Book . r^ '0"VT~- THE BALLOT AND THE BULLET HOW TO SAVE THE NATION. A D D R E S S -7^2 OF HENRY STAN BERY, Esq. DELIVERED IN NEWPORT, KENTUCKY, f^atiirday Kvening,, J?i«'i)t. \7 , ISH-l. C I iN C I N :N A T^ J : (JAZKTTE CO. STEAM PBINTIN6 HOUSE, CORNER FOCKTH AND VINE STS; 1864. S7? -ADDRESS HEI^RY STA:NBERY, Esq. THE WAR AM) THE TRESIDENTIAL ELECTION. Fellow Citizens : I have said more than once since the conimencenient of this rebellion, that it was a fortunate thinp:, since it was to begin, that it did begin when a Presidential election was as remote as possible. I'had seen too much of our Presidential contest not to dread the liercc party strifes which they engender. The great work, then, before the nation, required our undivided attention. The great issue then presented was, whether we could save the nation. Save it first, and administer it afterward, seemed to me the dictate of wisdom. Finish the con test with the rebels, and then begin, if you please, the other contest for the spoil, ol victory. So, for nearly four years, the contest for the preservation of the Nation lu.s gone on ; but it is not ended, and at last, a Presidential election has come in like a disturbing force before the good work is quite finished. In this particular the rebels are more fortunate. In anticipation of the contest before them, they said no 1 residential election should disturb them for six years, and the consequenci; is that the same fixed will, the same experienced leader that has carried on their affairs from the beginning, still holds the reins. And so, unlike ourselves, they are free from a party contest of their own, and quite at liberty to take a hand in this party contest of ours. Does any one need to ask on which side? [No, no.] It IS true they can't vote. If, throughout what is left of the Southern Confed- erate, they should regularly choose electors for President at the very time and manner fixed in our Constitution, I hardlv think their votes would be recen-ed. iMo party at the North has, as yet, gone quite to that length in favor of free elec- tions. No one has, as yet, admitted the vote of a rebel in arms. But if the rebel has no arms in his hands, though out and out disloval, he may, according to some, do anything, write anything, counsel anvthing, utter anvthing, in favor of the rebellion, and yet he is a good voter and perfectly entitled to the free ballot! ^ Hut let us suppose that rebels in arms were allowed to vote. What State in the Confederacy would vote for Abraham Lincoln? Whf.t State in the Confederacy wouldnot rather vote for George B. McClellan? Which do you think would stand in that region the best chance for the Vice Presidency, Johnson or Pendle- ton . If you were called upon to stake your monov upon such an election, would you hesitate ? No, my friends, you would give tcn''to one upon McClellan against Lincoln, or any odds on Pendleton against the field. Let us put it another way. Who would Davis vote for ? Consider that, men ot the Nortli. Of these two men now presented to your choice, if Davis had a 3 vote, which of them would get it? You wish to vote for the man most likely to put down the rebellion. Davis, on the contrary, would cast his vote for the man least likely to do it. I am not a betting man; if I were, I would give any odds tliat the Arch traitor would vote for McClellan. There is an ancient maxim, that it is wise to learn from our foes. If they pro- f(n' McClellan, we can have no stronger reason for preferrindf Lincoln. There is another thing which we are taught by this rebel preference for the (Uiicago nomi- nee, and that is, that Lincoln is considered by the South the most foi-midabh' antagonist of the two. McClellan's friends tell us that he, too, goes for the ])ros- ecution of the war ; and that he is as good a Union man as Lincoln. That may be so, but the rebels are not just of that opinion. [Laughter.] If lighting is to be the order of the day, they would rather light McClellan tlian Lincoln. 'I'hev have tried them both, and they prefer McClellan as an antagonist. It was said at Chicago that the war had been a failure under the auspices oi' Tjincoln, and therefore they present a distinguished General to take his j)lac(\ IJut how does it happen that the rebels are equally anxious to get rid of Lincoln ? Do they find fault with him because he has failed to whip them? Do they want to change him for McClellan because 3IcClellan will light them more success- fully? Do they, think you, wish to change an antagonist whose blows are feeble and easily warded, for one who has more .^kill and will strike harder? THE CANDIDATES BEFORE THE PEOPLE. Now, my friends, let us examine these opposing candidates and their jilatfornis for ourselves. And first let us take cognizance of the new men — those who an- lirought forward as better men for the great business in hand than those now iti place. A General and a member of Congress — both gentlemen of intolligoncc and respectability — but neither of them at all likely to have been thought of :ts candidates except to represent particular ideas. Therefore, one is to represent the War Democrats, the other the Peace Democrats; and yet th(!y must stand on the same platform, and seem to represent a united party. On the eastern portico of the Capitol at A'N'ashington stands two colossal statues. -One represents War, with sword in hand, the other Peace, holding the olive +)ranch. "Weld these statues together, l)ack to back, and you have the efiigies of McClellan and Pendleten. Look now at our Union candidates : Lincoln and Johnson arc of on(> miiui ; t'aeh equally intent upon one great purpose, and that is to put down this rebellion in the only way in which it ever can bo put down, and that is by force of arms. If Lincoln should die before the contest, is ended, there is Johnson to take his jilace and carry out the same policy ; but if McClellan should die and Pendleton take his place, then what are we to expect? Then this Janus-faced statue is turned around ; then the sword is cast aside, and then comes a change of policy, with " not another man or another dollar^ Let the War Democrats, whose fiiith is fixed on McClellan, not forget tin* risk which is run that his vote nuiy place our destinies in the hands of Pendleton. >ry friends, I did not vote for Lincoln. I have never seen liini; but from the 4th of March, 18G1, to the present time, I have watched him closely. He has suid some things which I do not approve. He Inis done some things which did luit suit me; but for all that, I prefer him to any new and untried man. All my wishes, all )nj' hopes, are centered in one thing, and that is the crushing out <)f this rebellion by force of arms. There is no other way to save the Republic. Whatever else may be said of Mr. Lincoln, no one can doubt that he has the same purpose, and that from first to last he lias never faltered in the good work. Aly friends, I do not wish to change our President or his (Cabinet, or our (icn- erals in the field. Lincoln suits me; so does Seward and Stanton, and Fessendeii and Wells, and Grant and Sherman, and Sheridan and Winslow, and Porter and Parragut. CABINET OFFICERS AND UENERALS. It was a long time and after many changes before we got the right man in the right place. Where will you find a new Secretary who will keep our relation; with other nations — a matter of the greatest moment — in better trim than Sew- urd? Many find fault with Stanton."" They say he is rude and overbearing-, but who questions iiis honesty or ability? Look at our vast armies. Raised, eciuiji- ped, transported over great distances — every soldier to be ]>rovided every day with his punctual rations — and consider the vast and multiplied agencies which must be provided. It is Stanton who presides over all this Tuachinery, and he works it well. Vast as his duties are. he neglects nothing. There he is, always at his post, earnest and indefatigable. 3ly friends, if you turn out Lincoln, you turn out Sewanl ami Stant(ni, and all the oiher members of the Cabinet. Can any one assure yuu thaKirant and Sher- man will not go also? I very much fear there would be a clean sweep not only in the cabinet but in the field. There is more than one disatJeeted Major-Cren- eral, who has been retired like McClellan, who would be sure to be restored. What further? A clean sweep of all other civil officers, from our foreign minis- ters down. Tills rule fully established, first introduced by a Democratic Admin- istration, and never since omitted. We complain of fraud and jieculation in our officers, but how shall we stand a new and hungry swarm? ClIAX(iK OF ADMINISTRATION FATAL. There is another most weighty consideration against such a change, and it is this: If in November next it should happen that the people displace the present Administration, what would Ijc the result? That Administration would be par- alyzed. Set aside by the {)eople — their services ignored — their policy cmidemned, they would lose heart and confidence in themselves, and they would lose the con- fidence and support of the country. What capitalist would lend another dol- lar — what soldier would risk his life in another battle, for a people who condemn or seem to condemn this war? An outgoing Administration whose policy has been condemned, is powerless, and so from November to March, nothing would be done. Precious time lost, perhaps never to be regained. Have you forgotten the fatal delays of tlie outgoing Administration of liuchanan, when for months the rebels were '-let alone?" The country never was in such peril as in that six months. Our esciipe was providential. My friends, in view of such obvious I'esults, what true lover of the Linion will consent to make a change now? Is tliere any man so wedded to his party as to forget what he owes to his country? Alas! tl)ere are many, many true I'nion men, who have a personal preference for a Democratic candidate, and many others who have a personal dislike to Lincoln. AVe call this class War Demo- crats. They incline to follow their party instincts and their personal feelings. PERSONAL PRKJIJDICES OR PREFERENCES. For myself, I have lost sight of all party ideas since this war broke out. In November, 18*i0, no persuasion could induce me to vote for Lincoln. In Novem- ber, 18tJl, if I live to cast a vote, it shall be; for him. Not vote for him because he did not belong to my party in 1860! Not vote for him because our political creeds do not coincide! We agree in the great business now in hand, and that is enough for me. *' SluiU T ask tlie Ipimvo soMitr wlio fights by my side, In tliL' cmisi; of imiiikiiul, if our creeds asree?" VIOLATIONS 01'' TlIK (M)NSTITI'TION. Some ardent lover of the rights of the citizen might usk me: "How is it, Mr. Stanbery, that you, an old lawyer, can vite 'or a man that lia.s violated the Constitution of his country ? " I would answer: "It is a great wrong if he has violated that Constitution, but it seems quite clear tome, that while he may have been careless of the Constitu- tion, he has been veri/ careful, of the nation. If he has tried to destroy the one, lie has tried to save the other. If hB has torn the garment, he ha.s takkn pkkcious CARK OF THE BODY, and is not the bod;/ better than the raiment f Mind you, fellow-citizens, I do not admit that Mr. Lincoln has violated our Constitution. I do not admit that these arrests, in time of war, are forbidden by the Constitution. I do not object to Mr. Lincoln on tliat account, nor yet to Mr. McClellan on the same ground. Nay, on the contrary, there is no act of General McClellan's that I so cordially approve as his wholesale arrest of that 3Iaryland Legislature. If he had been as prompt and successful in putting down the whole rebellion as he was in putting down that branch of it, we would have Inul peace long ago. Who can tell how much precious blood has been saved by that timely act? What would be the condition of Maryland now, if that convention of traitors had carried her into the Southern Confederacy? But for those arrests, we should have witnessed all over Maryland such scenes as those in Baltimore, when the loyal soldiers of the Kepublic were murdered by a mob. Was that a time for the Sheriff and his posse '' Was that a time for the habeas eorpus ami trial by jury? All was terror and confusion, and the whole nation hailed 15ntler and bis soldiers as deliverers. When a nation is in a state of war, no matter what may be its form of Govern- ment, it is the executive power, whether lodged in a King or President, that is called into action. The Legislature and the Judiciary do not do the liglitiug. We do not carry on war by statute-, debates, or judicial decisions. War requires action, and a guiding will ready on the instant for any emergency. If you look into our frame of Government, you will see that it is on the President that the power and responsibility are cast to carry on the war. He cannot declare war or make peace. It requires the intervention of Congress to begin it or end it — but whilst it exists, it is the President who must act. He commands our armies and navi(!S, and ho directs their moviMnents. Without his authority nothing can be done. Now, my friends, this nation is not only engagiul in war, but in a war a^-ainst the rebellion. It is a war waged by us for self-preservation. It is not the com- mon form of a rebellion which aims only to change the dominant power while the nation is preserved, but its aim is to dastroy the nationality. Alas! what blood, what treasure, what sorrow, what lamentation have followed that crime .against humanity, civilization and civil liberty, which was committed in Charle.— ton harbor on the 13th of April, 18G1. It could have been committed nowhere else throughout the South but just there. The mortal instruments could have been found nowhere else. Those disaffected spirits had been trained and pre- pared for it long before. Twenty-eight years before, they had, under the pre- tense of an unconstitutional tariff, passed an ordimmce of secession in the very words of their ordinance of December, IStiO. What, then, s-aved the country? It was a President. It was Executive power in hamls that would have wielded it with terrible retribution. Think you that Jackson would have hesitated about arrests if those traitors had fired upo.i our flag? No, my friends; he would have seized them all wiih a grasp of iron, and instead of allowing then the habeas corpus, he would have arrested any judge who dared to issue it, as he did at New Orleans in 1815. Now again, if this nation is to be saved, it can only be saved under the auspices of the Executive. It is the war power that must s-ive us. In the plain and expressive language of our President, "wo must keep pegging away." P.low must follow blow, harder and harder, without ces:ration, until the traitor ' cry. "hold, enough." It is no time for treati(!S or armistices. Oiu- antag- onist reels with the hard hits he has received at Mobihs and Atlanta, and is gasp- ing for breath under the close hug of Grant at Petersburg. [Cheers.] tHE CHICAGO PLANS FOR PEACE, tt is just iit this juncture that a cry for peace and cessation of war comes to us from Cliicago. That Convention proposes to save the nation by means of an armistice and a Convention of all the States. Stop fighting, say they, and let us try talking. We have tried, for four years, to whip these rebels in, and they won't come. Now let us see if we can't coax them in. Let us consider their plan. A change of Administration is the first thing. Tt is their party which is to bring about this glorious consummation. The next thing i* tin "immediate armistice;" but as their President, if elected, could not propose an armistice before the fourth of March, it will not be exactly "immediate." There must, therefore, be first of all a delay of four months before their plan can go into operation. But we will suppose this time to have elapsed, and that Mc- ('lellan is in the Executive chair, what then is he to do according to the platform? He must propose an immediate armistice. And to whom? To that other Presi- dent who is now in Richmond. Where he will be on the 4th of March, is more than I can say — but wherever he is, our President mvist enter into formal negotia- tions with him. They must negotiate as equals, with all the forms and all the courtesies of diplomatic intercourse. Fellow citizens, this is recognition. The moment that our government enters into diplomatic intercourse with the Confederacy, the moment we cease to coerce the rebellious citizens and begin to deal with the political power that he lias set up — the moment you send and receive embassadors, ministers, or commissioners, from that moment you give to the rebels the character of an established gov- tjrnment. Year after year, Davis and his diplomatic agents have been knocking for admis- sion at every court in Europe. The answer has been : "We can't admit you. We can't recognize you ; we can't enter into commercial relations or diplomatic inter- course with you. The nation to which you owed allegiance treats you as rebels, and refuses you all diplomatic intercourse." The moment it is announced at London, or Paris, that the United States has opened diplomatic intercourse with the Confederate States, Slidell and Mason will no longer be kept out in the cold. Now an Armistice is a temporary cessation of all hostilities on land or water. If an army is in line of battle, it must stack its arms. If it is pushing a siege, it must raise it. If a fleet is blockading a port, it must hoist anchor and depart, or if it remains on the coast, it cannot train a gun upon a single vessel. If, whilst the armistice is in force the Kearsarge should meet another Alabama, our gallant tars must fold their arms. But Davis will claim, that whilst the armistice is in f(_)rce, all our armies shall be withdrawn from that indefinite territory called the Southern Confederacy. I hardly think ]McClellan will agree to this, and after long negotiation, Davis will probably give up the claim. How much time this preliminary negotiation will take, I cannot pretend to say. It will drag its slow length along after the fashion of diplomatic intercourse. At last, however, the armistice is agreed upon. What next? A Convention of all the States. Not a separate convention in each State, loj'al and rebel, meet- ing in one place. In the first place it is evident that a long time must elapse before this convention can meet. There must be time for the election of delegates and for their assembling. Several months will necessarily be consumed, for wo must wait for the delegates from the Pacific side. Let us stop at this point, for a moment, to consider what will have become of our armies. No progress from November till March, then another delay whilst the armistice is under negotiation ; and finally a longer pause, until the delegates to their great Convention shall have been elected and come together. All this time our soldiers are idle. They cannot so much as be employed on military roads or fortifications, for that would be hostile work. Fellow citizens, it would be impossible to keep our armies together. They would melt away by expiration of time and desertions, and by furloughs, never to re-assemble. Then, again, as to this Convention — where is it to meet? That is a difficult point to be settled. Perhaps it will be somewhere in Canada, if you can call that neutral 'ierritory. Then it must be a Convention of all the States, thirty-five in all. Y.i, see I count on Western Virginia, and I do so, because Western Vir- ginia is a State of this Union, recognized by Contjress and the Executive. There can be no longer any question that AVest Virginia is de jure as well as dc faclo a State. Her political staiua is irrevocably fixed. It matters not what seeming irregularities attended her admittance into the Union, for she was admitted by the very authority which had the right to say, come or keep out. We can no more agree to exclude "West Virginia from the Convention of States, than we can agree to exclude Kentucky. But while we can never consent to exclude lier, 1 very much doubt if Virginia and the other rebel States will ever agree to admit her. Upon that question the Convention would come to a dead lock in the very act of organization. No doubt there will be two sets of delegates, whose claims must be first settled — one loyal, the other rebel — from several of the States- — say from Missouri, Tennessee, Arkansas and Louisiana, and perhaps from Afarylanil, and even from Kentucky. Next as to the vital question of the mode of deciding matters in this convfiitioi}. The matters to be decided are at issue between the parties met together. There is no provision for an umpire, no third and disinterested party to be calh^d in ; but this convention is to settle and decide for itself Shall each State have only owQ vote? Shall New York have no more voting power than Delaware ? Nay, shall each State have one vote? "Will the South ever consent to that ? The loyal States are as three to one, and where it comes to a vote on the basis of members the loyal States would carry the point. No, my friends, depend upon it, these rebellious States will never consent to the decision of the majority. They would claim that the loyal and rebel States should stand each as one party, equal in dig- nity and voting power. In settling great national questions which concern us all. one rebel vote must count equal to three loyal votes ! Nothing short of that will satisfy the South. When it comes to that what are you to expect? Everlasting debate without any result. Suppose a single branch of a single subject bo under con- sideration — the question of slavery in the Territories. Is there a free loyal State that would vote for that claim, or a rebel State that will vote against it? There is no occasion to enumerate the other issues which would arise, but we know quite well that the South would ask all sorts of guarantees, recognizing slavery — indemnity for their losses — assumption of their public debt, and I know not what besides. What guaranty would they give the North? There is one we would re(iuire, and that is that hereafter there shall be no secession. This is precisely the guar- anty, give them what we may, which the South will not give us. No, fellow-citizens, this cunning platform of an armistice and a convention to save lihe Union, is all a delusion. Those that got it up intended to save Davis and the Ctiilcderacy, and they could have hit upon nothing more op])ortuno, or more certain, if adopted, to accomplish that purpose. [Cheers.] ARMISTICE, CONVENTION, AND DISUNION. Nothing seems to be more certain than that the election of McClellan, followed by an armistice and a convention, will end the struggle and the Union together. We shall then have a peace, but it W'ill be a peace purchased by dismemlier- ment — a peace that destroys our nationality — a peace in which we get nothing and surrender everything — a peace which compels us to lower our flag all over the ficrcat southern region, first purchased by our treasure, and since repossessed by the precious blood of our soldiers and sailors — a peace which changes us from a great nation, feared and respected all over the world, into disjointed and crumb- ilng elements, with new flags, new boundaries, new names and new treaties. That precious Union which was intrusted to this generation by that which ha.s passed, is to perish in our degenerate hands, and we must straightway set to work to reconstruct our North American map. We must mark ofl" tlie boundaries of the two governments, and run a line of division from the Atlantic to the Kocky Mountains, and perhaps to the Pacific. This line — the only one the South will agree to — must begin on the Atlantic coast, and run west by the old ]Mason and Dixon line to the Ohio river, along that river to the Mississippi, then up the Mis- sissippi so as to include Missouri, and from the southwest corner of that State to the West indefinitely. Look at your maps, and see what will ho left, north and west of that line. This Southern Confederacy will have more than two-thirds of our sea coast, and all our Gulf coast. They will have the mouth of the Chesapeake, our National cap- ital, and the control of the Mississippi. Citizens of Newport, where will be Kentucky? Consider where that line will leave you. Loyal men of this Kentucky city, who love the old flag, this line will take away your country and carry you under a new flag — with a new allegiance — into the holy keeping of the Southern Confederacy. As for myself, 1 am too old for such transplanting. They may take my pleas- ant home on my Kentucky hill, where I had hopedto pass" what remains of life. They may take my fields, but mj'self, never. [Cheers.] Kentucky did not invest me with my allegiance, and she shall not take it away. I am not one of those who look upon my State as n)y country. Three times in the course of my life, I have removed from Slate to State, but I have never been sensible of a change of allegiance, but only of a change of neighborhood — always in the same old Union, and always under the same old flag. [Cheers.] THE CRY FOR TEACK DELUSIVE. Stand fast, then, oh, loyal men, and do your duty. Arc you tired of war? Are you so smitten with the desire for peace, that you are willing to purchase it at such a price? Go to our gallant soldiers and take a lesson from them. Ask your brave boys who have left their pleasant homes to fight this great battle of liberty, if this is a time to give up. Ask them if all their comrades who have fallen in the struirgle, have died in vain; if all their labors — if all their battles — if all their hard-earned victories, shall end only in loss and dishonor. Ask them if these rebels whom they have driven from fleld to field, are at last to reap all the fruits of victory — whether the great reward earned with so nnich blood, now almost within their grasp, is to be surrendered ? Ask them, final}', whether this beloved country that lias been saved by their valor, that could not be destroyed by rebels in arms, is at last to be ruined by traitors at home? [Applause.] You who live at home at ease, and yet complain of the war, go to Anderson- ville in Georgia, where ;]0,000 loyal men are held in capitivity. Visit that pesti- enlial inclosure — where to pass out is instant destruction, and to stay is w'orse— where triumphant death in all its terrible forms of famine, pestilence and despair reigns supreme — ask those gallant soldiers whether we shall make peace and save them, or fight on and save the nation, and the answer would \)e,^'fffht on I" [Cheers.] THE PRESENT NOT THE TI.ME FOR CHANGE. Now my friends, this is no time for change — no time for an armistice — no time for a convention — no time for diplomacy' — no time for recognition When this rebellion is crushed — when these rebels have grounded their arjns, and have once more submitted themselves to the majesty of the laws — /hoi wo shall have a peace that will be permanent, and a country that will be safe for ages to come. This great struggle has cost us thousands of men and millions of treasure, and may cost us more; but what price is too great for the preservation of our country? We call this a long war, and many are discouraged. There was a time, long past, when I too felt despondent; but now I am hopeful and confident. The very continuance of the war, with all its sufferings, has yet its preciousness. it is the last rebellion this generation will wilness, and not this only, but many that arc to come after us. No, my friends, if those who rushed into secession could have seen thus far into the future — if those who gave the fatal order to open the bombardment of Sumter, could have seen the awful consequences — if some angel had shown them from some high mountain, as in a vision, the fields of blood and desolation that were to come, not a State would have passed an ordinance of secession — not a gun would have been fired. Yob, my friends, I am hopeful. The fierceness of the storm has pa.st. The skies begin to clear. Yet a little while, and a voice will be heard as of a ship- wrecked mariner, "A sail, a sail, we are saved." [Great applause.] lBWr20