y"v "*^. ^.^ 'P-^ ' '^^ vf ^^^% „» ,-> <;, *'ft€-^x5^» *r>. o " " * '^O ^ ,c^/^^^.^ ^^-V.. .9^. "^. ¥• U A' 1^ »»/•'* •> -i- <^_. v-> v-^ *' -^o ^^ ^° -% ' * /. s • r^^* ^<; ^^'^ ^j^sh: >>' o .1 ', A-*^ <,v V > .0 ^^* » • o. ' ". o ■^- '" ^^ .V.., '^. ' ^^ :. ^,. .^4"^ ,*v,:^-.% '^'^^ .0* 4q. ,•* .0 '%^'-'^-'' .V^' v^ ^: o V ^< -A'^ "-. THE PARSONAGE BETWEEN TWO MANORS REV. JOHN GABRIEL GEBHARD, V. D. M. " Delineavit A. Phillips 1820." THE PARSONAGE BETWEEN TWO MANORS ANNALS OP CLOVER-REACH Elizabeth L. Gebhard BRYAN PRINTING COMPANY HUDSON, N. Y. 1909 COPYRIGHT, 1909 BY ELIZABETH L,. GEBHARD ©CU25i9lG TO MY FATHER CHARI^ES WILLIAM GEBHARD, M. D. WHOSE TAtES OF OI.D CI^AVERACK WERE THE BEST BEI^OVED STORIES OF MY CHILDHOOD FOREWORD It is unusual for one clergyman to serve a congre- gation for fifty years, but it is still more exceptional that those fifty years should have begun contempo- raneously with the birth of a nation, and continued over the first half century of its founding and growth. The position of the church which the Rev. John Gabriel Gebhard served was unique, it being within the bounds of one Manor and almost on the border of a second. The Manor life for a hundred years or more before the Revolution, and for many years after- ward, possessed features, political and social, which give it special interest. The Lower Van Rensselaer Manor at Claverack, and the original Livingston Man- or on its southern boundary, have had few chroniclers outside of magazine articles treating of individual homes or persons. It has been said that we are a generation too late for the Manor stories, but hidden in by-ways, treasured by lovers of the past, to be read between the lines of sober facts and records, are still IX. FOREWORD golden threads of incident and romance, and the aim of the compiler and writer of this volume has been to gather together these tales of a by-gone day, before they have slipped away forever. A net-work of accurate historical fact lies under this story of fifty years of parsonage and Manor life. Beyond that are the stories passed down through pic- tures and letters and family possessions, which be- ing dumb yet speak a language of their own ; and more than all, the stories told at the fire-side, and in the twi- light, and along the country roads, of the men and women and children of the long ago, who were our next of kin, and whose lives bear a special interest for their descendants. There is still one more point which makes the Clav- erack Church and parsonage life important in itself. Though the parish of the Claverack Church covered miles of territory, and though the Church exerted an influence over a wide sweep of country, and was the mother of many churches, its early history is only recorded in its own parchment-bound books of record, for through almost a hundred years of its existence it was an independent organization. FOREWORD It is the hope of the author, that these stories of parsonage and Manors, the sweet and uplifting mem- ories of the past, may be like a cluster of clover-blos- soms from the old homes of Clover-reach, to the men and women of to-day whose ancestors called Claver- ack home. The information contained in this volume has been gathered from many sources, that relating to the Geb- hard family coming through the inheritance of letters and pictures, books and valuable papers, by various descendants of Dr. Gebhard. Thanks are due to Mr. M. D. Raymond for data pertaining to the records of the Collegiate Dutch Reformed Church of New York, and the unpublished correspondence of George Wash- ington ; also to Rev. Herman Hageman, Mrs. Anna Van Rensselaer Barnard, Mrs. Caroline Van Rensse- laer Hall, Mr. Stephen Van Cortlandt Van Rensse- laer, Mrs. Harold Wilson, Mr. R. Fulton Ludlow, Mrs. Arthur T. Sutcliffe, Mrs. Edward Hoffman Lynes, and Miss Georgina Schuyler, through whose generous co-operation, records and stories of the Van Rensselaers, Livingstons, Fultons, and various Clav- erack families have been obtained. zi. FOREWORD The books I have consulted are : Histories of Col- umbia, Greene, and Dutchess Counties; Historical Sketches of Hudson, Documents relating to the Colo- nial History of New York, Ecclesiastical Records of the State of New York, Albany Chronicles, Magazine of American History, Spark's Life of Gouverneur Morris, Bacon's Hudson River from Ocean to Source, Theodore Roosevelt's New York, Memoir of Rev. Richard Sluyter, Life of Washington Irving, Higgin- son's History of the United States, Manual of the Re- formed Church in America, Claverack Old and New, by F. H. Webb; the Claverack Centennial, Documen- tary History of New York, Annals of the Van Rens- selaers, Clarkson's Clermont or Livingston Manor, Church Records of Claverack, Livingston Manor, and the German Reformed Church of New York ; Cata- logue of Washington Seminary, The Posthumous Works of Ann Eliza Bleecker, Some Colonial Home- steads, Catherine Schuyler, by Mary Gay Humph- reys, the Goede Vrouw of Mana-ha-ha, Mrs. Ellet's Women of the Revolution, Sketches of Catskill, and The Early History of Saugerties. CONTENTS I-FROM WALDORF TO ESOPUS Rev. John Gabriel Gebhard, a native of Waldorf, Germany- Sailed for America — Pastor of the Churches of Whitpain and Worcester, Pennsylvania — Married in Philadelphia — Called to tha German Reformed Church of New York — Pronounced patriotic utterances — Driven to Esopus through New York's occupation by the British — Called to Claverack 1 II—CLAVERACKINTHELOWER VAN RENSSELAER MANOR Moving to Claverack — Situation of Church and parsonage — Hendrick Van Rensselaer and the Lower Manor of Rensselaer- wick — Fort Crailo— First settlers of the Lower Manor — Building a Church — Pastorless years — Hendrick Van Rensselaer's death ^Uolonel Johannes Van Rensselaer the Patroon — Erecting Clav- erack into a Manor — Colone' Johannes instrumental in building a second Church — The Dominie— The Dominie's wife ... 8 ///— THE FIRST SER VICE— THE FIRST SUMMER The Church — The " voorleser " — The singing of the Dominie's wife — The sermon — The first baptism — The baptisms and mar- riages which followed — Life in the parsonage 18 IV— WAR STORIES A T HOME Signers of the Declaration of Independence — Committee of Safety — The burning of Kingston and the Livingston houses — General Burgoyne'a surrender — Margaret Livingston's wager— Tradition of Washington's camp — Captain Conyn — The Dominie's patriotic 6«rmon— The killing of John Van Ness 37 XV. CONTENTS V— WASHING TON SEMINAR Y Youths sent to the parsonage for higher education — Records of first years of the Seminary — Old school books — Teachers of Wash- insrton Seminary — Letters of recommendation for students leav- ing Claverack— The educators of the early days of the Republic S5 VI-THE MINISTRY TO THE WILDER- NESS Fear of Indians andl^Tories — An extensive imstorate — Dangerous journeys — Description of Ghent and Schoharie Churches — Bap- tisms and marriages in the wilderness— Judge Brown the " fore- singer " — Courage in all walks of life 48 VII— WAR HEROES OF THE MANORS AND THE IN A UG URA TION OF GEORGE WASHINGTON Public appeal for funds from Governor Clinton— Colonel Jeremiah Hogeboom's regiment — Captain John McKinstry's narrow escape from death by torture — Captain Brant's visit to the Free Masons of Hudson — The Tories imprisoned in a cellar — Brigadier-General Henry B. Livingston and the capture of Andre — Marriage of Richard Montgomery and Janet Livingston— Death of General Montgomery — Surrender of Comwallis — Treaty of Peace with England — The Morrises and the celebration on "Bob Hill" — Dominie Gebhard's letter to Washington— Inaiiguration of George Washington 66 VIII— THE MANORS ON EITHER SIDE Colonel Johannes Van Rensselaer's visits to Claverack— First Manor House in Claverack — Colonel Robert Rutsen Van Rensse- laer's home — Henry I. Van Rensselaer's home — The Mills on the Manors— The quit-rent for the Patroon's domain— Killian Van Rensselaer — Leases of land— Rent days — Angelica Livingston, Colonel Johannes Van Rensselaer's wife — Chancellor Livingston's ', home at Clermont— Last Lord reigning on the Livingston Manor — Homes of the Livingston Manor 67 XVI. CONTENTS IX— LIFE ON THE MANORS »•*« Continuous building — Stocking the farm — Docks and sloops — Many exports and imports — Guests of the Manors — Costly plate and rich furnishing — Scripture tiles — Lady of the Manor — Alter- nate residence in ciiy and country 7T X— VISITING SPONSORS Sailing "ventures" — Travelers by stage — Catherine Schuyler as sponsor — Parsonage relatives from Philadelphia — John Barker Church and Angelica Schuyler as sponsors — Baptism spoons . 8S XI-STORIES OF THE POST ROAD Montgomery Place — Edward Livingston — Burning of Livingston homes — Brave Margaret Beekman — The " Hermitage " — " Teviot- dale " — Original Livingston Manor House — Its children and grandchildren — The Palatines — Flower-lined roads to Claverack 92 XII- VISITSFROM JOHN JACOB ASTOR Dominie Gebhard recalled to the New York Church — The call declined — Tablet to Baron Steuben — Letter from Germany — John Jacob Astor's visits to Claverack — His start in the fur business- Tales of journeys after pelts^History of his early life — Voyage to America — A member of the Consistory of the German Reformed Church of New York . 100 XIII-CHURCH CUSTOMS ONE HUN- DRED YEARS AGO Record Books of the Claverack Church— Building the Church — Renting seats— Minister's salaries — Dominie Gebhard preaches in throe languages — A divided Church united — Lists of members- Election of Consistory— Baptisms through the week— William Van Ness leader of singing— Church heating— Ministerial calls 112 XIV- LIFE A T THE PARSONAGE Time after 1800— Letter from Jacob Gebhard— The Dominie's daughter— Samplers— The parsonage parlor— Boy's work— Sun- day morning at the parsonage— The slaves in the congregation 121 XVII. CONTENTS XV— LOVER'S LANES AND PARSON- AGE WEDDINGS Sunday afternoon marriages— Refractory brides— China seta as grifts- Hudson Assemblies— The race on General Training Day 131 XVI— DIVIDING THE MANORS AND THE CLA VERA CK COURT HOUSE Columbia County— Dividing the Lower Van Rensselaer Manor- Dividing Livingston Manor— Trials held in tlie Claverack Court House— Alexander Hamilton at Claverack — His first speech in New York— Aaron Burr at Claverack— After occupants of the Court House 138 XVII— HOMES OE THE LOWER VAN RENSSELAER MANOR AT CLAVERACK Intermarriages with colonial families— Visiting relatives during the war— Family treasures buried at Greenbush— Furnishings of the homes of the Lower Van Rensselaer Manor— China and silver —Adam and Eve table-cloth— Family gatherings— Manor funer- als 147 XVIII— THE SCHUYLER ROMANCES Homes of Catherine Schuyler's girlhood — Description of Mrs. Philip Schuyler— Schuyler Bible records— Nursing during the war— Building the Schuyler Mansion— Visits to Claverack of the Schuyler boys and girls- Schuyler elopements— Letter of Ann Eliza Bleecker 169 XIX— ANTI-RENT TROUBLES Troubles over payment of rent— Boundary line between New York and Massachusetts— Lords of Livingston and Van Rensselaer Manors threatened— Boundary line settled— Sheriff Cornelius Hogeboom shot by Anti-rent leader— Uprising of 1840- "Big Thunder "and " Little Thunder " arrested— Victory of the Anti- renters under leadership of Governor Young in 1852— War of 1812 171 XVIII. CONTENTS XX— THE NE W C/T} ' OE HUDSON Presidential Electors at Hudson 1796-1813— Hudson became a city in 1785— Owned many vessels— Shipyards— Exports and imports- Contributions to useful arts— John Jay's visit to Hudson— Death of General Washington 182 XXI— THE MARRIAGE OE ALEXAN- DER HA MIL TON AND ELIZA- BETH SCHUYLER Claverack wedding outfits— Tories and Indians attack General Schuyler's house at Albany— Rescue of baby— Marriage of Alex- ander Hamilton and Elizabeth Schuyler— Child of Philip Jeremiah Schuyler brought t, Claverack for baptism— Return of children to old Claverack homes— Dutch toys 189 XXII— ROBERT EULTON AND THE EIRST STEAMBOA T Robert Fulton and Chancellor Livingston— First trip of the Cler- mont— Invited guests— Astonishment of sailors— Announcements of Chancellor Livingston— Youngest passenger aboard— Time from New York to Albany— First voyage with passengers— Thur- low Weed on Bompie's Hook— Rebuilding Clermont— The "North River "—Robert Fulton's marriage to Miss Harriet Livingston- Fulton's home— His art— His death— His wife's death , . . 196 XXIII— THE LEGEND OE^'SPOOK ROCK'' Hudson marriages at the Claverack Parsonage— Changes in the parsonage family— Marriages of sons and daughters— The Ghent Church— The Hogeboom Bible— Claverack Church independent — Methods of raising Church support — Parents sponsors in baptism —No death records— Legend of "Spook Rock" .... 210 XXIV- HIS ''HUIS VROUWE" The Dominie's wife— The tailoress and the shoemaker — New Year's day and St. Nicholas — Paas and Paas cakes — Nursing the sick — Philadelphia wives — The first linen-damask — City philan- thropy and country neighborliness 221 XIX. CONTENTS PAca XXV— CALLING AN ENGLISH COL- LEAGUE Change of language among the Claverack people — Calling an English associate — The Claverack Church joins the Classis of Rensselaer and Synod of the Reformed Dutch Church — Rev. Mr. Sluyter accepts call to Claverack — Dutch call remains un- altered — Dominie Gebhard's sons — Painting of the 17th Congress — Divided ministerial labors — Grandchildren at the parsonage- Monday mo)-ning ministerial meetings 229 XXVI— THE EIRST ROBERT LIVING- STONS CHILDREN AND GRANDCHILDREN Diary describing the upper Hudson in 1769 — Price paid Indians for Livingston Manor — Size of Grant— Boundaries — First Lord of the Manor — Building a Church— Livingston family at the Manor — Manor Houses — The second Lord of the Manor and his children — The third Lord of the Manor — Visiting relatives — Gover- nor William Livingston of New Jersey and his daughters — Liberty Hall— Letters from Miss Kitty Livingston — Order from Nantes— General Washington's letter to Miss Kitty Livingston- Livingston Manor Houses— Marriage of John Livingston and Mrs. Catherine Ridley 236 XX VII— MANOR JUNKETINGS Building of Oak Hill — Furnishings of Livingston homes — Pen por- trait of John Livingston — Winter on the Manor— Sloop journeys — Washington Irving's visit to Livingston Manor— '' Widow Mary " Livingston — The " Widow Mary's " snap dragon and Colonel Henry I. Van Rensselaer's buggy— Livingston funerals— Livingstons who belonged to the first fifty years of the Republic .... 257 XXVIII-.CHANCELLOR LIVINGSTON Chancellor Livingston's marriage— Offices held— State Convention to consider Constitution— Rejoicing over the ratification of New York— Constitution drafted by Alexander Hamilton— Illumination of Schuyler mansion— Chancellor Livingston appointed ambassa- dor to France— Negotiated purchase of Louisiana— Partnership with Robert Fulton in the Clermont— Chancellor Livingston's country life— Death 268 XX. CONTENTS PAGB XXIX-EARLY RESIDENTS OF CLA V- ERACK The Ludlows-Old portraits— The Mulders and the Court Martial House-The Miller store— The family of Killian Hogeboom- Daughter married General Samuel Webb— Old Webb house—" The Night Before Christmas "—The Esselstyn family-The Van . Nesses- Samuel Ten Broeck and Maria Van Rensselaer and the first Manor House— Fitz Muzigh of Livingston— Tobias Van Deu- sen and his son James— Intermarriages between Dutch and Quakers— The women of Claverack— Dominie Gebhard's life in Claverack 274 XXX-MONTGOMERY, LAFA YET T E, AND THE ERIE CANAL Removing General Montgomery's body to New York— His monu- ment—Visit of Lafayette— Entertainment at Clermont— At Hud- son—Governor Clinton and the Erie Canal— Its opening — Its success 288 XXXI-SHADOWS ACROSS THE SUN- SHINE The Dominie'8 youngest daughter— Her engagement— The lost gold piece— Her death 298 XXXII— THE CRO WN OF LIFE President John Adams' call to fasting and prayei^Governor Clinton's first proclamation for the observance of a public thanks- giving—Withdrawal of Hillsdale from the Claverack Church- Resignation of Dominie Gebhard— Final baptisms and marriages- Dr. Currie's description of Dominie Gebhard's last Church ser- vice — Death of Dominie Gebhard— Numbers of those baptized and married — Records in family Bibles 302 XXXIII~IN BLOSSOM TIME Mr. Richard Morse's visit to Claverack— Interest in the old Dom- inie's library— Meeting with the Dominie's granddaughter — Engagement — Marriage 308 XXI. LIST OF ILLUSTRATIONS PAGB Rev. John Gabriel Gebhard, V. D. M Frontispiece University of Utrecht — An Unchanged Corner .... 4 Crailo 10 Court Martial House 28 Claverack College 44 Old Church and Parsonage and Washington Seminary . 52 Schoharie Church 52 First Van Rensselaer Manor House in Claverack ... 68 Catherine Van Rensselaer Schuyler 86 Van Ness-Livingston House 116 Claverack Church — " Van Rensselaer Kirk " 128 Court House 140 Jacob Rutsen Van Rensselaer Manor House 148 Henry I. Van Rensselaer Manor House 164 The " Widow Mary " Livingston Manor House .... 164 "Spook Rock" 216 Mrs. John Gabriel Gebhard— The Dominie's Wife ... 220 Robert Livingston, 3rd Lord of Livingston Manor . • . 246 Chancellor Livingston's Home 262 Margaret Beekman Livingston Manor House 262 Ludlow Mansion 274 James Watson Webb's Birthplace • . 278 Bay House 298 Mrs. Richard C. Morse, and Two of Her Children . . , 308 XXIII. The Parsonage Between Two Manors. CHAPTER I. FROM WALDORF TO ESOPUS. In one of the colonial houses of Esopus, sat a young clergyman in his middle twenties, with his face bowed in his hands in deep thought. The question before him was a momentous one. Five years before he had left his native home in Waldorf, Germany, and started as many of the young men in that day did, for the new land of opportunity across the sea. It was the eventful year of 1776, and Esopus (Kings- ton) was full of refugees from New York, which city being invested by the British, many of her residents had fled to the smaller towns and villages further up the Hudson, that they might at least find safety for their families in the dangers which threatened. In the X 2 THE PARSONAGE BETWEEN TWO MANORS. fatherland young John Gabriel Gebhard had been trained for his life work in the best educational insti- tutions of the day. He had received his earlier uni- versity education at Heidelberg, and after a further course of theological study at Utrecht, had been li- censed to preach by the Refomed Church of Holland. A son of a minister of the Gospel, it would seem that he brought with him to America special fitness for his calling, and a pfomise of good things to come. In the five years that he had been on American shores, this was the second time he had been called to change his home, and this time he had a wife still under twenty, and two small children to consider. The young clergyman, after his month-long voyage froiri Germany, during which storms had swept the little vessel into the hollows of the sea and upon the crests of the billows, washed her decks, and even found the freight and luggage stored away in cabins and holds of the ship, at last landed, it is believed, at Philadelphia. For three years he had served the two congregations of Whitpain and Worcester, among the German portion of the population of Montgomery county, Pennsylvania. Here in the first year of his 2 FROM WALDORF TO ESOPUS. pastorate, he met and loved Anna Maria Magdalene Carver, a descendant of some of the early settlers of Philadelphia. She was a charming girl of fifteen, and the customs of the time tending toward early matur- ity, in June of the following year they were married. Succeeding years proved the choice of the girl wife to have been one of the wisest steps of the young man's life. They had been married only a year when a call came to Mr. Gebhard to become the pastor of the German Reformed Church of New York. This church had been formed a few years earlier from a small body of the German-speaking members of the Collegiate Reformed Dutch Church in Nassau St., who wished to hear the Gospel preached in the High-Dutch tongue with which they were familiar. In this desire they had the full consent of the mother church. Indeed she ever gave her offspring a fostering care, the pastors of the German Church meeting in consistorial and classical gatherings with the ministers of the Collegiate Church, and being installed by the ministers of the older or- ganization ; while the members who had gone out to form the new church, also showed their attachment for 3 THE PARSONAGE BETWEEN TWO MANORS. their previous place of worship, by requesting the privilege of returning to the old fold in case their enterprise should fail, and to be allowed to bury their dead with the Collegiate Church as formerly. The call to the New York church had been accepted, and the young couple had taken up their abode in the city, the German Church being situated at that time in Nassau St. between John St. and Maiden Lane. Here two boys, Jacob and Philip, came to bless the minister's home, and the two years of his pastorate were full of activity in the growing town and congregation, and rich in friendships with men who like himself had left their old home and friends, to make a new home and life on American shores. Rev. Frederick Muhlenberg was at this time in charge of the only German Luth- eran Church in the city, and the two young clergymen were fast friends. Later Mr. Gebhard named a third son for the friend from whom he was parted when New York became no longer a safe place of residence for either of them, for both were patriotic and devoted already to this new country for which they had dared so much. Neither of them was bound by ties of kin- dred to the British, who claimed the righi of taxing 4 THE UNIVERSITY OF UTRECHT A corner which has remaine