<* .•■ >. •• ': ^ ^S 5 V i -• y % ^v;-* a<> ***» 0^ • «SH8IBir" ^ <^' » ^ * v * % A* ♦k\VA % **~ <$*" ••« V •TRTi* a ^\ <■•. P* .♦i^r* - i * EVIDENCES J OF NATURAL AND REVEALED RELIGION; ALSO. QL\)t ^Doctrines ant) Jnatituftons CHRISTIANITY WITH QUESTIONS FOR USE IN BIBLE CLASSES. IN PAROCHIAL, FAMILY. SUNDAY. AND OTHER SCHOOLS. BY THE AUTHOR OF 'REASONS WHY I AJM A GHUSCHMAN." N E W - Y O R IC : GENERAL PROTESTANT EPISCOPAL & S. UNION, Depository 20 Johii S 1343. $% Entered, according to Act of Congress, in the year 1848. BY JOHN W. MITCHELL, (As Treasurer of The General Protestant Episcopal S. S. Union,) in the Clerk's Ornce of the District Court of the United States, for the Southern District of New York. — - f The Library of Cong^ C. DAVISON &: CO., Stereo - jet, New York. PREFACE. The present work is offered to the public in the belief, that among the numerous treatises extant on the Evidences of Natural and Revealed Religion, there is not one which answers all the purposes of a book for general reading and for instruction, on this most important subject, in our parochial, Sun- day and other schools. To provide such a book has been the object in preparing the following pages. The author has aimed, where so much might be said, at comprehensiveness, brevity and perspicuity. The testimony of the Church, as " the pillar and ground of the truth," will be found running through the chain of evidence. The objective Doctrines and Institutions of Christianity, in the concluding chap- ters, will not, it is hoped, be found out of place at the present day. In using the work as a book of instruction, much must be left to the living teacher. A few leading questions are appended to each page ; the faithful ' IV PREFACE. teacher, however, will not confine his attention to these, but will see to it that the pupil is thoroughly acquainted with the subject examined. Particular care should be taken not to hurry forward too rapidly. A few pages will be sufficient for a single lesson, ex- cept in reviews, which should be frequent, repeated and thorough. Should the present volume shield any of the young from the enticements and the doom of the skeptic, or should it, in a single instance, lead to a more intelli- gent, ennobling service of the one only and true G-od, in the way of His appointment, many an hour of arduous, pleasing labor will not have been spent in vain. I CONTENTS. CHAPTER I. Page Evidences of the Existence of God, from the Light of Nature 7 CHAPTER II. Attributes of God, as proved from the Light of Nature . . 22 CHAPTER III. Probability and Necessity of a Revelation 41 CHAPTER IV. Authenticity of the Old Testament 61 CHAPTER V. Same subject continued — Mosaic Account of the Deluge examined and confirmed 87 CHAPTER VI. Prophecy, Proof of the Inspiration of the Old Testament 108 CHAPTER VII. Authenticity and Genuineness of the Books of the New Testament 126 1* VI CONTENTS, CHAPTER VIII. PAGE Inspiration of the New Testament — Miracles and Prophecy U9 CHAPTER IX. Internal Evidence of the Inspiration and Truthfulness of the New Testament 167 CHAPTER X. Revelation contains both Doctrines and Institutions 185 CHAPTER XI. Institutions of Christianity defined and proved 200 CHAPTER I. EXISTENCE OF GOD PROVED FROM THE LIGHT OF NATURE. There are multitudes of persons, who, if they were required to state definitely what they mean by the Being of God, and why they believe in His existence, would find their ideas on the subject consisting only of a few vague generalities. On the subject of religious truth generally, there is a tendency abroad to rest satisfied with a few un- defined impressions, which float like shadows across the surface of the mind, but which are found to lack reality, when tested by a thorough examination. Here is one strong reason why many who have been educated under religious influences, and are perhaps professed believers in revealed religion, are seen, under a change of circumstances, swelling the number of the scoffers and the profane. They never were thoroughly instructed in the principles of Chris- 1. What is the subject of the present chapter 1 2. What is too generally true respecting this subject 1 3. What general remark is too often true 1 4. What is often seen as a consequence of this 1 5. What was true of them 1 8 EXISTENCE OF GOD PROVED tianity. They are conscious of exercising belief without evidence, and hence feel that they have no power to withstand the assaults of the enemies of the Cross of Christ. Hence it is the imperious duty of every believer of natural and revealed religion, to examine the foun- dation on which he stands. And it is also the bounden duty of all parents and sponsors, and all religious teachers, to fortify the faith of those who are placed under their care with reasons which the enemy can neither gainsay nor resist. To assist in this important work is the object of the following pages. TTe propose to examine with some minuteness the Evidences of Natural and Eevealed Eeligion ; and trust they who give to the subject their attention will find themselves amply rewarded, not only in their ability to resist attacks from without, but, what is far more, in the acquisition of a more in- telligent Faith, of more animating hopes, and of more intimate acquaintance with the God of all Truth. The subject of our present examination is, The Beixg and Existence of God.; on which subject we propose to answer two questions— I. "What do we understand by the Being of God ? 6. What are they conscious of* 7. What are they the victims of? 8. What duty arises 1 9. What is the object of the following pages'? 10. What do we propose to examine ? 11. What encouragement is offered to us 1 1*2. What is the first subject examined in the present chapter 1 FROM THE LIGHT OF NATURE. 9 II. Why do we believe in His existence ? Let ns implore, that He, whose existence, perfec- tions, and works, are to form the subject of our study, will vouchsafe the constant assistance of His Holy Spirit. I. In respect to the first inquiry, there have been held erroneous views as to the nature of God. A glance at two or three of these views, will enable us more intelligently to fasten our minds upon the truth. One erroneous conception of the nature of God, is that which regards Him, not as a person, but only as a principle. According to this theory, God is only that principle of life which pervades the animal and vegetable world ; that principle which, year after year, clothes the earth with verdure, and covers the forests with beauty. And as all things are found to be instinct with life, so God is said to be every thing and every thing God. This doctrine is usually de- nominated Pantheism. It had once obtained great prevalence among the more enlightened heathen na- tions. It has had great influence in shaping modern systems of corrupt Christianity. Even at the present day, much of the Rationalism which exists under a 13. What is the second 1 14. Respecting the first inquiry, what errors have been held 1 15. What is the first erroneous idea mentioned 1 16. What has it been called 1 17. When had it great prevalence? 1 8. Where does it exist now 1 19. What is such corruption usually called % 10 EXISTENCE OF GOD PROVED Christian name, seems to be little else than the Pan- theism of pagan times. In this theory there may be ingenuity and appa- rent beauty. But it is stamped with guilt of the deepest dye — for it denies to G-od the possession of the most essential attributes of His character, and robs Him of that homage and worship which are His due. Such a theory is gloomy and comfortless to those who embrace it. Like the marble statuary, it may have the semblance of life ; but yet it is cold and cheerless as death in an hour of need. Instead of teaching that all things will work for good to those who love God, it makes the God of heaven and earth a mere imaginary principle, without the possession of wisdom, volition, love, or power. Again : Another erroneous view of the Being of G-od, is that, which, while it allows Him to be a per- son, in distinction from a principle, yet regards Him as subject to a law of inevitable fatality ; and teaches, that whatever has been, is, or shall be, takes place not by the permission or direction of God, but by the same law of fatality. Such a theory, like that just noticed, is in the high- est degree derogatory to the character of God. It 20. What is said of the guilt of this theory ? 21. Why must this be true 1 22. What is its tendency 7 23. What is another erroneous view held 1 24. How does this affect the character of God 7 25. How does it derogate from Him 1 FROM THE LIGHT OF NATURE. 1 1 denies to Him the essential perfections of His cha- racter. It teaches that He neither chooses, wills, nor controls ; that he neither can punish nor reward moral action, according to its deserts ; but that He sits an unconcerned spectator of what is passing before Him. This theory has another necessary consequence. It blots out the line of distinction between virtue and vice, It needs no argument to prove that no virtue can attach to actions which are not voluntary, and that no vice can belong to conduct which is the result of an inevitable fatality. And yet this theory has, in past ages, been extensively held, and even in modern times, is one of those hiding-places of lies where de- pravity has sought to conceal itself. In speaking of erroneous conceptions of the Being of G-od, we have made no mention of the Atheist, who denies entirely that there is a God. Few indeed there are, who can shut their eyes at noon-day, and profess to believe that all is dark around them. So overpowering and so varied are the evidences of the existence of the Supreme Being, that even from the Atheist the confession is sooner or later wrung, " Yerily there is a G-od that dwelleth on the earth." In distinction from these erroneous conceptions of the nature and being of God, we believe, that He is a 26. What is another consequence ? 27. Must this be its necessary result % 28. What do you say of its prevalence 1 29. Of what have we made no mention ? 30. Have such notions often been held 1 31. What is our definition of the Being of GodI 12 EXISTENCE OF GOD PROVED person, In distinction from a principle, and that He is free and voluntary in all things, governed only by His most high and holy will, instead of being con- trolled by the laws of an irresistible fatality. Our idea of God may be expressed in saying, that He is a Spiritual Being, possessing, naturally and eternally, every absolute possible perfection, in an infinite degree. II. Our next general inquiry is. Why do we be- lieve THAT GrOD EXISTS ? In examining this important question, fundamental in all true religion, one thing we must take for grant- ed 5 to wit, our own existence, and our oMlity and au- thority to draw certain inevitable conclusions. If any man therefore denies his own existence, or the neces sity of certain axioms which are as evident as his ex- istence, with him we have no controversy. These axioms men, all men, feel, not only that they are true, but that they cannot be false. One of these axioms, which we make the basis of our present argument, is, that wherever there EXISTS INDISPUTABLE MARKS OF CONTRIVANCE, THERE MUST HAVE BEEN AT WORK THE HAND OF A CONTRIVER. For illustration, a traveller upon the high seas is thrown by accident upon the shores of an unknown 32. How may this idea be expressed 1 33. What inquiry next arises % 34. What do we take for granted 1 35. What do you say of such axioms 1 36. What one is here the basis of our argument ? 37. Give the illustration. FROM THE LIGHT OF NATURE. 13 coast. He begins to explore its curiosities. He wanders here and there, amidst its valleys and groves, and discovers before him an imposing building. He notices first, the strong foundation, on which the mas- sive superstructure is reared : the towering walls, strongly compacted together ; the windows, freely admitting the light, yet excluding the storms and the cold; the lofty spire, pointing toward heaven, sur- mounted by a deep-meaning symbol ; the doors by which a congregation might enter, and well-arranged seats for their accommodation ; the altar for the offering up of prayer and praise, and the pulpit, whence a congregation might be addressed; the niches, here and there, where stand monuments of holy men of &od, and the entablature, recording lives well spent. He gazes, and upon the canvass before him is a living picture of the Crucifixion of his Saviour. There is depicted the cruel torture, the convulsive writhing of every muscle ; the deep, soul- subduing agony which fills the countenance ; the eyes upturned to heaven for help ; and yet, over all is impressed the subdued serenity which seems to say, " Even so, Father, for so it seemeth good in thy sight." — He gazes upon the lengthened aisles, the fluted columns, the vaulted arches, while the dim re- ligious light, of every varied hue, is diffused around him. He listens, and from the tower above him the clock strikes accurately the hour of time. He sees, 38. What does he find % 39. Mention every mark of contrivance. 14 EXISTENCE OF GOD PROVED he hears, he feels all this ; and he knows, as he knows the fact of his own existence, that all this is not the work of chance. He could not be more confident than he is, that no possible combination of the powers of nature, no accidental confusion or blending of the elements, ever brought into one harmonious whole such beautiful and varied results as he sees around him. He knows that this must be the effect of deep design, of laborious contrivance ; and that in what he sees around him, there has been at work the hand of a skilful contriver. Now precisely this, is the argument for the exist- ence of God. It is an argument which applies in its fullest strength. For never in human art has there been exhibited such marks of design, as are exhibited in that Great Temple of the Most High God, the natural world. St. Paul thus states the argument : " The invisible things of Him from the creation of the world, are clearly seen ; being understood By the things that are made, even his eternal power and Godhead." Rom. i. 20. Wherever we turn amid the works of nature, so called, we find ourselves met at every point by the most obvious proofs of contrivance and design : evinc- 40. What conclusion does he draw ? 41. Does he feel that he can be mistaken % 42. What does contrivance prove in this case 1 43. Does this argument prove the existence of God 1 44. Does this argument exist in its full strength 1 45. What does St. Paul say ? 46. Where do we find contrivance 1 FROM THE LIGHT OF NATURE. 15 ing, beyond question, the hand of a Contriver. We behold, every where, perfect adaptation of means to ends ; systematic order ; matchless skill ; exquisite beauty ; endless variety. Amidst the ten thousand illustrations of the fact that contrivance proves a Contriver, we select the com- mon fluid, water ;. not as being the most striking, but as among the most familiar and useful. One of the two elements of which water is com- posed (hydrogen), is a destructive poison. The con- trivance by which the two are united,, renders the combination into one, essential to human health and comfort. Again : had the vast body of water on the globe remained perfectly motionless, it must have become a stagnant mass, charging the atmosphere with deathful exhalations. Hence the contrivance of the ebb and flow of the tides, the extensive currents of the sea, which, with the winds, keep it in constant and healthful agitation. Again : had this element been limited to one place, the whole animal and vegetable world must have perished by thirst and drought. Hence the contri- vance of the system of evaporation, by which the water, though more dense than the atmosphere, is yet drawn up into it, is there cleansed and made fit for use, is rendered almost tasteless and colorless, as beicg thus fitted for combinations, and is then suffered to 47. What illustration is selected 7 48. What contrivance in respect to agitation of the tides 1 49. What contrivance brings it within reach of all 1 16 EXISTENCE OF GOD PROVED descend again, not in overwhelming torrents, but so gently as not to injure the most sensitive plant and flower. Again : had this element remained on the surface of the earth, it would soon have become useless : or had it descended deep into the earth, it would have become inaccessible. Hence the contrivance of those little rivulets, which, shielded alike from summer's heat and winter's cold, burst forth in cool and re- freshing streams, ministering to the necessities of ail living things, and spreading beauty and verdure over the landscape. Again : had this element been suffered to remain on the surface of the earth, it must soon have gathered into vast and destructive quantities ; and hence the contrivance of rills, brooks and rivers, which roll their waters back again to the ocean, turning meanwhile the wheels of industry, and bearing upon their bosom to the busy marts of commerce, the varied productions of the lands through which they flow. Again : had this element, in high latitudes, been suffered to be exposed to the extreme colds, it must soon have become a solid mass, covering vast portions of the globe with perpetual desolation. Hence the contrivance of the expansion of water, in the form of ice. by which its specific gravity being less, it rises to 50. What contrivance preserves it in a fit state for use 1 51. What contrivance in respect to disposal of it'? 52. What contrivance renders it useful ? 53. "What contrivance protects it from cold? FROM THE LIGHT OF NATURE. 17 the surface, and offers a sufficient protection from the rigor of the cold to the depths below. Again : a not less wonderful instance of contrivance is seen in the newly discovered power which water becomes in the form of steam, and which promises to affect deeply the commercial, social, and religious in- terests of mankind. Such are some of the proofs of contrivance in one of the most familiar objects in nature. Now, this argument from contrivance, in proof of a Contriver, is not to be estimated by a single illus- tration. The argument is almost endlessly cumula- tive. It increases in strength with every new instance in which contrivance is manifest. And such instances multiply and become more and more striking, just in proportion to the accuracy and minuteness of cur examination. They are seen in the peculiar con- struction of every species of insect, bird, fish, animal, and plant ; adapting each to their own peculiar sphere of existence and to no other. Instances of contrivance are seen in every blade of grass, and in the formation of the various parts of every delicate flower. As we examine with the microscope the more delicate works of nature, as, for instance, the myriads of animalculae in the smallest drop of water — and scan the wonders which are never seen by the multitude with the naked 54. What renders it subservient to other purposes 1 55. Is this the whole strength of the argument ? 56. Is it only the beginning of the argument 1 57. Where is contrivance further seen 1 58. What do you say of microscopic observations ? 2* 18 EXISTENCE OF GOD PROVED eye, there we find growing still upon us, proof on proof of contrivance varied and multiplied in every form which every where exists. And so again, if, with the telescope, we turn our eye to the heavens above, and read the laws of order, the proofs of wisdom, power, and goodness which there abound, still it is only one accumulating mass of proof, growing continually upon us, to convince us of the power and the wisdom of the Creator. And so, in every place, and on every hand, from the rolling of a planet to the microscopic mite, there is never lacking the most complete adaptation of every thing to its own end ; the nicest arrangement of every thing to its own sphere ; in a word, the most conclusive evidence of contrivance, proving the ex- istence of a Contriver. And that Contriver is God. Here, then, is our first argument for the existence of God. Contrivance proves a Contriver. All these multiplied exhibitions of wisdom, skill, power, design, are not the offspring of mere chance. On the con- trary, " the invisible things of Him, from the crea- tion, are clearly seen, being understood by the things that are made, even His eternal power and God- head." III. Our next argument in proof of the existence of God, is of a different kind. It is less imposing at 59. "What of telescopic 1 60. What is seen every where ? 61. What conclusions do we form % 62. Does St. Paul endorse this argument % 63. What is the next general argument 1 FROM THE LIGHT OF NATURE. 19 the first, but yet will bear the strictest examination. It is drawn from the general consent of mankind. In all ages of the world, ia all countries of the world, in all degrees of civilization, the belief has prevailed that thep.e is a God. If there have been found excep- tions to this rule, they are insignificant in number, and do not affect the main fact, that the whole world of mankind,