Book^OVga. Digitized by the Internet Archive in 2010 with funding from The Library of Congress http://www.archive.org/details/narrativeofjonatOOrath ay NARRATIVE OF JONATHAN RATHBUN, WITH ACCURATE ACCOUNTS OF THE CAPTURE OF GROTON FORT, THE MASSACRE THAT FOLLOWED, AND THE SACKING AND BURNING OF NEW LONDON, September 6, 1781, by the British Forces^ under the command of the TRAITOR BENEDICT ARNOLD. BY RUF.US AYiERY, AND STEPHEN HEMPSTEAD, Eye witnostes of the saiae. TOGETHER WITH AN INTERESTING APPENDIX. ^^'^v a^ IN EXCHAN{^ Entered according to Act of Congress, in the year 1840, By Jonathan Rathbun, in the Clerk's Office of the District Court of Connecticut. CONTENTS Page. Preface. . ^ - - - 3 Narrative of Jonathan Rathbun, - 9 Narrative of Rufiis Avery, - - 17 Narrative of Stephen Hempstead, - 41 APPENDIX Desertion of Arnold from West Point, 57 Anecdote of Mrs. Bailey, - - 63 Eulogy on General Washington, - 65 Female Whig of '76, by Miss Sizer, 71 Names of the Killed, - - - 74 Names of the Wounded, - - - 79 PREFACE • Whoever reads the Narratives which follow, will feel himself indebted to Mr. Rathbun, the Proprietor of the work, for the indefatigable industry, with which, for several years, he has employed himself in collecting the materials. When more than seventy years of age, he found himself in poverty ; and as a measure of relief he conceived the plan of this publication, which he has now the happiness of presenting to the patronage of a discerning public. He has often been forced by the necessities which a destitute old age, infirm health and a sick family impos- ed on him, to solicit the charities of the benefi- cent for his relief. Now he has the pleasing consciousness of oflTering to his fellow citizens a work, which will no doubt nurture the spirit of patriotism wherever it may be circulated ; while the moderate profits which he anticipates, will relieve, at least to a good degree, the wants of his old age. He justly feels, in the opinion of the writer of this Preface, that his patrons will find themselves doubly repaid by the value of his book ; and at the same time experience the satisfaction of saving one of the last soldiers of the American Revolution from the pain of begging his daily bread. The Narra- tive of Mr. Rathbun, with which the volume opens, will still further disclose the claims, which he has on the patronage of all who value the blessings of a free government. The Narrative of Mr. Avery has never be- fore been given to the public, and will be found to contain the most interesting incidents of the Capture of Groton Fort, expressed in the de- scriptive and glowing language of an eye wit- ness. The other articles need only be read to be highly appreciated. They are thought to add much to the value of the work. The whole presents to the public a connec- ted view of many minute particulars respecting* the events of the fatal 6th of September 17S1, which have never before appeared in print ; and though history has recorded the outlines and monuments stand to perpetuate the san- guinary facts, those who read this account will have an impression of that day, which none but an actor in the scene can impart. Fathers read it to your children, and early impress on their minds a love for Freedom, and teach them to detest a Traitor like Arnold ; and to scorn the inhuman and dishonorable con- duct of the frenzied villian, who murdered our brave Ledyard with his own sword after sur- rendering ! For the perusal of the young, it is especially appropriate, as what they can obtain from his- tory will be explained to their understandings, and when those in the vicinity tread the ground of New London and Groton, they will feel as if a voice echoed from the now peaceful hills, inspiring them with new ardour and zeal for their rights as Freemen, and boldness in de- fending their country from foreign invasion. NARRATIVE OF JONATHAN RATHBUN. I was born in Colchester, Connecticut, in f 1765. When 16 years of age, I joined as a i volunteer a company of Militia, belonging to j my native town, and marched to the relief of New London, intelligence having just reached us of an attack on that place by the British, un- der the conduct of the Traitor Benedict Arnold. We left home to the number of about one hun- dred men early in the morning of the 7th of September 1781, the day after the battle. On our arrival in New London we witnessed a scene of suiFering and horror which surpasses description. The enemy were not to be found, but they had left behind them the marks of their barbarism and cruelty. The city was in 2 10 ashes. More than one hundred and thirty na- ked chimneys were standing in the midst of the smoking ruins of stores and dwelling houses. Very little property had escaped the conflagra- tion, except a part of the shipping which, on the first alarm, was sent up the river. But though the city was destroyed, it was far from being deserted. Numerous companies of mili- tia from the neighborhood were pouring into the town; and the inhabitants, who had fled from their burning dwellings, were returning to gaze with anguish on the worthless remains of their property. Women were seen walking with consternation and despair depicted in their countenances, leading or carrying in their arms their fatherless and houseless babes, who in a few short hours had been bereaved of all that was dear on earth. Their homes, their provisions and even their apparel were the spoils of the enemy or lay in ashes at their feet. Some were inquiring with the deepest distress for the mangled bodies of their friends, while others were seen following the carts which bore their murdered fathers, husbands or brothers 11 to the grave- More than forty widows were made on that fatal day. Never can I forget the tears, the sobs, the shrieks of wo, which fell from the kindred of our brave countrymen, who then gave their lives to achieve our national in- dependence. It was my melancholy duty to assist in the burial of the dead, which brought me directly into the midst of these heart rend- ing scenes where the wife first recognized her husband, the mother her son, the sister her brother, in the body of a mangled soldier, so disfigured with wounds and clotted with blood and dust, as to be scarcely known! Often on my visits to New London have I walked near the spot where I helped to inter my slaughtered countrymen ; and though many years have since rolled away, the recollection is still'fresh in my mind, awakening anew the strong feel- ings of sympathy I then felt, and rousing into activity the love of my country. I recollect several interesting facts, con- nected with the capture of Fort Griswold and the burning of New London, which, I believe, are not mentioned in the narratives of Messrs. Avery and Hempstead. 12 After the capture of the fort and the mas- sacre which followed, the enemy laid a line of powder from the magazine of the fort to the sea, intending to blow up the fort, and com- plete the destruction of the wounded within and around it. Stillman Hotman who lay not far distant, wounded by three strokes of the bayo- net in his body, proposed to a wounded man near him, to crawl to this line and saturate the powder with their blood, and thus save the magazine and fort, and perhaps the lives of someof their comrades, not mortally wounded. He alone succeeded in reaching the line, where he was found dead lying on the powder which was completely wet with his blood. I do not find his name among the killed in the list of Mr. Avery. Another fact of a different character was currently reported at the time and deserves to be recorded to the deeper disgrace of the infa- mous Arnold. He had a sister living in New London, with whom he dined on the day of the battle, and whose house was set fire to, as is supposed, by his orders, immediately after- wards. Perhaps he found her too much of a 13 patriot for his taste, and took this step in re- venge. * The next year, 1782, I was led by the spirit which the scenes I had witnessed in New London had fanned into a flame, to leave my father's house and the peaceful pursuits of agriculture, and to enlist as a private in the Connecticut State troops. Never shall I for- get the impressive circumstances under which I took the soldier's oath. With five others of my townsmen, who enlisted with me, I was marched into the meeting house on the first Monday in April, it being freeman's day, and there in the presence of a large concourse of people, we swore to discharge our duty faithfully. We were ordered to fort Stan- .\fich, in Stamford, Ct., where I remained during all but the last month of my term of service. Here I was subjected to the usual hardships of a military life. Many a time have I been out for several days on scouting parties, sometimes to the distance of twenty- five miles. These were not only attended with fatigue, cold and hunger, but with no little 2* 14 peril of life. On one occasion a rifle ball passed through my hat and cut away the hair of my head^ but a kind Providence protected me. A party of fourteen men, under Lewis Smith; were surprised by a body of mounted troops to the number of sixty, by whom they were ordered to surrender. Lewis Smith per- ceiving the hopelessness of resistance against such an overwhelming force, inquired of the British officer in command, whether if they should surrender, they would be treated as prisoners of war. The answer was, yes ; but no sooner had they lowered their muskets, than the enemy shot them down. As a specimen of the hardships to which the private soldier in time of war is constantly liable, I may mention the following. One evening the orderly sergeants passed around among the men and with a whisper commanded us to equip ourselves without noise ; and then we were marched out of the fort to a woods two miles distant, and ordered to lie down on the frozen ground, where we passed a bitter 15 cold night with only a single blanket and our over coats to protect us. We afterwards learned that this step was taken to avoid the enemy, who it was reported were that night to attack the fort with an overwhelming force. From such exposures and hardships as these my constitution received a shock, from which I have never recovered. The sickness of my father was considered a sufficient reason for giving me a discharge ; and after eleven months service I left Stamford for Colchester. On reaching home I was immediately taken sick, and for six months was unable to do any business. From that time mingled mercies and misfortunes have attended me. The in- firmities thus contracted in the service of my country, disabled me from arduous manual labor, and much of my life has therefore been spent in trade and other light employments. My heaviest misfortune, however, has been the sickness of my excellent wife, who for forty years has been confined to her bed, and for whose medication and comfort, with the other expenses of my family, the earnings of my 16 industry have proved insufficient, especially since the infirmities of old age have come upon me. But of none of these things do I com- plain. They are wisely appointed, and have been greatly alleviated by the kindness of a generous community. I mention them for the sole object of interesting my countrymen in my present effort to supply my wants through this little book. JONATHAN RATHBUN. NARRATIVE OF RUFUS AVERY, Coniainwg an account of the transactions at New London and Groton, on the Qth Septem- ber, 1781, 171 his oicn words. '* I had charge of the garrison the night previous to the attack. The enemy had not yet appeared near us, nor did we expect them at this time more than ever ; but it is true * we know not what shall he on the morrow.' About 3 o'clock in the morning, as soon as daylight appeared, so as I could look off, I saw the fleet in the harbor, a little distance below the light- house ; it consisted of thirty- two in number, ships, brigs, schooners and sloops. It may well be imagined that a shock of consternation, and a thrill of dread appre- 18 hension flashed over me. I immediately sent for Capt. William Latham, who was captain of said fort, and who was near by. He came and saw the fleet, and sent notice to Colonel Ledyard, who was commander of the harbor, and also of Forts Griswold and Trumbull. He ordered two large guns to be loaded with heavy charges of good powder, &c. Captain William Latham took charge of the one which was to be discharged from the north east part of the fort, and 1 had to attend the other, on the west side, and thus we as speedily as possible prepared to give alarm to the vicinity, as was to be expected in case of danger, two guns being the specified signal for alarm in distress. But a difnculty now arose from having all our plans communicated by a trai- tor ! The enemy understood our signal was two regular guns, and they fired a third, which broke our alarm, and caused it to signify, good news or a prize, and thus it was understood by our troops, and several companies which were lying back ready to come to our assist- ance in case of necessity were by this meas- 19 ure deterred from coming. The reader may well suppose, though time would not permit us to consider, or anticipate long, yet the sense of our helplessness without additional strength, and arms, was dreadful ; but the trying events of the few coming hours we had not known ! Colonel Ledyard now sent expresses from both forts, to call on every militia captain to hurry with their companies to the forts. But few came : their excuse was, that it was but a false alarm, or for some trifling alarm. The ene- my's boats now approached and landed eight hundred officers and men, some" horses, car- riages and cannon, on the Groton side of the river, about 8 o'clock in the morning ; and another division on the New London side, below the light house, consisting of about seven hundred otlicers and men. The army on Groton banks was divided into two divis- ions. Colonel Ayres took command of the division, south east of the forts, consisting of about half, sheltering them behind a ledge of i rocks, about one hundred and thirty rods back. Major Montgomery with his division about one 20 hundred and fifty rods from the fort, behind a high hill. The army on New London side of the river, had better and more accommodating land to march on than that on Groton side. As soon as their army had got opposite Fort Trumbull, they divided, and one part pro- ceeded to the city of New London, plundered and set fire to the shipping and buildings, the rest marched down to Fort Trumbull. Cap- tain Adam Shapley, who commanded, seeing that he was likely to be overpowered by the enemy, spiked his cannon, and embarked on board the boats which had been prepared for him in case of necessity ; but the enemy were so quick upon him, that before he and his little handful of men could get out of the reach of their guns, seven men were badly w^ounded in the boats. The remaining one reached Fort Griswold, where, poor fellows, they met a mortal blow. Ayres and Montgomery got their army stationed about 9 o'clock in the morning. When they appeared in sight, we threw a number of shots among them, but they would 21 immediately contrive to disappear behind their hills. About 10 o'clock they sent a flag of truce to demand the surrender of the fort. When the flag ^Yas within about forty rods from the Fort, we sent a musket ball in front of them, and brought them to a stand. Col. Ledyard called a council of war, to ascertain the minds of his officers and friends about what was best to be done in this momentous hour, when every moment indicated a bloody and de- cisive battle. They all agreed in council, to send a flag to them. They did so, choosing Capt. Elijah Avery, Capt. Amos Staunton, andCapt. John Williams, who went immedi- ately to meet the British flag and receive their demand, which was to give up the Fort, to them. The council was then inquired of what was to be done? and the answer returned to the Brit- ish flag wasjthat "the Fort would not be given up to the British." The flag then returned to their division commanded by Ayres, but soon returned to us again ; when about a proper distance our flag met them and attended to their summons, and came back to inform Col. 3 22 Ledyard, that the enemy declared that "if they were obliged to take it by storm, they should put the Martial Law in full force," that is, " what they did not kill by ball, they should put to death by sword and bayonet !" Col. Led- yard sent back the decisive answer, that " we should not give up the Fort to them, let the consequences be what they would." While these flags were passing and repas- sing, we were exchanging shots with the Brit- ish at Fort Trumbull, as they had got posses- sion of it before the battle commenced in action at Fort Griswold. We could throw our shot into Fort Trumbull without any difficulty, but the British could not cause theirs to enter Fort Griswold, because they could not aim high enough. They had got possession and in use, some of our best pieces and ammunition, which were left in Fort Trumbull, when Capt. Shapley left it and retreated. About 11 o'clock in the morning, when they perceived what we were about to do, they started with both their divisions, Colonel Ayres advancing with his in solid columns. As soon as they 23 reached the level ground, and in a proper range, we saluted them with an eighteen pounder, then loaded with two hags of grape shot. Captain Elias H. Halsey was the one who directed the guns, and took aim at the enemy. He had long practiced on board a privateer, and manifested his skill at this time. I was at the gun with others when it was dis- charged into the British ranks, and it cleared a very wide space in their solid columns. It has been reported, by good authority, that about twenty were killed and wounded by that one discharge of grape shot. As soon as the column was broken by loss of men and offi- cers, they were seen to scatter and trail arms, coming on with a quick step towards the fort, inclining to the west. We continued firing, but they advanced upon the south and west side of the fort. Colonel Ayres was mortally wounded. Major Montgomery now advanced, with his division, coming on in solid columns, bearing around to the north, until they got east of the redoubt or battery ,^ which was east of the fort, then marching with a quick step 24 into the battery. Here we sent among them large and repeated charges of grape shot, which destroyed a number, as we could per- ceive them thinned and broken. Then they started for the fort, a part of them in platoons, discharging their guns ; and some of the offi- cers and men scattering, they came around on the east and north side of the fort. Here Major Montgomery fell, near the north east part of the fort. We might suppose the loss of their commanders might have dismayed them, but they had proceeded so far, and the. excitement and determination on slaughter was so great, they could not be prevented. As soon as their army had entirely surrounded the garrison, a man attempted to open the gates ; but he lost his life in a moment, before he could succeed. There was hard fighting, and shocking slaughter, and much blood spilt before another attempt was made to open the gates, which was at this time successful ; for our little number, which was only one hundred and fifty five, officers and privates, (the most of them volunteers,) were, by this time over- 25 powered. There was then no block house on the parade as there is now, so that the enemy had every chance to wound and kill every man. When they had overpowered us and driven us from our station at the breastwork into the fort, and Colonel Ledyard saw how few men he had remaining to fight with, he ceased resistance. They all left their posts and went on to the open parade in the fort, where the enemy had a fair opportunity to massacre us, as there were only six of us to an hundred of them ! This, this was a mo- ment of indiscribable misery ! We can fight with good hearts while hope and prospects of victory aid us ; but, after we have fought and bled, and availed nothing, to yield to be mas- sacred by the boasting enemy, 'tries men's hearts !' Our ground was drenched with hu- man gore ; our wounded and dying could not have any attendance, while each man was almost hopeless of his own preservation ; but our country's danger caused the most acute anxiety. Now I saw the enemy mount the parapets like so many madmen, all at once 3* 26 seemingly. TKey swung their hats around, and then discharged their guns into the fort, and then those who had not fallen by ball, they began to massacre with sword and bayonet. I was on the west side of the fort, with Cap- tain Edward Latham and Mr. C. Latham, standing on the platform, and had a full view of the enemy's conduct. I had then a hole through my clothes by a ball, and a bayonet rent through my coat to my flesh. The enemy approached us, knocked down the two men I mentioned, with the britch of their guns, and I expected, had ended their lives, but they did not. By this time that division which had been commanded by Montgomery, now under charge of Bloomfield, unbolted the other gates, march- ed into the Fort and formed into a solid column. I, at this moment left my station and wxnt across the parade, towards the south end of the barracks. I noticed Col. Wm. Ledyard on the parade, stepping towards the enemy and Bloomfield, gently raising and lowering his sword as a token of bowing and submission ; he was about six feet from them when I turned my 27 eyes off from him, and went up to the door of the barracks and looked at the enemy who were discharging their guns through the win- dows. It was but a moment that I had turned my eyes from Col. L. and saw him alive, and now I saw him weltering in his gore ! Oh, the hellish spite and madness of a man that will murder a reasonable and noble-hearted Officer, in the act of submitting and surrendering ! I can assure my countrymen, that I felt the thrill of such a horrid deed, more than the honorable and martial-like war of months ! We are in- formed, that the wretch who murdered him, exclaimed, ashecamenear, " Who commands this Fort ?" Ledyard handsomely replied, " I did, but you do now :" at the some moment handing him his sword, which the un- feeling villain buried in his breast ! The column continued marching towards the south end of the parade, and I could do no better than to go across the parade before them, amid their fire. They discharged three platoons, as I crossed before them at this time. I believe there were not less than five or six hundred of ?8 the British on the parade, and in the Fort. They killed and wounded every man they possibly could, and it was all done in less than two min- utes ! I had nothing to expect but to drop with the rest; one mad looking fellow put his bayonet to my side, swearing "by Jesus he would skipper me!" I looked him earnestly in the face and eyes, and begged him to have mercy, and spare my life ! 1 must say, I be- lieve God prevented him from killing me, for he put his bayonet three times into me, and I seemed to be in his power, as well as Lieut. Enoch Staunton, who was stabbed to the heart and fell at my feet at this time. I think no scene ever exceeded this for continued and barbarous massacre after surrender. There were two large doors to the Magazine, which made a space wide enough to admit ten men to stand in one rank. There marched up a pla- toon often men just by where I stood, and at once discharged their guns into the Magazine among our killed and wounded, and also among those who had e caped uninjured, and as soon as these had fired another platoon was ready, 29 and immediately took their place when they fell back. At this moment Bloomlield came swiftly around the corner of the building, and raising his sword with exceeding quickness, exclaimed " stop firing ! or you will send us all to Hell together ! I was very near him when he spoke. He knew there must be much powder deposit- ed and scattered about the Magazine, and if they continued throwing in fire we should all be blown up. I think it must, before this, have been the case, had not the ground and every thing been wet w^ith human blood. We trod in blood ! We trampled under feet the limbs of our Countrymen, our neighbors and dear kindred. Our ears were filled with the groans of the dying, when the more stunning sound of the artillery w^ould give place to the death shrieks. After this they ceased killing and went to stripping, not only the dead, but the wounded and those who were not wounded. They then ordered us all who were able to march, to the N. E. part of the parade, and those who could walk to help those who were wounded so bad as not to go of themselves. 30 Mr. Samuel Edgcomb Jr. and myself were or- dered to carry out Ensign Charles Eldridge, who was shot through the knee joints ; he was a very large heavy man, and with our fasting and violent exercise of the day, we were but ill able to do it, or more than to sustain our own weight ; but we had to submit. We with all the prisoners were taken out upon the parade, about tv/o rods from the Fort, and ordered to sit down immediately, or they would put their bayonets into us. The battle was nov/ ended. It was about 1 o'clock in the afternoon, and since the hour of eight in the morning, what a scene of carnage, of anxiety, and of loss had we experienced. The enemy now began to take care of their dead and wounded. They took off six of the outer doors of the barracks, and with four men at each door, they brought in one man at a time. There were twenty- four men thus employed for two hours, as fast as they could walk. They deposited them on the west side of the parade, in the Fort, where it was the most comfortable place, and screen- ed from the hot sun which was pouring down 31 upon us, aggravating our wounds, and causing many to faint and die who might have lived with good care. By my side lay two most worthy and excellent officers, Capt. Youngs Led^^ard, and Capt. N. Moore, in the agonies of death. Their heads rested on my thighs, as I sat or lay there. They had their reason well and spoke. They asked for water. I could give them none, as I was to be thrust through if I got up. I asked the enemy, who were passing by us, to give us some w^ater for ray dying friends and for myself. As the well was near they granted this request ; but even then I feared they would put something poison into it, that they might get us out of the way the sooner ; and they had said, repeatedly, that the last of us should die before the sun set f ' Oh what revenge and inhumanity pervaded their steeled hearts ! They effected what was threatened in the summons, sent by the flag in the morning, to Col. Ledyard, "That those who were not killed by the musket, should bo^ by the sword," Eli Jones, do. Thomas Lamb, do. Frederick Chester, do. Daniel Davis, do. Daniel D. Lester, do. 78 ' Capt. Adam Shapley, New London. Capt. Peter Richards, do. Benoni Kenson, do. James Comstock, do. Richard Chapman, do. John Holt, do. John Clarke, do. Jonathan Butler, do. John Whittelsey, do. Stephen Whittelsey, do. William Bolton, do. William Comstock, do. EHas Coit, do- Barney Kinney, do. Capt. Elias Henry Halsey, Long Island. Lieut. Enoch Stanton, Stonington. Sergeant Daniel Stanton, do. Thomas Williams, do. Lamb Latham, (Colored.) Jordan Freeman, do. NAMES OF THE WOUNDED, PATROLED AND LEFT AT HOME BY CAPT. BLOOMFIELD. Capt. William Latham, wounded in the thigh, Groton. Capt. Solomon Perkins, in the face, do. Capt. Edward Latham, in the body, do. Lieut. P. Avery, lost an eye, do. Lieut. Obadiah Perkins, in the breast, do^ Lieut. William Starr, in the breast, do. Ensign Charles Eldridge, in the knee, do. Ensign Joseph Woodmaney,lost an eye, do. Ensign Ebenezer Avery, in the head, do. John Morgan, shot through the knee, do. Sanford Williams, shot in the body, do. John Daboll, shot in the head, do. Samuel Edgecomb, Jr. in the hand, do. Jabish Pendleton, in the hand, do. Asahel Woodworth, in the neck, do. 80 Thomas Woodworth, in the leg, Groton. Ebenezer Perkins, in the face, do. Daniel Eldridge, in the neck and face, do. Christopher Latham, in the body, do. Christopher Eldridge, in the face, do. Amos Avery, in the hand, do. T. Woodworth, in the knee, do. Frederick Wave, in the body, do. Elisha Prior, in the arm. do. Sergeant Daniel Stanton, in the body, Stonington. Corporal Judd, shot in the knee, Hebron, William Seymour, lost his leg, Hartford. •V