','1 . K^' f'.T.lf 'r-SL G[ass___yL^j4^ Book__Z££J_ uc/^K ^7 A LITERARY IMPOSTURE. Interesting Correspondence. On Thursday, the 12th of March last, after the close of the obsequies in honor of Dr. Kane, a number of his comrades dined to- gether at Parkinson's. On that occasion the conversation turned upon the different pub- lished accounts of the Arctic expedition. Among these was one purporting to have been written by Auguste Sontag, which the party determined to denounce as being, in their opinion, a spurious work. This they did in the following PROTEST. We, the undersigned members of the Arctic Ex- pedition, under the command of the late Dr. Elisha K. Kane, having noticed a book purporting to be written by one of our comrades, Auguste Sontag, astronomer to the Expedition, &o., take this op- portunity to say that we believe it never to have been published with his consent or 1 nowledge, he being at this time, and for some time before the book went to press, in Mexico. We are induced to make this public exposure because we believe the book injures our comrade to whom its authorship is attributed, and it is no record of our labors. We therefore caution the public against its pur- chase, and respectfully request all editors favor- able to the late expedition to copy this notice. Henry Brooks, Amos Bonsall, H. Goodfellow, William Morton, J. J. Hayes, Geo. Stephenson. The proceedings of the meeting were re- ported in the Philadelphia Evening Journal, and having given offence to the publisher of Sontag's reputed book, he requested us to do him the justice to print the following card,to which we gave place in our columns the fol- lowing day : — To the Editor of the Phila. Evening J ourtial. In your paper of Saturday, I noticed in an account of the proceedings at an entertainment given by Mr. G. W. Childs, of the firm of Childs and Peter- son, to some of the members of the Grinnell Ex- ploring Expedition in Search of Sir John Franklin, a protest signed by some of them, in relation to the publishing of Sonntag's Narrative of the Grinnell Expedition, which does much injustice to me as the publisher. If you will have the kindness to give the enclosed affidavit a place in your paper, you will oblige Yours, CnARiiES C. Rhodes. Philadelphia, March 14, 1857. Rosa Sonntag, being duly sworn, doth depose and say, that Mr. Charles C. Rhodes bought the narrative written by her husband, giving an ac- count of his voyage to the Arctic regions, under the command of Dr. E. K. Kane, and that she be- ! lieyes he bought it for the purpose of publishing it. , Rosa Sonntag. t Sworn and subscribed before me this 14th day of , March, Anno Domini 1857. Geo. ttKYER, i Alderman Thirteenth Ward, i Between these conflicting statements, the community, of course, found it difficult to de- cide, and we know that an effort was made at the time to misrepresent the relations of Messrs. Childs & Peterson, the publishers of Dr. Kane's narrative, to the controversy, and thereby to injure that firm in public estima- tion. Time, however, generally sets such matters right, and we now lay before our read- ers the following letters from Mr. Sontag and Mr. Goodfellow, the originals, and post-marked envelopes of which, we have seen. The first letter we shall give, is from Henry Goodfellow, to G. W. Childs, Esq.:— Philadelphia, March 16, 1857. My Dear Sir : — A card, signed by Charles C. Rhodes, the publisher of the alleged work of Mr. Sonntag, has been brought to my attention. I desire to state to you how indignant I feel, and I believe all the rest of our party will feel, upon reading it, at this insolent perversion of an act of kind hospitality and attention to the members of our party, who, by your goodness, upon their re- turn from the funeral of Dr. Kane, after an expo- sure all day without refreshment, were enabled to ' partake of the so necessary refreshment, while we were re-united once more around your table. After dinner, the conversation turning upon our ! absent messmate, I believe it was myself who first alluded to the wretched work attributed to my ab- Isent comrade, Mr. Sonntag. One of our party (Dr. ; Hayes) proposed that we should notice the work, in order to save Mr. Sonntag harmless; but I sug- gested that it was too apparent a fabrication to iriseto the dignity of contradiction. It was an- swered that thousands of the book had been sold, ! producing in the minds of inconsiderate and badly informed persons an impression disparaging of the 'expedition. The card, drawn up, has since re- ceived the signature of every member of our party who has seen it. You disclaimed all interest in the matter, and the act was entirely that of the signers, who alone are responsible for it. What was my amazement, a day or two after- wards, to read the card, and the affidavit of Mrs. Sonntag appended to it, setting forth that C. C. Rhodes had purchased "the narrative written by her husband giving an account of his voyage," (fee, without stating of whom the purchase was made, or what narrative it was, showing, you per- ceive, no identity of the article purchased with Che article published. And for the best of reasons^ as the narrative purchased, according to Rhodes' own confes- sion to both you, sir, and myself, was intend^ ed for a mere magazine article for Harper, of some ten to fifteen pages, and its only similarity was in the main facts of the history of the expedi- tion, which could have been obtained from the public papers of the date of our arriyal. The jumble of extracts from Arctic books, and the pictures, I have grounds for believing, amount- ing almost to certainty, no more emanated from - Mr. Sonntag than they resemble the facts. But C. C. Rhodes goes further, and promises to produce Mr. Sonntag's affidavit ; the affidavit of a man who will not be able to recognize a single sentence in the book, and will be as mucti horror struck, to a moral certainty, as I would be if the title page bore my own name. The force of folly could no further go. Very respectfully and truly yours, Hknky Goodfellow. G-. W. Childs, Esq., Arch street. The next letter is one from Mr. Sonntag, to Gr. W. Childs, aa follows :— Hotel Iturbide, ) Mexico, April 22, 1857. J Dear Sir : — A few days ago I received a letter from Philadelphia, informing me that a narrative of the last Arctic expedition was published under my name, and, almost at the same time, a friend, who returned from the United States, brought me the book- itself. I am very much mortified to see my name at the head of such a wretched concern, especially as I never wrote anything about the ex- Dedition which could have given cause to a book like this. To make the thing as absurd as possible, one of the copies which I saw is dedicated to Dr. Jayne, a man whose name I never heard before, and whose medicines I certainly never used; the other to Com- modore Stockton, a gentleman whom I highly re- spect. It pains me very much to think he might possibly believe me to be the author who is imper- cinent enough to dedicate such a wretched publi- cation to him. I did not write the book., it is a shameful impo- sition, and I am determined to prosecute the ras- cally impostor who published it under my name. I send to-day a note to the New York Herald, protesting against the authorship of this book, and you would oblige me very much if you could inr duce some of the Philadelphia and Washington papers to publish the same protest. I want to bring a lawsuit against the publisher, and would receive it as a particular favor if you will inform me about the steps which I have to take in this matter. I am sorry that I cannot well leave here at present to come to Philadelphia, but I hope there are some means to punish a cowardly im- postor who takes advantage of my absence to abuse my name for the sake of filling his pocket. Waiting anxiously for a few lines from you, I remain, truly yours, Augusts Sonntag. "We ought to add that Mr. Childa has never corresponded with Mr. Sonntag on any sub- ject whatever, and that he was surprised when he received from him the above letter. DOCTOR HOOFLAND'S CELEBRATED PREPARED BY Dr. 0. M. JACKSON, Philada., Pa. WILL EFFECTUALLY CURE LIVER COMPLAINT, DYSPEPSIA, JAUNDICE, Chronic or Nervous Debility, Diseases of the Kidneys, and all diseases arising from a disordered Liver or Stomach. Snch as Constipa- tion, Inward Piles, Fulness or Blood to the Head, Acidity of the Stomach, Nausea, Heartburn, Disgust for Food, Fulness or Weight in the Stomach, Sour Emc- tations, Sinking or Fluttering at the Pit of the Stomach, Swimming of the Head, Hurried and difficult Breathing, Fluttering at the Heart, Choaking or suffocating sensations when in a lying posture, Dimneaa