A A PV m \ YTVAL Edwat Mnun cc. LIBRARY OF CONGRESS. Shelf -3?* A UNITED STATES OF AMERICA. /x? m rr<*is. N THK SUPREMACY SPIRITUAL. CLOU EDWARD RANDALL KNOWLES, LL. D. - ^\ Copyrighted 1895. E. R. Knowles, LL. D. All rights reserved. THE SUPREMACY OF THE SPIRITUAL TT7HE further and more logically scien- tists proceed with the question of the one only absolute reality, the closer they approach to the full acceptance of the conclusions which I have for years advocated concerning the absolute supremacy of the spiritual. A striking example of this is to be found in Doctor Thornton's " Philosophy of the Three Ethers." The first, which he identifies with Life, affords the potentialities of the other two. All other theories call to their aid self-contradictory propositions, absurd ideas or vague theories, which would 2 THE SUPREMACY need greater ingenuity to substantiate them, even were they capable of proof, than the clear and simple truth of the One Substance, the onty Life, Spirit and Power in absolute existence. "We feel but the pulse of that viewless Hand Which has ever been and still shall be, In the stellar orb and the grain of sand, Through nature's endless paternity." So much has been written, and so ably, upon this subject, that I should be indisposed to venture upon this field of discussion were it not for the fact that I may be able, in my imperfect way, to offer some suggestions which are new and original, and which, I am convinced, are absolutely true and perfectly logical and clear. Scientists assume the being and action of a substance, omnipresent throughout infinite space, which com- OF THE SPIRITUAL. 3 municates light, heat, electricity and gravitation from one body to another, and even mental emotion and imaginary ideas from one mind to another. This omnipresent medium they call " the ether," attributing to it, in the case of some phenomena, qualities utterly in- compatible with those which they are compelled to assign to it in the examin- ation of other phenomena. An omni- present substance of some kind, how- ever, is a necessary inference from the following facts : — The planets attract each other, and are all attracted by the sun. It is generally agreed that the atmos- phere does not, in its most attenuated degree, extend more than three hundred miles beyond the earth's surface. Heat, light, electricity, magnetism and gravitation operate in an exhausted receiver just as well as elsewhere. 4 THE SUPREMACY One mind sometimes influences another independently of ordinary sen- sation or muscular motion, without con- tact or perceptible connection. Says Professor Tyndall : "The domain in which this motion of light is carried on lies entirely beyond the reach of our senses. The waves of light require a medium for their forma- tion and propagation, but we cannot see or feel or taste or smell this medium. How, then, has its existence been estab- lished? By showing that by the assumption of this wonderful intangible ether all the phenomena of optics are accounted for with a fulness and clear- ness and conclusiveness which leave no desire of the intellect unfulfilled. When the law of gravitation first sug- gested itself to the mind of Newton, what did he do? He set himself to examine whether it accounted for all OF THE SPIRITUAL. 5 the facts. He determined the courses of the planets ; he calculated the rapidity of the moon's fall toward the earth ; he considered the precession of the equinoxes, the ebb and flow of the tides, and found all explained by the law of gravitation. He, therefore, re- garded this law as established, and the verdict of science subsequently con- firmed his conclusion. On similar, and if possible, on stronger grounds, we found our belief in the existence of the universal ether. It explains facts far more various and complicated than those on which Newton based his law. If a single phenomenon could be pointed out which the ether is proved incompe- tent to explain, we should have to give it up ; but no such phenomenon has ever been pointed out. It is, therefore, at least as certain that space is rilled with a medium by means of which suns 6 THE SUPREMACY and stars diffuse their radiant power as that it is traversed by that force which holds, not only our planetary system, but the immeasurable heavens them- selves in its grasp." Thus Professor Tyndall clearly and conclusively proves the certainty of the existence of an omnipresent substance acting as the medium of many of the phenomena of the universe. But in doing so, he proves far more than he probably ever intended to prove. While the existence of this medium is clearly proven, yet the most superficial consid- eration of the phenomena of light, heat, gravitation, electricity and magnetism readily shows that it is necessary to as- sign to this medium in the case of some phenomena qualities utterly incompati- ble, according to the laws of matter, with its action in the case of other phenomena, and hence that this medium OF THE SPIRITUAL. 7 must be a substance which transcends the known laws of this material world. Furthermore, the hypothesis of one medium as the basis of light, for ex- ample, a different one for gravitation, and yet another for electricity, is wholly inadmissible, since it supposes two or more substances existing and operating in exactly the same point of space (an utter absurdity according to the laws of the material world alone) and without either one nullifying or ex- cluding the action of the other, or others. Admitting, therefore, the clearly proven existence of this " ether " (or whatever you may please to call it), it is yet necessary to proceed further and recognize the fact that this single universal medium is not only omni- present, but immaterial, and hence not of the material existence and its condi- 8 THE SUPREMACY tions and laws, but spiritual. We find it to be " A motion and a spirit that impels All thinking things, all objects of all thought, And rolls through all things." And right here, we recall the fact, by the way, that already many scientific men have supposed this so-called "ether" to be homogeneous with the immaterial, simple substance, the soul. And this supposition is confirmed when we find the same spiritual substance operating as the medium of communication in the already well-known phenomena of thought transference and mental sug- gestion from one mind to another. The idea that the will of man can direct the operation of this medium is perfectly consistent with the nature of the will. In the case of the electric eel, we find an instance of the will OF THE SPIRITUAL. 9 directing electricity in such a way as to paralyze the limbs of animals at a dis- tance, and even to cause death; and we find the invisible and spiritual medium of communication in thought transference and mental suggestion easily directed by the human will. But there is one more phenomenon, or rather class of phenomena, to be added to our data before ultimately de- termining, according to the canons of scientific investigation and verification expressed by Professor Tyndall, the ex- act character and nature of this omnipres- sent spiritual substance and medium, — the class of phenomena known as matter. Knowing that the will of man can direct the operation of this medium in " telepathy " and mental suggestion to other minds, we readily infer by analogy what we find to be the only tenable theory of the nature of the existence of 10 THE SUPREMACY matter: viz., that the ideal theory is substantially correct, so far as it goes positively to account for facts, and that this principle of spirit governed by will underlies the phenomena of matter. " That which truly is, or essence," is the proper meaning of substance. Substance is " the ultimate point in analyzing the complex idea of any ob- ject. Accident denotes all those ideas which the analysis excludes as not be- longing to the mere being or nature of the object." The substance, then, of all matter, is spirit. The accidents of any object are its peculiar modifications. The accidents of all material objects are constantly sustained and presented, for the contemplation of created spirits, by the Divine Will in accordance with fixed and permanent laws. At any point in space such presenta- tion is constantly governed by the OF THE SPIRITUAL. 11 Divine Will in such a way that an ob- ject there situated has a real existence there, whether any one perceives it or not. It exists there, in a special sense, as an idea of the infinite and omnipres- ent God, whose ideas, in the form of material objects, are infinitely more real than any image or hallucination which we can impress, by suggestion, upon the minds of others, and whose in- fluence in our hearts is a far more stir- ring emotional power than any which can be imparted by merely human will to the most susceptible person. An ob- ject situated at a certain point in space is presented to the contemplation of every spirit who happens to come into communication with that point in space, this presentation being governed by fixed laws, and any one who has already perceived a particular object knows that upon going again to the 12 TEE SUPREMACY place where it is, the same object will be perceived by him. The recognition of the sole absolute existence of one infinite, omnipresent, eternal spirit does not conflict with a belief in this spirit as a personal God, Who is above all human comprehension, Whose ways are not our ways, and in Whom we and all created things exist. Yet care should be taken against affirm- ing the statement " God is all," in a sense that really so limits God as to ignore the fact that an Infinite Being may have personality and must have an infinite power of self-adaptation in any degree, and thus must be capable of as- suming the closest personal relations with finite persons. Sir Isaac Newton held that God by existing constitutes time and space, He being infinite and eternal. In Him, and consequently in them, all created OF THE SPIRITUAL. 13 persons and things (His ideas) exist. We have a clear and necessary intuitive knowledge of unlimited time and space through Him, the omniscient, omni- present, Eternal One, in Whom we exist, and of Whom we are, and because space and time are necessary to our present conditions of existence. Our perception, therefore, of real ideas or material objects is the result of the action of the Divine Will on our minds, and the Eternal Spirit constantly sustains and presents these real ideas for the contemplation of created spirits, but they also exist, furthermore, out of the created minds which perceive them. Bishop Berkeley erred on this point ; viz., in his maintaining of real ideas or material objects that " their esse is per- dpi, nor is it possible they should have any existence out of the minds or thinking things which perceive them." 14 THE SUPREMACY This theory does not merge the crea- ture in the Creator, as may readily be seen ; and, since it recognizes the free will and accountability of created spirits, does not make God the agent or power in everything that is done. Nor can it by any means lead any spiritually minded and clearly reasoning person to adopt Hume's view : viz., that the mind is but a mere series of impressions, and that we can have no knowledge of it. Now, Berkeley erred in maintaining that the esse of things is jjercipi ; i. e., they can have no existence " out of the minds or thinking things which perceive them." He wrote, in the " Treatise Concerning the Principles of Human Knowledge " : — "III. That neither our thoughts, nor passions, nor ideas formed by the imag- ination, exist without the mind, is what everybody will allow." OF THE SPIRITUAL. 15 To this I readily agree, but not to what follows : — " And it seems no less evident that the various sensations or ideas imprinted on the sense, however blended or com- bined together (that is, whatever objects they compose), cannot exist otherwise than in a mind perceiving them. I think an intuitive knowledge may be obtained of this by any one that shall attend to what is meant by the term exist when applied to sensible things. The table I write on, I say, exists, that is, I see and feel it ; and if I were out of my study I should say it existed, meaning thereby that if I was in my study I might perceive it, or that some other spirit does actually perceive it. There was an odor, that is, it was smelled ; there was a sound, that is to say, it was heard ; a color or figure, and it was perceived by sight or touch. 16 THE SUPREMACY This is all I can understand by these and the like expressions. For as to what is said of the absolute existence of unthinking things without any relation to their being perceived, that seems perfectly unintelligible. Their esse is percipi, nor is it possible they should have any existence out of the minds or thinking things which perceive them." The fallacy of Berkeley's reasoning is readily perceptible to us if we con- template the omnipotence and omni- presence of the Infinite Eternal Spirit Who sustains the idea presented, as, e. g., a table. The very existence in the Infinite Mind of an object as directly and solely and especially re- lated to a particular point in space, con- stitutes for it a real and special exist- ence there (whether contemplated by any created spirit or not), without any relation to its being perceived by any OF THE SPIRITUAL. 17 other than the omnipresent Infinite Mind, its origin. Berkeley appears to have been lacking in an intuitive knowl- edge of the nature of the existence of the Infinite Divine Mind and Its power of thought. Though our perception of real ideas or material objects is the result of the action of the Divine Will on our minds, and the Eternal Spirit constantly pre- sents and sustains these real ideas for the contemplation of created spirits, yet their esse is not percipi, and they exist out of, as well as in, the created minds which perceive them. The table I write on exists ; I see and feel it ; and if I were out of my study, I should say it existed, but I mean thereby not only that " if I was in my study I might perceive it, or that some other spirit actually does perceive it," but that the table has an actual existence there, in that place, 18 THE SUPREMACY whether any one is there to perceive it or not. This is because it is an idea of the omnipotent and omnipresent Divine Mind. This theory, moreover, implies the greater reality and the omnipresence of the spiritual world. Two worlds there are; the one is real, The other but seeming; both are here. The seeming doth to us reveal Its attractions great and our friends most dear. But greater far in the Spirit's light Are the pleasures of matter's sense bereft, When the world of the seeming fades from sight, And the real existence alone is left. And dearer yet our friends will be When illusions of earth from our lives have passed, And the spirit from matter's bond is free, And the life eternal be