, each having the same border and other decorative fea- tures, but a different inscription. The bronze used in making these tablets shall be United States standard bronze, the bronze castings shall be free from holes, spongy places or any imperfections that will mar the appearance of the work. The letters of the inscription shall be perfect copies of the design of letters furnished by the sculptor, and they shall be arranged on the tablets in a neat and true man- ner. The bronze tablets shall be carefully hand finished and shall be given an artistic patina by proper chemicals and not colored with lacquers or paints. The tablets shall be fastened to the granite by 3^-inch bronze dowels, one at each corner. The work shall be open to inspection by the commis- sion or sculptor at any time during the manufacture. The foundry shall give bond in the full amount of the contract for the faithful performance and completion of the work. The specifications for the bronze tablets that were in- serted in the back of the regimental monument, although of a different design, was in all particulars like the one for the cavalry monument. A cut showing the design of the regimental and battery tablets is shown on the oppo- site page. REPORT OF THE COMMISSION 87 C/3 u X ei O bo c8 o a> be .!!"^ (1) a> u a* a.2 1^ .a N o u (0 O M a J> a 1 ^ CO &* < m Pi W W O > O ^ cei ffi w fe ^ --^ 000 w . ^ ^ J F o ^ :z H fo r h _, sa « o S Q :?: w < . (2{ Pi i/i -J 1 t—t S) cJ +J •a 00 -M ■> >% (O •.H tH Q C +3 W3 < 88 ILLINOIS AT SHILOH 02 rgg<£w:. ;g^ SSS< I— t o CO -< Pi t-1 t3 s •r-l Q Td a ci Q « ° g g -2 "^ ^ ^ ■% < - 2 < o REPORT OF THE COMMISSION 89 CO O I ^ O o CJ I— • << S "^ 1 iOh o • 1-1 Q a C! ^ u to 'C PQ •i > 'S b r-4 s p ■4 ■8 < 03 CO Pi O CO -M s REPORT OF THE COMMISSION 91 ^ -^ .... ffirdHffi J2c05^'=^ . . . W J^-^WH^?;;5 Q 06 s ffi ^ i 2 « :£ fc- I " I X § t; o g "MM W CO ^ 4j '^'h Q 2: < ^ Pi Qi < m ^ 1 s n? fH J.* ^ -»^ a •»-i -•A ;3 o o >4 « H PQ CD rfl OS o «+-< CO ^ 94 ILLINOIS AT SHILOH ►-I ?^ ^ O *^ Ctl H _> HH .►^Jfi^.. :^ 55 j -< 9> 2 fo ^ E8 5 ^ . ;< 3 ^, t ^ \ * ^ i 2> CO H P •< ff • l-H »-] >i »J PiS Oii _) tD l-t 1 |Z4 H- 1 •S 1 § .r-< gJ U2 CO So Q +3 ^ l/i 4-> r-l "^ I .s s REPORT OF THE COMMISSION 95 •s i o d Pi o CO .J S < 1-3 O o I 00 CL, < ^ . ffi • -S ffig>HH5^^p^H * m Q p <: o o 02 o o U ffi W! a H < CO < •a PQ CO » •-3 O o H o z ^ O 1 o 1 0) :^ 'd 1 03 1 bX) s:! •a o m S5 ^ Q 1^ <^ en (A a o a 96 ILLINOIS AT SHILOH en o t— I &• Pi o CO 55 o 0) O » Q < O o 1 &§S2^2 i . sg^ogS <* • cvj C/2 Q O <<^SW --re- »-< (M CO o5-H>H^<;a H X t3 P3 < > ID w 1 1^ i I 1 w biO •a c« H '> /,'■> CO PQ i Tf -d Q (M (D ,£3 +* a •>-i -y ?j >. Q 55 CO < p^ Pi < Pi pi! <1 w CJ H ^ Pi! H < 0) ^ 0) ^ c c C/2 1 w E=i 1 (0 'd ^' 4J o3 1 bjo 1 <-*-( •c a pq >> r?-^ s CO 5-1 •4J o 98 ILLINOIS AT SHILOH CO o H- 1 tH H- 1 o CO N o (U o P^ o CO •^ »— I rS C_l _] s »0 iz -< S xn ;3 CO 1 CO 1 1 0) Oj .2 -(J PQ Q C (-i V- (M < t REPORT OF THE COMMISSION 99 > K Q ^ W Q Ph' Z < § § §' ^ u hi o (/) w o >H < a> I i & ^ * § I— I 'Tz! P* q3 '^ »— I I S .§^ i o ^ w +S CO .^ ^ ;3 w < h-) J >< <3 CD ^ (D h4 C/D ffi ^ '^ 5-1 CO s < lOO tn ILLINOIS AT SHILOH =: tj cd rx^ i-^ '^ o^ -:;-'" (xtxH^w ^ ^ ^ f g^?«!:go^g . g§s£iog§C§ H-j Q ^ ^ % 2§S 51a < I ^ * en Q ^ I • en ^-d^^ * ^-So S K '^ ' "" W -^ >. ^ S ^ ^ .2 b * O n O Q ^ w Q Ph' 1 Z 1 < Ph 4-» S ;§ H o p o w a> J S) a o Vh rQ (1) to ^ ^ +i o a ►—1 H o Ph HH Pi U CO 12; REPORT OF THE COMMISSION loi oO^^ Q H ^ pqcoW . •-^ .^^P-H'-' :». Q W W ^ CQ H ^(Ni-tQW-^ -^ ir^ -rl o < 0) ^ ^ t ^ :3 ffi e2 0) 1 1 S 1 a «4-l o § PQ o 1— I < rC! 13 -•^ <^ •S -p ;3 o 0) pq <: OS ^ ^ oi < (D s p< (1> w C K c C/3 1 eS 1 0) 102 ILLINOIS AT SHILOH C/2 o H a, s o S a; o Q W Q ^; o u ^ < z«p l-H n '=0 _ HH H ^ 55 ^ H P^ o « (M CO Hffi MA' ^^«Pss9g- Pip ?^ .o^O^J CT ^ Q < 6 in Q 1 Pi W CD :3 0) § PQ B .2 Q ■s -(J CO +-> < > w r— 1 :^ C/3 '€ « 0) •::! g en •a !>, p^ Q 1 4J t/3 4^ < REPORT OF THE COMMISSION 103 Ci3 I— I LJ " re ^^ i-H ►t- < < ,(Xi^S o j . «> to V-i 0) C/1 ? a; < 'd a C (U . Pi! -i-> < :3 I04 ILLINOIS AT SHILOH A 2 2: ^ Q J"Z O >^ Q I— I O CO o t/3 Ah i-i - CU (-\ Cd ►"! •-* "-I f-4 ^ b ;^ < ID • t-H 'Z CO « te Pi w ►J o u t/3 9 3 P!i •4J CU H a ri:! H ^ a +-> i a •a o •> o a 1^ -^ < a> c? rH ^ -M d • r1 -H ;3 O >% Q u 2 o < .—1 •»H S;; W < w o w 4J o >* hJ :^ « +f 1 u c 1 H (U a H a _o •< PQ 'So C/5 ^ Q -^ C a REPORT OF THE COMMISSION 105 < WAS IN IN THE wound- d s' C/3 z n P Ph < Q 1 < w <3 oi p J" ^ -3 3?^ J- p l-H H- ( n< 1 0) OS 2 THIS POSIT i2, AND UN THIS LINE. EONEOFFI ISSING; TGI p H Q to 00 ^ < CO ^ ^ 0^ ^«S c/5 < Pi p^ CTIO ATTL D; 3 H < < m w C^ Pi CO » P a p o o o CO 3 w < M W W c^- ^ H H 2 W K Q Q CO CO J H •-« < 3 ^ oi ^ < CO ^ ,^ Pi W < ^ Pi - g CO C5 s ^ >• s '^ S o fe W <5 ^ ffi ^ >H CO >H Q p 2 O Pi S ^P2 5 Pi < o w coco oW O hJ < b« (U r—l C/3 ^ 't. 10 fe < TZJ >- d .5f ^ Pi -(J ' i/i (U u C tn ^ H . d p^ a wi ■s '« c < a> (N ^ +j •X- b 0) 0) 0) w ^^ en ■f S OT <: ^ a ^ P -(J c 0) .I S en ^ 6 ctJ u 0) OD -< ^