THE HISTORY VIRGIL A. STEWART, ADVENTURE IN CAPTURING AND EXPOSING THE GREAT " WESTERN LAND pirate" and his GANG, IN CONNEXION WITH THE EVIDENCE ; ALSO OF THE TRIALS, CONFESSIONS, AND EXECUTION A NUMBER OF MURRELL's ASSOCIATES IN THE STATE OF 1 MISSISSIPPI DURING THE SUMMER OF 1835, AND THE EXECUTION OF FIVE PROFESSIONAL GAMBLERS BY THE CITIZENS OF VICKSBURG, ON THE 6tH JULY, 1835. *' I am not willing to admit to the world that I believe him."— ^ bitter enemy " I care nothing for his jealous animosity. . He may vent his poisonous spleen. I am susulned before the world by evidence that shall chaia his enrenomed tongue."— Srew'art. COMPILED BY H. R. HOWARD. NEW-YORK : HARPER & BROTHERS, CLIFF-ST. 18 3 9. [Entered, according to Act of Congress, in the year 1836, by Harper «5c Brothers, in the Clerk's Office of the Southern District of New-York.^ Z^^prs PREFACE. The public have long been expecting the final history of Virgil A. Stewart's perilous and ronian- tfte adventure in capturing " John A. Murrell," the great " Western Land Pirate." We now propose giving a full and perfect account of that strange performance, in connexion with the evidence sus- taining each important fact as it is related. We make no pretensions to author-craft, or skill in working up materials so as to heighten interest ; nor is it necessary. The deep interest that every Southerner and every honest man must feel in the subject matter of this history, is sufficient to invest a plain and simple statement of facts with attrac- tion. Our only care has been to adhere strictly to the truth, and to exhibit the details in a clear and intelligible narrative. We have commenced with a brief account of Mr. Stewart's early life to the time when he under- took the capture of Murrell and his party. We then continue with his adventure on that expedi- tion, and conclude with a full history of the insur- rectionary movements among the negroes in the southern country during the summer of 1835. In 1* VI PREFACE. the perusal of this narrative the reader will be made acquainted with many scenes of horror and depravity. When the " Western Land Pirate" was in course of publication, Mr. Stewart's health was such that he could pay but little attention to the task of su- pervision, which rendered it very imperfect in many respects, and especially in the omission of some important portions of his conversation with Mur- rell, and of his reasons for many proceedings that should have been explained to the reader : — but as the only object of that narrative was to arouse the people of that region to a sense of their danger, past and present, he deemed it unnecessary to delay the publication. As an apology for the detention of this work, we would remind the public that Mr. Stewart has been compelled to travel over a vast country in collect- ing his evidence for the compilation. In conclu- sion, we would congratulate those of Mr. Stewart's friends who have nobly stood by him in the hour of danger and persecution, amid a legion of exasper- ated enemies. He has ably sustained himself and his cause, and proved himself worthy of the con- fidence reposed in him by his fellow-citizens. In the compilation of this work the most of Murrell's profanity has been suppressed ; but re- taining his manner of expression in every other particular, and in all cases the substance of his conversation has been preserved. LIFE AND ADVENTURES VIRGIL A. STEWART. A BRIEF history of the early life of Mr. Virgil A. Stewart, whose adventures will form the subject of the following pages, may not here be out of place, not only as a gratification of public curiosity, but as an impor- tant commentary upon the facts to be disclosed in the succeeding narrative ; since, in substantiating the char- acter of Mr. Stewart as a worthy and reputable cit- izen, the reader will be the better enabled to reject the unfounded and malicious imputations attempted to be cast upon him by some of the more daring emissaries of the Murrell gang. Mr. Stewart was born in Jackson county, in the State of Georgia, of highly respectable parentage. His fa- ther, Mr. Samuel Stewart, migrated to Amite county, in Mississippi, while Virgil was yet an infant, and died there a few months after his arrival. His widow, becoming dissatisfied with that part of the country, re- turned to the State of Georgia, where her son Virgil grew up to manhood. He was sent to school until he was fourteen years of age ; but little attention was paid to his pecuniary interests, and a large portion of his slender patrimony was squandered. His early desire was to receive a liberal education ; but the income of his father's estate would not allow of the expenses attendant upon a classical course. 8 Soon after he left school he engaged in the printing business, as an employment best suited to improve his mind. Relinquishing "this, he afterward entered into a copartnership with a manufacturer of cotton-gins, in his native place, with whom he employed his time and a small capital to great advantage. By the time he had reached his twentieth year, he had established a character for industry, decision of character, and much moral worth, among his fellow- citizens. About this time his term of partnership ex- pired by its own limitation, and he determined to travel, and seek a place to settle upon amid the newer regions- of the western country. He concluded upon migrating to Madison county, in Tennessee, whither he removed with his property in the fall of 1830, and settled upon a farm, with his negroes, six miles west of Jackson. Here he remained until the latter part of the year 1832, closely attending to his farm and business, when he concluded to sell off his property, remove to the Choctaw Purchase, and in- vest his whole property in land in that country. Mr. Stewart had now, by industry and economy, in- creased the little estate left him by his father to a re- spectable competency for a young man just starting in life ; with this he made his arrangements for visiting the Choctaw Purchase, and furnished himself with such articles of merchandise as he expected to sell with profit to the Indians and early settlers of that region. On the first day of June, 1833, Mr. Stewart left Jackson in high spirits, on board a boat bound for Tus- cahoma, in the Choctaw Purchase, and arrived at AND ADVENTURES. U Odom's landing, on the Yallabusha river, twelve miles below Tuscahoma, on the third day of July, where the boat was forced to land for want of water. He had a house prepared for the reception of his goods about one mile above the town of Tuscahoma ; but, soon after his arrival, sold off his stock on credit, and began examining the country so as to be prepared to enter land as soon as opportunity should offer, in which labours he was engaged until the Chocchuma land-sales in the same fall. The period of Mr. Stewart's life at which we have now arrived is a point where it becomes necessary to examine with the strictest scrutiny every act, no mat- ter how trivial — and not only is it necessary to notice his acts, but to scan with severity his motives for act- ing. No matter how trifling the circumstances here recorded, they will be found important in the progress of the narrative. While he was attending the land-sales at Chocchu- ma, and awaiting the settlement of his late affairs, a Mr. Clanton, who had established a little country store in the neighbourhood, and with whom he had formerly been slightly acquainted in Tennessee, requested him to take the agency of his business until he could go to Tennessee for his family and return, alleging, as a reason for his request, " that he had been selling goods on credit, and that many of his customers would take advantage of his absence, and leave the country without paying their arrearages, as the greater part of them were strangers of doubtful character." At this time Mr. Stewart was very much occupied with his own affairs ; but, ever ready to accommodate a A3 10 Stewart's life friend, even at his individual inconvenience, he con- sented to take charge of Mr. Clanton's books and busi- ness during his absence. Mr. Clanton then urged him to sleep at his store- house at night, which vrould not interfere with his business, as he could ride to the land-office at Choc- chuma and back very easily in the day ; to this Mr. Stewart consented, provided it would not hinder too much his own affairs. The small quantity of goods and liquors left by Mr. Clanton in possession of Mr. Stewart, amounted to about two hundred and fifty or three hundred dollars. These articles he requested Mr. Stewart to dispose of in any way that might offer, as he expected to be much in want of money on his return. During the six weeks that Mr. Stewart had charge of Mr. Clanton's affairs, he disposed of more than one hundred dollars worth of this property — and as he received the pay for a pint of whiskey or a handkerchief, he deposited the money in the drawer of Mr. Clanton's store. In this small way he took in about ninety dollars, while at the store mornings and evenings, which was never entered upon any book, as there was no cash- book used in the establishment. What few goods he sold for credit were charged upon a day-book as de- livered, and upon this book he opened but one new ac- count, which was against himself for goods delivered to Mr. Elijah Smith, a gentleman who lived near the storehouse, and from whom Mr. Stewart had purchased corn for his horse while at the store, which was gen- erally every night. The two accounts stood open ; as Stewart required corn, he got it from Smith; and as AND ADVENTURES. 11 Smith wanted any thing that he could find among Clan- ton's remnants, he procured it from Stewart, the latter accounting for it by a charge against himself on Mr. Clanton's books. He also took some things for his own use, amounting to five or six dollars, which he paid for and deposited the money in the drawer, with the proceeds of the other cash sales. In the month of January, 1834, Mr. Clanton return- ed from Tennessee with his family. Upon again re- ceiving his affairs from the hands of Mr. Stewart, he expressed the highest satisfaction at the manner in which the latter had taken charge of his business, and as a token of his gratitude presented him with a lot of land in a little town-site that he had laid off for a village where his storehouse stood. He was extremely anxious to form a copartnership with Mr. Stewart ; but the latter, wishing to invest all his capital in land, declined the proposition, but ac- cepted the lot, and promised to build upon it as soon as he should return from a visit to Tennessee, so as to induce others to settle upon the same site ; and he in turn, while absent, left his property in charge of Mr. Clanton. Previous to his departure, Clanton requested that he would have his goods removed to the house of Mr. William Vess, as he had not the room to spare in his own, observing, at the same time, that Vess was a very clever fellow, but that he (Clanton) would see to his property liimself. Accordingly, Mr. Stewart had his property removed ; and leaving all his affairs in the charge of Mr. Clanton, he set out upon his journey on the 18th of January 1834. On the 21st of th. 12 STEWARTS LIFE same month lie reached Madison coimty, in Tennes- see, where lived his old friend and neighbour the Rev- erend John Henning. Soon after his arrival he called on Mr. H., who informed him that he and his son Richard had lost, on the night of the 18th of January, two negro men ; and remarked, that recent develop- ments had attached suspicion upon one John A. Mur- rell, a man of doubtful and suspicious character, who resided in the neighbourhood. He stated, also, that he had learned from one of Murrell's near neighbours (whom he had desired to watch his movements), that he would leave Madison county on the 25th for Ran- dolph, a town on the Mississippi river ; and suggested that, if he had stolen the negroes, his object probably was to proceed to the place of their concealment. Mr. H. solicited Mr. Stewart, who, as the reader has already been told, was on terms of friendship and intimacy with him and his family, to accompany his son Richard in pursuit of Murrell, hoping thereby to obtain some intelligence of the negroes, as it was prob- able that so soon as the excitement occasioned by their abduction, and the suspicion resting upon Murrell, had in a measure subsided, he would take some measures to remove them from the country. Mr. Stewart con- sented, and promised to make every exertion in his power to ferret out the thief and reclaim their prop- erty. Although Mr. Stewart had lived within five miles of Murrell's house a part of the time while he was resident in Tennessee, he had never made his ac- quaintance, nor had he seen him but once : he was then pointed out to him, but at a distance too remote AND ADVENTURES. 13 to enable him to obtain any definite knowledge of his features. Besides, considerable time had since elap- sed, so as to leave him no hope of being able to recog- ► nise him should he be so fortunate as to overtake him. He was therefore obliged to rely on the description given of him by Mr. Henning. Mr. Henning proposed to remunerate him for his services and loss of time ; but, fired with indignation against the perpetrator of such villany, Stewart re- fused any recompense, and professed to desire nothing beyond the gratification of being instrumental in over- taking and bringing the offender to justice. With feelings such as these, and a desire to serve an old and valued friend, he took leave of Mr. H., and pro- ceeded to the house of a Dr. Evans, with the promise to meet Mr. H.'s son at Denmark (a small country^il- lage about four miles distant) at as early an hour on the following morning as their convenience might permit. As much that is set forth in the " Western Land Pirate" has been questioned, we deem it due, both to Mr. S. and the public, to accompany each material statement with a certificate of undoubted authority. As such, we offer the following certificate : — " State of Tennessee, Madison County. " I do hereby certify, to all whom it may concern, that all Virgil A. Stewart has said in the ' Western Land Pirate,' so far as it relates to me and my request, is strictly correct. " Mr. Stewart pursued John A. Murrell by my request ; and I further certify that said Stewart lived in ray im- mediate neighbourhood two years ; and that there was 2 14 STEWART S LIFE no young man who conducted himself more honour- ably, or who deserves the confidence of the public more than Mr. Stewart. " Given under my hand and seal, this 10th day of Oc tober, 1835. [Sealed.] "JOHN HENNING." On the morning of January 26th, 1834, Mr. S. was at Denmark, according to appointment ; but young Henning failed to make his appearance. He remain- ed several hours awaiting the young man's arrival, till at length, becoming impatient, he concluded to prose- cute his journey alone, supposing that his intended companion had been taken ill, as he had left him some- what indisposed when they parted on the preceding evening. He accordingly left Denmark about ten o'clock, A. M., and proceeded on his w^ay to the turnpike at Estanaula, over the Hatchee river, about seven miles distant (this being the only crossing-place in the win- ter season), where he expected to obtain intelligence of Murrell. The weather was unusually cold, and the hard-fro- zen road, much cut up by recent travelling and cover- ed with sleet, considerably retarded his progress. When he reached the toll-house at Estanaula, he inquired of the keeper if Murrell had gone by, and whether his gates might be passed during the night without his knowledge 1 While he was yet conver- sing with him, the keeper turned himself about, and ob- served, " Yonder comes Murrell, now !" Upon look- ing in the direction indicated, Mr. Stewart saw him ; but he was too near to admit of farther conversation AND ADVENTURES. 15 with the keeper. Murrell rode quickly up, paid his toll, and proceeded on his way ; when Stewart renew- ed his conversation with the keeper, and asked if he was satisfied that the individual who had passed was Murrell. The keeper assured him that he was, and added that he knew him well. Upon this Mr. Stew- art paid his toll and proceeded after him. He followed close upon him for a short time, with a vi«w to learn, if possible, to what place he was travelling, without giving Murrell any occasion to suspect his intentions. At length it occurred to him, that, by falling into his company, he might obtain a better idea of his plans and business. He accordingly rode up, and accosted him very respectfully, which was returned with equal ci- vility and address, but with a look of inquiry and scru- tiny that savoured somewhat of embarrassment. The following dialogue ensued : — Stewart. " We have disagreeable travelling, sir." Murrell. " Extremely so, sir." S. " The travelling and my business correspond very well." M. " Pray, sir, what can be your business that you should compare it to travelling on such a road as this ?"