■At /Us i 2830 16 py 1 t/ SCHOOL ACCOUNTING A Practical Bookkeeping System for a Small City By J. A. ALLEN Business Director of the Board of Education Terre Haute, Ind. Reprinted from The American School Board Journal cTWilwaukee, Wis. Copyright 1913, By Wm. Geo. Bruce EIREB FRO] 3FY3JQHT MAY 3 1915 School Accounting An authority says: "An account is a state- ment in general of reasons, causes, grounds, etc., explanatory to some event; a statement of facts or occurrences." But, the definition of more importance to one concerned in the keeping of accounts is the definition that "An account is a statement, an explanation or vindication of one's conduct with reference to judgment there- on." In the keeping of accounts, as in everything else, we should work with a clearly defined object in view. An account is a record of trans- actions with persons, property or things ar- ranged to show a definite result. The results are the things we are interested in. If an ac- count is a record of transactions with persons, property or things arranged to show a definite result, the definite result shown may be juggled to express what is in the mind of the one keep- ing the account. This emphasizes the impor- tance of system. Objections are often made to some systems that the least variation in the manner of carrying them out causes confusion. This is one of the strongest arguments in favor of system ; the more difficult it may be to depart from the regular routine of carrying it out makes it imperative that, once a system is in- stalled, it be carried along without deviation. Some of the best accountants are men who have learned their lesson from actual experience. It is undoubtedly true that a knowledge of fundamental principles of accounting science is indispensable in the creation of thorough sys- tem. Practical experience, thorough analysis of conditions and clear perception of what is most essential in the business, and a clear under- standing of what the final result should be are equally important. Especial Problems of School Accounting. School accounting in its nature is peculiar. Many conditions surround the question of ac- counting in the schools that do not occur in a private corporation. Each fund must be used only for the purpose provided by law. One fund may be used for a number of purposes, while another may be for a specific purpose only. The idea that one must merely be a bookkeeper to step into an office and systematize the work is an erroneous one; a fair knowledge of exist- ing conditions is necessary. This is true in the management of any office. When a business man requires the services of an accountant, it is seldom, indeed, that an outsider is brought in to take the management of the office. Usu- ally we find the head of the department is one who has grown into the business, ofttimes start- ing from the bottom and thereby gaining a thorough knowledge of the work. "Make haste slowly" certainly applies with peculiar empha- sis in departing from established office methods to the establishment of a new system. In attempting to reconstruct the accounting department of any office, and particularly a school office, it is absolutely necessary that one should thoroughly understand all the conditions surrounding the work before an attempt is made to change the form of accounting. Certain fun- damental principles may be insisted upon from the start, but it is a grave error to try to ac- complish the task of establishing an entirely new system in a short time; to do so causes confusion, waste of energy and additional ex- penses brought about by the use of books, forms, etc., which later experience will prove to be in- adequate for the purpose for which they were intended. School accounting embraces more than the mere keeping of accounts, ranging from the or- ganization of the working forces, outside of the office, the buying and selling to departments, to the management of the accounting. A study of the systems in vogue in a number of public offices discloses the fact that the sys- tems of the business offices differ very greatly. In fact, it is hard to find two cities using two systems that are at all similar, except as to fun- damental principles. Being more familiar with the system in use in the schools of Terre Haute, the writer will endeavor to give as clearly as possible a brief outline of the work as now car- ried on. Importance of Accounting. The principle which the managers in the business offices of schools should keep before them at all times, is that they occupy a posi- tion between the board and the public; their conduct and manner of performing their duties are often responsible for the standing of the board members with the public. The manage- ment of the financial department of a school is either a protection or a menace to the board of control. We should keep in mind that the Board of Trustees is legally responsible for the acts of those intrusted with the work. It should also be borne in mind that the reputation of the one placed in charge of the accounting de- partment is at stake. We not only should be careful in the keeping of accounts, but should be able at all times to prove the correctness of them. Probably more difficulties are brought about through carelessness and through the inability of the accountants to prove what they have done than from any other cause. This being true, it is very important that the work not only be carefully done, but that it be performed in such a manner that we are able to prove beyond a doubt, at all times, that what has been done is correct. We should have a thorough understanding of the system so as to be able to prove beyond a doubt each step in all transactions. If pos- sible, copies of the original entries should be in the "Minutes" of the board. If this is done, it places the responsibility entirely with the board of trustees who approve the minutes. It is of the utmost importance that all matters pertain- ing to the receipts and expenditures be brought before the Board of Trustees for its approval. It would cause delay and would not be at all practical for the board to pass on all expendi- tures for repairs, supplies, etc., prior to each transaction. But reports should be presented to them for their consideration at regular per- iods, the same to include a report of all work of any description, all receipts and expenditures and this should be made a part of the perma- nent record of the board. As an additional pre- caution, the board should be asked to scrutinize their "Minutes" very closely. We find it a good plan to make carbon copies of the minutes for each member of the board. This enables them to look over the record and suggest any changes they desire. The "Exhibit Ledger". Journals and Ledgers are rapidly giving way to the "Exhibit Ledger." With an Exhibit Ledger, a simpler exhibit of all accounts can be made. An Exhibit Ledger especially con- structed for the work in school accounting is one which shows the warrant number, the name of the payee, the invoice number and the total amount of the warrant in the order named. This gives us the first division of the ledger. Next in order, reading from left to right as before, should follow the different funds, such as library fund, tuition fund, sinking fund, etc. To the right of this section should be a column in which to show the balance of all funds. The third section should show such ac- counts as supplies, repairs, printing, lights, tele- phone, coal, etc. The head of these accounts, beside showing the name of the account, should be numbered consecutively. It is advisable in making an Exhibit Ledger of this kind to have quite a number of blank columns, to the right of the regular printed accounts, to take care of any emergency that may arise. To the right of these accounts should be columns headed with the name or number of the school buildings, and between each column, a smaller column with the heading "Account Number". In the third section it was explained that the different accounts should be numbered. By having an account number column in the fourth section it is easy to check backward and forward. It is often said that a system of accounting adapted to the needs of a small office is im- practicable in a large one. This is, in a great measure, untrue, especially when Exhibit Led- gers are used. The Exhibit Ledger here de- scribed can be used in a city of 5,000 popula- tion and is equally as valuable in a city of 200,000. Consider the advantages of having in one book a true exhibit of all the business. Take into consideration the time saved and the fact that the task of getting a trial balance at the end of the month is no longer the nightmare of your office. There is not an hour in the day that you are not preparing your trial balance with the use of the Exhibit Ledger, such as here described. First, you have the total amount of the warrant drawn, next the fund from which it is paid. These two sets of columns must bal- ance. The next distribution is to the different accounts. The total of this set of columns must balance with the fund columns and total of warrant columns. The next distribution is to charge the different items of expense to the department or school for which the money is spent. The total of these columns must bal- ance with the total of the account columns, and balance with the account of the fund columns and with the total amount of the warrant col- umn. The totals of all columns should be car- ried forward. At the end of the calendar month you have before you an exhibit of the work, which with the use of a regular journal and of ledger accounts, would take considerable time to obtain. Additional Uses of Ledger. An Exhibit Ledger can be made to add to its usefulness by using the same blanks before described. Enter the month in the date column, and in the total amount of warrant column enter the expenditure for the month; in the fund columns, show the total expenditure from each fund; at the right of the fund columns enter your balances; under the different accounts, such as supplies, repairs, etc., as before enum- erated, enter the amount chargeable to these accounts, and further extend the work by show- ing the distribution of expenditures to the de- partments, schools, etc. At the end of the year you have a true exhibit of the receipts and ex- penditures, to whom paid, the cost of main- tenance, supplies, etc., and the cost of main- taining each department, without additional work. The laws of Indiana provide that all public offices receiving and disbursing public funds shall keep a book which shall show the name of the payee, from what fund payment is made, and daily balances. If an Exhibit Ledger, such as before described, is used, it meets the re- quirements of the law and no additional book is necessary. One of the columns in the exhibit ledger is described as the invoice column. This is found to be of great assistance in tracing an invoice. If invoice books are used, the invoices are num- bered consecutively and the number of the in- voice is carried to the column in the exhibit ledger. It is easy then to refer to the Exhibit Ledger for any invoice by linding the number and then finding the corresponding number in the "Invoice Book". A still further check may be had by making extensions in the invoice book and taking the total at the end of the month, which added to the payrolls which are usually kept in the invoice book, will give the total amount of the expenditures for the month, and must balance with the total expenditures shown by the Exhibit Ledger. Buying School Supplies. Particular care should be taken in ordering goods and vouchering. Goods should be bought only on an order issued from the office and a duplicate of the order should be retained. Some offices go farther than this and make out all orders in triplicate and quadruplicate. This is only necessary in securing the vouchers from the different departments showing the transac- tion. First, the placing of the order, second, the receipt of the goods, third, a voucher as to quality, fourth, a voucher as to entry in the "Stock Book" of the goods received. A more simple plan, and entirely satisfactory with us, is to make the orders in duplicate, one to be sent to the merchant and the other to be re- tained in the office. When the goods are re- ceived they should be entered into the stock book kept for the purpose, showing the firm making the delivery and the amount of material delivered. The merchants should be required to return the order to the business office along with their invoice. This should go first to the stock -keeper, who vouchers it, then to the per- son in charge of prices, etc., who vouchers it, and then to the bookkeeper. When the invoice and original order is received from the mer- chant, the original order should be compared with the duplicate order retained in the office. These duplicate orders are valuable in obtain- Fig. Al— Page A. Fig. A2— Page B. Fig. A6— Page F. Exhibit Ledger Form Used in t Fig. 1. A 1-2-3-4-5-6 represents a siDgle "page" of the "Exhibit Ledger'' used, in the Terre Haute schools. Each warrant entered on Page A is distributed to respective account anc 6 t [ te" .«.,,, -sr? »«..., | «„., "K7 1 A sr "sr? 1 «"» sr .« T « *nTis' w *£»' nTm »- [»"•»-» ™„ Rc«. S K* «* ri £-,■ p i™°"' F °Sd™ -* ^ «- "3" - - »— SK — "sac N J. - Fig. A3— Page C. Fig A5— Page E. ■rre Haute, Ind., Public Schools. chool so that the total outlay for each can be seen at a glance. The "ledger" permits of keep- ag the books posted up at all times so that an accurate trial balance may be taken when desired. 7 ing former prices, etc. If invoice books are not used, a still better system is to have a single sheet which should provide a space for the vouchering, and after the proper vouchers have been obtained the invoice should be attached to this sheet. The sheet should be of proper size to fold neatly to a convenient size of about 3x8 inches. These invoices and voucher sheets are then filed and after receiving the return war- rant from the bank, the cancelled warrant should be attached to the voucher sheet and invoice. This gives a complete explanation of the transaction, provided the plan of obtaining the board's approval of the different steps has been secured. Discounting Bills. A custom in most cities, which should be abandoned, is that of paying bills at stated periods. No business house would try to en- force such a rule as this. To do so means the loss of considerable money as it is impossible to take advantage of the discounts usually offered. By all means, bills should be paid as they fall due. To do this, it is advisable to have an auditing committee consisting of one mem- ber of the board. This will not work a hard- ship on the board from the fact that it is sel- dom necessary for the auditing committee to meet more than twice a week to pass on the bills before they are paid. By having but one member of the board on the auditing commit- tee, the work can be divided among the different board members so as not to prove burdensome. An objection is sometimes made to this plan from the fact that it is necessary to give the bead of the department of accounting a number of warrants signed in blank. To overcome tbis, the one in charge of the accounting department should be under heavy bond, and the secretary and treasurer should limit the number of war- rants to the number that would probably be needed. These warrants should be listed by number, and when used a report should be made to the auditing committee showing the number used and the number remaining on hand. This together with all invoices and a report showing the complete transaction, should be placed be- fore the auditing committee when his voucher is secured. This completed exhibit should then be presented to the board at its next meeting for approval. Monthly Statements. Often one of the difficulties of the school boards is that they do not at all times know exactly where they stand as to finances, the probable amount of expenditures for a given period, and the receipts for the year. To over- come this, it is a good plan to call a meeting of the board just before the beginning of the fiscal year to define a policy for the coming year and to make appropriations to each de- partment and to each account. If this is done, the first entry in the exhibit ledger should be the appropriations filled in at the head of the column with red ink. At the end of the month, two statements should be prepared for the board and a copy delivered to each member. First should be the financial statement showing the receipts and disbursements for the preceding month, the balance at the beginning of the month, the bal- ance in the different funds at the close of the month, and the balance of all funds. The sec- ond report should show the cost of operation for the past month. It is possible to prepare a report of this nature if careful attention is given to details, without making it too large or bulky. It can be prepared to show a true exhibit and condition of the business at a glance. The report should be ruled to admit all the names of the schools or departments in the first column to the left, commencing at the top TERRE HAUTE PUBLIC SCHOOLS Receipts and Disbursements for the Month of 191 T— | —--;;" ^xnvss \ —>™. 1 »i?' ij r. !.,,.„ t l '\\_ Fig. C. Monthly Report Form for Receipts and Disbursements. working to the bottom of the page. The dif- ferent account heads should be in the columns standing full length of the sheet. If this is done it is easy to obtain a complete review of the work for the preceding month. To prepare these reports let us suppose that the schools instead of being named are numbered. On the first horizontal line will appear school number one; second, school number two and so on down the page until all the schools are enumerated. In the columns at the top should appear such items as supplies, books, repairs, heat, light, telephones, etc. The total of the figures read- ing from left to right of the school numbers will give the cost of operation for that particu- lar school for the month. The total of entries under any particular account-column will show the cost of the account for the month. The total of the extensions at the extreme right of the school number will give the cost of opera- tion for the month. Filing Papers. Particular attention should be given to the filing of all papers coming into the possession of the business office. A very successful plan with us has been to open a "Document Book" wherein are recorded all papers filed, except such papers as come before the board and are kept with the proceedings of the board. These papers are filed alphabetically. Instead of re- ferring to the different files and searching through a number of papers for the one wanted, we first consult our document book. Suppose the paper wanted to be a notice of "Street Im- provement concerning the Deming School." In our document book, under the D's, is entered "Notice Street Improvement" file 16. This system of keeping a record of all documents filed is as essential in a small office as in a large one. We should not lose sight of the fact that in our attempt to eliminate details to a minimum, with the use of the Exhibit Ledger, that a num- ber of supplementary books must be kept. A cash book, of course, is indispensable. In con- nection with the cash book should be used a receipt book. All moneys received by the office should be receipted for and the stubs retained. These stubs assume vast importance at times, especially when your office is undergoing an investigation by the state department. Teachers' Payrolls. One phase of the work that has proven a source of worry and dissatisfaction has been the different methods of meeting the monthly payrolls. This matter is not of as much impor- tance in a small place where there is from ten to forty persons to be paid, but when the num- ber of persons increases to three or four hun- dred, it becomes a different problem. Our meth- od of handling this matter has proven very satisfactory and has been approved by the state department having charge of all public offices. We prepare a payroll with the heading of "Re- ceipt" at the top of the sheet. To the left is the name of the employee; set opposite each name to the right is the amount due each per- son. This payroll is then sent to the bank with a check to cover the full amount of the pay- roll. Each employee calls at the bank and re- ceipts for the amount specified in the payroll. But one objection has been offered to this plan, namely, that no bank can be found that cares to do this work. An investigation, however, will undoubtedly disclose the fact that the banks are willing to do the work for the additional business and prestige it gives them. However, if it should be found that no bank cares to handle the payrolls in this manner, it is pos- sible for the business office to make payments, drawing a warrant for the full amount and placing the respective sums in an envelope to be given to the employee when the payroll is signed. This eliminates the stupendous task of drawing a warrant for each individual, and mistakes are reduced to a minimum, for the reason, that if warrants are used, the name of each payee, with the amount paid to them, must be copied from the warrant into the proper book. With the use of the above payroll plan but one entry is necessary. Probably in the following order: Teachers $31,000.00, distributed to the following schools, and only the totals of the different sums paid to the teachers of any one school must be entered. This system of meeting the payrolls saves time and work. It is accurate and far less subject to juggling than is the plan of issuing a warrant to each individ- ual employee. Distributing Supplies. As the business offices are in charge of work other than the accounting, careful attention should be given to all the different departments. The question of supplies offers a loop-hole for innumerable leaks. Leaks in any system should be sought for, and when discovered should be remedied at once. There is probably more chance for leaks in furnishing supplies than in any other department. To control this, all sup- plies should be entered in a "Supply Book" im- mediately upon receipt of the goods. Further- more, each school and department should have a separate account showing the amount of sup- plies furnished them. Before any goods are delivered to any department or school, a requisi- tion from someone authorized to make it should be in the hands of the business office. Suppose the requisition is to come from the Deming School and calls for chalk, pencils, ink, etc. In our stock-book we would turn to the Deming School account. This stock-book is ruled to provide a certain number of deliveries each month. We find that in the preceding months, among other things, the Deming School has been supplied with chalk, penci.s, ink, etc. All that is necessary then, is to enter in the proper column of the present month, the amount of each item to be delivered. At the end of the year the totals of the different columns will give the total amount of each article delivered. The total of each separate column for each school or department will give the total amount of any particular item delivered for the year. At the end of the fiscal year the total of the inventory, which should be taken at the beginning of the inventory, plus the amount bought, less the amount supplied to the different departments or schools, should give the correct inventory for the commencement of the next year. Handling Labor. Quite frequently a number of men, employed by the day or month, as the case may be, are under the charge of the business office. As it is impossible to personally superintend all the work, such as electrical work, carpenter work, minor repairs, plumbing, etc., it is necessary that some system be devised whereby the office may check up on all work done. To do this we use a time card showing first, the name of the person doing the work, second, the place where the work was done, third, the place where the worker left to go to the place where the work is to be done, fourth, the time it takes to go, from the place the worker starts, to the place where he does the work, and fifth, the amount of time it takes to do the work, and tools broken on the job. If some supplies are required to do the job the order must come from the business office and go to the stock room and the goods de- livered to the one doing the work. Whatever may be the system of accounting it should be carried out faithfully; if this were done there would be fewer defalcations. There is no way in which dishonesty can be practiced without detection, it cannot be covered up by manipulating the accounts. Loose, indifferent methods makes the one keeping them liable to suspicion and so I wish to emphasize the im- portance of keeping them properly. Do not be lazy but insist on each day's work being per- formed at the proper time. Laziness rather than incompetency is the cause of disorder in public offices. Do not be afraid of work, give full measure and insist on all in the department doing the same. Do not depend on the bank to keep the bank account ; require them to balance the bank books at the end of each month and keep a list of un- paid accounts. By doing this any discrepancy between office accounts and the bank account can be discovered at once and corrected. It has been my purpose in this article to show the value of Exhibit Ledgers in school accounting and to emphasize the value of the personality of a school accountant in relation to such work; his keen sense of order and sys- tem; his sound business judgment and tact; his power of initiative and fibre of completeness constitute an accounting system of value. 10 LIBRARY OF CONGRESS ■If 021 324 889 3