■l«H : :;i ^.M9G51 [ :i -^^0^ ° ''^w ^ oK .iJ-, ■"'j7 . A TRUE HISTORY OF THK MASSACRE OF NINETY-SIX CHRISTIAN INDIANS, AT GNADENHUETTEN, OHld, MARCH 8th, IT 82, Published bt the Gnadenhuetten Monument Sociktt, Organized Oct. 7th, 1843. NEW PHILADELPHIA, Printed at the •recautions. Parties were at work in the cornfields, at each of the three settlements. Gnadenhuetten, Salem, and Schoen- brunn. They had already made fine progress, and gathered a large quantity of grain, and were beginning to bundle up their packs in order to take their final leave of the places, when sud- denly the mililia made their appearance. When within a mile of Gnadenhuetten, Col. Williamson's party had encamped lor the night and reconnoitered their po- sition. On the morning of the 6th of March the following plan t My authorities for the following narration are Zeisberger's Journal, Holmes' and Loskiel's Histories; WiUet's Scenes in the Wilderness, and Doddridge's Notes. [7] for an assault vras devised. One half the men were to cross the river, and attack the Indians who were at work in their cornfields on the West side, whilst the other half, being divided into three detachments, were to fall simultaneously irom diff- erent quarters upon the village on the East side, — When the former division reached ihe river, they could not ford it, be- came it was high and filled with floating ice; but, observing something like a canoe on the other side, a young man of the party swam across, and brought over what proved to bo a large sap-trough. In this, going two by two, they commenced cross- ing, but impatient at the delay, a few got over, swimming at its side and holding fast to the edges. In this manner sixteen had crossed over, when the sentinels, who were in advance, discovered a lad, named Joseph Shabosh, the son of the assist- ant missionary, fired at him and broke one of his arms. The rest hastened to the spot, sending word by those who remained on the East side, for the other detachments to march upon Gnadenhuetten without a moment's delay, supposing that the firing would have alarmed the inhabitants. With most piteous entreaties young Shabosh begged them to spare his life, repre- senting that he Avas the son of a white man; but, regardless of his cries and tears, they killed him with their hatchets, and ^calped him. After thus whetting their appetites in his warm life-blood, the party approached the plantations. The first to discover their approach was an Indian named Jacob, a brother-in-law to young Shabosh, who was employed near the banks of the river, tying up his corn. Remaining un- perceived he was about to hail them, supposing them to be a friendly party, when at that instant they shot at one of the brethren who was just crossing the river from the town. Up- on perceiving this, Jacob fled with the utmost precipitation, and before their faces were turned towards him, was out of sight. Had he acted with some coolness and courage, he micht have saved many a valuable life; especially by proceeding to Salem, and giving the alarm. But instead of this, fear led him to flee several miles in an opposite direction, where he hid him- self a day and a night. The party of sixteen now drew near to the Indians, who were at work in the fields in considerable numbers, and had their guns with them, and finding that they were greatly out- numbered, accosted them in a friendly manner. They pretend- ed to pity them on account of their past sufl"erings, said they had come to conduct them to a place of safety near Pittsbu'g, and advised them to discontinue their v/ork at once, and return with them to the town to hold a further parley. To all this the Indians, anticipating no harm from American soldiers, and ig- norant as yetol the murder of Shabosh, cheerfully acceded. — [8] Not dreaming that they were to be caught "like fish in an evil net, and as birds that are caught in the snare," they rejoiced that they had found such true friends, and imagined they saw the hand of God in it — who was about to put an end to all their suffering?, and lead them to a more secure and pleasant country. The other detachments had meanwhile arrived at the village, where they found but one man, and a woman, whom they shot, as she was hiding in the bushes. But so prepossessed were the Indians with the idea of removing, that nothing was able to shake their confidence in the white men. They cheerfully sur- rendered their guns, hr.tchots and other weapons, upon receiv- ing the promise that they should bo restored at Pittsburg, .showed then> where they had secreted their communion-wine and other property in the woods, helped them to pack it up, and began to make every preparation for the journey to Pitts- burg. The native assistant John Martin had gene to Salem, imme- diately upon the arrival of the party, to inform the inhabitants of the state of af!airs; and the next dny a troop of horsemen rode down to bring ihem all in. VViih the same confiding trust in their professions of poace and good-will, they returned with ihem, conversing on the road upon religious topics, in which their attendants joined with much appearance of piety. Simple children of the forest, how dove-like had Christi;miiy made you! How little did you dream of deliberate deceit aiid base treach- ery, and that as sheep you were being led to the slaughter! — Arriving at the river-bank opposite Gnadenhuetten, their eyes began to open, however, when it was too late. Tlviv discov- ered a spot of blood on the sand, wliich excited disquietude and alarm. Soon their boding fears received full confirmation. As soon as they entered the town ail were seized, as those in town had been a short time before, their guns and pocket knives were taken by their conductors; they were pinioned, and con- lined in two houses standing some distance apart; the men in one, the women and children in the other. Here they met to- gether — associates for the last time in sorrow. They mingled their tears and their sympaifiies together, and their prayers ascended to the throne of grace. The miscrcanrs now held a consultation, to decide the late of the prisioners. The charges which ihey brought against them were, that their horses, as also their axes, pewter basins and spoons, and all they possessed had been stolen or obtained by improper means from the white people, and also that they were warriors, and not christians. All of ijiese accusations were ut- terly false and frivolou?. On the contrary it is presumable that the expediiion would never have been undertaken, or at least not so imprudently conducted, il they iiad anticipated resistance. [9] They well knew th<» pacific principle's of the Moravian Indians, and calculated on blood and plunder without having a shot fired at them. With a mere show of defence it is likely thai such men might have been rt'pulsed. Some deeds of blood were, no doubt, imputed to these Indians, for, according to the statement of the missionaries, the Wyandot and Delaware warriors, who were inimical to the Gospel, had always made it a point to re- turn from their campaigns through their settlements, in the ex- pectation that It would brin;j: the whiles upon the Moravians. Some warriors, too, accompanied ihem on their return irom Sandusky, crossed the Ohio and committed several murders, and *, and united in singing praises unto Him, in the joyful hope that they should soon enter into His glorious presence, in everlasting bliss. In this hour the consolations of divine grace abounded in their souls; they felt the peace of God which passelh all understanding, and cheerlully resigned, they awaited the summons ol their executioners. It was the morning of ttie 8lh of March when the awful scene was enacted. The murderers came to them whilst they were engaged in singing, and asked, "'wliether they were ready to die?" and received lor answer, '-that they had commended themselves to God, who had given them the assurance in their hearts that he would receive iheir souls." The carnage then immediately commenced. By couples they were led bound into two houses that had been selected for the purpose, and were aptly termed the "Slaughter-Houses;" the men to the one, the women and children to the other, and as they entered were knocked down and butchered. A Pennsylvanian of the party conducted the slaughter of the brethren. Taking up a cooper's mallet, (the house had been occupied by a cooper.) he said, looking at it, and handling it, "How exactly this will answer for the business.'' With this as the instrument of death, ho continued knocking them down one after another, until he had killed fourteen with his own hands. He then handed the mal- let to one of his fellow-murderers, saying: "My arm tails me; goon in the same way: 1 think I have done pretty well."* Ot the horrors that fanspired in the house of the poor women and children we have no further aecount, than that a woman, called Christina, who had resided in Bethlehem, Pa., and could speak Enirlish well, tell upon her knees before the Captain, and beg- ged him to spare their lives, but was told it was impossible. So ferocious had they become that they were not satisfied with jiimply destroying their lives, but disfigured the dead and dying * Ttiia was related by a lad who escaped out of the house, and who oaderstood Engliah well. ID 1.4BAlfi t'O bodies in a horrible manner. Thus perished at least ninety innocent persona, of all ages — from the grey-haired sire down to the helpless innocent at itf mother's breast. Leaving the houses which were now reeking with the blood and man^jled remains of their victims, they went to a little distance, making merry over the horrid deed ; but returning a^ain they saw one named Abel, who thoiii^h scalped and mangled was attempting to rise, and despiitcrlied him. The whole number of the slain was ninety-six ; of these •ome were killed before the general massacre, as Shabosh and bis wife, and several who in attempting to esciipe by swimming the river were shot. — Several warriors were likewise killed at the same tim**, outside of the town. Of the whole number of Moravian Indians, lorty were men, twenty- two were women, and thirty-four children. Five of the men were respectable native assistants : Samuel Moore, Tobias, Jonas, Isaac Glickhican and John Martin. Samuel Moore and Tobias had been members of the congregation of that eminently devoted servant of God and most faiihlul missionary, David i^rainerd. After his death they left New Jersey and joined the Mora- vians. Samuel had received his education from Brainerd, could read, and was so well acquainted with the Engii;Ji language, that for many years he served in the capacity ot interpreter. The others, also, bore excellent characters, and were very useful members of the Church. Isaac Glickhican had been a sachem, and was noted among his countrymen lor superior wisdom and courage. Only two lads of fourteen or fifteen years of age effected their escape from the hands of the murderers. One of these was knocked down and scalped with the rest in the sljiughlei- house of the brethren. Recovering a little he looked around, and beheld on all sides the mangled corpses ot thni dead. Among them he observed Abel attempting to rise, whom tha tvhite men, coming in soon afterwards, despatclu'd. With great presence of mind he lay quite still among ihe heaps of slatn, and when they had deparieu, cept over the bodies to the door, still keeping himself in such a position as easily to feign death, it any person should approach. As it l»egan to grow dusk, he qnickly ijot out at the door, hid iumselt beiund the house until it was quite dark, and then escaped. The other lad hart loosed his bonds, soon after it was ascertained that they were to die, succeeded in escaping out of the house where they were confined, and crept by a small cellar window under the house where the women were subsequently butchered. Here he remained imdetected, and as the butchery proceeded, saw^ the blood How in streams into the cellar- He kept hiinseli con- cealed till evening, when he with much ditiicjulty made his way [12j out of the narrow window into the woods. These two lads mot providenlially, and staying awhile to watch the move- ments of the white party, journeyed together to Sandusky. The Indians who were gathering corn at Schoenbrunn were saved from the fate of their brethren. They had despatched two bretheren lo Gnadenhuetten and Salem, carrying intelli- gence to ihem from the missionaries, on the day that the band arrived. These, on their way, discovered lo their great sur- prise the marks of hr rses' hoofs along and beside the path, and cautiously followed the tracks, until they found the body of Shabosh. They buried his body, and after observing that there were many white men in the village, and concludiug from the fate of Shabosh that their hretheren had all perished by the same cruel hands, hastily returned to Schoenbrunn. Here all took to instant flight concealing themselves in the woods for some days, on the opposite side of the river. When the murderers arrived therefore upon the following day, they might easily have been discovered ; but, being struck with an i unaccountable blindness, and finding no trace of Indians, they soon rode ofT, after pillaging and burning the village. In the same night of the massacre the white men set fire to all the houses of Gnadenhuetten, and to the slaughter houses among the rest. The dead bodies Avere but partinlly consumed, and their bones remained to bleach in the sun, until alter some twenty yea-s they received interment by friendly hands. By the light of the burning village the murderers then departed, lending the air with shouts and yells more savage ^han ever arose in the wilderness before, carrying with them the scalps, about fifty horses, numerous blankets, and some other aiticles of plunder, which they exposed for sale in Pittsburg. On their way back they made another attuck on an Indian settlement a short distance from Pittsburgh, and were paitiallv success- ful. After a journey, attended with innumerable hardships, the Indians from Shoenbrunn arrived at Sandusky alinoiit f;imished, having left all their provisions behmd. They returned to a dreary country; and to add to their distress, they returned to take anotlier leave of their teachers. Well might they say with the patriarch Jacob, ''All these things are agiiinst me. " But they muimured not — they trusted in God, and look courage. In conclusion, may 'he memory of our red brethren who at Gnadenhuetten sealed their faith with blood, ever ren ain; and may their pious confession of the Saviour in sufleiing, their nieek endurance, and triumphant Chiislian death, bear testimo- ny to the Truth as it is in Jesus, as long as the memory of the atrocious deed shall last! K c°"..i,V^;,-. °o >\.,a^,;.,*-^^^ c°\v '^MrS. ^oK -^^0^ K*^' y ^o^ '>^^/ /^% ^^m^^ / ^'o, •^ v^ .sr^.% o^ .^' .-J^^-. %/ .•>>^?-^-'. %,^* /,^fe\ "^ .0' ,.:.^';'% .^\< .€ ^"•^.^ V % * * ' ' o . ' • "' > '^o •^_ ,/.. <^. ^ %/f;^ia^:%.^' ^m^. ^^-'^^ '.^^ A ^ G ^ 'o , . * .A. .^y--\% //;w^^% ^^.^^-^:-^ .v^ >^ WC^/" ^^ '^^^ \^P.*" S % ^^^^^^ "■■ -^o 'i^'^ c ° •: ° * "'<^ 0^ . - ,^^\ ^"^^ k o. ^o-n^ '^ ] C03BSSROS. .V^ Z^LJ^ „ ,