THEE MARYELLOUS IN ~NL oderii Times, BY LEWIS H. STEINER, M, D, CHAMBERSBURG, PA: M. KIEFFER ft CO'S. CALORIC PRINTING PRESS. 1860. THE MARVELLOUS IN Modern Times, BY LEWIS H. STEINER, M, D. CHAMBERSBTTRG, PA: a. KIEFFER & CO'S. CALORIC PRINTING PEES 186& 12. Histoire du Merveilleux dans les Temps Modernes, par Louis Figuier. Tome premier (Les Diables de Loudun, Les Convulsionaires Jansenistes), — Tome deuxieme (La Baguette divinatoirc, Les Prophetes protestants). We are not of those who reject every marvel simply be- cause it seems to have occurred in direct contravention of the laws of nature. There is really an extreme of incredu- lity as well as of credulity in the world, — one manifested by those who reject every thing they cannot understand, and the other by those who hail with delight all that is myste- rious and obscure, reject the proper modes of testing its claims on our belief, and live a life of servile dependence on the creations of their own or their neighbor's fancies. There is a singular fact, connected with these extremes, il- lustrating the old proverb " that extremes meet," — a spirit of irreligion, or rather a want of true religious faith, seems to pervade both the extremely credulous and the willfully incredulous. Thus we find these two classes rarely properly represented among humble, faithful, God-fearing Chris- tians. These are willing to recognize the wonders of an Almighty hand in the pages of history, whether blood- stained by the records of battles or adorned with the tri- umphs of inventive peace, — those dispute the existence of every thing that is not plainly the result of known physical laws : or these reject all demonstrations of natural phe- nomena which are claimed to be produced by spiritual means as lying wonders calculated to bewilder the mind and lead the soul from the wholesome ways of truth, — while those, too proud to be humble Christians, and anx- ious for some new revelation, hail all the miserable tricks of charlatans as so many indications of spiritual communi- cation and interference, and allow themselves to be blind- ed by their conceit until all the security, afforded by the sheet-anchors of reason and faith, being lost, they drift out into the illimitable ocean of ignorance and superstition. The Christian does not feel himself obliged to believe every thing his senses report to his brain, if such reports involve a contradiction of the laws of nature, and are mani- festly not intended to communicate anv great fact or won- drous message from the Creator ; and, on the other hand, he does not feel called upon to explain the cause — the trickery it may be — of the mysterious phenomenon. Where pretended revelations from the spiritual world attack the truth of Holy Scripture, the teachings of the Church, and the experience of the saints of all ages, it is a matter of small importance, whether the Devil and his wicked spirits be considered mediately or immediately concerned. It is not worth the time consumed in the discussion, to determine whether the powers of the lower world have acted upon the hearts of men so as to make them conscious deceivers of their fellow men. The main point for the Christian to keep in view, in these cases, is, that, whatever attacks di- rectly a part of his Christian faith, must be thrust aside as dangerous and even deadly in its tendency. If he do this, he may be called illiberal, unprogressive and superstitious, but he will keep in the true path and will be justly entitled to none of these stigmas. On the other hand, it is not unchristian to believe in "the continuance of apostolic gifts." Dr. Bushnell has well ..aid,* on this subject, "there are yet, in every age, great numbers of godly souls, and especially in the lower ranges of life, to whom the conventionalities of opinion are noth- ing, and the walk with God every thing, who dare to claim an open state with Him ; to pray with the same expecta- tion, and to speak of faith in the same manner, as if they had lived in the apostolic times. And they are not the noisy, violent class, who delight in the bodily exercises that profit little, mistaking the fumes of passion for the revelations of God, but they are, for the most part, such as walk in silence, and dwell in the shades of obscurity." Via media is always the most difficult path to discover, *Nature and Supernatural, 490. but it is the safest, nay the only safe path for the traveller. JSTo labor, or care, is too great which may lead to its dis- covery. We must steer clear from those who solely believe in the every day natural phenomena of life, as well as those who delight in the glitter of novelties. Both will have a host of followers. Mankind is not only prone to disbelief, but also paradoxical as it may seem, to adopt novelties. " Whate'er absurdity the brains May hatch, yet it ne'er wants wet-nurses to suckle it : Or dry ones, like a hen, to take the pains To lead the nudity abroad, and chuckle it ; No whim so stupid but some fool will buckle it To jingle bell-like on his empty head; No mental mud — but some will knead and knuckle it, And fancy they are making fancy bread." The History of the Marvellous in Modern Times is fraught with interest to the student. It shows how prone man is to run after novelties, to desert old paths, and how epidemic the belief in wonders may be at certain periods in the world's history. "Whole countries have been over run with strange delusions seizing the wisest as well as the most ignorant, and fanaticism, laughing reason to scorn, has reigned triumphant over all. To collect clear and im- partial accounts of some of these in modern times has been the self-consigned task of the sprightly Figuier, and two volumes have already appeared as the half of his contribu- tion to the literature of this subject. He promises addi- tional volumes on Animal Magnetism, Table-rappings and quasi-Spiritual communications. We doubt whether the world is yet prepared to discuss these, but when his vol- umes appear, if other engagements do not claim our pen, we hope to make them subjects of other papers for the consideration of the readers of the Eeview. For the pres- ent, we purpose noticing the two volumes, which have al- ready appeared, full of much that is interesting, novel and instructive to those who will tear off the covering to read the concealed moral. The past is pregnant with that which may be made instructive to the present, if we will but labor to understand it. Figuier, looking upon the pretended marvellous manifes- 6 tations of the present as the necessary and almost inevita- ble development of similar phenomena in past ages, is somewhat skeptical, but his facts are always reliable. He considers that " the marvellous is food so necessary to the human mind, that, among all people and in all ages, there has existed a belief in extraordinary things and an admis- sion of the existence of supernal facts. The harmony of the phenomena of the world, the order of nature and the constant regularity with which its laws are exhibited, can not satisfy this passion for wonder." The priests of India, — the brahmins of the first rank — proceeding from the brain of Brahma, were supposed to be the proper media for the communications of man with the divinity. Zoroaster formed the spiritual and material world out of an univer- sal fluid, which was the actual substance of divinity. From this, it was an easy matter, to form minor deities and to create prodigies. The Pythoness, seated on the tripod, in- haling exhalations from the earth, fell into convulsions and uttered words which were interpreted by her attendants as prophetic communications. The pages of classic history are full of wonders of this kind, showing that the Greeks and Romans were ever ready to believe in something high- er and more powerful than the merely human. As we approach the Christian Era the curious legend of Epithases meets our eyes ; while becalmed near the isles of the ^Egean Sea, a mysterious voice calls on Thamas, the pilot, and orders him to cry out with a loud voice, when the vessel should arrive at a certain position, that great Pan was dead. Thamas having obeyed this order, the air was filled with groanings and lamentations. Whether this is entitled to credence, or is merely a poetic mode of express- ing the opening of the period when the overthrow of pa- ganism was to be accomplished, and the reign of true mir- acles was to be established, — it is foreign from our design to discuss now. Shortly after the beginning of the Christian Era, prodi- gies arc attributed to the wonderful supernatural power of magicians and soothsayers, which far exceed those said to have been produced in the more distinctly pagan days of Eoman history. Simon of Samaria was thought, by the enemies of the Christians, to be the special envoy of the ancient divinities with full authority to demonstrate their powers and might, — by the Christians he was considered as being favored by demoniacal aid. All his acts, seen through the dim corridors of the past, assume a miraculous character. He is said to have created statues that moved boldly before wondering crowds, and to have remained sound and uninjured amid the flames of a funeral pile. Contemporaneous with this juggler, was Apollonius of Thyanes, who lived to the age of one hundred and thirty years. He possessed the power of transporting himself at will from one place to another, of converting himself in- to various objects like the fabled Proteus, and of evoking " spirits from the vasty deep." At Ephesus, when the plague was depopulating the city, he attributed the cause to an evil spirit they were harboring within the walls. An old beggar was seized upon as this evil spirit. Being stoned to death, instead of the body of a man a carcass of a dog was found, which being interred the plague ceas- ed. In these days sorcerers and magicians became so nu- merous that " the poets complain of them as a scourge, and edicts of expulsion were issued on several occasions by the emperors." Tacitus relates that the opportunity was also employed to rid the city, at the same time, of the philoso- phers. They were followed by men who worked in accordance with their formulae, but without a tithe of their talents or skill. The very edicts of banishment gained them parti- sans. Mankind is always disposed to array itself on the side of the apparently persecuted. Christian rites and cer- emonies, not understood, were mingled with pagan cere- monies, and a mongrel magical art was the result which increased with the lapse of time, till saints, angels and archangels were invoked to aid in the most questionable investigations and pursuits. The psalms were employed as an important part of the ritual of the magicians. The 8 disease gained its height in the middle ages, and we turn over the pages, written by its followers, with an astonish- ment that knows not whether to express itself in smiles or tears. A collection of forty chief treatises, on Magic and allied subjects, written in the middle ages and published under the title of Schcitze aus Kloster-Bibliotheken, has come into our possession, and we think it incomparably the greatest farrago of nonsense we have ever met. Hebrew, Chaldaic and meaningless words are strung together, like beads on a string, — and supposed, when cited in due order, to be all powerful in bringing forth familiar spirits.* But we cannot follow the history of magic with any closeness, — the whims, conceits, follies and supposed de- moniac possessions of ages nearer the present demand our attention. Demoniacal possession being a fact in the ear- ly portion of the Christian era, when the period of divis- ion and schism had arrived, this charge proved a powerful weapon in the fratricidal wars that were constantly taking place. The Church distinguished between those who had voluntarily signed the contract with the Evil One, and those who were affected through the vile arts of sorcery. It was supposed there were those, like Faust, who would peril their soul's salvation for the power of commanding the powers of the earth, air and sea. These were subject- ed to death in ail the forms that an ingenious cruelty could command. The Church had a special rite for exor- *A spirit is thus invoked, who was supposed to have charge of hidden treas- ure : Audi, audi spiritus obstinax, qui Thesaurum sub hac terra, unde ista portio desumpta est, latentem custodis, aut possides. Adonay, Sabbaoth, Cadas, adonay, ammara, alii, adoy, Sabbaoth, ammara, collniziara, offina, altennedera, fuffa, Menfent, Bengraf, haraasixin, ula, ula, coraf. Jasuren, omasixel, sehani, eissoas, leroas, Ilasiedin, hasiedinomdin, lafonaff, Kaslah, laugna, bosuras, chaphirh, chaphirach, hand, Kopa, heogunh, Scheuschen, togas, togos, hage, Phanim, debugim, menaihuh, menaihuch, Schegamhim, &c., &C, &., &c. Veni, compare, et affer statim Thesaurum petitum modo hbi, tuisque praescripto hiolooi, etsatisfao petitioni meae in omnibus ad amussim ocyus. Letamnim, letaglogo, letasynin, tebaganaritin, letarminim, letagelogin, letaf'alosin, Amen. Will the reader only think of 718 pages done up in tbat style ! Bohatze aus Kloster-bibliotheken, 548. 9 cising a demon who had become incarnate in the body of a man. After mass, the person, having previously fasted, the demon was ordered to make a certain sign in the name* of Christ. If this was made, the fact of possession was es- tablished, and the rites of exorcism were proceeded with. In 1436, in the environs of Berne and Lausanne, a class of men arose who devoured human flesh, even eating their own children, pretending that these foul deeds were done in accordance with the command of Satan. Hundreds of individuals, suspected of these crimes were exposed to tor- ture and acknowledged them.* In 1459 the mania of sor- cery seized Artois, and those apprehended by the ecclesi- astical authorities admitted attendance on nocturnal meet- ings, where the filthiest orgies were performed. In 1484, Innocent VIII. issued a bull against those who practiced the arts of sorcery in the regions of Cologne, Mayence, Treves and Salzburg. Among those arrested in this region many confessed the crime of anthropophagy, being impell- ed thereto by "un instinct diaboliqne." One sage-femme, who was burned at Dann, in the diocese of Basle, confessed that she had destroyed more than forty infants. It is a ques- tion whether any of the accused were really guilty of an- thropophagy, or had merely pretended the performance of the act, under the influence of an epidemic mania. In the Sixteenth century, the juridical horrors were the same as in the Fifteenth. Over thirty thousand victims w 7 ere made to suffer for the crime of heresy in the reign of Philip II. of Spain, and many were burned alive at Cala- horra, being accused of sorcery. In Italy appeared the Stryges, sorceresses, who claimed that, by mentally invok- ing the power of a demon and by virtue of some sacramen- * J'ai appartenu, disait 1' un d' eux, ainsi que ma femme, a la corporation des sorciers ; j'ai renonce aux graces du bapteme, a la foi chretienne, a 1'ad- oration du Christ. J'ai pris l'engagement de flechir le genou devant le mai- tre de l'enfer ; j'ai bu du sue extrait de la chair d'enfant, sue que les adora- teurs de Satan conservent precieusement dans des outres ; ce breuvage pro- cure un savoir qui n'appartient qu'aux inities. Hist, du Marv. I. 39. 10 tal words, they could transform themselves into cats. In the shape of the latter they pretended that they could enter, through windows and other openings, rooms where infants were exposed, and then extract their blood through punc- tures made for the purpose. In 1521, Zoanthropia assum* ed another form in the mountains of the Jura. It was pretended that men assumed the form of wolves, and de- voured women and little children. Three men, Pierre Burgot, Michel Verdung and Philibert Montot, charged with being were-wolves (loups-garoas), were burned alive, and their portraits were suspended in the church at Polig- ny. In 1522, the convents of Holland, Germany and Ita- ly became objects of attraction trom the singular forms which hysteria assumed in the nuns. Exorcisms were resorted to, and where these would not quiet the nervous irregularities, severer penalties were adopted. From many of the symptoms reported we can have no difficulty in guessing at the cause of the hysteria, but medical disquisi- tions are prohibited in the pages of the Review. The mother of the great Kepler was charged with the practice of magic and barely escaped being burned alive. Her son deemed it his duty to protect his mother from the charge, although he did not deny the reality and power of sorcery. Indeed the seventeenth century abounded in instances of men and women, who were subjected to severe tortures, and even death, on account of complicity with the powers of the lower regions. Fire was the catholicon supposed to be alone efficient in such dire cases, and its purifying agency was invoked in the most absolute way imaginable. Figuier gives, at full length, an account of the demon- mania which prevailed, about the year 1G32, in an Ursuline Convent, composed of the daughters of the nobility and established at Loudun, a little village in the diocese of Poitiers. At first, the nuns were said to leave their beds at nights, and to crawl over the roofs as somnambulists, thence descending to the chambers of the boarders. Com- plaint was made that they were beset by spectres at night, 11 and that blows had been received, the marks of which remain- ed. The priest, attached to the establishment, Mignon, con- cluded that the symptoms justified the idea of possession dia- bolique. The advice of a neighboring priest, who was con- tinually employed in hunting out demoniacs, being obtain- ed, he began to exorcise the superior and two of the nuns. The condition of affairs in the convent was soon made public, and the two zealous priests deemed it proper to re- port to the Judge and Civil Lieutenant of the village. As soon as they reached the convent, they were informed by Barre, the Exorcist, that he had driven the demons out of the Superior and one of the Sisters, and that one was named Astaroth, and the other Sabulon. It seems, however, that the exorcism wasn't very efficient, as the Superior was seized with convulsions at this visit. The sorcerer, charged with the foul work, was Urbain Grandier, a priest. The de- mon was publicly interrogated in Latin, and answers were returned in the. same tongue*, — but when the demon, pos- sessing a lay sister (who did not understand Latin), was interrogated no answer could be obtained. The Civil Lien- tenant wished to know whether the possessed had any diffi- culty with Grandier, but the priest would not allow, what he called, " indiscreet questions." On investigation, after leaving the convent, the civil au- thorities found that the same series of questions had previ- ously, on several occasions, been proposed to the supposed demon who inhabited the Superior's body. They demand- ed that all further exorcisms should be performed in con- junction with exorcists appointed by civil authorities, Mig- non simply asserted that they had not objected to the pres- ence of the civil authorities; and Barre asserted that he * The following queries and answers are said to have been made by the exorcist and given by the demon, possessing the Superior. Q. Propter quam causam ingressus es in corpus hujus virginis ? A. Causa anirnositatis. Q. Per quod pactum ? A. Per flores. Q. Quales ? A. Rosas. Q. Quis misit? A. Urbanus. Q. Die cognomen? A. Grandier. Q. Die qualitatem ? A. Sacerdos. Q. Cujus ecclesise? A. Sancti Petri. Q. Quae persona attulit flores ? A. Diabolica. 12 had discovered, instead of one devil, Astaroth, tormenting the Superior, there were really seven, whose names he glibly recited. The history of the parte was as follows : " Urbain Grandier had delivered it, in the form of a bouquet of roses, to a certain Jean Pivart — a magician of an inferior order — ; this Pivart gave it to a young girl, who had thrown it over the garden wall into the convent." The authorities demanded that they should be allowed to see the possessed. But the energumens exhibited then neith- er contortion nor grimace, and chanted quietly, along with the other sisters, during the celebration of the mass. On another occasion, however, the Superior was seized with convulsions, foaming at the mouth, and the demon, when asked at what time he would leave her, answered, eras mane. He resisted the litanies and even the power of the holy ciborium, when placed on the head of the possessed. Shortly after the Superior regained her natural condition and, smiling, said to Barre : 11 rCy a plus de Satan en mm. A circumstance is related here that was very common in demonopathia, the Superior, freed from this crisis, neither recollected the questions or answers. She pretended that at ten o'clock at night her hand had been seized and prick- ed, and that immediately afterwards she discovered three spines in it. A cat being found in the chamber, it was declared to be the demon, but the cat proved to be an old attache of the convent. A large bouquet of white roses was gathered in the garden, and was thrown into the fire by Barre with the hope of eliciting some preternatural phenomena, but they only burned in the natural way. Barre, however, pledged his faith as an exorcist that he would compel the devil to leave or to make manifest, in a most indubitable manner, the possession of the Ursulines. Let us see, for the clear understanding of this curious event in history, who was Urbain Grandier. He had been a student with the Jesuits at Bordeaux, afterwards care of the church of St. Peter at Loudun, and a prebend in the chapter of Sainte-Croix at the same place. This possess- 13 ion of two benefices irritated his brethren, — and, moreover, he was a good preacher, an easy and elegant writer, and a gallant, attractive gentleman. Charges had been brought against him involving his moral character in the most ab- solute way. A large number of persons figured as his ac- cusers, although they did not appear against him on trial. He was condemned to fast on bread and water for three months, interdicted a divinis for five years in the diocese of Poitier, and forever in the city of Loudun. Having ap- pealed to the parliament, of Paris, the whole affair was en- trusted to the Presidial of Poitiers. Here the sentence was reversed, and the archbishop of Bordeaux absolved him from the ecclesiastical penalty. Grandier used his triumph so as to annoy his enemies as much as possible, re-entered the city shaking a laurel branch as a token of his victory. His fame having penetrated the convent, associated with re- ports of his eloquence, and beauty, contests with and victory over his enemies, without doubt was the cause of his name being suggested to the poor nuns, in the height of their hysterical attacks, as the cause of the same. But to proceed with our epitome of this history, — Gran- dier demanded that the nuns be examined separately and by approved exorcists, who were at least not his open ene- mies. However, the exorcisms were carried on in church by the same Barre. The possessed always answered in Latin, indicative of bad grammatical training, and full of solecisms. In every- case, the name of Grandier was men- tioned as the magician. A series of contradictions having been from time to time detected in the communications of the quasi-possessed, the archbishop of Bordeaux sent his own physician to examine into the matter, but nothing being discovered by him, the prelate forbade the pretended exorcists from hereafter practising the art, and assigned its practice to two priests. ISTo more indications being found, in the convent, of demonopathia, Grandier was again triumphant. Such triumph could not last long, especially in an age when the really mysterious was being overlooked in the 14 Church, and mankind was on the alert for something that should claim its wonder. Despite the contradictory and improbable character of the testimony, he was at length condemned to death. The only proof was that arising from a persistance, on the part of the accused, in their accu- sation. Grandier was finally burned at the stake. His last words were : " Deus, Deus, ad te vigilo, miserere mei, Deus ! While the priest Lactance was lighting the fire, Grandier said — there is a God in heaven, who will be both thy judge and mine, — I summons thee to appear before him in one month. It is a singular fact, that Lactance died exactly one month from the death of Grandier, in frightful convulsions, as though he had been possessed of all the demons that he had been pursuing. The death of Grandier did not diminish the troubles in the nunnery. We sicken as we read the details of inci- dents, connected with demonopathia among these females, who had separated themselves from the world with the view of serving God, but who, on the contrary, were con- tributing to the support of the worst passions and feelings of their fellow men, by enabling them to denounce any troublesome person as a magician. " The mortal blow to the whole, was the withdrawal of the pension of four thou- sand livres per month, which the king had allowed for the support of the exorcists and the nuns. Richelieu began to believe that if it were continued longer, the farce would only serve to exhibit the injustice of the condemnation of Grandier ; * * his own death (Dec. 18, 1638) was the signal of the definitive flight of all the inferior demons that still swarmed about Loudun." The nuns, nevertheless, were the recipients of distinguished honors. "Jeanne de Belfiel — the mother superior — one of the principal actress- es in the troop, was the object of the greatest favors. Pre- sented at Court, she was complimented by the King and Queen, and honored by the benediction of the cardinal- minister, * * she lived for years, surrounded with an aureola of sanctity, and wanted nothing to prevent her can- onization after death." 15 Can modern science aid ns in comprehending this curious episode in the history of the seventeenth century ? Es- quirol considers all the phenomena, exhibited by the nuns, as symptoms of what he styles demonomania ; Bertrand claims that they were only phenomena of extacy. Figuier puts the whole matter very forcibly before his readers, as follows ; " The convulsions proceeded from hysteria, The disease was perfectly marked in three of them. We believe that it existed a priori in the convent, and that it caused the first convulsive and contagious symptoms, through imitation. But this affection, the nervous system being constantly irritated, gives rise to such a physiological con- dition, that every physical or moral excitement would bring this system into play, provoking disorders and extraordi- nary cries from the sick person. Indeed young hysterical girls are now considered marvellous subjects for magnetizers. The hysterical nuns thus became pliant tools, in their fits of somnambulism, in the hands of the zealous exorcists." They were to a certain extent moved at the suggestion of the latter, to adopt any ideas which might be presented. The name of Grandier had been associated with every thing calculated to bewilder and charm the young, for he had beauty, talent, wit and reputation. It was an easy matter to make one, who had allowed her mind to dwell upon him, to believe that he was the cause of the convulsions to which she was subject. Imitation would soon place others in the same position. The general belief in magic easily induced them to charge this, upon the gay and handsome young priest. These were the days, our readers will recol- lect, when ugly, old women were put out of the way, by first being charged with witchcraft and sorcery, and dash- ing youths were disposed of under the plea that they were magicians. The old proverb reminds us that " to give a dog a bad name is the sure method of destroying him," and we know that even a dog may be scared to death when a tin-pan is tied to his tail. We can destroy a man, either by exciting the public against him, or by so wounding his own sensibility that he shall shun the public eye. 16 "With the above mentioned causes inducing the belief that they were under some influence of Grandier, it is easy to perceive how the nuns would feign demoniacal possession. The latter gave them notoriety, — brought them prominent- ly before the community. This notoriety was too dear not be preserved at any price. Thus, the first wreng step hav- ing been taken, the path was comparatively an easy one through deceit, and lies innumerable. The devils of Loudun would be exorcized now, not by ecclesiastical butby medi- cal treatment, and their history would be a very short one. The fall of the Jansenists in 1720 had been accomplished, after protracted and vigorous efforts on the part of the Jesuits. The propositions of Quesnel had been the cause of much dissension, and ecclesiastic quarrels had become a disgrace to the Church. At this time of defeat and overthrow of the Jansenists, they began to exhibit miraculous phenomena as a "protest against their overthrow and with the view of showing the world, that Providence did not approve of the judgments pronounced on their cause by men." Shortly before this period, James II, of England, found his greatest consolation in exile, at Saint Germain, in touching those afflicted with scrofula. The king's touch was sup- posed to be endowed with miraculous healing properties. After his death, the Jesuit fathers claimed for his tomb still more wonderful properties. " The sainted monarch, says Salgues, did not confine himself to curing the King's evil ; he made the lame to walk, gave suppleness to the limbs of the gouty, corrected defective vision and untied the tongues of stammerers and mutes." It was necessary that the Jansenists should show some signs as wonderful as those exhibited at the monarch's grave. Vialart, archbishop of Chalons sur Marne, had exhibited great piety conjoined with gentle tolerance dur- ing his life, had opposed the persecution of protestants, and the stigma thrown on the character of Jansenius by the charge of heresy. At his grave, rheumatisms, diseases of the skin and ulcers were relieved almost instantly. In- vestigations being had, the following results wereannounc- 17 ed by the examining physicians in the case of thirty four miracles reported,— twenty two were explainable from causes purely physical, eleven were probably supernatural, and one necessarily so. But the reputation of these was overshadowed by tbat of the Abbe Francis of Paris, more familiarly known as Dea- con Paris. He had lived a life of extreme religious morti- fication, which was terminated by death, May 1, 1727. His remains were interred in the cemetery of Saint Medard, and the grave became the scene of some of the most as- tonishing performances ever executed by religious fanatic- ism. The first cure was alleged to have been performed in the case of an old-clothes-man, Pierre Lero, who had been suffering from indolent ulcers on his left leg, which had resisted all the treatment of his barber-surgeon Tanson. He was carried to the grave, gave twelve sous to a good woman to perform a neuvaine (nine days devotion) for him, twelve to a sacristan to have a mass said. In addition he obtained a piece of the bed of the deacon which he applied to the leg and kept himself quiet On the tenth day, he was cured and the cure was considered a miracle performed by deacon Paris. This case was followed up by the cure of Marie Jeanne Orget, who for thirty years had been treated by physicians and surgeons for erysipelas. Being carried to the cemetery, she prayed the saint that she might not only be cured, but be supplied with strength to work for her support (she was then 57 years old). The relief was immediate, and she was able to leave the cemetery without assistance. It is true, that the recovery of this woman was seriously doubted by the Jesuit fathers, and that she had said nothing about the cause of it until obliged by her Jan- senist confessor, still at her last moments she repeated her belief in the presence of the notaries. These quasi miracles were nothing to what followed, when a tomb was erected over the remains of the deacon, around which were to be exhibited those wonderful con- vulsions and transports of prophetic delirium, which at- tracted the attention of all France and made the account of 2 18 the " Convulsiomiaires Jansenistes" occupy a curious place in the history of the last century. After the erection of the tomb, the miracles, asserted to be effected by the effi- cacy of the saint, increased. A girl afflicted with par- alysis was cured, and other cases followed so rapidly, that Montgeron, published in three large quarto volumes, an account of the miracles operated through the inter- cession of the deacon. "The cemetery of Saint Medard, al- though all the soil and stones contained therein partook of the efficacy of the ashes of the deacon, became a theatre too small for the expansive nature of the work to be per- formed. It extended to other churches and cemeteries." The Jesuits availed themselves of the power of the govern- ment, and soon the Jansenists obtained the benefits which accrue from a vindictive persecution. Now began the famous convulsive movements, which always accompanied the cures of those who resorted to the mortuary shrine of the Abbe Francis of Paris. Our limits warn us that we can only furnish an account of one case, but ex uno disce ornnes. We cite the case of Marie- Anne Vassereau, who was laboring under a frightful aggregation of infirmities : swelling of the legs, resulting from badly treated small pox, paralysis, lachrymal fistula, caries of the nasal- bones &c, &c. " At first, the spirit of the saint made no remarkable demonstration. But as she heard mass, Dec. 1, 1731, her body was seized with tremblings ; she en- tered the cemetery and the tremblings increased ; she ap- proached the tomb and they became convulsions. On the next day the spirit of the saint acted still more strongly. Her head became confused, — her legs, arms and thighs were extraordinarily agitated. She*lost consciousness, but, being carried in the charnel-house (eharniers) and restora- tives being applied, she recovered. She returned home, but the convulsions attained such a character then, that the domestics and neighbors were required to hold her limbs. The convulsive movements accompanied her when she walk- ed out, so that passcrsby were obliged to prevent her from breaking her head or throwing herself in the river. The 19 days following exhibited similar scenes. She attained curious notoriety in the Faubourg of Saint-Jacques, and nothing was spoken of, save the convulsions of Marie- Anne Vassereau. Her nurses were deprived of all rest ; she fell in the pews, in the kitchen and wherever she went." Finally the relief came — . The denoument arrives, somewhat after the ridiculus-mus-order of the poet. " These convulsions were the signal that lighted up a new dance of Saint-Guy, resuscitated in Paris in the eigh- teenth century, with infinite variations, some more lugu- brious or buffoon-like than others. From all quarters of the city they ran to the cemetery of Saint-Medard, to par- ticipate in the shiverings, or crispations, and tremblings. Sick or not, each pretended to fall into convulsions, and had his own style of convulsions. It was a true tarentula- dance. * * The soil of the cemetery and the adjoining streets was an arena of contention for a multitude of girls, women and invalids of all ages, who zealously contended in convulsions. Men on the ground struggled in real epilepsy, and some swallowed pebbles, bits of glass and even live coals." The most indecent and filthy exhibitions were made by both sexes, and, in the name of religion, things were perpetrated which would not have been tolerated in the Saturnalia of pagan Rome. Certain of the convulsion- naires assumed positions representing some religious mys- teries, selecting especially scenes from the Passion. "In the midst of all this, nothing was heard but groaning, sing- ing, howling, hissing, declaiming, prophecying, and cat- erwauling. But what predominated in this convulsionary epidemic was the dance. The chorus was conducted by Abbe Becherand, an ecclesiastic, who stood, so that every one could see him, on the tomb of the saint. There he daily executed, with a skill above all rivalry, his favorite pas, the tamous saut de carpe (somer sault), which the spec- tators never tired of admiring. The Abbe himself belong- ed to the number of those who had undergone the curative convulsions. One of his legs was fourteen inches shorter than the other, — a defect however which did not interfere 20 with bis favorite dance. He declared* that the leg was lengthened, every three months, one line." " On the twenty seventh of January 1732 the cemetery was closed and the entrance walled up by order of the king." A distinguished, Jansenist lawyer, named Carre de Montgeron, going to the king to present the book he had written to demonstrate the truth of the miracles, was brutally arrested and thrown into prison, where he died after seventeen years imprisonment. The convulsionnaires were now treated with the greatest rigor, and, of course, thrived under it amazingly. Although tracked from street to street, driven from quartier to quartier, they increased in numbers. The chevalier Folard, distinguished for his con- tributions to military writings, was soon affiliated with them. His religion was nothing. Curious to observe the operations at Saint-Medard, he went to the cemetery. There, wounds received in war were cured, and seven days afterwards he was attacked with convulsions. He renounc- ed all his honors and expectations, and made the rest of his life a series of convulsions, associating only with those Who frequented the houses of convulsionnaires, or spending his time in prayer and reading books of devotion. The cemeteiy being closed, a new phase was assumed by this religious mania. Patients submitted their bodies to blows from hammers and bars of iron, to cuts with knives, upon the breast, abdomen, hips, and thighs; and the victims, instead of complaining, expressed their joy. The convulsion- naires believed themselves specially set apart for the general work of edification, and with the view of accomplishing this, in the best possible manner, adopted the brutal mal- treatment of their bodies, and those of their followers. They called the inhuman violences, to which they were subjected, secours. These were known either as petits secours, consisting in blows with the fist and small sticks of wood, stampings and other similar operations, — aud les grand secours or secours mcurtricrs which were of a more terrible character. They pretended that all this was re- 21 quired to aid in the restoration of a corrupt and gangrened church.* In 1741 the excitement seemed to have ceased in Paris, but in fact the convulsionnaires still existed, and eighteen years later, it was found the epidemic was raging in all its force. We are indebted to a report of La Condamine for an account of one of their exhibitions April 13, 1759, to which he had gained admission by a subterfuge. A num- ber of males and females had collected together in a cham- ber at Marais. Sister Francoise, the deanness of the con- vulsionnaires, was first beaten, on all parts of the body, with a bundle of chains weighing 8 to 10 pounds, by two men. This was followed by blows with sticks of wood, and being placed on her back on the ground the director walked over her several times. This woman was then nailed to a cross, and allowed to remain there for thee hours and a half. At the same time, a young proselyte, Sister Marie, was nailed to another cross and allowed to remain attached to it for half an hour. La Condamine remarks that " only girls and women have submitted to this cruel operation. Those who recognize in all this a good work, assert as a proof of the miracle that the victims do not suffer, and that on the contrary their torments are agreeable. This would be, indeed, a great prodigy. But I saw them give indica- tions of the keenest anguish, and the only astonishing fea- ture to which I can testify is the constancy and courage that fanaticism was able to inspire." The performances of the Hindoo devotees are not more sickening in their de- tails than these ; — the deluded worshipper at the shrine of Juggernaut does not resort to more horrible tortures than the convulsionnaires willingly exposed themselves to, in the name of Him who claims worship from the heart, and who * Elle est couche dans l'ordure et dans la poussiere, s'ecriait une con- vulsionnaire, les vers lui rongent la chair, la pourriture s'est mise jusque dans ses os, une odeur insupportable s'exhale sans cesse de la corruption qui l'en- veloppe. Venez done a sons secours, appliquez-y le fer et le feu, n'epargnez rien pour la guerir, coupez, tranchez, brnlez : il lui faut les remedes les plus violents." Doni. Lataste, Lettres Theologiques. Quoted by Figuier. 22 exhibits to his disciples the example of the publican, with his penitent cry for pardon, as that of one who " went down to his house justified" rather than the Pharisee who thanked God that he was not as other men. With the close of 1760 Paris was freed from this terrible form of religious mania, although the end was not then of the miraculous cures attributed to the deacon Paris. With our knowledge of the years required to uproot a supersti- tion from the hearts of the people, we may not be surpriz- ed to learn, that instances of miracles worked in the name of the deceased deacon are recorded as late as 1787, — and it may be that our own enlightened age has witnessed sim- ilar instances of delusion. Error is hydra-headed, — the re- moval of one head seems to give that stimulus which, in time, will cause another to shoot forth in fullest vigor. Figuier attempts an explanation of the singular phenom- ena we have briefly laid before our readers. Two things are required in order to make such an attempt successful; careful examination, 1st of the facts, 2nd their character whether natural or miraculous. And here again, let us not be too easy with our definition of what is miraculous. In one view, all nature is a miracle past the finding-out of man, — the human body, something calculated to excite our awe as well as admiration. Plow wondrous the law which keeps its manifold organs in harmonious relations to each other ! Why do the disturbing actions of natural causes not injure or destroy this harmony and thus bring about, that which we call, disease ? And when disease is raging, who can explain how all the mysterious harmonies of health are brought to play in happy accord again ? All this is a mystery, — yes, a mystery past finding out. We are still playing on the sea shore, — collecting the beautiful pebbles which the waves have cast up from the deep, but the boundless expanse of the unknown extends oil' into the distance. Let us learn humility. and reverently bow before the Omnipotence ofour Creator and Preserver. "Miracles," as has been stated by a writer in this Review (Vol. II. 578), "must themselves be authenticated as genuine heaven- 28 3y miracles, by carrying in them proper spiritual contents, and hy being surrounded with proper spiritual connections and relations. They are of force, not abstractly and on the outside of the revelation or mission they are employed to prove, but concretely and in living union with this, as part and parcel of the whole." Judged by such a norm as this, all these miracles are dissipated as the morning clouds be- fore the light of the sun. But we can afford to examine these epidemic convulsions more closely, so as to get at their physiological cause. In examining the facts connected with the convulsionary epidemic, we must admit that cures were had of some of the numerous sick who crowded around the deacon's tomb. But these were very few indeed,- — only "iifteen or s<>x4e>en among the large number of devotees, whose exercises are narrated by Carre de Montgeron. These, however, are of such a character, that we do not require resort to the sup- position of a miracle to explain them. The only argument in favor of any connection between the cures and the visits to Saint-Medard, is that those occurred after the visit had been made and a neuvaine performed. The validity of the post hoc, ergo propter hoc argument has been exploded long since. Still this argument cannot be adduced, " since the cures took place very arbitrarily, sometimes before, some- times during and often even very long after the worship paid to the saint." No desperate cases were in fact ever brought to the notice of the saint, and some of the so-called cures proved to be deceptive as the relapses indicated. These induce us to believe that the diseases were often feigned. And some of the convulsions were voluntary imitations of those witnessed in the cemetery, as was ac- knowledged afterwards. Among the convulsionnaires there were some epileptics, — and involuntary imitation caused the semblance of this disease in some which may finally have really become the disease itself. "Watson, in his Practice of Medicine, quotes the following from Baglivi. Vidimus, anno 1670, in Dal- matia juvenem gravissimis correptum convulsionibus, prop- 24 terea quod inspexerat solummodo alinm juvenem dum epilepsia humi contorquebatur : and states that " there is no spectacle of horror so efficacious in producing a fit of epilepsy in others, as that of a person suffering under epilepsy." The symptoms, generally presented by these fanatics, were simply due to a species of nervous affection, which was either St. Vitus' dance, epilepsy or hysteria,— and the latter was probably the principal cause. The curative means recognized as proper for the latter were gen- erally efficient. Occasionally the adoption of purely moral treatment proved sufficient. At one time there was a sui- cidal epidemic in Milet, among the girls, and the town feared depopulation. It was checked by a decree, that /fe. ct m v y body ofsugirl who hung herself should be exposed naked in public, and then be dragged by a cord around the neck on a hurdle. The decree cured the disease. Boerhaave's cases at the Harlem hospital are known to medical men. All the female patients in one of the wards fell into convulsions in imitation of one naturally so affect- ed. He brought into the ward, a chafing dish full of live coals, and proceeded to heat a steel instrument red hot, announcing that he would burn the first patient who would have a convulsion. The result was — the disappear- ance of the disease. A word or two as to the cause of toleration of painful blows and cuts, which were altogether disproportionate to the feeble strength of those receiving them. " The power of resistance and the condition of insensibility seem to arise from the extreme changes in sensibility, which the exaltation of any passion will produce in the animal econo- my. Rage, fear, in a word, any passion, having reached its climax, can produce such insensibility. * * Moral ex- citement often extinguishes all sensibility. Soldiers with fatal wounds, have continued to fight, without suspecting their presence, until they have fallen dead. * * In Italy a fanatic having crucified himself his physician reports, that he suffered nothing from his wounds duri the religious delirium, although he experienced horrible sufferings when 26 reason had returned." From all the foregoing it will be readily concluded, with our author, that there was nothing in the convulsions and extacies of the Saint-Medard ceme- tery, which is inexplicable by the laws of medicine, phy- siology or psychology. Towards the end of the seventeenth century, the spirit of persecution, evinced by the Eomanists, excited a species of religious fervor among the Protestants, which manifest- ed itself in erratic acts that entitle the "Protestant Pro- phets" to a notice in our retrospective of the marvellous in Modern Times. Louis XIV, in the midst of his debauches, was sometimes visited by compunctions of conscience and dreams of future punishment. His spiritual advisers sug- gested that he could ensure his own salvation by securing proselytes from the heretical reformers to the ranks of the Eoman Church, — and that the best way of accomplishing this was by means of money, — purchasing the poor. Un- der the direction of Cardinal Le Camus, this important business of bribery for religious purposes was carried on by Pellisson, an apostate Calvinist. Among the poor classes of Huguenots this plan, it is asserted, had some success. The medium price allowed did not exceed a crown of six liVres. The additions to the list of converts were shown to the king, every quarter, and the courtier, Pellisson, endeavor- ed to make the monarch believe that the whole world would yield either to his might or his benevolence. The king became more anxious to increase the church, and adopted every cruel plan suggested by the bigoted Roman- ists ; in 1680 twenty Protestant churches were destroyed in Vivarais. Children were allowed to abjure their religion at seven years of age ; and many were taken away from their parents in the provinces, simply because they had learned the Ave Maria from the servants, which was an evidence of their desire to abjure Protestantism. This act, so similar to that of the Mortara boy in Italy, which created so much excitement a few years since, was in violation of all the protection guarranteed by the Edict of Nantes. It was only the signal for persecutions in a thousand forms 26 each more ingenious than its predecessor. A regular system of compulsory retraction was established under the agency of Louvois, the minister. Bribes were changed for force. A dragoonade of the country, beginning at Beam — the birth-place of Henry of Navarre, was adopted and soldiers were employed as the missionaries of a religion professing to breathe peace and goodwill. Voltaire* thus speaks of the manner this dragoonade was begun : "An archbishop, an intendant, a pastor, or some one with authority march- ed at the head of the soldiers. The principal Calvinistic families, especially those considered most pliable, were as- sembled. Thes-e renounced their religion in the name of the others : the obstinate were delivered over to the sol- diers, who were allowed to do any thing with them but take their lives. Notwithstanding this, some were so cruelly treated that they died." Louis XIV, thinking to free his kingdom at once from heretics revoked the Edict of Nantes, October 22, 1685. The Chancellor Le Tellier signed the fatal measure, crying out with hideous joy, "nunc dimittis servum tuum &c." Bossuet expended his eloquence in a funeral oration on Le Tellier, prostituting it thus in a most disreputable man- ner. The Revocation caused a general migration. Fifteen hundred ministers left the country ! " Holding the Bible in one hand and their walking staves in the other, they set out for the different frontiers of the kingdom." These were followed b}^ their people, when the laws and ordi- nances of the king had become insupportable. For a Pro- testant to live in France at this period was a continuous martyrdom. "He could neither marry nor make a will; his children were considered bastards." All the liberal professions and municipal offices were interdicted. He was allowed only to be a laborer, mechanic or shepherd. Religious worship was prohibited. Death was the punish- ment for an Evangelical minister who remained in France; death for every one engaged in Protestant worship, or caught in a worshipping assembly. ir fhistoire gen 021 075 707 7