B 1,000,107 CORE The Roederer Library By Seymour de Ricci ?; 997 R71呂 ​R49 ASTIR VKRĪTAJ OF THE LIBRARY UNIVERSITY OF MICHIGAN TTHA PRESENTED BY THE PUBLISIER : ! The Roederer Library of French Books Prints and Drawings of the Eighteenth Century By SEYMOUR DE RICCI EDITOR OF THE Guide de l'Amateur de Livres à Gravures du XVIII Siecle THE ROSENBACH COMPANY 1320 WALNUT STREET PHILADELPHIA 273 MADISON Avenue NEW YORK 1923 Z 997 R712 R41 Publisher gr. -19-1923 THE ROEDERER LIBRARY Of all the various kinds of books which tempt and have tempted collectors of all coun- tries, no series perhaps has such a wide appeal to every well-read man or woman as the French volumes of the eighteenth century. Do we consider the text: what is more desirable than a fine Molière or a first edition of Rousseau? Do we prefer handsome printing: here we have Didot's masterpieces and Cor- neille's Rodogune from Madame de Pompadour's own private press? Does our taste incline us towards the beauty of the illustration: what greater names could we wish for than Boucher, Moreau or Fragonard? Lastly, are we lovers of bindings: have we not the gems produced by Padeloup and Derôme? And when we sum up, are we not entitled to query whether any other century in any other country has produced a more brilliant combination of pleasing and masterful talent? Three years ago, I had the proud pleasure of bringing to the notice of the American public the treasures of the Robert Schuhmann library, one of the very best ensemble of the kind which has ever been brought together. And now the destinies of books have brought under the same roof the treasures, greater still by far, of the Roederer collection, the finest series of eight- eenth-century French books any one connois- seur has ever succeeded in bringing together. Louis Roederer, whose name has been famil- iar for half a century to a considerable portion of the public, was, in the Parisian book-market, one of the meteors of the last century: from 1875 to 1881, he was the most generous and the most enthusiastic of all French buyers. Not only did he secure practically all the important items that came up for auction, not only did he liberally patronize every bookseller in Europe; he went as far as to persuade nearly all the French collectors of his day to surrender their treasures to his bid. Léon Mercier's collection he purchased as a whole; Comte de Sauvage and Emile Pereire could not resist his tempting offers for their series of Marillier and Oudry drawings; he even succeeded-no easy task, believe me-in obtaining from Baron Pichon the drawings for the 1767 Ovid, and in per- suading Baron James de Rothschild to part with his wonderful drawings by Gravelot, Boucher and Eisen for the 1757 Boccaccio. After Louis Roederer's death, not a volume was added to his library and few connoisseurs were ever granted leave to examine his books. Nevertheless, the collection he made remained famous and the sixth edition of Cohen's Guide de l'amateur de livres à gravures du dix-huitième siècle, published by me in 1912, contains a fairly accurate description of most of the out- standing items. Nevertheless, circumstances prevented me from fully listing many features of this carefully guarded collection, and the arrival in America of this practically unknown accumulation of unique art treasures is one of the most singular and striking events in the history of the book world. A dramatic episode in the history of the Roederer library was its removal from Reims under shell-fire. With typical nonchalance, the packing of the books was delayed until the task became a dangerous one. It speaks highly for the skill and care of French packers that not one binding received a scratch, not one drawing a blemish, in spite of the circum- stances under which the library was transferred to comparative safety in the Paris home of the Olry-Roederer family. Of their stately house in Reims, with the beautiful old oak-panelled library, only blackened ruins now remain. Lack of time prevents the compilation of a worthy catalogue of the Roederer Library. The following rough notes should enlighten the casual reader as to the general character of the library and some of its more obvious fea- tures. The aims and methods of the collector will thus become clearer to the inquisitive visitor who, from the collection itself, seeks to be brought into contact with the spirit of the man who formed it. THE DRAWINGS Rich beyond belief as the various series in the library may be, they would perhaps not suffice to stamp as unique the Roederer collec- tion. Other amateurs, such as Eugène Paillet, were equally successful in collecting proofs and etchings for book illustrations; others again, such as the late Baron Ferdinand de Roths- child, brought together fine series of these celebrated French books in elaborate contem- porary bindings. But the great outstanding feature of the Roederer Library is that it con- tains more original drawings for book illus- trations of the French eighteenth century than any other collection of the kind. No compari- son can be made and not even by combining any other two libraries would it be possible to equal the vast assemblage of nearly three thou- sand drawings brought together by Louis Roederer. Every artist of the eighteenth century is represented, from Oudry to Moreau, and it may be said without exaggeration that the greater the artist, the more brilliant the representation. Boucher's drawings are not common; his book illustrations are among the scarcest of the scarce-six of his best designs for the 1757 Boccaccio were obtained by Roederer, who also owned a most exquisitely finished red chalk series by Punt after Boucher for the excellent Amsterdam edition of Molière, a set of unri- valled beauty comparable only to the Moreau set in the Pierpont Morgan Library. Cochin, the most skillful portraitist of the century and the masterful designer of innumer- able ceremonies and processions, is very fully illustrated by his eight drawings for the Aminta of Tasso (1745), by the seven for Terence (1770), the three for Lemierre, La Peinture (1769), and by single drawings for the 1757 Boccaccio, the 1776 Télémaque, the 1780 Raynal, the Fastes of Ovid (1783), etc. Better still, we find here the magnificent copy of the 1775 French Ariosto from the Detienne, De Bure and Garnier collections, with the set of 48 original drawings (46 by Cochin and two by Moreau le Jeune). That Oudry, the famous designer of tapestry cartoons and the greatest animal painter of his century, should have undertaken to illustrate La Fontaine's Fables is, in itself, a singular piece of good fortune; that he should have abandoned the usual minute scale of book-illus- trators for a larger size, better suited to his talent, is a hardly less felicitous happening. That the well-known engravings of the 1755 La Fontaine should have been made, not from the original drawings, but from tracings by Cochin is another remarkable circumstance which leaves to Oudry's drawings all the charm of an undiscovered landscape. This extra- ordinary series of 276 highly finished pictures in black and white on blue paper, in a beautiful old binding, was formerly in the De Bure, Thibaudeau, Solar and Pereire collections. The immortal illustrator of the Contes de La Fontaine (1762), Charles Eisen, is one of the French draughtsmen of whom it is the most difficult to obtain really satisfactory specimens. His delicate pencilwork, often on vellum, has seldom withstood the injuries of time and of human negligence. Even the celebrated draw- ings for the Contes, preserved at Chantilly, are in a condition which is far from perfect. Of this, Louis Roederer was fully aware and he was particularly keen in securing for his library the finest Eisen drawings in existence. First of all, he purchased from Baron Jérome Pichon the wonderful series for the four-volume Ovid of 1767-1771, formerly in the Renouard and Thibaudeau collections, containing no less than fifty-seven drawings by Eisen, in addition to all those by Moreau, Monnet and Gravelot. To these, he added the five drawings contrib- uted by Eisen to the 1757 Boccaccio and the four beautiful small drawings for Rousseau's Emile (1762). Leprince, the talented painter of Russian life and customs, is better known by his oils than by his drawings, a not surprizing circumstance since practically all his scarce book illustra- tions had been absorbed into the Roederer library: the plate he contributed to the 1767 Ovid, the four exquisite illustrations to Saint- Lambert's Saisons (1769), and above all the wonderful series of drawings for Chappe d' Auteroche's Voyage en Sibérie (1768), many of the greatest beauty: the volume contains no less than thirty-two drawings by Leprince, seven by Moreau and fourteen by Caresme, a combination of unrivalled interest, containing the originals of several famous compositions. popularized by innumerable reproductions. Gravelot, by his long stay in England, and by his numerous illustrations for English books, will always have a particular appeal for any English-speaking collector. He is better represented in the Roederer library than in any other collection in the world. First of all, we find his celebrated series for the 1757 Boccaccio, some hundred and thirty drawings (not to speak of those by Eisen, Boucher, etc. for the same work), partly obtained from Baron James de Rothschild (who had secured them from the Villot sale), partly from the Mahérault collection. From the same Mahérault library, Roederer bought four charming draw- ings for Tom Jones (1750), to which he added on his shelves the six drawings for the Partie de chasse de Henri IV (from the La Bedoyère, Capé and Gautier collections), the seven draw- ings for the 1767 Ovid, the drawings for the 1768 Tibère and several others. But what confers a unique character to Gravelot's representation in the Roederer library is the presence of the artist's own port- folio, preserved intact with nearly a thousand sketches for practically all his book illustrations. The late Emmanuel Bocher had obtained this priceless series from the Marquis de Fourque- vaulx and Roederer finally induced him to part with it. It includes all the first sketches for such celebrated books as Gay's Fables (1727- 1738), the 1757 Boccaccio, the Partie de chasse de Henri IV, the famous 1764 Corneille, Mar- montel's Lucan (1776), the 1768 Oeuvres de Voltaire, the 1768 Racine, the 1771 Tasso, the Lucrèce, the Pucelle, the Nouvelle Héloïse, and gives us a unique opportunity to study the progress of the artist's work at every stage of his adventurous career. Greater still than Gravelot was his wonder- fully gifted continuator Moreau le Jeune, the most remarkable book-illustrator of the whole eighteenth century. The series of his drawings in the Roederer library is the most extensive and the most comprehensive in existence. Louis Roederer admired Moreau above all artists and made tremendous efforts to secure every exam- ple from his hand which could be obtained at any price. The result is stupendous and it seems incredible that in half a dozen years any collec- tor should have succeeded in bringing together such an extraordinary accumulation of his miniature masterpieces. The life-work of the artist is there, from the free and sketchy designs of his youth to the minutely beautiful miniatures of his older age, illustrating every aspect of his genius, the unlimited range of his invention, the lightness of his touch and the almost incredible skill of his technique. The twenty-six drawings for the 1767 Ovid and the seven drawings for the Voyage en Sibérie (1768) have already been mentioned; together with a few selected drawings for the Baskerville Ariosto (1773), they represent Moreau's earliest and most spontaneous efforts. The crowning masterpiece of the artist's life is undoubtedly the series of twenty-four illustrations for the world-famous Monument du Costume. Louis Roederer was fortunate enough to secure two matchless drawings for that celebrated series: Madame Guillotin seated as represented in Oui ou Non, and Madame Moreau standing, as portrayed in La Petite Loge. The technique is of singular perfection and the combination of black, white and red crayon, with the latter tone predominating, has been made use of with consummate skill and remarkable success. No more felicitous examples from Moreau's hand exist in any col- lection public or private. We next find the 1780 Raynal, in a sumptu- ous contemporary morocco binding with the five celebrated drawings by Moreau and Cochin representing the natives of America as seen by the French artist of the eighteenth century; the sumptuous 1780 Metastasio with eight fine designs by Moreau (not to mention those by Cochin and Cipriani), one of the most hand- somely illustrated books of the eighteenth cen- tury, the eight delightful sepias for the Lettres d'Héloïse (1796), the most successful example of Moreau's full-blown genius, the two sepias for the Marcus Aurelius of 1800, the six Moreau and the ten Monnet for the Comte de Valmont (1807), six beautiful drawings for Boileau (with two portraits by the famous Augustin de Saint-Aubin), twelve no less exquisite compositions for Racine (the gem of the Mahérault collection), twelve for the Nouvelle Héloïse and a great many others, too numerous to be listed here in detail. Most of these come from the Renouard and La Bedoyère collections. A series of a hundred and sixteen drawings by Moreau, Lebarbier and Monsiau for the 1806 Ovid, formerly in the Pourtalès collection, also deserves a special mention. Hardly less gifted than Moreau was his rival Marillier, a great master of minute design and small-size groups of figures. The Roederer Library contains three beautiful series by his hand: sixty-seven drawings (eleven unpub- lished) for Ponce, Les illustres Français, from the Renouard and Behague collections with a complete set of the etchings, twelve for the 1797 Gil Blas and the artist's masterpiece, the three hundred illustrations by himself and by Monsiau for the 1789 Bible, a most brilliant and highly finished set, from the collections of Detienne, La Bedoyère, Montgermont and the Comte de Sauvage. Nothing is more worthy of admiration than the persistent freshness of invention and execution throughout this exten- sive series, a parallel to which it would be no easy task to discover in any collection. Lebarbier's classical and refined drawings. were greatly appreciated by the French public during the last thirty years of the eighteenth century. He is very fully illustrated in the Roederer library by the forty-one drawings for the Fastes of Ovid (1783), from the La Bedoyère and Gautier sales, in their handsome old red morocco bindings, by the two drawings for the Chansons de Piis (1785), by eight beautiful com- positions for Daphnis et Chloè, by the four draw- ings for Thomson's Seasons (1795) from the La Bedoyère and Huillard sales, by the draw- ings for the 1796 Racine (Duriez, Hanrott, Morris and Portalis collections) and by the eight exquisite designs for the Lettres d'une Péruvienne (1797), formerly belonging to Comte de La Bedoyère and to L. de Mongermont, in a charming contemporary binding by Courteval. Other series of drawings by various artists include Coiny's eighteen delicate compositions for Renouard's Psyches et Cupidinis Amores (1796), an extremely scarce little book of which no copy has come on the market for the last forty years; a series of eighteen drawings by Debu- court, the scarcest of all French draughtsmen, as nearly all his drawings have been destroyed; the eighteen drawings by Huet for the 1806 Virgil, practically the only set of book illus- trations by that artist existing in any collec- tion; fifty superb drawings by Monnet and Lepicié for the Figures de l'Histoire de France; four charming illustrations by Queverdo for Sedaine's Déserteur (1770) and a large number of other drawings by celebrated French book illustrators of the whole of the eighteenth century. There remains to be described a collection of drawings of such a singular importance that they cannot be bracketed with any other series in this great library. In the whole of the French eighteenth cen- tury, no name calls to our mind more brilliant memories than that of Fragonard, no artist more aptly impersonates the whole life and spirit of his day, no painter was more spon- taneously human and lovable. For the last two generations, collectors of all countries have eagerly gathered every scrap of paper from his pen, and nearly every drawing from his hand has been reproduced and discussed by art- historians. As a book-illustrator, Fragonard was little known in his own days. His drawings for the Contes de La Fontaine (1795) were never com- pleted and seem to have attracted little atten- tion when they came out, during the most agitated days of the French Revolution. As for his wonderful series for Ariosto, the painter's most ambitious and most successful effort as an illustrator, it has remained unknown and unpublished to the present day, save for notices by his biographer, the late Baron Portalis. As stated above, Louis Roederer secured two or three drawings for the 1795 Contes; what must have been his joy when, at the Walferdin sale (and Walferdin had obtained them straight from Fragonard's family), he purchased no less than one hundred and thirty-six astonishing drawings by Fragonard for Ariosto's Orlando Furioso. Nor are these by any means meagre and insignificant sketches; each of these draw- ings is a picture in itself, dashed off with incredible brilliancy on a large folio sheet, heightened with touches of bistre and sepia by a man who with three dabs of his brush could create light and movement. To turn over these leaves is a great lesson in invention in composi- tion, in execution, and it is hardly to be believed that a series so important for the history of French art should have ever been allowed to leave the artist's native land. THE BINDINGS So far, this account has mainly been con- cerned with drawings; but after all, in a library the really important feature is the bookshelf. Louis Roederer was not only the enthusiastic appreciator of drawings and engravings, but above all a keen lover of beautiful books. Modern collectors have long discussed the respective merits of uncut copies in solander cases or in modern bindings, compared with copies in the original morocco bindings with or without dentelle, with or without armorial bearings. Roederer solved the problem in his own way by obtaining the books whenever possible, in both states: the copies in full levant by Trautz-Bauzonnet or Capé usually contain the proofs and etchings; those in old bindings are all in the finest obtainable condi- tion, in magnificent state, often with the arms of some exalted personage. The 1718 Boileau and the 1732 Ovid bear the three towers of Madame de Pompadour; like- wise the stately folio of the Galerie de Versailles (1752), with a broad dentelle by the elder Derôme and the Pompadour arms stamped in silver; the 1755 La Fontaine Fables, of which no finer copy is known, is in a sumptuous dentelle binding with the Montmorency-Luxembourg arms; Moreau's Bibliothèque de la Dauphine, the catalogue of Marie Antoinette's library, with her portrait on the frontispiece, is the Dauphin's (afterwards King Louis XVI) own copy, an association volume of extraordinary in- terest; the same arms adorn the beautiful copy of the 1774 Agriculture; Marmontel's Chefs d' oeuvre dramatiques (1773), belonged to King George III, his Contes moraux (1765) to Maure- pas, the Exercice de l'Infanterie (1757) to the Comte d'Artois, afterwards King Charles X, and a charming little Bossuet bears the emblems of Longepierre. A liturgical book from Plan- tin's press (1573) is a strikingly handsome example from De Thou's library and the finest early binding in the Roederer collection. For over a century, old French mosaic bind- ings have been considered by book-collectors as the choicest prize they could secure. In spite of the competition of such great enthusiasts as Baron de Lacarelle or James de Rothschild, Roederer succeeded in obtaining several strik- ingly beautiful examples of these wonderful inlays. The series opens with the 1728 Henriade in a remarkable mosaic binding, strongly reminiscent of the seventeenth century style, formerly in the Hangard, Radziwill and Montgermont collections. The Pine Horace (1733), equal in beauty to the celebrated Dutuit copy, is a well-known example of Derôme's skill, from the famous libraries of Lauraguais- Brancas, Clos, Duparc, Pieters and Robert S. Turner. More beautiful still is the matchless Temple de Gnide (1772), once the gem of the De Bure collection and a magnificent example of design and tooling. To obtain possession of the finest copy of the most celebrated book of the eighteenth century, must have been the greatest satisfaction of Roederer's career as a collector. The Fermiers Généraux edition of La Fontaine's Contes has long enjoyed the deserved reputation of being the finest book of its kind and the Roederer copy, for a century and a half, has been known as the most beautifully bound example of the book. We follow it from sale to sale, ever since it was bound by Derôme for the Fermier- Général Bonnemet, one of the original patrons of the edition, through the hands of the Duc de La Vallière, Naigeon, Didot, La Bedoyère, Brunet, Fontaine, Henri Bordes and E. L. Benzon. The citron morocco binding, with a green and red mosaic of flowers and fruit, is of a most tasteful design and in faultless condition, the colours being as fresh as when the book left Derôme's hands. Each side of each volume is decorated with a different pattern and the tool- ing is of unsurpassed elegance and accuracy. I have little hesitation in claiming it to be one of the most desirable treasures that ever graced a book-collector's shelves. * * After items of such outstanding importance, it may seem futile to draw attention to the standard works of the eighteenth century in their beautiful contemporary morocco bind- ings. And yet it would be unfair to pass in silence great examples of bookbinding like the luxuriant dentelles on the 1775 Berquin, the splendid 1728 Fontenelle, the equally magnif- icent 1733 Regnier, the Eloge de la Folie (1751), the Longus of 1718, the 1754 Lucretius, and the beautiful reliure de présent on one of the copies of the Fermiers Généraux La Fontaine (1762). Many of the less gorgeously decorated bind- ings are also worthy of the greatest attention: what other collection could show on the same shelf, in bindings by Derôme with his charac- teristic little bird, such standard works as Dorat's Baisers, Dorat's Fables and the Chansons of La Borde, the latter with the famous and extremely scarce portrait of La Borde's expect- ant wife? PROOFS AND ETCHINGS For a print lover like Roederer, these magnif- icent copies in their sumptuous contemporary bindings had a great drawback. They nearly always contained the illustrations in the pub- lished state. The trial proofs and etchings remained in the print-collectors' portfolios and until about 1810 were very seldom bound into the books. During the whole of the nineteenth century the few stray examples of these trial pieces were carefully picked up by collectors like Renouard or La Bedoyère or enthusiastic dealers like Vignères or Sieurin and gradually inserted into fine uncut copies of the books for which they were engraved. These were then bound by the great French artists of the day, from Bozérian and Simier to Trautz-Bauzonnet and Cuzin, and the combination thus obtained of a perfect copy of the book, the scarcest variations of the prints and the handsomest obtainable binding produced volumes of the most attractive nature. At the beginning of his career as a biblio- phile, Louis Roederer was fortunate enough to secure some of the finest examples of the kind when he purchased the Léon Mercier collec- tion. Mercier, not unlike his contemporary Eugène Paillet, was apt to consider French book-illustrations, above all other things, as masterpieces of the engraver's art. And, as every print lover would have done, he revelled in the joy of full uncut margins, of proofs before letters or before certain variations, and in the costly privilege of gathering trial-proofs and eaux-fortes. All his copies were beautifully bound by Trautz-Bauzonnet and the other masters of the day and by buying the Mercier library Louis Roederer secured a solid foundation for the great building he was striving to erect. Characteristic of these books is the copy of the Contes de La Fontaine (1762), the famous Fermiers Généraux edition with all the tail- pieces in separate impressions (tirages hors texte), or the 1795 edition of the same tales with Fragonard's beautiful illustrations in various states, including a few of the original drawings. Carrying on Mercier's pursuits in this partic- ular line, Louis Roederer added greatly to his predecessor's store of rarities and we now find in the library practically all the famous sets of trial proofs. Side by side with the celebrated Sieurin copy of the 1795 Contes, the finest in existence, we find the scarce and beautiful etchings for the 1734 Molière (the only other sets on record are in the Bibliothèque Nationale and the Roths- child collection), all the tirages hors texte for Dorat's Fables and the far scarcer Baisers, most of the eaux-fortes for such celebrated books as the 1773 Molière or the Chansons de La Borde, the hors texte of the Anacreon, Gravelot's Iconologie before all letters, the "introuvable trial-proofs for the 1757 Boccaccio, the etch- ings for the Liaisons dangereuses, for Faublas and for the whole of the dainty little Bleuet collection; last but not least, the famous La Bedoyère and Montgermont copy of Buffon's works in fifty-six volumes, the most sumptuous on record, with the unique set of plates before letters, of coloured engravings and other valu- able illustrations. Roederer also owned a matchless copy of the 1773 Anacreon, in an old citron morocco binding, with contrepreuves of all the illustrations, beautifully coloured by hand. Roederer had also collected fine copies of the great "Fêtes" and other ceremonies in their sumptuous old morocco bindings and of the celebrated series of plates on architecture, gardening, ornament, interior decoration, fur- niture, the goldsmiths' craft, so valuable for the knowledge of French art of the eighteenth century and so seldom met with in really fine condition. THE PRINTS Nor are the books and drawings the whole of the library: Louis Roederer was also an enlightened appreciator of earlier art, as we can see from the large portfolios of engraved portraits, from a fine set of Dürer wood cuts. and from a wonderful Italian miniature of the fifteenth century, Pope Sixtus IV receiving the homage of a book from the founder of Paris typography, the kneeling Guillaume Fichet, the gem of the former Payne collection and a masterpiece of the illuminator's art, closely related to the celebrated fresco by Melozzo da Forli in the Vatican Museum. The print collection forms a valuable addi- tion to the library and completes in a remark- able way the representation of a number of the greatest French draughtsmen and engravers. Prints after Chardin are all scarce and have always been much sought for by French col- lectors; here we have perhaps the only set on record which has come down to us in an old binding. Particularly characteristic of the eighteenth- century French engraver at his best are the beautiful compositions of contemporary life by Baudouin and Lavreince. Of most of these plates, trial-proofs and etchings are in existence and count among the choicest treasures of the French iconophile. Of late years, extremely few have come on the market and of several only two or three copies are known to exist. The extensive series of these etchings and trial- proofs in the Louis Roederer collection bears. testimony both to his taste and knowledge and to his unusual foresight in securing prints today unobtainable at any price. The ''œuvre" of Baudouin is not very exten- sive and the set in the Roederer collection is practically complete. All his famous plates are here, several in the scarcest states, from the famous Four Hours of the Day (Le Matin, Le Midi, Le Soir, La Nuit) to the even more famous Couché de la Mariée, so skilfully engraved by Moreau le Jeune and Simonet. He had three variations of Rose et Colas, two of the Soins Tardifs, of the Sentinelle en Défaut and of the Epouse Indiscrète. Other dainty and celebrated compositions. are the Jardinier Galant, the Fruit de l'Amour Secret, the Modèle honnête and the Baigneuses, in which Baudouin shows himself the worthy disciple of Boucher, the great painter of Nymphs and Naiads. Not less brilliantly represented are Fragonard with proof impressions of his most celebrated plates (Les Beignets, Dites donc s'il vous plaît, L'Heureuse Fécondité, Le Chiffre d'Amour, etc.), and Moreau le Jeune, Roederer's idol, with some of his scarcest etchings such as the Revue de la Plaine des Sablons, the Sacre de Louis XVI and the various states of the Cou- ronnement de Voltaire. Of all series of plates of the French eight- eenth century, none is more generally and more deservedly famous than the Monument du Costume, with the twelve plates by Freudeberg for the first volume (here present in several sets, one being in the original old red morocco), and the twenty-four by Moreau for the second and third. Nothing is scarcer than the etchings and the proofs before letters for these delightful compositions and, for the last thirty years, hardly any single impressions (not to speak of sets) have come into the auction-room. Only two sets of these trial pieces were known to be in existence, one in a great Parisian collection and the other acquired a few years ago by an American amateur. The discovery in the Roed- erer Library of a similar collection of trial plates for the Monument du Costume will be greeted by all iconophiles as an event of the first importance. These rarities are accompanied by a very fine and extensive series of French engraved portraits of the seventeenth and of the eight- eenth century, beginning with superb exam- ples of Masson and Edelinck, two large port- folios of portraits by Robert Nanteuil, with all his great engravings in the scarcest states, and a stately array of Drevet's portraits of cele- brated Frenchmen. The nineteenth century is represented by a few selected items, such as some excellent bind- ings by Marius-Michel and other great artists, a most beautiful series of sixteen water-colours by Eugène Lami, the great exponent of Parisian life under the third Napoleon, and by a very extensive and remarkable oeuvre of Gavarni, with nearly every known variation of every plate, probably the largest collection of Gavarni lithographs ever brought together. * * * That such a collection should have left France for the United States is a remarkable evidence of American catholicity and a homage of modern taste to the century of Voltaire and Rousseau, of Boucher and Fragonard, of Hou- don and Pajou, of Mademoiselle Clairon and of Madame de Pompadour. SEYMOUR DE RICCI UNIVERSITY OF MICHIGAN 3 9015 03360 8954