'J / ^7 p 549 ljs-/V^^-<'^-/-' ^npAr>^ .R6 P3 Copy 1 ^.c, THE PUBLIC SERVICES OF HIRAM PRICE. 6oi Affairs. He entered upon the work of his new position with his usual zeal and energy, and for four years labored to better the condition of the Indians, and reform some of the methods of dealing with them by the Government. He was now nearly seventy years of age, and had since boyhood led an active life, toiling early and late, in both private and public affairs. Whatever business claimed his attention was prosecuted with untiring vigor and generally led to success. For more than thirty years he had been a leader in reform, financial and political affairs in the State. From youthful poverty he had won a competence; in the temperance movement he was con- ceded the highest rank ; in financial enterprises he had achieved great success; in official life his record was above suspicion, and his influence was second to none in the State, As a public speaker Mr. Price never resorted to the artifices of the professional orator. He did not care to amuse his audi- ence with a stock of anecdotes sandwiched in at regular inter- vals to raise a laugh or win applause. He never " posed " for effect, nor did he ever seek occasions to make speeches for the purpose of advertising himself When he spoke in public it was certain that he had something to say, and he went at it in the most direct and straightforward manner. There was no policy, no honeyed phrases to please the ear and conceal an opinion. He used the plainest English, looking his audience squarely in the eyes; he held their closest attention and aroused the highest degree of enthusiasm by his fearless and earnest utterances. No one could mistake his position. It was always taken and maintained with a positiveness that left no room for doubt. He never waited to catch the drift of the popular breeze, but always led off, prompted only by his con- victions of right and wrong. He was never a compromiser, but on the contrary was one of the most vigorous fighters ot the times. When overborne by the majority he acquiesced gracefully, not because he was convinced that the decision was right, but because he was loyal to the fundamental principle of our republican government — that the majority should rule. He made bitter enemies in his life-long war against evil-doers, rS'f'^ 602 ANNALS OF IOWA. but intense as was their hatred, they secretly entertained a profound respect for a foe so vaHant and sincere. Mr. Price was often urged to become a candidate for Gov- ernor, by friends who recognized his superb e.xecutive abihty, but he did not care to enter into a contest for that exalted position, and is content to live a quiet life as old age ap- proaches. One of his last kindly remembrances of his old Davenport home was a recent gift to the public library of that city. He set aside an amount of money, the interest of which is used to furnish a free reading room with thirty of the best magazines, weekly and daily papers. He also furnished and fitted up a commodious room where the people have free access to the best current literature of the times. And now past eighty years of age, his mental vigor unim- paired, he is living a quiet life in his Washington home. Our Iowa people remember and honor him for his noble life work in behalf of our great State, and his name will be for all time associated with the stirring events of the brightest pages of its history. The steel portrait which appears with this article was en- graved from a photograph of Mr. Price taken in 1878. FORT ARMSTRONG. BV MRS. MARIA PECK. Upon the large and beautifully wooded island in the Missis- sippi now occupied by the splendid piles of solid masonry comprising Rock Island Arsenal, picturesque and solitary Fort Armstrong once .stood. To ascertain the initial facts underlying the history of the establishment of this military post in 1816, it is necessary to go back to the earlier years of the century and review the FORT ARMSTRONG. 603 most important incidents upon which was based the claim of the United States to an immense and valuable tract of country then in the possession of the Indians. In the year 1700, as nearly as the date can be determined, the federated tribes of Sacs and Foxes — or Sauks and Rey- nards — came from the vicinity of Green Bay and established themselv^es on the eastern bank of the Mississippi near the mouth of Rock River. Accordini^ to their own traditions, both tribes originally came from Canada. The date of their migration to the upper lake region is not definitely known, though Father Hennepin speaks of the Foxes as residents on Green Bay in 1680, and another writer of the existence of a Sac village on Fox River in 1689. There is very good authority for the supposition that they both descended from the great Chippewa nation. It is known that the Foxes found and fought their way to their new home first, and when joined some years later by the Sacs, were in such a weakened condition from an encounter with the allied forces of the French and Indians, followed by frequent attacks of other hostile tribes, that they were unable to main- tain themselves longer as an independent nation. The Sacs in their wanderings had fared better though they had suffered from a war with the Iroquois. So, in addition to an aflfinity of kinship, the stronger bond of mutual protec- tion induced the formation of a union — a relation which was sustained uninterruptedly for upwards of a century. The con- federacy was governed by two sets of chiefs, the civil and military; each had separate and distinct powers conferred upon it, though in all matters involving the sale of lands, the making of important treaties or declaration of war, the two ruling powers, to make such transaction valid, must act con- junctively. When they finally settled in the surpassingly beau- tiful and fertile Rock River region, the principal Sac village — the one of historic fame — was located on the isthmus or point of land formed by the junction of Rock River with the Mississippi, about four miles below Rock Island. This 604 ANNATE OF IOWA. village became in time one of the largest, most populous, and prosperous of the Indian villages on the continent. Having secured by conquest a footing, these enterprising and indomitable people were not content until they had sub- jugated their southern neighbors and added to their posses- sions rich and extensive hunting grounds, where in a more genial climate they could spend the winter months. After gaining the supremacy they sustained themselves as masters of the country, not only against their ancient and implacable enemies, the Sioux, and other warlike nations, but against a powerful federation. Nevertheless these Indians, of whom it has been said, that they had more courage in battle than wisdom in council, in the year 1804 ceded to the United States all of their possessions east of the Mississippi River for a most insignificant compensation. The complications and disagreements that followed the consummation of this treaty caused all the serious difficulties that subsequently arose between the Government and the Indians down to and including the final struggle that resulted in their expulsion from the country east of the river, and almost the extinction of one of the bravest tribes that ever wielded a tomahawk or followed a trail in the Mississippi valley. In the first article of the famous treaty, the Sac and Fox- Indians were received, with much show of interest, into the friendship of the United States and full protection guaranteed them. For and in consideration of these valuable assets, including two thousand two hundred and thirty-four dollars and fifty cents in goods delivered at the time, and a promised annual stipend amounting in value to one thousand dollars in goods, the United States acquired a title to twenty millions of acres of land. Article VII of the treaty contains its redeeming feature. It reads as follows: " As long as the lands which are now ceded to the United States remain their- property, the Indians belonging to the said tribe shall enjoy the privilege of living and hunting upon them. The treaty was negotiated at Saint Louis, November, 1804. William Henry Harrison, FORT ARMSTRONG. 605 Superintendent of Indian Affairs for Indiana Territory and the District of Louisiana, acted for the Government and five representatives of the united Sac and Fox nation in behalf of the Indians." Many of the most prominent chiefs afterward repudiated the treaty, saying that it was unauthorized, fraudulently obtained, and therefore invalid. Black Hawk in his autobiog- raphy gives an explicit account of the incidents which led to its execution. It had its origin according to his story in this way : one of their number had killed a white man and was arrested and imprisoned at Saint Louis for the offense. A council was called at the Sac village on Rock River (Black Hawk's village) to consider the best means of obtaining his release. . It was decided that a deputation consisting of four men be sent to confer with the Indian authorities at Saint Louis with instructions to offer money and horses, after their own way of dealing in such matters, as a ransom. While there on this business it was claimed that these delegates were made drunk and in that condition induced to sign the objectionable treaty. When they returned, after a protracted absence, it was observed that they acted strangely, were dressed in fine clothes and wore medals, but could give no very satisfactory account of the mission with which they had been charged. They reported that the agents wanted some of their land and that they had agreed to give it to them, but the full import of the transaction was not understood until some time later. After a critical examination of all of the available evidence General D. W. Flagler, in his History of Rock Island Arsenal, says : " Other facts of history and the treaty itself .seem to prove that this story, or at least its application, was without good foundation." Still, judging of this matter from whatever bias modern historians may choo.se to give it. the conscientious student of history will hardly be able to divest himself of the conviction that there was something unfair about the treaty and irregular, if not intentionally dishonorable, in the way that it was obtained. The persistent efforts of the (jovernment in 6o6 ANNALS OF IOWA. after years to secure its confirmation may be construed into- an admission of its weakness. Through the artful machinations of the English, and on account of the bad faith of the Americans in not fulfilling their pledges to furnish the Indians with supplies upon the same favorable terms given by the English, Black Hawk and two hundred warriors were persuaded to join the British army in the war of 1812. This contingent under the leadership of " General Black Hawk " was ever afterward known as the " British Band." The participation of this party in the war furnished a pretext for inviting all the chiefs of the two nations to a general peace conference held at Portage des Sioux some- time after its conclusion. The Fox chiefs and warriors responded and joined in a treaty of peace in which w^s incor- porated a ratification of the one of 1804. Black Hawk and his followers refused to attend the meeting, though a short time after a treaty of similar import was effected with a part}' of Sacs. It has been alleged that Black Hawk signed the latter, but he strenuously affirmed that he did not, and from the fact that another invitation to the Sac chiefs to attend a meeting at Saint Louis was issued the following year, it would appear that his statement must be accepted as the more reasonable. This conference was called for the avowed purpose of conclud- ing a new treaty that would bind the war faction of the Sac nation to the provisions of the old ones. Twenty-one chiefs,, including Black Hawk, attended, and on the 13th of May, 18 16, a new document was executed and signed by all the chiefs present. But this did not terminate the troubles, for afterward Black Hawk complained bitterly that he was deceived and did not know when he touched the goose quill to- the treaty that he was consenting to give away his village. A general feeling of uneasiness caused by the continued un- friendly attitude of the Sacs and Foxes, and their evident dis- position to contest the claim of the Government to their lands resulted in a regiment of infantry under Col. R. C. Nichol.s being started from Saint Louis for Rock Island to establish a KOKT ARMSTRONG. 607 fort in September, 1815. The troops with necessary supplies were transported in keel-boats, but before their destination was reached the river was so obstructed b\' ice that they were com- pelled to abandon the expedition until the following spring. The troops under General Smith finally landed upon Rock Island in May, 1816. The construction of the Fort was im- mediately begun, and in honor of the Secretary of War was called Fort Armstrong. After a temporary stay on Rock Island, General Smith left the work in charge of Colonel Law- rence and passed on up the river to Prairie du Chien to estab- lish another post. It was estimated that the united Sac and Fox nations num- bered at that time 1 1,800 persons, all living in villages on both sides of the Mississippi near Rock Island. The day followmg the arrival ot the troops on the Island General Smith sent messengers to all of the villages with an invitation to their chiefs to meet him in council, but no atten- tion was paid to the request. The Indians at first looked with unfriendly eyes upon the project, for they knew only too well the significance of a garrisoned fort in their immediate neigh- borhood. The island itself had long been used by them as a sort of pleasure park ; it was held in special veneration because it was believed to be under the supervision of a good spirit, whose habitation was in a cave in the rocks near the site of the fort. No forcible resistance, however, was made to its erec- tion, though it appears that an unsuccessful attempt was made which probably, if it had not been frustrated, would have resulted in a surprise and massacre of the encampment. One day, while a large party of soldiers was engaged some distance away in cutting timber, a party of warriors approached the island on the north side in canoes and after landing danced up to the encampment and wanted to enter the com- mander's tent. At the same time another large party headed by Keokuk was discovered coming over a ridge on the south side. The sound of the bugle quickly recalled the soldiers to their post, and in a very short space of time 600 men were under arms with the cannon ready for action in front of the 6o8 ANNALS OF IOWA. encampment. The warriors immediately dispersed and the contemplated attack was averted. The following description of the completed fortress is taken from General Flagler's History of Rock Island Arsenal : " The interior of the fort was 400 feet square. The lower half of the walls was of stone and the upper half of hewn timber. At the three angles, the northwest, southwest and southeast, block houses were built and these were provided with cannon. One side of the square was occupied by barracks and other buildings. These were built of hewn timber with roofs sloping inward as a protection against their being fired by the Indians, and that they might not furnish a safe lodging-place for the enemy in an attack. The fort was placed at the extreme angle of the island. Its northwest corner was about 200 feet from the present location of the island end of the bridge." The unrivalled beauty and peculiar charm of scenery attaching to the island and surroundings, when found as mother nature finished it, has been the theme which has in- spired many of the most exquisite word pictures ever drawn by pen. Lieutenant Pike in 1805 was captivated by its won- drous loveliness, and James Hall, author of the History of the North American Indians, in 1829 paid the varied scenic attrac- tions of this historic region a long and beautifully worded tribute. Governor Ford, in his History of Illinois, gives a splendid description of Fort Armstrong and the " romantic wilderness " in which it was set, as it appeared to him when he first saw it in 183 1. He compares "the white-washed walls and tower of the fort perched upon a high cliff, as seen from a distance, to one of those enchanted castles in an uninhabited desert, so graphically described in the Arabian Nights." After the completion of Fort Armstrong nothing occurred to disturb the peaceful and friendly relations early established between the occupants and the Indians until rhe trouble arose which culminated in the Black Hawk war. The Indians con- tinued going south in winter on hunting expeditions and while absent their villages were left unprotected. In the FORT ARMSTRONG. 609 Avinter of 1828, a number of lawless individuals, called at that time squatters, took possession of Black Hawk's village and on his return contended with him for its occupancy. Ordina- rily the Indians would have been equal to an emergency of this kind, but either from motives of policy or a sincere desire to avoid trouble with their white neighbors, no attempt was made to avenge their wrongs by a resort to violence. The aggressors, emboldened by the seeming good nature of the Indians, continued to annoy them until retaliatory measures were at last provoked. Black Hawk, especially, resented the introduction of whisky among his people, and to prevent it, resorted to some vigorous and effective prohibition methods. Thereupon the intruders appealed to the authorities for pro- tection, and without regard for the merits or justice of the case, this flimsy pretext was used as an excuse for selling, pre- maturely, a few sections of land on Rock River, including the one occupied by the Sac village. As has been seen by one of the provisions of the treaty of 1804, the Indians were not tenants at will, but retained the right to live upon their lands until they were sold. It is perfectly apparent that the exped- ient of disposing of a small portion was resorted to for the sole purpose of dispossessing them of this right. The transaction furnishes another exemplification of the political creed ot might as well as a strange inconsistency, for at the same time that the Government was insisting upon the fulfillment of the letter of a compact on one hand it was openly violating its spirit on the other. A peremptory order for the removal of all Sac and Fox In- dians to the west side of the Mississippi quickly followed the sale. Keokuk, a popular and rising young war chief listened to the counsel of his friends at the fort and with a large party of followers settled on low^a River. Black Hawk was not so complacent, and persistently refused to give up the home to which he was so deeply attached. Meanwhile niat- ters between the trespassers and the remaining Indians grew more and more aggravating, until a second appeal was made for protection. This brought General Gaines with a regiment 6lO ANNALS OF IOWA. of soldiers from Jefferson Barracks, and Governor Reynolds of Illinois with i,6oo mounted militiamen to the scene. General Gaines, wishing to accomplish the ejectment of the Indian tenants, peaceably if possible, called a general council at Fort Armstrong, and might have gaiAed his object sooner if he had better understood the spirit and temper of the people with whom he was dealing. He began with a speech which was admirably calculated to kindle the hostility of those whom he desired to conciliate. Among other things he called for the reading of the treaty of 1804. This brought Black Hawk to his feet with some very forcible and convincing arguments concerning its invalidity. The General then asked : " Who is Black Hawk? Is he a chief? By what right does he appear in council?" The old chief, highly indignant, wrapped his blanket about him and stalked out of the room. The following day, after resuming his seat, he arose and said : " My father, you inquired yesterday, who is Black Hawk ? Why does he sit among the chiefs ? I will tell you who I am. I am a Sac, my father was a Sac ; I am a warrior and so was my father. Ask those young men who have followed me to battle and they will tell you who Black Hawk is. Provoke our people to war and you will learn who Black Hawk is." Because of this rupture the conference resulted in the refusal of the Indians to vacate their village. A more dispassionate view of the situation was arrived at later, and in a few days the Indians quietly withdrew from their village, crossed over to the west bank of the Mississippi and encamped under the protection of a white flag. On the 30th of June, 1831, a coun- cil was again summoned at the fort, a treaty of peace concluded, the memorable treaty of 1804 again ratified, and an additional pledge exacted from Black Hawk that he would not recross the river, duly incorporated. The motives which led to the violation of this stipulation the following year, have been variously interpreted. The re-appearance of the old chieftain, accompanied by a few hundred of his faithful adherents, was construed at the time into a hostile intention to re-occupy his old village, whereas, it would seem now that, whatever ulterior FORT ARMSTRONG. 6ll designs he may have entertained, the rash act was undertaken with nothing more serious in view than the acceptance of an invitation from his old friends and neighbors, the Winnebagoes, on the upper part of Rock River to pay them a visit and raise a crop of corn on their lands. The note of alarm was immediately sounded ; an order issued by General Atkinson for their return was ignored, and decisive measures were at once instituted to compel obedience. The Black Hawk war followed — a useless conflict in which in ad- dition to the sacrifice of many lives both the national honor and treasury suffered. A few thousands of dollars in connec- tion with a spirit ot sincere good will would have at almost any time secured the territory in dispute, and the peaceful re- moval of the Indians to their lands west of the Mississippi. It is a fact worthy of mention that only a short time prior to the events which precipitated the final contest, si.\ thousand dollars paid to the disaffected fragments of the Sacs and Foxes would have effected the substantial results achieved by the war, and quieted all complaints. The Government refused to compromise, and waged a war of extermination during which the flag of truce, held sacred by all the civilized nations of the world, was twice fired upon. The war cost two million dollars. The treaty made by General Scott with the Indians at the con- clusion of the war terminated at last the difficulties and also added six million acres west of the Mississippi (afterwards comprised in the State of Iowa) known as the " Black I lawk Purchase," to the territory of the United States. Owing to the fact that an epidemic of cholera was raging among General Scott's troops detained at Fort Armstrong, all the deliberations connected with this important treaty were conducted in a tent on the west bank of the river. The ground occupied was the site upon which was afterward built the first house erected in the city of Davenport. Black llawk and a few of his adherents were held as hostages, ami with a view of impressing them with the vastness of the country, the nutnerical strength and greatness of the people, they were taken to Washington antl from there through many of the large cities of the East. 6l2 ANNALS OF IOWA. Probably no more pathetic, affecting, and in some respects more ludicrous scene was ever enacted at Fort Armstrong than the closing one in the long series that formally severed all con- nection of the Sacs and Foxes with their old homes, and also achieved by the intervention of the Government the humilat- ing subjugation of the broken, but true-hearted son of the wilderness. Black Hawk, and the official recognition of his pow- erful and hated rival, Keokuk, as the leader of his nation. Upon the arrival of Major Garland with his captives at the fort, a grand council was convened so that the liberation of the prisoners might be attended with the most impressive and im- posing ceremonies. " The princely Keokuk," who was expect- ing the party, was encamped in the vicinity, and came up to the island in a style that befitted his newly acquired rank and the oc- casion. In two canoes lashed together side by side, fantastically decorated and covered by a canopy, the stars and stripes floating from above, sat Keokuk and his three wives. His approach was announced by the sound of Indian drums and the wild shouts and songs of his followers ; next came a fleet consist- ing of twenty canoes in which were seated the chiefs and one hundred warriors. The most careful attention had been be- stowed upon their toilets, and the spectacle as they moved slowly up to the island is said to have been exceedingly bril- liant and novel. The commodious council room at the fort had been fitted up for the occasion with more than usual barbaric splendor. Major Garland acted as chief speaker for the Govern- ment. The delicate business, however, of announcing to the as- sembled chiefs and warriors that the deposed chieftain must henceforth conform to the counsels and authority of Keokuk was indiscreetly managed, and the fiery spirit that once animated the illustrious warrior was again manifested. Serious difficulty was averted by the timely and pacific words of the eloquent, talented and politic Keokuk and the friendly advice of Colonel George Davenport, to whom Black Hawk was sincerely at- tached. The pomp and magnificence of Keokuk and his party, the discordant surroundings and ostentatious ceremonies, little ac- FORT ARMSTRONG. " 613 corded with the melancholy mood of the fallen hero, and in his mind added an unnecessary drop to the bitter cup that had been forced upon him ; yet with the exception of the episode referred to, he maintained throucjhout the conference a digni- fied but respectful silence. When the banishment of the last remnant of the Sacs and Foxes from their villages, for which they entertained, says General Flagler, " an affection like that of the Jews for the city of Jerusalem," was effected, the ultimate object for which Fort Armstrong was established was attained, and it was soon after abandoned, never to be re-garrisoned. About these Indians it may be said that those of the early settlers who knew them best have given them the best charac- ter for honesty and sobriety. Davenport, Iowa. LETTERS OF WILLIAM CLARK AND NATHANIEL PRYOR. BY ELLIOTT COUES. When Captains Lewis and Clark were returning from their expedition, and had reached the Mandan villages, in August, 1806, they then and there took with them, for a visit to President Jefferson, a Mandan chief known by the names ot Shahaka, Gros Blanc and Big White. For this chief, see the 1893 edition of Lewis and Clark, pp. xxxix, ciii, 182, 185, 192, 209, 236, 242, 247, 1 184, 1 185. 1 186, 1 191, 1212. The attempt to send Shahaka safe home again, and its frus- tration by a sharp collision with hostile Indians, in the vicinity of Bismarck, S. D., in September, 1807, form the main sub- ject of the four letters now first published. The originals, in the handwritings of Captain Clark and Ensign Pryor, respect- ively, are on file in the archives of the War Department at LIBRARY OF CONGRESS 016 090 965 1^ 614 ANNALS OF IOWA. Washington, where I have examined and copied them, word for word, letter for letter and point for point. General Clark's three letters are in official correspondence with General Henry- Dearborn, Secretary at War, in his capacity as Indian Agent for Louisiana ; one of them covers and transmits Ensign Pry- or's official report to him, narrating the interesting incident, no sufficient account of which has hitherto appeared in print. We know very little of Nathaniel Pryor, beyond the main fact that he was one of four sergeants of Lewis and Clark's expedition (the others being Charles Floyd, who died early in the expedition ; Patrick Gass ; and John Ordway), and afterward commissioned in the army. It appears from Heitman's Regis- ter of the United States Army that Nathaniel Pryor, of Ken- tucky, was appointed an ensign in the First Infantry, Feb. 27, 1807; promoted to be second lieutenant. May 3, 1808; re- signed, April I, 1 8 10; was made first lieutenant in the Forty- fourth Infantry, August 30, 181 3; promoted to be captain, October i, 1814; and honorably discharged, June 15, 1815. Saint Louis June ist 1807. Sir In my letter to you of the i6th ulto: 1 informed you that a deputation from several bands of the Sieoux Nation had arrived at this place with Wm. Dorion, &c. Those Indians set out on their return a few days past highly pleased with the presents & treatment which they have received. Colonel [Thomas] Hunt fur- nished a Lieut, seven men and a boat to escort those people to their Country in safety. By the recjuest of the Mandan Chief [Shahaka, Gros Blanc or Big White], I have suffered him to delay and go in Company with the Sieoux. The party accompanying those Indians consists of I Lieut. I Ensign, i Sergt. I Corpl. 18 privates, i hunter and 3 hired boatmen. Young Chouteau (late an Officer) has a boat and perogue and 32 men (for the Mandan Trade) Young Dorion has a boat and 10 men (for the Sieoux Trade) those together with the 2 interpreters makes a total of 70 men ; exclusive of the 18 Indian Men and womin and 6 chil- dren. After Lieut. Kimble's [Joseph KimbaH's] return which will be from the Sieoux Country, Ensign I'ryors Party will consist of 48 men which will be fully sufficient to pass any hostile band which he may probably meet with. I am informed that the Ricaras have moved moved [bisj to the Mandans for fear of being cut off by the Sieoux of the North ; I think it probable that the report is correct, and a measure which I advised them to as I decendetl Jast fall from a knowledge of their dependence on the Sieoux. Mr. Bolvar [Nicholas Roilvin] has returned from the Saukees without the \ LIBRARY OF CONGRESS llllii 016 090 965 1 <