% ^^ ,-«? ^%. u :'^ %. /■v^ . "-y, .^^' ^m %. X-' ^*,i«o»«:* v n WASHINGTON AT TAKUYTOWX. A PAPER READ BEFORE THE TARRYTOWN HISTORICAL SOCIETY B Y M A R C 1 U S D.RAYMOND, ^rqGsdcj}' Mve., WGCGii|bei^ 16, 1890. PUBLISHED BY THE AUTHOR BY REQUEST. TARRYTOWN, N. Y. 1893. / ■/ / 1 ^ /■ -«#j"TARRYTOWN ARGUS" PRINT. J*— This paper is published at this time and in this form so that the faets whieli it cni bodies ma}- be better pre- servetl, and in the hope that it may be the means of some aAvakened interest in our k)eal histcjr}'. And so it is ]iresented to the members and friencKs of the Tarry- toAvn Historieal Soeicty ] \\'ith\ the e(,)m]diments of the author and pul)lisher. M. D. Raymond. Tarrytcjwn, X. Y., CJet. 30, ICS93. To the mcinory of tJie Patriots of Tarrytoivn Diii'iiig the Revolution, This vohtine is respeetfitllv dedicated. WASHINGTON AT TARRYTOWN. HE gathering up of the fragments of our local history, of the leaflets of tradition, and their pious preserva- tion troni the ruthless devastation of time, is a sufficient justihcation for the existence of this Society. It is not a meaningless mission, a mere innocuous sentiment, a diversion, without \vorthy and useful aim and results; it is a means of in- struction as well as a theme of interest. The present is but the projected past — the life evolved from yesterday, and throbbing with impulses received from it. Ol^serving what is, we look for causes — we look baclv wards. And we find that nothing happens by chance. P'or instance, Tarrytown \vas iiot an accident. The mighty convulsions of nature that separated the rock-ribbed hills on the east from the west, and opened up a way for the ^vaters of our noble River — and the broad Tappan Zee, environed by our castellated heights, with fertile slopes between inviting the sturdy Dutch burghers hither, was not an accident; it was Providence. And the rich legacy which has come down from them to us of faithful, patriotic. God-fearing, well-ordered lives, may \vell be ])rized as among our choicest treasures. The story of those times, and of their lives can never fail to be of moment to us. The halo of romance and mystery which envelop them but adds to the charm of their ever fascinating interest. There can be but one early history of any place or l)eople, and this place is peculiarly blessed in that the Fathers made ami left it hallowed ground. There may have been rudeness and lack of culture among them, they may not have had the polish and learning of the schools, but they had the attractive garb of simplicity, the sturdy, rugged virtues 6 WASHINGTON AT TARRVTOWN. that make for manhood and character, and so long as the quaint spire of the okl Dutch Church where they worshipped points heavenw^ard, and the venerable tomes of its records are preserved, and God's acre, where their sacred dust reposes remain, so lon.i^ shall their memory be cherished. And this treasure trove of history and legendary lore is shared and prized by others as well as ourselves. On remarking recent- ly to a youth in Southern Ohio, that vv^e Vv'ere from Tarr}-town; "Oh, yes," he replied, "That is historic ground." How much the arms of Washington and the genius of Irving have served to make it so. The history of Tarrytown while yet a part and parcel of the Manor of Phillipsburg, is in itself a distinct era, and may well be entitled the Patriarchal period. It was pre-eminently i>astoral and peaceful; the tending of the flocks and the cultivating of the fields, with no greater ambition than neighborhood influence and rural prosperity. Then came the shock and upheaval of the Re\-- olution. And to their everlasting ln)nor be it recorded, that not- withstanding the fact that the Lord of the Manor was in accord ^^ath the King, there were but few Tories in this vicinage. From the first, the tenantr}' were in full sympathy with tlie cause of the Colonies, and although sore trials u'ere in store for them, — their fields devastated, their proj)erty wasted and the tragedy of war enacted at their doors, its rude alarms and terrible realism did not serve to re])ress their patriotism or awe them into sub- mission. The British General Howe could not well have paid them a higher compliment than when he said, after his fruitless movement in this direction in 1777, "I can do nothing ^vith this Dutch population; I can neither buy then with money, nor con- quer them by force." And then, again, later in the same year, date of Nov., 1777, their persistent patriotism elicited that in- famous brutal order from the Royal Governor Tryon, to burn Tarrytozvn ! Which, however, happily, in the face of the ringing defiance of General Parsons of the Continental Army, he had not the temerity to undertake. But ^vhat less of sturdy patriotism and courage could have been expected of the descendants of the heroic Netherlanders WASlllXCTOX AT TARRVTOWN. 7 who under William the Silent maintained lor 30 years siiccessfvil resistance against the nn)st ])o\verriil and cruel despotism ol" the 17th century in Kurope. and by their g^lorious deeds forever im- mortalizetl the annals of the Dutch Reinil)lic. The Revolutionary j)eriod was indeed of thrilling local interest, the records of much of ^\•hich yet remain to he gatheretl up, and it is not strange that the connection with it oi the name of Wash- ington, whose fame the genius of our own Irving has made to shine with brighter lustre on our coiuitry's annals, should give an added glow to the history and tradition of that time; for Washington was re])eatedly in Tarrytown, although "Washington at Tarrytown" is the broader theme of this paper. IlIF. MARN' RIIII.IJI'SK ROMANCK Has served in some mystical way to connect the name of Wash- ington with Tarr\town at an earlier date, and the follo^ving from an article by Wilson Cary Smith, in the American Magazine of ///s^ory, for Fehvuarv , 1881, entitled " The Roger Morris House," is a bold attempt to bring the storied tale within the domain of history, in the averment that he passed through this place, if he )aoclasts of historv have repeatedly belabored this legend with their little hatchets, it still survives, — that is, the fallacy of his visit to Mary Phillipse at the Manor House here, and of his pass- age through Tarrytown at that time. Otherwise the article re- ferred to is in the main historically correc-t, in so far as it re- lates to the journey from Alexandria, Virginia, to Boston, via of New York, where he unquestionably was the guest of Col. Bev- erh' Robinson, but it was at his house in the city, and not at his country-seat in the Highlands, where he was entertained, on that occasion. But the writer referred to has strangely fallen into another error, for this journey cd" Washington was not under- taken in the summer of 1756, the cold facts of history informing us that it was on the 4th day of February that he set out, — his own diary, in which the minute details of events in each day's progress are carefully recorded, witli all the particularity so 8 WASIIINCTOX AT TARRVTOWX. characteristic of him, is the imciiiestioned authority for this state- ment — and that he reacheil Alexandria on tlic 23d ot March on his return. However it sets forth our hero in sucli <^h)wing coh)i-s. and makes such a pretty picture of his rt)ljust manhood that the whole story is here given, phantasy as w^ell as fact, as follows: "The disputes as to relative rank between officers bearing the royal commission and those appointed by the Colonial Governors assumed such shape and importance that in the year 1756 Wash- ington, who 'had been duly commissioned by the Governor as commander of the Virginia troops, fountl his authority as such disputed by a Ca])tain of British regulars whose force tlid not ex- ceed thirty men. This absurd assumption brought tne affair to an issue. Washington was de])uted by the authorities of Virgin- ia to lay the \vhole matter before General Shirley, then Comman- der-in-chief of the royal forces with headtjuarters at Boston, in the Massachusetts Bay Colony. "In the summer of 1756, accompanied by his aitls, Captain Mercer, and Captain Stewart, and a retinue of such as w^ell be- came his wealth, rank, and official errand, Washington started northward on his mission. "Their five-hundred miles journey, from Virginia, was on horse-back, attended by their black servants in livery — tlie equip- ments for the same as w^ell as the housings of Washington's horses, being sent from London per order, and emblazoned with the Washington arms. In their progress the}^ made a sensation in the country, as well by the clattering of the hoofs of their steeds in the streets of Philadelphia, New York and Boston. "No man \\'as more v.'ideh' or more favorablv known throughout the colonies. The hero of Fort Duquesne, \%'hom the Indians believed to bear a charmed life, had a personal presence and dignity of bearing which commendetl him to the favor of those among whom he now came for the first time. The most distin- guished honors and hospitalities were showered upon him at every point on his journey. ■?;•** -jf * "Arriving at New York, the party were entertciined for some days at the house of Beverly Robinson in the Highlands. Robin- son, a native of Virginia, had lately married Susannah, the eldest WASIlIXC.rOX AT TARRYTOWX. 9 daughter of Frederick Phillipsc, owner of the Manor of Phillipse- burgh, an estate granted to liis grandfather by Governor Fletcher, which comprised a great portion of Westchester County and parts of Dutchess and Putnam. The entail, however, had been broken by the now obsolete legal process known as fine and common recovery, and the estate divided among the heirs at law, among whom was Mary Phillipse, sister of Mrs. Robinson and heiress in her own right of fifty thousand acres of land. Beautiful, and accomplished, this yoimg heiress is credited in the gossi}) of the day with having proved so attractive to Washington that he not only tarried for several days on his way to Boston, but that on his return he sought the fair damsel and lingered under the sj)ell of her charms. Some assert even that he made her an offer of marriage, which Avas r(.'jected." WASIIIXGTON'S FIRST APPEARANCE AT TARRVTOWN. Putting aside this romantic tradition, the fi.rst well authenticat- ed appearance of Washington at Tarrytown, and in this vicinity, \vas in the campaign of 1776, which included the disastrous re- treat from Long Island, and entled with the battle of White Plains and the withdrawal of the Continental forces to New Jersey. On the I 2th of July of that year, and ^vhile the main part of the army under Washington was yet encamped on Long Island, and his headciuarters were in New York, t\vo British Men-of-War, the Plia'nix of 44, and the Rose of 20 guns, \\'ith their tenders, sailed up past the city of New York, and came to anchor that evening off Tarrytown, causing thereby no little consternation to the inhabitants, and some anxiety to the Commander-in Chief. The object of the enemy was doubtless to encourage those favor- ably inclined to declare themselves for the King; but if so, they must have been badly disappointed, as means were at once taken for active resistance, there being evidence that Lieut. Col. Ham- montl that very night ordered out his forces to meet the enemy, making his headquarters at the noted Van Tassel Tavern, now the residence of Mr. Jacob Mott. The following official comnumi- cation sent by Lieut. Col. Hammond to Gen. Washington, dated Tarrytown, July 15th, 1776, is in this connection of interest; lO WASHINGTON AT TARRYTOWN. Tarrvtown, July 15, 1776. May it please your Excellency to take into account our humble petition. Whereas, two of the enemy's ships of war with their barges and tenders are arrived up the North River as far as Tarrytown, \ve suppt)se with a hostile design to distress us; \v4th the concurrence of the Congress and assistance of the Comniittee, and by the forwardness of a number of vt)lunteers; a considera- ble number of people are collected to our assistance, most of whom are very anxious about their harvests, \vhich are now ht for collection, and in a suffering condition for want of laborers. We therefore humbly petition your Excellency to send us such a number of troops as your Excellency shall judge proper, to res- cue the inhabitants up and down the river from the cruel designs of the enemy. As to further particulars must beg leave to refer your Excellency to the bearer. Capt. (William) Dutcher. Jas. Hammond, Lic2it.-Col. First Battalion of Militia i)i W'i'stchcstcr County. To the Hon. Geo. Washington, Esquire. The frigates sailed away up the river to the Highlands on July 1 6th, and return^ed about Avig. 3d to this place. On the 6th of August Col. Thomas sent a communication to Washington show- ing the desirability of having some breastworks thrown up here in which to place cannon to aid the galleys in an anticipated at- tack upon the British Men-of-War. That attack took place on the 8th of August, and was a gallant affair, resulting ho^vever in a drawn battle. It ^vas doubtless during that time that the earth- works were thrown up on the place lately owned by Mr. C. W. Smith, just to the south of Tarrytowni, some vestiges of ^vhich still remain. In the meantinie Long Island had been evacuated, and after the battle of Harlem Plains the backward movement of the Con- tinental army continued until it finally took position near White Plains, where it engaged in unequal contest with the enemv on October the 28th. Immediately pi-eceding- the latter event still more vigorous measures had been taken for the defence of Tarrytown, it being now on the right flank of the Continental lines, and during that period it is believed that Washington was repeatedly here. Well preserved tradition has it that on one of these occasions, together I WASIIIXO TON AT TARRVTOWN. II with his Staff, a brilliant array t)f officers, he took a position tor observation on Wolf Hill, near the present residence of Col. Sigafus, which place has ever since been known as the Pine Tree Lot, a venerable pine still marking the spot near which he stood as he looked down i)ossibly for the first time on the broad Tappan Zee, where safely rode at anchor tlie hostile British frigates. It must have been to him a vision wliich he \vouJd not be likely to soon forget. Washington may at one time have considered the moving of the main army in this direction, iind so perhaps do battle here, but he finally decided on the Fabyan policy of falling l)ack to the North Castle hills. In any event, however, his right must be protected. It was then, just before the battle of White Plains, and ^vhile his headquarters were at the Miller House, (jn the east side of, and near the Bronx, by the Lower Cross Roads to the Plains, and only a short distance from our borders, that on one occasion he certainly was at the famous Diivids (Wm. Davids) house, on and between the old White Plains and the Bedford Roads, which is still standing, now owned and occupied by Mr. Abram D. Stephens, a lineal descendant of the Revolutionary Davids, where he held a consultation or council of \var \vith Col. Hammond and other officers, in regartl to the military situation here, and what measures should be adopted for offensive and de- fensive warfare. It ^^'as in the large west room of that house that the council was held, and around a table which is still pre- served in the family. The late Aunt Betsey See, ^vho was a Davids, and born in that house, is the unquestioned authority for this statement in regard to tliat api)earance of Washington at Tarr}'to\vn. As an incident of his presence there at that time, it is stated that a small lad of a related family, named James Vail, afterwards the father of the late Hammond Vail, and grandfather of Mr. J. H. Vail of Washington St., who happened to be present, received the gift of a silver dt>llar from Washington, who was much amused at the little fellow's ineffectual efforts to properly speak his name, which, o\\'ning to an impediment in his speech, he pronounced Washing-////^ .' That dollar was for a long time a 12 \vashin(;to.\ at tarrvtowx. treasured keepsake in the family, and would now, we take it, be gladly redeemed at par by the Treasurer of the Tarryto\vn His- torieal Soeiety ! All this is substantiated by the reeolleetion of Mrs. Jas. Hawes, who had often heard her aged aunt tell the story. Washington is also said to have repeatedly visited Kaak- out, nearby, as related 1j}' the older citizens in days of yore. As the result of this visit of Washington to the Da\'ids house earthworks were then thrown up on the rise of ground to the westward, which was thereafter long known as the Breastworks Lot ; and also on Jones Hill, to the north, near and on the prop- erty of Col. Kent, the clearly defined outlines of which are still to be seen. It was during this period, and perhaps on his return from this very reconnoisance to the Davitl's house that W^ashington came near being captured at the house of Col. Ham- mond, which is still standing, being the hrst house beyond the brick school house, and on the north side of the road, this side, to the west, of Mr. Robert Bonner':., whose farm as well as the Reynold's place, vv-ere fornierly parts of Col. Hammond's posses- sions. The story is told as foliO%vs, by Aunt Betsey See, as ap- pears in Bolton's History of Westchester Cou.nt}' : ATTEMPT TO CAl'TURK WA.SIlIXdTON. "Col. Hammond li\'ed in the first house on the right hand side of the road leading from Tarrytown to VVhite Plains (the Lower Cross Road) just beyond the brick school house, directly M^est of Mr. Bonner's farm. The house used to have tall pine trees and very old box borders in front ; it is now owned by Mr. Kingsland. A part of the American Army under his command had been 1\'- ing in front on the fine })lateau. General Washington came one day to consult with him and staid quite late in the evening after w^hich he returned to his headcpiarters near White T^lains. The army had also been withdrawn and the Colonel vi-^as left alone for the night. Just before daybreak the Colonel's \vife was awakened by a heavy rinnbling noise, and she awoke her hus- band, but he thought it \vas only distant thunder. Soon it be- came louder and louder, and then it stopped directly opposite their house. This was followed by loud rapping at the door and w ASniNc; TON a i tarrn rowN. 13 demands to open. The Col. dressed as c|uickly as jiossihle, and as he opened tlie door, several ICn^lish soldiers demanded his surrender and all within. The Colonel replied, T do surrender and all with me.' They then ck-manom Maj. Strang's oljserva- tions Lord Sterling's present ground near or west of Yoinig's House, is not the most advantageous. From the description of the face of the country given by Maj. Strang and some of the members of Convention, Bald Hill, near David's, i 1-2 or 2 miles north of west of Youngs, should be immediately occupied. From thence is a curved chain of hills trending East, or rather North East, afterwards E. N. E., through which is only one natural nar- 14 WASniNClTON AT TARRYTC^WX. row^ pass on the rciad which leads from Youngs. From BaKl Hill to Hudson River, near Phillipse Upper Mills, is |)retty high ground, a little more than a mile; and from Bald Hill is a chain of hills, or rather high ground running Sovith West on the west side of Brunson's, or Saw Mill River. If the enemy could be confined ^vithin the hills v/est of SaAv Mill River, it would keep open your communication \vith Tarryto\vn and keep them at a distance from Hudson River. From every accoimt Bald Hill shoidd be examined by some General officer, that if important it should be secured, &c. Bald Hill \vas perhaps another name for Kaak-out, at least its location nearly conforms to the description given. Other coim- sels how^ever prevailed, and so the defeated army of Patriots march- ed away and dwindled away, while Gen. Hovv^e. Vv'iih little mater- ial fruit of victory returned leisurely to Ne\v York. That it had been aperiodof great anxiety and depression to Washington is well evinced by the following extract from a private letter written by him to his brother, at Hackensack, date of N(/V. 19. He says: "I am Avearietl almost to death with tlie retrograde motion of things, and I solenmly protest that a reward of 20,000 lbs. a year would not induce me to luidergo what I do, and after all perhaps lose my character; as it is impossiljk^ luider such a variety of distressing circumstances to conduct matters agreeably to public expectation." The iron had already entered into his soul, but his character gre^\^ nobler vmder all these trials, and other and greater ones that w^ere before him. TARR^■T()\V^' DURI.NC; TlIK RKVOLUTIO.X. But to take a retrospective view of Tarrvtown as it was during this stormy period. Commencing as far southward on the old post road as AI)b()tsford, was the now historic Odell Tavern, an old stone hostelry of pre-Revokitionary construction, from Avhich its then owner, Jonathan Odell, the great-grandfather of Hon. N. Holmes Odell of this place, was rudely taken and con- fined, "with some of his Patriot neighbors, in the t)ld Sugar House Prison, New York. At the present village of Irvington, was the homestead of that sturdy Patriot, Capt. Wm. Dutcher ; next to WASHINGTON AT rAKRVTOWN. I 5 the northward, that ol' .Ahrahaiii Ack'ci", 2d, who took up arms in the cause of the Coh)nies, and taken [)risoner, was tor a time incarcerated in the noted Su<^ar House, New York ; then we come to the residence of tliat valiant son of Mars, Major Jacob Van Tassel, who troubled the enemy not a little with his uiidnii^ht sallies and the \-iL;-()rous defence of his Castle with his celebrated Goose (inn, making Wolfert's Roost, — the future " Sunnysidc," fore\'er historic i;-i-ound. Then c-ame th.e homestead of Stej^hen Acker, a patriot partisan, and Glode Reqiui, a Captain in the Westchester Comity levies; tlien Ceo. llepworth, John Van Wart, Wm. Hunt, Win. V^an Wart, Thos. Wylde, wdio, it is said, was killed in the l)attle of White Plains, (his farm being lartijely the Benedict and Cobb estate;) then Abran.i Reviere, ^\•ho lived in the jn'esent D. O. Archer house, and had a l)lacksmith shoj) on the site of the present Savinj^s Bank ; (jCo. Combs, who li\'eil oppo- site, on the present Dean corner, and who was apjjointed Com- missar\- of the troo}:)s at Tarrx'town under command of Col. Hammond, b\' the \. Y. Con\-ention tlate oi" July i6. 1776, and was also commissioned as Ca|)tain on Jime 16, 1778, ami was a i)rominent citizen ; on the opi)osite, the North West corner of the Post Road (now Broadway) and the road to Martling's Lanilin^,^, was the residence and Inn of lulward Couenhoven, who with his wife Annatje Roome Couenhoven, had imited with the old Dutch Church by certificate Irom the Reformed Church in New York tlate of Oct. I, 1772. The plot comprised altogether 18 acres, and extended tlown as far as the present Orchard Street. On the opposite side of the highway to the eastward — there was then no Ui)i)er Main Street — was the homestead of John Van Tassel 1, comprising 160 acres, the residence, which had a wide reputation as the Van Tassel Inn, being the present homestead of Mr. and Mrs. Jacob Mott John Van Tassell was a volunteer in Col. Hammond's Regiment. Then came the lands of Michael Mc- Keel, 327 acres, whose residence, off from the highway, was on the present Chas. J. Gould place ; and to the northward of that, the celebrated Wm. Davids place; to the eastward on the old White Plains Road the Isaac Reed place, where the captors of Major Andre stopped for an hour with their prisoner on that l6 WASHINGTON AT TARRYTOWN. eventful and ever to be remembered 231! of September, 1780; and then to the northward and westward of the Davids y)lace, the lands adjoining the Phillipse Castle — Manor House, which ap- pear after the enforced retirement of Frederick Phillpse to have been occupied by one Wm. Pugslev, from ^^dlom it was trans- ferred by the Commissioners of Forfeiture in 1785 to General Beekman, and so became the celebrated Beekman estate. Then there was a small settlement at the Landing — -Martling's — of less than a dozen houses, where lived Capt. Daniel Martling, and his brother Isaac, who v/as "inh^umanly skiin," Capt. Drake, and the family of Buice and others. And this is all there was then of Tarrytown, a hamlet of perhaps something less than a hm^idred souls. During this trying period it is wonderful how on this Debata- ble and Bloody Ground the existence of the forms of law and "order and civil government were preserved. For instance we read from the ()ld records of the Phillipsburg Manor of that time, as follows : " Memorandum of all Public Officers appointed and chosen at a Town Meeting held as iisjial, in the Manor, the 6th day of April, 1779, and in the third year of our Independency." The "third year of our Independency" is good. These Dutch burghers evidently had no thought of surrendering to the enemy. WASHINGTON'S NEXT APPEARANCE HERE. Washington next appeared at Tarrytown in the memorable campaign of 1781. After conference with De Rt)chambeau and a plan of operations agreed upon at Wethersfield in May of that year, the allied armies w^ere marshalled for an advance upon the city of Nev^^ York, Washington's right resting on the Hudson at Peekskill, and the French forces on his left. At 3 o'clock on the morning of July 2d, the Continental troops were put in motion^ it is said by Gordon, with each a clean shirt and 4 days' cooked provisions in their haversacks. The allies moved forward two or three days later. Washington gives the following account in his Diary of this day's march : "At 3 o'clock this morning I commenced my march with the WASHINCTOX AT I" AK K\ TOWN. I 7 Continental arm\-, in order to cover the detaclied troops, and im- prove any advanta<2^e whieh niiury's Light Infantry. And so Washington and his army marched through Tarrytown on the evening of July 2d, 17.S1. after resting themselves at the Old Dutch Church, some authorities sa}-, for two hours, for the march \vas wearisome even to veteran troops that hot summer s([., and Lieut-Gov. Pierre Van Corthuult is rei)resented here by a great-granddaughter in the person of Mrs. Gertrude Beekman ot North Tarrytown, while at least one of the Continental soldiers who marched through Tarrytown under Washington on the night of July 2d, I 78 I, and again in return on the 19th of August of the same year, is represented here, in the person oi tlie writer. The portrait of Washington jjresented is after a Trumbull, which has been engrave