/c/// DOCUMENTS RELATING TO THE CAREER OF COL. ISAAC FRANKS. Prof. MORRIS JASTROW, Jr. University of Pennsylvania, Phila. From the Pubucations of the American Jewish Historical Society, No. 5, 1896. ^'■triL.sr _-, cy./^^t-^^/C C4.^>%*. c: ^/ /4^^^^^^"1^ EI zo-^ PORTRAIT OF IS*AC FRANKS, PAINTED BY GILBERT STUART IN 1802. GIBSON COLLECTION OF THE PENNSYLVANIA ACADEMY OF FINE ARTS, PHILADELPHIA. REPRODUCED BY PERMISSION OF THE ACADEMY. DOCUMENTS RELATING TO THE CAREER OF COLONEL ISAAC FRANKS. By Professor Morris Jastrow, Jr., University of Pennsylvania, Philadelphia. Some time ago, the Council of this Society learned through its president, the Hon. Oscar S. Straus, of the existence of papers relating to the career of Isaac Franks. These papers were at the time in the possession of George W. Huffnagle, of New Hope, Bucks Co., Pa., a grandson of Isaac Franks.* By resolution of the Council, the writer was deputed to com- municate with Mr. Huffnagle, with a view of examining and, if possible, of obtaining copies of these papers for the purpose of issuing them in the Publications of our Society. Mr. Hufinagle, in response to a letter, forwarded copies of some of the papers in his possession, and declared his willing- ness to lay the remainder before me at some future time. Illness prevented Mr. Huffnagle from making an appoint- ment for a visit which I was anxious to pay him, and last winter Mr. Huffnagle died. His son, the Rev. John C. Huffnagle, residing in Imlaystown, N. J., most generously offered to place at our disposal all documents in his posses- sion that might be of any use, and as the result of a visit paid to Mr. Huffnagle, I am privileged to lay before you a number of documents — in all 33 — which enable us to follow, in somewhat greater detail than was heretofore possible, the career of one who served the cause of American independence most honorably and for this reason deserves to be remem- bered. The thanks of our Society are eminently due to the Rev. Mr. Huffuagle, for his kindness in permitting me to take * The daughter of Colonel Isaac Franks, Miss Sarah Eliza Franks, was married to John Huffnagle, of Lancaster, on Sept. 9, 1806. Atu-. ^ift 8 American Jewish Historical Society. whatever papers I desirtd with me and to have copies of them made. The documents may be divided into seven classes : (1) Illustrating the Revolutionary career of Colonel Franks. (2) Referring to a claim made by him against the United States in 1812, for an error in his favor, in his accounts as Forage Master of the garrison of West Point, — a posi- tion held by him from the 1st of January, 1778, to the 5th of September, 1781. (3) Applications for appointment to office under the United States Government, 1812-1813. (4) Commissions from Thomas Mifflin, Governor of Penn- sylvania, («) as a Notary and Tabellion Public, 1789 ; (6) as Lieutenant-Colonel of the Second Regiment of Philadelphia, 1794; (c) as Justice of the Peace in the county of Phila- delphia, 1795. (5) Papers relating to the renting of Colonel Franks' house in Germantown to President Washington, 1793. (6) Applications for a pension from the United States Government, 1818-1819, and certificate of pension. (7) Miscellaneous documents, bearing on his relations to his children, biographical notices and the like. The documents in the first six classes formed part of Colonel Franks' own papers ; those in the seventh class emanate only in part from him, a number having been collected by his grandson, George W. Huifnagle. Among the latter is a biographical notice, copied from an unknown source, which gives an epitome of his career : " Isaac Franks, son of Moses and Sarah Franks, was born at the city of New York on the 27th of May, 1759. He embarked in the Revolutionary contest of 1776 between the colonies and the kingdom of Great Britain, and served under Washington with the reputation of a gallant, brave and useful officer during the whole of the American Revo- lution, during which he received several wounds. After the Documents relating to Colonel Isaac Franks — Jastrow. 9 peace of 1783 he filled various civil commissions, and was the intimate friend and companion of Washington, who, with his family, spent the summers of 1793 and 1794 with Colonel Franks* at his residence ... in Germantown. Colonel Franks died on the 4th of March, 1822, of a pulmonary complaint, being at the time Prothonotary of the Supreme Court of Philadelphia." \_sic .'] In connection with an application for a government pension, made in 1818 (Appendix No. 9), which was rendered necessary by his straitened circumstances. Colonel Franks drew up a statement of his services during the war of Independence. A draft of this statement and several copies of the statement itself, formally drawn up and cer- ified to, are among the documents that have come into our possession. From this statement we learn that he entered upon his military career in May or June, 1776, at the early age, therefore, of seventeen. He joined Colonel Lesher's regiment as a volunteer in the city of New York, from which we may conclude that the city of his birth con- tinued to be his residence and that of his parents, until this period. He took part in the battle of Long Island, being, as he says, " in the heat of the battle," and under the immediate command of General Washington. He equipped himself at his own expense, and tells us "'that in July of that year, in parade order, attended the first communication of the Declara- tion of Independence, which was read to the troops, when we all, as with one voice, declared that we would support and defend the same with our lives and our fortunes." In the year 1777, he joined the Quartermaster's Depart- ment in the Continental village, a few miles above Peeks- kill in the State of New York, as an Assistant Forage Master. In 1778 he became Forage Master, and was stationed at West Point till 1781, when he entered as an Ensign into the service of the 7th Massachusetts Regiment, * Inaccurate. See below. "Washington rented the house from Franks in the winter of 1793-94. 10 American Jewish Historical Society. then stationed in the garrison of West Point. His certificate of appointment is preserved (Appendix No. 1). It is dated Boston, February 22, 1781, " in the fifth year of the indepen- dence of the United States of America," and is signed by John Hancock and by the latter's secretary, John Avery. The formal commission itself was not received till March 12, 1782, but his appointment and rank began on January 1, 1781, and continued till June, 1782, when on account of ill health he was forced to resign. He took this step with the approbation of the Commander-in-chief. From another statement, signed by Isaac Franks, we obtain some details of his career in Colonel Lesher's regiment. The regiment was annexed to the army of the United States under the command of General Washington. After the battle of Long Island, Franks retreated with the army to New York, and was on the detached guard at the Fly Market on the East river, at the time that the English took possession of the city, September 15, 1776. Franks was taken prisoner, but after nearly three months of confinement succeeded in making his escape. " In a small, leaky skift," he tells us, " with one single paddle," he crossed to the Jersey shore. After receiving his " furlough," as he calls it, in June, 1782, from Major-General Alexander McDougal, the com- mander of West Point and its dependencies, he visited his friends, and was in the city of Philadelphia when the news of peace arrived.* On the 9th of July, 1782, he was married in Philadelphia to Mary, the daughter of Captain Samuel Davison. Four children were born to the couple. Two died at an early age. One, a son, Samuel D. Franks, became Judge of the Court of Quarter Sessions and Common Pleas for the counties of *A memorandum on the back of a copy of Colonel Franks' com- mission as Ensign, and also on a draft of one of his statements, reads, "The Preliminaries of Peace were signed at Parris [sic] on the 30th of November, 1782, and the ratification of the Definitive Treaty were [sic] exchanged in May, 1784." Documents relating to Colonel Isaac Franhs — Jastrow. 1 1 Schuylkill, Lebanon and Dauphin, and his daughter, Sara Eliza, married Peter Huffnagle of Philadelphia. After his marriage, Mr. Franks took up his permanent residence in Germantown, where he purchased a dwelling house (now No. 5442 Main street) which is still standing (Appendix No. 14). For a number of years we lose sight of him. In the beginning of 1789 he was appointed by Governor Mifflin of Pennsylvania "a Notary and Tabellion Public" for the commonwealth of Pennsylvania (Appendix No. 3). It was presumably from the fees attaching to this office, that he derived an income which supported him and his family. At all events for about twenty-five years after the close of his military career, he appears to have been in a prosperous condition. In 1784 we find him associ- ated with Benjamin Rush in the purchase of" 19 tracts" of land in Westmoreland Co. (now Indiana), and he continued to hold these lands as late as 1804. In 1794 he was honored by Governor Mifflin with an appointment as Lieutenant-Colonel of the Second Regiment of Philadelphia County Brigade of the Militia of the Common- wealth of Pennsylvania. It is through this appointment that he became generally known as Colonel Franks (Appendix No. 4). In 1795 he received another appointment at the hands of the same Governor Mifflin, this time to the office of "Justice of the Peace in the District consisting of the Townships of Germantown and Roxborough in the county of Philadel- phia" (Appendix No. 5). But previous to this, he must have engaged in some undertaking that led him to Bethle- hem, for in the winter of 1793 we find him setting out from that place for a short visit to his Germantown residence. The occasion of the visit was a note received from President Washington, who desired to rent the house during the prev- alence of yellow fever in Philadelphia when, as is well known, the seat of the United States Government was removed to Germantown. On November 6, Mr. Franks 12 American Jewish Historical Society. sets out with his wife from Bethlehem, in order to put his house in order. The negotiations are completed and, in December of the same year, Franks pays another visit to Germantown, in order to ascertain how long the President intends to occupy the house. Among our documents are two copies of the bill ]Mr. Franks presented to Washington for two months' rental and sundry expenses (Appendix No. 13). The owner is careful not to omit any item, and some of the charges are exceedingly curious. Whatever may have led Franks to Bethlehem — perhaps the prevalence of the plague in Philadelphia — he returned to Germantown and appears to have stayed there until early in this century. Then for some reasons unknown to us, he removed to Ephrata, Lancaster County. In October, 1802, we still find him at Germantown. At that period Gilbert Stuart finished an oil painting of Mr. Franks, which was presented to the latter by the artist.* There are bills paid to Mr. J. Rowan of Philadelphia for tuition for Mr. Franks' daughter, dated December 15, 1802, and March 15, 1803. Between the latter date and 1806 the removal to Ephrata takes place. He evidently regards Ephrata as his permanent residence, for in a letter, dated May 8, 1806, addressed to his daughter, who was attending a school kept by Mr. and Mrs. Rowan in Philadelphia, he speaks of the time when his daughter will come to reside with him. In the fall of that year, his daughter was married at Lancaster. We find Franks at Ephrata as late as 1812. Things have *The painting is referred to by Franks in a memorandum pre- pared by him for his children. It was left conjointly to Samuel and Sara, each one by turns to have the right of possessing it for one year. The picture was sold by G. W. HufEnagle to the late Henry C. Gibson of Philadelphia. By the will of the latter, it has come into the possession of the Philadelphia Academy of Fine Arts. On the back there was pasted a slip reading, "Portrait of ^Ir. Isaac Franks. Presented to friend Isaac Franks as a token of regard by Gilbert Stuart. Germantown, Oct. 1st, 1802." This slip has been framed by the Academy and attached to the portrait. Documents relating to Colonel Isaac Franks — Jasirow. 13 not gone well with him. He appears to be in straitened circuiustanees and takes various steps to secure an income. In December, 1811, he puts in a claim against the United States for an "erroneous credit" which he inadvertently gave the United States while serving as Forage Master at West Point. His claim is for |463.12, which with interest up to the date of his claim brings the sum up to almost $1,400. He bases his claim upon the fact that he gave receipts for his pay as Forage Master during his term of service (13 months and 2 days) without first liquidating the same by the scale of depreciation, established by Con- gress on January 2, 1780, and by which all the payments to the army from September 1, 1777, to March 18, 1780, were liquidated and settled (see Appendix No. 6). He makes strenuous efforts to secure this claim. First, he applies to the Treasurer of the State of Massachusetts, Jonathan L. Austin, who tells him that if his commission as Ensign in the Seventh Regiment was dated after December, 1780, his pay must come from the United States. On December 11, 1811, he sends a formal statement of his claim to Jonathan Burrell, Commissioner for the Quartermaster's Department at New York. In January, 1813, on the occa- sion of a visit to Philadelphia, he M-rites to Charles Jared Ingersoll, representative in Congress, in support of his claim (Appendix No. 7), and refers to the fact that "a memorial and vouchers " in his behalf " had been put into the hands of Mr. Hyneman, then a representative in Congress." Owing to Mr. Hyneman's resignation of his seat, the papers were not pre- sented, but placed in the hands of Jonathan Roberts, a repre- sentative in Congress from Pennsylvania. On March 4, 1812, he writes to the U. S. Comptroller, Richard Rush, at Washington (Appendix No. 8), who in reply (March 30) sends a copy of Isaac Franks' account to show that the "erroneous item was included and properly settled in that account." Richard Rush in a supplementary note expresses his regard for Mr. Franks and regrets that he 14 American Jewish Historical Society. caunot serve him. About this time, feeling that the hopes of securing his claim are slight (although he sends a reply to Rush's note), Franks makes application for some appointment in the Quartermaster's Department. He writes to Colonel Clement Biddle, of Philadelphia, under date of March 17, 1812, asking for a certificate. The request is granted, but Franks is not successful in his endeavors. A year later — May 10, 1813 — he applies to Richard Rush for a position in the Comptroller's Office. In his application he refers to his " sincere friend, the celebrated Dr. Rush," and offers his condolence to the son upon the death of his father. In a postscript, he also takes the opportunity of inquiring whether anything has occurred favorable to his " equitable claim against the Treasury." In this quest, too, he is unsuc- cessful, and when next we hear of him, in 1818, he has moved back to Philadelphia and is making an effort, by " reason of his reduced circumstances," to secure a pension from the United States government. His papers are drawn up and certified to on April 8, 1818, by Joseph B. McKean, Judge of the District Court for the city of Philadelphia (Appendix Nos. 9 and 10). Mr. Jonathan Roberts, at the time a member of the Senate for Pennsylvania, is appealed to on December 15th of the same year to take (Appendix Nos. 11 and 12) the claim for a pension " under his patron- age." The interval of eight months between the drawing up of the papers and their being placed in the hands of Mr. Roberts is due to the fact that Congress adjourned in April and Mr. Franks did not wish to trouble Mr. Roberts " late in the session." Mr. Roberts takes the matter up. A note from the Pension Office dated June 22, 1819, and addressed to Mr. Roberts, states that the application will be granted "when proof of his (Mr. Franks') being in reduced circum- stances shall be attached to his declaration." On the 14th of December, 1819, the pension certificate was forwarded to Mr. Franks (Appendix No. 2). The pension was fixed at $20 per month, to commence from Documents relating to Colonel Isaac Franks — Jastrow. 15 the date that his papers were drawn up, April 8, 1818. Isaac Franks eujoyed his pension for only four years. In 1819 (Feb. 18)* he was appointed Prothonotary of the Supreme Court of Pennsylvania, and it is a comfort to know that his closing years were thus rendered free from care. He died on Monday, March 4, 1822, at the age of sixty- three, and was buried from his residence, No. 55 Clierry street, on March 6.t Appendix. A selection from the documents illustrating the career of Isaac Franks is herewith published.^ The publication includes fourteen documents as follows: I. Five certificates: (1) as Ensign in the Seventh Regi- ment of Massachusetts ; (2) pension certificate ; (3) as notary and tabellion public ; (4) as lieutenant-colonel ; (5) as justice of the peace. II. Franks' claim against the United States : (6) memo- randum and copy of account; (7) letter to Charles Jared Ingersoll. III. Application for office : (8) letter to Richard Rush. IV. Application for pension : (9) statement of military career; (10) statement made before Joseph B.McKean; (11) letter to Hon. Jonathan Roberts, December 15, 1818; (12) letter to the same, February 22, 1819. V. Germantown residence : (13) copy of bill presented to President Washington; (14) statement regarding the history of the property. The remainder of the documents have been copied and deposited in the office of the Secretary of the American Jevv- ish Historical Society at Washington. * Martin, Bench and Bar of Philadelphia, p. 26. fSee Poulson's Daily American Advertiser, for March 5, 1822. Martin gives the date of Franks' death erroneously as March 3. tThe spelling of the originals is retained, only obvious slips being corrected. 16 American Jewish Historical Society. (1) Certificate of Colonel Isaac Franks' Commission as Ensig-n in the 7th Regiment of the Common- wealth of Massachusetts, 1781. Commonwealth of Massachusetts, To Isaac Franks — Gentleman Greeting, — Reposing espe- cial Trust and Confidence in your ability Courage and good Conduct, I Do by these presents Constitute and appoint you the said Isaac Franks to be an Ensign in the seventh Regi- ment of Foot — one of the Battalions raised by this Common- wealth to serve in the Continental Army, where John Brooks Esqr. is Lieutenant Colonel Commandant, — You are there- fore carefully and diligently to discharge the Duty of an Ensign in said Regiment in all things appertaining thereto, observing such Orders and Instructions as you shall receive from the Commandant of said Regiment or any other Your Superior Officers, for which this shall be your sufficient Warrant till you shall receive a Commission in manner and form pointed out by the Resolves of Congress of March 8th and June 28th, 1779. — Dated at Boston this twenty-second of February one thousand seven hundred and eighty one, in the fifth year of the Independence of the United States of America. By His Excellency's command, John Hancock. John Avery, Secy. (2) Pension Certificate. War Department. Revolutionary Claim. I certify that in conformity with the Law of the United States, of the 18 th March 1818, Isaac Franks, Late an Documents relating to Colonel Isaac Franks — Jastrow. 17 Ensign in the Army of the Revolution, is inscribed on the Pension List Roll of the Pennsylvania Agency, at the rate of twenty dollars per month, to commence on the Eighth day of April one thousand eight hundred and eighteen. Given at the War office of the United States, this four- teenth day of December one thousand eight hundred and nineteen. C. Vanderventer, Acting Secretary of War. On the back of this certificate: [Seal of the Payable semi-annually. The first pay- United States ment on this Certificate will be made on the War Office.] 4th of March next, in Philadelphia, at the Bank of the United States. (3) Commission as Notary and Tabellion Public. [Seal Thomas Mifflin. of the State In the Name and by the Authority of of Pennsylvania.] the Freemen of the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania. The Supreme Executive Council, of the said Commonwealth. To Isaac Franks, Esquire, of the Oity of Philadel])hia — [Coat o^ Arms We, reposing especial Trust and Confi- of dence in your Prudence, Integrity and Pennsylvania.] Abilities, have appointed you the said Isaac Franks a Notary and Tabellion public in and for the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania. You are therefore by these presents commissioned to be a Notary and Tabellion Public in and for the said Commonwealth — to have and hold the said office of Notary and Tabellion Public — With all the Rights, powers, and emoluments to said office belonging, or by Law in any Wise appertaining, until this Commission shall be legally revoked. 18 Ame7'ican Jeioish Historical Society. Given in Council, under the Hand of His Excellency Thomas Mifflin, Esquire — President, and the Seal of the State at Philadelphia, this seventh Day of February in the year of our Lord one thousand seven hundred and eighty- nine. Attest : Cha^. Biddle, Sec^. [Enrollment Inrolled in the Rolls office of the State Office of of Pennsylvania In Commission Book No. 1, Pennsylvania page 224, &c. "Witness my hand and Seal of Seal.] office the 10th February, 1789. Math^^. Ir^vin, 31. R. (4) Commission as Lieutenant Colonel. Pennsylvania. In the Name, and by the Authority of the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania, Thomas Mifflin, Governor of the said Commonwealth, To Isaac Franks of the County of Philadelphia Greeting: Know That you, the said Isaac Franks [Coat of Arras (being duly elected and returned) are hereby of Commissioned Lieutenant Colonel of the Pennsylvania.] Second Regiment of Philadelphia County Tho. Mifflin. Brigade of the Militia of the Common- wealth of Pennsylvania. To have and to hold this Commission exercising all the powers, and discharg- ing all the duties thereto lawfully belonging and attached, for the term of seven years. In Testimony whereof, I have set my Hand and caused the great Seal of the said State to be affixed to these Presents, at Philadelphia the Fifteenth Day of July in the Year of our Lord One Thousand Seven Hundred and Ninety-four and of the Commonwealth the Nineteenth. By the Governor. A. I. Dallas, Sec. Documents relating to Colonel Isaac Franks — Jastrow. 19 (5) Commission as Justice of the Peace. Pennsylvania. In the Name, and by the Authority of the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania, Thomas Mifflin, Governor of the said Commonwealth. To Isaac Franks of the County of Philadelphia Esq. Sends Greeting : [Coat of Arms Know You, That reposing especial of Trust and Confidence in your Integrity, Pennsylvania.] Judgment, and Abilities, I the said Thomas Tho. Mifflin. Mifflin, have appointed and by these Presents, do appoint and commission you, the said Isaac Franks to be a Justice of the Peace, in the District consisting of the Townships of Germantown and Roxborough in the county of Philadelphia Hereby giving and granting unto you, full Right and Title, to have and exe- cute all and singular the Powers, Jurisdictions and Author- ities, and to receive and enjoy, all and singular, the lawful Emoluments of a Justice of the Peace aforesaid, agreeably to the Constitution and Laws of the Commonwealth. To have and to hold this Commission, and the Office hereby granted unto you the said Isaac Franks, so long as you shall behave yourself well. Given under my Hand, and the Seal of the State, at Phil- adelphia this twenty-fifth Day of September in the year of our Lord One Thousand Seven Hundred and Ninety-five and of the Commonwealth the twentieth. By the Governor. James Trimble, Deputy Sec. 20 American Jewish Historical Society. II. (6) Memorandum of Claim against the United States Government. Ephrata, Lancaster County, Dec''. 12, 1811. In looking over my old Military papers this day, I have discovered an Erroneous credit which I have inadvertently given to the United States in my exhibited account, against myself, of which the enclosed is a copy. Viz. "To the first item on the Credit side of my account I " have inadvertently given to the U. S. credit for 520 "dollars |4 Continental Money (as specie) which I " received of Col. Bostwick for Pay as Forage Master " from the 1 Jan^. 1778 to the 2 feb^. 1779. 13 months & " 2 days at $40 p'^ mo. Without first Liquidateing the " same by the scale of Depreciation, established by " Congress on the 2^ June 1780, and by which all the "payments to the Army from the 1^' Septem'" 1777 to " the 18*'' March 1780 were Liquidated and Settled. My Pay for said item of Service to which said erroneous Credit is annexed, viz. from the 1** Jan^ 1778 to the 2*^ feb^ 1779, 13 months and 2 days at $40 p' month is $522..67 The said 520 dollars f|^ Continental Money By the scale of Depreciation on the 2 feb^' 1779 at ll|-j <^ for 100 dollars is 59..55 Balance due I. F $463.. 12 with Interest from 1779* * Amount due is fixed at $469.16 {sic !). In another copy, interest is calculated till January, 1812, at $924, making a total sum of $1393 16. Documents relating to Colonel Isaac Franks — Jastrow. 21 [Copy.] The United States in Account with Isaac Franks. D^ To my services as Forage Master of the Garrison of AVest Point from the first January 1778 to the fifth September 1781, both days included is 44 Months and 5 days at 40Dr8 per month 1766-60 1779. By Pay from CoP Andrew Bostwicke from dollars. the first Jany. 1778 to the 1^ feby 1779 13 months & 2 days 520-60 Sep' 12, 1779. By Cash on acct. from Col° Clement Biddle C. G. Forage = 1000 dollars Con- tinental Money Equal to 53y2^ 53..22 By Merchandize from Daniel Carthy A. D. Q. M. G. am*^ to X4..2. N. York Money 10..22 BalP due by the U. S. to Is. Franks 1182..56 1766..60 Errors Excepted. Philad% Jany 18, 1788. Isaac Franks. (7) Letter to Charles Jared Ingersoll. Philadelphia, Jan 24th, 1813. The Honorable Charles Jared Ingersoll Esq. Sir. At the time I did myself the honor to state to you my claim on the U. S. I was not informed that a Memorial & Vouchers in my behalf had been put into the hands of Mr. Hyneman, then a Representative in Congress, who, in con- sequence of his intention to resign his seat did not present them, & on his departure put the same into the hands of Jonathan Roberts, Esq., a Representative in Congress. 22 American Jewish Historical Society. As I have not heard that Mr. Roberts has acted on the same, I take the liberty, Sir, in consequence of your polite oifer to present my Memorial, to address myself to you, to entreat your patronage, and solicit the favor of you to confer with Mr. Roberts on the subject of my Memorial, so that it be presented. The object Sir, of my Memorial is, to rectify an error, made in the settlement of my Acct. by the Commissioner & overlooked by myself. The Error is, that I gave credit for 520 dollars ^^^ received as for my pay from the first of January 1778 to the 2°*^ of Feb. 1779, whereas that sum being paid me in Conti- nental paper Money, should have been reduced by the Scale of Depreciation, to its specie value, which was but |59.55 making an error in my favor of $463. 1 2. It appears by the settlement made out by Mr. Burrell, the Commissioner, that he sliped over the Item to which the erroneous credit is annexed, and thecredit with it ; and in place of commencing his settlement of my account from the 1®* Jan. 1778, the day on which my services as F. M. commenced at West Point, he, together with the Commissioner's settlement, dates his partial settlement only from the 2°^^ Feby. 79, by which artifice the $520f| was suffered to stand without being reduced by the Scale of Depreciation, as in full for my pay from the 1^' Jany. '78 to the 2°